id
stringlengths
9
16
vector
listlengths
1.02k
1.02k
title
stringlengths
2
382
abstract
stringlengths
16
3.07k
authors
stringlengths
3
128
categories
stringlengths
5
125
month
stringclasses
12 values
year
int64
1.99k
2.01k
url
stringlengths
31
38
gr-qc/9208011
[ 0.07800143212080002, 0.2542440593242645, 1.1391026973724365, 0.4156140387058258, -0.6827254891395569, 0.07170471549034119, -0.7115435004234314, -0.21797649562358856, -1.8848187923431396, 1.5157239437103271, 0.5292903780937195, -0.3699165880680084, 0.0598037913441658, -0.8427152037620544, -0.6487296223640442, 0.1988285481929779, -0.11320604383945465, 0.07950977981090546, -0.5844848155975342, -0.17058773338794708, 0.486112117767334, -0.285977840423584, -1.0003646612167358, -0.43953147530555725, -0.729721188545227, 1.0140682458877563, -0.15478649735450745, 0.043085984885692596, 1.0075825452804565, 0.6131755113601685, 0.5804585814476013, -0.33884021639823914, -0.28123992681503296, -0.8119962215423584, -0.21922074258327484, 0.21313951909542084, 0.2771785259246826, 0.3411983251571655, 0.6033884882926941, -0.6572335958480835, 0.6227039694786072, -0.053661689162254333, 0.25924813747406006, -0.21238498389720917, 0.008630583062767982, 0.011420178227126598, -0.8158701658248901, 0.1726752519607544, 0.12205879390239716, -1.0944244861602783, -0.35652121901512146, -0.0613325871527195, 0.6705004572868347, -0.8702712655067444, -0.4027844965457916, -0.611747145652771, -0.022199830040335655, -0.015758946537971497, -0.21241161227226257, -0.04716762527823448, 0.43355119228363037, 0.05149805545806885, 0.5495378375053406, -0.44462013244628906, 0.1439734399318695, 1.1445493698120117, -0.45400533080101013, 0.8542563319206238, -0.288953959941864, 0.11641689389944077, 0.14631806313991547, -0.35243651270866394, -0.13053347170352936, 0.4403478503227234, -0.8070951700210571, 0.2531702220439911, -0.32651132345199585, -0.4808151125907898, -1.0305390357971191, -0.25529611110687256, 0.10075855255126953, -0.8491870760917664, -0.08018272370100021, 0.21854731440544128, 0.3039674162864685, -0.488383412361145, 0.12532739341259003, -0.19621165096759796, 0.02961164340376854, 1.2971550226211548, 0.13732942938804626, 0.6626636385917664, -0.5163698196411133, -0.7332535982131958, 0.3999554514884949, 0.4445476531982422, 0.5150364637374878, 0.021465573459863663, 0.5026527047157288, 0.45989441871643066, 0.009259922429919243, 0.37153932452201843, 0.13964487612247467, 0.8658720850944519, -0.17454859614372253, 1.1245596408843994, 0.5592241883277893, 0.8163223266601562, -0.5772525668144226, -0.16793708503246307, 0.06844457238912582, -0.015972046181559563, 0.5579442381858826, 0.6803947687149048, -0.03385629504919052, 0.47851425409317017, 0.1798432618379593, 0.14147843420505524, -0.8376690149307251, -0.20778058469295502, -0.26043078303337097, 1.050992488861084, 0.6025243401527405, 0.5981765389442444, -0.06602955609560013, -0.5165317058563232, -0.513052225112915, 0.14944539964199066, -0.3144553303718567, -0.43239253759384155, -0.2813231647014618, -0.09763249009847641, -0.1485651731491089, -0.2990686893463135, 0.05626092106103897, 0.726552426815033, 0.2158111184835434, 0.16493290662765503, -0.6811441779136658, -0.5541665554046631, 0.24332156777381897, -0.9680882692337036, -0.3007809817790985, 0.7732779383659363, -1.1751717329025269, 0.2591589689254761, 0.5172985792160034, -0.40947821736335754, -0.0710369199514389, -0.28652364015579224, -0.7076757550239563, -0.11421326547861099, 0.3236753046512604, -0.30256521701812744, -0.32700636982917786, -0.3825661242008209, -0.5023293495178223, -0.04524872079491615, -0.8166888356208801, -0.4789389669895172, 0.8318686485290527, -0.018960272893309593, 0.004787457175552845, 0.29554614424705505, 0.06709131598472595, 0.06600835919380188, -0.6269141435623169, -1.056618571281433, 0.3562139570713043, -0.4358498454093933, -0.46815168857574463, 0.35421857237815857, -0.13174143433570862, 0.7905117869377136, 0.5977454781532288, 0.14400386810302734, 0.057285040616989136, -0.752113938331604, -0.6590707898139954, -0.29630857706069946, -0.3626402020454407, -0.15010561048984528, 0.4746136963367462, 0.6203495264053345, 0.05666865035891533, -0.10891443490982056, -0.8074847459793091, -0.45547226071357727, 0.11814995110034943, 0.5093821883201599, -0.10133534669876099, 0.8362289667129517, -0.6266645193099976, 0.5377322435379028, -0.891077995300293, 0.10703610628843307, -0.6320921182632446, 0.8524945974349976, 0.6432896852493286, -1.3638995885849, 0.373361736536026, 0.43338754773139954, -1.3108975887298584, 0.5702165961265564, -1.0226576328277588, 1.2102766036987305, 1.0135971307754517, 0.23942968249320984, -0.27094802260398865, -0.12145328521728516, -0.14804507791996002, -0.12001068890094757, -0.14779260754585266, 0.03713485226035118, -0.018685268238186836, 0.3208366334438324, 0.41206321120262146, 0.1793709397315979, -0.09187731891870499, -0.05306735262274742, -0.0630415752530098, -0.564910888671875, 0.725986659526825, 1.1193678379058838, 0.5180911421775818, -0.5204027891159058, -0.13659100234508514, 0.8462800979614258, 0.9428431391716003, -0.24732938408851624, -0.4819318652153015, 0.16323700547218323, -0.17221136391162872, 0.17905296385288239, -0.13316410779953003, 0.16942711174488068, 0.9154711365699768, 0.25939658284187317, -0.08871135115623474, 0.46118268370628357, -0.11666841059923172, 0.07557888329029083, 0.9110355377197266, 0.4875985383987427, -0.19169743359088898, 0.49221986532211304, -0.36297789216041565, 0.3339173197746277, -0.5361909866333008, 0.4170610308647156, -0.6517144441604614, 0.29296234250068665, 0.9517677426338196, 0.5326441526412964, -0.2893678545951843, -0.4135225713253021, 0.12126097828149796, 0.8430033922195435, -0.04057176038622856, -0.46048736572265625, -0.5334178805351257, 0.19843518733978271, -0.34323593974113464, -0.6316100358963013, -0.28677308559417725, 0.7070488333702087, -0.4334043562412262, -0.270480751991272, 0.21009746193885803, -0.4560038149356842, -1.2957948446273804, -0.08101030439138412, 0.010185866616666317, 0.2134234458208084, -0.1592123657464981, -0.21148766577243805, -0.01343532931059599, -0.6027325987815857, 0.8829794526100159, 0.034702837467193604, -0.8701443076133728, 0.3555457293987274, -0.24837975203990936, 0.35426411032676697, 0.4372759163379669, 0.13754242658615112, -0.5015532970428467, 0.6088826656341553, -0.7915585041046143, 0.056087471544742584, 0.04083925113081932, -0.28840702772140503, -0.3080148994922638, -0.20543840527534485, 0.20072630047798157, 0.49861177802085876, -0.40780526399612427, 0.191231831908226, 0.0693131685256958, -0.540452778339386, -0.14934313297271729, 0.4948023557662964, -0.025934791192412376, -0.5710222721099854, -1.3687258958816528, 0.230771005153656, -0.2800130248069763, -0.5257599949836731, 0.2922340929508209, 0.23268726468086243, -0.773863673210144, 0.5150089859962463, -0.8642769455909729, 0.3272815942764282, -0.36726707220077515, 0.3568299114704132, 1.2004847526550293, 0.24924996495246887, 0.2136608362197876, -0.9465441107749939, -0.2497609555721283, -0.15917041897773743, 0.5271196365356445, -0.49039027094841003, 0.636330783367157, 0.5567110776901245, 0.20187616348266602, -0.08685776591300964, 0.6483872532844543, -0.6483521461486816, -0.9072744250297546, 0.007609621621668339, -0.2487795650959015, 0.05082596838474274, 0.1704021692276001, -0.19783282279968262, -0.49431246519088745, 0.4531145691871643, -0.18971605598926544, 0.5705356597900391, 0.3135184347629547, 0.23448446393013, 0.4862215518951416, 0.3012131452560425, 0.005708807148039341, 0.08827491104602814, 0.9344920516014099, -0.06310203671455383, -0.7290136218070984, 0.1310611367225647, -0.3563418984413147, -0.36736607551574707, 0.3640761971473694, 0.5994975566864014, 0.37148919701576233, 0.7402228713035583, -0.13445718586444855, 0.6747949123382568, -0.5639157295227051, -0.3396664261817932, -0.12126313149929047, 0.34026604890823364, 0.3781134784221649, 0.00776094663888216, -0.5136567950248718, 0.1920890063047409, 0.2859916388988495, -0.39499160647392273, 0.8009868264198303, -0.7625967860221863, -0.0796785056591034, -0.24665877223014832, -0.651604950428009, -0.6670507192611694, 0.2895255982875824, 0.7809103727340698, 0.193847194314003, 0.22865058481693268, 1.416567325592041, -0.695033073425293, -0.49131155014038086, -0.26219186186790466, 0.6348668932914734, 0.40967029333114624, -0.16294187307357788, 0.11457180976867676, -0.8971815705299377, 0.012753059156239033, -0.2778918743133545, -0.5239980220794678, -0.2199888378381729, -0.37712231278419495, -0.30908745527267456, -0.4465109407901764, -0.22142094373703003, -0.24993547797203064, 0.3930562436580658, 0.11801578104496002, -0.4758431017398834, 0.2830143868923187, 0.2503214478492737, -0.56878662109375, 0.3717080354690552, 0.2636096775531769, 0.15486331284046173, 0.13260629773139954, -0.5983818769454956, 0.43095940351486206, -0.10129380971193314, 0.3996899127960205, 0.06561778485774994, 0.18979448080062866, 0.025414641946554184, -0.0141245536506176, 0.28378257155418396, 0.6270670890808105, -0.13442032039165497, 0.6842665076255798, 0.7677012085914612, 0.26497384905815125, 0.12495269626379013, 0.7603064179420471, -0.24896617233753204, 0.20204176008701324, 0.4205128848552704, -1.2056536674499512, 0.8351380825042725, -0.1688619703054428, 0.4311130940914154, 1.0256932973861694, -0.45067834854125977, -0.6592689752578735, -0.5727677345275879, 0.4940465986728668, -0.0415780134499073, 0.5210121273994446, 0.6466516256332397, -0.2137034386396408, -0.12955518066883087, 0.5282451510429382, -0.2871403098106384, 0.6813932657241821, -0.5599680542945862, -0.4779246747493744, 0.36336252093315125, 0.04962611570954323, -0.1186540275812149, 0.28733307123184204, 0.1676926165819168, -0.8238185048103333, 0.5011985898017883, -0.8571667075157166, 0.6324517726898193, -0.4530767798423767, 0.1259184181690216, 0.5061938762664795, 0.15414977073669434, -0.9021597504615784, 0.44211718440055847, -0.3641253113746643, -0.26006853580474854, 0.040187038481235504, -0.39535242319107056, -0.6494742631912231, -0.4563867449760437, 0.28086307644844055, 0.07428476959466934, 0.7383073568344116, 0.3603062927722931, 0.07335931062698364, 0.5301749110221863, 0.05474144592881203, -0.5256189703941345, -0.2484910935163498, 0.24851758778095245, -0.5218484401702881, -0.177670419216156, -0.47409021854400635, 0.22612079977989197, -0.7942976355552673, 0.06709330528974533, 0.24558953940868378, -0.24096699059009552, -0.19684484601020813, 0.25304463505744934, -1.3608360290527344, -0.6973228454589844, -0.08597951382398605, -0.7211476564407349, 0.8043186068534851, -0.6775447726249695, -0.16254949569702148, -0.4051596522331238, -1.0357578992843628, -0.33029285073280334, 0.14832228422164917, -0.44641223549842834, -0.3304347097873688, 0.19571904838085175, 0.36402997374534607, -0.07390200346708298, -0.37767890095710754, -0.3154738247394562, 0.8919727802276611, 0.566729724407196, -0.4584137201309204, -0.490313321352005, -0.6258795261383057, -0.035004016011953354, -0.4187970459461212, 0.06852081418037415, -0.3012605607509613, -0.017520153895020485, 0.10885131359100342, -0.00787757895886898, -0.28658023476600647, 0.5253013372421265, -0.9582370519638062, -0.2829410433769226, 0.4119674265384674, 0.03369935601949692, -0.8114880919456482, 0.12682147324085236, 0.7836611866950989, 0.027765003964304924, 0.24746274948120117, -0.07200369238853455, -1.3254661560058594, 0.26513776183128357, -0.48534271121025085, -0.30336248874664307, -0.7085549235343933, 0.22790943086147308, -0.47003546357154846, -0.33316510915756226, -0.5205897092819214, 0.1972809135913849, 0.4958846867084503, -0.39553990960121155, -0.10355844348669052, -0.2287125438451767, 0.19594718515872955, -0.5156261920928955, -0.43035888671875, -0.1663709282875061, -0.3756823241710663, -0.5426444411277771, 0.8586951494216919, -0.7334125638008118, -0.46106085181236267, 0.6530753970146179, -0.30468058586120605, 0.23730966448783875, 0.2939353883266449, 0.1623598039150238, -0.5828959941864014, 0.12796306610107422, 0.5191652774810791, 0.5545745491981506, -0.12225615978240967, -0.49927425384521484, 1.027991533279419, -0.7641400694847107, 0.546436071395874, -0.47417566180229187, 0.11924684047698975, 0.2568780481815338, 0.17305609583854675, 0.3314753770828247, -0.7057730555534363, 0.4945310652256012, 0.48265522718429565, 0.031215112656354904, 0.4338906705379486, 0.4916421175003052, -0.18993395566940308, -0.45427408814430237, -0.6947579979896545, -0.7528676390647888, 0.7034436464309692, 0.13014698028564453, -0.1994294673204422, 0.20379634201526642, -0.3327848017215729, -0.43547531962394714, -0.08570137619972229, 0.29239991307258606, 0.5988608002662659, -0.09768745303153992, -0.12710164487361908, -0.22477322816848755, 0.15171335637569427, -0.3547557294368744, 0.12527842819690704, 0.5586881637573242, 0.10509567707777023, -0.5577738285064697, -0.3440215587615967, -0.1634065955877304, -0.4584176242351532, -0.3666272461414337, 0.8212432265281677, 0.6949064135551453, -0.4358978569507599, 1.186721920967102, 0.18914231657981873, -0.20990335941314697, -0.0871676579117775, 0.1984066218137741, 0.9287019371986389, 0.588826596736908, 0.4914732873439789, -0.0904543474316597, -0.1849958896636963, -0.2814040780067444, 0.15398551523685455, -0.8587698340415955, -0.23015408217906952, 0.45225346088409424, -0.7717285752296448, -0.010932790115475655, 0.32656216621398926, 0.21028925478458405, -0.552175760269165, -0.2578124701976776, -0.34770578145980835, -0.301469624042511, -0.21753837168216705, -1.0774726867675781, -0.22213923931121826, -0.3017590045928955, -0.7902318835258484, 0.423340380191803, 0.2529742419719696, 0.06654831767082214, 0.35234755277633667, -0.2437724471092224, -0.444853276014328, -0.6853061318397522, -0.21355509757995605, 1.4058326482772827, -0.2560761570930481, -0.04120852053165436, -0.3686172366142273, -0.06223823130130768, -0.19919919967651367, -0.27679410576820374, 0.7748509049415588, 0.027010899037122726, 0.09931891411542892, 0.0971909835934639, 0.36444592475891113, -0.2259700745344162, 1.0631232261657715, 0.2691122591495514, 0.19002050161361694, -0.3019721508026123, -0.6069112420082092, -0.6011319160461426, 0.2076503187417984, 0.6668316721916199, 0.380147248506546, -0.1715211123228073, -0.05671229586005211, -0.19825612008571625, -0.5194461345672607, -0.15508027374744415, -0.3688827455043793, 0.5055515766143799, -1.289001226425171, -0.646612823009491, -1.018949031829834, -0.8800021409988403, 0.37304097414016724, 0.7585476636886597, -0.21745043992996216, -0.2451135367155075, 0.13271957635879517, -0.2167385369539261, 0.6153814792633057, 0.3729470670223236, 0.057672321796417236, -0.3140052258968353, -0.9240055680274963, 0.09785277396440506, -0.3469335436820984, -0.7188920974731445, 0.046145785599946976, 0.2618333697319031, -0.008583566173911095, 0.77733314037323, -0.4770691394805908, 0.73752760887146, -0.3422018885612488, -0.15186841785907745, 0.1403270661830902, -1.0834741592407227, -0.8401600122451782, 0.8869408369064331, -0.35989630222320557, 0.7767216563224792, 0.18639734387397766, 0.07659849524497986, -0.2593230605125427, -0.31120243668556213, -0.9324105978012085, 0.41618287563323975, -0.22178037464618683, 0.9241445660591125, -0.01181782316416502, -0.06498228758573532, 0.1609552949666977, 0.254455029964447, -0.9111970067024231, 0.1939571499824524, -0.6968972682952881, 0.4897804260253906, 0.08079901337623596, -0.0020313768181949854, -0.16988179087638855, 0.42806190252304077, 0.02832266315817833, 0.4135820269584656, -0.488359659910202, -0.26678362488746643, -0.08425338566303253, 0.23159867525100708, 0.21884343028068542, -0.1833367794752121, 0.16251172125339508, -1.0826209783554077, 0.3417249023914337, 0.4696165919303894, 0.06909916549921036, -0.5439718961715698, 0.13264934718608856, -0.235120952129364, -0.004045804962515831, -0.27530956268310547, -0.9419951438903809, 0.7621846795082092, 0.6645649075508118, -0.21990711987018585, -0.03902173042297363, -0.8816009163856506, -0.49760252237319946, 0.8344184160232544, -0.5777406096458435, 0.31725338101387024, 0.05378880351781845, 0.017467793077230453, 0.0971890464425087, 0.05660411715507507, -0.7296921610832214, 0.271755576133728, -0.5794875621795654, 1.0531059503555298, 0.2415594607591629, 0.09170348942279816, -0.24726416170597076, 1.1170333623886108, -0.5256496071815491, 0.08203338086605072, -0.5508993268013, 0.48405811190605164, -0.3946928083896637, -0.35394248366355896, -0.0773601084947586, 0.45083269476890564, -0.3231673538684845, -0.4417775273323059, -0.355851948261261, 0.6029571890830994, -0.12526154518127441, -0.13235978782176971, -0.21523433923721313, -0.36986204981803894, -0.4955589175224304, 0.5202036499977112, -0.002239684574306011, -0.41530072689056396, -0.007086123339831829, -0.07662863284349442, 0.38452014327049255, -0.20616504549980164, -0.5654269456863403, 0.9649121165275574, 0.22061190009117126, -0.7681738138198853, 0.7465304136276245, 0.8669931888580322, 0.41100651025772095, 0.14711301028728485, -0.6624306440353394, 0.03230845555663109, 0.13110317289829254, -0.2443084418773651, 0.559503972530365, 0.37432849407196045, -0.3267919719219208, 0.397269606590271, -0.06776231527328491, 0.5652440190315247, 0.1458343118429184, 0.418271541595459, 0.18524418771266937, 0.8317221403121948, -0.21721786260604858, 0.3152409791946411, -0.14333561062812805, 0.22643829882144928, 0.044528715312480927, 0.3352721929550171, 0.22659890353679657, 0.03456803038716316, -0.5728126764297485, 0.3514706492424011, -0.7332802414894104, -1.063981533050537, -0.7845950722694397, 0.5659618377685547, 0.3406694233417511, -0.2857828438282013, 0.4046277105808258, 0.9607831239700317, 0.2287699580192566, 0.48061662912368774, -0.028163088485598564, 0.29877883195877075, 0.015895841643214226, 0.37362906336784363, 0.0014135520905256271, 0.35409167408943176, 0.5774410367012024, 0.6977044939994812, 0.41193175315856934, -0.6181124448776245, 0.16955994069576263, 0.06243586167693138, -1.361797571182251, -0.07553792744874954, -0.215134397149086, 0.020998403429985046, 0.6216333508491516, -0.4217882454395294, 0.8406515717506409, -0.6065335273742676, -0.14555351436138153, 0.49380090832710266, -0.39786025881767273, -0.08597906678915024, 0.6481639742851257, 0.2051369845867157, 0.33876967430114746, 0.6760233640670776, 0.22366543114185333, -0.09818657487630844, 1.1447409391403198, 1.123252272605896, 0.20951318740844727, -0.26054123044013977, 0.09275566041469574, -0.29172489047050476, -0.0830097422003746, 0.8004902601242065, -0.6600478291511536, 1.2695084810256958, -0.3083416223526001, 0.09619135409593582, -0.06622721254825592, 0.0339101180434227, -0.27067652344703674, 0.24176549911499023, 0.5440587997436523, 0.32925859093666077, -0.05820511281490326, 0.17058858275413513, 1.2750087976455688, 0.4294263422489166, 0.08843453973531723, -0.05143050104379654, -0.004723717458546162, -0.10462435334920883, -0.5078076124191284, -0.2931004464626312, 0.264321506023407, -0.4754243791103363, -0.2394164502620697, -0.1000237688422203, -0.4852013885974884, -0.18545159697532654, -0.4037529230117798, -0.38382863998413086, -0.48417213559150696, 0.17880438268184662, 0.7452021837234497, 0.8376895189285278, 0.24329529702663422, -0.6242546439170837, 0.0846114233136177, -0.012064492329955101, 0.7412627339363098, -0.45791879296302795, -0.1385161578655243, 0.13216252624988556, -0.037567753344774246, -0.10626489669084549, 0.443355917930603, 0.4953263998031616, -0.5081256628036499, 0.2822953164577484, -0.05530939996242523, 0.5833466649055481, -0.007029564585536718, 0.13393902778625488, 0.05000125616788864, 0.5613589286804199, 0.14699025452136993, 0.33780092000961304, -0.9455106258392334, 0.1455439031124115, -0.86534583568573, 0.20696225762367249, -0.3106398284435272, 0.6419297456741333, 0.5276558995246887, 0.1600608080625534, 0.22813597321510315, -0.5636007189750671, 4.247241973876953, 0.48889270424842834, 0.7893275618553162, -0.5828335285186768, 0.5050551295280457, 0.8721535801887512, -0.3028154671192169, -0.6693978309631348, 0.3147800862789154, -0.6014476418495178, -0.3525018095970154, -0.10306001454591751, -0.10301125049591064, -0.19838061928749084, 0.06666330993175507, 0.33507221937179565, -0.26749658584594727, -0.7483288049697876, 0.09864212572574615, -0.8893547058105469, -1.0508406162261963, 0.3762114346027374, -0.04523983597755432, -0.08630933612585068, -0.06416042149066925, 0.08089766651391983, 0.5704920291900635, -0.11600940674543381, -0.40257057547569275, -0.5022416114807129, -0.9300475716590881, -0.9299325942993164, 0.42747363448143005, -0.22354547679424286, -0.7354464530944824, 0.2383611798286438, -0.7142984867095947, 0.4979173243045807, 0.11330758780241013, -0.6815052628517151, 0.05108657851815224, -0.12581616640090942, -0.00995416659861803, 0.16842733323574066, -0.7024036645889282, 1.1048319339752197, 0.049297165125608444, 0.7784987688064575, 0.8124599456787109, -0.5966426134109497, 0.727810263633728, -0.4034961760044098, 0.6270968914031982, -0.16743195056915283, -1.0036355257034302, 0.07400203496217728, -0.6812208294868469, -0.5534622073173523, 0.09377015382051468, 0.13710735738277435, 0.6445910930633545, 0.1460641622543335, -0.29966333508491516, 0.05247211456298828, 0.12244569510221481, 0.4878937602043152, 0.5733205676078796, 0.21639518439769745, -0.5251618027687073, 0.22340074181556702, -0.6005485653877258, -0.07364366203546524, -0.28250640630722046, -0.574286937713623, 0.26541009545326233, 0.3017904758453369, 0.03816960006952286, 0.533287525177002, -0.0802961066365242, 0.0529414601624012, -0.2751163840293884, -0.3205929696559906, -0.3956003487110138, -0.13877755403518677, 0.37353846430778503, 0.8573026061058044, -0.16340236365795135, 0.46421876549720764, 0.08467607945203781, 0.5243239402770996, 0.1593998372554779, 0.620774507522583, 0.06157390773296356, -0.4345126152038574, -0.7708626985549927 ]
Comparison of the Sachs-Wolfe Effect for Gaussian and Non-Gaussian Fluctuations
A consequence of non-Gaussian perturbations on the Sachs-Wolfe effect is studied. For a particular power spectrum, predicted Sachs-Wolfe effects are calculated for two cases: Gaussian (random phase) configuration, and a specific kind of non-Gaussian configuration. We obtain a result that the Sachs-Wolfe effect for the latter case is smaller when each temperature fluctuation is properly normalized with respect to the corresponding mass fluctuation ${\delta M\over M}(R)$. The physical explanation and the generality of the result are discussed.
Jong H. Kung
gr-qc astro-ph
August
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9208011
gr-qc/9209001
[ -0.003557482734322548, 0.3450431227684021, 0.34126153588294983, 0.2480439692735672, -0.2520442605018616, 0.22747746109962463, -0.031217366456985474, -0.14356650412082672, -0.6106698513031006, 1.9675716161727905, 0.3041318655014038, -0.8021355867385864, 0.1837669163942337, -1.0835227966308594, -0.1878867745399475, 0.4326494634151459, -0.3731130063533783, -0.3738597631454468, -1.6510025262832642, 0.7390462756156921, 0.2629602551460266, 0.1861265003681183, -0.9661059379577637, -0.6978566646575928, -0.419755756855011, 0.8434520363807678, 0.255583792924881, 0.062430765479803085, 0.8964371085166931, 0.884096086025238, 0.6092913746833801, -0.17146719992160797, -0.4985817074775696, -0.656024694442749, -0.10282114148139954, 0.08098220825195312, -0.21586918830871582, -0.0377766452729702, 1.232101559638977, -0.1913226842880249, 0.5897392630577087, 0.24808824062347412, 0.25986719131469727, -0.4057534635066986, -0.4178415834903717, -0.06961371749639511, 0.02954966202378273, -0.025146078318357468, -0.21389654278755188, -0.784217894077301, 0.23244363069534302, -0.4084351062774658, 0.2666129469871521, -0.8043866753578186, 0.5709317326545715, -0.6835458874702454, 0.06601043790578842, 0.13865657150745392, -0.45581120252609253, 0.23793642222881317, 1.1059991121292114, 0.4601667523384094, 0.5790854096412659, -1.0149567127227783, 0.32974767684936523, 1.2678585052490234, -0.02065245993435383, 0.8268077969551086, -0.3294222354888916, -0.7147020697593689, -0.42567917704582214, -0.13386748731136322, -0.1397954225540161, 0.1937233954668045, -0.9616596698760986, 0.4272739589214325, -0.15431734919548035, -0.10645318776369095, -0.571334958076477, -0.37450653314590454, -0.0024283656384795904, -0.30438101291656494, -0.21189257502555847, 0.23067213594913483, -0.39856189489364624, -0.5791826844215393, -0.0723988488316536, -0.06602315604686737, 0.1661890298128128, 0.14460928738117218, -0.46196457743644714, 0.4615562856197357, -0.22113418579101562, 0.45929375290870667, 0.7816835641860962, 0.912446916103363, -0.40592771768569946, 0.2757537364959717, -0.10550423711538315, 0.08709099143743515, -0.5236803293228149, 0.6491420269012451, -0.2335590422153473, -0.46247488260269165, -0.6823977828025818, 0.6868871450424194, -0.3725478947162628, 0.23677411675453186, -0.19825118780136108, -0.6601445078849792, -0.0412074439227581, 0.16468432545661926, 0.3868798315525055, 0.5964398980140686, 0.12443838268518448, 1.1331695318222046, -0.46577680110931396, -0.2513834536075592, -0.9439360499382019, -0.6121854186058044, -0.0695844441652298, 0.5076531171798706, 0.28728169202804565, 0.8445091843605042, 0.027164112776517868, -0.3857850730419159, -0.047165192663669586, 0.2694653570652008, -0.6885047554969788, 0.8547968864440918, -0.047887686640024185, -0.42428743839263916, 0.043557051569223404, 0.10341528803110123, 0.4924052953720093, 0.3464851677417755, -0.02329093962907791, 0.13659577071666718, -0.4382666349411011, -0.6578992605209351, 0.4019708037376404, -0.4473770558834076, 0.31926974654197693, 0.8391631841659546, -0.7732710838317871, -0.08716151863336563, -0.0881853848695755, 0.27656757831573486, -0.2031879723072052, 0.4269374907016754, -0.4054979383945465, -0.054191604256629944, 0.10851691663265228, 0.48531684279441833, -0.3127691149711609, 0.17944267392158508, -1.3761875629425049, 0.17332610487937927, -0.4504866898059845, -0.7760646939277649, 0.016121644526720047, 0.27995914220809937, 0.42481979727745056, 0.8819493055343628, -0.5883708000183105, 0.613877534866333, -0.844429612159729, -0.4847838878631592, 0.08141100406646729, -0.1325160264968872, -0.31302812695503235, 0.039173901081085205, 0.01924607902765274, 0.6400196552276611, 1.0722285509109497, 0.37378379702568054, 0.009438256733119488, -0.7984757423400879, -0.6702991127967834, 0.4092678725719452, 0.05335669219493866, -1.0192815065383911, 0.49395525455474854, 0.4380282163619995, -0.41549909114837646, -0.4614569842815399, 0.04826856777071953, -0.4322892129421234, 0.6144074201583862, 0.23071788251399994, -0.4803559184074402, 0.6366649866104126, -1.5128695964813232, 0.6829373240470886, -0.3696657717227936, -0.10656656324863434, -1.1498292684555054, -0.10952278226613998, 0.31823664903640747, -0.599574089050293, 0.32025131583213806, 0.10931175947189331, -0.5265302062034607, 0.5515128970146179, -1.4233766794204712, -0.02090873196721077, 0.5294768810272217, 0.6650326251983643, -0.5555118918418884, 0.21592845022678375, 0.7000410556793213, -0.4604731798171997, -0.2285413146018982, -0.38704898953437805, -0.05261223763227463, 0.2743253707885742, -0.6875653862953186, 0.38347989320755005, 0.1123439148068428, -0.15999405086040497, 0.6995677947998047, -0.21490055322647095, 0.05613154545426369, 0.8076132535934448, 0.41582757234573364, -0.11000295728445053, 0.4901885688304901, 0.4626691937446594, -0.06892221421003342, 0.31561920046806335, 0.20296721160411835, 0.3463672697544098, 0.5543058514595032, 0.09522700309753418, 0.4097181558609009, -0.5780956149101257, -0.005944650154560804, 0.9923305511474609, -0.22271306812763214, -0.06009487435221672, 0.43456804752349854, -0.06315818428993225, 0.3160652220249176, 0.3227051794528961, -1.2556867599487305, 0.1094949021935463, 0.4330500662326813, 0.4446854591369629, -0.38759809732437134, 1.253341555595398, -0.48770084977149963, 0.39213210344314575, 0.6561617255210876, 0.01175631769001484, -1.4401929378509521, 0.25813981890678406, -0.0869867131114006, 0.2527051866054535, 0.5219021439552307, -0.7710943222045898, -0.502288281917572, 0.36589694023132324, -0.02156897261738777, -0.9628597497940063, -1.0231140851974487, 0.05403251573443413, -0.8539638519287109, 0.5739473104476929, 0.9592582583427429, -0.40241503715515137, -0.6959661245346069, -0.07285113632678986, -0.20479494333267212, 0.3147405683994293, -0.2801092565059662, -0.09903153032064438, -0.06362820416688919, -0.5531071424484253, 0.9852793216705322, 0.4686846137046814, -0.10810867697000504, 0.16039171814918518, 0.5216160416603088, 0.4814084470272064, 0.01826103962957859, 0.311475545167923, -1.437683343887329, -0.19242380559444427, -0.8690048456192017, -0.05504974350333214, -0.24400286376476288, -0.8357542753219604, 0.6281293630599976, -0.007102589122951031, 0.3114454448223114, 0.5856249332427979, -0.34720948338508606, 0.6837885975837708, -0.16887855529785156, -1.0213953256607056, 1.0916450023651123, 0.7601028084754944, 0.005072042811661959, 0.37040650844573975, -0.8399266600608826, 0.8633638024330139, -0.5051921010017395, -0.18076835572719574, 1.1269594430923462, -0.20005658268928528, -0.6117616891860962, 0.3024475872516632, -0.14709429442882538, 0.5861254334449768, 0.06959065049886703, 0.40284061431884766, 0.43598484992980957, 0.39835959672927856, 0.01679075136780739, -0.0043191807344555855, -0.6331686973571777, -0.4553890824317932, 0.2892243266105652, -0.7924763560295105, 0.6439278721809387, 0.45910224318504333, 0.44843727350234985, -0.7085795998573303, 0.4434281289577484, -1.0211868286132812, -0.9795905351638794, 0.16782252490520477, -0.4171179234981537, -0.02062802016735077, 0.12433972209692001, -0.024296844378113747, -0.3530270457267761, -0.26414546370506287, -0.48727771639823914, 0.5914669632911682, 0.5884433388710022, -0.2493874877691269, 0.5931037068367004, 0.4651464819908142, 0.3419938087463379, 0.2649935185909271, 0.8161689639091492, -0.24018068611621857, -0.7562369704246521, 0.4825790524482727, -0.27339425683021545, 0.30201640725135803, 0.10265267640352249, 0.14127951860427856, -0.14674679934978485, -0.0020365258678793907, -0.22313052415847778, -0.6880075931549072, -1.0861799716949463, -0.8277223706245422, 0.2167385369539261, 0.35929930210113525, 0.275425523519516, -0.7023922204971313, -0.14019082486629486, -0.07244716584682465, -0.07591179758310318, 0.13641954958438873, 0.5188233256340027, -0.7095593810081482, -0.10833249986171722, 0.5900773406028748, -0.2599678039550781, -0.2537965178489685, -0.22567127645015717, 0.3643929362297058, 0.471750408411026, 0.5081964135169983, -0.0616806261241436, -0.03824888542294502, -0.10678894072771072, -0.7398542165756226, 1.0492593050003052, 0.10052524507045746, 0.43904393911361694, -0.2446160912513733, -0.14896680414676666, 0.6506040692329407, -0.6137576699256897, -0.552798330783844, -0.11905038356781006, -0.4498099386692047, 0.3388431966304779, -1.0481294393539429, -0.511561930179596, 0.2617797553539276, -0.03969283774495125, 0.34726932644844055, -0.04525715485215187, 0.0466868095099926, -0.08027619868516922, -0.30008676648139954, -0.18662714958190918, 0.26586320996284485, -0.2496820092201233, 0.16212183237075806, -0.9516521096229553, 0.8715143203735352, 0.6339060068130493, 0.34434354305267334, 0.39668670296669006, -0.752951443195343, 0.2264636605978012, -0.4486905038356781, 1.1103181838989258, -0.012982516549527645, -0.03881646320223808, 0.2113770991563797, 0.5233463644981384, 0.022641710937023163, -0.08229172974824905, 0.36143946647644043, 0.6638634204864502, 0.040595538914203644, -0.41929954290390015, -0.7553858757019043, 0.14140424132347107, -0.24932505190372467, -0.36415913701057434, 0.7858063578605652, 0.27084454894065857, -0.9763717651367188, -0.43730610609054565, 0.2595875561237335, 0.40938130021095276, 0.13661500811576843, 0.7252671122550964, 0.658119261264801, 0.34239786863327026, -0.29389551281929016, 0.0663382038474083, 1.066138744354248, -0.2933747470378876, -0.45835167169570923, -0.08853684365749359, -0.28651314973831177, 0.23629705607891083, 0.3353695869445801, 0.15714913606643677, -0.9095935225486755, 0.06468123197555542, -0.21597591042518616, 0.9215549230575562, -0.1537371128797531, -0.42862817645072937, -0.16316257417201996, 0.15004248917102814, -0.2591364085674286, 0.3505314588546753, -0.4369513690471649, 0.15262830257415771, -0.060312557965517044, -0.004338428843766451, -0.6793881058692932, -0.08806072175502777, 0.07196317613124847, -0.1214432418346405, 1.0737804174423218, 0.4529466927051544, 0.5072273015975952, 0.6969516277313232, 0.44696879386901855, -0.7463787794113159, 0.247078076004982, 0.585378110408783, -0.11181575804948807, -0.3708183467388153, 0.13204222917556763, -0.36518609523773193, -0.6555024981498718, -0.03477053716778755, 0.2726665437221527, -0.48607486486434937, 0.5369136929512024, 0.06551483273506165, -1.1346943378448486, 0.058500953018665314, -0.5126280188560486, -0.24822747707366943, 0.4048791527748108, -0.06417085230350494, -0.07283346354961395, -0.3515406847000122, -0.0014349985867738724, 0.013400205411016941, -0.5121719837188721, -0.30717891454696655, -0.5355226397514343, -0.25998547673225403, 0.07617444545030594, -0.2694673240184784, 0.7267241477966309, -0.8075230121612549, 0.6664966940879822, -0.4047805964946747, -0.44155630469322205, -0.47015395760536194, -0.8281689286231995, -0.3850107789039612, 0.13341230154037476, 0.5280814170837402, -0.18902890384197235, 0.4970743954181671, -0.02280663140118122, 0.604261040687561, 0.31305527687072754, -0.381265252828598, -0.8390073776245117, -0.31541329622268677, 0.37790852785110474, 0.4667574465274811, -0.5015594363212585, -0.0770694836974144, 0.4014793336391449, -0.7554817199707031, 0.23623237013816833, -0.4570135772228241, -0.8285741806030273, 0.24983727931976318, -1.4740923643112183, 0.5466559529304504, -0.7892099022865295, -0.25618961453437805, 0.20446430146694183, -0.6381643414497375, 0.3181447684764862, 0.6106092929840088, -0.3723491430282593, -0.3728918433189392, -0.13856399059295654, -0.08577951788902283, -0.00848112627863884, -0.11703699827194214, 0.12066993117332458, -0.9327989220619202, 0.02618301846086979, -0.9840651750564575, 1.0167639255523682, -1.0671809911727905, 0.07515107840299606, 0.3231837749481201, 0.3332497477531433, -0.8458799719810486, 0.5272032618522644, 0.1201867163181305, 0.11948695033788681, -0.45300036668777466, 0.3834494352340698, 0.6264209747314453, 0.599509596824646, -0.374298095703125, 0.36217042803764343, -0.1975831687450409, 0.7956404685974121, -0.5889014005661011, -0.5339803695678711, 0.49130919575691223, 0.08046988397836685, 0.4343663454055786, -0.1506638377904892, 0.10568021982908249, 0.717865526676178, -0.12067557871341705, 0.4530694782733917, 0.08009933680295944, -0.23436829447746277, -0.13419483602046967, -0.8214011192321777, -0.6178597807884216, 0.6548515558242798, 0.4955308735370636, -0.09083706885576248, -0.4512805640697479, -0.3860151469707489, -0.43357303738594055, -0.7193411588668823, -0.35088759660720825, 0.13288229703903198, 0.06392865628004074, 0.3675440549850464, -0.4521467387676239, 0.0018094426486641169, -0.9505307078361511, 0.25381407141685486, 0.36590418219566345, -0.16709700226783752, 0.13177430629730225, -0.4011762738227844, -0.02315637096762657, -0.45567765831947327, -0.18359814584255219, 0.30653390288352966, 0.43717822432518005, 0.42434799671173096, 0.9386274814605713, -0.2434729039669037, -0.42683231830596924, -0.6883277297019958, -0.22883084416389465, 0.6833589673042297, -0.49495822191238403, 0.21746116876602173, 0.7585664391517639, -0.32625988125801086, -0.0023964312858879566, -0.23995567858219147, -0.6388311982154846, -0.2489771842956543, 0.8709848523139954, 0.00437292130663991, -0.28350839018821716, 0.5508521199226379, -0.10097573697566986, -0.670014500617981, -1.1408134698867798, -1.0356569290161133, -0.3707665205001831, 0.431742399930954, -0.38056090474128723, -0.08091616630554199, 0.30867597460746765, 0.35022661089897156, 0.019379787147045135, 0.27007949352264404, 0.44637930393218994, 0.460889995098114, 0.13506102561950684, -0.09967107325792313, -0.2705021798610687, -0.27098241448402405, 1.3495948314666748, -0.15339477360248566, -1.0672557353973389, -0.33763429522514343, -0.41186589002609253, -0.2815941572189331, -0.5863582491874695, 0.9839210510253906, -0.5760766863822937, -0.17578153312206268, -0.24824677407741547, 0.11894690990447998, 0.010811159387230873, 0.003583799581974745, -0.20818547904491425, 0.022874031215906143, -0.28793612122535706, -0.5941913723945618, -0.15889830887317657, -0.20546618103981018, 0.21153776347637177, 0.25881466269493103, 0.2494870126247406, -0.0073820012621581554, -0.029819753021001816, -0.10919789969921112, 0.13007290661334991, -0.43508389592170715, 0.0264702457934618, -1.1751229763031006, -0.5372070074081421, -1.033429741859436, -0.34895947575569153, 0.10095798969268799, 0.1449742168188095, -0.5118466019630432, 0.5534014701843262, 0.03576875850558281, -0.11449405550956726, 0.04390912503004074, 0.7634321451187134, -0.7650648951530457, -0.9309131503105164, -0.6924493312835693, 0.1323714554309845, -0.052524615079164505, -0.9958818554878235, -0.4131135940551758, 0.055321235209703445, -0.17155827581882477, 1.03828763961792, -0.6889525651931763, 0.6876899600028992, -0.712910532951355, -0.822399914264679, 0.5906487703323364, 0.4401390850543976, -0.39062461256980896, 1.0115623474121094, -0.3883531391620636, 0.2500131130218506, 0.5608121752738953, 0.10961123555898666, -0.022826360538601875, -0.1815296858549118, -0.9857027530670166, 0.15034125745296478, -0.12363266199827194, 0.7477816343307495, 0.5235843062400818, -1.2605596780776978, 0.21044960618019104, 0.00824015960097313, -0.9810593128204346, 0.0811607763171196, -0.6975004076957703, 0.4206472635269165, -0.3643746078014374, -0.046890053898096085, -0.12687622010707855, 0.14006859064102173, -0.19895048439502716, 0.04498439282178879, -0.7954720854759216, -0.29205361008644104, 0.15564973652362823, -0.004033767152577639, -0.027053792029619217, -0.02893049642443657, 0.35150501132011414, 0.0567520447075367, 0.2974556088447571, -0.18406513333320618, 0.2546597123146057, -0.05775463208556175, 0.10449963063001633, -0.16337867081165314, -0.013010585680603981, 0.7128965854644775, -0.380679726600647, 0.6035832166671753, 0.819031298160553, 0.03169233724474907, 0.6147820949554443, -0.40372323989868164, -1.1639207601547241, 0.2651882767677307, -0.12414883077144623, -0.41352197527885437, -0.253324419260025, -0.03660452365875244, 0.12473229318857193, 0.4056057631969452, -0.4478911757469177, 0.10200315713882446, -0.08051211386919022, 0.6439270377159119, 0.8844406604766846, -0.518193781375885, -0.4189673066139221, -0.1971292793750763, -0.6889083385467529, -0.27409085631370544, -0.6148282289505005, 0.45251035690307617, -0.27149173617362976, -0.6186664700508118, -0.10882590711116791, 0.399963915348053, -0.17530480027198792, -0.04132836312055588, 0.4578610956668854, -0.5627013444900513, -0.14350062608718872, -0.05735687166452408, -0.22395043075084686, -0.2189740240573883, -0.39309370517730713, 0.7436850070953369, -0.11974852532148361, -0.5160647034645081, 0.4505244493484497, -0.5023061633110046, 0.6223374009132385, 0.07217037677764893, 0.39916837215423584, 0.8933805227279663, -0.06250115483999252, 0.18108877539634705, 0.4424054026603699, 0.4426245391368866, 0.12537074089050293, 0.5792424082756042, -0.5664463043212891, -0.16101786494255066, 0.37214526534080505, -0.3030838072299957, 0.6862532496452332, -0.07041115313768387, -0.44581225514411926, 0.39160314202308655, 0.21988356113433838, -0.011972323060035706, -0.09353175759315491, 0.25375330448150635, 0.03223129361867905, 0.3648477792739868, 0.1981814056634903, -0.061231598258018494, -0.36633405089378357, 0.5565018057823181, 0.832491397857666, 0.30396658182144165, -0.40838924050331116, -0.73195880651474, -0.07729289680719376, 0.1891610026359558, 0.11347048729658127, -0.2482658177614212, 0.08221530169248581, 0.035292331129312515, 0.5383471250534058, 0.2554282248020172, -0.4389464557170868, 0.9762776494026184, 0.6262632012367249, -0.0458238311111927, -0.4379040598869324, 0.47286275029182434, 0.2053256779909134, 0.7815014123916626, 1.0616977214813232, 0.20873278379440308, 0.47969359159469604, 1.071399450302124, 0.06115727126598358, -0.48845231533050537, 0.5817351341247559, 0.3646508753299713, -0.9768431782722473, -0.1670655757188797, 0.11847870796918869, 0.24545109272003174, -0.021306512877345085, -0.9383782744407654, 0.10159766674041748, -0.03039902076125145, 0.35629791021347046, 0.07116956263780594, -0.5046842694282532, 0.14187806844711304, 0.012269883416593075, 0.012147854082286358, 0.7844591736793518, 0.2694138288497925, 0.5157852172851562, -0.45369112491607666, 0.4694713056087494, 0.7599905133247375, 0.10788995772600174, -0.07831839472055435, -0.4767370820045471, -0.5323095321655273, 0.47014230489730835, 1.037203073501587, -0.2852858304977417, 0.29639580845832825, 0.10428740829229355, -0.016771165654063225, -0.5864904522895813, 0.008835836313664913, -0.7120616436004639, 0.11474312841892242, 0.06555149704217911, 0.010926294140517712, -0.06230155751109123, 0.0935145765542984, 0.4475664496421814, 0.7091349959373474, -0.7032405138015747, -0.5779503583908081, 0.4828108549118042, -0.6581639051437378, 0.10871463268995285, -0.7677887082099915, 0.5137932300567627, -0.03613964468240738, -0.010126940906047821, -0.6058241128921509, 0.07675523310899734, -1.4449694156646729, -0.8779105544090271, -0.038837578147649765, -0.29819372296333313, 0.27018797397613525, 0.7175411581993103, -0.2489853948354721, 0.2776848375797272, -0.47120875120162964, 0.15010923147201538, -0.16877484321594238, 1.1959537267684937, 0.31803929805755615, -0.023488067090511322, 0.709187388420105, 0.18579907715320587, -0.5544708371162415, 0.598550021648407, 0.7795346975326538, -0.11057274788618088, 0.7153486609458923, -0.8375911116600037, -0.27645668387413025, 0.11059070378541946, 0.07281975448131561, 0.21779319643974304, 0.13753646612167358, 0.3117067217826843, 0.0076508610509335995, -0.06545668095350266, 0.48600107431411743, -0.6562353372573853, -0.686970055103302, -0.4570443034172058, 0.10035411268472672, 0.43671858310699463, -0.23702768981456757, 0.5454573035240173, -0.9396570920944214, 4.163726806640625, 0.5036536455154419, 0.372759610414505, 0.4614114463329315, 0.957717776298523, 1.353744387626648, 0.17188681662082672, 0.11264494061470032, -0.18678754568099976, -0.36206376552581787, -0.39872413873672485, -0.06686457246541977, -0.10744047164916992, -0.08572313189506531, 0.08237674087285995, 0.42123883962631226, -0.08763866126537323, -0.01184041891247034, -0.16296692192554474, -0.48102888464927673, -1.1126559972763062, 0.10056495666503906, -0.05211510881781578, -0.27206698060035706, 0.36157435178756714, 0.7776259183883667, 0.34361985325813293, -0.05270653963088989, -0.5247476696968079, -0.03942092880606651, -0.8860506415367126, -0.2744324803352356, -0.22823642194271088, -0.2037091702222824, -1.4178615808486938, 0.7334827780723572, 0.2487734705209732, 0.01513553224503994, 1.025606632232666, -0.3015810549259186, 0.2229364514350891, -0.49255549907684326, 0.11430639028549194, -0.1163601353764534, -0.1292291134595871, 0.7969931364059448, 0.6422995924949646, 0.973949134349823, 1.0754812955856323, -0.6911993622779846, 0.6628767251968384, 0.8708131909370422, 0.756990373134613, -0.27508485317230225, -1.0291821956634521, -0.4620130658149719, -0.16685378551483154, -0.003533346578478813, 0.363974928855896, -0.5299683213233948, 0.6735625863075256, -0.3541018068790436, -0.021824747323989868, -0.03304057940840721, 0.2724188566207886, 0.41726163029670715, 0.6356905698776245, 0.7767531871795654, -0.3112681210041046, -0.09354466199874878, -0.6504101753234863, 0.11881744116544724, -0.6808304190635681, -0.24110010266304016, 0.11280220001935959, -0.0045458171516656876, 0.06354216486215591, 0.43881621956825256, -0.21735142171382904, -0.014387843199074268, -0.48967722058296204, -0.058859001845121384, -0.2338617891073227, 0.6025159358978271, 0.1719714105129242, 0.24867981672286987, 0.37816351652145386, 0.04811406508088112, -0.41410738229751587, 0.40902596712112427, -0.38562479615211487, 0.3650992214679718, -0.017886744812130928, 0.4649982452392578, -0.7592097520828247 ]
Quantum Gravity, the Origin of Time and Time's Arrow
The local Lorentz and diffeomorphism symmetries of Einstein's gravitational theory are spontaneously broken by a Higgs mechanism by invoking a phase transition in the early Universe, at a critical temperature $T_c$ below which the symmetry is restored. The spontaneous breakdown of the vacuum state generates an external time and the wave function of the Universe satisfies a time dependent Schrodinger equation, which reduces to the Wheeler-deWitt equation in the classical regime for $T < T_c$, allowing a semi-classical WKB approximation to the wave function. The conservation of energy is spontaneously violated for $T > T_c$ and matter is created fractions of seconds after the big bang, generating the matter in the Universe. The time direction of the vacuum expectation value of the scalar Higgs field generates a time asymmetry, which defines the cosmological arrow of time and the direction of increasing entropy as the Lorentz symmetry is restored at low temperatures.
J. W. Moffat
gr-qc
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209001
gr-qc/9209002
[ 0.29374659061431885, 0.5712034106254578, 0.1659485250711441, 0.47081515192985535, -0.16418960690498352, -0.713523805141449, -0.38524797558784485, 0.14049173891544342, 0.09743344038724899, 1.6848857402801514, 0.6951879262924194, 0.37753304839134216, -0.25233206152915955, -0.5620325803756714, -0.5283018350601196, 0.8865224719047546, -0.08917569369077682, -1.0922845602035522, -1.2318075895309448, 0.11903591454029083, -0.19574491679668427, 0.039485540241003036, -0.7329403758049011, -0.39080870151519775, -0.03108324483036995, 0.6802216172218323, 0.41000884771347046, 0.7184550166130066, 0.802731990814209, 0.7484588623046875, 0.4563017785549164, 0.1468868851661682, -0.06595639139413834, -0.9903414249420166, -0.09606730192899704, 0.029174981638789177, -0.17929072678089142, -0.4398270547389984, 0.3118310868740082, -0.05256154388189316, 0.23941326141357422, -0.27133074402809143, 0.19087769091129303, -0.15315434336662292, -1.338383436203003, -0.3215087354183197, 0.3044719398021698, 0.7707586288452148, -0.016949016600847244, -0.904472827911377, 0.09727776795625687, -0.3375186324119568, 0.7134900093078613, -0.5100345015525818, -0.0192688200622797, 0.5579066276550293, 0.30553990602493286, 0.02080589160323143, -0.6375256180763245, -0.7157680988311768, 0.21015223860740662, 0.2597207725048065, 0.19293807446956635, -0.6783889532089233, -0.5751529932022095, 1.5724865198135376, -0.6028933525085449, 0.6143092513084412, 0.34993383288383484, -0.6133826971054077, -0.6391833424568176, 0.1831807643175125, 0.12687653303146362, 0.8184205889701843, -0.2905619144439697, 0.613644003868103, -0.4405445456504822, -0.20926430821418762, -0.38985297083854675, 0.23549394309520721, -0.5371668338775635, 0.43507087230682373, -0.08699364960193634, 0.6643823385238647, -0.8389140367507935, -0.2913118004798889, -0.15464454889297485, -0.44122838973999023, 0.7967929244041443, 0.2025402933359146, -0.029690351337194443, 0.15050950646400452, -0.5453124046325684, 0.2635975182056427, 0.9908300638198853, 0.7414796948432922, -0.23696844279766083, 0.13941825926303864, -0.10862921178340912, -0.12797410786151886, -0.42123833298683167, 0.853582501411438, -0.7100176811218262, 0.41592589020729065, -1.048758864402771, 0.655576229095459, -0.2698318064212799, 0.11665719002485275, -0.6395348310470581, -1.0594823360443115, 0.2136131227016449, 0.32710155844688416, 1.1974990367889404, 0.3085845410823822, 0.0020077999215573072, 0.6734163761138916, -0.3174189031124115, -0.026683581992983818, -0.8928999304771423, -0.5125032663345337, -0.758974015712738, 0.7153386473655701, 0.5653336644172668, 0.0802685022354126, -0.3557828664779663, -0.6133006811141968, -0.10731155425310135, 0.2954116761684418, -1.027551531791687, 1.1924355030059814, 0.35450124740600586, -0.34966492652893066, 0.04199407994747162, 0.8448107838630676, -0.01043473370373249, -0.07041501998901367, 0.04141756147146225, 0.66641765832901, -0.07094555348157883, -0.016965871676802635, 0.1602589190006256, -0.39594611525535583, -0.2617330551147461, 1.4084231853485107, -0.354918509721756, 0.2202756553888321, 1.0774587392807007, -0.06101871654391289, -0.39022117853164673, 0.45414331555366516, 0.11823225766420364, -0.20182807743549347, -0.4110207259654999, 0.0970529094338417, -0.10644125938415527, 0.2988376021385193, -0.9226483702659607, -0.12063797563314438, 0.27094921469688416, -0.19165430963039398, 0.3129864037036896, 0.01368519477546215, 0.12069240212440491, 0.2433878779411316, -0.195174440741539, -0.23505204916000366, -1.2845735549926758, -0.5058276653289795, 0.20084437727928162, 0.2676125168800354, -0.5183489322662354, 0.5121349692344666, 0.28736433386802673, 1.0721954107284546, 0.8918973207473755, 0.20569343864917755, 0.08402681350708008, 0.29873207211494446, -0.25655892491340637, 0.23276248574256897, -0.01726270280778408, 0.3137754201889038, 0.5321997404098511, 0.3564419448375702, -0.5995259284973145, -0.25922179222106934, 0.33516252040863037, -0.10801789909601212, -0.25542452931404114, -0.33382683992385864, -0.39516720175743103, 0.3825119733810425, -0.9069643020629883, 0.3917613625526428, -0.8830825686454773, 0.26665198802948, -0.8678421378135681, -0.5057001113891602, -0.6175090670585632, -0.3139325976371765, 0.4862021207809448, -0.002984606893733144, -0.9141368865966797, 0.4275237023830414, -0.4315377175807953, -0.525608479976654, 0.8759915232658386, 0.9820665121078491, -0.31448549032211304, 0.012523366138339043, 0.43079301714897156, -0.18827570974826813, 0.2671922445297241, 0.03903089836239815, 0.6292197704315186, -0.10653245449066162, -0.29678553342819214, 0.2749759256839752, -0.34430593252182007, 0.4185872972011566, 0.5107772946357727, 0.18606261909008026, -0.36846914887428284, 0.8113076090812683, -0.4859170913696289, -0.686062216758728, 0.10693096369504929, 0.5948928594589233, -0.5270925760269165, 0.5637539625167847, -0.2907876670360565, 0.5547651648521423, 0.3342396914958954, 0.07543600350618362, 0.6918506026268005, 0.1310689002275467, 0.529071033000946, 0.8714314699172974, -0.06563158333301544, -0.2316187024116516, -0.17381031811237335, -0.06622033566236496, 0.16840273141860962, -0.24242302775382996, -0.161018505692482, 0.8418350219726562, -0.28620222210884094, -0.6587504744529724, -1.3190714120864868, 0.29670625925064087, -1.0265262126922607, 0.8188542723655701, -0.08916512876749039, 0.2068924605846405, -1.1755377054214478, 0.4939734935760498, -0.20412038266658783, 0.19953913986682892, 0.19523878395557404, -0.1265803873538971, -0.4231328070163727, 0.14253917336463928, -0.45737311244010925, -0.3634544312953949, 0.30064281821250916, -0.016276204958558083, -0.17527256906032562, -0.021405689418315887, 0.2553384602069855, 0.3263128101825714, -1.5290383100509644, -0.3336942493915558, -0.7343586683273315, 0.06921496987342834, -0.3388076424598694, 0.35823073983192444, 0.8973021507263184, -0.2858625054359436, 0.6868512630462646, 0.3026403486728668, 0.08440186828374863, 0.5421479940414429, -0.6856968998908997, -0.44633927941322327, -0.03524865210056305, 0.4010978639125824, -1.1217858791351318, -0.28739267587661743, -0.416594922542572, 0.28249073028564453, -0.8469885587692261, -0.24642708897590637, 0.91713947057724, 0.0038857499603182077, 0.19573108851909637, 0.34884607791900635, -0.16709531843662262, -0.3502844274044037, -0.4018949270248413, -0.6751256585121155, 0.725837230682373, -0.366000235080719, -0.09665203094482422, -0.6828082203865051, -0.6381728053092957, 1.226945161819458, 0.5953201055526733, -0.031248943880200386, 0.33227360248565674, 0.10969500243663788, -0.3709360361099243, 0.6389564275741577, 0.30872195959091187, 0.7531803846359253, -0.13945293426513672, 0.6761363744735718, 0.6766287684440613, -0.12357567250728607, 0.34899744391441345, -0.6939119100570679, -0.1952551007270813, 0.15692239999771118, 0.491075336933136, -1.0203286409378052, 0.4487368166446686, 1.4150210618972778, 0.014622175134718418, -0.8500550389289856, 0.4745780825614929, -1.3015154600143433, -0.6454713344573975, 0.17964281141757965, 0.3374924957752228, 0.2493724524974823, 0.3714427053928375, 0.7339980602264404, 0.051435161381959915, -0.7569015026092529, -0.6553948521614075, 0.42030665278434753, 0.104275643825531, -0.34414342045783997, -0.43217191100120544, 0.8342546224594116, 0.12155573815107346, -0.4651012718677521, 0.27079513669013977, -0.7371227741241455, -0.5392298698425293, 0.4411639869213104, -0.7710035443305969, 0.5869200825691223, 0.4286304712295532, 0.04257599636912346, 0.19537653028964996, -0.3264094889163971, -0.5716695189476013, -0.35714054107666016, -0.8405287265777588, -0.4484403133392334, -0.5750944018363953, 0.21429428458213806, 0.07489548623561859, -0.7482385039329529, -0.4488919675350189, -1.1471754312515259, -0.08733002841472626, 0.48767298460006714, 0.46934694051742554, -0.8647971749305725, 0.8998387455940247, 0.30515530705451965, -0.6404436826705933, 0.7277902960777283, 0.1381150782108307, 0.47356048226356506, 0.8235934972763062, 0.14710600674152374, 0.6454959511756897, -0.28552767634391785, -0.8377361297607422, 0.30199092626571655, 0.9421383142471313, 0.1848902851343155, 0.1264360547065735, 0.13595236837863922, 0.3945108950138092, -0.792506992816925, -0.24326907098293304, -0.044487837702035904, -0.35139307379722595, -0.14869949221611023, 0.31986314058303833, -0.36526405811309814, -0.2259722501039505, -0.17927362024784088, 0.39903220534324646, 0.587246298789978, 0.2593006193637848, 0.36157265305519104, 0.5347699522972107, 0.06707247346639633, 0.35114121437072754, 0.3558465242385864, -0.7924352288246155, 0.09483183175325394, -0.052959538996219635, 0.32025471329689026, 0.6336942911148071, -0.5305129885673523, -0.020956242457032204, -0.6462300419807434, 0.13422664999961853, -0.23073016107082367, 0.6580019593238831, 0.33885109424591064, -0.5148505568504333, 0.27746325731277466, 0.4970284402370453, 0.1837768703699112, -0.9857011437416077, 0.4835182726383209, 0.6473831534385681, 0.37203001976013184, 0.4604794383049011, -0.3388710916042328, 0.03885962814092636, -0.6306912899017334, 0.6361278295516968, 0.16872817277908325, -0.17417943477630615, -0.2341558188199997, -0.45370280742645264, 0.1472213715314865, 0.3520289659500122, 0.2766741216182709, 0.7262102961540222, 0.29379802942276, 0.14395178854465485, -0.5266344547271729, -0.06448369473218918, 1.4756596088409424, -0.11356683820486069, 0.3574813902378082, -0.8584540486335754, 0.19000360369682312, -0.33813199400901794, 0.3525087535381317, -0.2921468913555145, -0.8772395849227905, -0.5526922941207886, -1.0656700134277344, 0.4072897732257843, -0.23932823538780212, -0.4549359679222107, 0.5777672529220581, -0.22605149447917938, 0.07191701978445053, 0.40123265981674194, 0.07200425863265991, 0.17719751596450806, -0.3367336690425873, 0.38935422897338867, 0.029133828356862068, -0.036145031452178955, 0.23400114476680756, 0.07807464897632599, 0.7479307651519775, 0.650025486946106, 0.6032936573028564, -0.10437767952680588, 0.2781575620174408, 0.2869300842285156, -0.11180470138788223, 0.1280311942100525, -0.5280659198760986, -0.035958338528871536, -0.5112515091896057, -0.6850162744522095, -0.37739816308021545, -0.5793315172195435, 0.37359532713890076, -0.7194043397903442, -0.4031604528427124, 0.48786070942878723, -0.4120500981807709, -0.7868056297302246, -0.7302529215812683, -0.8668457865715027, 0.5373270511627197, -0.003269993234425783, -0.2786012589931488, 0.1409909427165985, 0.0404878593981266, -0.13068033754825592, -0.23007798194885254, 0.11668770760297775, -0.6881785988807678, 0.24414095282554626, 0.7742139101028442, -0.043137166649103165, 0.3522414565086365, -0.1745026856660843, 0.6052730679512024, -0.6435539722442627, 0.28117460012435913, -0.6313443779945374, -0.30912265181541443, -0.6988389492034912, -0.6039954423904419, 0.6693425178527832, 0.0029019347857683897, -0.27338770031929016, 0.6500899791717529, 0.06612012535333633, 0.6228182911872864, -0.25282976031303406, -0.47848328948020935, 0.06051533296704292, 0.2535995543003082, 0.10917657613754272, -0.02837611734867096, -0.6152159571647644, 0.6077409982681274, 0.18504904210567474, 0.44749805331230164, -0.13914012908935547, -0.3452562689781189, 0.2852730453014374, -0.4315308928489685, 0.8314098715782166, -0.7242742776870728, -0.5677277445793152, -0.750887393951416, -0.36627620458602905, -0.31551024317741394, -0.010350104421377182, -0.25233542919158936, -0.7724998593330383, 0.23289459943771362, -0.20508167147636414, 0.5327534079551697, -0.1820802241563797, -0.18779131770133972, -0.8396990299224854, -0.1307796984910965, -0.26434510946273804, 1.4862390756607056, -0.6204110383987427, -0.171522319316864, 0.5451067686080933, -0.04478757455945015, -0.16767233610153198, 0.43629395961761475, -0.0020800712518393993, -0.13166543841362, -1.1513001918792725, -0.2911488115787506, 0.7888687252998352, 0.12742073833942413, -0.5636745095252991, -0.016492826864123344, -0.4782099723815918, 0.051041584461927414, -0.289821058511734, 0.11118265986442566, 0.46678367257118225, -0.4463579058647156, 0.6714773178100586, -0.7253658771514893, 0.08597995340824127, 0.7348161339759827, 0.20865680277347565, 0.5270975828170776, -0.22605237364768982, 0.09144354611635208, -0.9003738760948181, 0.0013109667925164104, -0.7984880208969116, 0.45228859782218933, 0.0007184571586549282, -0.42487436532974243, -0.8069982528686523, -0.6943578124046326, 0.2420935332775116, -0.5131955146789551, 0.4189944863319397, 0.7823175191879272, 0.09516653418540955, 0.34629273414611816, -0.1280325949192047, -0.11395300179719925, -0.1765761822462082, -0.2107730358839035, -0.35557740926742554, -0.3651975989341736, 0.29527902603149414, -0.7759711146354675, -0.22733962535858154, -0.5910196900367737, -0.21510940790176392, 0.015291960909962654, 0.6419923901557922, -1.1818040609359741, 0.8961470127105713, 0.33466917276382446, -0.26160192489624023, -0.7591093182563782, 0.11162688583135605, 0.36113423109054565, -0.6730300784111023, 0.8291528224945068, -0.26866796612739563, -0.09762468934059143, -0.11360371112823486, -0.3539925813674927, -0.9899525046348572, 0.1397208571434021, 0.6612654328346252, -1.2247443199157715, 0.014057690277695656, 0.6195156574249268, 0.24004648625850677, -0.8774924874305725, -0.6673537492752075, -1.6651898622512817, 0.1920178085565567, 0.476392537355423, -0.5052320957183838, 0.009473959915339947, -0.39795586466789246, -0.5145438313484192, -0.13718870282173157, 0.011729959398508072, 0.18327221274375916, 0.8649750351905823, 0.3973739445209503, 0.33173272013664246, -0.9953942894935608, 0.58525550365448, 0.4463384747505188, 0.2840452790260315, -0.8778530359268188, 0.24338530004024506, 0.27443403005599976, -0.6537318825721741, -0.24699518084526062, 0.9305437803268433, -0.17881488800048828, 0.5958483219146729, -0.34436270594596863, 0.3103954493999481, 0.4646903872489929, -0.18187133967876434, -0.3551894426345825, 0.143093541264534, -0.7107618451118469, -0.324957013130188, -0.035231202840805054, -0.22449398040771484, 0.260285884141922, 1.3658621311187744, -0.06613298505544662, -0.3632409870624542, -0.7387439012527466, 0.3159756660461426, -0.13443823158740997, -0.7864162921905518, -0.8706477880477905, -1.4453213214874268, -0.8646462559700012, -0.9830231666564941, -1.2401179075241089, -0.3812519311904907, 0.3331673741340637, -0.583243727684021, 0.5478076338768005, -0.2523794174194336, 0.2583966851234436, -0.3994995653629303, 1.2735142707824707, -0.34822842478752136, -0.3098657429218292, -0.6250715851783752, 0.2061280608177185, 0.23020890355110168, -0.648581862449646, -0.37850266695022583, -1.1201176643371582, -0.01461375318467617, 0.8665179014205933, -0.41747185587882996, 0.4814799129962921, -0.2696972191333771, -0.8182171583175659, 0.15893933176994324, 0.18144139647483826, -0.14670239388942719, 1.0701113939285278, -0.047587860375642776, 0.7696863412857056, 0.2576713562011719, -0.34988167881965637, 0.051014844328165054, 0.3238455653190613, -0.7514938116073608, 0.2604871094226837, -0.019550856202840805, 0.13158276677131653, 0.41955024003982544, -0.450064480304718, -0.15372417867183685, 0.7843906283378601, -0.619733452796936, -0.15789316594600677, -0.49062979221343994, -0.17070114612579346, -0.5957841873168945, 0.42144718766212463, 0.2678636908531189, -0.0169882420450449, -0.8533664345741272, 0.005772885400801897, -0.808422863483429, -0.2995232939720154, 0.026219358667731285, 0.532584547996521, -0.5792221426963806, -0.3176630139350891, 0.6475917100906372, -0.34682413935661316, 0.893922746181488, 0.4383660554885864, -0.22052665054798126, -0.06643912941217422, 0.174913689494133, -0.37456271052360535, -0.4019899368286133, 0.3752526640892029, 0.04535158723592758, 0.47463545203208923, -0.034835826605558395, -0.6933005452156067, 0.06247858330607414, -0.09060727059841156, -0.8613715171813965, 0.10762694478034973, -0.646789014339447, -0.305596262216568, -0.5437630414962769, 0.4692821800708771, -0.21688835322856903, 0.8739334344863892, -0.045684151351451874, 0.10890813171863556, -0.40271374583244324, 1.3971055746078491, 0.25578823685646057, 0.06677436083555222, -0.3743651807308197, 0.6000824570655823, -0.2619449198246002, 0.5913370847702026, 0.13768835365772247, 0.6745885014533997, -1.0198637247085571, -0.731091320514679, -0.30171218514442444, 0.6161260604858398, -0.41233304142951965, -0.1324014812707901, 0.2777467370033264, -0.4946739375591278, -0.279867559671402, -0.18996857106685638, -0.3301801085472107, -0.5912988781929016, -0.3421473205089569, 0.9388872981071472, 0.46364283561706543, -0.7915796041488647, 0.24332952499389648, 0.15364451706409454, 0.6708643436431885, -0.02792251482605934, -0.22418420016765594, 1.239946722984314, 0.6305942535400391, -0.2190839946269989, -0.47059518098831177, 0.07972787320613861, 0.021787535399198532, 0.6436073780059814, -0.7044431567192078, 0.18124833703041077, 0.5657515525817871, 0.376226007938385, 0.960794985294342, 0.16490322351455688, 0.5467941761016846, 0.9479644894599915, -0.0339764729142189, -0.1363716870546341, 0.5816457867622375, 0.10192833840847015, 0.48340073227882385, 0.44621196389198303, -0.8522221446037292, -0.2135314643383026, 0.41593635082244873, -0.030372245237231255, 0.18559178709983826, -0.4042035937309265, -0.6382505893707275, -0.19360589981079102, 0.5299861431121826, 0.5623859167098999, -0.7499258518218994, -0.6631895303726196, -0.4699517786502838, -0.2179216891527176, 0.321772962808609, 0.1588471531867981, -0.4141051471233368, -0.15931884944438934, 0.5233930349349976, -0.14165188372135162, 0.2814815640449524, 0.6019935011863708, 0.29703569412231445, 1.0848153829574585, 0.7710890769958496, -0.18129323422908783, 0.385518342256546, 0.2567123770713806, -0.16897305846214294, -0.6178593039512634, -0.2556597888469696, 0.8766486048698425, -0.5781489610671997, -0.33859434723854065, -0.04772941395640373, -0.4578438401222229, -0.6469232439994812, -0.28867822885513306, 0.3539007902145386, -0.19674940407276154, 0.31703779101371765, 0.4664023220539093, -0.31059831380844116, 0.49533358216285706, 0.8020294904708862, 0.3613280951976776, 0.7025758028030396, 0.12607474625110626, 0.3390410542488098, -0.3456144630908966, 1.1371558904647827, 1.2572593688964844, 0.27290764451026917, 0.5047746300697327, -0.12009476870298386, -0.20903021097183228, 0.32751917839050293, -0.032840795814991, -0.3414614200592041, 0.0563293918967247, -1.0681440830230713, -0.16372019052505493, -0.2757002115249634, 0.3651738464832306, -0.38698044419288635, -0.027626879513263702, 0.2829130291938782, 0.3768360912799835, -0.8480122685432434, 0.45140570402145386, 0.9003137946128845, 0.4425320029258728, 0.2811480760574341, -0.8462601900100708, -0.070008285343647, -0.0506642609834671, 0.15933090448379517, -0.7013468742370605, 0.8364003896713257, -0.6405947208404541, 0.3320832848548889, -0.049855731427669525, -0.39420631527900696, -0.7268872261047363, -1.5313900709152222, 0.14434164762496948, -0.8368554711341858, 0.6044637560844421, 0.5375039577484131, -0.2523389756679535, 0.13260357081890106, -0.593783438205719, 0.26211681962013245, 0.006303096190094948, 0.676113486289978, -0.36865824460983276, 0.29027438163757324, 0.4968665838241577, -0.5130384564399719, -0.9140781164169312, 0.3285242021083832, 0.2648003399372101, -0.1958654224872589, 0.848246157169342, -0.16923736035823822, 0.8047938942909241, 0.004357702098786831, -0.241547629237175, -0.2411484718322754, 0.1837289035320282, 0.9231574535369873, 0.5033414363861084, -0.7716202735900879, 0.309400737285614, -0.7415564060211182, 0.03201627731323242, -0.376985639333725, 0.5947739481925964, 0.391520231962204, 0.15008510649204254, -0.09698193520307541, -0.8308412432670593, 3.977308750152588, 0.44434666633605957, 0.8717790842056274, 0.06249913200736046, 0.5509106516838074, 1.2794183492660522, -0.11594411730766296, 0.08376667648553848, 0.05001440644264221, -0.3118428587913513, 0.4177541434764862, 0.38998597860336304, 1.0474517345428467, 0.5116091966629028, 0.2206718772649765, 0.9276290535926819, 0.15494224429130554, 0.21874992549419403, -0.26043418049812317, -0.45075151324272156, -1.1556814908981323, 0.7270764708518982, 0.2537577152252197, 0.3308456242084503, 0.36031779646873474, 1.022496223449707, 0.13372495770454407, -0.9737510085105896, -0.4302171766757965, -0.6373645663261414, 0.08997059613466263, -0.8780027031898499, 0.7063503265380859, -0.12682096660137177, -0.7744948863983154, 0.2388230413198471, 0.4854130446910858, -0.5153358578681946, 0.7659926414489746, -0.008878251537680626, -0.22197258472442627, -1.1347854137420654, 0.776940643787384, -0.6858267188072205, -0.6224265694618225, 0.18210726976394653, 0.9264385104179382, 0.2898145318031311, 0.47344955801963806, -0.4308917820453644, -0.1266491562128067, -0.11641550064086914, 0.0011668764054775238, -0.15303058922290802, -0.9682088494300842, -0.3729969263076782, -0.33113178610801697, 0.09695518761873245, -0.29899272322654724, -0.1778792291879654, 1.180307149887085, 0.08981996774673462, -0.3544600009918213, 0.4825684726238251, -0.2881423532962799, 0.45925262570381165, -0.4630982279777527, -0.24969622492790222, 0.4483637809753418, -0.06715026497840881, -1.037521243095398, -0.35573944449424744, -0.5730080604553223, -0.2629888951778412, 0.3053200840950012, 0.11326513439416885, 0.1931791454553604, 0.27322906255722046, 0.08520683646202087, 0.27139541506767273, -0.3558783233165741, -0.055211301892995834, -0.6340839266777039, 1.1573257446289062, -0.04790617898106575, 0.4940252900123596, -0.6661859750747681, -0.1667020469903946, -0.5969590544700623, 0.8373709321022034, 0.27258187532424927, 0.9983208775520325, 0.1594206839799881, 0.48923367261886597, -0.4432711899280548 ]
Results on exact solutions of low energy string theory
A family of solutions to low energy string theory is found. These solutions represent waves traveling along "extremal black strings"
David Garfinkle
gr-qc
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209002
gr-qc/9209003
[ 0.10951247066259384, -0.09471355378627777, 0.49691465497016907, -0.0679827481508255, 0.3191809058189392, 0.4430999457836151, 0.45317453145980835, -0.48007917404174805, -0.6334564685821533, 0.970916211605072, 0.7352055311203003, 0.08745516836643219, 0.14939992129802704, -1.7545360326766968, 0.1499708592891693, 0.7482543587684631, -0.15084189176559448, -0.39004841446876526, -1.488604187965393, 0.030212778598070145, 0.41579899191856384, 0.35538217425346375, -1.0714662075042725, -0.10380291938781738, -0.15178167819976807, 0.5454776883125305, 0.8336917757987976, -0.04047439992427826, 1.199678897857666, 0.6351035833358765, 0.5304234623908997, 0.08978761732578278, -0.003154434496536851, 0.09203691780567169, -0.38339218497276306, 0.0527157261967659, -0.22956056892871857, -1.0725438594818115, 0.6704904437065125, -0.13663877546787262, 0.8063347339630127, 0.3976810872554779, -0.30637940764427185, -0.6858985424041748, -0.9763481616973877, 0.08589165657758713, 0.24341444671154022, 0.17278242111206055, -0.25399479269981384, -1.1160712242126465, -0.006109070498496294, -0.4076952338218689, 0.11644728481769562, -1.3116520643234253, -0.2685299515724182, -0.23985351622104645, 0.1810070127248764, 0.23178616166114807, 0.26854974031448364, 0.5693382024765015, 0.17996846139431, 0.09074338525533676, -0.1490040123462677, -0.820894718170166, -0.367842435836792, 0.3494107723236084, 0.0075024450197815895, 0.6615080237388611, 0.24993076920509338, -0.20869717001914978, -0.1116766706109047, -0.1276671141386032, -0.25169622898101807, 0.6018468737602234, -0.6060691475868225, 0.9692764282226562, -0.4296523332595825, -0.568558394908905, -0.7827990651130676, -0.09492521733045578, -0.5689541697502136, -0.004202915821224451, -0.5970406532287598, 0.6072750091552734, -0.36918359994888306, -0.13987219333648682, 0.1814594715833664, -0.14828261733055115, 0.23456189036369324, 0.029034296050667763, -0.5539031028747559, 0.6509115695953369, -0.22214308381080627, 0.03616008535027504, -0.03674106299877167, 0.5252800583839417, -0.47791746258735657, 1.1146422624588013, -0.02757197804749012, -0.20730458199977875, -0.697611391544342, 1.7921005487442017, 0.11603135615587234, 0.2890496551990509, -0.6066474318504333, 1.1022346019744873, -0.5269348621368408, 0.4623822271823883, -0.6728567481040955, -0.43714985251426697, 0.5278052687644958, 0.27903494238853455, 1.021960973739624, -0.020780786871910095, -0.3276088833808899, 0.5122925639152527, -0.5374747514724731, 0.08766628056764603, -1.2180711030960083, -0.09855565428733826, 0.17449074983596802, -0.2845902144908905, 0.6544163227081299, 0.9023541808128357, -0.7511948943138123, -0.3739602565765381, 0.10215862840414047, 0.3016933798789978, -0.4961387813091278, -0.13327571749687195, 0.23880411684513092, -0.48888951539993286, 0.25258854031562805, 0.14274145662784576, -0.3120898902416229, -0.20412610471248627, -0.5103337168693542, -0.09486809372901917, 0.10847201943397522, -0.13198210299015045, 0.4757671058177948, -0.38726282119750977, 0.10300317406654358, 1.6164264678955078, -0.21504037082195282, 0.28628411889076233, 0.2031756490468979, 0.21533551812171936, -0.922104001045227, 0.2716391682624817, 0.1976415365934372, 0.14672403037548065, 0.07089904695749283, 0.0711318776011467, 0.2280791699886322, 0.5006657838821411, -0.8477762341499329, 0.34387487173080444, -0.6006475687026978, -0.7603480219841003, 1.126133918762207, -0.29446253180503845, -0.10958626866340637, 1.2522881031036377, -0.6029680967330933, 0.5621514320373535, -0.6840391755104065, 0.17653793096542358, -0.012897218577563763, -0.3109106123447418, 0.40122365951538086, 0.31808486580848694, 0.08650072664022446, 0.7147769927978516, 0.8395069241523743, 0.7350912690162659, 0.28195464611053467, -0.3209967315196991, -0.43168893456459045, 0.3373887538909912, -0.010563159361481667, -0.9226512908935547, 0.905194878578186, 1.0699598789215088, -0.5506361126899719, 0.19827766716480255, 0.6265488862991333, 0.16284635663032532, 0.475293904542923, 0.09543737769126892, -0.8288719654083252, 0.8282349109649658, -0.28324639797210693, 0.6056678891181946, -0.6792540550231934, 0.4492151737213135, -0.9292495250701904, 0.1413300335407257, -0.2595944106578827, -0.01262582652270794, 0.10929764807224274, -0.27804380655288696, -1.1207374334335327, 0.1146811693906784, -1.1693840026855469, 0.5977334380149841, 0.5639821290969849, 0.5353583097457886, -0.4814394414424896, 0.19812504947185516, 0.5744571685791016, 0.15296585857868195, 0.3475843667984009, -0.25026580691337585, 0.12524008750915527, -0.021951347589492798, -0.5524849891662598, 0.3990291357040405, 0.43671780824661255, 0.21572285890579224, 0.21872369945049286, 0.29293206334114075, 0.18031463027000427, 1.162355661392212, -0.06145424768328667, -0.2528991401195526, 0.33019277453422546, 1.4788076877593994, -0.8618802428245544, 0.360716313123703, 0.4618157148361206, -0.016907934099435806, 0.4785204827785492, 0.6364308595657349, 0.6954522728919983, -0.527050256729126, 1.2562003135681152, 1.0042866468429565, 0.7510109543800354, 0.4248564541339874, 0.1422356218099594, 0.2771068811416626, 0.5615858435630798, -0.6104215979576111, -0.6225213408470154, 0.3274846374988556, 0.44579511880874634, 0.26798030734062195, -0.6480757594108582, 0.7669798731803894, -0.10916990786790848, 0.29795849323272705, 0.4782484173774719, 0.028430622071027756, -1.5485525131225586, 0.026814885437488556, 0.04024071618914604, 0.4342372417449951, 0.12975941598415375, -0.003690598998218775, -0.23606038093566895, -0.09180115163326263, 0.1860383301973343, 0.17789442837238312, -0.7390851378440857, 0.10289672017097473, -0.6709765195846558, -0.15045852959156036, 0.7853278517723083, -0.4990379810333252, -1.3219555616378784, -0.06360582262277603, -0.7970775961875916, -0.07006390392780304, -0.870033860206604, 0.18262767791748047, 0.1875820755958557, 0.020671192556619644, 0.7920991778373718, -0.1289433389902115, 0.00298087066039443, -0.03110749088227749, -0.17571431398391724, 0.1350765973329544, 0.36283114552497864, -0.04308130219578743, -1.0714913606643677, 0.48356908559799194, -0.874372124671936, -0.4230986535549164, -0.06461639702320099, -0.2327640950679779, 1.110689401626587, 0.2430320680141449, 0.10587019473314285, 0.47611579298973083, -0.6045821309089661, -0.20921207964420319, -0.4615548551082611, -0.8907202482223511, -0.0397060364484787, 0.18415752053260803, 0.19592590630054474, 0.5997743010520935, -0.9745795726776123, 1.0072190761566162, 0.0984378457069397, -0.21650440990924835, 0.5374407172203064, -0.1592394858598709, -0.596397876739502, 0.007160796318203211, 1.0969622135162354, 0.017906056717038155, 0.04375467821955681, 0.3188208043575287, 0.7858865857124329, 0.3037804365158081, -0.17050881683826447, -0.5361919403076172, -0.3901613652706146, 0.2881034314632416, 0.7458119988441467, -0.7044292092323303, 0.32592570781707764, 0.7345187664031982, 0.1821829080581665, -0.34198832511901855, 0.5892728567123413, -1.31576406955719, -0.6031254529953003, -0.6720904111862183, -0.6684039831161499, 0.02908831089735031, -0.07509515434503555, 0.0023688864894211292, 0.007216637954115868, -0.3890962600708008, 0.02538936585187912, 0.4254295229911804, 0.2370619922876358, -0.021190788596868515, 0.3617406487464905, 0.5351119637489319, 0.279989629983902, 0.1238243356347084, 0.04099881649017334, -0.6520139575004578, -0.1272038221359253, 0.46677714586257935, -0.4974779784679413, 0.4380585253238678, 0.21084339916706085, 0.08178931474685669, -0.20233748853206635, 0.28326529264450073, -0.4272530674934387, -0.19828420877456665, -0.7517978549003601, -0.010368023999035358, 0.32358068227767944, 0.599830150604248, -0.12675443291664124, -1.1255189180374146, -0.9020441174507141, -0.2279335856437683, -0.8045065402984619, 0.3512655198574066, 0.656653881072998, -0.9482413530349731, 0.3368741571903229, 0.5494428277015686, -0.47179797291755676, 0.10634151101112366, -0.1439087837934494, 0.6397569179534912, 0.6603500843048096, 0.349691778421402, 0.19249999523162842, -0.7487394213676453, -0.22728317975997925, -0.5615116953849792, 0.08277577906847, 0.27864202857017517, 0.7497989535331726, 0.2817801237106323, -0.3695562481880188, -0.07537172734737396, 0.1351335048675537, -0.40518808364868164, -0.2650222182273865, -0.0068262675777077675, -0.15568429231643677, -0.5412238836288452, -0.13725459575653076, -0.006829811725765467, 0.39645904302597046, 0.006708953529596329, -0.0984482541680336, 0.13823330402374268, -0.2230772227048874, 0.6863076686859131, 0.17972567677497864, 0.3985691964626312, -0.8656308650970459, 0.2507389485836029, -0.6130383610725403, 0.5581746697425842, -0.021791653707623482, 0.3314799964427948, 0.2481047660112381, -1.1912773847579956, 0.1341519057750702, 0.1106833964586258, 0.6363266110420227, 0.24318775534629822, -0.6795573234558105, 0.6589248180389404, 0.17209279537200928, 0.04891600087285042, 0.31694504618644714, 0.14517180621623993, 0.8337967991828918, 0.2954474687576294, 0.16881375014781952, -0.7713242173194885, 0.08032272011041641, -0.8666907548904419, 0.6525607705116272, 0.1382797658443451, -0.6392765641212463, -0.7741411924362183, -0.14989018440246582, 0.3724254369735718, -0.12487605959177017, 0.042443398386240005, 1.0175166130065918, 0.5016139149665833, 0.4570431411266327, -0.45135220885276794, 0.11799168586730957, 0.7752818465232849, -0.4548689126968384, 0.06491170823574066, -0.090359628200531, -0.2170664370059967, 0.035083699971437454, 0.32314082980155945, 0.545413613319397, -0.36918923258781433, -0.3283844590187073, 0.04653738811612129, 0.2351759374141693, -0.46523725986480713, -0.5005797147750854, -0.44175899028778076, -0.21797098219394684, 0.39119842648506165, 0.34830015897750854, -0.45121362805366516, 0.03446269780397415, 0.18930120766162872, -0.38298308849334717, -0.7781679630279541, 0.6221004724502563, 0.28397536277770996, 0.2534743845462799, 0.7089909315109253, 0.9754685759544373, 0.021231645718216896, 0.4029555022716522, -0.2606097161769867, -0.07596976310014725, 0.24017038941383362, 0.7864019274711609, -0.6093029975891113, 0.0955137237906456, 0.3050123453140259, -0.056377582252025604, -0.8945242762565613, -0.4013742506504059, 0.5263802409172058, -0.5626555681228638, -0.09353086352348328, 0.2820645868778229, -0.9624987244606018, -0.6653452515602112, -1.0433576107025146, -1.146263599395752, 0.49052977561950684, 0.30033114552497864, -0.2015116661787033, 0.4315963387489319, -0.21912331879138947, -0.7619384527206421, -0.13986119627952576, -1.0738130807876587, -0.11820042878389359, -0.6812334656715393, 0.3779561519622803, 0.38336995244026184, 0.4186522662639618, -0.16951146721839905, 0.009067744947969913, -0.6862183809280396, -0.12429143488407135, -0.44053056836128235, -0.8286833167076111, -0.21728049218654633, 0.2068469077348709, -0.3955664336681366, -0.1889674812555313, 0.127933070063591, 0.2968749403953552, 0.2619674801826477, 0.1065853163599968, -0.31194618344306946, -0.8982248306274414, -0.07857562601566315, 0.7415597438812256, 0.4697510898113251, -0.16164568066596985, -0.5100667476654053, 0.6085754036903381, 0.18623916804790497, 0.4685857892036438, 0.09753309190273285, -0.3423604965209961, 0.1266203671693802, -1.2813479900360107, 0.5146711468696594, -1.2767630815505981, 0.10135076940059662, -0.5223325490951538, -0.8793376684188843, 0.9233828186988831, 0.06342588365077972, 0.26977136731147766, -0.09092918783426285, -0.785155713558197, -0.23157064616680145, 0.6133005619049072, -0.6638763546943665, 0.7651149034500122, -0.8765315413475037, -0.9594758749008179, -0.9446602463722229, 1.3417037725448608, -0.5017799735069275, 0.14521601796150208, 0.07775303721427917, 0.39752960205078125, -0.20553909242153168, 0.2874985337257385, 0.4766365885734558, -0.07729821652173996, -0.3013838529586792, -0.38789379596710205, 0.16016706824302673, -0.01043074019253254, -0.39683181047439575, 0.454642117023468, -0.4704250395298004, 0.4524681866168976, -0.18559587001800537, 0.00646360544487834, 0.04716988280415535, -0.25063905119895935, 0.518112301826477, -0.7771508097648621, -0.16544032096862793, 0.35294508934020996, -0.16295574605464935, 0.3751727044582367, -0.07984402775764465, -0.7167798280715942, -0.4187904894351959, -0.7670157551765442, -0.729172945022583, 0.2658349275588989, -0.2706463038921356, -0.37011995911598206, -0.43880507349967957, -0.3692735433578491, 0.31445837020874023, -0.2845686972141266, 0.31442680954933167, 0.3277463912963867, 0.7234647870063782, 0.3469451069831848, -0.12761472165584564, -0.3030247092247009, -1.116484522819519, -0.13902688026428223, -0.4059556722640991, -0.09904169291257858, 0.05528048798441887, -0.27249276638031006, -0.5032495260238647, -0.7412444353103638, -0.1587890088558197, 0.6542066335678101, 0.001120094326324761, -0.2792087495326996, 0.34546157717704773, 0.2056645303964615, -0.09651481360197067, -0.4292266368865967, -0.03558933734893799, 0.29627206921577454, -0.35809454321861267, 0.717362105846405, 0.7767488360404968, 0.2718755006790161, -0.10964725911617279, 0.6122850179672241, -0.21365967392921448, -0.6320755481719971, 0.6102014780044556, -0.7471970915794373, -0.05925505980849266, 1.0487966537475586, -0.44241952896118164, -0.1261066496372223, -0.3405771553516388, -0.7149734497070312, -0.47761115431785583, -0.0038443857338279486, 0.3361890912055969, 0.677837610244751, 0.006618982180953026, 0.032111555337905884, 0.222368061542511, 0.09295139461755753, 0.47990337014198303, 0.09472226351499557, 0.09624667465686798, 0.29381752014160156, 0.013832720927894115, -0.1411435306072235, 1.2509406805038452, 0.1619197428226471, -0.9924181699752808, -0.13428747653961182, 0.4690040946006775, -0.4554893374443054, -0.711479663848877, 0.9687236547470093, -0.6879817247390747, 0.03722212091088295, -0.2921193838119507, -0.09068193286657333, 0.36313965916633606, -0.06091982498764992, -0.20872056484222412, -0.18060988187789917, -0.6639069318771362, -0.3796394467353821, 0.3585231900215149, -0.17099718749523163, -0.09774772077798843, -0.03654758632183075, -0.0206142570823431, 0.7159080505371094, 0.017983023077249527, 0.4812854528427124, -0.030271457508206367, -0.7551714181900024, -0.36806192994117737, -2.0039117336273193, -0.5140500068664551, -0.6999205946922302, -0.6754935383796692, 0.1355125606060028, 0.556973934173584, -0.23563894629478455, 0.14994625747203827, -0.18004165589809418, 0.23778493702411652, -0.10253417491912842, 1.547676682472229, -0.4413917660713196, -0.46043381094932556, -0.9326162338256836, 0.1697256714105606, -0.21810846030712128, -0.8489931225776672, -0.40983062982559204, -0.4030207693576813, 0.30583643913269043, 0.5365619659423828, 0.011432223953306675, -0.3243950307369232, -0.08892931789159775, -0.8683890104293823, 0.7177490592002869, 0.16068340837955475, -0.10448057949542999, 0.7721895575523376, 0.18854323029518127, 0.7549113631248474, 0.20119646191596985, 0.4034121036529541, -0.012867661193013191, -0.10694624483585358, -1.0061123371124268, 0.4178490936756134, 0.629061222076416, 0.7692684531211853, -0.3584271967411041, -1.0157766342163086, 0.37900927662849426, -0.11208101361989975, -0.2725469470024109, 0.9084909558296204, -0.24507753551006317, 0.48745715618133545, -1.157217025756836, 0.002861322369426489, 0.07586100697517395, 0.3475132882595062, 0.18598124384880066, 0.06896109133958817, -0.7990014553070068, 0.29715004563331604, -0.0722203329205513, 0.018582219257950783, -0.42575952410697937, -0.23602057993412018, 0.632839560508728, 0.37906700372695923, 0.726942241191864, 0.3027663826942444, -0.1318376213312149, 0.14762650430202484, -0.6104504466056824, -0.3836810290813446, -0.1253853142261505, 0.4018629789352417, -0.06206817552447319, 0.765633761882782, -0.2067488729953766, 0.1987527757883072, 0.48339593410491943, -0.5356345772743225, -0.7394042611122131, 0.18731878697872162, -0.6176912784576416, -0.3988194763660431, -0.07144388556480408, 0.11254411190748215, -0.055938296020030975, 0.7706519365310669, -0.6458427309989929, -0.29854708909988403, 0.5310955047607422, 1.3269656896591187, 0.6484682559967041, -0.11723734438419342, -0.25486478209495544, 0.14017698168754578, -1.0515799522399902, -0.35280904173851013, 0.058972932398319244, 0.1034538522362709, -0.8456217050552368, -0.625167191028595, -0.01538632158190012, 0.20176243782043457, -0.2620421051979065, -0.3176148235797882, -0.08228195458650589, -0.6337714195251465, 0.09787769615650177, -0.5535716414451599, -0.1727670580148697, -0.06567129492759705, -0.8389697074890137, 0.5370041131973267, -0.4503166675567627, -0.4442477822303772, -0.1612706184387207, -0.35412776470184326, -0.20650731027126312, 0.2688876688480377, -0.11143476516008377, 0.9367621541023254, 0.1390416920185089, -0.5473170280456543, 0.5124416947364807, 0.6021686792373657, -0.006384607404470444, 0.8310081362724304, -0.6183142066001892, 0.46139752864837646, 0.5869508385658264, -0.027290217578411102, 0.9503167271614075, 0.16754649579524994, -0.25515446066856384, 0.04008821025490761, 0.5665498375892639, -0.37668439745903015, -0.19618402421474457, -0.39453068375587463, 0.7300245761871338, 1.0601694583892822, -0.4747421145439148, -0.430576354265213, 0.09493754059076309, -0.07029733061790466, 0.6909657716751099, -0.3190785050392151, -0.4827058017253876, -0.3412949740886688, 0.509294867515564, 0.3770540654659271, -0.4154426157474518, -0.6963574886322021, -0.02886900305747986, 0.1804562360048294, 0.2779165804386139, 0.21741481125354767, -0.5147631764411926, 0.1463223099708557, 0.2966144382953644, -0.2185862511396408, 0.5565075874328613, 0.14130418002605438, 0.2214624136686325, 0.5787926912307739, 0.8921529650688171, -0.09173206239938736, 0.11697836220264435, 0.46387365460395813, 0.4230010509490967, -0.6282051801681519, -0.19867366552352905, 0.46745795011520386, -0.42504048347473145, 0.3609074354171753, 0.4140795171260834, -0.6523861885070801, -0.6150721907615662, -0.6194157004356384, 0.22562870383262634, 0.23087136447429657, 0.18092121183872223, -0.6089115738868713, -0.7249063849449158, -0.6236136555671692, 0.40362823009490967, -0.003935983870178461, 0.4282100200653076, -0.2021617293357849, 0.453172504901886, 0.1399696171283722, 0.8564934134483337, 0.6365247964859009, 0.25627148151397705, 0.046578481793403625, 0.00899204146116972, -0.04212052375078201, 0.7036916613578796, 0.3426671326160431, -0.30235886573791504, 0.40790438652038574, -0.9617723226547241, -0.23249250650405884, -0.1110638976097107, 0.1059269979596138, -0.0050017512403428555, -0.15795648097991943, 0.7128705978393555, 0.5228923559188843, -0.4164745807647705, 0.2944052815437317, 0.17581935226917267, 0.23166389763355255, -1.1269413232803345, 0.12253837287425995, 0.6952794790267944, -1.0917414426803589, -0.5962219834327698, -1.4212675094604492, 0.583248496055603, 0.4625554084777832, 0.12211117893457413, -0.6328221559524536, -0.24786248803138733, -0.3813350796699524, -0.2099863588809967, 0.43352240324020386, -0.16607660055160522, 0.2524243891239166, 1.4240659475326538, -0.653324544429779, 0.040510136634111404, -0.2789270281791687, -0.7207361459732056, -0.5480635762214661, 1.1599864959716797, -0.3516070544719696, 0.4543137550354004, 0.36775216460227966, 0.2018638253211975, -1.0642551183700562, 0.2982264757156372, 0.3537595570087433, -0.5817744135856628, 0.9769545197486877, -0.8391448259353638, 0.2183876633644104, 0.20381560921669006, -0.15016859769821167, -0.1712062507867813, 0.6340591311454773, 0.034477416425943375, 0.6714972257614136, -0.008381049148738384, -0.12545126676559448, -0.42998644709587097, -0.18696856498718262, -1.1362024545669556, -0.2890844941139221, 0.18776050209999084, -0.08637212216854095, -0.1691506952047348, -0.5796189308166504, 4.0408172607421875, 0.7410970330238342, 0.4267235994338989, -0.24625983834266663, 0.3334457576274872, 1.3462549448013306, -0.0045478083193302155, 0.16468660533428192, 0.503165602684021, -1.004900574684143, -0.1672922670841217, -0.07885002344846725, 0.17602898180484772, -0.058161430060863495, -0.37107300758361816, 0.4092354476451874, -0.3375030755996704, -0.10349977761507034, -0.06614735722541809, -0.02068113535642624, -1.061798334121704, 0.3221651613712311, -0.24331839382648468, -0.133485347032547, 0.3198893070220947, 0.10550323128700256, 0.05800417810678482, -0.5550243258476257, -0.24325783550739288, -0.5250987410545349, -0.25337034463882446, -0.3369809091091156, -0.06731778383255005, -0.0338527075946331, -1.2771389484405518, 0.6196277737617493, -0.45809343457221985, -0.25069501996040344, 0.5655304193496704, 0.4032251536846161, -0.36077094078063965, -0.28191885352134705, 0.5394660234451294, -0.3921380937099457, 0.7167198061943054, 0.9393160939216614, 0.10817942768335342, 0.592393159866333, 0.31054553389549255, -0.9995288252830505, 0.18666166067123413, 0.036781977862119675, 0.6588523387908936, -0.9308381676673889, -0.3064039349555969, -0.40946245193481445, -0.14078517258167267, -0.4157882630825043, 0.4294857978820801, -0.5450894832611084, 0.2448088377714157, -0.3688916265964508, 0.0011662213364616036, -0.13314852118492126, 0.3968290090560913, 0.052406370639801025, 0.1917179524898529, 0.21355615556240082, 0.5447443723678589, 0.035409554839134216, -0.44813498854637146, -0.7350047826766968, -1.0262539386749268, -0.19461828470230103, -0.018083184957504272, 0.1405247002840042, -0.2442948967218399, 0.7097371220588684, 0.22600698471069336, 0.7077566981315613, -0.5173221230506897, 0.4009767770767212, 0.42324090003967285, -0.2332109808921814, 0.23218531906604767, 0.7114338278770447, -0.12932457029819489, 0.7116769552230835, -0.6048666834831238, 0.35075488686561584, 0.1242927759885788, 1.001474142074585, -0.28846877813339233, 0.43358519673347473, -1.1105955839157104 ]
Transformations and BRST-Charges in 2+1 Dimensional Gravitation
Canonical transformations relating the variables of the ADM-, Ashtekar's and Witten's formulations of gravity are computed in 2+1~dimensions. Three different forms of the BRST-charge are given in the 2+1 dimensional Ashtekar formalism, two of them using Ashtekar's form of the constraints and one of them using the forms suggested by Witten. The BRST-charges are of different rank.
G\'eza F\"ul\"op
gr-qc hep-th
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209003
gr-qc/9209004
[ 0.1912527084350586, 0.5622087121009827, 0.6244987845420837, -0.5056551098823547, -0.27516067028045654, 0.43284207582473755, -0.4266812801361084, 0.2789299488067627, -0.18647801876068115, 1.236664891242981, 0.12891055643558502, -0.530217170715332, -0.3135533928871155, -0.3409363627433777, -0.5183602571487427, 0.23892827332019806, -0.09781022369861603, 0.1720450073480606, -1.0068154335021973, 0.2657102644443512, -0.17444126307964325, 0.5919773578643799, -1.3516110181808472, -0.7542676329612732, -0.5295316576957703, 0.8223095536231995, 0.6987320780754089, 0.05216898024082184, 1.0953166484832764, 1.2489067316055298, 0.2158978134393692, -0.8265920281410217, -0.17983104288578033, -1.1391600370407104, -0.18730637431144714, 0.04828533157706261, 0.6724599599838257, -0.5665466785430908, 0.48168110847473145, -0.4845595955848694, 0.03309960663318634, 0.047105904668569565, 0.6463969349861145, -0.5934187173843384, -0.44725823402404785, -0.2038225680589676, -0.10054129362106323, -0.5829130411148071, 0.4693479835987091, -0.6591414213180542, -0.37400972843170166, 0.2746424376964569, 0.4076595604419708, -0.42756974697113037, 0.2229619324207306, -0.3600330054759979, 0.3677821457386017, 0.6687275171279907, -0.25437772274017334, 0.7708503603935242, 0.7768656015396118, 0.562008798122406, 0.696510910987854, -0.9082401394844055, -0.10162632912397385, 1.2305090427398682, 0.4890606999397278, -0.21041928231716156, 0.6099380254745483, -0.15079431235790253, -0.3195596933364868, 0.06470421701669693, -0.5888029336929321, -0.4697503447532654, -0.4171396791934967, 0.647741973400116, 0.40711721777915955, 0.15332220494747162, -0.19107948243618011, -0.5106588006019592, 0.26778435707092285, 0.31099700927734375, -0.062325309962034225, 0.46364715695381165, -0.3418115973472595, -0.543695867061615, 0.5300436615943909, -0.1800134778022766, 0.2402721643447876, 0.11979428678750992, -0.28257980942726135, 0.9507355093955994, 0.07937357574701309, 0.43074682354927063, 0.4577219486236572, 0.6662676334381104, -0.15094466507434845, 0.3081677556037903, 0.5832644104957581, 0.19415156543254852, 0.3183642625808716, 1.1465903520584106, -0.545417845249176, 0.3633337616920471, -0.4363528788089752, 1.0311923027038574, -0.371823787689209, 0.33249810338020325, -0.14915335178375244, -0.9709596037864685, 0.1535467654466629, 0.09396728873252869, 0.5736706256866455, 0.33546122908592224, 0.128900408744812, 0.8688123822212219, -0.519813060760498, 0.30527690052986145, -0.5035016536712646, -0.5930600166320801, -0.021139588207006454, 0.7054510712623596, 0.27380049228668213, 0.7407426834106445, 0.1590730845928192, -0.062007397413253784, -0.1488068401813507, -0.025948693975806236, -0.8112466931343079, -0.4330298602581024, 0.13467736542224884, -0.27902868390083313, -0.35559386014938354, 1.055810570716858, 0.2122252881526947, -0.17825058102607727, 0.46473419666290283, 0.3070043623447418, -0.4095577299594879, -0.973637044429779, 0.3037782609462738, 0.1992243528366089, -0.4794527292251587, 1.260532259941101, -1.1171373128890991, 0.7618936896324158, -0.3830040991306305, 0.3866015374660492, -0.07631107419729233, 0.09944996982812881, -0.22210609912872314, -0.1623554676771164, 0.017099110409617424, 0.18383567035198212, -0.8284943103790283, -0.10378842800855637, -1.0946089029312134, 0.016686290502548218, -0.7342690825462341, -0.7320669889450073, -0.18932045996189117, -0.02698705345392227, 0.038281798362731934, 0.5494269728660583, -0.7544411420822144, 0.6163758039474487, -1.1117732524871826, -0.4822790026664734, 0.23786427080631256, -0.39700832962989807, 0.0917898640036583, 0.016359344124794006, -0.39398103952407837, 0.31138354539871216, 1.2665952444076538, 0.6859768033027649, 0.2377353012561798, -0.513262152671814, -0.27766090631484985, 0.8001545071601868, -0.5873875617980957, -0.7306405305862427, 0.07938338071107864, 0.31863638758659363, -0.6454987525939941, 0.001450655865482986, -0.34921830892562866, -0.6213473081588745, 0.2635424733161926, -0.5335190296173096, -0.5208674073219299, 0.3918456733226776, -1.1164793968200684, 0.7755987048149109, -0.9980913400650024, 0.09980043768882751, -1.0180197954177856, 0.12019233405590057, -0.127904012799263, -0.8818396329879761, 0.12922802567481995, -0.36628928780555725, -0.19376766681671143, 0.6027604937553406, -1.1048141717910767, 0.20888753235340118, 0.5737128257751465, 0.6113774180412292, -0.8592915534973145, -0.12953773140907288, 0.5856348276138306, 0.15136736631393433, -0.047811299562454224, -0.2819683253765106, 0.5158566236495972, -0.03610629960894585, -0.34243834018707275, 0.45348724722862244, -0.2484544813632965, 0.12830060720443726, 0.5798199772834778, 0.21132715046405792, 0.42293357849121094, 0.41489148139953613, 0.6730044484138489, -0.23879072070121765, -0.09196535497903824, 0.6184876561164856, -0.25254833698272705, 0.5522275567054749, -0.4359196722507477, 0.3466954827308655, 0.013388616032898426, 0.6396558284759521, 0.41260018944740295, 0.05629727244377136, 0.7800105214118958, 0.499277800321579, -0.0451621487736702, -0.35925647616386414, -0.2594394385814667, 0.021754976361989975, 0.6538882255554199, 0.2581172287464142, -1.1837271451950073, 0.5255911350250244, 0.10140048712491989, -0.023583240807056427, -0.015045258216559887, 0.688717246055603, -0.5792254209518433, 0.5372089743614197, 0.7862717509269714, 0.19304122030735016, -1.3679929971694946, 0.048618149012327194, -0.1237114816904068, 0.45427343249320984, -0.12679234147071838, -0.9515127539634705, -0.3531113862991333, 0.5493402481079102, 0.12190748751163483, -0.8209877610206604, -0.48783162236213684, 0.22329385578632355, -0.5295355319976807, 0.20128309726715088, 0.6708356738090515, -0.9482531547546387, -0.7599061727523804, 0.25883445143699646, -0.4864554703235626, 0.18115636706352234, -0.3320327401161194, 0.025526665151119232, 0.17509393393993378, -0.7090349197387695, 0.21244476735591888, 0.2799306809902191, -0.3284793198108673, 0.1608765572309494, 0.3575541377067566, 0.3640681803226471, -0.7893486618995667, 0.5242335200309753, -0.732639729976654, 0.7212755680084229, -0.9434055685997009, 0.5019850134849548, -0.5424237847328186, -0.38938668370246887, -0.14975012838840485, -0.5507104396820068, 0.6603206992149353, 0.15840181708335876, -0.33659178018569946, 0.7335005402565002, -0.15375666320323944, -0.8876549005508423, 0.33264604210853577, -0.17708100378513336, -0.15452095866203308, 0.049585334956645966, -1.161177158355713, 0.7034065127372742, -0.5045495629310608, -0.07816467434167862, 0.8345121741294861, -0.1245100125670433, -0.5856547951698303, 0.688090443611145, 0.3288416564464569, 0.5589287281036377, -0.08254733681678772, 0.08374513685703278, 0.35602453351020813, -0.14983013272285461, 0.4652920067310333, -0.08731601387262344, -1.0754162073135376, -1.037028193473816, 0.40846166014671326, -0.5880178213119507, -0.06263341754674911, 0.3891696333885193, 0.41030430793762207, -1.100887417793274, 0.13056506216526031, -1.165656566619873, -0.9487754106521606, 0.19700592756271362, 0.15444883704185486, 0.7841454148292542, -0.36647874116897583, -0.2844168543815613, -0.37810274958610535, -0.08219027519226074, -0.24464893341064453, 0.4302784502506256, 0.9116584658622742, -0.7546694874763489, 0.17344048619270325, 0.7010357975959778, 0.09332124888896942, -0.4668063223361969, 0.6887197494506836, -0.2626877725124359, -0.19174370169639587, -0.20188358426094055, -0.46001800894737244, -0.3785308301448822, -0.574903666973114, 0.2426040917634964, -0.44528403878211975, 0.13718992471694946, -0.27249839901924133, -0.2333226352930069, -0.4483647644519806, -0.3833984434604645, 0.05683999881148338, 0.44567012786865234, 0.7137644290924072, 0.12317266315221786, -0.8094013929367065, 0.014612414874136448, -0.14734692871570587, -0.30731362104415894, 0.2862895727157593, -1.2971203327178955, 0.25561434030532837, -0.12852364778518677, -0.466684490442276, -0.22728972136974335, -0.10694916546344757, -0.03178354725241661, 0.8397700190544128, 0.04839489981532097, -0.007042989134788513, -0.628197968006134, 0.10116123408079147, -0.5820760130882263, 0.635525643825531, 0.28340017795562744, -0.08682090044021606, 0.16759805381298065, 0.1214267760515213, 0.04542706161737442, -0.4862751364707947, -1.003559947013855, -0.7334427833557129, -1.052525520324707, 0.4926064908504486, -0.7252529859542847, -0.7295442819595337, -0.03391479700803757, 1.0961270332336426, 0.8693728446960449, 0.08042260259389877, -0.4199824631214142, -0.03479746729135513, -0.4643283486366272, 0.2945294678211212, 0.7634746432304382, -0.23255662620067596, 0.21597638726234436, -0.8673966526985168, 0.6585540175437927, -0.40218716859817505, -0.04883517324924469, 0.05903207138180733, -0.10238757729530334, -0.25534990429878235, -0.01026908028870821, 0.6257534027099609, 0.2292083501815796, 0.0022075439337641, 0.5991160273551941, 0.18507279455661774, -0.3124283254146576, -0.46812957525253296, 0.27036771178245544, 0.46132832765579224, 0.3793703019618988, 0.1760125756263733, -0.6544111967086792, -0.3333670496940613, -0.8784547448158264, 0.2050764560699463, 0.39685696363449097, -0.3264200985431671, -1.4097199440002441, -0.6832745671272278, -0.4741806983947754, -0.387222021818161, 0.24319002032279968, 1.1962026357650757, 0.11004398763179779, 0.3685161769390106, -0.247979998588562, -0.030289260670542717, 0.2569858431816101, -0.38578465580940247, -0.4247027039527893, 0.22231833636760712, 0.36648768186569214, -0.17757928371429443, 0.6952991485595703, -0.627708911895752, -0.7450349926948547, -0.3800585865974426, -0.7862083911895752, 1.3037132024765015, -0.1423949897289276, -0.8747729063034058, 0.6325739622116089, 0.3285481631755829, -0.7976124882698059, 0.26692524552345276, -0.17322927713394165, 0.22123417258262634, 0.7387689352035522, 0.31803134083747864, -0.8240668177604675, -0.5811839699745178, 0.20153667032718658, -0.3536679446697235, 0.6085156202316284, 0.9099554419517517, 0.17917266488075256, 0.5253616571426392, 0.7784730195999146, -0.10921084880828857, -0.012081346474587917, 0.2574479877948761, -1.0933765172958374, -0.24749276041984558, -0.03990532457828522, -0.3315277099609375, -0.03305264189839363, 0.033351968973875046, 0.15325549244880676, -0.20525938272476196, 0.5811074376106262, -0.3103461265563965, -0.8672486543655396, -0.3930242955684662, -0.2091267704963684, -0.2972530424594879, 0.8873944282531738, -0.42361322045326233, 0.06498804688453674, 0.3048263192176819, -0.4869064390659332, 0.0755053237080574, 0.49131470918655396, -0.23107948899269104, -0.8668277859687805, -0.26925089955329895, 0.17696109414100647, -0.12638132274150848, 0.308194637298584, -0.9035861492156982, 0.07816145569086075, -0.5511803030967712, -0.9695568084716797, -0.7233083248138428, -0.00905162375420332, -0.2587156593799591, 0.2806839942932129, 0.09177381545305252, 0.11925236135721207, 0.329263299703598, -0.22474029660224915, -0.02172001637518406, 0.45821258425712585, 0.48336201906204224, -0.35791489481925964, 0.41149216890335083, 0.6294102072715759, 0.514212965965271, -1.0131632089614868, 0.10485471785068512, 1.0066523551940918, -0.12591154873371124, 0.3171289563179016, -0.4369553029537201, -0.47862741351127625, 0.6883664727210999, -1.170225739479065, 0.08805227279663086, -0.590144693851471, -0.14896850287914276, -0.2633788585662842, -0.5436131358146667, 0.16870054602622986, 0.7577733397483826, 0.1546398252248764, -0.22362680733203888, -0.38475069403648376, -0.07667151093482971, 0.6543678641319275, -0.3426833152770996, 0.3441336750984192, -0.311953604221344, -0.18997564911842346, -0.9656327962875366, 1.4487192630767822, -0.5347484350204468, -0.8264040350914001, -0.07542379945516586, 0.5749114751815796, -0.309874564409256, 0.19169262051582336, 0.3257792890071869, -0.3011937737464905, -0.7309084534645081, 0.058923568576574326, 0.46947216987609863, 0.23756097257137299, -0.44906795024871826, 0.016301047056913376, -0.3330591320991516, 0.23017148673534393, 0.15293221175670624, -0.17532862722873688, 0.3243117928504944, 0.1556922197341919, 1.0517686605453491, 0.11785499006509781, -0.08064346760511398, 0.9393383860588074, 0.5843328237533569, 0.7401019334793091, -0.11015617102384567, -0.3419514000415802, -0.01990857720375061, -0.3229599595069885, -0.6050698757171631, -0.10322337597608566, 0.22981558740139008, -0.139803946018219, -0.38575106859207153, -0.6736873388290405, -0.16628597676753998, -0.14211028814315796, 1.090803623199463, 0.15625856816768646, 0.5804944634437561, -0.2809496521949768, -0.3711097538471222, -0.15926402807235718, -0.023579880595207214, -0.00845813937485218, 0.2928144633769989, -0.07803048193454742, 0.29834166169166565, -0.23838108777999878, -0.2522840201854706, -0.5160021185874939, -0.8396387696266174, 0.14592024683952332, 0.5120775699615479, -0.29909399151802063, 0.8942984342575073, -0.15114736557006836, -0.4437272250652313, -0.569027841091156, 0.33295392990112305, 0.865160346031189, 0.05146386846899986, 0.5298337340354919, 0.22893400490283966, -0.5582769513130188, 0.7761725187301636, 0.229159876704216, -0.6717411279678345, -0.3234892189502716, 1.3757034540176392, -0.4811704754829407, -0.14937177300453186, 0.4241410493850708, 0.20265047252178192, -0.9682400226593018, -1.108130931854248, -0.44477441906929016, 0.06126011535525322, 0.5337404012680054, -0.6402989029884338, -0.3881407082080841, -0.04273673892021179, -0.06227065250277519, -0.15536773204803467, 0.5731963515281677, 0.5670753717422485, 0.3659912049770355, 0.3303784132003784, 0.31282567977905273, -0.3956993818283081, -0.472790390253067, 1.3087644577026367, 0.21179960668087006, -0.8535921573638916, -0.11793766915798187, -0.25469931960105896, 0.16672679781913757, -0.5080615878105164, 1.2201433181762695, -0.1753922402858734, -0.32866573333740234, 0.16723398864269257, 0.24798886477947235, 0.2525677978992462, 0.3934950828552246, -0.035182543098926544, 0.6498337388038635, -0.546015739440918, -0.7594481110572815, -0.37719622254371643, 0.3757115304470062, 0.3072255253791809, 0.13550181686878204, 0.3817271888256073, -0.7163470387458801, 0.01205810159444809, -0.5281450152397156, 0.11831635236740112, -0.5882424116134644, -0.8595744371414185, -0.4936006963253021, -0.6854750514030457, -0.4545019567012787, -0.055362991988658905, -0.03923241049051285, -0.0372174009680748, -0.4558541178703308, 0.5090441703796387, 0.0900593027472496, 0.24620577692985535, -0.06181744486093521, 1.0294089317321777, -0.6137882471084595, -0.5129209756851196, -0.5458248257637024, -0.12359508126974106, -0.08694285899400711, -1.3398610353469849, 0.2901883125305176, -0.08737713098526001, 0.3389127552509308, 1.0926425457000732, -0.8471747040748596, 0.8244185447692871, -0.37287357449531555, -0.00676359748467803, 0.16568244993686676, -0.02860613726079464, -0.9445105195045471, 1.2760882377624512, -0.5393701195716858, 1.099614143371582, 0.6543446183204651, 0.3977004885673523, -0.18697477877140045, 0.022510595619678497, -1.1036924123764038, 0.5455097556114197, 0.5259157419204712, 0.9502441883087158, 0.4603710472583771, -0.2160658985376358, 0.14326225221157074, 0.31188052892684937, -0.8550547957420349, -0.6916079521179199, 0.03441036120057106, 0.37521418929100037, -0.14482924342155457, 0.12957194447517395, -0.2111321985721588, 0.5778565406799316, 0.1707542985677719, -0.06784877926111221, -0.7405745387077332, 0.131954625248909, 0.0458720363676548, 0.3492657244205475, -0.13435667753219604, -0.06354740262031555, 0.1732584536075592, -0.7203258872032166, 0.608173131942749, 0.11444371938705444, -0.3037383556365967, 0.03595665842294693, -0.3448994755744934, 0.03910461813211441, 0.32633745670318604, 0.5041238069534302, -0.5895939469337463, 0.779498279094696, 0.5091719627380371, 0.4509497582912445, 0.6588364839553833, -0.13527122139930725, -1.3525892496109009, 0.6368570923805237, -0.17751720547676086, -0.54405677318573, 0.7379264831542969, 0.0804922953248024, -0.26756003499031067, 0.22598889470100403, -0.9421078562736511, 0.3980987071990967, 0.39318105578422546, 0.2231781929731369, 1.212509036064148, -0.06217533349990845, -0.11973442137241364, 0.25766727328300476, -0.8137224912643433, -0.8666983246803284, -0.41179534792900085, 0.5029656291007996, -0.526736855506897, -0.7665808200836182, 0.016031300649046898, 0.22745205461978912, 0.49835479259490967, 0.13357692956924438, -0.08688845485448837, -0.09501640498638153, 0.2773300111293793, -0.2525058686733246, 0.2516321539878845, -0.056527163833379745, -0.5371404886245728, 0.4657478332519531, -0.03078390471637249, 0.09564455598592758, 0.6067489385604858, 0.09505779296159744, 1.073908805847168, 0.1000915914773941, -0.6962243318557739, 0.7790166139602661, 0.5117002129554749, 0.07617787271738052, 0.8838755488395691, 0.028169535100460052, 0.6027533411979675, 0.802672266960144, -0.7472870945930481, 0.17342562973499298, 0.4960126280784607, 0.12720848619937897, 0.45403656363487244, -0.11240720003843307, 0.08407916873693466, 0.3295482397079468, 0.2989138662815094, 0.029456421732902527, 0.07199296355247498, -0.238652765750885, -0.15148544311523438, -0.17400752007961273, -0.188954159617424, -0.2957337498664856, -0.1227731704711914, -0.22257313132286072, -0.3765222132205963, -0.35048314929008484, -0.34629490971565247, -0.8422665596008301, -0.04532058537006378, 1.058546543121338, -0.14607104659080505, -0.7565285563468933, -0.13112300634384155, 0.5660611987113953, 0.1909767985343933, -0.08163723349571228, -0.6081329584121704, 0.6985999941825867, 0.31866100430488586, 0.23913761973381042, -0.9493969082832336, 0.1845065951347351, 0.4364391565322876, 0.6854374408721924, 0.27995607256889343, 0.5635162591934204, 0.4470587968826294, 0.8852511048316956, -0.3835068345069885, -1.519910454750061, 0.332058846950531, 0.3751803934574127, -0.3043406307697296, 0.16028828918933868, 0.520010232925415, -0.8633403182029724, 0.041353750973939896, -0.8790792226791382, -0.05669841915369034, -1.0514838695526123, -0.3787510097026825, 0.090768001973629, -0.18829770386219025, -0.3249945044517517, 0.5841296911239624, 0.36869850754737854, 0.5828080177307129, 0.6646091938018799, 0.3911299705505371, 0.5998718738555908, 0.9193241000175476, 1.048376202583313, 0.4389333128929138, -0.5024746656417847, -0.36742275953292847, -0.01317068375647068, 0.7431142330169678, 0.18130308389663696, -0.28395670652389526, 0.8018150329589844, 0.08483263850212097, 0.5603702068328857, -0.18078909814357758, -0.20327772200107574, 0.04780881851911545, 0.3864859640598297, -0.1410231590270996, 0.6787673830986023, -0.18628491461277008, -0.47038859128952026, 0.09230794757604599, 0.5118104219436646, 0.023151516914367676, -0.47432881593704224, 0.3042934536933899, -0.7648603320121765, 0.31995370984077454, -0.4221073389053345, 0.3967238962650299, 0.36428678035736084, -0.16302478313446045, -0.14066900312900543, -0.30829066038131714, -0.5846551060676575, -0.6873698830604553, -0.3146703839302063, -0.25453421473503113, 0.40363919734954834, 0.7969359159469604, 0.24740947782993317, 0.07496728748083115, -0.6538286209106445, -0.18758732080459595, -0.3995882272720337, 0.9030841588973999, -0.04307226464152336, 0.6921133995056152, 0.7354463338851929, 0.2591765224933624, -0.5124772191047668, 0.5741373896598816, 0.4100334048271179, -0.21570846438407898, 0.3242141604423523, 0.11488419026136398, 0.1417238861322403, -0.3381686508655548, -0.8146144151687622, 0.25374266505241394, 0.5188107490539551, -0.08006330579519272, 0.039206746965646744, -0.5707951784133911, 0.03278634697198868, -0.14967811107635498, -0.18509547412395477, -0.11200519651174545, 0.33928924798965454, 0.20039841532707214, -0.31040704250335693, -0.059444013983011246, -1.0185695886611938, 4.133895397186279, 0.6527908444404602, 0.45876672863960266, 0.26804471015930176, 0.8714461922645569, 0.5479559898376465, 0.15206950902938843, -0.1631438285112381, -0.006544244941323996, 0.07939302176237106, -0.058727119117975235, -0.23732499778270721, 0.18530692160129547, 0.26352325081825256, 0.6674850583076477, 0.49005281925201416, 0.5107088088989258, -0.2532965838909149, -0.015691230073571205, -0.151851087808609, -0.6997105479240417, -0.1025797501206398, 0.26534485816955566, -0.8078900575637817, 0.3446666896343231, -0.018167173489928246, -0.061167798936367035, -0.3717899024486542, -0.4842117726802826, -0.6272813081741333, 0.3243989646434784, -0.35728558897972107, 0.15358030796051025, -0.4997531771659851, -1.0645052194595337, 0.49301236867904663, 0.30970293283462524, -0.19540323317050934, -0.1515507847070694, -0.01914961263537407, 0.18319089710712433, -0.07514505088329315, 0.3540065288543701, -0.321401447057724, 0.32271528244018555, 1.014244556427002, 0.2404581755399704, 0.19906434416770935, -0.009442574344575405, -0.8039239645004272, 0.5169057846069336, 0.31983116269111633, -0.2598423957824707, -0.2963427007198334, -0.9881991744041443, -0.24710364639759064, 0.16667787730693817, 0.061423756182193756, -0.4528117775917053, -0.07670487463474274, 0.7091136574745178, -0.6121278405189514, -0.24784737825393677, -0.027543887495994568, -0.15654174983501434, 0.1822679340839386, 0.17872050404548645, 0.04946267232298851, 0.005779517348855734, -0.08571238815784454, -0.5824797749519348, 0.16912777721881866, -0.428922176361084, -0.2962418496608734, 0.2539788782596588, 0.2661099433898926, -0.3447776436805725, 0.1484156996011734, -0.22184649109840393, -0.13566231727600098, -0.701515793800354, -0.29193663597106934, -0.19946300983428955, 1.0875014066696167, -0.05682947859168053, 0.6050665378570557, -0.5322721600532532, -0.7090777158737183, -0.8073169589042664, 0.02415868081152439, 0.13179147243499756, 0.2151995450258255, -0.21086512506008148, -0.5172238945960999, -0.3443213999271393 ]
A Quasilocal Test of the Finiteness of the Universe
The Cosmological Principle states that the universe is both homogeneous and isotropic. This, alone, is not enough to specify the global geometry of the spacetime. If we were able to measure both the Hubble constant and the energy density we could determine whether the universe is open or closed. Unfortunately, while some agreement exists on the value of the Hubble constant, the question of the energy density seems quite intractable. This Letter describes a possible way of avoiding this difficulty and shows that if one could measure the rate at which light-rays emerging from a surface expand, one might well be able to deduce whether the universe is closed.
Edward Malec and Niall \'O Murchadha
gr-qc astro-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209004
gr-qc/9209005
[ 0.34559202194213867, -0.4501388370990753, 0.12282124906778336, 0.049218468368053436, -0.36374202370643616, -0.3663647472858429, -0.6650753617286682, -0.3687741458415985, -0.8048422336578369, 1.224846601486206, 0.5258890986442566, -0.1263832002878189, 0.05762959644198418, -0.38361862301826477, -0.34428849816322327, 0.15971817076206207, -0.09369851648807526, 0.035469911992549896, -1.4025795459747314, 0.3524349331855774, 0.24659736454486847, 0.08878624439239502, -1.0470657348632812, -0.37914934754371643, -0.24312350153923035, 0.50495445728302, 0.5106059908866882, 0.6456156969070435, 1.135109543800354, 1.4111175537109375, 0.5404770374298096, 0.25852474570274353, 0.009389897808432579, -0.7350453734397888, 0.1255200058221817, 0.039051711559295654, 0.11622042953968048, -0.39349254965782166, 0.6330557465553284, -0.26392844319343567, 0.4343198835849762, 0.27114251255989075, 0.385931134223938, -0.4541800320148468, -0.9487773180007935, -0.2564716935157776, -0.30355116724967957, 0.3761696219444275, 0.06469200551509857, -0.7050106525421143, 0.134908065199852, -0.3440230190753937, 0.11175671219825745, -0.39585450291633606, -0.09322233498096466, -0.3806265890598297, 0.31367895007133484, 0.4211229681968689, -0.34849414229393005, -0.12185253202915192, 1.0384759902954102, 0.013989017345011234, 0.34472233057022095, -1.4067881107330322, -0.028305768966674805, 1.1994856595993042, -0.18719647824764252, 0.3425893187522888, -0.1253337562084198, -0.5337249040603638, -0.04793236404657364, -0.698782205581665, -0.4244726300239563, -0.05870106443762779, -0.6426913738250732, 0.8311681151390076, -0.24218517541885376, 0.048751380294561386, -0.7815433144569397, 0.10793592035770416, 0.38788750767707825, -0.17194610834121704, 0.26482778787612915, 0.430682510137558, -0.36578765511512756, -0.5019661784172058, 0.10202231258153915, -0.4329168200492859, 0.790747344493866, -0.41936635971069336, -0.3586302101612091, 0.3584451973438263, -0.37199971079826355, 0.3075435757637024, 0.7905700206756592, 0.5465614795684814, -0.18791918456554413, 0.764169454574585, 0.5496538877487183, -0.1769905537366867, -0.23607252538204193, 0.6527632474899292, -0.1315254122018814, 0.5945174694061279, -0.7813174724578857, 0.18983489274978638, -0.5009757876396179, -0.30083730816841125, -0.5291633605957031, -0.7568120956420898, 0.2499396950006485, 0.2594180703163147, 0.24576525390148163, 0.581219494342804, 0.08298231661319733, 0.8641057014465332, -0.3329732120037079, -0.13960173726081848, -0.7117571830749512, -0.11429587751626968, 0.6314258575439453, 0.01215453539043665, 0.5675103664398193, 0.6963083744049072, 0.07127328217029572, -0.37143054604530334, -0.22763827443122864, 0.4872893691062927, -0.31429603695869446, 0.18236491084098816, 0.42379552125930786, -0.28499284386634827, -0.10788089036941528, 0.29431891441345215, 0.37922659516334534, 0.18955285847187042, 0.08382977545261383, 0.5100356340408325, -0.24546168744564056, -0.6075940132141113, 0.45684754848480225, -0.46876370906829834, 0.7974525094032288, 0.8751834630966187, -0.6363821029663086, 0.2460978478193283, -0.20497570931911469, 0.5450666546821594, -0.5452518463134766, -0.04940371960401535, 0.245433047413826, -0.4673056900501251, -0.07048235833644867, 0.3769538104534149, -0.5829418897628784, 0.1454097330570221, -0.6910887956619263, -0.3629378378391266, -0.6607321500778198, -0.2531285285949707, -0.1076652780175209, 0.28102442622184753, -0.03345639631152153, 0.7812883257865906, -0.018469789996743202, 0.036841511726379395, -0.7927764058113098, -0.8908593058586121, 0.03335792198777199, -0.5330696105957031, -0.40804535150527954, 0.06766945123672485, 0.013622607104480267, 0.6485115885734558, 1.0545293092727661, 0.4194158911705017, -0.13238441944122314, 0.09045982360839844, -0.3910565972328186, 0.06379306316375732, -0.15114213526248932, -0.5024852752685547, 0.8206218481063843, 0.06648091226816177, -0.6193078756332397, -1.3085432052612305, 0.25879359245300293, -0.5556789636611938, -0.3385465145111084, 0.23659688234329224, -0.46637195348739624, 0.5310683846473694, -1.1738758087158203, 1.347320795059204, -0.3485778570175171, 0.4233120083808899, -1.5510834455490112, -0.47386467456817627, -0.2521951496601105, -0.576687216758728, 0.33266371488571167, -0.13051079213619232, -0.6037605404853821, 0.4407934248447418, -0.6416639685630798, 0.24915766716003418, 0.7781571745872498, 0.4006955027580261, -0.20570579171180725, 0.09229544550180435, -0.11340942978858948, -0.1599055677652359, 0.6446745991706848, -0.47141411900520325, 0.30841898918151855, -0.1823783963918686, 0.4738621115684509, 0.47396111488342285, -0.03727096691727638, 0.21410292387008667, 0.4813687205314636, 0.23541714251041412, 0.13180050253868103, 0.5780393481254578, 0.2242778092622757, -0.28506025671958923, -0.33792755007743835, 0.3383057713508606, -0.11947042495012283, 0.5041015148162842, -0.34879380464553833, -0.25367921590805054, 0.054576922208070755, 0.1902492493391037, 0.7048551440238953, -0.07320313155651093, 0.596694827079773, 0.1252278834581375, 0.062279097735881805, 0.057828471064567566, 0.34336644411087036, -0.31243327260017395, 0.691075325012207, -0.18284709751605988, -0.24715597927570343, 0.6323442459106445, 0.40455737709999084, -0.21380960941314697, -0.6676650047302246, 0.9078651070594788, -0.4538284242153168, -0.023024730384349823, 0.36244502663612366, 0.13522253930568695, -0.6053916811943054, -0.02973705157637596, 0.3854360282421112, 0.5095518231391907, -0.025775695219635963, -0.9083877205848694, -0.3429099917411804, 0.5272592306137085, -0.5291613340377808, -1.1018015146255493, 0.1393795907497406, 0.0011865014676004648, -0.12091919034719467, 0.2049073427915573, 0.7795287370681763, -0.1582498401403427, -1.2950681447982788, -0.12921804189682007, -0.6028509736061096, -0.17698778212070465, -0.20154786109924316, -0.49215206503868103, 0.6479954123497009, -0.6485403776168823, 0.7619308829307556, -0.005673848092556, -0.25599974393844604, 0.07999511808156967, 0.11965654790401459, 0.6216378211975098, -0.3984358608722687, 0.05212020128965378, -0.6082245111465454, 0.29354625940322876, -0.68352872133255, 0.08507785201072693, -0.037684179842472076, -0.31500306725502014, 0.08614315837621689, 0.05893055349588394, -0.2105443924665451, 0.06139661371707916, 0.23860318958759308, 0.5147947072982788, -0.42420944571495056, -0.6692423224449158, 0.5578737854957581, 0.7195322513580322, 0.22407211363315582, -0.07024739682674408, -0.8505764603614807, 0.5173671245574951, 0.09815280884504318, -0.45231956243515015, 0.7187207937240601, -0.5185466408729553, -0.8133805394172668, 0.27695444226264954, 0.029440833255648613, 0.7648096680641174, -0.189583420753479, 0.7892202734947205, 0.8475369811058044, 0.11488436162471771, 0.17756646871566772, 0.09931492805480957, -0.6375390291213989, -0.11338011920452118, 0.4366135001182556, -0.9547337293624878, 0.3756730556488037, 0.4053781032562256, 0.04198242723941803, -0.5937773585319519, 0.7001847624778748, -0.7862223982810974, -0.7513981461524963, 0.36384549736976624, -0.1472749263048172, 0.2743094563484192, 0.022278884425759315, -0.1044301986694336, -0.4351564347743988, -0.4497300386428833, 0.18024855852127075, 0.6604315638542175, 0.5032052993774414, -0.311686247587204, 0.22352446615695953, 0.43382877111434937, 0.7168163657188416, -0.21024054288864136, 0.5168643593788147, -0.6826229691505432, -0.17478644847869873, 0.03933405503630638, 0.2829726040363312, -0.0027206181548535824, 0.24871176481246948, 0.019252212718129158, 0.11853226274251938, 0.186189666390419, -0.39505600929260254, -0.393394410610199, -1.0670368671417236, -0.5839508771896362, 0.17268098890781403, 0.2117285132408142, 0.06069532409310341, -0.6357304453849792, -0.5005553960800171, 0.042821887880563736, 0.2736833691596985, 0.10155145078897476, 0.32698854804039, -1.3724920749664307, 0.5741599798202515, -0.03781402111053467, -0.3429579436779022, 0.39985665678977966, -0.4326527416706085, 0.19827808439731598, 0.25448310375213623, 0.6962783336639404, 0.23378939926624298, -0.44733718037605286, -0.4004761278629303, -0.4329838752746582, 0.7535041570663452, -0.06664092093706131, 0.46446600556373596, -0.13666965067386627, -0.034512124955654144, 0.021649464964866638, -0.450218141078949, -0.03270670399069786, -0.6047554612159729, -0.7673600912094116, 0.4749099314212799, -0.20495359599590302, -0.1805316060781479, -0.02368135191500187, 0.9000362157821655, 0.9176109433174133, 0.0401080958545208, 0.015457426197826862, -0.02145339921116829, -0.22421923279762268, -0.19450980424880981, 0.6351034641265869, -0.3081197142601013, 0.073780357837677, -0.4923168420791626, 0.7124992609024048, 0.10459383577108383, 0.349378377199173, 0.40127506852149963, -0.3834690749645233, -0.32624974846839905, -0.5826224684715271, 0.41933104395866394, 0.2544328570365906, -0.01640314795076847, 0.17519348859786987, 0.5746134519577026, -0.4694518446922302, -0.46786803007125854, 0.5587575435638428, 0.426077276468277, 0.45370423793792725, -0.0003318619274068624, -0.7475752830505371, -0.021842671558260918, 0.39443203806877136, 0.5196938514709473, 0.6489250659942627, -0.05003995820879936, -0.4401692748069763, -0.5193017721176147, -0.2511430084705353, 0.1798238754272461, 0.8958716988563538, 0.40430644154548645, 0.7084037661552429, -0.04248570278286934, -0.06548433005809784, 0.06446071714162827, 1.3698991537094116, -0.4466876983642578, -0.5095803737640381, -0.08872239291667938, 0.5975466370582581, -0.01427513174712658, 0.5392529368400574, -0.3172227442264557, -0.02451396733522415, -0.04547657072544098, -0.4290781021118164, 0.4372255802154541, -0.6425533890724182, -0.6389431953430176, 0.1673823744058609, 0.414527952671051, -0.6400236487388611, 0.6356912851333618, -0.053625937551259995, -0.03199058771133423, -0.3799664080142975, -0.01543510239571333, -0.18084746599197388, -0.15618087351322174, -0.323820561170578, -0.0807860866189003, -0.24689480662345886, 0.4287900924682617, 0.2120514214038849, 0.5105170607566833, 0.4107465445995331, -0.41543281078338623, -0.6090037822723389, 0.6149911880493164, 0.1214083582162857, -0.7017003297805786, -0.2800952196121216, 0.12458990514278412, -0.8145222663879395, -0.2966650128364563, 0.03574861213564873, 0.14758218824863434, 0.7143803834915161, 0.11736693233251572, -1.2485190629959106, -0.7585288882255554, -0.7081587910652161, -0.6045384407043457, -0.17249059677124023, -0.09488910436630249, 0.0032834250014275312, 0.30023759603500366, -0.08813250809907913, -0.33864516019821167, -0.2464713305234909, -0.1557614803314209, -0.798621654510498, 0.13483329117298126, 0.3891735076904297, 0.03431112691760063, 0.4092402458190918, -0.11412900686264038, 0.42451995611190796, -0.34697166085243225, 0.033368732780218124, -0.9350410103797913, -1.0557433366775513, -0.1358756273984909, -0.10268843919038773, -0.11879931390285492, 0.17029240727424622, 0.5872363448143005, -0.05210811644792557, 0.43949806690216064, 0.1781468689441681, -0.25462549924850464, -0.4809405207633972, 0.013614362105727196, 0.6324111223220825, 0.19826824963092804, -0.5631670951843262, -0.36093685030937195, 0.10065292567014694, -0.416679710149765, 0.04059838876128197, 0.09309421479701996, -0.9082770347595215, -0.07837015390396118, -1.249018907546997, 0.7594402432441711, -0.502894401550293, -0.19839562475681305, -0.47500258684158325, -1.1002743244171143, 0.2729896306991577, 0.19331321120262146, -0.2959565818309784, -0.6203710436820984, -0.20294012129306793, -0.07807796448469162, 0.35314714908599854, -0.9391874670982361, -0.047621216624975204, -0.3113372325897217, -0.057337451726198196, -0.2685430943965912, 1.1503633260726929, -1.0335228443145752, 0.4318895936012268, 0.2942793667316437, -0.2376154512166977, -0.23531056940555573, 0.0345340333878994, -0.012712848372757435, -0.5096393823623657, -0.5149548649787903, 0.03063136525452137, -0.07695078104734421, 0.47487673163414, -0.3086003363132477, -0.023787813261151314, -0.11068984121084213, 0.3471089005470276, -0.2428610622882843, -0.4955580234527588, -0.383497953414917, 0.2997598350048065, 0.668346107006073, -0.8990657329559326, 0.25903233885765076, 0.4508311152458191, 0.625095009803772, 0.7334021925926208, 0.3228616714477539, -0.17990568280220032, -0.15575219690799713, -0.9146338701248169, -0.5052661895751953, 0.66765296459198, 0.21089471876621246, 0.4646915793418884, -0.7550613284111023, -0.5040819048881531, -0.09034499526023865, -0.3420340418815613, 0.5535858869552612, 0.6877924799919128, 0.2617538869380951, 0.3605878949165344, -0.49634045362472534, 0.10833979398012161, -0.7565453052520752, -0.07387762516736984, 0.36560094356536865, 0.34505224227905273, 0.06766124069690704, -0.9918462038040161, -0.6818139553070068, -0.798114538192749, -0.039006784558296204, -0.13972072303295135, 0.1267596185207367, 0.14210253953933716, 0.6250649094581604, 0.12461188435554504, -0.3106718361377716, -0.772382378578186, 0.3101170063018799, 0.3537504971027374, -0.0784921869635582, 0.35758545994758606, 0.16509878635406494, -0.15792407095432281, -0.19449158012866974, 0.18878714740276337, -0.8769047856330872, -0.5510004758834839, 0.9698383808135986, -0.5659118890762329, -0.1677512228488922, 1.136437177658081, -0.38663628697395325, -0.5456775426864624, -1.2083752155303955, -0.9201210141181946, -0.03752322867512703, -0.3034566640853882, -0.2039872407913208, -0.2531871199607849, -0.09621834009885788, -0.1878373622894287, -0.15433785319328308, 0.4941711127758026, 0.6049225330352783, 0.08022047579288483, 0.001129777287133038, 0.1701185256242752, -0.707618772983551, -0.4613160789012909, 0.8992220759391785, -0.2839391529560089, -0.749960720539093, 0.39944660663604736, -0.09204936772584915, 0.20429585874080658, -0.14943364262580872, 0.5281251668930054, -0.3735875189304352, 0.2985784113407135, -0.4406796097755432, -0.01654861308634281, 0.9272387623786926, 0.1265975832939148, -0.15864534676074982, 0.3085533380508423, -0.5461333394050598, -0.6599217653274536, 0.32293862104415894, 0.08516941964626312, 0.4270940124988556, 0.4630858898162842, -0.0661182850599289, -0.2635812759399414, -0.04714183881878853, 0.010659754276275635, 0.20231743156909943, -0.6047284603118896, -0.8011650443077087, -0.9160165786743164, -0.49161863327026367, -1.3947129249572754, -0.10218989849090576, -0.36076951026916504, 0.6171448230743408, -0.43316057324409485, 0.4016774892807007, -0.8067709803581238, 0.17317713797092438, 0.15872876346111298, 1.0048655271530151, -0.1930023431777954, -0.6475061774253845, -0.7323075532913208, 0.12719374895095825, -0.00919361226260662, -1.0244373083114624, -0.5411228537559509, 0.03290027379989624, 0.3113178312778473, 1.1580268144607544, -1.3618069887161255, 0.6588523387908936, -0.1391957551240921, -0.7552999258041382, 0.399869441986084, 0.15826405584812164, -0.7332614064216614, 1.298593282699585, 0.12794460356235504, 1.0824607610702515, 0.3368731141090393, 0.052730951458215714, -0.11075884848833084, -0.5252234935760498, -1.085472583770752, 0.9713371396064758, -0.13274161517620087, 0.3837297558784485, 0.8671808242797852, -0.757073700428009, -0.15258868038654327, -0.15487176179885864, -1.0839365720748901, -0.20963959395885468, -0.014326334930956364, 0.45649269223213196, -0.5120956301689148, 0.1820952445268631, -0.11971677094697952, 0.15614083409309387, -0.10786573588848114, 0.6777185201644897, -0.42334720492362976, -0.6328054666519165, -0.10053710639476776, 0.33756223320961, -0.44326940178871155, -0.1118544414639473, -0.09830021858215332, 0.03034174256026745, -0.2712632119655609, -0.0330793634057045, -0.13787095248699188, 0.22562538087368011, -0.6435126662254333, 0.004107001703232527, -0.10270792245864868, 0.847927451133728, -0.6530845165252686, 0.12270396947860718, 1.0792557001113892, 0.12975655496120453, 0.7184076309204102, -0.6261320114135742, -1.507700800895691, 0.09441670775413513, -0.290152907371521, -0.6354604363441467, 0.194052055478096, -0.10493484139442444, -0.12418653070926666, 0.630994975566864, -0.6979671120643616, -0.13043831288814545, 0.6474848985671997, 0.6777022480964661, 0.896141529083252, -0.46468865871429443, -0.7564179301261902, 0.5602480173110962, -0.35258781909942627, -0.5141318440437317, -1.300493836402893, 0.4011825621128082, -0.9605433344841003, -1.2991230487823486, -0.4457963705062866, 0.3045042157173157, -0.07177309691905975, -0.12325851619243622, -0.6528768539428711, 0.14913511276245117, 0.14320693910121918, -0.0032489788718521595, -0.26077285408973694, 0.058818697929382324, 0.05322395637631416, 0.5995427966117859, 0.4242571294307709, -0.6061182022094727, 0.019882991909980774, -0.12841354310512543, 1.3948441743850708, 0.6628974676132202, 0.11772777140140533, 0.9562789797782898, 0.03312826156616211, -0.32620006799697876, 0.04895341768860817, 0.6633176207542419, 0.21103091537952423, 0.5074896812438965, -0.6183112859725952, 0.02426774986088276, 0.4278527796268463, -0.22528982162475586, 0.6523998975753784, -0.2590447664260864, 0.21473371982574463, 0.46046602725982666, 0.42123329639434814, 0.4222884774208069, -0.00470042135566473, 0.7803691029548645, -0.5357110500335693, 0.7343606948852539, -0.18111208081245422, -0.3874509930610657, -0.32744506001472473, 0.06279172748327255, 0.46800222992897034, -0.08378008008003235, -0.16840654611587524, -1.0336278676986694, 0.11156527698040009, 0.7207736968994141, -0.2514026463031769, -0.523372232913971, -0.5307051539421082, 0.42618608474731445, -0.15980567038059235, 0.632054328918457, -0.7612945437431335, 0.04884431138634682, 0.5256232023239136, 0.5142353773117065, -0.9695301651954651, 0.6822642087936401, 0.4284118711948395, 0.9360318779945374, 1.1991419792175293, 0.1334940642118454, 0.4195214807987213, 0.6452456116676331, -0.017494210973381996, -1.143891453742981, 0.20019245147705078, -0.009824656881392002, -0.6530324816703796, -0.12205037474632263, -0.08612802624702454, -0.2824602425098419, -0.18795856833457947, -0.4050178527832031, 0.16515474021434784, -0.5403531193733215, 0.36496785283088684, 0.2536739110946655, -0.5659627318382263, -0.02380717545747757, 0.12744690477848053, 0.31082767248153687, 0.7205362319946289, 0.35462918877601624, 0.18088439106941223, 0.1875499188899994, 1.1202960014343262, 1.130898118019104, 0.34539178013801575, -0.2985844612121582, 0.027826957404613495, 0.3639861047267914, 0.15091432631015778, 0.7812921404838562, -0.7521445155143738, 0.572317898273468, -0.14242708683013916, -0.17114080488681793, -0.4491225481033325, 0.4589304029941559, -0.017001692205667496, -0.5736614465713501, -0.21911658346652985, 0.47528231143951416, -0.2590142488479614, -0.05465666577219963, 1.1047797203063965, 0.6612739562988281, -0.6045539975166321, -0.8503470420837402, 0.784063458442688, -0.6952604055404663, 0.15385891497135162, -0.6845282316207886, 0.38886040449142456, -0.32287856936454773, -0.0037009958177804947, -0.11828845739364624, -0.5876374244689941, -0.23179875314235687, -1.012815237045288, -0.25856906175613403, -0.04058241844177246, 0.8660772442817688, 0.5418148040771484, 0.1398564875125885, 0.3686724603176117, -0.12721362709999084, -0.33170491456985474, -0.10838572680950165, 0.6840763092041016, -0.5523169040679932, -0.06577903777360916, 0.5130894780158997, 0.6338955760002136, -0.7129799127578735, 0.7747611999511719, 1.1561172008514404, -0.40955591201782227, 0.49828892946243286, -0.38070783019065857, 0.6258384585380554, -0.36178746819496155, -0.01280191633850336, -0.2535475790500641, 0.0070010581985116005, 0.44953441619873047, 0.8245664238929749, -0.5279416441917419, 0.2192777693271637, -0.623688817024231, -0.31621453166007996, -0.8537172079086304, 0.8933854103088379, 0.2720399796962738, -0.30257275700569153, 0.1381763368844986, -0.6338414549827576, 4.204628944396973, 0.92862868309021, 0.7537654042243958, 0.35425809025764465, 1.0212713479995728, 1.4307973384857178, 0.2288239449262619, -0.018807940185070038, 0.0773870050907135, -0.3663593828678131, 0.4163188934326172, -0.21326884627342224, -0.11522305756807327, 0.21039451658725739, 0.014612489379942417, 0.6375991702079773, 0.2121974676847458, 0.17119982838630676, 0.24466128647327423, -0.7924862504005432, -0.7318522930145264, 0.1569093018770218, 0.21645160019397736, 0.11212726682424545, 0.2172304391860962, 0.7798492312431335, 0.6643251776695251, -0.4187837541103363, -0.6812445521354675, -0.3877083361148834, -0.3245329260826111, -0.5431334376335144, 0.3532024919986725, -0.3096785843372345, -0.9846347570419312, 0.22824954986572266, 0.19333897531032562, -0.177802175283432, 0.36591506004333496, -0.34872856736183167, 0.028784340247511864, -0.41015148162841797, 0.1456531137228012, -0.43903398513793945, -0.39575499296188354, 0.9940663576126099, 0.34855467081069946, 0.7405861020088196, 1.0149425268173218, -0.9488894939422607, 0.6349483132362366, 0.4230405390262604, 0.09191035479307175, -0.18127785623073578, -0.5679133534431458, 0.29654473066329956, 0.117286816239357, 0.47428053617477417, 0.4037770628929138, -0.8763940930366516, 1.055336833000183, -0.36376652121543884, -0.1031259298324585, 0.0704912468791008, -0.011240573599934578, 0.07152675092220306, 0.027218688279390335, 0.15333740413188934, -0.039249345660209656, 0.10878604650497437, -0.6532872319221497, -0.022708682343363762, -0.693656325340271, -0.08490096777677536, 0.3490924537181854, 0.0668896809220314, -0.04017716273665428, 0.7984119057655334, -0.7535865902900696, 0.07754984498023987, -0.22626176476478577, -0.5787994265556335, 0.04377226158976555, 0.29395052790641785, -0.349376380443573, 0.8383172154426575, 0.3235642910003662, 0.28841206431388855, -0.5410470366477966, 0.14910446107387543, 0.20319922268390656, 0.821797251701355, -0.16473506391048431, 0.4510708451271057, -0.17852044105529785 ]
The Loss of Unitarity in the Vicinity of a Time Machine
We construct the propagator of a non-relativistic non-interacting particle in a flat spacetime in which two regions have been identified. This corresponds to the simplest "time machine". We show that while completeness is lost in the vicinity of the time machine it holds before the time machine appears and it is recovered afterwards. Unitarity, however, is not satisfied anywhere. We discuss the implications of these results and their relationship to the loss of unitarity in black hole evaporation.
Dalia S. Goldwirth, Malcolm J. Perry and Tsvi Piran
gr-qc hep-th
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209005
gr-qc/9209006
[ 0.4848182797431946, 0.2664937973022461, 0.560478925704956, -0.009668984450399876, 0.46051013469696045, -0.0523345023393631, -0.5065914988517761, 0.06294874101877213, 0.03426135331392288, 1.2656445503234863, 0.4857936203479767, -0.47008320689201355, -0.3873710632324219, -0.6312534213066101, -0.40622296929359436, 0.3359713554382324, 0.0668841078877449, -0.16674260795116425, -0.8668179512023926, 0.6774206757545471, -0.153741717338562, 0.059123601764440536, -0.7169461250305176, -0.7293566465377808, -0.39506518840789795, 0.4457430839538574, 0.04169290512800217, 0.26878902316093445, 0.5083560347557068, 0.9384151101112366, 0.43668270111083984, -0.2704177796840668, 0.018315812572836876, -0.3578963577747345, -0.5105424523353577, -0.4571237862110138, 0.049948737025260925, -0.47723180055618286, 0.4580708146095276, -0.3965190649032593, 0.5539602637290955, -0.5861175656318665, 0.05192132294178009, 0.46818503737449646, -0.10579778999090195, -0.135380357503891, -0.04521308094263077, 0.4571263790130615, -0.3324241638183594, -0.6181737184524536, -0.10354126989841461, 0.018739603459835052, -0.1273946762084961, -1.2585668563842773, -0.26990556716918945, -0.14256472885608673, 0.35996294021606445, 0.12117169052362442, -0.7526332139968872, -0.7147237062454224, 0.06476893275976181, 0.7744709253311157, 0.32169443368911743, -0.5969157218933105, -0.23031441867351532, 1.2134881019592285, 0.05586694926023483, 0.15253819525241852, 0.5314818620681763, -0.21961627900600433, -1.214178204536438, -0.19834162294864655, -0.06353578716516495, 0.29973092675209045, -0.6766812801361084, 0.22115381062030792, -0.7138606309890747, -0.3553907573223114, -0.515396237373352, -0.34725168347358704, 0.18173038959503174, 0.1646966189146042, -0.2341955602169037, 0.22353804111480713, -0.16674800217151642, -0.2549748122692108, 0.3844132721424103, 0.17684856057167053, 0.8277624249458313, 0.7644700407981873, -0.16795864701271057, 0.3590952754020691, -0.4151730537414551, 0.01415384840220213, 0.9494432210922241, 0.8184824585914612, -0.1683291494846344, -0.06586138159036636, 0.09017115831375122, -0.19184254109859467, -0.3914133906364441, 1.1393990516662598, -0.8232041001319885, 0.180648535490036, -0.8934230804443359, 0.7596343755722046, -0.0508548729121685, 0.3119848966598511, -0.07863326370716095, -0.6015443801879883, 0.30218061804771423, 0.3450511693954468, 0.8826679587364197, 0.6446499824523926, -0.0741940513253212, 0.22348333895206451, -0.4611179530620575, -0.16649648547172546, -1.0344364643096924, -0.5485190153121948, -0.3139633536338806, 0.20733460783958435, -0.197066992521286, 0.44796666502952576, 0.19578078389167786, -0.47101205587387085, -0.4246268570423126, 0.35421839356422424, -0.33312293887138367, 0.5475923418998718, 0.6175836324691772, -0.4438536763191223, 0.2798890173435211, 0.4552733898162842, 0.7954975366592407, 0.30685389041900635, -0.18142293393611908, -0.06464400887489319, -0.07436919212341309, -0.8451919555664062, 0.2727680504322052, -0.42195573449134827, 0.5860633850097656, 1.2332916259765625, -0.9052005410194397, 0.6601478457450867, -0.23241423070430756, 0.057672105729579926, -0.189215287566185, 0.4361943006515503, 0.06100556626915932, -0.4626677334308624, -0.019596809521317482, 0.2614915370941162, 0.5990608930587769, 0.2140710949897766, -0.9333407282829285, -0.38375017046928406, 0.18053649365901947, -0.33717185258865356, 0.3597508668899536, 0.17316870391368866, 0.2772778272628784, 0.5572954416275024, -0.31168097257614136, 0.8524133563041687, -0.772009015083313, -0.25399523973464966, -0.1251501590013504, 0.1839165985584259, 0.06944133341312408, 0.5041844248771667, 0.2864876985549927, -0.0669703260064125, 0.7529718279838562, 0.5109542012214661, 0.1379396766424179, -0.14145225286483765, -0.33514511585235596, 0.6326467394828796, 0.0046742158010602, -0.8805779814720154, 0.5942585468292236, 0.0261716116219759, -1.1311143636703491, -0.4957652688026428, 0.3507399260997772, -0.3343607783317566, 0.12591730058193207, -0.4861510694026947, -0.9580582976341248, 0.07231269776821136, -0.919861376285553, 0.3413847088813782, -0.7470157742500305, 0.0713854506611824, -0.45413175225257874, -0.741493284702301, 0.009132523089647293, 0.03289991244673729, 0.10704207420349121, -0.14344432950019836, -0.6858596205711365, 0.839957058429718, -1.0558445453643799, -0.1470341682434082, 0.510517418384552, 0.7669661641120911, -0.21308006346225739, 0.016703540459275246, 1.039181113243103, -0.4351814389228821, 0.4743577539920807, -0.4802370071411133, 0.21552778780460358, 0.24380812048912048, -0.28328272700309753, 0.29937154054641724, 0.32917237281799316, 0.1886923909187317, 0.7025570273399353, 0.7016958594322205, -0.5420289039611816, 0.8247315883636475, 0.35382670164108276, -0.07190349698066711, -0.04831305518746376, 0.6948299407958984, -0.45095399022102356, 0.896517813205719, -0.2750175893306732, 0.011851286515593529, -0.1696869283914566, 0.17337267100811005, 0.15218019485473633, -0.5668417811393738, 0.5064129829406738, 0.8077117800712585, -0.3357579708099365, 0.8463523387908936, 0.4327903389930725, -0.03478005900979042, 0.26332226395606995, 0.008843300864100456, -0.889890730381012, 1.149467945098877, 0.05077081918716431, 0.41259080171585083, -0.3513680398464203, 1.182053565979004, -0.9586257934570312, 0.6107762455940247, 0.20938849449157715, 0.11087539792060852, -1.4682978391647339, -0.15669825673103333, 0.10142737627029419, 0.09371306002140045, 0.17162352800369263, -0.3828604817390442, -0.23557594418525696, 0.7945201992988586, -0.22559286653995514, -0.605384349822998, -0.008471887558698654, 0.2018139511346817, -0.7240949273109436, 0.1439494788646698, 0.68449467420578, -0.4239318370819092, -0.8521043062210083, -0.050383057445287704, -0.901192843914032, 0.39240753650665283, -0.03680399805307388, -0.2181241810321808, -0.17268438637256622, 0.0909993126988411, 0.24259796738624573, 0.48909711837768555, -0.263683557510376, 0.419948935508728, 0.18492203950881958, 0.2833573520183563, -0.5675165057182312, -0.2765847444534302, -0.977837860584259, -0.02985069714486599, -0.9580590128898621, -0.18210984766483307, -0.34344011545181274, -0.6134626865386963, -0.173234224319458, -0.23965635895729065, 0.5513626933097839, 0.23088179528713226, -0.23355576395988464, 0.39887550473213196, -0.08431099355220795, -0.6511087417602539, 0.5335481762886047, 0.28026503324508667, -0.18528059124946594, -0.264713317155838, -0.08073034882545471, 1.1145192384719849, -0.38452181220054626, -0.383464515209198, 0.5300649404525757, -0.20560751855373383, -0.18839892745018005, 0.22082257270812988, 0.32060006260871887, 0.7837957739830017, -0.48426881432533264, 1.4079219102859497, 0.6495876908302307, -0.19046825170516968, 0.5300084948539734, -0.39868462085723877, -0.4139062762260437, -0.5497825145721436, -0.05339883640408516, -0.934169352054596, 0.5836007595062256, 0.8569479584693909, 0.6674032211303711, -0.8559005856513977, 0.7238622307777405, -0.7725858688354492, -0.9989134669303894, 0.0721365436911583, -0.458259254693985, 0.534583568572998, 0.4697660803794861, 0.5082472562789917, -0.4277196228504181, -0.2200813889503479, -0.5087363123893738, 0.08282282203435898, 0.34441015124320984, -0.17703938484191895, 0.01650412566959858, 0.5131992697715759, -0.18544404208660126, 0.07238268852233887, 0.9956372976303101, -0.3897623121738434, 0.16272614896297455, 0.022005179896950722, -0.09244708716869354, 0.05950837954878807, 0.12147251516580582, 0.034617479890584946, -0.3819703757762909, -0.7466356158256531, -0.2756655812263489, -0.2119286060333252, -1.0694615840911865, -0.55014568567276, 0.22629040479660034, -0.018366264179348946, 0.18483883142471313, -0.48246943950653076, -0.39581620693206787, 0.2453916370868683, -0.3282923996448517, 0.19051070511341095, 0.3946587145328522, -0.6434838175773621, 0.11435399204492569, 0.5215132832527161, -0.5627514123916626, 0.13300180435180664, -0.02409072034060955, 0.4492083489894867, 0.5116370320320129, 0.09249123930931091, -0.03059985488653183, 0.5289417505264282, 0.02075440064072609, -1.0295277833938599, 0.7723479866981506, 1.1074461936950684, 0.12132687121629715, 0.1189585030078888, 0.24562427401542664, -0.15274454653263092, -0.26888519525527954, -0.5731775760650635, -0.3117006719112396, -0.9351010322570801, -0.15951599180698395, -0.6455509066581726, -0.4632038474082947, 0.09938932210206985, 0.36677053570747375, 0.7940026521682739, -0.1282571405172348, 0.406882107257843, -0.1687753051519394, -0.23861372470855713, 0.20269261300563812, 0.8706845045089722, -0.36733272671699524, 0.8443224430084229, -0.3834954798221588, 0.682965099811554, 0.5834053158760071, 0.23839087784290314, 0.21983768045902252, 0.011132006533443928, -0.08525179326534271, -0.18012069165706635, 0.4842008948326111, 0.08197475969791412, -0.04578178748488426, 0.34012672305107117, 0.37407270073890686, -0.7578060626983643, -0.21008016169071198, 0.24578581750392914, 0.7506819367408752, 0.8146002888679504, -0.28118541836738586, -1.19508957862854, -0.1578618288040161, -0.21264900267124176, 0.35996609926223755, 0.6722872853279114, 0.017690220847725868, -0.6650331616401672, -0.19768156111240387, -0.21786916255950928, -0.19217434525489807, 0.45874348282814026, 0.7718855142593384, 0.6010845899581909, 0.3505629897117615, -0.46874845027923584, -0.07786961644887924, 1.2866894006729126, 0.10305164009332657, -0.3145439624786377, -0.17343828082084656, 0.27654513716697693, 0.42019230127334595, 0.9880416393280029, -0.3214731216430664, -0.9894952774047852, -0.4061974883079529, -0.6167924404144287, 0.6019417643547058, 0.08714443445205688, -0.5026025772094727, -0.053403131663799286, 0.5066359639167786, -0.34498196840286255, 0.6848472356796265, -0.1593773514032364, -0.19529113173484802, 0.1275458037853241, -0.41572439670562744, -0.11937391012907028, -0.2606755793094635, 0.17199739813804626, -0.1818910837173462, 0.9412268996238708, 0.2978208065032959, -0.14228324592113495, 0.0393066368997097, 0.3433033525943756, -0.00577941071242094, 0.13017286360263824, 0.12897177040576935, -0.5873957872390747, -0.02149765007197857, 0.35568371415138245, -0.5617507696151733, 0.16772332787513733, 0.1264229565858841, 0.48980000615119934, -0.21142712235450745, 0.1867319941520691, 0.15670990943908691, -0.6683782339096069, -0.26968929171562195, -0.4457501173019409, -0.8738963007926941, 0.22515642642974854, -0.16591645777225494, -0.006973428186029196, 0.025953197851777077, -0.7632943391799927, 0.019185876473784447, -0.24374759197235107, 0.2233545035123825, -0.4697501063346863, -0.28514978289604187, 0.7375831007957458, 0.09147322177886963, 0.29860246181488037, -0.43136876821517944, 0.25592103600502014, -0.20614412426948547, -0.6124939322471619, -1.2949998378753662, -0.4272644817829132, -0.28875574469566345, 0.031745363026857376, 0.4413341283798218, -0.05645134299993515, 0.15069009363651276, 0.5146978497505188, -0.18102189898490906, 0.5080026984214783, 0.15219633281230927, -1.016786813735962, 0.5716537237167358, 0.2735094130039215, 0.3035512864589691, -0.37036821246147156, 0.11388181895017624, 0.7774462699890137, 0.16421964764595032, 0.5647762417793274, -0.24760711193084717, -0.35384222865104675, 0.4093102216720581, -0.9625985026359558, 0.3597770929336548, -0.9053029417991638, -0.16421090066432953, -0.4688488245010376, -0.3943025767803192, 0.5460330247879028, 0.03949477896094322, 0.04326435178518295, -0.4747399389743805, -0.4551357924938202, -0.8237531185150146, 0.36827152967453003, -0.7504684925079346, 0.11957148462533951, -0.6125785708427429, -0.9103152751922607, -0.32797256112098694, 1.3790816068649292, -0.6411014199256897, 0.016492411494255066, 0.1540728509426117, -0.24757541716098785, -0.4052846133708954, 0.1778273582458496, -0.004376002121716738, 0.004155311733484268, -0.5732926726341248, -0.0801621526479721, 0.4198579490184784, 0.5412645936012268, -0.608862042427063, 0.15888424217700958, -0.42976129055023193, 0.7348621487617493, -0.07367732375860214, -0.4259643256664276, 0.1924026608467102, -0.27131208777427673, 0.34508904814720154, -0.38404229283332825, -0.09586329013109207, 0.7396776676177979, 0.172528475522995, 0.33750200271606445, -0.16259817779064178, -0.15627186000347137, -0.0720699280500412, 0.018630830571055412, -0.43319302797317505, 0.8516421318054199, -0.04153831675648689, -0.32867443561553955, 0.07052682340145111, -0.7302782535552979, -0.32456907629966736, -0.22645331919193268, 0.21165741980075836, 0.5106234550476074, 0.16041287779808044, 0.6559018492698669, -0.4971010684967041, 0.3150289058685303, -0.7470141649246216, -0.15606026351451874, -0.19972097873687744, -0.043027281761169434, -0.5678050518035889, -0.2843438982963562, 0.14583681523799896, -0.397279292345047, 0.09407555311918259, 0.20458516478538513, 0.9446256160736084, -0.10790639370679855, 0.6049721240997314, -0.3532135784626007, -0.42086827754974365, -0.5117918252944946, 0.03891530632972717, 0.09827643632888794, 0.32647666335105896, 0.3736012279987335, -0.2016807645559311, 0.24885590374469757, 0.6023540496826172, 0.13735635578632355, -0.6703946590423584, -0.2593853771686554, 0.7332496643066406, -0.9577678442001343, -0.4983845353126526, 0.4090701639652252, -0.3930509686470032, -0.30680787563323975, -0.9221293926239014, -0.5359984636306763, -0.5656696557998657, 0.24926327168941498, -0.45335274934768677, 0.3428576588630676, 0.20484890043735504, -0.395129919052124, 0.36994633078575134, 0.4855313003063202, 0.3263840079307556, 0.25106576085090637, 0.11299309134483337, 0.28890469670295715, -0.14658771455287933, 0.2493077963590622, 1.027788758277893, 0.2482306957244873, -0.4425222873687744, -0.1345909833908081, -0.3036523461341858, -0.26741060614585876, -1.032005786895752, 0.2947208285331726, -0.4636264443397522, -0.02543850801885128, -0.5416017770767212, 0.48375675082206726, 0.2939137816429138, -0.29129278659820557, -0.4949824810028076, 0.11846306920051575, -0.6842871308326721, -0.43205389380455017, -0.015561975538730621, -0.07197290658950806, 0.6726177334785461, 0.7624557614326477, 0.09991665184497833, -0.19287119805812836, -0.19141584634780884, -0.43850255012512207, -0.10802234709262848, -0.6035272479057312, -0.4771457612514496, -0.324716180562973, -0.8741480708122253, -0.5404382944107056, -0.6598443388938904, -0.2566656470298767, 0.6061000227928162, -0.16975519061088562, 0.7817209362983704, 0.08511386811733246, 0.0015107314102351665, 0.31820622086524963, 0.6258422136306763, -0.18151243031024933, 0.19498364627361298, -0.2743432819843292, 0.29014599323272705, 0.2074289470911026, -0.8844077587127686, -0.03308631107211113, -0.47137516736984253, 0.4396372139453888, 1.2524335384368896, -0.23701083660125732, 0.2090010941028595, -0.12311214208602905, -0.616851270198822, -0.015869315713644028, -0.3124164044857025, -0.5531442761421204, 0.9064782857894897, -0.8087973594665527, 0.8633400797843933, 0.6322786808013916, -0.3703784644603729, 0.04956083744764328, 0.5895858407020569, -1.1952680349349976, 1.1113399267196655, 0.022738490253686905, 0.43205705285072327, 0.5260873436927795, -0.6882655024528503, 0.053704820573329926, 0.09804582595825195, -0.33962559700012207, -0.008940811268985271, -0.22551967203617096, 0.131887748837471, 0.07910958677530289, -0.15430067479610443, 0.20486792922019958, 0.530251145362854, -0.27550944685935974, -0.14131857454776764, -0.9342058897018433, 0.32236790657043457, 0.14763446152210236, 0.31329280138015747, -0.09945404529571533, -0.8533601760864258, 0.023312974721193314, -0.15687532722949982, 0.08138381689786911, 0.2738729417324066, 0.19612319767475128, -0.2657814919948578, 0.6378904581069946, -0.15105056762695312, -0.30313199758529663, 0.3947161138057709, -0.8104425072669983, 0.6650107502937317, 0.23849543929100037, 0.46648159623146057, 0.6751545667648315, -0.6541696786880493, -1.4985222816467285, 0.18427594006061554, -0.30823543667793274, -0.46048691868782043, 0.16580036282539368, -0.2000153809785843, 0.13294366002082825, 0.2439407855272293, -0.4191402196884155, -0.06636513024568558, -0.1629524677991867, 1.1187374591827393, 0.9926154613494873, 0.21254347264766693, -0.08712437748908997, 0.038137733936309814, -0.4732605516910553, 0.024560805410146713, -0.3493605852127075, 0.0011375643080100417, -0.5226463079452515, -0.3039885461330414, -0.5053145289421082, -0.2675124406814575, -0.00009845401655184105, -0.06364407390356064, -0.3913596272468567, -0.48173788189888, -0.027194801717996597, -0.6660748720169067, -0.1095065325498581, 0.02627301774919033, -0.30448639392852783, 0.21167004108428955, 0.050465017557144165, 0.10042496025562286, 0.21107053756713867, 0.07216786593198776, 0.48675960302352905, 0.13046033680438995, 0.37217527627944946, 1.081741452217102, -0.13565975427627563, 0.1296980381011963, -0.2400142252445221, 0.2545580565929413, 0.0884888619184494, -0.4102352559566498, -0.2505703270435333, 0.5555288791656494, 0.21663837134838104, -0.495258092880249, 0.4368038773536682, -0.06917563825845718, -0.4047686755657196, 0.4403805732727051, -0.17736713588237762, 0.20986920595169067, -0.09254337102174759, -0.30916666984558105, -0.0167765524238348, 0.1171775683760643, -0.3883371353149414, -0.6509433388710022, -0.1582484096288681, 0.38047927618026733, 1.0931519269943237, -0.347066193819046, 0.03836218640208244, -0.13472823798656464, 0.11279647797346115, 0.49103641510009766, -0.4896949827671051, -1.0362553596496582, -1.0439372062683105, 0.08258139342069626, 0.5190929770469666, 0.06434725224971771, 0.007918513379991055, 0.554180920124054, 0.03965101018548012, 0.048066578805446625, -0.709617018699646, 0.8555611371994019, 0.6457529664039612, 0.4356309175491333, 0.636164665222168, 0.4115196168422699, 0.21199698746204376, 0.09526269137859344, 0.018706409260630608, -1.0089725255966187, -0.07458397001028061, 0.3846610188484192, -0.6409892439842224, 0.3401346206665039, 0.36257433891296387, -0.4324251711368561, -0.6092734336853027, -0.6274605989456177, 0.31778326630592346, -0.6849631667137146, 0.12568062543869019, 0.09935803711414337, -0.5762848258018494, -0.09437107294797897, 0.25531673431396484, -0.06415717303752899, 0.20568111538887024, 0.11653036624193192, -0.0667414739727974, 0.4728272259235382, -0.08773951232433319, 0.7446462512016296, 0.5538407564163208, 0.321917861700058, -0.6810107231140137, -0.6341047286987305, 0.6614019274711609, 0.22179344296455383, 0.01674063690006733, 0.17231608927249908, -0.9252978563308716, 0.5446543097496033, 0.35033518075942993, 0.06930623203516006, 0.00625626090914011, 0.5735770463943481, -0.27248048782348633, 0.45198917388916016, 0.10352904349565506, 0.3784523606300354, 0.44192004203796387, 0.06273877620697021, 0.20247779786586761, -0.44585105776786804, 0.042363930493593216, -0.678949236869812, 0.4285856783390045, -1.0184015035629272, 0.3941705524921417, 0.49707767367362976, 0.07519499212503433, -0.6693471670150757, -0.5287501215934753, -0.14676760137081146, -0.7130737900733948, -0.2666436433792114, -0.6510751247406006, 1.1102941036224365, 0.7449661493301392, 0.0897485688328743, 0.17795589566230774, -0.19335611164569855, -0.14044548571109772, -0.3734213709831238, 0.716788649559021, 0.21206840872764587, 0.507401168346405, 0.04242725670337677, 0.3019563555717468, -1.2518095970153809, 0.8082937598228455, 1.0100377798080444, -0.10675463080406189, 0.5380553603172302, 0.08984562009572983, 0.016936538740992546, -0.19140027463436127, -0.5877714157104492, -0.09408682584762573, -0.33059266209602356, 0.9215037226676941, -0.2688562572002411, -0.6236675977706909, 0.622013509273529, -0.5735687017440796, -0.5363842844963074, -0.2380267232656479, 0.2953311800956726, 0.3072156310081482, 0.1342286318540573, -0.1771986186504364, -1.0604785680770874, 4.346854209899902, 0.9229721426963806, -0.07291767746210098, -0.3401411175727844, 0.6463750600814819, 0.42881253361701965, 0.07272858172655106, 0.1385183334350586, -0.09064465761184692, -0.552603006362915, -0.02404644526541233, -0.13100063800811768, 0.6515117883682251, 0.12860874831676483, 0.12655934691429138, 0.7295643091201782, 0.09841130673885345, 0.3351222574710846, -0.14717258512973785, -0.5001562237739563, -0.7599894404411316, 0.6134455800056458, 0.15470102429389954, -0.6762337684631348, 0.6180833578109741, -0.04346989095211029, -0.07257066667079926, -1.1296716928482056, -0.13143442571163177, -0.07457027584314346, -0.2919662892818451, -0.6297658085823059, 0.03642921894788742, -0.48160216212272644, -0.9690108299255371, 0.47437113523483276, -0.27247798442840576, -0.1502700299024582, 0.5236503481864929, -0.37811288237571716, 0.46950146555900574, -0.5744684934616089, 0.29541248083114624, -0.053500883281230927, 0.5336711406707764, 0.2537376880645752, 0.5044799447059631, 0.28290918469429016, 0.6727100610733032, -0.809285044670105, 0.43399694561958313, -0.0741332396864891, 0.4162321984767914, -0.330684095621109, -0.6539510488510132, -0.7044661045074463, 0.12542803585529327, -0.12961317598819733, 0.37785276770591736, 0.19240474700927734, 0.8469336032867432, -0.478498637676239, -0.2088938057422638, 0.16674163937568665, -0.21381454169750214, 0.582135796546936, -0.08765009790658951, -0.2145865112543106, 0.21507064998149872, -0.6812769174575806, -0.6816408634185791, -0.29763081669807434, -0.2838751971721649, -0.2578018605709076, 0.4255521595478058, 0.22291140258312225, 0.24781468510627747, 0.9472362399101257, -0.6230716109275818, 0.3569686710834503, -0.5877373218536377, 0.1750110387802124, -0.23272335529327393, 0.7987679243087769, 0.05846400558948517, 0.4321874678134918, -0.14491170644760132, -0.21344248950481415, -1.094341516494751, 0.5058799386024475, 0.01661944016814232, 0.2460700273513794, -0.26342108845710754, -0.34745144844055176, -0.8529046773910522 ]
Asymptotic Behavior of the $T^3 \times R$ Gowdy Spacetimes
We present new evidence in support of the Penrose's strong cosmic censorship conjecture in the class of Gowdy spacetimes with $T^3$ spatial topology. Solving Einstein's equations perturbatively to all orders we show that asymptotically close to the boundary of the maximal Cauchy development the dominant term in the expansion gives rise to curvature singularity for almost all initial data. The dominant term, which we call the ``geodesic loop solution'', is a solution of the Einstein's equations with all space derivatives dropped. We also describe the extent to which our perturbative results can be rigorously justified.
Boro Grubisic and Vincent Moncrief
gr-qc
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209006
gr-qc/9209007
[ 0.3898085951805115, 0.4456014931201935, 0.6846566200256348, -0.29965534806251526, -0.03384764865040779, -0.06937827914953232, -0.5586706399917603, -0.12642475962638855, -0.4179058372974396, 1.093568205833435, 0.351970911026001, -0.566797137260437, -0.1629866659641266, -0.7550656795501709, -0.01872856914997101, 0.6405690908432007, -0.21047453582286835, -0.05842673033475876, -1.4676183462142944, 0.2047920823097229, -0.10540031641721725, 0.24837231636047363, -0.9002528190612793, -0.6019054651260376, -0.018745742738246918, 0.8268327116966248, 0.3661196827888489, 0.09036216884851456, 1.1154890060424805, 0.6661719679832458, 0.4929572641849518, 0.6041497588157654, 0.2338719516992569, -0.4377893805503845, -0.42577314376831055, 0.5564711689949036, -0.019941681995987892, -0.4367096722126007, 0.5254204869270325, -0.0640411302447319, 0.5813180208206177, -0.10480467975139618, 0.24004356563091278, 0.005364345386624336, -1.0136972665786743, 0.15943612158298492, 0.039772678166627884, 0.28234925866127014, -0.12137185782194138, -1.3380235433578491, 0.1420733779668808, -0.029719742015004158, 0.7885876893997192, -1.3028156757354736, -0.0926547646522522, -0.2065160572528839, 0.22505581378936768, 0.3407498598098755, -0.22979488968849182, 0.10184065252542496, 0.19340994954109192, 0.6035289764404297, 0.8749704957008362, -0.20738045871257782, 0.09765730798244476, 1.152740240097046, -0.1497853696346283, 0.30524924397468567, 0.2859102487564087, -0.1498485505580902, -0.17044572532176971, -0.3646477162837982, -0.7269441485404968, 0.07270358502864838, -0.0542479008436203, 0.36558181047439575, -0.5189785957336426, -0.17860427498817444, -0.5347466468811035, -0.7182396650314331, -0.09070641547441483, 0.04467809572815895, 0.1407342553138733, 0.4354352653026581, 0.04953557252883911, -0.278138130903244, 0.3632256090641022, 0.008882424794137478, 0.8205243945121765, 0.1435265988111496, -0.5705925822257996, 0.6060073971748352, -0.0948224887251854, 0.3777780532836914, 0.7808324098587036, 0.574487566947937, -0.23693834245204926, 0.7252600789070129, 0.4464013874530792, 0.19542483985424042, -0.5977681279182434, 0.9934821724891663, -0.3010362386703491, 0.047271039336919785, -0.8125932812690735, 1.2656865119934082, -0.8085060715675354, 0.6189180016517639, -0.4527267813682556, -0.3062690794467926, -0.1559576690196991, -0.05660168081521988, 1.0384575128555298, -0.04856538027524948, -0.12084832787513733, 0.5929705500602722, -0.7039623260498047, 0.18192102015018463, -0.900088369846344, -0.8106432557106018, -0.3965279459953308, 0.7760173082351685, -0.03489777818322182, 0.4364294111728668, 0.01704217866063118, -0.5238070487976074, -0.7111794948577881, 0.10802319645881653, -0.7233029007911682, 0.21411365270614624, 0.3180835545063019, -0.8469549417495728, 0.05300714075565338, 0.5771793723106384, -0.27763450145721436, -0.07396763563156128, 0.4840327203273773, 0.3260522782802582, -0.8767069578170776, -0.4768564701080322, 0.1296158879995346, -0.4332599341869354, 0.14548064768314362, 1.434584140777588, -0.7842347025871277, -0.0022083327639847994, -0.012807847000658512, -0.22947163879871368, -0.5668949484825134, 0.20143811404705048, -0.48180654644966125, -0.8088710904121399, 0.32370248436927795, 0.7842702269554138, 0.03279057890176773, -0.1393159180879593, -1.1584646701812744, -0.16417033970355988, -0.06727008521556854, -0.6469210386276245, 0.14436344802379608, -0.36536145210266113, -0.12459786981344223, 1.3115100860595703, -0.4456869065761566, -0.0074185896664857864, -0.3359834849834442, -0.021727539598941803, -0.023479769006371498, -0.474296897649765, -0.7330853343009949, 0.24171948432922363, -0.24726121127605438, 0.22089235484600067, 0.7681341171264648, 0.35478857159614563, 0.2651045620441437, -0.04112286493182182, -0.3444392681121826, 0.2799914479255676, 0.005395037587732077, -0.5799694657325745, 0.3006821274757385, 0.7393369078636169, -0.9414279460906982, -0.35836470127105713, 0.04593377187848091, 0.07560627907514572, 0.6694227457046509, 0.14433693885803223, -0.554157018661499, 0.5670936703681946, -1.390714406967163, 0.9146466851234436, -0.6249715089797974, 0.13550236821174622, -1.2720484733581543, -0.19633477926254272, -0.45283013582229614, 0.1562802791595459, 0.7071179747581482, -0.18914180994033813, -0.7385306358337402, 0.5126430988311768, -1.1142667531967163, 0.2558184862136841, 0.480527400970459, 0.7142522931098938, -0.27048349380493164, -0.11810322850942612, -0.07426799833774567, -0.3600001633167267, 0.2743947207927704, 0.1535845845937729, 0.46079450845718384, -0.1371573656797409, -0.19279128313064575, 0.38451582193374634, 0.577948808670044, -0.4181425869464874, 0.6918961405754089, -0.03427383676171303, -0.13584470748901367, 1.4752801656723022, 0.05535903573036194, 0.2559988796710968, 0.675796389579773, 1.150404691696167, -0.42336776852607727, 0.40095046162605286, -0.03502969816327095, 0.278804749250412, 0.4053614139556885, 0.30176451802253723, 0.1867973655462265, -0.6599358916282654, 1.1694692373275757, 0.8568437695503235, -0.5880081653594971, 0.3901207149028778, 0.3545762300491333, -0.13897576928138733, 0.7075114846229553, 0.5977033972740173, -0.7068500518798828, 0.31633636355400085, 0.16695888340473175, 0.19451168179512024, -0.21688948571681976, 0.7588579654693604, -0.8172831535339355, 0.5515025854110718, -0.05903295427560806, 0.16556069254875183, -1.6937800645828247, -0.05978750064969063, -0.4445805251598358, 0.6713510155677795, 0.22683113813400269, -0.6756795048713684, -0.38604408502578735, 0.3281151056289673, -0.2681368291378021, -0.4662921726703644, -0.18431004881858826, -0.5284233689308167, -0.6316056251525879, 0.0835043415427208, 0.43830549716949463, -0.493550181388855, -1.1955490112304688, -0.06044657528400421, 0.1949462741613388, 0.3799360990524292, -0.4363137483596802, 0.0005557250697165728, -0.16730298101902008, -0.32436493039131165, 0.4162190854549408, 0.1344354897737503, -0.34621691703796387, 0.7038013935089111, -0.010304535739123821, 0.28929221630096436, -0.3940224349498749, 0.09771175682544708, -1.5005391836166382, -0.08946080505847931, -1.4622762203216553, 0.05952836200594902, 0.22118143737316132, -1.0313701629638672, -0.08650516718626022, -0.5071612596511841, 0.3859027028083801, 0.2702092230319977, -0.4535585939884186, 0.6085110306739807, -0.3252732455730438, -0.295624703168869, 0.8640110492706299, 1.0099496841430664, 0.04423641413450241, -0.2600807547569275, -0.32443690299987793, 0.6389310359954834, -0.3684137165546417, -0.3316052556037903, 0.4292200207710266, -0.5214030146598816, -0.49809521436691284, 0.36012279987335205, -0.03154430165886879, 0.8937422037124634, -0.3815920352935791, 0.372317910194397, 0.48282092809677124, -0.4220287799835205, 0.07144216448068619, -0.33945420384407043, -0.40974682569503784, -0.2845175266265869, 0.837321400642395, -0.3499299883842468, 0.4998970031738281, 0.8030961751937866, 0.11734533309936523, -0.8027253746986389, 0.10302898287773132, -0.8747016191482544, -0.7652855515480042, -0.42752936482429504, -0.7354792356491089, -0.03634810075163841, 0.08792480826377869, 0.5935192108154297, -0.28931790590286255, -0.06897856295108795, -0.10165175050497055, 0.46689102053642273, 0.29954031109809875, 0.1828591525554657, 0.26586100459098816, 0.4120194613933563, -0.08492226153612137, 0.1362292468547821, 1.1319069862365723, -0.2748959958553314, 0.06218681111931801, 0.4675285518169403, 0.03814525902271271, 0.19767875969409943, -0.12960930168628693, -0.3601045310497284, -0.20576559007167816, -0.19656217098236084, -0.2922525107860565, -0.28406116366386414, -0.6385661959648132, -0.8055674433708191, 0.07667852938175201, 0.33832353353500366, 0.26032137870788574, -0.49966779351234436, -0.5474724173545837, 0.07837385684251785, -0.3221750855445862, 0.0929650366306305, 0.357221394777298, -0.79524165391922, 0.5940179228782654, 0.43294739723205566, -0.9951461553573608, -0.07456871122121811, -0.21151317656040192, 0.594957172870636, 0.8421058058738708, 0.5255865454673767, 0.247787743806839, 0.05784619599580765, -0.3395554721355438, -0.5724679231643677, 0.5142614841461182, 0.4040559232234955, 0.09792441874742508, -0.40428969264030457, 0.2499120682477951, 0.5251109004020691, -0.6920900344848633, -0.6920479536056519, -0.013346160762012005, -0.6584687829017639, 0.4147064983844757, -1.0414539575576782, -0.3665163516998291, 0.22283335030078888, 0.5552049279212952, 0.878516435623169, -0.28939926624298096, 0.04727953299880028, -0.11751999706029892, 0.09437475353479385, -0.05858127400279045, 0.5648370385169983, 0.321492075920105, -0.1351267397403717, -0.8404080867767334, 0.6659680604934692, 0.021726645529270172, 0.37453895807266235, 0.4470438063144684, -0.5405124425888062, 0.021142253652215004, -0.6024428606033325, 0.28914719820022583, 0.46730837225914, -0.516731321811676, 1.164157509803772, 0.5709636807441711, 0.16945482790470123, -0.6229190826416016, 0.4295516014099121, 0.24114319682121277, 0.2363927960395813, 0.015685737133026123, -0.2706102728843689, -0.07115156948566437, -0.0016293226508423686, 0.27875733375549316, 1.0247267484664917, 0.006915556266903877, -1.0521661043167114, -0.37027737498283386, 0.08254732191562653, 0.43112608790397644, 0.2333347350358963, 0.6608178019523621, 0.00970574002712965, 0.4848552644252777, 0.028936877846717834, -0.032847318798303604, 1.1553771495819092, -0.3302769958972931, -0.27288150787353516, -0.5514948964118958, 0.32818838953971863, -0.5275040864944458, 0.8516568541526794, 0.5085179805755615, -0.9366810917854309, -0.14580592513084412, -0.013714738190174103, 0.23099613189697266, -0.19820313155651093, -0.8011197447776794, 0.6040447354316711, 0.5604386329650879, -0.5054778456687927, -0.003100380767136812, -0.15766222774982452, 0.08432545512914658, 0.2777070105075836, -0.5521917343139648, -0.2441747784614563, 0.06862882524728775, 0.013285654596984386, -0.030154822394251823, 0.515570878982544, 0.07423266023397446, 0.175759419798851, 0.791704535484314, -0.22398412227630615, -0.661289393901825, 0.5002841353416443, 0.7639524936676025, -0.18996748328208923, -0.19378678500652313, 0.07929813861846924, -0.2259315401315689, -0.5957657694816589, -0.1498221606016159, -0.026762492954730988, -0.5772563219070435, 0.3336036801338196, -0.09750474989414215, -1.1359134912490845, -0.7144536375999451, -0.5888554453849792, -0.6925503611564636, 0.6960474848747253, -0.17034775018692017, -0.40428534150123596, -0.24218761920928955, 0.032915789633989334, 0.12391629070043564, -0.3218398094177246, -0.08154522627592087, -0.5767819881439209, -0.2127392292022705, 0.44751855731010437, -0.6416221857070923, 1.0477294921875, -0.884289562702179, 0.22252576053142548, -0.010688350535929203, -0.24752838909626007, -0.46500054001808167, -0.8880212903022766, -0.7676153779029846, -0.04422584921121597, -0.22986353933811188, -0.1585996150970459, -0.028484411537647247, -0.001060878625139594, 0.04682747274637222, 0.3077707588672638, 0.0754481703042984, -0.6488224864006042, -0.5155121684074402, 0.5786241888999939, 0.5487321019172668, -0.09651952236890793, -0.017623484134674072, 0.7379505634307861, -0.5613455176353455, 0.957068681716919, -0.23094236850738525, -0.341305673122406, 0.4336857199668884, -0.9415780901908875, 0.37648800015449524, -0.9670963287353516, -0.1492433249950409, -0.1256556659936905, -0.16558051109313965, 0.10780429095029831, 0.006533678621053696, 0.41483795642852783, -0.16302204132080078, -0.9140361547470093, -0.27534282207489014, 0.04333733767271042, -0.7954124212265015, 0.32494431734085083, -0.38339710235595703, 0.1448926478624344, -1.1672359704971313, 1.443528175354004, -0.9310488104820251, 0.19074226915836334, 0.7470134496688843, 0.3397054374217987, -0.0691145732998848, 0.7631059288978577, -0.029031876474618912, 0.34694960713386536, -0.993727445602417, 0.28750017285346985, 0.5558047890663147, 0.1687854379415512, 0.0848182737827301, 0.2569398581981659, -0.4606688916683197, 0.7002727389335632, -0.7580580711364746, -0.26940038800239563, 0.7939886450767517, 0.36065012216567993, 0.32697299122810364, -0.35341158509254456, -0.04603305086493492, 0.6136800646781921, 0.13994942605495453, 0.7307736873626709, 0.034301742911338806, -0.11289674788713455, -0.23311826586723328, -0.22914133965969086, -0.8508409857749939, 0.7569478750228882, 0.30872464179992676, -0.16964182257652283, -0.2676723003387451, -0.5797896981239319, -0.28149425983428955, -0.47630831599235535, 0.14728842675685883, 0.4286237955093384, 0.0482976958155632, -0.05861620232462883, -0.15143021941184998, 0.21118193864822388, -0.24729211628437042, -0.0941372662782669, 0.7674104571342468, 0.20072966814041138, 0.04312041029334068, -0.916929304599762, -0.017281610518693924, -0.812812089920044, -0.7347232103347778, 0.7162588834762573, 0.5241780281066895, -0.4041111469268799, 1.0022341012954712, -0.3562002182006836, -0.12613092362880707, -0.7207927107810974, 0.10490915179252625, 0.11128079891204834, -0.5189986228942871, 0.4537736177444458, 0.7613547444343567, 0.29904985427856445, -0.06815739721059799, -0.17846940457820892, -0.7299128174781799, -0.4297066330909729, 0.666680097579956, -0.7464911937713623, -0.04535854607820511, 0.7575817108154297, 0.008837747387588024, -0.577642560005188, -0.5667458772659302, -1.1571729183197021, -0.5095981359481812, 0.2663082778453827, -0.8973941206932068, 0.26331573724746704, 0.22439128160476685, -0.14940288662910461, 0.28356215357780457, 0.08257453888654709, 0.7498652935028076, 0.5037720203399658, -0.024870149791240692, -0.02063334546983242, -0.6526370644569397, 0.016185082495212555, 1.1653937101364136, 0.08929162472486496, -0.6750144362449646, 0.27967917919158936, -0.09338591992855072, -0.07121158391237259, -0.7261503338813782, 0.7441924810409546, -0.1923200935125351, -0.2780403196811676, -0.09301791340112686, -0.24341776967048645, 0.43885987997055054, 0.032183993607759476, -0.41986939311027527, -0.26767614483833313, -1.1228326559066772, -1.0347135066986084, -0.11739089339971542, -0.012610695324838161, 0.33569666743278503, 0.24985243380069733, -0.4082161784172058, 0.06732264906167984, -0.8715178370475769, 0.1893893927335739, 0.2786628007888794, -0.768735945224762, -0.5577667355537415, -0.9464015960693359, -0.74111008644104, -1.1582804918289185, 0.14228279888629913, -0.3477728068828583, 0.41065093874931335, -0.38028424978256226, 0.9939696788787842, -0.059259187430143356, -0.10632380843162537, -0.10027340054512024, 0.8574150204658508, -0.027504093945026398, -0.731579065322876, -0.7376762628555298, 0.4774579405784607, 0.35054609179496765, -1.4435782432556152, -0.4224494695663452, 0.12260702252388, 0.23238660395145416, 1.7085849046707153, -0.8098477721214294, 0.11238252371549606, -0.5927339792251587, -0.5358862280845642, 0.49319276213645935, 0.3588411808013916, -0.2659991681575775, 0.8756400346755981, -0.9141422510147095, 0.8696761727333069, 0.20575112104415894, -0.0845462903380394, -0.9625598788261414, 0.36308303475379944, -0.926237940788269, 0.47728773951530457, -0.19749592244625092, 0.7133285403251648, 0.4735022485256195, -0.506591260433197, -0.09264271706342697, 0.31951895356178284, -1.1113046407699585, 0.07912474870681763, 0.24996940791606903, 0.4015134274959564, -0.46416139602661133, 0.5332369208335876, 0.15266510844230652, 0.07584408670663834, -0.3840862810611725, 0.3962022662162781, -0.7702771425247192, 0.21261227130889893, 0.0008025791612453759, 0.34403231739997864, -0.2593437731266022, -0.8350481390953064, 0.1167510598897934, -0.628683865070343, 0.7106959223747253, 0.31975582242012024, 0.1902455985546112, 0.3651154041290283, -0.08165954053401947, -0.26094046235084534, -0.6593006253242493, 0.21261076629161835, -0.6390642523765564, 0.860170841217041, 0.15471655130386353, 0.6088679432868958, 0.6819045543670654, -0.19879041612148285, -0.545366644859314, 0.05061870813369751, -0.3287869989871979, -1.102575659751892, 0.36182060837745667, 0.11494002491235733, -0.38103076815605164, 0.19082023203372955, -0.5208171010017395, 0.08050426840782166, 0.33972474932670593, 0.8608852028846741, 0.9207538962364197, 0.40365609526634216, -0.6757560968399048, 0.17990028858184814, -0.47235020995140076, -0.7731030583381653, -0.056925635784864426, 0.2863163948059082, -0.755747377872467, -0.15270540118217468, -0.03426889330148697, -0.216008260846138, -0.22307318449020386, 0.23359549045562744, 0.05717867240309715, -0.1296820044517517, -0.19157655537128448, 0.11338002234697342, -0.8175732493400574, -0.060160569846630096, -0.6027578115463257, 0.30209267139434814, 0.2831709384918213, 0.13434898853302002, 0.13689067959785461, 0.19481496512889862, 0.8888431191444397, 0.385111540555954, 0.2674923241138458, 1.6952143907546997, -0.15816551446914673, 0.05264033377170563, 0.37851831316947937, -0.08938387036323547, -0.00281938211992383, 1.0511294603347778, -0.35825297236442566, 0.20590795576572418, 0.6072657108306885, 0.06491679698228836, 0.7419556379318237, 0.07284959405660629, -0.6640778183937073, 0.44157853722572327, 0.11880726367235184, -0.056435853242874146, 0.1876743882894516, 0.1927633434534073, 0.7466732263565063, 0.2801518142223358, -0.3477184772491455, -0.16987471282482147, -0.28098857402801514, 0.149732306599617, 0.24222850799560547, 0.12110477685928345, -0.24214962124824524, -0.7714105248451233, -0.05158526450395584, 0.2551378011703491, -0.5528699159622192, -0.383254736661911, -1.3317644596099854, 0.35096919536590576, -0.35390815138816833, 0.10182029008865356, -0.1400446742773056, 0.4901661276817322, 0.367837131023407, 0.19625915586948395, -0.5033918619155884, 0.22161446511745453, 0.29298192262649536, 0.34583809971809387, 1.0546048879623413, 0.25102168321609497, 0.2977777123451233, 0.6828654408454895, 0.35646945238113403, -1.0968713760375977, 0.21280360221862793, 0.3374781012535095, -0.6063895225524902, 0.32009705901145935, -0.003543566446751356, -0.11846223473548889, 0.17965014278888702, -0.48793572187423706, 0.05255381017923355, -0.3890860676765442, 0.24127860367298126, -0.3073277771472931, -0.4144361615180969, 0.07197829335927963, 0.17255452275276184, 0.0008125374442897737, 0.44379281997680664, 0.656091570854187, 0.7265365123748779, 0.3760755658149719, 0.27947551012039185, 0.9236270189285278, 0.05043191462755203, 0.035891737788915634, -0.05185599997639656, 0.1686919778585434, 0.6861457824707031, 0.45166218280792236, -0.7327265739440918, 0.2517086863517761, -0.5820676684379578, -0.3558295667171478, -0.4063120186328888, 0.2679080665111542, -0.018229564651846886, -0.12346584349870682, 0.2923550307750702, 0.31942498683929443, 0.09706692397594452, 0.6851326823234558, 0.22080020606517792, 0.48085176944732666, -0.5106275081634521, -0.9422116279602051, 0.46251970529556274, -0.7687464952468872, 0.4875168204307556, -1.557942509651184, 0.7363009452819824, -0.07542780041694641, 0.28703102469444275, -0.2867833971977234, -0.12131676077842712, -0.4016481935977936, -0.24590884149074554, -0.2929789423942566, -0.3349679708480835, 0.2910391688346863, 0.6596832871437073, -0.0715135857462883, -0.2584189772605896, -0.6507168412208557, -0.6319960951805115, 0.13858626782894135, 1.2084314823150635, -0.4916497766971588, 0.1823575496673584, 0.6617529392242432, 0.14835567772388458, -0.5506407618522644, 0.8641594648361206, 0.8298388123512268, -0.21533450484275818, 0.37167009711265564, -0.0997675210237503, 0.165853813290596, 0.180707648396492, -0.5001212954521179, -0.43717092275619507, 0.4714590609073639, 0.5907300710678101, 0.20079711079597473, -0.4274498522281647, 0.4020194113254547, -0.6998847723007202, -0.8038122653961182, -0.34413281083106995, 0.9735702276229858, 0.2967568039894104, -0.27810636162757874, 0.6715507507324219, -1.2496895790100098, 4.012186527252197, 0.42531800270080566, 1.1049517393112183, -0.15449410676956177, 1.0800162553787231, 0.8584855198860168, 0.23447822034358978, 0.16246257722377777, 0.6785193085670471, -0.7919557094573975, -0.147596076130867, -0.41740715503692627, 0.2136567384004593, 0.1423444151878357, -0.13933363556861877, 0.4425891935825348, -0.000845627102535218, 0.09862363338470459, -0.4626328647136688, 0.014111447148025036, -1.0739861726760864, 0.017224512994289398, -0.08480411022901535, 0.05490132048726082, 0.11154729872941971, 1.0094236135482788, -0.1506606489419937, -0.8828683495521545, -0.55213862657547, -0.41225767135620117, -0.6405552625656128, -0.7638342380523682, -0.16807663440704346, 0.2541320323944092, -1.1644726991653442, 0.368981271982193, -0.41217538714408875, 0.0023424739483743906, 0.6436153054237366, -0.5198825001716614, 0.09762119501829147, -0.691437840461731, 0.15826599299907684, -0.42001229524612427, 0.13333864510059357, 0.5920238494873047, 0.5934120416641235, 0.867261528968811, 0.6641715168952942, -0.5410445928573608, -0.15176112949848175, 0.338521271944046, 0.6262094974517822, -1.0991032123565674, -1.22490394115448, -0.3603566288948059, 0.09045371413230896, -0.12862184643745422, 0.40274882316589355, -0.612345278263092, 0.7297870516777039, -0.38054418563842773, -0.014488859102129936, -0.2535865306854248, 0.28315848112106323, 0.049041613936424255, 0.7125462889671326, -0.12223248183727264, 0.0678974986076355, -0.05059630796313286, -0.980211079120636, 0.1702854037284851, -0.615372359752655, -0.49968525767326355, 0.16317419707775116, 0.09304673224687576, 0.5634299516677856, 0.3823970854282379, -0.2324654757976532, -0.007379571441560984, -0.49002906680107117, 0.14697128534317017, 0.03288310393691063, 0.7324369549751282, -0.6423986554145813, 0.3288125991821289, 0.17288948595523834, 0.3525870144367218, -0.3846971094608307, 0.9247579574584961, 0.007251433562487364, 0.8733657002449036, -0.3026110827922821, 1.053044319152832, -0.5968121886253357 ]
Semiclassical Effects and the Onset of Inflation
We present a class of exact solutions to the constraint equations of General Relativity coupled to a Klein - Gordon field, these solutions being isotropic but not homogeneous. We analyze the subsequent evolution of the consistent Cauchy data represented by those solutions, showing that only certain special initial conditions eventually lead to successfull Inflationary cosmologies. We argue, however, that these initial conditions are precisely the likely outcomes of quantum events occurred before the inflationary era.
E. Calzetta and M. Sakellariadou
gr-qc
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209007
gr-qc/9209008
[ 0.12353231012821198, 0.6282501816749573, -0.18594574928283691, 0.10353057831525803, -0.415628582239151, 0.02828049659729004, 0.07796072214841843, -0.1250939965248108, -0.29273465275764465, 1.1558005809783936, 0.7243856191635132, -0.09018593281507492, 0.08323509246110916, -0.9395818710327148, 0.006063200533390045, 0.4339243471622467, 0.7049291133880615, -0.18893961608409882, -0.8476893901824951, 0.5244320631027222, -0.1606922149658203, 0.11577766388654709, -0.563198983669281, -0.5943104028701782, -0.4300939738750458, 1.3190776109695435, 1.2349416017532349, 0.3477943539619446, 0.3984178602695465, 0.7537437677383423, 0.353204607963562, -0.1278606653213501, -0.6782907843589783, -0.14703530073165894, -0.44330811500549316, 0.04987919703125954, -0.056983307003974915, -0.25328928232192993, 0.7316422462463379, -0.6448894143104553, 0.2297079861164093, -0.188740074634552, 0.4172709584236145, -0.5726268887519836, -0.26402899622917175, 0.37280794978141785, 0.8380425572395325, 0.7947219014167786, 0.39207422733306885, -0.49088022112846375, -0.05886642634868622, -0.36060473322868347, 0.5639125108718872, -0.7510630488395691, -0.12836405634880066, 0.40728244185447693, 0.6089423894882202, -0.259834349155426, -0.7361879348754883, -0.31764888763427734, 0.28171059489250183, 0.7029200792312622, 0.2729433476924896, -1.1931219100952148, 0.25789573788642883, 0.8663536310195923, 0.17443300783634186, 0.9935097098350525, 0.28032582998275757, -0.2325565218925476, 0.07969734817743301, -0.08971995860338211, -1.2538213729858398, 0.10583123564720154, -0.6420051455497742, 0.05769599229097366, -0.608311116695404, -0.188988596200943, -0.04799375310540199, -0.7429412007331848, 0.008835718967020512, 0.4696131646633148, -0.09834280610084534, -0.047640521079301834, -0.8483309745788574, 0.08918556571006775, -0.12415213137865067, -0.002807880286127329, 0.2621992230415344, 0.3341592252254486, 0.06335113197565079, 0.4560280740261078, 0.18556296825408936, -0.0960744172334671, 0.3778659999370575, 0.8261045813560486, -0.9550330638885498, 0.893811821937561, -0.17495734989643097, -0.2306658923625946, -0.6591702699661255, 1.0506032705307007, -0.05521002411842346, -0.3414432108402252, -0.07572554051876068, 0.8091663718223572, -0.44387856125831604, -0.08901131898164749, -0.8422690629959106, -0.458545982837677, 0.02094789780676365, 0.16232597827911377, 0.419805645942688, 0.3253432810306549, 0.04825235903263092, 0.2692951560020447, -1.1607588529586792, -0.26368477940559387, -1.257155179977417, -0.039400164037942886, -0.31513774394989014, 0.5911791920661926, 0.1040002629160881, 0.48851534724235535, -0.4295191168785095, -1.0874241590499878, -0.13798291981220245, 0.17346301674842834, -0.2650027871131897, 0.22522985935211182, 0.09733856469392776, -0.35048386454582214, 0.2731475830078125, 0.6117491722106934, -0.5272096395492554, -0.22645406424999237, 0.16191652417182922, -0.056185878813266754, -0.16432033479213715, -0.47102394700050354, 0.021789012476801872, -0.1691715121269226, -0.007177586201578379, 1.1529279947280884, -0.09834449738264084, 0.36967167258262634, -0.003625019220635295, 0.021546941250562668, -0.12357962876558304, -0.07021590322256088, -0.3642677664756775, -0.4789711833000183, -0.005931817460805178, 0.11310777813196182, -0.29619601368904114, 0.022712716832756996, -1.4531599283218384, -0.02530859038233757, -0.09218564629554749, -0.6057847142219543, 0.9785508513450623, 0.020742781460285187, 0.27505508065223694, 0.9439536333084106, -0.8426856994628906, 0.25843340158462524, -0.987748920917511, 0.07802505046129227, 0.24825742840766907, -0.8400915861129761, 0.2234601080417633, 0.6294822692871094, 0.40417012572288513, 0.475445032119751, 0.8232235312461853, 0.34737280011177063, -0.35284993052482605, -0.3070264160633087, -0.3769472539424896, -0.14689312875270844, -0.1082238033413887, -0.7741333842277527, -0.054013073444366455, 0.48735833168029785, -0.8751733303070068, -0.23279598355293274, 1.0739376544952393, -0.7917216420173645, 0.5431017875671387, 0.27141693234443665, -0.6494417786598206, 0.5585792660713196, -0.8668531179428101, 0.39092209935188293, -1.1392107009887695, 0.39812999963760376, -1.1255137920379639, -0.27927082777023315, 0.4840238094329834, 0.012911579571664333, 0.5061834454536438, -0.110329769551754, -0.5301852822303772, 0.12436164170503616, -0.7185212969779968, 0.01616690121591091, 0.4512782692909241, 0.674578845500946, -0.9620236158370972, -0.5125266313552856, 0.7282289862632751, -0.49892163276672363, 0.2819240987300873, -1.1654804944992065, 0.8652844429016113, 0.1614377647638321, -0.6378400921821594, 0.0030517634004354477, 0.23057380318641663, -0.18189463019371033, 0.5810160040855408, 0.37628400325775146, -0.14829567074775696, 0.852536141872406, -0.19775019586086273, -0.3828096091747284, -0.0027695985045284033, 0.5044708847999573, -0.12437650561332703, 0.23782879114151, 0.3005630373954773, -0.15171018242835999, 0.2509431838989258, 0.4802905023097992, 0.15270116925239563, -0.2665391266345978, 0.5377131700515747, 0.4560253918170929, 0.06422501802444458, 0.4148969054222107, -0.17814940214157104, 0.0556095689535141, 1.0350052118301392, -0.23820257186889648, -1.0112316608428955, 0.19756273925304413, -0.06926177442073822, 0.319929838180542, -0.9284185767173767, 0.6614319682121277, -0.8264099359512329, 0.5486956834793091, 0.0879833847284317, 0.3289221525192261, -1.4450175762176514, 0.13568784296512604, -0.20096498727798462, 0.21048425137996674, 0.26413023471832275, -0.23259422183036804, -0.41678449511528015, 0.03538556769490242, -0.11324615776538849, -0.9483602643013, -0.44599345326423645, 0.4613465964794159, -0.28428536653518677, 0.11835359781980515, 0.30603888630867004, -0.41302743554115295, -0.7854277491569519, 0.10668667405843735, -0.5694637298583984, 0.13530051708221436, -1.025937557220459, -0.4582725167274475, 0.6221429109573364, -0.04606291651725769, 0.7846660614013672, 0.2185508757829666, -0.23924541473388672, 0.6710258722305298, 0.0009853109950199723, 0.1701064109802246, 0.5055593848228455, 0.09514208137989044, -1.441285252571106, 0.11319786310195923, -1.4264439344406128, 0.22759220004081726, -0.4471049904823303, -1.153106451034546, 0.27338773012161255, -0.40746787190437317, 0.2990720272064209, 0.7156285047531128, 0.09922725707292557, 0.6346525549888611, -0.25430867075920105, -0.47625255584716797, 0.37469109892845154, 0.3178783357143402, -0.006051246542483568, 0.009288648143410683, -0.9000239968299866, 0.8328859210014343, -0.2469833344221115, -0.15810923278331757, 0.47107169032096863, -0.15036973357200623, -0.4041481018066406, 0.44776052236557007, 0.3502057194709778, 0.8388878107070923, 0.2197214961051941, 0.7331908941268921, 0.5187132954597473, 0.1004021093249321, 0.04323713108897209, -0.03296010568737984, -0.13382801413536072, -0.41981151700019836, 0.40478408336639404, -0.4080703854560852, 0.9348199367523193, 0.6764614582061768, 0.4309934675693512, -0.7242056131362915, 1.008711814880371, -1.0532186031341553, -0.886017382144928, -0.4444330334663391, -0.10661913454532623, -0.13873182237148285, 0.06269440054893494, 0.04304587095975876, -1.0956844091415405, -0.6153144240379333, -0.3998306095600128, 0.6514221429824829, 0.7854588031768799, -0.010903911665081978, 0.12321124225854874, -0.097430519759655, 0.7981473207473755, -0.6907109618186951, 0.5409128665924072, -0.7041323184967041, 0.20373228192329407, -0.05750897899270058, -0.2284471094608307, 0.023657821118831635, -0.1273462325334549, -0.05795241892337799, 0.043199989944696426, -0.2094857096672058, -0.5964903235435486, 0.07976622879505157, -0.7263420820236206, -0.7720563411712646, 0.45089906454086304, 0.2342934012413025, 0.29331138730049133, -0.8179110884666443, -0.8113393783569336, 0.09513728320598602, 0.041077788919210434, 0.27522796392440796, 0.5577715039253235, -0.4640256464481354, 0.6093482971191406, 0.37490248680114746, -0.385162353515625, -0.06303612142801285, -0.1131822019815445, 0.1768069863319397, 0.13408558070659637, 0.11257556080818176, 0.06164576858282089, 0.00032827144605107605, -0.651441752910614, -0.38491150736808777, 0.5752599835395813, 0.5036027431488037, 0.35368967056274414, -0.4676235020160675, -0.1381864845752716, 0.1618937849998474, -0.310709148645401, -0.5238058567047119, -0.3263457417488098, -0.45831814408302307, 0.3464270830154419, -0.10053327679634094, -0.26999664306640625, 0.10752855241298676, 0.09912193566560745, 0.6726102232933044, -0.09318310767412186, -0.10611583292484283, 0.24240675568580627, -0.2163013368844986, 0.3079846203327179, 0.4109290540218353, -0.14828072488307953, 0.42747762799263, -0.24867664277553558, 1.006142020225525, 0.6951416730880737, 0.19399838149547577, 0.2458827942609787, -0.7933164238929749, -0.0786823108792305, -0.07059254497289658, 0.7839852571487427, 0.2548453211784363, -0.2507893145084381, 0.2050233632326126, 0.781274676322937, -0.219880610704422, 0.2851567566394806, -0.0768372043967247, 1.4359453916549683, 0.2995014488697052, 0.12436428666114807, -0.32100602984428406, -0.1835746020078659, -0.261281281709671, -0.44706031680107117, 0.2512952983379364, -0.3694063425064087, -0.6989946961402893, -0.33942845463752747, 0.4119066596031189, 0.25047993659973145, 0.0561588779091835, 0.9618249535560608, 0.4396941065788269, 0.3997970521450043, 0.22294797003269196, 0.03842822462320328, 1.6961565017700195, -0.39651474356651306, -0.36921393871307373, -0.04503254219889641, 0.03758624196052551, 0.0559920109808445, 1.0965458154678345, -0.615363359451294, -0.8559191823005676, -0.7768263816833496, -0.31147730350494385, 0.31088897585868835, -0.25595301389694214, -0.6015706062316895, 0.16891038417816162, -0.32915446162223816, 0.05614016205072403, 0.01499993447214365, -0.7493170499801636, -0.25995129346847534, 0.21395514905452728, -0.33827143907546997, -0.04644991084933281, 0.04301689937710762, -0.20132498443126678, -0.008858023211359978, 0.8152772784233093, 0.4764872193336487, 0.38330399990081787, 0.5908243060112, 0.07431000471115112, -0.050570715218782425, -0.47373393177986145, 0.7165769338607788, -0.15576057136058807, -0.3751180171966553, 0.08518628776073456, 0.03794106841087341, -0.26502567529678345, -0.469016432762146, 0.20516811311244965, -0.3226793110370636, 0.6014112234115601, -0.08785771578550339, -0.5943068265914917, -0.7194975018501282, -0.4623940885066986, -0.6017088890075684, 0.9142197370529175, -0.4376007914543152, -0.3836832642555237, 0.4587962031364441, -0.43152397871017456, -0.04798302799463272, -0.3564593493938446, 0.5021542310714722, -0.15059392154216766, -0.4085996747016907, 0.8992704749107361, -0.02658887952566147, 0.6536970734596252, -1.193912148475647, 0.1989363580942154, -0.8562846183776855, -0.6258378028869629, -0.48161643743515015, -0.2641424834728241, -0.20832543075084686, -0.3031001091003418, -0.07383927702903748, -0.09329801052808762, 0.44363704323768616, 0.29549336433410645, -0.24280273914337158, 0.807261049747467, -0.31664809584617615, -0.4312666058540344, 0.3833443820476532, 0.3656732738018036, 0.29179102182388306, -0.4724506139755249, -0.31678056716918945, 1.0703004598617554, -0.07491271942853928, 0.4925627112388611, -0.28399255871772766, -0.12469074875116348, 0.04609142988920212, -0.6934230327606201, 1.0076067447662354, -0.4879668653011322, -0.4855160415172577, 0.22756418585777283, -0.27322936058044434, -0.05126643553376198, 0.555781364440918, -0.3212687075138092, -0.37243062257766724, 0.032783087342977524, -0.25492411851882935, 0.5120270252227783, -0.6113865375518799, 0.8262796401977539, -0.7423969507217407, -0.8876214623451233, -0.1819571554660797, 1.1777870655059814, -0.32815301418304443, 0.28896430134773254, 0.14085815846920013, 0.24620720744132996, -0.5109200477600098, 0.15042303502559662, -0.3138759136199951, 0.6760943531990051, -0.3099701702594757, 0.03018014132976532, -0.1714402735233307, 0.13131992518901825, -0.26314404606819153, -0.15243931114673615, -0.6932136416435242, 0.16203808784484863, -0.2828402519226074, 0.018205814063549042, 0.6216090321540833, -0.33657222986221313, 0.7349561452865601, -0.7148224711418152, 0.26929187774658203, 0.6159705519676208, -0.06968910992145538, 0.3582679331302643, 0.004595469683408737, -0.64350426197052, -0.45570796728134155, -0.48952287435531616, -0.7800275683403015, 0.8439198732376099, 0.1394500881433487, -0.30142539739608765, -0.43788596987724304, -1.0095149278640747, -0.1900414526462555, 0.022813372313976288, -0.10152474045753479, 0.39714211225509644, -0.15080158412456512, 0.7544804811477661, -0.5368362069129944, 0.05216169357299805, -0.5181260108947754, -0.28861090540885925, 0.5556410551071167, 0.2909744381904602, 0.6352235674858093, -0.3615954518318176, -0.3313867151737213, -0.2859131991863251, -0.13558457791805267, 0.23372898995876312, 0.190679669380188, 0.00832030363380909, 0.7578532099723816, 0.05976887047290802, -0.5917021632194519, -0.6119475364685059, -0.21259848773479462, 0.6732628345489502, -0.32010647654533386, -0.0031658930238336325, 0.6861647963523865, 0.13893793523311615, 0.42396625876426697, -0.10842258483171463, -1.4435641765594482, -1.016436219215393, 0.8440216779708862, -1.0876325368881226, 0.1717357188463211, 0.2579241991043091, -0.6046921014785767, -0.35868021845817566, -0.7913260459899902, -1.4602515697479248, 0.14221569895744324, 0.12995144724845886, -0.8272186517715454, 0.4336688220500946, -0.33499377965927124, 0.02938169799745083, 0.43093931674957275, 0.13753803074359894, 0.2957170903682709, 0.5000832676887512, 0.8402305841445923, 0.1068161353468895, -0.6691523194313049, 0.1593421846628189, 1.2403275966644287, 0.3859613537788391, -0.333652526140213, -0.17518173158168793, 0.6009596586227417, -0.2985101640224457, -0.28142961859703064, 0.8431346416473389, -0.4897594749927521, -0.02849237062036991, -0.07916444540023804, 0.04186790809035301, 0.3925948143005371, 0.3258016109466553, 0.051125768572092056, 0.19263088703155518, -0.6564510464668274, -0.8680219650268555, 0.010296785272657871, -0.397986501455307, 0.10038052499294281, 0.6113263964653015, 0.41126585006713867, -0.013279242441058159, -0.23541902005672455, 0.02190386690199375, -0.17488636076450348, -0.6602355241775513, -0.1405133157968521, -0.6707119345664978, -0.49016666412353516, -0.6709105968475342, -0.0008985779713839293, -0.013806047849357128, 0.5525955557823181, -0.7025009393692017, 0.6347636580467224, -0.23824457824230194, 0.3597082793712616, 0.3708561658859253, 0.44736722111701965, -0.7172494530677795, -0.7316849231719971, -1.1655977964401245, 0.10194937884807587, -0.0815512165427208, -1.198965311050415, -0.46548062562942505, -0.891701877117157, 0.7102862000465393, 1.5622990131378174, -0.6935537457466125, 0.12587803602218628, -0.7615324854850769, -0.8706878423690796, 0.23425740003585815, -0.04378455504775047, -0.5466287732124329, 0.6025866270065308, -0.055915892124176025, 0.7000587582588196, 0.9570967555046082, 0.3748784065246582, -0.22023892402648926, 0.13336214423179626, -0.8787786364555359, 0.9536586403846741, 0.560581386089325, 0.5694925785064697, 0.307734876871109, -0.7932191491127014, 0.20952337980270386, 0.00013080693315714598, -0.5916720032691956, 0.21537373960018158, -0.6017791032791138, 0.23439998924732208, -0.566251814365387, 0.604232132434845, 0.2618314325809479, 0.36790451407432556, -0.4546035826206207, 0.3300575315952301, -0.9091343283653259, 0.537955641746521, 0.39659327268600464, 0.01595398038625717, -0.5801296830177307, -0.506066620349884, 0.7252475619316101, -0.5104678273200989, -0.053651753813028336, 0.28122296929359436, 0.1714020073413849, 0.4041175842285156, 0.364949494600296, -0.19910521805286407, -0.51933354139328, -0.06446973979473114, -0.7069122791290283, 0.799643337726593, 0.39138951897621155, -0.5322192907333374, 1.1345453262329102, -0.5371055603027344, -1.1933361291885376, 0.20912310481071472, 0.33497563004493713, -0.5885283350944519, 0.693362832069397, 0.11565320193767548, -0.23475013673305511, -0.012986649759113789, -0.32420217990875244, 0.0004752260574605316, 0.09566975384950638, 1.1613540649414062, 0.7214565277099609, 0.08241197466850281, 0.05151411518454552, -0.13963674008846283, -1.1181621551513672, 0.0991271585226059, -0.48039522767066956, 0.46284106373786926, -1.025435209274292, -1.0637197494506836, 0.032597675919532776, -0.12203898280858994, 0.2834432125091553, -0.26728367805480957, 0.3185897767543793, -0.07645600289106369, -0.23257075250148773, 0.1561162918806076, 0.3567013442516327, -0.42927461862564087, -0.5945994257926941, 0.04912921041250229, 0.3700844645500183, 0.09858404099941254, 0.2456279993057251, 0.1456184834241867, 0.8986403346061707, -0.2224191278219223, -0.22489358484745026, 1.4133648872375488, 0.01666385494172573, 0.3247928321361542, 0.2792290151119232, 0.9061700105667114, -0.10469995439052582, 0.20555232465267181, -0.2467789649963379, -0.08614188432693481, 0.17024701833724976, -0.18489234149456024, 1.0126012563705444, 0.018497051671147346, 0.21814140677452087, 0.982665479183197, 0.2752962112426758, -0.24276763200759888, 0.42228469252586365, -0.013814219273626804, -0.24968449771404266, 0.9038018584251404, -0.32307225465774536, -0.24925245344638824, 0.08128949254751205, -0.045850083231925964, 0.0019159716321155429, -0.01682344451546669, -0.36547034978866577, -0.22917839884757996, 0.24397587776184082, 0.28073349595069885, -0.7478916645050049, -0.6675341129302979, -0.44736817479133606, -0.1052616536617279, 0.42189469933509827, 0.11950460076332092, -0.5712598562240601, -0.7428491115570068, 0.32121410965919495, 0.0823480561375618, 0.0023329018149524927, 0.630486011505127, 0.16784422099590302, 1.2238105535507202, 1.1325476169586182, 0.2904140055179596, 0.16096939146518707, 0.4239985942840576, 0.6790586113929749, -0.7161712646484375, 0.2725769877433777, -0.038520634174346924, -0.5184263586997986, 0.12168269604444504, 0.1999650001525879, -0.0419645756483078, -0.4743056893348694, -0.2710060179233551, 0.4515080749988556, -0.4479650855064392, 0.0052353451028466225, -0.6133431792259216, -0.14871087670326233, -0.22622814774513245, 0.1747899055480957, 0.34602421522140503, 0.1880984753370285, 0.20193500816822052, 0.36124885082244873, 0.2861584722995758, 0.2921770215034485, 1.4119842052459717, 0.1301952749490738, 0.3358513116836548, -0.47323471307754517, -0.19838882982730865, 0.584983766078949, 0.893949031829834, -0.38938039541244507, 0.36970385909080505, -1.372689127922058, 0.21095533668994904, -0.35443830490112305, 0.0024640075862407684, -0.27942317724227905, -0.25435033440589905, 0.4371994733810425, 0.46270400285720825, -0.3678802251815796, -0.30952882766723633, 1.2775217294692993, 0.8619849681854248, -0.4864685833454132, -0.6252842545509338, 0.8339011073112488, -0.6028919816017151, 0.2702125906944275, -0.8051431179046631, 0.34227433800697327, -0.24784456193447113, -0.10036084800958633, -0.6946303844451904, -0.1498125195503235, -0.4062313437461853, -0.12069990485906601, 0.2821880578994751, -0.12860311567783356, 0.24159850180149078, 1.1540493965148926, -0.5314496755599976, -0.10585077852010727, -0.5984534621238708, -0.6238465905189514, -0.428718626499176, 0.631520688533783, -0.11267305165529251, 0.1278301328420639, 0.49247676134109497, -0.2745126485824585, -1.1497122049331665, 0.8137882351875305, 0.40386489033699036, -0.41543662548065186, 0.876078724861145, -0.19126996397972107, 0.13162072002887726, 0.4702393412590027, -0.44264620542526245, 0.005518482066690922, -0.4112592935562134, 0.32003703713417053, 0.137220561504364, -0.3656429350376129, -0.09998166561126709, -0.18658921122550964, -0.6194297075271606, -0.4236849546432495, 0.49313950538635254, 0.11389590054750443, -0.48820528388023376, 0.2523573040962219, -0.907706081867218, 4.068004608154297, 0.20214185118675232, 0.4360377788543701, 0.22433769702911377, 0.9931946396827698, 1.1522136926651, -0.26978015899658203, 0.7342126369476318, 0.23505298793315887, -1.0741488933563232, -0.032589301466941833, 0.11178194731473923, 0.5815730094909668, 0.21460413932800293, 0.3376578688621521, 0.37240445613861084, 0.03966517373919487, 0.08797255903482437, -0.14214560389518738, -0.40573468804359436, -0.9178850054740906, 0.473306804895401, 0.2864876389503479, 0.18779399991035461, 0.7278378009796143, 0.3250683844089508, 0.07554244250059128, -0.7923893928527832, -1.1806814670562744, -0.3668730556964874, 0.020096903666853905, -0.46470096707344055, 0.19380415976047516, -0.28032395243644714, -0.9314336776733398, 0.029614463448524475, -0.1617855280637741, -0.21563856303691864, 0.8211323022842407, 0.06381195783615112, -0.10542275011539459, -0.5167941451072693, 0.29195743799209595, -0.6143890619277954, 0.49231261014938354, 0.8732741475105286, 0.9742600917816162, 0.5725423693656921, 0.310965359210968, -0.7240347266197205, -0.22991259396076202, 0.28493639826774597, 0.30561527609825134, -0.8155428767204285, -0.3956436812877655, -0.8250429034233093, -0.29500627517700195, 0.06038491800427437, 0.042349375784397125, 0.01037196721881628, 0.6608952879905701, -0.18208204209804535, -0.10441925376653671, -0.2328525334596634, 0.051811907440423965, 0.13494563102722168, 0.4434147775173187, -0.10552061349153519, 0.1368117779493332, -0.39570531249046326, -1.0211321115493774, 0.23249779641628265, -0.31812402606010437, 0.12315463274717331, 0.34025120735168457, 0.15662524104118347, -0.11093014478683472, 0.5475475192070007, 0.11657357215881348, 0.7765765190124512, -1.0612623691558838, -0.035172220319509506, -0.6249261498451233, 0.34406691789627075, -0.3345782458782196, 0.554350733757019, -0.4841507375240326, -0.24327866733074188, -0.38307276368141174, 0.569428026676178, 0.16293029487133026, 0.7918742895126343, -0.07827265560626984, 0.3989926874637604, -0.881126880645752 ]
Continuous Family of Einstein-Yang-Mills Wormholes
It is shown that for some particular value of the cosmological constant depending on the gauge coupling constant a continuous one-parameter family of Einstein-Yang-Mills wormholes exists which interpolates between the instanton and the gravitating meron solutions. In contradistinction with the previously known solutions the topological charge of these wormholes is not quantized. For all of them the contribution of gravity to the action exactly cancels that of the gauge field.
E.E. Donets and D.V. Gal'tsov
gr-qc hep-th
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209008
gr-qc/9209009
[ -0.054827697575092316, -0.22314295172691345, -0.46342161297798157, -0.7147559523582458, -0.5000098943710327, 0.2679879665374756, -0.5485028624534607, -0.6554819941520691, -0.003909518476575613, 1.1745188236236572, 0.15387295186519623, 0.6817867159843445, 0.11400908976793289, -0.5008466839790344, -0.3688339591026306, 0.13707873225212097, -0.760802149772644, -0.4103325605392456, -1.0413062572479248, 0.38586580753326416, 0.09515227377414703, 0.9111436009407043, -0.7808728814125061, -0.846950113773346, -0.3556632995605469, 0.4903455376625061, 0.40634894371032715, -0.04964054003357887, 1.0483839511871338, 1.2295136451721191, 0.10310463607311249, -0.08371341228485107, 0.2557106018066406, -0.7428736686706543, -0.3092464208602905, -0.3133535385131836, 0.4359320402145386, -1.1394338607788086, 0.24691830575466156, -0.4455912113189697, 0.22188572585582733, -0.4762805998325348, 0.3040097653865814, -1.1415916681289673, -0.6134097576141357, -0.18998835980892181, 0.14564014971256256, -0.1610744446516037, -0.2685009837150574, -1.416676640510559, 0.0713881105184555, -0.40820667147636414, 0.060158900916576385, -0.7102609872817993, -0.05434710532426834, 0.03227066248655319, 0.21891000866889954, 0.10912992060184479, -0.5509706139564514, 0.44198325276374817, 0.6693822145462036, 0.10547934472560883, -0.20848064124584198, -1.5102204084396362, 0.36718735098838806, 0.24131852388381958, -0.3358212113380432, 0.42166629433631897, -0.49370473623275757, -0.42479801177978516, -0.36278605461120605, -0.17572824656963348, 0.36680617928504944, 0.4929811656475067, 0.21824076771736145, 0.46475738286972046, -0.2702368199825287, -0.6208056211471558, -0.5023894906044006, -0.09063485264778137, -0.14773446321487427, 0.06707045435905457, -0.8596075177192688, 0.2908153831958771, -0.5463373064994812, -0.20294202864170074, 0.23659713566303253, 0.13231977820396423, 0.8822554349899292, 0.1880304515361786, 0.8229350447654724, 0.8479308485984802, -0.09936271607875824, 0.05131706967949867, 0.08188500255346298, 0.18794535100460052, -0.5903673768043518, 0.9601643085479736, 0.05474895238876343, 0.7993793487548828, 0.22672085464000702, 1.6105016469955444, -0.03356482833623886, 0.8778396248817444, -0.863240659236908, 1.5031920671463013, -0.27186262607574463, -0.23496894538402557, 0.15013664960861206, -0.7487265467643738, 0.04153105616569519, -0.332069993019104, 0.17256082594394684, 0.7161011099815369, 0.5409514307975769, 0.6941211819648743, -0.8808166980743408, 0.4161445200443268, -0.5409778952598572, 0.6576180458068848, -0.38810282945632935, 0.6423876285552979, 0.5274258852005005, 0.05140857771039009, 0.3254110813140869, -0.3120507597923279, -0.04703924432396889, 0.3368065655231476, -0.6330435276031494, -0.40921303629875183, 0.15649071335792542, -0.37034285068511963, -0.12081561982631683, 0.379526823759079, 0.34880879521369934, 0.4987010955810547, 0.1596081554889679, -0.037518374621868134, -0.1252613663673401, 0.005887071136385202, -0.40191274881362915, -0.35712146759033203, 0.34199967980384827, 1.1637444496154785, -0.3666551411151886, 0.21645984053611755, -0.0027759354561567307, -0.02219005674123764, -0.6670899391174316, -0.043849650770425797, 0.48284339904785156, -0.347420871257782, -0.5381951332092285, 0.13058361411094666, -0.2688138782978058, -0.22799234092235565, -0.4656643867492676, -0.8597654104232788, -0.07567434012889862, -0.26039227843284607, 0.004494779743254185, -0.07686300575733185, -0.09147364646196365, 1.3695714473724365, -0.350193589925766, -0.06827441602945328, -1.270255208015442, 0.21960680186748505, 0.08389313519001007, 0.8144753575325012, 0.05925457924604416, 0.22097620368003845, 0.4776475429534912, 0.3163103461265564, 0.5701552033424377, 0.9445049166679382, 0.18851721286773682, -0.3665250539779663, -0.10047038644552231, 0.1841455101966858, -0.21499724686145782, -0.8045700788497925, 0.3446308374404907, 0.27679213881492615, -0.12014512717723846, -0.1565786898136139, -0.13320539891719818, 0.03917958214879036, 0.5249863266944885, 0.08216574043035507, -0.09087201952934265, 0.8579966425895691, -1.4797894954681396, 0.8457448482513428, -0.7792114615440369, 0.2716136872768402, 0.23446093499660492, -0.12204115092754364, -0.20048688352108002, -1.2317982912063599, 0.04060053452849388, -0.12853892147541046, -0.9506756663322449, 0.1418311446905136, -1.2907296419143677, -0.4190404713153839, 0.9574389457702637, 0.5594178438186646, -0.33858150243759155, 0.39075425267219543, 0.3368396759033203, 0.2125832885503769, -0.42128393054008484, -0.5331178903579712, 0.34117943048477173, 0.6221686005592346, 0.6507825255393982, 0.6539198160171509, -0.07841207087039948, 0.5506178140640259, 1.0796048641204834, 0.5447509288787842, -0.02067463845014572, 0.4115544557571411, 0.02545517310500145, -0.8415340781211853, -0.38363781571388245, 1.029653787612915, 0.1465139240026474, 0.36800652742385864, -0.33798450231552124, 0.054394662380218506, 0.3126443922519684, 0.5924091935157776, 0.8828599452972412, 0.5901435017585754, 0.6960521340370178, 0.5864688158035278, -0.13392654061317444, 0.44306138157844543, 0.8183339238166809, 0.7874902486801147, 0.8648595809936523, -0.2490631639957428, -0.3601568341255188, 0.873007595539093, 0.22982484102249146, 0.47366294264793396, -0.5626946091651917, -0.23716989159584045, -0.7747765183448792, 0.14269433915615082, 0.5895094871520996, -0.2862820625305176, -1.4791568517684937, 0.6135940551757812, 0.004678075201809406, 0.8816878795623779, 0.3971446454524994, -1.1548609733581543, 0.5874951481819153, 0.8513904213905334, -0.6096279621124268, 0.2922428846359253, -0.03513868525624275, 0.35919028520584106, -0.4071134030818939, 0.3612399399280548, -0.18702545762062073, -0.46695879101753235, -1.2051182985305786, -1.1810872554779053, -0.9072496294975281, -0.4276943504810333, -0.3992283046245575, -0.26177528500556946, 0.23266425728797913, -0.22508187592029572, 1.203399658203125, 0.6895689964294434, -0.2490503340959549, -0.0904899463057518, -0.2524697482585907, 0.3101576268672943, 0.142924964427948, 0.7514964938163757, -0.300258606672287, 0.4302466809749603, -0.374806672334671, 0.8204796314239502, 0.34496039152145386, -1.1714186668395996, 0.07984688878059387, -0.3528693914413452, 0.36636173725128174, 0.07452249526977539, -0.2874184250831604, 0.720941960811615, -1.0407243967056274, -1.079468011856079, 0.10571864247322083, 0.31712859869003296, 0.10913809388875961, -0.033471569418907166, -0.4865194857120514, 0.7606369853019714, -0.16862063109874725, -0.43114566802978516, 0.32363778352737427, -0.21972115337848663, -0.9991419911384583, 0.5560633540153503, 0.3813695013523102, 0.2606958746910095, -0.18021920323371887, 1.650455355644226, 0.816265344619751, -0.44167301058769226, 0.023193662986159325, -1.0156421661376953, 0.14038525521755219, -0.0028504393994808197, 0.8655908107757568, -1.0255217552185059, -0.07935892790555954, 1.3861110210418701, 0.38874340057373047, -1.142290472984314, 0.7938952445983887, -0.496227890253067, -1.7624428272247314, -0.39642441272735596, -0.3721798360347748, -0.14206956326961517, 0.1624804586172104, -0.15947717428207397, -0.31636035442352295, -0.956662654876709, 0.43738359212875366, -0.0002033612399827689, 0.5776364803314209, -0.38170936703681946, -0.10081957280635834, 1.0110975503921509, 0.7039328813552856, 0.058582853525877, 0.27659112215042114, -0.5903266668319702, 0.04495798423886299, 0.43337205052375793, 0.22195746004581451, 0.15432217717170715, -0.43149298429489136, 0.05572649836540222, 0.31236186623573303, 0.0971204861998558, -0.46436619758605957, 0.15394212305545807, -0.6371185183525085, -0.33858123421669006, 1.0818227529525757, -0.02265283465385437, 0.06615252792835236, -1.0252279043197632, -0.7243660688400269, -0.6697530150413513, 0.07826030254364014, 0.04324192926287651, 0.41917160153388977, -1.070801854133606, 0.5340975522994995, -0.43682852387428284, -0.9019672870635986, -0.03296820446848869, 0.08182410150766373, -0.24962101876735687, 0.10086282342672348, 1.1762797832489014, 0.6506047248840332, -1.3836419582366943, -0.9356942176818848, -0.10069561749696732, 0.7231684923171997, 0.4367848038673401, -0.03754405677318573, -0.19695088267326355, -0.5654746294021606, -0.3732314109802246, -0.05190803110599518, -0.8697437047958374, -0.024228138849139214, -0.10402592271566391, -0.23467114567756653, -0.045420266687870026, -0.32298511266708374, 0.5686268210411072, 0.8039341568946838, 0.2910664677619934, 0.37029606103897095, 0.09107467532157898, 0.36110979318618774, 0.17904838919639587, 0.5918360948562622, 1.0590888261795044, -0.006698029115796089, 0.18863445520401, -0.48560813069343567, 0.09369053691625595, 0.4637700319290161, 0.11297823488712311, -0.015997709706425667, -0.5500050187110901, 0.2457490712404251, 0.07763942331075668, 0.049675360321998596, 0.3928869366645813, -0.30130913853645325, 0.5793148875236511, 0.617057740688324, 0.5513353943824768, -0.34017014503479004, 0.3587116301059723, 0.36421769857406616, 1.0567214488983154, 0.270035058259964, -0.7606652975082397, -0.8033971190452576, -0.8940148949623108, 0.011582798324525356, 0.21574445068836212, 0.023252390325069427, -0.03134775161743164, -0.7981847524642944, 0.3643173277378082, 0.16952449083328247, 0.5410133600234985, 0.7026642560958862, 0.4176733195781708, 0.13197778165340424, -0.8212432861328125, -0.1614273637533188, 1.250261902809143, -0.22400718927383423, -0.09152241796255112, -0.5475620627403259, 1.0873619318008423, -0.012474734336137772, 0.6722819209098816, -0.47120922803878784, -0.785783052444458, -0.3013865649700165, -0.479778915643692, 1.1048707962036133, -0.32619625329971313, -0.5513449311256409, 0.0970548689365387, 0.4265996217727661, -0.1736270636320114, 0.3431406319141388, 0.4749036431312561, -0.3183121383190155, -0.07295064628124237, 0.0925137922167778, -0.3692566156387329, -0.5922960638999939, 0.22752882540225983, -0.33596110343933105, 0.07079675793647766, 0.4162967801094055, -0.015453817322850227, 0.9221340417861938, -0.3012552857398987, -0.19488561153411865, 0.2202773243188858, 0.4494517743587494, -0.5112817883491516, -0.4960864186286926, 0.14494483172893524, -0.9470725059509277, -0.2626889646053314, -0.07261831313371658, -0.38356930017471313, -0.21200165152549744, 0.16791576147079468, -0.3907625377178192, -0.5532755255699158, -0.48347175121307373, -0.41078057885169983, -0.2426515519618988, -0.08584292978048325, -0.15992358326911926, 0.11914676427841187, -0.32283222675323486, -0.41392120718955994, -0.35623496770858765, -0.5003524422645569, 0.33991846442222595, -0.6289601922035217, 0.3718412518501282, 0.662930965423584, 0.2845240533351898, -0.02716618962585926, -0.148247629404068, -0.05829351022839546, -0.0652550533413887, -0.2960602641105652, -0.7703226208686829, 0.09080570191144943, -0.06324318051338196, 0.6778517961502075, 0.5047814846038818, -0.14644567668437958, 0.2346206158399582, 0.5103145241737366, 0.8600080013275146, 0.7475135922431946, -0.41035035252571106, -0.5866454839706421, -0.36143821477890015, 0.6061442494392395, 0.13417313992977142, -0.8599520325660706, -1.0940147638320923, 0.2674865126609802, -0.2605205774307251, 0.6913952231407166, 0.11361024528741837, -1.312366247177124, -0.2570055425167084, -1.057101845741272, 0.25670644640922546, -0.7631412744522095, -0.8262659907341003, -0.8535826206207275, 0.3343549370765686, -0.24955981969833374, 0.37532100081443787, 0.8839476704597473, -0.5088072419166565, -0.6810715794563293, -0.8838556408882141, 0.13208100199699402, -0.5710992217063904, 0.4287702441215515, -0.3391810655593872, -0.24015140533447266, -0.05015628784894943, 1.2484403848648071, -0.3521549701690674, -0.5022172927856445, -0.09098879247903824, 0.6921466588973999, 0.2783830761909485, 0.5050185322761536, 0.4550166428089142, -1.0798338651657104, -0.5571980476379395, -0.475580632686615, 0.47201910614967346, -0.1970575600862503, -0.8962143659591675, 0.2898613512516022, -0.4453013837337494, 0.3624119460582733, -0.24551494419574738, 0.05450299009680748, 0.18926462531089783, -0.9062138795852661, 0.4711328148841858, -0.9912014603614807, -0.1101982519030571, 0.5620852708816528, 0.06150640547275543, 1.1371501684188843, -0.7007147669792175, -1.1176687479019165, -0.6704253554344177, -0.8165140151977539, -0.826680064201355, 0.20189081132411957, 0.07420073449611664, -0.7833691239356995, -1.0887951850891113, -0.672970712184906, 0.1920207291841507, -0.35803478956222534, 0.4366846978664398, 0.8272726535797119, 0.28476595878601074, 0.3762446939945221, -0.6444399952888489, -0.05419357493519783, -0.05966818705201149, -0.010521240532398224, 0.7273630499839783, -0.39601776003837585, -0.5715833902359009, -0.28787675499916077, -0.45059436559677124, -0.024592049419879913, -0.0026183398440480232, 0.23563964664936066, 0.4654463231563568, -1.1821881532669067, 0.2604476809501648, 0.17205464839935303, -0.6739464402198792, -0.04509788379073143, 0.17720440030097961, 1.0971838235855103, -0.5807567834854126, 0.4844778776168823, 0.28076815605163574, 0.27784064412117004, 0.04598652571439743, -0.43159523606300354, -0.7502396702766418, 0.6047664880752563, 0.937294065952301, -0.8932782411575317, -0.372983455657959, 0.08654170483350754, 0.07479222118854523, -0.32859423756599426, -0.7468634247779846, -0.43004339933395386, 0.18978258967399597, 0.3107258379459381, -0.7762863636016846, 0.42697811126708984, 0.4578394889831543, -0.0467197485268116, 0.12255766987800598, 0.28662002086639404, 0.44912979006767273, 0.11713691800832748, 0.9343852400779724, -0.313955157995224, -1.3332780599594116, 0.3771069645881653, 1.145910382270813, 0.3267543315887451, -0.09256187081336975, 0.18555784225463867, -0.5195961594581604, -0.6610732078552246, -0.37299686670303345, 0.4792325794696808, -0.6814975738525391, 0.49676012992858887, 0.2660025954246521, 0.48303690552711487, 0.9382129907608032, 0.4315307140350342, -0.20590072870254517, 0.8520355820655823, -0.7722814083099365, -0.8448173403739929, 0.17791970074176788, 0.734216034412384, 0.19469261169433594, 0.15106160938739777, -0.18820281326770782, 0.20572473108768463, 0.055758725851774216, -0.46425724029541016, -0.04732245206832886, -0.26538214087486267, -0.8736569881439209, -0.7691892981529236, -1.0309958457946777, -0.6893354654312134, -0.3864680230617523, 0.1029762253165245, 0.21405592560768127, -0.6462893486022949, 0.8372137546539307, 0.15692146122455597, 0.229469895362854, -0.09530869126319885, 0.9999638199806213, -0.5628339648246765, -0.33614638447761536, -0.7689560651779175, -0.4506678283214569, 0.06676172465085983, -0.9209743738174438, -0.3607005476951599, -0.06679195910692215, 0.2919909656047821, 0.8448858261108398, -0.33486130833625793, 0.32325395941734314, -0.5170365571975708, -0.13348352909088135, -0.18104436993598938, -0.5355821847915649, -0.821174681186676, 1.1859873533248901, -0.3230316638946533, 0.037604719400405884, 0.03725876286625862, -0.08837803453207016, -0.10932183265686035, -0.43651214241981506, -0.9014095067977905, 0.34913888573646545, -0.41348180174827576, 1.0801575183868408, -0.049415454268455505, 0.11465512216091156, -0.28682848811149597, 0.24036221206188202, -0.4555011987686157, 0.1061769425868988, -0.1383397877216339, 0.2989697754383087, -0.6651355028152466, -0.5390739440917969, 0.5570833086967468, 0.7397499680519104, -0.19296690821647644, 0.5666853785514832, -0.4470205008983612, -0.5328002572059631, -0.09825712442398071, -0.25141680240631104, -0.5079481601715088, 0.28417110443115234, 0.05222652480006218, -1.1730644702911377, 0.4818844199180603, -0.04270635545253754, -0.0025236790534108877, -0.322128027677536, -0.01986219733953476, 0.2873629331588745, -0.4542149603366852, 0.2882862389087677, -0.20624269545078278, 0.46659180521965027, 0.3346083164215088, 0.4051419496536255, -0.0199997890740633, -0.2040283977985382, -0.4428139328956604, 0.5404441952705383, -0.8230058550834656, -0.4693417251110077, 0.35699018836021423, -0.2925356924533844, 0.2644728124141693, -0.01303549762815237, -0.77347731590271, 0.2523280382156372, 0.14057642221450806, 0.4345090389251709, 0.31966984272003174, 0.07504743337631226, -0.7248296737670898, 1.0524567365646362, -0.9715597629547119, 0.27172815799713135, -0.3829399347305298, 0.5712358951568604, -0.532453179359436, -1.1179709434509277, -0.780631422996521, -0.016504628583788872, -0.9858829975128174, -0.3005942702293396, -0.6558138132095337, 0.38266652822494507, -0.035616882145404816, -0.6480475664138794, 0.31359562277793884, -0.4766521453857422, -0.45968297123908997, -0.0024354245979338884, 0.19280385971069336, -0.1443312168121338, -0.14588281512260437, -0.28564581274986267, 0.6932150721549988, -0.0024416923988610506, -0.24365872144699097, 0.730782687664032, 0.32184678316116333, -0.3271166682243347, -0.02642008662223816, 0.5217713713645935, 0.30638423562049866, 0.4199428856372833, -0.9092950820922852, 0.3312934637069702, -0.13700740039348602, -0.05501352250576019, -0.04391665384173393, -0.0072739762254059315, 0.20167109370231628, 0.7843135595321655, 0.045104630291461945, 0.5682604312896729, -0.27153193950653076, -0.30194029211997986, 0.04943028837442398, 0.19801335036754608, -0.2305203229188919, 0.5972365140914917, -0.21749891340732574, 0.15254491567611694, 0.6577234268188477, -0.542688250541687, -0.3207850456237793, -0.014640282839536667, 0.2190854698419571, 0.6666789054870605, -0.3807952404022217, -0.7988954186439514, -0.7931181192398071, -0.1390582174062729, 0.5203417539596558, 0.3957115113735199, -0.19158810377120972, 0.2099875509738922, 0.9347327947616577, 0.16463598608970642, -0.44267353415489197, 0.6546480059623718, 0.08671601861715317, 0.5765693187713623, 0.24700428545475006, -0.029067276045680046, 0.4678930938243866, 0.2863124907016754, -0.0873858854174614, -0.26093024015426636, -0.17417822778224945, -0.17745572328567505, -0.7776036858558655, -0.8370645046234131, 0.43666768074035645, -0.4059821665287018, -0.23878152668476105, -0.494148850440979, 0.4907708764076233, -0.6446151733398438, -0.4892612397670746, 0.445176899433136, -0.19553972780704498, -0.4822704792022705, 0.3082677125930786, 0.24234771728515625, 0.5222305059432983, 0.4744575321674347, 0.09719308465719223, -0.20868223905563354, 1.7508443593978882, 0.767903208732605, 0.4652203321456909, -0.19683662056922913, 0.03936692699790001, -0.3993256986141205, 0.1967497020959854, 0.6504600048065186, -0.3449872136116028, 0.4534628391265869, -0.04614386335015297, -0.12013218551874161, -0.3694838285446167, 0.04299008846282959, -0.5472036004066467, 0.3197334408760071, 0.4903050363063812, 0.937476396560669, 0.022398993372917175, -0.011372126638889313, 0.4691283404827118, 0.4516274631023407, 0.5641393065452576, -0.23475489020347595, 0.027052586898207664, -0.6328083872795105, -0.3349277377128601, -0.9596549868583679, 0.8215543627738953, -0.39473456144332886, 0.4469306170940399, -0.503911018371582, 0.3628372251987457, -0.06062326952815056, -0.6073881983757019, -0.7768006920814514, 0.5667273998260498, 0.6911255121231079, 0.8425005674362183, -0.44579219818115234, 0.3320559561252594, -0.24096009135246277, -0.8713476657867432, 0.0072211152873933315, 0.18767471611499786, 0.036065127700567245, 0.6444739103317261, 0.6124292612075806, -0.008484071120619774, -0.7230128645896912, 0.9991843700408936, 0.4223615825176239, -0.21440760791301727, 0.6396037340164185, -0.19688451290130615, 0.03731619194149971, 0.07235218584537506, -0.37890228629112244, 0.05421781539916992, 0.6488223075866699, 0.21296747028827667, 0.31802037358283997, -0.7990156412124634, -0.10821382701396942, 0.2341003268957138, 0.08173207938671112, -0.226284459233284, 0.4779636561870575, 1.020278811454773, -0.5529154539108276, -0.016841396689414978, -0.13928960263729095, 3.924804449081421, 0.550688624382019, 0.23492693901062012, -0.1624535471200943, 1.0831371545791626, 1.1981486082077026, 0.18160349130630493, 0.23995815217494965, 0.42599180340766907, -0.36208412051200867, -0.1561303436756134, 0.17221051454544067, -0.4728362262248993, 0.20220208168029785, -0.03642059862613678, 0.16392776370048523, 0.3373374044895172, -0.8061748147010803, 0.4719724655151367, -0.4932606518268585, -0.7448481321334839, 0.19212937355041504, 0.0761500671505928, -0.23141740262508392, 0.5663450956344604, 0.14609378576278687, 0.21609121561050415, -0.7084723114967346, -0.06157582998275757, -0.48187145590782166, -0.8161613941192627, -0.3454863727092743, 0.44966456294059753, 0.2588684856891632, -0.9924350380897522, 0.6165100336074829, 0.2232518196105957, -0.17638620734214783, 0.1314728856086731, 0.0675506591796875, -0.14317212998867035, -0.5017162561416626, 0.17470824718475342, 0.039103154093027115, -0.12359298765659332, 0.9704552888870239, 0.4741063117980957, 0.7921519875526428, 0.2079228311777115, -0.9375348091125488, 0.7614223957061768, 0.23755310475826263, 0.1493665724992752, -0.06958629935979843, -0.5284573435783386, 0.04178726673126221, 0.6008530259132385, -0.24648217856884003, 0.8386626243591309, -0.3804044723510742, 0.8052411079406738, 0.1893049031496048, 0.022126302123069763, -0.15512964129447937, 0.21356946229934692, -0.46753498911857605, 0.7189310789108276, -0.2400697022676468, -0.08972736448049545, -0.19882842898368835, -0.7838200330734253, 0.1150987520813942, -0.009781922213733196, -0.16500622034072876, 0.606156051158905, 0.12535704672336578, 0.01947135291993618, 0.6085292100906372, -0.7740796208381653, -0.03612801060080528, -0.6062861680984497, -0.18013063073158264, -0.11537442356348038, 0.44770511984825134, 0.5173226594924927, 1.0883197784423828, -0.5122883319854736, -0.19831371307373047, -0.5229998230934143, 0.5500372052192688, -0.08750340342521667, 0.8397557139396667, 0.16015982627868652, 0.7119224667549133, -0.39451172947883606 ]
Euclidean Maxwell-Einstein Theory
After reviewing the context in which Euclidean propagation is useful we compare and contrast Euclidean and Lorentzian Maxwell-Einstein theory and give some examples of Euclidean solutions.
Dieter Brill
gr-qc
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209009
gr-qc/9209010
[ 0.06238457188010216, 0.3440588712692261, 0.14536623656749725, 0.08590870350599289, -0.7856858968734741, -0.2736310660839081, -0.6883140206336975, 0.4838123619556427, -0.4328795373439789, 0.9222152829170227, 0.33988818526268005, 0.13232949376106262, -0.2773558795452118, -0.6886558532714844, -0.4492568373680115, -0.13437038660049438, -0.22236961126327515, 0.13592448830604553, -1.073846459388733, -0.3385832905769348, 0.29299646615982056, 0.4581500291824341, -1.143434762954712, -0.41560283303260803, -0.7474436163902283, 0.3046362102031708, 0.7333537936210632, -0.06542044878005981, 1.0636526346206665, 0.7208424210548401, 0.4747526943683624, -0.5542435646057129, -0.3389900326728821, -1.2914140224456787, 0.06543290615081787, -0.04049743339419365, 0.780347466468811, -0.051616884768009186, -0.20574931800365448, -0.49010205268859863, 0.3017520308494568, 0.5832604765892029, 0.10702967643737793, -0.3708600699901581, -0.9127302169799805, -0.562099039554596, -0.35254597663879395, 0.014027000404894352, 0.5109266638755798, -0.4441274404525757, -0.5854856967926025, 0.02242663875222206, 0.7055590152740479, -0.5380468368530273, -0.040011946111917496, -0.21137458086013794, 0.3832397162914276, 0.6974281668663025, 0.20308828353881836, -0.12139883637428284, 0.7416285276412964, 0.2612813115119934, 0.378131628036499, -0.6814957857131958, -0.05873768404126167, 1.018595576286316, -0.20495443046092987, 0.1480807214975357, -0.0017551915952935815, -0.5188711285591125, 0.4000798165798187, 0.6038788557052612, -0.00852350052446127, 0.01866726577281952, -0.3015901744365692, 0.4078451097011566, 0.17908069491386414, 0.09622285515069962, -1.0318409204483032, 0.48637670278549194, -0.014661270193755627, -0.013612531125545502, -0.360195517539978, 0.4598921239376068, 0.20474915206432343, -0.4068301320075989, 0.6755865216255188, -0.34693577885627747, 0.20581358671188354, -0.45594263076782227, 0.24112166464328766, 0.6034653782844543, -0.8500072956085205, 0.13396327197551727, 0.834955096244812, -0.01767265610396862, -0.09745481610298157, 0.1332962065935135, 0.3031095862388611, 1.0820305347442627, -0.4636076092720032, 1.7269080877304077, -0.3158177137374878, 0.3775789439678192, 0.06898844987154007, 0.7747215628623962, 0.009685912169516087, 0.10086831450462341, -0.8774460554122925, -0.3838682472705841, 0.3442380726337433, -0.22560763359069824, 0.5193597674369812, 0.3980850875377655, -0.19436615705490112, 0.5398796200752258, -0.43819770216941833, 0.30855679512023926, -0.4376581311225891, -0.6288467049598694, -0.368020623922348, 0.493817538022995, 0.8474650979042053, 0.2609136700630188, -0.035380564630031586, -0.4673847556114197, 0.40854954719543457, -0.5713329911231995, -1.2039192914962769, 0.30008426308631897, -0.19341176748275757, -0.19238999485969543, -0.13252045214176178, 0.209478959441185, 0.10376802086830139, 0.0526360385119915, 0.4471740424633026, 0.4284681975841522, -0.36233311891555786, -0.6915369629859924, 0.4796195328235626, -1.2196882963180542, 0.17669425904750824, 1.066332221031189, -1.2507644891738892, 0.6967724561691284, -0.08141779899597168, -0.177389457821846, -0.10584386438131332, 0.6071133613586426, 0.1725524514913559, -0.8452678322792053, -0.374502032995224, 0.5180087685585022, 0.09891939908266068, -0.20918406546115875, -0.7250270247459412, 0.12966091930866241, -0.051498424261808395, -0.20232966542243958, 0.42718765139579773, -0.12441438436508179, -0.3118951916694641, 0.5343117117881775, -0.1346788853406906, -0.15906156599521637, -0.27935487031936646, -0.6921043395996094, 0.7154309153556824, -0.1952221691608429, -0.25150033831596375, 0.371271550655365, 0.1946125328540802, 0.34837859869003296, 0.6011902093887329, -0.23619772493839264, 0.7959696650505066, -0.4123138189315796, -0.4639912247657776, -0.0046152411960065365, 0.09226420521736145, -0.4898320734500885, 0.8755358457565308, 0.4821855127811432, -0.05723635479807854, -0.18482516705989838, 0.42828643321990967, 0.41603726148605347, 0.37520143389701843, 0.10863398015499115, -0.035546377301216125, 0.5890169143676758, -0.7714815139770508, 0.14681749045848846, -1.2114413976669312, -0.332952082157135, -0.26897454261779785, -0.11131244897842407, -0.329690158367157, -1.2592147588729858, 0.5015084743499756, 0.011306135915219784, -0.5426927208900452, 1.043755054473877, -0.8284903764724731, -0.12830011546611786, 1.0254052877426147, 0.35383790731430054, -0.8282449245452881, 0.09952389448881149, 0.5098013281822205, 0.2485327571630478, 0.16316546499729156, 0.29290279746055603, 0.11745073646306992, -0.3544928729534149, -0.11889327317476273, 0.15411095321178436, 0.07140173763036728, 0.36094292998313904, 0.6346082091331482, 0.1697203665971756, 0.38467666506767273, 0.6108273863792419, 0.7414647936820984, -0.5389873385429382, 0.006774023175239563, 1.2367279529571533, -0.19998043775558472, 0.5323007702827454, -0.3320004940032959, 0.3015667498111725, 0.5231233239173889, 0.09659133106470108, 0.9250397682189941, 0.007971572689712048, 0.7321555018424988, 0.6405268311500549, -0.17529602348804474, -0.020996280014514923, 0.45330244302749634, 0.29471322894096375, 0.13933344185352325, 0.517730176448822, -0.263919472694397, 0.15937361121177673, 0.09886772185564041, -0.20354178547859192, -0.6835663318634033, 0.47330015897750854, -0.8503206968307495, 1.1706773042678833, 0.5639543533325195, 0.3079209327697754, -0.6018636226654053, -1.037111520767212, -0.39804041385650635, 0.636755108833313, -0.03797433525323868, -0.6070867776870728, -0.0975867286324501, 0.5299860835075378, 0.07898173481225967, -0.13053889572620392, -0.23009926080703735, 0.059999532997608185, -0.24084840714931488, 0.16710413992404938, -0.07050546258687973, -0.5631554126739502, -1.0209332704544067, 0.040366169065237045, -0.21658477187156677, -0.16007715463638306, 0.020350784063339233, -0.08245489001274109, 0.33177363872528076, -0.48237282037734985, 0.5518035292625427, -0.39574286341667175, -0.4940643608570099, 0.6452653408050537, -0.6330751180648804, 0.013553888536989689, -0.16844449937343597, -0.010294090956449509, -0.6367802023887634, -0.02356477826833725, -0.819263756275177, 0.7085027694702148, -0.2941468060016632, -0.4425697326660156, -0.5746161341667175, -0.223650723695755, 0.2763785123825073, -0.014941454865038395, -0.5114316940307617, -0.06687041372060776, 0.005650135222822428, -0.5326189398765564, 0.387098491191864, 0.41753238439559937, 0.2231781780719757, -0.022213095799088478, -0.9914499521255493, 0.8335281610488892, -0.056724630296230316, -0.3235073685646057, -0.14301779866218567, 0.10029523074626923, -0.6175029873847961, 0.6689509749412537, -0.5095670223236084, 0.04705169051885605, 0.022839892655611038, 0.41551756858825684, 0.48724982142448425, -0.7163417339324951, 0.37345609068870544, 0.008715029805898666, -0.4745221734046936, -0.5334369540214539, 0.029248904436826706, -0.5402398109436035, 0.35193344950675964, 1.5342540740966797, 0.24790264666080475, -0.4928097128868103, 0.47352340817451477, -1.1837087869644165, -0.8678351044654846, 0.16700437664985657, -0.1981111466884613, 0.22028441727161407, 0.5938262939453125, -0.21997451782226562, -0.18070001900196075, 0.34236660599708557, -0.6258580684661865, 0.5884535908699036, 0.6430672407150269, -1.3216534852981567, -0.035703565925359726, 0.2972554862499237, -0.315214067697525, 0.3382386565208435, 0.6336913108825684, -0.15057863295078278, -0.37510812282562256, 0.5292267203330994, -0.36125344038009644, 0.28523650765419006, 0.3374806046485901, 0.3045528531074524, -0.2377534657716751, -0.11540275812149048, -0.06877312064170837, -0.23651756346225739, -0.18414781987667084, -0.1452498883008957, 0.08206339925527573, 0.29911527037620544, 0.5460414290428162, 0.43322885036468506, -0.5888186693191528, -0.30830317735671997, -0.363246887922287, -0.06851744651794434, 0.5035374760627747, -1.1720610857009888, 0.5870174765586853, -0.4211089015007019, -0.3306494355201721, -0.5557070970535278, -0.17378684878349304, -0.11978541314601898, 0.31103819608688354, 0.6537778377532959, 0.9710054993629456, -0.6433237195014954, -0.48775604367256165, -0.30776315927505493, 0.6649940013885498, 0.03771728277206421, 0.28906264901161194, -0.2948836088180542, 0.6140276789665222, 0.1893465220928192, -0.318159282207489, -0.1761425882577896, -0.25500351190567017, -1.2976877689361572, 0.15029416978359222, -0.6104947328567505, -0.6167320609092712, -0.02600979432463646, 0.3628831207752228, 0.5546813011169434, -0.05077969282865524, -0.41370752453804016, -0.09389099478721619, -0.4458853304386139, 0.2268027812242508, 0.07575559616088867, -0.2676222622394562, 0.7302984595298767, -0.45730048418045044, 0.028824761509895325, -0.24889525771141052, 0.014757468365132809, 0.3137299120426178, -0.1958949714899063, 0.10454028844833374, -0.09011387079954147, 0.4914470911026001, 0.38803350925445557, 0.16374081373214722, 1.3358476161956787, 0.08732934296131134, -0.5003768801689148, -0.6784265637397766, 0.7024073004722595, 0.41212213039398193, 0.9645743370056152, -0.018567455932497978, -0.8173536658287048, 0.20838657021522522, -0.57808917760849, 0.2763955295085907, 1.1260045766830444, -0.7132938504219055, -1.0063706636428833, -0.04348354786634445, -0.0838845819234848, 0.24084937572479248, 0.1360338032245636, 1.2939046621322632, 0.12177016586065292, 0.4037420451641083, -0.14986751973628998, 0.14496812224388123, 0.8853061199188232, -0.6303514838218689, -0.18669405579566956, 0.5099520087242126, 0.6352442502975464, -0.13085484504699707, -0.23752249777317047, -0.5641952157020569, -0.5860275030136108, -0.34874629974365234, -0.7934397459030151, 0.5366240739822388, -0.666804850101471, -0.47880133986473083, 0.7017190456390381, 0.9251108765602112, -1.055625557899475, 0.3485235273838043, -0.27285584807395935, 0.02959284372627735, -0.03540236875414848, 0.3252878785133362, -0.7898984551429749, -0.33254244923591614, -0.43197759985923767, 0.04065262898802757, 0.25361597537994385, 0.8141385912895203, -0.6371936202049255, 0.632304847240448, 0.7259895205497742, -0.20612874627113342, -0.4064817428588867, -0.19219523668289185, -0.4632810652256012, 0.014166099950671196, -0.18378354609012604, -0.6073961853981018, 0.05500359460711479, -0.07918412238359451, 0.6104577779769897, 0.5512240529060364, -0.20235233008861542, 0.10148120671510696, -0.5892127156257629, -0.335875928401947, -0.4009037911891937, -0.8043989539146423, 0.9564161896705627, -0.7345662117004395, -0.3335435092449188, -0.5404933094978333, -0.5230104327201843, -0.07947801798582077, -0.3298451602458954, -0.08581015467643738, -0.45586854219436646, 0.4854351580142975, 0.40491244196891785, 0.028737971559166908, -0.09623904526233673, -0.6762163043022156, 0.054989948868751526, -0.43718308210372925, -0.8751747608184814, -0.86037278175354, -0.1650933176279068, 0.03242990002036095, 0.04944951832294464, -0.025707164779305458, 0.09337889403104782, -0.40872347354888916, -0.08518064767122269, -0.19133144617080688, -0.020072484388947487, -0.30784159898757935, -0.8198440670967102, 0.016234179958701134, 0.6956138610839844, 0.6589457988739014, -1.3736947774887085, -0.917205810546875, -0.14875763654708862, -0.41009223461151123, 0.2487993985414505, -0.5626271367073059, -1.3769199848175049, 0.8687157034873962, -0.9022037982940674, 0.30955180525779724, -0.26565733551979065, 0.24061912298202515, -0.5886375308036804, -1.0905776023864746, -0.5256142020225525, 0.23579524457454681, 0.7644776701927185, -0.26204463839530945, 0.2542801797389984, -0.20716579258441925, 0.6599453091621399, -0.24374274909496307, 0.3111477196216583, 0.06548858433961868, -0.05576339736580849, -0.70844566822052, 1.2528208494186401, 0.030531195923686028, -0.6173128485679626, 0.019250132143497467, 0.1787688434123993, 0.3852415680885315, 0.7917670011520386, 0.3880769908428192, -0.5268641710281372, -0.3554825484752655, -0.0198744498193264, 0.20130828022956848, 0.671082615852356, -0.4862344563007355, 0.5307395458221436, -0.19603979587554932, 0.8412847518920898, -0.3324793577194214, 0.3428328335285187, 0.10058701038360596, -0.16862830519676208, 1.1095869541168213, 0.06769499182701111, 0.017411300912499428, 1.229684591293335, -0.1991959810256958, 0.11138606816530228, 0.27998775243759155, -0.5627659559249878, -0.9833468198776245, -0.15134106576442719, -0.37151819467544556, 0.6204710602760315, 0.24255208671092987, -0.11715546995401382, -0.15592755377292633, -0.1663619577884674, 0.18536701798439026, -0.8190608024597168, 0.8265048265457153, -0.1539350301027298, 0.16653820872306824, -0.24429403245449066, -0.815141499042511, -0.5942712426185608, -0.17358867824077606, -0.41456618905067444, 0.39670175313949585, -0.3804035186767578, -0.6867883205413818, -0.05014842376112938, -0.565283477306366, -0.878143846988678, -0.4656713008880615, 0.014006459154188633, 0.42742910981178284, -0.04881763830780983, 0.46569767594337463, 0.19622379541397095, -0.4135896861553192, -0.2128937840461731, 0.44566428661346436, 0.5423620939254761, -0.13346704840660095, 0.8686551451683044, 0.33689603209495544, -0.07884495705366135, 0.07161886990070343, -0.19543947279453278, -0.5889500379562378, -0.4307091236114502, 0.6698132753372192, -0.4187382459640503, -0.343845933675766, 0.4140021502971649, 0.38568830490112305, -0.6705459952354431, 0.07521135360002518, -0.1851513683795929, -0.5626527070999146, 0.22903220355510712, -0.14956320822238922, -0.5096844434738159, -0.37937819957733154, -0.6319085359573364, 0.14853116869926453, 0.05063154175877571, 0.17941710352897644, -0.06748058646917343, 0.3158646821975708, -0.48622044920921326, -1.1332777738571167, 0.08087942004203796, 1.414422869682312, 0.3980838656425476, -0.25816744565963745, -0.28454726934432983, 0.10251571238040924, -0.7338037490844727, -0.6708172559738159, 0.27082523703575134, 0.2515076994895935, -0.10695801675319672, 0.49633339047431946, 0.19987048208713531, 0.6007736325263977, 0.5409272313117981, 0.3491913974285126, 0.783517599105835, -0.8009243607521057, -0.8671887516975403, 0.033923495560884476, -0.12034481763839722, 0.2428993135690689, 0.26180872321128845, -0.21271100640296936, 0.015839166939258575, -0.14641135931015015, 0.37495195865631104, 0.42089158296585083, 0.0835789367556572, 0.2361181378364563, -0.8005995750427246, -0.6605688333511353, -0.9001471400260925, -0.6210653781890869, 0.4132864475250244, 0.8436592221260071, -1.1162903308868408, 0.5307669639587402, 0.5557843446731567, 0.14104752242565155, 0.26348403096199036, 0.6683952212333679, -0.511907696723938, -0.8117483258247375, -0.5908511877059937, -0.13688555359840393, -0.36771440505981445, -1.3937008380889893, -0.5928914546966553, -0.1421603113412857, 0.4088498651981354, 0.8014474511146545, -0.6687490940093994, 0.5006192326545715, -0.10557331889867783, 0.04419766366481781, 0.13934354484081268, -0.028367197141051292, -0.6089004278182983, 0.9540673494338989, -1.0228173732757568, 0.8705468773841858, -0.2533373534679413, 0.1640433818101883, 0.07642078399658203, 0.14922332763671875, -0.46980077028274536, 0.8040107488632202, -0.2916421890258789, 0.8108835220336914, 1.1279418468475342, -0.2059735655784607, 0.6506440043449402, 0.42694076895713806, -0.35872215032577515, -0.06849577277898788, -0.3391280472278595, 0.3100830018520355, -0.16199186444282532, 0.24004223942756653, -0.1185050830245018, 0.4830261170864105, 0.006173575762659311, 0.5104866623878479, -0.4070075452327728, -0.5029780864715576, 0.004646999295800924, 0.7297934293746948, 0.3150491714477539, -0.270399272441864, -0.3134143054485321, 0.041740983724594116, 0.6081790328025818, 0.8818372488021851, 0.12113203853368759, -0.3507375717163086, -0.34425047039985657, 0.2807701528072357, -0.0010175707284361124, -0.29902195930480957, -0.5236222743988037, 0.450208455324173, -0.04268200322985649, 0.3087404668331146, -0.01049995981156826, -0.11635805666446686, -1.117499828338623, 0.7534679174423218, -0.6904681324958801, -1.036246657371521, 0.7265242338180542, -0.0037448026705533266, 0.012060243636369705, 0.7017565965652466, -0.6283881664276123, 0.14156948029994965, -0.08516022562980652, 0.4809826910495758, 1.1302059888839722, 0.19331294298171997, -0.726967990398407, 0.7891732454299927, -0.9074122905731201, 0.09183759987354279, -0.906432569026947, 0.4616455137729645, -0.5976853966712952, -0.6462720632553101, -0.3163560628890991, 0.7255163192749023, 0.09690757840871811, -0.33911368250846863, -0.4614742398262024, -0.5585834383964539, 0.2725788950920105, -0.8209149241447449, -0.26204782724380493, -0.10121376067399979, -0.42296716570854187, 0.7014594674110413, -0.4890132546424866, -0.0975353941321373, 0.29265427589416504, -0.07886513322591782, 0.8845364451408386, 0.16945329308509827, -0.3945872187614441, 0.3460562229156494, 0.3306610882282257, -0.38966479897499084, 0.03440513461828232, 0.5425354838371277, 0.3377073407173157, 0.8356778025627136, -0.3881116807460785, 0.7734367251396179, -0.04309618100523949, 0.4107842445373535, 0.543584406375885, -0.5789924263954163, 0.11792350560426712, 0.19395621120929718, 0.031470440328121185, -0.10933218151330948, 0.2886575162410736, -0.22906559705734253, 0.2063574343919754, 0.30660197138786316, -0.3191072940826416, 0.3581596612930298, -0.2757200002670288, 0.1440979689359665, 0.3623982071876526, -0.504377007484436, -0.126620352268219, -0.28631243109703064, -0.16094397008419037, 1.1874980926513672, -0.6217435002326965, -0.5716109275817871, -0.6178919672966003, 0.47196799516677856, 0.2638065218925476, -0.19481885433197021, -0.23504029214382172, -0.007121716625988483, 0.28700321912765503, 0.2572595179080963, -0.9382748603820801, 1.1069234609603882, 0.769811749458313, 0.432198166847229, 0.6608250141143799, 0.6189318895339966, 0.16335006058216095, 0.7688958644866943, 0.07844177633523941, -0.5640678405761719, 0.17059177160263062, -0.31194284558296204, -0.15312539041042328, 0.17326143383979797, 0.2677045166492462, -0.4065721035003662, -0.11436925828456879, -0.6445378065109253, 0.6490139961242676, -1.0424597263336182, 0.013858478516340256, 0.2244940847158432, -0.09449227154254913, -0.3423028290271759, 0.33674776554107666, 0.2601689398288727, 0.10858211666345596, 0.8697840571403503, 0.5300011038780212, -0.23665988445281982, 1.3452039957046509, 0.7161936163902283, 0.16926686465740204, 0.31368595361709595, -0.5062443017959595, 0.267859548330307, 0.3631347417831421, -0.4252893328666687, 0.0664815679192543, 1.220110535621643, -0.28497278690338135, 0.24931617081165314, -0.6869900226593018, -0.25826871395111084, 0.2067442238330841, -0.11751624196767807, 0.6960488557815552, 0.09408024698495865, -0.2592768371105194, -0.18363729119300842, 0.6464138031005859, 0.5073217153549194, -0.003011411288753152, -0.6100991368293762, 0.3345957398414612, -0.9826344847679138, -0.05039413273334503, -1.1342700719833374, 0.2125643938779831, 0.14852236211299896, -0.1835775524377823, -0.4016333520412445, -0.25971874594688416, 0.17980599403381348, -0.9422240853309631, -0.2908423840999603, -0.2619687020778656, -0.03710845857858658, 0.5371341109275818, 0.37783190608024597, -0.036030273884534836, -0.5761772394180298, -0.03448696434497833, -0.0870942547917366, 0.6960839033126831, -0.32511091232299805, 0.5830082893371582, 0.6037123799324036, 0.41391128301620483, -1.1300201416015625, 0.5750994086265564, 0.02167542651295662, -0.4594755172729492, 0.7522927522659302, 0.037773605436086655, 0.1981218159198761, -0.3138420581817627, -0.403678834438324, -0.17465615272521973, 0.24542376399040222, -0.07735534757375717, 0.8799864649772644, -0.20266248285770416, 0.32163530588150024, -0.5777990818023682, -0.20832766592502594, 0.33093133568763733, 0.6310311555862427, 0.10451530665159225, -0.13409852981567383, -0.5769606232643127, -1.3795944452285767, 4.121727466583252, 0.8773608207702637, 0.6899102926254272, 0.3117868900299072, 1.001147985458374, 0.505756139755249, 0.3431936502456665, -0.516697108745575, 0.3586326837539673, -0.0663226991891861, 0.1325213462114334, -0.2391219586133957, 0.057594772428274155, 0.029331346973776817, -0.37417784333229065, 0.9449818134307861, 0.27554965019226074, -0.9182641506195068, 0.6788090467453003, -0.7192379832267761, -1.438607096672058, 0.572445273399353, -0.3601343631744385, -0.39400601387023926, -0.18830010294914246, 0.4935768246650696, -0.026937706395983696, -0.4301934242248535, -0.3520128130912781, -0.11614460498094559, -0.09004969894886017, -0.8248687982559204, 0.8873949646949768, -0.005634171888232231, -0.4825110137462616, 0.7873052358627319, 0.27465763688087463, 0.006771914195269346, -0.28152650594711304, -0.38295790553092957, 0.4686771631240845, -0.5149191617965698, -0.36702048778533936, -0.4894285500049591, -1.2294769287109375, 1.4072396755218506, 0.42736905813217163, 1.0865811109542847, 0.7775543928146362, -0.764959990978241, 0.1914929300546646, 0.2667360007762909, 0.4008902609348297, -0.15978708863258362, -1.1911048889160156, 0.10063736140727997, -0.7490643262863159, -0.33665573596954346, -0.33285388350486755, 0.19311310350894928, 0.4901321828365326, 0.029189668595790863, -0.7008534669876099, -0.12275770306587219, -0.2771807014942169, 0.017185093834996223, -0.08212992548942566, -0.21329531073570251, -0.06831356883049011, 0.2821149230003357, -0.6202099919319153, -0.23818755149841309, -0.3786548972129822, -0.5460433959960938, -0.1075359657406807, 0.5769496560096741, 0.11386693269014359, -0.016136929392814636, -0.37119540572166443, -0.7437151074409485, 0.032708704471588135, 0.22700467705726624, 0.25456908345222473, -0.06387219578027725, 0.25426456332206726, 0.9361277222633362, -0.23600095510482788, -0.02847396768629551, -0.8507621884346008, 0.2918509244918823, 0.19661647081375122, 0.37781965732574463, 0.03978007659316063, 0.045676812529563904, -0.20590388774871826 ]
Detection, Measurement and Gravitational Radiation
Here I examine how to determine the sensitivity of the LIGO, VIRGO, and LAGOS gravitational wave detectors to sources of gravitational radiation by considering the process by which data are analyzed in a noisy detector. By constructing the probability that the detector output is consistent with the presence of a signal, I show how to (1) quantify the uncertainty that the output contains a signal and is not simply noise, and (2) construct the probability distribution that the signal parameterization has a certain value. From the distribution and its mode I determine volumes $V(P)$ in parameter space such that actual signal parameters are in $V(P)$ with probability $P$. If we are {\em designing} a detector, or determining the suitability of an existing detector for observing a new source, then we don't have detector output to analyze but are interested in the ``most likely'' response of the detector to a signal. I exploit the techniques just described to determine the ``most likely'' volumes $V(P)$ for detector output corresponding to the source. Finally, as an example, I apply these techniques to anticipate the sensitivity of the LIGO and LAGOS detectors to the gravitational radiation from a perturbed Kerr black hole.
Lee Samuel Finn
gr-qc astro-ph
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209010
gr-qc/9209011
[ 0.0554865263402462, -0.09560631215572357, -0.17096060514450073, -0.03577398508787155, 0.572300374507904, -0.22427386045455933, 0.19510579109191895, 0.3834926187992096, -0.7641729712486267, 1.5201380252838135, 0.32208573818206787, 0.3716031610965729, -0.11545580625534058, -0.7874906659126282, -0.03867647796869278, 0.9338199496269226, -0.22941134870052338, -0.7265685796737671, -1.2183078527450562, 0.2976296842098236, 0.433490514755249, 0.2682873010635376, -0.8479061126708984, -0.4501221776008606, -0.5611684918403625, 0.4833891987800598, 1.0216827392578125, 0.05116098001599312, 0.9301638603210449, 1.2982549667358398, 1.0445510149002075, -0.039278410375118256, -0.030032504349946976, -0.4424206614494324, -0.12364831566810608, 0.3888786733150482, -0.015638476237654686, -0.17461149394512177, 0.7719317674636841, -0.23114027082920074, 0.4489637613296509, 0.023701507598161697, 0.06529828161001205, -0.1213131919503212, -0.45374953746795654, -0.22223453223705292, -0.08113547414541245, -0.14889030158519745, -0.01492113247513771, -1.212430715560913, 0.2237050086259842, -0.27252721786499023, 0.7309939861297607, -0.9261849522590637, -0.6108125448226929, -0.5149015188217163, 0.42108917236328125, 0.1214020773768425, -0.20808996260166168, -0.13257817924022675, 0.0676717534661293, 0.3413517475128174, -0.07937498390674591, -0.8252477645874023, 0.48067963123321533, 0.38767653703689575, 0.06793784350156784, 0.7040067911148071, 0.19874750077724457, -1.1410510540008545, -1.0395779609680176, 0.1108807623386383, -0.5584747791290283, 0.41767919063568115, -0.6342788338661194, 0.32788869738578796, -0.1813206821680069, -0.2444978654384613, -0.871717631816864, -0.5253715515136719, 0.07811520993709564, -0.09079331904649734, -0.6179640889167786, 0.1792784184217453, -0.3282262980937958, -0.4002317786216736, -0.304025799036026, -0.24321936070919037, -0.01758539490401745, -0.17717623710632324, -0.059321966022253036, 0.5776969194412231, 0.23888495564460754, -0.6520310640335083, 0.5544399619102478, 1.4943174123764038, -0.026600569486618042, 0.8799831867218018, 0.25121811032295227, 0.0873597040772438, -0.19056078791618347, 1.0988428592681885, -0.3244459927082062, 0.4906255602836609, -0.7541074752807617, 0.7545562982559204, -0.5369436144828796, -0.3207063674926758, -0.48415395617485046, -0.31618595123291016, 0.2625468671321869, -0.35269761085510254, 1.0640716552734375, 0.5149590373039246, 0.12970633804798126, 0.5556212067604065, -0.5885981917381287, 0.2401159703731537, -0.7401934862136841, -0.5183812379837036, 0.671032726764679, -0.11714650690555573, 0.49752476811408997, 0.17945453524589539, -0.2607053220272064, -0.5017539858818054, -0.15516874194145203, 0.44157442450523376, -0.7947856187820435, 0.4196905791759491, 0.2057843804359436, -0.48711416125297546, 0.42907992005348206, 0.1242443397641182, -0.3827373683452606, 0.2509724795818329, -0.8958849310874939, -0.3167922794818878, -0.03808753937482834, -0.05146436020731926, 0.9088220000267029, -0.7061842083930969, 0.5295976400375366, 1.2459686994552612, -0.3330756425857544, 0.04961558058857918, 0.6146780252456665, 0.2717859447002411, -0.23134277760982513, 0.2183310091495514, 0.014690037816762924, 0.0665169507265091, -0.5433618426322937, 0.25948718190193176, -0.35217002034187317, -0.05263781175017357, -0.9159387350082397, 0.6907531023025513, -0.6955681443214417, 0.250705748796463, 0.8486034274101257, -0.16993165016174316, 0.13360829651355743, 0.8065477013587952, -0.06242770329117775, 1.059073805809021, -0.6638996005058289, -0.7222666144371033, 0.32237619161605835, -0.4653967618942261, 0.04016093164682388, 0.06440582126379013, -0.33210834860801697, 0.9117836356163025, 1.545394778251648, 0.325812965631485, 0.07364767044782639, 0.04225247725844383, -0.37612786889076233, 0.424643337726593, -0.42054224014282227, -0.8647324442863464, 1.2230405807495117, 0.4461294710636139, -0.5926131010055542, -0.45054325461387634, 0.28423717617988586, -0.24389764666557312, 0.45365390181541443, -0.03306610509753227, -1.098536491394043, 0.2812497019767761, -0.4457974433898926, 0.6333951950073242, -0.4263768494129181, 0.2561241388320923, -0.6188319325447083, 0.2503634989261627, -0.36690106987953186, -0.0722050666809082, 0.01244360115379095, 0.05858692154288292, -1.033810019493103, 0.2696315348148346, -0.9944931864738464, 0.09882798790931702, 0.4470859169960022, 0.8455841541290283, -0.27471157908439636, 0.11256147921085358, 0.4094826579093933, -0.18998196721076965, 0.3012527525424957, 0.22185130417346954, 0.44717589020729065, -0.5134578943252563, -0.3505728542804718, 0.12545016407966614, 0.2908938229084015, -0.13104721903800964, 0.706888735294342, 0.4193543493747711, -0.024640003219246864, 0.8789160847663879, -0.367133766412735, -0.31465595960617065, 0.055596452206373215, 0.7414584159851074, -0.08727633953094482, 0.6489159464836121, 0.06236819922924042, 0.35708126425743103, 0.227555513381958, 0.848983883857727, 0.10529797524213791, 0.39581751823425293, 0.7157432436943054, 0.6698309779167175, 0.3492054343223572, 0.14178887009620667, 0.12939919531345367, 0.23199617862701416, 0.3969111740589142, 0.15771900117397308, -0.6685281991958618, 0.7312023639678955, 0.042633675038814545, -0.01651516743004322, -0.8295725584030151, 1.0000531673431396, -0.8001265525817871, 0.142446368932724, 0.27871501445770264, -0.23941101133823395, -0.8531310558319092, -0.22002241015434265, -0.20681852102279663, 0.2658044695854187, 0.21018803119659424, -0.17909938097000122, -0.07790642976760864, 0.028549697250127792, 0.30072471499443054, -0.9404082894325256, -0.03401980921626091, 0.4007469415664673, -0.019281424582004547, 0.2782447934150696, 0.6434312462806702, -0.09826242178678513, -0.9313751459121704, -0.24506133794784546, -0.5978068113327026, 0.24585379660129547, -0.9992454051971436, 0.2746475338935852, 0.4130849838256836, -0.5340977311134338, 0.539011538028717, 0.06387443840503693, 0.5645433068275452, 0.18288938701152802, -0.26888829469680786, 0.08892535418272018, 0.3284846246242523, -0.6047949194908142, -0.42735302448272705, 0.0027460807468742132, -0.9008165001869202, 0.5458799004554749, -0.8176134824752808, -0.37894678115844727, 1.185119867324829, 0.07502235472202301, 0.21232111752033234, -0.19624286890029907, -0.3239515423774719, -0.16242243349552155, -0.2920907735824585, -0.7017629742622375, 0.13930732011795044, 0.7045981884002686, 0.13227148354053497, 0.2866714298725128, -0.32946377992630005, 0.9280736446380615, 0.009740669280290604, -0.5657694339752197, 0.7636751532554626, -0.6821698546409607, -0.5747746229171753, 0.5461710095405579, 0.1996716409921646, -0.14803755283355713, 0.005763795226812363, 0.706349790096283, 0.7032397389411926, -0.1257697194814682, -0.19258885085582733, -0.40430837869644165, -0.36967405676841736, -0.36344224214553833, 0.6301567554473877, -0.8170055747032166, 0.36485135555267334, 0.9103089570999146, 0.18690809607505798, -0.6670082807540894, 0.4727633595466614, -1.3471975326538086, -0.3104284405708313, -0.6944237947463989, -0.49713557958602905, 0.48113805055618286, 0.33009180426597595, 0.175510436296463, -0.2620522379875183, 0.00011132189683848992, 0.4689891040325165, 0.49632635712623596, -0.19426484405994415, -0.36716121435165405, 0.4252094030380249, 0.17862261831760406, 0.3424091041088104, 0.20610828697681427, 0.2657940089702606, -0.9527823328971863, -0.35447195172309875, -0.13885319232940674, -0.4123590886592865, 0.728618323802948, 0.40882349014282227, 0.1775750070810318, 0.11224538087844849, 0.433912068605423, -0.7404496669769287, -0.4896778464317322, -1.2205325365066528, -0.2191198319196701, 0.1493767499923706, 0.36677438020706177, -0.16144470870494843, -0.41627025604248047, -0.6877934336662292, -0.05816151574254036, -0.24338820576667786, 0.6793658137321472, 0.6917121410369873, -0.5938915610313416, 0.3963092565536499, 0.1269472986459732, -0.3386058509349823, -0.1472131907939911, -0.3682361841201782, 0.34812989830970764, 0.1992039978504181, 0.624131441116333, 0.2731386423110962, -0.5636736750602722, -0.7658032178878784, -0.37792104482650757, 0.41090941429138184, 0.036105927079916, 0.8146251440048218, -0.4771922528743744, -0.3138289153575897, -0.06071889400482178, -0.010255875065922737, -0.3456818461418152, -0.2838325500488281, -0.4759567677974701, -0.40638843178749084, -0.6206324100494385, -0.29256558418273926, -0.1466406136751175, 0.5266522765159607, 0.22595404088497162, 0.3161836862564087, -0.20113955438137054, 0.6187657117843628, 0.6332598924636841, 1.022208571434021, 0.1734614372253418, -0.39242348074913025, 0.2998349070549011, -0.788827121257782, 0.524208128452301, 0.73201984167099, 0.6861286163330078, -0.1734475940465927, -0.4290161430835724, -0.06254536658525467, -0.4599577784538269, 0.5031758546829224, 0.2877283990383148, -0.5902979373931885, 1.1317024230957031, 1.014760136604309, -0.048738982528448105, 0.09242347627878189, 1.0559636354446411, 1.0615229606628418, 0.25916343927383423, -0.08071889728307724, -0.8831704258918762, -0.016079094260931015, -0.50789874792099, 0.09755808115005493, 0.9042553305625916, -0.7061967253684998, -0.6225971579551697, -0.45502549409866333, -0.02541341446340084, 0.12353283911943436, 0.6341394782066345, 0.6223511695861816, 0.17071492969989777, 0.3342372179031372, -0.19235223531723022, 0.5421422123908997, 0.43734294176101685, -0.15177367627620697, -0.4072892963886261, 0.0006644964450970292, -0.256839394569397, -0.11460432410240173, 0.272006630897522, 0.32827118039131165, -0.26896190643310547, -0.3476802408695221, -0.46888217329978943, -0.19035419821739197, -0.016190260648727417, -0.7131912112236023, -0.2349565625190735, 0.021696453914046288, -0.7692374587059021, 0.3223203420639038, -0.49047043919563293, 0.22089919447898865, -0.3162817060947418, -0.31053364276885986, 0.2780062258243561, 0.1509948968887329, 0.7049006819725037, -0.18637464940547943, 0.6523452401161194, 0.47050195932388306, -0.2885461449623108, 0.10030913352966309, 0.03952469304203987, 0.6152066588401794, 0.23751965165138245, 0.35906580090522766, -0.20353928208351135, -0.035310786217451096, -0.4529193639755249, -0.2933467626571655, -0.3391815721988678, -1.0383069515228271, 0.4948936700820923, -0.4419797360897064, 0.37527191638946533, 0.40565285086631775, -0.7664040327072144, -0.5026932954788208, -1.057188630104065, -1.1998318433761597, 0.3853709101676941, -0.19922634959220886, -0.02616068348288536, 0.001311569008976221, -0.5630422830581665, -0.17834830284118652, -0.6409415006637573, -0.7654609680175781, -0.26717934012413025, -0.33126381039619446, 0.6908228397369385, 0.08417748659849167, 0.505052387714386, 0.015679102391004562, 0.6520408391952515, -0.3872508704662323, 0.2235107719898224, -0.45014312863349915, -0.8904522657394409, -0.41072210669517517, -0.4578680694103241, 0.10032866150140762, -0.6451107263565063, 0.35175761580467224, 0.5796889662742615, 0.2551723122596741, 0.38384830951690674, -0.46888595819473267, -0.39971351623535156, -0.03250296786427498, 0.903089702129364, 0.651577353477478, -0.7071657180786133, -0.05135016888380051, 0.8731071949005127, -0.5885409116744995, 0.282527357339859, 0.14522093534469604, -0.3459196090698242, 0.25030434131622314, -1.3521233797073364, 1.0234155654907227, -1.1792900562286377, -0.3947528302669525, -0.16965295374393463, -0.9773484468460083, 0.5955214500427246, 0.08346469700336456, -0.20049522817134857, -0.30237632989883423, -0.3283291757106781, -0.2471723109483719, -0.07901883125305176, -0.6300051212310791, 0.35852161049842834, -1.0118950605392456, -0.2874188721179962, -0.6242456436157227, 0.5518929958343506, -0.5811437368392944, 0.477611243724823, 0.6419878602027893, 0.17918941378593445, -0.27970045804977417, 0.43689265847206116, 0.13408271968364716, -0.43836236000061035, -0.9005246162414551, 0.1781487911939621, 0.264464795589447, 0.17437486350536346, -0.30905836820602417, 0.8548752665519714, -0.6771019697189331, 0.4179759621620178, 0.039571844041347504, -0.2657945156097412, 0.22124531865119934, 0.04794670268893242, 0.2522607743740082, -0.6278142333030701, -0.505687415599823, 0.571397602558136, 0.17068104445934296, 0.24414914846420288, -0.6804448366165161, -0.5182477235794067, -0.41793954372406006, -0.23920279741287231, -0.5961453318595886, 0.10661683231592178, -0.15665073692798615, -0.09875385463237762, -0.8132895231246948, -0.5921752452850342, 0.23003597557544708, -0.043026152998209, 0.41680729389190674, 0.45959776639938354, 0.6843165159225464, 0.21182261407375336, -0.27534031867980957, -0.352571040391922, -0.722885012626648, 0.454751193523407, -0.052864450961351395, 0.06122371554374695, 0.26940470933914185, -0.0011165740434080362, -0.19428235292434692, -0.7355985045433044, -0.16753335297107697, 0.2384975254535675, -0.05644521117210388, -0.19927853345870972, 0.5306838750839233, 0.2867947816848755, -0.08513183146715164, -0.5406340956687927, -0.17046663165092468, -0.13942015171051025, 0.03462886065244675, 0.48055848479270935, 0.03936123475432396, 0.3843574821949005, -0.5570334196090698, -0.01809585839509964, -1.047529697418213, -0.5106198787689209, 0.8473228216171265, -0.9547248482704163, -0.4105534851551056, 0.4607202410697937, -0.44349682331085205, -0.3018934428691864, -0.5124693512916565, -0.8628220558166504, -0.5553333759307861, 0.22207742929458618, -0.2792178988456726, 0.23571115732192993, -0.16318920254707336, 0.3227123022079468, 0.8539276123046875, 0.6101524233818054, 0.22129306197166443, 0.2184833437204361, 0.15826024115085602, -0.4971606433391571, 0.1716316044330597, 0.35041990876197815, 0.7319892048835754, 0.07674804329872131, -0.9128937125205994, 0.09226086735725403, 0.335134357213974, 0.2516728341579437, -0.2872277796268463, 0.930943489074707, 0.04078226909041405, 0.5610356330871582, 0.1162741482257843, 0.9249435663223267, 0.44887974858283997, 0.24413399398326874, -0.4325471818447113, -0.7668614983558655, -0.3497549593448639, -1.2460910081863403, 0.2678200900554657, -0.0608372762799263, 0.3268571197986603, 0.4323311746120453, -0.4527340233325958, -0.1778518557548523, 0.3510175347328186, 0.4735589921474457, -0.3483743667602539, -0.9975773096084595, -0.3276638686656952, -1.6879328489303589, -0.3293501138687134, -1.10346257686615, -0.2176218330860138, 0.20792579650878906, 0.4049566090106964, -0.75165194272995, -0.1476818174123764, -0.37040388584136963, -0.09548041969537735, -0.2690356969833374, -0.14053595066070557, -0.6742808818817139, -0.26017677783966064, -0.8088697791099548, -0.12860219180583954, 0.26442474126815796, -1.0059038400650024, -0.6458473205566406, -0.6918678283691406, 0.2442658543586731, 0.6308772563934326, 0.10367143899202347, 0.6059769988059998, -0.22769998013973236, -0.8704854846000671, 0.47440922260284424, 0.24334315955638885, -0.9405876994132996, 0.7222965359687805, 0.1770142763853073, 0.503507137298584, 0.3455333113670349, 0.9588887095451355, 0.19948439300060272, 0.1343233734369278, -1.0599974393844604, -0.043598003685474396, 0.06078983470797539, 0.49783816933631897, 0.5186111927032471, -0.943716287612915, 0.2551087737083435, -0.24961580336093903, -0.5397851467132568, 0.48600876331329346, -0.47699835896492004, 0.5990251898765564, -0.1844797283411026, 0.32879969477653503, -0.31004875898361206, 0.5730419754981995, -0.04573621228337288, 0.5313836932182312, -0.2744121551513672, -0.14573416113853455, -0.1273781657218933, 0.2077704519033432, -0.18015103042125702, 0.11969652026891708, 0.03021911345422268, -0.0640895813703537, -0.08825360983610153, -0.3461962342262268, -0.3399805426597595, 0.6658734679222107, -0.2684159576892853, -0.3069271743297577, -0.35567930340766907, 0.24935533106327057, -0.13362035155296326, 0.5711202621459961, 0.5716683268547058, -0.47499608993530273, -0.0664869174361229, -0.54494309425354, -0.8659761548042297, -0.0750192254781723, -0.7074393630027771, -0.8865812420845032, -0.12223299592733383, -0.04299796372652054, 0.10168810933828354, 0.5946377515792847, -0.41794946789741516, -0.17288295924663544, -0.1453249156475067, 0.952509343624115, 0.46387842297554016, -0.6803296804428101, 0.031024901196360588, 0.424395889043808, -0.7152253985404968, -0.20272399485111237, -0.5382764339447021, 0.5397959351539612, -1.104577898979187, -0.20578370988368988, 0.21642723679542542, 0.10330913960933685, -0.44760915637016296, 0.14815959334373474, -0.0013246445450931787, -0.6833105087280273, 0.572708249092102, -0.22373606264591217, -0.5213800668716431, -0.10921794176101685, -0.4124106168746948, 0.5392624139785767, 0.41995224356651306, -0.860558271408081, 0.5118259787559509, 0.10440374165773392, 0.1428118348121643, 0.12656979262828827, 0.008651593700051308, 1.7466578483581543, -0.26258182525634766, -0.3480153977870941, 1.1454310417175293, 0.22936835885047913, 0.14779943227767944, 0.46206292510032654, -0.6169137358665466, 0.3320200443267822, 0.7041676044464111, 0.3385695517063141, 0.8345546126365662, 0.021876782178878784, 0.25464925169944763, -0.2454809695482254, 0.4021643400192261, 0.12306798249483109, -0.1377141773700714, 0.372897744178772, 0.5062597393989563, 0.5574548840522766, -0.23803409934043884, -0.19593112170696259, -0.6365710496902466, 0.17368298768997192, 0.7039584517478943, -0.16254648566246033, -0.3059503138065338, -0.41277241706848145, 0.3345547020435333, 0.41321104764938354, -0.6069909930229187, -0.5555709600448608, -0.138548344373703, 0.1938556432723999, 0.04071293771266937, 0.1801144778728485, -0.1442483365535736, 0.39089465141296387, 0.6236031651496887, 0.022600749507546425, 0.09552284330129623, 0.8290993571281433, 0.2952011823654175, 0.6294909715652466, 0.6265701651573181, 1.2069975137710571, 1.0362733602523804, 0.9229437112808228, -0.1366223245859146, -0.6699051856994629, -0.05203258991241455, 0.5523422956466675, -1.0221889019012451, 0.1948995292186737, -0.001221067737787962, 0.005536883138120174, -0.49585291743278503, -1.1474717855453491, 0.17435258626937866, -0.18472422659397125, -0.11404502391815186, -0.2109760344028473, -0.16529592871665955, -0.45380693674087524, 0.43757522106170654, -0.0072786700911819935, 0.5634521245956421, 0.28427740931510925, 0.2685892879962921, -0.535699725151062, 0.5923161506652832, 0.988657534122467, 0.09333962947130203, 0.3821081817150116, -0.2914711833000183, -0.2683334946632385, 0.3214928209781647, 0.39918941259384155, 0.0643339529633522, 0.13648340106010437, -0.8570836186408997, 0.3351968824863434, -0.09188149869441986, 0.3640002906322479, 0.0670948401093483, 0.20458942651748657, 0.4755221903324127, 0.6221452951431274, -0.5995540618896484, 0.525575578212738, 0.8112764954566956, 0.7568840384483337, -0.6208111643791199, -0.5473392605781555, 0.7562052607536316, -1.0780502557754517, -0.3134840130805969, -1.232979416847229, 0.394493967294693, 0.03237980604171753, -0.14217889308929443, -0.2883155047893524, -0.41891515254974365, -0.7740088105201721, -1.1836249828338623, -0.229967400431633, -1.1435894966125488, 0.5982133150100708, 0.7898120284080505, -0.7288999557495117, 0.5061966776847839, -0.6863743662834167, 0.10212739557027817, -0.14730095863342285, 1.3907170295715332, 0.24171875417232513, 0.6061803102493286, 0.9552721381187439, 0.1658114790916443, -0.9429931044578552, 0.0054943454451859, 0.7356805801391602, -0.9269943237304688, 0.9948718547821045, -0.678378701210022, 0.4991026222705841, -0.13308744132518768, -0.20556297898292542, 0.4036743640899658, -0.5406365990638733, 0.43334636092185974, 0.35797107219696045, -0.6431994438171387, -0.06548461318016052, -0.6304884552955627, 0.05998377501964569, -1.233421802520752, 0.0669374018907547, -0.1197478398680687, 0.03231998533010483, -0.005821838043630123, -0.5548643469810486, 4.055538177490234, 1.1652690172195435, 1.1177418231964111, 0.8700289726257324, 0.6263493299484253, 1.2159395217895508, -0.25016799569129944, 0.41079628467559814, 0.036179088056087494, -1.4999034404754639, 0.20844562351703644, 0.2012578397989273, -0.12217932939529419, 0.2924822270870209, -0.19712254405021667, 0.8790770173072815, -0.025582274422049522, 0.5345456004142761, -0.6370209455490112, -0.8713930249214172, -1.350563883781433, 0.5902085900306702, 0.19704051315784454, -0.1721678376197815, -0.015162723138928413, 0.7701390385627747, 0.6145715117454529, -1.2835689783096313, -0.3907405734062195, -0.637668251991272, -0.6190686821937561, -0.8379599452018738, -0.22327254712581635, -0.172764852643013, -0.9825454354286194, 0.6075059175491333, -0.02423013560473919, -0.6748447418212891, 0.05911492556333542, -0.10428212583065033, 0.05322657898068428, 0.127731591463089, 0.28222736716270447, -0.18324853479862213, -0.25041741132736206, 0.856909990310669, -0.2627827227115631, 0.6125731468200684, 0.4744463860988617, -0.98785400390625, 0.6616123914718628, 0.0029793863650411367, 0.3220362067222595, -0.4500851631164551, -0.21493054926395416, -0.1747981756925583, 0.022870667278766632, 0.2480488121509552, 0.4259345531463623, -0.29241934418678284, 0.6575204133987427, -0.08273664116859436, -0.20164768397808075, 0.30247896909713745, 0.5458906292915344, 0.6637721061706543, 0.34391820430755615, -0.1934652477502823, 0.16474570333957672, -0.17591920495033264, -0.5849066972732544, -0.07821590453386307, -0.8468902707099915, -0.19165034592151642, 0.15476775169372559, 0.41900038719177246, -0.10399341583251953, 0.531764566898346, 0.0882660448551178, 0.15885187685489655, -0.6736248731613159, -0.18426841497421265, -0.07388080656528473, -0.05242931470274925, -0.5866117477416992, 0.2296694964170456, 0.0546547956764698, 0.17413119971752167, -0.14062634110450745, 0.42525994777679443, 0.26129671931266785, 1.1181691884994507, -0.3344811797142029, -0.12553717195987701, -0.5187057256698608 ]
The Modular Group, Operator Ordering, and Time in (2+1)-Dimensional Gravity
A choice of time-slicing in classical general relativity permits the construction of time-dependent wave functions in the ``frozen time'' Chern-Simons formulation of $(2+1)$-dimensional quantum gravity. Because of operator ordering ambiguities, however, these wave functions are not unique. It is shown that when space has the topology of a torus, suitable operator orderings give rise to wave functions that transform under the modular group as automorphic functions of arbitrary weights, with dynamics determined by the corresponding Maass Laplacians on moduli space.
S. Carlip
gr-qc hep-th
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209011
gr-qc/9209012
[ -0.019160475581884384, 0.6600888967514038, 0.5242838263511658, 0.1507335901260376, -0.39246177673339844, 0.2526061236858368, 0.4129994213581085, -0.3338722288608551, -0.7243086695671082, 1.4686371088027954, 0.4564315676689148, 0.19402043521404266, -0.6059306263923645, -1.0702273845672607, 0.3179839551448822, 0.5183268189430237, -0.3693031072616577, -0.19940198957920074, -1.0981817245483398, 0.10510166734457016, 0.13893736898899078, 0.21040719747543335, -0.9158976078033447, -0.8637622594833374, -0.3954941928386688, 0.41014212369918823, 0.734200656414032, 0.5080925226211548, 1.0939372777938843, 0.7665220499038696, 0.41645491123199463, -0.10068491101264954, -0.3237732946872711, -1.0101577043533325, -0.0797075629234314, 0.2926534116268158, 0.14017698168754578, -0.6411432027816772, 0.8127413392066956, -0.8633814454078674, 1.091261863708496, -0.02689851075410843, 0.197037935256958, -0.09753137081861496, 0.16241362690925598, -0.20643234252929688, -0.08413930237293243, -0.3770178258419037, -0.04181106761097908, -0.9865067005157471, -0.11981537193059921, 0.3196890354156494, 0.19434784352779388, -1.05842924118042, -0.3476808965206146, -0.09177589416503906, 0.10044628381729126, 0.265907347202301, 0.4507475793361664, -0.016323750838637352, 0.5004133582115173, 0.3314644992351532, 0.010521824471652508, -0.6532155275344849, -0.37108319997787476, 0.9035277366638184, -0.20075057446956635, 1.1008254289627075, 0.5146439671516418, -0.3247523903846741, -0.22906696796417236, 0.18154314160346985, -0.40163367986679077, 0.031737420707941055, -0.726606547832489, 0.4416787922382355, -0.3658810257911682, -1.0274311304092407, -0.9377717971801758, -0.7448253035545349, -0.043404851108789444, -0.16842202842235565, 0.268743097782135, 0.7818050980567932, -0.2435234636068344, -0.43796825408935547, -0.46726369857788086, -0.10324597358703613, 0.44271615147590637, -0.24928615987300873, 0.022440016269683838, 0.6843458414077759, -0.27103692293167114, -0.44942426681518555, 0.5823087692260742, 0.8698272109031677, -0.04640336334705353, 0.6017653942108154, -0.4143182635307312, 0.34263643622398376, -0.04334582760930061, 1.6146306991577148, -0.6603464484214783, 0.6491472125053406, -0.6621025800704956, 0.859736442565918, -0.11825225502252579, 0.11091195791959763, 0.5451775789260864, -0.7260339260101318, 0.02076909691095352, 0.04626203328371048, 0.8736186623573303, 0.1964263916015625, -0.02785622514784336, 0.34489718079566956, -0.31448620557785034, -0.33637696504592896, -0.6507270932197571, -0.5701879858970642, 0.26809272170066833, -0.1405918151140213, 0.2559913396835327, 0.455523282289505, -0.39503219723701477, -0.6274271011352539, 0.1707945615053177, -0.3639064431190491, -0.16581490635871887, -0.09573676437139511, 0.2680208086967468, -0.2585938572883606, 0.19037289917469025, 0.423307329416275, 0.03471554070711136, 0.5258174538612366, -0.41928109526634216, 0.4683447480201721, -0.0062851207330822945, -0.5978795289993286, 0.5722031593322754, -0.5292618870735168, 0.5515000820159912, 1.2724251747131348, -0.2825380563735962, 0.7512597441673279, 0.07761227339506149, -0.038855813443660736, -0.35041436553001404, 0.400799036026001, -0.4502597153186798, -0.11819416284561157, -0.5184502005577087, 0.634379506111145, 0.036727044731378555, 0.4194105267524719, -1.170919418334961, 0.5796491503715515, -0.46378710865974426, -0.39839762449264526, 0.6369990706443787, -0.37494340538978577, 0.5051913857460022, 0.8906759023666382, -0.45228609442710876, 0.06589953601360321, -0.8672342896461487, -0.25081902742385864, -0.018173228949308395, 0.4003324508666992, 0.03340517729520798, 0.5363951921463013, 0.08321625739336014, 0.3295985758304596, 0.9602274894714355, 0.4236678183078766, 0.05223211646080017, -0.023875975981354713, -0.8313173651695251, 0.6615366339683533, -0.017283901572227478, -0.9455555081367493, 0.4323946535587311, 0.6164511442184448, -0.9709532260894775, -0.15913449227809906, -0.34968799352645874, 0.3185863494873047, 0.11573122441768646, 0.07263782620429993, -0.6501083970069885, 0.6078607439994812, -0.8917329907417297, 0.5359036326408386, -0.39837881922721863, 0.14813198149204254, -0.5848842263221741, -0.05512615293264389, -0.4688265323638916, -0.47216108441352844, -0.017177212983369827, -0.10696312040090561, -0.7731803059577942, -0.4962671101093292, -1.5357917547225952, -0.091126948595047, 1.2886780500411987, -0.05870267003774643, -0.669277548789978, -0.28577539324760437, 0.42067772150039673, -0.3061487674713135, -0.004866417963057756, -0.48792949318885803, 0.4273129999637604, 0.18724684417247772, -0.03382408246397972, -0.009386295452713966, 0.1818866729736328, -0.21334485709667206, 0.7711765170097351, 0.46506795287132263, -0.8437924385070801, 1.307139277458191, -0.07922032475471497, -0.3211399018764496, -0.5206233263015747, 0.8956356048583984, -0.41063472628593445, 0.5378869771957397, 0.4076346457004547, 0.19261221587657928, 0.3063030242919922, 0.5622266530990601, 0.9113510847091675, -0.1698470413684845, 0.9206011891365051, 1.032606840133667, 0.8029108047485352, 0.040186770260334015, 0.4484480619430542, 0.3397671580314636, 0.3137109577655792, -0.020492156967520714, 0.0519343800842762, 0.6928476095199585, 0.22428743541240692, 0.41269707679748535, -0.1793547421693802, 0.6640217900276184, -1.2026431560516357, 0.6807492971420288, -0.008952134288847446, 0.18126195669174194, -1.2038662433624268, -0.39397311210632324, 0.08790642023086548, 0.06606262922286987, 0.03994128853082657, 0.03592436760663986, -0.12625814974308014, 0.7821345329284668, -0.35264211893081665, 0.06315978616476059, -0.029637731611728668, 0.7142577767372131, -0.08335123211145401, -0.22117838263511658, 1.0743350982666016, -0.3285890519618988, -1.3577858209609985, -0.09567879885435104, -0.6485112905502319, 0.20878109335899353, -0.39723923802375793, 0.00945883896201849, 0.5433406233787537, -0.22788186371326447, 0.5434250831604004, 0.05613812431693077, -0.032953135669231415, 0.23590435087680817, -0.024821944534778595, 0.2615428864955902, -0.6738189458847046, 0.1776907593011856, -1.3084572553634644, -0.1777384728193283, -0.7264864444732666, 0.23383979499340057, -0.40960147976875305, -0.46867430210113525, 0.5960627198219299, -0.10131338983774185, -0.25150173902511597, -0.15878230333328247, -0.29976585507392883, 0.23262089490890503, -0.1258489489555359, -0.5782741904258728, 0.45038503408432007, 0.3661738634109497, -0.15694968402385712, 0.10864762961864471, -1.1984448432922363, 0.9177489280700684, 0.015010888688266277, -0.11342369019985199, 0.5681504607200623, -0.3978577256202698, -0.538375735282898, 0.5634523034095764, 0.00439161341637373, 0.519982099533081, -0.11164487898349762, 0.8632638454437256, 0.736739993095398, -0.06103012338280678, 0.3884316384792328, -0.13810580968856812, -0.6012478470802307, -0.8559080958366394, 0.9089322686195374, -1.474599003791809, 0.04773758351802826, 0.7463961243629456, 0.5158361792564392, -0.7450221180915833, 0.01658703200519085, -1.5742714405059814, -0.085263691842556, -0.6394049525260925, -0.0021751485764980316, 0.5738515257835388, -0.13453130424022675, -0.038637131452560425, -0.617304801940918, -0.4035683274269104, 0.015058723278343678, 0.6950663924217224, 0.7688747644424438, -0.8269476294517517, 0.8785175085067749, 0.3762546181678772, 0.4528929889202118, -0.20590339601039886, 0.4848615825176239, -0.24285544455051422, -0.38897737860679626, 0.46895283460617065, -0.49340465664863586, -0.446894109249115, 0.39904507994651794, 0.3561134934425354, -0.1917082518339157, 0.44146785140037537, -0.14503981173038483, -0.27026626467704773, -1.1925643682479858, -0.06440641731023788, 0.5813681483268738, 1.3731848001480103, 0.2920835316181183, -0.5608739256858826, -0.9392561316490173, -0.11427029967308044, 0.17237421870231628, -0.24033430218696594, 0.6092641949653625, -0.57020103931427, 0.5425655841827393, 0.03415466845035553, 0.09725497663021088, -0.36602503061294556, -0.5195382833480835, 0.29485049843788147, 0.5705291032791138, 0.6223500967025757, 0.6298021674156189, 0.2649475932121277, -0.41172993183135986, -0.5057100057601929, 0.4745309352874756, 0.0724235251545906, 0.352891743183136, 0.27911415696144104, -0.3719711899757385, 0.46532610058784485, -0.3454880118370056, -0.5487245917320251, -0.35922953486442566, -0.5862799286842346, 0.19598360359668732, -0.44542673230171204, -0.1530567705631256, -0.08492419123649597, 0.5711601972579956, 0.27045467495918274, 0.1980801522731781, -0.20553790032863617, 0.10227203369140625, 0.29235419631004333, 0.282393217086792, 0.6138501763343811, -0.7869337797164917, -0.07810677587985992, -0.5081627368927002, 0.41512012481689453, 0.24365808069705963, 0.508083701133728, 0.3188387155532837, -0.4534456729888916, 0.43097707629203796, -0.22777362167835236, 1.337602972984314, 0.5700944662094116, -0.28828173875808716, 0.9596930742263794, 0.25989973545074463, 0.08900074660778046, -0.5313878655433655, -0.3479745388031006, 0.8144527673721313, 0.7298144698143005, 0.17664672434329987, -0.5434800982475281, -0.40911954641342163, -0.10351600497961044, 0.4154389798641205, 0.024704070761799812, -1.0466372966766357, -1.1491196155548096, -0.10684728622436523, 0.3742707669734955, -0.21159760653972626, 0.24926398694515228, 0.8846770524978638, 0.5179376602172852, 0.790989339351654, 0.3719530999660492, -0.3187274932861328, 0.9198474287986755, -0.39342954754829407, -0.183610200881958, 0.33405590057373047, -0.20104973018169403, -0.4077182710170746, 0.32706305384635925, -0.02659267745912075, -0.7805629968643188, -0.1843418926000595, 0.44940993189811707, 0.6745267510414124, -0.3677578270435333, -0.9049851298332214, 0.22943255305290222, -0.3542880415916443, -0.38021358847618103, 0.733511209487915, -0.49794065952301025, -0.1698012501001358, 0.5225321650505066, -0.26328587532043457, -0.2757605016231537, 0.1535109132528305, -0.0005246172659099102, -0.393757700920105, 0.9456148147583008, 0.6158598065376282, 0.2299523651599884, 0.501449465751648, 0.34556832909584045, -0.008815326727926731, -0.11035364121198654, 0.26199427247047424, -0.6710615754127502, -0.36123135685920715, -0.2844272553920746, -0.4208604693412781, -0.8065183162689209, 0.18955697119235992, 0.7620418071746826, -0.6763039231300354, 0.6479842066764832, -0.08205807209014893, -0.9160062074661255, -0.422153502702713, -0.47549527883529663, -1.0190715789794922, 0.9247254729270935, -0.26728662848472595, -0.5022079944610596, -0.07731015235185623, -0.5958281755447388, 0.10975703597068787, -0.37282997369766235, -0.0420207753777504, -0.27327442169189453, 0.16374026238918304, 0.2564212679862976, 0.09090562909841537, 0.2731938660144806, -0.3114772140979767, 0.3202405571937561, -0.6251668930053711, -0.5864575505256653, -0.7558197975158691, -0.8239801526069641, -0.13941729068756104, 0.07873188704252243, 0.05108695477247238, -0.16969822347164154, -0.004754710476845503, 0.07637692987918854, -0.03212808817625046, 1.0510119199752808, 0.3286081850528717, -0.8820726871490479, -0.37308013439178467, 0.727310061454773, 0.2995120882987976, -0.5461803078651428, -0.5917927622795105, 0.8486122488975525, 0.37214207649230957, -0.05082182586193085, -0.4586234986782074, 0.35900619626045227, 0.23825818300247192, -0.5411927103996277, 0.5603678822517395, -0.8172658681869507, -0.1543855220079422, -0.11968015134334564, -0.9252732396125793, 0.28606492280960083, 0.27341726422309875, 0.43034252524375916, -0.7783465385437012, -0.5724029541015625, 0.14817874133586884, 0.7380174398422241, 0.2928493022918701, 0.31320884823799133, -1.080988883972168, -0.4539342224597931, -1.1234241724014282, 0.8512777090072632, -0.44771701097488403, 0.14642344415187836, 0.21564801037311554, 0.44064655900001526, -0.21465964615345, 0.5370916128158569, 0.35170668363571167, 0.39628466963768005, -0.4813409447669983, 0.05550028756260872, 0.40205952525138855, 0.32503512501716614, -0.5650311708450317, 0.6225691437721252, -0.858228862285614, 0.4205784201622009, -0.1527530699968338, -0.36753857135772705, 0.20833222568035126, -0.42419543862342834, 0.42979493737220764, -0.16882973909378052, -0.27423447370529175, 0.8516897559165955, 0.31523048877716064, -0.14366650581359863, -0.020394766703248024, -0.40917372703552246, -0.415811151266098, -0.8635926246643066, -0.5583442449569702, 0.5379217267036438, 0.14137329161167145, -0.20823146402835846, -0.6088023781776428, -0.8304200172424316, -0.34872376918792725, -0.6496675610542297, 0.3296819031238556, 0.521043598651886, 0.5892961621284485, 0.3442404866218567, -0.5715306401252747, 0.08540304750204086, -0.5529870986938477, 0.17598797380924225, 0.4175603687763214, -0.1395888775587082, 0.31950485706329346, -0.3085044324398041, -0.8662395477294922, -0.6831737756729126, -0.8724836111068726, 0.6294535398483276, 0.30584561824798584, -0.18897049129009247, 1.0599169731140137, 0.2806376814842224, -0.37706148624420166, -0.14597125351428986, -0.08658667653799057, 0.1837567538022995, 0.4686192274093628, 0.4708470404148102, 0.4493016302585602, 0.0019775577820837498, 0.032035622745752335, 0.5738044381141663, -0.5898092985153198, -0.37706896662712097, 0.7550042271614075, -0.6439869403839111, -0.16126373410224915, 0.3005968928337097, -0.008170682936906815, -0.331112802028656, -0.6613534092903137, -1.143741488456726, -0.39812180399894714, 0.09518156945705414, -0.7887688279151917, -0.16051553189754486, -0.042736802250146866, -0.39922451972961426, 0.13613301515579224, 0.23260214924812317, -0.3262087404727936, 0.34997496008872986, -0.17824262380599976, -0.031011709943413734, -0.019386576488614082, -0.247840017080307, 1.4532923698425293, 0.19481882452964783, -0.6604031324386597, 0.17869830131530762, -0.18886709213256836, -0.03132708743214607, -0.3863082528114319, 0.5981142520904541, -0.24071870744228363, -0.27602845430374146, -0.5228816270828247, 0.23088213801383972, 0.24232923984527588, 0.5771682262420654, -0.3288210928440094, -0.34276649355888367, -0.634901225566864, -0.4683662950992584, 0.22539860010147095, -0.21963414549827576, 0.4617661237716675, 0.496437668800354, 0.21256709098815918, 0.11940626055002213, -0.7834134697914124, -0.23249146342277527, -0.18671469390392303, -0.4819645583629608, -0.04274561256170273, -0.9864403605461121, -0.5048899054527283, -0.8790119886398315, -0.5324254631996155, -0.2265578955411911, 0.36551836133003235, -0.24975495040416718, 0.3229018449783325, -0.27339279651641846, 0.2889913022518158, 0.005386633332818747, 0.9338924884796143, 0.06606993824243546, -0.6382771730422974, -0.7685830593109131, 0.24102050065994263, -0.30666279792785645, -1.2370647192001343, -0.021724402904510498, -0.3093251585960388, 0.7118175625801086, 0.6181145310401917, -0.646868109703064, 0.46997836232185364, -0.36171332001686096, -1.1146029233932495, 0.3289678692817688, -0.12359024584293365, -0.6988835334777832, 0.9871360659599304, -0.03623832017183304, 0.7463518977165222, 0.420226126909256, 0.6576131582260132, -0.6178016662597656, 0.6325706243515015, -1.3167725801467896, 0.2973858416080475, 0.0972793698310852, 1.0679023265838623, 0.012117970734834671, -0.7025359272956848, 0.010726887732744217, 0.6681831479072571, -0.4594273269176483, -0.19129319489002228, -0.44252702593803406, 0.5503308773040771, -0.12560157477855682, 0.09269839525222778, 0.6108554601669312, 0.17054948210716248, 0.278738796710968, -0.2675648033618927, -1.1556296348571777, -0.19669212400913239, 0.07253212481737137, -0.03577296435832977, -0.685369610786438, -0.7648483514785767, 0.755800724029541, -0.6369190216064453, 0.7262571454048157, 0.7364310622215271, -0.3863161504268646, 0.30780330300331116, -0.1816089153289795, -0.23004069924354553, 0.17336983978748322, -0.1463870406150818, -0.6789388656616211, 0.9442447423934937, 0.15133093297481537, 0.11294440180063248, 0.7690034508705139, -0.13638100028038025, -0.7683084011077881, 0.01080718170851469, -0.3244418799877167, -0.5110834836959839, 0.08020983636379242, -0.1950916349887848, 0.1415730118751526, 0.6663264632225037, -0.5389230251312256, 0.19943074882030487, 0.03102404996752739, 1.036952257156372, 0.9250641465187073, -0.08875954151153564, -0.6791618466377258, 0.12591728568077087, -0.890033483505249, 0.27914419770240784, -0.29644444584846497, 0.2988470792770386, -0.9903346300125122, -0.6389564275741577, -0.021848468109965324, 0.28776776790618896, -0.17613355815410614, 0.23035788536071777, -0.55098557472229, -0.3797217309474945, -0.046792030334472656, -0.6566802263259888, -0.0800870731472969, -0.5157055258750916, -1.0532146692276, 0.24566705524921417, 0.014382412657141685, -0.18351267278194427, 0.03990320488810539, 0.19788804650306702, 0.44866690039634705, 0.2108781784772873, -0.061847127974033356, 0.38599100708961487, -0.038661520928144455, -0.5709301829338074, 0.3687990605831146, 0.41818907856941223, -0.13841888308525085, 0.03163078427314758, -0.31556910276412964, 0.1145554780960083, 0.14217503368854523, 0.10703645646572113, 0.5973532795906067, 0.11169201135635376, -0.15574441850185394, 0.5079628825187683, 0.8355020880699158, -0.13769474625587463, 0.27531611919403076, -0.19290995597839355, 0.4155558943748474, 0.5368823409080505, -0.356478750705719, -0.5877135992050171, -0.027128949761390686, 0.5301966667175293, -0.24657294154167175, -0.6467530727386475, -0.5433410406112671, -0.49881234765052795, 0.40396857261657715, 0.6727160215377808, -0.42970898747444153, -0.6874691247940063, -0.4787825644016266, 0.5299620032310486, 0.5156786441802979, -0.40355363488197327, -0.0685623437166214, 1.124642252922058, 0.5934751629829407, 0.3804413974285126, -0.5875300168991089, 0.5546576380729675, 0.42314663529396057, 0.3433488607406616, 0.5099704265594482, 0.6751267910003662, 0.3189166188240051, 0.7489809989929199, -0.1363154798746109, -0.7733543515205383, -0.0428432859480381, 0.14942190051078796, -0.7103952765464783, 0.08502430468797684, 0.028596803545951843, -0.6085618138313293, -0.2003924548625946, -0.6606022119522095, -0.077733114361763, -0.5004675388336182, 0.35063058137893677, 0.6173624396324158, -0.6242185235023499, -0.2591875195503235, 0.3927316963672638, 0.1647985577583313, 0.4161507785320282, 0.8717443346977234, 0.07887698709964752, 0.4753061830997467, 0.7802044153213501, 1.0851125717163086, 0.17858627438545227, 0.06427506357431412, -0.3713241219520569, -0.1929602473974228, 0.6791048049926758, 0.15170125663280487, -0.12745000422000885, 1.117486596107483, -0.6363728046417236, 0.8998522758483887, 0.4883357286453247, 0.13699951767921448, -0.2618139982223511, -0.18512509763240814, 0.5004739165306091, 0.4221029281616211, -0.727866530418396, -0.37785279750823975, 0.6018550992012024, 0.01195876020938158, 0.10891197621822357, -0.2515828311443329, 0.6222613453865051, -0.9413743615150452, -0.2727729380130768, -0.9442180395126343, 0.32498061656951904, 0.11972668021917343, -0.4162827134132385, -0.7800206542015076, -0.5775524377822876, -0.08524944633245468, -1.1168969869613647, -0.32908087968826294, -0.6373481154441833, 0.6750074625015259, 1.0244204998016357, -0.2400018721818924, 0.44384825229644775, -0.7820654511451721, -1.121932029724121, -0.2634872794151306, 1.0313751697540283, 0.2669369876384735, 0.36085274815559387, 0.9406127333641052, 0.19569003582000732, -0.4583171606063843, 0.7434679865837097, 0.498215913772583, -0.7922990322113037, 0.8455164432525635, -0.2811400592327118, 0.005704647395759821, 0.1984141319990158, -0.27966973185539246, 0.14884468913078308, -0.004759357310831547, 0.828671932220459, 0.29198727011680603, -0.08041060715913773, -0.08392736315727234, -0.718331515789032, -0.10048782825469971, -0.20405834913253784, -0.45277202129364014, 0.8220825791358948, -0.38079121708869934, -0.2598210871219635, -0.41062214970588684, 4.011725425720215, 0.7549315690994263, 0.6598528027534485, -0.8539993166923523, 0.7700638771057129, 0.7252772450447083, -0.007617257069796324, -0.44896265864372253, 0.27746036648750305, -0.45163998007774353, 0.016847029328346252, 0.5172408223152161, 0.5027016401290894, -0.2559918761253357, 0.41350340843200684, 0.4156493544578552, -0.34134799242019653, -0.17265991866588593, 0.06780844926834106, -0.34902599453926086, -0.9975402355194092, -0.019006449729204178, 0.12291250377893448, -0.3145357370376587, 0.2703309953212738, 0.5719681978225708, -0.19946032762527466, -0.429503858089447, -0.3544422686100006, -0.39498621225357056, 0.0297933891415596, -0.8027424812316895, 0.01885666698217392, 0.138010635972023, -0.985999345779419, 0.7027342915534973, 0.0169469453394413, -0.27214208245277405, -0.17486931383609772, -0.08598431944847107, -0.5142892599105835, -0.3466881811618805, 0.06457550823688507, -0.28142210841178894, -0.13215172290802002, 1.586353063583374, 0.22124220430850983, 0.8905356526374817, 0.676324188709259, -0.8697962760925293, 0.16253244876861572, 0.05329954996705055, 0.32013189792633057, 0.024064073339104652, -1.3923957347869873, -0.5511907339096069, 0.08063451945781708, 0.0189261082559824, 0.5502672791481018, -0.22749100625514984, 0.6898661851882935, -0.5135826468467712, -0.3208068609237671, 0.04214569181203842, -0.11507625132799149, 0.4102945327758789, 0.25250333547592163, 0.044007185846567154, -0.019406843930482864, 0.10600993782281876, -0.8642236590385437, -0.09520187973976135, -0.6811251640319824, -0.34476587176322937, -0.08704093843698502, -0.13813833892345428, -0.060057383030653, 0.4851137399673462, -0.2529098093509674, 0.5645895004272461, -1.204625129699707, 0.1166251003742218, -0.024750184267759323, 0.8578460812568665, -0.4284680187702179, 0.7438807487487793, -0.2030780017375946, -0.0963442251086235, -0.49958884716033936, 0.05799964442849159, -0.24444960057735443, 0.9594310522079468, -0.403072714805603, -0.22748425602912903, -0.8015677332878113 ]
Quasilocal Energy and Conserved Charges Derived from the Gravitational Action
The quasilocal energy of gravitational and matter fields in a spatially bounded region is obtained by employing a Hamilton-Jacobi analysis of the action functional. First, a surface stress-energy-momentum tensor is defined by the functional derivative of the action with respect to the three-metric on ${}^3B$, the history of the system's boundary. Energy density, momentum density, and spatial stress are defined by projecting the surface stress tensor normally and tangentially to a family of spacelike two-surfaces that foliate ${}^3B$. The integral of the energy density over such a two-surface $B$ is the quasilocal energy associated with a spacelike three-surface $\Sigma$ whose intersection with ${}^3B$ is the boundary $B$. The resulting expression for quasilocal energy is given in terms of the total mean curvature of the spatial boundary $B$ as a surface embedded in $\Sigma$. The quasilocal energy is also the value of the Hamiltonian that generates unit magnitude proper time translations on ${}^3B$ in the direction orthogonal to $B$. Conserved charges such as angular momentum are defined using the surface stress tensor and Killing vector fields on ${}^3B$. For spacetimes that are asymptotically flat in spacelike directions, the quasilocal energy and angular momentum defined here agree with the results of Arnowitt-Deser-Misner in the limit that the boundary tends to spatial infinity. For spherically symmetric spacetimes, it is shown that the quasilocal energy has the correct Newtonian limit, and includes a negative contribution due to gravitational binding.
J. David Brown and James W. York
gr-qc hep-th
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209012
gr-qc/9209013
[ 0.6386103630065918, 0.09717944264411926, -0.032830312848091125, -0.3554456830024719, 0.0741146057844162, 0.024456394836306572, 0.43647488951683044, -0.2726629078388214, 0.40342026948928833, 1.4841082096099854, 0.12735861539840698, 0.14715725183486938, 0.159987673163414, -1.255420207977295, -0.2663407027721405, 1.0582762956619263, -0.003560098819434643, -0.12805359065532684, -0.9459099769592285, 0.817913830280304, 0.1589565873146057, 0.1581422984600067, -0.9314061999320984, -0.33974316716194153, -0.392191082239151, 0.6428815126419067, 0.9451502561569214, 0.35896801948547363, 0.9214315414428711, 1.1454218626022339, 0.5634225606918335, -0.16459311544895172, -0.06338859349489212, -0.783470869064331, -0.5067046284675598, 0.3460487127304077, 0.09701385349035263, -0.7957648634910583, 0.6183268427848816, -0.45965176820755005, 0.8236103057861328, 0.08648833632469177, -0.1393943428993225, -0.21223878860473633, -1.017712116241455, -0.08352664858102798, 0.6388739347457886, 0.27657559514045715, 0.1866319328546524, -0.9560354948043823, 0.19345059990882874, -0.25529471039772034, 0.6449928879737854, -0.7603090405464172, -0.3668329119682312, -0.12391014397144318, 0.39556431770324707, -0.22706238925457, -0.39759036898612976, 0.09794028103351593, 0.1835811585187912, 0.23412679135799408, 0.16873978078365326, -0.6256760358810425, -0.4495396018028259, 1.0937343835830688, -0.45251700282096863, 0.6855944991111755, -0.23867365717887878, -0.41677966713905334, -0.601673424243927, -0.14343468844890594, -0.3452768325805664, 0.5850146412849426, -0.24461796879768372, 0.7204024195671082, -0.9049094915390015, -0.7179595828056335, -0.653394877910614, -0.06768488883972168, -0.5929675102233887, 0.4097232520580292, -0.2594383955001831, 0.5365265011787415, -0.7061945199966431, 0.3215366303920746, 0.13170187175273895, -0.24276810884475708, 0.6123875379562378, -0.06868866831064224, -0.3298074007034302, 0.2013469934463501, -0.6174612641334534, 0.2949099838733673, 0.5431627631187439, 0.7317061424255371, -0.21719908714294434, 0.6993924975395203, 0.4874144196510315, -0.0983755812048912, -0.3905244469642639, 1.102982521057129, -0.4674035906791687, -0.11915922164916992, -0.8940762281417847, 0.5513640642166138, -0.4010413587093353, 0.25352174043655396, -0.7346189022064209, -0.519584059715271, 0.36969462037086487, 0.05407416447997093, 0.5817387104034424, 0.27638885378837585, 0.12329805642366409, 0.4385700523853302, -0.3905247151851654, -0.14492732286453247, -0.15577992796897888, -1.0888296365737915, -0.12598024308681488, 0.1985953152179718, 0.27281245589256287, 0.5702794194221497, -0.5842013955116272, -0.5171538591384888, 0.33627161383628845, 0.18212193250656128, -0.7584258317947388, 0.8291595578193665, 0.6165245771408081, -0.5439379811286926, 0.09180185943841934, 0.454999178647995, -0.013758433051407337, 0.13562814891338348, -0.0942036435008049, 0.14065581560134888, 0.18423877656459808, -0.09597042202949524, 0.02319755218923092, -0.40081459283828735, -0.0015768532175570726, 1.287806749343872, -0.16646303236484528, 0.44965091347694397, 0.17963385581970215, -0.0440104715526104, -0.4275062084197998, 0.39752963185310364, 0.20344455540180206, -0.1861225813627243, 0.38815152645111084, 0.6913025975227356, -0.2905040979385376, 0.10846491903066635, -1.010986566543579, 0.06047812104225159, 0.29763463139533997, -0.6139018535614014, 0.3282744288444519, -0.4182340204715729, 0.21183708310127258, 0.9157254695892334, -0.27471181750297546, 0.2159643918275833, -0.5846745371818542, 0.1275724619626999, 0.005856463685631752, -0.030067279934883118, -0.5846731066703796, 0.5512860417366028, 0.1270183026790619, 1.1283183097839355, 0.9336159229278564, 0.5033240914344788, 0.018453482538461685, -0.10227830708026886, -0.40216153860092163, 0.3024125397205353, 0.2584211528301239, -0.9346191883087158, 0.5142163634300232, 0.34193992614746094, -0.5849454402923584, 0.023942239582538605, 0.4214734435081482, -0.3495340347290039, 0.28177765011787415, -0.12762345373630524, -0.6501390933990479, 0.19690072536468506, -1.112790584564209, 0.5882817506790161, -0.8397969007492065, -0.09054144471883774, -1.0962295532226562, -0.2708396017551422, -0.6555726528167725, -0.27475160360336304, 0.22405897080898285, 0.48611578345298767, -1.1669472455978394, 0.3553549647331238, -0.8913527727127075, -0.3125222623348236, -0.22601507604122162, 0.4248754382133484, -0.4922550916671753, 0.13890522718429565, 0.8660028576850891, -0.48766258358955383, 0.4987342953681946, -0.0011151281651109457, 0.3020980954170227, 0.25515228509902954, -0.5862628817558289, -0.09323891252279282, -0.3772599697113037, 0.07225554436445236, 0.9307401776313782, 0.7761443853378296, -0.5892851948738098, 1.1172118186950684, 0.054865311831235886, -0.45947638154029846, 0.25821566581726074, 0.6721202731132507, 0.027931708842515945, 0.6021370887756348, 0.12365688383579254, 0.7274852991104126, 0.533258318901062, 0.7844987511634827, 0.5373049974441528, -0.12317034602165222, 1.0396074056625366, 0.44653162360191345, 0.49992477893829346, 0.4255346655845642, 0.1466645896434784, 0.2557872533798218, 0.2886376678943634, -0.5176107287406921, -0.4061553478240967, 0.6525068283081055, -0.06119038537144661, 0.029186073690652847, -0.7991535067558289, 0.7198805809020996, -0.6329928636550903, 0.689338207244873, -0.600044846534729, 0.33950817584991455, -1.4701526165008545, 0.25806933641433716, 0.44502493739128113, -0.053869303315877914, 0.13790130615234375, 0.05419011786580086, -0.3817087411880493, -0.4816756844520569, -0.5744832754135132, -0.21022644639015198, -0.2514132559299469, 0.5308055877685547, -0.5788957476615906, -0.14300696551799774, 0.44755104184150696, -0.42007365822792053, -1.0413321256637573, 0.11930575966835022, -0.6222105622291565, -0.22239859402179718, -0.6256160736083984, 0.07668235152959824, 0.5308346748352051, 0.12286331504583359, 0.4977814257144928, 0.39771807193756104, -0.5815454125404358, 0.6923253536224365, -0.38571247458457947, -0.13227765262126923, 0.20509716868400574, 0.2092646211385727, -1.4121798276901245, -0.5120834112167358, -1.224802851676941, 0.04914820194244385, 0.24364033341407776, -0.26197493076324463, 0.5452160835266113, -0.0827547013759613, 0.16106337308883667, 0.355790913105011, -0.23517349362373352, -0.11126010864973068, -0.02768458053469658, -0.9661082625389099, 0.24608556926250458, 0.3095431923866272, -0.08218167722225189, -0.41038694977760315, -0.749085009098053, 1.4077882766723633, 0.37316325306892395, -0.2150314301252365, 0.43340909481048584, -0.08945562690496445, -0.3459603786468506, 0.3491085171699524, 0.5434882640838623, 0.5149803757667542, -0.007571832742542028, 0.5287834405899048, 0.7724288105964661, -0.011532080359756947, 0.27745291590690613, 0.16683736443519592, -0.36948779225349426, 0.1385076642036438, -0.014766024425625801, -0.3343827724456787, 0.49730485677719116, 0.8185677528381348, -0.09471997618675232, -0.7049229741096497, 0.7171651124954224, -0.7210355997085571, -0.8167718052864075, -0.24049526453018188, -0.4080859422683716, 0.5075012445449829, 0.22276510298252106, 0.38804203271865845, -0.0149201899766922, -0.560694694519043, -0.8410629630088806, 0.4501239061355591, 0.6188710927963257, -0.12239216268062592, 0.1495039165019989, 0.7855374217033386, -0.023673055693507195, -0.0749649628996849, 0.10130459815263748, -0.9268016219139099, 0.10967942327260971, 0.3673779368400574, -0.5791786313056946, 0.14335273206233978, 0.0610920786857605, -0.19875913858413696, -0.0370422899723053, 0.44687020778656006, 0.07868868857622147, -0.5872340798377991, -0.8326867818832397, -0.2080150544643402, 0.5715894103050232, 0.7424411177635193, 0.20874536037445068, -0.7025899887084961, -0.43888357281684875, 0.12604179978370667, -0.2652600407600403, 0.46881160140037537, 0.4162406623363495, -1.099171757698059, 0.3461366593837738, 0.2551628053188324, -0.34633415937423706, 0.10940595716238022, 0.004390531685203314, -0.2602093517780304, 0.5789511203765869, 0.2599296569824219, 0.3051685392856598, 0.2784748375415802, -0.08304505795240402, -0.11084132641553879, 0.08395488560199738, -0.2172088772058487, 0.22237904369831085, -0.3118167519569397, -0.36328092217445374, 0.11108905076980591, -0.7268654108047485, -0.1435214728116989, -0.2649204134941101, -0.7544471621513367, 0.1113821417093277, -0.22869187593460083, -0.42990246415138245, 0.20589597523212433, 0.3141862154006958, 0.7082418203353882, 0.35006022453308105, -0.33778443932533264, -0.005069192964583635, 0.3294666111469269, 0.016050776466727257, 0.4209837317466736, -0.7529628276824951, 0.3256833553314209, -0.7012647986412048, 0.4558277428150177, -0.04610700160264969, -0.29925620555877686, 0.2657899558544159, -0.7557166814804077, -0.4733070731163025, -0.06534072756767273, 0.7374159693717957, -0.14657022058963776, -0.05044855177402496, 0.5196951627731323, 0.07533755898475647, -0.24725037813186646, -0.6207097172737122, 0.22756823897361755, 1.0191380977630615, 0.3240893483161926, 0.2645811140537262, -0.26905664801597595, 0.6145481467247009, -0.23233725130558014, 0.11845056712627411, 0.6309782862663269, -0.24363967776298523, -0.908732533454895, -0.11153870820999146, 0.018987953662872314, 0.5934833884239197, -0.09033387154340744, 0.48150965571403503, 0.39769983291625977, 0.6668436527252197, -1.1258704662322998, 0.19197580218315125, 1.3631258010864258, -0.4329497814178467, 0.5267478227615356, 0.34145936369895935, -0.23324160277843475, 0.16075898706912994, 0.35902291536331177, -0.2983519434928894, -0.529516875743866, -0.04586396366357803, -0.6817530393600464, 0.2508073151111603, -0.6290059685707092, -0.5600004196166992, 0.6992989182472229, -0.3893161118030548, -0.11748914420604706, 0.6413926482200623, -0.3283737897872925, 0.3802095651626587, 0.2303427904844284, 0.22094732522964478, 0.2565186619758606, 0.8632341623306274, 0.46192413568496704, 0.4159094989299774, 0.7222355604171753, 0.5552929043769836, 0.2081771045923233, -0.2520330548286438, 0.18300992250442505, 0.2258109152317047, 0.05179457738995552, 0.3762176036834717, -0.7389076352119446, -0.7091948986053467, -0.0776599794626236, -0.4590003490447998, -0.48938995599746704, -0.18637530505657196, 0.5889850854873657, 0.04009130597114563, 0.2735324203968048, 0.573162853717804, -0.8077672123908997, -0.5500006675720215, -1.2337031364440918, -0.8328319787979126, 0.21197977662086487, -0.08288193494081497, -0.14399249851703644, 0.05697495862841606, -0.9870642423629761, -0.20471611618995667, -0.45350217819213867, 0.17254064977169037, -0.2247820794582367, -0.10615222156047821, 0.18535833060741425, 0.5173719525337219, 0.6203261613845825, -0.4994569718837738, -0.024982698261737823, -0.4758860766887665, 0.22148190438747406, -0.7520385384559631, -0.6215581893920898, -0.8045828938484192, -0.0899711549282074, 0.35602501034736633, -0.009420053102076054, 0.08965443819761276, 0.1436174064874649, 0.07251591235399246, 0.3146972954273224, -0.28559765219688416, -0.8284788131713867, -0.25862735509872437, 0.41148579120635986, -0.09524643421173096, -0.3679392635822296, -0.24350638687610626, 0.5054555535316467, 0.5692762136459351, 0.816827118396759, -0.10787273943424225, -0.024998480454087257, -0.12790654599666595, -1.188319444656372, 0.7504125833511353, -0.6471439003944397, -0.07858181744813919, -0.18894509971141815, -0.6710340976715088, -0.06339915841817856, 0.46793919801712036, -0.43462756276130676, -0.5128334760665894, 0.03904975950717926, -0.4822944104671478, 0.3750413656234741, -0.9288569092750549, -0.06051463261246681, -0.5969099402427673, -0.03599719703197479, -0.7353711128234863, 1.1853569746017456, -0.38029244542121887, -0.02568606287240982, 0.6120163798332214, 0.1368013620376587, 0.1816139966249466, 0.13487669825553894, 0.31053540110588074, 0.2760288119316101, -0.16755512356758118, 0.08550628274679184, 0.24995335936546326, 0.19380666315555573, -0.3703829348087311, 0.6221711039543152, -0.05650538578629494, 0.3067419230937958, 0.5066820383071899, -0.11602965742349625, 0.2925983667373657, -0.13109083473682404, 1.0251412391662598, -0.633186936378479, -0.702755868434906, 0.5988938212394714, -0.5480731129646301, 0.3909444212913513, 0.35627663135528564, -0.45350050926208496, -0.4777734875679016, -0.14484842121601105, -0.7836617827415466, 0.7039434313774109, 0.10883026570081711, -0.5417884588241577, -1.0262547731399536, -0.8282260298728943, -0.006079751532524824, -0.5538070797920227, -0.010937654413282871, 0.1237783133983612, -0.040136903524398804, 0.45684847235679626, 0.08700958639383316, 0.15961776673793793, -0.2816268503665924, 0.09022536873817444, -0.10945708304643631, -0.09075268357992172, -0.0998578891158104, -0.252635657787323, -0.6266017556190491, -0.8500235676765442, -0.3038236200809479, -0.03773157671093941, 0.6073989272117615, -0.16689136624336243, 1.0545592308044434, 0.26819902658462524, -0.1893656849861145, -0.058921631425619125, 0.15669240057468414, -0.1468498855829239, -0.3858369290828705, 0.6419939398765564, 0.25965791940689087, 0.3453294336795807, -0.0835559219121933, 0.07795034348964691, -0.5097100138664246, 0.0017442971002310514, 0.77109694480896, -0.8707794547080994, 0.050702568143606186, 0.28149300813674927, -0.1231299415230751, 0.0011382328812032938, -0.26995372772216797, -1.2379755973815918, -0.5991178154945374, -0.14398807287216187, -0.14553140103816986, 0.4462841749191284, 0.13856253027915955, -0.3776089549064636, 0.08273816853761673, 0.47682687640190125, 0.03593279793858528, 0.5366206169128418, 0.7460542321205139, -0.24157840013504028, -0.45181024074554443, -0.27329084277153015, 1.053839087486267, 0.09080351889133453, -0.5730393528938293, 0.2339068055152893, 0.016755348071455956, -0.510197639465332, -0.7188974022865295, 1.0173853635787964, -1.2429029941558838, 0.034285008907318115, 0.14989154040813446, 0.24818503856658936, 0.3713221549987793, -0.07320957630872726, -0.40652602910995483, 0.2481951117515564, -0.9567077159881592, -0.4912835657596588, -0.24821624159812927, -0.5466598272323608, 0.6715415716171265, 0.9560744166374207, 0.21212249994277954, 0.22666659951210022, -0.23083215951919556, 0.6223399639129639, -0.0669940859079361, -0.5923788547515869, -0.6412221193313599, -1.1176642179489136, -0.449527770280838, -0.962307333946228, -0.7300443649291992, 0.07625766843557358, 0.523853600025177, -0.2677823603153229, 0.11978253722190857, 0.33405834436416626, -0.5330712795257568, -0.25762349367141724, 0.8992238640785217, -0.1796298325061798, -1.059722661972046, -0.5968296527862549, 0.19904577732086182, 0.34990066289901733, -0.7481213808059692, -0.2743067741394043, 0.18359917402267456, 0.16453582048416138, 1.0143159627914429, 0.08322730660438538, 0.47598400712013245, 0.05270085856318474, -0.6439214944839478, 0.3211416006088257, 0.015342272818088531, -1.3017579317092896, 0.23611263930797577, -0.2842683792114258, 0.9271728992462158, 0.4187839925289154, 0.31393977999687195, 0.2090703397989273, 0.1953079253435135, -1.2621630430221558, 0.2066633105278015, -0.07063284516334534, 0.5632891058921814, -0.46905624866485596, -0.36330920457839966, -0.12079879641532898, 0.4015149474143982, -0.5507649183273315, 0.6257274150848389, 0.11882009357213974, 0.022779954597353935, -0.7452040910720825, 0.6348897218704224, 0.09118298441171646, -0.31969964504241943, -0.3265351355075836, 0.688910722732544, -0.7876487374305725, 0.068354032933712, 0.3217202425003052, 0.4970144033432007, -0.07260238379240036, -0.6525666117668152, 0.3295234441757202, -0.2812628448009491, 0.4334322512149811, 0.1050940454006195, 0.24744196236133575, 0.1355273276567459, -0.33812305331230164, -0.2651253640651703, -0.09689801186323166, 0.39749637246131897, -0.2682879865169525, 0.45881325006484985, 0.03142054006457329, 0.1490919440984726, -0.06166067719459534, -0.317727267742157, -1.1872024536132812, -0.12050747126340866, -0.8871534466743469, -0.6794930100440979, 0.6819576025009155, 0.012602309696376324, 0.26318809390068054, 0.15986084938049316, -0.06973831355571747, 0.14883720874786377, 0.09215574711561203, 0.9800028800964355, 0.3350423276424408, -0.5756751298904419, -1.110122799873352, 0.19071945548057556, -0.5638601779937744, -0.17288996279239655, -0.37809130549430847, 0.48239973187446594, -0.5510634183883667, -0.5457940697669983, 0.2571428120136261, 0.36816924810409546, -0.46454253792762756, -0.5344322919845581, 0.6437863111495972, -0.584260106086731, -0.32054197788238525, -0.05634720250964165, -0.0780985876917839, -0.04073749855160713, -0.5817263126373291, 0.08526591956615448, 0.3288850784301758, -0.33081597089767456, -0.5194402933120728, 0.4028542637825012, 0.4025655686855316, -0.26123031973838806, 0.7319397926330566, 0.8083200454711914, 0.17730191349983215, -0.21904480457305908, -0.048467837274074554, 0.21939639747142792, 0.2674345374107361, 0.7951560020446777, -0.724125862121582, 0.01831558533012867, 0.39388471841812134, -0.14043574035167694, 0.4931235611438751, -0.3245069980621338, 0.2788477838039398, 0.3724120557308197, -0.053448259830474854, 0.09975208342075348, 0.19728942215442657, 0.00552180502563715, 0.7525156140327454, 0.5477854013442993, 0.09870743751525879, -0.40679261088371277, 0.08512330800294876, -0.18035630881786346, 0.8446599841117859, -0.898659348487854, -0.6450734734535217, -0.6940123438835144, 0.17781758308410645, 0.4172283411026001, -0.07494048774242401, -0.8186185359954834, 0.10615735501050949, 0.060494329780340195, 0.4790349006652832, -0.0825364962220192, -0.29965484142303467, -0.06873168796300888, 0.24961768090724945, -0.30404478311538696, 0.07558908313512802, 0.5858659148216248, 0.6884167194366455, 0.5245825052261353, 1.0838127136230469, -0.14414279162883759, 0.08406304568052292, 0.13639099895954132, 0.01301612425595522, -0.9012291431427002, 0.1389923244714737, -0.23071569204330444, -0.7627509832382202, 0.6396965384483337, 0.5158560276031494, -0.1472565233707428, -0.9371013641357422, -0.07478756457567215, 0.2799244225025177, -0.23840397596359253, 0.46485280990600586, 0.05799642205238342, -0.37693384289741516, -0.41903188824653625, 0.033578913658857346, -0.03592068329453468, 0.2822360396385193, 0.47611361742019653, 0.30875441431999207, 0.5210038423538208, 0.8633937835693359, 0.8925434947013855, 0.36591923236846924, 0.4893004298210144, -0.9589303731918335, -0.33810415863990784, 0.49360164999961853, 0.4021897614002228, -0.10789450258016586, 0.6631512641906738, -0.8037542700767517, -0.3012199103832245, 0.5036083459854126, -0.19340549409389496, -0.20951610803604126, -0.2933804988861084, 0.5290476679801941, 0.5533718466758728, -0.6741743683815002, 0.3963659107685089, 0.747444748878479, 0.15312862396240234, -0.44327473640441895, -0.5263455510139465, 0.3221692740917206, -0.745265007019043, 0.4338023364543915, -0.9367813467979431, 0.4387386441230774, -0.04043005034327507, -0.08824705332517624, -0.38040345907211304, -0.060717541724443436, -0.43089529871940613, -0.9740644693374634, -0.07866828143596649, -0.6524182558059692, 0.32835158705711365, 0.8336482048034668, -0.27994653582572937, 0.18575121462345123, -0.29528993368148804, -0.47398796677589417, -0.37523961067199707, 0.8089430332183838, -0.04799684137105942, 0.21680821478366852, 0.18443121016025543, 0.138524129986763, -1.0597221851348877, 0.3027990162372589, 0.5485883951187134, -0.4981953203678131, 0.5237479209899902, -0.33366286754608154, 0.06283742934465408, 0.15463508665561676, -0.6893236637115479, 0.24091196060180664, 0.08015678077936172, 0.23006725311279297, 0.5475751757621765, -0.033275164663791656, 0.07710366696119308, 0.03166836127638817, -0.42598065733909607, -0.6496784090995789, -0.10416513681411743, 0.5022001266479492, -0.23207108676433563, 0.3087703287601471, -0.7358066439628601, 4.272617816925049, 0.48496314883232117, -0.07507763803005219, 0.21195486187934875, 0.5593881607055664, 0.8394700288772583, 0.2748851478099823, 0.09074219316244125, 0.3072408139705658, -0.9764345288276672, -0.36042529344558716, 0.12999647855758667, 0.811016857624054, -0.13493601977825165, 0.1256856769323349, 0.5612556338310242, 0.23203793168067932, 0.2737422585487366, -0.28157076239585876, -0.2974017560482025, -0.6847836375236511, 0.1726454198360443, 0.10960785299539566, 0.2739780843257904, 0.6663904190063477, 0.40563419461250305, -0.37251877784729004, -0.4174101650714874, -0.5773802399635315, -0.7014204263687134, -0.24147005379199982, -0.495674729347229, 0.04097163677215576, -0.32955050468444824, -0.8246836066246033, 0.04731018468737602, -0.596651017665863, -0.7389969825744629, 0.5393462777137756, 0.5085195899009705, -0.4015973210334778, -0.7046705484390259, 0.8106226921081543, -0.3500552177429199, 0.24882659316062927, 1.1882262229919434, 0.6901525259017944, 0.8176513314247131, 0.7224899530410767, -0.5251727104187012, 0.02182885631918907, -0.13255900144577026, -0.13899379968643188, -0.9253002405166626, -0.8625277280807495, -0.21069690585136414, -0.6254438161849976, -0.2858540713787079, 0.3249516487121582, -0.3199319839477539, 0.42078259587287903, 0.09279843419790268, -0.510675311088562, 0.17549318075180054, 0.21430134773254395, 0.27522143721580505, 0.1840202510356903, 0.02490459755063057, 0.3391657769680023, -0.42729365825653076, -0.3172418475151062, -0.05411138758063316, -0.24405531585216522, -0.5950689315795898, 0.3045685887336731, 0.31507939100265503, -0.2584393322467804, 0.402365505695343, -0.2723793387413025, 0.6028457880020142, -0.5208393335342407, 0.010261538438498974, -0.5351105332374573, 0.3377276360988617, -0.06621216982603073, 0.419408917427063, -0.7021778225898743, -0.020479664206504822, -0.6252864003181458, 0.27911415696144104, 0.21202756464481354, 0.662222683429718, -0.30225181579589844, 0.5471940040588379, -0.7624421119689941 ]
Poincar\'e Gauge Theories for Lineal Garvity
We have shown that two of the most studied models of lineal gravities - Liouville gravity and a ``string-inspired'' model exhibiting the main characteristic features of a black-hole solution - can be formulated as gauge invariant theories of the Poincar\'e group. The gauge invariant couplings to matter (particles, scalar and spinor fields) and explicit solutions for some matter field configurations, are provided. It is shown that both the models, as well as the couplings to matter, can be obtained as suitable dimensional reductions of a 2+1-dimensional ISO(2,1) gauge invariant theory.
G. Grignani and G. Nardelli
gr-qc
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209013
gr-qc/9209014
[ -0.20946389436721802, -0.42038434743881226, 0.663578450679779, 0.14891810715198517, -0.11394010484218597, -0.36277705430984497, 0.1701575666666031, 0.0999753549695015, -0.7532455921173096, 1.5242383480072021, 0.8937258720397949, 0.2179764360189438, -0.20891818404197693, -0.6443756222724915, 0.29396486282348633, 0.6526820063591003, -0.05472589656710625, -0.3484605848789215, -1.3816715478897095, 0.11264462023973465, 0.4733884930610657, -0.0968843400478363, -1.550848364830017, -0.5041195154190063, -0.5555534958839417, 0.4098442792892456, 1.0374417304992676, 0.5743958353996277, 1.1995676755905151, 1.0175248384475708, 0.6393682956695557, -0.4839490056037903, -0.2224840372800827, -1.1228150129318237, 0.04243914410471916, 0.4267004430294037, 0.5609152317047119, -0.8395256400108337, 1.0214698314666748, -0.06898675113916397, 1.031760811805725, 0.15684452652931213, -0.06842781603336334, -0.24147042632102966, -0.6163597702980042, -0.24332362413406372, 0.06505811959505081, 0.457971453666687, 0.09732381999492645, -1.2620618343353271, 0.04641028121113777, -0.33519986271858215, 0.6063701510429382, -1.065529704093933, 0.24465253949165344, 0.10160844027996063, 0.320748895406723, 0.2894068956375122, 0.052502408623695374, 0.08302319794893265, 0.86834716796875, 0.08021746575832367, 0.45034855604171753, -1.0137858390808105, -0.5545600056648254, 0.9032317996025085, -0.14954866468906403, 0.9661108255386353, 0.13393670320510864, -0.8141489624977112, 0.11524229496717453, -0.14262861013412476, -0.8033941984176636, 0.36671876907348633, -0.38748547434806824, 0.8277122974395752, -0.3634969890117645, -0.5465737581253052, -0.4130602478981018, -0.03323305770754814, 0.06244838610291481, -0.04161340743303299, -0.22980237007141113, 0.6684802174568176, -0.47287726402282715, -0.25848647952079773, -0.5067959427833557, -0.7205034494400024, 0.14175330102443695, -0.2970469295978546, -0.028307808563113213, 0.7036673426628113, -0.5195940732955933, -0.22280651330947876, 0.12451079487800598, 0.9813339710235596, -0.5414208769798279, 0.626259982585907, -0.3330395519733429, 0.2521721124649048, -0.2587577998638153, 1.2856755256652832, -0.4562266767024994, 0.48016083240509033, -0.07121912389993668, 0.6766176819801331, -0.41214966773986816, 0.11754532903432846, -0.075709767639637, -0.9393758773803711, -0.08081458508968353, 0.300038605928421, 0.7105381488800049, -0.1849554479122162, -0.022551944479346275, 0.3740513324737549, -0.4816637337207794, -0.15031860768795013, -0.30522918701171875, -0.27639901638031006, 0.8983845114707947, 0.3236088156700134, 0.46505361795425415, 0.4548291265964508, -0.4342864751815796, -0.7058024406433105, 0.06574389338493347, 0.3345942199230194, -0.5444464683532715, 0.30672648549079895, 0.0003638712805695832, -0.29292330145835876, -0.4045659005641937, 0.02919009141623974, 0.3293337821960449, 0.998434841632843, -0.27767762541770935, 0.16709458827972412, -0.15127044916152954, -1.121029257774353, 0.4938778281211853, -0.3206457793712616, 0.38351503014564514, 1.075392484664917, 0.15082430839538574, 0.8288952112197876, 0.5129194855690002, 0.015970399603247643, -0.0626959502696991, 0.4529908001422882, 0.03444655239582062, -0.7773169279098511, -0.4717557430267334, -0.01029177289456129, 0.07484862953424454, -0.15976224839687347, -1.1906979084014893, 0.6391582489013672, -0.7172431349754333, -0.11395274847745895, 0.3494180142879486, -0.30121302604675293, -0.45603248476982117, 1.0481418371200562, -0.3104768693447113, 0.10322649031877518, -0.5026960968971252, -0.018406983464956284, -0.11526267230510712, 0.0324922539293766, -0.1849752813577652, 0.11627137660980225, 0.5216746926307678, 0.39220017194747925, 1.0247234106063843, 0.0367388054728508, -0.628915548324585, -0.6683750748634338, -0.5176419615745544, 0.5185382962226868, -0.4264112412929535, -0.34139594435691833, 0.5382815599441528, 0.5278472304344177, -0.6718688607215881, -0.6044785976409912, -0.04960373416543007, 0.10403314232826233, -0.21148410439491272, 0.15207339823246002, -0.31891298294067383, 0.5368276834487915, -1.1884828805923462, 0.6271833777427673, -0.6783996820449829, 0.16747984290122986, -1.0087858438491821, -0.30625155568122864, -0.914340615272522, -0.6357964277267456, 0.40248608589172363, -0.15169601142406464, -0.555019199848175, 0.1447354406118393, -1.3451814651489258, 0.027710525318980217, 0.6261069774627686, 0.03843763843178749, -0.3830815255641937, -0.40432700514793396, 0.5899031758308411, -0.331598162651062, -0.04345967248082161, -0.025039546191692352, 0.17113454639911652, 0.05263892933726311, -0.1277114301919937, -0.14616094529628754, 0.04500209540128708, 0.02508222684264183, 0.8936359882354736, 0.4331929087638855, -0.7851541638374329, 1.0220167636871338, 0.031916968524456024, -0.47520819306373596, -0.41408342123031616, 1.3044317960739136, -0.662159264087677, 0.5610237121582031, 0.16326433420181274, 0.12016727030277252, 0.2853949964046478, 0.34924012422561646, 0.3559585213661194, 0.01941586472094059, 0.9584839344024658, 0.9397570490837097, 0.11120028048753738, -0.18933218717575073, 0.2555062770843506, 0.44378185272216797, 0.05792864039540291, -0.36208128929138184, -0.08931592851877213, 0.8366451263427734, -0.2053394466638565, 0.2773110568523407, -0.5413994789123535, 0.43903887271881104, -0.6980864405632019, 1.0005934238433838, 0.08030448853969574, -0.33930230140686035, -1.1292115449905396, -0.055966541171073914, 0.3308621644973755, 0.3395253121852875, 0.021435167640447617, -0.8710500597953796, -0.47271767258644104, 0.28244271874427795, -0.08747586607933044, -0.12222646176815033, -0.6666469573974609, 0.5100647807121277, -0.0801410973072052, -0.23673281073570251, 0.2699829339981079, -0.27300167083740234, -1.2732200622558594, -0.0029393876902759075, -0.6039413809776306, 0.09000159054994583, -0.10721401870250702, -0.6200949549674988, 0.41562047600746155, 0.1293596476316452, 0.5618707537651062, 0.2560651898384094, 0.26087966561317444, 0.2360335886478424, -0.09095027297735214, -0.01347500178962946, -0.32540780305862427, -0.15985168516635895, -0.9109790325164795, 0.2870377004146576, -1.099908709526062, -0.014969272539019585, -0.18741127848625183, -0.6473564505577087, 0.425581693649292, 0.13458795845508575, -0.09065386652946472, 0.622980535030365, -0.3205619156360626, -0.1691213697195053, 0.12436690181493759, -0.4608719050884247, 0.7164185047149658, 0.6406024098396301, 0.20044629275798798, -0.28385424613952637, -0.8280587792396545, 0.7212951183319092, 0.20704255998134613, -0.3145965039730072, 0.4228300452232361, -0.34554311633110046, -0.42623022198677063, 0.40523478388786316, -0.19346188008785248, 0.1092127338051796, -0.0023647439666092396, 0.5559680461883545, 0.8293465375900269, 0.4927491545677185, 0.2682110071182251, -0.21047069132328033, -0.3892856240272522, -0.2987947165966034, 0.2816210687160492, -1.0883965492248535, 0.6560176014900208, 0.4695284068584442, 0.5567951798439026, -0.3247765004634857, 0.45829007029533386, -1.367902398109436, -0.2738492488861084, -0.6135703325271606, -0.18407994508743286, -0.22979094088077545, -0.13234515488147736, -0.06931140273809433, -0.5402671098709106, -0.14086727797985077, 0.10180361568927765, 0.4403473734855652, 0.9275075197219849, -0.9543094635009766, 0.2698248326778412, 0.2404250204563141, 0.2467946708202362, -0.22359837591648102, 0.5172333717346191, -0.4898127615451813, -0.5407488346099854, 0.5417803525924683, -0.6395378112792969, -0.07397837191820145, 0.8931092619895935, 0.5337992906570435, -0.26777204871177673, -0.14793628454208374, -0.17178276181221008, -0.32250815629959106, -0.3868826627731323, -0.2727731168270111, 0.40717440843582153, 0.3802597224712372, -0.080332912504673, -0.01801670342683792, -0.1948387771844864, -0.07363210618495941, 0.32738104462623596, 0.3342705965042114, 0.5313637852668762, -1.2294946908950806, 0.4108366072177887, -0.12469880282878876, 0.2668856382369995, -0.2691088616847992, -0.20899486541748047, -0.042408160865306854, 0.3907630145549774, 0.39600038528442383, 0.5839465856552124, -0.12730050086975098, -0.39480480551719666, -0.5255643129348755, 0.3480232357978821, 0.3127906024456024, 0.5129523873329163, 0.0696989968419075, -0.8772839903831482, 0.004694589879363775, -0.14615407586097717, -0.3911168873310089, -0.6282250881195068, -0.6563844680786133, 0.45582500100135803, -0.5061659812927246, -0.7023460865020752, -0.4153691232204437, 0.480816125869751, 0.40173113346099854, 0.1516602486371994, -0.23770400881767273, -0.10595403611660004, -0.4701192080974579, 0.03608096018433571, 0.1907377541065216, -0.8239402770996094, 0.22264127433300018, -0.6630711555480957, 0.6955564618110657, 0.062254585325717926, 0.5505295395851135, 0.4218628406524658, -0.5340920686721802, 0.26308122277259827, -0.3731706142425537, 0.7331369519233704, 1.157504916191101, -0.25364434719085693, 0.8175472617149353, 0.06817000359296799, -0.5029650926589966, -0.3797388970851898, 0.12029622495174408, 1.1582950353622437, 0.988018810749054, -0.13219507038593292, -0.49925103783607483, -0.4822857975959778, 0.4662955105304718, 0.571631908416748, 0.06559934467077255, -0.4776844382286072, -0.9059663414955139, -0.49223050475120544, 0.4939115047454834, -0.11534462124109268, 0.020295636728405952, 1.0591248273849487, -0.294023334980011, 1.0959765911102295, 0.053850334137678146, -0.18559004366397858, 0.7061373591423035, -0.34176287055015564, -0.10491502285003662, 0.5617415308952332, -0.2106206864118576, -0.07143445312976837, 0.4465562105178833, -0.1349039375782013, -0.46596431732177734, -0.1368074268102646, -0.09407433122396469, 0.7764792442321777, -0.5842159986495972, -1.0276920795440674, 0.4913684129714966, 0.17809221148490906, -1.0206624269485474, 0.4232136607170105, -0.5298756957054138, -0.11106549203395844, -0.04345322400331497, -0.15944907069206238, -0.3806883692741394, 0.09736131876707077, -0.03427017852663994, -0.8037974834442139, 0.5923342108726501, 0.3605734705924988, 0.3842974603176117, 0.42387160658836365, 0.3004459738731384, 0.3070182204246521, 0.3229016065597534, 0.6920750737190247, -0.3798379600048065, -0.3530672788619995, -0.29941898584365845, -0.3948550224304199, -0.708629310131073, -0.11966370046138763, 0.3918473422527313, 0.43858104944229126, 0.7131788730621338, 0.12839479744434357, -0.8421946167945862, -0.5923457741737366, -0.4366871118545532, -0.7115678787231445, 0.5306431651115417, -0.42709386348724365, -0.3215124011039734, -0.4537273645401001, -0.1280418187379837, 0.07832267135381699, -0.21285836398601532, 0.11488493531942368, -0.5956308841705322, -0.2548202574253082, 0.0021488203201442957, 0.10921420902013779, 0.46081385016441345, -0.010330206714570522, 0.5631352066993713, -0.4216761589050293, -0.5117766857147217, -0.8938830494880676, -0.5571797490119934, -0.03118101879954338, 0.04213033244013786, 0.08090180903673172, -0.5658934116363525, -0.13456213474273682, 0.18365544080734253, -0.28940272331237793, 0.6624128818511963, -0.3564925789833069, -0.6137264966964722, 0.5507434606552124, 0.6070980429649353, 0.38732022047042847, -0.6921551823616028, 0.1296955943107605, 0.7426983714103699, 0.009009885601699352, -0.06980489939451218, -0.24003151059150696, -0.28824666142463684, 0.8439502716064453, -0.854681670665741, 0.4643537104129791, -0.7666352391242981, -0.09936452656984329, -0.11924785375595093, -0.7158060073852539, -0.07686164230108261, 0.251663476228714, -0.016125669702887535, -0.5627443790435791, -0.40420570969581604, 0.03752792254090309, 0.6419620513916016, -0.5040194392204285, -0.01681980863213539, -0.631679892539978, -0.022212844341993332, -0.6628112196922302, 0.8113456964492798, -0.2558874189853668, -0.029672296717762947, 0.22019709646701813, -0.5516083240509033, -0.27858296036720276, 0.6748673915863037, -0.06302190572023392, 0.23559878766536713, -0.5466281771659851, -0.05791854485869408, 1.0303846597671509, 1.1094305515289307, 0.14226670563220978, 0.41924721002578735, -0.3316076099872589, 0.8296476602554321, -0.3117895722389221, -0.5879853367805481, -0.243178591132164, -0.27162235975265503, 0.6875313520431519, -0.20877031981945038, -0.3146507143974304, 0.7303416132926941, -0.021320398896932602, 0.29986482858657837, -0.12526172399520874, -0.8577238917350769, -0.26069721579551697, -0.5375118851661682, -0.7432368397712708, 0.3851976990699768, 0.4411846101284027, 0.162006676197052, -0.42445108294487, -0.1344229131937027, 0.007505099289119244, -0.47153744101524353, -0.13115951418876648, 0.49439123272895813, 0.10217516124248505, 0.5334547758102417, -0.21223050355911255, 0.1047305092215538, -0.28197216987609863, -0.11904730647802353, 0.018262529745697975, -0.3065199553966522, 0.04180534556508064, -0.5936456918716431, -0.6124116778373718, -0.677764892578125, -0.4232631027698517, 0.7235507369041443, 0.16672907769680023, 0.13316908478736877, 1.2732772827148438, 0.04848756268620491, -0.43541693687438965, -0.2891310453414917, -0.06857067346572876, 0.025252792984247208, -0.12058908492326736, 0.6470537781715393, -0.024125322699546814, 0.11817076057195663, 0.24003611505031586, 0.17331568896770477, -0.638691246509552, -0.8598440885543823, 0.6998424530029297, -0.49711713194847107, 0.24491730332374573, 0.5713726282119751, -0.3882775902748108, -0.22500407695770264, -0.0715012177824974, -0.8730168342590332, -0.22286242246627808, -0.031704872846603394, -0.6293887495994568, -0.04655914381146431, -0.10119123756885529, -0.5441560745239258, 0.06682557612657547, 0.10860716551542282, -0.24566499888896942, 0.4283977150917053, -0.11328354477882385, -0.06742344796657562, -0.312400221824646, 0.0915704220533371, 0.8950010538101196, 0.02299346588551998, -0.48695215582847595, -0.31895574927330017, 0.08436670154333115, 0.20455525815486908, -0.3124462366104126, 0.7068151831626892, -0.14860092103481293, -0.18844419717788696, -0.4161153733730316, 0.6013906598091125, 0.19172608852386475, 0.7505443096160889, -0.1631951630115509, -0.24532976746559143, -0.7635616660118103, -0.5109223127365112, 0.5885400772094727, -0.3936290442943573, 0.596440315246582, 0.55351322889328, -0.3407649099826813, 0.1812707781791687, -0.2526068389415741, -0.33107608556747437, -0.43526509404182434, -0.9471478462219238, -0.02691839262843132, -1.3203372955322266, -0.5037244558334351, -1.0263962745666504, -0.505199134349823, 0.10998240858316422, 0.8686237931251526, -0.4642110764980316, 0.28221094608306885, -0.5071585178375244, 0.09653531014919281, 0.54368656873703, 0.7219722867012024, -0.1953185498714447, -0.8169656991958618, -0.22057846188545227, 0.6131112575531006, -0.19753000140190125, -1.053130865097046, -0.4543282091617584, -0.18685948848724365, 0.23579147458076477, 0.7602863907814026, -0.4982426166534424, 0.9673523306846619, -0.24803276360034943, -1.2109824419021606, 0.8338226079940796, -0.0906057357788086, -0.7201851010322571, 0.6413235664367676, 0.15734773874282837, 0.9138222932815552, -0.04824555292725563, 0.13793422281742096, -0.2962903380393982, -0.24222242832183838, -0.812771201133728, 0.8252385258674622, -0.17509578168392181, 0.6435235142707825, 0.29991090297698975, -0.41921794414520264, 0.029050031676888466, 0.045828212052583694, -0.6359464526176453, 0.3153459429740906, -0.25377920269966125, 0.6362993121147156, -0.3566585183143616, -0.25366151332855225, 0.9516438841819763, -0.21586062014102936, -0.2890281081199646, 0.033996015787124634, -0.3473227322101593, 0.1035933718085289, 0.16187725961208344, 0.01485607959330082, -0.18848754465579987, -0.3932380676269531, 0.03514741733670235, -0.5567676424980164, 0.6149285435676575, 0.22606690227985382, -0.12906019389629364, 0.1726997047662735, 0.0003770951589103788, -0.16943731904029846, -0.14160293340682983, 0.152550607919693, -0.8813854455947876, 0.6717710494995117, 0.48616936802864075, 0.20660874247550964, 0.24393804371356964, -0.5101920366287231, -1.235202431678772, 0.1392631083726883, -0.2515980005264282, -0.23735681176185608, 0.04900750145316124, -0.21166394650936127, -0.3333055078983307, 0.6468313336372375, -0.31663328409194946, 0.22655679285526276, 0.29434868693351746, 0.8654302358627319, 0.3765067160129547, -0.5244266986846924, -0.3012777268886566, -0.04613047093153, -1.3071433305740356, -0.5592097043991089, -0.04854315519332886, 0.9764558672904968, -0.7540424466133118, -0.29704785346984863, 0.11285434663295746, 0.34833601117134094, 0.030993515625596046, 0.31387561559677124, -0.054450638592243195, -0.23297631740570068, 0.10178541392087936, 0.0005186136113479733, 0.13397829234600067, -0.13988088071346283, -0.5167872905731201, 0.51552814245224, -0.10472221672534943, -0.4610520601272583, 0.3576926290988922, -0.4873110055923462, 0.10276629775762558, 0.36008667945861816, -0.2557677924633026, 0.5689142942428589, -0.08314260095357895, -0.8751373887062073, 0.17640821635723114, 0.5951830744743347, 0.13022753596305847, 0.28664252161979675, -0.29578033089637756, 0.13546018302440643, 0.4989722967147827, 0.5513553619384766, 0.557479977607727, -0.4502222537994385, -0.40742385387420654, 0.4192054867744446, 0.5787943601608276, 0.36348482966423035, -0.06018144264817238, 0.17128613591194153, 0.36436277627944946, 0.5822035670280457, 0.36806899309158325, 0.011062785983085632, 0.008905885741114616, 0.43319758772850037, 0.15469008684158325, -0.03286893665790558, -0.6675252914428711, -0.7407172322273254, 0.13529762625694275, 0.9396432042121887, -0.4159527122974396, -0.6206552386283875, -0.31931713223457336, 0.6278653144836426, 0.439236044883728, -0.2709041237831116, -0.22011636197566986, 0.27790558338165283, 0.6171170473098755, 0.2297750860452652, -0.0747833102941513, 0.4773544669151306, 0.2803133428096771, -0.1627737432718277, 0.9636598229408264, 0.18340998888015747, 0.6527219414710999, 0.7823116183280945, -0.44626906514167786, -0.9690032601356506, -0.3284352421760559, -0.10268113017082214, -0.7619972825050354, 0.5930145382881165, -0.20186907052993774, -0.11170117557048798, -0.03550846129655838, -0.6829788088798523, 0.184586301445961, -0.6820496320724487, 1.0803941488265991, 0.5393731594085693, -0.30114468932151794, 0.23863856494426727, 0.41601768136024475, 0.2237287312746048, 0.6331976652145386, 0.17839834094047546, -0.32392850518226624, 0.6086447834968567, 1.1242315769195557, 0.9247515797615051, -0.023161916062235832, 0.07275015860795975, -0.08782845735549927, 0.11694686114788055, 0.6115630865097046, 0.0071379500441253185, 0.019480494782328606, 0.8313294649124146, -0.4991476237773895, 0.6058951020240784, -0.2858223617076874, 0.032553259283304214, -0.16531860828399658, 0.03910469263792038, 0.45036861300468445, 0.45066556334495544, -0.4497425854206085, -0.16845661401748657, 0.2802528142929077, 0.4377969801425934, -0.04085942357778549, -0.5099210739135742, 0.17284905910491943, -1.012116551399231, -0.15691903233528137, -0.6214026212692261, 0.6715459227561951, 0.11817176640033722, -0.3344128429889679, -0.844977855682373, -0.5583399534225464, -0.031221887096762657, -1.3396550416946411, -0.38929545879364014, -0.08520233631134033, 0.39213740825653076, 0.7750263214111328, 0.0982469692826271, 0.47157570719718933, -0.829284131526947, -0.4941290318965912, -0.23317395150661469, 0.9288639426231384, -0.016076065599918365, -0.200911745429039, 0.4118177592754364, 0.44179388880729675, -0.6695346236228943, 0.5147674083709717, 0.5328998565673828, -0.6257510781288147, 0.9386832118034363, 0.12111152708530426, -0.2166639119386673, 0.1281382441520691, -0.2604326903820038, 0.21656376123428345, 0.3952414095401764, 0.36754029989242554, 0.6073583960533142, -0.1690676361322403, 0.02460804581642151, -0.7083122134208679, -0.439223051071167, -0.6531785130500793, 0.5154109597206116, 0.669549822807312, -0.036387521773576736, -0.019897043704986572, -0.5648941993713379, 4.186008930206299, 0.8632493019104004, 0.29308590292930603, -0.4039810299873352, 1.2343497276306152, 0.8087295293807983, 0.32882973551750183, -0.24170386791229248, 0.29122743010520935, -0.5952536463737488, -0.45344170928001404, 0.5345470905303955, 0.35231390595436096, -0.21988940238952637, 0.16821379959583282, 0.6756751537322998, -0.0956740453839302, -0.2020014524459839, -0.08432706445455551, -0.6822616457939148, -1.4048497676849365, 0.43242156505584717, 0.08665213733911514, 0.3233780562877655, 0.14088883996009827, 0.7293370366096497, 0.13652358949184418, -0.480947345495224, -0.7059943675994873, -0.953937292098999, 0.09125098586082458, -1.1568918228149414, -0.025472531095147133, -0.2664574980735779, -0.7529804706573486, 0.06571952253580093, 0.30105867981910706, -0.04488614574074745, 0.24631676077842712, -0.044007688760757446, -0.22385267913341522, -0.3457077443599701, 0.03212909772992134, -0.1511540710926056, -0.3452790081501007, 1.3171796798706055, 0.4217700660228729, 1.0627408027648926, 0.5268779397010803, -0.38827890157699585, 0.0014752992428839207, 0.31299886107444763, 0.16324825584888458, -0.04896790534257889, -0.8261865973472595, -0.46127837896347046, -0.3192531168460846, -0.14958342909812927, 0.057529810816049576, -0.4687957167625427, 0.9289344549179077, -0.34902527928352356, 0.3835771083831787, 0.37077537178993225, -0.2699034810066223, 0.8873137831687927, -0.18288704752922058, 0.3859405517578125, -0.1485896110534668, 0.030453553423285484, -1.2410372495651245, 0.26334768533706665, -0.4829140603542328, -0.8504175543785095, -0.06692920625209808, -0.10121475160121918, -0.34365928173065186, 0.4786025583744049, 0.13324826955795288, 0.09211127460002899, -0.6251609921455383, 0.15056893229484558, 0.3370688557624817, 0.37879255414009094, -0.345171719789505, 0.8076587915420532, -0.25837814807891846, 0.3171975314617157, -0.2179177701473236, 0.12292603403329849, -0.26825690269470215, 0.9788922667503357, -0.28079524636268616, 0.007089099381119013, -0.820383608341217 ]
The Microcanonical Functional Integral. I. The Gravitational Field
The gravitational field in a spatially finite region is described as a microcanonical system. The density of states $\nu$ is expressed formally as a functional integral over Lorentzian metrics and is a functional of the geometrical boundary data that are fixed in the corresponding action. These boundary data are the thermodynamical extensive variables, including the energy and angular momentum of the system. When the boundary data are chosen such that the system is described semiclassically by {\it any} real stationary axisymmetric black hole, then in this same approximation $\ln\nu$ is shown to equal 1/4 the area of the black hole event horizon. The canonical and grand canonical partition functions are obtained by integral transforms of $\nu$ that lead to "imaginary time" functional integrals. A general form of the first law of thermodynamics for stationary black holes is derived. For the simpler case of nonrelativistic mechanics, the density of states is expressed as a real-time functional integral and then used to deduce Feynman's imaginary-time functional integral for the canonical partition function.
J. David Brown and James W. York
gr-qc hep-th
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209014
gr-qc/9209015
[ -0.19323524832725525, 0.12541812658309937, 0.39548614621162415, 0.05288425460457802, -0.5693832635879517, 0.3126177191734314, -0.5944901704788208, 0.09762664884328842, -1.2350058555603027, 1.5508086681365967, 0.31950896978378296, -0.43341267108917236, -0.4605690538883209, -0.769397497177124, 0.04142698645591736, -0.011412565596401691, -0.10429730266332626, 0.10940646380186081, -1.1165441274642944, 0.6020858287811279, 0.2986518442630768, 0.7043783068656921, -0.8641101717948914, -0.4433961510658264, -0.39333006739616394, 1.2724288702011108, 0.7760952115058899, 0.076478011906147, 0.7012546062469482, 0.4206685721874237, 0.5147608518600464, 0.4102594554424286, 0.4531768262386322, -0.2825571596622467, -0.4661957621574402, 0.05825177580118179, 0.1277574598789215, -0.4403858482837677, 1.0684868097305298, -0.045955996960401535, 0.7895082831382751, 0.7043021321296692, -0.000518416112754494, -0.8744800686836243, -0.6469897627830505, -0.13378095626831055, 0.16177894175052643, -0.04490054398775101, 0.13606341183185577, -0.9727911949157715, -0.31744149327278137, -0.22015564143657684, 0.7582477927207947, -0.9109853506088257, -0.08250429481267929, 0.08069737255573273, 0.6858304142951965, 0.6824865937232971, -0.7676694989204407, -0.28394848108291626, 0.3083678185939789, 0.2782118320465088, 0.5226864814758301, -0.6024820804595947, 0.31930121779441833, 1.0470808744430542, 0.004520768765360117, 0.15662585198879242, 0.38395607471466064, -0.8392276167869568, 0.10247111320495605, -0.6322633624076843, -0.6252257823944092, -0.15113531053066254, -0.4712352156639099, 0.52982097864151, -0.6442485451698303, -0.18937230110168457, -0.2801194190979004, -0.2296208143234253, 0.08081689476966858, 0.1741592288017273, 0.0708397850394249, 0.10203007608652115, -0.25012683868408203, 0.11454156041145325, 0.5575500130653381, 0.5767906904220581, -0.06301836669445038, 0.1293128877878189, -0.481892466545105, 0.6322171092033386, 0.12338414043188095, 0.15671148896217346, 0.5982995629310608, 0.869369626045227, -0.43191930651664734, 0.7156860828399658, -0.25663328170776367, 0.08209484070539474, -0.42820441722869873, 0.6186253428459167, -0.41290101408958435, -0.22493015229701996, -0.49167194962501526, 0.8784762620925903, -0.5661276578903198, 0.09776177257299423, -0.8212366104125977, -0.7389618158340454, 0.09097441285848618, -0.05085209757089615, 0.41853541135787964, 0.23926106095314026, 0.45271730422973633, -0.32506704330444336, -0.27288398146629333, -0.07914136350154877, -0.0996202677488327, -0.4495241045951843, 0.08631305396556854, 0.49931350350379944, 0.4838869273662567, 0.6043871641159058, -0.30930188298225403, -0.5362564325332642, 0.13103291392326355, -0.07266802340745926, -0.5054931044578552, -0.5584093332290649, 0.27675479650497437, -0.431275337934494, -0.12645910680294037, 0.7122107744216919, -0.2863383889198303, 0.08812358975410461, -0.038003019988536835, 0.14975495636463165, -0.7222328782081604, -0.19138263165950775, 0.2892354130744934, -0.06179432198405266, 0.06614159792661667, 0.8437197208404541, -0.18496526777744293, -0.39650464057922363, -0.07356078177690506, 0.7469262480735779, -0.4734187424182892, 0.35589599609375, -0.21829132735729218, -0.5285409688949585, 0.3262201249599457, -0.016351431608200073, -0.43885985016822815, 0.12172703444957733, -1.316665530204773, 0.3382016718387604, 0.17080773413181305, -0.6535672545433044, 0.2643949091434479, 0.0569424033164978, 0.037199296057224274, 0.8657689094543457, -0.5552374720573425, 0.2605781853199005, -0.32968172430992126, 0.1466590017080307, -0.31489482522010803, 0.1967414915561676, 0.0071923634968698025, -0.11564096808433533, -0.3593776822090149, 0.9942104816436768, 0.9768410921096802, 0.506422221660614, -0.027785392478108406, -0.3972267806529999, -0.07568318396806717, 0.16645176708698273, 0.05185477063059807, -0.9498457908630371, 0.14961190521717072, 0.4758402109146118, -0.8841181993484497, -0.5961881279945374, 0.41634291410446167, -0.31768056750297546, 0.3364395201206207, 0.4493027925491333, -0.5996986031532288, 0.3744933605194092, -1.0978944301605225, 0.7650822997093201, -0.32257452607154846, 0.5188907980918884, -1.5764497518539429, -0.32509681582450867, -0.1400863081216812, -0.7918918132781982, 0.4111136198043823, -0.07104295492172241, -0.45835182070732117, 0.36310985684394836, -0.40410616993904114, -0.43260395526885986, 0.43333256244659424, 0.4534585475921631, -0.6712910532951355, 0.3162126839160919, 0.39426150918006897, -0.5004947781562805, 0.5476831793785095, 0.04972635209560394, 0.1668064445257187, 0.1951148360967636, -0.729354739189148, 0.044067587703466415, 0.1261335164308548, 0.2550654411315918, 0.33469218015670776, 0.4871689975261688, -0.025791510939598083, 0.5260053277015686, -0.5339060425758362, -0.8055616617202759, 0.5677221417427063, 0.8864872455596924, -0.058843400329351425, 0.13676661252975464, 0.5077572464942932, -0.06812784820795059, 0.47675079107284546, 0.772439181804657, 0.17507578432559967, -0.406977117061615, 0.8738031387329102, 0.6313731074333191, -0.3470669388771057, -0.271962970495224, 0.3575816750526428, -0.3819117248058319, 0.6295090317726135, -0.19227376580238342, -0.41894447803497314, -0.034599557518959045, -0.1177082359790802, 0.2482810765504837, -0.058499228209257126, 0.48118269443511963, -0.43838438391685486, 0.39449551701545715, 0.32302433252334595, 0.00974337849766016, -0.6915362477302551, 0.3156827986240387, 0.018963433802127838, -0.3269718885421753, -0.3178873062133789, -0.36979755759239197, -0.346983939409256, 0.38404354453086853, -0.205046147108078, -0.5761120915412903, -0.39750584959983826, 0.2898266017436981, -0.27887067198753357, 0.19618083536624908, 0.42768990993499756, -0.39421364665031433, -0.9325608015060425, 0.03658183664083481, -0.2081907093524933, 0.2695123255252838, -0.10584568977355957, 0.18070009350776672, 0.42829692363739014, -0.2601619064807892, 0.27629128098487854, -0.010484171099960804, 0.09711489081382751, 0.7862850427627563, -0.030394913628697395, 0.16486932337284088, 0.41880375146865845, -0.06172781065106392, -0.6536837816238403, 0.45022842288017273, -1.2580124139785767, -0.09369411319494247, -0.04222462326288223, -0.749767541885376, -0.07110074162483215, -0.2890205681324005, 0.6461653709411621, 0.431964248418808, -0.36939719319343567, 0.3300975263118744, 0.05538415536284447, -0.5252078771591187, 0.5054924488067627, -0.025648536160588264, -0.4156353771686554, 0.0022344798780977726, -0.6642864346504211, 1.0131475925445557, 0.16950948536396027, -0.3744164705276489, 0.7190433144569397, 0.11125583201646805, -0.5930492281913757, -0.2402096539735794, 0.16139085590839386, 0.4946022033691406, -0.14099852740764618, 0.7758596539497375, 0.9613892436027527, -0.16274213790893555, 0.15292873978614807, -0.3479471504688263, -0.6620644330978394, -0.03461992368102074, 0.5833757519721985, -0.7375072240829468, 0.565350353717804, 0.7554689049720764, 0.03977048024535179, -1.1126958131790161, 0.6407597064971924, -0.9911631345748901, -0.583957850933075, -0.46393951773643494, -0.3223740756511688, 0.1657724380493164, 0.4903514087200165, 0.23642341792583466, 0.12367323040962219, -0.7175186276435852, -0.1351442188024521, 1.0300201177597046, 0.599885880947113, 0.019397037103772163, 0.3367389440536499, 0.03268835321068764, 0.415054053068161, -0.5057883262634277, 0.8377851247787476, -0.28702375292778015, -0.25149527192115784, 0.14251242578029633, -0.27359312772750854, 0.5539413094520569, -0.13330987095832825, 0.18518969416618347, -0.03608264401555061, 0.4476945996284485, -0.4486822485923767, -0.3665889799594879, -1.2193148136138916, -0.3419903516769409, 0.02651026099920273, -0.36857250332832336, 0.22264191508293152, -0.9159500598907471, -0.829491376876831, -0.3061267137527466, 0.36980029940605164, 0.8207314014434814, 0.12892328202724457, -1.0234886407852173, 0.23772326111793518, -0.13672608137130737, -0.13085688650608063, -0.03860073164105415, 0.19159099459648132, -0.032628174871206284, 0.6082075834274292, 0.14153578877449036, 0.3791646659374237, -0.47515279054641724, -0.1358041763305664, -0.3046146631240845, 0.4411259889602661, 0.237972691655159, 0.637302041053772, -0.4719577133655548, -0.33172598481178284, 0.6116319298744202, -0.6650500893592834, -0.18038561940193176, -0.6377207636833191, -0.9115177989006042, 0.3168497383594513, -0.49274253845214844, -0.5089947581291199, 0.08727839589118958, 0.3872043490409851, 0.8992286324501038, 0.24944904446601868, 0.003679026383906603, 0.10348010808229446, -0.2619907259941101, -0.04092080146074295, 0.3639678359031677, -0.3375660181045532, 0.2618577778339386, -0.7429794073104858, 0.7477368712425232, 0.2375015914440155, 0.13199971616268158, 0.5596351027488708, -0.8505399227142334, -0.689971387386322, 0.06378014385700226, 0.37948447465896606, 0.7343916893005371, -0.37889596819877625, 0.5822967886924744, 0.2255958914756775, 0.2223810851573944, -0.472297728061676, 0.5911145210266113, 0.6775327324867249, 0.15103790163993835, 0.03555351495742798, -0.2552267909049988, -0.534782886505127, -0.4638235569000244, 0.5183814167976379, 0.6463034749031067, -0.3929465115070343, -0.8830764293670654, -0.5975433588027954, 0.15702997148036957, 0.4545232951641083, 0.32830893993377686, 0.6266091465950012, 0.1548037976026535, 0.6177586913108826, -0.19551345705986023, 0.440694123506546, 0.5838014483451843, -0.04297279566526413, -0.3982403576374054, -0.6395066380500793, 0.2957973778247833, -0.20203213393688202, 1.1457351446151733, -0.3055914640426636, -1.6020030975341797, -0.6066500544548035, -0.3387925922870636, 0.38032039999961853, -0.2959679067134857, -0.4474424719810486, 0.07265733182430267, -0.10503288358449936, -0.006914135534316301, 0.24134112894535065, -0.37819305062294006, 0.3151947855949402, 0.26437562704086304, 0.3332326412200928, -0.3528045415878296, 0.3467595875263214, 0.19381093978881836, -0.30489176511764526, 0.5252889394760132, 0.31789201498031616, 0.403054803609848, 0.8495370745658875, 0.8046069741249084, 0.5795016884803772, 0.04738990589976311, 0.7285118699073792, -0.14363664388656616, -0.1834598034620285, -0.45872873067855835, -0.14475059509277344, -0.7269046902656555, -0.44421854615211487, 0.45583221316337585, -0.5861979126930237, 0.3244277834892273, 0.2946401536464691, -0.6740279793739319, -0.12766824662685394, -0.7017459273338318, -0.7070505023002625, 0.7263116240501404, -0.2065536230802536, -0.4088156819343567, 0.20859237015247345, -0.49192845821380615, -0.35485705733299255, 0.16740387678146362, 0.4991309642791748, -0.4024485945701599, 0.21644708514213562, 0.6554777026176453, -0.11025851219892502, 0.8047623634338379, -0.6364996433258057, 0.09610453993082047, -0.4777642488479614, -0.7508017420768738, -0.6349506378173828, -0.7531123161315918, -0.5374625325202942, -0.11727911233901978, 0.4046971797943115, -0.3280126452445984, 0.20876659452915192, 0.15325380861759186, -0.14892978966236115, 0.7015120387077332, 0.004228202626109123, -0.7478551864624023, -0.20993773639202118, 0.14027154445648193, 0.05645992234349251, -0.5718920826911926, -0.15266677737236023, 0.7755908966064453, -0.03076746128499508, 0.6240490674972534, -0.4471791684627533, 0.22762002050876617, 0.4069887399673462, -0.5671623945236206, 0.4678478240966797, -0.27807357907295227, -0.6865483522415161, 0.18923413753509521, -0.3491073548793793, -0.1199309304356575, 0.1864779144525528, -0.46228617429733276, -0.7951959371566772, -0.19539481401443481, -0.47483617067337036, 0.5249257683753967, -0.46723631024360657, 0.48583582043647766, -0.6694332361221313, 0.11615566164255142, -0.1857154667377472, 1.132453203201294, -0.007924951612949371, 0.24277420341968536, -0.0455157496035099, -0.10038211941719055, -0.7546402812004089, 0.5064290165901184, 0.2997452914714813, 0.34779495000839233, -0.6022858619689941, -0.06419672071933746, 0.3989599645137787, 0.0012206672690808773, -0.2786116600036621, 0.37229958176612854, -0.8243941068649292, 0.10680554807186127, -0.20949065685272217, 0.05256232991814613, 0.3755989968776703, 0.06048886850476265, 0.1582259237766266, -0.39846304059028625, 0.2243606299161911, 0.5259928107261658, 0.16767624020576477, 0.22754138708114624, 0.5106297731399536, -0.8111389875411987, -0.02263825386762619, -0.8754332065582275, -0.7706068158149719, 0.5530392527580261, -0.3198481798171997, -0.4120761752128601, -0.15740977227687836, -0.6972265839576721, 0.19402143359184265, -0.27105945348739624, 0.18604332208633423, 0.3713294267654419, 0.34129178524017334, 0.30702143907546997, -0.2735402286052704, -0.04652286320924759, -0.8189099431037903, -0.32661423087120056, 0.018180740997195244, -0.08534599095582962, 0.5550270080566406, -0.519045889377594, -0.38393634557724, -0.6695888042449951, -0.7659311890602112, 0.5248081684112549, 0.48593536019325256, -0.10903111100196838, 1.1096574068069458, -0.13516569137573242, -0.2220410406589508, -0.25717514753341675, -0.13000106811523438, 0.5829855799674988, -0.3305038809776306, 0.5343474745750427, 0.6871812343597412, 0.014488651417195797, -0.07868991792201996, 0.3152333199977875, -0.7853474617004395, -0.8690560460090637, 0.5867474675178528, -0.5111483335494995, -0.05172557756304741, 1.1041620969772339, 0.05801485478878021, -0.348093718290329, -0.602928876876831, -0.950458288192749, -0.4400930404663086, 0.2004270851612091, -0.6853640079498291, 0.40682172775268555, -0.3716127872467041, -0.2254854142665863, 0.0908888652920723, 0.4375912845134735, 0.2699681520462036, 0.49744895100593567, -0.09422796219587326, 0.16843196749687195, -0.12632271647453308, -0.08839353919029236, 0.9884527325630188, 0.20871984958648682, -0.6462173461914062, -0.4382614195346832, 0.6380648016929626, -0.3506678640842438, 0.1358296126127243, 0.7087100744247437, -0.2203940749168396, -0.133389413356781, 0.3694264888763428, 0.3363352417945862, 0.565741240978241, 0.13197460770606995, -0.23155660927295685, 0.3293802738189697, -0.9782141447067261, -0.9608207941055298, 0.02305912785232067, -0.22354023158550262, 0.5104930996894836, 0.27603238821029663, -0.35132673382759094, 0.184240460395813, -0.3524652421474457, 0.23813636600971222, -0.06421512365341187, -0.9696664810180664, -0.07640546560287476, -1.195331335067749, -0.9755584597587585, -0.940273642539978, 0.5527716279029846, -0.19070836901664734, 0.19900421798229218, -0.10594738274812698, 0.42621609568595886, -0.34416818618774414, 0.3145299553871155, 0.22902020812034607, 1.1176953315734863, -0.5404562950134277, -0.6157846450805664, -0.7297583818435669, 0.18549181520938873, -0.2775968313217163, -0.956745445728302, -0.32946595549583435, -0.3475397825241089, 0.12714970111846924, 1.0921694040298462, -0.8948357105255127, 0.3041220009326935, -0.8493742346763611, -0.8049695491790771, 0.16942450404167175, 0.15494801104068756, -1.0332629680633545, 0.2558952271938324, -0.12409985810518265, 0.662178099155426, 0.2680647671222687, -0.11253025382757187, 0.015702465549111366, 0.04168834537267685, -1.1072900295257568, 0.3608376681804657, 0.25699707865715027, 0.40401872992515564, 0.34454500675201416, -0.3343049883842468, -0.22275671362876892, -0.27398425340652466, -1.0011311769485474, -0.09636618196964264, -0.31793591380119324, 0.41924232244491577, -0.7544711828231812, 0.37585869431495667, 0.6251957416534424, 0.4191889762878418, -0.32262709736824036, 0.5311147570610046, -0.277644544839859, 0.3441273868083954, -0.15360800921916962, 0.06316246092319489, -0.058549556881189346, -0.5454397201538086, 0.3605038821697235, -0.4713696241378784, -0.02923687733709812, -0.18429657816886902, 0.10837557166814804, -0.08241024613380432, -0.5348647236824036, -0.1741802990436554, -0.30286580324172974, 0.5064554810523987, -0.11437652260065079, 0.9167940020561218, 0.3994346857070923, -0.27654826641082764, -0.003878343151882291, -0.4048979580402374, -0.7846856713294983, 0.5127105712890625, -0.2517563998699188, -0.5480749011039734, -0.03318515047430992, 0.06462348997592926, -0.5060783624649048, 0.18055066466331482, -0.40740951895713806, 0.15182067453861237, 0.38897058367729187, 1.340427041053772, 0.5789795517921448, -0.14325085282325745, 0.37334495782852173, 0.2392534464597702, -0.732410728931427, 0.04743482917547226, -0.37952205538749695, 0.639144241809845, -1.1302247047424316, -0.4843357503414154, -0.34395989775657654, 0.09355202317237854, 0.421304851770401, 0.21432332694530487, 0.2434115707874298, -0.19546322524547577, 0.2900260090827942, 0.16362982988357544, -0.3549743890762329, -0.023696154356002808, -0.6064648628234863, 0.5209863781929016, 0.1949746161699295, 0.00039416170329786837, 0.4306565523147583, -0.2359739989042282, 0.7702825665473938, -0.0385347418487072, 0.06766489893198013, 1.202951431274414, -0.0006365924491547048, -0.2630285322666168, 0.2665540277957916, 0.5020662546157837, 0.5068323016166687, 1.1305807828903198, -0.5007813572883606, 0.5183417201042175, 0.6348663568496704, 0.25296103954315186, 0.6386934518814087, 0.09023980796337128, -0.09323432296514511, 0.05435330793261528, 0.32348790764808655, 0.012211679480969906, 0.44368502497673035, -0.2072603702545166, 0.4104665219783783, 0.5948601961135864, -0.5782939791679382, 0.15585017204284668, 0.5528921484947205, 0.01279658917337656, 0.4095284342765808, -0.14639727771282196, -0.3919646143913269, -0.5422492623329163, -0.16611754894256592, 0.6205023527145386, -0.33568209409713745, -0.9310125112533569, -0.058142513036727905, -0.20143193006515503, 0.5975802540779114, -0.013579386286437511, -0.5280715823173523, 0.21668735146522522, 0.4847705364227295, 0.35421472787857056, -0.35932639241218567, 0.35703375935554504, -0.04799750819802284, 0.6602700352668762, 0.46972593665122986, 0.2787090837955475, 0.48099446296691895, 0.8125433325767517, -0.3667930066585541, -0.8347408175468445, 0.8904260993003845, 0.47301793098449707, -0.7907382845878601, 0.12367840856313705, 0.29074159264564514, 0.08222442865371704, -0.8255744576454163, 0.19954311847686768, 0.1240379735827446, -0.9206666946411133, 0.05834776163101196, -0.5782843232154846, 0.02326112426817417, -0.29086804389953613, 0.36091703176498413, 0.3476713299751282, 0.7002744674682617, 0.628020703792572, 0.3473552167415619, -0.06675373017787933, 0.6432720422744751, 0.7476957440376282, -0.28217387199401855, 0.5175087451934814, -0.4208716154098511, -0.20970478653907776, 1.1036103963851929, -0.20501667261123657, -0.12541869282722473, 0.09028272330760956, -0.7021757364273071, -0.31270721554756165, -0.5604904890060425, 0.17788425087928772, -0.2542370855808258, -0.8832557797431946, 0.40138229727745056, 0.6117185354232788, -0.2767530679702759, 0.41990676522254944, 0.9629825949668884, 0.49487707018852234, -0.4343005120754242, -0.35826000571250916, 0.9616196751594543, -0.8658875823020935, 0.301161527633667, -1.0618311166763306, 0.29138535261154175, 0.06959230452775955, -0.048635102808475494, -0.5810096859931946, -0.2017865777015686, -0.25730273127555847, -0.27472496032714844, -0.018198661506175995, -0.4957042932510376, 0.4072364568710327, 0.9493117332458496, 0.13407857716083527, 0.033946532756090164, -0.6264204978942871, -0.5512161254882812, -0.2713967263698578, 0.5315043330192566, -0.27170416712760925, 0.43527519702911377, 0.5104240775108337, -0.0344492606818676, -0.880687952041626, 0.832150399684906, 0.22616900503635406, -0.7073760032653809, 0.2258501648902893, -0.3070855140686035, 0.04837837815284729, 0.3723627030849457, -0.08776413649320602, 0.06315822899341583, -0.22576123476028442, 0.3713628053665161, 0.5922693014144897, -0.6132606863975525, 0.05249762535095215, -0.33438628911972046, -0.5264270305633545, -0.8525687456130981, -0.21301068365573883, 0.5169764161109924, -0.13160301744937897, 0.31775814294815063, -0.9422693848609924, 4.300060749053955, 0.5995050668716431, 0.6802905201911926, -0.26928359270095825, 0.8465474843978882, 0.789251446723938, -0.12941022217273712, -0.4413747191429138, 0.32895126938819885, -1.2445508241653442, 0.26357710361480713, 0.488229364156723, -0.010121408849954605, -0.06371258944272995, 0.09595651179552078, 0.4406724274158478, -0.20491689443588257, -0.20951639115810394, -0.6510915160179138, -0.534710168838501, -0.7152471542358398, 0.043572816997766495, 0.5557950139045715, -0.5605644583702087, 0.687288761138916, 0.6050941944122314, -0.2051084041595459, -0.3407055139541626, -0.9370498657226562, -0.6563066840171814, 0.1507783830165863, -0.6589539647102356, 0.4261842370033264, -0.18887950479984283, -1.2430856227874756, 0.45712146162986755, 0.3287118077278137, -0.16306979954242706, 0.6748706698417664, -0.23034709692001343, 0.15588636696338654, -0.5133339762687683, 0.4370092451572418, -0.40746355056762695, -0.06820829957723618, 0.7434001564979553, 0.5934144854545593, 0.744365394115448, 0.3872348666191101, -0.6622453331947327, -0.32717159390449524, -0.021272778511047363, 0.5100961923599243, -0.922517716884613, -0.528792679309845, -0.6704093217849731, -0.04004818946123123, 0.0012012207880616188, -0.4162558615207672, -0.22039411962032318, 0.8522207736968994, -0.1011146828532219, -0.23511259257793427, -0.0287936944514513, 0.3369274437427521, 0.3058790862560272, 0.25140902400016785, -0.10037421435117722, 0.35360437631607056, -0.6771553158760071, -0.91985023021698, -0.06785213202238083, -0.25900697708129883, -0.23033736646175385, 0.5056650638580322, 0.07676741480827332, 0.31120777130126953, 0.2753077447414398, -0.17187775671482086, 0.6078680753707886, -0.46696603298187256, -0.11669594794511795, -0.4129481315612793, 0.22744275629520416, -0.47815415263175964, 0.8642139434814453, -0.16403156518936157, -0.010909097269177437, 0.17916789650917053, 0.6887218356132507, 0.21125413477420807, 0.6801628470420837, -0.5379481911659241, -0.1491045504808426, -0.6146053075790405 ]
Jordan-Brans-Dicke Quantum Wormholes and Coleman's Mechanism
We consider the quantum gravity and cosmology of a Jordan-Brans-Dicke theory, predicted by string effective actions. We study its canonical formalism and find that the constraint algebra is that of general relativity, as a consequence of the general covariance of scalar-tensor theories. We also analyze the problem of boundary conditions and propose that they must be imposed in the Jordan frame, in which particles satisfy the strong equivalence principle. Specifically, we discuss both Hartle-Hawking and wormhole boundary conditions in the context of quantum cosmology. We find quantum wormhole solutions for Jordan-Brans-Dicke gravity even in the absence of matter. Wormholes may affect the constants of nature and, in particular, the Brans-Dicke parameter. Following Coleman's mechanism, we find a probability distribution which is strongly peaked at zero cosmological constant and infinite Brans-Dicke parameter. That is, we recover general relativity as the effective low energy theory of gravity.
Luis J. Garay and Juan Garcia-Bellido
gr-qc hep-th
September
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9209015
gr-qc/9210001
[ 0.2328135371208191, -0.0016710200579836965, 0.35624802112579346, -0.260894238948822, 0.34997624158859253, -0.23520977795124054, 0.2805689871311188, 0.011313688941299915, -0.6085084080696106, 1.200144648551941, 0.700468897819519, 0.16448573768138885, -0.2710692584514618, -0.6416188478469849, 0.635197103023529, 0.5037786364555359, -0.5461485981941223, -0.5696892142295837, -0.962941586971283, -0.08577589690685272, 0.06358755379915237, 0.7647340297698975, -0.7888882160186768, -0.6403056383132935, -0.30009153485298157, -0.06294690072536469, 0.5905746221542358, 0.12791688740253448, 0.7836412191390991, 0.8921900987625122, 0.42684268951416016, 0.0928032398223877, 0.36249592900276184, 0.09222713112831116, -0.521632194519043, -0.09267475455999374, 0.553796112537384, -1.268843650817871, 1.1544005870819092, -0.05301852524280548, 0.5302984714508057, 0.16957136988639832, 0.10589519143104553, -0.2771092355251312, -0.9452120661735535, 0.40225139260292053, 0.012201935052871704, -0.07509219646453857, -0.6881386041641235, -0.9654024243354797, -0.4434788227081299, -0.4610218405723572, 0.36761733889579773, -1.2736032009124756, -0.778626024723053, -0.3633822202682495, 0.009499384090304375, 0.10268925875425339, -0.06325466930866241, 0.25004222989082336, 0.5266957879066467, 0.36333000659942627, -0.0942944809794426, -1.0870198011398315, 0.5359379053115845, 1.0479615926742554, -0.23318880796432495, 0.3554578721523285, 0.28527745604515076, -0.49560555815696716, -0.7217509746551514, -0.354574978351593, -0.6180142760276794, 0.14343245327472687, -0.1522250920534134, 0.5424532294273376, -0.3094840347766876, -0.40835630893707275, -0.22115924954414368, -0.6381233334541321, 0.25658923387527466, 0.4222612977027893, -0.5519728064537048, 0.5483995079994202, -0.6285899877548218, -0.4927780330181122, 0.12128495424985886, -0.31383100152015686, 0.967151403427124, -0.4483371376991272, -0.6695156693458557, 0.7879071831703186, 0.012265834957361221, -0.3095221519470215, 0.7238545417785645, 0.5818638801574707, -0.09884302318096161, 0.8216636776924133, 0.14640678465366364, 0.06234104558825493, 0.19123151898384094, 1.1819535493850708, -0.2779741883277893, 0.2514236867427826, -0.47959473729133606, 0.8282604217529297, -0.3927173316478729, 0.24260523915290833, -0.012707210145890713, -0.9940781593322754, 0.8031975626945496, -0.17607833445072174, 1.1882914304733276, 0.710289478302002, 0.3547896146774292, -0.026535505428910255, -0.3251695930957794, 0.5039558410644531, -1.2362403869628906, -0.058224186301231384, -0.07231499999761581, 0.36274099349975586, 0.3120719790458679, 0.29988643527030945, -0.16309791803359985, -0.5214293003082275, -0.18781276047229767, 0.551503598690033, -0.597905158996582, 0.2199905514717102, 0.5590739846229553, -0.7056805491447449, 0.1673436462879181, 0.7287616729736328, -0.7415987253189087, 0.2938823699951172, -0.5000693798065186, 0.21212448179721832, -0.14914238452911377, -0.3528040945529938, 0.6731177568435669, -0.2860078513622284, 0.6056736707687378, 1.1926325559616089, -0.21969136595726013, -0.029906919226050377, 0.3945803940296173, -0.17028920352458954, -0.7370395064353943, 0.2386961728334427, 0.7215296030044556, -0.7110190987586975, -0.624765932559967, 0.1716596484184265, 0.2845759093761444, 0.37441009283065796, -0.829620897769928, -0.15621639788150787, -0.27965447306632996, -0.005484404973685741, 0.5485045909881592, -0.8646730780601501, 0.5491275191307068, 1.1893211603164673, 0.09264542907476425, 0.524167537689209, -0.6620081067085266, 0.03519933670759201, 0.24933777749538422, 0.2051103711128235, -0.14182013273239136, -0.0835413858294487, 0.5117157697677612, 0.5443792343139648, 1.0865198373794556, 0.38829973340034485, -0.08344676345586777, -0.24846099317073822, -0.3166418969631195, 1.1271687746047974, -0.13046908378601074, -1.0109236240386963, 0.8755260705947876, 0.5179161429405212, -0.8817816376686096, -0.6948440074920654, -0.12576986849308014, -0.3326764404773712, 0.475610613822937, -0.2771680951118469, -0.6596123576164246, 0.5588529109954834, -1.442232370376587, 0.6877868175506592, -0.37112584710121155, 0.252736359834671, -0.6997198462486267, 0.012772662565112114, -0.19006085395812988, -0.3465636670589447, -0.2486051619052887, 0.5780150890350342, -0.7904396057128906, 0.515656590461731, -0.8909713625907898, -0.046740490943193436, 0.30958810448646545, 0.4637376070022583, -0.38907989859580994, 0.38628703355789185, 0.4245590567588806, -0.1434374898672104, 0.005919125396758318, -0.0455576553940773, 0.6656972169876099, 0.6782447695732117, 0.04803302884101868, 0.3006812036037445, 0.0566440187394619, 0.8139763474464417, 0.5431546568870544, 0.33847907185554504, -0.02112223394215107, 1.4395101070404053, -0.068740114569664, -0.3492230772972107, -0.33741605281829834, 0.7938835620880127, 0.09078295528888702, 1.2854094505310059, 0.1159137710928917, -0.4564554989337921, -0.26216423511505127, 0.19865624606609344, 0.9637656807899475, -0.18690314888954163, 1.1034648418426514, 0.6942784786224365, 0.06558739393949509, 0.3823605179786682, 0.45973050594329834, 0.3310936391353607, 0.6950663924217224, 0.5765431523323059, -0.6532996892929077, 0.03084554709494114, 0.5744828581809998, -0.07652416080236435, -0.41348811984062195, 0.6610842347145081, -0.6564051508903503, 0.49456363916397095, -0.10078395903110504, -0.5845969915390015, -1.444678544998169, -0.056953299790620804, -0.40831348299980164, 0.5396566987037659, -0.24984478950500488, -0.25064748525619507, -0.46474596858024597, -0.31432461738586426, 0.38306835293769836, -0.4909614324569702, -0.5055094361305237, -0.2822467088699341, 0.06786753237247467, 0.13134317100048065, 0.1645076423883438, -0.4872630536556244, -1.2460802793502808, -0.5067608952522278, -1.2035605907440186, 0.025926094502210617, -0.6487469673156738, -0.3426000475883484, 0.3717557191848755, -0.05325646325945854, 0.3649820387363434, 0.2058631032705307, 0.07745350152254105, -0.13418027758598328, -0.27576518058776855, 0.07535038888454437, -0.17269004881381989, -0.21398617327213287, -0.7221036553382874, 0.1403815597295761, -1.3212212324142456, 0.07990167289972305, -0.03547684848308563, -0.9306464195251465, 0.972601056098938, -0.5384163856506348, -0.06846784055233002, 0.11703398078680038, -0.9481824636459351, 0.1543792337179184, -0.7761301398277283, -0.6142674684524536, -0.27886953949928284, 0.3024936020374298, -0.36883068084716797, 0.01722571812570095, -0.6785948872566223, 0.7848084568977356, -0.07133657485246658, -0.5922905206680298, 0.31183990836143494, 0.09946533292531967, -0.5958812832832336, 0.2039865404367447, 0.6823946833610535, 0.31758564710617065, -0.06567436456680298, 0.6258808374404907, 0.6380718350410461, 0.20148631930351257, -0.033309243619441986, -0.15230023860931396, -0.13533248007297516, 0.249618262052536, 0.7506763339042664, -1.068274974822998, -0.13879084587097168, 1.1937618255615234, -0.06833893060684204, -0.9829743504524231, 0.02547825314104557, -0.8495449423789978, -0.7487557530403137, 0.13297975063323975, -1.007201910018921, -0.01943073235452175, 0.16667000949382782, 0.5816436409950256, 0.36130064725875854, -0.25713974237442017, 0.36712080240249634, 0.036722421646118164, 0.42849111557006836, -0.2942812442779541, 0.24390839040279388, -0.08538266271352768, 0.6516411304473877, 0.4475038945674896, 0.05973874405026436, -0.16069349646568298, 0.022809375077486038, -0.01269226148724556, 0.03640596941113472, 0.11677070707082748, -0.38488858938217163, -0.12706132233142853, 0.04514750465750694, -0.19820812344551086, -0.4885244369506836, 0.26549360156059265, -0.7834036946296692, 0.16310715675354004, 0.38283297419548035, 0.11347828805446625, 0.21307210624217987, -0.4857962429523468, -0.6112370491027832, 0.13977202773094177, -0.3235113322734833, 0.36430656909942627, 0.7336358428001404, -0.7244740724563599, 0.5117620825767517, 0.4037167727947235, -0.20324338972568512, 0.4530046880245209, -0.21033047139644623, 0.06018286198377609, 1.0190593004226685, 0.01528083998709917, 0.17674119770526886, -0.3626004755496979, -0.14617562294006348, -0.48240727186203003, 0.3606097102165222, 0.32520633935928345, 0.5437521934509277, -0.5033624172210693, 0.2827487289905548, -0.2587915360927582, -0.30320489406585693, -0.2516216039657593, -0.496855229139328, -0.7344675660133362, -0.03830825909972191, -0.33447811007499695, -0.6080931425094604, 0.23712356388568878, 0.46182647347450256, 0.3935474157333374, 0.5889133214950562, -0.06541554629802704, -0.1336163878440857, 1.0390625, 0.02021511271595955, 0.9112119674682617, -0.8021528720855713, -0.7449421286582947, -0.8565381765365601, 0.6774499416351318, 0.6701796650886536, -0.003197240410372615, -0.17862743139266968, -0.005172407254576683, 0.32979917526245117, -0.04500636085867882, 1.036836862564087, 0.6422465443611145, -1.0379173755645752, 0.37608495354652405, -0.2415803223848343, 0.04884999990463257, -0.07262993603944778, 0.0049018580466508865, 0.7220876812934875, 0.36892884969711304, 0.49968358874320984, -0.20689740777015686, -0.3106222152709961, -0.9925817847251892, 0.8744841814041138, 0.4528706669807434, -0.789454460144043, -0.7146798968315125, -0.19662877917289734, -0.04311102256178856, 0.025106392800807953, 0.32292142510414124, 0.5369089841842651, 0.7168813347816467, 0.3039795160293579, -0.5842108130455017, -0.046882059425115585, 0.8370150923728943, -0.7265263795852661, 0.06668680906295776, -0.7071162462234497, 0.06936109811067581, -0.13724812865257263, 0.79750657081604, 0.037763018161058426, -0.7340802550315857, -0.1467047780752182, -0.263514906167984, 0.10649923980236053, -0.0005892221233807504, -1.0462617874145508, -0.22803683578968048, 0.32518357038497925, 0.007156075909733772, 0.6977095007896423, -0.4233696460723877, 0.1117108091711998, -0.3219503164291382, 0.04864361137151718, -0.5986442565917969, -0.3782079219818115, 0.3039357662200928, 0.05767151713371277, 0.48273366689682007, 0.32490962743759155, 0.3205527365207672, 0.8248125314712524, -0.17114682495594025, -0.09175141155719757, 0.08927106857299805, 0.3858565092086792, -0.5655816793441772, -0.5541451573371887, -0.02651451714336872, -0.628841757774353, -0.4934978187084198, -0.4083796739578247, -0.009990893304347992, -0.3876914381980896, 0.3060356080532074, -0.40722689032554626, -0.5592241883277893, -0.886277437210083, -0.6426736116409302, -0.3683679401874542, 0.5028529167175293, -0.25278523564338684, 0.07647146284580231, 0.039210934191942215, -0.18626318871974945, -0.08936427533626556, -0.06150626763701439, -0.3982730507850647, -0.06550362706184387, -0.2919054925441742, 0.2582835853099823, -0.0960104763507843, 0.8074778318405151, 0.1649945229291916, -0.007530164904892445, -0.45556944608688354, -0.32142820954322815, -0.6018893122673035, -0.3246065378189087, 0.004150371998548508, 0.37489253282546997, 0.2835679352283478, -0.5503823757171631, 0.06023236736655235, 0.6916473507881165, -0.24120259284973145, 0.5016328692436218, 0.25323644280433655, -0.06969033181667328, -0.08014966547489166, 0.740278422832489, 0.5254740715026855, -0.3207407295703888, 0.21144619584083557, 0.44786179065704346, -0.054096855223178864, 0.33268362283706665, 0.28566938638687134, 0.14064857363700867, 0.4524657726287842, -1.4771668910980225, 0.6562187671661377, -1.195379376411438, -0.6200292706489563, -0.5895722508430481, -0.23301908373832703, 0.7206674814224243, 0.3977785110473633, 0.24702411890029907, -0.4475615620613098, -0.3932533264160156, -0.6915369033813477, 0.4208659529685974, -0.18643340468406677, -0.1151733249425888, -1.198387622833252, -0.33105629682540894, -0.5297829508781433, 0.9890912175178528, -0.5513632893562317, 0.07141038030385971, 0.5101984143257141, -0.08460947871208191, -0.23309972882270813, 0.5905436873435974, 0.20892667770385742, 0.031234731897711754, -0.6266377568244934, 0.5829586386680603, 0.08326078951358795, 0.6997448801994324, 0.22853650152683258, 0.484747976064682, -0.564070999622345, 1.1676032543182373, -0.09661383181810379, -0.04822273179888725, 0.5548437237739563, -0.37382280826568604, 0.011045573279261589, -0.3396325707435608, -0.36703744530677795, 0.0660192221403122, 0.25662171840667725, 0.019836412742733955, -0.3937733471393585, -1.1586894989013672, -0.38943442702293396, -0.3120574951171875, -0.30189263820648193, 0.40736255049705505, -0.34558847546577454, -0.11290331929922104, -1.4556806087493896, -0.5113709568977356, -0.019007159397006035, 0.04978083446621895, 0.3469412624835968, 0.1260785013437271, 0.8210427761077881, 0.5207184553146362, -0.2796027958393097, 0.17432333528995514, -0.49031126499176025, 0.13564057648181915, -0.1056583896279335, -0.29594680666923523, -0.16031230986118317, 0.03748980909585953, -0.5252594351768494, -0.6329555511474609, -0.1741108000278473, 0.5452994704246521, -0.08241913467645645, -0.49459975957870483, 0.630409836769104, 0.005296371411532164, -0.2151162475347519, -0.019525084644556046, 0.300751656293869, -0.22114333510398865, -0.1654447615146637, 0.41405463218688965, 0.3398633897304535, 0.15982477366924286, 0.3254193663597107, 0.19237756729125977, -0.7805636525154114, -0.5990127921104431, 0.6379625797271729, -0.5256569385528564, 0.025039151310920715, 0.46672841906547546, -0.34886229038238525, -0.19464433193206787, -0.9180231094360352, -0.7814522981643677, -0.5261471271514893, 0.3149164319038391, -0.6177213191986084, 0.6369084715843201, 0.2900967597961426, -0.332833468914032, 0.36210572719573975, 0.28224995732307434, 0.5410080552101135, 0.7176111340522766, 0.5404837727546692, -0.21640154719352722, -0.09312955290079117, -0.026839526370167732, 0.5338199138641357, 0.33379513025283813, -1.1169511079788208, 0.44092807173728943, 0.048437077552080154, -0.5395526885986328, -0.21780997514724731, 0.5794875025749207, -0.3621927499771118, -0.1093604564666748, 0.2864331603050232, 0.4061959385871887, 0.23682309687137604, 0.022697389125823975, 0.08096791058778763, -0.15283890068531036, -0.7110873460769653, -0.4773302972316742, 0.09132321923971176, 0.2559053897857666, 0.1394123136997223, 0.17750409245491028, -0.19792112708091736, 0.0021423909347504377, 0.2194386124610901, 0.7815183401107788, -0.02070784941315651, -1.0484645366668701, -0.6501040458679199, -1.2975472211837769, -0.6518418192863464, -1.2279901504516602, -0.048989299684762955, 0.5078356266021729, 0.6062613129615784, -0.5897420048713684, 0.5386791825294495, -0.03687213733792305, 0.5445860624313354, 0.303697407245636, 1.136906385421753, -0.5810713768005371, -0.44506359100341797, -0.08185383677482605, 0.3457203507423401, 0.36228349804878235, -0.8162089586257935, -0.5625184178352356, -0.6403584480285645, 0.47419050335884094, 0.7324963808059692, -0.3118647038936615, 0.05993180349469185, -0.5087273716926575, -0.9009177088737488, 0.44236159324645996, -0.6316515207290649, -0.7289620637893677, 1.3428115844726562, -0.6180248856544495, 0.9301947951316833, -0.29945772886276245, 0.2228819727897644, -0.07252506166696548, 0.12138920277357101, 0.10263044387102127, 0.49546870589256287, 0.33546093106269836, 0.40688595175743103, 0.21297003328800201, -0.7379943132400513, -0.22914032638072968, 0.02345864474773407, -0.3527560830116272, 0.2409435212612152, 0.3051544427871704, 0.6509472131729126, -0.7627907991409302, -0.32903364300727844, 0.07525038719177246, 0.18242336809635162, -0.1948333978652954, -0.11104004830121994, -0.7376722097396851, -0.16861703991889954, -0.5469144582748413, 0.2139727920293808, -0.39559420943260193, -0.25046393275260925, 0.4935828745365143, 0.040229905396699905, 0.16988001763820648, 0.20099259912967682, -0.5932124257087708, 0.34799623489379883, 0.3259613811969757, -0.549451470375061, 0.014420617371797562, 0.23284196853637695, -0.12641078233718872, 0.8718022704124451, 0.2566305994987488, 0.23440471291542053, 0.6979284286499023, -0.4856897294521332, -1.2849020957946777, 0.4562246799468994, -0.5135533213615417, -0.7099670171737671, 0.5072158575057983, -0.17241409420967102, 0.42559611797332764, 0.7244117259979248, -1.1513153314590454, 0.27692484855651855, 0.2506687045097351, 0.6574602723121643, 0.9225192666053772, -0.10238079726696014, -0.008311170153319836, -0.16037411987781525, -1.1065630912780762, -0.4805566370487213, -0.33462077379226685, -0.1319013088941574, -0.7216113805770874, -1.0786631107330322, -0.19846756756305695, -0.3358839750289917, -0.41456088423728943, -0.3327065110206604, 0.06989680975675583, -0.42433246970176697, -0.20159921050071716, -0.10428529232740402, -0.0992603525519371, -0.30221566557884216, -0.9318169951438904, 0.44652625918388367, -0.18490341305732727, -0.17406406998634338, -0.26616474986076355, 0.30655404925346375, -0.06395647674798965, 0.6056005954742432, 0.2695351541042328, 1.132350206375122, 0.28308701515197754, -0.47975561022758484, 0.5375902056694031, 0.4626144766807556, 0.5577637553215027, 0.8806407451629639, -0.4846949875354767, 0.6134878396987915, 0.6579299569129944, 0.2659369111061096, 0.6613693833351135, 0.4772360324859619, -0.1483498364686966, 0.2644047439098358, 0.755354642868042, 0.1862494796514511, -0.24071064591407776, -0.3896356225013733, 0.19023612141609192, 0.15571345388889313, -0.18588894605636597, -0.3026025593280792, 0.3502799868583679, 0.786788821220398, 0.30699872970581055, -0.3218560218811035, -0.6464110612869263, -0.6430794596672058, 0.7921183109283447, 0.32355859875679016, -0.3000487685203552, -0.2908416986465454, -0.5113437175750732, 0.42761704325675964, 0.04310768097639084, -0.0006260446971282363, -0.30712890625, 0.2015257626771927, 0.8237752914428711, 0.0567396804690361, -0.43600523471832275, 0.689791202545166, 0.4691672623157501, 0.3420180678367615, 0.9081470966339111, 0.5499951243400574, 0.8473647236824036, 0.36358463764190674, -0.04150009527802467, -0.2860546410083771, -0.48316100239753723, -0.044054217636585236, -0.6598206162452698, 0.6570751667022705, 0.6794736981391907, -0.7036083340644836, -0.6752740144729614, -1.0067986249923706, 0.6338057518005371, -0.17713457345962524, 0.6696143746376038, -0.21533341705799103, -0.27430275082588196, -0.33948421478271484, 0.8274403214454651, 0.11966469883918762, 0.47683122754096985, 1.0418720245361328, -0.04829581454396248, 0.6088165640830994, 0.8836682438850403, 0.5397505164146423, 0.45806628465652466, -0.030119847506284714, -0.37905585765838623, -0.44354814291000366, 0.6327823996543884, -0.2543821632862091, -0.2750563323497772, 0.10139025002717972, -0.5276560187339783, -0.33509308099746704, -0.3517645001411438, 0.3032984435558319, -0.4242156445980072, -0.025498749688267708, 0.36597204208374023, 1.0678783655166626, -0.7729882001876831, -0.2812740206718445, 0.8818172216415405, 0.2211155891418457, -0.06337495893239975, -0.9642722606658936, 0.715660810470581, -1.5836987495422363, -0.13433243334293365, -1.2120342254638672, 0.5055478811264038, 0.89914470911026, 0.10657933354377747, -0.6444298028945923, -0.4567471742630005, -0.01577586866915226, -0.08941888064146042, -0.10797855257987976, -0.5417073369026184, 0.25718244910240173, 0.8391286730766296, -0.8004838824272156, 0.1577470451593399, -0.671808123588562, -0.4120974838733673, -0.6241824626922607, 0.6551747918128967, -0.2843236029148102, 0.25358572602272034, 0.9780058860778809, 0.1230744794011116, -1.3689472675323486, 0.7527382969856262, 0.7923479080200195, -0.4358689785003662, 0.9670149087905884, -0.1781909167766571, 0.6384302973747253, 0.1788332760334015, -0.16273966431617737, 0.1447037160396576, 0.16415077447891235, 0.5112057328224182, 0.26769277453422546, -0.4167095124721527, 0.1529316008090973, -0.5255312919616699, -0.432129830121994, -0.7767620086669922, 0.013448326848447323, 0.24144934117794037, 0.1433907002210617, 0.01498534344136715, -0.8899785876274109, 4.036136627197266, 0.669033408164978, 0.33032914996147156, 0.3672981560230255, 0.8431474566459656, 1.4369723796844482, -0.47749391198158264, 0.43283534049987793, 0.23813368380069733, -0.8353568315505981, -0.048605892807245255, 0.2688073217868805, 0.09369217604398727, -0.20400309562683105, -0.03894612938165665, 0.590556263923645, -0.02878022938966751, -0.16336296498775482, -0.29542598128318787, 0.15123416483402252, -0.5390769839286804, 0.33086585998535156, 0.8668705224990845, 0.0847729817032814, 0.27819105982780457, 0.9963567852973938, 0.028690217062830925, -1.0976834297180176, -0.3267401456832886, -0.5729892253875732, -0.22582200169563293, -1.298649549484253, -0.2640119791030884, -0.6213047504425049, -1.2596889734268188, 0.5599137544631958, -0.3139719069004059, -0.44507503509521484, 0.3329143524169922, -0.04328422248363495, -0.46413013339042664, -0.19134218990802765, -0.08567409962415695, -0.3941413164138794, 0.28409963846206665, 0.9273178577423096, 0.32219770550727844, 0.8068409562110901, 0.5670372843742371, -0.9839578866958618, 0.13343514502048492, -0.3404150903224945, 0.2913905680179596, -0.6310165524482727, -0.18948706984519958, -0.39115336537361145, -0.13338954746723175, 0.08571923524141312, 0.8579532504081726, -0.17858511209487915, 0.14000390470027924, -0.4181370437145233, -0.07536432147026062, -0.005226170644164085, -0.04777448624372482, -0.5572572946548462, 0.2316960245370865, -0.2828080654144287, 0.0982954278588295, -0.6139891743659973, -0.5440698266029358, -0.30610767006874084, -0.28030845522880554, -0.17609788477420807, -0.32967907190322876, 0.549235999584198, -0.09128430485725403, 0.5700539946556091, -0.4721912443637848, 0.14014248549938202, -1.2342978715896606, 0.033346857875585556, 0.31770002841949463, 0.271396279335022, -0.009397072717547417, 0.48589715361595154, 0.016317449510097504, 0.14277170598506927, -0.8519883155822754, 0.46940433979034424, 0.2055073380470276, 0.5072988271713257, 0.22300662100315094, 0.552118182182312, -0.9988833069801331 ]
Clifford Algebra of Two-Forms, Conformal Structures and Field Equations
I review the equivalence between duality operators on two-forms and conformal structures in four dimensions, from a Clifford algebra point of view (due to Urbantke and Harnett). I also review an application, which leads to a set of "neighbours" of Einstein's equations. An attempt to formulate reality conditions for the "neighbours" is discussed.
Ingemar Bengtsson
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210001
gr-qc/9210002
[ -0.1602148860692978, 0.6234813928604126, 0.8468195796012878, -0.15809524059295654, -0.7226602435112, 0.48078489303588867, -0.46723413467407227, 0.1920251101255417, -0.19408608973026276, 0.28074711561203003, 0.4101959466934204, 0.02233533002436161, -0.2192167192697525, -0.1577511429786682, -0.6174424290657043, 0.9328975081443787, -0.04077396169304848, -0.954719066619873, -1.3145025968551636, -0.1590011864900589, -0.36005887389183044, -0.018890447914600372, -1.3274387121200562, -0.44417640566825867, -0.2162889540195465, -0.15933126211166382, 1.337182641029358, 0.7333732843399048, 1.5169626474380493, 0.5190308690071106, 0.9665375351905823, -0.5688062310218811, 0.2686022222042084, -0.4796390235424042, 0.19005464017391205, 0.29492461681365967, 0.2399478554725647, -0.16703760623931885, 0.5601137280464172, -1.179162859916687, 1.2639226913452148, 0.07429393380880356, 0.19343408942222595, -0.01766275241971016, 0.08953248709440231, 0.18233972787857056, -0.1453893929719925, -0.566465437412262, -0.4246022701263428, -0.6459081768989563, 0.35668864846229553, -0.1435483694076538, 0.01896825060248375, -0.7099356651306152, -0.026588093489408493, 0.20269669592380524, 0.20028680562973022, 0.05422084033489227, -0.186489075422287, 0.057973556220531464, 0.04674108326435089, -0.14260393381118774, 0.5140248537063599, -0.26982736587524414, -0.31419694423675537, 0.6435931921005249, 0.23061808943748474, -0.07644744217395782, 0.4846733808517456, -0.8012274503707886, -0.040097884833812714, 0.5588257312774658, 0.44700363278388977, 0.4177408516407013, -0.46293291449546814, 0.6294344067573547, -0.6487493515014648, 0.3144434094429016, -0.3202499449253082, 0.1603471040725708, 0.5086844563484192, 0.23722364008426666, -0.14396272599697113, 0.39166614413261414, 0.18716807663440704, -0.07809633761644363, 0.44053640961647034, 0.30934008955955505, 0.2985154688358307, -0.3343808054924011, -0.14999385178089142, 0.9872040748596191, -0.08357545733451843, 0.6464520692825317, 0.24249695241451263, 0.24901141226291656, -0.5177513360977173, 0.7778187394142151, 0.1446274369955063, -0.1066104918718338, 0.6908866763114929, 0.9056817889213562, -1.1276566982269287, 0.3132016658782959, -0.07898173481225967, 1.2797116041183472, 0.5665512084960938, 0.7069422006607056, 0.534475564956665, -0.5090638399124146, 0.9069482088088989, 0.410057932138443, 0.26282209157943726, 0.2504194974899292, 0.5445189476013184, 0.2036462277173996, -1.2851921319961548, -0.5104950666427612, -0.8018943667411804, 0.06344548612833023, 0.23449106514453888, 0.8158359527587891, 0.5939337015151978, 0.6314650774002075, -0.0445045605301857, -0.14737027883529663, -0.13392314314842224, 0.09370670467615128, -1.0008801221847534, -0.7649341821670532, -0.41545552015304565, -0.30209726095199585, 0.2434903234243393, 0.9566445350646973, 0.202813982963562, -0.053923599421978, -0.04798203706741333, -0.018397586420178413, 0.44093042612075806, -1.3498351573944092, -0.1115712970495224, -0.28603628277778625, -0.7263972759246826, 1.3307888507843018, -0.49656176567077637, 0.8365766406059265, -0.3787555694580078, 0.42972591519355774, -0.507611870765686, 0.7855563163757324, -0.6558661460876465, -0.3792594373226166, -0.6896559000015259, 0.9832101464271545, 0.14306804537773132, -0.27308008074760437, -0.25555187463760376, -0.47841721773147583, 0.4022713899612427, -0.6933735609054565, 0.14809966087341309, -0.6000155806541443, 1.0742441415786743, 0.24421297013759613, 0.5026196241378784, -0.03562365099787712, -0.2984594404697418, -0.8459236025810242, 0.4073590040206909, 0.06100655719637871, 0.6560012102127075, 0.0005025684949941933, 0.06804456561803818, 0.03791787475347519, 1.0615837574005127, 0.735207200050354, 0.6428865194320679, -0.8147093057632446, -0.08416029810905457, 0.3732323944568634, 0.12316346168518066, -0.16046421229839325, 0.7014256715774536, 0.4927625060081482, -0.9671326279640198, -0.4878403842449188, 0.096378393471241, 0.514619767665863, 0.04649030789732933, -0.6324423551559448, 0.21106182038784027, 0.454363077878952, -0.052600063383579254, 0.13704578578472137, -0.15800434350967407, -0.20906347036361694, -0.05758582428097725, 0.08126746118068695, -0.3791502118110657, -0.6855277419090271, 0.21377535164356232, 0.6906006932258606, -0.4990517199039459, -0.3752804398536682, -0.7851406335830688, -0.35702449083328247, 1.207948088645935, 1.0953909158706665, -0.07909134030342102, 0.6235503554344177, 0.8260223865509033, 0.08312901854515076, 0.837907075881958, 0.772146999835968, 0.18712511658668518, 0.9477086067199707, -0.7740588188171387, 0.48316699266433716, -0.6024557948112488, 0.09182385355234146, 0.7564772963523865, -0.07811591774225235, -0.524161696434021, 0.29459062218666077, 0.41421645879745483, 0.009593239985406399, 0.11606773734092712, 1.3523049354553223, -0.33838027715682983, 0.5079195499420166, 0.04617217928171158, 0.3031635880470276, -0.14805258810520172, 0.4586125612258911, 0.38215371966362, -0.1719287931919098, 0.3276260793209076, 0.07828905433416367, -0.018540048971772194, -0.021140312775969505, 0.9671012163162231, -0.3133464753627777, 0.39557674527168274, -0.1278010755777359, 0.5081644654273987, 0.5889800786972046, -0.08260013908147812, -0.06037425994873047, 0.08322681486606598, 0.5491044521331787, -0.15992246568202972, 0.44422996044158936, -0.22280116379261017, -0.052365221083164215, -1.199029803276062, -0.21979781985282898, 0.31816959381103516, -0.2717225253582001, -0.28413912653923035, -0.33857986330986023, -0.25534334778785706, -0.038527775555849075, 0.0858146920800209, -0.2489381730556488, -0.023045189678668976, 1.1224524974822998, -0.04433165490627289, 0.4996975362300873, -0.1723904311656952, -0.46372267603874207, -1.036319375038147, -0.6965250372886658, -1.0966012477874756, -0.5616324543952942, -0.030986730009317398, 0.12044578045606613, 0.33981841802597046, -0.6922804117202759, 0.0439700186252594, -0.3015352189540863, -0.6174595952033997, 0.34312358498573303, -0.27072227001190186, 0.4658619463443756, -0.21178044378757477, 0.515885591506958, -0.6606962084770203, 0.3836175203323364, -0.6072136163711548, -0.126248300075531, 0.2161768525838852, -0.4655715823173523, 0.19666585326194763, -0.6242240071296692, 0.6942688822746277, 0.3869117498397827, -0.1785249561071396, -0.5078707933425903, 0.2824370861053467, -0.9187914133071899, 0.2453409731388092, -0.5894904136657715, 0.08524470776319504, 0.5717909336090088, 0.05557012930512428, -0.11900785565376282, -0.2123904526233673, -0.6770434379577637, 0.004042450804263353, 0.012619338929653168, -0.3243198096752167, 0.5087747573852539, -0.3441535532474518, -0.01002034917473793, -0.4227369427680969, 0.35711315274238586, 0.0469479076564312, -0.4677256643772125, 0.18692824244499207, -0.8323715329170227, -0.23031310737133026, -0.4741511940956116, -0.7355813384056091, -0.45621562004089355, 0.03907834365963936, 0.7881482243537903, 0.20321087539196014, -0.08851120620965958, 0.7411176562309265, -0.9177439212799072, -0.7575128078460693, -0.23173405230045319, -0.4244333803653717, 0.6400080323219299, -0.7050313353538513, -0.35598117113113403, -0.0821007490158081, -0.28668275475502014, 0.22126027941703796, -0.3999238908290863, 0.3587905764579773, -0.5100478529930115, 0.03520864620804787, -0.12286010384559631, -0.849554717540741, -0.25336262583732605, 0.413526713848114, -0.14851176738739014, 0.13041619956493378, 0.6494868397712708, -0.5974578261375427, 0.3493642807006836, 0.5294941067695618, 0.22560051083564758, -0.1451217383146286, 0.8642311692237854, 0.5120505094528198, -0.0013750778743997216, 0.10955765098333359, -0.5421791672706604, -0.055112674832344055, -0.09625381231307983, 0.08650143444538116, -0.8358498215675354, -0.6773760318756104, 0.043960295617580414, 0.0575728639960289, -0.13481131196022034, 0.3230251371860504, -0.014699102379381657, 0.40863925218582153, 0.6516067981719971, -0.05218716710805893, -0.5971723794937134, 0.123353011906147, 0.15823543071746826, 0.608130156993866, 0.6082605719566345, 1.0593241453170776, -0.6484671831130981, -0.17330816388130188, 0.271664023399353, -0.40581968426704407, 0.3342011570930481, 0.6070321202278137, 0.1069890707731247, 0.6211949586868286, 0.10500510782003403, -0.478928804397583, -0.7850844860076904, 0.04890550300478935, -0.10355190187692642, -0.1513626128435135, -0.20148354768753052, -1.109553575515747, -0.31038162112236023, 0.8817285299301147, 0.8323363065719604, -0.022647256031632423, -0.11448114365339279, -0.16957104206085205, -0.8419017791748047, -0.12381234019994736, 0.5135213136672974, -0.1768077313899994, -0.054525744169950485, -0.38684654235839844, 0.8857505321502686, 0.4306304454803467, -0.17997343838214874, -0.030864806845784187, -0.5624945163726807, -0.05355909466743469, -0.34961119294166565, 0.8182785511016846, 0.051755741238594055, 0.2858923375606537, 0.20671391487121582, 0.012270556762814522, 0.19022373855113983, 0.9363774657249451, 0.1737416833639145, -0.007523961830884218, 1.2243187427520752, 0.49961456656455994, -0.4502280056476593, -0.2682874798774719, -0.7434983849525452, 0.45983800292015076, 0.3916253447532654, -0.4657246172428131, -0.360178679227829, -0.022908786311745644, 0.1769481897354126, -0.5894549489021301, -0.17639778554439545, 1.1854186058044434, 0.4924550950527191, 0.5007292032241821, -0.634858250617981, 0.6204898357391357, 1.0337952375411987, -0.14199893176555634, 0.03543495014309883, 0.5242321491241455, 0.5695632100105286, 0.2095496654510498, 0.49096962809562683, 0.11738476157188416, -0.5802802443504333, -0.4815196990966797, -0.27894845604896545, 0.8668849468231201, -0.998937726020813, -0.08902641385793686, 0.35504764318466187, 0.04659310355782509, -0.8729527592658997, 0.7407397627830505, -0.5231829881668091, 0.06168060749769211, -0.4847990870475769, 0.1567750722169876, -0.5896481275558472, -0.5171250700950623, 0.15806587040424347, -0.5920858979225159, 0.5671699047088623, 0.31267985701560974, 0.07049913704395294, 0.34079623222351074, -0.061226800084114075, 0.6369287371635437, 0.09804167598485947, 0.41721832752227783, 0.41685307025909424, 0.42025113105773926, -0.7708628177642822, 0.04411863163113594, 0.11452510207891464, -0.2347082495689392, 0.3220028877258301, 0.0066040572710335255, -0.6312441229820251, 0.22595657408237457, -0.8352490663528442, 0.03389967605471611, -0.06661847978830338, -1.1317843198776245, 0.6139479279518127, -0.7259098887443542, -0.017392264679074287, -0.18376129865646362, -0.21501772105693817, -0.06236158311367035, -0.5555171370506287, -0.29909971356391907, -0.802739679813385, 0.635357141494751, 0.5609422922134399, -0.4688187837600708, -0.08054229617118835, -0.12561506032943726, 0.47364988923072815, 0.32502683997154236, -0.5855990052223206, -0.12093283236026764, -0.4607543349266052, -0.49362418055534363, -0.36470678448677063, -0.20153433084487915, 0.23607167601585388, -0.3137827217578888, 0.23649480938911438, -0.06405849009752274, 0.8398053646087646, 0.8684483170509338, 0.08689384162425995, 0.09040515124797821, 0.1952868402004242, 1.0354844331741333, -0.8717740774154663, -0.5944736003875732, 0.20466433465480804, 0.4316644072532654, -0.35426098108291626, -0.02103685960173607, -0.41216927766799927, -1.1504768133163452, -1.0433883666992188, -0.4694925546646118, -0.265006959438324, -0.8426293134689331, -0.5673869848251343, -0.3594600260257721, -0.3607119917869568, 0.48840463161468506, 0.12035346031188965, -0.7411351203918457, -0.19981749355793, -1.1328895092010498, 0.409155011177063, 0.19078968465328217, 0.5619203448295593, -0.7098096609115601, -0.2870907187461853, -0.38286855816841125, 1.5044116973876953, -0.9358236193656921, -0.2218220829963684, -0.8854678869247437, -0.08871178328990936, 0.6995793581008911, 1.0828680992126465, -0.23026242852210999, -0.18538673222064972, 0.7622746825218201, -0.2477579116821289, -0.3274917006492615, 0.6391021609306335, -0.22315962612628937, 0.5790762901306152, -0.6698734760284424, 0.0005526504246518016, 0.1990315318107605, -0.04121175408363342, -0.5903777480125427, -0.23030835390090942, 0.2703252136707306, -0.024026604369282722, 0.40659093856811523, 1.0206594467163086, -0.4490807056427002, 0.6236717104911804, 0.2661934792995453, -0.6339159607887268, -0.8611982464790344, -0.12498843669891357, -0.5062032341957092, 0.823009729385376, 0.0454060323536396, 0.00028993128216825426, -0.249609112739563, -0.8455643653869629, 0.0032673280220478773, -0.855513870716095, -0.32567405700683594, 0.8038158416748047, 0.1277909129858017, 0.6384339928627014, -1.1648030281066895, -0.17258889973163605, -0.22271494567394257, 0.08685170859098434, 0.41816002130508423, -0.283801406621933, -0.38957276940345764, 0.3638005554676056, 0.2208072990179062, -1.023046851158142, -0.9673658609390259, 1.1727337837219238, -0.11025996506214142, -0.14492659270763397, 0.4772363603115082, -0.18501132726669312, -0.8958209753036499, -0.21963149309158325, 0.5497625470161438, 0.5571408867835999, -0.46857383847236633, 0.6841930747032166, -0.29864397644996643, 0.35875990986824036, 0.11825014650821686, -0.33522364497184753, -0.3920597732067108, 0.21676993370056152, 0.8481996059417725, -0.9168468713760376, -0.8190380334854126, 0.4486110508441925, 0.5170581936836243, -0.5961782336235046, 0.03772968798875809, 0.30778345465660095, -0.4735654294490814, 0.3561325967311859, 0.055054113268852234, 0.0030263885855674744, 0.31665199995040894, -1.1469477415084839, 0.27879422903060913, 0.7205190062522888, -0.15846170485019684, -0.15534844994544983, 0.07965101301670074, 0.6858189702033997, -0.2666334807872772, 0.9860308766365051, 1.3057974576950073, 0.8230252861976624, -0.5710426568984985, -0.8772501945495605, -0.5158883929252625, -0.4817351996898651, -0.4055024981498718, 0.2528213560581207, -0.32067859172821045, 0.4880748689174652, 0.2735081613063812, 0.5896890759468079, 0.4305640459060669, 0.10185238718986511, -0.17675505578517914, 1.2530975341796875, -0.9050782322883606, -1.0681718587875366, -0.7928475141525269, 0.03516775369644165, -0.1539871096611023, 0.4955252408981323, -0.1519743949174881, -0.11585038155317307, 0.8903870582580566, 0.03155016526579857, 0.0763724148273468, 0.08193324506282806, 0.704290509223938, -0.2930120825767517, -0.658984899520874, -0.5660091042518616, -0.342130571603775, 0.011249210685491562, 0.3395073115825653, -0.4156443774700165, -0.5382314920425415, 1.0069637298583984, 0.10117986053228378, 0.8293282389640808, 0.9382270574569702, -0.13533951342105865, -0.06537880003452301, -0.3431117832660675, -1.1779333353042603, -0.8114081025123596, -0.8107739686965942, 0.13587921857833862, 0.37594074010849, -0.6757003664970398, 0.5403455495834351, -0.17688730359077454, 1.1503393650054932, -0.27673259377479553, -0.15979808568954468, 0.02132413536310196, -0.45759955048561096, -0.3832840621471405, 0.5243874788284302, -0.5905272960662842, 0.6407677531242371, 0.940889298915863, -0.5950260758399963, -0.516301155090332, 0.28283900022506714, -0.7672629356384277, 1.0989683866500854, 0.1863391101360321, 0.941114604473114, 0.3206797242164612, -0.045721545815467834, -0.11791332066059113, 0.2707316279411316, -1.0179567337036133, 0.06235964223742485, 0.09308744966983795, 0.8846619129180908, 0.4318835735321045, -0.4359612762928009, -0.0046682157553732395, 0.5683324933052063, 0.20056888461112976, 0.5730771422386169, -0.3961121737957001, -0.15925785899162292, 0.024475837126374245, 0.3094010651111603, 0.0321061797440052, -0.10630492866039276, 0.2685030400753021, -0.3552435338497162, -0.2404043972492218, 0.5716062188148499, 0.5121310949325562, -0.13476993143558502, 0.2020840346813202, 0.09621642529964447, -0.8483524322509766, 0.48058652877807617, -1.2932653427124023, 0.07042228430509567, 0.157980278134346, 0.48005908727645874, -0.2945455312728882, -1.05128014087677, -0.7809814214706421, 0.240099236369133, -1.292603850364685, -0.839851975440979, 0.17910143733024597, -0.25623130798339844, 0.20819000899791718, 0.6778834462165833, -0.7690915465354919, 0.5709558129310608, 0.5329791903495789, 0.2705226242542267, 0.5651252269744873, 0.4068588316440582, -0.38605278730392456, -0.27422231435775757, -0.4762175679206848, -0.8014267086982727, -0.8684703707695007, -0.44094905257225037, -1.1639471054077148, -1.0248595476150513, -0.44522735476493835, 0.5268781781196594, -0.37176668643951416, -0.2870083153247833, -1.0352150201797485, -0.2116788774728775, 0.26382943987846375, -0.47915729880332947, -0.6727412939071655, 0.7802908420562744, -0.005008205771446228, 0.27760952711105347, -0.3056355118751526, -0.4179868698120117, 0.31670746207237244, 0.34781748056411743, 0.7565499544143677, 0.06782342493534088, 0.006412416696548462, 0.02722158655524254, 0.8980506062507629, -0.06678912043571472, 0.7176282405853271, 0.6444886922836304, -0.03545040264725685, 0.41811662912368774, -0.1084182858467102, 0.5521883368492126, 0.34619855880737305, -0.6492426991462708, 0.11272161453962326, 0.28664547204971313, -0.1073574647307396, -0.3804202675819397, -0.34021857380867004, -0.3353136479854584, 0.23332512378692627, -0.5647745728492737, -0.3901258409023285, 0.4252742826938629, -0.7358710765838623, -0.6263838410377502, 0.067672498524189, -0.30138126015663147, 0.5969501733779907, 0.08283234387636185, 0.01355568878352642, -0.2881932258605957, -0.08368536084890366, 1.155404806137085, -0.5787399411201477, -0.4576605260372162, -0.541741669178009, -0.5339983701705933, 0.6128481030464172, -0.27428966760635376, 0.17068146169185638, -0.3270088732242584, 0.48003020882606506, 0.13237784802913666, 0.06536370515823364, 0.6112363338470459, 0.12545554339885712, 0.5551636815071106, 0.5541551113128662, 0.5602988004684448, 0.1341763138771057, 0.1902969479560852, -0.3896912932395935, -1.4554256200790405, -0.45157310366630554, 0.010567345656454563, -0.4004771411418915, -0.7402499914169312, 0.7529571652412415, -0.3984757959842682, -0.42807531356811523, 0.17251244187355042, 0.2917253077030182, -0.7731103301048279, 0.25954216718673706, 0.6205465793609619, -0.22554567456245422, -0.6450573801994324, 0.25700539350509644, 0.03193196654319763, 0.6833949089050293, 0.17492042481899261, 0.6486209034919739, -0.2651382386684418, 0.6906941533088684, 0.7635527849197388, -0.04679376631975174, -0.5516181588172913, -0.8347395062446594, -0.19961191713809967, -0.05759362876415253, -0.08006601780653, 0.07435343414545059, 1.0143673419952393, -0.44651538133621216, -0.520331621170044, 0.13281485438346863, -0.034137774258852005, -0.48440051078796387, -0.08603907376527786, 0.5825360417366028, 0.3866889774799347, -0.32066628336906433, -0.49282026290893555, -0.5602047443389893, 0.9259003400802612, 0.2732256352901459, -0.36121469736099243, 1.1000434160232544, -1.0726001262664795, -0.4186805784702301, -1.0293254852294922, -0.20656631886959076, -0.22712291777133942, -0.7489699125289917, -0.8676534295082092, -0.2782600522041321, 0.09465043991804123, -0.7715386748313904, -0.024407655000686646, -0.7437257170677185, 0.5232617855072021, 0.3338075876235962, 0.5231164693832397, 0.6120719313621521, -0.3543212413787842, -0.3376443684101105, 0.48438653349876404, 1.0146727561950684, 0.1692240983247757, 0.6182224750518799, 0.3662984371185303, 0.5846433043479919, -0.7162910103797913, -0.5746762752532959, -0.28692713379859924, -1.0416169166564941, 0.7264847159385681, 0.07654713094234467, -0.29924315214157104, -0.3867618143558502, -0.5743670463562012, 0.4487530589103699, 0.6266681551933289, 0.8794502019882202, -0.05796287581324577, -0.12655435502529144, 0.4208315908908844, -1.718375563621521, 0.10199739784002304, -0.9439113736152649, -0.31760743260383606, -0.3050505220890045, -0.16333241760730743, -0.24474197626113892, -0.5056778192520142, 3.839722156524658, 0.5692852735519409, 0.7206706404685974, 0.2892000079154968, 0.3853294551372528, 0.34973469376564026, 0.0016340517904609442, -1.087753415107727, -0.35451868176460266, -0.5752727389335632, 1.061363697052002, -0.2026071846485138, 0.14355458319187164, -0.738399088382721, -0.2323279231786728, 1.0359431505203247, -0.8132574558258057, -0.2130686491727829, 0.7328171133995056, -0.9679480195045471, -0.28397247195243835, 0.5345858335494995, 0.45713070034980774, -0.22028551995754242, -0.29798269271850586, 0.6454021334648132, 1.060349464416504, -0.5332086086273193, -0.5073800683021545, -0.5637617707252502, -0.6622198820114136, -0.9372236728668213, 0.8124422430992126, 0.5902614593505859, -0.23564882576465607, 0.0831531211733818, -0.9915266036987305, -0.051721539348363876, -0.5865572690963745, -0.4866189956665039, -0.349317729473114, -0.03717764839529991, -0.002032669261097908, -0.4087776839733124, 0.5405930280685425, 0.6683118343353271, 0.5663156509399414, 0.5235843062400818, 0.8501344323158264, -1.1307570934295654, 0.26443716883659363, -0.5708391666412354, 0.5872038006782532, -0.28108516335487366, -1.02700674533844, 0.08828968554735184, -0.42370736598968506, -0.11167431622743607, 0.6714178919792175, 0.1381257027387619, 0.14602982997894287, 0.16939394176006317, -0.9556310772895813, 0.5595528483390808, -0.6178058385848999, 0.7022051215171814, -0.19549739360809326, -0.07824459671974182, -0.5186806917190552, -0.3670218586921692, -0.685604453086853, -0.7626827359199524, -0.4573362469673157, 0.5683808922767639, 1.0259422063827515, 0.5226972103118896, 0.02167481556534767, 0.5363895297050476, -0.5152839422225952, 0.24070952832698822, 0.38160428404808044, 0.08159659802913666, -0.16154804825782776, -0.4161537289619446, 0.31892159581184387, 1.6556910276412964, 0.00992156658321619, -0.2320277839899063, -0.7291616201400757, 0.8725383281707764, 0.38988131284713745, 0.19736751914024353, -0.5355565547943115, 0.04402545467019081, -0.4212372899055481 ]
The Nordtvedt effect in the Trojan asteroids
Bounds to the Nordtvedt parameter are obtained from the motion of the first twelve Trojan asteroids in the period 1906-1990. From the analysis performed, we derive a value for the inverse of the Saturn mass 3497.80 \pm 0.81 and the Nordtvedt parameter -0.56 \pm 0.48, from a simultaneous solution for all asteroids.
R.B. Orellana and H. Vucetich
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210002
gr-qc/9210003
[ 0.5382266640663147, 0.16737456619739532, 0.6587881445884705, -0.3487337827682495, -0.07656880468130112, -0.004683998879045248, -0.2516707181930542, 0.011906306259334087, -0.6149886250495911, 1.2795346975326538, 1.2700004577636719, -0.09811069071292877, -0.5719507932662964, -0.517208993434906, -0.7077743411064148, 0.22123922407627106, -0.14392216503620148, -0.16080208122730255, -1.2937262058258057, -0.02070564217865467, -0.010024862363934517, 0.5481666922569275, -1.3751829862594604, -1.1680268049240112, -0.2733929455280304, 0.30167311429977417, 1.142539381980896, 0.1053619533777237, 0.8374572992324829, 0.6433115601539612, 0.8184088468551636, -0.2959350049495697, 0.003669354133307934, -0.6205681562423706, -0.33093515038490295, 0.12982366979122162, 0.3621732294559479, -0.6051118969917297, 0.5896540880203247, -0.17434914410114288, 0.2908247411251068, 0.36062365770339966, 0.49790942668914795, -0.43989041447639465, -0.8161845803260803, -0.41060420870780945, 0.2654106318950653, -0.0792173370718956, -0.16176831722259521, -0.8991256952285767, -0.15115483105182648, 0.12445872277021408, 0.27793407440185547, -0.9511077404022217, -0.04717859998345375, -0.2719059884548187, 0.656924843788147, 0.5222029685974121, -0.48808151483535767, 0.39130932092666626, 0.8876648545265198, 0.5577284097671509, 0.642239511013031, -0.8922653794288635, 0.0792834460735321, 0.9629637002944946, -0.3536490797996521, 0.7322412729263306, 0.4154154658317566, -0.14621838927268982, 0.10884689539670944, -0.5611850023269653, -0.28563806414604187, 0.28678658604621887, -0.045196328312158585, 0.7436389923095703, -0.009684419259428978, -0.09292758256196976, -0.4078168272972107, -0.3575059473514557, -0.06902237981557846, -0.20011469721794128, -0.09146817773580551, 0.4201952815055847, -0.6354058980941772, -0.4433543384075165, 0.08572842180728912, -0.023042693734169006, 0.11526098847389221, -0.06867045164108276, 0.33351466059684753, 0.5963342189788818, 0.22782939672470093, -0.23532001674175262, 0.4571433365345001, 1.3615939617156982, -0.23742666840553284, 0.6454830765724182, 0.12465441226959229, 0.7272606492042542, -0.377358615398407, 0.8738875985145569, -0.505946934223175, 0.7232896685600281, -0.6734448671340942, 1.0576225519180298, -0.4052675664424896, 0.10951584577560425, -0.36923477053642273, -0.862131655216217, 0.17060676217079163, -0.028968805447220802, 0.6160933375358582, 0.4546155333518982, -0.03716824948787689, 0.46286115050315857, -0.21109488606452942, -0.15602503716945648, -0.8866103887557983, -0.5641732215881348, 0.16958513855934143, 0.3554648160934448, 0.6417652368545532, 0.532820999622345, 0.3066651523113251, -0.5601581931114197, -0.26384347677230835, 0.25013795495033264, -0.6072880029678345, 0.675304114818573, 0.4390900731086731, -0.7313119769096375, 0.07617637515068054, -0.0006547947414219379, 0.2546229958534241, 0.5458909273147583, -0.2687641382217407, -0.16422954201698303, 0.11262336373329163, -0.5396839380264282, 1.0425748825073242, -0.3619937300682068, -0.21764793992042542, 0.9233801960945129, -0.25988641381263733, 0.29039958119392395, -0.3574964106082916, 0.24101930856704712, -0.17219793796539307, 0.0826156884431839, -0.2131919413805008, 0.41807836294174194, -0.24031199514865875, 0.15493404865264893, 0.28809523582458496, 0.3466606140136719, -0.8291013836860657, 0.09286181628704071, -0.4940873682498932, -0.5285059809684753, 0.16603758931159973, -0.04715357720851898, -0.1687750369310379, 1.0259593725204468, -0.4000929892063141, 0.19431526958942413, -0.48450592160224915, -0.21960845589637756, -0.2905987501144409, -0.1984604001045227, -0.11734005808830261, -0.07979416847229004, -0.34652355313301086, 0.4255303740501404, 1.103429913520813, 1.1930582523345947, 0.6057471632957458, -0.5755040645599365, -0.7408351898193359, 0.1984221339225769, -0.18586620688438416, -0.29933467507362366, 0.6404426693916321, 0.496140718460083, -0.9903382062911987, -0.41684529185295105, -0.03738531470298767, 0.14240875840187073, -0.11611318588256836, -0.015988416969776154, -0.3346650004386902, 0.3415432870388031, -1.4190877676010132, 0.594273567199707, -1.0279972553253174, 0.11470510065555573, -0.701913058757782, 0.09334700554609299, -0.5881643295288086, -0.42931967973709106, -0.16686438024044037, -0.24630632996559143, -0.6651279330253601, 0.04164678230881691, -1.1563032865524292, 0.48524001240730286, 0.07656238228082657, 0.9100157022476196, -0.4250491261482239, 0.11608898639678955, -0.0869482085108757, -0.2897892892360687, 0.5582184195518494, -0.4331885278224945, 0.29797717928886414, -0.19849570095539093, 0.1908186376094818, 0.30691003799438477, 0.1656678467988968, 0.425309956073761, 1.1002087593078613, 0.5184766054153442, -0.23645618557929993, 0.5245277285575867, 0.08708616346120834, -0.4649059474468231, 0.15180164575576782, 1.011595606803894, -0.2788929343223572, -0.13878825306892395, 0.1903299242258072, 0.009341767057776451, 0.486007958650589, 0.20165923237800598, 0.09805601090192795, -0.02279653213918209, 0.6799260973930359, 0.7444016337394714, -0.019511913880705833, 0.25785553455352783, -0.048044417053461075, -0.11496992409229279, 0.7622289061546326, 0.1362091600894928, -0.0350232794880867, 0.22541622817516327, 0.14485381543636322, 0.48973414301872253, -0.3933125138282776, 0.8005728125572205, -0.5728520154953003, 0.61347895860672, -0.022956961765885353, 0.3289554715156555, -1.3796709775924683, 0.03476322069764137, 0.1682501882314682, 0.3587166368961334, -0.45299091935157776, -1.4401637315750122, -0.30988410115242004, 0.2490086853504181, -0.07583920657634735, -0.6107990741729736, -0.7805084586143494, 0.6747305989265442, 0.05251578986644745, 0.06437472999095917, 0.12292101979255676, -0.2775167226791382, -0.8854566812515259, 0.25276345014572144, -0.6612759232521057, -0.15826566517353058, -0.3210468590259552, -0.11131028831005096, -0.006003404036164284, -0.5635952353477478, 0.7031375765800476, -0.2509080767631531, -0.1276402324438095, -0.30660977959632874, 0.17947962880134583, 0.1372774839401245, -0.16537156701087952, -0.06255565583705902, -0.573350727558136, 0.2725367248058319, -0.9341902732849121, 0.49413883686065674, -0.33319199085235596, -0.7122761011123657, 0.5788118243217468, -0.6615539193153381, -0.05949069559574127, -0.3226402997970581, -0.32519111037254333, 0.7359387278556824, -0.17885679006576538, -0.2976251542568207, 1.0042405128479004, 0.7078869938850403, 0.20919904112815857, 0.33605632185935974, -0.9940488934516907, 0.7913050651550293, -0.10732044279575348, -0.2536945044994354, 0.7663499116897583, -0.28366729617118835, -0.7792315483093262, 0.6041002869606018, 0.2509564459323883, -0.05546198785305023, 0.016297850757837296, 0.5885927677154541, 0.6317667365074158, -0.12139731645584106, -0.03160920739173889, -0.7383826971054077, -1.1102542877197266, -0.3685437738895416, 0.06943472474813461, -0.1680079698562622, 0.8077345490455627, 0.7366792559623718, 0.2733997106552124, -0.6547263264656067, 0.5260241627693176, -1.2610372304916382, -0.7229266166687012, -0.32135382294654846, -0.16408801078796387, 0.3597620129585266, -0.23112082481384277, -0.39058858156204224, -0.15033482015132904, -0.14384472370147705, 0.059211365878582, 0.5566426515579224, 0.9194658994674683, -0.1271844357252121, 0.057315390557050705, 0.6799469590187073, 0.2732985019683838, 0.11835115402936935, 0.686086893081665, -0.13056698441505432, -0.408598393201828, 0.4282524287700653, -0.5617344379425049, 0.11368853598833084, -0.05642963945865631, 0.1653345376253128, -0.3276597261428833, 0.3049796223640442, -0.22912335395812988, -0.5508784651756287, -0.8376897573471069, -0.29986801743507385, 0.39859816431999207, 0.9113417267799377, 0.20348531007766724, -0.33663246035575867, 0.01701168343424797, 0.09593256562948227, -0.24776878952980042, -0.2911500632762909, -0.054311685264110565, -1.4827890396118164, -0.3491496443748474, -0.0872269943356514, 0.011968309059739113, 0.022563068196177483, 0.08166886866092682, -0.046125490218400955, 0.19388161599636078, 0.9964286684989929, 0.13537803292274475, -0.403473436832428, -0.4864528477191925, -0.3025517165660858, 1.0570720434188843, 0.6149864792823792, 0.4644398093223572, 0.1179545596241951, -0.4256496727466583, 0.21776846051216125, -0.12416651844978333, -0.9724365472793579, -0.5043582916259766, -0.8393113613128662, 0.5100197196006775, -0.7785683870315552, -0.5981370210647583, 0.32946255803108215, 0.19703459739685059, 0.3292333781719208, 0.047910816967487335, -0.08023712784051895, 0.017808694392442703, 0.2103470265865326, 0.10105819255113602, 0.8418959379196167, -0.20978182554244995, 0.2362840324640274, -0.6952235698699951, 0.7396098375320435, 0.4476747512817383, 0.23185443878173828, -0.14387765526771545, -0.8391692638397217, 0.13443145155906677, -0.33526864647865295, 1.1538517475128174, 0.453861266374588, -0.4931395351886749, 0.683508574962616, 0.2846725583076477, 0.1286712884902954, -0.2952931225299835, 0.34968218207359314, 0.08195914328098297, 0.2873535454273224, 0.17583365738391876, -1.0886809825897217, -0.32782089710235596, -0.5739127993583679, 0.9128689765930176, 0.6266815662384033, -0.3287180960178375, -1.2479429244995117, -0.9847174882888794, 0.35655832290649414, 0.04582656919956207, 0.5451928973197937, 0.8241070508956909, 0.1597709208726883, 0.49056243896484375, -0.4474448561668396, -0.1784704625606537, 0.799759566783905, -0.07552305608987808, -0.7198774814605713, -0.11548743396997452, -0.23890136182308197, -0.04985494911670685, 0.7289248704910278, -0.4756803512573242, -0.908431887626648, 0.36898645758628845, -0.19545109570026398, 0.828101396560669, -0.17825372517108917, -0.4948912560939789, 0.07939670234918594, -0.1196795329451561, -0.8739097714424133, 0.4954964816570282, 0.15392108261585236, -0.04449531063437462, 0.12945184111595154, -0.0012327723670750856, -0.6326579451560974, 0.08146855980157852, 0.30333834886550903, 0.011453837156295776, 0.7615978121757507, 0.5733835697174072, -0.2640776038169861, 0.4771478772163391, 0.29633453488349915, 0.011306395754218102, 0.03167952597141266, 0.6214004755020142, -0.5381726026535034, -0.6914412975311279, 0.19884420931339264, -0.1060965359210968, -0.3752971291542053, 0.01075207069516182, -0.21459951996803284, -0.5104421973228455, 1.0096718072891235, 0.37214070558547974, -0.7787985801696777, -0.6745925545692444, -0.5237560272216797, -0.7434114813804626, 0.01002899743616581, -0.28518399596214294, -0.29230785369873047, -0.06412220001220703, -0.05933328717947006, 0.2689780592918396, -0.3056507110595703, -0.6027926206588745, -0.6293919682502747, -0.13681931793689728, 0.6488300561904907, 0.4150831401348114, 0.8363988399505615, -0.3893735408782959, 0.4348723590373993, 0.1671060472726822, -0.010577930137515068, -0.7992055416107178, -0.7838751077651978, 0.32508814334869385, 0.10522908717393875, -0.06151444837450981, 0.23423193395137787, 0.7012954354286194, -0.4517071843147278, 0.06080498546361923, 0.28129127621650696, -0.5857013463973999, -1.0701097249984741, -0.3408823609352112, 0.7589079141616821, 0.21237339079380035, -0.7387824654579163, -0.2970011830329895, 0.2118454873561859, -0.28031671047210693, 0.28148379921913147, -0.19482550024986267, -0.9012277126312256, 0.48897796869277954, -1.1304470300674438, 0.024171357974410057, -1.3987921476364136, -0.0016510438872501254, -0.6457402110099792, -0.6550147533416748, 0.43257126212120056, 0.2776774764060974, 0.4673249125480652, -0.2193472981452942, -0.21554940938949585, -0.4166027009487152, 0.39442136883735657, -0.5492379069328308, 0.05295174568891525, -0.6962341666221619, 0.3899720013141632, -0.480790376663208, 1.0232905149459839, -0.7834535837173462, 0.11048904806375504, 0.30835843086242676, -0.05826819688081741, -0.23938484489917755, 0.2697177827358246, -0.2896716892719269, -0.5085495114326477, -0.33486855030059814, -0.14519712328910828, 0.8541844487190247, 0.2607605755329132, -0.006856302265077829, 0.7557985782623291, -0.6711942553520203, 0.36676010489463806, -0.40383073687553406, -0.2971048653125763, 0.5612282752990723, -0.17434090375900269, 0.8804334402084351, -0.32467758655548096, -0.3183816373348236, 0.44156157970428467, 0.1281174272298813, 0.778264582157135, -0.3595680892467499, -0.6885115504264832, -0.5399917960166931, -0.6387155652046204, -0.8581246137619019, 0.5511913299560547, 0.1661888211965561, -0.14215904474258423, -0.18352586030960083, -0.6850789785385132, -0.3785663843154907, -0.5581430196762085, 0.341433584690094, 0.37959814071655273, 0.5284036993980408, 0.3270204961299896, -0.07666924595832825, 0.44102293252944946, -0.7771879434585571, 0.319965124130249, -0.20056599378585815, 0.3151634931564331, 0.08301891386508942, -0.39878156781196594, -0.8755764365196228, -0.9013371467590332, -0.9429581165313721, 0.8065289258956909, 0.4937608540058136, -0.05542517080903053, 0.8772863745689392, -0.1139627993106842, -0.18379835784435272, 0.06843104958534241, 0.11465510725975037, 0.7740810513496399, 0.10506203770637512, 0.4698391556739807, 0.33768683671951294, 0.5762764811515808, -0.1349620819091797, 0.08346503973007202, -0.7041675448417664, -0.3065643906593323, 1.069522500038147, -0.8625218272209167, 0.07758621871471405, 0.48914721608161926, 0.6281688809394836, -0.7408650517463684, -1.0103304386138916, -1.1882507801055908, -0.11484760046005249, 0.16426391899585724, -0.2328827828168869, 0.5197319388389587, -0.00029212707886472344, 0.16187012195587158, 0.5398644208908081, 0.18843089044094086, 0.2342061698436737, 0.6236962676048279, 0.660209059715271, 0.3968011736869812, -0.3817656934261322, 0.28705987334251404, 1.3992513418197632, -0.10535186529159546, -0.6186820864677429, 0.03074915148317814, -0.17702916264533997, -0.32962167263031006, 0.27145102620124817, 0.7125387191772461, -0.24190250039100647, -0.18106205761432648, 0.4293939769268036, 0.16304495930671692, 0.293608158826828, 0.4947052597999573, 0.12880484759807587, -0.29357147216796875, -0.4921538829803467, -0.6605668663978577, -0.11052919179201126, 0.3014734089374542, 0.19427447021007538, 0.4605662226676941, 0.3646182417869568, -0.020761141553521156, -0.5518302321434021, 0.1549375206232071, -0.34886685013771057, -0.7548218369483948, -0.08155203610658646, -1.0667208433151245, -0.2577093541622162, -0.7410065531730652, -0.0413939543068409, 0.3744681775569916, 0.3524790108203888, 0.08173579722642899, 0.5830485224723816, 0.3090367615222931, 0.48351576924324036, -0.17568571865558624, 0.6835145354270935, -0.7053220868110657, -0.13953520357608795, -1.109631061553955, 0.09682711958885193, -0.06437092274427414, -0.8345192670822144, -0.30577266216278076, 0.06176699325442314, -0.20116403698921204, 1.1711944341659546, -0.3778609037399292, 0.793728768825531, -0.7601286768913269, -0.5571584701538086, 0.29932355880737305, -0.13181501626968384, -1.6152697801589966, 0.9410274028778076, -0.333120197057724, 0.40064164996147156, 0.17161940038204193, 0.5132783055305481, -0.7987062931060791, -0.26125967502593994, -1.0733660459518433, 0.42220109701156616, 0.04934077709913254, 0.3203393816947937, 0.004031674936413765, -0.5460678935050964, 0.6492286920547485, -0.28643935918807983, -0.8566358685493469, -0.009887820109724998, -0.32689568400382996, 0.5595022439956665, -0.00637842109426856, 0.3620348274707794, -0.04569702968001366, -0.3438718914985657, -0.219570130109787, 0.07067769765853882, -0.1363147795200348, -0.17030741274356842, -0.08590585738420486, -0.08052517473697662, -0.4645926058292389, 0.39695674180984497, 0.11496324092149734, -0.4241100251674652, -0.118175208568573, 0.4293578267097473, -0.16633276641368866, -0.537878155708313, -0.22678346931934357, -0.33810120820999146, -0.5364218354225159, 0.17141099274158478, -0.6161118149757385, 0.4796677529811859, 0.12478689104318619, -0.6349435448646545, -0.052560191601514816, -0.15149617195129395, -0.9593775868415833, 1.092989444732666, -0.23147734999656677, -0.49054932594299316, 0.15783746540546417, -0.22303959727287292, 0.32071930170059204, 0.1340477168560028, -0.9828102588653564, 0.62196284532547, 0.4206397831439972, 0.8057525157928467, 0.4832976758480072, -0.43662378191947937, -0.3364168703556061, -0.025982381775975227, -1.3978772163391113, -0.8142715692520142, -0.4817202389240265, 0.7477278709411621, -0.6848357319831848, -0.9731492400169373, -0.04273572936654091, 0.1697586625814438, -0.05892877280712128, -0.2821260392665863, 0.49991512298583984, -0.04697824642062187, 0.5140743255615234, -0.45840147137641907, -0.10301713645458221, -0.008868326433002949, -0.24935796856880188, 0.4200477600097656, -0.14572781324386597, -0.3352962136268616, 0.395103394985199, 0.3358283042907715, 0.7102426290512085, -0.14158064126968384, -0.18672634661197662, 0.6661730408668518, 0.09880298376083374, -0.35264384746551514, 0.3972865343093872, 0.05315309017896652, 0.18659695982933044, 0.4863564968109131, -0.3295521140098572, 0.33195483684539795, 0.5333718657493591, 0.6470481157302856, 0.6713888049125671, -0.31700029969215393, -0.04661771282553673, 0.44309890270233154, 0.297573447227478, -0.060776930302381516, 0.05000563710927963, 0.5424338579177856, 0.30604851245880127, -0.039928920567035675, -0.12446436285972595, -0.588403046131134, -0.14937950670719147, -0.2464584857225418, -0.1914042979478836, -0.1375957876443863, -0.23751208186149597, -0.41627565026283264, 0.2825758457183838, 0.7039716243743896, -0.1802615523338318, -0.3633655905723572, -0.6506807208061218, 0.41418230533599854, 0.5492074489593506, -0.29838621616363525, -0.17791223526000977, 0.7842363119125366, 0.6399286389350891, 0.24458707869052887, -0.16794298589229584, 0.6019689440727234, 0.3372790813446045, 0.09502333402633667, 0.566962480545044, 0.16695332527160645, 0.5091241598129272, 0.42981454730033875, -0.3045489192008972, -0.7495298981666565, 0.14066962897777557, 0.32003146409988403, -0.5865751504898071, 0.019393833354115486, 0.0505286268889904, -0.41182950139045715, -0.7307150363922119, -0.926254153251648, -0.03059300035238266, -0.34657323360443115, -0.04438550025224686, 0.6145033836364746, -0.4361298978328705, -0.4012485146522522, 0.35233062505722046, 0.45530229806900024, 0.21126556396484375, 0.34772223234176636, 0.20527991652488708, 0.050247903913259506, 0.9973703622817993, 1.0513532161712646, 0.3589024543762207, -0.1736167073249817, -0.21273910999298096, -0.10374107956886292, 0.5371207594871521, 0.725877046585083, 0.014783992432057858, 0.482142835855484, -0.3076615631580353, 0.2816797196865082, -0.693438708782196, 0.2397925704717636, -0.336983323097229, -0.06853461265563965, 0.4090670347213745, 0.7269142270088196, -0.03613385930657387, 0.20489995181560516, 0.4746178388595581, 0.5777144432067871, -0.351758748292923, -0.29417261481285095, 0.31508782505989075, -0.9879102110862732, 0.2384260892868042, -1.2314014434814453, 0.6927125453948975, 0.4597836136817932, 0.23795242607593536, -0.5452640652656555, -0.16300733387470245, -0.39748409390449524, -0.7430263161659241, 0.0604715421795845, -0.09896061569452286, 0.14350733160972595, 1.1290600299835205, -0.15372063219547272, 0.28658339381217957, -0.8342198133468628, -0.4340827465057373, 0.020850345492362976, 1.3193318843841553, 0.01194127555936575, -0.008073770441114902, 0.6852242350578308, -0.13587526977062225, -0.7770823836326599, 0.8586708307266235, 0.9262888431549072, -0.4134632349014282, 0.47950828075408936, -0.66082763671875, 0.326180636882782, 0.1454915702342987, -0.14230278134346008, 0.08271726965904236, 0.003075498156249523, 0.58378666639328, -0.43493062257766724, -0.18466795980930328, -0.10981101542711258, -0.6404991745948792, 0.17982839047908783, -0.8292496800422668, 0.8006410598754883, -0.23958052694797516, -0.2569814622402191, -0.03775564208626747, -0.632071316242218, 4.158576965332031, 1.3497354984283447, 0.6846283078193665, 0.15687862038612366, 1.1368474960327148, 0.6872268319129944, -0.5247946977615356, -0.3545002043247223, 0.18324922025203705, -0.9246636629104614, -0.32284975051879883, 0.3193196654319763, -0.431774377822876, 0.27691659331321716, -0.17197799682617188, 0.8367885947227478, -0.20960162580013275, 0.3536527752876282, -0.40039536356925964, -0.48097628355026245, -1.2972768545150757, 0.08322695642709732, 0.26826104521751404, -0.7053908109664917, 0.17039009928703308, 0.9673950672149658, 0.18179471790790558, 0.16916584968566895, -0.3664014935493469, -0.2703409790992737, -0.5940666198730469, -0.8073556423187256, 0.044263336807489395, 0.12855222821235657, -0.7590723633766174, 0.4090462625026703, 0.09644973278045654, 0.051630809903144836, 0.07128728926181793, -0.21607401967048645, 0.23348741233348846, -0.7176043391227722, 0.7103474140167236, -0.6292867064476013, -0.322837233543396, 0.5890413522720337, -0.10607262700796127, 0.4106104373931885, 0.19851917028427124, -1.0531964302062988, 0.9835116863250732, 0.10580527037382126, 0.4476296007633209, -0.7063477635383606, -0.957912802696228, -0.4207763671875, 0.13363873958587646, 0.18683740496635437, 0.4756295382976532, -0.07689111679792404, 0.8983535170555115, -0.5702013373374939, -0.04489387199282646, -0.22984899580478668, 0.20821574330329895, 0.5739380717277527, 0.5142682194709778, 0.14200212061405182, 0.04969260096549988, 0.42547607421875, -1.0229672193527222, -0.34869489073753357, -0.7843589186668396, -0.15062904357910156, 0.324588805437088, -0.39995765686035156, 0.16617104411125183, -0.05695940926671028, -0.1279166340827942, -0.1592751443386078, 0.020732900127768517, -0.31128671765327454, 0.1379108726978302, 0.10160135477781296, -0.07403850555419922, 0.9194079041481018, 0.20520420372486115, 0.00672049168497324, -0.0976841077208519, -0.012392076663672924, 0.018632886931300163, 1.0566335916519165, -0.461654394865036, -0.4273015558719635, -0.6014776229858398 ]
The Wave Function of the Universe by the New Euclidean Path-integral Approach in Quantum Cosmology
The wave function of the universe is evaluated by using the Euclidean path integral approach. As is well known, the real Euclidean path integral diverges because the Einstein-Hilbert action is not positive definite. In order to obtain a finite wave function, we propose a new regularization method and calculate the wave function of the Friedmann- Robertson-Walker type minisuperspace model. We then consider a homogeneous but anisotropic type minisuperspace model, which is known as the Bianch type I model. The physical meaning of the wave function by this new regularization method is also examined.
Atushi Ishikawa and Haruhiko Ueda
gr-qc hep-th
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210003
gr-qc/9210004
[ 0.21199482679367065, -0.7386283278465271, 0.7232270836830139, -0.3401661515235901, 0.14504176378250122, -0.19249922037124634, -0.3420346677303314, -0.49955517053604126, -0.9860609173774719, 1.2196763753890991, 0.9792981743812561, -0.059460971504449844, -0.08161869645118713, -0.3635704517364502, -0.2438659965991974, 0.5532887578010559, -0.9655328989028931, -0.28868603706359863, -0.9759601354598999, 0.22512932121753693, 0.37287843227386475, 0.2634977102279663, -1.3031573295593262, -0.4906279444694519, -0.7488712072372437, 0.19005516171455383, 0.9485680460929871, 0.15362566709518433, 1.2192977666854858, 1.0417417287826538, 1.374949336051941, -0.1792842596769333, -0.19518378376960754, -0.5990732312202454, -0.28984683752059937, -0.004064347594976425, 0.23510093986988068, -0.49650925397872925, 0.9774207472801208, -0.36247146129608154, 0.7760927081108093, 0.1476297527551651, 0.4514542520046234, -0.7063547372817993, -0.8456515073776245, -0.3202456831932068, -0.37837010622024536, -0.5226895809173584, -0.7166319489479065, -1.0176911354064941, 0.024179181084036827, -0.37572142481803894, 1.0060274600982666, -0.46510475873947144, -0.16098050773143768, -0.28314557671546936, 0.017912575975060463, 0.7201686501502991, -0.16365312039852142, 0.42068979144096375, 0.459065318107605, 0.12184717506170273, -0.1547481268644333, -0.8226266503334045, 0.3697778582572937, 0.9210343360900879, -0.4235401451587677, 0.3854030966758728, -0.07741022109985352, -0.6291917562484741, -0.23835916817188263, -0.44132936000823975, -0.48835301399230957, 0.22997723519802094, -0.5556634664535522, 0.7591108679771423, -0.03608876094222069, -0.09416687488555908, -0.5654175281524658, -0.5878660082817078, 0.1497940868139267, -0.5676368474960327, -0.5261716246604919, 0.27014321088790894, -0.29996684193611145, -0.27534395456314087, 0.10244257748126984, -0.12208770960569382, 0.006753447465598583, 0.2887699604034424, 0.12906695902347565, 0.4740086793899536, 0.4249083697795868, -0.7424008846282959, 0.2473721206188202, 1.0777637958526611, -0.06169585511088371, 0.6517643928527832, -0.0018385450821369886, 0.6145482063293457, -0.3476857841014862, 0.8104023933410645, -0.529278039932251, 0.47673508524894714, -0.17969921231269836, 1.2082113027572632, -0.672107994556427, 0.4684169590473175, 0.10248811542987823, -0.9150147438049316, 0.0887427106499672, -0.07742147147655487, 0.32580700516700745, 0.05834998935461044, 0.033114660531282425, 0.19729536771774292, -0.5360050797462463, 0.21098896861076355, -0.4673766791820526, -0.35620883107185364, 0.18581172823905945, 0.27664390206336975, 0.723440408706665, 1.0280426740646362, 0.06160103529691696, -0.326628714799881, -0.29249808192253113, -0.36344432830810547, -0.5038732886314392, -0.05236028879880905, 0.5457693934440613, -0.4310779571533203, 0.510355532169342, -0.18219874799251556, 0.16482777893543243, 0.4574442207813263, -0.1186874657869339, -0.49304184317588806, -0.5054933428764343, -0.4246353209018707, 0.4138086438179016, -0.8746614456176758, 0.5240483283996582, 0.7770481705665588, -0.24972355365753174, 0.49795520305633545, -0.41793370246887207, 0.10133747011423111, -0.4335542917251587, 0.007156199309974909, -0.011038809083402157, -0.6382759809494019, -0.777857780456543, 0.13764551281929016, 0.15268222987651825, -0.3980763554573059, -0.8000665903091431, -0.09024928510189056, -0.4122861623764038, -0.059670813381671906, -0.33092227578163147, -0.5287705659866333, -0.13537216186523438, 1.115761399269104, -0.171632319688797, 0.4756781756877899, -0.6816016435623169, -0.1495182067155838, -0.13048872351646423, 0.02538638561964035, -0.3134421706199646, 0.22804825007915497, 0.35740455985069275, 0.6308377981185913, 1.3402782678604126, 0.8455524444580078, 0.47820860147476196, -0.25581392645835876, -0.44168320298194885, 0.46501001715660095, -0.3103565275669098, -0.04272599145770073, 1.0628201961517334, 0.5334680080413818, -0.20262080430984497, -0.7760646939277649, -0.5936228632926941, 0.5969288945198059, 0.3343854248523712, -0.2953447103500366, -0.38676485419273376, 0.29426419734954834, -1.0193285942077637, 1.2759841680526733, -0.32326778769493103, 0.29278403520584106, -0.7280828952789307, -0.11165517568588257, 0.24791334569454193, -0.722166895866394, -0.1599911004304886, -0.5240724086761475, -0.54002445936203, 0.13930298388004303, -1.0840520858764648, 1.2276700735092163, 0.5557110905647278, 0.48494598269462585, -0.5284414291381836, 0.6119713187217712, 0.021653560921549797, 0.0007735540857538581, 0.18978311121463776, -0.2439054399728775, 0.09528778493404388, -0.6854642629623413, 0.0023072855547070503, 0.1918737143278122, 0.2069275677204132, 0.34074804186820984, 0.4005301296710968, 0.01227024756371975, 0.11561712622642517, 0.8718652725219727, 0.21624697744846344, -0.30440738797187805, 0.1984090656042099, 1.0842474699020386, -0.3912980258464813, 0.6744951009750366, 0.28700679540634155, 0.34101229906082153, 0.13266600668430328, 0.5489364266395569, 0.26090502738952637, 0.07884649932384491, 0.5227915644645691, 0.002943323226645589, 0.34568336606025696, 0.2568233013153076, 0.5305830836296082, -0.18939705193042755, 0.6284104585647583, 0.29614055156707764, -0.5499135851860046, 0.5250072479248047, 0.434312641620636, 0.15539179742336273, -0.09517879039049149, 0.8296676278114319, -1.1120421886444092, 1.0259121656417847, 0.200434148311615, -0.17150162160396576, -0.7134104371070862, -0.1192711889743805, 0.45018601417541504, 0.3082043528556824, -0.18164291977882385, -0.7544035911560059, -0.20105844736099243, 0.5821331143379211, -0.5252997875213623, -0.2439551204442978, -0.46636757254600525, 0.7097418308258057, 0.08839345723390579, -0.056160952895879745, 0.19400571286678314, -0.4492579996585846, -0.7629268765449524, -0.37026098370552063, -0.5113088488578796, 0.025743046775460243, -0.4100392162799835, -0.8629816770553589, 0.1034567803144455, -0.2734566330909729, 1.1423708200454712, -0.4197646975517273, -0.15567763149738312, 0.8210203051567078, 0.46602049469947815, 0.22851254045963287, 0.03878629952669144, -0.20172429084777832, -0.271937757730484, 0.3212093412876129, -0.4098675549030304, 0.2685810923576355, 0.31254783272743225, -0.6722619533538818, 0.5058492422103882, -0.4354243576526642, 0.12835577130317688, 0.1182689368724823, -0.6958903670310974, 0.20484627783298492, -0.19706232845783234, -0.8293730616569519, -0.02267211303114891, 0.5018855333328247, 0.18680764734745026, -0.09026072174310684, -0.47397610545158386, 1.0085352659225464, 0.34599024057388306, -0.7204465866088867, 0.3054472506046295, -0.14054381847381592, -0.8305063843727112, 0.8842450976371765, 0.5469553470611572, 0.5449197292327881, 0.4330779016017914, 0.4184112250804901, 0.49486038088798523, 0.01304234191775322, 0.31743377447128296, -0.033299610018730164, -0.9049883484840393, -0.5956615805625916, 0.6164055466651917, -0.818179190158844, 0.30334219336509705, 1.03925359249115, -0.017749780789017677, -0.9316352009773254, 0.2638428807258606, -0.9004820585250854, -1.013663411140442, -0.31812265515327454, -0.29167360067367554, -0.09717924892902374, -0.3501046895980835, -0.6024910807609558, -0.5133686065673828, -0.18031464517116547, 0.3357718288898468, 0.6520087122917175, -0.15342502295970917, -0.735380232334137, 0.7234529852867126, 0.027461571618914604, 0.9157493114471436, 0.09633181989192963, 0.22645597159862518, -0.8922686576843262, -0.4413614571094513, 0.37271830439567566, -0.18803125619888306, 0.42268210649490356, -0.0005290974513627589, 0.18945737183094025, 0.23267728090286255, 0.2915610671043396, -0.23653055727481842, -0.07890608161687851, -1.157423496246338, -0.05000865459442139, 0.15982772409915924, 1.0104118585586548, -0.1332295536994934, -0.07887808233499527, -0.8452058434486389, -0.27655768394470215, -0.1403401494026184, -0.2700459957122803, 0.5524320006370544, -1.13762366771698, 0.45960286259651184, -0.07480814307928085, -0.4490068852901459, -0.3264649212360382, -0.37706056237220764, 0.4271906018257141, 0.5715847611427307, 0.8027388453483582, 0.5167103409767151, -0.16911739110946655, -0.7643341422080994, -0.2569839060306549, 0.5040782690048218, -0.06280333548784256, 0.9016315937042236, -0.1971050649881363, 0.04105985909700394, 0.31350427865982056, -0.20583927631378174, -0.24743570387363434, -0.6221668720245361, -0.28963780403137207, 0.4267675280570984, -0.8015626072883606, 0.03469186648726463, 0.10012916475534439, 0.8954650163650513, 0.20766597986221313, 0.06619720160961151, -0.013259055092930794, 0.03095399960875511, 0.13236281275749207, 0.5228514075279236, 0.6776445508003235, -0.11399564892053604, -0.0740135982632637, -0.8324869871139526, 0.32968512177467346, 0.6640567779541016, 0.4841229021549225, -0.3104936182498932, -0.6650571823120117, -0.08674050122499466, -0.11274480819702148, 0.05006938427686691, 0.4631585478782654, -0.5569959282875061, 0.10962946712970734, 0.5708672404289246, 0.6023657917976379, 0.27753138542175293, 0.46428924798965454, 0.8908922672271729, 0.5275862216949463, 0.13378553092479706, -1.0118638277053833, -0.07041726261377335, -0.562372088432312, 0.2221618890762329, 0.6991198658943176, -0.2958992123603821, -0.48806288838386536, -1.2198983430862427, 0.03247687965631485, -0.7656583786010742, 0.5286558270454407, 1.0337082147598267, -0.1234697550535202, 0.23653484880924225, -0.4370039403438568, -0.5952662825584412, 0.8357927203178406, -0.12736426293849945, -0.4462795853614807, 0.1329515278339386, 0.27569159865379333, -0.6056221723556519, 0.10636569559574127, 0.0019651539623737335, -0.7136417627334595, 0.20552662014961243, -0.32446351647377014, 0.635123074054718, -0.475035697221756, -0.40737953782081604, -0.11128856241703033, 0.42486926913261414, -0.765541672706604, 0.6919065117835999, 0.21130363643169403, 0.5549488663673401, 0.13635003566741943, 0.6094589829444885, -0.18850921094417572, 0.3803076148033142, 0.19672304391860962, -0.20742516219615936, 0.15249982476234436, 1.00315260887146, 0.03419438749551773, 0.22925011813640594, 0.26714026927948, -0.6918879151344299, -0.062076907604932785, 0.5657016634941101, -0.06980625540018082, -0.04257962107658386, 0.17016972601413727, -0.49463552236557007, -0.42225098609924316, -0.38453808426856995, 0.20490795373916626, -0.447799414396286, 0.667108416557312, 0.14533938467502594, -1.0404094457626343, -0.8873323202133179, -1.018157720565796, -1.0751539468765259, -0.19069916009902954, -0.3455650806427002, -0.533367931842804, -0.20256149768829346, -0.4316330850124359, -0.662681519985199, -0.19844700396060944, -0.33981987833976746, -0.8576902151107788, -0.2715733051300049, 0.13954339921474457, 0.006995640695095062, 0.5233277082443237, -0.20175963640213013, 0.4637811779975891, -0.3091806173324585, -0.00019428820814937353, -0.6062745451927185, -1.0645838975906372, 0.35446813702583313, 0.3332708775997162, 0.23089268803596497, -0.11514147371053696, 0.19524511694908142, 0.8284391164779663, 0.6558400988578796, -0.3692648410797119, -0.3580314815044403, -0.959364652633667, -0.18929094076156616, 1.0489437580108643, 0.1597067266702652, -0.6551000475883484, -0.09833145141601562, 0.17114019393920898, -0.46912288665771484, -0.04096827656030655, 0.01930653676390648, -0.43474411964416504, -0.004825963173061609, -0.8757759928703308, 0.4785446524620056, -0.7879840731620789, 0.05329594388604164, -0.8294642567634583, -0.7574799060821533, 0.485344797372818, -0.1472334861755371, 0.8477994203567505, -0.8257855176925659, -0.627248227596283, -0.3267022371292114, -0.005417573265731335, 0.09372695535421371, 0.24035228788852692, -0.3667229413986206, 0.20683342218399048, -0.4911980628967285, 0.9504566788673401, -0.7282770276069641, 0.023289596661925316, 0.4418494701385498, -0.05852706730365753, -0.2545870542526245, 0.379064679145813, 0.13840624690055847, -0.7054740786552429, -0.4069754183292389, -0.13361553847789764, 0.2187596708536148, 0.19722846150398254, -0.23809973895549774, 0.30651500821113586, -1.0801643133163452, 0.19084441661834717, -0.1128227710723877, -0.619965136051178, 0.15932467579841614, 0.16339825093746185, 0.2775402367115021, -0.9375538229942322, -0.05515156686306, 0.3592226505279541, 0.7387316226959229, 0.1993274986743927, -0.8118120431900024, -0.7675798535346985, -0.3298347592353821, -0.7378998398780823, -0.6217774748802185, 0.6626468896865845, 0.11955824494361877, 0.45691677927970886, -0.605189859867096, -0.5335341095924377, -0.06498418003320694, -1.0339298248291016, 0.4211512804031372, 0.9841324687004089, 0.8710185885429382, 0.15045534074306488, 0.3147789537906647, -0.2456531524658203, -1.1439491510391235, 0.015615949407219887, -0.087074875831604, 0.27183735370635986, -0.07107456773519516, -0.08573796600103378, -0.6275156140327454, -0.5432103872299194, -0.30218997597694397, -0.05836976319551468, 0.33117347955703735, 0.07158711552619934, 0.10527841746807098, 0.20202086865901947, -0.5036329030990601, -0.4889296889305115, 0.15640294551849365, 0.18689197301864624, 0.2966677248477936, 0.5285133123397827, -0.0010243469150736928, -0.11127965897321701, -0.9986381530761719, 0.4476388990879059, -0.7052944898605347, -0.11234688758850098, 1.1435881853103638, -0.3444283902645111, 0.16542945802211761, 1.2364543676376343, 0.3129741847515106, -0.3804379105567932, -0.8446539640426636, -0.25476789474487305, 0.12205284088850021, -0.05504973605275154, -0.519509494304657, -0.07740477472543716, 0.18137766420841217, -0.6184679269790649, 0.02992105670273304, 0.528379499912262, 0.024663766846060753, 0.16572076082229614, 0.04551642760634422, -0.016649339348077774, -0.30732405185699463, 0.03255020081996918, 1.2389100790023804, 0.036571092903614044, -0.2162456065416336, -0.08495377004146576, 0.1290736049413681, -0.1860555112361908, -0.4686545431613922, 0.6255195140838623, -0.5138380527496338, -0.1573222428560257, 0.22343143820762634, 0.7264522910118103, 0.1797121912240982, 0.5855756402015686, -0.3594684302806854, -0.005486677400767803, -0.19987696409225464, -0.5481625199317932, 0.4036601483821869, 0.14664047956466675, 0.5276957750320435, 0.4176362156867981, -0.1392778754234314, -0.45554670691490173, 0.34164661169052124, 0.4368721544742584, -0.09687751531600952, -1.2322372198104858, -0.17581351101398468, -1.3320013284683228, -0.688302755355835, -1.3650230169296265, -0.050511348992586136, 0.5376169085502625, 0.7686882019042969, -0.7099526524543762, 0.1292707473039627, -0.5653203129768372, 0.7101243734359741, -0.06309780478477478, 1.1263145208358765, -0.4935338497161865, -0.5387787222862244, -0.5666164755821228, 0.10243622213602066, -0.19703884422779083, -0.7160996794700623, -0.6685407161712646, -0.42779532074928284, 0.3488914966583252, 0.8505371809005737, -0.7850834131240845, 0.8479161262512207, -0.6062337160110474, -0.6300190091133118, 0.27924028038978577, -0.27708563208580017, -1.0872944593429565, 1.0669928789138794, -0.36061540246009827, -0.0008424694533459842, 0.3802103102207184, 0.7263206839561462, -0.45484644174575806, -0.46976402401924133, -1.264672040939331, 0.3734866976737976, -0.06045446917414665, 0.4803648293018341, 0.01235190499573946, -1.050144076347351, 0.2838602066040039, -0.002711839508265257, -0.9447199702262878, 0.01763267256319523, -0.02162168361246586, 1.0858783721923828, -0.548591136932373, -0.023787042126059532, 0.09172147512435913, 0.19678333401679993, -0.28438156843185425, 1.0398080348968506, -0.18167744576931, -0.48940688371658325, -0.1391511857509613, 0.24106420576572418, -0.24342472851276398, 0.17207196354866028, -0.357073575258255, -0.5197851657867432, 0.1673697680234909, 0.13020123541355133, -0.1609715223312378, -0.19473889470100403, -0.36651933193206787, -0.06897981464862823, -0.6584047675132751, 0.12707489728927612, -0.40526896715164185, 0.8825592994689941, 0.647010326385498, 0.28633958101272583, 0.4372057020664215, -0.5480361580848694, -0.3552972972393036, 0.30671271681785583, -0.6938664317131042, -0.6967424750328064, 0.07628884166479111, 0.017877161502838135, 0.2955477833747864, 0.21018925309181213, -0.6092561483383179, 0.04544822871685028, 0.8323080539703369, 0.8214932084083557, 0.4645976126194, -0.4554327130317688, -0.8767630457878113, 0.35478535294532776, -0.6928826570510864, -0.6093453764915466, -0.660286009311676, 0.10246281325817108, -1.1349455118179321, -1.0386866331100464, -0.28334444761276245, 0.38007253408432007, -0.08895205706357956, -0.3557066321372986, 0.0036228036042302847, 0.4201953113079071, -0.06534364819526672, -0.3281862437725067, -0.3125212490558624, 0.22667649388313293, -0.06094308942556381, 0.6325932741165161, 0.13025148212909698, -0.2487388253211975, 0.14096003770828247, 0.4612549841403961, 0.6888057589530945, 0.07462556660175323, -0.3484320640563965, 0.8925495743751526, -0.5146334767341614, -0.29927536845207214, 0.6716534495353699, 0.3646014630794525, 0.3205527365207672, 0.562221109867096, -0.742438018321991, -0.010766392573714256, 0.37716367840766907, 0.6695394515991211, 0.46151429414749146, 0.15385082364082336, -0.14581027626991272, 0.2469807118177414, 0.4414103031158447, -0.09696942567825317, -0.48553991317749023, 0.13078942894935608, 0.2071983814239502, 0.2551177740097046, 0.14103378355503082, -0.3028899133205414, -0.019482560455799103, 0.4648503065109253, 0.6573151350021362, -0.5857672691345215, 0.027456464245915413, -0.39681747555732727, 0.26395469903945923, 0.2681366205215454, -0.4599209427833557, -0.5362516641616821, -0.38412585854530334, 0.5495143532752991, 0.30106696486473083, -0.1777438372373581, -0.0939251184463501, 0.19379840791225433, 0.9074960350990295, 0.3366757333278656, -0.3708203434944153, 0.7530047297477722, -0.13433972001075745, 0.5263853073120117, 0.6987988948822021, 0.3342854678630829, 0.6213415861129761, 1.1744602918624878, -0.027947168797254562, -0.47456786036491394, -0.32696494460105896, -0.39598172903060913, -0.7871267199516296, 0.2011614590883255, 0.017931150272488594, -0.3097606301307678, -0.08899065107107162, -0.5216257572174072, 0.31789880990982056, -0.31145069003105164, 0.6361178755760193, 0.24712610244750977, -0.5940974950790405, -0.697577953338623, 0.297982394695282, 0.20640689134597778, 0.6276109218597412, 0.6422964334487915, -0.0345461405813694, -0.143502339720726, 0.6253344416618347, 0.7697973251342773, 0.1351940780878067, -0.13678699731826782, 0.01825193129479885, 0.431575208902359, 0.8959438800811768, 0.5671527981758118, -0.02527380734682083, 0.6171516180038452, -0.009151304140686989, 0.466555655002594, 0.10945452749729156, 0.4742736518383026, -0.4438724219799042, -0.10572640597820282, 0.2997070550918579, 0.5945185422897339, -0.014678285457193851, 0.018883585929870605, 1.0613958835601807, 0.15534938871860504, -0.3410193622112274, -0.2255944162607193, 0.23872686922550201, -0.9149450659751892, 0.20828421413898468, -1.5287435054779053, 0.170369952917099, 0.4149496257305145, -0.04217598959803581, -0.08049555122852325, -0.3716120719909668, -0.12005700170993805, -0.7311948537826538, -0.33465370535850525, -0.4689609408378601, 0.07703576982021332, 0.8583448529243469, 0.3350922465324402, -0.009281376376748085, -0.7406556010246277, -0.5381193161010742, 0.07767972350120544, 1.060465931892395, -0.04199947789311409, 0.3893210291862488, 0.4603739082813263, 0.26805007457733154, -0.8877204656600952, 0.7156258225440979, 0.8525773882865906, -0.7489449977874756, 0.3686429560184479, -0.012817170470952988, 0.4758067727088928, -0.1599416732788086, -0.17642617225646973, -0.21498756110668182, -0.19014984369277954, 0.5066704154014587, 0.23955366015434265, -0.041341956704854965, -0.023784667253494263, -0.372848242521286, 0.18800464272499084, -0.7977679967880249, 0.46744248270988464, 0.10642259567975998, -0.2075997143983841, -0.2461366206407547, -0.8017658591270447, 4.06449556350708, 0.876159131526947, 0.7952709794044495, -0.1364268958568573, 0.7649389505386353, 1.1388872861862183, -0.06609451770782471, -0.08064945787191391, 0.41816312074661255, -0.6785809397697449, 0.21211948990821838, 0.6234799027442932, -0.6279809474945068, 0.10097019374370575, -0.221002459526062, 0.8090232014656067, -0.5932355523109436, -0.0009747814619913697, -0.3299606144428253, -0.6794924736022949, -1.025364637374878, 0.44182464480400085, 0.10482985526323318, -0.020388666540384293, 0.25803977251052856, 0.9011756181716919, 0.23473913967609406, -0.5818415284156799, -0.6328616738319397, 0.126163512468338, -0.1775919795036316, -0.4937094449996948, -0.029013441875576973, 0.21555934846401215, -1.4395426511764526, 0.16799090802669525, -0.02342149056494236, -0.5415930151939392, 0.4921706020832062, 0.061943989247083664, 0.6740047931671143, -0.48618802428245544, 0.5379969477653503, -0.08854108303785324, -0.8249821066856384, 0.9206961989402771, -0.2262895107269287, 0.7369883060455322, 0.6207389831542969, -0.9615764021873474, 0.19072352349758148, 0.6777713298797607, 0.6019264459609985, -0.4013591706752777, -0.4218849837779999, -0.4295695126056671, 0.32713261246681213, -0.30868175625801086, 0.7754979133605957, 0.22645260393619537, 1.4027845859527588, -0.6561604738235474, 0.01113738864660263, 0.17978447675704956, 0.9313074350357056, 0.4929317235946655, 0.9667487144470215, 0.015444676391780376, 0.137699156999588, -0.28591397404670715, -0.5232878923416138, -0.09833080321550369, -0.756933331489563, -0.4945547580718994, -0.03008466586470604, -0.16017615795135498, -0.08611167222261429, 0.41848117113113403, -0.24291899800300598, 0.2177964746952057, -0.4059615433216095, -0.26790428161621094, 0.2581523060798645, 0.0744389072060585, -0.4409771263599396, 0.8937382698059082, 0.024449843913316727, 0.6086483597755432, -0.496858686208725, 0.2645489275455475, 0.26128414273262024, 1.092118501663208, -0.6042803525924683, -0.06547141820192337, -0.8463844060897827 ]
The Spacetime Approach to Quantum Mechanics
Feynman's sum-over-histories formulation of quantum mechanics is reviewed as an independent statement of quantum theory in spacetime form. It is different from the usual Schr\"odinger-Heisenberg formulation that utilizes states on spacelike surfaces because it assigns probabilities to different sets of alternatives. Sum-over-histories quantum mechanics can be generalized to deal with spacetime alternatives that are not "at definite moments of time". An example in field theory is the set of alternative ranges of values of a field averaged over a spacetime region. An example in particle mechanics is the set of the alternatives defined by whether a particle never crosses a fixed spacetime region or crosses it at least once. The general notion of a set of spacetime alternatives is a partition (coarse-graining) of the histories into an exhaustive set of exclusive classes. With this generalization the sum-over-histories formulation can be said to be in fully spacetime form with dynamics represented by path integrals over spacetime histories and alternatives defined as spacetime partitions of these histories. When restricted to alternatives at definite moments of times this generalization is equivalent to Schr\"odinger-Heisenberg quantum mechanics. However, the quantum mechanics of more general spacetime alternatives does not have an equivalent Schr\"odinger-Heisenberg formulation. We suggest that, in the quantum theory of gravity, the general notion of "observable" is supplied by diffeomorphism invariant partitions of spacetime metrics and matter field configurations. By generalizing the usual alternatives so as to put quantum theory in fully spacetime form we may be led to a covariant generalized quantum mechanics of spacetime free from the problem of time.
James B. Hartle
gr-qc hep-th quant-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210004
gr-qc/9210005
[ 0.4878784418106079, 0.514531135559082, 0.9517061710357666, 0.05230669677257538, -0.5496718883514404, 0.08913399279117584, -0.15974849462509155, 0.04991048574447632, -1.2717268466949463, 1.4374066591262817, 0.948053240776062, -0.23459617793560028, -0.590106725692749, -1.1850167512893677, -0.11620758473873138, 0.441650390625, 0.2308768332004547, -0.20539598166942596, -0.7999810576438904, 0.057710569351911545, 0.06620452553033829, 0.2123400866985321, -1.510021686553955, -0.4055337905883789, -0.21578875184059143, 0.721147894859314, 0.19687888026237488, 0.4272363483905792, 0.8716758489608765, 0.6827093958854675, 0.4716276228427887, -0.4507773220539093, 0.0008376214536838233, -0.6212379932403564, -0.12519626319408417, 0.08966679871082306, 0.4226737916469574, 0.18227121233940125, 0.9757975339889526, -0.4799344539642334, 0.5393857359886169, -0.025181323289871216, 0.29785916209220886, 0.00579872727394104, -0.3229452967643738, -0.4585597813129425, -0.43332889676094055, 0.030086612328886986, 0.6447548270225525, -0.8315450549125671, -0.21846763789653778, -0.03317779675126076, 0.7325995564460754, -1.1381783485412598, 0.15940792858600616, -0.30297982692718506, 0.25593626499176025, 0.4990626573562622, -0.20655062794685364, -0.11405135691165924, 0.13731518387794495, 0.6830611228942871, 0.6329771876335144, -0.7169570326805115, 0.21075358986854553, 1.0953811407089233, 0.01020910032093525, 0.2541898488998413, -0.18066951632499695, 0.09541363269090652, 0.19367647171020508, -0.3928684592247009, -0.7999709248542786, 0.20860087871551514, -0.13394604623317719, 0.18719714879989624, 0.20588575303554535, -0.44701695442199707, -1.1171995401382446, -0.35639721155166626, 0.3157629668712616, 0.023884745314717293, -0.08649085462093353, 0.3837431073188782, -0.1559087485074997, -0.7424871325492859, 0.21713027358055115, 0.08387721329927444, 0.0843929722905159, 0.316972017288208, -0.03799488767981529, 0.7008783221244812, -0.2095305323600769, 0.07664302736520767, 0.6521923542022705, 0.4337018132209778, -0.0011777582112699747, 0.34918874502182007, 0.05857296288013458, 0.49513885378837585, -0.25153103470802307, 0.5755157470703125, -0.26941394805908203, 0.5494751930236816, -0.291113018989563, 1.010597825050354, 0.06487948447465897, 0.18770234286785126, 0.24342529475688934, -0.7686032652854919, -0.15591339766979218, -0.30376964807510376, 0.3026933968067169, 0.32621848583221436, 0.32997992634773254, 0.5876367092132568, -0.269002228975296, 0.20584499835968018, -0.24290679395198822, -0.4596172273159027, 0.347733736038208, 0.528103232383728, 0.596844494342804, 0.8899430632591248, 0.1301959902048111, -0.8626932501792908, -0.2476062774658203, -0.384082168340683, -0.578549325466156, 0.031274423003196716, -0.05007703974843025, -0.7744797468185425, -0.7406896352767944, 0.16833078861236572, -0.26723089814186096, 0.22165675461292267, 0.5468254089355469, 0.2868827283382416, -0.8775838613510132, -0.8903539776802063, 0.6597194075584412, -0.6632625460624695, -0.1359615921974182, 0.7352373600006104, -0.9757748246192932, 0.25989311933517456, -0.34863749146461487, 0.6769468784332275, -0.40910810232162476, 0.23341678082942963, -0.3177083432674408, 0.11543705314397812, -0.029803337529301643, 0.5138090252876282, -0.09507720917463303, -0.17796838283538818, -0.9916524887084961, 0.24384930729866028, 0.11422233283519745, -0.9131050109863281, 0.5273287892341614, -0.008139202371239662, 0.12292150408029556, 0.9939907193183899, -1.4255658388137817, 0.10383058339357376, -0.7096750140190125, -0.27776700258255005, -0.10801638662815094, 0.07830169796943665, -0.5096216797828674, 0.5425863862037659, -0.4701581597328186, 0.07793404161930084, 0.5831856727600098, 0.4183935225009918, 0.1465909332036972, -0.45138609409332275, -0.02260894700884819, -0.03716076910495758, -0.2760474383831024, -0.2546736001968384, 0.19586098194122314, 0.4230612516403198, -0.36990484595298767, -0.04943805932998657, -0.41066259145736694, 0.413747102022171, -0.03182100132107735, 0.07657626271247864, -0.9835779070854187, 0.601382851600647, -1.0646520853042603, 0.8287678956985474, -0.519254207611084, 0.4758770763874054, -0.5998908877372742, 0.1406610757112503, -0.3320748507976532, -0.8994479179382324, 0.5488044023513794, 0.03978028893470764, -0.28339874744415283, 0.4946451485157013, -1.0578728914260864, 0.47866034507751465, 0.5065771341323853, 0.6240600943565369, -0.8706606030464172, 0.1305280327796936, 0.18788214027881622, -0.4021405875682831, 0.31298089027404785, 0.04769772291183472, 0.2605239748954773, -0.014016957953572273, -0.2087111473083496, 0.16683393716812134, 0.4747197926044464, 0.0374259427189827, 0.5570420622825623, -0.07158053666353226, -0.20927584171295166, 0.6589320302009583, 0.15540963411331177, 0.019170016050338745, -0.005745563190430403, 1.0252201557159424, -0.49239853024482727, 0.37730705738067627, -0.05840473249554634, 0.01684598997235298, 0.6559083461761475, 0.2831215560436249, -0.1104697436094284, -0.4119361340999603, 0.7407656908035278, 0.4132068455219269, -0.7445346713066101, -0.18560846149921417, -0.16466015577316284, -0.07829254120588303, 0.022225992754101753, 0.23158308863639832, -0.45071062445640564, 0.538250744342804, 0.014085314236581326, 0.2982584536075592, 0.025355709716677666, 0.759792149066925, -0.7447332143783569, 0.3346278965473175, 0.03095412813127041, 0.4603852927684784, -1.3146876096725464, -0.20246833562850952, 0.07586472481489182, 0.5154024958610535, -0.20163550972938538, -0.5300992131233215, -0.609050989151001, 0.5958430767059326, -0.01127972174435854, -0.3706151843070984, 0.11808218061923981, -0.42643502354621887, -0.8673127889633179, 0.44165635108947754, 0.48031437397003174, -0.09132504463195801, -0.5712010860443115, 0.37664321064949036, -0.43830764293670654, -0.0797637328505516, -0.531320333480835, 0.3465568721294403, 0.008091945201158524, -0.7496582269668579, 0.49788787961006165, -0.28699520230293274, -0.03609425202012062, 0.5685140490531921, -0.10112475603818893, 0.09699500352144241, 0.058299630880355835, 0.60756516456604, -0.710354208946228, 0.3496984839439392, -0.9262412190437317, 0.29741278290748596, 0.06549082696437836, -0.4628658890724182, -0.07236549258232117, -0.5613074898719788, 0.6309658288955688, -0.21987853944301605, -0.6572195887565613, 0.17168602347373962, 0.3016819357872009, -0.40554431080818176, 0.7515519261360168, 1.0371441841125488, -0.005063836462795734, -0.21059760451316833, -1.0680513381958008, 0.5958573222160339, -0.1672697216272354, -0.19405239820480347, 0.4427502751350403, -0.46558308601379395, -0.6959929466247559, 0.10412956774234772, -0.05377383157610893, 0.8284264206886292, -0.1916336864233017, 0.1265222579240799, 1.127860426902771, -0.18773144483566284, -0.006516518536955118, -0.07675166428089142, -1.1202373504638672, -0.49568137526512146, 0.45852580666542053, -0.38994598388671875, 0.34998053312301636, 0.5932375192642212, 0.6873942613601685, -0.7526884078979492, 0.00019017163140233606, -0.7053793668746948, -0.5252259969711304, -0.08628933131694794, -0.45381349325180054, 0.35786446928977966, -1.054259181022644, 0.08733975887298584, -0.5735029578208923, -0.06289026886224747, -0.688942015171051, 0.7238682508468628, 0.5012263655662537, -0.16362904012203217, -0.11410414427518845, 0.5522672533988953, 0.2614096403121948, 0.05847740173339844, 0.5226758122444153, 0.33354178071022034, -0.3469286262989044, 0.1984758973121643, -0.43329092860221863, 0.2247619479894638, 0.3697007894515991, 0.4606592655181885, 0.10424859821796417, 0.04511949047446251, 0.3536241054534912, -0.42640992999076843, -0.931083619594574, -0.5023720860481262, -0.5879737138748169, 0.6878793239593506, 0.4715215563774109, -0.09684811532497406, -0.595997154712677, 0.12007198482751846, -0.08318056166172028, -0.6657518148422241, 0.48812371492385864, -0.7679998278617859, 0.2395406812429428, 0.12422214448451996, -0.6712069511413574, -0.0963754802942276, 0.16465039551258087, 0.3434355854988098, 0.4418247640132904, 0.6152943968772888, -0.20752492547035217, -0.017091678455471992, -0.4741619825363159, -0.5800010561943054, 0.6892328858375549, 0.5111521482467651, 0.1710883527994156, -0.013610238209366798, -0.40729430317878723, 0.36993661522865295, -0.26060032844543457, -0.5723058581352234, -0.6791003346443176, -0.6193439364433289, -0.08947908133268356, -0.7199277877807617, -0.3758758008480072, -0.3486042618751526, 0.7912335991859436, 0.3508261740207672, -0.17763523757457733, 0.054983388632535934, -0.08357862383127213, -0.0843266174197197, -0.044627394527196884, 0.39067360758781433, 0.06989584863185883, 0.2135106921195984, -1.4680240154266357, 0.3521450161933899, -0.027609482407569885, 0.5453242063522339, 0.373371958732605, -0.31724950671195984, 0.23837816715240479, -0.42786329984664917, 0.9366050362586975, 0.41119384765625, -0.03750220686197281, 0.6607106328010559, 0.10907433182001114, 0.12242458760738373, -0.36640045046806335, 1.0654113292694092, 0.04540826007723808, 0.37443822622299194, -0.23423819243907928, -0.7422032952308655, 0.18222908675670624, -0.7007012367248535, 0.40243422985076904, 0.40020182728767395, -0.9187191724777222, -1.1522743701934814, -0.8155176043510437, 0.23221318423748016, -0.009951869025826454, 0.06591825187206268, 0.8082376718521118, -0.28543493151664734, 0.43319544196128845, -0.04776744917035103, -0.23036085069179535, 0.2927016615867615, -0.3288136422634125, -0.5569122433662415, 0.32109004259109497, -0.11744057387113571, -0.3640750050544739, 0.46096789836883545, 0.20840869843959808, -1.4777923822402954, 0.36946719884872437, 0.12015890330076218, 0.24834921956062317, -0.5674801468849182, -0.5740525722503662, 0.35969799757003784, 0.2428261935710907, -1.1706671714782715, 0.021711796522140503, 0.001863913843408227, 0.18096864223480225, 0.1571613848209381, 0.32222115993499756, -0.6903436779975891, 0.1310642957687378, -0.20429627597332, -0.4762346148490906, 0.828040361404419, 0.30134403705596924, 0.015047029592096806, 1.0153846740722656, 0.5366326570510864, -0.4718762934207916, -0.08262962847948074, 0.5750696063041687, -0.1569492667913437, -0.10251729935407639, -0.5243110656738281, 0.34180739521980286, -0.9276657700538635, -0.06801875680685043, 0.5537780523300171, -0.43488433957099915, 0.027989249676465988, -0.22542603313922882, -0.8704630732536316, -0.8633633852005005, 0.07587163895368576, -0.7421896457672119, 1.2224045991897583, -0.4252265989780426, -0.42577019333839417, 0.17185598611831665, -0.5630215406417847, 0.5477946996688843, 0.25248900055885315, -0.29868921637535095, -0.7901449799537659, -0.02094416320323944, 0.2662371098995209, 0.1883033812046051, 0.6780896782875061, -1.2131187915802002, 0.3259791433811188, -0.07124882936477661, -0.7646610736846924, -0.613686203956604, -0.6911770701408386, 0.17195039987564087, -0.024157708510756493, 0.035535573959350586, -0.42520496249198914, 0.2630658745765686, 0.06884889304637909, -0.15712592005729675, 0.26127463579177856, 0.315012127161026, -0.9505099654197693, -0.12584617733955383, 0.49850398302078247, 0.666224479675293, -0.4973883628845215, -0.20502710342407227, 0.5948508977890015, -0.15780359506607056, 0.5282612442970276, -0.786865770816803, -0.6580535173416138, 0.7128790020942688, -0.7245870232582092, -0.14684349298477173, -0.7098947167396545, 0.07667350023984909, 0.09101440757513046, -0.8762881755828857, -0.054827384650707245, -0.02452823333442211, 0.4336220622062683, -0.42401644587516785, -0.3598608374595642, 0.2987194359302521, 0.9001665115356445, 0.06996850669384003, 0.1944005936384201, -0.2531663775444031, -0.03682159632444382, -1.0769872665405273, 1.093204379081726, -0.8702858686447144, -0.42760100960731506, 0.028953785076737404, -0.14473572373390198, -0.4023914635181427, 0.6339260339736938, 0.2305421382188797, -0.3036438524723053, -0.11432647705078125, 0.5860958099365234, 0.4656079113483429, 0.16869638860225677, -0.5215863585472107, 0.37130874395370483, -0.3831721842288971, 0.3538563549518585, -0.23300398886203766, -0.09579359740018845, 0.349071741104126, -0.028310466557741165, 0.16915802657604218, -0.006214608438313007, 0.1579965204000473, 0.9045618176460266, 0.33854353427886963, 0.10661744326353073, 0.29802560806274414, -0.09667621552944183, -0.3375009000301361, -0.8553053140640259, -0.694568395614624, 0.22216881811618805, 0.683608889579773, -0.26482346653938293, 0.533964991569519, -0.24766471982002258, -0.12853294610977173, -0.8233062028884888, 0.28936633467674255, -0.2146310806274414, 0.4140993058681488, 0.1568983942270279, -0.024798426777124405, -0.050975196063518524, -0.49986857175827026, -0.2227964699268341, 0.505501925945282, -0.11212487518787384, 0.15703792870044708, -0.5256090760231018, -0.1697099208831787, -0.721652090549469, -0.9768223762512207, 0.8292837142944336, 0.4018789529800415, 0.22791063785552979, 1.0749132633209229, 0.2573999762535095, -0.3101156949996948, -0.42475321888923645, 0.03941674530506134, 0.5680540800094604, -0.06041568145155907, 0.8884024024009705, 0.4877166152000427, 0.02406899444758892, -0.08497221022844315, 0.20670415461063385, -0.772002637386322, -0.2222519814968109, 0.6843613386154175, -0.7318231463432312, -0.21777483820915222, 0.4452655613422394, -0.014956505037844181, -0.9912221431732178, -0.5335398316383362, -1.4015687704086304, -0.2090027630329132, 0.3549751937389374, -0.9448533654212952, -0.3912825286388397, -0.34598308801651, -0.2860206365585327, 0.10866109281778336, 0.04768861457705498, 0.6474039554595947, 0.5310207009315491, -0.01834346354007721, 0.12209739536046982, -0.43534931540489197, -0.00126332335639745, 1.795802116394043, 0.4041745066642761, -0.7626587748527527, 0.20839300751686096, 0.005067764315754175, -0.46097975969314575, 0.07787328213453293, 1.052154541015625, -0.37558335065841675, -0.06643195450305939, 0.1890951544046402, 0.4265941083431244, 0.13661062717437744, 0.8345217704772949, -0.050364937633275986, -0.023590467870235443, -0.752729594707489, -0.785070538520813, 0.016172289848327637, 0.24553251266479492, 0.5309554934501648, 0.6282473206520081, 0.09466788172721863, -0.1831868588924408, -0.751358151435852, -0.6157376170158386, -0.32022759318351746, -0.4769708812236786, 0.1509164571762085, -0.35460910201072693, -0.4016954302787781, -0.6554140448570251, -0.26918497681617737, 0.16069312393665314, 0.5512788891792297, -0.6326649188995361, 0.6098717451095581, -0.2237747460603714, 0.1783413141965866, 0.042868051677942276, 0.4702082872390747, 0.1993480622768402, -0.4426218271255493, -0.6164267063140869, 0.22654272615909576, -0.01851162128150463, -1.5651297569274902, -0.42396777868270874, -0.37230244278907776, 0.1980484575033188, 1.09306800365448, -0.8311857581138611, 0.7606543302536011, -0.612044632434845, -0.4421963393688202, 0.4490073621273041, -0.31798669695854187, -0.8888682723045349, 0.7463135123252869, -0.8218435645103455, 0.812953531742096, 0.4020213186740875, 0.4338250458240509, -0.8201016187667847, -0.007077604997903109, -0.9154787659645081, -0.07148195058107376, 0.10214542597532272, 0.6336302757263184, 0.14895746111869812, -0.6435257196426392, 0.3848961591720581, 0.0744420513510704, -0.3154408633708954, -0.517745316028595, -0.6013099551200867, 0.7002031207084656, -0.11141939461231232, 0.17031723260879517, -0.35162633657455444, 0.9987510442733765, 0.02876928634941578, -0.010078818537294865, -0.7500569224357605, 0.17964421212673187, 0.452352374792099, 0.5317805409431458, 0.03900504857301712, -0.14328835904598236, 0.14385119080543518, -0.6926659941673279, 0.4718269109725952, 0.2767375409603119, 0.1764548122882843, -0.05427480861544609, -0.2585906684398651, 0.2612551152706146, 0.2079003006219864, -0.040627893060445786, -1.0225975513458252, 1.118324637413025, -0.026770299300551414, 0.011378730647265911, -0.18197396397590637, -0.3200165331363678, -0.4486691355705261, 0.8145677447319031, -0.6232063174247742, -0.7143665552139282, 0.38298195600509644, -0.04975825175642967, -0.24446944892406464, 0.2834474444389343, -0.6602701544761658, 0.29062363505363464, 0.1538645178079605, 0.6071698069572449, 0.9789541959762573, 0.1623033583164215, -0.16303808987140656, 0.3157557547092438, -0.8238572478294373, -0.6283893585205078, -0.7190669178962708, 0.04380147159099579, -1.035226821899414, -0.9305424690246582, -0.2081027328968048, 0.4842274487018585, 0.41988521814346313, 0.3671838939189911, -0.19366158545017242, -0.35296401381492615, 0.5277224183082581, -0.7375947833061218, -0.6045246124267578, -0.19711953401565552, -0.4528958797454834, 0.42398858070373535, 0.018607020378112793, -0.3093770146369934, 0.8254639506340027, 0.41075748205184937, 0.950115442276001, 0.3190501928329468, -0.35576990246772766, 0.9923138618469238, 0.5363317131996155, -0.013692761771380901, 0.5831120610237122, 0.1931810826063156, 0.3531970679759979, 0.5923240184783936, -0.38752949237823486, 0.30096790194511414, 0.6486765146255493, 0.09430970996618271, 0.7056533694267273, 0.07325141131877899, -0.35438552498817444, 0.008274613879621029, 0.40282294154167175, 0.14465360343456268, 0.006275183986872435, 0.1747579723596573, 0.3683842420578003, 0.05297921225428581, -0.16768911480903625, -0.4916883409023285, 0.062529057264328, 0.14078891277313232, 0.2976877987384796, 0.014289782382547855, -0.029533540830016136, -0.753753125667572, -0.2598039507865906, 0.5192925333976746, -0.2346072942018509, -0.7324863076210022, -0.42270493507385254, 0.7702454924583435, 0.3517163395881653, -0.2680074870586395, -0.4992475211620331, 0.9033350348472595, 0.4861936867237091, -0.17889495193958282, -0.24492624402046204, 0.27672892808914185, 0.2137368619441986, 0.546615481376648, 0.5249479413032532, 0.6154999136924744, 0.33966541290283203, 1.1843868494033813, 0.4734354019165039, -1.0885698795318604, 0.518997848033905, 0.3053796589374542, -0.8818426728248596, -0.13254348933696747, -0.24598398804664612, -0.20971214771270752, -0.13377980887889862, -0.3308856189250946, -0.1291990578174591, -0.9810497164726257, 0.17718863487243652, 0.585615336894989, 0.07531449943780899, 0.1363288015127182, 0.13320089876651764, 0.36158111691474915, 0.4540106952190399, 1.0545610189437866, 0.21142075955867767, -0.0028415601700544357, 0.7496517300605774, 0.9267741441726685, 0.6571705341339111, 0.14451099932193756, -0.28371983766555786, 0.4757067859172821, 0.3758312463760376, 0.06408112496137619, -0.5823552012443542, 1.5036232471466064, -0.07411184906959534, 0.5821311473846436, -0.43626609444618225, 0.14915692806243896, 0.046779971569776535, 0.34908002614974976, 0.30526021122932434, 0.24760234355926514, 0.06155644729733467, -0.17046821117401123, 0.6381474733352661, 0.24675507843494415, -0.2062637060880661, -0.4613121747970581, 0.2639205753803253, -0.5361037254333496, 0.2164699137210846, -0.7991715669631958, 0.8100957274436951, -0.04399995505809784, 0.0015050421934574842, 0.12067434191703796, -0.5570360422134399, -0.2977648377418518, -0.7575313448905945, 0.01816079020500183, -0.5828900337219238, 0.34088432788848877, 0.7197011709213257, -0.1671626716852188, -0.013468108139932156, -0.8960326910018921, -0.5954057574272156, -0.06648344546556473, 1.0531054735183716, -0.3936306834220886, -0.14901316165924072, 0.6661804914474487, 0.5139806866645813, -0.7660380601882935, 0.675643801689148, 0.023255735635757446, -0.688514232635498, 0.8481554388999939, -0.40338876843452454, 0.3686263859272003, 0.23728974163532257, 0.16989099979400635, 0.109528087079525, 0.24231365323066711, 0.25411278009414673, -0.02836957387626171, -0.22742928564548492, 0.27812278270721436, -0.28028714656829834, -0.766845703125, -0.5727227330207825, -0.020321886986494064, 0.5356011986732483, -0.20776315033435822, 0.12522830069065094, -1.1256544589996338, 4.1617865562438965, 0.5550627112388611, 0.28839969635009766, -0.27642592787742615, 0.9769819378852844, 0.8218955397605896, -0.36939454078674316, -0.40195393562316895, 0.4041135907173157, -0.33220282196998596, -0.2934046983718872, 0.40982404351234436, -0.04170403257012367, -0.2881580591201782, 0.15422634780406952, 0.3824862837791443, -0.10530059039592743, -0.45732176303863525, -0.5423715710639954, -0.17198431491851807, -1.0954080820083618, 0.12993572652339935, 0.0626465454697609, -0.8408940434455872, 0.29738849401474, 0.41905370354652405, -0.028432881459593773, -0.3526275157928467, -0.8611633777618408, 0.11179908365011215, 0.30623629689216614, -0.7578957676887512, 0.27233362197875977, -0.003931742627173662, -1.1500588655471802, 0.4439846873283386, 0.029749350622296333, -0.37558701634407043, 0.18307526409626007, -0.046291351318359375, -0.08834272623062134, -0.12455650418996811, -0.12694871425628662, -0.4259912669658661, -0.3923148214817047, 1.4628318548202515, 0.42926162481307983, 0.7014682292938232, 0.35891711711883545, -0.6805738210678101, 0.3200972378253937, 0.3233014643192291, 0.6087646484375, -1.0889676809310913, -1.3009642362594604, -0.5612667202949524, 0.308242529630661, 0.17738156020641327, 0.12220797687768936, 0.21015363931655884, 0.6080430150032043, -0.6726003885269165, 0.07708294689655304, 0.3698021471500397, 0.29486000537872314, 0.34810394048690796, 0.83008873462677, 0.4118509292602539, -0.4663195013999939, -0.10155493766069412, -0.6778945326805115, 0.06656500697135925, -0.8184799551963806, -0.6078269481658936, 0.13112525641918182, 0.10751964151859283, 0.40123823285102844, 0.052603211253881454, -0.6447709202766418, 0.4504244327545166, -0.43697303533554077, 0.020107651129364967, -0.26460257172584534, -0.150919571518898, -0.22002293169498444, 1.2535957098007202, 0.2580816149711609, 0.014626369811594486, -0.006667498964816332, 0.5634737610816956, -0.553013026714325, 0.9991016983985901, -0.18026022613048553, -0.06686868518590927, -0.4581642746925354 ]
The Dark Matter Problem in Light of Quantum Gravity
We show how, by considering the cumulative effect of tiny quantum gravitational fluctuations over very large distances, it may be possible to: ($a$) reconcile nucleosynthesis bounds on the density parameter of the Universe with the predictions of inflationary cosmology, and ($b$) reproduce the inferred variation of the density parameter with distance. Our calculation can be interpreted as a computation of the contribution of quantum gravitational degrees of freedom to the (local) energy density of the Universe.
T. Goldman, J. P\'erez-Mercader, Fred Cooper and Michael Martin Nieto
gr-qc astro-ph hep-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210005
gr-qc/9210006
[ -0.2487516850233078, -0.3579617738723755, 0.5927534699440002, -0.27561143040657043, 0.07637222111225128, -0.12027125805616379, -0.3975822925567627, -0.47228002548217773, -1.0875704288482666, 1.4379454851150513, 1.0107944011688232, 0.022672630846500397, -0.6110996007919312, -0.3838587999343872, -0.6881446838378906, 0.4354688227176666, -0.7798553109169006, -0.05216363072395325, -1.768698811531067, -0.05715850368142128, 0.00003347175879753195, 0.24124597012996674, -1.3254317045211792, -0.3884316384792328, -0.6885282397270203, 0.5516362190246582, 0.7258495092391968, 0.3655605912208557, 0.9337058067321777, 0.9934970140457153, 0.9306593537330627, -0.22189727425575256, 0.07590809464454651, -1.0966365337371826, -0.052986081689596176, 0.2469508945941925, 0.6465485095977783, -0.46776074171066284, 0.6913093328475952, -0.7525715827941895, 0.5900262594223022, 0.3444725275039673, 1.0304211378097534, -0.6154573559761047, -0.8905014395713806, 0.023168489336967468, -0.38369104266166687, -0.3703387975692749, -0.3069104254245758, -0.7953298091888428, -0.07903721928596497, -0.17303186655044556, 0.35848256945610046, -0.6008602976799011, -0.10864927619695663, -0.234055295586586, 0.12984907627105713, 0.7157149314880371, -0.19615308940410614, 0.8015372157096863, 0.9622843265533447, 0.20512810349464417, 0.7798628807067871, -0.99239182472229, 0.1485520303249359, 1.0773284435272217, -0.38237854838371277, 0.3262287974357605, -0.2831178605556488, -0.7708606719970703, 0.5364294052124023, -0.82049161195755, -0.32618385553359985, -0.14399175345897675, -0.5175902247428894, 0.8697673678398132, -0.005295592360198498, 0.1922818422317505, -0.33238929510116577, -0.4922811686992645, 0.7127163410186768, -0.3851470947265625, -0.11518595367670059, 0.21490955352783203, 0.1466173231601715, -0.3047794997692108, 0.25875183939933777, -0.025705737993121147, -0.09965832531452179, 0.110965795814991, 0.1288146823644638, 0.7975369095802307, 0.27721700072288513, 0.022581439465284348, -0.09874501824378967, 0.7560743689537048, -0.10240526497364044, 0.6739498376846313, 0.1777227222919464, 0.9747710824012756, -0.30709415674209595, 0.8340418338775635, -0.32205793261528015, 0.4555360972881317, -0.38368117809295654, 0.43360939621925354, -0.2841629385948181, 0.9191493988037109, -0.5247246026992798, -0.9270824790000916, 0.040138307958841324, -0.18807965517044067, -0.010205800645053387, 0.42104604840278625, 0.4682479798793793, 0.7642420530319214, -0.22954803705215454, 0.3344723880290985, -0.48030656576156616, -0.16762688755989075, -0.05905306339263916, 0.4980337619781494, 0.7269461154937744, 0.38319841027259827, 0.47548744082450867, -0.21352483332157135, -0.4689845144748688, -0.20136430859565735, -0.48771432042121887, -0.26049110293388367, -0.20810963213443756, -0.6389955878257751, 0.3037278354167938, 0.2867954671382904, 0.035451605916023254, 0.28303518891334534, 0.09376289695501328, 0.4077446460723877, -0.6763200759887695, -1.0465949773788452, 0.3010827898979187, -0.5779715776443481, -0.0793154165148735, 0.5328905582427979, -0.6742827892303467, 0.6536712050437927, -0.38982781767845154, 0.7224597334861755, 0.03173051029443741, 0.17675013840198517, -0.38259148597717285, -0.5766832232475281, 0.3371819853782654, 0.16761747002601624, -0.8713407516479492, -0.6702638864517212, -0.749159038066864, 0.40691879391670227, -0.9007344841957092, -0.5712141990661621, -0.4309755563735962, 0.08900376409292221, 0.30199941992759705, 0.4650845229625702, -0.11544725298881531, -0.021441856399178505, -0.6201496124267578, -0.901280403137207, -0.11676755547523499, -0.11615502834320068, -0.3408114016056061, -0.09740935266017914, -0.09685724228620529, 0.2572423219680786, 1.2181082963943481, 0.662621021270752, 0.01930377259850502, -0.11509069055318832, -0.22996723651885986, 0.3537897765636444, -0.6039197444915771, -0.5049743056297302, 1.0508689880371094, 0.3747977316379547, -0.5609148144721985, -1.053783655166626, -0.978470504283905, 0.2245970368385315, -0.6715792417526245, 0.4326981008052826, -0.3821132183074951, 0.6422873139381409, -1.336755394935608, 0.8951271176338196, -0.2184939980506897, 0.05851687118411064, -0.8970624208450317, 0.3236542046070099, 0.35394662618637085, -0.5331349968910217, -0.04317464306950569, -0.35046929121017456, -0.9748411178588867, 0.3321843147277832, -1.4069448709487915, 0.5875344276428223, 0.44749608635902405, 0.7018633484840393, -0.40167248249053955, 0.20339971780776978, -0.1724906712770462, -0.43635985255241394, -0.09929285198450089, 0.12065592408180237, 0.17557132244110107, -1.0298737287521362, -0.40660059452056885, 0.5831982493400574, 0.4835423529148102, -0.243294820189476, 0.8782524466514587, 0.05296829342842102, 0.07735685259103775, 0.7045400738716125, -0.1425682008266449, -0.0837506577372551, 0.020195797085762024, 0.7708151936531067, 0.14778056740760803, 0.33066463470458984, 0.4029620885848999, 0.7877166867256165, 0.1013604924082756, 0.14227810502052307, 0.5001426339149475, -0.25688424706459045, 0.8064275979995728, 0.4056881368160248, 0.09245838969945908, -0.18199345469474792, 0.16632212698459625, 0.08313421159982681, 0.6912212371826172, 0.4924468994140625, -0.7800031304359436, -0.046608567237854004, 0.438454806804657, -0.03565419465303421, -0.5070532560348511, 0.8372320532798767, -0.8735911250114441, 0.5064472556114197, 0.4512880742549896, 0.3529384732246399, -0.8157431483268738, 0.08627000451087952, 0.387844979763031, 0.3057916760444641, -0.7596967816352844, -0.8061621785163879, -0.04430941492319107, 0.15648548305034637, -0.010955731384456158, -0.6791999936103821, -0.42566680908203125, 0.3802168369293213, 0.16187821328639984, 0.44925644993782043, 0.3465658128261566, -0.3988918960094452, -0.728198766708374, -0.020145175978541374, -0.37265467643737793, 0.3047988712787628, -0.3997949957847595, -0.14041048288345337, -0.04401993006467819, -0.9375874400138855, 1.2267446517944336, 0.029551688581705093, 0.024527590721845627, 0.7774431705474854, 0.6447368860244751, 0.6848171353340149, -0.815880298614502, -0.5818086266517639, -0.8023666739463806, 0.6734040975570679, -0.44904494285583496, 0.05403190851211548, 0.2664061188697815, -0.40770912170410156, 0.06809480488300323, -0.4817431569099426, 0.1514822542667389, -0.2183217704296112, -0.6730411648750305, -0.03774963319301605, -0.2328784018754959, -0.8688828945159912, -0.08453552424907684, 0.4681303799152374, 0.14769358932971954, 0.43345028162002563, -1.0745728015899658, 1.0769752264022827, -0.13981375098228455, -0.45208072662353516, 0.941468358039856, -0.14430977404117584, -0.628136396408081, 0.14196299016475677, -0.16632378101348877, 0.3134240508079529, 0.0848638266324997, 0.8204108476638794, 0.7351945042610168, 0.05544288828969002, 0.3031739592552185, 0.08062034845352173, -1.2738314867019653, -0.7764332294464111, 0.24508754909038544, -1.271700143814087, -0.14279872179031372, 0.8337119221687317, 0.08621947467327118, -0.9336100220680237, 0.22369444370269775, -0.9593480825424194, -0.8413811922073364, 0.46839311718940735, -0.3010939657688141, 0.5141713619232178, -0.4037206470966339, -0.13904298841953278, -0.3460153639316559, -0.03623991459608078, -0.14955218136310577, 1.1702473163604736, 0.7544410228729248, -0.22279685735702515, 0.4472754895687103, -0.008419639430940151, 0.14079847931861877, -0.05651819705963135, 0.6123059391975403, 0.06179509684443474, -0.40406087040901184, 0.04548519104719162, -0.3845917284488678, 0.11045609414577484, 0.037093061953783035, 0.018352605402469635, -0.11212708055973053, 0.3780253529548645, -0.8398513197898865, -0.00665111793205142, -0.6124653220176697, 0.0005369035061448812, -0.09944812953472137, 0.5621756315231323, 0.1547497659921646, -0.01853995770215988, -0.7817365527153015, -0.4040607511997223, 0.22283263504505157, -0.20875126123428345, 0.36291906237602234, -1.3118866682052612, 0.6020233631134033, -0.32634809613227844, -0.28115934133529663, -0.1029990166425705, -0.2014922797679901, 0.18830803036689758, 0.22493071854114532, 0.7134032249450684, 0.17787505686283112, -0.5860873460769653, -0.4781339168548584, -0.6087490916252136, 0.5075237154960632, 0.37782731652259827, 0.41180551052093506, -0.045339588075876236, -0.018315551802515984, 0.4950719177722931, -0.8672133088111877, -0.497624009847641, -0.3310430645942688, -0.3280823528766632, -0.16255426406860352, -0.8577926754951477, -0.17236001789569855, -0.14574915170669556, 0.7464285492897034, 0.3253397047519684, -0.46149325370788574, -0.26348674297332764, 0.13068237900733948, 0.07063674926757812, -0.11955535411834717, 0.8815639615058899, -0.1728048175573349, -0.003957453183829784, -0.9920271635055542, 0.4933610260486603, 0.30892276763916016, 0.18756835162639618, -0.2826646566390991, -0.35071688890457153, 0.07445001602172852, -0.6292543411254883, 0.7197085618972778, 0.14107874035835266, -0.04313914477825165, 0.14622831344604492, 0.40042659640312195, 0.5722292065620422, -0.483341246843338, 0.5242517590522766, 0.1710871160030365, 0.8740038275718689, -0.30548495054244995, -0.7947793006896973, 0.11025475710630417, -0.1678040623664856, 0.7193602919578552, 0.7119735479354858, 0.23084962368011475, -1.1324214935302734, -0.8586921691894531, 0.2692156732082367, -0.6149619817733765, 0.11189141124486923, 0.7584260106086731, -0.6130653619766235, 0.6574636101722717, 0.2525990307331085, -0.28821873664855957, -0.09181395173072815, -0.18346749246120453, -0.6401667594909668, 0.3645188808441162, 0.16501110792160034, -0.30129343271255493, 0.5869280099868774, -0.11475381255149841, -0.655439555644989, 0.32224833965301514, -0.4455118179321289, 0.7211185097694397, -0.255275160074234, -0.5595929026603699, 0.048355743288993835, 0.3570398986339569, -0.8651939630508423, 0.3268415033817291, 0.22443225979804993, 1.106436014175415, 0.18776431679725647, 0.4564005434513092, -0.5369934439659119, -0.31772559881210327, 0.4499923288822174, -0.17003171145915985, -0.019667809829115868, 0.7864155769348145, 0.46185171604156494, 0.6345530152320862, 0.2217273712158203, -0.7496643662452698, 0.19246481359004974, 0.7860227823257446, -0.6430709362030029, -0.32437586784362793, -0.0017951569752767682, -0.14174196124076843, -0.8316888809204102, -0.1352449506521225, 0.02489476278424263, -0.12226706743240356, 0.945412814617157, -0.08549119532108307, -1.1586123704910278, -0.6085492968559265, -0.2435000240802765, -0.5498841404914856, 0.4607903063297272, -0.3694591224193573, -0.07683435082435608, -0.3365279734134674, -0.13633938133716583, -0.5268823504447937, 0.0506133958697319, -0.2924167215824127, -0.7761595845222473, 0.07189720869064331, 0.03208818659186363, -0.23759622871875763, 0.8584182858467102, -0.2563059329986572, 0.19948527216911316, 0.16695815324783325, -0.6386961340904236, -0.9464792013168335, -0.9545366168022156, -0.22880327701568604, 0.5717947483062744, -0.12608619034290314, -0.5735746026039124, 0.33411645889282227, 0.059637073427438736, 0.3230384588241577, -0.09654359519481659, -0.09225636720657349, -0.6281656622886658, 0.06941944360733032, 0.3014276623725891, 0.27741143107414246, -1.0431567430496216, 0.022877788171172142, 0.336831271648407, -0.6805061101913452, 0.19836649298667908, -0.2192489057779312, -0.569705605506897, 0.5376716256141663, -1.2174148559570312, 0.3131939768791199, -0.8773153424263, 0.12435026466846466, -0.20036344230175018, -0.1661316454410553, 0.10647430270910263, 0.5080708861351013, 0.06520877778530121, -0.29553908109664917, -0.6811119914054871, -0.09838952124118805, 0.08665861934423447, 0.003153230994939804, 0.0819869413971901, -0.543161928653717, 0.09754515439271927, -0.9138949513435364, 0.8752822279930115, -0.8495904207229614, 0.09500458836555481, 0.44997522234916687, 0.15532271564006805, -0.21653658151626587, 0.07703319936990738, 0.21643084287643433, -0.3749370574951172, -0.5610821843147278, 0.10356087982654572, 0.506836473941803, 0.7045984268188477, -0.42007941007614136, 0.055858734995126724, -0.7110223770141602, 0.41949716210365295, -0.07672543078660965, -0.5170935988426208, 0.3089505136013031, 0.30491766333580017, 0.4664989113807678, -0.7403082847595215, -0.2449723333120346, 0.09630664438009262, 1.014381766319275, 0.7320850491523743, -0.33708712458610535, -0.4515927731990814, -0.37945637106895447, -0.9781899452209473, -1.0438346862792969, 0.7486300468444824, 0.4099073112010956, 0.2950637638568878, -0.34681788086891174, 0.03335142135620117, -0.0697493627667427, -0.8774293065071106, 0.024732915684580803, 0.32533353567123413, 0.40093332529067993, -0.5647619962692261, -0.24998468160629272, 0.06192304193973541, -0.7665143609046936, -0.003665186697617173, 0.144029900431633, 0.42290523648262024, -0.0527418777346611, -0.2286563366651535, -0.8865841627120972, -0.7365261912345886, -0.54640132188797, 0.3801732659339905, 0.9385559558868408, 0.5967243909835815, 0.923851728439331, 0.11358052492141724, -0.10326291620731354, -0.13370157778263092, 0.20349538326263428, 0.46152400970458984, 0.16535459458827972, 0.9556638598442078, -0.04103919118642807, 0.0020857423078268766, -0.5555257797241211, 0.5105603933334351, -0.6630601286888123, -0.24105806648731232, 1.1432268619537354, -0.21143002808094025, 0.049325525760650635, 0.41798216104507446, 0.3294808268547058, -0.8311382532119751, -0.9695471525192261, -0.8718135356903076, 0.00768356304615736, 0.3467315435409546, -0.8068464994430542, -0.29053136706352234, -0.04039314389228821, -0.02762005850672722, -0.023842819035053253, 0.52945876121521, 0.1179002970457077, 0.3991449773311615, -0.022209741175174713, 0.13286682963371277, -0.32628703117370605, -0.06175711378455162, 1.4671391248703003, 0.2480708360671997, -1.1096190214157104, -0.4897715747356415, 0.12639664113521576, 0.08274468034505844, 0.010789143852889538, 0.8859574794769287, -0.22568969428539276, -0.4917157292366028, 0.32247453927993774, 0.296156108379364, -0.02878347411751747, 0.7345671057701111, 0.20479893684387207, 0.27927279472351074, -0.5804258584976196, -1.1706852912902832, 0.35629361867904663, -0.010678143240511417, 0.3838476538658142, 0.13859640061855316, -0.10452540218830109, -0.2326471507549286, 0.16243763267993927, 0.27806419134140015, -0.13058485090732574, -0.8737686276435852, -0.3598431348800659, -1.139852523803711, -0.5525205135345459, -1.0642364025115967, -0.03776703402400017, 0.02592218481004238, 0.2841518521308899, -0.33168187737464905, 0.09031076729297638, -0.646300733089447, -0.14627701044082642, -0.00804637186229229, 1.3194133043289185, -0.720109224319458, -0.26744747161865234, -1.427877426147461, 0.44098538160324097, -0.05094918608665466, -0.7358385920524597, -0.6209447383880615, 0.17341561615467072, 0.03437171131372452, 0.9999439120292664, -1.297829508781433, 1.3583440780639648, 0.005996782332658768, -0.06947839260101318, 0.2327503263950348, -0.5738943219184875, -0.7929349541664124, 1.0135736465454102, 0.04731033369898796, 0.4886128008365631, 0.38234004378318787, 0.3784124255180359, -0.2223319113254547, -0.5191891193389893, -1.2412960529327393, 0.43852609395980835, -0.19556431472301483, 0.5917748808860779, 0.41760069131851196, -0.5990873575210571, 0.9209244251251221, 0.0077125211246311665, -1.177335262298584, -0.7861966490745544, -0.20407605171203613, 0.5789880156517029, -0.14212225377559662, -0.05489836633205414, -0.24634988605976105, 0.7804242968559265, -0.19889704883098602, 0.6753187775611877, -0.4019623100757599, -0.5121121406555176, 0.3504715859889984, 0.36318594217300415, 0.4173252284526825, 0.132110133767128, -0.4256235361099243, -0.17794761061668396, -0.39483046531677246, 0.008379251696169376, -0.46066588163375854, 0.04593838378787041, -0.7387405037879944, -0.08865818381309509, -0.4977332651615143, 0.28743618726730347, -0.9983579516410828, 0.3112059235572815, 0.7540246248245239, 0.11226741224527359, 0.015384884551167488, -0.4627383053302765, -0.3308827579021454, 0.5873706936836243, -0.600534200668335, -0.513922929763794, 0.2824283838272095, -0.1969461590051651, -0.156047061085701, 0.354011207818985, -0.8999008536338806, 0.17192678153514862, 0.3242824971675873, 1.1729439496994019, 0.6110334396362305, 0.2732294797897339, -0.8983579874038696, 0.6259176135063171, -0.22560539841651917, -0.9921709299087524, -0.5368510484695435, 0.4433458745479584, -0.903266191482544, -0.6266670823097229, -0.6446885466575623, 0.27915292978286743, 0.17660951614379883, -0.2893316149711609, -0.22880639135837555, 0.4759390652179718, 0.06597629189491272, 0.1788584589958191, -0.25213518738746643, 0.2862624526023865, 0.08708655834197998, 0.5555760860443115, 0.3122354745864868, -0.15587906539440155, 0.0756082758307457, 0.39705121517181396, 1.2948557138442993, 0.07787057012319565, -0.11556974798440933, 0.8869757652282715, -0.01598331518471241, -0.07942696660757065, 0.5884034633636475, 0.42806681990623474, 0.5554189085960388, 0.8788884878158569, -0.23342449963092804, 0.1693311333656311, 0.4556414484977722, 0.33000171184539795, 0.38040995597839355, 0.1283334493637085, 0.15400686860084534, 0.09525369852781296, 0.33837348222732544, -0.17641915380954742, 0.2966086268424988, 0.514602541923523, -0.20369814336299896, 0.027223793789744377, 0.03697261959314346, 0.019832702353596687, -0.1972295641899109, 0.08881516754627228, -0.03295929357409477, -0.08974526822566986, -0.31960025429725647, -0.5500962734222412, -0.2559303343296051, 0.7727025151252747, 0.05857716128230095, -0.47099432349205017, -0.7020131349563599, 0.7130452394485474, -0.3244873285293579, 0.3662303388118744, -0.16263318061828613, 0.3750742971897125, 0.6603320240974426, 0.520335853099823, -1.0147970914840698, 0.5654499530792236, 0.6334217190742493, 0.1459762305021286, 0.39384108781814575, 0.7072784900665283, 0.7036839127540588, 1.049041509628296, -0.33187800645828247, -1.174775242805481, 0.3660498559474945, 0.21942222118377686, -1.050339698791504, -0.42055898904800415, 0.19499287009239197, -0.09287286549806595, 0.07398752123117447, -0.7713363170623779, 0.4051057696342468, -0.45082464814186096, -0.13982290029525757, 0.5337457060813904, -0.21837760508060455, -0.4560520350933075, 0.26880982518196106, 0.23546797037124634, 0.7539141178131104, 0.7348296046257019, 0.28293830156326294, -0.11534781008958817, 0.9123982787132263, 1.273630142211914, 0.2183542102575302, -0.4691466689109802, 0.28634119033813477, 0.7981478571891785, 0.2986348569393158, 0.36760082840919495, -0.5088983774185181, 0.9214150309562683, 0.5295798182487488, -0.42703506350517273, -0.1215994581580162, -0.04899381101131439, -0.220955491065979, 0.1330377757549286, 0.4798336923122406, 0.6715312600135803, -0.15891912579536438, 0.28321897983551025, 0.5103852152824402, 0.03237079456448555, -0.35812005400657654, -0.32181572914123535, 0.5024386644363403, -0.6821998953819275, 0.42836418747901917, -0.9959439039230347, 0.5787490606307983, -0.031845562160015106, -0.12845058739185333, -0.06970438361167908, -0.620921790599823, -0.48806044459342957, -0.9729477763175964, -0.049761515110731125, -0.39234599471092224, 0.20444831252098083, 1.258092999458313, 0.6631470322608948, 0.02754140831530094, -0.8999777436256409, -0.16497333347797394, -0.1556139439344406, 1.2675637006759644, -0.16737569868564606, 0.1334608495235443, 0.5246065258979797, -0.15966735780239105, -0.7476024031639099, 0.781251072883606, 0.6922462582588196, -0.512615978717804, 0.5078205466270447, -0.4501826763153076, 0.5432609915733337, -0.17311634123325348, -0.2112087607383728, 0.5248615145683289, 0.136993870139122, 0.5734192132949829, 0.10220345854759216, -0.7701178789138794, 0.03197557106614113, -0.8342490792274475, 0.2373161017894745, -0.5400394201278687, 0.714813232421875, 0.2527596652507782, -0.706056535243988, -0.3132896423339844, -0.31483590602874756, 3.9866955280303955, 0.7122712731361389, 0.9838786721229553, 0.18498463928699493, 1.3744144439697266, 0.8668538331985474, 0.012105390429496765, -0.1800840049982071, 0.8949573636054993, -0.5622451305389404, 0.3199666142463684, 0.3291504383087158, -0.22337773442268372, -0.026441268622875214, 0.23244240880012512, 0.5719714164733887, -0.27649736404418945, 0.3317936062812805, -0.22526244819164276, -0.6126506328582764, -0.9397695660591125, 0.04923636466264725, 0.4073878526687622, -0.7077764272689819, -0.20877723395824432, 0.11272675544023514, 0.5837896466255188, -0.36771535873413086, -0.5722153782844543, -0.40907227993011475, -0.2637602388858795, -0.8700435757637024, 0.06783311069011688, 0.04296538978815079, -0.8948465585708618, 0.10830171406269073, 0.21466419100761414, -0.13881538808345795, 0.37382036447525024, 0.13244597613811493, 0.2587577998638153, 0.08765485882759094, 0.2708336412906647, -0.03859913349151611, -0.34056657552719116, 1.0758646726608276, -0.37726274132728577, 0.7534417510032654, 0.2876020669937134, -0.8880414962768555, 0.8058890104293823, 0.024315768852829933, 0.7980832457542419, -0.2771473824977875, -0.22745352983474731, -0.5341759324073792, 0.05394082888960838, -0.22891300916671753, 0.21777401864528656, -0.07700837403535843, 0.9614095687866211, -0.37418386340141296, 0.036078568547964096, 0.028457939624786377, 0.660911500453949, 0.15026390552520752, 0.8469491004943848, 0.008097564801573753, 0.03169170394539833, 0.035846199840307236, -0.5547837018966675, 0.0325741283595562, -0.9239266514778137, -0.6637092232704163, 0.37018564343452454, 0.24909289181232452, -0.30116093158721924, 0.4647350013256073, -0.26136574149131775, -0.1358969509601593, -0.16765320301055908, -0.7299872040748596, 0.1291969269514084, -0.0696539357304573, 0.11618639528751373, 1.0948741436004639, 0.19655369222164154, 0.21290436387062073, -0.25525668263435364, 0.005310702603310347, 0.16052311658859253, 0.7757449746131897, -0.041664883494377136, -0.034112539142370224, -0.3408620357513428 ]
The Quantum Mechanics of Closed Systems
A pedagogical introduction is given to the quantum mechanics of closed systems, most generally the universe as a whole. Quantum mechanics aims at predicting the probabilities of alternative coarse-grained time histories of a closed system. Not every set of alternative coarse-grained histories that can be described may be consistently assigned probabilities because of quantum mechanical interference between individual histories of the set. In the quantum mechanics of closed systems, containing both observer and observed, probabilities are assigned to those sets of alternative histories for which there is negligible interference between individual histories as a consequence of the system's initial condition and dynamics. Such sets of histories are said to decohere. Typical mechanisms of decoherence that are widespread in our universe are illustrated. Copenhagen quantum mechanics is an approximation to the more general quantum framework of closed subsystems. It is appropriate when there is an approximately isolated subsystem that is a participant in a measurement situation in which (among other things) the decoherence of alternative registrations of the apparatus can be idealized as exact. Since the quantum mechanics of closed systems does not posit the existence of the quasiclassical domain of everyday experience, the domain of the approximate aplicability of classical physics must be explained. We describe how a quasiclassical domain described by averages of densities of approximately conserved quantities could be an emergent feature of an initial condition of the universe that implies the approximate classical behavior of spacetime on accessible scales.
James B. Hartle
gr-qc hep-th quant-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210006
gr-qc/9210007
[ 0.48230957984924316, -0.5737809538841248, 0.24558478593826294, -0.199999138712883, 0.35252004861831665, 0.21571366488933563, -0.08313806354999542, -0.465803325176239, -0.5156077146530151, 1.4142940044403076, 0.9706462621688843, 0.6987285017967224, -0.4339841902256012, -0.7820638418197632, -0.07717248052358627, 0.5775928497314453, 0.0713704451918602, -0.93895423412323, -1.3924949169158936, 0.3355475962162018, 0.34285983443260193, 0.31222981214523315, -1.7937971353530884, -0.6255252957344055, -0.12078897655010223, 0.4636390507221222, 1.2227550745010376, -0.2992302477359772, 0.9484996199607849, 1.1783431768417358, 0.6362951397895813, -0.4982079565525055, 0.29275521636009216, -0.06033795326948166, -0.29933831095695496, -0.11209402233362198, -0.09048474580049515, -0.40463733673095703, 1.4185142517089844, -0.5613232254981995, 0.911970853805542, 0.2576916515827179, 0.05392121523618698, -0.4612892270088196, -0.8162195086479187, 0.26693403720855713, 0.08378534764051437, 0.21987563371658325, -0.15925943851470947, -1.0562406778335571, -0.17316865921020508, -0.2379891276359558, 0.3265308141708374, -0.6690316796302795, -0.34552469849586487, 0.028057167306542397, 0.41802525520324707, 0.0395275242626667, -0.4681144952774048, 0.12100754678249359, 0.12063272297382355, 0.3425860106945038, -0.07683683931827545, -1.1855591535568237, 0.061109643429517746, 0.44864222407341003, -0.11342820525169373, 0.4466160535812378, 0.10192260891199112, -1.0951112508773804, -0.31630221009254456, -0.43181106448173523, -0.7639232873916626, 0.3142291307449341, -0.30259940028190613, 0.7835121750831604, -0.5707685351371765, -0.271386981010437, -1.027515172958374, -0.02009551040828228, 0.05232180655002594, 0.035020336508750916, -0.4249664545059204, 0.31684502959251404, -0.6113800406455994, 0.10324139147996902, -0.1835567057132721, -0.19494903087615967, 0.19769904017448425, -0.386773020029068, -0.1287258118391037, 0.5790949463844299, 0.32568123936653137, -0.2762027978897095, 0.48692211508750916, 1.0305485725402832, -0.33204934000968933, 1.1361157894134521, 0.20207372307777405, 0.4130275547504425, -0.24254047870635986, 1.4255889654159546, -0.021710529923439026, 1.0002084970474243, -0.8409638404846191, 0.4573479890823364, -0.30199283361434937, -0.14744462072849274, -0.5197209715843201, -0.3349226713180542, 0.32751667499542236, -0.07717007398605347, 0.64754718542099, 0.2074861228466034, -0.03692077472805977, 0.4323313534259796, -0.5316005945205688, -0.42690208554267883, -0.7054832577705383, -0.20562517642974854, 0.5041440725326538, -0.21678771078586578, 0.5222446322441101, 1.0671454668045044, -0.09108203649520874, -0.7269911766052246, -0.1316719949245453, -0.05124009773135185, -0.6177626252174377, -0.13055334985256195, 0.3330540955066681, -1.0431078672409058, -0.11147470027208328, -0.657355546951294, -0.17844121158123016, 0.009585878811776638, -0.5894558429718018, 0.17564505338668823, -0.48300856351852417, -0.35424044728279114, 0.9257823824882507, -0.6417698264122009, 0.7042551636695862, 1.2525213956832886, -0.30543866753578186, 0.853083074092865, 0.03087291494011879, 0.5401260852813721, -0.47183531522750854, 0.13393756747245789, 0.32131028175354004, 0.06130492314696312, -0.19582004845142365, 0.5425874590873718, -0.11906541138887405, 0.2217210978269577, -0.8716016411781311, 0.7190045118331909, -0.8011420965194702, -0.14470314979553223, 0.4188517928123474, 0.1789628565311432, 0.19249708950519562, 1.7791227102279663, -0.5608947277069092, 0.47559458017349243, -0.7190756797790527, -0.06865084916353226, -0.2102517932653427, -0.03931548446416855, -0.26650214195251465, -0.16031138598918915, -0.2589612603187561, 0.4915418326854706, 0.8036571145057678, 0.3006662130355835, -0.47157201170921326, -0.19306346774101257, 0.2876058518886566, 0.5123485326766968, -0.31533053517341614, -1.0374728441238403, 1.0904533863067627, 0.5101005434989929, -0.4983920753002167, -0.4229446053504944, 0.025766341015696526, 0.06483221054077148, 0.28256192803382874, 0.4729529917240143, -1.128179907798767, 0.10041332244873047, -0.4938271939754486, 0.35091572999954224, -0.48964887857437134, 0.31179922819137573, -1.0426268577575684, -0.21171900629997253, -0.6302147507667542, 0.19287298619747162, -0.39513835310935974, 0.050333231687545776, -0.9515416026115417, 0.27586448192596436, -0.9620259404182434, 0.25441011786460876, 0.5042521953582764, 0.37826985120773315, -0.3389446437358856, 0.3869117200374603, 0.7080485820770264, -0.24064500629901886, 0.195291206240654, 0.046370215713977814, 0.41216522455215454, -0.39067742228507996, -0.523118793964386, -0.07998195290565491, 0.3258284330368042, 0.0337214358150959, 1.13105046749115, 0.6025494337081909, -0.04297690838575363, 0.6865290403366089, 0.03132631257176399, -0.37155064940452576, -0.39201632142066956, 1.4261959791183472, -0.39877474308013916, 0.711472749710083, -0.16524863243103027, 0.045095294713974, 0.07956960797309875, 0.4072469174861908, 0.671584963798523, 0.3833443224430084, 0.6089988946914673, 0.9198120832443237, 0.3435826897621155, 0.30705520510673523, 0.6077648997306824, 0.21850189566612244, 0.6731706261634827, -0.2134922444820404, -0.451425701379776, 0.6611351370811462, 0.2218293994665146, 0.352163702249527, -0.298007071018219, 0.9080357551574707, -0.573484480381012, 0.5424538254737854, 0.1962173730134964, 0.18414059281349182, -0.6553617715835571, 0.466644287109375, 0.06470631062984467, 0.5932329297065735, 0.09876665472984314, 0.07711738348007202, 0.19045120477676392, -0.07747995108366013, 0.31087255477905273, -0.378133088350296, -0.42464157938957214, 0.22159484028816223, -0.237435445189476, 0.3830261826515198, 0.7114424109458923, -0.19755405187606812, -0.9458205103874207, -0.12392120808362961, -0.8279497027397156, -0.224617138504982, -0.7752926349639893, -0.02229374460875988, 0.32951703667640686, -0.07869882881641388, 0.4801473915576935, -0.021069495007395744, 0.21773363649845123, 0.16677305102348328, -0.10955701768398285, 0.30888983607292175, 0.7566277980804443, -0.5330305099487305, -0.9145568013191223, 0.3234047293663025, -1.1231786012649536, -0.006498947273939848, -0.09096358716487885, -0.25730836391448975, 0.4627434313297272, 0.29437267780303955, -0.22233515977859497, 0.12731017172336578, -0.5602399706840515, -0.48627912998199463, -0.7192466855049133, -0.21659141778945923, -0.42293888330459595, 0.42403700947761536, 0.39772137999534607, 0.789498507976532, -0.324643611907959, 1.0831595659255981, -0.21803517639636993, -0.5881808400154114, 0.6040454506874084, -0.44626355171203613, -0.7513940930366516, -0.140674889087677, 0.6197916269302368, 0.08972302079200745, 0.13619311153888702, 0.900498628616333, 0.7846645712852478, -0.21052375435829163, 0.1405508816242218, -0.4174831807613373, -0.6157884001731873, -0.10741616040468216, 0.6491074562072754, -0.8236135840415955, 0.3704664409160614, 0.9336826801300049, 0.08262336999177933, -0.671824038028717, -0.06359688937664032, -0.9110002517700195, -0.505751371383667, -0.6146970391273499, -1.0206243991851807, 0.11810891330242157, 0.06740667670965195, 0.191017746925354, -0.0519862100481987, 0.06144978851079941, -0.012206236831843853, 0.412308931350708, 0.2712094485759735, -0.5070639848709106, 0.6978748440742493, 0.05332630127668381, 0.7559024691581726, 0.3570610284805298, 0.31038931012153625, -0.3618418574333191, -0.22269394993782043, 0.4436781704425812, 0.04332595318555832, 0.4658828377723694, 0.5631294846534729, -0.030289599671959877, 0.2797054648399353, 0.00873500481247902, -0.5991531014442444, -0.3439376652240753, -1.2356853485107422, -0.19011539220809937, 0.1751178801059723, 0.7019932866096497, -0.09979961812496185, -0.8592771291732788, -0.6726168394088745, 0.20351918041706085, -0.24670855700969696, 0.5306761860847473, 0.801590085029602, -1.062223196029663, 0.20285125076770782, 0.24416503310203552, -0.10875537991523743, 0.421541690826416, -0.46480992436408997, 0.1544719636440277, 0.3454173803329468, 0.34928402304649353, -0.21510262787342072, -0.637386679649353, -0.5446965098381042, -0.5434741973876953, 0.27138376235961914, 0.04449370875954628, 0.7874298691749573, -0.319924920797348, -0.5110828280448914, -0.024725280702114105, -0.23172330856323242, -0.5483468770980835, -0.10539328306913376, -0.5916816592216492, -0.29176419973373413, -0.48970454931259155, -0.588253378868103, -0.2279476374387741, 0.41114872694015503, 0.3595975637435913, 0.4903070628643036, 0.09065801650285721, 0.31261324882507324, 1.237919807434082, 0.48611146211624146, 0.4741419851779938, -0.6550393104553223, -0.31140080094337463, -0.8448376655578613, 0.9067159295082092, 0.44703683257102966, 0.3245086073875427, 0.07298103719949722, -1.0999131202697754, 0.12106277048587799, 0.19985051453113556, 1.0261675119400024, 0.8235697150230408, -0.3431231677532196, 0.374014288187027, 0.39881712198257446, 0.14144180715084076, -0.328561007976532, 0.32932722568511963, 0.5137687921524048, 0.6692206263542175, 0.25264549255371094, -0.5474956035614014, -0.18922851979732513, -0.3197462856769562, 0.44973239302635193, 0.5075386166572571, -1.0263246297836304, -0.7153310775756836, -0.20483684539794922, 0.875400185585022, 0.10913319885730743, 0.5908412337303162, 0.9691150784492493, 0.0503690168261528, 0.9495243430137634, 0.0013302022125571966, 0.11147614568471909, 0.4798031747341156, -0.6295801401138306, -0.3113209903240204, 0.14915882050991058, -0.21070414781570435, -0.08146955072879791, 0.28488245606422424, 0.3811313807964325, -0.4113432765007019, -0.1393723338842392, -0.22080059349536896, 0.03692862018942833, -0.43467098474502563, -0.2246963083744049, -0.44974803924560547, 0.21661917865276337, -0.2750132977962494, -0.3144979476928711, -0.3750974237918854, 0.17510128021240234, 0.28664177656173706, -0.06349136680364609, -0.28847113251686096, 0.12601988017559052, 0.3415534794330597, -0.33505433797836304, 0.48891356587409973, 0.6176978349685669, 0.061710868030786514, 0.2894733250141144, -0.11137838661670685, 0.18166469037532806, -0.1992570161819458, 0.5820055603981018, -0.4660690724849701, -0.18711155652999878, -0.16806936264038086, -0.36726847290992737, -1.1249282360076904, -0.5229814052581787, 0.38148292899131775, -0.4055180251598358, 0.34014785289764404, 0.423747181892395, -0.9114612340927124, -0.4867308437824249, -0.7809509038925171, -1.2317068576812744, 0.3900204002857208, -0.48695385456085205, 0.023440714925527573, 0.2059919536113739, -0.46709468960762024, -0.17519012093544006, -0.16834890842437744, -1.0698246955871582, -0.3055841326713562, -0.6080352663993835, 0.03233655169606209, 0.06734646111726761, 0.46683377027511597, -0.39303356409072876, 0.28721439838409424, -0.5854238271713257, -0.22324593365192413, -0.8532766699790955, -0.805472731590271, -0.43406355381011963, 0.19774474203586578, -0.18195505440235138, -0.6921339631080627, 0.27498799562454224, 0.36463648080825806, 0.21996475756168365, -0.205430269241333, -0.22671400010585785, -0.6713570952415466, 0.34814685583114624, 1.2151505947113037, 0.4472910165786743, -0.8380100131034851, -0.04960901662707329, 0.21148113906383514, 0.3581850528717041, 1.031723141670227, 0.09580645710229874, 0.3045756220817566, 0.4137241840362549, -1.2559394836425781, 0.5724003911018372, -1.4227451086044312, -0.40469279885292053, -0.13983368873596191, -0.5250049829483032, 0.26170024275779724, 0.12521366775035858, -0.05435134842991829, -0.9835240840911865, -0.5953105688095093, -0.17403732240200043, 0.1407075673341751, -0.9874617457389832, 0.5056463479995728, -0.8203361630439758, -0.30433759093284607, -0.7304983139038086, 0.29996830224990845, 0.06425745785236359, 0.34118443727493286, 0.5762850046157837, 0.07325562834739685, -0.24542935192584991, 0.34608909487724304, 0.26575446128845215, -0.18072572350502014, -0.7456669807434082, 0.047773007303476334, -0.02300843596458435, 0.2018173187971115, 0.14411284029483795, 0.6245174407958984, -0.5073981285095215, 1.0683825016021729, -0.5550323128700256, -0.1316264271736145, 0.01755020208656788, 0.12574836611747742, 0.5690672397613525, -0.7553541660308838, -0.4355292022228241, 0.006029168609529734, 0.21303780376911163, 0.012886839918792248, -0.5996692180633545, -0.8424332737922668, -0.46664974093437195, -0.33215397596359253, -0.17231665551662445, 0.34751468896865845, -0.21604818105697632, 0.16311988234519958, -0.24764087796211243, -0.44094014167785645, 0.20438456535339355, -0.3212422728538513, 0.4016109108924866, 0.5113956332206726, 0.2830162048339844, -0.11378948390483856, -0.9868229627609253, 0.1615789532661438, -0.6751658320426941, -0.042666662484407425, -0.3337983787059784, -0.141169011592865, 0.13401933014392853, 0.16939513385295868, -0.5479811429977417, -0.9301588535308838, -0.4680507779121399, 0.4433475136756897, -0.216496542096138, -0.005681500770151615, -0.018128177151083946, 0.33227965235710144, 0.020418429747223854, -0.753967821598053, -0.15091286599636078, -0.1595289409160614, -0.44106531143188477, 0.6556212306022644, 0.07278759777545929, 0.3689901530742645, -0.320616215467453, 0.39852404594421387, -1.0002344846725464, -0.24298226833343506, 0.8112638592720032, -0.42764291167259216, 0.0816539078950882, 0.4254752993583679, -0.13803263008594513, -0.4590763449668884, -0.8898975253105164, -0.8970285654067993, -0.7774369716644287, 0.029387515038251877, 0.18011474609375, 0.38152483105659485, -0.2853497564792633, -0.0308047104626894, 0.07592736184597015, 0.12606211006641388, 0.21033810079097748, 0.21839101612567902, 0.16440044343471527, 0.10090778023004532, -0.06556402891874313, 0.40621712803840637, 1.2771730422973633, 0.6123060584068298, -1.0511800050735474, -0.2106625884771347, 0.4797893166542053, 0.24484212696552277, 0.043022800236940384, 0.5767289400100708, -0.22891391813755035, -0.045876819640398026, 0.1856643259525299, 0.6635701656341553, 0.2336975485086441, 0.10883471369743347, -0.434609979391098, -0.37300071120262146, 0.030810819938778877, -0.854459285736084, 0.4624081254005432, -0.45129308104515076, 0.42503058910369873, 0.7833586931228638, -0.3807366192340851, 0.22342398762702942, 0.6206870675086975, 0.2281382828950882, -0.024368105456233025, -0.6346997022628784, -0.3614606559276581, -1.612932801246643, -0.596738338470459, -0.8296424150466919, -0.09535623341798782, 0.04512365162372589, 0.2532605230808258, -0.7046768069267273, 0.20680536329746246, 0.16997452080249786, -0.11193355917930603, -0.2027740776538849, 1.0384304523468018, -0.55130535364151, -0.2133510261774063, -0.8401922583580017, 0.08058232069015503, 0.013524161651730537, -0.8489561676979065, -0.6353558301925659, -0.6756191253662109, 0.29912564158439636, 0.6747975945472717, -0.14984451234340668, -0.0008520496776327491, 0.283916711807251, -0.7946329116821289, 0.3309308588504791, -0.410510390996933, -0.6711018085479736, 0.7000418305397034, -0.07381186634302139, 1.0034338235855103, 0.17642205953598022, 0.6019787192344666, 0.27601760625839233, 0.24134279787540436, -0.4758036732673645, 0.23517857491970062, 0.12454839050769806, 0.32712823152542114, -0.28809553384780884, -0.6055634617805481, 0.4323744773864746, -0.5975409746170044, -0.6003186702728271, 0.2925010919570923, -0.13637807965278625, 0.8137575387954712, -0.8134974837303162, 0.1019028052687645, -0.3164180815219879, 0.28667548298835754, 0.25845271348953247, 0.03851819410920143, -0.6377105116844177, 0.009184400551021099, -0.2115139365196228, 0.09672432392835617, -0.1951615959405899, -0.0742015540599823, -0.3401232659816742, 0.04009964317083359, 0.043593451380729675, 0.6039001941680908, -0.33611786365509033, 0.12452571094036102, -0.8017575144767761, -0.2561626434326172, -0.2172153890132904, 0.6019220352172852, -0.4467024505138397, 0.7594744563102722, 0.19539402425289154, -0.6843293309211731, -0.02923441492021084, -0.449621319770813, -0.3415869474411011, -0.18150070309638977, -0.7680360078811646, -0.7044572830200195, 0.11644583940505981, -0.29791805148124695, -0.33534684777259827, 0.6424793601036072, -0.7625102996826172, 0.22567135095596313, 0.4383712410926819, 1.5212231874465942, 0.4257780909538269, 0.11033887416124344, 0.04757796600461006, 0.44505080580711365, -1.2128604650497437, -0.6387484669685364, -0.36099085211753845, -0.25532084703445435, -0.9457324147224426, -0.4980126917362213, -0.33143606781959534, 0.07837343215942383, -0.4074006676673889, 0.0009648595005273819, 0.3617475926876068, 0.056664444506168365, 0.345186322927475, 0.059798840433359146, -0.2827477753162384, 0.9483003616333008, -0.44059550762176514, 0.4356413781642914, -0.24655909836292267, -1.115702748298645, -0.42244797945022583, 0.02549975924193859, -0.016430994495749474, 0.1791226714849472, 0.34317025542259216, 1.2267528772354126, -0.2962615489959717, -0.6416729092597961, 0.4674699008464813, 0.7261896729469299, 0.6916338205337524, 0.6967071294784546, -0.3220558762550354, 0.4369300603866577, 0.4979909658432007, 0.816616952419281, 0.8356603384017944, 0.08110048621892929, -0.4172024428844452, -0.04959479719400406, 0.8866319060325623, -0.36268457770347595, -0.16518782079219818, -0.10582870244979858, 0.5120162963867188, 0.9567118883132935, -0.2960250973701477, -0.34594178199768066, 0.12029599398374557, 0.34264904260635376, 0.7884321808815002, 0.198469877243042, -0.4358538091182709, -0.3065488338470459, 0.17776386439800262, 0.6339804530143738, -0.6270596385002136, -0.8473332524299622, -0.20319972932338715, 0.3018915057182312, 0.04567568376660347, 0.1576557159423828, -0.46335849165916443, 0.6791027188301086, 0.29890307784080505, 0.16709886491298676, -0.009401542134582996, 0.021475834771990776, 0.5582447648048401, 0.5674070119857788, 0.9184465408325195, 0.5127807259559631, 0.03370249643921852, 0.6016730070114136, -0.027014773339033127, -0.5720863938331604, -0.24839474260807037, 0.3723869025707245, -0.9754542708396912, -0.08629178255796432, -0.045322004705667496, 0.0628763884305954, -0.5388436317443848, -0.5950806736946106, 0.28108012676239014, 0.07246813923120499, 0.4630596935749054, 0.024753063917160034, -0.526645839214325, -0.7409789562225342, 0.4199274480342865, 0.13948862254619598, 0.6222726106643677, 0.22618231177330017, 0.32076704502105713, 0.38332557678222656, 0.7357954978942871, 0.6892462968826294, 0.09764213114976883, 0.3212909996509552, -0.2553017735481262, 0.23761603236198425, 0.7878425121307373, 0.2985250949859619, -0.20007197558879852, 0.38400939106941223, -0.6629239320755005, -0.726177990436554, 0.246506005525589, 0.4007259011268616, -0.3084161579608917, -0.10022295266389847, 1.118151307106018, 0.2665034234523773, -0.6266130208969116, 0.4541796147823334, 0.6877333521842957, 0.6786395907402039, -0.29482272267341614, 0.09331410378217697, 0.7539049386978149, -1.4623178243637085, -0.15975421667099, -1.3877182006835938, 0.2632855176925659, 0.45999857783317566, 0.17306090891361237, -0.5028461217880249, -0.3264614939689636, -0.2614453434944153, -1.0900830030441284, -0.03502793610095978, -0.5954998731613159, -0.018162477761507034, 1.0230348110198975, -0.3777271807193756, 0.3133031725883484, -0.8310506343841553, -0.8462294936180115, -0.7892515063285828, 1.1992274522781372, -0.19113337993621826, 0.45951786637306213, 0.9045800566673279, 0.27270644903182983, -0.5912901163101196, -0.009130379185080528, 0.6708879470825195, -1.188339114189148, 0.8510905504226685, -0.6907338500022888, 0.12309866398572922, 0.19781267642974854, -0.3459826409816742, 0.4322962164878845, 0.2340255081653595, 0.6771682500839233, 0.32127654552459717, -0.29867592453956604, -0.010787749662995338, -0.8794885873794556, -0.41660967469215393, -1.1782164573669434, -0.04290005937218666, 0.10969746112823486, -0.31221023201942444, 0.05614516884088516, -0.4859389364719391, 3.9880192279815674, 0.7466146945953369, 1.0600758790969849, -0.15236687660217285, 1.0048578977584839, 1.1512527465820312, -0.4558316469192505, 0.7777394652366638, 0.367970734834671, -0.9450198411941528, -0.057689134031534195, 0.6096371412277222, 0.1927282214164734, -0.413698673248291, -0.16089650988578796, 0.6728034615516663, 0.09675481170415878, 0.036359790712594986, -0.6112861037254333, -0.2087928056716919, -0.9455373287200928, 0.388094961643219, -0.04617198556661606, -0.18906192481517792, 0.23114505410194397, 0.6420087218284607, 0.3385902941226959, -0.9494375586509705, -0.6607136726379395, -0.6246357560157776, -0.377939373254776, -0.3823489844799042, -0.1751561313867569, -0.1496528685092926, -1.24081289768219, 0.24237379431724548, -0.6000591516494751, -0.6773035526275635, 0.3446137309074402, 0.3166227638721466, 0.4017912447452545, 0.04624750837683678, 0.34957149624824524, -0.3938831686973572, 0.12500573694705963, 1.1286762952804565, -0.5039812326431274, 0.8151925802230835, 0.8979369401931763, -0.6320515871047974, 0.21657617390155792, 0.22159869968891144, 0.5701490640640259, -1.345996379852295, -0.04366828128695488, -0.07585491240024567, -0.04121929779648781, -0.10002361983060837, 0.828884482383728, -0.11703533679246902, 0.3001307547092438, 0.03563491627573967, 0.025156740099191666, -0.15244796872138977, -0.10386403650045395, 0.31836259365081787, 0.04893689230084419, -0.17694082856178284, 0.08106137812137604, -0.11748914420604706, -0.42327749729156494, -0.3282754123210907, -0.5990676283836365, -0.4035130441188812, 0.09931429475545883, 0.6353003978729248, -0.08277371525764465, 0.7233754396438599, -0.07470719516277313, 0.7660508155822754, -0.5726894736289978, 0.28979337215423584, 0.46334922313690186, -0.23571936786174774, -0.09631308913230896, 1.1360574960708618, 0.39984238147735596, 0.4068046808242798, -0.5909702777862549, 0.4172235429286957, 0.42488908767700195, 1.2091789245605469, -0.8034346699714661, 0.2326902151107788, -0.6940927505493164 ]
Unitary Equivalence of the Metric and Holonomy Formulations of 2+1 Dimensional Quantum Gravity on the Torus
Recent work on canonical transformations in quantum mechanics is applied to transform between the Moncrief metric formulation and the Witten-Carlip holonomy formulation of 2+1-dimensional quantum gravity on the torus. A non-polynomial factor ordering of the classical canonical transformation between the metric and holonomy variables is constructed which preserves their classical modular transformation properties. An extension of the definition of a unitary transformation is briefly discussed and is used to find the inner product in the holonomy variables which makes the canonical transformation unitary. This defines the Hilbert space in the Witten-Carlip formulation which is unitarily equivalent to the natural Hilbert space in the Moncrief formulation. In addition, gravitational theta-states arising from ``large'' diffeomorphisms are found in the theory.
Arlen Anderson
gr-qc hep-th
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210007
gr-qc/9210008
[ -0.048749200999736786, -0.24484626948833466, 0.3965301215648651, 0.3858885169029236, 0.11981984972953796, -0.09865356236696243, -0.10542819648981094, -0.5237391591072083, -0.996058464050293, 1.5304608345031738, 0.9345986843109131, -0.2952876091003418, -0.4288724660873413, -0.5559312701225281, -0.23911070823669434, 0.43265289068222046, -0.1364859938621521, -0.3904893398284912, -0.877708375453949, 0.2662525177001953, 0.20999817550182343, 0.1619197577238083, -0.9330021739006042, -0.44568926095962524, -0.26555192470550537, 0.7291014790534973, 0.8536489009857178, 0.11763999611139297, 0.9498935341835022, 0.8365435004234314, 0.877861499786377, 0.21854916214942932, -0.45483654737472534, -0.9290834665298462, -0.17282505333423615, -0.356952965259552, 0.39899110794067383, -0.48820266127586365, 1.0058852434158325, 0.24852053821086884, 0.20000892877578735, -0.11312880367040634, 0.1956515610218048, -0.18250834941864014, -0.1696447730064392, -0.5023662447929382, -0.1123557761311531, -0.3077370226383209, -0.03843828663229942, -1.1948288679122925, 0.20521068572998047, -0.07956022769212723, 0.39388611912727356, -0.8925260305404663, -0.5754097700119019, -0.4308450222015381, 0.1435411274433136, 0.2597923278808594, 0.15411482751369476, 0.16551819443702698, 0.17201775312423706, 0.3673105537891388, 0.13617774844169617, -0.9502823948860168, -0.058288171887397766, 0.8618613481521606, 0.06782950460910797, 0.9224629998207092, -0.040981877595186234, -0.5853372812271118, -0.5048215389251709, -0.2694006562232971, -0.5291805267333984, -0.05573350191116333, -0.5662837028503418, 0.15841437876224518, -0.5204739570617676, -0.6056495904922485, -0.6895161271095276, -0.8564221858978271, 0.11752305179834366, -0.22691141068935394, -0.5262503623962402, 0.15305300056934357, 0.08807873725891113, -0.14089788496494293, 0.3514651656150818, -0.4779445230960846, 0.6709133386611938, 0.5118672847747803, 0.25559425354003906, 0.5962135195732117, 0.029398828744888306, -0.7745137214660645, 0.3567817211151123, 0.829188346862793, -0.17428039014339447, 0.592920184135437, 0.35203102231025696, 0.5022261738777161, -0.4542403519153595, 1.0518447160720825, -0.3697934150695801, 0.3625538647174835, -0.27948540449142456, 1.4195514917373657, -0.4564966559410095, 0.14694251120090485, -0.5672938823699951, -0.6536983847618103, 0.4313816726207733, -0.0655067190527916, 0.2896168828010559, 0.5351437330245972, -0.4100121855735779, 0.5783057808876038, -0.7212349772453308, 0.28648126125335693, -0.7723020315170288, -0.47655004262924194, -0.013876376673579216, 0.36908701062202454, 0.8286044597625732, 0.5284113883972168, -0.1301402747631073, -0.8429512977600098, -0.39953309297561646, -0.05022667720913887, -0.28043869137763977, 0.9730134606361389, 0.36827173829078674, -0.2958960235118866, 0.10009816288948059, -0.12144991010427475, -0.047445233911275864, 0.7079530954360962, -0.0354672446846962, -0.2708871364593506, -0.27830660343170166, -0.8373361825942993, 0.11593365669250488, -0.5631814002990723, 0.3980114758014679, 0.8599786758422852, -0.5318190455436707, 0.5069135427474976, -0.23462684452533722, 0.03112613968551159, -0.29686662554740906, -0.21837766468524933, -0.12611784040927887, -0.2727717161178589, -0.14241671562194824, 0.1407531052827835, -0.06061458960175514, -0.01957005448639393, -1.188981056213379, 0.18566738069057465, -0.4971952736377716, -0.4656008780002594, 0.5574400424957275, -0.1760326474905014, 0.10674583166837692, 1.1788990497589111, -0.036706458777189255, 0.4546572268009186, -0.6146611571311951, -0.7124960422515869, 0.4324198067188263, -0.035722970962524414, 0.021766580641269684, 0.27303260564804077, 0.30976665019989014, 0.32453036308288574, 0.5807433128356934, 0.743147611618042, 0.442597359418869, -0.4771781265735626, -0.2760649621486664, 0.1789332926273346, -0.4398937523365021, -0.8224930763244629, 0.35298457741737366, 0.5525913834571838, -0.8477398157119751, -0.6145667433738708, -0.3339889347553253, -0.3921138644218445, 0.5703647136688232, 0.1606796532869339, -0.7250484228134155, 0.3982512950897217, -0.8409647345542908, 0.4066981077194214, -0.6997940540313721, 0.23186443746089935, -1.1813158988952637, -0.15132611989974976, 0.11267731338739395, -0.9230855107307434, -0.2583109438419342, -0.3716731369495392, -0.6745265126228333, 0.019409742206335068, -1.736508846282959, 0.6538457870483398, 0.6279670000076294, 0.7914090752601624, -0.11850597709417343, -0.061274752020835876, 0.5013347268104553, -0.5306796431541443, -0.007051211781799793, -0.24124085903167725, 0.0024486493784934282, -0.2529620826244354, 0.5666539669036865, 0.34345030784606934, 0.5699559450149536, 0.34561747312545776, 0.20593416690826416, -0.035586319863796234, -0.04736971855163574, 0.5152170658111572, 0.0480303056538105, 0.1303606480360031, -0.12092940509319305, 0.5833577513694763, -0.08090995997190475, 0.41483381390571594, -0.08047787100076675, 0.16693110764026642, 0.28774964809417725, 0.6094508171081543, 0.22026129066944122, 0.4089798033237457, 0.8079041838645935, 0.9195565581321716, -0.025972070172429085, 0.16933085024356842, 0.5975120663642883, 0.12158357352018356, 0.412204772233963, 0.1905870884656906, -0.6132422089576721, -0.17592352628707886, 0.5644809603691101, 0.4508408308029175, -0.4225485026836395, 1.3414790630340576, -1.0474305152893066, 0.3354417681694031, 0.7160993218421936, 0.11119797080755234, -0.7837854027748108, -0.04875563830137253, -0.13589809834957123, 0.6753226518630981, 0.17364045977592468, -0.5800486207008362, -0.13938263058662415, 0.40793073177337646, 0.10081851482391357, -0.2880951464176178, -0.543664813041687, 0.37240180373191833, -0.572441577911377, 0.11431516706943512, 0.25532227754592896, -0.03918182849884033, -0.5787131190299988, -0.5147584080696106, -0.5464735627174377, 0.04778425022959709, 0.08656521141529083, -0.27634066343307495, 0.3012387454509735, -0.49717333912849426, 1.3431934118270874, -0.08844995498657227, 0.23783332109451294, 0.2734437882900238, 0.24170812964439392, 0.11854724586009979, -0.14409670233726501, 0.10092544555664062, -0.6037709712982178, 0.49259889125823975, -0.9667677879333496, 0.5140179395675659, -0.3742567300796509, -0.8294755220413208, 0.5192532539367676, -0.3515090346336365, 0.2977580428123474, -0.2375563383102417, -0.26790884137153625, -0.05884489789605141, 0.11133472621440887, -0.4623485207557678, 0.8383339047431946, 0.6788204908370972, 0.06807586550712585, -0.16826654970645905, -1.2991422414779663, 0.9338303208351135, 0.09941969066858292, -0.05999300256371498, 0.5644591450691223, -0.1594887226819992, -0.8188862800598145, 0.7652501463890076, 0.3210747241973877, 0.303603857755661, -0.2194855660200119, 0.5819591283798218, 0.9114914536476135, -0.3665127754211426, 0.23452536761760712, -0.16582509875297546, -0.33852553367614746, -0.25161856412887573, 0.5330622792243958, -0.6245976686477661, 0.49910619854927063, 0.7551599740982056, 0.5367208123207092, -0.4264630675315857, 0.5137467980384827, -1.0430923700332642, -0.7057288289070129, -0.32994866371154785, -0.5056113600730896, 0.02426653727889061, -0.15692149102687836, -0.10282053053379059, -0.1257898360490799, -0.4094465970993042, -0.2373424917459488, 0.636071503162384, 0.7270634174346924, -0.24290086328983307, 0.426347017288208, 0.2319229245185852, 0.40548285841941833, 0.6751364469528198, 0.6493573784828186, -0.13659825921058655, -0.8791534900665283, 0.3188181519508362, -0.33853423595428467, 0.27735549211502075, -0.10319424420595169, 0.0804954543709755, -0.047469399869441986, -0.10627952963113785, -0.2813238501548767, -0.42923271656036377, -0.567258894443512, -0.2454642653465271, -0.09392843395471573, 0.4726639688014984, -0.06637334823608398, -0.40269145369529724, -0.40207841992378235, -0.1556238830089569, -0.4097435772418976, -0.08696296811103821, 0.41165679693222046, -1.0276788473129272, -0.0570913627743721, 0.021999502554535866, -0.15890970826148987, -0.5647647976875305, -0.39563992619514465, 0.6268239617347717, 0.40029284358024597, 0.08992502093315125, -0.022474560886621475, -0.7234772443771362, -0.8470590114593506, -0.5199428796768188, 1.1878347396850586, 0.7583081722259521, 0.6672732830047607, -0.4235086441040039, -0.4438951909542084, 0.04269452393054962, 0.16388969123363495, -0.01651112735271454, -0.5295844078063965, -0.3656980097293854, 0.29372379183769226, -0.4197726547718048, -0.5000104308128357, 0.1954757571220398, 0.054470352828502655, 0.7221800088882446, -0.19003374874591827, -0.12075144052505493, 0.049301423132419586, 0.4212262034416199, 0.4596630036830902, 0.5095585584640503, -0.17887172102928162, 0.02501414529979229, -0.7220404744148254, 0.7414504885673523, 0.21576982736587524, 0.9908832907676697, 0.12064856290817261, -0.07834144681692123, -0.04833047464489937, -0.26434212923049927, 0.778134286403656, 0.380434513092041, -0.472121000289917, 0.7184009552001953, 0.4499521851539612, -0.18998287618160248, 0.09783979505300522, 1.0358306169509888, 0.48101213574409485, 0.3682350218296051, -0.062485869973897934, -1.074507713317871, -0.12201293557882309, -0.1824352890253067, -0.07154438644647598, 0.3687169551849365, -0.47046640515327454, -0.5864839553833008, -0.5679331421852112, 0.16528858244419098, 0.1710328608751297, 0.49613237380981445, 0.9787259697914124, -0.1609988957643509, 0.14778676629066467, 0.15285396575927734, 0.09840536117553711, 0.9110119342803955, -0.6136111617088318, -1.0679587125778198, 0.026548495516180992, 0.34429171681404114, -0.20343270897865295, 0.5810527801513672, -0.451099157333374, -0.8378759622573853, 0.22475802898406982, -0.15580743551254272, 0.7591296434402466, 0.07449953258037567, -1.0872737169265747, -0.1256774514913559, 0.42155712842941284, -0.5768876671791077, 0.14257001876831055, -0.09344140440225601, 0.3782294690608978, 0.2623586654663086, 0.28633230924606323, -0.7079209685325623, 0.4087959825992584, 0.23637822270393372, -0.3177478313446045, 1.131134033203125, 0.5828253626823425, 0.3822598159313202, 1.2253148555755615, 0.3879253566265106, -0.48095542192459106, -0.19803394377231598, 0.41520699858665466, -0.015036542899906635, 0.053732119500637054, -0.05939994007349014, -0.15619565546512604, -0.5427510738372803, -0.3342868685722351, 0.4093303680419922, -0.2680289149284363, 0.3872734606266022, -0.054922301322221756, -1.1824867725372314, -0.3834258019924164, -0.67940753698349, -0.8421106934547424, 0.4130198359489441, -0.2711913585662842, -0.5655204057693481, 0.041967179626226425, -0.3201681971549988, -0.3591230809688568, -0.6499859690666199, -0.5154014229774475, -0.9401594996452332, -0.4203987121582031, 0.7127664089202881, -0.013383249752223492, 0.44069182872772217, -0.46323201060295105, 0.6425625681877136, -0.5003230571746826, -0.6394429206848145, -0.9059513807296753, -0.23971013724803925, 0.28975531458854675, -0.05143347382545471, 0.03913923725485802, -0.13206526637077332, 0.29837530851364136, -0.16668199002742767, 0.46451643109321594, 0.33354076743125916, -0.21244052052497864, -0.519169807434082, 0.2789553105831146, 0.7294910550117493, 0.3617594540119171, -1.108863115310669, -0.24579335749149323, 0.5956685543060303, -0.4873311221599579, 0.511914849281311, 0.3852570950984955, -0.6170111298561096, 0.20742574334144592, -1.0770889520645142, 0.5702146291732788, -0.7932817935943604, -0.1271752417087555, -0.16727380454540253, -0.6957288384437561, 0.020000064745545387, 0.12043026089668274, 0.2684269845485687, -0.4823429584503174, -0.552186906337738, 0.05975070223212242, 0.25609949231147766, -0.27142253518104553, 0.4428337514400482, -0.31402021646499634, -0.08066890388727188, -0.4289795458316803, 0.8311963081359863, -0.46775922179222107, 0.05557507276535034, 0.35028913617134094, 0.15583300590515137, -0.10598032921552658, 0.5216352343559265, -0.06177366152405739, -0.5262854695320129, -0.39316263794898987, 0.18292167782783508, 0.5479003190994263, -0.12833172082901, -0.4410167932510376, 0.9326632618904114, -0.72147536277771, 0.6831132173538208, -0.060938332229852676, -0.5122531056404114, 0.394604355096817, -0.14533866941928864, 0.4301876127719879, -0.7271936535835266, -0.1785350739955902, 0.7706321477890015, 0.34729111194610596, -0.18409331142902374, -0.10922663658857346, -0.5680346488952637, -0.37912237644195557, -1.027398705482483, -0.5731416940689087, 0.2483195662498474, 0.42331185936927795, -0.014741199091076851, -0.11381974816322327, -0.5181983113288879, 0.0030469601042568684, -0.22816705703735352, 0.13875575363636017, 0.43055233359336853, 0.46940815448760986, -0.4367533028125763, -0.47293999791145325, -0.38519591093063354, -1.0210758447647095, -0.04186296835541725, 0.22655625641345978, 0.09852423518896103, 0.08908570557832718, -0.7795962691307068, -0.44962915778160095, -0.1701182723045349, -0.07849694788455963, 0.3813420236110687, 0.2521454095840454, 0.1458057165145874, 0.7378699779510498, 0.14324356615543365, -0.596650242805481, -0.22588467597961426, -0.02673695795238018, 0.2657681107521057, -0.026453811675310135, 0.5750042796134949, 0.17685994505882263, 0.5595637559890747, -0.24405744671821594, -0.0960402637720108, -0.772333025932312, -0.25966784358024597, 0.9355097413063049, -0.5942617058753967, -0.17943471670150757, 0.8083345890045166, -0.18468303978443146, -0.15290920436382294, -1.1381433010101318, -0.5837781429290771, -0.3796754777431488, 0.3337212800979614, -0.5561299920082092, 0.04142209142446518, -0.07454469799995422, -0.2981603741645813, -0.0009758132509887218, 0.1949298083782196, 0.5150256156921387, 0.46303850412368774, 0.2712387442588806, -0.3451608121395111, -0.4192437529563904, -0.13150598108768463, 1.4745314121246338, -0.14518794417381287, -0.3878941237926483, -0.25539058446884155, 0.028661414980888367, -0.31269484758377075, -0.3025946319103241, 0.7722426652908325, -0.5187522172927856, 0.03289581835269928, -0.17603307962417603, 0.16603325307369232, 0.38082510232925415, 0.8004083633422852, -0.05566122755408287, -0.06482931971549988, -0.22313867509365082, -0.6220415830612183, 0.3041173815727234, 0.7343840599060059, 0.14262616634368896, 0.38245323300361633, -0.08775186538696289, -0.23801811039447784, -0.23869165778160095, -0.19681641459465027, -0.09192954003810883, -0.9059366583824158, -0.4604124128818512, -0.9255300164222717, -0.5853357315063477, -1.421582818031311, -0.6382524371147156, 0.15521271526813507, 0.7190555930137634, -0.6075502634048462, 0.7572034001350403, -0.6467351913452148, 0.47913849353790283, 0.3538453280925751, 0.7241719961166382, -0.8281381130218506, -0.522668182849884, -0.7966228723526001, 0.24928680062294006, 0.027403179556131363, -1.06572425365448, -0.910463273525238, -0.2135777771472931, 0.23184965550899506, 0.42745885252952576, -0.6459866762161255, 0.761406660079956, -0.4344557225704193, -0.7452874183654785, 0.384371817111969, 0.2963523268699646, -1.0362886190414429, 1.4978774785995483, -0.10265757888555527, 0.2731527090072632, 0.4503803253173828, 0.4123820662498474, -0.17183251678943634, -0.18567624688148499, -0.723551869392395, 0.43636295199394226, 0.030950648710131645, 0.4819413721561432, 0.6427531242370605, -0.8413493037223816, -0.006682958919554949, -0.4642398953437805, -0.8542577028274536, 0.09652949124574661, -0.5391310453414917, 0.9074775576591492, 0.038336046040058136, -0.1525578647851944, 0.01792200654745102, -0.09045669436454773, -0.019637513905763626, 0.7023197412490845, -0.9086140394210815, -0.02152264304459095, 0.24648040533065796, 0.4425671398639679, -0.07555755227804184, -0.22546762228012085, 0.422984778881073, -0.3760621249675751, 0.6645189523696899, 0.06556812673807144, -0.35844606161117554, 0.09944215416908264, -0.579725980758667, 0.19111768901348114, -0.7037327289581299, -0.3293363153934479, -0.6384897232055664, 0.8644629716873169, 0.3819485604763031, 0.33439725637435913, 0.5276618003845215, -0.7246872782707214, -0.8280170559883118, 0.2610000967979431, -0.22224001586437225, -0.9270065426826477, 0.34570202231407166, 0.14093641936779022, -0.03634771704673767, 0.6688476800918579, -0.9810777306556702, 0.3442856967449188, 0.1821894496679306, 0.5801448822021484, 0.8675341010093689, 0.031013045459985733, -0.33118683099746704, -0.018260419368743896, -0.5741664171218872, -0.2454645335674286, -0.42186763882637024, 0.26024186611175537, -0.9411177635192871, -0.784570574760437, -0.027397114783525467, 0.16561879217624664, -0.030748752877116203, -0.27957651019096375, -0.04827209934592247, 0.25776493549346924, 0.029010461643338203, -0.7619746327400208, 0.07054115831851959, -0.06805136799812317, -0.5109650492668152, 0.6260120868682861, 0.19151003658771515, -0.492942750453949, 0.7758594155311584, -0.12485228478908539, 0.3923492133617401, 0.3176772892475128, 0.11534612625837326, 0.5099997520446777, 0.3468579351902008, -0.40149909257888794, 0.5995728373527527, 0.15247982740402222, 0.360744446516037, 0.34758269786834717, -0.44567540287971497, 0.2272549867630005, 0.31135332584381104, 0.6887797117233276, 0.7309879660606384, -0.21892915666103363, 0.05886001139879227, 0.6306913495063782, 0.3138415217399597, -0.029541775584220886, 0.11850836873054504, 0.16239047050476074, 0.07677385210990906, 0.41879114508628845, 0.1176055446267128, -0.11276575177907944, -0.5550294518470764, 0.34519219398498535, 0.2031194418668747, -0.20754192769527435, 0.041551604866981506, -0.6002248525619507, 0.7821584939956665, 0.5294331908226013, -0.16254152357578278, -0.6818222999572754, -0.3304678499698639, 0.29549291729927063, 0.1638919711112976, -0.34982535243034363, -0.32213109731674194, 0.392553448677063, 0.4603520631790161, 0.18707725405693054, -0.5125548839569092, 0.5408395528793335, 0.132073312997818, 0.11379624903202057, 0.858365535736084, 0.38820621371269226, 0.9422153830528259, 0.4446338713169098, 0.16405294835567474, -0.46016931533813477, -0.269833505153656, -0.08413209766149521, -0.8069082498550415, 0.25307703018188477, -0.02085106633603573, -0.27886247634887695, -0.2019028514623642, -0.9401214718818665, 0.02067743055522442, -0.15226855874061584, 0.3751833140850067, 0.12462560832500458, -0.5510040521621704, -0.26473119854927063, 0.8422778844833374, 0.3784577548503876, 0.24123959243297577, 0.5135459899902344, -0.02580541931092739, 0.12713365256786346, 0.8557746410369873, 0.7851687073707581, 0.028929051011800766, 0.17961932718753815, -0.12665075063705444, 0.2201584428548813, 0.5186932682991028, 0.5894256234169006, -0.04206288605928421, 0.8399174809455872, -0.627316415309906, 0.5172167420387268, 0.07822611927986145, -0.006176729686558247, -0.6839322447776794, 0.0773315578699112, 0.031252384185791016, 0.9443507790565491, -0.10584449023008347, -0.048980485647916794, 0.9077820777893066, 1.0657734870910645, 0.0858638733625412, -0.4103100299835205, 0.47637370228767395, -1.0533736944198608, -0.3733328878879547, -1.1033167839050293, 0.5871909260749817, 0.10011745244264603, 0.17138135433197021, -0.6766466498374939, -0.43344250321388245, -0.8348227739334106, -0.5698325037956238, -0.3476301431655884, -0.3843407928943634, 0.48759791254997253, 0.6357605457305908, -0.16919176280498505, -0.26630720496177673, -0.49563759565353394, -0.48874884843826294, -0.4419115483760834, 1.0709232091903687, 0.28943735361099243, -0.5674144625663757, 0.20207732915878296, 0.047558847814798355, -0.8706008195877075, 0.6369913816452026, 0.5122262835502625, -0.5448306202888489, 1.0266973972320557, -0.2363186925649643, 0.29587462544441223, 0.0956713855266571, -0.1391870081424713, 0.19718541204929352, -0.06715183705091476, 0.34803417325019836, 0.5620012879371643, -1.1265372037887573, 0.18553027510643005, -0.25641971826553345, 0.08742469549179077, -0.09737048298120499, 0.13997066020965576, 0.4497894048690796, -0.18342900276184082, 0.10268519073724747, -0.4941723048686981, 4.219006538391113, 0.6188763380050659, 0.10528116673231125, -0.09082469344139099, 1.2592607736587524, 0.9852742552757263, 0.20085358619689941, -0.30163419246673584, 0.24552422761917114, -0.6857576370239258, -0.28694358468055725, 0.6011252403259277, 0.048310428857803345, 0.15792487561702728, 0.022852180525660515, 0.6483144164085388, -0.022353753447532654, -0.7081730365753174, -0.6228457093238831, -0.6255698800086975, -0.8764234781265259, 0.5835888981819153, 0.33985191583633423, -0.07583501935005188, 0.26303631067276, 0.7987833619117737, 0.4122110903263092, -0.2355746477842331, -0.6236386895179749, -0.16808508336544037, -0.12443128228187561, -0.6170328259468079, -0.3165307641029358, -0.19578933715820312, -1.6178052425384521, 0.1548401564359665, 0.06676411628723145, -0.5620608329772949, 0.16542647778987885, -0.09633015096187592, 0.26851344108581543, -0.3365136682987213, 0.058258239179849625, 0.1081489697098732, -0.32401949167251587, 0.9894442558288574, 0.14859698712825775, 0.9165133237838745, 0.5179784297943115, -0.9002507328987122, 0.3650702238082886, 0.8042684197425842, 0.43621739745140076, -0.4224663972854614, -0.801295280456543, -0.41269391775131226, 0.11975286155939102, -0.05364328622817993, 0.22853899002075195, 0.25913339853286743, 0.5057750344276428, -0.6973382830619812, -0.007501943036913872, 0.3121902346611023, 0.17595258355140686, 0.32179322838783264, 0.5275800228118896, 0.0518738217651844, -0.12692075967788696, -0.4181833863258362, -0.7380412220954895, -0.12189878523349762, -0.81916344165802, -1.0920172929763794, 0.14423905313014984, 0.21291711926460266, -0.02611456625163555, 0.5977749228477478, -0.1369582861661911, 0.20102664828300476, -0.5541378855705261, -0.31557849049568176, 0.112053781747818, 0.46347516775131226, -0.17080239951610565, 0.42609190940856934, 0.2933322489261627, 0.3399474024772644, -0.8215247392654419, 0.32658645510673523, -0.23148268461227417, 0.39259839057922363, -0.18635882437229156, -0.09040331840515137, -0.7001324892044067 ]
Dynamical Origin of the Lorentzian Signature of Spacetime
It is suggested that not only the curvature, but also the signature of spacetime is subject to quantum fluctuations. A generalized D-dimensional spacetime metric of the form $g_{\mu \nu}=e^a_\mu \eta_{ab} e^b_\nu$ is introduced, where $\eta_{ab} = diag\{e^{i\theta},1,...,1\}$. The corresponding functional integral for quantized fields then interpolates from a Euclidean path integral in Euclidean space, at $\theta=0$, to a Feynman path integral in Minkowski space, at $\theta=\pi$. Treating the phase $e^{i\theta}$ as just another quantized field, the signature of spacetime is determined dynamically by its expectation value. The complex-valued effective potential $V(\theta)$ for the phase field, induced by massless fields at one-loop, is considered. It is argued that $Re[V(\theta)]$ is minimized and $Im[V(\theta)]$ is stationary, uniquely in D=4 dimensions, at $\theta=\pi$, which suggests a dynamical origin for the Lorentzian signature of spacetime.
J. Greensite
gr-qc hep-th
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210008
gr-qc/9210009
[ 0.661898672580719, 0.5227474570274353, 0.29564470052719116, -0.09681613743305206, 0.20371787250041962, 0.13718031346797943, 0.6664776802062988, -0.6676234602928162, -0.5882360339164734, 1.3264976739883423, 0.4832043945789337, 0.22752521932125092, -0.08130776137113571, -0.9905276894569397, 0.3446887731552124, 0.2503650188446045, -0.3082245886325836, -0.5640704035758972, -1.6230696439743042, 0.09185556322336197, 0.19003167748451233, 0.335750013589859, -0.7184712886810303, -1.191474199295044, -0.2145136147737503, 0.068634532392025, 0.8792737126350403, -0.08371276408433914, 1.0650392770767212, 0.7963026762008667, 0.5863889455795288, 0.189980149269104, -0.13923536241054535, -0.5865458846092224, -0.24065449833869934, -0.17242565751075745, 0.0419284887611866, -0.6931582689285278, 0.5510088205337524, -0.2650008201599121, 0.7650066018104553, -0.5332473516464233, 0.3386857509613037, -0.06967490911483765, -0.2409527450799942, 0.15499699115753174, 0.4010157287120819, -0.14037814736366272, -0.14085480570793152, -1.0288722515106201, -0.22727344930171967, 0.017666740342974663, 0.10799139738082886, -1.174788475036621, -0.05403931811451912, 0.04894635081291199, -0.2141377329826355, -0.29375120997428894, -0.1453726440668106, 0.56720370054245, -0.04265136644244194, 0.5001824498176575, 0.17668868601322174, -1.0823546648025513, -0.21790631115436554, 0.635269820690155, -0.3118268549442291, 0.6180098056793213, 0.19296084344387054, -0.5349985957145691, -0.44623032212257385, -0.055798206478357315, -0.21809186041355133, 0.3662041127681732, -0.4640902280807495, 1.1382442712783813, -0.01662367582321167, -0.8967260718345642, -0.6334859132766724, -0.9014180302619934, -0.05184653028845787, -0.27528318762779236, 0.26826974749565125, 0.4616920053958893, -0.7567276954650879, -0.5314884781837463, -0.10681197792291641, -0.8328306078910828, 0.517614483833313, -0.27503451704978943, -0.14926284551620483, 0.5332275629043579, -0.1261281967163086, -0.4916769564151764, 0.5191704630851746, 0.33790722489356995, -0.2648048996925354, 0.6721938252449036, 0.3122038245201111, 0.09533054381608963, -0.6409283876419067, 1.2733995914459229, -0.5221166014671326, 0.6191878914833069, -1.1263391971588135, 1.268728256225586, -0.3031923472881317, 0.06113096699118614, 0.41509872674942017, -0.8271155953407288, 0.6658455729484558, 0.38110649585723877, -0.17930926382541656, 0.23145949840545654, 0.5329822301864624, 0.3531603217124939, -0.07517431676387787, 0.03167121112346649, -0.29909271001815796, -0.7809237241744995, 0.1310972422361374, 0.13762018084526062, -0.16495366394519806, 0.9533973932266235, -0.5584654808044434, -0.4736293852329254, 0.18735156953334808, 0.012908803299069405, -1.0546255111694336, 0.9532524943351746, 0.6751807332038879, -0.5311216115951538, 0.3808150589466095, 0.19569213688373566, 0.4157436490058899, 0.6949850916862488, -0.20130635797977448, 0.2779700458049774, -0.4456561207771301, -0.462799996137619, 0.19501401484012604, -0.7648046612739563, 0.8342560529708862, 1.0734307765960693, -0.48893222212791443, 0.8500832915306091, 0.4005342721939087, -0.14759257435798645, -0.6964368224143982, -0.0017933800118044019, -0.17434987425804138, 0.008645560592412949, 0.12103801220655441, 0.9644715785980225, 0.4605553150177002, -0.3223346173763275, -0.7606317400932312, -0.05807831883430481, -0.4807776212692261, 0.23302190005779266, 0.26784226298332214, -0.3393681049346924, 0.6841987371444702, 1.217613697052002, -0.39107218384742737, 0.5494200587272644, -0.6375336647033691, -0.7148801684379578, 0.16558898985385895, 0.11604530364274979, -0.507973849773407, 0.14795619249343872, 0.5932726860046387, 0.216652512550354, 1.158207893371582, 0.605209469795227, -0.04414287954568863, -0.3245326280593872, -0.28920552134513855, 0.7107250094413757, 0.47495850920677185, -0.8253280520439148, -0.01124451495707035, 0.586114764213562, -0.7981871962547302, -0.26455822587013245, -0.05231868103146553, -0.357393354177475, 0.4801361560821533, 0.004367474000900984, -0.8032326698303223, 0.8201324939727783, -0.7281647324562073, 0.012265900149941444, -0.11069782823324203, 0.12630325555801392, -0.6404677629470825, -0.0005375571781769395, -0.36856114864349365, -0.20929542183876038, -0.02391268126666546, -0.43804416060447693, -0.47380712628364563, 0.0627133846282959, -1.9314992427825928, 0.4221901297569275, 0.34595438838005066, 0.6062104105949402, 0.02487115189433098, -0.1494259536266327, 0.8861793875694275, -0.43352776765823364, 0.04947903752326965, -0.055511366575956345, 0.45534488558769226, 0.8108591437339783, 0.5376396775245667, 0.17602330446243286, 0.014962074346840382, -0.15553075075149536, 0.30572840571403503, 0.2048797458410263, 0.16343475878238678, 0.867702305316925, 0.10288967937231064, -0.25438669323921204, 0.12485922873020172, 0.901142418384552, -0.34494662284851074, 0.22237662971019745, -0.26772478222846985, -0.6669378280639648, 0.45397546887397766, -0.014299575239419937, 0.7199574112892151, -0.0503619946539402, 0.6063892841339111, 0.9472429752349854, 0.5414620637893677, 0.5931086540222168, 0.581922173500061, 0.4695532023906708, 0.7577375173568726, 0.24826668202877045, -0.5765202045440674, -0.23317427933216095, 0.4116922616958618, 0.2630408704280853, -0.5896874666213989, 0.9691089987754822, -0.6777670383453369, 0.3643482029438019, 0.06010700762271881, 0.004488757811486721, -1.2155649662017822, 0.14973889291286469, 0.41761618852615356, -0.19954246282577515, 0.34560757875442505, -0.520247757434845, -0.38270145654678345, -0.09536229074001312, -0.6781774759292603, -0.13477970659732819, -0.1937965452671051, 0.791333019733429, -0.8312886357307434, -0.27785465121269226, 0.5912960171699524, -0.4374949634075165, -0.9952898025512695, 0.15288236737251282, -0.8473002910614014, 0.41128090023994446, -0.4476815164089203, -0.3739722967147827, 0.30566444993019104, -0.6165709495544434, 0.8490427136421204, -0.04046110808849335, 0.4938730001449585, 0.06094342842698097, 0.05931701511144638, 0.24727976322174072, -0.17416688799858093, 0.309896856546402, -0.9887261986732483, 0.21881386637687683, -1.1756062507629395, 0.8822933435440063, -0.19349761307239532, -0.9567270874977112, 0.29404887557029724, -0.3027883768081665, 0.098295658826828, 0.09335916489362717, 0.1949959099292755, 0.17202125489711761, -0.6173540353775024, -0.8439798951148987, -0.004456020891666412, 0.16363398730754852, -0.023533111438155174, 0.25678765773773193, -0.7828517556190491, 0.8186150193214417, 0.01613653637468815, -0.12045547366142273, 0.48268669843673706, -0.0672474056482315, -1.0214207172393799, 0.9886772036552429, 0.5723899006843567, 0.6212986707687378, -0.6085749268531799, 0.6365585923194885, 0.7596697807312012, 0.10933450609445572, -0.11441224068403244, -0.5339905619621277, 0.17153377830982208, -0.3137717843055725, 0.6112865805625916, -1.0447269678115845, 0.04999890178442001, 0.7973765134811401, 0.38933810591697693, -0.5881258845329285, 0.42802494764328003, -0.8299278020858765, -0.6088109612464905, -0.42727795243263245, 0.07406093925237656, -0.06392433494329453, -0.3558460474014282, 0.21405433118343353, -0.032222501933574677, -0.5096947550773621, 0.2578418552875519, 0.32180413603782654, 0.6919444799423218, -0.4861942529678345, 0.6006993651390076, 0.2852497696876526, 0.468406081199646, -0.056954044848680496, 0.4120219647884369, -0.35855570435523987, -0.20255693793296814, 0.1882171779870987, -0.2628830075263977, -0.41627252101898193, 0.40562185645103455, -0.07318903505802155, 0.36709219217300415, 0.08381692320108414, -0.4491344392299652, -0.5778635740280151, -0.5275362730026245, 0.009982145391404629, -0.02129502035677433, 0.9508427977561951, 0.471152126789093, -1.377048373222351, -0.4483324885368347, 0.28403499722480774, -0.5421757698059082, 0.09595182538032532, 0.3310944437980652, -1.0178650617599487, 0.306467205286026, 0.3078373968601227, -0.25514036417007446, -0.44024181365966797, -0.3700767457485199, 0.6027835011482239, 0.8695343136787415, 0.4611422121524811, 0.24135656654834747, -0.11734101921319962, -0.5067082047462463, -0.11567094177007675, 1.085739016532898, -0.3371676206588745, 1.1275732517242432, 0.27217718958854675, -0.4149986207485199, -0.09924021363258362, -0.21420882642269135, -0.9556655287742615, -0.2917303144931793, -0.5909965634346008, 0.27797627449035645, -0.45619964599609375, -0.5928006768226624, 0.19295670092105865, 0.21570292115211487, 0.36246657371520996, -0.37935882806777954, -0.17050224542617798, -0.32085004448890686, 0.5959481000900269, 0.35539811849594116, 0.5382956862449646, -0.4378178119659424, -0.1402561217546463, -0.2221977412700653, 0.48994794487953186, 0.5013678073883057, 0.490923136472702, 0.446849524974823, -0.818498432636261, -0.3451690971851349, -0.04386252164840698, 0.5801252722740173, 0.6561406850814819, -0.509218692779541, 0.6034045815467834, 0.3333434462547302, 0.03671973943710327, -0.4424956440925598, 0.12127478420734406, 0.3115929663181305, 0.5945698618888855, 0.13685205578804016, -0.43268609046936035, 0.05776550993323326, -0.2664225101470947, 0.3833944797515869, 0.07603860646486282, -0.44037649035453796, -0.23376381397247314, -0.18347768485546112, 0.28470516204833984, 0.28743964433670044, 0.8337669372558594, 0.5826053619384766, 1.2925628423690796, -0.008011055178940296, 0.24938590824604034, -0.10693007707595825, 1.1699233055114746, -0.8917748928070068, -0.5341406464576721, -0.05777202919125557, -0.14271046221256256, -0.5380333065986633, 0.49928534030914307, -0.09455808997154236, -0.8153086304664612, -0.04260195791721344, -0.017562173306941986, 0.6617201566696167, -0.14036697149276733, -0.550971508026123, 0.3918103873729706, -0.04873966798186302, 0.3767510950565338, 0.4607507288455963, 0.12740816175937653, -0.5356883406639099, -0.20659881830215454, 0.007392099592834711, -0.521129846572876, 0.13869675993919373, 0.2977202832698822, -0.5297337174415588, 1.035009503364563, 1.1245105266571045, 0.19953155517578125, 0.35662734508514404, -0.058637816458940506, -0.5343924164772034, -0.45836544036865234, 0.8302316665649414, -0.2847635746002197, -0.1415662318468094, 0.13032352924346924, -0.34811046719551086, -0.7890403866767883, 0.14337299764156342, 0.3629303276538849, -0.2824256420135498, -0.227484792470932, -0.061708882451057434, -0.858970046043396, -0.13245344161987305, -0.5486255288124084, -0.38227608799934387, 0.4602751135826111, 0.198258638381958, -0.47854235768318176, -0.18475525081157684, -0.4126914143562317, 0.6111906170845032, -0.7219666838645935, -0.33948394656181335, -0.443038672208786, 0.07280650734901428, 0.2572137117385864, 0.10935677587985992, 0.23942255973815918, -0.08398439735174179, 0.2743103802204132, -0.7762021422386169, -0.5760387778282166, -0.45127546787261963, -0.7803898453712463, -0.10104016959667206, 0.24302026629447937, 0.384207546710968, -0.3481937050819397, 0.023746799677610397, 0.32111650705337524, 0.30638831853866577, 0.7107667326927185, -0.01853640377521515, -0.7748836874961853, -0.03890911117196083, 0.48951518535614014, 0.05761002004146576, -0.8884437084197998, 0.26130715012550354, 0.379782497882843, 0.2804226875305176, 0.11963551491498947, -0.24582438170909882, -0.058837827295064926, 0.004271139856427908, -1.1889057159423828, 0.29426589608192444, -0.678675651550293, -0.7613388299942017, -0.26179856061935425, -0.9185479879379272, 0.4697825610637665, -0.06375790387392044, -0.09577629715204239, -0.5931487083435059, -0.3428223133087158, -0.24796682596206665, 0.5248333811759949, -0.6177976727485657, 0.27827489376068115, -1.2454845905303955, -0.3647487759590149, -0.5508441925048828, 0.8909211158752441, -0.11219329386949539, 0.29518163204193115, 0.28133687376976013, 0.01661006174981594, -0.028574248775839806, 0.33544865250587463, -0.04656976833939552, 0.15694868564605713, -0.9536694288253784, -0.09308309853076935, 0.5914118885993958, -0.37141233682632446, -0.016767824068665504, 0.3039814829826355, -0.38222798705101013, 0.5481148958206177, 0.08889900892972946, -0.03046460822224617, 0.4096163809299469, -0.7136218547821045, 0.426379531621933, -0.15094488859176636, -0.0844331681728363, 0.5209124088287354, 0.35005924105644226, -0.1226649209856987, -0.7418319582939148, -0.48114603757858276, 0.32922831177711487, -0.7751966714859009, -0.39857548475265503, 0.37008601427078247, 0.2742513120174408, -0.031370609998703, -0.3937271535396576, -0.6434077620506287, 0.37265080213546753, -0.22898010909557343, 0.2874545454978943, 0.337614506483078, 0.010229308158159256, 0.41050925850868225, -0.9155446290969849, 0.20121319591999054, -0.10593507438898087, -0.32857877016067505, 0.0865965485572815, -0.15163372457027435, 0.24733299016952515, 0.03243178129196167, -0.1125541552901268, -0.367388516664505, -0.3452782928943634, 0.7169743776321411, 0.14946319162845612, -0.3982565999031067, 0.798710286617279, -0.07589055597782135, -0.1756734549999237, -0.1922018676996231, -0.1550115942955017, -0.037027757614851, 0.27824580669403076, -0.05904175341129303, 0.22870057821273804, 0.5787851214408875, 0.5674931406974792, 0.03368191421031952, -0.4840359389781952, 0.06914690136909485, 0.7335301041603088, -0.45062658190727234, 0.46882933378219604, 0.21813225746154785, -0.23651471734046936, -0.4290277063846588, -0.7721685767173767, -0.3461746871471405, -0.014085223898291588, 0.05153633654117584, -0.24965029954910278, 0.40376123785972595, 0.14140139520168304, -0.09209761023521423, -0.1662939339876175, 0.3046940267086029, 0.47368836402893066, 0.8307647109031677, -0.17114530503749847, 0.25190016627311707, -0.308709055185318, -0.0019377765711396933, 1.0087119340896606, -0.20555369555950165, -0.24739697575569153, 0.05091898515820503, -0.7964418530464172, 0.01707901433110237, -0.5368265509605408, 0.7960277795791626, -0.5549109578132629, 0.7456462979316711, -0.36432328820228577, 0.1428826004266739, 0.27068519592285156, 0.32582488656044006, 0.3870508074760437, 0.279099702835083, -0.3383878171443939, 0.06278552860021591, -0.009288359433412552, 0.11819832772016525, 0.4108934700489044, 0.06751265376806259, 0.43116241693496704, -0.13244977593421936, -0.12566252052783966, 0.21918290853500366, 0.21193024516105652, -0.5686309933662415, -0.7481510043144226, -1.0871175527572632, -0.7656634449958801, -0.9673832058906555, -0.03209886699914932, 0.2279762625694275, 0.7293280363082886, -0.6593006253242493, 0.3787512481212616, -0.235658198595047, 0.18490253388881683, 0.7646408081054688, 0.4695713222026825, -0.1960107535123825, -0.7925791144371033, -0.7087655067443848, -0.5660810470581055, -0.0411938838660717, -1.1554906368255615, -0.3972037136554718, -0.3150036931037903, -0.47362279891967773, 0.9723675847053528, -0.473829448223114, -0.06156815588474274, -0.3416357934474945, -1.0578197240829468, 0.16381245851516724, 0.17931878566741943, -1.0573161840438843, 1.5139095783233643, 0.20946307480335236, 0.891400933265686, 0.3033428490161896, 0.39149901270866394, 0.39538446068763733, -0.03154248371720314, -1.1597977876663208, 1.1870132684707642, 0.02386968955397606, 0.9574984312057495, -0.1464305818080902, -1.0389230251312256, -0.09205379337072372, 0.2757613956928253, -0.7077485918998718, -0.0911712795495987, -0.6830871105194092, 0.4991077184677124, -0.7969599962234497, -0.29068872332572937, 0.08275435119867325, -0.21677498519420624, 0.07377172261476517, 0.047495897859334946, -0.6778010129928589, -0.3561370074748993, -0.012984721921384335, 0.2208794504404068, -0.458194375038147, -0.4703078866004944, 0.5436205267906189, -0.6777143478393555, 0.5555264353752136, 0.7143614292144775, 0.3061547875404358, 0.4330039918422699, -0.12360803037881851, 0.011367007158696651, -0.8003771901130676, 0.5697134137153625, -0.6796217560768127, 0.9498395323753357, 0.9592396020889282, 0.05383008345961571, 0.5716157555580139, -0.5930463671684265, -0.9736353754997253, -0.4499436318874359, -0.592133641242981, 0.012601770460605621, -0.009104074910283089, -0.6210951209068298, 0.05592504143714905, 0.6969749927520752, -1.323543906211853, 0.32826417684555054, 0.18445169925689697, 1.2554993629455566, 0.6096002459526062, -0.14075985550880432, -0.3042796850204468, 0.3258606791496277, -0.8060675263404846, -0.11882393062114716, -0.16970676183700562, 0.13675369322299957, -0.7770156264305115, -0.7351390719413757, -0.21544897556304932, 0.06935480237007141, -0.046408217400312424, -0.25142204761505127, 0.2302790731191635, -0.03086399845778942, -0.20798291265964508, 0.3955989181995392, 0.016872543841600418, -0.5578646063804626, -0.5243160128593445, 0.05053487792611122, 0.0802413821220398, -0.4756143093109131, -0.09442538768053055, -0.19938038289546967, 0.3196890354156494, 0.6314029693603516, 0.36662089824676514, 0.8802840709686279, 0.4361272156238556, -0.2191699892282486, 0.5125548839569092, 0.21795295178890228, 0.432367205619812, 0.2396349161863327, -0.16188718378543854, 0.3086766004562378, 0.535405158996582, 0.27538925409317017, 0.9184795022010803, 0.32940417528152466, -0.47040361166000366, 0.27371811866760254, 0.07634788006544113, -0.15881843864917755, -0.346187949180603, -0.30162104964256287, -0.4555525779724121, 0.25046250224113464, -0.6336272954940796, -0.46308690309524536, -0.43397313356399536, 0.11375323683023453, -0.1733672320842743, -0.11144595593214035, -0.546466052532196, -0.29493018984794617, 0.5132791996002197, 0.8063451051712036, -0.6813550591468811, -0.06757260113954544, -0.2532826364040375, 0.17142082750797272, 0.6191710829734802, 0.23955686390399933, -0.4048480987548828, 0.818270206451416, 0.5730133056640625, -0.025374725461006165, -0.3845362663269043, 0.39870715141296387, -0.07402129471302032, 0.12322314828634262, 0.6802739500999451, 0.5242873430252075, 0.7106513381004333, 0.6068612933158875, -0.005871379282325506, -0.41717109084129333, -0.3167928159236908, -0.15924136340618134, -0.952157199382782, -0.3448129892349243, -0.22708167135715485, -0.509427547454834, -0.18070758879184723, -0.9013321995735168, -0.26711609959602356, -0.13376203179359436, 0.09493181109428406, 0.11871218681335449, -0.16348378360271454, -0.33124110102653503, 0.4474092423915863, 0.004774069879204035, 0.5470166802406311, 0.22254355251789093, 0.44872239232063293, 0.17399431765079498, 1.0454602241516113, 0.5213733315467834, 0.008793446235358715, 0.18154814839363098, 0.3163631856441498, -0.23585978150367737, 0.3890676498413086, 0.6444558501243591, -0.25503790378570557, 0.5419216752052307, -0.30873870849609375, -0.38558894395828247, 0.26671865582466125, -0.27704402804374695, -0.3732684254646301, -0.1287400871515274, 0.3931043744087219, 0.5243501663208008, -0.5155802369117737, -0.660060465335846, 0.721687912940979, -0.22126927971839905, 0.3354809284210205, -0.6403275728225708, 0.47757863998413086, -1.6582443714141846, -0.1679939180612564, -1.1054096221923828, 0.6692195534706116, -0.03328513726592064, 0.2381695657968521, -0.7042976021766663, -0.18111494183540344, 0.13876666128635406, -1.1791025400161743, -0.6288560628890991, -0.35527247190475464, 0.348593145608902, 0.9961098432540894, -0.4567421078681946, -0.20602649450302124, -0.32436907291412354, -0.8746156096458435, 0.2466103583574295, 1.0125293731689453, 0.3338301181793213, -0.13508304953575134, 0.753232479095459, -0.0044646840542554855, -0.698846697807312, 0.33120810985565186, 0.7686243057250977, -0.5124034285545349, 0.4929925203323364, -0.1095186173915863, 0.09331712126731873, 0.079705148935318, -0.6176905035972595, 0.06339028477668762, 0.6429951786994934, 0.2848084568977356, 0.2562946379184723, -0.5088723301887512, -0.4243651032447815, -0.15150469541549683, 0.06567312777042389, -0.39205554127693176, -0.416642963886261, 0.6400059461593628, -0.48120835423469543, -0.031301628798246384, -0.8117115497589111, 4.151518821716309, -0.02722821570932865, 0.49284982681274414, 0.16051964461803436, 1.0080411434173584, 1.3251539468765259, -0.010695843026041985, 0.09462014585733414, 0.24188360571861267, -0.691972017288208, -0.42413756251335144, 0.16912242770195007, 0.1803399622440338, -0.05673898011445999, 0.4167778789997101, 0.3045822083950043, -0.14035624265670776, -0.08789750933647156, -0.16661706566810608, -0.3158265948295593, -0.640632152557373, 0.26031985878944397, -0.029649486765265465, 0.35912978649139404, 0.5235323309898376, 0.6998778581619263, -0.4545149505138397, -0.6475288271903992, -0.23441314697265625, -0.2371351271867752, -0.4432409405708313, -0.40162521600723267, -0.07081054151058197, -0.39791280031204224, -1.3837987184524536, 0.5102129578590393, -0.16189846396446228, -0.5036212205886841, 0.3253591060638428, 0.051497381180524826, -0.1149669885635376, -0.32899796962738037, -0.3952675759792328, -0.010137354955077171, 0.8260758519172668, 0.6897153258323669, 0.48029065132141113, 0.9901638627052307, 0.4757828116416931, -0.6242370009422302, 0.13532313704490662, 0.505294680595398, -0.04512889310717583, -0.12462389469146729, -0.48685896396636963, -0.17820347845554352, -0.18723267316818237, -0.1964784413576126, 0.938680112361908, -0.05704077333211899, 0.7091378569602966, -0.2777012288570404, 0.23391415178775787, -0.10277191549539566, -0.4792614281177521, 0.5308836698532104, 0.269014447927475, 0.02690601721405983, -0.39938610792160034, -0.5874255895614624, -0.9627590179443359, -0.2703096866607666, -0.2892727851867676, -0.6241140961647034, 0.19247286021709442, 0.24782083928585052, 0.1824936866760254, 0.00994194857776165, 0.12406200915575027, 0.10395970195531845, -0.913958728313446, -0.6402897834777832, 0.10135836899280548, 0.15809239447116852, 0.25602468848228455, 0.4373643696308136, 0.2959756851196289, -0.24207407236099243, -0.8861708641052246, 0.26908108592033386, 0.40888750553131104, 0.6384004950523376, -0.7211933732032776, 0.5020852088928223, -0.08930762112140656 ]
Improved Energy-Momentum Currents in Metric-Affine Spacetime
In Minkowski spacetime it is well-known that the canonical energy-momentum current is involved in the construction of the globally conserved currents of energy-momentum and total angular momentum. For the construction of conserved currents corresponding to (approximate) scale and proper conformal symmetries, however, an improved energy-momentum current is needed. By extending the Minkowskian framework to a genuine metric-affine spacetime, we find that the affine Noether identities and the conformal Killing equations enforce this improvement in a rather natural way. So far, no gravitational dynamics is involved in our construction. The resulting dilation and proper conformal currents are conserved provided the trace of the energy-momentum current satisfies a (mild) scaling relation or even vanishes.
Ralf Hecht, Friedrich W. Hehl, J. Dermott McCrea, Eckehard W. Mielke and Yuval Ne'eman
gr-qc hep-th
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210009
gr-qc/9210010
[ 0.055468861013650894, -0.38699468970298767, 0.5072990655899048, -0.08918969333171844, 0.14010292291641235, -0.20206134021282196, -0.4797672629356384, -0.790093183517456, -1.1695338487625122, 1.4106900691986084, 1.0698217153549194, -0.270595520734787, -0.3537220060825348, -0.5852103233337402, 0.17163708806037903, 0.09023784846067429, -0.8911187648773193, -0.0651707723736763, -1.6866374015808105, 0.47565406560897827, 0.27686983346939087, 0.194937601685524, -0.8318886160850525, -0.7312602996826172, -0.622011125087738, 0.4321094751358032, 0.6225020289421082, 0.522911012172699, 1.0334049463272095, 0.9331053495407104, 0.6012182831764221, 0.21276049315929413, -0.09338345378637314, -1.09585702419281, -0.19602982699871063, -0.23671166598796844, 0.5619955658912659, -0.22440962493419647, 0.7199193835258484, -0.4631481468677521, 0.9701948761940002, 0.1525532305240631, 0.6844364404678345, -0.4502728283405304, -0.7087899446487427, -0.33017492294311523, 0.08324938267469406, -0.46115678548812866, -0.39644744992256165, -0.9697848558425903, 0.0842030867934227, -0.14326898753643036, 0.31009480357170105, -0.44675618410110474, 0.1146191731095314, 0.05244165658950806, 0.07146506011486053, 0.2623092532157898, -0.07804843038320541, 0.39652520418167114, 0.9223999381065369, 0.1869700700044632, 0.7727903127670288, -0.67236328125, -0.0963808223605156, 0.910668671131134, -0.4279179871082306, 0.5636925101280212, -0.30445462465286255, -0.35851767659187317, 0.51284259557724, -0.993531346321106, -0.48139306902885437, 0.09647037833929062, -0.6124154329299927, 0.5546221733093262, -0.0469357967376709, -0.11756226420402527, -0.39300069212913513, 0.009791768155992031, 0.7277418375015259, -0.5898215770721436, 0.17092759907245636, 0.31707602739334106, 0.28262653946876526, -0.24194391071796417, 0.2142106592655182, -0.11288853734731674, 0.11390907317399979, -0.19873563945293427, 0.17730998992919922, 0.5276527404785156, -0.07479280978441238, -0.22866876423358917, 0.215874582529068, 0.767983078956604, 0.012128842994570732, 1.0342670679092407, 0.277262419462204, 0.6755064725875854, -0.48629096150398254, 0.8780370354652405, -0.10880962759256363, 0.3098343014717102, -0.37009817361831665, 0.42208418250083923, -0.1594502329826355, 0.6549574732780457, -0.5643142461776733, -0.8612581491470337, 0.02712656557559967, 0.09732628613710403, -0.2825448215007782, 0.7393178939819336, 0.4464893639087677, 0.6868780851364136, -0.1975817233324051, -0.3325440287590027, -0.6750187277793884, -0.29784461855888367, -0.10836589336395264, 0.2752360999584198, 0.6652981638908386, 0.4376762807369232, 0.34189170598983765, -0.5929887890815735, -0.30220291018486023, 0.10559934377670288, -0.5430487394332886, 0.0634152889251709, -0.14981043338775635, -0.4694262146949768, 0.17236247658729553, 0.4046182930469513, 0.23289738595485687, 0.06130031496286392, -0.02757536992430687, 0.4404712915420532, -1.0568392276763916, -0.4487385153770447, 0.3012067675590515, -1.1777572631835938, -0.2523845136165619, 0.8735967874526978, -0.20891758799552917, 0.010688606649637222, -0.4419421851634979, 0.6157899498939514, 0.2756378650665283, 0.17535865306854248, -0.33883512020111084, -0.07293158024549484, 0.2571878433227539, 0.31088024377822876, -0.6530234217643738, -0.5825660824775696, -1.0154062509536743, 0.5186427235603333, -0.5486199855804443, -0.21647727489471436, 0.17643767595291138, -0.11028527468442917, -0.13877791166305542, 0.6533098816871643, -0.513037383556366, 0.2667063772678375, -0.710235059261322, -0.768379807472229, -0.1791311502456665, -0.24539941549301147, -0.10729961842298508, 0.044462405145168304, -0.22584383189678192, 0.2372177690267563, 1.0424752235412598, 0.5300853252410889, 0.2746654748916626, 0.08147783577442169, -0.1760684847831726, 0.09386621415615082, -0.6127482056617737, -0.18982991576194763, 0.6969611048698425, 0.5803853869438171, -0.9008135199546814, -1.242613673210144, -0.6514166593551636, 0.30618545413017273, -0.16220234334468842, 0.6037326455116272, -0.20154573023319244, 0.2735212445259094, -1.2328490018844604, 0.8435728549957275, -0.35795387625694275, 0.05397023260593414, -1.0664293766021729, -0.046915166079998016, -0.0233000498265028, -0.5064508318901062, 0.16118235886096954, -0.36859142780303955, -0.7434418201446533, -0.04638197273015976, -1.164894700050354, 0.7272465229034424, 0.1918306052684784, 0.5765508413314819, -0.40896132588386536, 0.10868768393993378, -0.22447197139263153, -0.6037737727165222, -0.13380832970142365, 0.25441041588783264, -0.2719263732433319, -1.11580491065979, -0.37353208661079407, 0.4959198236465454, 0.8598638772964478, -0.18986202776432037, 0.6159772276878357, -0.23752760887145996, 0.04564128816127777, 0.4452868402004242, 0.15825025737285614, -0.08051465451717377, 0.1011764407157898, 0.8491897583007812, 0.07748980820178986, 0.2182309329509735, 0.50374436378479, 0.4159485697746277, -0.26716870069503784, 0.5173831582069397, 0.5903346538543701, -0.4191741645336151, 0.7528977394104004, 0.4780001938343048, 0.2156834602355957, 0.1300811767578125, 0.2070925384759903, -0.00452856719493866, 0.5752604603767395, 0.5201079845428467, -0.6441907286643982, 0.5350067615509033, 0.21441897749900818, 0.014824015088379383, -0.555935263633728, 0.4793799817562103, -0.6521552801132202, 0.7351040840148926, 0.44979220628738403, 0.3939847946166992, -0.8949217796325684, 0.060747187584638596, 0.31997689604759216, 0.252195805311203, -0.5595579147338867, -0.7022059559822083, 0.10202748328447342, 0.49331948161125183, 0.21117329597473145, -0.6279600858688354, -0.5556063652038574, 0.4281758666038513, -0.48231491446495056, 0.4321776032447815, 0.11591356247663498, -0.14090648293495178, -0.38804545998573303, -0.018494991585612297, -0.3872862160205841, 0.19121351838111877, -0.494276225566864, -0.41702505946159363, 0.4941892623901367, -0.986303985118866, 1.105741262435913, 0.32284435629844666, 0.11043681204319, 0.6058772206306458, 0.056614428758621216, 0.704169750213623, -0.5810390710830688, -0.8417392373085022, -0.8372678160667419, 0.14435730874538422, -1.1641759872436523, 0.001970813609659672, 0.4139341115951538, -0.6726222634315491, -0.7261661887168884, -0.31782764196395874, 0.4090629816055298, 0.0019452080596238375, -0.5288687944412231, -0.13483132421970367, -0.6118758320808411, -0.6537668108940125, -0.13098526000976562, 0.005694623105227947, 0.17536740005016327, 0.21194598078727722, -1.0359861850738525, 0.9278560280799866, 0.21495601534843445, -0.6842475533485413, 0.770551323890686, -0.18676602840423584, -0.8620800375938416, 0.27209728956222534, -0.14968033134937286, 0.42166274785995483, -0.06410644948482513, 1.2411017417907715, 0.8526153564453125, -0.6880732178688049, 0.14524410665035248, -0.0015788085293024778, -0.8124588131904602, -0.3448810279369354, 0.1434658169746399, -1.106087565422058, 0.11294958740472794, 0.9737247228622437, 0.02589617855846882, -0.5933128595352173, 0.23768246173858643, -0.5759401917457581, -0.828312873840332, 0.19339968264102936, -0.41198205947875977, 0.7268005013465881, -0.34234580397605896, 0.21970924735069275, -0.261002779006958, -0.09295196086168289, 0.020800016820430756, 1.33453369140625, 0.44074559211730957, 0.4336087107658386, 0.2499905675649643, 0.09913848340511322, -0.07144681364297867, 0.08308998495340347, 0.870459794998169, -0.43058866262435913, 0.10516832768917084, 0.48245474696159363, -0.269381046295166, 0.2213522493839264, -0.2066016048192978, 0.010799815878272057, 0.12742556631565094, 0.3650325536727905, -1.016910433769226, -0.22928769886493683, -0.9409116506576538, -0.27629679441452026, -0.04510233923792839, 0.7436252236366272, 0.13126620650291443, 0.19800199568271637, -0.5642510056495667, -0.19050061702728271, 0.5968472957611084, -0.11198939383029938, 0.6477969884872437, -0.9865192174911499, 0.4733988046646118, -0.0675600990653038, -0.3349575698375702, -0.024829324334859848, 0.07442047446966171, -0.046381913125514984, 0.38888129591941833, 0.6079545021057129, 0.5638176798820496, -0.3806554079055786, -0.42574453353881836, 0.07950399070978165, 0.8151370882987976, 0.38212987780570984, 0.6417226791381836, 0.05250571668148041, -0.566468358039856, 0.4382305145263672, -1.0488529205322266, -0.1774081289768219, -0.0007377906586043537, -0.5328377485275269, -0.12557454407215118, -0.8243677616119385, -0.4749298095703125, -0.3316597044467926, 0.506764829158783, 0.40186116099357605, -0.46133285760879517, -0.24342983961105347, 0.011877612210810184, -0.07271020859479904, 0.24065463244915009, 0.9801978468894958, 0.42062056064605713, -0.2861151099205017, -0.8006904125213623, 0.31043651700019836, 0.009827887639403343, 0.3660435676574707, -0.00787255261093378, -0.44475802779197693, 0.17704668641090393, -0.6454127430915833, 0.9726753830909729, 0.3592275083065033, 0.03199825435876846, 0.38978713750839233, 0.6357439756393433, 0.2869211435317993, -0.504658579826355, 0.7514565587043762, 0.35786178708076477, 0.5969857573509216, -0.10120546817779541, -0.6259225010871887, -0.08389469236135483, -0.19925309717655182, 0.649465024471283, 1.1843087673187256, 0.21659593284130096, -0.9772252440452576, -0.43935900926589966, 0.6464606523513794, -0.06814394146203995, 0.28912919759750366, 0.7871831655502319, -0.7038013935089111, 0.7440012097358704, 0.37533795833587646, -0.43018364906311035, 0.2637949585914612, -0.6075625419616699, -0.23990263044834137, 0.030357755720615387, -0.00825737789273262, -0.22653283178806305, 0.685065746307373, -0.4640458822250366, -0.5491040945053101, 0.18326421082019806, -0.5463947653770447, 0.7442514896392822, 0.12647317349910736, -0.7799195051193237, 0.17410233616828918, -0.12485964596271515, -0.3230932354927063, 0.18262144923210144, 0.3305525779724121, 0.6827238202095032, 0.17970184981822968, 0.2066192626953125, -0.4688279628753662, -0.0685683861374855, 0.5077739953994751, 0.18152250349521637, 0.0443093366920948, 0.8364058136940002, 0.2636863589286804, 0.9419066905975342, 0.03920218348503113, -0.8716720342636108, -0.17574889957904816, 0.6853455901145935, -0.3434984087944031, -0.08671695739030838, -0.24340303242206573, -0.024947253987193108, -0.8382083177566528, -0.34569090604782104, 0.2807658314704895, -0.013162628747522831, 0.5090478658676147, 0.02918177843093872, -1.2596076726913452, -0.289659321308136, -0.626796305179596, -0.6935471296310425, 0.16884741187095642, 0.09364112466573715, -0.6112774014472961, -0.026864686980843544, -0.48996701836586, -0.38174450397491455, 0.27376124262809753, -0.1298321783542633, -0.45304563641548157, 0.16626465320587158, 0.29690560698509216, -0.09540625661611557, 0.3751993179321289, -0.14276714622974396, 0.3730536699295044, -0.2033264935016632, -0.26922211050987244, -0.9437099695205688, -0.7001330256462097, 0.12924867868423462, 0.5697705149650574, 0.27367261052131653, -1.0463711023330688, 0.4211077392101288, 0.06671631336212158, 0.3301832377910614, -0.037673480808734894, -0.4230287969112396, -0.998198926448822, -0.23652736842632294, 0.37710511684417725, 0.2328743040561676, -0.8823212385177612, -0.050027284771203995, 0.3234940469264984, -0.41002383828163147, -0.007457909639924765, 0.043701961636543274, -0.8104141354560852, 0.18693919479846954, -0.9020059108734131, 0.4771738648414612, -0.761314868927002, -0.07998915016651154, 0.05304393544793129, -0.15692898631095886, 0.0338829830288887, 0.12306109070777893, 0.22306346893310547, -0.10087864845991135, -0.7690126895904541, -0.13852645456790924, 0.15496712923049927, -0.4114357829093933, -0.29814571142196655, -0.5681739449501038, 0.276745080947876, -0.4445922076702118, 0.8429416418075562, -0.42385026812553406, 0.08794254809617996, 0.7053347229957581, 0.027559000998735428, -0.13875101506710052, -0.004659758415073156, 0.05594870075583458, -0.5158408284187317, -0.6643022298812866, 0.2935309410095215, 0.26862379908561707, 0.49117186665534973, -0.3385304808616638, 0.2964121401309967, -0.6719648241996765, 0.5897060036659241, -0.6055365800857544, -0.44227614998817444, 0.449087917804718, 0.36520975828170776, 0.6071198582649231, -0.9001926183700562, -0.3237408995628357, 0.3306652009487152, 0.437120258808136, 0.019032111391425133, 0.15387940406799316, -0.6143427491188049, 0.2484467476606369, -1.176708459854126, -0.7548222541809082, 0.6176731586456299, 0.19858668744564056, 0.3490539789199829, -0.40196654200553894, -0.31434714794158936, 0.1845412403345108, -0.9214844107627869, 0.2725464403629303, 0.410888135433197, -0.0342533253133297, -0.406904935836792, -0.553128182888031, 0.042133431881666183, -0.6234426498413086, -0.11329354345798492, 0.11701380461454391, 0.47074052691459656, 0.07398787885904312, -0.34882068634033203, -0.8678596615791321, -0.6437469124794006, -0.5615152716636658, 0.4209352135658264, 0.8708808422088623, 0.22586499154567719, 1.046363115310669, 0.44682085514068604, -0.10896971076726913, -0.16420647501945496, 0.40899986028671265, 0.28973880410194397, 0.12641994655132294, 0.8379727005958557, -0.21500840783119202, 0.19873526692390442, -0.6916679739952087, 0.2473091334104538, -0.7119742035865784, -0.4033491611480713, 0.7018471360206604, -0.2832469940185547, -0.19460970163345337, 0.42599740624427795, 0.4584786593914032, -0.4693770706653595, -0.9413681030273438, -0.808589518070221, -0.03005303628742695, 0.03328760713338852, -1.078022837638855, -0.36458662152290344, -0.07924991101026535, 0.29080337285995483, 0.08663365244865417, 0.48034822940826416, -0.12602493166923523, 0.5079439878463745, -0.07073081284761429, -0.4845840036869049, -0.8569850325584412, 0.05252750962972641, 1.3531731367111206, 0.12682215869426727, -0.7708263993263245, -0.24991662800312042, 0.4986465871334076, -0.2609315514564514, -0.040507495403289795, 0.8899523019790649, -0.2744312286376953, -0.28046828508377075, -0.14208672940731049, -0.0673736110329628, 0.0421045683324337, 0.3770425319671631, 0.1599888950586319, 0.335359126329422, -0.2366524487733841, -1.061885118484497, -0.31603530049324036, 0.219557523727417, 0.2852475643157959, -0.1373416632413864, 0.007021106313914061, -0.11392755061388016, 0.12094791233539581, 0.4115305244922638, -0.15086111426353455, -0.7785375714302063, -0.34066271781921387, -1.4820358753204346, -0.5202715396881104, -1.314806580543518, -0.11371723562479019, -0.5348160862922668, 0.4898588955402374, -0.29738134145736694, 0.3304985761642456, -0.6616382598876953, -0.4397761821746826, 0.321052610874176, 0.6253395676612854, -0.9086672067642212, -0.5290459394454956, -1.197232961654663, 0.308626264333725, 0.11806805431842804, -0.6741006374359131, -0.0647340714931488, 0.18644067645072937, -0.18498295545578003, 0.6207654476165771, -1.1480251550674438, 1.0301498174667358, -0.07223504036664963, -0.4168773293495178, 0.45825639367103577, 0.15531595051288605, -0.5967397689819336, 0.8480988144874573, -0.1212833970785141, 0.7816795110702515, 0.03335028141736984, -0.09942726790904999, -0.7155775427818298, -0.3535301983356476, -1.3413981199264526, 0.15692070126533508, -0.5174525380134583, 0.8347049355506897, -0.3080965578556061, -0.5132832527160645, 0.8192558288574219, 0.008208096027374268, -1.4321069717407227, -0.38815945386886597, -0.5558562278747559, 0.5758057832717896, -0.6399092078208923, 0.1231054738163948, -0.0983312577009201, 0.5898190140724182, 0.19644474983215332, 0.6358885169029236, -0.5088983178138733, -0.9062137603759766, 0.023785846307873726, 0.20852592587471008, 0.4143458306789398, -0.18362706899642944, -0.05100444704294205, -0.5898765325546265, -0.07110477238893509, -0.05742046982049942, -0.4998423755168915, 0.16492897272109985, -0.9708918929100037, -0.2347830832004547, -0.3744050860404968, 0.0680362731218338, -0.8538239002227783, 0.34790486097335815, 0.3535182774066925, -0.11763329058885574, -0.22931577265262604, -0.5736353993415833, -0.35594117641448975, 0.7422119379043579, -0.41830652952194214, -0.18094129860401154, 0.44319450855255127, 0.05832751840353012, -0.5940386652946472, 0.28433382511138916, -0.548554003238678, 0.07385054975748062, 0.4002496600151062, 0.9537556767463684, 0.7129401564598083, 0.5923511385917664, -0.797235369682312, 0.5163367986679077, -0.29810911417007446, -1.251486897468567, -0.6253907680511475, 0.6553589701652527, -0.8632439374923706, -0.5193138718605042, -0.37517687678337097, 0.37600645422935486, 0.1128430962562561, -0.19698752462863922, -0.5384261608123779, 0.1968790590763092, 0.1276261955499649, 0.48637959361076355, -0.3931431174278259, 0.29284945130348206, -0.12593312561511993, 0.49545201659202576, 0.20831020176410675, -0.3995424807071686, -0.002176189562305808, -0.15956315398216248, 0.868689775466919, 0.2648906707763672, -0.0557655394077301, 1.0126781463623047, -0.040573131293058395, -0.2080417275428772, 0.7232162356376648, -0.06547882407903671, 0.681472897529602, 0.7032123804092407, -0.5236446261405945, -0.03884824365377426, 0.3842703700065613, -0.02110673300921917, 0.36319687962532043, 0.0721328929066658, 0.11984314024448395, 0.4856986999511719, 0.5791451930999756, 0.26149001717567444, 0.581933319568634, 0.6092031002044678, -0.09109748899936676, 0.1270471215248108, -0.6534449458122253, 0.6795198321342468, -0.28262653946876526, 0.3021133244037628, -0.291421115398407, -0.10386346280574799, -0.5597479939460754, -0.5726960301399231, -0.10813397169113159, 0.5583644509315491, -0.025125358253717422, -0.5382479429244995, -0.7606346011161804, 0.4997395873069763, 0.11166473478078842, 0.28568723797798157, -0.06893943250179291, 0.7978110909461975, 0.8382567167282104, 0.46357929706573486, -0.5750869512557983, 0.43491870164871216, 0.5376620888710022, 0.34437277913093567, 0.041867535561323166, 0.6704092025756836, 0.8399949073791504, 0.5748841166496277, -0.12618818879127502, -0.7026718854904175, 0.3838755786418915, 0.18526695668697357, -0.8917743563652039, 0.047020331025123596, -0.4932079613208771, -0.10989250987768173, -0.013073557056486607, -0.8230947852134705, -0.052156344056129456, -0.30328869819641113, -0.24488529562950134, 0.6056375503540039, -0.3395836055278778, 0.17235374450683594, 0.4309777617454529, 0.41054776310920715, 0.6459526419639587, 0.6254459619522095, 0.593859851360321, -0.24416863918304443, 0.880213737487793, 1.8083205223083496, 0.010548677295446396, 0.05739340931177139, 0.32543179392814636, 0.497892826795578, -0.049023278057575226, 0.6231275796890259, -0.7694931030273438, 0.8950890898704529, 0.28484076261520386, -0.40479332208633423, -0.0010257397079840302, 0.17464548349380493, -0.4109345078468323, -0.4095917046070099, 0.25924986600875854, 0.1580454558134079, -0.2819935083389282, 0.07605274766683578, 0.7128856182098389, 0.4304462671279907, -0.7037721872329712, -0.1805879771709442, 0.4937986135482788, -0.867909848690033, 0.43773314356803894, -0.970762312412262, 0.8637573719024658, -0.15447330474853516, -0.33939072489738464, -0.08173640072345734, -0.32367292046546936, -0.6244001984596252, -1.0722347497940063, 0.11618425697088242, -0.17297427356243134, 0.2706708014011383, 0.8890455365180969, 0.4320060908794403, 0.013296380639076233, -0.8521455526351929, -0.1692533940076828, -0.11732577532529831, 1.250934362411499, -0.024664437398314476, 0.2403794825077057, 0.7224503755569458, -0.018118632957339287, -0.8252989649772644, 0.7264401316642761, 0.6519170999526978, -0.18023206293582916, 0.3874160945415497, -0.48931533098220825, 0.17653053998947144, 0.03436645492911339, 0.100305937230587, 0.920478105545044, 0.18070878088474274, 0.6272441148757935, 0.4102265536785126, -0.6377480030059814, 0.31542542576789856, -0.6240814328193665, 0.2118990272283554, -0.569657027721405, 0.6373569965362549, 0.5565268993377686, -0.7519707679748535, 0.10164754092693329, -0.5316354036331177, 4.110252857208252, 0.6117643117904663, 0.8820489645004272, 0.029783286154270172, 1.1787078380584717, 0.8628700971603394, 0.2262798547744751, 0.08782672882080078, 0.7482731342315674, -0.61018967628479, 0.018298320472240448, 0.7354291677474976, -0.2581031620502472, -0.28931471705436707, -0.12324358522891998, 0.36009177565574646, -0.16853483021259308, 0.3687623143196106, -0.30655550956726074, -0.49992725253105164, -0.5561196208000183, 0.21917422115802765, -0.2070496380329132, -0.3335486054420471, -0.1890978068113327, 0.18216517567634583, 0.6820330023765564, 0.030019741505384445, -0.08909106254577637, -0.32698073983192444, -0.3675649166107178, -1.0784404277801514, 0.21956923604011536, -0.5226428508758545, -0.7653185725212097, 0.45163384079933167, 0.3885971009731293, -0.1521509289741516, 0.5415811538696289, 0.4653748869895935, 0.3414817154407501, 0.05903056263923645, 0.0868290513753891, -0.15986675024032593, -0.4237964451313019, 0.7748193144798279, -0.1796499788761139, 0.6996062994003296, 0.4236283302307129, -1.1326526403427124, 0.6313607096672058, 0.20254875719547272, 0.4441826641559601, -0.676956295967102, -0.3652476966381073, -0.045062556862831116, -0.13294290006160736, -0.196283757686615, -0.25116056203842163, -0.4878438711166382, 0.8261357545852661, -0.5530441999435425, 0.13016563653945923, 0.1663796603679657, 0.6788362264633179, 0.10554538667201996, 0.5721960067749023, 0.3453364670276642, -0.023448294028639793, 0.029915811493992805, -0.4498252868652344, 0.22175948321819305, -0.8420425057411194, -0.29563137888908386, 0.537236750125885, 0.367389053106308, -0.4533456861972809, 0.3977493643760681, 0.18344652652740479, -0.2601429522037506, 0.0029089623130857944, -0.8521962761878967, 0.3996886909008026, 0.02440406195819378, 0.48414117097854614, 0.4911755323410034, 0.39336684346199036, 0.16769282519817352, -0.3123648762702942, 0.28954213857650757, -0.07132063060998917, 0.9242367148399353, 0.2792183458805084, 0.37587666511535645, -0.38657814264297485 ]
Classical Equations for Quantum Systems
The origin of the phenomenological deterministic laws that approximately govern the quasiclassical domain of familiar experience is considered in the context of the quantum mechanics of closed systems such as the universe as a whole. We investigate the requirements for coarse grainings to yield decoherent sets of histories that are quasiclassical, i.e. such that the individual histories obey, with high probability, effective classical equations of motion interrupted continually by small fluctuations and occasionally by large ones. We discuss these requirements generally but study them specifically for coarse grainings of the type that follows a distinguished subset of a complete set of variables while ignoring the rest. More coarse graining is needed to achieve decoherence than would be suggested by naive arguments based on the uncertainty principle. Even coarser graining is required in the distinguished variables for them to have the necessary inertia to approach classical predictability in the presence of the noise consisting of the fluctuations that typical mechanisms of decoherence produce. We describe the derivation of phenomenological equations of motion explicitly for a particular class of models. Probabilities of the correlations in time that define equations of motion are explicitly considered. Fully non-linear cases are studied. Methods are exhibited for finding the form of the phenomenological equations of motion even when these are only distantly related to those of the fundamental action. The demonstration of the connection between quantum-mechanical causality and causalty in classical phenomenological equations of motion is generalized. The connections among decoherence, noise, dissipation, and the amount of coarse graining necessary to achieve classical predictability are investigated quantitatively.
Murray Gell-Mann and James B. Hartle
gr-qc hep-th quant-ph
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210010
gr-qc/9210011
[ 1.0205154418945312, -0.0016891544219106436, 0.07419940084218979, 0.4462969899177551, 0.21228931844234467, -0.1041073426604271, -0.5067284107208252, 0.02518240176141262, -0.8641648888587952, 1.247711181640625, 0.8682862520217896, 0.7771636247634888, 0.04999690502882004, -1.047694206237793, 0.29837244749069214, 0.5859621167182922, -0.09600403904914856, -0.5514267683029175, -0.8986695408821106, -0.017714397981762886, 0.5305911302566528, 0.5487161874771118, -0.8816297650337219, -0.2330004870891571, -0.3455852270126343, 0.7619389295578003, 0.21862293779850006, -0.012475373223423958, 0.9330594539642334, 1.0214532613754272, 0.8554412126541138, -0.12233497947454453, 0.2580336034297943, -0.6523151397705078, -0.04262746497988701, -0.32032904028892517, 0.16936464607715607, -0.7634735107421875, 1.2235268354415894, 0.00835247989743948, 0.34222936630249023, 0.4395388066768646, 0.2630618214607239, -0.7111588716506958, -0.7095010280609131, -0.4833107590675354, -0.17028668522834778, -0.17523963749408722, -0.5089449882507324, -0.7494887709617615, 0.44458529353141785, -0.08280853927135468, 0.7016174793243408, -0.8896269798278809, -0.5478425621986389, -0.19284602999687195, 0.17556487023830414, -0.00047158333472907543, -0.6025723218917847, -0.04472377523779869, 0.40672627091407776, 0.5097494125366211, 0.11346840858459473, -1.2417501211166382, 0.3835446238517761, 0.882908821105957, -0.216816246509552, 0.4174397587776184, -0.04578053578734398, -0.5490344166755676, -0.6946789026260376, -0.950120210647583, -0.15544790029525757, 0.37595251202583313, -0.3052930533885956, 0.9354062080383301, -0.27667003870010376, -0.14170494675636292, -0.9632298946380615, -0.1768019050359726, 0.18530839681625366, -0.2923876643180847, -0.8787054419517517, 0.011991126462817192, -0.32698506116867065, -0.4479247033596039, -0.36429399251937866, -0.10715053230524063, 0.5149691104888916, -0.3153996765613556, -0.6118652820587158, 0.48444250226020813, -0.45724424719810486, -0.3528212010860443, 0.5825166702270508, 0.6423925757408142, -0.1333935409784317, 0.9106453061103821, 0.07258891314268112, 0.03255676478147507, -0.39737385511398315, 1.0385626554489136, -0.46192753314971924, 0.5969263911247253, -0.9881700277328491, 0.27383702993392944, -0.827028214931488, -0.670077383518219, -0.42304933071136475, -0.3449351489543915, -0.09811607003211975, 0.008631090633571148, 0.7765524983406067, 0.028037095442414284, 0.1361377239227295, 0.3507334887981415, -0.6171767711639404, 0.02129371091723442, -0.8493920564651489, -0.08518244326114655, 0.15077446401119232, 0.5419837832450867, 0.6808329820632935, 0.7343955636024475, 0.10065682232379913, -0.9218471646308899, -0.3252146244049072, 0.152505025267601, -0.7024258375167847, 0.24711473286151886, -0.0740499421954155, -0.2648119628429413, 0.3082584738731384, -0.08137857913970947, 0.013312681578099728, 0.31908324360847473, -0.09642603993415833, -0.2698478698730469, -0.5846189260482788, -0.9445977210998535, 0.2774081230163574, -0.4932824671268463, 0.9282763600349426, 0.9696197509765625, -0.22618116438388824, 0.282585471868515, 0.19144177436828613, 0.13862214982509613, -0.5389213562011719, 0.5379859209060669, -0.2121363878250122, -0.48162397742271423, -0.5180237293243408, 0.2500883638858795, -0.33862265944480896, -0.3153250813484192, -0.7065261006355286, 0.255234956741333, -0.15607677400112152, -0.23651862144470215, 0.5089824795722961, 0.09965323656797409, 0.12484733760356903, 1.1554207801818848, -0.29430434107780457, 0.21260270476341248, -0.027719752863049507, -0.47244155406951904, 0.5618269443511963, -0.18375250697135925, -0.34582602977752686, 0.022931866347789764, -0.19392867386341095, 0.5364489555358887, 0.8558782935142517, 0.46380719542503357, 0.16869787871837616, 0.33531808853149414, 0.4077445864677429, 0.2775002121925354, -0.25302594900131226, -0.8231441974639893, 1.2253797054290771, 0.8641722798347473, -0.027100639417767525, -0.613327145576477, 0.08331329375505447, -0.10816122591495514, 0.698488175868988, 0.2358676791191101, -0.6705635786056519, 0.503093957901001, -0.6101585626602173, 1.2987562417984009, -0.12134289741516113, 0.23675376176834106, -1.0401546955108643, -0.04712527245283127, 0.044502366334199905, -0.5350086092948914, -0.124836765229702, 0.016724595800042152, -0.03040187992155552, 0.5183876156806946, -0.7945697903633118, 0.43581411242485046, 0.224969282746315, 0.40353891253471375, -0.05507366731762886, 0.4762306809425354, 0.4082533121109009, -0.07627855241298676, 0.3806564211845398, -0.09605509042739868, 0.12625430524349213, -0.48650631308555603, -0.6382012963294983, 0.6554229855537415, 0.15253794193267822, 0.2844699025154114, 0.5736095905303955, 0.19644328951835632, -0.22796033322811127, 1.023913860321045, 0.3814334571361542, -0.5951678156852722, -0.2030477076768875, 0.9855307340621948, 0.008254146203398705, 1.3141746520996094, 0.4742196500301361, -0.11872348189353943, 0.7505013346672058, 0.49658268690109253, 0.7511014938354492, -0.006189823150634766, 0.8976066708564758, 0.9224525690078735, 0.25221651792526245, -0.06575009971857071, 0.2385854870080948, -0.3765980005264282, 0.8094511032104492, -0.01629776693880558, -0.4496400058269501, 0.8658363819122314, 0.48093879222869873, 0.16165922582149506, -0.03333261236548424, 0.9244942665100098, -0.6512194871902466, 0.8685983419418335, 0.3649260997772217, 0.11076632887125015, -0.36457666754722595, 0.17304563522338867, 0.229124516248703, 0.5686917901039124, -0.0890732854604721, -0.6465562582015991, -0.07119237631559372, 0.5029366612434387, 0.05302054435014725, -0.49957916140556335, -0.33952727913856506, 0.24865654110908508, -0.04032306745648384, -0.07760210335254669, 0.44691622257232666, -0.15124593675136566, -0.8497052788734436, -0.07744235545396805, -0.5998457074165344, -0.05607989430427551, -0.9789077639579773, -0.10775276273488998, 0.35431724786758423, -0.566605806350708, 1.153017520904541, 0.030330965295433998, 0.389810174703598, 0.5157954692840576, -0.5853562355041504, 0.789029061794281, -0.13094638288021088, 0.05149020999670029, -0.6166315674781799, 0.16303272545337677, -0.8072335720062256, 0.27570661902427673, -0.23334521055221558, 0.18729788064956665, 0.5680326819419861, -0.11336082965135574, 0.47592729330062866, 0.010964402928948402, -0.5480199456214905, 0.008465315215289593, -0.4807189404964447, -0.7280912399291992, 0.2774985134601593, 0.6728281378746033, 0.6359148621559143, 0.7685170769691467, -0.5734657049179077, 0.7695277333259583, 0.13642364740371704, -0.6186266541481018, 0.9294331073760986, -0.5375871658325195, -0.5850302577018738, 0.20023280382156372, 0.0016304624732583761, 0.9313552379608154, -0.3316778838634491, 0.8518131971359253, 0.8225893974304199, 0.3875834047794342, 0.5163394808769226, -0.23762474954128265, -0.06611540168523788, 0.12007565051317215, 0.6164522171020508, -0.6717148423194885, 0.2609250247478485, 0.7503689527511597, 0.5248890519142151, -0.7856948375701904, 0.05533193051815033, -1.0397093296051025, -0.9354097247123718, -0.6016373634338379, -1.1380562782287598, 0.06674212962388992, -0.5010696649551392, 0.08516286313533783, -0.06892366707324982, -0.4104123115539551, -0.0008175610564649105, 0.8166577219963074, 0.0767664909362793, -0.050995584577322006, 0.4194609522819519, 0.4609176218509674, 0.09252025932073593, 0.3912106454372406, 0.7240810394287109, -0.7741122245788574, -0.3779822587966919, 0.2611621916294098, -0.3325592577457428, 0.6087886095046997, 0.30705374479293823, -0.4731524884700775, -0.1861279457807541, 0.6394422650337219, -0.7552287578582764, -0.2169671654701233, -1.411257266998291, -0.22350065410137177, 0.4786628782749176, 0.04616964980959892, 0.11369676142930984, -0.6326998472213745, -0.610442578792572, -0.10249722748994827, 0.4112969636917114, 0.3062347173690796, 1.0527513027191162, -1.3666880130767822, 0.5190675258636475, -0.005266161169856787, -0.6625795960426331, -0.17670083045959473, -0.6980627775192261, 0.12795282900333405, 0.6171249747276306, 0.3818805515766144, -0.5001404285430908, -0.08713287860155106, -0.16825111210346222, -0.31833499670028687, 0.5133575201034546, 0.04541464522480965, 0.4065987765789032, -0.10672828555107117, -0.2451239824295044, 0.3443147838115692, 0.0021839840337634087, 0.004895980469882488, -0.16906581819057465, -1.134345293045044, -0.00276974868029356, -0.8537235856056213, 0.051186416298151016, -0.41186851263046265, 0.42920365929603577, 0.7718951106071472, 0.26838040351867676, -0.36618316173553467, 0.45155149698257446, 0.1657702773809433, -0.14933374524116516, 0.4765688478946686, 0.23997870087623596, -0.17090535163879395, -1.1879477500915527, 0.7410403490066528, 0.9668173789978027, 0.28531599044799805, 0.3103805184364319, -0.35964301228523254, 0.10998193919658661, -0.14031508564949036, 0.4431232511997223, -0.1346130520105362, -1.1003285646438599, 0.6997945308685303, 0.1258331686258316, -0.5670387744903564, -0.3072851300239563, 0.44044071435928345, 0.4962461590766907, 0.3909010887145996, -0.044485270977020264, -0.2592327296733856, 0.13738833367824554, -0.18070445954799652, 0.2651557922363281, 0.862828254699707, -0.40177232027053833, -0.2034626454114914, -0.18509012460708618, -0.08102216571569443, -0.07551005482673645, 0.2546873390674591, 0.38826704025268555, 0.005883865524083376, -0.1077042818069458, -0.21444590389728546, 0.2671807110309601, 0.8821195363998413, -0.31671345233917236, -0.27323365211486816, -0.27718138694763184, -0.04200940951704979, -0.7898204326629639, -0.13288649916648865, 0.6598585844039917, -0.6514244675636292, 0.09661560505628586, -0.33460137248039246, -0.15413372218608856, -0.40492674708366394, -0.7159443497657776, -0.1290459781885147, 0.515807032585144, -0.45047545433044434, 0.31991273164749146, -0.21216893196105957, 0.19999542832374573, -0.3604724705219269, 0.13661950826644897, -0.37881389260292053, 0.22419373691082, -0.1929992139339447, 0.2660369873046875, 0.006879863329231739, 0.21903929114341736, 0.5255816578865051, 0.44272616505622864, 0.22622618079185486, 0.11903384327888489, 0.4055435359477997, 0.353507399559021, -0.2989594638347626, -0.30773603916168213, 0.10499108582735062, -0.1671738624572754, -0.6063521504402161, -1.260335922241211, 0.45837199687957764, -0.36440280079841614, 0.27940917015075684, 0.41145437955856323, -1.0791467428207397, -0.5295946002006531, -0.8436146378517151, -1.0537112951278687, 0.5241372585296631, 0.2227087765932083, -0.39929527044296265, 0.20495261251926422, -0.4998079538345337, -0.5912173986434937, 0.10032400488853455, -0.2763175964355469, -0.49624204635620117, -0.36533257365226746, -0.2906407117843628, 0.14071224629878998, 0.5391907691955566, 0.128608837723732, 0.03152242302894592, -0.5320559144020081, -0.5599562525749207, -0.14343784749507904, -1.5317302942276, -0.19096310436725616, 0.18214520812034607, 0.3024267554283142, -0.953619658946991, 0.6224075555801392, 0.4807593822479248, 0.5426834225654602, -0.3686579465866089, -0.1382060945034027, -0.8436342477798462, -0.22267740964889526, 1.0967649221420288, 0.17902772128582, -0.5782963633537292, 0.12425174564123154, 0.6026557087898254, 0.018655816093087196, 0.9330597519874573, 0.05813942849636078, -0.48262450098991394, 0.24476194381713867, -1.9561421871185303, 0.25975489616394043, -0.7752947807312012, -0.011006923392415047, -0.3257308006286621, -0.8977314233779907, 0.37957850098609924, -0.35342296957969666, 0.2740621268749237, -0.7083825469017029, -0.03538956493139267, -0.3216765820980072, 0.6969537734985352, -0.568045437335968, 0.7650684714317322, -0.7571648955345154, -0.08323594927787781, -0.34034377336502075, 1.0825883150100708, -0.22658969461917877, 0.5876339673995972, 0.2456253618001938, -0.016991499811410904, -0.6471607685089111, 0.7050783634185791, -0.05879927799105644, -0.7552651166915894, -0.3126612603664398, 0.7541875243186951, 0.03674566000699997, -0.3500271439552307, 0.0047408281825482845, 0.9150318503379822, -0.24532830715179443, 0.3277300298213959, -0.029719194397330284, -0.6504246592521667, 0.08374481648206711, 0.17372135818004608, 0.5196505784988403, -0.32539716362953186, -0.4251381754875183, 0.6815093755722046, 0.2704981565475464, 0.8784504532814026, -0.576837420463562, -0.38400083780288696, -0.11596893519163132, -0.4517621099948883, -0.6190069913864136, 0.7938615679740906, 0.20882520079612732, 0.268064945936203, -0.8274353742599487, -0.3225783109664917, 0.3545302748680115, -0.61487877368927, 0.5115386247634888, 0.3762989938259125, 0.0726267471909523, 0.13374334573745728, -0.6751136183738708, -0.3754500448703766, -0.9350031614303589, 0.8844377994537354, 0.26712164282798767, -0.2891150414943695, 0.10063136368989944, -0.5914327502250671, -0.9610961675643921, -1.0334358215332031, -0.3184856176376343, 0.4055611789226532, 0.2997104823589325, 0.2989882230758667, 0.6446825265884399, 0.10577002167701721, -0.18703597784042358, -0.8469918370246887, 0.5771166086196899, -0.09458574652671814, -0.15845243632793427, 0.5074652433395386, 0.27269184589385986, -0.35616016387939453, -0.929943323135376, 0.3512193560600281, -0.725669264793396, -0.7397800087928772, 0.616914689540863, -0.8459364771842957, 0.1499248445034027, 0.6390326023101807, 0.29944708943367004, -0.25916823744773865, -1.0592705011367798, -0.7811151742935181, -0.07809712737798691, -0.00752904312685132, -0.3315316140651703, 0.13571208715438843, -0.21823030710220337, -0.01964712142944336, -0.21846897900104523, -0.3269557058811188, 0.36813482642173767, -0.07614882290363312, 0.13515794277191162, -0.11465416103601456, -0.21159395575523376, -0.10032592713832855, 0.705645740032196, -0.0793679878115654, -0.7594078183174133, -0.42960885167121887, -0.1334964632987976, 0.17847242951393127, -0.4823867976665497, 0.847324550151825, -0.7968853712081909, -0.24753934144973755, 0.506460964679718, 0.4928174316883087, 0.425129771232605, 0.08514343947172165, -0.4512139558792114, 0.404657781124115, -0.9701890349388123, -0.8002495765686035, 0.3228558599948883, 0.318747878074646, -0.1215309128165245, 0.3118214011192322, -0.16250143945217133, -0.37367457151412964, -0.1382618099451065, 0.23548002541065216, -0.4550057053565979, -1.0918470621109009, -0.42997872829437256, -1.82047700881958, -1.131451964378357, -1.2499678134918213, 0.2593230605125427, -0.21377608180046082, 0.6307007074356079, -0.9441430568695068, 0.1318688839673996, -0.630490779876709, 0.028543880209326744, 0.22101248800754547, 0.4021967053413391, -0.8229118585586548, -0.05079151690006256, -1.1205109357833862, 0.059568025171756744, 0.3971043527126312, -1.1784981489181519, -0.8484899401664734, -0.1995561569929123, 0.5555211901664734, 0.8760668039321899, -0.6375300884246826, 0.5216352343559265, -0.09988865256309509, -0.5789645314216614, 0.3013446033000946, 0.1089295744895935, -0.39372947812080383, 0.9921628832817078, 0.08351492881774902, 0.8587561249732971, 0.07061227411031723, 0.5878061056137085, -0.08937257528305054, 0.18019603192806244, -0.871344268321991, 0.06789512187242508, 0.25718432664871216, 0.7935529351234436, 0.24235744774341583, -1.7868921756744385, 0.19870446622371674, -0.365464448928833, -0.7245833277702332, 0.5035092830657959, -0.37277716398239136, 0.1962060183286667, -0.7999985218048096, 0.07314636558294296, 0.083828866481781, 0.13915887475013733, 0.1511179655790329, 0.7021222710609436, -0.13485649228096008, -0.3702845573425293, -0.08850616961717606, 0.07424546033143997, 0.17152749001979828, 0.37712937593460083, -0.2397264689207077, -0.08257509768009186, 0.44218799471855164, -0.3941151201725006, -0.4320056736469269, -0.29029580950737, -0.728101372718811, -0.3371058702468872, -0.41662314534187317, 0.4634036421775818, -0.41025424003601074, 0.9258802533149719, 0.8152369856834412, -0.19538654386997223, 0.052850618958473206, -0.722739040851593, -0.8923489451408386, 0.15891654789447784, -0.14691928029060364, -1.0213738679885864, 0.16380368173122406, 0.12480977177619934, 0.11685378849506378, 0.7913177609443665, -0.8970307111740112, -0.16942648589611053, 0.16650527715682983, 1.0936447381973267, 1.0193272829055786, 0.21983639895915985, -0.3652947247028351, 0.6942130923271179, -0.5549899935722351, -0.2935928702354431, -0.7570239901542664, 0.22449935972690582, -1.0629487037658691, -0.5375891327857971, -0.7233597636222839, 0.2927250862121582, -0.004002100322395563, 0.1330862194299698, 0.0867110937833786, -0.29935896396636963, 0.08057082444429398, -0.11771108955144882, -0.39513251185417175, -0.03506951406598091, -0.06568926572799683, 0.46907684206962585, 0.037048254162073135, -0.9576277732849121, 0.08846263587474823, -0.38209468126296997, 0.5910767912864685, 0.5145406723022461, -0.22201630473136902, 1.2850838899612427, -0.2931377589702606, -0.39189741015434265, 0.6180503368377686, 0.58859783411026, 0.2279805839061737, 1.1385084390640259, -0.7392430305480957, 0.1245330348610878, 1.0374709367752075, 0.38727042078971863, 0.9809753894805908, 0.2704308032989502, -0.5477921962738037, 0.006801574490964413, 0.3406437635421753, 0.6102575063705444, 0.13703785836696625, 0.6087777018547058, 0.537489652633667, 0.581218421459198, -0.26429951190948486, -0.408096581697464, -0.38556504249572754, 0.4909597933292389, 0.810639500617981, -0.3134513795375824, -0.4595828354358673, -0.3646495044231415, -0.10265609622001648, 0.6945921778678894, -0.23899975419044495, -0.18640971183776855, -0.36703944206237793, -0.11289262026548386, -0.05879845842719078, 0.35984185338020325, -0.2640685439109802, 0.6779036521911621, 0.32931265234947205, 0.34913352131843567, -0.10921365767717361, 0.35375213623046875, 0.3759700655937195, 1.0209779739379883, 0.57108074426651, 0.0504378043115139, 0.16861064732074738, 1.0756841897964478, -0.5251238346099854, -0.94629967212677, 0.12343688309192657, 0.22036221623420715, -0.9258995652198792, -0.2605653703212738, -0.08428946137428284, -0.2331572026014328, -0.5864465236663818, -0.4562839865684509, -0.4974530041217804, -0.44453930854797363, 0.2587352991104126, -0.29199638962745667, -0.3337671458721161, -0.2243364304304123, 0.5381584763526917, -0.2340071052312851, 0.31979432702064514, 0.7303258180618286, 0.6822015643119812, -0.3197595179080963, 0.5061185359954834, 1.2765241861343384, 0.09861139208078384, -0.6318466067314148, -0.4496738910675049, 0.47334447503089905, 0.7636392116546631, 0.6226829886436462, -0.4661426246166229, 0.4094105064868927, -0.3813346028327942, 0.2577701807022095, -0.5547155737876892, 0.43536239862442017, -0.8570306897163391, 0.11416888982057571, 0.39098256826400757, 0.36599379777908325, -0.41087740659713745, 0.334556519985199, 0.7496280074119568, 0.6187856197357178, -0.581153154373169, -0.22105298936367035, 0.7104910016059875, -0.8085301518440247, 0.17486260831356049, -1.4470921754837036, 0.15102757513523102, 0.11193516105413437, 0.09005537629127502, -0.36712586879730225, -0.4423849284648895, -0.1972980946302414, -0.8273379802703857, -0.5925878882408142, -0.5560535192489624, 0.47731003165245056, 1.2283531427383423, -0.17802375555038452, 0.5257633924484253, -0.8701761960983276, -0.17724503576755524, -0.14566926658153534, 1.0222655534744263, 0.10946503281593323, 0.06591495871543884, 0.648690938949585, 0.15478627383708954, -1.1865143775939941, 0.25395309925079346, 0.6163359880447388, -0.39527881145477295, 0.6324067711830139, -0.5914945602416992, 0.37831392884254456, -0.2539299726486206, -0.0470440536737442, 0.06012995168566704, 0.2580270767211914, 0.3204468786716461, 0.36283382773399353, -0.5216981768608093, 0.31977978348731995, -0.4111218750476837, -0.023349327966570854, -0.8958948850631714, 0.350078284740448, 0.5079507827758789, -0.45766252279281616, -0.2320413440465927, -0.6313763856887817, 3.9663264751434326, 0.9658918976783752, 1.046517014503479, 0.1904604583978653, 0.8527724742889404, 1.400682806968689, -0.13767194747924805, 0.1132497638463974, 0.6089309453964233, -0.7396479249000549, 0.27977895736694336, -0.16762937605381012, -0.23286239802837372, -0.45275864005088806, 0.3226190507411957, 0.8037141561508179, 0.38541415333747864, -0.15947237610816956, -0.05090361461043358, -0.10388894379138947, -0.935084342956543, 0.36650392413139343, 0.17155982553958893, -0.1411084681749344, 0.7714636325836182, 0.5007320046424866, 0.5762766599655151, -0.8304608464241028, -0.9743252396583557, -0.008565815165638924, -0.24927933514118195, -0.540069043636322, -0.10412635654211044, -0.11760975420475006, -1.1310864686965942, 0.7844280004501343, 0.1425330489873886, -0.3161027133464813, 0.2778136432170868, -0.2737269401550293, 0.08174051344394684, 0.290880411863327, 0.7547099590301514, -0.4704439043998718, 0.2902836501598358, 1.0188267230987549, 0.3932875692844391, 0.5977984666824341, 0.9978101253509521, -0.43680107593536377, 0.131605863571167, 0.23290656507015228, 0.3331845700740814, -0.4146701395511627, -0.6911245584487915, -0.4186147451400757, 0.3990791141986847, 0.25957390666007996, -0.24680502712726593, 0.06950514763593674, 0.09769860655069351, -0.6235073804855347, 0.02170620858669281, 0.27213650941848755, -0.09375797212123871, 0.1758546382188797, 0.3913431465625763, -0.23710256814956665, -0.22970189154148102, 0.42302992939949036, -0.4556905925273895, 0.003254127223044634, -0.7608421444892883, -0.41393062472343445, 0.15550391376018524, 0.4948727488517761, 0.09947359561920166, 0.5177435874938965, -0.025092804804444313, 0.46275123953819275, -0.9618539810180664, -0.6813231110572815, -0.14385345578193665, -0.16394434869289398, -0.4767172932624817, 0.6653344035148621, 0.008686522953212261, 0.24230560660362244, -0.8427599668502808, 0.3905763030052185, -0.5062451362609863, 0.8332403898239136, -0.013386139646172523, -0.567436933517456, -0.4201606512069702 ]
Canonical Quantum Gravity and the Problem of Time
This is the write-up of my lectures at the NATO Summer School held in Salamanca in June 1992. The paper deals with the problem of time in quantum gravity. All the major schemes are reviewed. Please note that the paper is in two parts for ease of email transmission; this is part 1. The mailer from gr-qc may further subdivide these two sections.
Chris J. Isham
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210011
gr-qc/9210012
[ 0.25931546092033386, 0.07057724893093109, 0.23086731135845184, 0.26370394229888916, 0.11038562655448914, -0.4048808217048645, -0.3572167754173279, 0.22425483167171478, -0.29196399450302124, 1.3815908432006836, -0.10691453516483307, -0.11727157235145569, -0.06526361405849457, -1.0651742219924927, -0.34253227710723877, 0.6719961762428284, -0.008659281767904758, -0.2073429971933365, -1.0193389654159546, 0.672357976436615, 0.08289765566587448, 0.23199056088924408, -0.8563195466995239, -0.473341166973114, -0.1724533885717392, 0.9005311727523804, 0.7156869769096375, 0.5380958318710327, 1.2653156518936157, 1.0579863786697388, 0.37639880180358887, 0.004279659129679203, 0.1750146746635437, -0.3843691349029541, -0.34556424617767334, 0.047265298664569855, 0.3560119867324829, -0.5578143000602722, 1.060187816619873, -0.3296537697315216, 0.4990878403186798, -0.5419431328773499, 0.21418370306491852, -0.5870583653450012, -0.49716490507125854, -0.10732967406511307, -0.021710442379117012, 0.2732609808444977, -0.023850005120038986, -1.3224495649337769, -0.11834122240543365, -0.04237945377826691, 0.24157844483852386, -0.574785590171814, -0.5302326679229736, -0.4467359483242035, 0.2971210479736328, 0.22757938504219055, -0.14028368890285492, 0.1707991361618042, -0.05684376135468483, 0.18434856832027435, 0.07135310769081116, -1.1936084032058716, -0.21816004812717438, 0.7755746841430664, 0.4355873465538025, 0.6028067469596863, 0.4381349980831146, -0.5401545763015747, -0.3708537817001343, -0.1630280613899231, -0.23249191045761108, 0.504982590675354, -0.30702951550483704, 0.46313080191612244, -0.23776905238628387, -0.3525257706642151, -0.33749932050704956, -0.26306796073913574, -0.17992185056209564, 0.12188301235437393, -0.028387343510985374, 0.30248671770095825, -0.15459120273590088, -0.47544223070144653, 0.45685628056526184, -0.3400147557258606, 0.572920024394989, -0.28565526008605957, 0.0025813686661422253, 0.40538063645362854, -0.38400334119796753, 0.03314818814396858, 0.5438505411148071, 0.6139368414878845, -0.3827085494995117, 0.921123206615448, 0.05102050304412842, -0.20306731760501862, -0.6702200174331665, 1.1816469430923462, -0.42873021960258484, 0.20722900331020355, -0.808756411075592, 0.34949836134910583, -0.22517408430576324, 0.024649130180478096, -0.7263208031654358, -0.5598717331886292, 0.426388680934906, -0.1167491227388382, 0.6825854778289795, 0.22892513871192932, 0.16528116166591644, 0.6792532801628113, -0.7913962006568909, 0.08424842357635498, -1.2581844329833984, -0.703223466873169, -0.13707749545574188, 0.2672339379787445, 0.2489771693944931, 0.4932319223880768, -0.21318775415420532, -0.33324840664863586, -0.21048566699028015, 0.43085548281669617, -0.6583365201950073, 0.7093744874000549, 0.617021918296814, -0.04655902832746506, 0.5678508281707764, 0.4533299505710602, 0.16302189230918884, -0.021973866969347, -0.3058255910873413, 0.4432884752750397, -0.5159875154495239, -0.6154507398605347, -0.14329782128334045, 0.010307501070201397, -0.13588958978652954, 1.297345519065857, -0.6626062989234924, 0.016781730577349663, -0.21424813568592072, 0.6730270385742188, -0.5703058838844299, -0.021680250763893127, -0.3994287848472595, -0.434455007314682, -0.13077004253864288, 0.6670026779174805, -0.30359891057014465, -0.03114764764904976, -1.5176066160202026, -0.08720702677965164, -0.27641358971595764, -0.3488546907901764, 0.5573378205299377, 0.1138431578874588, 0.2823503613471985, 1.0611481666564941, -0.27672576904296875, 0.2885929048061371, -0.9998185038566589, -0.7052682042121887, 0.30178678035736084, 0.15799787640571594, -0.6192633509635925, 0.30648159980773926, 0.06361422687768936, 0.8451902270317078, 1.5992392301559448, 0.4011041522026062, 0.1387668251991272, -0.4036117196083069, -0.5526742935180664, 0.6473276019096375, -0.6607545018196106, -0.8735666871070862, 0.36966076493263245, 0.37940385937690735, -0.5547969341278076, -0.47626158595085144, 0.4292556047439575, -0.7497662901878357, 0.4386085569858551, 0.09788605570793152, -0.976477861404419, 1.078396201133728, -0.9494503736495972, 0.8198942542076111, -0.36480584740638733, 0.2106568068265915, -1.1531842947006226, -0.207979217171669, -0.23252935707569122, -0.061016745865345, 0.18224410712718964, -0.47084975242614746, -0.7248349189758301, -0.22743669152259827, -0.9261046051979065, 0.1376124918460846, 0.36173343658447266, 1.0006922483444214, 0.043575480580329895, -0.10000599920749664, 0.4960419237613678, -0.32206255197525024, 0.10952293872833252, 0.0032193537335842848, 0.09350569546222687, -0.2047320008277893, -0.023983485996723175, 0.49455735087394714, 0.24229513108730316, 0.2862604260444641, 0.4583353102207184, -0.010871194303035736, 0.34751930832862854, 0.9798005819320679, -0.025480570271611214, 0.1888696551322937, -0.22650554776191711, 0.32829734683036804, -0.11165023595094681, 0.4584578573703766, -0.003503948450088501, 0.3225040137767792, 0.34997040033340454, 0.22583787143230438, 0.2230689823627472, -0.1852264255285263, 0.6998330354690552, 0.32132381200790405, 0.1190800666809082, 0.22203291952610016, 0.03906695917248726, 0.12792429327964783, 0.3073974847793579, 0.08176901936531067, -0.607555091381073, 0.8884456753730774, 0.24321557581424713, 0.28810033202171326, -0.3223411738872528, 0.685245931148529, -0.7522642016410828, 0.06499133259057999, 0.32757940888404846, -0.15774671733379364, -1.1305770874023438, -0.0014964933507144451, -0.6687240600585938, 0.20682945847511292, 0.27968737483024597, -0.6627938151359558, 0.07723865658044815, 0.0470556877553463, -0.3015865385532379, -0.8739523887634277, 0.192876935005188, 0.15090657770633698, -0.5599602460861206, 0.3685339093208313, 0.772594153881073, -0.27658820152282715, -1.0871140956878662, 0.1027579978108406, -0.8720889091491699, 0.4314011037349701, -0.2609083652496338, -0.20735348761081696, 0.6988772749900818, -0.8027499914169312, 0.7457366585731506, 0.19692939519882202, -0.012953689321875572, 0.43362730741500854, 0.12924788892269135, 0.0354035347700119, -0.8463377952575684, 0.4010757505893707, -1.5105154514312744, 0.31371748447418213, -1.082298755645752, 0.3116447627544403, -0.7849349975585938, -0.27497103810310364, 0.221837118268013, 0.10447071492671967, 0.5561042428016663, 0.5819206237792969, -0.22387973964214325, -0.23975849151611328, -0.6092596650123596, -0.989603579044342, 0.4780429005622864, 0.26190871000289917, 0.0973319336771965, -0.3381797969341278, -0.8710359334945679, 1.3097208738327026, -0.28938159346580505, -0.3669464588165283, 0.7066437005996704, -0.41461804509162903, -0.42450499534606934, -0.20234514772891998, 1.1467416286468506, 0.9221072793006897, -0.31251904368400574, 0.8765531182289124, 0.6733759641647339, -0.09691927582025528, 0.5239596962928772, 0.1008160263299942, -0.1902378350496292, -0.15926657617092133, 0.9985164999961853, -0.6645861268043518, 0.43876171112060547, 0.9139381051063538, 0.1703391671180725, -0.6055764555931091, 0.5781065821647644, -1.0482006072998047, -0.7170005440711975, 0.2839010953903198, -0.05777880549430847, 0.5261403918266296, 0.1295793205499649, 0.6534551382064819, -0.33109748363494873, -1.1394284963607788, -0.5183731317520142, 0.3535342812538147, 0.34252309799194336, 0.26635047793388367, -0.24007949233055115, 0.36589255928993225, 0.3933185040950775, -0.05370492488145828, 0.613926887512207, -0.9417651295661926, -0.2478654682636261, -0.19145166873931885, -0.5173380970954895, 0.31107378005981445, 0.0661039724946022, -0.18735741078853607, -0.4431228041648865, 0.4004868268966675, -0.4002693295478821, -0.4844302535057068, -1.2412631511688232, -0.7627812027931213, 0.40856271982192993, 0.14133422076702118, -0.28355810046195984, -0.7988515496253967, -0.46292051672935486, -0.394310861825943, 0.6600282192230225, 0.25342118740081787, 0.7300825715065002, -0.38721123337745667, 0.5855059027671814, 0.3733495771884918, -0.5131091475486755, 0.020956939086318016, -0.14323367178440094, 0.08012270927429199, 0.2685343325138092, 0.029138006269931793, 0.21816855669021606, -0.13930508494377136, -0.7649577260017395, -0.6849039196968079, 0.7304195761680603, 0.03213543817400932, 0.5132315754890442, -0.015140486881136894, -0.14816299080848694, -0.35741159319877625, -0.11090528964996338, -0.38226014375686646, -0.3963269591331482, -0.16186150908470154, -0.09026261419057846, -0.3897697627544403, -0.31687816977500916, 0.03415271267294884, 0.21811039745807648, 1.3019763231277466, -0.04687771201133728, 0.16722911596298218, -0.3300829231739044, -0.17109590768814087, 0.18077702820301056, 0.7574024796485901, -0.37551501393318176, 0.4308510720729828, -0.5282977819442749, 0.6408781409263611, 0.5186193585395813, 0.2718864977359772, 0.32815951108932495, -0.8153193593025208, -0.2895023822784424, -0.24575559794902802, 0.4534614086151123, -0.07095932960510254, -0.598014771938324, 0.5064092874526978, 0.4200594127178192, -0.17455743253231049, -0.31323549151420593, 0.6432720422744751, 0.598210334777832, 0.24199850857257843, -0.16272102296352386, -0.5495234131813049, -0.2934643030166626, -0.1673840880393982, -0.27295154333114624, 0.36190831661224365, -0.1057855486869812, -0.6075092554092407, -0.48635220527648926, -0.5736797451972961, -0.4758915603160858, 0.3724832832813263, 0.7092340588569641, 0.5552393794059753, 0.41736355423927307, -0.1459909826517105, -0.050613969564437866, 1.198494791984558, -0.011425758711993694, -0.47038528323173523, -0.15189392864704132, 0.4344639778137207, 0.030374646186828613, 0.7503993511199951, -0.06387729942798615, -0.49541860818862915, -0.6772693991661072, -0.15510141849517822, 0.5722581148147583, -0.3357718884944916, -0.640623152256012, 0.11840850859880447, -0.0022688782773911953, -0.33729302883148193, 0.3712872266769409, -0.2324627786874771, 0.25993162393569946, -0.13131141662597656, -0.15581075847148895, -0.24185141921043396, -0.025414710864424706, 0.13181766867637634, -0.030323239043354988, 0.11535216122865677, 0.7452357411384583, 0.4641073942184448, 0.4079667329788208, 0.3993173837661743, -0.2555643916130066, 0.4011738896369934, 0.5171597003936768, -0.3072274625301361, -0.2604914903640747, -0.10081504285335541, -0.28444012999534607, -0.4104551374912262, -0.34158143401145935, 0.4364466369152069, -0.27270767092704773, 0.12351773679256439, 0.46361249685287476, -0.5511594414710999, -0.42581990361213684, -0.6164557933807373, -0.6299091577529907, 0.5059716105461121, -0.2236390858888626, 0.26996445655822754, 0.8087626099586487, -0.3065040111541748, -0.6889048218727112, -0.5274500250816345, -0.35059788823127747, -0.4416596591472626, -0.16184642910957336, 0.8876473307609558, 0.14221051335334778, 0.6391080617904663, -0.5419498682022095, 1.0183498859405518, -0.5371118783950806, -0.5229686498641968, -0.5592312812805176, -0.19902469217777252, -0.4791598916053772, 0.361435204744339, 0.1548895388841629, -0.011111825704574585, 0.5017280578613281, 0.043479546904563904, -0.1177196204662323, 0.6382623910903931, 0.2154008448123932, -0.5786487460136414, -0.09244933724403381, 0.10393189638853073, 0.34982749819755554, -0.7041143774986267, -0.024725206196308136, 0.9708646535873413, 0.013206317089498043, 0.42821142077445984, -0.20993566513061523, -0.27493715286254883, 0.21604953706264496, -1.4095368385314941, 0.5298866033554077, -0.7687714099884033, -0.28932785987854004, -0.26214835047721863, -0.4023565351963043, 0.5554870963096619, 0.08920957893133163, -0.6591364145278931, -0.7542943954467773, -0.6267749071121216, 0.11035913228988647, 0.5244792699813843, -1.0157668590545654, 0.20970755815505981, -0.40518298745155334, -0.4372415542602539, -1.0297120809555054, 1.181631088256836, -0.4158564805984497, 0.2062588632106781, 0.4895074665546417, 0.1161825880408287, -0.3282667398452759, 0.5020000338554382, -0.05869070813059807, 0.14241938292980194, -0.9235394597053528, 0.021577252075076103, -0.42520618438720703, 0.450124591588974, -0.5260775089263916, -0.14336131513118744, -0.07727636396884918, 0.5243088006973267, 0.03106984868645668, -0.2916589677333832, 0.36696577072143555, -0.06850860267877579, 0.7571687698364258, -1.0485332012176514, -0.2530413568019867, 0.8422137498855591, 0.32692891359329224, 0.32010307908058167, 0.018727080896496773, -0.4937998354434967, -0.4993545114994049, -0.5581056475639343, -0.7674506902694702, 0.2727549970149994, 0.03361650928854942, -0.17064061760902405, -0.7016276121139526, -0.6127330660820007, 0.3225318491458893, -0.38818177580833435, -0.10984331369400024, 0.6734122037887573, -0.1429002583026886, 0.23178337514400482, -0.22149653732776642, -0.16564743220806122, -0.5322923064231873, -0.09196829050779343, 0.22358864545822144, 0.07068481296300888, 0.07334066927433014, -0.11723484843969345, -0.23374472558498383, -0.3799761235713959, -0.37514135241508484, 0.10622163861989975, 0.31655415892601013, -0.2432681769132614, 0.5235212445259094, 0.25231292843818665, -0.3039161264896393, -0.7536405324935913, 0.13811175525188446, -0.05358509346842766, -0.06983613967895508, 0.3438083529472351, -0.32795456051826477, 0.05967540293931961, 0.4171651005744934, -0.012838089838624, -0.5784899592399597, -0.6581717133522034, 0.8614469766616821, -0.7599570155143738, 0.09424792975187302, 0.3371867835521698, -0.2415839433670044, -0.6542200446128845, -1.2237677574157715, -0.6683021783828735, -0.3946242034435272, 0.450757771730423, -0.29849985241889954, 0.07404099404811859, 0.1441742479801178, 0.1497243493795395, -0.032525673508644104, 0.6388503909111023, 0.9228236079216003, 0.44930562376976013, 0.23615047335624695, 0.0621810108423233, -0.8268794417381287, -0.014249878004193306, 1.1252986192703247, 0.3574851453304291, -1.1345374584197998, 0.07491786032915115, 0.3159683346748352, 0.04306202381849289, -0.6141018271446228, 1.2060279846191406, -0.2993300259113312, 0.452446311712265, -0.2251712828874588, -0.16141872107982635, 0.4432918131351471, 0.06532992422580719, -0.6918335556983948, 0.26767802238464355, -0.45164981484413147, -0.1930404007434845, 0.0838916003704071, -0.0258332472294569, 0.24513034522533417, 0.44361183047294617, 0.0328628346323967, -0.42605501413345337, -0.0638115331530571, 0.20775765180587769, 0.03775576502084732, -0.6550366282463074, -0.6201199889183044, -0.5833345055580139, -0.7709862589836121, -0.7549301981925964, -0.24150407314300537, -0.1170959547162056, 0.26385530829429626, -0.8446930050849915, -0.09886639565229416, -0.17549599707126617, 0.1113058403134346, 0.054906126111745834, 1.2776081562042236, -0.5745013356208801, -1.0653656721115112, -0.9923180341720581, 0.65574049949646, -0.0009582455386407673, -1.3847965002059937, -0.3792068660259247, -0.24063146114349365, 0.09904540330171585, 0.6578443050384521, -0.6141377687454224, 0.7566773295402527, -0.1317969709634781, -0.7907906174659729, 0.5714948177337646, 0.4043441414833069, -0.40566304326057434, 1.0007357597351074, 0.3761700689792633, 0.7880579829216003, 0.8587023019790649, 0.1747773289680481, 0.15835893154144287, -0.2325579822063446, -0.9372309446334839, 0.9819228649139404, 0.08500903099775314, 1.1052113771438599, 0.44512122869491577, -1.2340507507324219, 0.2766015827655792, 0.5714816451072693, -0.8476548194885254, 0.08585436642169952, -0.6122375726699829, 0.31528669595718384, -0.6564297676086426, 0.32256028056144714, 0.28876808285713196, 0.34811002016067505, -0.15829524397850037, 0.24193264544010162, -0.889108419418335, 0.30497291684150696, 0.2228299230337143, 0.41478481888771057, -0.5145674347877502, -0.4338150918483734, 0.3022218644618988, -0.3053112030029297, 0.17516089975833893, -0.5167443752288818, -0.0015922057209536433, 0.5097684264183044, 0.3181716203689575, -0.2217869758605957, -0.19710087776184082, 0.42935696244239807, -0.7470660209655762, 0.4881208539009094, 0.13881954550743103, -0.1874665766954422, 1.0193908214569092, -0.2753559947013855, -1.5192036628723145, 0.21807150542736053, 0.0778663232922554, -0.6606955528259277, 0.144908607006073, -0.06890363991260529, 0.2910769283771515, 0.6253880858421326, -0.35123175382614136, -0.12527741491794586, 0.08653592318296432, 0.7984260320663452, 0.6371705532073975, 0.11364629119634628, -0.5841882228851318, -0.047242965549230576, -0.2355693131685257, -0.30282872915267944, -0.35938796401023865, 0.15168938040733337, -0.6183826923370361, -0.47350361943244934, -0.09627746045589447, 0.1276995837688446, -0.5078082084655762, -0.3627283275127411, 0.03493054211139679, -0.6787698864936829, -0.3146662712097168, -0.10823693126440048, -0.444172739982605, -0.4325249493122101, -0.7738873362541199, 0.7851552963256836, 0.5258192420005798, -0.3844287097454071, 0.4979996681213379, -0.14089369773864746, 0.8550123572349548, 0.4533887803554535, 0.3175734877586365, 1.0487724542617798, 0.010788572952151299, 0.4076007604598999, -0.014127681963145733, 0.25246235728263855, 0.08353955298662186, 0.31241151690483093, -0.8287506699562073, 0.13759316504001617, 0.46805131435394287, -0.32909172773361206, 1.003180742263794, 0.26209160685539246, 0.19842594861984253, 0.506306529045105, 0.4265218675136566, 0.2501174509525299, 0.3165990710258484, -0.3013271391391754, 0.15380193293094635, 0.10496460646390915, -0.2662582993507385, -0.18378806114196777, -0.11877179145812988, 0.1915854662656784, 0.2239881157875061, -0.32150858640670776, -0.2509777843952179, -0.8341413140296936, 0.3500298857688904, 0.6060352921485901, -0.31915438175201416, -1.1115554571151733, -0.8015902638435364, 0.17864282429218292, 0.0014914590865373611, 0.5260795950889587, -0.7097891569137573, 0.3810293972492218, 1.0410115718841553, 0.32448163628578186, -0.4632275700569153, 0.4912361204624176, 0.0727190375328064, 1.2071967124938965, 1.0029361248016357, 0.28415927290916443, 0.4574892520904541, 0.5892784595489502, 0.2113046497106552, -1.0516598224639893, -0.210109680891037, 0.414065957069397, -0.4555296301841736, 0.5001576542854309, 0.06371208280324936, -0.4803164601325989, -0.04232862591743469, -0.4410236179828644, 0.05265118554234505, -0.2510359585285187, -0.37161874771118164, -0.1358713060617447, -0.11307451874017715, -0.20589251816272736, 0.27271535992622375, 0.021918514743447304, 0.6993286609649658, 0.5849190950393677, 0.33482855558395386, -0.08297788351774216, 0.6371607780456543, 0.9242186546325684, 0.22948114573955536, 0.5520832538604736, -0.03959864377975464, -0.046658970415592194, 0.29238542914390564, 0.3367201089859009, -0.5579956769943237, 0.4413956105709076, -0.4415864050388336, 0.02017522044479847, 0.45677798986434937, -0.1151019036769867, -0.08858969807624817, -0.258457750082016, -0.16312071681022644, 0.81932532787323, -0.45681118965148926, -0.12127357721328735, 0.6877565383911133, 0.3963555693626404, -0.4460022747516632, -0.5721296072006226, 1.0239869356155396, -0.8202546238899231, 0.21964062750339508, -0.5883187055587769, 0.4809628129005432, -0.2248910665512085, -0.18086247146129608, -0.2640485465526581, -0.6154713034629822, -0.6812063455581665, -0.7642269134521484, -0.13818016648292542, -0.5104831457138062, 1.1545133590698242, 0.7112914323806763, -0.07918889075517654, 0.028329240158200264, -0.4140629470348358, -0.3713018000125885, -0.3201291561126709, 1.174920678138733, 0.20668987929821014, 0.2618923485279083, 0.3501158654689789, 0.28197935223579407, -0.901421844959259, 0.49329134821891785, 0.4333527386188507, -0.22889484465122223, 0.9489856958389282, -0.35142332315444946, 0.39668288826942444, -0.07359648495912552, -0.38438087701797485, -0.3419845700263977, -0.07775095850229263, 0.44563284516334534, 0.32315170764923096, -0.5768229365348816, 0.05277356505393982, -0.05367209389805794, -0.1346934586763382, -0.44077399373054504, -0.20445610582828522, 0.547581672668457, -0.3499615788459778, 0.16071563959121704, -0.38517624139785767, 4.166754245758057, 0.6971501111984253, 0.4907194674015045, 0.23033832013607025, 0.5635660290718079, 0.7255955934524536, -0.022791162133216858, 0.3190651535987854, -0.10900642722845078, -0.48987096548080444, -0.24306620657444, -0.35516005754470825, 0.4576033353805542, 0.504517674446106, -0.04905536025762558, 0.2610929608345032, 0.08174068480730057, 0.05849987640976906, -0.324582576751709, -0.2772464454174042, -0.8182803988456726, 0.5103632211685181, 0.6832736134529114, 0.20203973352909088, 0.1406158059835434, 0.2465742826461792, 0.14389503002166748, -0.8594091534614563, -1.0786536931991577, -0.9751638174057007, -0.34206023812294006, -0.8792372941970825, 0.3674992620944977, -0.034529298543930054, -1.1244885921478271, 0.3788512647151947, 0.2880769968032837, -0.6008371710777283, 0.4746365249156952, 0.1069922223687172, -0.07529512047767639, -0.20751236379146576, 0.46645215153694153, -0.8849560022354126, 0.4812573790550232, 0.6140194535255432, 0.4048173129558563, 0.9654356241226196, 0.6074108481407166, -0.7675806283950806, -0.055838800966739655, 0.32296842336654663, 0.013119598850607872, -0.003909070044755936, -0.6898511648178101, -0.5484558939933777, -0.4642525613307953, 0.15817834436893463, 0.033070050179958344, -0.28178247809410095, 0.7247347831726074, -0.2568129301071167, -0.23453094065189362, 0.28476542234420776, -0.2643393576145172, 0.509132444858551, -0.5100082755088806, 0.1377587765455246, -0.39715293049812317, -0.48250827193260193, -0.6579991579055786, 0.334921658039093, -0.6974362730979919, 0.08108103275299072, 0.5019172430038452, 0.521291971206665, 0.2855079770088196, 0.9703947305679321, -0.16123685240745544, 0.454148530960083, -0.5815327167510986, -0.3900710642337799, -0.2027045488357544, 0.9814428687095642, 0.2825602889060974, 0.5649710297584534, -0.4386003911495209, 0.08752556145191193, -0.6269699335098267, 0.22028309106826782, -0.21371333301067352, 0.711476743221283, 0.21053250133991241, 0.4296455383300781, -0.7866005897521973 ]
No Time Machines from Lightlike Sources in 2+1 Gravity
We extend the argument that spacetimes generated by two timelike particles in D=3 gravity (or equivalently by parallel-moving cosmic strings in D=4) permit closed timelike curves (CTC) only at the price of Misner identifications that correspond to unphysical boundary conditions at spatial infinity and to a tachyonic center of mass. Here we analyze geometries one or both of whose sources are lightlike. We make manifest both the presence of CTC at spatial infinity if they are present at all, and the tachyonic character of the system: As the total energy surpasses its tachyonic bound, CTC first begin to form at spatial infinity, then spread to the interior as the energy increases further. We then show that, in contrast, CTC are entirely forbidden in topologically massive gravity for geometries generated by lightlike sources.
S. Deser and Alan R. Steif
gr-qc hep-th
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210012
gr-qc/9210013
[ 0.18884973227977753, -0.19959403574466705, 0.4542995095252991, -0.03694292530417442, 0.5726269483566284, -0.02086688205599785, -0.21465884149074554, 0.00202974583953619, -0.5002133250236511, 1.3061740398406982, 0.4494001567363739, 0.1724565476179123, 0.1523190587759018, -0.9009901881217957, 0.3435196876525879, 0.5751449465751648, 0.2525422275066376, -0.13789400458335876, -1.2812907695770264, 0.6562585830688477, -0.35482823848724365, -0.006664970889687538, -1.31050705909729, -0.34907180070877075, -0.3430574834346771, 0.8003953695297241, 0.6414919495582581, 0.5609128475189209, 0.829930305480957, 1.0324944257736206, 0.4729703664779663, -0.018976297229528427, 0.2380717396736145, -0.7341583967208862, -0.5785560607910156, -0.02921340987086296, 0.1066574826836586, -0.7626760005950928, 0.6880958676338196, -0.29969510436058044, 0.5403218865394592, -0.06956247240304947, 0.4195852279663086, 0.020986495539546013, -0.669880747795105, -0.03361412510275841, 0.07714398950338364, -0.20110449194908142, 0.5051736235618591, -0.546796441078186, -0.4233349561691284, -0.7978126406669617, 0.21226952970027924, -0.5078480839729309, -0.3594140112400055, -0.44444260001182556, 0.01499013602733612, 0.16833697259426117, -0.6883435249328613, -0.05754877254366875, 0.4941156506538391, 0.5156526565551758, 0.5516944527626038, -0.24708960950374603, 0.22196710109710693, 1.6312296390533447, -0.1551167219877243, 0.4387536644935608, 0.20881083607673645, -0.6552820801734924, -0.3382391929626465, 0.06126641854643822, -0.8094245195388794, 0.5481175184249878, 0.1289612054824829, -0.009926133789122105, -0.2020421028137207, -0.2677745819091797, -0.6014121770858765, -0.009878712706267834, -0.19914087653160095, -0.13543277978897095, 0.1799827218055725, 0.7369702458381653, 0.2253280133008957, -0.20886948704719543, -0.12011461704969406, -0.301853209733963, 0.5179029703140259, 0.28450292348861694, 0.2742878794670105, 0.39316993951797485, -0.1832818239927292, -0.26776227355003357, 0.3181864619255066, 1.0542058944702148, -0.6378613710403442, -0.025315480306744576, -0.14111647009849548, 0.16690178215503693, -0.7878206968307495, 0.9988489747047424, 0.009991413913667202, 0.2429562509059906, -0.7823905348777771, 0.8891608119010925, -0.2994588017463684, 0.3951795697212219, -0.7644159197807312, -1.1717742681503296, 0.37737175822257996, 0.013595683500170708, 0.7543553709983826, 0.17051859200000763, 0.22769686579704285, 1.0344823598861694, -0.8695534467697144, 0.20345714688301086, -1.3599971532821655, -0.5995072722434998, -0.8461024165153503, 0.5782554745674133, -0.07903668284416199, 0.3573816418647766, 0.199893057346344, -0.7303434610366821, -0.31266772747039795, 0.004819198045879602, -0.8483753800392151, 0.18475481867790222, 0.5587594509124756, -0.6353737115859985, -0.47308915853500366, 0.6483320593833923, -0.06267089396715164, 0.7133969068527222, 0.42701268196105957, -0.18425136804580688, -0.6080538034439087, -0.8345248699188232, 0.5159934759140015, -0.4755464494228363, 0.3381640911102295, 1.0251362323760986, -0.5443462133407593, 0.8124382495880127, 0.5549693703651428, -0.30658552050590515, -0.8749271035194397, 0.0744018703699112, 0.361502468585968, -0.6130321621894836, -0.18328824639320374, -0.2219342291355133, -0.1141262799501419, 0.0874774381518364, -1.6105120182037354, 0.7924324870109558, -0.33985358476638794, -0.1733044534921646, 0.7501827478408813, 0.18798936903476715, 0.1944492757320404, 1.287987470626831, -0.11108504980802536, -0.25484585762023926, -0.5823241472244263, -0.7559667825698853, 0.35364028811454773, -0.4214411973953247, -0.5557823181152344, 0.21462731063365936, -0.006990324705839157, -0.2651084065437317, 0.905288815498352, 0.4992806315422058, 0.3591051995754242, -0.43468040227890015, -0.4806758761405945, 0.3917102813720703, -0.15793412923812866, -0.8403780460357666, 0.731245219707489, 0.9255036115646362, -0.618591845035553, -0.4980512857437134, 0.35909751057624817, -0.30778178572654724, 0.16258026659488678, 0.23890946805477142, -0.6833299398422241, 0.35417306423187256, -1.2194231748580933, -0.06569799780845642, -1.1217498779296875, 0.7552472949028015, -0.8588550686836243, 0.15635016560554504, -0.14917965233325958, 0.09686329215765, 0.0007221056148409843, 0.2821291983127594, -1.060689091682434, 0.9338734149932861, -0.7459806203842163, 0.014787470921874046, 0.596470296382904, 0.1698104441165924, 0.33330339193344116, -0.17486852407455444, 0.7180203795433044, -0.5914799571037292, -0.19171467423439026, 0.21947281062602997, 0.8624138832092285, 0.265336275100708, -0.4996357858181, 0.27209338545799255, 0.04612105339765549, 0.5614215135574341, 0.8362116813659668, 0.2746938169002533, -0.01010551955550909, 1.263136863708496, 0.2524447441101074, 0.20719701051712036, -0.2353685200214386, 0.8865092396736145, 0.0411561019718647, 0.4407307207584381, -0.4683845341205597, 0.0518239326775074, 0.3121011555194855, -0.015573663637042046, 0.4903540313243866, 0.16816307604312897, 0.8353592753410339, 0.7794422507286072, -0.25254184007644653, -0.2478312849998474, 0.32589322328567505, 0.2584986090660095, 0.2659545838832855, 0.3504173159599304, -0.45076024532318115, 0.5438730716705322, 0.08245434612035751, -0.2928375005722046, -0.7946464419364929, 0.6809459328651428, -1.113696575164795, 1.6310547590255737, 0.24520929157733917, -0.03931073844432831, -1.4005638360977173, 0.3830924928188324, -0.628512442111969, 0.3636029362678528, 0.23641836643218994, -0.8522790670394897, -0.7313823103904724, 0.6453613638877869, -0.15424588322639465, -0.339557409286499, -0.06465375423431396, 0.19089961051940918, -0.6476258039474487, -0.1924484372138977, 0.2093607634305954, -0.7234334945678711, -1.458837628364563, -0.18249019980430603, -0.5355236530303955, 0.34954190254211426, 0.3602254092693329, -0.060514628887176514, 0.3433646261692047, 0.22759990394115448, 0.8263939023017883, -0.13527408242225647, 0.3339058458805084, -0.2683044970035553, -0.6364535093307495, 0.1578812152147293, -0.4903455972671509, 0.4990329444408417, -0.9948260188102722, 0.02629527635872364, -1.3629846572875977, -0.1416182518005371, -0.4555354118347168, -0.5011523365974426, 0.513208270072937, -0.7698624730110168, 0.3104396462440491, 0.514370858669281, -0.18273785710334778, -0.01704438216984272, -0.5774685740470886, -0.0607706755399704, 0.055493105202913284, 0.3770858943462372, -0.30038559436798096, -0.17317703366279602, -0.41550737619400024, 1.276330828666687, -0.1928967386484146, -0.05685868114233017, 0.9443464279174805, -0.4847555160522461, -0.688579797744751, -0.22239084541797638, -0.21584096550941467, 0.7862604260444641, -0.18662254512310028, 0.24570821225643158, 0.9418312311172485, -0.25453826785087585, 0.7203853726387024, 0.09597513824701309, -0.4449712038040161, 0.11550875753164291, 0.6109793186187744, -0.6193532943725586, 0.4367798864841461, 0.9425246715545654, 0.6074574589729309, -0.8872312307357788, 0.36201155185699463, -0.8502717018127441, -1.0348132848739624, -0.07570544630289078, -0.013600330799818039, 0.27317267656326294, 0.17569708824157715, 0.5322213172912598, 0.431061714887619, -0.10183822363615036, -0.8211366534233093, 0.4420929551124573, 0.34406808018684387, 0.12856216728687286, 0.04510324448347092, 0.6098578572273254, 0.5418420433998108, 0.1849159151315689, 0.2836947441101074, -0.6047362089157104, -0.4327837824821472, -0.1638948619365692, -0.5383804440498352, 0.08577079325914383, 0.5826644897460938, -0.7102057933807373, -0.2635379135608673, -0.15300293266773224, 0.0036130184307694435, -0.2631448805332184, -0.7185145020484924, -1.2697163820266724, 0.14879460632801056, -0.26161080598831177, -0.08280716091394424, -0.29390883445739746, -0.4669070839881897, 0.008797152899205685, 0.3196612000465393, 0.3497565686702728, 0.7183629274368286, -0.5737488269805908, 0.3231689929962158, 0.47637394070625305, -0.244442880153656, -0.49567049741744995, 0.23825624585151672, 0.4912954270839691, 0.5094698071479797, 0.22065839171409607, 0.042286466807127, -0.25513944029808044, -0.4208177328109741, -0.24776746332645416, 0.6999065279960632, 0.1872328519821167, 0.18309172987937927, -0.6596264243125916, -0.25491583347320557, -0.13102391362190247, 0.2564714252948761, -0.06250181049108505, -0.183639258146286, -0.9826347231864929, 0.20697559416294098, -0.31890788674354553, -0.69749516248703, 0.08162691444158554, 0.3328816294670105, 0.8073065280914307, 0.12172296643257141, 0.01392985787242651, 0.15516206622123718, 0.12207453697919846, 0.22665733098983765, 0.40366703271865845, -0.7419463992118835, 0.033736106008291245, -0.7054314017295837, 0.8874529600143433, 0.21252231299877167, -0.3910819888114929, 0.217820942401886, -0.08999761939048767, 0.3245348632335663, 0.1436224728822708, 0.4909626543521881, 0.7803165912628174, -0.1422089785337448, 0.006071357522159815, 0.5673889517784119, -0.5687984228134155, -0.4523274302482605, 0.07555897533893585, 1.0368189811706543, 0.3544105887413025, 0.12081632018089294, -0.4178192913532257, 0.3163565993309021, -0.17603081464767456, -0.42835456132888794, 0.261267751455307, -0.7076093554496765, -0.7073062062263489, -0.7739898562431335, 0.32033881545066833, 0.2511473000049591, 0.32927796244621277, 0.909751832485199, 0.296954870223999, 0.8349891304969788, -0.10307685285806656, 0.4870760142803192, 1.1190117597579956, -0.2843378484249115, -0.2509765028953552, 0.1589951068162918, 0.5161753296852112, 0.1927666813135147, 0.9444945454597473, -0.2586209177970886, -0.503438413143158, 0.3984360098838806, -0.6995915770530701, 1.0375890731811523, -0.1231917217373848, -0.037559591233730316, 0.24360640347003937, 0.2434394657611847, -0.5144573450088501, 0.48452311754226685, -0.17289701104164124, -0.15274342894554138, 0.23615674674510956, -0.04809222370386124, -0.9084645509719849, -0.03804832324385643, 0.07101871818304062, -0.6925996541976929, 0.5613369941711426, 0.10897840559482574, -0.17114554345607758, 0.15475215017795563, 0.5177713632583618, -0.33136746287345886, 0.20626024901866913, 0.37421736121177673, -0.6279163956642151, -0.11169004440307617, 0.033394742757081985, -0.31343093514442444, -0.6123539805412292, 0.7094775438308716, 0.6594281792640686, -0.7834380865097046, 0.11815527826547623, 0.35937413573265076, -0.6743495464324951, -0.3802335560321808, -0.7482600808143616, -0.5918848514556885, 0.6429181098937988, -0.513668954372406, 0.13370896875858307, -0.07895005494356155, -0.4430992007255554, 0.2656739354133606, -0.1505662500858307, 0.07517692446708679, -0.42548149824142456, -0.44365766644477844, -0.02520325779914856, -0.4462328553199768, 0.4312879145145416, -0.6446059346199036, 0.03755072131752968, -0.3258547782897949, -0.5820751190185547, -1.19053053855896, -0.8159842491149902, -0.6628475785255432, 0.2171257585287094, 0.22449682652950287, -0.7190612554550171, -0.33726316690444946, 0.15183107554912567, -0.5313664078712463, 0.31844520568847656, 0.1421399712562561, -1.0946999788284302, 0.5971338748931885, 0.8145085573196411, 0.579814612865448, -0.2308281660079956, 0.41052645444869995, 1.2016109228134155, -0.40029728412628174, 0.8200258016586304, -0.4256020188331604, -0.5009278059005737, 0.33700358867645264, -1.0636587142944336, 0.3887350261211395, -0.611263632774353, -0.7260984182357788, -0.41258832812309265, -0.3734453320503235, 0.0614192858338356, -0.0027368508744984865, 0.1956034004688263, -0.6981328725814819, 0.12508365511894226, -0.12054212391376495, -0.1928008645772934, -0.6072337031364441, -0.1437298059463501, -0.3460468351840973, -1.1840126514434814, -0.8168869018554688, 1.2629437446594238, -0.469245582818985, 0.21243682503700256, 0.6520575284957886, -0.221567764878273, -0.345882773399353, 0.9969093203544617, 0.08696776628494263, -0.015340611338615417, -0.5583564639091492, 0.27280575037002563, 0.6899622678756714, 0.32036516070365906, -0.2082880437374115, 0.03843394294381142, -0.42439723014831543, 1.0498982667922974, 0.09552806615829468, -0.1002788096666336, -0.005658107344061136, -0.12966009974479675, 0.2329191267490387, -0.23496797680854797, 0.16292719542980194, 0.880316972732544, -0.3807452917098999, 0.3144831657409668, -0.15137417614459991, -0.49605292081832886, -0.5768848061561584, -0.676382303237915, -0.5212820172309875, 0.08550649136304855, 0.406536340713501, 0.08766503632068634, -0.46321988105773926, -0.513493537902832, 0.4837459921836853, -0.7475681900978088, 0.21838119626045227, 0.3291524648666382, -0.01992695778608322, 0.011442340910434723, -0.7194502949714661, 0.17769528925418854, -0.17223361134529114, -0.049111656844615936, -0.04960819333791733, 0.3042699098587036, 0.12079014629125595, -0.6076170206069946, -0.535870373249054, -0.3547671139240265, -0.0789518803358078, 0.5608577728271484, 0.4304109811782837, -0.1016356348991394, 0.5601130127906799, 0.059917427599430084, -0.10795465856790543, -0.13992968201637268, 0.0029238841962069273, 0.6921761631965637, -0.08428902179002762, 0.2084696888923645, -0.045183319598436356, -0.08674350380897522, 0.5451549291610718, -0.1435210406780243, -0.5481666922569275, -0.3338083028793335, 0.9733014702796936, -0.35497379302978516, -0.041213758289813995, 0.3331354260444641, -0.828098475933075, -0.4643392264842987, -0.0612650066614151, -1.4794436693191528, -0.716585636138916, -0.15899811685085297, -0.513158917427063, 0.18447166681289673, -0.12013361603021622, 0.05495833978056908, 0.2986203134059906, 0.06870507448911667, 0.7603538036346436, 0.570351243019104, 0.23233550786972046, 0.3733123540878296, -0.4894604980945587, 0.2485729455947876, 1.485024094581604, 0.016737518832087517, -0.680324375629425, 0.1032698005437851, -0.23879322409629822, -0.5930864810943604, -0.20947536826133728, 0.6942050457000732, 0.3682155907154083, 0.5170612931251526, -0.4180240333080292, 0.6568364500999451, 0.844064474105835, 0.314233660697937, -0.18597742915153503, 0.0571979284286499, -0.5722774863243103, -0.4073975682258606, 0.36429786682128906, 0.23572412133216858, 0.417863130569458, 1.2047181129455566, -0.6097621321678162, -0.3098950684070587, -0.19765418767929077, -0.389396607875824, -0.21099868416786194, -0.7743107676506042, -0.5340815186500549, -1.0358085632324219, -0.62708580493927, -1.4768413305282593, -0.43489429354667664, -0.4256385266780853, 0.9535444974899292, -0.8010759949684143, 1.2425155639648438, -0.038542766124010086, 0.18418511748313904, 0.14448705315589905, 0.14381840825080872, 0.1534009426832199, -1.218085765838623, -0.29735133051872253, 0.13973836600780487, 0.48346003890037537, -1.4503517150878906, -0.8914627432823181, -0.0003772387863136828, 0.14827434718608856, 0.7729073166847229, -0.6894493103027344, 0.1704656034708023, -0.5193677544593811, -0.6811713576316833, 0.6870628595352173, 0.5366187691688538, -0.1928466111421585, 0.7904918193817139, -0.6002397537231445, 0.3176145851612091, 0.19311614334583282, -0.07692805677652359, 0.13576096296310425, 0.5943242907524109, -0.7896968126296997, 0.8593637347221375, -0.22669728100299835, 0.013104026205837727, 0.3797273635864258, -0.5766964554786682, 0.32901161909103394, -0.0490313321352005, -0.3444175124168396, 0.22412574291229248, -0.6088822484016418, 0.935034990310669, -0.1366683393716812, 0.2669125497341156, 0.5217243432998657, 0.4766157865524292, -0.10968343168497086, -0.19858503341674805, -0.1781170815229416, -0.06598207354545593, 0.05324310064315796, 0.8511415719985962, -0.1932561844587326, -0.5840905904769897, 0.15287213027477264, -0.41710013151168823, 0.036384448409080505, 0.7545701861381531, -0.22527039051055908, 0.4698972702026367, -0.4514075219631195, -0.08045527338981628, -0.39114660024642944, 0.4965610206127167, -0.775262713432312, 0.8574227094650269, 0.16828978061676025, -0.026554016396403313, 0.4301372468471527, -0.5786063075065613, -1.1455581188201904, 0.4669441878795624, 0.023611431941390038, -0.8163661360740662, -0.16876474022865295, -0.1599506437778473, -0.3259075880050659, 0.3165978789329529, -0.9748625755310059, -0.017138449475169182, -0.45628848671913147, 0.9048781991004944, 0.8860523700714111, -0.4188975989818573, -0.5571054220199585, 0.17573679983615875, -0.5576722621917725, 0.3914347290992737, -0.23981450498104095, 0.3562949597835541, -0.40675804018974304, -0.8541125655174255, -0.1729017198085785, 0.2631240785121918, -0.1165308728814125, -0.13722965121269226, 0.08706942200660706, -0.3823418617248535, -0.2560407519340515, -0.30282828211784363, -1.047112226486206, -0.04987802356481552, -0.1696624904870987, 0.255452960729599, 0.255709171295166, -0.17040565609931946, 0.06306461989879608, -0.2147250771522522, 0.5286339521408081, 0.21660618484020233, 0.21910811960697174, 0.836638867855072, 0.23528364300727844, -0.08143065869808197, 0.1266874521970749, 0.8375438451766968, 0.5041823387145996, 0.8859594464302063, -0.3544280529022217, 0.317739874124527, 0.6159209609031677, 0.37491074204444885, 1.0614601373672485, 0.18957772850990295, 0.10330573469400406, 0.2875819802284241, 0.7026686668395996, 0.10783625394105911, -0.35526472330093384, 0.27365559339523315, -0.029131578281521797, 0.490045964717865, -0.49662408232688904, 0.45949283242225647, -0.45123857259750366, 0.5317694544792175, 0.3412695527076721, 0.3471775949001312, -0.08901599794626236, -0.8272611498832703, -0.39675819873809814, 0.44892317056655884, -0.40465259552001953, -1.089479684829712, -0.08974362164735794, 0.2408667951822281, 0.32308995723724365, 0.19216060638427734, -0.3142457902431488, -0.004665624815970659, 0.32031118869781494, 0.2841857671737671, -0.5518741011619568, 0.2538130283355713, 0.26786795258522034, -0.2181801199913025, 1.1358529329299927, 0.22613000869750977, 0.35282012820243835, 0.5665580034255981, -0.22964155673980713, -0.7949455976486206, -0.4759048521518707, 0.41720518469810486, -0.44372573494911194, 0.8213424682617188, 0.3219062387943268, -0.01925996132194996, -0.15312567353248596, -0.5591437220573425, 0.33307144045829773, -0.6788921356201172, 0.31100383400917053, 0.4497450590133667, 0.15977631509304047, -0.2384682446718216, 0.09118249267339706, -0.10807676613330841, -0.061077579855918884, 0.3184826076030731, -0.12282898277044296, 0.18634292483329773, 0.5362141132354736, 1.1147260665893555, 0.05179271474480629, 0.2953576445579529, -0.3905123472213745, -0.15222406387329102, 0.8388959765434265, 0.06956770271062851, -0.48472073674201965, 1.0652790069580078, -0.4988294541835785, -0.12452199310064316, -0.37336283922195435, -0.2670702338218689, -0.29323631525039673, 0.46512287855148315, 0.5257657766342163, 0.3549364507198334, 0.07846658676862717, -0.25694888830184937, 0.6041169166564941, 0.7562649250030518, -0.4258882701396942, -0.41883543133735657, 0.5199719071388245, -0.7907149791717529, 0.21108363568782806, -0.7899807095527649, 0.8581044673919678, -0.025596704334020615, -0.05687251314520836, -0.5236672163009644, -0.21786493062973022, -0.062435850501060486, -0.4001358449459076, -0.39499878883361816, -0.2088598906993866, 0.23281238973140717, 0.4319165050983429, -0.2237655222415924, -0.3748300075531006, -0.6869097948074341, -0.08086660504341125, -0.45181789994239807, 0.8114827275276184, -0.05425762012600899, -0.13773080706596375, 0.8253309726715088, 0.014716855250298977, -0.9436493515968323, 0.9274922609329224, 0.668717622756958, 0.07418312132358551, 0.6490955352783203, 0.3005143702030182, 0.40427714586257935, 0.8772536516189575, -0.4088921844959259, 0.6048197746276855, -0.6379631161689758, -0.02984735742211342, 0.2798946499824524, -1.042718529701233, 0.10044760257005692, -0.5703141689300537, -0.5411354899406433, -0.10667545348405838, 0.7322266101837158, 0.05280689522624016, -0.21191637217998505, 0.7403213977813721, -1.574399471282959, 4.007242679595947, 0.7188406586647034, 0.6990238428115845, 0.2214508354663849, 0.8679584264755249, 0.4493257701396942, 0.21420025825500488, -0.03804628923535347, 0.1918509155511856, -0.7721375823020935, 0.007161145564168692, 0.4350768029689789, 0.5481393337249756, -0.061375781893730164, -0.11471585929393768, 0.391747385263443, 0.4478028416633606, -0.6154480576515198, -0.21439151465892792, -0.5149603486061096, -0.7077136635780334, 0.23752781748771667, -0.17636564373970032, 0.12717150151729584, 0.40582358837127686, 0.4546161890029907, 0.21650756895542145, -1.289029598236084, -0.47553449869155884, -0.867244303226471, -0.4211371839046478, -1.254320740699768, 0.03972667083144188, -0.43203020095825195, -1.0619771480560303, 0.4281165897846222, 0.008648633025586605, -0.43707171082496643, 0.4838016629219055, -0.3363569378852844, 0.43687963485717773, -1.0020710229873657, -0.08853907883167267, 0.08907794207334518, 0.2672616243362427, 0.9611073732376099, 0.4126667082309723, 0.5176393985748291, 0.5344603657722473, -0.5419617295265198, 0.18792183697223663, -0.12334027886390686, -0.5090821981430054, -0.2895399332046509, -0.9821085929870605, -0.34595397114753723, -0.2247818410396576, -0.5630821585655212, 0.24610646069049835, -0.08234251290559769, 0.486754447221756, -0.271776020526886, -0.7864417433738708, 0.19122357666492462, 0.2822688817977905, 0.5252861380577087, -0.23147089779376984, 0.13754084706306458, 0.19183966517448425, -0.47888216376304626, -0.18871793150901794, -0.5800850987434387, -0.09171756356954575, -0.7875044941902161, 0.377360463142395, -0.3329731822013855, 0.5398244857788086, 0.18096530437469482, -0.2506583333015442, 0.3954826593399048, -0.5722376704216003, -0.015842141583561897, -0.6570883393287659, 0.6429007053375244, -0.09516111016273499, 0.4879390299320221, 0.4308314323425293, -0.7494174838066101, -0.6218451261520386, 0.4628961384296417, 0.37877774238586426, 0.8358064889907837, 0.04759069159626961, 0.42375892400741577, -0.7150368690490723 ]
Quantum Effects in Black Hole Interiors
The Weyl curvature inside a black hole formed in a generic collapse grows, classically without bound, near to the inner horizon, due to partial absorption and blueshifting of the radiative tail of the collapse. Using a spherical model, we examine how this growth is modified by quantum effects of conformally coupled massless fields.
Warren G. Anderson, Patrick R. Brady, Werner Israel, and Sharon M. Morsink
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210013
gr-qc/9210014
[ 0.5681398510932922, 1.2215795516967773, -0.1493367999792099, -0.14796306192874908, -0.39794859290122986, 0.006557050626724958, 0.49746134877204895, 0.2759741544723511, -0.1848069131374359, 1.6360143423080444, 0.6590837836265564, 0.4580492675304413, -0.29527097940444946, -0.6884990334510803, -0.24871990084648132, 0.4067557752132416, -0.20791634917259216, 0.07677382975816727, -0.9167956709861755, 0.28881219029426575, -0.041696399450302124, 0.1330753117799759, -0.9415498375892639, -0.3948943316936493, -0.46054893732070923, 0.4136884808540344, 0.7374908924102783, 0.07870611548423767, 1.157011866569519, 0.8991553783416748, 0.09624037891626358, 0.48102325201034546, -0.09300874918699265, -0.570190966129303, -0.2586410939693451, -0.5228642821311951, 0.3363885283470154, -0.4126903712749481, 1.3698426485061646, -0.40042367577552795, 0.3454149663448334, 0.6807471513748169, 0.7405151128768921, -0.26849839091300964, -1.143261194229126, -0.280031681060791, 0.4492648243904114, -0.09130328893661499, 0.47239354252815247, -0.8714928030967712, -0.21620896458625793, -0.08719275146722794, 0.773362398147583, -0.868960976600647, -0.20980826020240784, 0.09717769920825958, 1.0312072038650513, 0.03900832682847977, -0.4981605112552643, 0.6039599776268005, 0.25691384077072144, 0.2821211814880371, 0.6879112124443054, -0.5383991599082947, 0.10026369243860245, 1.1392991542816162, -0.10686972737312317, 0.10096999257802963, -0.04630409553647041, -0.5194370746612549, -0.4969208240509033, -0.6024035215377808, -0.30555540323257446, 0.2947608232498169, -0.18548591434955597, 0.43493518233299255, -0.48396173119544983, -0.542560338973999, -0.8045595288276672, -0.041815876960754395, 0.03659318387508392, 0.07640903443098068, -0.2076912820339203, 0.9654878973960876, -0.5307875275611877, 0.1039242222905159, 0.5306535959243774, 0.39397159218788147, 0.27583327889442444, 0.0689697414636612, -1.0031640529632568, 0.4951121509075165, -0.4912358522415161, 0.0972922220826149, 0.34158405661582947, 1.1100019216537476, -0.5554121136665344, 0.8671471476554871, 0.36678168177604675, 0.07999248057603836, -0.18054302036762238, 0.7302938103675842, -0.24942678213119507, -0.12413021922111511, -0.6461622714996338, 0.893366813659668, -0.32225775718688965, 0.014466489665210247, -0.6485975980758667, -0.6316269636154175, 0.10829105973243713, 0.7436211109161377, 0.6280168890953064, -0.08138105273246765, 0.05582575127482414, 0.3952544331550598, 0.09624676406383514, 0.18406172096729279, -0.7940546274185181, -0.5435578227043152, 0.49164146184921265, 0.6736058592796326, 0.6025640964508057, 0.5978592038154602, -0.7157332301139832, -0.4853218197822571, 0.2544533312320709, 0.19412913918495178, -0.6327774524688721, 0.34237316250801086, 0.44738802313804626, -0.4339498281478882, 0.05755417048931122, 0.020441485568881035, 0.18299990892410278, 0.12025071680545807, 0.5037031769752502, 0.19634465873241425, 0.2516063451766968, -0.6921789050102234, -0.2719596326351166, -0.40667471289634705, -0.11617933958768845, 1.0689435005187988, -0.08337133377790451, 0.32491177320480347, -0.6259629726409912, 0.6559828519821167, -0.6333643198013306, -0.1769176870584488, -0.5599709749221802, -0.6113076210021973, 0.09589710831642151, 0.7224836349487305, -0.36756980419158936, -0.19323207437992096, -1.3699228763580322, -0.20708943903446198, 0.26795220375061035, -0.3037404716014862, 0.2080136239528656, -0.5689042210578918, 0.3613296449184418, 1.3322192430496216, -0.23456071317195892, 0.7776960134506226, -0.7518122792243958, -0.4582882821559906, -0.5425521731376648, -0.09264510869979858, -1.0863280296325684, 0.6214309930801392, 0.002758017275482416, 0.2418406903743744, 0.6479929685592651, 0.7356339693069458, 0.283832311630249, -0.1307591199874878, -0.559160053730011, 0.420976459980011, 0.19413790106773376, -0.45712894201278687, 0.3284766972064972, 0.8646053075790405, -0.5730253458023071, -0.4551543891429901, 0.1655997782945633, 0.03223888948559761, 0.04278033226728439, 0.054558590054512024, -0.9604102969169617, 0.4047872722148895, -1.1345707178115845, 1.3176918029785156, -0.5695990324020386, 0.09749467670917511, -0.9133623242378235, -0.25452861189842224, -0.339277058839798, -0.6024730801582336, 0.5575249195098877, -0.34570035338401794, -0.8011193871498108, -0.11542397737503052, -1.3572841882705688, 0.07509305328130722, -0.09947848320007324, 0.7439950108528137, -0.45388904213905334, 0.19814947247505188, 0.44632598757743835, -0.4232896864414215, -0.18135382235050201, -0.2331889271736145, 0.20690807700157166, 0.09445994347333908, -0.015244932845234871, 0.05076765641570091, 0.43042102456092834, 0.16048119962215424, 0.7043932676315308, 0.04651442542672157, -0.6151231527328491, 1.3318413496017456, 0.28126636147499084, -0.5691806674003601, 0.49515846371650696, 0.693164050579071, -1.1400718688964844, 0.7025312781333923, 0.47097572684288025, 0.3619386553764343, 0.3119962811470032, 0.08387422561645508, 0.7877048254013062, -0.06184021383523941, 0.5229817032814026, 1.1123580932617188, -0.21158583462238312, 0.4282843768596649, 0.7428053617477417, 0.5746007561683655, 1.2178529500961304, -0.2949669063091278, -0.8448081612586975, 0.44019752740859985, 0.7460283041000366, 0.14942224323749542, -0.4804418981075287, 0.55674147605896, -0.2967485785484314, 0.3749071955680847, 0.4381023943424225, 0.33556821942329407, -0.8617210388183594, 0.6915080547332764, 0.3225351870059967, 0.13578689098358154, -0.1687617152929306, -0.37390056252479553, -0.11301273107528687, 0.40083587169647217, 0.010252938605844975, -0.3525797724723816, -0.6287949085235596, -0.29360586404800415, -1.5366616249084473, -0.1477201282978058, 0.3201291859149933, -0.5405615568161011, -0.866685152053833, 0.07212627679109573, -0.07906928658485413, 0.09191273152828217, -0.5266979932785034, -0.5627158284187317, 0.30430203676223755, -0.10967998951673508, 1.157746434211731, 0.1348332166671753, -0.5636842846870422, 0.281383216381073, -0.37649983167648315, 0.06775666028261185, -0.4022582471370697, 0.4251217842102051, -1.1066045761108398, 0.07385006546974182, -0.8764433860778809, -0.2116260826587677, 0.10726723074913025, -0.7111861705780029, 0.422092467546463, 0.5017616152763367, 0.7176312208175659, 0.6929773688316345, -0.13003511726856232, 0.16986073553562164, -0.8397195935249329, -0.8205823302268982, 0.986373245716095, -0.06208955496549606, 0.10340370237827301, 0.21983112394809723, -0.10729315876960754, 0.525911271572113, 0.12000754475593567, -0.4386616051197052, 0.8174279928207397, -0.3035516142845154, -0.3735722303390503, -0.1902693510055542, 0.4152912199497223, 0.7644431591033936, -0.6118670701980591, -0.022604992613196373, 0.44218167662620544, 0.3810384273529053, -0.2594950497150421, -0.443739116191864, -0.45723292231559753, -0.45786556601524353, 0.37536051869392395, -0.30303072929382324, 0.8656647205352783, -0.12006595730781555, 0.24273400008678436, -0.8206118941307068, 0.5392096638679504, -0.8222365379333496, -0.09999638050794601, -0.5656746625900269, -0.12759430706501007, -0.020142443478107452, -0.6588642597198486, -0.028557155281305313, 0.10987444967031479, -0.35822445154190063, 0.23494136333465576, 0.9110232591629028, 0.6590375304222107, 0.21477404236793518, 0.1525096595287323, 0.0385342538356781, -0.046010199934244156, 0.07376863062381744, 0.0910213366150856, -0.7001501321792603, 0.020201435312628746, 0.2101798951625824, -0.3265397846698761, 0.019954834133386612, 0.3887580633163452, 0.1683904230594635, 0.11933077126741409, 0.3490106463432312, -0.02728263847529888, -0.3609841465950012, -1.1893303394317627, 0.010564574040472507, 0.47908976674079895, 0.4098992347717285, 0.23026113212108612, -1.5087233781814575, -0.4139784872531891, 0.11022073030471802, 0.11707934737205505, 0.15544576942920685, 0.23746410012245178, -0.8920790553092957, 0.5492141842842102, 0.6848115921020508, -0.741320788860321, 0.30470624566078186, -0.1722332239151001, 0.2970641255378723, 0.7198235392570496, 0.3765374422073364, -0.49579498171806335, -0.10305915772914886, 0.02303256280720234, -0.3705446720123291, 0.3452572822570801, 0.1913420557975769, 0.5921991467475891, -0.14127281308174133, -0.18953001499176025, 0.5998505353927612, -0.6300330758094788, -0.4848598539829254, -0.4237475097179413, -0.9217569828033447, 0.6562513709068298, -0.7350143790245056, -0.041595976799726486, 0.24329563975334167, 0.4094015657901764, 0.9228715300559998, 0.27352428436279297, 0.22552433609962463, -0.14592532813549042, -0.1892983317375183, -0.517370343208313, 0.3506220579147339, -0.5628700852394104, -0.25968995690345764, -0.7354308366775513, 0.47881218791007996, 0.2993820607662201, 0.2890866696834564, 0.5034643411636353, -0.9571169018745422, 0.17795252799987793, -0.23477905988693237, 1.0030601024627686, 0.2039255052804947, -0.2507878541946411, 0.6696330308914185, 0.2601235508918762, -0.2642902731895447, -0.2166881263256073, 0.17851172387599945, 0.5257998704910278, 0.5885988473892212, 0.10766389220952988, -0.9590184092521667, -0.23899586498737335, -0.8570104837417603, 0.5758533477783203, 0.23613309860229492, 0.014533257111907005, -0.9145363569259644, -0.25823286175727844, -0.06381411850452423, 0.17973418533802032, 0.47082555294036865, 0.4467319846153259, 0.4964025020599365, 0.835083544254303, -0.1616179347038269, -0.4078519642353058, 0.8898401856422424, 0.3021467626094818, 0.1407930850982666, -0.1639852523803711, 0.09986676275730133, -0.2489151507616043, 0.575657069683075, 0.1683560609817505, -0.9393090605735779, -0.08687373250722885, -0.2866256535053253, 0.6228276491165161, -0.19905222952365875, -0.7630254030227661, -0.0883200466632843, -0.16108441352844238, -0.4063985049724579, 0.22152173519134521, -0.6442558169364929, 0.3801388442516327, 0.09473298490047455, -0.21321210265159607, -0.5432727932929993, 0.44910579919815063, -0.13892534375190735, -0.21018053591251373, 0.6125923991203308, 0.9386165738105774, 0.4090754985809326, 0.9631593227386475, 0.32314616441726685, 0.04174584522843361, 0.4298340082168579, 0.9995639324188232, -0.4430865943431854, 0.11879456788301468, 0.3828701674938202, -0.06656856089830399, -0.9395936131477356, -0.46685680747032166, 0.5057042241096497, -0.14724844694137573, 0.35203278064727783, -0.31518328189849854, -1.3562779426574707, -0.7781584858894348, -0.3917035460472107, -0.509181559085846, 0.5892060399055481, -0.20725606381893158, -0.09593456983566284, -0.2644953727722168, -0.6435709595680237, -0.25197842717170715, -0.12419566512107849, 0.38333040475845337, 0.07378196716308594, -0.27989494800567627, 0.505178689956665, -0.1106511726975441, 0.7836407423019409, -0.9800560474395752, 0.3785085678100586, -0.569490373134613, -0.17399565875530243, -0.7179549932479858, -0.7440956830978394, 0.3662329614162445, 1.0095409154891968, 0.06200945004820824, -0.11928263306617737, 0.1150781661272049, 0.49084198474884033, 0.4747513234615326, 0.22689305245876312, -0.1577695608139038, -0.4792407751083374, -0.354954332113266, 0.8699854612350464, -0.3096992075443268, -0.48758870363235474, -0.64252769947052, 0.44597291946411133, 0.22422857582569122, -0.08242323994636536, -0.3833519220352173, -0.2946214973926544, 0.4440196454524994, -1.9356681108474731, 0.3317456841468811, -0.9843801856040955, -0.39661896228790283, -0.25676000118255615, -0.70443195104599, -0.14878316223621368, -0.1886686086654663, 0.156707301735878, -0.12644904851913452, -0.14609301090240479, -0.2083553820848465, 0.1384131759405136, -0.8876298069953918, -0.029968852177262306, -0.6907129287719727, -0.28842878341674805, -0.3412608504295349, 1.400059700012207, -0.17572255432605743, 0.06838560104370117, 0.24824798107147217, 0.20964543521404266, -0.17712323367595673, 0.4595852792263031, 0.20505724847316742, -0.10248705744743347, -1.1411296129226685, -0.31287312507629395, 0.9807687401771545, 0.7011262774467468, 0.08750341832637787, 0.17513476312160492, -0.3647577464580536, 0.6786655783653259, -0.319775253534317, 0.6774265766143799, -0.31333717703819275, -0.9223088622093201, 0.2675228714942932, 0.0252624973654747, -0.5208935737609863, 0.7398130893707275, 0.22064651548862457, 0.06660298258066177, -0.3652198016643524, -0.5005022883415222, 0.387931764125824, -0.35454320907592773, -0.7487316131591797, 0.9088031053543091, 0.24845841526985168, -0.2561644911766052, -0.6209340691566467, -0.6539025902748108, -0.26274386048316956, -0.5320619940757751, -0.33382779359817505, 0.7544729113578796, 0.5766987800598145, 0.514155387878418, 0.045837875455617905, 0.3522931635379791, 0.2690175771713257, 0.08686650544404984, -0.2783753275871277, 0.1212472915649414, -0.06099681928753853, -1.5626479387283325, -0.5412976741790771, -0.9734539985656738, -0.783790111541748, 1.1702345609664917, 0.7730680108070374, -0.077531598508358, 0.3311184048652649, -0.15968313813209534, -0.5368272066116333, -0.6589600443840027, 0.5673625469207764, 0.3743571937084198, -0.17153765261173248, 0.9310427308082581, 0.4666329622268677, -0.07701915502548218, 0.02911817468702793, 0.06031802296638489, -0.7914962768554688, -0.15970785915851593, 0.9493355751037598, -1.0035816431045532, 0.15324825048446655, 0.9813790917396545, 0.00006516090797958896, -0.9966951012611389, -0.3651812970638275, -0.6671828627586365, -0.00506124971434474, 0.5741296410560608, -0.5235073566436768, -0.09682123363018036, -0.5542823076248169, -0.3224236071109772, -0.12562662363052368, -0.13200563192367554, -0.09551035612821579, 0.5201926827430725, -0.3826991021633148, 0.45341548323631287, -0.016884498298168182, -0.6994207501411438, 0.7332471013069153, 0.13706186413764954, -0.4902278184890747, 0.39025047421455383, -0.36683160066604614, 0.4350099265575409, -0.4017251431941986, 0.8547219634056091, -0.8347187638282776, 0.19416311383247375, -0.1444200873374939, -0.1956552416086197, -0.19016478955745697, -0.25992804765701294, 0.043075382709503174, 0.13602682948112488, -1.378055214881897, -0.11873794347047806, 0.21450287103652954, -0.40737786889076233, 0.6875039935112, -0.08348749577999115, -0.11011417210102081, -0.437428742647171, -0.20185531675815582, 0.3425382971763611, 0.2594467103481293, -0.6125470399856567, -0.308860719203949, -1.4505010843276978, -0.6873033046722412, -1.6234368085861206, -0.37495481967926025, -0.3018774390220642, 0.1433396339416504, 0.32605835795402527, 0.2743415832519531, 0.2933116555213928, -0.2420666366815567, -0.08423392474651337, 0.3391169011592865, -0.5697591304779053, -0.41899287700653076, 0.13281482458114624, 0.12612666189670563, -0.258905827999115, -1.228602647781372, -0.15440696477890015, 0.10464761406183243, -0.15028366446495056, 1.378882646560669, -0.3277204930782318, 0.30615559220314026, -0.4002113938331604, -0.6696387529373169, 0.82355135679245, -0.02170388214290142, -0.9040266275405884, 1.1173856258392334, -0.42048123478889465, 1.4658467769622803, 0.12155427783727646, -0.04076017066836357, -0.08541378378868103, 0.02384946495294571, -1.8580023050308228, 0.7357039451599121, -0.005263227503746748, 0.19786936044692993, -0.65848708152771, -1.4835196733474731, 0.13008083403110504, 0.13107432425022125, -1.186939001083374, -0.14807923138141632, -0.3366347551345825, 0.7573664784431458, -0.9072190523147583, 1.0628536939620972, 0.05471022427082062, 0.5060170292854309, -0.4097782373428345, 0.022063221782445908, -0.2273523062467575, -0.2774961590766907, 0.22603417932987213, 0.009042393416166306, 0.3195525109767914, 0.007793302182108164, -0.08713708072900772, -0.5342184901237488, 0.10487895458936691, -0.12230264395475388, 0.2984465956687927, 0.15184323489665985, -0.14195409417152405, 0.16178306937217712, 0.1923702359199524, 0.2685665488243103, -1.0979840755462646, 0.6674211621284485, 0.34553954005241394, -0.03839948773384094, 0.37955307960510254, -0.016255822032690048, -1.135022521018982, 0.11310931295156479, -0.03895105794072151, -0.38833239674568176, -0.04300348088145256, 0.09933441877365112, 0.49997034668922424, 0.3159182667732239, -0.19419623911380768, -0.23130854964256287, 0.4219265282154083, 1.2950304746627808, 1.0539289712905884, -0.06213613972067833, -0.38116705417633057, 0.35534948110580444, -0.7580954432487488, -0.47567424178123474, 0.20037031173706055, 0.7136727571487427, -0.8480584025382996, -0.747063398361206, -0.398529052734375, -0.09952344745397568, -0.19421787559986115, -0.5328011512756348, 0.5354341864585876, -0.20247560739517212, 0.18164479732513428, -0.15198315680027008, -0.5014985799789429, -0.007240987848490477, -0.8383616805076599, 0.9731867909431458, -0.02937718667089939, -0.5977239608764648, -0.0070012290962040424, 0.6162977814674377, 0.5355827808380127, 0.15137538313865662, 0.0062477667815983295, 1.0397388935089111, 0.38833045959472656, -0.17179395258426666, 0.24844153225421906, 0.6392455101013184, 0.7069334983825684, 0.11028563231229782, -0.8463139533996582, 0.4759625494480133, 1.3195736408233643, 0.23671822249889374, 0.2121001034975052, 0.35865986347198486, -0.8224656581878662, 0.45328009128570557, -0.4457537531852722, -0.17945677042007446, 0.39520516991615295, -0.12558339536190033, 0.05352438986301422, 0.2885744571685791, 0.28654876351356506, -0.24552565813064575, -0.21345782279968262, -0.03882034495472908, 0.25344374775886536, -0.26114851236343384, -0.5894595384597778, -0.3352242112159729, 0.4049803912639618, 0.14957143366336823, -0.31966647505760193, -0.303955078125, -0.34004199504852295, 0.27870821952819824, 0.0011789430864155293, 0.18705062568187714, -0.3691108524799347, 0.19835099577903748, -0.12462033331394196, -0.20608462393283844, -0.13162283599376678, 0.36464300751686096, -0.21140927076339722, 0.689741849899292, 1.02885901927948, -0.27169322967529297, 0.32612162828445435, -0.06790602207183838, 0.13640058040618896, -0.4883953630924225, -0.09022504091262817, -0.20167817175388336, -0.7631694078445435, -0.3375760316848755, 0.4792430102825165, -0.48118874430656433, -0.5913954973220825, -0.08994051814079285, 0.26093992590904236, -0.21609696745872498, 0.9394777417182922, -0.06479703634977341, -0.28590086102485657, -0.13868172466754913, 0.3123617470264435, 0.3976518511772156, 0.6269662976264954, 0.11852244287729263, 0.5723907947540283, 0.3627254068851471, 0.44555434584617615, 1.0712711811065674, 0.5230998396873474, 0.10465233027935028, 0.05014163255691528, -0.21965105831623077, 0.4015406668186188, 0.2277941256761551, -0.28608351945877075, 0.7426661849021912, -0.32704317569732666, 0.3899327218532562, -0.546384871006012, 0.20939823985099792, -0.05682506039738655, -0.1151798665523529, 0.6279458999633789, 1.07393217086792, -0.0441153421998024, 0.1624087393283844, 0.04606849327683449, -0.004267256241291761, -0.1207554042339325, -0.42550450563430786, 0.7475118637084961, -0.9686000943183899, 0.45057395100593567, -1.463945984840393, 0.18373329937458038, -0.32171115279197693, -0.398102343082428, -0.23303662240505219, -0.12137601524591446, -0.15891654789447784, -0.7992898225784302, -0.5899471044540405, -0.1666068285703659, 0.4509936273097992, 0.6963760256767273, -0.38870981335639954, 0.0893389955163002, 0.00024777493672445416, -0.460063099861145, 0.14826229214668274, 0.9668998718261719, -0.12792877852916718, -0.07261805981397629, 0.13265886902809143, 0.2977563738822937, -0.9616846442222595, 0.9668716788291931, 0.458183616399765, -0.908421516418457, 0.39428314566612244, -0.3485437333583832, 0.9172208309173584, 0.47337606549263, -0.724007248878479, -0.17994850873947144, 0.13729839026927948, 0.3374086916446686, 0.6615443229675293, 0.01806688867509365, 0.1283181756734848, -0.4610517919063568, -0.7510668039321899, -1.427059531211853, 0.2500482499599457, 0.14566263556480408, -0.7712872624397278, 0.3530540466308594, -0.8101727962493896, 3.9096052646636963, 0.7638368010520935, 0.43231502175331116, 0.30755600333213806, 0.4200602173805237, 0.85121089220047, -0.003048813436180353, 0.9540206789970398, -0.00875719916075468, -0.5887207984924316, 0.413356751203537, 0.4381672739982605, 0.5398585796356201, -0.5187376737594604, -0.2534411549568176, 0.022225622087717056, -0.04760408774018288, -0.10862624645233154, -0.2542807161808014, -0.054562926292419434, -1.0044697523117065, 0.2358357012271881, -0.3371857702732086, -0.06123952940106392, 0.09725045412778854, 0.20091675221920013, 0.05415407195687294, -0.09785617142915726, -1.0861897468566895, -0.550697922706604, -0.37084680795669556, -0.5374941229820251, 0.22656753659248352, -0.448152095079422, -1.2855322360992432, 0.5745693445205688, -0.0538758747279644, -0.28544992208480835, 0.2717105448246002, -0.4780195951461792, 0.011724346317350864, -0.424654096364975, 0.25705796480178833, -0.26727014780044556, 0.8295018076896667, 0.9027460813522339, 0.37827128171920776, 0.5484529733657837, 0.5703135132789612, -0.7725728154182434, 0.5477675795555115, 0.32326287031173706, 0.7329438328742981, -0.5579404830932617, -1.2638685703277588, -0.21156230568885803, -0.12150400876998901, -0.16418011486530304, 0.20226801931858063, -0.4515502154827118, 0.8870723843574524, -0.4559398889541626, 0.2735291123390198, 0.09286860376596451, 0.5378702878952026, -0.06683097034692764, 0.07444499433040619, 0.13419455289840698, -0.2900611460208893, 0.03331365808844566, -1.4032676219940186, 0.20191699266433716, -0.2749691307544708, -0.11345672607421875, 0.34850019216537476, -0.055962760001420975, 0.5822155475616455, 0.7907975316047668, -0.19715279340744019, 0.44984397292137146, -0.7595868110656738, -0.30347758531570435, -0.3517581522464752, 0.05272878333926201, 0.3978809118270874, 0.5136203169822693, -0.17032656073570251, 0.23968634009361267, -0.9723954200744629, 0.24990975856781006, -0.3512115776538849, 0.26041167974472046, -0.32218602299690247, 0.41608691215515137, -0.6639505624771118 ]
A Nonsingular Universe
We construct an effective action for gravity in which all homogeneous solutions are nonsingular. In particular, there is neither a big bang nor a big crunch. The action is a higher derivative modification of Einstein's theory constructed in analogy to how the action for point particle motion in special relativity is obtained from Newtonian mechanics.
Robert H. Brandenberger
gr-qc astro-ph hep-th
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210014
gr-qc/9210015
[ 0.5931949019432068, 0.07928528636693954, 0.9124914407730103, -0.6091486811637878, 0.1278684139251709, -0.3746173083782196, -0.3709792196750641, -0.4105651080608368, -0.4747624397277832, 1.6476937532424927, 0.34193894267082214, -0.39569175243377686, 0.2737991511821747, -0.7813947796821594, -0.07472562044858932, 0.40130919218063354, -0.10254299640655518, -0.4470672309398651, -1.7136932611465454, 0.19556868076324463, -0.45852383971214294, -0.09539773315191269, -1.2592676877975464, -0.286577433347702, -0.5561971664428711, 0.8310238718986511, 0.10798405855894089, 0.27945956587791443, 0.9603523015975952, 1.133279800415039, 0.19624118506908417, -0.1139606386423111, -0.0006654018070548773, -0.6377249360084534, -0.5431467294692993, 0.3080945909023285, 0.10668749362230301, -0.6255688071250916, 0.47046083211898804, -0.5315895676612854, 1.0526660680770874, -0.41248106956481934, 0.2963317632675171, -0.13715313374996185, -0.54911208152771, 0.13234494626522064, 0.050378672778606415, 0.6258347630500793, 0.18014779686927795, -1.2306073904037476, 0.08006279915571213, -0.19847990572452545, -0.09623934328556061, -0.44330450892448425, -0.507683277130127, -0.43311211466789246, 0.44310447573661804, 0.1508239358663559, 0.09496364742517471, -0.32190802693367004, 0.5894732475280762, 0.4764878451824188, 0.27225250005722046, -0.41990578174591064, -0.19897004961967468, 1.2102949619293213, -0.09959360212087631, 0.17473863065242767, 0.033806610852479935, 0.3175179362297058, -0.042606763541698456, -0.5083868503570557, -0.4738832116127014, 0.12939117848873138, -0.03063581883907318, 0.5876687169075012, -0.19517607986927032, -0.3421761095523834, -0.5449872612953186, -0.7057515382766724, 0.3538125455379486, 0.5679401159286499, -0.05512770265340805, 0.4211376905441284, 0.12524844706058502, -0.4330408275127411, 0.5722665786743164, 0.12197484076023102, 0.6804317235946655, 0.28885161876678467, -0.5227466821670532, 0.4529809355735779, -0.43050050735473633, 0.511970579624176, 0.9789907336235046, 0.4380525052547455, -0.1990441083908081, 0.7871529459953308, 0.08258409053087234, -0.08001678436994553, 0.07331567257642746, 1.113979458808899, -0.49776846170425415, 0.2309655249118805, -1.0453789234161377, 1.0837591886520386, -0.31513547897338867, 1.049501895904541, -0.6020145416259766, -1.1089627742767334, 0.04071592912077904, 0.2291969209909439, 0.6841241121292114, 0.2852696180343628, 0.3113507628440857, 0.9838599562644958, -0.5405768156051636, 0.04402890428900719, -0.8534544110298157, -0.11086417734622955, 0.1275171935558319, 0.43152227997779846, -0.010018880479037762, 0.17771707475185394, -0.270551860332489, -0.12550203502178192, -0.7114334106445312, 1.213819980621338, -0.17520155012607574, 0.32489362359046936, 0.18011996150016785, -0.41317492723464966, -0.19183027744293213, 0.6277547478675842, 0.34799325466156006, -0.34386539459228516, -0.17921797931194305, 1.0912150144577026, -0.394103080034256, -0.4481619596481323, 0.12092898786067963, -0.3499929904937744, -0.17254595458507538, 1.2967360019683838, -0.7345980405807495, -0.01939273811876774, 0.11547470837831497, -0.6829801201820374, -0.5147639513015747, -0.03249143809080124, -0.29540470242500305, 0.33020129799842834, 0.3661438524723053, 0.8571898341178894, -0.22369426488876343, -0.07124373316764832, -1.2103116512298584, -0.0936765968799591, -0.33374616503715515, -0.8531597256660461, 0.5186479091644287, -0.7120339870452881, 0.2125266194343567, 1.1239465475082397, -0.4704160690307617, 0.32716861367225647, -1.048360824584961, 0.19189362227916718, 0.000069509755121544, -0.8666085004806519, -0.27722373604774475, 0.3505302667617798, -0.9717633724212646, 0.9026659727096558, 0.5910905599594116, 0.688437819480896, 0.2703532576560974, -0.6100372076034546, -0.30454593896865845, 0.08967216312885284, -0.15865252912044525, -0.25679832696914673, 0.29861485958099365, 0.5451997518539429, -0.37130266427993774, -0.23470205068588257, 0.7802661061286926, -0.12400848418474197, 0.37008264660835266, 0.24965500831604004, -0.730017364025116, 0.8745848536491394, -1.3056342601776123, 0.4738967716693878, -1.0958831310272217, -0.5193381309509277, -0.9564741849899292, 0.2859870493412018, -0.035593386739492416, -0.2191077023744583, 0.0921877846121788, -0.2307867407798767, -0.9023855924606323, 0.5979106426239014, -0.6191731095314026, -0.09599653631448746, -0.15796491503715515, 0.7374091744422913, -0.641985297203064, 0.1700497269630432, 0.31466054916381836, -0.3661212921142578, 0.03242810070514679, -0.6953057050704956, -0.25525933504104614, 0.01761440560221672, -0.11223827302455902, 0.12195123732089996, -0.13043896853923798, 0.30361971259117126, 1.128509521484375, 0.006221645511686802, -0.1764160841703415, 1.030081033706665, 0.046388424932956696, 0.055975645780563354, 0.5510803461074829, 0.447031170129776, 0.38454827666282654, 0.3965122401714325, -0.01104587409645319, 0.29215478897094727, 0.6032851338386536, -0.08815698325634003, 1.100437045097351, -0.2695801556110382, 1.2019439935684204, 0.5182592868804932, -0.538295567035675, 0.5679228901863098, 0.16090655326843262, -0.200141042470932, 0.15731637179851532, 0.538562536239624, -0.6314746737480164, 0.5565833449363708, 0.38136425614356995, -0.25118160247802734, -0.0335201732814312, 0.6445472240447998, -0.5962909460067749, 0.6134255528450012, -0.10372771322727203, 0.11468783020973206, -1.8097493648529053, -0.20929384231567383, -0.266711950302124, 1.005327820777893, 0.0013798289000988007, -0.8494328856468201, -0.21905198693275452, 0.27971455454826355, 0.036620743572711945, -0.49088358879089355, -0.18217287957668304, 0.6575614213943481, -0.5230790972709656, 0.18367999792099, 0.9694621562957764, -0.5153559446334839, -0.8625259399414062, 0.10828731954097748, -0.3439609110355377, -0.013205833733081818, -0.14432953298091888, 0.2660617232322693, -0.2040558159351349, -0.48129934072494507, 0.1011529341340065, -0.19448897242546082, -0.06446303427219391, 0.5610918402671814, 0.1395605057477951, 0.30407893657684326, -0.4642885625362396, 0.26707181334495544, -1.4377782344818115, 0.386147141456604, -0.8509127497673035, -0.14598508179187775, -0.36302515864372253, -0.5217693448066711, -0.037822168320417404, -0.4191064238548279, 0.2954387962818146, 0.9548722505569458, 0.16753362119197845, 0.6385672092437744, 0.13806046545505524, -0.9850425124168396, 0.32516440749168396, 0.05229372903704643, -0.5790483951568604, -0.3705345094203949, -0.8665280342102051, 0.9029912948608398, -0.2345593124628067, -0.2670636773109436, 0.651654839515686, -0.22512367367744446, -0.363378643989563, -0.04865996539592743, 0.17755304276943207, 0.8011224865913391, -0.26293817162513733, 0.47630757093429565, 0.557220458984375, -0.08176002651453018, 0.19074910879135132, -0.07466836273670197, -0.5822762846946716, -0.31659793853759766, 0.5214732885360718, -0.6743116974830627, 0.10285838693380356, 0.9678250551223755, 0.046627581119537354, -1.0022727251052856, 0.15935218334197998, -0.5586922764778137, -0.5374667644500732, 0.2098361998796463, -0.1679038405418396, 0.7363876700401306, 0.17733468115329742, 0.5024161338806152, -0.17214331030845642, -0.3133465051651001, -0.5887188911437988, 0.2866705358028412, 0.9088588356971741, -0.14929316937923431, -0.03332803398370743, 0.8248886466026306, 0.23891715705394745, -0.2463250756263733, 1.0809736251831055, 0.030782680958509445, 0.4459526538848877, -0.21210439503192902, 0.09153909981250763, 0.057926297187805176, -0.015275736339390278, -0.15606577694416046, -0.3290112316608429, 0.7626227736473083, -0.5019546747207642, -0.2063690721988678, -1.2382375001907349, -0.5399720668792725, 0.3055024743080139, -0.3554930090904236, -0.6161121726036072, -0.4360320270061493, -0.4619194567203522, 0.2928984761238098, 0.33877891302108765, 0.06589392572641373, 0.0027081381995230913, -1.2182971239089966, 0.2867682874202728, 0.2543717622756958, -0.5469514727592468, 0.10958036035299301, 0.20634825527668, 0.3784487545490265, 0.4060297906398773, 0.4177633821964264, 0.3361092805862427, -0.15798784792423248, -0.5293726325035095, -0.9209370613098145, 0.4081116020679474, 0.24896381795406342, 0.2670630216598511, 0.7686751484870911, 0.08120101690292358, -0.5335313081741333, -0.06993082910776138, -0.3416174650192261, -0.5377905964851379, -0.8163926005363464, 0.138472318649292, -1.2680987119674683, -0.2404361069202423, 0.047517262399196625, 0.4161093235015869, 1.0474857091903687, 0.2055310308933258, 0.15070560574531555, -0.17140363156795502, -0.3590579330921173, -0.5005146265029907, 0.6562129855155945, -0.05693860352039337, 0.3030773401260376, -1.3274348974227905, 0.44473719596862793, -0.32519423961639404, -0.03347322344779968, 0.6993865966796875, -1.136940598487854, 0.12051903456449509, -0.6139407157897949, 0.603960394859314, 0.4023600220680237, -0.3448844254016876, 0.521520733833313, -0.09669385105371475, -0.02127194218337536, -0.5572080612182617, 0.08633843809366226, 0.5757541656494141, 0.5136802792549133, -0.5918095707893372, -1.0155640840530396, 0.03878087177872658, -0.2402094602584839, 0.37030816078186035, 0.6573242545127869, -0.6931053400039673, -1.0294328927993774, -0.6062692403793335, 0.1088893860578537, 0.6643593907356262, 0.2193041294813156, 0.5712688565254211, 0.06150679662823677, 0.8137810230255127, -0.12468961626291275, -0.3805965781211853, 1.0991920232772827, -0.08620709925889969, -0.8479762077331543, -0.19304002821445465, 0.2940085530281067, -0.16856186091899872, 0.5788285732269287, -0.33996742963790894, -0.9798562526702881, -0.48390698432922363, -0.4537566900253296, 0.3698294758796692, -0.425053209066391, -0.7359127998352051, 0.7056180834770203, 0.3246091902256012, -0.09105149656534195, 0.10816242545843124, 0.03628535568714142, -0.04812328889966011, 0.03499370813369751, -0.21741817891597748, -0.7537559866905212, -0.1524321585893631, -0.0032469695433974266, 0.8295018076896667, 0.2736026644706726, 0.9396613836288452, 0.3652227222919464, 0.3234648108482361, 0.23910850286483765, 0.15578612685203552, -0.2474508285522461, 0.4811558723449707, -0.3509582281112671, -0.8649386763572693, 0.4579924941062927, 0.2626205086708069, -0.7647751569747925, -0.14390170574188232, 0.0993901789188385, -0.4713665246963501, 0.22184588015079498, -0.5752055048942566, -0.6670337319374084, -0.9062314033508301, -0.40768614411354065, -0.45616912841796875, 0.43288469314575195, -0.34836113452911377, -0.20046932995319366, 0.6869656443595886, -0.6238473057746887, -0.11526979506015778, -0.43857482075691223, 0.3303523063659668, 0.15725871920585632, -0.1272238940000534, 0.17408162355422974, -0.48424679040908813, 1.196475625038147, -0.8441755175590515, 0.24533683061599731, -0.31775718927383423, -0.4588432013988495, -0.46647319197654724, -0.09400254487991333, -0.12043164670467377, 0.29216906428337097, -0.35393527150154114, -0.07930689305067062, 0.025552958250045776, -0.4834408164024353, 0.06582718342542648, 0.402957022190094, -0.25756222009658813, -0.6294701099395752, -0.011874977499246597, 0.2650533616542816, 0.16577288508415222, -0.2204078584909439, -0.10149972140789032, 0.6608445644378662, -0.4605241119861603, 0.7147201895713806, -0.5049923062324524, -0.7081793546676636, 0.46816474199295044, -1.3404000997543335, -0.09598403424024582, -0.7872893214225769, 0.032140426337718964, -0.15970264375209808, 0.05588608980178833, 0.586081862449646, 0.43972381949424744, 0.29538434743881226, -0.31419166922569275, -0.19457566738128662, -0.3584356904029846, 1.0338579416275024, -1.2682687044143677, -0.3031170070171356, -0.4269844591617584, 0.29799678921699524, -0.6660573482513428, 0.884361982345581, -1.028355360031128, 0.07222916185855865, -0.0656445324420929, 0.23928077518939972, -0.11757087707519531, 0.4926161766052246, -0.13360191881656647, 0.17243432998657227, -0.5405055284500122, 0.07518512010574341, 0.12643347680568695, 0.3420109152793884, -0.6348412036895752, 0.2181456983089447, -0.7714701294898987, -0.009883806109428406, -0.1091892346739769, -0.12318756431341171, 0.6559104323387146, 0.4961830675601959, 0.402760773897171, -0.6982595324516296, 0.15786875784397125, 0.7037898898124695, 0.08030951768159866, 0.6343804001808167, 0.3970338702201843, -0.34118208289146423, 0.12582677602767944, -0.6358810067176819, -0.6774181723594666, 1.0484898090362549, -0.17646849155426025, -0.20968523621559143, -0.40756598114967346, -0.5009422898292542, -0.29735785722732544, -0.09058423340320587, 0.19491928815841675, 0.27042436599731445, 0.4163086414337158, -0.2124946564435959, 0.20936495065689087, -0.07968850433826447, 0.04240259528160095, 0.24544906616210938, 0.305717796087265, 0.5776867866516113, -0.25557294487953186, -0.21329256892204285, -0.40377694368362427, -0.6981111764907837, -1.0134856700897217, 0.5944418907165527, 0.6956585049629211, -0.3162896931171417, 1.1290009021759033, -0.4695877730846405, -0.6847512722015381, -0.509763240814209, -0.21257640421390533, 0.16119375824928284, -0.6984565854072571, 0.4535960257053375, 0.09515006095170975, -0.4366925358772278, 0.45810091495513916, 0.01841590367257595, -0.7444056272506714, -0.5491794943809509, 0.49139535427093506, -0.34669217467308044, -0.11505632102489471, 0.6875883340835571, 0.035149555653333664, -0.4219771921634674, -1.112706184387207, -1.4563310146331787, -0.3820568919181824, 0.12383892387151718, -0.36422768235206604, 0.0004381067701615393, 0.35086876153945923, -0.5953245162963867, 0.6999632120132446, 0.3629325032234192, 0.7701271176338196, 0.35675281286239624, 0.5434885621070862, 0.50914067029953, -0.5228108167648315, 0.1524784117937088, 1.0379024744033813, 0.2303411215543747, -0.40662872791290283, 0.29953375458717346, 0.5677037835121155, -0.3024304509162903, -0.10694007575511932, 0.7474002242088318, -1.1285768747329712, -0.16734528541564941, 0.1449955701828003, -0.24998682737350464, -0.07623530924320221, -0.016317740082740784, -0.24068792164325714, 0.04100384563207626, -0.8906357288360596, -0.38885772228240967, 0.10154826939105988, -0.18509326875209808, 0.14925655722618103, 0.5421110987663269, -0.013608742505311966, 0.09807639569044113, -0.6663098931312561, -0.38070055842399597, -0.12219784408807755, -0.6931590437889099, -0.7561162710189819, -1.1256763935089111, -0.4513205289840698, -0.27728623151779175, 0.3311864733695984, 0.06325554847717285, 0.010105831548571587, 0.2952967882156372, 0.26757410168647766, -0.2105909138917923, -0.19134144484996796, 0.31124237179756165, 1.2398442029953003, -0.17448727786540985, -0.647534966468811, -0.40024334192276, 0.39424875378608704, -0.5674418807029724, -0.7463984489440918, -0.7305219173431396, 0.2065737098455429, -0.05748836696147919, 0.9761891961097717, -0.27592718601226807, 0.7649165987968445, -0.5092636346817017, -0.2811194658279419, -0.02413669042289257, 0.1799091249704361, -1.1494084596633911, 0.5651749968528748, -1.1180466413497925, 0.6294388771057129, 0.5344077944755554, -0.30747079849243164, -0.03685314208269119, -0.18028177320957184, -1.0131334066390991, 0.4021542966365814, 0.68100506067276, 1.2049710750579834, 0.11125143617391586, -0.886707067489624, 0.2748742997646332, 0.3761026859283447, -0.999899685382843, 0.38137274980545044, -0.7236735224723816, 0.6562715172767639, -0.38809773325920105, 0.6825383901596069, 0.24211274087429047, 0.7687405943870544, -0.28368502855300903, 0.8472073674201965, -0.7928555011749268, -0.34011879563331604, 0.0940142422914505, 0.5389213562011719, 0.3221329152584076, -0.7083951830863953, 0.5733728408813477, -0.6718733906745911, 0.6781045198440552, 0.08250436931848526, -0.13281166553497314, 0.0634165108203888, 0.004478966351598501, -0.7836124300956726, -0.21078485250473022, 0.21123330295085907, -0.6752435564994812, 0.8900436758995056, 0.102494977414608, 0.5671061873435974, 0.05107540637254715, -0.15935508906841278, -1.4803694486618042, 0.10997600108385086, -0.2173357754945755, -0.1937042623758316, 0.6821801066398621, -0.36738553643226624, 0.1405375897884369, 0.24160288274288177, -0.19243773818016052, -0.11012071371078491, -0.228131502866745, 1.1051547527313232, 1.2595380544662476, 0.11455660313367844, -0.4254164397716522, 0.40400487184524536, -0.8164371848106384, -0.6383145451545715, -0.11319100111722946, 0.18821339309215546, -0.7311549782752991, -0.6061791181564331, -0.28534945845603943, 0.36322352290153503, -0.7201307415962219, -0.24591700732707977, 0.05556544288992882, -0.1281219869852066, -0.1611630618572235, -0.031077837571501732, -0.7148502469062805, -0.028300948441028595, -0.05325218290090561, 0.35905906558036804, 0.08550306409597397, -0.06606203317642212, 0.024553120136260986, 0.17270126938819885, 0.8707683682441711, -0.021013205870985985, -0.22029580175876617, 1.1548247337341309, -0.13492166996002197, -0.13653600215911865, 0.7296328544616699, 0.32641756534576416, 0.5489126443862915, 0.7658648490905762, -0.2818045914173126, -0.12216296046972275, 0.5313434600830078, 0.00944479089230299, 0.5108298063278198, 0.3866712152957916, -0.300461083650589, 0.7297066450119019, 0.3453769087791443, 0.05948977917432785, 0.26899710297584534, -0.02260558493435383, -0.21839436888694763, 0.034733548760414124, -0.11433728039264679, 0.1789529025554657, -0.17016680538654327, 0.02771127037703991, -0.2322777807712555, -0.2907317578792572, 0.5778053402900696, -0.28941255807876587, -0.11589571833610535, 0.5086543560028076, -0.2863554358482361, -1.1780344247817993, -0.9510821104049683, 0.6588477492332458, -0.2555084526538849, -0.05754636228084564, -0.05025032162666321, 0.28023114800453186, 0.20479705929756165, 0.18229761719703674, -0.38165125250816345, 0.7034643292427063, 0.2374967336654663, 1.0613850355148315, 0.6795355677604675, 0.48309406638145447, 0.46762266755104065, 0.21888267993927002, 0.16265948116779327, -0.6176744103431702, 0.5132068991661072, 0.3250243067741394, -1.0544445514678955, 0.1964980959892273, 0.5249668955802917, -0.8088329434394836, -0.4107096493244171, -1.0243006944656372, 0.014568476937711239, -0.7294233441352844, 0.28041547536849976, 0.23159846663475037, -0.32257845997810364, 0.22231794893741608, -0.23563945293426514, 0.5614637136459351, 0.1891874521970749, 0.7157871127128601, 0.3899269104003906, 0.11943744868040085, 0.5825983881950378, 1.3031041622161865, 0.3529644310474396, 0.12429865449666977, -0.23334063589572906, -0.13096219301223755, 0.36259716749191284, 0.20690634846687317, -0.7876459956169128, 0.3188582956790924, -0.213736429810524, -0.4394398331642151, 0.5201836824417114, 0.38682836294174194, 0.131300687789917, -0.1627279818058014, -0.009733745828270912, 0.47909894585609436, -0.0004391568654682487, -0.3658434748649597, 0.03444313257932663, 0.3507976830005646, -0.8313776850700378, -0.0747247040271759, 0.42250049114227295, -0.6962716579437256, 0.2879961431026459, -0.6383869051933289, 0.8426091074943542, 0.3468581736087799, -0.3629402816295624, -0.19133812189102173, -0.5598868727684021, -0.7555094361305237, -0.6894968748092651, -0.08301660418510437, 0.3562135100364685, 0.11876494437456131, 1.1350687742233276, 0.3772980868816376, 0.12791189551353455, -0.6085473299026489, -0.25617191195487976, -0.14975503087043762, 1.1001856327056885, -0.09160743653774261, 0.29956531524658203, 0.45291709899902344, 0.32091063261032104, -0.5200060606002808, 0.8052825927734375, 0.7377931475639343, -0.21921196579933167, 0.39178210496902466, -0.27718624472618103, 0.4064299464225769, 0.3284063935279846, -0.7917492985725403, 0.021313345059752464, 0.8365277051925659, 0.5142176151275635, -0.19602584838867188, -0.05929957330226898, -0.25335225462913513, -0.23962156474590302, 0.2867017686367035, -0.10219864547252655, 0.37069007754325867, 0.14958171546459198, -0.43876826763153076, 0.31201350688934326, -0.921217143535614, 4.001386642456055, 0.8678481578826904, -0.011199344880878925, 0.06149633228778839, 0.6008655428886414, 1.1109434366226196, 0.3357699513435364, 0.4266130328178406, 0.13337144255638123, -0.9254628419876099, 0.03158777207136154, -0.11811535805463791, 0.38328468799591064, 0.6391783952713013, -0.41327816247940063, 0.3168395757675171, 0.048126254230737686, 0.20852133631706238, -0.52467280626297, -0.05573248490691185, -0.8765023946762085, 0.33986276388168335, 0.05466114357113838, -0.26126840710639954, -0.0166560560464859, 0.001493420684710145, 0.7307131886482239, -0.4303857088088989, -0.47978779673576355, -0.690840482711792, -0.12197030335664749, -0.7973935604095459, -0.43256309628486633, -0.3267439603805542, -1.1488624811172485, 0.6673957109451294, 0.17185476422309875, -0.3656548857688904, 0.12667857110500336, -0.04798393324017525, -0.336382120847702, -0.488603413105011, 0.38668888807296753, -0.6676049828529358, 0.0959748700261116, 0.9552707672119141, 0.3650965988636017, 0.43485888838768005, 0.661338746547699, -0.6796488165855408, 0.4943491518497467, -0.04974423348903656, 0.4101230800151825, -0.4252040386199951, -0.8956902027130127, -0.48755666613578796, -0.7909365892410278, -0.29547831416130066, 0.0335562638938427, 0.2208092212677002, 0.7836185097694397, -0.6481128931045532, -0.7018635869026184, 0.46975982189178467, 0.3076263666152954, -0.10619491338729858, 0.017078351229429245, 0.07611801475286484, 0.2880170941352844, -0.6270929574966431, -0.47264915704727173, -0.1497838795185089, -0.43527188897132874, -0.8299100399017334, 0.692595899105072, -0.2403162717819214, 0.24271753430366516, 0.12347244471311569, -0.5672887563705444, 0.3534788489341736, -0.40728849172592163, 0.23690316081047058, 0.027707520872354507, 1.182129144668579, -0.15050014853477478, 0.44571080803871155, -0.015593312680721283, -0.12330406904220581, 0.7144599556922913, 0.7981758117675781, 0.35621458292007446, 1.3126543760299683, 0.02083992213010788, 0.5861223936080933, -1.0087676048278809 ]
Cosmological Models in Two Spacetime Dimensions
Various physical properties of cosmological models in (1+1) dimensions are investigated. We demonstrate how a hot big bang and a hot big crunch can arise in some models. In particular, we examine why particle horizons do not occur in matter and radiation models. We also discuss under what circumstances exponential inflation and matter/radiation decoupling can happen. Finally, without assuming any particular equation of state, we show that physical singularities can occur in both untilted and tilted universe models if certain assumptions are satisfied, similar to the (3+1)-dimensional cases.
K.C.K. Chan and R.B. Mann
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210015
gr-qc/9210016
[ -0.15013767778873444, 0.34600263833999634, 0.4951626658439636, -0.42644360661506653, 0.3542192578315735, -0.21547093987464905, -0.4767470955848694, -0.03758316487073898, -0.10945790261030197, 0.854050874710083, 0.1726844608783722, -0.46709877252578735, -0.1515527367591858, -0.8618883490562439, 0.08811349421739578, 0.04322720319032669, -0.20576830208301544, -0.6052344441413879, -1.4993782043457031, 0.4011995196342468, 0.27672499418258667, -0.21737909317016602, -1.3155763149261475, -0.9570257663726807, 0.2798418402671814, 0.2598661482334137, 0.6101438999176025, -0.17899549007415771, 1.205458402633667, 1.2160564661026, 0.7182401418685913, -0.5824459791183472, 0.09786450862884521, 0.09306347370147705, -0.07233301550149918, -0.11260022968053818, 0.2984354496002197, -0.8772033452987671, 0.5663992762565613, -0.08544104546308517, 0.16446997225284576, -0.014416603371500969, 0.5113709568977356, -0.664656400680542, -0.4841875731945038, -0.4197448492050171, 0.47995227575302124, 0.3060731589794159, -0.21246641874313354, -0.7834224700927734, -0.18556155264377594, -0.46595728397369385, 0.1271708905696869, -0.7826642394065857, -0.5173056125640869, 0.18671998381614685, 0.8807317614555359, -0.023945476859807968, -0.6575266122817993, -0.016156351193785667, 0.49019548296928406, 0.4767042100429535, 0.185739666223526, -0.6273040175437927, -0.012140042148530483, 1.1684545278549194, 0.014429531060159206, 0.14508503675460815, -0.07022804021835327, 0.10135485976934433, -0.5317703485488892, -0.5487825274467468, 0.24724586308002472, 0.14391270279884338, -0.16842177510261536, -0.01723199523985386, -0.1480594277381897, -0.35074278712272644, 0.09379521012306213, -0.4462604820728302, -0.13118208944797516, 0.240219846367836, -0.04284042865037918, 0.3096935749053955, -0.07673919945955276, -0.3609370291233063, 0.5717515349388123, -0.07769449055194855, 0.36419540643692017, -0.3420180380344391, -0.4742702543735504, 0.25978052616119385, 0.07245204597711563, -0.02367498353123665, 0.46904414892196655, 0.17432910203933716, -0.5884680151939392, 0.7765247225761414, -0.16153134405612946, 0.3316180408000946, -0.31287500262260437, 1.3140077590942383, -0.8501375913619995, 0.1500529944896698, -0.4518669545650482, 0.7369701266288757, 0.10441483557224274, -0.3138148784637451, 0.3344135582447052, -0.870088517665863, 0.229524165391922, 0.7956240773200989, -0.0342465303838253, 0.4391463100910187, -0.007828443311154842, 1.1162831783294678, -0.7065441012382507, -0.19001391530036926, -0.29600849747657776, 0.3937244415283203, 0.21015606820583344, 0.44890978932380676, -0.22665047645568848, 0.6455839276313782, 0.2114575356245041, -0.590790867805481, 0.17548911273479462, 0.5381308794021606, -0.5930306315422058, 0.09242568910121918, 0.386790007352829, -0.6851433515548706, -0.5293407440185547, 0.8557621836662292, 0.26497459411621094, 0.6555175185203552, 0.4910212755203247, 0.1601090133190155, -0.5610895156860352, -0.7233219742774963, 0.3829154968261719, -0.6202312111854553, 0.787283182144165, 1.4309567213058472, -0.9323768019676208, 0.4988100230693817, -0.11893519014120102, 0.29059889912605286, -0.4512364864349365, -0.10380487143993378, -0.5111678838729858, -0.5460517406463623, -0.18533094227313995, 0.2968142628669739, 0.4401838779449463, -0.2688545882701874, -0.36784934997558594, -0.06994286179542542, -0.720635175704956, -0.17932716012001038, 0.6407304406166077, 0.11435069143772125, 0.17828859388828278, 1.5335825681686401, -0.3250647187232971, 0.31817036867141724, -0.5124441385269165, -0.48055219650268555, -0.3132430911064148, -0.29742151498794556, -0.19807368516921997, -0.5543740391731262, 0.3134097158908844, 0.25301870703697205, 1.2052589654922485, 1.0454825162887573, -0.04977605864405632, -0.26470786333084106, -0.2057565599679947, 0.6596575379371643, -0.3923846185207367, -0.7387456297874451, 0.7050331830978394, 0.8503403067588806, -0.22603966295719147, -0.41926324367523193, 0.6329941749572754, 0.144511878490448, -0.3629632294178009, 0.29288312792778015, -0.36469927430152893, 0.36347106099128723, -0.920695424079895, 1.050166130065918, -0.7912318110466003, -0.26486241817474365, -0.345186322927475, -0.14827167987823486, -0.5636452436447144, -0.15758420526981354, 0.11528840661048889, 0.0028861211612820625, -0.7122772336006165, 0.6788204908370972, -0.6404185891151428, 0.08941029012203217, 0.021551258862018585, 0.2967166304588318, -0.33597755432128906, 0.32825303077697754, 0.1548607498407364, -0.4100106656551361, -0.24890029430389404, -0.0791836678981781, 0.15180423855781555, 0.4087413549423218, -0.34964340925216675, 0.3695671260356903, 0.6159412264823914, -0.15860332548618317, 1.3983914852142334, 0.10906381905078888, -0.395162433385849, 0.737897515296936, -0.21139997243881226, -0.4724164605140686, -0.6076871156692505, 1.0858150720596313, 0.23340818285942078, 0.6107171177864075, 0.22682593762874603, 0.2669965624809265, -0.3407278060913086, -0.053762998431921005, 0.5370877385139465, -0.28516533970832825, 1.091317892074585, 0.7539556622505188, -0.1683076173067093, -0.006478858180344105, 0.17044761776924133, -0.07918058335781097, 0.4091384708881378, 0.5665446519851685, -0.40156126022338867, 1.2892190217971802, 0.7512661218643188, -0.2579014301300049, -0.20434872806072235, 0.634197473526001, -0.8640758991241455, 1.310678243637085, -0.3256094455718994, -0.18708226084709167, -1.5783039331436157, 0.2327294945716858, 0.15228018164634705, 0.6780158877372742, -0.13409437239170074, -0.7772411108016968, -0.30173036456108093, 0.4455949366092682, 0.0996062383055687, -1.00784170627594, -0.34569481015205383, 0.46131736040115356, -0.3058328628540039, -0.5183737277984619, 0.7265270352363586, -1.0102112293243408, -1.0983983278274536, -0.4353054165840149, -0.3211652934551239, -0.5035685896873474, 0.08329737931489944, -0.964907705783844, 0.22270044684410095, -0.09504587203264236, 0.4640803933143616, 0.017642710357904434, 0.09660907834768295, -0.23592375218868256, -0.4473845660686493, 0.12291212379932404, -0.0014136137906461954, -0.08731157332658768, -0.5967521071434021, -0.09795475006103516, -0.48083624243736267, 0.45222118496894836, -0.2169562727212906, -1.0564402341842651, 0.1976001262664795, -0.3794648051261902, 0.46746376156806946, 0.31173279881477356, -0.18378198146820068, -0.10675131529569626, -0.6580380797386169, -0.5745360851287842, 0.31394416093826294, 0.03498348593711853, -0.39619526267051697, -0.28972357511520386, 0.48454636335372925, 0.5843644738197327, -0.4668945372104645, -0.5646867752075195, 0.9593308568000793, -0.3854545056819916, -0.8910598158836365, -0.3751426935195923, -0.013300325721502304, 0.6215232014656067, -0.3305797278881073, 1.0321232080459595, 0.7725515365600586, -0.4589718282222748, 0.028051160275936127, -0.17617599666118622, -0.29306676983833313, 0.16813760995864868, 0.030324898660182953, -0.20699001848697662, -0.11092643439769745, 0.9365994334220886, 0.4152175784111023, -0.28616955876350403, 1.1198142766952515, -0.3399570882320404, -1.0352317094802856, 0.3616574704647064, -0.29853886365890503, 0.2950282096862793, 0.2867661714553833, 0.2772015631198883, -0.31894931197166443, -0.38305744528770447, -0.2462109625339508, 0.15619602799415588, 0.509238600730896, -0.6265276074409485, 0.0918709933757782, 0.5994506478309631, 0.1265670508146286, -0.26495790481567383, 1.006100058555603, -0.586227297782898, -0.1690961718559265, -0.20991630852222443, -0.41928860545158386, -0.12803541123867035, 0.2980746626853943, -0.04840892180800438, -0.013567779213190079, 0.07549223303794861, -0.6902725696563721, -0.3633372485637665, -0.6354846358299255, -0.1634950488805771, 0.896358072757721, 0.2561492621898651, 0.09231758862733841, 0.10443573445081711, -0.21072112023830414, -0.15294115245342255, 0.3397673964500427, 0.35233327746391296, 0.11054392158985138, -0.5714705586433411, 0.6691111922264099, 0.4284823536872864, -0.4885566234588623, -0.2822206914424896, 0.05743439123034477, 0.15657544136047363, 0.4333639442920685, 0.5375756025314331, 0.6978098750114441, -0.034809328615665436, -0.3879706859588623, -0.7226568460464478, 0.7966105937957764, 0.3107284903526306, -0.046973712742328644, -0.00481981597840786, 0.12319500744342804, -0.16007453203201294, -0.3924311399459839, -0.4855777621269226, -0.554963231086731, -0.9233633875846863, 0.4707658886909485, -0.7203683257102966, -0.45799314975738525, -0.11347763985395432, 0.7246854305267334, 0.8577733635902405, 0.14152270555496216, -0.299394816160202, 0.1799035668373108, -1.0941519737243652, -0.5127682685852051, 0.5594194531440735, -0.3996676504611969, 0.22667840123176575, -0.5893957018852234, 0.6357914805412292, 0.522553026676178, 0.1150643527507782, 0.5351974964141846, -0.36851054430007935, 0.42403101921081543, 0.34818485379219055, 0.8964200615882874, 0.4829493761062622, -0.35338860750198364, 0.17114320397377014, -0.32637134194374084, -0.17937617003917694, -0.5273000001907349, 0.3470655083656311, 0.6867243647575378, 0.9365846514701843, -0.7914729118347168, -0.7239161729812622, -0.048545341938734055, -0.9387465715408325, 0.3479515016078949, -0.34369680285453796, -0.25980502367019653, -0.12811917066574097, -0.09590025246143341, 0.11534871906042099, 0.005288358777761459, 0.9029960632324219, 0.8208007216453552, 0.2535591423511505, 0.79637211561203, -0.47751545906066895, -0.17853066325187683, 1.2280367612838745, 0.444984495639801, -0.04799766466021538, 0.6207013130187988, 0.49453336000442505, -0.3791780173778534, 0.5544187426567078, -0.24034146964550018, -0.4806613624095917, -0.1193917989730835, -0.4512338936328888, 0.6336169242858887, -0.5129972696304321, -0.8189961910247803, -0.3551749885082245, 0.9875167608261108, -0.11103478074073792, 0.14911827445030212, -0.1143801286816597, -0.05978553369641304, -0.017817648127675056, -0.26284506916999817, -1.3069080114364624, -0.8173224925994873, 0.11635182052850723, -0.2627846300601959, -0.23258310556411743, 1.0794581174850464, 0.2622144818305969, -0.2719297707080841, 0.32458534836769104, 0.22487978637218475, 0.49553582072257996, 0.44159743189811707, -1.38889741897583, 0.28885260224342346, 0.378950297832489, -0.7404547333717346, -0.28682565689086914, -0.3437035381793976, 0.6533998847007751, -0.6831240653991699, -0.4031466543674469, -0.1523604840040207, -0.3001856505870819, -0.23509849607944489, -0.37783899903297424, -0.5377198457717896, 0.31449878215789795, -0.5001699328422546, -0.47934699058532715, -0.38961169123649597, -0.3717142939567566, -0.6617618799209595, -0.23325388133525848, -0.057961542159318924, -0.2723847031593323, -0.35409608483314514, 0.3964022397994995, -0.13620103895664215, 0.1274937242269516, -0.6091772317886353, 0.2158248871564865, -0.07928768545389175, -0.8216249942779541, -1.0777825117111206, -1.0498727560043335, 0.31569811701774597, 0.11128471791744232, -0.4132526218891144, -0.20144438743591309, 0.5616490244865417, 0.2751787304878235, -0.17798340320587158, 0.4259193241596222, 0.14682868123054504, -0.3952106535434723, 0.3955899775028229, 0.6119771599769592, 0.28888607025146484, -1.108458399772644, -0.380972295999527, 0.292981892824173, -0.11602968722581863, 0.4436674118041992, -0.6004012823104858, -0.2506163716316223, 0.7080599665641785, -1.2558271884918213, 0.49975916743278503, -0.802796483039856, -0.4911358952522278, -0.3862857222557068, -1.451751708984375, 0.40038177371025085, 0.0669303685426712, 0.4979708194732666, -1.0389519929885864, -0.7931041717529297, -0.5441823601722717, 0.1715630292892456, -1.13419771194458, 0.1762164980173111, -0.6385127305984497, -0.8970691561698914, -0.6560050249099731, 1.4220952987670898, -0.348239928483963, -0.05171658471226692, 0.3370799124240875, 0.3423179090023041, -0.5403597950935364, 0.15240533649921417, 0.09135701507329941, -0.29492831230163574, -0.5393211841583252, 0.29133662581443787, 0.6177279353141785, 0.13854101300239563, 0.3243170976638794, 0.3493354320526123, -0.524482786655426, 0.49627751111984253, -0.3212180435657501, 0.4039515554904938, 0.010839340277016163, -0.31724727153778076, 0.3747575581073761, -0.2463439255952835, 0.16257157921791077, 0.6682080030441284, 0.21137119829654694, 0.7548171281814575, 0.2326941192150116, 0.2877219021320343, -0.08313320577144623, -0.6029345989227295, -0.802541971206665, 0.2403310090303421, 0.15373757481575012, -0.19443874061107635, -0.7125783562660217, 0.09234054386615753, 0.09541287273168564, -0.33931615948677063, 0.1720585823059082, 0.3791907727718353, 0.7849442362785339, 0.3990557789802551, -0.5817119479179382, 0.1657143235206604, 0.1318856030702591, 0.1656734049320221, 0.23700571060180664, 0.1259901523590088, -0.49243220686912537, 0.22428876161575317, -0.23759980499744415, -0.7117716670036316, -0.7424011826515198, 0.22758743166923523, 0.8098722100257874, -0.4148048162460327, 1.2360649108886719, 0.0485365130007267, -0.5481747388839722, -0.4447917342185974, 0.13327133655548096, -0.05037502199411392, 0.00002742602737271227, 0.8379935622215271, -0.37927308678627014, -0.011650819331407547, -0.18390238285064697, 0.5035609006881714, -0.4701610207557678, -0.3939308524131775, 1.1185052394866943, -0.8695868253707886, -0.11334126442670822, -0.0958188846707344, -0.2810831367969513, -0.449579119682312, -0.9859610795974731, -0.9041902422904968, 0.2715672254562378, -0.04468880966305733, -0.579437792301178, 0.13872027397155762, -0.5128729939460754, -0.17435146868228912, 0.10550805181264877, 0.47059985995292664, -0.05169528350234032, 0.5754209756851196, 0.0445844940841198, 0.6886383295059204, -0.6465452313423157, 0.6613101363182068, 0.8261656761169434, 0.037151362746953964, -0.20294545590877533, -0.5487418174743652, -0.2960333526134491, -0.295314222574234, -0.7006500363349915, 0.4144240915775299, 0.36811932921409607, 0.31374087929725647, -0.20870384573936462, 0.4343825578689575, 0.31505292654037476, -0.24431918561458588, 0.35100096464157104, 0.04034585505723953, -0.927659809589386, -0.5022558569908142, -0.17912887036800385, 0.4812268018722534, -0.024568958207964897, 0.7259916067123413, 0.13206559419631958, -0.2558167576789856, 0.22230301797389984, 0.21647222340106964, -0.19068953394889832, -0.6426991820335388, -0.35903263092041016, -0.5631083846092224, -0.6965453624725342, -0.853282630443573, -0.2721541225910187, -0.1783803552389145, 0.310566246509552, -0.17959962785243988, 0.36427807807922363, 0.1245306059718132, -0.14467798173427582, 0.2108902633190155, 0.30378079414367676, -0.4106762707233429, -0.11289035528898239, -0.5207229256629944, 0.06111161410808563, -0.17231661081314087, -1.3695684671401978, -0.7396435737609863, 0.23709408938884735, 0.8258072137832642, 1.3783328533172607, -0.596942126750946, -0.00412337388843298, 0.09833759069442749, -1.1660150289535522, 0.5826039910316467, 0.4337770640850067, -0.584162712097168, 1.0230413675308228, -0.3045887351036072, 1.5202099084854126, 0.09322686493396759, 0.011626248247921467, -0.2802227735519409, -0.2227180153131485, -0.9458242654800415, 0.8867700695991516, 0.5500218868255615, 0.6524361371994019, 0.02146955579519272, -1.0495203733444214, 0.6884474158287048, 0.15122286975383759, -1.3555997610092163, 0.12862907350063324, 0.5849957466125488, 0.4081021547317505, -0.4169166386127472, -0.5346966981887817, 0.37323564291000366, 0.6953122019767761, 0.10527902096509933, -0.34064745903015137, 0.10218261182308197, 0.44127222895622253, -0.17542490363121033, 0.5238736867904663, -0.48729896545410156, -0.4994807839393616, 0.3774518370628357, -0.6737813949584961, 0.45494431257247925, 0.06734590232372284, -0.23390497267246246, 0.44272124767303467, 0.2529977262020111, 0.08601853251457214, -0.6624361276626587, 0.19177544116973877, -0.643328070640564, 0.5921334028244019, 0.6263862252235413, -0.07813384383916855, 0.969514012336731, -0.44321683049201965, -1.4335581064224243, -0.16489818692207336, -0.599180281162262, -1.0365791320800781, -0.11449925601482391, -0.5969151854515076, 0.48674365878105164, 0.12805503606796265, -0.5136416554450989, -0.08074139058589935, -0.1178366169333458, 1.2631497383117676, 0.6604763269424438, 0.07658889144659042, -0.3462671637535095, 0.3976741433143616, -0.9098089933395386, -0.7260981202125549, -0.12229848653078079, -0.07581532746553421, -0.6906175017356873, -1.1804709434509277, -0.4426155686378479, -0.10249144583940506, -0.21981795132160187, 0.009047681465744972, -0.3061088025569916, 0.35786619782447815, 0.15355421602725983, -0.3134504556655884, -0.7692326307296753, -0.13012944161891937, -0.33538806438446045, 0.06067473441362381, 0.17720110714435577, 0.40598535537719727, -0.5012496113777161, 0.13455261290073395, 0.5730667114257812, 0.47191116213798523, -0.06694398820400238, 0.6755379438400269, 0.24386143684387207, -0.322226881980896, 0.7593448162078857, 0.20424582064151764, 0.6843751668930054, 0.26198387145996094, -0.2118273675441742, 0.862384021282196, 0.597634494304657, -0.24098306894302368, 0.7937336564064026, -0.29551491141319275, -0.09341076761484146, 0.6153504252433777, 0.07369627058506012, 0.13664580881595612, 0.12901756167411804, 0.7057608962059021, -0.02580452151596546, 0.002459397306665778, -0.3560854196548462, -0.07716075330972672, -0.902792751789093, 0.9954439401626587, 0.6640129685401917, -0.5796343088150024, 0.06926979869604111, -0.7851454019546509, -0.397629052400589, 0.393587201833725, -0.3083857595920563, -0.8599933981895447, -0.030399512499570847, 0.4037221670150757, 0.46784111857414246, 0.1458807736635208, -0.40005800127983093, 0.20161131024360657, -0.05954609811306, 0.40470585227012634, -0.5438112616539001, 0.993010938167572, 0.9597266912460327, 0.6226447224617004, 0.44380226731300354, 0.6794494986534119, 0.34576842188835144, 1.0408354997634888, -0.3611414134502411, -0.7269710302352905, -0.17633885145187378, 0.26899126172065735, -0.7504377961158752, 0.2721654772758484, -0.21424953639507294, -0.3699307143688202, -0.2482992559671402, -0.6648459434509277, -0.3237086832523346, -0.40785831212997437, -0.0696081891655922, 0.12037449330091476, -0.30150821805000305, -0.6017653942108154, 0.5370973944664001, 0.29768162965774536, 0.5125464200973511, 0.4830929934978485, 0.5667873620986938, 0.002014840254560113, 1.089486002922058, 0.7026063203811646, 0.5892975926399231, -0.27079370617866516, -0.5159687995910645, -0.1784178465604782, 0.20841751992702484, 0.2707863748073578, -0.33603599667549133, -0.031145915389060974, -0.5109719634056091, -0.0720910057425499, -0.7177006006240845, -0.44648587703704834, -0.6196717619895935, 0.18758632242679596, 0.873214840888977, 0.528161346912384, -0.32854267954826355, 0.05307084321975708, 0.05002741888165474, 0.3157956600189209, 0.034064263105392456, -0.4632635712623596, 0.4319823980331421, -0.8856326341629028, 0.8538439869880676, -1.3987431526184082, 0.3378186821937561, 0.22281569242477417, -0.3012322783470154, -0.9420917630195618, -0.07174345850944519, 0.1629447191953659, -0.7751220464706421, -0.44884151220321655, 0.05207309126853943, 0.6360543370246887, 1.232836127281189, 0.0501079298555851, 0.52114337682724, -0.22190232574939728, 0.12938198447227478, -0.3323776423931122, 1.1964870691299438, 0.22876997292041779, 0.4525492787361145, 0.7030981779098511, 0.2381279617547989, -0.799822986125946, 0.44485121965408325, 0.7495193481445312, -0.7867122888565063, 0.34893283247947693, 0.5729857087135315, 0.10634350776672363, -0.27552446722984314, -0.4643634557723999, -0.7344303727149963, 0.07912413030862808, 0.21325188875198364, 0.26467227935791016, -0.2207830846309662, 0.3872911334037781, -0.753784716129303, -0.41042572259902954, -0.5768414735794067, 0.6143630146980286, 0.8840193748474121, -0.4132852256298065, -0.08606556802988052, -0.2588300108909607, 4.043562889099121, 0.7806401252746582, 0.4720756411552429, -0.35305172204971313, 0.6933506727218628, 0.843749463558197, 0.3560630679130554, -0.3645927906036377, 0.2965719401836395, 0.005585840903222561, 0.28282061219215393, -0.06588137149810791, 0.5739858746528625, -0.024190619587898254, 0.27788984775543213, 0.4974699020385742, -0.014203059487044811, 0.34939470887184143, 0.2764640748500824, -0.4977390170097351, -1.4187339544296265, 0.45008525252342224, 0.11953023076057434, 0.17108401656150818, 0.3232544958591461, 0.8225777745246887, 0.3271401524543762, -0.7551477551460266, -0.44480207562446594, -0.5735300779342651, -0.4209466278553009, -0.8138853311538696, -0.3820520341396332, 0.1686164289712906, -0.6897345781326294, 1.0696485042572021, 0.5819535255432129, -0.2603926956653595, 0.13154824078083038, -0.19389066100120544, 0.16135655343532562, -0.36742740869522095, -0.29056721925735474, -0.27965685725212097, 0.27597856521606445, 0.8331517577171326, 0.5716171264648438, -0.08462824672460556, 0.618267834186554, -1.0069249868392944, 0.02312546595931053, -0.06537701189517975, 0.3647611141204834, 0.6868987679481506, -0.9052063226699829, -0.8178229331970215, -0.3085310161113739, -0.19940267503261566, 0.20439401268959045, -0.16737599670886993, 1.1167961359024048, -0.31080925464630127, -0.18827399611473083, 0.4779791235923767, -0.20980112254619598, 0.386918842792511, 0.019225122407078743, -0.16556832194328308, 0.15002581477165222, 0.08152186125516891, -0.4892345070838928, 0.2460789829492569, -0.6398285031318665, 0.5713250637054443, 0.3411776125431061, 0.07027139514684677, -0.4056588411331177, 0.4674266278743744, -0.11156465113162994, 0.1859932243824005, 0.10187531262636185, -0.11014032363891602, -0.07045876979827881, 0.03666258230805397, -0.0457337349653244, 0.37079936265945435, -0.10484658926725388, -0.2354123294353485, -0.5403705835342407, 0.5996702909469604, 0.03526216372847557, 0.8686972856521606, -0.4876994788646698, 0.41936081647872925, -0.6023122072219849 ]
Towards a Singularity-Proof Scheme in Numerical Relativity
Progress in numerical relativity has been hindered for 30 years because of the difficulties of avoiding spacetime singularities in numerical evolution. We propose a scheme which excises a region inside an apparent horizon containing the singularity. Two major ingredients of the scheme are the use of a horizon-locking coordinate and a finite differencing which respects the causal structure of the spacetime. Encouraging results of the scheme in the spherical collapse case are given.
Edward Seidel and Wai-Mo Suen
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210016
gr-qc/9210017
[ -0.2966090142726898, 0.056557007133960724, 0.02765839174389839, 0.4167436361312866, -0.05423767864704132, 0.07909698039293289, -0.1982957273721695, -0.20039330422878265, -0.7978086471557617, 1.291652798652649, 1.041420817375183, -0.07912284135818481, -0.19798262417316437, -0.533426821231842, -0.9147550463676453, 0.3892638087272644, 0.46931469440460205, -0.6258880496025085, -1.11363685131073, 0.526473879814148, 0.28981074690818787, -0.051307566463947296, -0.8375963568687439, -0.4109245538711548, -0.6912693381309509, 1.1237436532974243, 0.5453149676322937, 0.4984831213951111, 0.7831617593765259, 0.8961257934570312, 0.6384481191635132, -0.08712946623563766, -0.31024911999702454, -0.297058641910553, -0.09341107308864594, 0.04143497720360756, 0.38188591599464417, -0.15625999867916107, 0.8238717913627625, -0.5005530714988708, 0.2991877496242523, -0.007673172280192375, 0.12411780655384064, -0.19580598175525665, 0.16614237427711487, -0.09579967707395554, 0.06457218527793884, 0.26000112295150757, 0.13083620369434357, -1.0957194566726685, -0.09487177431583405, -0.10548140853643417, 0.7229644060134888, -0.6787110567092896, -0.6133832335472107, -0.03626546263694763, 0.5063462257385254, 0.3194471597671509, -0.4265608787536621, -0.2629135251045227, 0.48650118708610535, 0.5235127210617065, 0.4385594427585602, -1.0959991216659546, 0.22938863933086395, 0.9546446204185486, -0.08960357308387756, 0.9469611644744873, 0.3041299283504486, -1.0762816667556763, -0.6641222238540649, 0.0591493658721447, -1.2134703397750854, -0.39986318349838257, -0.6583215594291687, 0.4008222818374634, -0.6452926993370056, -0.2385348230600357, -0.9996550679206848, -0.1699669510126114, 0.4572264850139618, 0.0795707255601883, 0.22533635795116425, 0.2244112640619278, -0.3960738778114319, -0.0014783476945012808, 0.2142801433801651, 0.4071725606918335, -0.16263970732688904, 0.14131976664066315, 0.44208255410194397, 0.8035955429077148, 0.27650392055511475, -0.2466542273759842, 0.6377328634262085, 0.7675902843475342, -0.7169721126556396, 0.606476366519928, 0.05180538073182106, 0.28122562170028687, -0.3711291253566742, 1.1019169092178345, -0.1050453782081604, 0.33850720524787903, -0.23477964103221893, 0.8231596350669861, -0.004153864923864603, 0.03211880475282669, -0.49791228771209717, -0.8675752878189087, -0.036010392010211945, 0.05487111210823059, 0.06583750993013382, 0.19675900042057037, 0.08541557937860489, 0.28639107942581177, -0.8122520446777344, 0.14645418524742126, -0.38363882899284363, -0.4223993420600891, -0.5356276631355286, 0.3419835567474365, 0.9641358852386475, 0.6142470240592957, -0.29386624693870544, -0.785439670085907, 0.2641400396823883, 0.26208141446113586, -0.18179212510585785, 0.3940754532814026, 0.036885760724544525, -0.23147942125797272, 0.08354782313108444, 0.31599295139312744, -0.21846389770507812, -0.03671427071094513, 0.23343156278133392, 0.008679348975419998, 0.07206469029188156, -0.457823246717453, 0.47931426763534546, -0.48852261900901794, 0.5483957529067993, 1.076178789138794, -0.42864060401916504, 0.5088415145874023, 0.5633562803268433, 0.007804764434695244, 0.21463347971439362, -0.13756786286830902, -0.2085990011692047, -0.5272400975227356, -0.21986915171146393, 0.009899411350488663, -0.5807626843452454, -0.021803205832839012, -1.1652894020080566, 0.4139312207698822, -0.22556966543197632, -0.26929083466529846, 0.0832352265715599, 0.3795795738697052, 0.350014328956604, 1.1910691261291504, -0.8051695823669434, -0.14757901430130005, -0.671976625919342, -0.26189154386520386, 0.43507394194602966, 0.0666041150689125, 0.06975023448467255, 0.3168983459472656, -0.31341904401779175, 0.6264709234237671, 0.89674311876297, 0.4820023775100708, -0.24469250440597534, -0.16064637899398804, -0.5538920760154724, 0.0615951232612133, -0.303365021944046, -0.6842529773712158, 0.8476048111915588, 0.4874487817287445, -0.8091711401939392, -0.9252322912216187, 0.09450337290763855, -0.6323716640472412, 0.28382977843284607, 0.37899383902549744, -0.4109669327735901, 0.5357252359390259, -1.1991692781448364, 0.2657608389854431, -0.2845129668712616, -0.2289242297410965, -1.2341430187225342, -0.3761714696884155, 0.4604076147079468, -0.3592751920223236, 0.009606867097318172, -0.33270907402038574, -0.5822311639785767, -0.20613335072994232, -1.1079519987106323, 0.14193058013916016, 0.8063443899154663, 0.8240558505058289, -0.381306529045105, -0.2601982355117798, 0.3237815499305725, -0.4356546700000763, 0.17283199727535248, 0.014754541218280792, 0.6606349945068359, -0.16858410835266113, -0.28195157647132874, 0.9448323845863342, 0.7340136170387268, -0.29512104392051697, 0.4073656499385834, 0.3594546616077423, -0.39561641216278076, 0.9842138886451721, -0.5685433745384216, -0.12682969868183136, -0.01631283573806286, 0.3110690712928772, -0.044637441635131836, 0.28794851899147034, 0.1799270510673523, 0.17951339483261108, 0.0000735427820472978, 0.1566336303949356, 0.7228466868400574, -0.04396729916334152, 0.7193808555603027, 0.4235019087791443, -0.26335379481315613, -0.2036246657371521, 0.2741485834121704, 0.4077787697315216, 0.1187407374382019, 0.028731735423207283, -0.4006442129611969, -0.22445905208587646, 0.009436365216970444, -0.026383312419056892, -0.7399994730949402, 0.73729008436203, -0.7933325171470642, 0.6827512383460999, -0.03750307857990265, 0.026203863322734833, -1.1415776014328003, 0.06384655088186264, -0.7286679744720459, 0.3684460520744324, -0.5026048421859741, -0.3997547924518585, -0.30984076857566833, 0.4188562333583832, -0.09759746491909027, -0.8419780731201172, -0.25037500262260437, 0.14501357078552246, -0.8188088536262512, 0.2337123155593872, 0.1108362004160881, -0.02973918430507183, -1.4023816585540771, -0.1795969158411026, -0.35103490948677063, -0.2309075891971588, -0.13636444509029388, 0.06495256721973419, 0.28662893176078796, -0.1686924248933792, 1.2341982126235962, -0.11205441504716873, -0.2802968919277191, 0.5639639496803284, 0.20279157161712646, 0.4659574627876282, -0.39294958114624023, -0.1051524206995964, -0.7608944773674011, 0.09896092116832733, -0.48516613245010376, 0.3235185742378235, -0.6621321439743042, -0.5427230596542358, 0.2790217995643616, -0.2431197464466095, 0.49851974844932556, 0.02711452543735504, -0.007386563811451197, -0.03647291287779808, 0.3126130700111389, -0.4784826934337616, 0.14303454756736755, 0.03479989245533943, 0.16328853368759155, -0.14921371638774872, -1.0550605058670044, 1.0422430038452148, -0.13610930740833282, -0.27333182096481323, 0.7136070728302002, -0.06518440693616867, -0.8709902763366699, 0.33332890272140503, -0.022786632180213928, 0.5164480805397034, -0.1971285194158554, 1.5150669813156128, 1.1446623802185059, -0.25428688526153564, 0.16251039505004883, -0.17541536688804626, -0.3197522759437561, -0.4201064705848694, 0.2688193917274475, -1.0170246362686157, -0.26984545588493347, 1.017934799194336, 0.5840442180633545, -0.6951172947883606, 0.15259522199630737, -1.1587073802947998, -0.30577683448791504, -0.31041401624679565, -0.4545978307723999, 0.5977692604064941, -0.02778594195842743, -0.1978282928466797, -0.380222886800766, -0.2776990830898285, 0.18073150515556335, 0.9842078685760498, 0.7857422828674316, -0.648318886756897, 0.10826098918914795, 0.13966849446296692, 0.08517509698867798, -0.780005693435669, 0.4423104226589203, -0.510664701461792, -0.6196427345275879, 0.30151379108428955, -0.09027430415153503, 0.25256064534187317, 0.5143771171569824, 0.2957969009876251, 0.34631744027137756, -0.03985518589615822, -0.9756504893302917, -0.5163984298706055, -0.680414617061615, -0.5580762028694153, -0.3609417974948883, 0.11352857947349548, 0.12353639304637909, -0.4785180687904358, -0.622107744216919, -0.2181680053472519, 0.35778528451919556, 0.6108013391494751, 1.1532026529312134, -0.7057704329490662, 0.2606905400753021, -0.8163799047470093, -0.4837299883365631, 0.1746385246515274, 0.03379978984594345, 0.3557033836841583, 0.3737647533416748, 0.13035240769386292, -0.3355987071990967, -0.5444437861442566, -0.2988545596599579, -0.357399046421051, 1.0916699171066284, 0.7197110056877136, 0.35705286264419556, -0.3700667917728424, -0.44764444231987, 0.1064264252781868, -0.6278625130653381, -0.31492459774017334, -0.8389000296592712, -0.7208287119865417, 0.36232441663742065, -0.16029515862464905, -0.291985422372818, 0.05229468643665314, 0.41386309266090393, 0.9168240427970886, 0.19048991799354553, 0.05335566774010658, 0.13630138337612152, 0.19084328413009644, 0.1702217161655426, 0.31775662302970886, -0.16274887323379517, 0.2052503079175949, -0.717219889163971, 0.8864431977272034, 0.09227880090475082, 0.12311313301324844, -0.24790242314338684, -0.13115526735782623, -0.06710925698280334, -0.3836236894130707, 0.3819862902164459, 0.6516212821006775, -0.460917592048645, 0.7409077882766724, 0.545181155204773, -0.38150322437286377, -0.3747590482234955, 0.29005929827690125, 0.7452584505081177, 0.24346157908439636, -0.10588790476322174, -0.41629931330680847, -0.5475181937217712, 0.12496029585599899, -0.04541682451963425, 0.6363248229026794, -0.3839086890220642, -0.5212956070899963, -0.4325680136680603, 0.14713507890701294, -0.4012081027030945, 0.18761137127876282, 0.9613732695579529, -0.46082213521003723, 0.15504954755306244, 0.2828501760959625, 0.19414357841014862, 0.9856546521186829, -0.13993698358535767, -0.805754542350769, -0.12869328260421753, 0.5136876702308655, -0.35686975717544556, 1.246751070022583, -0.7669905424118042, -0.8362732529640198, -0.3311002552509308, -0.15278224647045135, 0.2792660892009735, 0.0476110577583313, -0.36850062012672424, 0.23557890951633453, 0.6274303197860718, -0.5970685482025146, 0.49282512068748474, -0.0008315405575558543, 0.5204476714134216, 0.010641842149198055, 0.00048103107837960124, -0.7090941667556763, -0.40761661529541016, -0.1284852772951126, -0.4146060049533844, 0.6198946833610535, 0.4364929497241974, 0.5114264488220215, 0.3585071265697479, 0.6799057722091675, 0.020317047834396362, -0.3754599690437317, 0.4223402738571167, -0.47722724080085754, 0.1732168048620224, -0.37552645802497864, -0.22146674990653992, -0.33633118867874146, -0.4294998347759247, 0.432707816362381, -0.31090787053108215, 0.9406781792640686, 0.3809496760368347, -0.28908222913742065, -0.18783341348171234, -0.3833842873573303, -0.5796984434127808, 0.7900623679161072, -0.4453110992908478, 0.006736419629305601, 0.2622678875923157, -0.3141612112522125, -0.1954898238182068, -0.11760193854570389, 0.410971462726593, -0.8303582072257996, 0.3161754310131073, 0.7349064946174622, -0.2109546810388565, 1.1280308961868286, -0.9813095331192017, -0.06415826827287674, -0.34080544114112854, -0.6405109167098999, -0.5064160227775574, -0.7177616953849792, -0.02963109314441681, -0.020267732441425323, -0.05717460438609123, -0.378620982170105, 0.15515434741973877, 0.20999670028686523, 0.001233235583640635, 0.8562527298927307, -0.11834092438220978, -0.46461182832717896, 0.17656242847442627, 1.0968236923217773, 0.07229547202587128, -0.9533640742301941, -0.11163850873708725, 1.0316457748413086, -0.22820843756198883, 0.8441005945205688, -0.15670159459114075, -0.43984749913215637, 0.24151097238063812, -0.5931601524353027, 0.757925808429718, -0.8216596245765686, -0.41960543394088745, -0.4148899018764496, -0.09066750854253769, 0.013343374244868755, 0.2651853859424591, -0.36964356899261475, -0.5042691826820374, 0.20111890137195587, -0.5009262561798096, 0.18181398510932922, 0.09269028902053833, 0.5345606803894043, -0.13471172749996185, 0.0011022138642147183, -0.07206377387046814, 1.1412217617034912, -0.4026343822479248, -0.04584645479917526, -0.42379602789878845, 0.010904521681368351, -0.5027477145195007, 0.5820959806442261, 0.11025811731815338, 0.32229068875312805, -0.49818578362464905, 0.34522852301597595, -0.06154392287135124, 0.40760576725006104, -0.5902808904647827, 0.20486384630203247, -0.8979556560516357, 0.05143573507666588, 0.19182859361171722, -0.27391019463539124, 0.3369412124156952, -0.020688606426119804, 0.477387398481369, -0.3896436095237732, 0.38654008507728577, 0.3960668444633484, -0.018999144434928894, 0.34576061367988586, -0.08236314356327057, -0.6159010529518127, -0.06882929056882858, -0.6732070446014404, -0.5294143557548523, 0.6597952842712402, 0.41954347491264343, 0.03009195253252983, -0.6032387614250183, -0.7556765079498291, 0.20945371687412262, -0.39635252952575684, -0.06747563928365707, 0.6795896887779236, -0.05365734547376633, 0.19327521324157715, -0.1956777125597, -0.02863071672618389, -0.6285610795021057, -0.396080881357193, 0.1855909824371338, 0.4477863013744354, 0.47028374671936035, -0.37937119603157043, -1.01605224609375, -0.3259638547897339, -0.2774011194705963, 0.3425208628177643, 0.49091729521751404, 0.2721729576587677, 1.1273027658462524, 0.23195652663707733, -0.28671303391456604, -0.6486019492149353, -0.04994070157408714, 0.776252269744873, 0.18588124215602875, -0.11611398309469223, 0.408770352602005, -0.642236053943634, -0.09921416640281677, 0.06316711753606796, -0.7532328367233276, -0.28481030464172363, 1.0142377614974976, -0.5424087643623352, -0.21466101706027985, 0.7925775051116943, -0.15724146366119385, -0.8211513161659241, -1.1409566402435303, -1.4040014743804932, -0.31167367100715637, 0.3142869472503662, -0.5351706743240356, -0.029428783804178238, -0.24275776743888855, -0.1983477771282196, 0.2839733958244324, 0.6966431736946106, 0.6660308837890625, 0.4375728666782379, 0.01386540662497282, -0.04566337913274765, -0.15353839099407196, 0.24835866689682007, 1.4503085613250732, 0.12442837655544281, -0.6028827428817749, -0.6340802311897278, 0.28457650542259216, -0.03789672255516052, -0.1407458484172821, 0.3762836754322052, -0.5976585149765015, 0.1490677297115326, 0.08332923799753189, 0.30991458892822266, 0.6286522150039673, 0.9334731101989746, 0.3582417964935303, -0.12273773550987244, -0.38225656747817993, -0.5659105181694031, 0.2970013916492462, 0.210189551115036, -0.017193136736750603, 0.987113356590271, 0.24598416686058044, -0.2309643179178238, -0.5443810224533081, -0.504898190498352, -0.6299763321876526, -0.7436724901199341, -0.40085774660110474, -1.2189300060272217, -0.9308042526245117, -1.564454436302185, -0.06836594641208649, 0.1286907196044922, 0.43782737851142883, -0.9400376677513123, 0.7597485184669495, -1.0523886680603027, 0.14059025049209595, 0.10114502161741257, 0.9490863084793091, -0.7453975677490234, -0.9149137735366821, -1.4740785360336304, -0.41459646821022034, 0.04842574521899223, -1.0326730012893677, -0.9108270406723022, -0.26576223969459534, 0.23873642086982727, 0.8434363007545471, -1.3859964609146118, 1.0396592617034912, -0.8365775346755981, -0.3052651882171631, 0.2650555372238159, -0.12186147272586823, -1.108311414718628, 0.8365275263786316, -0.2542349398136139, 0.49457475543022156, -0.04492710530757904, 0.2737862169742584, -0.21014003455638885, -0.05688461288809776, -0.8474302291870117, 1.0593172311782837, -0.3835318684577942, 0.34469178318977356, 0.555965006351471, -0.8838557004928589, 0.6472669839859009, -0.2512665390968323, -0.7862996459007263, 0.21258291602134705, -0.48319968581199646, 0.5649167895317078, -0.3647572100162506, -0.09366955608129501, -0.19640955328941345, 0.19412639737129211, -0.5193734765052795, 0.4517090320587158, -0.5232418775558472, 0.0762886181473732, 0.346718430519104, 0.5969177484512329, -0.13016122579574585, -0.06253562867641449, -0.03952647000551224, -0.4497034549713135, 0.5665547251701355, 0.03502080217003822, -0.14852267503738403, 0.39075109362602234, -0.5534002184867859, -0.09651703387498856, -0.16478340327739716, 0.07221127301454544, -0.991250216960907, 0.40114596486091614, -0.07881810516119003, -0.5350849628448486, 0.7193804979324341, -0.6769016981124878, -1.2151342630386353, 0.3108816146850586, -0.25666168332099915, -0.7882317304611206, -0.206019788980484, -0.03795688599348068, -0.775392472743988, 0.21722884476184845, -0.7615265250205994, 0.22864092886447906, -0.1333986073732376, 1.0236493349075317, 1.073371171951294, 0.019521469250321388, 0.41040876507759094, 0.2530886232852936, -0.7753289341926575, 0.2178172469139099, -0.807929277420044, 0.02259192056953907, -0.7360889315605164, -0.44021981954574585, -0.13191062211990356, 0.041877586394548416, -0.09848930686712265, -0.052567847073078156, -0.21606233716011047, -0.19356751441955566, 0.48644182085990906, 0.05893260985612869, -0.17898455262184143, 0.2025749683380127, -0.14387167990207672, 0.48599711060523987, 0.7771160006523132, 0.047771986573934555, 0.7049645781517029, 0.356183797121048, 0.930947482585907, 0.23673194646835327, -0.3676203787326813, 1.4744067192077637, -0.24783112108707428, 0.014277733862400055, 0.49959561228752136, 0.4430887997150421, 0.36400821805000305, 0.400363564491272, -0.3496730923652649, -0.3422541916370392, 0.34098681807518005, -0.09088356792926788, 0.8754854798316956, 0.20826387405395508, 0.2693280875682831, 0.6158711910247803, 0.1610593944787979, 0.043780215084552765, 0.24755610525608063, 0.15824638307094574, -0.004627668764442205, 0.8883761167526245, -0.634857177734375, -0.1686343401670456, -0.13583040237426758, -0.045936599373817444, -0.03451301157474518, 0.5712093710899353, -0.2876395285129547, 0.17813117802143097, 0.3718336522579193, 0.6680336594581604, -0.015996651723980904, -1.0281084775924683, 0.008795181289315224, 0.26275360584259033, 0.2224142998456955, -0.22234989702701569, -1.0930105447769165, -0.354139506816864, 0.8295575380325317, 0.26914533972740173, -0.5133860111236572, 0.5106163620948792, 0.13543646037578583, 0.3798382878303528, 0.48950591683387756, 0.9999745488166809, 0.5012507438659668, 1.0869532823562622, -0.17416439950466156, -0.9007518291473389, -0.19576619565486908, 0.8786211609840393, -0.697166383266449, 0.6420835256576538, -0.13484792411327362, 0.02222975343465805, -0.2981514036655426, -0.9055848717689514, -0.19769176840782166, -0.5560840368270874, 0.040927790105342865, 0.14271436631679535, 0.3549954295158386, -0.7908234596252441, 0.32928892970085144, -0.07767447829246521, 0.2804810404777527, 0.42804616689682007, 0.2703976333141327, -0.23117098212242126, 0.4453047215938568, 1.1517401933670044, 0.04929013177752495, 0.1964963674545288, -0.030301492661237717, -0.09670668095350266, 0.5068919062614441, -0.2564500570297241, -0.3748839795589447, 0.9575696587562561, -0.49404260516166687, 0.18098141252994537, -0.015581496991217136, -0.006652251351624727, -0.7890127301216125, 0.0321214534342289, -0.03634800761938095, 1.004684567451477, -0.2970089614391327, -0.05202348530292511, 0.6316295266151428, 0.8073946237564087, -0.5074996948242188, -0.6227492094039917, 0.35538166761398315, -0.3708738386631012, -0.17310373485088348, -0.8374226689338684, 0.31989699602127075, -0.17284029722213745, -0.3060290515422821, -0.1487056463956833, -0.21324807405471802, -0.25266286730766296, -0.5889251828193665, -0.038727179169654846, -0.36258259415626526, 0.29624661803245544, 0.8423468470573425, 0.6228575706481934, -0.0012632004218176007, -1.080053448677063, -0.3441634774208069, 0.05513530224561691, 1.165402889251709, 0.39357224106788635, 0.004133225884288549, 0.5446128845214844, -0.5888782143592834, -0.8717971444129944, 0.7365394830703735, 0.9374573230743408, -0.41465437412261963, 0.5722548961639404, -0.4120446741580963, 0.11008331924676895, -0.36223000288009644, 0.108035609126091, 0.25381529331207275, -0.25112321972846985, 0.8542605042457581, -0.5010645389556885, -0.6330894827842712, 0.09350989758968353, -0.5264536738395691, 0.07215545326471329, -0.9602309465408325, 0.26952508091926575, 0.2658955156803131, -0.73088538646698, -0.5032154321670532, -0.635094940662384, 4.051845550537109, 0.5494554042816162, 0.7882763147354126, -0.1940229833126068, 1.0232889652252197, 0.69968181848526, 0.2167038470506668, -0.03342248126864433, 0.34291329979896545, -0.5446527004241943, 0.2148761749267578, 0.5161231756210327, 0.19228576123714447, 0.4806938171386719, 0.5519198775291443, 0.42454794049263, -0.5256770849227905, 0.1360938549041748, -0.1633303463459015, -0.637584924697876, -0.9834322333335876, -0.06276915222406387, 0.8150925636291504, -0.3899053931236267, 0.8760581016540527, 0.42348918318748474, 0.3418077826499939, -0.3944438099861145, -1.0575824975967407, -0.38724735379219055, -0.22518396377563477, -0.7753244042396545, 0.5739814639091492, 0.021100033074617386, -1.2941386699676514, 0.37110909819602966, 0.27317729592323303, -0.05891386419534683, 0.3885011374950409, 0.07745718955993652, 0.35963472723960876, -0.519148588180542, 0.25454458594322205, -0.21515938639640808, 0.10662905126810074, 1.0995502471923828, 0.7595990896224976, 0.5291705131530762, 0.8000441789627075, -0.7091132998466492, 0.04359682276844978, 0.22972477972507477, 0.1796482801437378, -0.723579466342926, -0.4917987585067749, -0.6280354857444763, 0.10421690344810486, -0.1361098736524582, 0.4595455527305603, 0.02180854231119156, 0.6644960641860962, 0.06453272700309753, 0.1626836657524109, 0.03919054940342903, 0.4455675184726715, -0.06505614519119263, 0.23118197917938232, -0.0016711853677406907, -0.14468437433242798, -0.6956527233123779, -1.107538104057312, -0.19246847927570343, -0.6034531593322754, -0.29561808705329895, 0.6004048585891724, 0.09560669958591461, -0.09912291914224625, 0.5841158032417297, 0.17348365485668182, 0.920120894908905, -0.5621210336685181, -0.2708180248737335, -0.28442806005477905, 0.6323986053466797, -0.10012010484933853, 0.6854313611984253, 0.1474127173423767, -0.4813551604747772, -0.2544291615486145, 0.6043093800544739, -0.008313070051372051, 0.7662624716758728, -0.2561873495578766, 0.4850626289844513, -0.9769323468208313 ]
Is Quantum Spacetime Foam Unstable?
A very simple wormhole geometry is considered as a model of a mode of topological fluctutation in Planck-scale spacetime foam. Quantum dynamics of the hole reduces to quantum mechanics of one variable, throat radius, and admits a WKB analysis. The hole is quantum-mechanically unstable: It has no bound states. Wormhole wave functions must eventually leak to large radii. This suggests that stability considerations along these lines may place strong constraints on the nature and even the existence of spacetime foam.
Ian H. Redmount and Wai-Mo Suen
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210017
gr-qc/9210018
[ 0.2570629119873047, -0.40453028678894043, 0.37804892659187317, -0.24447070062160492, -0.1445421576499939, 0.4231734573841095, -0.45299896597862244, 0.15521328151226044, -0.04145767539739609, 1.7244375944137573, 0.5923233032226562, -0.22856514155864716, 0.052558038383722305, -0.9732905626296997, -0.22415831685066223, 0.36308327317237854, -0.10666347295045853, 0.6991099715232849, -1.2783482074737549, 0.3191283941268921, 0.38499894738197327, 0.32764941453933716, -0.544939398765564, -0.756145715713501, -0.739223837852478, 0.27928444743156433, 0.8894726634025574, 0.21064992249011993, 1.496728777885437, 0.9965439438819885, 1.2023594379425049, -0.36565157771110535, 0.09313802421092987, -0.7116713523864746, 0.23594200611114502, -0.26927706599235535, 0.30562353134155273, -0.15428884327411652, 0.6311477422714233, -0.2924986183643341, 0.13793067634105682, -0.1091141402721405, -0.23680101335048676, -0.47927016019821167, -0.6537211537361145, -0.5306252241134644, 0.010249171406030655, -0.28318411111831665, -0.2990629971027374, -0.3979267179965973, 0.3081170320510864, -0.3596906363964081, 0.8920337557792664, -0.683864176273346, 0.018496090546250343, -0.4895395338535309, 0.5380973815917969, 0.6836321353912354, -0.5680640339851379, 0.5677428841590881, 1.225097894668579, 0.7350769639015198, 0.3031638264656067, -0.9894130229949951, -0.022917792201042175, 0.7124017477035522, 0.3227757513523102, 0.24970893561840057, -0.23722799122333527, -0.35847988724708557, -0.8951501846313477, 0.1460978239774704, 0.11574991792440414, 0.007740018889307976, -0.6435838341712952, 0.4605654776096344, -0.3377770781517029, -0.3186209201812744, -0.2584659457206726, 0.6301213502883911, -0.16736558079719543, -0.17698229849338531, 0.03722988814115524, 0.7129806876182556, -0.5270208716392517, -0.1602565199136734, 0.3166913390159607, 0.6613849401473999, -0.02432907372713089, 0.13944384455680847, 0.27250128984451294, 1.2332005500793457, -0.6254784464836121, 0.054795123636722565, 0.3195117115974426, 1.047808289527893, 0.08958073705434799, 0.6859948635101318, 0.1663604974746704, -0.16601204872131348, 0.16077880561351776, 1.2543646097183228, -0.005662455223500729, 0.6615784168243408, 0.06992235779762268, 0.8125295639038086, -0.5998836159706116, 0.13271477818489075, -0.06722474843263626, -0.1294582188129425, -0.4198414087295532, 0.1713741421699524, 0.26816266775131226, -0.1350523829460144, 0.08098435401916504, 0.3766849637031555, -0.5186859965324402, -0.2990097105503082, -0.41360870003700256, -0.4153219759464264, 0.3339783549308777, -0.06422176212072372, 0.5581386685371399, 0.7241959571838379, -0.5295084714889526, -0.3663492500782013, 0.6205906271934509, -0.21571272611618042, -0.9231788516044617, -0.20706433057785034, 0.09975714981555939, -0.6690127849578857, -0.21516411006450653, 0.05499868094921112, 0.2556421160697937, -0.578430712223053, 0.47120165824890137, 0.750697910785675, -0.44834795594215393, -0.14385643601417542, 0.20964711904525757, 0.28141987323760986, 0.3518249988555908, 0.8222947716712952, -0.6965607404708862, 0.1397603154182434, -0.15308427810668945, 0.730867862701416, -0.369754821062088, 0.475900799036026, -0.3880079984664917, -0.6878326535224915, -0.021253492683172226, 0.36732783913612366, -0.29854702949523926, -0.5421000719070435, -0.9804671406745911, -0.045152995735406876, 0.3687712550163269, -0.41069695353507996, -0.39303845167160034, 1.0750362873077393, -0.21900424361228943, 0.6757612824440002, -0.2899883985519409, 0.7370986342430115, -0.04811660200357437, -0.019103122875094414, 0.0509515255689621, 0.25027522444725037, 0.49100345373153687, 0.3818809986114502, -0.46790629625320435, 0.05468342453241348, 1.375058650970459, 0.7693267464637756, 0.4487750232219696, -0.5042144656181335, -0.38211098313331604, 0.5662165880203247, -0.21587993204593658, -0.6724657416343689, 1.1117628812789917, 0.36231911182403564, -0.057226672768592834, -0.39381882548332214, -0.11140641570091248, -0.10799939930438995, 0.7427581548690796, -0.21828770637512207, -0.7892013192176819, 0.3800292909145355, -0.8832770586013794, 0.7364353537559509, -0.6624062657356262, 0.40841931104660034, -0.5719007849693298, -0.5763124227523804, -0.07092953473329544, -0.9569072127342224, -0.07113119959831238, 0.37933748960494995, -1.160759449005127, 0.2727302610874176, -0.24261374771595, -0.1362796276807785, 0.32182618975639343, 0.6451246738433838, -0.6415205597877502, 0.6749938130378723, 0.6559889912605286, 0.18643850088119507, 0.28177180886268616, -0.03853563219308853, -0.3078520596027374, -0.3476780652999878, -0.474668949842453, 0.21946270763874054, -0.010880045592784882, 0.629514753818512, 0.8448543548583984, 0.2897517681121826, -0.4592444896697998, 0.9703199863433838, 0.22512751817703247, -0.3407837152481079, 0.6747599244117737, 1.0656569004058838, -0.9076711535453796, 0.6982980966567993, -0.007049186155200005, 0.7443158030509949, -0.09907282888889313, 0.24898487329483032, 0.33563148975372314, -0.7535685300827026, 0.7139917016029358, 0.638483464717865, -0.00034964666701853275, -0.11277861893177032, 0.23708055913448334, 0.38661807775497437, 0.6669796705245972, -0.00974184274673462, -0.9677122831344604, 1.261743426322937, 0.03189241513609886, 0.4815417528152466, 0.045632507652044296, 0.12725217640399933, -0.24411235749721527, 0.5711568593978882, 0.3334047496318817, 0.1813162863254547, -1.2420654296875, 0.5815869569778442, 0.24265776574611664, 0.31515178084373474, 0.03328101709485054, -1.042838454246521, -0.13685739040374756, 0.27761438488960266, -0.5190524458885193, -0.6533229947090149, -0.2747694253921509, -0.260170578956604, -0.8680964708328247, 0.020365474745631218, 0.6814444661140442, -0.48199784755706787, -0.7115607261657715, -0.30878129601478577, -0.49895521998405457, -0.23205094039440155, -0.4100504219532013, -0.017017288133502007, -0.15489283204078674, -0.4231027364730835, 1.4212013483047485, 0.3057853877544403, -0.5818085670471191, 0.5769729614257812, 0.24247191846370697, 0.2966882586479187, -0.006048905663192272, 0.5531772375106812, -0.2970265746116638, 0.2866307497024536, -0.425516277551651, 0.24329295754432678, 0.4882645606994629, -1.0072991847991943, 0.19575725495815277, 0.07133523374795914, 0.5769302845001221, 0.292764812707901, -0.03723803162574768, 0.2544121742248535, -0.23747551441192627, -0.5512214303016663, 0.8115454912185669, 0.46347811818122864, 0.161454439163208, 0.5866999626159668, -0.4607306718826294, 0.33045703172683716, 0.23075278103351593, -0.3226912319660187, 0.6370996832847595, -0.913506031036377, -0.633010745048523, -0.16092327237129211, -0.1210961639881134, 0.8005756735801697, -0.19229647517204285, 0.3282216489315033, 0.3305147588253021, -0.06966111809015274, 0.4324547350406647, -0.4714372456073761, -0.3231252133846283, 0.11117406189441681, 0.5580083727836609, -0.8845828175544739, -0.013315497897565365, 0.6806597709655762, 0.11847629398107529, -1.0929995775222778, 0.5807012319564819, -1.384283185005188, -0.5048208236694336, -0.35205361247062683, -0.498020738363266, 0.5513057708740234, 0.04424638673663139, -0.04555126652121544, -0.1810639500617981, -0.23890000581741333, 0.009027624502778053, 0.6080694198608398, -0.19486601650714874, -0.21461838483810425, -0.30166056752204895, 0.9901906847953796, 0.08532551676034927, 0.1614566296339035, 0.4978683888912201, -0.49409741163253784, -0.37706831097602844, 0.7167897820472717, -0.3491706848144531, 0.9281070828437805, 0.14130108058452606, 0.5929178595542908, 0.2816203534603119, 0.17992232739925385, 0.16551944613456726, -0.4632875621318817, -1.0314936637878418, -0.6575490236282349, -0.11782239377498627, 0.3646630048751831, 0.05015219375491142, -0.595786452293396, -0.6476333141326904, -0.23476046323776245, -0.6598962545394897, 0.13232217729091644, 0.7159092426300049, -0.498545378446579, 0.6483978033065796, -0.3080446422100067, -0.7675653100013733, 0.16626891493797302, -0.15162992477416992, -0.4835353493690491, 0.5501314997673035, 0.24036411941051483, 0.42601466178894043, -1.0596965551376343, -0.6449658274650574, -0.21134774386882782, 0.3553209900856018, 0.3363017737865448, -0.28019484877586365, 0.4199233949184418, -0.6619493365287781, 0.6676101684570312, -0.7674099802970886, -0.5940149426460266, 0.0844242125749588, -0.5905059576034546, 0.21183273196220398, -0.6165611743927002, -0.34743547439575195, -0.6188583374023438, 0.5490870475769043, 0.8192581534385681, 0.45756271481513977, 0.7333266139030457, 0.7076359391212463, -0.6482366919517517, -0.09445411711931229, 0.4571588635444641, -0.6999494433403015, 0.6630938649177551, -0.5096173882484436, -0.025442974641919136, 0.46291154623031616, -0.027191635221242905, 0.12718477845191956, -0.3828132748603821, 0.3305995464324951, -0.16583485901355743, 0.4582115411758423, -0.077229805290699, -0.11815657466650009, 0.3973110616207123, 0.46819007396698, -0.2475084662437439, -1.0602360963821411, 0.1276916265487671, 0.8411701917648315, 0.9072920083999634, 0.015609563328325748, -0.7766757011413574, -0.7060099840164185, -1.2515370845794678, 0.6597213745117188, 0.43700066208839417, 0.5049726963043213, -1.1015504598617554, -0.17563846707344055, -0.10824298113584518, -0.48423704504966736, 0.17381428182125092, 0.7775736451148987, -0.24507373571395874, 0.08935321122407913, -0.7592086791992188, -0.1910766214132309, 0.1714424043893814, 0.24956011772155762, 0.12078119814395905, 0.2307594269514084, 0.5084593296051025, -0.22415174543857574, 0.8482769131660461, 0.019010866060853004, -0.558991014957428, -0.07249193638563156, -0.41843181848526, 1.0464863777160645, -0.42367422580718994, -0.460244745016098, 0.3056489825248718, 0.29647591710090637, -0.6771180629730225, 1.0413484573364258, -0.5012380480766296, 0.49415653944015503, 0.6060906052589417, -0.01843838393688202, -0.7525872588157654, 0.5742330551147461, -0.01458309218287468, -0.2819252014160156, 0.9047854542732239, 0.3118365705013275, 0.10466479510068893, 0.7613532543182373, 0.4601587653160095, 0.27053356170654297, 0.3464745581150055, 0.6373633742332458, -0.5256457328796387, 0.4516274631023407, -0.3834243714809418, -0.3810998499393463, -0.143974170088768, -0.5484159588813782, 0.9611272811889648, -0.301239013671875, 0.23668132722377777, 0.15307113528251648, -0.5993404984474182, -0.7923279404640198, -0.9604918956756592, -1.015533685684204, 0.5984789729118347, -0.2842724323272705, 0.17399415373802185, 0.0036344316322356462, -0.2794305384159088, -0.6355270743370056, 0.0570717491209507, 0.12746737897396088, -0.7573444247245789, -0.6678884029388428, 0.3830987513065338, -0.06270451098680496, 0.08600705116987228, -0.17920757830142975, 0.3710862994194031, 0.19081176817417145, -0.6819549798965454, -1.290112018585205, -0.921723484992981, -0.09474210441112518, 0.5149408578872681, 0.1849389523267746, -0.044606246054172516, 0.55645352602005, 0.5173214673995972, -0.03363248333334923, -0.5933830142021179, 0.014026285149157047, -0.5596537590026855, -0.7179105877876282, 0.8763025999069214, 0.3049567639827728, -1.0473906993865967, -0.7923159599304199, 0.5325663685798645, 0.30420181155204773, 0.1991058737039566, -0.07296419143676758, -0.866263747215271, 0.1278611719608307, -0.9642534255981445, 0.6135950088500977, -0.22406503558158875, -0.13166247308254242, -0.3756328523159027, -0.1090531125664711, -0.10061657428741455, 0.3207526206970215, 0.3563900589942932, 0.264583557844162, -0.20398418605327606, -0.9123222231864929, 0.9387248754501343, -0.06647466868162155, 0.40414899587631226, -0.419332891702652, -0.08250797539949417, -0.5693631172180176, 1.8315297365188599, -0.5278918743133545, 0.0049459682777523994, 0.41559648513793945, 0.3409196436405182, -0.5884552597999573, 0.8653640151023865, 0.5456030368804932, -1.1588900089263916, -0.641106903553009, -0.13378162682056427, 0.2255917191505432, 0.14522027969360352, -0.4905598759651184, 0.34505635499954224, -0.697807252407074, 0.7190126776695251, 0.2733485698699951, -0.1410420835018158, -0.026048054918646812, -0.7031700015068054, 0.6866428256034851, -0.6347947120666504, -0.14334480464458466, 0.646849513053894, 0.09124645590782166, 0.924235999584198, -0.1975456178188324, -1.2552520036697388, 0.12603159248828888, -0.5513855814933777, -1.032317042350769, 0.21650300920009613, 0.012246018275618553, -0.48891112208366394, -0.5531772375106812, -0.3076837956905365, 0.29179850220680237, -0.9361030459403992, 0.17834219336509705, 0.7644926905632019, -0.056131307035684586, -0.06072666496038437, -0.29319053888320923, 0.11354821175336838, -0.11075710505247116, 0.14112664759159088, -0.0756341964006424, -0.49351680278778076, -0.1173800528049469, -1.067525863647461, -0.2170487493276596, -0.8348153233528137, -0.6753200888633728, -0.26362738013267517, 0.12733496725559235, -0.24879440665245056, 0.5338603854179382, -0.27715882658958435, -0.656203031539917, -0.9475204944610596, 0.6500067114830017, 0.41207200288772583, -0.2739078998565674, 0.7538747191429138, 0.40733200311660767, -0.3230263888835907, -0.48037558794021606, 0.5632637143135071, -0.8331742286682129, -0.41169705986976624, 1.1226441860198975, -0.5776700377464294, -0.0433511920273304, 1.1487977504730225, 0.4079549014568329, -0.843020498752594, -0.40518951416015625, -0.914259672164917, -0.3752288818359375, 0.07360862195491791, -0.5767517685890198, -0.29661786556243896, -0.382234662771225, -0.3082120716571808, 0.028936846181750298, 0.7460915446281433, 0.03678862378001213, 0.4779578447341919, 0.2644553780555725, -0.015545050613582134, -0.6079842448234558, 0.08288028836250305, 1.1937435865402222, 0.2750660181045532, -0.675083339214325, -0.5406964421272278, -0.14127406477928162, -0.17303909361362457, -0.8430852293968201, 1.0509333610534668, -0.7604820728302002, 0.4321939945220947, 0.6339367628097534, 0.2852504849433899, 0.8314948081970215, -0.15556101500988007, -0.1191767007112503, 0.2718955874443054, -0.6886927485466003, -1.0266019105911255, -0.5365958213806152, 0.05970315635204315, 0.6010370254516602, -0.08622201532125473, -0.24689246714115143, -0.36812347173690796, 0.09383776038885117, 0.4531451165676117, 0.016962887719273567, 0.12629294395446777, -0.9673362970352173, -1.21232271194458, -0.8314915299415588, -0.6936408281326294, -0.20315079391002655, -0.37562593817710876, 0.33598262071609497, -0.229291170835495, 0.3269922733306885, -0.3845551609992981, -0.29762229323387146, -0.4031440019607544, 1.3514810800552368, -0.3652094304561615, -0.6837987899780273, -0.6699317097663879, 0.168696328997612, -0.09169086813926697, -1.118343710899353, -0.09794200956821442, 0.16108450293540955, 0.009873991832137108, 0.6019680500030518, 0.18579865992069244, 0.6332216262817383, -0.33674052357673645, -0.5869784355163574, 0.6063414216041565, -0.036461591720581055, -0.9727245569229126, 0.2458856850862503, -0.5085398554801941, 0.7087492942810059, -0.1338139772415161, 0.2678775489330292, -0.45967745780944824, -0.32929131388664246, -1.4049171209335327, 0.17091061174869537, -0.04917976260185242, 0.06356102228164673, -0.0016632993938401341, -0.29068848490715027, 0.08857136964797974, 0.025730594992637634, -0.44345083832740784, 0.2933451533317566, 0.04319959506392479, 0.6518611311912537, -0.4145660698413849, -0.47458624839782715, 0.09578438103199005, 0.38401806354522705, -0.15600845217704773, 0.23968306183815002, -0.31804409623146057, -0.036971140652894974, -0.01973840408027172, -0.20539215207099915, 0.7107259631156921, -0.5274277925491333, 0.10872342437505722, -0.278695672750473, -0.3878546953201294, 0.1343216449022293, 0.1282341629266739, -0.5368266105651855, -0.30717939138412476, 0.4288770258426666, 0.16960495710372925, 0.8203166127204895, -0.43278709053993225, 0.46604350209236145, 0.30444827675819397, -0.02974134124815464, 0.2022237628698349, -0.46130043268203735, -0.7059565186500549, 1.154179334640503, -1.2664525508880615, -0.6571041941642761, -0.15200036764144897, 0.604766845703125, -0.5912632346153259, 0.04800375923514366, -0.5725071430206299, 0.07385259866714478, 0.7045563459396362, 0.4453131854534149, 1.0514017343521118, -0.39403221011161804, -0.14075733721256256, 0.39056649804115295, -0.22442248463630676, -0.46982353925704956, -1.0832973718643188, 0.49073830246925354, -0.8652786612510681, -0.42524027824401855, -0.18516294658184052, -0.32172340154647827, -0.06963878870010376, -0.12386519461870193, -0.21491920948028564, -0.2747350037097931, -0.24590666592121124, -0.4632647633552551, -0.4032593071460724, -0.5473190546035767, -0.35575491189956665, 0.512492835521698, 0.38011276721954346, -0.09352957457304001, -0.1462256908416748, -0.44158926606178284, 0.7766920924186707, -0.4593469798564911, -0.17987394332885742, 0.7471373677253723, 0.3760048449039459, -0.34991657733917236, 0.2760539948940277, 0.4047655761241913, 0.08322663605213165, 0.2922697365283966, -0.10817558318376541, 0.9300078749656677, 0.7869468927383423, -0.17290322482585907, 0.6249363422393799, -0.07294980436563492, 0.12758077681064606, 0.3008733093738556, 0.6313307881355286, 0.3015827238559723, -0.1930745542049408, -0.507070779800415, 0.17736384272575378, -0.31312882900238037, 0.11612804979085922, 0.02599831484258175, -0.20497505366802216, -0.10420457273721695, 0.5972450375556946, -0.06272768974304199, -0.5251196622848511, -0.6088483929634094, -0.2736099064350128, 0.5623226761817932, -0.8331633806228638, -0.23168276250362396, -0.42324772477149963, 0.39841464161872864, 0.7452545166015625, 0.14060911536216736, -0.49974942207336426, 0.47688618302345276, 0.06508855521678925, -0.3098057806491852, -0.3754090368747711, 0.37409791350364685, -0.022217482328414917, 0.8022124767303467, 0.3725765347480774, 0.32929280400276184, 0.9506250023841858, 0.9093633890151978, -0.1906316578388214, -0.8304064273834229, 0.17091834545135498, 0.04702352359890938, -0.8503238558769226, 0.08185123652219772, 0.18425194919109344, -0.18594162166118622, -0.17561407387256622, 0.1835780292749405, -0.03576751798391342, -0.9281694293022156, 0.18231479823589325, -0.0896618589758873, -0.4261877238750458, -0.2052755355834961, 0.40680626034736633, 0.29598739743232727, 0.5847073197364807, -0.08529224246740341, 0.8548923134803772, -0.1887136548757553, 0.9328540563583374, 1.2885181903839111, 0.6438786387443542, -0.06010804697871208, 0.39464059472084045, -0.3068808913230896, 0.29720333218574524, 0.4223311245441437, -0.2077779322862625, 0.6958527565002441, 0.46236875653266907, 0.48777687549591064, -0.3631593585014343, -0.029052533209323883, -0.27371206879615784, 0.11063386499881744, 0.2742396295070648, 0.9228948354721069, 0.5161516666412354, -0.17292773723602295, 0.7924034595489502, 0.2053985744714737, -0.3571193218231201, -0.2388211339712143, 0.13537169992923737, -1.0995872020721436, -0.09446007013320923, -0.7318582534790039, 0.48780131340026855, 0.16756093502044678, -0.5031513571739197, -0.706966757774353, -0.3394644558429718, -0.22887112200260162, -0.5758951902389526, 0.33491241931915283, -1.1415746212005615, 0.15564779937267303, 0.6637574434280396, 0.23951850831508636, -0.22760115563869476, -0.606661319732666, -0.1333160549402237, -0.36480751633644104, 0.8390448093414307, -0.1763722151517868, 0.6174094080924988, 0.47994622588157654, 0.20456352829933167, -1.1471887826919556, 0.5320221781730652, 0.6960229277610779, -0.5782783031463623, -0.10639926791191101, 0.023302672430872917, -0.7173047065734863, 0.0016099684871733189, -0.10173182189464569, 0.3283748924732208, 1.1548607349395752, 0.1875859498977661, -0.39850446581840515, -0.2684459090232849, 0.07002093642950058, -0.21657030284404755, 0.05991404131054878, -1.067702054977417, 0.027229201048612595, 0.2967156171798706, -0.6526992917060852, 0.292464941740036, -1.071311354637146, 3.9646012783050537, 1.1838971376419067, 0.4872026741504669, -0.20881164073944092, 0.6418101787567139, 0.5882232189178467, 0.2223571091890335, -0.45986804366111755, 0.3469450771808624, -0.1476331204175949, -0.09331098943948746, 0.3370206356048584, -0.024804728105664253, -0.2953355014324188, -0.10829875618219376, 0.46431320905685425, -0.1638280600309372, -0.3572077751159668, 0.38571974635124207, -0.10567676275968552, -0.8696350455284119, -0.2532189190387726, -0.45353588461875916, -0.6371550559997559, 0.510092556476593, -0.08330750465393066, 0.32400280237197876, -0.7084419131278992, -0.9437019228935242, -0.24514631927013397, -0.18634524941444397, -0.45797285437583923, 0.10154677927494049, -0.47225815057754517, -1.3861327171325684, 0.5578964948654175, 0.1379867047071457, -0.3535504937171936, 0.5500524044036865, -0.22919407486915588, 0.27941158413887024, 0.3325728476047516, 0.40721309185028076, -0.1976054459810257, -0.17020240426063538, 0.10938475281000137, 0.7548326253890991, 0.8187276721000671, 0.7629419565200806, -1.0579419136047363, -0.08328761905431747, 0.7498767971992493, 0.8871793746948242, -0.684177041053772, -1.0776046514511108, -0.17534472048282623, 0.2529957592487335, -0.2741784155368805, 0.9459552764892578, -0.3743111491203308, 0.31554368138313293, -0.7635075449943542, -0.24707119166851044, 0.22643958032131195, 0.4111274778842926, -0.35265931487083435, 0.3768256604671478, 0.08433287590742111, 0.34578579664230347, -0.2502687871456146, -0.8520700931549072, 0.03819885104894638, -0.5442312359809875, -0.28605449199676514, 0.24542737007141113, 0.49538496136665344, 0.23395711183547974, 0.6299916505813599, 0.07779726386070251, 0.7076684236526489, -0.8659186959266663, -0.3608040511608124, 0.12306346744298935, -0.18885022401809692, 0.6344968676567078, 0.7869357466697693, -0.32498404383659363, -0.11056812107563019, -0.7183593511581421, 0.7257818579673767, -0.22298847138881683, 0.8029131293296814, -0.1796814203262329, 0.201895609498024, -0.7700783014297485 ]
Self-Consistence of Semi-Classical Gravity
Simon argued that the semi-classical theory of gravity, unless with some of its solutions excluded, is unacceptable for reasons of both self-consistency and experiment, and that it has to be replaced by a constrained semi-classical theory. We examined whether the evidence is conclusive.
Wai-Mo Suen
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210018
gr-qc/9210019
[ 0.4554082453250885, -0.13176703453063965, 0.09685693681240082, 0.16492553055286407, 0.033337920904159546, -0.33396202325820923, -0.27289173007011414, -0.5073586702346802, -1.1557836532592773, 1.3624109029769897, 0.6158009767532349, 0.1456238478422165, -0.10612557828426361, -0.3064371645450592, -0.16964690387248993, 0.7204172611236572, -0.22151239216327667, -0.5881507992744446, -1.1582818031311035, 0.6748062372207642, 0.5271021723747253, 0.05934520438313484, -1.2469351291656494, -0.4024077355861664, -0.21654775738716125, 0.5572395324707031, 0.8751896023750305, 0.36581501364707947, 0.9664393067359924, 0.9163460731506348, 0.8856568336486816, -0.18933768570423126, -0.019259130582213402, -0.46853068470954895, -0.31712964177131653, 0.05339471623301506, 0.010331454686820507, -0.6375746726989746, 1.1463778018951416, 0.16098342835903168, 0.8739891648292542, -0.20475220680236816, 0.7538155913352966, -0.059497665613889694, -0.4255814850330353, -0.4302977919578552, 0.16602110862731934, 0.11944551765918732, 0.00950547680258751, -1.018675446510315, -0.007594720460474491, -0.06838958710432053, 0.3738068640232086, -0.494396448135376, -0.39654725790023804, -0.47213947772979736, 0.4256131947040558, 0.5349375009536743, -0.2330547422170639, 0.43361127376556396, 0.6673048138618469, -0.4119526743888855, 0.3120841085910797, -1.0099607706069946, -0.03807932883501053, 1.2041778564453125, -0.2801486551761627, 0.8683619499206543, -0.0008895641658455133, -0.691053569316864, 0.1381259262561798, -0.9097217321395874, -0.47895413637161255, 0.5496101379394531, -0.7052356600761414, 0.6805077195167542, -0.35282841324806213, -0.1324729472398758, -0.49057695269584656, 0.3800122141838074, -0.19271686673164368, -0.7431805729866028, -0.32114043831825256, 0.38693585991859436, -0.8191475868225098, -0.17353381216526031, -0.25887179374694824, -0.26081570982933044, 0.4507429897785187, 0.2246563732624054, 0.45623546838760376, 0.9535432457923889, 0.22122056782245636, -0.931662380695343, 0.4702707827091217, 0.964387059211731, -0.5193997621536255, 0.3418017625808716, -0.15621960163116455, 0.25511810183525085, -0.42528340220451355, 0.340254008769989, 0.10057269036769867, 0.6457444429397583, -0.8705282807350159, 0.9870721101760864, -0.05557350814342499, -0.05461391434073448, -0.721148669719696, -0.8995822668075562, 0.36679112911224365, -0.14211949706077576, 0.24942249059677124, 0.4093959927558899, 0.0747198760509491, 0.8135836720466614, -0.07609295845031738, -0.30460649728775024, -0.3034382462501526, -0.19234441220760345, 0.24137096107006073, -0.09295877814292908, 0.9782128930091858, 0.853432834148407, 0.13929881155490875, -0.6449936628341675, -0.43351709842681885, -0.07303141802549362, -0.4227547347545624, 0.05006144568324089, 0.5210754871368408, -0.3439449071884155, 0.2543177604675293, -0.06097278743982315, -0.21766431629657745, 0.8937870264053345, -0.26801538467407227, -0.4972864091396332, 0.4150606691837311, -0.6169787049293518, 0.29455921053886414, -1.1343538761138916, 0.14737264811992645, 0.9156854152679443, -0.5056965351104736, 0.45023098587989807, -0.23386628925800323, 0.9936348795890808, -0.3953188359737396, 0.09215009957551956, -0.04971032962203026, -0.29036399722099304, -0.7965453267097473, 0.20824456214904785, -0.44314008951187134, 0.3787412941455841, -0.5901886820793152, 0.2081485539674759, -0.5033795833587646, -0.19988970458507538, -0.008970217779278755, -0.4757760763168335, -0.11978062987327576, 1.2095935344696045, -0.19774925708770752, 0.21998751163482666, -1.12729811668396, -0.8582913875579834, 0.08036161959171295, -0.32952532172203064, 0.007008499000221491, -0.32023972272872925, 0.062264613807201385, 0.3276471197605133, 0.9205126762390137, 0.9960891008377075, 0.2830219268798828, -0.23472696542739868, -0.34017661213874817, -0.20028653740882874, -0.5909801721572876, -0.36439287662506104, 0.5160617828369141, -0.041796691715717316, -0.5479840040206909, -0.8744354844093323, -0.4365842044353485, 0.05091016739606857, -0.543501079082489, 0.1964288353919983, -0.12975576519966125, 0.05074835196137428, -1.0298340320587158, 0.853026807308197, -0.24361036717891693, 0.2955579161643982, -1.149734377861023, 0.117373026907444, -0.31648412346839905, -0.7741716504096985, 0.16435933113098145, -0.4634469449520111, -0.8482242822647095, -0.21267169713974, -1.471280813217163, 0.20859628915786743, 0.7876167297363281, 0.7067883610725403, -0.29134905338287354, -0.08925777673721313, -0.08020252734422684, -0.2906084358692169, 0.46850094199180603, -0.796829342842102, 0.1537916511297226, -0.4078682065010071, -0.11201849579811096, 0.5192737579345703, 0.19542230665683746, 0.22721776366233826, 0.5444547533988953, 0.2576487064361572, 0.3394891321659088, 0.5112253427505493, 0.14111414551734924, -0.6655903458595276, 0.06197505444288254, 0.5661710500717163, 0.04266579821705818, -0.20856350660324097, -0.07268188893795013, 0.19039006531238556, -0.40658801794052124, 0.2862267792224884, 0.010535985231399536, 0.47319895029067993, 0.5344588756561279, 0.4114130437374115, 0.2785640358924866, -0.09653589129447937, 0.39550599455833435, 0.06787069141864777, 0.9072906970977783, -0.1444168984889984, 0.03924896940588951, 0.366674542427063, 0.1526855081319809, 0.26082322001457214, -0.6889271140098572, 0.9733030200004578, -0.6405385732650757, 0.5935531854629517, 0.40388935804367065, -0.11488927900791168, -0.48363953828811646, 0.031895317137241364, 0.06768222153186798, 0.027622541412711143, -0.24916552007198334, -0.5653202533721924, -0.023411590605974197, 0.8240135312080383, -0.835051953792572, -0.4723398983478546, -0.349926233291626, 0.43247926235198975, -0.45699456334114075, 0.0811765044927597, 0.4279225170612335, -0.3716089725494385, -0.704450786113739, -0.06863497942686081, -0.8099802732467651, 0.015515429899096489, -0.6407001614570618, -0.7598483562469482, 0.866478681564331, -0.5572062730789185, 0.7963407039642334, -0.37250760197639465, 0.03357415646314621, 0.2188444882631302, 0.23085914552211761, 0.23905278742313385, -0.3993643820285797, -0.1443873643875122, -0.5929476022720337, 0.28419506549835205, -0.8651628494262695, -0.18666476011276245, -0.14068429172039032, -0.4688279926776886, 0.7021248936653137, -0.019242767244577408, -0.44045960903167725, -0.558079719543457, -0.27224481105804443, 0.5071437954902649, -0.45076116919517517, -0.4213143289089203, 0.6952335834503174, 0.43302664160728455, 0.3146021068096161, 0.02607628144323826, -1.2258628606796265, 0.9791025519371033, 0.17514874041080475, -0.7714181542396545, 0.9236202239990234, 0.012106198817491531, -0.8523489236831665, 0.3260675072669983, 0.3164660334587097, 0.4254862070083618, -0.08058208972215652, 0.8992423415184021, 0.686078667640686, -0.39392462372779846, 0.3094017803668976, -0.37158870697021484, -0.4849115312099457, -0.11259922385215759, 0.3209794759750366, -0.7256372570991516, 0.3154313862323761, 0.6366850137710571, 0.3383537232875824, -0.09594248980283737, 0.6287955641746521, -0.697881281375885, -0.4802356958389282, -0.11645805835723877, -0.00041500735096633434, 0.4622842073440552, 0.4657396376132965, -0.5015373229980469, -0.5246320366859436, -0.12258947640657425, 0.698462963104248, 0.7018924355506897, 0.9779366254806519, -0.606865644454956, 0.6551480293273926, -0.013177506625652313, 0.6731576323509216, -0.02740488201379776, 0.22544501721858978, -0.1234230175614357, -0.5981841683387756, 0.3539070785045624, -0.4531744122505188, -0.13027791678905487, -0.31843146681785583, 0.03494255989789963, 0.01221061684191227, 0.1125417947769165, -0.5863168835639954, -0.5740565061569214, -1.2128833532333374, -0.13308298587799072, 0.35922718048095703, 0.6972321271896362, 0.30481937527656555, -0.526949942111969, -0.3476407527923584, 0.20532304048538208, 0.28412795066833496, -0.07230640202760696, 0.31658226251602173, -1.0359702110290527, 0.4464593529701233, -0.5951430201530457, -0.18577255308628082, 0.04961288347840309, -0.4554769694805145, 0.7614638209342957, 0.49225765466690063, 0.8160330653190613, 0.20290865004062653, -0.26063430309295654, -0.7495731711387634, -0.3997587561607361, 0.6160854697227478, 0.5118377804756165, 0.6789605617523193, -0.29679378867149353, 0.3444240093231201, 0.11319424211978912, 0.11545471101999283, -0.6954506635665894, -0.6112696528434753, -0.41784414649009705, 0.566300630569458, -0.5117097496986389, -0.3972569704055786, -0.01373362448066473, 0.2925144135951996, 0.15561707317829132, -0.03409677371382713, -0.1252792924642563, -0.28859564661979675, 0.06320483237504959, 0.8008283376693726, 0.6443910002708435, 0.008595315739512444, 0.4704912304878235, -0.9750147461891174, 0.8939144611358643, 0.22694599628448486, 0.8287305235862732, -0.16788814961910248, -0.7286412119865417, 0.10833805054426193, -0.2597973346710205, 0.42219460010528564, 0.036474257707595825, -0.24312624335289001, 0.2890400290489197, 0.5788684487342834, 0.030459873378276825, -0.020741311833262444, 0.3317798674106598, 0.2593556046485901, 0.44559240341186523, 0.18411056697368622, -0.9388664364814758, -0.45296990871429443, -0.37171363830566406, 0.6599262952804565, 0.02161296084523201, -0.4027850925922394, -0.8904125690460205, -0.8720918297767639, 0.3672938346862793, 0.15411242842674255, 0.5791116952896118, 0.7623161673545837, 0.6485498547554016, 0.5678484439849854, -0.40105393528938293, -0.26934340596199036, 1.0237287282943726, -0.2314724624156952, -0.7339165210723877, 0.22324392199516296, 0.1358349472284317, -0.20152625441551208, 0.4650873839855194, -0.2743512988090515, -0.6521915793418884, 0.4838387668132782, -0.38071489334106445, 0.6579232811927795, -0.43437227606773376, -0.41228845715522766, -0.008501945063471794, -0.02202044054865837, -0.5911056399345398, -0.05994695425033569, 0.3981229364871979, -0.24389278888702393, -0.4036974310874939, -0.03545588627457619, -0.6003751158714294, 0.09199602901935577, 0.24747414886951447, -0.4421965181827545, 0.08793769031763077, 0.7255077362060547, 0.4766441881656647, 0.33463025093078613, 0.3288939893245697, -0.5100235939025879, 0.23469898104667664, 0.5809748768806458, -0.6138755679130554, -0.6384109854698181, 0.06576675176620483, -0.10059008002281189, -0.6506955027580261, -0.6611210107803345, -0.5247657299041748, -0.6938481330871582, 1.108802318572998, 0.30641958117485046, -1.2506732940673828, -0.358593225479126, -1.0210460424423218, -0.45782336592674255, -0.17812874913215637, 0.08692394942045212, 0.2205534726381302, 0.10563026368618011, -0.3599745035171509, -0.08661756664514542, -0.5671522617340088, -0.2904955744743347, -0.5114450454711914, -0.2608988285064697, 0.34778615832328796, -0.12434655427932739, 0.9392661452293396, -0.5189034938812256, 0.7349504232406616, -0.05663645267486572, -0.2859914004802704, -0.4380321204662323, -0.4584762752056122, 0.46675875782966614, -0.039393648505210876, 0.13355545699596405, 0.13800956308841705, 0.7515500783920288, -0.1326730102300644, 0.38023635745048523, 0.2616516649723053, -0.382705420255661, -0.1625072956085205, 0.3752032518386841, 0.5895377993583679, 0.2974656820297241, -0.8709625005722046, -0.4486420750617981, 0.32115301489830017, -0.5384359955787659, -0.08126500993967056, 0.29977115988731384, -1.0836422443389893, -0.2647690773010254, -0.9466360807418823, 0.5258069634437561, -1.1753268241882324, -0.6102023720741272, -0.17511878907680511, -1.0889078378677368, 0.3331291377544403, -0.31395456194877625, 0.4851316511631012, -0.30312609672546387, -0.7903443574905396, -0.2310878485441208, -0.17539827525615692, -0.6880722641944885, -0.14453616738319397, -0.5060362815856934, -0.08414552360773087, -0.34722721576690674, 1.0782192945480347, -0.4293438494205475, 0.10832583904266357, 0.12462220340967178, 0.160176619887352, -0.33258137106895447, 0.33938270807266235, 0.5362501740455627, -0.5334107875823975, -0.27051427960395813, 0.30322399735450745, 0.13911131024360657, 0.33028796315193176, 0.014595246873795986, 0.34648385643959045, -0.6838738918304443, 0.8878017663955688, -0.4646342396736145, -0.6346815824508667, -0.1308644860982895, 0.09476878494024277, 0.2386476844549179, -0.2995833456516266, -0.0017155144596472383, 0.3747449219226837, 0.21968969702720642, 0.41187161207199097, -0.34205958247184753, -0.37652239203453064, -0.23165686428546906, -0.806928277015686, -0.33139681816101074, 0.39091888070106506, 0.4241631329059601, 0.04403425753116608, -0.5690876245498657, -0.38223332166671753, 0.06711222976446152, -0.35269954800605774, 0.6983312964439392, 1.09147310256958, 0.12119033187627792, 0.09048149734735489, -0.65349280834198, 0.2382892370223999, -0.9557746648788452, 0.0902772769331932, 0.08632823824882507, 0.3628193438053131, 0.39380112290382385, -0.4113008379936218, -0.3134613633155823, -0.3501882553100586, -0.5297847986221313, 0.45073238015174866, 0.12893839180469513, -0.1750422567129135, 0.7338794469833374, 0.19286945462226868, -0.1403130292892456, -0.18873760104179382, 0.29667583107948303, 0.6952580809593201, 0.1118403822183609, 0.3426574766635895, -0.14882634580135345, 0.5606306195259094, -0.20582276582717896, 0.12375856190919876, -0.55494624376297, -0.589394211769104, 1.0031661987304688, -0.4729471802711487, 0.13362914323806763, 0.8481535911560059, 0.11949734389781952, -0.34591734409332275, -0.3493678569793701, -0.9197161793708801, -0.23433880507946014, -0.20165449380874634, -0.4978245794773102, 0.07927766442298889, -0.3382434546947479, 0.2298353910446167, -0.22936341166496277, 0.5026825070381165, 0.4113588333129883, 0.5055692195892334, -0.061865851283073425, 0.10754058510065079, -0.22968041896820068, -0.09061798453330994, 0.987665593624115, -0.1421532928943634, -0.5058078169822693, -0.1563906967639923, -0.235927551984787, -0.03005826659500599, -0.3672729432582855, 0.6492016315460205, -0.898444414138794, 0.009160399436950684, 0.025654001161456108, 0.2209755927324295, 0.03317636996507645, 1.231510043144226, -0.48736655712127686, -0.011829311959445477, 0.09076941013336182, -0.4889319837093353, -0.1458195149898529, 0.12505237758159637, 0.449435293674469, 0.7612777352333069, 0.06456182152032852, -0.1517375409603119, -0.21219919621944427, -0.36604252457618713, 0.0873679518699646, -1.0713474750518799, -0.4323015809059143, -0.9825866222381592, -0.654033899307251, -1.6651036739349365, -0.26139402389526367, 0.6734562516212463, 0.43917039036750793, -0.4093747138977051, 0.5311293005943298, -0.7440105080604553, -0.21247829496860504, 0.0913374200463295, 0.7691782116889954, -0.5067524313926697, -0.056772492825984955, -0.5277391672134399, -0.3055616021156311, -0.2237526774406433, -0.3616160452365875, -0.6336254477500916, -0.030515413731336594, 0.2774967551231384, 0.7643247246742249, -0.9148144721984863, 0.8170436024665833, -0.17449526488780975, -0.8183623552322388, 0.9339953660964966, 0.21249185502529144, -1.1705126762390137, 1.7639883756637573, 0.6059845089912415, 0.41374069452285767, 0.2532215118408203, -0.14429126679897308, -0.47347700595855713, -0.075995534658432, -0.959402322769165, 0.6520917415618896, -0.1172068864107132, 0.4046093821525574, -0.31158646941185, -0.5563125014305115, 0.4252553880214691, -0.5448508858680725, -0.7836710810661316, -0.6157852411270142, 0.08621872961521149, 0.7845423221588135, -0.7434617280960083, 0.24613849818706512, 0.011847476474940777, 0.2266983687877655, 0.6016208529472351, 0.7095611095428467, -0.4052453339099884, -0.07016539573669434, 0.01575816422700882, 0.24652566015720367, -1.0684975385665894, 0.5303981900215149, -0.15926878154277802, -0.19260112941265106, -0.13392390310764313, 0.6247182488441467, -0.057605259120464325, -0.021990962326526642, -0.6164756417274475, -0.1660127192735672, -0.5912104249000549, 0.377735435962677, -1.0948901176452637, -0.0980074554681778, 0.2585459053516388, -0.5256815552711487, 0.284155011177063, -0.543689489364624, -0.8705101609230042, 0.21028085052967072, -0.6813771724700928, -0.16039669513702393, -0.139143705368042, 0.04948042333126068, 0.10625577718019485, 0.5350434184074402, -0.7224291563034058, 0.04902726784348488, 0.6071269512176514, 0.8191716074943542, 0.40417951345443726, -0.5810582637786865, -0.381294310092926, 0.3300073444843292, -0.9590754508972168, -0.28838247060775757, -0.6111889481544495, -0.06379987299442291, -1.224386215209961, -0.92921382188797, -0.5368114113807678, -0.11424099653959274, -0.227629154920578, -0.6585926413536072, -0.49115636944770813, -0.08637643605470657, 0.5606966614723206, -0.5845897197723389, -0.5732095837593079, 0.4414871633052826, -0.23351456224918365, 0.9071083664894104, 0.30934032797813416, -0.2312692403793335, 0.0767471194267273, 0.5343135595321655, 1.0940982103347778, 0.09398173540830612, 0.368592232465744, 0.9615572690963745, -0.23084157705307007, -0.2318238466978073, 0.1674536019563675, 0.29314541816711426, 0.6965879797935486, 0.9209937453269958, -0.6088790893554688, 0.24893270432949066, 0.5437506437301636, 0.27416789531707764, 0.757686972618103, 0.14450058341026306, 0.263297438621521, 0.642378568649292, 0.3852008283138275, 0.2299700230360031, 0.1930292397737503, 0.7392605543136597, 0.0841001495718956, 1.0682487487792969, -0.3339293897151947, -0.1873241662979126, -0.00090887671103701, 0.05286207050085068, 0.32475754618644714, -0.0032007184345275164, -0.2550217807292938, -0.667539656162262, 0.6738802790641785, 0.944347083568573, 0.11076000332832336, -0.35042086243629456, -0.10225676000118256, 0.20463986694812775, 0.1657084971666336, 0.7798947095870972, -0.49838513135910034, 0.8680326342582703, 1.0699197053909302, 0.2610728144645691, -0.45536643266677856, 0.39120689034461975, 0.24920973181724548, 0.4665507972240448, 0.46976083517074585, -0.11845897138118744, 0.6343050003051758, 0.5807792544364929, -0.1613495796918869, -0.3782727122306824, -0.1245424747467041, 0.01494485791772604, -1.1759305000305176, 0.13952375948429108, -0.11918129026889801, -0.4878765642642975, 0.06874126940965652, -0.728692352771759, 0.5948861837387085, -0.29022955894470215, -0.1908160001039505, 0.5321154594421387, -0.47025761008262634, -0.21672098338603973, 0.49411359429359436, 0.093875952064991, 0.42962008714675903, 0.5643993020057678, 0.29343661665916443, -0.21993562579154968, 0.7336739301681519, 1.1969290971755981, 0.05659414455294609, -0.039021238684654236, 0.08251716941595078, 0.4816315174102783, 0.1791698932647705, 0.7144361734390259, -0.20534218847751617, 0.46833327412605286, -0.3487016558647156, -0.38741156458854675, -0.7274514436721802, 0.3954049348831177, -0.3280046582221985, -0.36251387000083923, 0.21243245899677277, 0.38230371475219727, -0.12704801559448242, -0.06653092056512833, 0.9358810782432556, 0.2707562744617462, -0.12025686353445053, -0.6972994804382324, 0.4576362371444702, -0.5328376293182373, -0.17296291887760162, -0.9011817574501038, 0.8362104892730713, -0.4311560392379761, -0.020299891009926796, -0.11104946583509445, -0.16200633347034454, -0.8626527786254883, -0.4295042157173157, -0.24356380105018616, 0.18993334472179413, 0.45938175916671753, 0.7893199324607849, -0.30813056230545044, -0.06240854784846306, -0.22207149863243103, -0.42964598536491394, -0.08562490344047546, 1.084480881690979, 0.022300373762845993, 0.10587447136640549, 0.23972126841545105, 0.44794920086860657, -0.637570321559906, 1.1426233053207397, 0.7256352305412292, -0.7519097924232483, 0.4764944016933441, -0.3620266616344452, 0.8470357656478882, 0.08303190767765045, -0.1708660125732422, -0.24238134920597076, -0.8774479031562805, 0.3591243028640747, 0.6177487373352051, -0.6799867153167725, -0.05439620465040207, -0.5542267560958862, -0.09775299578905106, -0.7821573615074158, 0.700941801071167, 0.1277569681406021, -0.2721465826034546, -0.4932125210762024, -0.44577813148498535, 4.115861415863037, 0.5124509334564209, 0.5981261730194092, 0.4037553071975708, 1.2066612243652344, 0.9252370595932007, -0.01157530676573515, -0.5322455763816833, -0.5346423983573914, -0.727388322353363, -0.25010839104652405, 0.012735445983707905, -0.14463359117507935, -0.0008576728869229555, 0.4954279065132141, 0.8682844638824463, -0.29968953132629395, 0.05505368858575821, 0.14126555621623993, -0.7240275144577026, -0.8101971745491028, -0.06804075837135315, 0.2613411247730255, -0.11277791112661362, 0.22794200479984283, 0.6685501933097839, 0.21747741103172302, -0.2746811509132385, -0.2515944540500641, -0.2872675061225891, -0.5853815674781799, -0.6478844881057739, 0.3881242871284485, -0.3427729904651642, -1.0350795984268188, -0.20354388654232025, -0.13070693612098694, 0.22482693195343018, 0.1313399076461792, 0.2599325180053711, 0.08935810625553131, -0.45245620608329773, 0.2073986977338791, -0.4065912961959839, -0.1271839290857315, 1.1614704132080078, -0.26256608963012695, 0.7029449939727783, 0.6268555521965027, -1.4184596538543701, 0.8054978847503662, -0.03954719379544258, 0.7112237811088562, -0.32707732915878296, -0.7705024480819702, -0.09559212625026703, 0.5185808539390564, 0.5035802721977234, 0.271412193775177, -0.23251891136169434, 0.9110959768295288, -0.27343273162841797, 0.31761759519577026, -0.008163949474692345, 0.3424338400363922, 1.0951921939849854, 0.3702317774295807, 0.17213234305381775, -0.20125141739845276, 0.0818580910563469, -0.7432949542999268, -0.46131014823913574, -0.37845557928085327, -0.13851258158683777, 0.6456971764564514, 0.11143484711647034, -0.14481167495250702, 0.547510027885437, 0.022807588800787926, -0.08907675743103027, -0.3040962219238281, -0.6726676821708679, 0.03466108813881874, 0.6050940752029419, -0.09101542830467224, 0.5956252813339233, 0.21309523284435272, 0.40071627497673035, 0.026754390448331833, -0.1052292138338089, 0.39958876371383667, 0.8375939130783081, -0.36093971133232117, 0.2503783404827118, -0.7989011406898499 ]
Path integration in relativistic quantum mechanics
The simple physics of a free particle reveals important features of the path-integral formulation of relativistic quantum theories. The exact quantum-mechanical propagator is calculated here for a particle described by the simple relativistic action proportional to its proper time. This propagator is nonvanishing outside the light cone, implying that spacelike trajectories must be included in the path integral. The propagator matches the WKB approximation to the corresponding configuration-space path integral far from the light cone; outside the light cone that approximation consists of the contribution from a single spacelike geodesic. This propagator also has the unusual property that its short-time limit does not coincide with the WKB approximation, making the construction of a concrete skeletonized version of the path integral more complicated than in nonrelativistic theory.
Ian H. Redmount and Wai-Mo Suen
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210019
gr-qc/9210020
[ 0.5813202261924744, 0.1287231594324112, 0.3727928400039673, -0.07368388026952744, -0.09866606444120407, 0.037864215672016144, 0.02254612371325493, 0.13997365534305573, -1.0524818897247314, 1.4544132947921753, 1.0388033390045166, -0.21261192858219147, -0.505198061466217, -0.5236785411834717, -0.36491841077804565, 0.644084095954895, -0.24607159197330475, -0.18788880109786987, -1.6108218431472778, 0.39867833256721497, 0.28511813282966614, -0.009466624818742275, -1.6383565664291382, -0.5912277698516846, -0.5032718181610107, 0.7674639225006104, 0.38480061292648315, 0.2798295319080353, 1.2736977338790894, 0.7324227094650269, 0.9379787445068359, -0.26195794343948364, 0.0946124941110611, -0.0055463798344135284, -0.6105459928512573, 0.4182036221027374, -0.2519828677177429, -0.0359187014400959, 0.887215256690979, -0.5897603631019592, 1.0161992311477661, 0.20519712567329407, 0.15095403790473938, 0.14299386739730835, -0.7411182522773743, -0.3604959547519684, 0.30643364787101746, 0.5420584082603455, -0.32574838399887085, -0.8623929619789124, -0.03923988342285156, 0.0690801665186882, 0.4269532859325409, -1.3391975164413452, -0.4622069299221039, 0.07739277929067612, 0.4665546715259552, -0.09883181005716324, -0.6365821957588196, -0.22975395619869232, 0.24966402351856232, 0.908413290977478, 0.4516063928604126, -0.48883554339408875, 0.18264640867710114, 0.9311222434043884, -0.19675005972385406, 0.503329336643219, -0.14573337137699127, -0.4368843734264374, 0.03901097923517227, -0.20815539360046387, -0.09322866052389145, 0.17020297050476074, -0.8691840171813965, 0.7028252482414246, -0.7906736135482788, -0.4632264971733093, -0.7612359523773193, -0.4133361279964447, 0.26929453015327454, -0.07164549827575684, 0.10044107586145401, -0.14941354095935822, -0.5420123934745789, -0.08355362713336945, 0.5263590812683105, -0.032222308218479156, 0.13655607402324677, 0.5246855616569519, -0.29031211137771606, 0.6567586064338684, -0.3802962303161621, 0.05444251000881195, 0.9594230651855469, 0.7766683101654053, 0.11913546174764633, 0.34355971217155457, 0.15484552085399628, 0.5063053965568542, 0.22030921280384064, 1.0944828987121582, -0.08515173196792603, 0.2184535712003708, -0.927344799041748, 0.8346251249313354, -0.1330927610397339, 0.418953537940979, -0.2457098513841629, -0.6980357766151428, -0.13758070766925812, 0.4252208471298218, 0.6667613983154297, 0.8009615540504456, -0.15121953189373016, 0.3552241623401642, 0.25356337428092957, 0.27258557081222534, -0.9199512600898743, -0.880835771560669, 0.016091126948595047, 0.8267635703086853, 0.6658262014389038, 0.766366720199585, 0.13549864292144775, -0.3388534188270569, 0.2653030753135681, 0.50232994556427, -0.8124963045120239, 0.27271583676338196, -0.062181271612644196, -1.0816941261291504, 0.24197904765605927, 0.37670454382896423, -0.2305363267660141, 0.340818852186203, 0.24467521905899048, 0.5845673680305481, -0.36928632855415344, -0.00903304386883974, 0.8921738862991333, -0.36957255005836487, 0.5910165905952454, 0.7978399395942688, -0.9680368304252625, 0.104453444480896, 0.25038647651672363, -0.34108951687812805, -0.1946541965007782, -0.19476188719272614, -0.14372439682483673, -0.4017634689807892, 0.49725115299224854, 1.3256430625915527, 0.025606276467442513, -0.6229445934295654, -1.2037577629089355, -0.0776173323392868, 0.19075417518615723, -0.7000555992126465, 0.5363602042198181, -0.11265943199396133, 0.18027980625629425, 1.2481188774108887, -0.31409284472465515, 0.11186309158802032, -0.39667826890945435, 0.21321888267993927, 0.18590371310710907, -0.2902873456478119, -0.23524264991283417, 0.35082903504371643, -0.14749792218208313, 0.47410452365875244, 0.5773593783378601, 0.7705972790718079, -0.08795559406280518, -0.5774658918380737, -0.46414539217948914, 0.0014478405937552452, 0.1229330524802208, -0.2828895151615143, 1.082802176475525, 0.08604186773300171, -0.3453933894634247, -0.6498382687568665, 0.3081791400909424, 0.010554332286119461, 0.6717434525489807, -0.3492194712162018, -0.7533403635025024, 0.44359290599823, -1.2137393951416016, 0.7534077763557434, -0.8213891386985779, -0.24905483424663544, -1.127607822418213, 0.028777530416846275, 0.07938919961452484, 0.4748682677745819, -0.05436057969927788, 0.44056159257888794, -1.2152057886123657, 0.37507760524749756, -1.0701484680175781, -0.0615738183259964, 0.23007602989673615, 0.8852556347846985, -0.6203828454017639, 0.45514798164367676, 0.23198910057544708, -0.7482112050056458, 0.32846903800964355, -0.24904415011405945, 0.6055756211280823, -0.09830547869205475, -0.1184103935956955, 0.7132350206375122, 0.34823834896087646, 0.0956997275352478, 0.5538390874862671, 0.3572351336479187, -0.11435511708259583, 0.8804473876953125, -0.1246061697602272, -0.7688568234443665, 0.7913428544998169, 0.8668274283409119, -0.11993171274662018, 0.3086191415786743, 0.4157262444496155, 0.13767234981060028, 0.28814685344696045, 0.463799387216568, -0.15953245759010315, -0.2356429100036621, 1.247498631477356, 1.0178911685943604, -0.24941633641719818, 0.19270367920398712, -0.05966240167617798, 0.04538815841078758, -0.158779114484787, 0.37220335006713867, -0.48507872223854065, 0.2728283405303955, 0.290410578250885, 0.5517998337745667, -0.11203604936599731, 0.5703611969947815, -0.22645866870880127, 0.5279865860939026, 0.00895709078758955, 0.35933586955070496, -1.5946283340454102, -0.23735173046588898, -0.1673220992088318, 0.5321871042251587, -0.1455983817577362, -0.6871062517166138, -0.14810426533222198, 0.1410330981016159, -0.46552762389183044, -0.88874751329422, -0.29046720266342163, 0.33255618810653687, -0.19966711103916168, 0.49636659026145935, 0.9575419425964355, -0.12053307145833969, -1.1207125186920166, -0.0014218655414879322, -0.7862054705619812, -0.13405805826187134, -0.8007256984710693, 0.2035200595855713, 0.13648661971092224, -0.6622930765151978, 0.5320807099342346, 0.015213141217827797, -0.5455905199050903, 0.24748826026916504, 0.15373387932777405, 0.40469107031822205, 0.010198302567005157, -0.03719964995980263, -0.6020386219024658, 0.3083607256412506, -1.0412172079086304, 0.2797493636608124, -0.09881129115819931, -0.5613787174224854, 0.24589227139949799, 0.0402272492647171, 0.5983443260192871, 0.15712641179561615, -0.19722329080104828, 0.7744284868240356, -0.36943280696868896, -0.22926993668079376, 0.648415207862854, 0.6674375534057617, -0.19207344949245453, 0.06870821118354797, -0.9107484817504883, 0.7725422382354736, -0.7952756285667419, -0.20924481749534607, 0.6512312889099121, -0.4926014244556427, -0.9919140934944153, 0.7104090452194214, -0.7128707766532898, 0.035456351935863495, -0.3209831714630127, 0.6782328486442566, 0.5661214590072632, -0.4089241325855255, 0.15859834849834442, -0.6633793115615845, -0.6449851393699646, 0.12066048383712769, 0.378067284822464, -0.2271745502948761, 0.2993488013744354, 1.0677237510681152, 0.33908677101135254, -0.5489059090614319, 0.17423096299171448, -1.3630393743515015, -0.41397973895072937, -0.24869327247142792, -0.4558826684951782, -0.10550404340028763, 0.06579327583312988, 0.7034062147140503, -0.6128469705581665, -0.10384858399629593, -0.7151276469230652, 0.5228793621063232, 0.49721089005470276, 0.2197667360305786, 0.34040623903274536, 0.6374473571777344, 0.15803730487823486, 0.20139935612678528, 0.5241916179656982, -0.2681657373905182, -0.42206594347953796, 0.4865824282169342, -0.07214417308568954, 0.5336174964904785, -0.0723014622926712, -0.1408511996269226, -0.2815956175327301, 0.835789144039154, -0.393716424703598, -0.678083598613739, -1.0496655702590942, -0.4498186707496643, -0.17310698330402374, 0.8621928691864014, 0.6523852348327637, -0.5044698119163513, -0.6839451789855957, 0.367960661649704, -0.04457024112343788, 0.15581437945365906, 0.6415490508079529, -0.6017425656318665, 0.10686077922582626, -0.16645124554634094, -0.6210565567016602, -0.058086104691028595, 0.14382989704608917, 0.22068879008293152, 0.7471203207969666, 0.8954411149024963, 0.0792330875992775, -0.1592942625284195, -0.2969248592853546, 0.20170556008815765, 0.19273589551448822, -0.06596291810274124, 0.035250987857580185, -0.22083508968353271, -0.41181686520576477, -0.21191780269145966, -0.1972486823797226, -0.4888811409473419, -0.8148698806762695, -0.9381636381149292, -0.5496376752853394, -0.9281572699546814, -0.5018501281738281, -0.013269372284412384, 0.3060205280780792, 0.8950312733650208, 0.40434953570365906, 0.09649552404880524, 0.2371833473443985, 0.7495331764221191, -0.02765393815934658, 0.5434470772743225, -0.3866453766822815, 0.7111098766326904, -0.6328408122062683, 0.839932918548584, 0.4398421049118042, 0.23651815950870514, 0.12827327847480774, 0.027016546577215195, 0.03421914204955101, -0.5283055901527405, 0.360589861869812, 0.4530895948410034, -0.7158368229866028, 0.14387661218643188, 0.32386648654937744, -0.12712371349334717, -0.6952847838401794, 0.2983831465244293, 0.596642017364502, -0.3032064139842987, 0.3155955970287323, -0.8777845501899719, 0.19977056980133057, -0.4029093086719513, 0.56836998462677, 0.905215322971344, -0.6856251358985901, -1.2312369346618652, -0.46376943588256836, 0.04541776701807976, -0.06963139027357101, 0.318979948759079, 0.3820507824420929, 0.9844388365745544, 0.5658344030380249, -0.2514282464981079, 0.0515834279358387, 1.0366517305374146, -0.5924831032752991, -0.4490562677383423, -0.013809900730848312, -0.13505060970783234, -0.34837156534194946, 0.5440813899040222, -0.2068200707435608, -1.143458604812622, 0.2806987166404724, -0.29822418093681335, 0.4192301332950592, -0.4575265645980835, -0.5705091953277588, -0.2809572219848633, 0.5197063684463501, -0.41272732615470886, 0.5795149207115173, -0.1443893313407898, -0.39961743354797363, -0.36806225776672363, -0.3582282066345215, -0.38906997442245483, -0.043393027037382126, 0.14985358715057373, 0.1320306807756424, 1.0414305925369263, 0.4356610178947449, 0.14926597476005554, 0.39182209968566895, 0.2677215337753296, 0.3621760904788971, -0.14423224329948425, 0.4282010793685913, -0.4462786614894867, -0.9084487557411194, -0.05402280390262604, -0.10202459245920181, -0.5797016024589539, -0.16641473770141602, 0.06906551122665405, -0.5486574172973633, -0.007690821774303913, 0.34659910202026367, -0.5883526802062988, -0.6983107328414917, -0.5310487747192383, -0.920458197593689, 0.8828902840614319, -0.34387871623039246, 0.28159916400909424, 0.052686627954244614, -0.6413975358009338, 0.14955760538578033, -0.33811408281326294, -0.055855683982372284, -0.10938413441181183, 0.09565383940935135, 0.831573486328125, 0.12192762643098831, 1.208080530166626, -0.6742374300956726, 0.45339417457580566, 0.3298790454864502, -0.38904812932014465, -0.6983895301818848, -0.7723546624183655, -0.09060272574424744, 0.16223859786987305, 0.23803697526454926, -0.30445078015327454, 0.6746752858161926, -0.4512043297290802, -0.132353737950325, -0.02929145283997059, 0.10396447032690048, -0.9629240036010742, -0.3068844676017761, 0.29571646451950073, 0.9082284569740295, -0.3208446502685547, -0.06600956618785858, 0.22811944782733917, -0.26251423358917236, 0.5447967648506165, -0.9693783521652222, -0.4818839430809021, 0.5227108597755432, -1.320056438446045, 0.18161335587501526, -0.9959337711334229, -0.19209140539169312, -0.2079545110464096, -0.7433269619941711, 0.5062776207923889, 0.2667025029659271, 0.13377833366394043, -0.5119611620903015, -0.39711642265319824, -0.46547216176986694, 0.5496692657470703, -0.7773531675338745, -0.035537175834178925, -0.3765513300895691, 0.019239673390984535, -0.22741343080997467, 0.7564620971679688, -0.7605425715446472, 0.22654207050800323, 0.4066167175769806, -0.29780229926109314, -0.0847650021314621, 0.4912624657154083, -0.06222879886627197, -0.15418212115764618, -0.1497347056865692, 0.245950847864151, 0.4714674651622772, 0.4758187532424927, -0.18285977840423584, 0.7146413922309875, -1.120762586593628, 1.1491731405258179, -0.19055701792240143, -0.254003643989563, 0.7293103933334351, 0.140036940574646, 0.7649394869804382, -0.3779149055480957, 0.3739113509654999, 0.6447629332542419, 0.10045385360717773, 0.18469151854515076, 0.15889929234981537, -0.4141679108142853, 0.09394160658121109, -0.6357430219650269, -0.6750087738037109, 0.7344191670417786, 0.16431641578674316, -0.2403509020805359, 0.1675342470407486, -0.784582793712616, -0.49762359261512756, -0.2048148214817047, 0.24545033276081085, 0.03716328367590904, 0.18403786420822144, 0.5120083093643188, -0.16093778610229492, 0.3706088960170746, -0.871746301651001, 0.047232817858457565, -0.10213158279657364, 0.15755878388881683, 0.26253971457481384, -0.09571368247270584, -0.2998931109905243, -1.0588644742965698, -0.46159470081329346, 0.47811177372932434, 0.8506030440330505, -0.10353143513202667, 0.794215977191925, 0.19507303833961487, 0.02842746488749981, -0.2666062116622925, 0.1240086555480957, 0.2134690135717392, -0.11154579371213913, 0.3044045865535736, 0.45338690280914307, -0.007633107714354992, -0.17173823714256287, 0.517884373664856, -0.8810932636260986, -0.4479047656059265, 0.9311023950576782, -0.9070882797241211, 0.07119029015302658, 0.30116692185401917, 0.5734890103340149, -0.7506317496299744, -1.1562168598175049, -1.2920880317687988, -0.21926818788051605, 0.04518768563866615, -0.5885394215583801, -0.06531865149736404, -0.2947758138179779, -0.40763771533966064, 1.0180151462554932, 0.13298861682415009, 0.4611428380012512, 0.9393159747123718, 0.1916479915380478, -0.07664811611175537, -0.023335745558142662, 0.20147213339805603, 1.8498289585113525, -0.12603119015693665, -1.1953471899032593, 0.41290146112442017, 0.6280993819236755, -0.12422073632478714, 0.38273030519485474, 0.6561495661735535, -0.5508613586425781, 0.26803308725357056, 0.17348416149616241, 0.057336028665304184, 0.5062004327774048, -0.22925566136837006, 0.4603140950202942, 0.039060767740011215, -0.6116611957550049, -1.0316638946533203, -0.2379816174507141, 0.16764222085475922, 0.9885119199752808, 0.44234663248062134, 0.17412617802619934, 0.10243942588567734, -0.8388670086860657, 0.3502937853336334, 0.09850464761257172, -0.5660796165466309, 0.16987183690071106, -0.7183659672737122, -0.41393518447875977, -0.6986839175224304, 0.4162684381008148, 0.5870987176895142, 0.36009860038757324, -0.4869534969329834, 0.18471123278141022, -0.07632574439048767, 0.1753578931093216, -0.3013429641723633, 0.7882511615753174, -0.32431575655937195, -0.30391961336135864, -1.385785460472107, 0.20035941898822784, -0.20899242162704468, -1.2726421356201172, -1.0212441682815552, -0.34469354152679443, 0.008389581926167011, 1.3341277837753296, -0.17238369584083557, 1.23737633228302, -1.2086749076843262, -0.7130028605461121, -0.023765776306390762, -0.16442584991455078, -0.8302580118179321, 0.8078634142875671, -1.242659330368042, 1.0523569583892822, 0.22122830152511597, 1.1442220211029053, -0.20508234202861786, -0.3156259059906006, -0.6354764699935913, 0.5052857398986816, -0.3414244055747986, 0.20956547558307648, 0.2195112258195877, -0.559808611869812, 0.6535470485687256, 0.3901419937610626, -0.674155056476593, 0.03764711320400238, -0.5417601466178894, 0.3051961362361908, -0.3254122734069824, 0.530648946762085, -0.3622027635574341, -0.20099081099033356, -0.27004024386405945, 0.5241466164588928, -0.7520350217819214, 0.21047765016555786, 0.24312302470207214, 0.2991826832294464, 0.17587801814079285, -0.04713737964630127, 0.24674935638904572, -0.3035019338130951, 0.3210597336292267, 0.12668798863887787, -0.43295255303382874, 0.10873976349830627, -0.08519850671291351, -0.28779324889183044, -0.12388144433498383, 0.27872002124786377, -0.42408910393714905, 0.5852657556533813, 0.22942940890789032, 0.04739505797624588, 0.19318318367004395, -0.5337904095649719, -1.2528562545776367, 0.2828110158443451, -0.850571870803833, -0.8760858774185181, -0.03734175115823746, -0.457751601934433, -0.3888400197029114, 0.12240707129240036, -0.5984522104263306, 0.2761397659778595, -0.3190006613731384, 0.5190279483795166, 1.2560395002365112, 0.09428954869508743, -0.4530438184738159, 0.01093972660601139, -0.8937524557113647, -0.3166702687740326, -0.3884768486022949, 0.3238379657268524, -1.1671953201293945, -0.9396838545799255, -0.25210973620414734, 0.6372727155685425, -0.2587509751319885, 0.02979050949215889, -0.0844433382153511, -0.3061615824699402, -0.41774243116378784, -0.11332685500383377, -0.23449312150478363, -0.20837222039699554, -0.4167914390563965, 0.409260094165802, 0.06452878564596176, -0.45220693945884705, 0.33815351128578186, 0.6522153615951538, 0.306339293718338, -0.11274581402540207, 0.2279052436351776, 0.7578765153884888, -0.3113238215446472, -0.010029368102550507, 0.35398170351982117, 0.18927152454853058, 0.4429503381252289, 0.5813640356063843, -0.32901400327682495, -0.08740133047103882, 0.4032726287841797, 0.19344863295555115, 0.7085750699043274, 0.0829039067029953, 0.16727183759212494, 0.25756755471229553, -0.006613138131797314, 0.05091148614883423, 0.025783762335777283, 0.18814432621002197, 0.3229580223560333, 0.008892322890460491, -0.3734254837036133, -0.13777755200862885, -0.2496616393327713, 0.244965597987175, 0.1526471972465515, 0.030675921589136124, 0.13900886476039886, -0.3603461682796478, -0.4273096024990082, 0.17704105377197266, -0.24873942136764526, -0.784397304058075, -0.7044046521186829, 0.6494836807250977, 0.2653443515300751, 0.23974548280239105, -0.1692759245634079, 0.5325961112976074, 0.5071207880973816, 0.2199215590953827, -0.10656214505434036, 0.6025030016899109, 0.7294753193855286, 0.7019726037979126, 1.1068440675735474, 0.6180576086044312, 0.05194728821516037, 1.009507417678833, -0.11461994051933289, -1.1355810165405273, -0.08412960916757584, 0.0525929220020771, -1.1603611707687378, 0.27706941962242126, -0.18794754147529602, 0.0060331206768751144, -0.13777296245098114, -0.687142550945282, -0.07251681387424469, -0.860382080078125, -0.08806675672531128, 0.10772727429866791, -0.933472752571106, -0.6303861141204834, 0.3065190613269806, 0.3038007915019989, 0.3146040141582489, 0.5083649158477783, 0.5438945889472961, -0.08269993215799332, 0.2555988132953644, 0.8923410773277283, 0.38537856936454773, 0.27015942335128784, -0.3105747401714325, -0.06431054323911667, 0.40241459012031555, 0.7329995632171631, -0.5952485203742981, 1.1110281944274902, -0.21072611212730408, -0.4599744379520416, -0.16285879909992218, -0.0818808302283287, -0.5618895292282104, -0.06123607978224754, 0.5406925082206726, 0.5641798377037048, -0.4556405246257782, 0.09959430247545242, 0.7026079297065735, 0.6538143157958984, -0.364198237657547, -0.2568416893482208, 0.1954260617494583, -0.7199055552482605, 0.04357030242681503, -1.1427251100540161, 0.17865604162216187, 0.16381612420082092, 0.25722411274909973, -0.7028316855430603, -0.21234847605228424, -0.5333912372589111, -0.3326238691806793, 0.044832151383161545, -0.6547974348068237, 0.23836372792720795, 1.3405486345291138, 0.3505365252494812, 0.07780188322067261, -1.074493646621704, -0.48478221893310547, 0.21114391088485718, 1.281126856803894, -0.5847502946853638, -0.20074866712093353, 0.6979750394821167, -0.21592062711715698, -0.7726150751113892, 0.5135880708694458, 1.111915946006775, -0.7313249707221985, 0.3345487117767334, -0.7081500887870789, 0.37998655438423157, -0.04713484272360802, -0.012111861258745193, 0.2560204565525055, -0.28262677788734436, 0.6562954187393188, -0.40919041633605957, -0.03893321380019188, 0.43300673365592957, -0.9403160214424133, -0.5483345985412598, -0.7777689695358276, 0.6213671565055847, 0.08853531628847122, -0.5937049388885498, 0.358450710773468, -1.067529559135437, 3.9106810092926025, 0.8748130202293396, 0.7669156193733215, -0.18362709879875183, 1.1744091510772705, 0.982964038848877, -0.10803945362567902, 0.18744975328445435, 0.7652378678321838, -0.9834955930709839, -0.5777853727340698, 0.22763220965862274, 0.08017130196094513, -0.0009974376298487186, 0.24498340487480164, 0.441563218832016, -0.33327898383140564, 0.3989274203777313, -0.5425605177879333, -0.7000666260719299, -1.3234895467758179, -0.23356793820858002, 0.4364807605743408, -0.3854917883872986, 0.5892989039421082, 0.3004789352416992, 0.1471170336008072, -0.41536837816238403, -0.34813347458839417, -0.5235503315925598, -0.5752508044242859, -0.7356651425361633, 0.12774881720542908, 0.2064623385667801, -1.1676301956176758, 0.37819287180900574, -0.4394437372684479, -0.11336461454629898, 0.45031240582466125, -0.6178463697433472, -0.08817903697490692, -1.4245859384536743, 0.260299414396286, -0.5619897842407227, -0.16025535762310028, 0.40388742089271545, 0.607566237449646, 0.5272030830383301, 0.5532481074333191, -0.7564204931259155, -0.3193296194076538, -0.05475342646241188, 0.6898654103279114, -0.8828305006027222, -0.5564601421356201, -0.39246052503585815, -0.41044726967811584, -0.27264729142189026, 0.5091495513916016, -0.44446346163749695, 0.4334906041622162, -0.4243881404399872, -0.13073895871639252, 0.2468634396791458, 0.21584157645702362, -0.3361322283744812, 0.6744053363800049, -0.49430039525032043, -0.020506402477622032, 0.20657828450202942, -0.7554180026054382, -0.3839121162891388, -0.2518163323402405, 0.050717007368803024, -0.14300166070461273, -0.1206488087773323, -0.15928031504154205, 0.07219763100147247, -0.23029689490795135, 0.25859907269477844, -0.3220110833644867, 0.08887111395597458, -0.03826766088604927, -0.05924287438392639, 0.2463948130607605, 1.0351102352142334, -0.10930884629487991, 0.4956580102443695, 0.4531368315219879, 0.7055571675300598, 0.13572600483894348, 0.8613486886024475, -0.2801929712295532, 0.0574420765042305, -1.196387529373169 ]
SO(4) Invariant States in Quantum Cosmology
The phenomenon of linearisation instability is identified in models of quantum cosmology that are perturbations of mini-superspace models. In particular, constraints that are second order in the perturbations must be imposed on wave functions calculated in such models. It is shown explicitly that in the case of a model which is a perturbation of the mini-superspace which has $S^3$ spatial sections these constraints imply that any wave functions calculated in this model must be SO(4) invariant. (This replaces the previous corrupted version.)
Fay Dowker
gr-qc
October
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9210020
gr-qc/9211001
[ 0.2183341532945633, 0.22170205414295197, 0.6130189299583435, -0.15041187405586243, 0.004403602331876755, -0.07784509658813477, 0.08638732880353928, 0.07055365294218063, -0.5600051283836365, 1.560238242149353, 0.5769601464271545, -0.1346338391304016, -0.36865970492362976, -0.8954824209213257, -0.3893232047557831, 0.7172161340713501, 0.15928317606449127, 0.06500829011201859, -0.9638398885726929, 0.452350914478302, 0.0693369135260582, 0.2827439606189728, -1.1935135126113892, -0.30795547366142273, -0.24340271949768066, 1.0297203063964844, 0.900307297706604, 0.1771654337644577, 0.9318945407867432, 1.0935508012771606, 0.21094225347042084, -0.5628815293312073, -0.4094472825527191, -0.306904137134552, -0.545080304145813, 0.43436577916145325, -0.10698229819536209, -0.34410983324050903, 0.681049644947052, -0.1451035588979721, 0.615191638469696, 0.06800186634063721, -0.26948732137680054, -0.18380874395370483, -0.8355045318603516, 0.20256809890270233, 0.28402960300445557, 0.47220829129219055, 0.2750488817691803, -0.8456068634986877, 0.32219022512435913, -0.5400986671447754, 0.8557863831520081, -1.0585047006607056, -0.5478885173797607, 0.010730934329330921, 0.6015629768371582, -0.10752083361148834, -0.3724941313266754, -0.13054339587688446, 0.31610336899757385, 0.4943157732486725, 0.2204267680644989, -0.6445102095603943, -0.048928581178188324, 1.219193935394287, -0.4777097702026367, 0.44865456223487854, -0.16153724491596222, -0.310586154460907, -0.48193851113319397, -0.3552337884902954, -0.3405660092830658, 0.7918482422828674, 0.09103132039308548, 0.7571644186973572, -0.6298657655715942, -0.8218483924865723, -0.7287044525146484, -0.2863300144672394, -0.3251948356628418, 0.6670303344726562, -0.2511012852191925, 0.47248202562332153, -0.3310346007347107, 0.08172425627708435, -0.04270530492067337, 0.19905206561088562, 0.4943239986896515, 0.09159925580024719, -0.3600683808326721, 0.2571788430213928, -0.2487444281578064, -0.07079154253005981, 0.6704138517379761, 0.44768568873405457, -0.06332921236753464, 0.6702055931091309, 0.5735412836074829, -0.689436674118042, 0.06226983293890953, 1.5450690984725952, 0.054758522659540176, 0.1377096325159073, -0.6023200750350952, 0.496044397354126, -0.7381722927093506, 0.3753218948841095, -0.9044384956359863, -0.07399753481149673, 0.42803049087524414, -0.012355313636362553, 1.0449210405349731, 0.39703643321990967, 0.21511687338352203, 0.30561837553977966, -0.8520362377166748, -0.3004021644592285, -0.41964036226272583, -0.3804152011871338, -0.1504768580198288, 0.05883719027042389, 0.8753097653388977, 0.4384686350822449, -0.6197459697723389, -1.0847599506378174, -0.19058354198932648, 0.6082347631454468, -0.4810411334037781, 0.46571627259254456, 0.8301138281822205, -0.3411824405193329, -0.13029257953166962, 0.21169039607048035, 0.2740781605243683, -0.8248985409736633, -0.4530099332332611, 0.23449987173080444, -0.2892863154411316, -0.5012682676315308, 0.15770454704761505, -0.45136842131614685, 0.23376721143722534, 1.3483033180236816, -0.5320250391960144, 0.5594483613967896, 0.011767427437007427, 0.2997516393661499, -0.3431605100631714, -0.18264684081077576, -0.0968879908323288, -0.07928483188152313, 0.3151339292526245, 0.2469085454940796, -0.03464492782950401, 0.2599281370639801, -1.3579339981079102, -0.01909046806395054, -0.23273849487304688, -0.4980548620223999, 0.44563496112823486, 0.23950710892677307, 0.1868094652891159, 1.3544484376907349, -0.7387685775756836, 0.6011743545532227, -0.7914943695068359, -0.23181194067001343, 0.026501968502998352, -0.31299957633018494, -0.019393067806959152, 0.12013302743434906, -0.047976136207580566, 0.9683877825737, 0.6432591676712036, 0.3659365177154541, 0.26426661014556885, -0.2999001741409302, -0.34404706954956055, 0.650093138217926, -0.054199010133743286, -0.9812930822372437, 0.5127155184745789, 0.9838081002235413, -0.5123983025550842, 0.3011981248855591, 0.6682291030883789, -0.43840715289115906, 0.6039538383483887, -0.15452048182487488, -0.4812733232975006, 0.6873965263366699, -0.945428192615509, 0.6411033868789673, -1.025733232498169, 0.15327732264995575, -1.1342532634735107, -0.287950724363327, -0.10009647905826569, -0.5662060976028442, 0.06407277286052704, -0.0823303684592247, -1.450021505355835, 0.40217143297195435, -0.5892310738563538, -0.22862093150615692, 0.014425186440348625, 0.8207535147666931, -0.5438546538352966, -0.4390895366668701, 0.7099318504333496, -0.2406727522611618, 0.6880977749824524, -0.3810161352157593, -0.09780648350715637, -0.11472493410110474, -0.4161257743835449, 0.38567230105400085, -0.11330851912498474, 0.058325059711933136, 0.6616342067718506, 0.6665827631950378, -0.39025694131851196, 1.0476833581924438, -0.10833362489938736, -0.16650384664535522, 0.7427080273628235, 0.9300171136856079, -0.04807421937584877, 1.1162433624267578, 0.30957186222076416, 0.4231773912906647, 0.41452035307884216, 0.7070479393005371, 0.8325418829917908, 0.14980028569698334, 0.8382832407951355, 0.8626139760017395, 0.5719022154808044, 0.33057159185409546, 0.22185343503952026, 0.736679196357727, 0.9239166378974915, -0.7800037860870361, -0.8739092350006104, 0.6852239370346069, 0.503119707107544, -0.09628117829561234, -0.7598031759262085, 0.7736966609954834, -0.4069474935531616, -0.1784016191959381, -0.44389814138412476, -0.088736392557621, -1.3880558013916016, 0.3773972690105438, -0.28572943806648254, 0.1224745661020279, 0.3078303933143616, 0.07188449054956436, -0.177974671125412, -0.22209089994430542, 0.2276189923286438, -0.6775235533714294, -0.23693765699863434, 0.6112063527107239, -0.5492963790893555, 0.20965948700904846, 0.3100271224975586, -0.7373890280723572, -1.486851692199707, 0.1996442824602127, -0.38704970479011536, -0.12294106930494308, -0.6698833703994751, 0.25926312804222107, 0.34868064522743225, 0.011093249544501305, 0.8465772867202759, 0.24718983471393585, -0.3629956841468811, 0.48273834586143494, -0.2361915558576584, 0.3887096643447876, 0.5311006307601929, 0.11149363219738007, -1.2556214332580566, -0.4675646424293518, -0.8294945359230042, 0.3117072284221649, -0.20979543030261993, -0.440591424703598, 0.6516568064689636, 0.05068621039390564, 0.2770150601863861, 0.6850329637527466, -0.05550287663936615, 0.22000116109848022, -0.44208982586860657, -1.1406856775283813, 0.442970335483551, 0.2078304886817932, -0.2708219885826111, 0.4798792600631714, -0.36302369832992554, 1.4156770706176758, -0.19717539846897125, 0.20044200122356415, 0.5024633407592773, -0.010655727237462997, -0.5448614954948425, 0.006924193352460861, 0.5576035976409912, 0.7443284392356873, -0.10519231110811234, 0.37869319319725037, 0.6473431587219238, -0.15914368629455566, -0.025667112320661545, 0.040765613317489624, -0.33951422572135925, -0.41945111751556396, 0.30460214614868164, -0.6715365052223206, 0.4790011942386627, 0.6340259909629822, 0.09330102801322937, -0.42680901288986206, 0.9440248012542725, -0.743141233921051, -0.6588131785392761, -0.4599374234676361, -0.652077853679657, 0.41114121675491333, -0.1707504689693451, 0.20076991617679596, -0.017672572284936905, -0.5874638557434082, -0.5411750674247742, 0.057286154478788376, 0.32488980889320374, -0.7352315783500671, -0.10055408626794815, 0.7654743194580078, 0.4508155286312103, 0.06351687014102936, -0.17233547568321228, -0.5847002863883972, 0.31148186326026917, 0.2588942348957062, -0.6046692132949829, 0.4900907576084137, 0.020212190225720406, -0.31485557556152344, -0.005867647472769022, 0.0735766664147377, -0.04898761212825775, -0.73249351978302, -0.8444318771362305, -0.3583616316318512, 0.16961117088794708, -0.1918543428182602, 0.011353191919624805, -1.0856316089630127, -0.7644436955451965, 0.12846709787845612, -0.348190575838089, 0.9612162113189697, 0.7698444724082947, -1.0211753845214844, 0.5400845408439636, 1.0103044509887695, -0.419514000415802, -0.08861038088798523, -0.07147887349128723, 0.6389185190200806, 0.4018850326538086, 0.32320892810821533, 0.020869437605142593, -0.5777788162231445, 0.020563438534736633, -0.528725802898407, 0.6751397252082825, -0.1342679262161255, 0.7065805792808533, 0.16405825316905975, -0.2947944104671478, 0.09278161823749542, -0.2635229825973511, -0.3953392505645752, -0.28977519273757935, -0.8002317547798157, 0.3325592875480652, -0.6837106347084045, 0.07576267421245575, 0.0013698136899620295, 0.4351438879966736, 0.523246169090271, 0.65704345703125, 0.18939831852912903, -0.028190430253744125, 0.12520447373390198, 0.5031203031539917, 0.47681504487991333, -0.7389575242996216, 0.46677660942077637, -0.5544745922088623, 0.67649906873703, 0.3500334322452545, 0.28119057416915894, 0.3583050072193146, -0.9648217558860779, 0.1271192580461502, 0.028113150969147682, 0.7026781439781189, -0.23139448463916779, -0.10829439014196396, 0.13697656989097595, 0.16191673278808594, -0.22775307297706604, -0.28331780433654785, 0.28951308131217957, 0.9738830924034119, 0.6562691330909729, -0.09654858708381653, -0.7657178044319153, 0.5331898331642151, -0.6499637365341187, 0.4932914078235626, 0.5354083776473999, -0.42679762840270996, -0.6804492473602295, -0.24427402019500732, -0.002212624764069915, 0.5724586844444275, 0.15741237998008728, 0.7359128594398499, 0.5150275230407715, 0.56206214427948, -0.7472402453422546, -0.16286371648311615, 0.7427957057952881, -0.23511342704296112, -0.12337139248847961, -0.18811775743961334, 0.3038635849952698, 0.21904414892196655, 0.2582361102104187, -0.08687170594930649, -0.8225610852241516, -0.47449636459350586, -0.443642795085907, 0.3435226380825043, -0.6494286060333252, -0.3432144820690155, -0.008753664791584015, -0.5319154262542725, 0.03880671411752701, 0.4891066253185272, -0.45169416069984436, 0.2127707302570343, 0.2896374464035034, -0.24393093585968018, 0.03345330059528351, 0.6225206255912781, 0.38815057277679443, 0.6534500122070312, 1.1524428129196167, 0.8500456213951111, 0.022804291918873787, 0.20658674836158752, 0.049438994377851486, -0.0612652562558651, 0.11050467193126678, 0.5980269312858582, -0.5317791700363159, -0.40649235248565674, 0.08853468298912048, -0.1360606551170349, -0.5531490445137024, -0.3297409117221832, 0.41425153613090515, -0.14934779703617096, 0.37598368525505066, -0.10454568266868591, -0.7962701320648193, -0.4454415440559387, -1.1666165590286255, -0.9424899816513062, 0.327444851398468, -0.3141235113143921, -0.25230997800827026, 0.6600341200828552, -0.9295912981033325, 0.025334149599075317, -0.7950679659843445, -0.01601405441761017, -0.10762721300125122, -0.6384151577949524, 0.28103506565093994, 0.5460037589073181, 0.46851465106010437, -0.8621857166290283, 0.20397886633872986, -0.8392603993415833, -0.17100970447063446, -0.5335066318511963, -0.22577983140945435, -0.462834894657135, -0.06216020509600639, 0.312990665435791, 0.24547232687473297, 0.1752430498600006, -0.14769789576530457, 0.12679675221443176, 0.2956296503543854, -0.794806718826294, -0.9703288674354553, -0.40857768058776855, 0.4385288953781128, -0.3681013584136963, -0.5050256252288818, 0.0547710657119751, 0.693393349647522, 0.48325037956237793, 0.5918694734573364, -0.180121049284935, -0.1803404688835144, -0.055542439222335815, -1.190002679824829, 0.7856852412223816, -0.9145206212997437, -0.25525718927383423, -0.2036311775445938, -0.41439497470855713, 0.9790343642234802, 0.3990476727485657, -0.6811419129371643, -0.03690894693136215, -0.31994807720184326, -0.6466405391693115, 0.1350344866514206, -0.9537331461906433, 0.42306673526763916, -1.009462594985962, -0.14137110114097595, -0.6335161328315735, 0.793306827545166, -0.1505863517522812, -0.045619916170835495, 0.2066909223794937, 0.17956240475177765, -0.03288957104086876, 0.4446367919445038, 0.27904948592185974, -0.04950851574540138, -0.6652851104736328, -0.2768068313598633, 0.25266146659851074, 0.03503658249974251, -0.5055534243583679, -0.030973777174949646, -0.3410051763057709, 0.754554271697998, 0.0008564975578337908, -0.2570846378803253, 0.4738498032093048, -0.0543019063770771, 0.4609156847000122, -0.7596427202224731, -0.6087777614593506, 0.9142436981201172, -0.6986629366874695, 0.8165903687477112, 0.11085168272256851, -0.7931345701217651, -0.5278064012527466, -0.4677013158798218, -0.9695675373077393, 0.6130614280700684, -0.01437406800687313, -0.3811751902103424, -0.6372448205947876, -0.9523200988769531, 0.12392247468233109, -0.21241319179534912, 0.5460524559020996, 0.09638091921806335, -0.006785579025745392, 0.24129362404346466, -0.25520220398902893, -0.24579064548015594, -0.29334792494773865, 0.6292322874069214, -0.15902812778949738, -0.1713358759880066, 0.20961393415927887, -0.6793527007102966, -0.6111589074134827, -0.8821938037872314, -0.38024380803108215, 0.13291814923286438, 0.29114142060279846, -0.5176060199737549, 0.793944776058197, 0.0925692766904831, -0.43054983019828796, -0.9734835028648376, 0.11386490613222122, 0.20981116592884064, -0.24615022540092468, 0.42686253786087036, 0.4519224464893341, 0.2059270739555359, -0.016317028552293777, 0.3112538158893585, -0.5387723445892334, -0.10960077494382858, 0.6607676148414612, -0.7810600996017456, -0.19040457904338837, 0.775847315788269, -0.1717698574066162, -0.12431757152080536, -0.7156735062599182, -1.2887611389160156, -0.6137447953224182, 0.03733369708061218, -0.1833791583776474, 0.42654868960380554, -0.32303476333618164, -0.09282413870096207, -0.061288025230169296, 0.36099258065223694, 0.5494129657745361, 0.31038621068000793, 0.6247237324714661, 0.07367272675037384, -0.09311745315790176, -0.37818533182144165, 1.0113998651504517, 0.18222932517528534, -1.17288076877594, -0.4981808662414551, 0.1294310986995697, -0.21206077933311462, -0.3230022192001343, 1.1545190811157227, -1.0371754169464111, 0.25315362215042114, -0.22888699173927307, 0.24419862031936646, 0.21432790160179138, 0.09014856070280075, -0.4035223722457886, -0.40293166041374207, -0.5859088897705078, -0.4068814814090729, 0.17404146492481232, -0.2688833177089691, 0.20414194464683533, 0.6117011904716492, 0.31454387307167053, 0.036514200270175934, -0.09437848627567291, 0.611748456954956, -0.09300734847784042, -0.803445041179657, -0.6089208722114563, -1.5736392736434937, -0.2828645408153534, -0.9886927008628845, -0.6153112649917603, -0.22102458775043488, -0.17837893962860107, -0.11734773963689804, 0.016357511281967163, 0.02929263934493065, -0.43080732226371765, 0.07039976119995117, 0.9422503709793091, -0.5522750020027161, -0.8734181523323059, -0.6915181875228882, -0.15977850556373596, 0.050667162984609604, -0.8129706978797913, -0.18702076375484467, -0.2053246945142746, -0.2088003009557724, 0.6592550277709961, 0.20100438594818115, 0.2189907729625702, -0.2815212905406952, -0.4703368544578552, 0.3465787172317505, 0.17127405107021332, -1.2239927053451538, 0.6053808331489563, -0.5698321461677551, 0.8993346095085144, 0.4871976375579834, 0.6108641624450684, -0.10043488442897797, 0.2259850949048996, -1.1948459148406982, 0.11159838736057281, 0.44280505180358887, -0.08770646899938583, -0.19192293286323547, -0.8763689994812012, 0.10320756584405899, -0.05787811800837517, -0.4539821743965149, 0.6746929883956909, 0.01547545101493597, 0.06523313373327255, -0.8998759984970093, 0.8285952806472778, 0.1222938671708107, 0.3256951868534088, -0.36093512177467346, 0.450999915599823, -1.1856200695037842, -0.28755298256874084, 0.393484503030777, -0.14361530542373657, -0.14370007812976837, -0.7098034620285034, 0.8520431518554688, -0.035443197935819626, 0.7227106690406799, 0.07394320517778397, -0.06967750936746597, 0.14025694131851196, -0.34942346811294556, -0.32261818647384644, -0.3163706064224243, 0.3954503536224365, 0.17657062411308289, 0.6712253093719482, 0.1431628316640854, -0.24084065854549408, 0.28020554780960083, -0.44983184337615967, -1.09136962890625, -0.23301827907562256, -0.47965407371520996, -0.49080851674079895, 0.4239963889122009, 0.3026333451271057, 0.21478469669818878, 0.5005108714103699, -0.17479132115840912, 0.11139943450689316, -0.004769572988152504, 1.3283189535140991, 0.712554395198822, -0.6739808917045593, -0.5170283913612366, -0.30707260966300964, -0.7488018274307251, -0.12578599154949188, -0.16694952547550201, 0.5825546383857727, -0.357022225856781, -0.22102272510528564, -0.3417558968067169, 0.1889832615852356, 0.04688464477658272, -0.42227113246917725, 0.22330108284950256, -0.5164654850959778, -0.09345000982284546, -0.2146824449300766, -0.05395927652716637, -0.13746735453605652, -0.3467216491699219, 0.3566302955150604, 0.0008165277540683746, -0.6762274503707886, -0.3255755305290222, 0.21264787018299103, 0.20260301232337952, -0.2075316160917282, 0.004068540409207344, 0.9652894139289856, -0.07043498009443283, 0.11660819500684738, 0.18524658679962158, 0.27771058678627014, 0.49949440360069275, 0.5985247492790222, -0.6427642703056335, 0.6614123582839966, 0.7303926944732666, 0.08943227678537369, 0.880488395690918, 0.03539794683456421, -0.24866604804992676, 0.38201016187667847, 0.4376917779445648, -0.19918863475322723, -0.21414688229560852, -0.13054654002189636, 0.3171364367008209, 0.5346755981445312, -0.08047015219926834, 0.05574381351470947, 0.08057429641485214, 0.19148468971252441, 0.7294775247573853, -0.48796385526657104, -0.6559288501739502, -0.33380597829818726, 0.6777291893959045, 0.5518471598625183, -0.7046327590942383, -0.6825476884841919, -0.15852010250091553, 0.06380053609609604, 0.11334202438592911, -0.08246017247438431, -0.5092269778251648, -0.11486168205738068, -0.04892706498503685, -0.7070464491844177, 0.1337609589099884, 0.9297815561294556, -0.048044025897979736, 1.265066385269165, 1.0524392127990723, 0.3745368719100952, 0.19551071524620056, 0.49830833077430725, 0.30585095286369324, -0.6165027022361755, 0.007639785297214985, 0.019020458683371544, -0.8954570293426514, 0.5062580704689026, -0.0666642040014267, -0.31241318583488464, -0.6514258980751038, -0.37125369906425476, 0.09688514471054077, -0.42439162731170654, 0.27620625495910645, -0.27003157138824463, -0.3358713388442993, -0.28665369749069214, 0.2142409235239029, 0.3383048474788666, 0.3272406756877899, 0.10118409246206284, 0.37223565578460693, 0.3450184464454651, 0.8645286560058594, 1.041425108909607, 0.6054612994194031, 0.47753646969795227, -0.5219237208366394, -0.24563679099082947, 0.6607116460800171, 0.3703899383544922, -0.5695950984954834, 0.766320526599884, -0.5676630139350891, -0.10262668132781982, 0.3503037393093109, 0.3010350465774536, -0.15513771772384644, -0.08477964997291565, 0.45853936672210693, 0.6606206297874451, -0.17754928767681122, 0.47085878252983093, 0.6865299344062805, 0.3825512230396271, -0.9045629501342773, -0.2335537225008011, 0.5817393064498901, -0.9821180701255798, 0.2809794545173645, -1.1402267217636108, 0.34219592809677124, 0.06935080140829086, -0.3059837818145752, -0.33656319975852966, -0.5366538166999817, -0.646748960018158, -0.7119907140731812, 0.30685415863990784, -0.49499908089637756, 0.0937090739607811, 0.883257269859314, -0.10274297744035721, 0.27200815081596375, -0.23009110987186432, -0.8678606152534485, -0.383636474609375, 1.0761855840682983, 0.008490732870995998, 0.4059707224369049, 0.9121587872505188, 0.055147070437669754, -0.6521503329277039, 0.7769378423690796, 0.323772132396698, -0.6653207540512085, 0.5136874318122864, -0.2111954241991043, -0.03821122273802757, 0.3139753043651581, -0.4404813349246979, 0.31333082914352417, 0.21902410686016083, 0.4182746112346649, 0.503681480884552, 0.054582588374614716, 0.25121620297431946, -0.03745470196008682, -0.30986469984054565, -0.2721787095069885, -0.2693426311016083, -0.006737283430993557, -0.21495142579078674, 0.5607292652130127, -0.9649786353111267, 4.057382106781006, 0.8958596587181091, 0.023593870922923088, 0.4364565908908844, 0.5954291820526123, 1.4068284034729004, -0.12385391443967819, 0.16762936115264893, 0.17801101505756378, -0.783599317073822, -0.3107515871524811, -0.10965199023485184, 0.6291171908378601, 0.004894379060715437, -0.27087411284446716, 0.27110743522644043, 0.1299484521150589, 0.005681516602635384, -0.5212451219558716, -0.10158547759056091, -0.5690285563468933, 0.4902265667915344, -0.442162424325943, 0.022209206596016884, 0.70615553855896, 0.42041847109794617, -0.20131704211235046, -0.4584200382232666, -1.0079658031463623, -0.9444120526313782, -0.818821370601654, -0.28673824667930603, -0.26461607217788696, -0.35874149203300476, -1.084917426109314, 0.0668061152100563, -0.05701209604740143, -0.7686926126480103, 0.5909059643745422, 0.46936938166618347, 0.17506223917007446, -0.10851550102233887, 1.3300549983978271, -0.5697857737541199, 0.3851205110549927, 0.5640425682067871, 0.42734017968177795, 0.8319077491760254, 0.4244318902492523, -0.6161606907844543, 0.05142734572291374, 0.25134825706481934, 0.24371354281902313, -0.6552839875221252, -0.6924667954444885, -0.46249517798423767, -0.3422335982322693, 0.1781962662935257, 0.4930448830127716, 0.2440372258424759, 0.04539268836379051, -0.03412994369864464, -0.35241106152534485, 0.2992604076862335, 0.12220785766839981, 0.30396249890327454, 0.0021657426841557026, -0.16617418825626373, 0.47246047854423523, -0.5032846927642822, -0.25018438696861267, -0.613429844379425, -0.09161776304244995, -0.7923519611358643, 0.13714678585529327, 0.16613653302192688, -0.23914986848831177, 0.8165252804756165, 0.0033677564933896065, 0.4670085310935974, -0.44640734791755676, 0.18323838710784912, -0.07637744396924973, -0.1578795164823532, -0.267410010099411, 0.2330598086118698, -0.5658965706825256, -0.01336485706269741, -0.6505827903747559, 0.5729607343673706, 0.27109965682029724, 1.3839526176452637, -0.1234884113073349, 0.17951810359954834, -0.9377493858337402 ]
Chern--Simons Gravity from 3+1 Dimensional Gravity
In the context of a Poincar\'e gauge theoretical formulation, pure gravity in 3+1-dimensions is dimensionally reduced to gravity in 2+1-dimensions with or without cosmological constant $\Lambda$. The dimensional reductions are consistent with the gauge symmetries, mapping ISO(3, 1) gauge transformations into ISO(2,1) ones. One of the reductions leads to Chern-Simons-Witten gravity. The solutions of 2+1-gravity with $\Lambda\le 0$ (in particular the black-hole solution recently found by Banados, Teitelboim and Zanelli) and those of 1+1-dimensional Liouville gravity, are thus mapped into 3+1-dimensional vacuum solutions.
G. Grignani and G. Nardelli
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211001
gr-qc/9211002
[ 0.16493195295333862, 0.20498335361480713, 0.6006407737731934, 0.178466334939003, -0.36178404092788696, 0.05467861518263817, -0.24293915927410126, 0.08292821049690247, -0.6815508604049683, 0.966481626033783, 0.6338778734207153, 0.12988048791885376, -0.5332069993019104, -1.0615910291671753, -0.4948228597640991, 0.31996646523475647, -0.2746354043483734, -0.3711949288845062, -1.085019588470459, 0.15135473012924194, 0.20482204854488373, 0.0015686569968238473, -1.369764804840088, -0.40378832817077637, 0.06354366987943649, 0.710282027721405, 1.1692994832992554, 0.08057372272014618, 1.173641324043274, 0.6024132370948792, 0.3404507637023926, -0.35931017994880676, -0.29915541410446167, -0.8663161993026733, 0.033651892095804214, 0.05699322745203972, 0.9352089762687683, 0.04240918532013893, 0.5563789010047913, -0.10828343778848648, 0.5408089756965637, -0.01160954125225544, 0.22173534333705902, -0.825027585029602, -0.6605299711227417, 0.009526731446385384, -0.13501198589801788, 0.03208450227975845, 0.005530694965273142, -1.2447431087493896, -0.4303045868873596, -0.019632192328572273, 0.20591148734092712, -1.3104342222213745, -0.23663358390331268, 0.3709675669670105, 0.5016085505485535, 0.06530661880970001, -0.8468196392059326, -0.582719624042511, 0.30223485827445984, 0.9247656464576721, 0.28378504514694214, -0.3658938705921173, -0.08872559666633606, 0.9769219756126404, 0.15497182309627533, 0.43046310544013977, 0.22275443375110626, 0.25719067454338074, -0.03274500370025635, -0.696766197681427, 0.22055645287036896, 0.08373402059078217, -0.25343307852745056, 0.39428767561912537, -0.296407014131546, -0.277069091796875, -0.5370447039604187, -0.23310919106006622, -0.19479645788669586, 0.04650437831878662, -0.06302034109830856, 0.5544575452804565, -0.00875154510140419, -0.35318201780319214, 0.7166866064071655, 0.12290271371603012, 0.7117875814437866, 0.29797878861427307, -0.8572167158126831, 0.4849352240562439, 0.215369313955307, -0.29521414637565613, 0.7269879579544067, 0.4795941412448883, -0.2067854404449463, 0.57157963514328, 0.05059611797332764, 0.2784067392349243, -0.2680268883705139, 0.5713006258010864, -0.026526784524321556, -0.21595773100852966, -0.7302117347717285, 1.6573013067245483, -0.49671244621276855, 0.24038662016391754, -0.4411570429801941, -0.32924237847328186, 0.44086524844169617, 0.3914967477321625, 0.42823031544685364, 0.03771132975816727, -0.030198797583580017, 0.050009243190288544, -0.4503494203090668, -0.22711092233657837, -0.4977181553840637, -0.2361084371805191, -0.20472124218940735, 0.9600210785865784, 0.9095205664634705, 0.08975856751203537, 0.05433494597673416, -1.1011556386947632, -0.26942428946495056, -0.02564225159585476, -0.9201000928878784, -0.10747080296278, 0.09417976438999176, -0.9037637114524841, 0.24077573418617249, 0.3840201497077942, 0.11272812634706497, 0.02478007972240448, 0.17179813981056213, -0.05281269922852516, -0.574738621711731, -0.29221805930137634, 0.437808096408844, -0.28771907091140747, 0.6955064535140991, 0.9440470337867737, -0.629804790019989, 0.4395657777786255, 0.1199910119175911, 0.3377368748188019, -0.34975460171699524, 0.2406219244003296, -0.14247243106365204, -0.3469272255897522, 0.009640416130423546, 0.050641074776649475, 0.09106399118900299, -0.47068729996681213, -1.0197659730911255, 0.07365618646144867, 0.5399273037910461, -0.40338465571403503, 0.5655965805053711, -0.19097591936588287, 0.24626024067401886, 1.3014343976974487, -0.5133857131004333, 0.05973862111568451, -0.5932695269584656, 0.2923574447631836, 0.29639989137649536, -0.00423898221924901, 0.21159373223781586, -0.1795072853565216, 0.42817971110343933, 0.32210326194763184, 0.9067181348800659, 0.7655020952224731, -0.05969732999801636, 0.4073866307735443, -0.808140754699707, 0.14700818061828613, 0.3726235330104828, -0.9476991891860962, 1.2623213529586792, 0.3821399509906769, -0.41546136140823364, -0.32469794154167175, 0.1360945701599121, 0.3606192469596863, 0.2254975140094757, 0.48875316977500916, -0.4353162348270416, 0.24002690613269806, -1.6287271976470947, 0.926345944404602, -0.7494921684265137, -0.38477590680122375, -1.112290859222412, 0.4191875755786896, -0.2140761911869049, -0.2271708995103836, 0.15504983067512512, 0.05393190309405327, -1.4278956651687622, 0.26057928800582886, -1.1830791234970093, 0.06900807470083237, 0.29245537519454956, 0.4424228370189667, -0.5922595858573914, 0.13523077964782715, 0.7020488977432251, -0.37569552659988403, 0.008628811687231064, 0.47312867641448975, 0.3299142122268677, 0.10885877907276154, 0.003956934902817011, 0.3921787440776825, -0.09124310314655304, 0.4396902322769165, 0.8401589393615723, 0.09626184403896332, -0.3211461305618286, 0.7824726700782776, 0.4697771966457367, -0.40977880358695984, 0.14152023196220398, 0.9717962145805359, -0.7222524285316467, 0.07913840562105179, 0.0895116776227951, -0.28918203711509705, -0.05505141243338585, -0.19077160954475403, 0.3184196352958679, 0.12304197996854782, 0.7993082404136658, 1.028786063194275, -0.17719052731990814, -0.3997926414012909, 0.2535163462162018, -0.15817514061927795, 0.7591345906257629, -0.37430548667907715, -0.6345658302307129, 0.8156507015228271, 0.4335308074951172, -0.06667249649763107, -0.4959864616394043, 0.8579352498054504, -0.30281153321266174, 0.7150489091873169, 0.1596178263425827, 0.24096143245697021, -1.4980087280273438, 0.11022620648145676, 0.11615057289600372, 0.3638089597225189, -0.3222842812538147, -0.8770580887794495, 0.24102482199668884, 0.22785653173923492, 0.40349188446998596, -0.26568692922592163, -0.18507501482963562, 0.23591619729995728, -0.8710748553276062, 0.17194193601608276, 0.6524959206581116, -0.2891935408115387, -0.7994784712791443, -0.24328146874904633, -0.5073691010475159, -0.29564130306243896, -0.11505579948425293, 0.2089838832616806, -0.06893041729927063, -0.34297314286231995, 0.5178340673446655, 0.28558480739593506, -0.3044225573539734, 0.0024264096282422543, -0.04523394629359245, 0.09916390478610992, 0.20487500727176666, 0.14516320824623108, -0.5645381808280945, 0.33554449677467346, -1.3433395624160767, 0.4958183765411377, 0.2735344171524048, -0.8073133230209351, 0.2908588647842407, -0.9761899709701538, 0.23683181405067444, 0.2998657524585724, -0.48320266604423523, 0.4776235818862915, -0.35929644107818604, -0.7032660841941833, 0.4998955726623535, 0.495904803276062, -0.32245343923568726, 0.08554884046316147, -0.43211862444877625, 1.2362319231033325, -0.2918095290660858, -0.3818439841270447, 0.7893508672714233, -0.4156729280948639, -0.6945492029190063, 0.3718368411064148, -0.0003729197196662426, 0.5188383460044861, -0.5391570925712585, 0.6580060124397278, 0.9813121557235718, -0.1720954179763794, -0.14779303967952728, -0.5259760022163391, -0.610784649848938, 0.069620780646801, 0.32381197810173035, -0.6269600987434387, 0.24389204382896423, 0.9116482138633728, -0.15352627635002136, -0.7658931016921997, 0.3364568054676056, -1.1376407146453857, -0.8798991441726685, -0.24740782380104065, -0.40823251008987427, 0.06887749582529068, -0.27118614315986633, 0.28471413254737854, -0.06358607858419418, -0.014204394072294235, -0.36809858679771423, 0.9771422147750854, 0.8259252905845642, -0.608633279800415, -0.16873589158058167, 0.6121690273284912, 0.32829517126083374, 0.673368513584137, 0.5997015833854675, 0.07292308658361435, -0.16382430493831635, 0.2781972587108612, -0.18018177151679993, 0.4271397888660431, -0.050787512212991714, 0.17687860131263733, 0.11726082861423492, -0.3334553837776184, -0.40070009231567383, -0.3738822042942047, -1.1493794918060303, -0.3404659628868103, 0.1826542168855667, 0.2788354456424713, 0.5326540470123291, -1.121463418006897, -0.6145069003105164, 0.10116647183895111, -0.19247955083847046, 0.14796310663223267, 0.12072747945785522, -0.8618624806404114, -0.014790039509534836, 0.12130173295736313, -0.3310110569000244, -0.3697862923145294, 0.09165295213460922, 0.4388868808746338, 0.5622067451477051, 1.1277638673782349, -0.040625784546136856, -0.15832370519638062, -0.24386216700077057, -0.5243078470230103, 0.8301135301589966, -0.12180079519748688, 0.19382958114147186, -0.706434965133667, -0.1423146277666092, 0.044655490666627884, -0.2799282371997833, -0.6490132808685303, -0.607959508895874, -0.5552659034729004, 0.3193635046482086, -0.9098225831985474, -0.5014204978942871, 0.11271592229604721, 0.5672791600227356, 0.2682228088378906, -0.03611798584461212, 0.35655856132507324, 0.16661149263381958, -0.28723564743995667, 0.3713150918483734, 0.5639168620109558, -0.2545129656791687, -0.3334449529647827, -0.6485623121261597, 1.019218921661377, 0.714457094669342, 0.5422976613044739, 0.5840665102005005, -0.6751351356506348, 0.5627548098564148, -0.6341373324394226, 0.973768949508667, 0.3762105703353882, -0.3059351146221161, 0.3294423818588257, 0.07464805990457535, 0.06377533823251724, -0.5785057544708252, 0.4192677438259125, -0.0002681817568372935, 0.2795755863189697, 0.3111671209335327, -0.7632513642311096, 0.0168117955327034, -0.8949156403541565, 0.6078693270683289, 0.6365913152694702, -0.0817328691482544, -0.711977481842041, -0.1678413450717926, 0.04959519952535629, 0.3120892345905304, 0.009486567229032516, 0.9475404620170593, 0.2454233318567276, 0.3566073477268219, -0.11337930709123611, -0.14121384918689728, 1.1111550331115723, -0.7143344283103943, -0.2805817723274231, 0.004233892075717449, -0.12223173677921295, -0.0708630383014679, 0.424919456243515, 0.2157561331987381, -0.7025654911994934, -0.12524951994419098, -0.10747243463993073, 0.6517763733863831, -0.27822214365005493, -0.8502217531204224, 0.1634598672389984, 0.15573546290397644, -0.5530180335044861, 0.2794218063354492, -0.05788404867053032, -0.11978340893983841, -0.10446973890066147, -0.242373988032341, -0.28413820266723633, -0.28468310832977295, 0.17247189581394196, -0.044742923229932785, 0.7453063130378723, -0.05265374854207039, 0.35660436749458313, 1.217846393585205, 0.45241808891296387, 0.0881047323346138, 0.3952302932739258, 0.5245288610458374, -0.45516908168792725, -0.181519016623497, -0.4270540177822113, -0.32412993907928467, -0.44932883977890015, -0.7097607851028442, -0.11772747337818146, -0.7837362289428711, 0.06773535162210464, 0.30749642848968506, -1.187817096710205, -0.5785610675811768, -0.2885238528251648, -0.7709455490112305, 0.7216002941131592, -0.6480481624603271, -0.40771910548210144, -0.44688042998313904, -0.3063278794288635, -0.09653958678245544, 0.01928812451660633, -0.2691371738910675, -0.21041828393936157, -0.3157694935798645, 0.3926544189453125, -0.08007378876209259, 0.29539480805397034, -0.3937770426273346, 0.7833333015441895, 0.40284264087677, -0.5585331916809082, -1.0362077951431274, -0.9290629029273987, 0.19241023063659668, 0.04064399003982544, -0.09618455916643143, -0.09763592481613159, 0.42383578419685364, 0.22011509537696838, 0.26966577768325806, 0.39631035923957825, 0.3569270372390747, -0.9378226399421692, -0.34785744547843933, 1.01331627368927, -0.07623989880084991, -0.38051125407218933, -0.0982818752527237, 0.6001718640327454, -0.16956934332847595, 0.6560057997703552, -0.7330272197723389, -0.4409913718700409, 0.3512316048145294, -0.9849572777748108, 0.22072608768939972, -1.0332447290420532, -0.5328854918479919, -0.3821965754032135, -0.6365768909454346, 0.19135820865631104, 0.13283072412014008, 0.3193119168281555, -0.21697799861431122, -0.5268979072570801, -0.46817925572395325, 0.0897628664970398, -0.3892979323863983, 0.3822880685329437, -0.35216355323791504, -0.08362957090139389, -0.8567624688148499, 1.2521542310714722, -0.9646837115287781, 0.12964436411857605, 0.5005150437355042, 0.2839057743549347, -0.21626253426074982, 0.6353289484977722, -0.15436121821403503, 0.18992610275745392, -0.722536563873291, 0.1089056208729744, 0.6519651412963867, -0.16128279268741608, 0.15563203394412994, 0.47605422139167786, -0.7697123885154724, 0.7356333136558533, -0.024340501055121422, -0.48683130741119385, 0.38982439041137695, -0.5820238590240479, -0.03932899236679077, -0.29888156056404114, -0.30703482031822205, 0.746014416217804, 0.18820376694202423, 0.4791313111782074, 0.5248183012008667, -0.40666595101356506, -0.6043751835823059, -0.2668353021144867, -0.6348015666007996, 0.5966761708259583, 0.32854220271110535, -0.06630153208971024, 0.1068452000617981, -0.2752918601036072, -0.4219959080219269, -0.9094974398612976, -0.012789303436875343, 0.10078109800815582, -0.06094105914235115, 0.20792263746261597, -0.7255427241325378, 0.5002545714378357, -0.4515608847141266, 0.3177417814731598, -0.01000780239701271, 0.2130773961544037, 0.3390028774738312, 0.05361194908618927, -0.932478666305542, -0.8739821910858154, -0.5854506492614746, 0.5806284546852112, 0.5220481753349304, -0.28175705671310425, 1.419049620628357, 0.45998188853263855, -0.12429115921258926, -0.5535143613815308, 0.48170799016952515, 0.38383591175079346, -0.20400720834732056, 0.5771371722221375, 0.1033027172088623, 0.3189954161643982, -0.299542635679245, 0.09607395529747009, -0.5127519369125366, -0.5297212600708008, 0.8491803407669067, -0.9341357946395874, -0.44439321756362915, 0.639281153678894, 0.31319135427474976, -0.26984935998916626, -0.6491950154304504, -0.664671003818512, -0.6141251921653748, 0.08556453883647919, -0.9957963228225708, 0.6573240160942078, -0.28038206696510315, -0.5614392161369324, 0.20572897791862488, 0.3612235486507416, 0.2351740002632141, 0.5312859416007996, -0.04184266924858093, 0.5241950750350952, -0.5212135910987854, -0.3459354341030121, 0.8719676733016968, 0.224895179271698, -0.5564871430397034, 0.07489388436079025, 0.39439857006073, -0.554520308971405, -0.3949493169784546, 1.1315573453903198, -0.11107957363128662, -0.1477166712284088, 0.3328712284564972, 0.075432687997818, 0.34809282422065735, -0.22568216919898987, 0.20683683454990387, -0.36607956886291504, -0.8356117010116577, -0.8028979301452637, -0.13389790058135986, 0.1458052098751068, 0.27533984184265137, 0.1975993812084198, 0.37081179022789, -0.175083190202713, -0.107578806579113, 0.569475531578064, 0.006447795312851667, -0.8432970643043518, -0.21824392676353455, -1.1599535942077637, -0.7759693264961243, -0.6920634508132935, -0.410586953163147, -0.00933308620005846, 1.0057398080825806, -0.6006758213043213, 0.5645968914031982, -0.16118818521499634, -0.023071706295013428, 0.15170599520206451, 0.5957431793212891, -0.35969078540802, -0.4968894124031067, -0.4024866223335266, -0.19988444447517395, 0.28397873044013977, -1.0925092697143555, -0.37990832328796387, 0.12309838831424713, 0.17993859946727753, 0.9021065831184387, -0.2119310349225998, 0.5719779133796692, -0.1508040577173233, -0.8361974954605103, 0.6075880527496338, 0.38112515211105347, -0.643945574760437, 0.5905294418334961, -0.6371469497680664, 1.1579091548919678, 0.36819255352020264, 0.36307522654533386, -0.636813223361969, 0.13312017917633057, -1.1501318216323853, 0.9810559749603271, 0.4562534689903259, 1.0008013248443604, 0.04842779412865639, -0.5383052229881287, 0.4785033166408539, -0.12963801622390747, -0.6973980665206909, -0.1904677003622055, 0.030684107914566994, 0.709602952003479, -0.39703288674354553, -0.21838513016700745, -0.21782851219177246, 0.9420188665390015, 0.1420697122812271, -0.21678104996681213, -0.7507843971252441, 0.1055615171790123, 0.11347327381372452, -0.05965448170900345, 0.3385791778564453, -0.2933948338031769, 0.1250084936618805, -0.5449492335319519, 0.12767457962036133, 0.09514782577753067, -0.13724751770496368, -0.2306140661239624, 0.25992992520332336, -0.15690816938877106, -0.4512697458267212, 0.41326138377189636, -0.69314044713974, 0.900448739528656, 0.5857158899307251, -0.06643437594175339, 0.25350216031074524, -0.3400461673736572, -0.6715347766876221, 0.5639674663543701, -0.4934405982494354, -0.9843665957450867, 0.4059848189353943, -0.051830802112817764, 0.277560830116272, 0.4728078246116638, -0.553955614566803, 0.07801494747400284, -0.07859864830970764, 0.7294262647628784, 1.213724136352539, -0.06635505706071854, -0.2844625413417816, 0.11398062109947205, -1.1224287748336792, -0.8094865083694458, -0.39721158146858215, 0.05191129446029663, -1.2145304679870605, -0.544350266456604, -0.1433093398809433, 0.05380277335643768, -0.17390277981758118, -0.13659684360027313, 0.05277423933148384, 0.6471890807151794, 0.12795555591583252, -0.2477971613407135, -0.3111024796962738, -0.2839723825454712, -0.46023377776145935, 0.4510171711444855, -0.2915719449520111, -0.1806786060333252, -0.15447041392326355, -0.1854993999004364, 0.8334972858428955, 0.5866033434867859, -0.23813581466674805, 1.3620685338974, 0.5370070338249207, -0.4878389537334442, 0.2833004593849182, 0.4205465614795685, 0.24318896234035492, 0.4273507297039032, -0.6375008821487427, 0.2004028707742691, 0.5797919631004333, 0.07660584896802902, 1.0423840284347534, -0.22847571969032288, -0.20407935976982117, 0.2947852313518524, 0.3161843717098236, -0.3971644937992096, -0.4867898225784302, 0.5408306121826172, 0.5352360010147095, -0.1509568691253662, -0.36573827266693115, -0.5525860786437988, -0.2296571582555771, 0.11554776877164841, 0.5323748588562012, -0.32416796684265137, 0.2910023331642151, -0.5498150587081909, -0.26763206720352173, 0.3514639139175415, -0.4664164185523987, -0.6664032936096191, -0.751725971698761, 0.18868127465248108, 0.4273786246776581, -0.41288241744041443, -0.21657302975654602, 0.6210779547691345, 0.38659346103668213, 0.2144753634929657, -0.004183510318398476, 0.6201685070991516, 0.284097820520401, 0.5067747235298157, 0.49132317304611206, 0.2892836332321167, 0.11718573421239853, 0.7588539719581604, 0.033261287957429886, -0.36506879329681396, 0.10049603134393692, 0.23341774940490723, -1.2212454080581665, 0.20950347185134888, -0.16206130385398865, -0.08658664673566818, -1.0022274255752563, -0.5093916058540344, -0.20981167256832123, -0.9177416563034058, 0.49222221970558167, -0.05972271412611008, -0.4461388885974884, -0.27860841155052185, 0.7553139328956604, 0.3919393718242645, 0.09197250008583069, 0.23631468415260315, 0.3425125777721405, 0.22245389223098755, 0.5535226464271545, 0.8340182900428772, 0.5324698090553284, 0.13528907299041748, -0.3293260335922241, -0.05823303759098053, 0.47781234979629517, 0.03679696097970009, 0.21866364777088165, 0.9618700742721558, -0.3478171229362488, 0.015467269346117973, -0.3280174434185028, -0.013568767346441746, -0.5534667372703552, 0.02021072991192341, 0.733839750289917, 0.8049371838569641, 0.21016240119934082, 0.38915523886680603, 0.2994768023490906, 0.49735215306282043, -0.12867136299610138, -0.6779038906097412, 0.5713432431221008, -0.8444857001304626, -0.0033341189846396446, -1.1065365076065063, 0.48410099744796753, 0.15686273574829102, -0.020527316257357597, -0.7338163256645203, 0.18483512103557587, -0.11235398054122925, -0.2923426926136017, -0.18932072818279266, -0.4196849465370178, -0.38424187898635864, 0.2936030328273773, -0.5681296586990356, -0.014403203502297401, -0.43606996536254883, -0.10589007288217545, 0.10567430406808853, 1.1124444007873535, -0.4290176033973694, -0.0521855391561985, 1.0904029607772827, 0.030586829409003258, -1.1086469888687134, 1.2571698427200317, 0.434783935546875, -0.43728405237197876, 0.4596053659915924, -0.22472746670246124, 0.3852623701095581, 0.1678500473499298, -0.5485737323760986, 0.08346050977706909, 0.06600568443536758, 0.8813849687576294, -0.3457273244857788, -0.3127749264240265, 0.12426282465457916, -0.4888550639152527, -0.2393549680709839, -0.2021009624004364, 0.17951162159442902, 0.8393599987030029, -0.1814786195755005, 0.1551576405763626, -0.7398300170898438, 4.1306471824646, 0.9434134364128113, 0.29450640082359314, -0.5988413691520691, 1.0377392768859863, 0.6698248386383057, -0.041386112570762634, 0.018513506278395653, 0.2624025046825409, -1.1858645677566528, -0.11095187813043594, 0.6321154236793518, 0.0941389799118042, -0.3831707239151001, 0.2724105715751648, 0.514565110206604, -0.017475444823503494, -0.1908947080373764, -0.23028267920017242, 0.2565661370754242, -1.406236171722412, 0.12792250514030457, 0.5345982313156128, -0.2459038347005844, 0.6953054070472717, 0.7573872804641724, 0.0614069439470768, -0.6131144762039185, -0.4282020926475525, -0.2748596668243408, -0.4230133295059204, -0.8148518800735474, -0.10241539776325226, -0.19886817038059235, -0.7318021655082703, 0.45072194933891296, -0.04064727947115898, -0.1932656168937683, 0.09717436134815216, -0.09641266614198685, 0.10505659878253937, -0.5511071681976318, 0.09135553240776062, -0.6128572225570679, 0.07420172542333603, 0.7394583821296692, 0.41640186309814453, 0.6416357755661011, 0.11411435902118683, -0.9199963212013245, 0.2209429144859314, -0.22827103734016418, 0.23057708144187927, -0.5541256070137024, -0.5873926281929016, -0.6304008364677429, 0.14348569512367249, 0.014744973741471767, 0.4204031527042389, -0.08983461558818817, 0.6883531212806702, -0.27851516008377075, -0.3429255187511444, 0.48881933093070984, 0.2555816173553467, 0.011355044320225716, 0.48150399327278137, -0.23564134538173676, -0.05960635468363762, -0.009330258704721928, -0.9301639199256897, -0.1590353101491928, -0.6550005674362183, -0.3742053806781769, 0.743487536907196, -0.08152737468481064, 0.1854114830493927, 0.4962312579154968, -0.6339699625968933, 0.29329249262809753, -0.12517699599266052, 0.06026499345898628, -0.25577428936958313, -0.05776190757751465, -0.2720172703266144, 0.8206785917282104, 0.254960834980011, 0.2740878164768219, 0.15252719819545746, 0.6084339022636414, 0.3214963972568512, 0.7998765110969543, -0.29761582612991333, 0.07408370822668076, -0.6008718609809875 ]
Einstein Equation with Quantum Corrections Reduced to Second Order
We consider the Einstein equation with first order (semiclassical) quantum corrections. Although the quantum corrections contain up to fourth order derivatives of the metric, the solutions which are physically relevant satisfy a reduced equations which contain derivatives no higher than second order. We obtain the reduced equations for a range of stress-energy tensors. These reduced equations are suitable for numerical solution, are expected to contain fewer numerical instabilities than the original fourth order equations, and yield only physically relevant solutions. We give analytic and numerical solutions or reduced equations for particular examples, including Friedmann-Lema\^\i tre universes with cosmological constant, a spherical body of constant density, and more general conformally flat metrics.
Leonard Parker and Jonathan Z. Simon
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211002
gr-qc/9211003
[ -0.6117926836013794, -0.4565637707710266, 0.8240426182746887, 0.8080422282218933, -0.3781591057777405, -0.6979596614837646, 0.06877729296684265, -0.3315925598144531, -0.3453287184238434, 1.0077253580093384, -0.11667615175247192, 1.0214424133300781, -0.0028885628562420607, 0.3690120577812195, -1.0246378183364868, -0.05562010779976845, -0.1962600201368332, -0.5536031126976013, -0.5285083055496216, 0.1701890230178833, -0.4716538190841675, -0.5762299299240112, -1.0282021760940552, -0.17810845375061035, -0.3470955491065979, 0.014987153932452202, -0.6225471496582031, -0.17277637124061584, 1.6217317581176758, 1.164672613143921, -0.3119044005870819, 0.13279882073402405, 0.22312454879283905, 0.040281686931848526, -0.008345283567905426, -1.1346912384033203, -0.027675706893205643, -0.385578989982605, 0.382225900888443, -0.9521055817604065, 0.6582925319671631, -0.1903093159198761, -0.015648651868104935, -0.611258327960968, -1.302351951599121, -0.13710413873195648, 0.35213711857795715, 0.7044735550880432, 0.04362015053629875, -0.8175644278526306, -0.20326445996761322, 0.1203896701335907, -0.1350213885307312, -0.08126416802406311, -0.2840072810649872, 0.13266979157924652, 0.3974066972732544, -0.7212333083152771, -0.5833181738853455, 0.3970573842525482, 0.2957359254360199, 0.6750386953353882, 0.2233409881591797, -0.8285999894142151, 0.4194597899913788, 0.362047016620636, -0.4769369661808014, -0.1635182797908783, -0.6866961717605591, 0.48542290925979614, 0.1377526819705963, -0.25988900661468506, -0.43399882316589355, -0.6916301846504211, -0.4159444570541382, 0.7053877711296082, -0.04555495083332062, -0.14329658448696136, -0.5668724775314331, 1.0359936952590942, -0.5558412671089172, -0.08404668420553207, 0.5666792392730713, -0.5595290660858154, -0.8705030679702759, 0.4776877462863922, 0.704684853553772, -0.13443623483181, 0.9383474588394165, -0.053470760583877563, -0.5931020379066467, 0.49004635214805603, -0.3083227872848511, 0.3661195933818817, -0.03486168012022972, 0.336127370595932, -0.15914683043956757, 0.03657316789031029, -1.0326390266418457, -0.173052117228508, 0.6769940853118896, 0.1748781055212021, 0.06589341908693314, 0.8481062054634094, -0.6370198130607605, 0.00004917094702250324, 0.782565712928772, -0.17507819831371307, -1.0458495616912842, 0.11123942583799362, -0.17693118751049042, 0.08907235413789749, -0.3642585575580597, 0.32984867691993713, -0.45610228180885315, 0.4290271997451782, 0.4831256866455078, 0.6635433435440063, -1.0251895189285278, -0.2306639850139618, 0.7847539186477661, 0.3981562554836273, 0.0562015138566494, 0.09910226613283157, 0.06501754373311996, 0.12158600986003876, 0.2880472242832184, 1.21363365650177, -0.40316078066825867, 0.234711691737175, 0.816696047782898, 0.3124218285083771, 0.5083233714103699, 0.2506266236305237, 0.45325207710266113, 0.39920610189437866, -0.1943085491657257, 0.42507222294807434, 0.9811474680900574, -0.5459255576133728, -0.004249779507517815, 0.1692558079957962, 0.14025700092315674, 0.896943986415863, -1.2481998205184937, 0.18505994975566864, 0.5096523761749268, -0.21473541855812073, -0.855623185634613, 0.2581312358379364, -0.20047566294670105, 0.0022612980101257563, -0.006730065215379, 0.25655829906463623, -0.40955236554145813, 0.10799656808376312, 0.49635738134384155, -0.8728352189064026, 0.08629819005727768, -0.08073548972606659, -0.11804770678281784, 0.689789891242981, 0.29748159646987915, 0.8785089254379272, -0.5480834245681763, 0.6946809887886047, -1.1839388608932495, -0.3938203454017639, 0.31187790632247925, -0.4871554374694824, -0.13126656413078308, 0.08593419939279556, -0.5227569937705994, 0.2213517129421234, 0.8205441236495972, -0.005658173467963934, 0.04345589503645897, -0.1924646943807602, 1.3061234951019287, 0.8184655904769897, -0.17905065417289734, 0.648677408695221, 0.17350058257579803, 0.6826088428497314, 0.07120687514543533, 0.07274898886680603, 0.8683221936225891, 0.10433001071214676, -0.7982392907142639, 0.004361088387668133, 0.6742067933082581, 0.07966315746307373, -0.009258110076189041, 0.2892225980758667, -0.09042290598154068, 0.05611301213502884, -0.8508182168006897, 0.49659574031829834, 0.23254553973674774, -0.46233758330345154, -0.9060302972793579, 0.042219534516334534, -1.3466781377792358, 0.3324103057384491, -0.8622115254402161, -0.28657296299934387, 0.6930666565895081, 0.7141571044921875, -0.27630889415740967, 0.22062544524669647, 0.6152136325836182, 0.0013316987315192819, -1.3545786142349243, 0.18516701459884644, 0.11211154609918594, -0.7076593041419983, 0.2335052192211151, 0.8329370021820068, -0.21008571982383728, 0.9867949485778809, -1.0147687196731567, 0.614791214466095, 0.6629791855812073, 0.48702386021614075, 0.25128090381622314, 0.531719446182251, -0.5522865653038025, 0.6234325766563416, 0.041828565299510956, 0.10400675982236862, -0.13539819419384003, 0.279256671667099, 0.22476248443126678, 0.2447928488254547, 0.24110925197601318, 0.6285234093666077, 0.9749904870986938, 0.08199344575405121, -0.7075191140174866, 0.5113458633422852, 0.5422136783599854, 0.9537057280540466, 0.6233865022659302, -0.08147521317005157, 0.2031179666519165, 0.6752718687057495, 0.48038843274116516, 0.21908928453922272, -0.5381156802177429, 0.004283025395125151, -0.04723988100886345, -0.020868506282567978, -0.1418590098619461, -0.04167218133807182, 0.13218888640403748, 0.16326597332954407, 0.4062640964984894, 0.5726684331893921, -0.727765679359436, -0.1579623967409134, -0.08978773653507233, 0.5459499955177307, -0.030382806435227394, -0.5696539282798767, 0.4642994701862335, -0.09587010741233826, 0.3481472432613373, 0.5014687776565552, -0.389796644449234, -0.14586956799030304, -0.8215048313140869, -0.41663792729377747, -0.7754999399185181, 0.02393161691725254, -0.9949160814285278, 0.017605474218726158, 0.7196252942085266, -1.077094554901123, 0.863662838935852, -0.1283717304468155, 0.2699742317199707, -0.5914559364318848, -0.15609115362167358, 0.24767562747001648, -0.07500530034303665, 0.6723955869674683, -0.12953558564186096, 0.25359031558036804, 0.05336735397577286, 0.6375924348831177, -0.24599185585975647, -0.1283445507287979, -0.25378844141960144, 0.43985581398010254, 0.14768162369728088, 0.034669410437345505, -0.02577899396419525, 0.23824337124824524, -1.1794021129608154, -1.0827357769012451, -0.583328902721405, -0.7825800180435181, 0.262151300907135, -0.46474412083625793, -0.5711614489555359, 0.09930630773305893, 0.31042611598968506, -0.4781418740749359, 0.5230719447135925, 0.16842231154441833, -0.6869478225708008, 0.011107226833701134, -0.07707229256629944, 0.013841700740158558, -1.1034283638000488, 0.11641789227724075, 0.17059452831745148, -0.18091514706611633, -0.4120120704174042, 0.08979620039463043, -0.5270141363143921, 0.60140061378479, 0.13223454356193542, -0.25737112760543823, 0.054800666868686676, 0.5156421661376953, 0.30322757363319397, -1.0303007364273071, 0.5717693567276001, -0.2981988787651062, -0.11113239824771881, -0.6547773480415344, -1.2066808938980103, -0.08495903015136719, 0.38448426127433777, 0.3656988739967346, 0.4090560972690582, -0.9216776490211487, -0.6397733092308044, 0.43698278069496155, 0.12945467233657837, -0.3923008143901825, -0.1531839221715927, 0.27561700344085693, -0.28364482522010803, 0.01096190232783556, 0.6124052405357361, -0.48077094554901123, 0.30898812413215637, -0.0834295004606247, 0.7454841136932373, 0.2821677625179291, -0.10502486675977707, 0.30549943447113037, 0.07504694163799286, 0.4414786398410797, -0.3720654845237732, -0.21835783123970032, 0.288351833820343, 0.5399084687232971, -0.15070649981498718, 0.1387994885444641, -0.006904566660523415, -0.35607531666755676, 0.22992247343063354, -0.6848769783973694, 0.4463115930557251, 0.7275042533874512, 0.8128568530082703, -0.4548216760158539, -0.33649078011512756, -0.21918676793575287, -0.2609274685382843, 0.6036303043365479, -0.3658107817173004, -0.6439422965049744, 0.32599347829818726, -0.10694051533937454, 1.3631805181503296, -1.2483952045440674, -0.3157093822956085, -0.7198438048362732, 0.6130039095878601, 0.3867720365524292, 0.5247977375984192, 0.006409391760826111, -0.6191321015357971, 0.27498987317085266, -0.0249737948179245, -0.6104559302330017, -0.46815288066864014, 0.2906009256839752, 0.1440303772687912, -0.19901089370250702, -1.3862961530685425, -0.8336548805236816, -0.32184189558029175, 0.22248877584934235, 0.29088228940963745, 1.1568400859832764, 0.45276063680648804, -0.2530023753643036, 0.1272909939289093, 0.5266932249069214, -0.3221418559551239, -0.3967946171760559, -1.0224977731704712, 0.5013500452041626, -0.4075518846511841, 0.10694798827171326, 0.05682750418782234, -0.33709853887557983, -0.02717108279466629, 0.6803927421569824, -0.08019980788230896, 0.033578865230083466, -0.533515453338623, 0.01372689288109541, 0.6399454474449158, 0.02697197161614895, -0.07920494675636292, -0.6084495782852173, -0.6385036110877991, -0.13619297742843628, 0.8376202583312988, -0.7140624523162842, 0.2331511527299881, 0.31853023171424866, 0.41220423579216003, 0.6771735548973083, 0.3306729197502136, -0.6229698657989502, 0.3428893983364105, -1.5233402252197266, -0.9649313688278198, 0.8565248250961304, 0.8093175888061523, 0.1623707115650177, 0.22556689381599426, 0.1994236707687378, 0.35786986351013184, 0.13634097576141357, -1.4927890300750732, -0.020245686173439026, -0.49756181240081787, -0.011470045894384384, 0.2016918808221817, 0.49493494629859924, -0.1413918137550354, -0.8038555383682251, 0.6095751523971558, -0.5912982821464539, 0.7528219819068909, -0.3543563485145569, -0.2909921109676361, -0.38641658425331116, 0.2496957629919052, -0.32231849431991577, 0.39568600058555603, -0.626471757888794, 0.09830881655216217, -0.19328492879867554, -0.6874241232872009, -0.9980623126029968, -0.41632235050201416, 0.6168645024299622, 0.680131733417511, -0.44333818554878235, 0.004184446297585964, 0.4150656759738922, -0.7572904825210571, -0.2932157814502716, -0.06457214802503586, -0.557870090007782, -0.00290465890429914, -0.4815896153450012, -0.407588392496109, -0.169260635972023, -1.2181758880615234, 0.11230085045099258, -0.6388433575630188, 0.5030072927474976, 0.49438297748565674, -0.3559657633304596, 0.012458396144211292, -0.03312091901898384, 0.007141123525798321, 0.08029334992170334, -1.0979108810424805, 0.3151884078979492, -0.052634838968515396, 0.4329681396484375, 0.2947131097316742, -0.26583656668663025, -0.07320792227983475, 0.8031238913536072, -0.8108484745025635, -0.4110300838947296, 0.5946362018585205, 0.7549553513526917, 0.47149014472961426, -0.43823787569999695, -0.47183820605278015, 0.5607764720916748, 0.8123171329498291, -0.2824598550796509, -1.3025530576705933, -0.7860532999038696, 0.4262859523296356, 0.4485165476799011, -0.17263640463352203, -0.13998915255069733, -0.3084307909011841, 0.4222732484340668, 0.7525715231895447, 0.2720726430416107, -0.15203195810317993, -0.00633575115352869, 0.29840290546417236, 0.6216995120048523, 0.14856600761413574, -0.9343485832214355, -1.0391062498092651, -0.011312262155115604, -0.43469473719596863, 0.7317453026771545, 0.6496478915214539, -0.1472858190536499, -0.3103979229927063, -0.7623715400695801, -0.13971634209156036, -0.32440584897994995, -0.5603835582733154, -0.6202012300491333, -0.401621013879776, 0.11275803297758102, 0.1397397220134735, 0.5790112614631653, -0.6049233078956604, 0.03259100764989853, -0.7326001524925232, 0.8397524356842041, -0.6448018550872803, -0.13852213323116302, 0.3302207291126251, -0.8007513284683228, -0.1249786838889122, 2.2565042972564697, 0.43501633405685425, -0.16252849996089935, -0.22565695643424988, 0.40512561798095703, 0.5244001746177673, 0.30614539980888367, -0.5571067929267883, -0.1742037534713745, 0.21596181392669678, -0.10551410913467407, 0.40503934025764465, 0.19160522520542145, -0.7282488346099854, 0.5042458176612854, -0.2729392349720001, 0.7453182935714722, -0.15520049631595612, 0.29661664366722107, -0.4046356678009033, -0.559729278087616, -0.4279780983924866, -0.6196383237838745, 0.3836511969566345, -1.3025377988815308, 0.33265355229377747, 0.11904382705688477, 0.7088659405708313, -0.07617321610450745, 0.31996604800224304, -1.0714621543884277, -0.4065110981464386, -0.20452290773391724, -0.36690574884414673, 0.380373477935791, -0.20557807385921478, -0.7281366586685181, 1.341362714767456, -0.7355759143829346, 0.22924402356147766, 1.1032339334487915, 0.43419212102890015, -0.09388331323862076, -0.3950924873352051, 0.7898037433624268, -0.32380327582359314, -0.8220424652099609, -0.19525086879730225, 0.5069283246994019, -0.9282448887825012, -0.4450150728225708, -0.2209281623363495, -0.1509450227022171, -0.6393433809280396, 0.4770084619522095, 0.4740120470523834, 0.14008308947086334, 1.34161376953125, -0.08917718380689621, -0.6724361777305603, -0.43876826763153076, 0.017870834097266197, 0.47979551553726196, 0.18122273683547974, 0.6503599882125854, -0.3386950194835663, -0.0744892880320549, 0.42927613854408264, -1.1740773916244507, 0.30169546604156494, -0.22994083166122437, 0.542803943157196, 0.8581072688102722, -0.9278020262718201, 0.7301293015480042, 0.18562853336334229, -0.05851084738969803, -0.9266072511672974, -0.21752025187015533, 0.08656321465969086, -0.49942919611930847, 0.2874787449836731, 0.9238995909690857, 0.45926788449287415, 0.8519367575645447, 0.061828531324863434, 0.38298022747039795, -0.32382839918136597, 0.6406410932540894, -0.5353052616119385, 0.7249836921691895, -0.16433577239513397, -0.7553054690361023, 0.8328227400779724, -0.16111989319324493, -0.005385178606957197, -0.6246359348297119, -0.2771371603012085, 0.01994713768362999, 0.2577519416809082, 1.034104585647583, 0.32693085074424744, 0.7154694199562073, 0.017453251406550407, 0.5807970762252808, 1.0168201923370361, 0.12757444381713867, 0.2415022850036621, 0.25152745842933655, -0.5678408145904541, -0.8570002317428589, -0.4916093647480011, 0.3835088908672333, -0.7803091406822205, -0.16132670640945435, -0.17408810555934906, 0.07941647619009018, 0.2519976496696472, 0.2437196522951126, 0.0028868908993899822, -0.5641129016876221, -0.152699276804924, -0.8687002062797546, -0.3971405029296875, -0.6227586269378662, -0.8317297101020813, 0.14626289904117584, 0.36168864369392395, -0.17490117251873016, 0.2796888053417206, -0.5963725447654724, 0.8168491721153259, -0.6215928196907043, -0.4033314883708954, 0.8610216975212097, 0.11148713529109955, 0.13240359723567963, -1.2683353424072266, -0.5150579214096069, -0.36174631118774414, 0.08946947008371353, 0.05774323269724846, -0.15153543651103973, 0.13490299880504608, -0.9257603287696838, 0.27369949221611023, 0.4599035680294037, -0.10360277444124222, 0.03030410222709179, -0.7462162375450134, -0.14847485721111298, 0.01612534373998642, -0.6026438474655151, 0.8218842148780823, 1.050612211227417, -0.48597586154937744, 0.15445242822170258, -0.7520716190338135, 0.04158788174390793, -0.06568265706300735, -0.005989991594105959, 0.2445605844259262, 0.4127582907676697, 0.02417815290391445, -0.1604471355676651, -0.21868067979812622, -0.7066113948822021, 0.24516510963439941, -0.6369417309761047, 0.6303894519805908, -0.08753080666065216, -0.8201889991760254, -0.5229566693305969, 0.23925340175628662, 0.14900808036327362, 0.13120298087596893, -0.41725954413414, -0.12866811454296112, 0.799262523651123, 0.31287631392478943, 0.82906574010849, -0.0034119118936359882, 0.31948122382164, 0.2312052845954895, 0.0015110966050997376, 0.38519608974456787, 0.14807897806167603, 0.1916031539440155, -0.3817332088947296, 0.10106053203344345, -0.30422842502593994, -0.18082168698310852, -0.11542769521474838, 0.1414465308189392, -0.2088415026664734, 0.022780410945415497, 0.47286900877952576, -0.04240334779024124, -0.5271644592285156, 0.6649772524833679, -0.3313554525375366, 0.21048618853092194, -0.20013371109962463, -0.07757039368152618, -0.1627861112356186, -0.5407282114028931, -0.6700051426887512, -0.2752167284488678, 0.17738331854343414, -0.3412928879261017, 0.3921256959438324, 0.7580510973930359, 1.1899981498718262, 1.325750708580017, -0.7994489669799805, -0.29635241627693176, 0.28350281715393066, 0.2983793616294861, -0.11639543622732162, -0.9557700753211975, -0.16335901618003845, 0.9000493288040161, -0.5896220207214355, -0.31933125853538513, -0.04378574341535568, 0.4757803976535797, 0.5019393563270569, 0.4639284908771515, 0.2431175261735916, 0.4818819463253021, -0.4758594036102295, 0.5769205093383789, -0.5304784178733826, -0.4996988773345947, -0.4858507215976715, -0.10923933982849121, 0.16357038915157318, 0.6265496015548706, -0.39999446272850037, 0.5325743556022644, 0.32609492540359497, -0.42460310459136963, -0.3104148507118225, 0.2181238830089569, 0.5061876177787781, 0.20559059083461761, -0.047915711998939514, -0.5679327249526978, 0.22636976838111877, -0.08406970649957657, 0.47741010785102844, -0.12533025443553925, 0.4314018785953522, -0.16085779666900635, -0.624614417552948, -0.3025205433368683, -0.4503357708454132, -0.10697702318429947, -0.18784546852111816, -0.4763546884059906, -0.10925754904747009, 0.06301122903823853, -0.6521937251091003, -0.0797252282500267, -0.05871782451868057, -0.5221020579338074, -0.32463765144348145, -0.0932735875248909, -1.1836895942687988, 0.33466917276382446, -0.4146783947944641, -0.6073647141456604, -0.09091957658529282, -0.5794400572776794, 0.6847834587097168, 0.8780663013458252, -0.32826557755470276, 0.0854797288775444, 0.7237437963485718, 0.33090803027153015, -0.2902797758579254, 0.5123926997184753, 0.1949642151594162, 0.5647436380386353, 0.4812694191932678, 0.07599581778049469, -0.27594661712646484, -0.21107091009616852, -0.035487186163663864, -0.05174161121249199, -0.7346330881118774, 0.4014301896095276, -0.6697371006011963, -0.25160273909568787, 0.22198861837387085, -0.20680567622184753, 0.03642112761735916, -0.0892045870423317, 0.08456941694021225, -1.1084740161895752, -0.20466482639312744, 1.2027913331985474, -0.42133376002311707, -0.308205783367157, -0.25893354415893555, 0.22103935480117798, 0.7526823878288269, -0.16383662819862366, 0.5659787058830261, 0.12964920699596405, 0.11236631870269775, 0.4620265066623688, -0.4415670931339264, -0.166433185338974, 0.1920059323310852, -0.5416063666343689, -0.5895927548408508, 0.2683778703212738, -0.542736828327179, -0.13989020884037018, 0.14257076382637024, 0.05152209475636482, -0.19060218334197998, 0.1364070028066635, -0.3598214387893677, 0.22926746308803558, -0.45491302013397217, 0.8141290545463562, -0.43494513630867004, -0.4940802752971649, 0.6021792888641357, 0.17082999646663666, -0.22590814530849457, -0.7319075465202332, -0.4118122160434723, -0.3208618760108948, 0.7200309634208679, -1.0662963390350342, -0.12051929533481598, 0.08792617917060852, -0.7059628963470459, -0.2026512324810028, -0.718026876449585, -0.21115900576114655, 0.3882075846195221, -0.3532831072807312, 0.27379000186920166, 0.5270851850509644, 0.19289734959602356, 0.6207162737846375, 0.8191961050033569, 0.09442571550607681, 0.165519580245018, 0.8478307127952576, 0.9125155210494995, 0.4293975532054901, 0.9158325791358948, 0.2590852379798889, -0.3571109473705292, -0.10726634413003922, 0.08515813201665878, 0.2762642502784729, -0.6700752973556519, -0.33513134717941284, -0.8003928661346436, 0.6626272201538086, -0.3143842816352844, 0.04154267534613609, -0.18541736900806427, 1.010082721710205, 0.048981208354234695, -0.26019880175590515, -1.2654151916503906, -0.21178172528743744, -0.9072490334510803, 0.14547236263751984, -0.6996353268623352, 0.5800286531448364, 0.6103553175926208, 0.48243287205696106, 0.2342185229063034, -0.6434308290481567, 3.9996302127838135, 1.1086407899856567, 0.43527328968048096, 0.6269620656967163, 1.0581576824188232, 1.305167555809021, -0.6346893310546875, -0.28605917096138, -0.07294945418834686, 0.25686517357826233, 0.5916354656219482, -0.23169052600860596, 0.5213743448257446, 0.33847498893737793, -0.28069016337394714, -0.4397216737270355, -0.6196717023849487, -0.4635847806930542, 0.3955819606781006, -0.6112596392631531, -0.7929970026016235, 0.005624852608889341, 0.45693764090538025, 0.8717431426048279, 0.1355791836977005, 0.14685003459453583, 0.7011498212814331, 0.009303347207605839, -0.10924548655748367, -1.0251322984695435, 0.3073969781398773, -0.29698896408081055, 1.3817596435546875, -0.6514713764190674, -0.3662814199924469, 0.01507926732301712, 0.26616132259368896, -0.5367480516433716, -0.3028661906719208, -0.22243048250675201, -0.563052237033844, 0.272655189037323, 0.23483020067214966, -0.6771058440208435, 0.5222627520561218, 0.4889734387397766, 0.19081123173236847, 1.514140009880066, 0.22326357662677765, -0.5010022521018982, 1.0712186098098755, -0.0027147862128913403, 0.41570666432380676, -0.5288875102996826, -0.7584788799285889, 0.46375375986099243, -0.490314781665802, 0.09898067265748978, 0.8515484929084778, 0.021268675103783607, -0.4430773854255676, 0.45335033535957336, 0.0883621871471405, 0.4026356637477875, -0.5222840905189514, -0.6177265048027039, -0.06484382599592209, 0.4780435860157013, 0.07524906098842621, -0.68658447265625, -0.09029415249824524, -0.5899643301963806, -0.6709469556808472, -0.49196532368659973, -0.105013906955719, 0.5680571794509888, -0.4315030872821808, 0.5387849807739258, 0.5965024828910828, -0.3368391692638397, 0.1844811588525772, -0.7328280806541443, 0.10934323072433472, -0.03680018335580826, 0.2564219534397125, 0.8495843410491943, -0.8964629769325256, -0.36572620272636414, -0.5771621465682983, 0.27217695116996765, 0.1271103322505951, 0.49509698152542114, 0.3628711402416229, 0.689657986164093, -0.486298531293869 ]
Hadamard States and Adiabatic Vacua
Reversing a slight detrimental effect of the mailer related to TeXability
Kay-Thomas Pirk
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211003
gr-qc/9211004
[ 0.21769928932189941, 0.27361005544662476, 1.0314456224441528, -0.4694560170173645, 0.2923128604888916, 0.05527148395776749, -0.5067325830459595, -0.6423835754394531, -0.5488914251327515, 1.6448901891708374, 1.3189796209335327, -0.04513254016637802, -0.15484878420829773, -0.8902087211608887, 0.2726123332977295, 0.531975507736206, -0.45895665884017944, -0.0441746711730957, -1.4952472448349, 0.11278439313173294, -0.1633857637643814, 0.2935882806777954, -1.7025188207626343, -1.1081138849258423, -0.8241454362869263, 0.8941007852554321, 0.5342969298362732, 0.5594834089279175, 1.2845916748046875, 0.8489032983779907, 0.7060656547546387, -0.11705444753170013, 0.22945086658000946, -0.6777396202087402, -0.3945416212081909, -0.11165110766887665, 0.5606096386909485, 0.07270107418298721, 1.324506402015686, -0.6002296209335327, 0.7916425466537476, 0.06868941336870193, 0.4494995176792145, -0.1696241945028305, -1.1686451435089111, -0.6428797841072083, 0.01696786843240261, -0.6846470832824707, -0.3509620130062103, -1.2135099172592163, 0.34686142206192017, -0.2987833023071289, 0.9280881881713867, -0.8811824917793274, 0.16318586468696594, 0.25017300248146057, -0.07086604088544846, 0.5291885137557983, -0.254174143075943, 0.1914258748292923, 0.37101903557777405, 0.21344666182994843, 0.44673359394073486, -0.46969786286354065, 0.09796764701604843, 1.137274146080017, -0.3576722741127014, 0.05610189586877823, -0.2572932541370392, -0.26580214500427246, 0.06262807548046112, -0.7510724663734436, -1.0332657098770142, 0.5430000424385071, -0.12142417579889297, 0.17563436925411224, -0.5148139595985413, -0.6235657334327698, -0.5051392912864685, -0.4989985227584839, 0.40369912981987, -0.5202077627182007, -0.27779334783554077, 0.930811882019043, -0.5704393982887268, -0.2357572764158249, 0.32599765062332153, -0.1441866159439087, 0.07221990823745728, 0.5071679949760437, 0.11056950688362122, 0.49353355169296265, -0.032465871423482895, 0.1106698215007782, 0.3895619511604309, 0.6263079643249512, 0.1368858814239502, 0.7281305193901062, 0.3584296703338623, 0.4647001028060913, -0.0003910707891918719, 1.072853446006775, -0.31552913784980774, 0.9803146719932556, -0.6414000988006592, 1.074087142944336, -1.0424058437347412, 0.565782904624939, 0.09416021406650543, -0.8011475801467896, 0.3272724747657776, -0.1769179403781891, 0.4955999553203583, -0.1802288144826889, 0.10125523805618286, 0.6625087857246399, 0.34994444251060486, 0.7123491764068604, -0.21009232103824615, -0.4030541777610779, 0.4446694254875183, 0.754062294960022, 0.29848408699035645, 0.6649816036224365, 0.008475229144096375, -0.7428497672080994, -0.4085567593574524, 0.3261367082595825, -0.6687559485435486, 0.11650831252336502, 0.2515951991081238, -1.3232375383377075, 0.10027007758617401, 0.36029279232025146, -0.01789022423326969, 0.2663257420063019, 0.425018846988678, 0.5902657508850098, -0.9984470009803772, -0.5358794331550598, 0.015578565187752247, -0.32639580965042114, 0.17299899458885193, 0.8357970714569092, -0.12236784398555756, 0.6348275542259216, -0.39433276653289795, 0.7760453224182129, -0.7683550715446472, -0.5392356514930725, 0.2397276759147644, -0.4445304274559021, 0.46088168025016785, 0.7785369157791138, -0.3005886971950531, -0.7885042428970337, -0.6937729716300964, 0.23549416661262512, -0.19488100707530975, -0.621235191822052, -0.4882495105266571, -0.303663432598114, 0.4732077419757843, 0.7542426586151123, -0.7438982725143433, 0.3997137248516083, -0.6093769669532776, -0.6332921385765076, -0.30707013607025146, -0.07536432892084122, -0.6973427534103394, 0.02004210464656353, 0.15674111247062683, 0.14885616302490234, 1.0598745346069336, 0.8109168410301208, 0.1496293991804123, -0.4855424165725708, -0.23724325001239777, 0.13819177448749542, 0.07048362493515015, -0.3304528594017029, 0.4610713720321655, 0.763604462146759, -0.5293188691139221, -0.34180721640586853, -0.6277592182159424, 0.19887486100196838, -0.16044881939888, -0.39637818932533264, -0.9326303005218506, 0.5152847766876221, -1.1892510652542114, 1.2993130683898926, -0.43961191177368164, 0.7793712615966797, -0.6322137713432312, 0.20832253992557526, 0.42948681116104126, -0.7631269693374634, -0.12565046548843384, 0.004166354890912771, -0.5020139217376709, -0.038536541163921356, -1.4021656513214111, 0.25203758478164673, 0.2637125849723816, 0.8503935933113098, -0.5610557198524475, 0.9077467918395996, 0.6293835043907166, -0.21258924901485443, 0.3117763102054596, -0.25806573033332825, 0.11507462710142136, -0.5737325549125671, 0.24589724838733673, 0.42876866459846497, -0.1884121298789978, 0.34509527683258057, 0.1123151183128357, 0.2867683172225952, 0.49006667733192444, 0.5293996930122375, -0.4597613513469696, -0.548402726650238, 0.7460241913795471, 1.2502449750900269, -0.6288720369338989, 0.5438433289527893, 0.22395779192447662, -0.45256367325782776, 0.1947467029094696, 0.770014762878418, 0.2809293270111084, -0.09516577422618866, 1.0825178623199463, 0.6696011424064636, 0.03886571526527405, 0.07015601545572281, 0.011606510728597641, 0.16816946864128113, 0.054659344255924225, 0.4551984965801239, -1.0328314304351807, 0.6196090579032898, 0.21494494378566742, -0.07566889375448227, 0.23560380935668945, 0.3280991315841675, -0.5194838643074036, 0.9252785444259644, 0.8061931133270264, 0.28563639521598816, -1.1397699117660522, -0.02533482015132904, 0.3602887690067291, 0.42608577013015747, -0.11793787777423859, -0.4129098355770111, -0.10754004120826721, 0.8020281195640564, -0.26946723461151123, -0.5103803873062134, -0.7742540240287781, 0.6355643272399902, -0.16541320085525513, -0.2530860900878906, 0.006214599125087261, -0.04153495654463768, -0.7496662735939026, -0.29668793082237244, -0.8511166572570801, 0.2640143036842346, -0.10757791996002197, 0.2759394943714142, 0.09753522276878357, -0.4132779836654663, 0.2562394142150879, 0.35002297163009644, -0.33244866132736206, 0.9001519083976746, 0.1392112374305725, -0.18440479040145874, 0.030546609312295914, -0.41336601972579956, -0.8262997269630432, 0.9424360394477844, -1.3429633378982544, 0.2047213912010193, 0.4911103844642639, -0.5484094023704529, -0.1902131289243698, -0.5867196917533875, 0.09144668281078339, 0.6023194193840027, -0.6910634636878967, 0.15316584706306458, -0.43837839365005493, -0.21282342076301575, 0.44222545623779297, 0.05759371072053909, -0.14792609214782715, 0.2328844517469406, -0.7155813574790955, 1.0845023393630981, -0.36892518401145935, -0.4658263325691223, 0.45026153326034546, -0.5442386269569397, -0.9730058312416077, 1.1904033422470093, 0.43625500798225403, 1.178267240524292, -0.12876872718334198, 0.5439167618751526, 0.814193844795227, 0.24376052618026733, 0.8517289161682129, -0.2596701681613922, -0.4658004641532898, -0.022780388593673706, 0.8943951725959778, -0.5843417644500732, -0.30612674355506897, 0.778618574142456, 0.09067375212907791, -1.2998709678649902, 0.1801130175590515, -0.6885498762130737, -0.7785713076591492, -0.1744285225868225, -0.08281257003545761, -0.31395041942596436, -0.5259268879890442, -0.13970713317394257, -0.7558057308197021, -0.45048779249191284, -0.2947338819503784, 0.6204195618629456, 0.7445462942123413, -0.5392272472381592, 0.56032794713974, 0.503576397895813, 0.12924456596374512, 0.25417739152908325, 0.5621947050094604, -0.756386399269104, -0.400534063577652, 0.3590866029262543, -0.26969388127326965, 1.067122220993042, -0.08608278632164001, -0.03531120344996452, -0.37385714054107666, 0.4909333884716034, -0.8829527497291565, -0.4231993854045868, -0.8601042628288269, -0.059728819876909256, -0.4220988154411316, 1.1210931539535522, -0.02128767780959606, -0.6466454267501831, -0.6879128217697144, -0.18986497819423676, -0.0916917696595192, 0.009629840962588787, 0.8434733748435974, -1.7393903732299805, 0.21126146614551544, 0.1455543488264084, -0.801611602306366, 0.05529779940843582, -0.4701823890209198, -0.2797536253929138, 0.6203130483627319, 0.6224785447120667, 0.05303160846233368, -0.6603081822395325, -0.5002124309539795, -0.328524112701416, 0.16323697566986084, 0.25980398058891296, 0.8679835796356201, 0.16382330656051636, -0.39956411719322205, 0.675022304058075, -0.15274155139923096, -0.5430250763893127, 0.06540404260158539, -0.6887559294700623, -0.1429932415485382, -1.2470684051513672, -0.7406312227249146, 0.13963425159454346, 1.0714070796966553, 0.47794026136398315, 0.2990601658821106, 0.018653975799679756, 0.32096174359321594, 0.8724873065948486, 0.07944652438163757, 0.6259550452232361, -0.2378886342048645, 0.48703324794769287, -0.9653486609458923, 0.776366114616394, 0.48941195011138916, 0.3709808886051178, -0.42562562227249146, -0.5916623473167419, -0.2635548412799835, -0.15675802528858185, 0.27648696303367615, 0.8522189259529114, -0.6753851771354675, 0.412211537361145, -0.026765696704387665, 0.17593346536159515, -0.8515934348106384, 0.49451547861099243, 0.35502251982688904, 0.4433037340641022, 0.18917816877365112, -1.3028279542922974, 0.022956592962145805, -0.47960641980171204, 0.1547660380601883, 0.9695311188697815, -0.5469964742660522, -0.9823318719863892, -0.24880065023899078, -0.06192135065793991, -0.7536400556564331, 0.6484627723693848, 0.7057621479034424, -0.2292284220457077, 0.855891227722168, -0.12415845692157745, 0.011058549396693707, 0.49805450439453125, -0.8007990121841431, 0.6736234426498413, -0.4735063910484314, 0.20326265692710876, -0.3672178387641907, 0.6382504105567932, 0.18967114388942719, -1.1457154750823975, 0.707027792930603, -0.5062779188156128, 0.3487742841243744, -0.032108139246702194, 0.16662442684173584, 0.1634225696325302, 0.48425641655921936, -0.6727145910263062, 0.06133633479475975, 0.03496891260147095, 0.37996187806129456, -0.33307310938835144, 0.7809692621231079, -1.0228453874588013, 0.6394546627998352, 0.5414672493934631, -0.001410769997164607, 0.5617053508758545, 0.3861737847328186, 0.22227469086647034, 0.5162851810455322, -0.18388067185878754, -0.38233575224876404, -0.5867874026298523, 0.464301735162735, -0.16692078113555908, 0.10605264455080032, 0.23984356224536896, -0.5005251169204712, -0.6380029916763306, -0.19983506202697754, 0.5333709716796875, -0.4923658072948456, 0.31246140599250793, -0.16930362582206726, -1.042675256729126, -0.35524579882621765, -0.7979674935340881, -0.6615191698074341, 0.06995661556720734, 0.16375693678855896, -0.24971766769886017, 0.1043534055352211, -0.41122329235076904, -0.2746880352497101, -0.050154492259025574, -0.6073287129402161, -0.7226881384849548, -0.3716273605823517, -0.13022586703300476, 0.3164242208003998, 0.8355867266654968, -0.05832095444202423, 0.07641507685184479, 0.033891718834638596, -0.08477740734815598, -0.4098438024520874, -1.0227603912353516, 0.06663589924573898, 0.9417366981506348, 0.3870287537574768, -0.37785661220550537, 0.4024892747402191, -0.0024757692590355873, 0.6667432188987732, 0.09532574564218521, 0.3923988938331604, -0.6785467267036438, -0.8983758091926575, 0.6204328536987305, 0.6826155781745911, -0.846832811832428, 0.43246564269065857, 0.6628831028938293, -0.842356264591217, 0.3301255702972412, -0.7631851434707642, -0.6482034921646118, 0.07484757900238037, -1.238702416419983, 0.029153691604733467, -0.6624391078948975, -0.289944052696228, -0.5635126829147339, -0.27519428730010986, 0.6234216690063477, 0.004826934076845646, 0.7795835733413696, -0.28079935908317566, -0.42925015091896057, -0.5884708166122437, 0.35837167501449585, -0.3893009126186371, 0.1741127371788025, -0.7106701731681824, 0.38621482253074646, -0.1853076070547104, 1.3972636461257935, -0.547632098197937, -0.30531036853790283, -0.09598655998706818, 0.09602200239896774, -0.1697871834039688, 0.6541204452514648, 0.25827059149742126, -0.25991857051849365, -0.3188951909542084, 0.17958520352840424, 0.6404600143432617, 0.7795642614364624, 0.07449473440647125, 0.473315954208374, -0.8138064742088318, 0.24879299104213715, -0.6901400685310364, -0.2633751332759857, 0.3566403388977051, 0.29519349336624146, 0.7244701981544495, -1.0884250402450562, -0.3751363456249237, 0.22296158969402313, 0.49894267320632935, 0.25194448232650757, 0.15272265672683716, -0.6533607244491577, -0.033714815974235535, -1.175277590751648, -0.5943015217781067, 0.049001529812812805, 0.1285955309867859, -0.09353456646203995, -0.16773124039173126, 0.1383017748594284, 0.34600090980529785, -0.779755711555481, 1.018263578414917, 0.33524200320243835, 0.6398095488548279, -0.1780485063791275, -0.23874111473560333, 0.32977232336997986, -0.5420625805854797, -0.5239199995994568, -0.44975629448890686, 0.16317273676395416, 0.2799898087978363, -0.7837046980857849, -0.8502845764160156, -0.717660129070282, -0.42772841453552246, 0.7175509333610535, 0.8692009449005127, -0.5874705910682678, 0.6061633825302124, 0.1783899962902069, -0.04396894574165344, -0.3286159336566925, 0.24905072152614594, 0.036676228046417236, 0.2542267143726349, 0.7060348391532898, -0.010539030656218529, -0.14499926567077637, -0.629432201385498, -0.04003963991999626, -0.6948694586753845, -0.5117450952529907, 0.8040794134140015, 0.05553501844406128, -0.24906665086746216, 0.241842582821846, 0.26381951570510864, -0.9262789487838745, -0.41128575801849365, -0.6656907200813293, 0.13107891380786896, 0.16129396855831146, -0.740045964717865, -0.14649200439453125, -0.03427997976541519, 0.058482859283685684, 0.2797485888004303, 0.07606896013021469, 0.6560364365577698, 0.5263508558273315, -0.04692061245441437, 0.3282007873058319, -0.45813316106796265, 0.05553080141544342, 1.3799691200256348, 0.3329869210720062, -0.8930181860923767, 0.3075611889362335, 0.084962397813797, -0.35778340697288513, 0.39600321650505066, 1.1930480003356934, -0.2764626443386078, -0.00609898054972291, 0.33944621682167053, 0.5621193647384644, 0.4170975983142853, -0.013347863219678402, 0.14488288760185242, 0.2880856692790985, -0.7420756220817566, -1.2464197874069214, 0.1380126029253006, 0.5947819352149963, 0.24988137185573578, 0.1088344156742096, -0.05197388678789139, -0.2037404477596283, 0.10442173480987549, -0.22818730771541595, 0.24785453081130981, -1.126555323600769, -0.4997565746307373, -1.0515515804290771, -0.5499237775802612, -0.650134801864624, 0.29662418365478516, 0.48902514576911926, 0.1506628692150116, -0.7048913240432739, 0.28476861119270325, -0.24075858294963837, 0.6928106546401978, -0.16325536370277405, 0.9289284348487854, -0.9093937277793884, 0.013755456544458866, -0.7915282249450684, 0.0660099983215332, 0.18490037322044373, -0.7372409701347351, -0.8449808955192566, -0.051948923617601395, -0.006737277843058109, 0.627977728843689, -0.4854084849357605, 0.5364519953727722, -0.5085028409957886, -0.41242095828056335, 0.4556499719619751, -0.05673611909151077, -0.5869311690330505, 0.526638925075531, -0.5503265857696533, 0.6060041189193726, -0.2713784873485565, 0.7366644144058228, -0.36995434761047363, 0.5752383470535278, -1.3157764673233032, -0.353287011384964, -0.2736858129501343, 0.39915862679481506, -0.034241050481796265, -0.63619464635849, 0.35602453351020813, -0.4093092978000641, -0.9340732097625732, -0.21801383793354034, 0.5781199932098389, 0.5898100137710571, -0.5663505792617798, -0.21098734438419342, -0.39316025376319885, 0.8097911477088928, -0.5740808844566345, 0.9219167232513428, -0.17867085337638855, -0.1765414923429489, -0.05540887638926506, -0.03817949816584587, 0.21241390705108643, -0.19281640648841858, 0.06735555827617645, -0.8308488130569458, 0.169448584318161, 0.47083500027656555, -0.3310176730155945, 0.48496901988983154, -0.9775090217590332, -0.28030088543891907, -0.6530039310455322, 0.380359023809433, -0.37475937604904175, 1.0143071413040161, 0.26341328024864197, 0.5967404842376709, 0.42160171270370483, -0.6033750772476196, -0.26170843839645386, 0.3945695757865906, -0.8354649543762207, -0.9322871565818787, 0.281738817691803, -0.0839243158698082, -0.27354177832603455, 0.3030603528022766, -0.763660192489624, -0.14761333167552948, 0.6882677674293518, 0.7943518161773682, 0.7449510097503662, -0.4404149651527405, -0.29710713028907776, 0.5056812763214111, -1.116109013557434, -0.8977933526039124, 0.1345607489347458, 0.31219810247421265, -0.9485782980918884, -1.187277913093567, 0.15027271211147308, 0.3034481108188629, -0.2089577466249466, -0.3030715584754944, 0.17963257431983948, 0.24755312502384186, -0.35856086015701294, -0.1865042746067047, -0.4882611632347107, 0.0723973736166954, -0.29773616790771484, 0.09093254059553146, 0.09412862360477448, -0.2255314439535141, 0.18858684599399567, 0.6296712756156921, 0.7334275841712952, 0.09072515368461609, -0.15216854214668274, 1.281386375427246, -0.2553181052207947, -0.18218407034873962, 0.9639617204666138, 0.13764482736587524, 0.8675494194030762, 0.9775711894035339, -0.6489588022232056, 0.45994648337364197, 0.36506345868110657, 0.5133063197135925, 1.0110957622528076, 0.28951817750930786, -0.3867892920970917, 0.6137300729751587, 0.9051028490066528, 0.2631567716598511, 0.2247179001569748, 0.08055921643972397, 0.007789172697812319, -0.08316807448863983, -0.4135214686393738, 0.40458354353904724, 0.3366304039955139, 0.40827247500419617, 0.18349754810333252, -0.34914058446884155, -0.07443846017122269, -0.5067018866539001, -0.023502910509705544, 0.2697412669658661, -0.8360251188278198, -0.41799136996269226, -0.9262167811393738, 0.6554041504859924, 0.13247697055339813, 0.19498787820339203, -0.04198726639151573, 0.8153769969940186, 1.102071762084961, 0.4140126407146454, 0.0447436161339283, 0.039632175117731094, 0.5153759717941284, 0.9059953689575195, 0.580245852470398, -0.4026503562927246, 0.7500081658363342, 0.8881964683532715, 0.03036896139383316, -0.5678180456161499, 0.03565465286374092, 0.09050611406564713, -0.8489107489585876, -0.3229314088821411, -0.01843136176466942, 0.09425817430019379, 0.23419125378131866, -0.709803581237793, 0.24475498497486115, -0.17823800444602966, 0.13064076006412506, 0.5327312350273132, 0.02316388301551342, -0.8361693024635315, 0.39707469940185547, 0.050695717334747314, 0.26293036341667175, 0.9333417415618896, 0.3655183017253876, -0.36300721764564514, 0.4120306372642517, 1.0667325258255005, 0.1856631487607956, 0.32983502745628357, -0.29039448499679565, 0.7828800082206726, 0.684284508228302, 0.4573613703250885, -0.757117509841919, 0.19297243654727936, 0.3659127354621887, 0.021577807143330574, 0.3458082973957062, -0.38451603055000305, -0.7572640180587769, -0.28948378562927246, 0.20148929953575134, 0.4691833257675171, 0.03866245225071907, 0.3131464123725891, 0.2973482608795166, -0.4096602499485016, -0.609906792640686, -0.21934469044208527, 0.1745915561914444, -0.9455166459083557, -0.11315837502479553, -1.4201809167861938, 0.3784807622432709, 0.38305404782295227, -0.04411255195736885, -0.7381415963172913, -0.1176847591996193, -0.18005193769931793, -0.7372003197669983, -0.33753645420074463, -0.4765342175960541, 0.04361243173480034, 0.7638643383979797, 0.45856231451034546, 0.37815532088279724, -0.834857702255249, -0.5996994972229004, 0.23193851113319397, 0.9110434651374817, 0.19044475257396698, 1.1576564311981201, 0.9128811955451965, 0.14935418963432312, -0.5174074769020081, 0.6287345886230469, 0.5707653164863586, -0.7624274492263794, 0.3063412308692932, -0.13915283977985382, 0.41342461109161377, 0.12034506350755692, -0.5984224081039429, 0.0425390787422657, 0.5477131009101868, 0.357311487197876, -0.26226311922073364, -0.5551950335502625, -0.03860335424542427, -0.19558045268058777, 0.07526864111423492, -0.9725987911224365, 0.01688312366604805, -0.07413985580205917, 0.07329417765140533, -0.2216162532567978, -0.9631904363632202, 3.785346746444702, 0.04096619039773941, 0.8394383192062378, -0.244939386844635, 1.072670817375183, 1.4123908281326294, 0.04279467836022377, 0.09492076933383942, 0.5013624429702759, -0.8035761117935181, -0.6492864489555359, 0.0990615114569664, -0.5676878690719604, 0.5194774866104126, 0.00894710049033165, 0.38616061210632324, -0.15774625539779663, -0.0018739121733233333, -0.9975054860115051, -0.5222213268280029, -1.2171177864074707, 0.1193532794713974, -0.16940511763095856, -0.38316911458969116, -0.3754747211933136, 0.5546355843544006, 0.1654484122991562, -0.663821280002594, -0.024050448089838028, -0.17666839063167572, -0.3683752119541168, -0.4714813828468323, 0.0669417753815651, -0.5109389424324036, -1.4019514322280884, 0.2779245376586914, 0.01973096840083599, -0.7631001472473145, 0.47457000613212585, 0.17550288140773773, 0.18695610761642456, -0.22367045283317566, 0.5721189975738525, -0.03705962002277374, -0.20593801140785217, 0.6953443288803101, -0.4824565052986145, 0.7676157355308533, 0.2284175455570221, -1.0827580690383911, 0.6769115328788757, 0.41097724437713623, 0.468243271112442, -0.9636639952659607, -0.41032835841178894, -0.9955724477767944, 0.30555781722068787, -0.6124822497367859, -0.4725582003593445, -0.047299981117248535, 0.5401644110679626, -0.21722303330898285, -0.20368033647537231, 0.7886772751808167, 0.5391548275947571, -0.15966399013996124, 0.31369492411613464, -0.382748007774353, 0.07132588326931, 0.3058546781539917, -0.06164569780230522, 0.14036156237125397, -0.549729585647583, -0.6844043731689453, -0.0932125523686409, 0.09479959309101105, -0.48909464478492737, 0.6845043897628784, -0.13779500126838684, 0.24654428660869598, -0.304159015417099, -0.28919145464897156, -0.09282275289297104, 0.1337207704782486, 0.00644637830555439, 0.6557944416999817, -0.20989376306533813, 0.014641980640590191, -0.21637345850467682, 0.38088345527648926, 0.019230691716074944, 0.6162887811660767, -0.44915980100631714, -0.31407269835472107, -0.4839850962162018 ]
Sum-over-histories origin of the composition laws of relativistic quantum mechanics and quantum cosmology
The scope of the paper has been broadened to include a more complete discussion of the following topics: The derivation of composition laws in quantum cosmology. The connection between the existence of a composition law in the sum over histories approach to relativistic quantum mechanics and quantum cosmology, and the existence of a canonical formulation.
Jonathan Halliwell and Miguel Ortiz
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211004
gr-qc/9211005
[ -0.36412110924720764, 0.8863205313682556, 1.0921822786331177, -0.06768546253442764, -0.7110358476638794, -0.03335349261760712, -0.9068751931190491, -0.7192604541778564, -0.4139189124107361, 1.3704890012741089, 0.8106620907783508, -0.056024909019470215, 0.19192077219486237, -0.2899385988712311, -0.17327150702476501, -0.18777452409267426, -0.5281512141227722, 1.324734091758728, -0.9062872529029846, -0.4603981077671051, 0.16771255433559418, -0.14286190271377563, -1.4783151149749756, 0.18554216623306274, -0.2342597097158432, 0.4685322344303131, 0.5776041746139526, 0.07548869401216507, 1.706690788269043, 0.5809586048126221, 0.30748993158340454, -0.30740177631378174, 0.6946150660514832, -1.0469177961349487, 0.2248910516500473, -0.558861494064331, 0.29873502254486084, 0.11364874243736267, 0.98618084192276, -0.9017136096954346, 0.9789270162582397, 0.19980360567569733, 0.08257673680782318, -0.19644850492477417, -1.1443252563476562, -0.644709587097168, -0.5332412719726562, -0.0565224289894104, -0.009888717904686928, -0.8073639869689941, 0.17817428708076477, -0.03287127614021301, 0.7358495593070984, -0.0963689461350441, 0.09582597017288208, 0.4691787660121918, -0.40746742486953735, -0.6766496300697327, -0.5108348727226257, 0.6272396445274353, 0.8660222887992859, 0.04574010893702507, 1.0428446531295776, -0.7774892449378967, 0.33656081557273865, 0.986625075340271, 0.09032928198575974, 0.2326178103685379, -0.4637983739376068, 0.15182040631771088, 1.0406818389892578, -0.09816432744264603, 0.06130571663379669, 0.011463290080428123, -0.23497402667999268, 0.714012861251831, 0.24812784790992737, -0.5420315265655518, -0.44404006004333496, 0.030965199694037437, -0.3884504735469818, 0.23650991916656494, -0.5158175826072693, 0.06729641556739807, -0.7428508996963501, 0.47019824385643005, 0.6122226715087891, 0.5346251130104065, 1.0161783695220947, 0.0186202060431242, -0.297107458114624, 0.7616438269615173, -0.35280171036720276, 0.16802619397640228, -0.13058358430862427, -0.11225268244743347, -0.2554270625114441, 0.4590447247028351, 0.3412536084651947, 0.16934369504451752, 0.16573114693164825, 0.9400461912155151, 0.17433424293994904, 2.023141860961914, -1.266339659690857, 0.603593647480011, -0.16363933682441711, 0.6120480895042419, -0.28211510181427, -0.17694805562496185, 0.2647065818309784, -0.1269916445016861, 0.31520241498947144, 0.369380384683609, 0.4676250219345093, 0.8147323131561279, 0.36157384514808655, 0.8619930744171143, 0.12486103922128677, -0.09140019863843918, 0.2557035982608795, 0.7062817811965942, 0.8573045134544373, 0.656765878200531, 0.630150318145752, -0.6853079199790955, -0.09493082761764526, -0.49581149220466614, -0.41865772008895874, -0.23491555452346802, 0.646670401096344, -0.5944364070892334, 0.2238881140947342, 0.7100235223770142, -0.4081384837627411, -0.10124216228723526, 0.4716711938381195, 0.6415703296661377, -0.7274336814880371, 0.24729767441749573, 0.2752531170845032, -0.4455662965774536, -0.45341601967811584, 1.3899970054626465, -0.5416021943092346, 0.31849899888038635, -0.14856991171836853, 1.1814388036727905, -0.31566616892814636, 0.2110268920660019, -1.3455036878585815, -0.812821090221405, -0.03971051797270775, 0.3329755961894989, -0.6934107542037964, -0.38889241218566895, -0.12189242243766785, -0.7232206463813782, -0.4794616103172302, -0.5411475300788879, -0.15480592846870422, 0.25342777371406555, 0.39346709847450256, 0.2800918519496918, -0.5946671962738037, 0.26530444622039795, -1.022471308708191, -0.7003191709518433, -0.1872260570526123, -0.13417503237724304, 0.27556636929512024, -0.04858144745230675, -0.4242744743824005, 0.5067617893218994, 0.7966948747634888, 0.316864937543869, 0.3903506398200989, -0.6827960014343262, -0.30820953845977783, 0.3632524907588959, -0.42010706663131714, -0.782535195350647, -0.1692250370979309, -0.22205501794815063, -0.6689488887786865, -0.6597029566764832, -0.5447443723678589, -0.3710969090461731, -0.25907525420188904, 0.008222932927310467, -0.4343530833721161, -0.08849997073411942, -0.7480546832084656, 0.8102498054504395, -0.3211638033390045, 0.20734627544879913, -1.0829391479492188, 0.460701048374176, 0.002500378992408514, -1.1382396221160889, 0.038905635476112366, 0.06222161278128624, -0.11779426783323288, 0.5305776596069336, -0.3550966680049896, -0.4332208037376404, 0.34531182050704956, 0.68165522813797, -0.8835530877113342, 0.481334924697876, 0.057774122804403305, -0.5251840353012085, 0.8087883591651917, 0.053559210151433945, 0.32600048184394836, -0.03155740723013878, -0.16441616415977478, 1.1928361654281616, -0.29800692200660706, 1.096253752708435, -0.11860460788011551, 0.32472124695777893, 0.08005226403474808, 0.5788474082946777, 0.9705473780632019, -0.7614319920539856, 0.5399366021156311, 1.0915883779525757, -0.1240076944231987, 0.003687524003908038, -0.39778152108192444, 0.5310642123222351, 0.07958780974149704, -0.04172868654131889, -0.29258784651756287, -0.5933338403701782, 0.25263944268226624, 0.4879046678543091, -0.14688968658447266, -0.0024118181318044662, 0.43925660848617554, 0.15640492737293243, 0.4238492250442505, 0.13314004242420197, -0.27633941173553467, 1.2124710083007812, 0.7937608957290649, 0.41082414984703064, -0.4374830722808838, 1.043051838874817, -0.24752077460289001, 0.4039601683616638, 0.6523242592811584, 0.6186137199401855, -0.7627776861190796, 0.035482726991176605, 0.17840953171253204, 0.4491834342479706, -0.045806847512722015, -0.8295078873634338, -0.40494057536125183, -0.010394720360636711, -0.2284398078918457, -0.6281800866127014, 0.30630627274513245, -0.1882556527853012, -0.8052153587341309, 0.2086435854434967, 0.02570112608373165, -0.028800638392567635, -1.4279308319091797, 0.29128292202949524, -1.0369970798492432, -0.2475292980670929, -1.0881315469741821, -0.22836820781230927, 0.31788960099220276, -0.3953027129173279, 0.731357753276825, -0.03916782885789871, -0.45988714694976807, 0.9641433358192444, -0.5061804056167603, 0.24665279686450958, 0.6476716995239258, 0.8478298187255859, -0.48953375220298767, 1.19578218460083, -1.1293882131576538, 0.03905033320188522, 0.20867085456848145, -0.7359261512756348, -0.544895350933075, -0.5563444495201111, 0.6327399611473083, -0.3630005717277527, -0.60343998670578, 0.4759620130062103, 0.05177103355526924, -0.7227506637573242, 0.1893966645002365, 0.10022375732660294, -0.3702431321144104, -1.0112850666046143, -0.5659187436103821, 0.7884876728057861, 0.14453823864459991, -0.02500941790640354, 0.345714807510376, 0.31603193283081055, -0.4001171588897705, 0.5093382596969604, -0.6544318199157715, 1.0420172214508057, -0.1824687272310257, 0.6738883256912231, 0.22554825246334076, 0.0695040300488472, 0.0748346820473671, -0.4091944098472595, -0.5713443756103516, 0.3268046975135803, -0.13723799586296082, -0.1531475931406021, -0.8721328377723694, 1.0357450246810913, -0.0477362796664238, -0.7879968285560608, 0.3198528289794922, -0.554399847984314, -1.1582071781158447, 0.45844897627830505, 0.11105745285749435, 0.09011848270893097, -0.3776157796382904, 0.34328600764274597, -0.211514413356781, -0.4767875671386719, 0.33147817850112915, 0.26435956358909607, 0.7302073836326599, -0.778532862663269, 0.003988230600953102, 0.08277368545532227, 0.6610795259475708, 0.6599939465522766, 0.6361482739448547, -0.1545252948999405, -0.02136988565325737, -0.4797876477241516, 0.5606634020805359, 0.7592885494232178, -0.1565943956375122, 1.2521346807479858, -0.1730564832687378, 0.5193725228309631, 0.4168393015861511, -0.3999285399913788, -0.21019600331783295, -0.09543417394161224, -0.1906760185956955, 0.6699628233909607, 0.07561183720827103, 0.3454655706882477, -0.3696575164794922, -0.08052638918161392, -0.17097274959087372, -0.19976398348808289, -0.2519457936286926, -0.9427217245101929, 0.06082160398364067, -0.511346161365509, 0.12697134912014008, 0.32808852195739746, 0.9217020273208618, -0.0371435210108757, 0.5423012375831604, 0.33826205134391785, 0.6970953345298767, -0.5753145813941956, -0.3878214657306671, 0.11402775347232819, -0.20330826938152313, 0.21120397746562958, -0.5252294540405273, -0.17616619169712067, -0.2779008150100708, -0.006567029748111963, -0.6888689398765564, -0.11014856398105621, -1.0564546585083008, -0.9961153268814087, -0.06476438790559769, -0.8109304904937744, -0.5836479663848877, -0.34596896171569824, 1.1297467947006226, 0.32888713479042053, 0.16691137850284576, -0.4336436986923218, 0.15366710722446442, 0.1369209587574005, 0.37650883197784424, 0.30461737513542175, -0.19499897956848145, 0.25613099336624146, -1.0204808712005615, 0.570156991481781, 0.27252107858657837, -0.2498079389333725, 0.13238771259784698, -0.46379637718200684, -0.2198210209608078, -0.7058824896812439, 0.9215285778045654, 0.07710545510053635, -0.07323697954416275, 0.08019955456256866, -0.5580903887748718, -0.5146737098693848, -0.36467626690864563, 0.22405549883842468, -0.020585602149367332, 0.5947669744491577, 0.42409107089042664, -1.2553443908691406, -0.031302329152822495, -0.646275520324707, 0.4717862904071808, 0.9577654600143433, -0.17056649923324585, 0.06229705736041069, -0.4054158926010132, -0.04119044169783592, -0.8132408857345581, 0.919457733631134, 1.1317481994628906, 0.22836175560951233, 0.17519605159759521, -0.6834179759025574, -0.3402637541294098, 0.5042892694473267, -1.423511028289795, 0.10467805713415146, 0.4445027709007263, 1.158164381980896, 0.9869080781936646, -0.02312588319182396, 0.12293413281440735, -0.004871236626058817, -0.07632507383823395, -1.2072538137435913, 1.4548509120941162, -0.23018644750118256, -0.3331231474876404, 0.24507462978363037, 0.29792043566703796, -0.26814785599708557, 0.289483904838562, -0.18084222078323364, -0.13059547543525696, -0.5136528611183167, 0.15041697025299072, -0.8779935836791992, -0.0827120691537857, 0.9076153635978699, -0.4265195429325104, 0.2687378227710724, 0.010879190638661385, -0.9668271541595459, 0.7303471565246582, 0.36229416728019714, -0.22361159324645996, -0.12005886435508728, 0.888077974319458, -0.03311280533671379, 0.025292815640568733, 0.2821372151374817, -0.17005974054336548, -0.9876548647880554, 0.6016514897346497, -0.5108931660652161, -0.6043334603309631, 0.09251628071069717, -0.22789302468299866, -0.5509499311447144, -0.8028609752655029, -0.055354535579681396, -0.6811360716819763, 0.02917286939918995, 0.08439892530441284, 0.4088330566883087, -0.22036179900169373, 0.29926639795303345, 0.2662914991378784, 0.3410762548446655, -0.5756101012229919, -1.033690094947815, -0.11886950582265854, 0.27002793550491333, 0.11365161836147308, 0.651951789855957, -0.7626078724861145, 0.5175138711929321, -0.6213856339454651, -1.179986596107483, 0.02371588908135891, -1.292005181312561, 0.3240584433078766, 0.6691344380378723, -0.21013888716697693, 0.009318956173956394, 0.29479241371154785, 0.03467259556055069, -0.42375415563583374, -0.19908979535102844, 0.842082679271698, -0.1360144168138504, -0.12907017767429352, 0.14605146646499634, 0.3699752986431122, -0.7419989705085754, 0.3717128336429596, 0.036605432629585266, -0.19679582118988037, 0.6004735231399536, -0.42398226261138916, -0.5951070785522461, -0.34278422594070435, -1.3324617147445679, 0.011303714476525784, -0.2982946038246155, -0.19760887324810028, -0.4061381220817566, -0.48722168803215027, 0.28949204087257385, 0.2842649817466736, 0.40816938877105713, -0.03996831551194191, -0.6764351725578308, -0.7245305776596069, 0.04601356387138367, 0.7508939504623413, 0.1816740781068802, -0.3511074185371399, -0.1644858866930008, -0.9270433187484741, 0.8095029592514038, -0.768160343170166, -0.17150381207466125, 0.3130449950695038, 0.4667210578918457, -0.3027486801147461, -0.042706411331892014, 0.4274463951587677, -0.24261429905891418, -0.507839560508728, 0.912287175655365, 0.07366698980331421, -0.2905011773109436, -0.16066274046897888, 0.5043962597846985, -0.7935854196548462, -0.02512272074818611, -0.36943721771240234, -0.05700821429491043, -0.44876232743263245, 0.10350643843412399, 0.699938178062439, 0.003743122098967433, -0.06736867129802704, 0.10413827002048492, 0.26757991313934326, 0.4868389070034027, 0.15912802517414093, -0.3176160752773285, -0.4993646442890167, -0.8125527501106262, -1.0516244173049927, 0.34640631079673767, 0.4654422700405121, 0.1507483571767807, -0.4643869698047638, -0.47434961795806885, 0.2335178107023239, -1.0087738037109375, 0.4092574715614319, 0.49498698115348816, 0.1618301123380661, -0.08652404695749283, -0.1398094892501831, 0.05417465791106224, -0.3797481060028076, -0.29438409209251404, -0.0835506021976471, -0.20817479491233826, 0.5140687823295593, -0.0869864746928215, -0.026717644184827805, -0.002189991995692253, -0.15417292714118958, 0.43165966868400574, 0.6565951704978943, -0.28879567980766296, 0.9399727582931519, -0.5667076110839844, -0.5547670125961304, -0.36334729194641113, 0.09201900660991669, 0.7561501264572144, -0.277263879776001, 0.8000622391700745, -0.36353352665901184, -0.09285595268011093, -0.1471407413482666, 0.4315917193889618, -0.7001515030860901, -0.47560182213783264, 1.2157223224639893, -0.09581205993890762, -0.7394167184829712, 0.5040973424911499, 0.25392454862594604, -0.8655593991279602, -0.045284952968358994, -0.553390383720398, 0.23300862312316895, -0.1475500762462616, -0.860821545124054, -0.6205344200134277, -0.3276837468147278, -0.1435021311044693, -0.7368381023406982, 0.1980477273464203, 0.7445745468139648, 0.18303276598453522, -0.20227128267288208, -0.12280722707509995, -0.7256247997283936, 0.2485022097826004, 1.7703150510787964, 0.44098415970802307, -0.43302950263023376, -0.6259060502052307, -0.5527145862579346, -0.3220524191856384, 0.29624831676483154, 1.1524741649627686, -0.12563596665859222, 0.16688703000545502, 0.8087237477302551, 0.7057140469551086, 0.09407240152359009, 0.2548740804195404, -0.03549223765730858, 1.475867748260498, -0.1432552933692932, -0.9561353325843811, -0.2433442771434784, -0.16670577228069305, 0.30897489190101624, 0.49478477239608765, -0.04663446173071861, -0.046931009739637375, 0.021764466539025307, -0.8300809860229492, 0.5942752361297607, -0.9588635563850403, -0.5454419255256653, -0.9311482906341553, 0.17271743714809418, -0.16839219629764557, -0.2702743113040924, 0.511570394039154, 0.747360110282898, -0.2509539723396301, 0.5416911244392395, -0.2984580099582672, 0.3924449682235718, -0.31161364912986755, -0.13528451323509216, -0.6413293480873108, -0.17295365035533905, -0.05452363193035126, -0.13459816575050354, -0.20957130193710327, -0.8222202062606812, -0.4115516245365143, 0.1758054494857788, 0.22809727489948273, 0.2959303855895996, 0.04765636473894119, 0.6758382320404053, -0.39461058378219604, -0.22618204355239868, 0.3299362361431122, -0.5609261393547058, -0.11196862161159515, 0.3521793782711029, -0.7590431571006775, 0.27811217308044434, 0.2925090789794922, -0.09152795374393463, -0.41288062930107117, 0.08021416515111923, -1.0722347497940063, 0.29025447368621826, 0.08342082053422928, 0.39865514636039734, -0.013039038516581059, 0.08460523933172226, -0.580430805683136, 0.008240659721195698, -0.7490408420562744, -0.9119905829429626, -0.3354336619377136, 0.1416371762752533, -0.33019331097602844, -0.26372426748275757, -0.5433599948883057, 0.560760498046875, 0.07756932824850082, 0.8818018436431885, -0.14073358476161957, 0.0022483011707663536, 0.13132894039154053, -0.1486034244298935, -0.20651091635227203, 0.037116244435310364, 0.20069506764411926, -0.36143410205841064, -0.45592227578163147, 0.47585436701774597, 0.24102193117141724, 0.421050488948822, -0.7865405082702637, 0.16033171117305756, 0.00334485387429595, 0.10148990154266357, -0.3820524513721466, 0.25919046998023987, 0.634190559387207, 0.21827204525470734, 0.4107193052768707, -0.627378523349762, -0.9467117786407471, 0.5064684748649597, -1.1156246662139893, -0.26760241389274597, -0.1844562441110611, -0.20991908013820648, 0.06796564161777496, 0.8280938267707825, -1.3993839025497437, 0.23779161274433136, 0.5938892960548401, 0.060537464916706085, 0.0669536367058754, 0.0949026495218277, -0.5286909341812134, 0.8631202578544617, -0.3716336488723755, -1.0595917701721191, 0.042269010096788406, -0.19582107663154602, -1.3457592725753784, -0.40763676166534424, -0.6540083885192871, 0.560895562171936, 0.025704436004161835, 0.1727907955646515, -0.9702598452568054, 0.5792428255081177, 0.14595957100391388, -1.0027716159820557, -0.06664957851171494, -0.2328929603099823, -0.6150426268577576, 0.0145003916695714, -0.9125314354896545, -0.24279704689979553, 0.6544017195701599, -0.049090202897787094, 0.40957576036453247, 0.3548194169998169, -0.729365348815918, -0.04000771418213844, 0.5002067685127258, 0.020576076582074165, 0.6106782555580139, 0.14455054700374603, 0.2686377465724945, 0.5139021277427673, -0.4909088909626007, 0.37861236929893494, 0.586876392364502, -0.24277032911777496, 0.4271095395088196, -0.1960723102092743, -0.5433849692344666, 0.5560593605041504, -0.343855619430542, 0.0037904351484030485, -1.3968526124954224, -0.48607510328292847, 0.2985321879386902, -0.23479972779750824, -0.7276522517204285, -0.0008045646245591342, 0.15963314473628998, -0.1806311458349228, 0.20007632672786713, -0.15093395113945007, -0.6942527294158936, -0.48373478651046753, -0.1443476378917694, 0.06971405446529388, -0.6204789876937866, -0.47064408659935, -0.20996598899364471, 0.12037612497806549, 0.40382063388824463, 0.07208137959241867, -0.32930999994277954, 0.393792062997818, 0.6133632063865662, -0.11780251562595367, -0.7324893474578857, 0.8364913463592529, -0.08439192175865173, 1.147687315940857, -0.11983735114336014, 0.0797148123383522, 0.24808068573474884, 0.3928449749946594, -0.1527308225631714, -1.4397435188293457, -0.0304036233574152, -0.010021407157182693, -0.698560893535614, -0.18834950029850006, -0.2121671885251999, -0.10713052749633789, -0.13360707461833954, -0.4004991054534912, 0.5381718277931213, -1.1345452070236206, 0.07289453595876694, 0.7790501117706299, 0.10678476840257645, -0.4671480357646942, 0.06406356394290924, 1.2046540975570679, 1.1500244140625, 1.3603641986846924, 0.27572742104530334, 0.8442950248718262, 0.8046754598617554, 1.1486320495605469, 1.0893359184265137, 0.4046947658061981, -0.6207367181777954, -0.5340981483459473, 0.11207547783851624, 0.13500958681106567, 0.16192014515399933, 1.0240602493286133, 0.8652879595756531, -0.5482869744300842, -0.2388758361339569, -0.05937924236059189, -0.4397163391113281, -0.2763594090938568, -0.14702023565769196, 0.2684607207775116, -0.22445034980773926, 0.0710778757929802, 0.4503880739212036, 1.2847621440887451, 0.4717961251735687, -0.7231955528259277, -0.27557918429374695, -0.6279112696647644, 0.7103009819984436, -1.0046494007110596, 0.5915655493736267, -0.0026920889504253864, -0.25081685185432434, 0.009920022450387478, -0.011853660456836224, -0.540361225605011, -0.7176510691642761, 0.23877030611038208, -0.02489667385816574, 0.008200608193874359, 0.3292900323867798, 0.8130916357040405, 0.4987003207206726, -1.0749192237854004, -0.3048405349254608, -0.25825464725494385, 0.4291122257709503, -0.9100856184959412, 1.2786331176757812, 0.8408380746841431, 0.3531931936740875, -0.35666725039482117, 0.6905709505081177, -0.15841041505336761, -0.602504551410675, 0.23061591386795044, 0.06360835582017899, 0.1626027673482895, 0.3101281523704529, -0.32455024123191833, 0.2508900761604309, 0.3030846118927002, -0.17433321475982666, 0.48208504915237427, 0.03754403069615364, 0.17303544282913208, -0.04985051974654198, -0.02101667784154415, 0.08752430975437164, 0.17158865928649902, -0.18556945025920868, 0.22472494840621948, 0.4957837462425232, -0.8809255361557007, 3.8523120880126953, -0.2565745711326599, -0.13879135251045227, 0.4262475371360779, 0.20727607607841492, 0.4657595753669739, -0.12218450009822845, -0.6970147490501404, 0.3970199227333069, 0.9388585686683655, -0.47658419609069824, -0.31717249751091003, 0.2533716559410095, -0.07511264830827713, 1.0498404502868652, 0.5999689698219299, -0.008688117377460003, -0.13719134032726288, 0.2096092402935028, -0.4707088768482208, 0.446039617061615, -0.4562852680683136, 0.15550671517848969, -0.6612859964370728, 0.4609471261501312, -0.1545538753271103, 0.11021263897418976, -0.5395733118057251, -0.05996543541550636, -0.738564133644104, -0.18320181965827942, -0.44701850414276123, 0.8395192623138428, -0.2835477888584137, -0.23343241214752197, -0.25387313961982727, -0.12191908806562424, 0.09053605049848557, 0.017282159999012947, 0.467142790555954, 0.2848709523677826, -0.15759994089603424, -0.5368199944496155, -0.35549458861351013, 0.09333230555057526, 0.6753363013267517, -0.07813765853643417, 0.3889322876930237, 0.08673214912414551, -0.8892945051193237, 0.8842028975486755, -0.3794527053833008, 0.7735025882720947, -0.9027435779571533, -1.5186963081359863, 0.032402556389570236, -0.30883556604385376, -0.3869234621524811, -0.12804730236530304, 0.16006408631801605, 0.5204789638519287, 0.12484060972929001, 0.2462623566389084, 0.12146212160587311, -0.27923884987831116, -0.02565462328493595, 0.9165956377983093, -0.18479488790035248, 0.18115991353988647, 0.07030689716339111, -0.10363636910915375, 0.04398932680487633, -0.3987363576889038, -0.19487755000591278, -0.08380325138568878, -0.010983681306242943, -0.19252482056617737, 0.8270010948181152, 0.15676918625831604, 0.08482915163040161, -0.20985738933086395, 0.04374903067946434, -0.5910341143608093, 0.3688531219959259, 1.0455236434936523, 0.9111255407333374, -0.6429470181465149, 0.029152972623705864, -0.08412619680166245, 0.46033620834350586, 0.1598479300737381, 0.03847775608301163, 0.5127605199813843, 0.26719725131988525, -0.49008652567863464 ]
M\"o\ss{}bauer null redshift experiment II
Accurate limits for the violation of the Principle of Equivalence have been found from the comparison of the redshifts of two identical nuclear species in different chemical environments.
M. De Francia, G. Goya, R. C. Mercader and H. Vucetich
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211005
gr-qc/9211006
[ 0.010180258192121983, 0.9700021147727966, -0.18048617243766785, 0.022129317745566368, -0.06511688232421875, 0.3069225549697876, -0.5645164251327515, -0.33949029445648193, -0.35823899507522583, 1.7676995992660522, 0.239601269364357, -0.13315121829509735, 0.39131397008895874, -0.3671220541000366, -0.357319176197052, 0.06375502049922943, 0.09462666511535645, -0.18740753829479218, -0.7232623100280762, -0.16697101294994354, -0.39255574345588684, 0.6808837056159973, -0.9879744052886963, -0.8282864093780518, -0.9216923713684082, 1.0753469467163086, 0.6995626091957092, 0.2741429805755615, 1.2088489532470703, 1.0945528745651245, 0.7026312947273254, -0.08000397682189941, 0.20264175534248352, -0.6351432204246521, -0.5206356644630432, 0.13315029442310333, 0.4976288378238678, -0.17263908684253693, 0.3087255656719208, -0.9575225710868835, 0.5088376998901367, 0.310548335313797, 0.3333122134208679, -0.47149279713630676, -0.06088677793741226, 0.21793866157531738, 0.5472975969314575, 0.575402021408081, 0.12016162276268005, -0.7863433957099915, -0.2621268332004547, -0.2766013741493225, -0.26475954055786133, -0.5347743034362793, 0.5060418248176575, 0.3408317267894745, 0.16943542659282684, 0.0018928935751318932, -0.2947670519351959, 0.2996225655078888, 0.47698643803596497, 0.729978084564209, 0.33236563205718994, -1.236071228981018, -0.025987623259425163, 0.8069019317626953, -0.17471973598003387, 0.789125382900238, 0.4969371557235718, -0.3745444715023041, -0.09477681666612625, -0.3830277621746063, -0.8518165349960327, -0.05484188720583916, -0.560350775718689, 0.8317482471466064, -0.3295890986919403, -0.13977856934070587, -0.1750832200050354, -0.2499142438173294, 0.4397053122520447, 0.4598258137702942, 0.05140705406665802, 0.1370101273059845, -0.33887752890586853, -0.2654963731765747, -0.02842753753066063, -0.3402678072452545, -0.04753099009394646, 0.31109821796417236, 0.3930530846118927, 0.6051710247993469, 0.5574560165405273, 0.1375022530555725, 0.6105734705924988, 0.30563604831695557, -0.7318966388702393, 0.4426079988479614, -0.2152794599533081, 0.06326071172952652, -0.5879380106925964, 1.2846298217773438, -0.13316978514194489, -0.14287713170051575, -0.14730462431907654, 1.1270710229873657, -0.3118419945240021, 0.13922984898090363, -0.38270139694213867, -0.7556771039962769, -0.39893463253974915, 0.19226737320423126, -0.17550306022167206, 0.08292625844478607, 0.019240140914916992, 0.536398708820343, -0.430329293012619, -0.2132684737443924, -0.7036479115486145, 0.2210405319929123, -1.0145223140716553, 0.6419340968132019, 0.5263970494270325, 0.7101226449012756, -0.30005601048469543, -1.0989104509353638, -0.46421822905540466, 0.38164809346199036, -0.21847526729106903, 0.02464991807937622, -0.3216894567012787, -0.4821551740169525, 0.023069243878126144, 1.184718132019043, 0.3214297294616699, 0.265625, 0.1268732249736786, 0.3489871621131897, -0.3642929494380951, 0.004626811482012272, 0.0512988306581974, -0.3682645261287689, 0.42654144763946533, 1.23842191696167, -0.8023871183395386, 0.32141953706741333, -0.6111323833465576, -0.08381135016679764, -0.6910997033119202, -0.07129062712192535, 0.20050354301929474, -0.6324430704116821, -0.38302236795425415, -0.025216277688741684, -0.5398625731468201, -0.41828230023384094, -0.8018311858177185, -0.16396504640579224, -0.1731167882680893, -0.3532406985759735, 0.4692145586013794, -0.05319562181830406, 0.5606762766838074, 0.5071772933006287, -0.9488875269889832, -0.06119508296251297, -0.8483239412307739, -0.049636360257864, 0.13605353236198425, -0.0002147360355593264, 0.2810710668563843, 0.388083279132843, 0.7326254844665527, 0.7356727123260498, 0.6750896573066711, 0.020434584468603134, -0.39525067806243896, -0.379761666059494, -0.8425292372703552, 0.04574217274785042, -0.0390244759619236, -0.49375855922698975, 0.08344658464193344, 0.28815892338752747, -0.3607523739337921, -0.6660615801811218, 0.894660234451294, -0.7114925980567932, 0.1604670137166977, 0.19166962802410126, -0.20302820205688477, 0.794213056564331, -1.1099886894226074, 0.4035490155220032, -0.9863044023513794, -0.3802033066749573, -0.6509208679199219, -0.6432812213897705, 0.5778094530105591, -0.25907036662101746, 0.058642517775297165, -0.23961153626441956, -0.36173391342163086, 0.5425701141357422, -0.7010370492935181, 0.22285477817058563, 0.15502183139324188, 0.8745238780975342, -0.9273039698600769, 0.16233192384243011, 0.17315472662448883, -0.9640825390815735, -0.3824617862701416, -0.8046140670776367, 0.36117759346961975, 0.3392831087112427, -0.26390644907951355, 0.5642379522323608, 0.4096234142780304, -0.8108369708061218, 0.9451181292533875, 0.07220184803009033, 0.3604845106601715, 0.43775516748428345, -0.5286862254142761, -0.08188541978597641, -0.13567721843719482, 0.5627055764198303, 0.35387828946113586, 0.9514777064323425, -0.167572021484375, 0.567213773727417, -0.12577266991138458, 0.8346117734909058, 0.03390689566731453, -0.4864211082458496, 0.2837948203086853, 0.9842392802238464, -0.5510506629943848, 0.18081337213516235, 0.5514997839927673, -0.30446115136146545, 0.2940025329589844, 0.1463785320520401, -0.9694838523864746, -0.020856734365224838, -0.07293862104415894, 0.11602067947387695, -0.4577358067035675, 0.5606841444969177, -1.184419870376587, 0.4223165810108185, 0.5361724495887756, -0.054138410836458206, -1.4786369800567627, 0.06157929450273514, -0.2743670642375946, 0.9015321731567383, -0.17890489101409912, -0.36222395300865173, -0.2832571268081665, 0.260233074426651, -0.5241348147392273, -0.8658177256584167, -0.0007675057277083397, 0.35377299785614014, -0.4965248107910156, 0.4726245105266571, 0.26991987228393555, -0.3936006426811218, -1.1300208568572998, -0.34226444363594055, -0.1743277907371521, 0.012762805446982384, -0.7595016360282898, -0.6642710566520691, 0.4172518849372864, -0.0462314635515213, 0.3326036036014557, 0.5140909552574158, -0.22002561390399933, 0.32743242383003235, -0.04332977533340454, 0.3758017420768738, 0.058653272688388824, 0.04917271062731743, -1.2082691192626953, 0.5026789307594299, -0.35775524377822876, 0.6477670669555664, 0.11729059368371964, -0.7762571573257446, -0.6736978888511658, -0.8781006336212158, 0.5277949571609497, 0.30234894156455994, -0.05951735004782677, 0.6669085621833801, 0.11981653422117233, -0.5755824446678162, 0.37945809960365295, 0.1053733378648758, 0.02508988417685032, -0.5027704834938049, -0.9952521324157715, 0.8233293294906616, -0.002302421722561121, -0.33423006534576416, 0.9572317600250244, -0.04361364617943764, -0.6582677960395813, 0.5548900961875916, 0.0935521051287651, 0.405845582485199, -0.00782512966543436, 1.3891552686691284, 0.7961294054985046, 0.11707106232643127, 0.38552892208099365, -0.5262030959129333, -0.030529391020536423, -0.17134013772010803, 0.2412024736404419, -0.6532771587371826, 0.34776225686073303, 0.9923555254936218, 0.6151211857795715, -0.8043909668922424, 1.05170738697052, -0.9005879163742065, -1.0421077013015747, 0.14851632714271545, -0.24009959399700165, -0.24384425580501556, 0.20621682703495026, 0.08141910284757614, -1.112808108329773, -0.9492168426513672, -0.12572793662548065, 1.0539902448654175, 1.3252239227294922, -0.4076850712299347, 0.2329002171754837, 0.09225402772426605, 0.3884449005126953, -0.5857383012771606, 1.517783522605896, -0.6598369479179382, -0.3094116747379303, 0.2816086709499359, 0.4007512927055359, -0.23186862468719482, 0.23509539663791656, -0.08712656050920486, -0.3692059814929962, 0.32902806997299194, -0.7298529744148254, 0.30347898602485657, -0.10022305697202682, -0.40910089015960693, 0.6667739748954773, 0.009721449576318264, 0.011632557958364487, -0.6751420497894287, -0.7754443883895874, -0.15160341560840607, 0.4973808228969574, 0.3983936011791229, 0.297153502702713, -1.0250993967056274, 0.012660560198128223, 0.009547277353703976, -0.22471581399440765, 0.1058415025472641, 0.21894070506095886, 0.06300008296966553, 0.5448780059814453, 0.21895596385002136, 0.535311222076416, -0.19344374537467957, -0.7970029711723328, -0.062154144048690796, 0.7326419949531555, 0.8247462511062622, -0.16488321125507355, -0.12514470517635345, -0.8008061647415161, 0.26319319009780884, -0.6079453229904175, -0.940499484539032, 0.018223688006401062, -0.6331468224525452, 0.10217514634132385, -0.5029826760292053, -0.624796986579895, 0.11950059235095978, 0.5622416734695435, 0.5549091696739197, -0.26047638058662415, -0.013425190933048725, 0.3121001422405243, -0.6470723748207092, 0.20739594101905823, 0.3403204381465912, -0.21202774345874786, 0.5800977349281311, -0.7443807721138, 0.9779940247535706, 0.5367971658706665, 0.43746045231819153, 0.6003566980361938, -0.7525558471679688, 0.18611697852611542, -0.06380140781402588, 0.4499528706073761, 0.25593358278274536, -0.42585888504981995, 0.34192562103271484, 0.407317191362381, -0.4035528600215912, -0.28904375433921814, 0.3425702452659607, 0.24955599009990692, 0.703545093536377, 0.05379103124141693, -1.0443902015686035, -0.31726232171058655, -0.4013751447200775, -0.06974396109580994, 0.6478467583656311, -0.37637263536453247, -0.5778527855873108, -0.11875172704458237, 0.40654170513153076, 0.19267722964286804, 0.4378115236759186, 0.5366936326026917, 0.12242422997951508, 0.07676635682582855, 0.2630418539047241, -0.08186867088079453, 1.2308311462402344, 0.04547492787241936, -0.4128060042858124, -0.2873819172382355, 0.7441608905792236, 0.04225807636976242, 0.8097594976425171, -0.7415382862091064, -1.0658197402954102, -0.49404850602149963, -0.2525942921638489, 0.43756964802742004, 0.050589680671691895, -0.8378751277923584, -0.20745515823364258, 0.16632893681526184, 0.2384214699268341, 0.3506734073162079, -0.8327047824859619, 0.1632692813873291, -0.15927772223949432, -0.0186221431940794, -0.793358564376831, -0.8498846292495728, -0.1418834924697876, 0.3161013424396515, 0.7018334269523621, 0.07497330009937286, 0.48479408025741577, 0.7739572525024414, 0.7863503694534302, -0.13677214086055756, -0.20779789984226227, 0.670142412185669, -0.6633763313293457, -0.1518300175666809, -0.11552556604146957, 0.12897641956806183, 0.08979927748441696, 0.2783762216567993, 0.2771802246570587, -0.6854460835456848, 0.37593355774879456, -0.007316200062632561, -0.5851325392723083, -0.43410393595695496, -0.5478727221488953, -0.3171519935131073, 0.14224590361118317, -0.3029422461986542, -0.18583951890468597, -0.22780074179172516, -0.2638850808143616, -0.04827938601374626, -0.08728418499231339, 0.24178874492645264, -0.6532403230667114, -0.03185164928436279, 0.6028125882148743, -0.39615896344184875, 0.5910874009132385, -0.7715352773666382, 0.03177100792527199, -0.6957162022590637, -0.7052481770515442, -0.955901026725769, -0.3021860122680664, 0.06816267967224121, -0.021533187478780746, -0.06426043808460236, -0.1747233122587204, 0.45009496808052063, -0.03827445209026337, 0.12737546861171722, 1.02306067943573, -0.4016874432563782, -0.5784587860107422, -0.5903226733207703, -0.20726343989372253, 0.3053734302520752, -0.9634020924568176, -0.04139016568660736, 0.8103029131889343, -0.9261599779129028, 0.3988056182861328, -0.20203424990177155, -0.4851517677307129, 0.17200946807861328, -0.5942597985267639, 0.2750946581363678, -1.0930207967758179, 0.49787768721580505, 0.013704394921660423, -0.41993793845176697, 0.11804929375648499, 0.5028382539749146, 0.11657349020242691, -0.5336044430732727, -0.16359597444534302, -0.2681991457939148, 0.5953564047813416, -0.7301973700523376, 0.467189222574234, -0.9435930252075195, 0.3223852217197418, -0.3755318224430084, 1.3478955030441284, -0.7906405925750732, -0.5744724869728088, -0.477173388004303, 0.16646556556224823, -0.5279238820075989, 0.22611041367053986, -0.4200480580329895, 0.21548034250736237, -0.4158532917499542, 0.2627565264701843, 0.3567712903022766, 0.29311299324035645, -0.5243284702301025, -0.03933357074856758, -0.17011752724647522, -0.283495157957077, -0.746039867401123, 0.02995740994811058, 0.7892441749572754, 0.04083365201950073, 0.8824363946914673, -0.4091966152191162, 0.3973015546798706, 0.6172614693641663, 0.6099733114242554, 0.4111579358577728, -0.059777624905109406, -0.6407355666160583, -0.06572697311639786, -0.761978805065155, -0.4732537269592285, 0.8076145052909851, 0.20833781361579895, 0.13771671056747437, -0.38450753688812256, -0.20337995886802673, 0.1691717654466629, 0.06095285713672638, 0.3230980634689331, 0.005851028487086296, -0.17362286150455475, 0.8822017312049866, -1.1074504852294922, 0.31901636719703674, -0.3625187277793884, -0.18148455023765564, 0.6569985151290894, 0.05283043161034584, -0.10987228900194168, -0.42511335015296936, -0.1598723977804184, -0.3288438022136688, -0.11908961832523346, 0.19826775789260864, 0.70871901512146, -0.23267658054828644, 1.1513946056365967, -0.44472336769104004, -0.6154583692550659, -0.29148876667022705, -0.09796300530433655, 1.240087628364563, -0.4460778534412384, -0.008515506982803345, 0.2987052798271179, -0.06790440529584885, 0.8178532123565674, -0.07368962466716766, -0.7432215809822083, -0.4078528881072998, 0.9099516868591309, -0.6971476674079895, -0.08090819418430328, 0.16304180026054382, -0.08004303276538849, -0.41910335421562195, -0.9377429485321045, -1.0215497016906738, -0.28157100081443787, 0.82927405834198, -0.6674568057060242, 0.24637667834758759, -0.25952601432800293, 0.534844160079956, -0.36792951822280884, 0.38601574301719666, 0.8942596912384033, 0.4977712035179138, 0.47711247205734253, 0.024335701018571854, -0.8678343296051025, 0.24559053778648376, 1.224353551864624, 0.27210891246795654, -0.4218408167362213, -0.5020220875740051, 0.16183391213417053, -0.30128443241119385, 0.21989800035953522, 0.6212518215179443, -0.8419045805931091, 0.8414900898933411, 0.6283130645751953, -0.030444663017988205, 0.4063529372215271, 0.4612574875354767, -0.0726509541273117, 0.41858145594596863, -0.7808331847190857, -0.5935103893280029, -0.16365979611873627, 0.6099755764007568, 0.05917709320783615, 0.43667086958885193, 0.3596673011779785, -0.3319946527481079, 0.13488323986530304, -0.551964521408081, -0.3257482647895813, -0.925815999507904, -0.34565269947052, -1.117104411125183, -1.2769997119903564, -0.9387674331665039, 0.08254405111074448, 0.5662866830825806, 0.2771296501159668, -0.9384516477584839, 0.40246516466140747, -0.16321270167827606, 0.42286890745162964, 0.28423798084259033, 0.8638530969619751, -0.78610759973526, -0.5564978718757629, -1.462087869644165, 0.024131877347826958, -0.41829320788383484, -0.98554927110672, -0.5624462962150574, -0.5181519985198975, 0.5649856925010681, 0.9806531667709351, -1.0005426406860352, 0.06615094840526581, 0.06223777309060097, -0.252302885055542, -0.07048159837722778, -0.12152907252311707, -0.9813723564147949, 1.1548891067504883, -0.529866099357605, 0.2173716276884079, 0.2546071708202362, -0.08881821483373642, 0.30314168334007263, 0.08262079209089279, -0.7823924422264099, 0.36977753043174744, 0.43540963530540466, 1.1526200771331787, 0.951206624507904, -0.8322278261184692, -0.24036823213100433, 0.10317423939704895, -0.9737414717674255, -0.428877055644989, -0.5932908058166504, 0.007875430397689342, -0.11766026169061661, 0.11972341686487198, -0.029663896188139915, 0.84588623046875, 0.13102194666862488, 0.7612506151199341, -0.7937322854995728, 0.3065614700317383, 0.28317496180534363, 0.04701283574104309, -0.8469706177711487, -0.19936983287334442, 0.28980380296707153, -0.8723417520523071, 1.0196757316589355, 0.3966972529888153, -0.2332613468170166, 0.23223549127578735, -0.19188269972801208, -0.8026646375656128, -0.7563241720199585, 0.42660850286483765, -0.4081423282623291, 0.5983935594558716, -0.1869255006313324, 0.02539432980120182, 0.9846686124801636, -0.6173061728477478, -1.3974499702453613, 0.2994670867919922, -0.1633416712284088, -0.44970881938934326, 0.2459006905555725, -0.17085257172584534, -0.12748312950134277, 0.054650597274303436, -0.6150238513946533, -0.16436468064785004, -0.2138119339942932, 1.1254831552505493, 0.4822593033313751, 0.0925152525305748, -0.1875000149011612, 0.39370831847190857, -0.8758084177970886, -0.06211501359939575, -0.45661047101020813, 0.21063947677612305, -1.1273760795593262, -0.8811128735542297, -0.04712589457631111, 0.3483174443244934, -0.6952731609344482, -0.41496342420578003, -0.22666189074516296, -0.20359861850738525, 0.14412054419517517, -0.1218038871884346, 0.09020731598138809, -0.11315274983644485, 0.0331309549510479, 0.14562714099884033, 0.4093016982078552, 0.006613023579120636, 0.2657489478588104, 0.14301060140132904, 0.871486246585846, 0.38104885816574097, 0.18834100663661957, 1.1894786357879639, -0.20199424028396606, 0.01851269230246544, 0.8157589435577393, 0.04677426815032959, 0.7645246982574463, 0.8303621411323547, -0.35921651124954224, -0.326555073261261, -0.033786073327064514, -0.19395257532596588, 0.707503080368042, -0.1579069048166275, 0.26921015977859497, 0.5342646241188049, 0.10120552033185959, -0.10604049265384674, 0.29918649792671204, -0.4391677975654602, -0.5319156050682068, 1.2333965301513672, -0.6213182210922241, 0.43451988697052, 0.20928621292114258, -0.21627429127693176, 0.2531123459339142, 0.002046678913757205, -0.09256545454263687, -0.8361254930496216, -0.34984663128852844, 0.6108682155609131, -0.20537100732326508, -0.9811719059944153, -0.5911444425582886, 0.09677496552467346, -0.23736751079559326, -0.009430733509361744, -0.23562248051166534, 0.6174461841583252, 0.7081543803215027, 0.4178917706012726, -0.5535807609558105, 0.33754128217697144, -0.007351885084062815, 0.8648588061332703, 0.9865766167640686, 0.41282081604003906, 0.1050882339477539, 0.297026127576828, -0.13394410908222198, -0.6985087990760803, 0.3218388855457306, 0.026183733716607094, -0.5527263283729553, -0.45856860280036926, 0.29046428203582764, 0.05662951245903969, -0.20367853343486786, -0.7306156158447266, -0.3894013464450836, -0.5297562479972839, 0.13451316952705383, -0.15358029305934906, -0.23009589314460754, 0.02452811598777771, 0.26021870970726013, 0.06928162276744843, 0.19770406186580658, 0.1711002141237259, 0.6643182039260864, -0.12493622303009033, 0.8032247424125671, 0.8249654173851013, -0.3096417188644409, 0.17784206569194794, -0.5042980313301086, -0.24874043464660645, 0.4042353630065918, 0.41306495666503906, -0.024158110842108727, 0.28114622831344604, -0.5499942898750305, 0.1516781449317932, -0.551466703414917, -0.37743714451789856, -0.41844555735588074, 0.2962792217731476, 0.19360992312431335, 0.8044508695602417, -0.11687707901000977, 0.5856514573097229, 0.5211436152458191, 0.6231432557106018, -0.22660720348358154, -0.3527884781360626, 0.7142464518547058, -0.5413457155227661, 0.2898808717727661, -0.6922040581703186, 0.5648530125617981, -0.04944790154695511, 0.20332208275794983, -0.6958332061767578, -0.11841452121734619, -0.9687470197677612, -0.8146393895149231, -0.10234221071004868, 0.19055426120758057, 0.3744405508041382, 1.1641587018966675, -0.18062040209770203, 0.4301134943962097, -0.5405752658843994, -0.23441405594348907, 0.15219047665596008, 0.7142393589019775, -0.38864150643348694, 0.011175481602549553, 0.32400476932525635, -0.0011316491290926933, -0.39481863379478455, 1.1686331033706665, 0.977591335773468, 0.06450334191322327, 0.2672238349914551, -0.24496018886566162, -0.05657642334699631, 0.11675584316253662, -0.31315383315086365, 0.07605169713497162, 0.3560498356819153, 0.41965892910957336, -0.32168883085250854, -0.37910473346710205, 0.29944348335266113, -0.12252260744571686, -0.1725551038980484, -0.016880325973033905, 0.775242030620575, 0.5964956879615784, -0.6003593802452087, -0.0863838940858841, -0.08208108693361282, 3.9877448081970215, 0.0973498672246933, 0.4794589877128601, -0.42040368914604187, 0.6282286643981934, 0.9277048707008362, 0.029238739982247353, 0.4324537217617035, 0.4667656719684601, -1.0380421876907349, -0.036257997155189514, 0.06804302334785461, 0.19904273748397827, 0.5348644256591797, 0.2265658974647522, 0.676047146320343, -0.13747426867485046, 0.12258309125900269, 0.45896339416503906, -0.6501176357269287, -0.8376020193099976, 0.3572905957698822, 0.13289356231689453, -0.3888229727745056, 0.5285263657569885, 0.9458199143409729, 0.4261232316493988, -0.2774710953235626, -0.5158405303955078, -0.13095949590206146, -0.08272893726825714, -0.40091776847839355, 0.6260436177253723, -0.04665103554725647, -1.2184326648712158, 0.33273667097091675, -0.3547862768173218, -0.10839292407035828, 0.22069497406482697, -0.6116307377815247, 0.23811949789524078, -0.5328786969184875, 0.002486484358087182, -0.32625338435173035, -0.14394770562648773, 1.0587184429168701, 1.1355448961257935, 0.4528542160987854, 0.8380299210548401, -0.971551239490509, -0.24997250735759735, 0.36098307371139526, 0.832683265209198, -0.5154930353164673, -0.5243178009986877, -0.3258596956729889, 0.10003435611724854, -0.5592777729034424, -0.18374189734458923, 0.07256525009870529, 0.9219304323196411, 0.3233919143676758, -0.4357225298881531, -0.4214201271533966, 0.31238487362861633, -0.13670602440834045, 0.782743513584137, -0.07193703204393387, -0.18245349824428558, -0.6018990874290466, -1.0231815576553345, 0.43115466833114624, -0.45915624499320984, -0.7317003607749939, 0.5298482775688171, 0.2589547336101532, -0.3596722483634949, 0.6360156536102295, -0.1468878835439682, -0.21868915855884552, -1.0041704177856445, -0.30505064129829407, -0.07546809315681458, 0.7373766303062439, -0.4974488317966461, 0.589522123336792, 0.4465312957763672, -0.5021078586578369, -0.30542251467704773, 0.5311911106109619, -0.1753697693347931, 0.45370736718177795, -0.3935680687427521, 0.8890547752380371, -0.23397552967071533 ]
Wormhole Cosmology and the Horizon Problem
We construct an explicit class of dynamic lorentzian wormholes connecting Friedmann-Robertson-Walker (FRW) spacetimes. These wormholes can allow two-way transmission of signals between spatially separated regions of spacetime and could permit such regions to come into thermal contact. The cosmology of a network of early Universe wormholes is discussed.
David Hochberg and Thomas W. Kephart
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211006
gr-qc/9211007
[ 0.14994408190250397, 0.4338923394680023, 0.7955792546272278, -0.07420085370540619, 0.11651773750782013, -0.18044224381446838, -0.10795190930366516, 0.21417438983917236, -0.17850038409233093, 1.4425796270370483, 0.022451475262641907, -0.10546553134918213, -0.24955719709396362, -0.6338236331939697, -0.31818878650665283, 0.31569579243659973, -0.13202619552612305, -0.8497792482376099, -1.5408846139907837, 0.21775348484516144, -0.4716755747795105, -0.0018324380507692695, -0.7642074227333069, -0.9010810852050781, 0.11135264486074448, 0.9352954030036926, 0.07852543145418167, 0.7665076851844788, 0.8277125954627991, 0.34214717149734497, 0.03422824665904045, -0.07756004482507706, 0.019359925761818886, -0.5427546501159668, -0.1356530487537384, 0.023376217111945152, -0.033565398305654526, -0.47306787967681885, 0.21295784413814545, 0.12332124263048172, 0.39945319294929504, -0.11489453911781311, 0.26107290387153625, -0.19637461006641388, -0.23671570420265198, 0.08359430730342865, -0.09998304396867752, 0.7225695252418518, -0.45895618200302124, -0.8074350357055664, -0.06917675584554672, -0.3845369219779968, 0.25145766139030457, -0.9778221845626831, -0.5055869221687317, -0.011640666052699089, 0.20588789880275726, 0.1657867580652237, -0.4375084340572357, -0.5258060097694397, -0.20093479752540588, 0.32077160477638245, -0.11274466663599014, -0.5801875591278076, -0.2729687988758087, 0.9685718417167664, -0.06674308329820633, 0.3773271143436432, 0.16486626863479614, -0.1526465117931366, -0.5669182538986206, -0.19206570088863373, 0.32497233152389526, 0.22736182808876038, -0.40802934765815735, 0.6384918093681335, -0.30792325735092163, -0.6721413135528564, -0.2483208328485489, -0.5279287695884705, -0.1017955020070076, 0.5905866622924805, 0.05772973597049713, 0.40762442350387573, -0.03656378760933876, -0.47491100430488586, 0.23671598732471466, 0.13443785905838013, 0.7668039202690125, 0.25671374797821045, -0.5433798432350159, 0.7521746754646301, -0.414680540561676, -0.0151253966614604, 0.9636496901512146, 0.6497600674629211, -0.03691832721233368, 0.7685024738311768, 0.3561941087245941, 0.25416240096092224, -0.3950946033000946, 0.8886659145355225, -0.8752060532569885, 0.20814476907253265, -0.2098044753074646, 0.851109504699707, -0.4755890369415283, 0.8057831525802612, -0.40708646178245544, -0.4074312150478363, 0.5385527014732361, 0.1430021971464157, 0.8290260434150696, 0.7032020092010498, 0.13786526024341583, 0.7021227478981018, -0.9433112144470215, -0.28216925263404846, -1.4679327011108398, -0.4107299745082855, -0.4090316891670227, 0.6693718433380127, 0.04536481574177742, 0.5540838837623596, -0.4119965434074402, -0.45506593585014343, -0.2265339493751526, 0.9249759912490845, -0.13184310495853424, 1.0214319229125977, 0.661763072013855, -0.40202099084854126, 0.28060999512672424, 0.7943769693374634, -0.03458987548947334, -0.1258862167596817, -0.16237056255340576, 0.34272488951683044, -0.430500328540802, -0.4389534592628479, 0.03664223104715347, -0.7400010228157043, 0.43614649772644043, 1.4680403470993042, -0.950959324836731, 0.5914754867553711, 0.15425240993499756, -0.19464243948459625, -0.8199425935745239, -0.23942385613918304, -0.6855120062828064, -0.26876747608184814, 0.04086662456393242, 0.3483414649963379, 0.31643015146255493, -0.22435669600963593, -0.9251669645309448, -0.5330219268798828, -0.07694452255964279, -0.17579661309719086, 1.201706886291504, -0.051677726209163666, 0.09526880085468292, 1.4387917518615723, -0.19333764910697937, 0.34666112065315247, -0.5361315608024597, -0.34105387330055237, 0.6663373112678528, -0.057212263345718384, -0.16710138320922852, 0.21568720042705536, 0.2880503535270691, 0.5993812680244446, 0.8072587847709656, 0.45501235127449036, 0.33247110247612, 0.02705564722418785, -0.9241753816604614, 0.7047691345214844, 0.43358689546585083, -0.3736373782157898, 0.9761661887168884, 0.6095269322395325, -0.5460140705108643, -0.39871490001678467, 0.6612638235092163, -0.83180171251297, -0.06757837533950806, 0.022530239075422287, -0.4137062728404999, 0.2952777147293091, -0.6235438585281372, 0.2777545154094696, -1.2085310220718384, 0.485860139131546, -0.8202602863311768, 0.13243788480758667, -0.5652039051055908, 0.47871121764183044, 0.15317608416080475, -0.18285034596920013, -1.2301054000854492, -0.016473352909088135, -0.9321129322052002, 0.02087622880935669, 0.6942136883735657, 0.5076143145561218, -0.4377685785293579, -0.42211079597473145, 0.577396035194397, -0.4769653081893921, 0.047762610018253326, -0.2621917426586151, 0.10691431164741516, 0.11599531024694443, -0.7148579955101013, 0.5441426634788513, 0.3163747787475586, 0.07691670209169388, 0.295949786901474, 0.07231368869543076, -0.5478801131248474, 1.179958701133728, 0.19247367978096008, -0.4432874917984009, -0.1916031837463379, 0.2024863213300705, 0.46326953172683716, 0.2649807631969452, 0.2894190847873688, 0.27105745673179626, 0.07811175286769867, 0.578540563583374, 0.8154900670051575, -0.13524290919303894, 0.6443124413490295, 0.9508249759674072, 0.15025965869426727, 0.19243057072162628, 0.11869533360004425, 0.27051544189453125, 0.2746726870536804, 0.27181729674339294, -0.6500344276428223, 0.5579707026481628, 0.10405468195676804, 0.1289893090724945, -0.2857770323753357, 1.4360779523849487, -0.8373829126358032, 0.32387980818748474, -0.014715795405209064, 0.08635780215263367, -1.3067933320999146, -0.07717818021774292, -0.39981064200401306, 0.2949026823043823, 0.43307483196258545, -0.20397250354290009, -0.16826540231704712, -0.175614595413208, -0.20353853702545166, -0.43186044692993164, -0.16215156018733978, -0.009089862927794456, -0.5449251532554626, -0.20688170194625854, 0.6023010611534119, -0.2581808269023895, -1.3088068962097168, -0.04595539718866348, -0.19113555550575256, 0.22804182767868042, -0.2779340147972107, -0.36867833137512207, 0.390214204788208, 0.13082915544509888, 0.5444728136062622, 0.25906509160995483, -0.049798596650362015, -0.19614562392234802, -0.5990938544273376, 0.231233149766922, -0.02966117486357689, 0.45583978295326233, -1.140074372291565, -0.287163645029068, -0.7734284400939941, 0.564217209815979, -0.6374163031578064, -0.4283270835876465, 0.4512695372104645, -0.22135889530181885, 0.570850133895874, 0.32397016882896423, -0.022180279716849327, 0.113017238676548, -0.41480809450149536, -0.41756585240364075, 0.08932582288980484, 0.14723776280879974, 0.202632874250412, -0.1083982065320015, -0.2667839825153351, 1.3198469877243042, -0.23907214403152466, -0.2007853388786316, 0.6272789835929871, -0.38076457381248474, -0.717464029788971, 0.49858009815216064, 0.6393882036209106, 0.8167237639427185, -0.46694716811180115, 0.9009900689125061, 0.21324339509010315, -0.24577614665031433, 0.11994479596614838, -0.5962589383125305, -0.5207276344299316, -0.5306901335716248, 1.0281423330307007, -0.8621971607208252, -0.142401784658432, 1.176648736000061, 0.7722127437591553, -0.5337958335876465, 0.9379545450210571, -0.962560772895813, -0.29605165123939514, 0.19205863773822784, -0.5069159269332886, 0.6682016849517822, 0.4670073688030243, 0.13686400651931763, -0.48968392610549927, -0.8190873265266418, -0.16182266175746918, 0.4103461802005768, 0.4990963339805603, -0.23440712690353394, -0.36732804775238037, 0.5920440554618835, 0.08081557601690292, -0.09372899681329727, 0.31942319869995117, -0.4982645809650421, 0.2937416136264801, 0.06993506848812103, -0.4685053527355194, -0.27324381470680237, 0.27192142605781555, -0.35096508264541626, 0.056420717388391495, 0.06285849213600159, -0.439888596534729, -0.21916155517101288, -0.7991012930870056, -0.3124445974826813, 0.5945743918418884, 0.433702677488327, -0.24675476551055908, -0.7501630783081055, -0.4036162197589874, -0.21925920248031616, -0.03590388968586922, 0.5952783226966858, 0.22206705808639526, -0.6209793090820312, 0.17581436038017273, 0.9458848237991333, -0.17682655155658722, 0.1710258424282074, -0.5905443429946899, 0.45522087812423706, 0.8021262884140015, 0.31955936551094055, 0.2857377231121063, 0.6088610887527466, -0.045936379581689835, -0.8381356596946716, 0.49793338775634766, 0.5886734127998352, 0.22865724563598633, 0.15772853791713715, -0.3208779990673065, 0.22084957361221313, -0.24070137739181519, -0.2902206480503082, -0.6294645071029663, -0.6914326548576355, -0.07686261832714081, -0.45744621753692627, 0.022447209805250168, 0.11734368652105331, -0.08363596349954605, 0.6431027054786682, -0.26519572734832764, 0.04074405878782272, -0.28006812930107117, 0.5631808042526245, 0.36256685853004456, 0.40819236636161804, -0.4942319095134735, 0.019929174333810806, -0.646172821521759, -0.1427634209394455, 0.44249165058135986, 0.6247977614402771, 0.43341439962387085, -1.1958813667297363, 0.1014726534485817, -0.19271321594715118, 0.8718863129615784, 0.1684303730726242, -0.82914137840271, 0.9384082555770874, 0.36294159293174744, -0.048231083899736404, -0.263229101896286, 0.48528027534484863, 0.5247655510902405, 0.5782511830329895, -0.22693751752376556, -0.8840019702911377, 0.057479482144117355, -0.5964465141296387, 0.26019909977912903, 0.21965394914150238, -0.646578848361969, -0.3480084538459778, -0.4520392417907715, -0.3816601037979126, 0.3178817629814148, 0.46637919545173645, 0.6720322966575623, 0.6636670231819153, 1.0217094421386719, -0.13486260175704956, -0.24631348252296448, 0.8323573470115662, 0.2833165228366852, -0.4653487801551819, 0.01392980758100748, 0.27954909205436707, -0.12607920169830322, 0.557773232460022, -0.07762150466442108, -0.9886136651039124, -0.08977680653333664, 0.07937416434288025, 0.5923056602478027, 0.0901905745267868, -0.9744501709938049, -0.3058863878250122, -0.298568457365036, 0.13409364223480225, 1.000732183456421, -0.09123195707798004, -0.00827596615999937, 0.352097749710083, -0.6070232391357422, -0.13818712532520294, -0.3739365339279175, 0.44642946124076843, -0.07028505206108093, 0.8697947263717651, 1.2006057500839233, 0.301444411277771, 0.006438817363232374, -0.06230317801237106, -0.06726089119911194, 0.4045960605144501, 0.6787887811660767, -0.5415184497833252, -0.2569422721862793, 0.03668340668082237, -0.5732526779174805, -0.5165712833404541, -0.5623615980148315, 0.5476455688476562, -0.22467343509197235, -0.03505604341626167, 0.160576730966568, -0.16808804869651794, -0.500457763671875, -0.6146903038024902, -1.1288975477218628, 0.1875738948583603, -0.46593165397644043, -0.4473797380924225, 0.4646190404891968, -0.8343479633331299, -0.10447777062654495, -0.5808130502700806, 0.07978878170251846, -0.20646513998508453, -0.2693391740322113, 0.40611737966537476, -0.5111082196235657, 0.2863892614841461, -0.7131245136260986, 0.39641839265823364, -0.016061797738075256, -0.2968428134918213, -0.9564486145973206, -0.17801371216773987, 0.3455120921134949, 0.26522910594940186, 0.14713269472122192, 0.11412560939788818, -0.17971271276474, -0.0017114339862018824, -0.10628622770309448, 0.4263787567615509, -0.23604923486709595, -0.6934024691581726, 0.3606712818145752, 0.4784245789051056, 0.3380992114543915, -0.6930102109909058, -0.2258266657590866, 0.8216627240180969, 0.022797642275691032, 0.6117286086082458, 0.11062762141227722, -0.302613765001297, 0.4144900441169739, -1.3380051851272583, 0.7564787268638611, -0.8446389436721802, -0.480299711227417, -0.8725195527076721, -0.12140689045190811, 0.5285151600837708, 0.16409392654895782, 0.03486795350909233, -0.8210034370422363, -0.3644961714744568, -0.7310113310813904, 0.655593752861023, -0.5259349942207336, -0.05320151895284653, -0.8815733790397644, -0.5257842540740967, -0.9446789026260376, 0.9293069839477539, -0.4333128035068512, 0.13619433343410492, 0.9457241892814636, -0.009586161002516747, -0.11802156269550323, -0.08851639181375504, 0.1689889281988144, -0.013613080605864525, -0.5966740846633911, -0.18747535347938538, 0.38904455304145813, 0.4432421624660492, -0.3416231870651245, 0.2541680634021759, -0.8298045992851257, 0.7618458271026611, -0.2470128834247589, -0.27989286184310913, 0.2216690629720688, -0.28605785965919495, 0.4788290858268738, -0.8775037527084351, -0.7492695450782776, 1.003706932067871, -0.09181544929742813, 0.342511922121048, -0.14674949645996094, -0.6008327603340149, -0.7933310270309448, -0.6152318716049194, -0.3098526895046234, 0.3025520145893097, -0.3785625398159027, -0.24145491421222687, -0.8765262961387634, -0.49120020866394043, 0.21474331617355347, -0.10102313756942749, 0.7735120058059692, 0.2143135964870453, 0.3879343271255493, 0.254192054271698, -0.47296687960624695, -0.014765709638595581, -0.4112870693206787, 0.4386242926120758, 0.0807674378156662, -0.013464781455695629, 0.14562693238258362, -0.18773293495178223, -0.32375094294548035, -0.5958362817764282, -0.4462803900241852, 0.020026307553052902, 0.7467369437217712, -0.6864842772483826, 0.30022022128105164, 0.5920164585113525, -0.2841198742389679, -0.49520549178123474, 0.028463007882237434, 0.0014773558359593153, 0.03843154385685921, 0.3102482855319977, 0.17736555635929108, 0.26272857189178467, 0.6125840544700623, 0.24568703770637512, -0.28226378560066223, -0.24655462801456451, 0.9546874165534973, -0.8696925640106201, -0.041946277022361755, -0.20954746007919312, 0.03827395290136337, -0.43802380561828613, -1.2028851509094238, -0.6359756588935852, 0.0015786518342792988, 0.770943820476532, -0.29205262660980225, 0.28057408332824707, -0.32313138246536255, -0.08063873648643494, 0.20948688685894012, 0.026862002909183502, 0.9178131818771362, -0.035518791526556015, -0.08850564807653427, -0.22146667540073395, -0.6960234045982361, 0.612820565700531, 1.3523114919662476, 0.40412086248397827, -0.8413671851158142, -0.21345828473567963, 0.11474671959877014, -0.6365965604782104, -0.2106105238199234, 0.46142372488975525, -0.32197779417037964, 0.16525833308696747, -0.46901851892471313, -0.16962888836860657, 0.14826177060604095, 0.03769742324948311, -0.635549783706665, 0.42738303542137146, -0.7699060440063477, -0.37246793508529663, 0.04402509331703186, 0.1492566466331482, 0.31573548913002014, 0.5458762049674988, 0.22702248394489288, -0.04095197096467018, -0.27629414200782776, 0.49792227149009705, 0.20073479413986206, -0.7044512629508972, -0.33805152773857117, -0.9281226992607117, -0.4849686324596405, -1.0336167812347412, -0.3502999246120453, -0.16480176150798798, 0.23707032203674316, -0.10590700060129166, 0.3268161416053772, 0.14645932614803314, -0.08481862396001816, 0.5378406643867493, 0.7750318050384521, -0.5825849175453186, -0.9629570245742798, -0.5459715723991394, 0.1917620152235031, 0.006075710523873568, -1.3475703001022339, -0.4857294261455536, 0.055021245032548904, 0.28969117999076843, 0.7914656400680542, 0.15882372856140137, 0.3280525207519531, -0.5458468198776245, -0.649002730846405, 0.46912577748298645, 0.97006756067276, -0.5638076663017273, 0.7407647371292114, -0.18507765233516693, 0.8595656156539917, 0.2566072344779968, -0.5902726054191589, -0.61906898021698, 0.6753630638122559, -0.655000627040863, 0.7820153832435608, 0.4138731062412262, 0.8421542644500732, 0.20093700289726257, -1.138909935951233, 0.09462186694145203, 0.49446308612823486, -0.9503951072692871, 0.47207507491111755, -0.538404107093811, 0.3575094938278198, -0.6055639982223511, 0.30138474702835083, 0.21760112047195435, 0.349058598279953, -0.20631344616413116, 0.46984443068504333, -0.8616095185279846, -0.3621128797531128, 0.05955309420824051, 0.32763662934303284, -0.3531512916088104, -0.5199496150016785, 0.9040266871452332, -0.4801136553287506, 0.6397579908370972, 0.050651099532842636, 0.13095659017562866, 0.008166723884642124, 0.10552940517663956, -0.3198075294494629, -0.8854929208755493, -0.027921920642256737, 0.08728906512260437, 0.8716910481452942, 0.047963593155145645, -0.3093770444393158, 1.091742753982544, -0.41497156023979187, -1.3046642541885376, 0.1428167223930359, -0.14731217920780182, -0.41673871874809265, 0.2775660753250122, -0.5716649889945984, 0.06869025528430939, 0.5603697896003723, -0.7315349578857422, -0.050192706286907196, 0.12916845083236694, 1.6909513473510742, 0.9115389585494995, -0.004668591544032097, 0.07883918285369873, 0.005080399103462696, -0.20501789450645447, -0.17863337695598602, 0.0750611424446106, 0.233561173081398, -1.0328718423843384, -0.7644873261451721, -0.4864322543144226, 0.25941142439842224, -0.32829204201698303, -0.3151756525039673, 0.0833858773112297, -0.5573899745941162, -0.4450831115245819, 0.04879108443856239, -0.2896677255630493, -0.6254164576530457, -0.9015129208564758, 0.2943595349788666, 0.036471690982580185, -0.287331223487854, -0.031040826812386513, 0.22044304013252258, 0.37527287006378174, 0.4819740951061249, -0.19434036314487457, 0.8759793043136597, -0.0032400772906839848, -0.2860417664051056, 0.4883718192577362, 0.21237227320671082, 0.3312649726867676, 0.38224515318870544, -0.7752245664596558, 0.6673249006271362, 0.5975355505943298, 0.4049111008644104, 0.6112244725227356, -0.12485650926828384, -0.14189191162586212, 0.9175567626953125, 0.19882860779762268, 0.5076465606689453, 0.3159782886505127, 0.23826724290847778, -0.6525981426239014, 0.6515437960624695, -0.2555522322654724, -0.2177262008190155, 0.15687786042690277, 0.34263911843299866, 0.11162501573562622, -0.0791638046503067, -0.43660929799079895, -0.22424425184726715, 0.18122154474258423, 0.228557288646698, -0.5050629377365112, -1.0031846761703491, -0.8138272166252136, 0.17615389823913574, 0.06395342946052551, 0.1685645878314972, 0.3649269640445709, 0.13400106132030487, 0.4439374804496765, -0.18555966019630432, -0.6158298850059509, 0.8947706818580627, 0.18406467139720917, 1.2014977931976318, 0.5485997200012207, 0.32264426350593567, -0.32835304737091064, 0.052396055310964584, -0.13003361225128174, -0.5536110401153564, -0.2278863787651062, 0.5389958620071411, -1.2881975173950195, 0.13474372029304504, -0.4172549843788147, -0.4085226058959961, -0.42301779985427856, -0.37909892201423645, -0.0815817341208458, -0.29099324345588684, -0.011225422844290733, -0.4664016664028168, -0.4228116273880005, -0.23334099352359772, 0.38488128781318665, 0.14949572086334229, -0.0027991002425551414, 0.7046802639961243, 0.6159792542457581, -0.28895801305770874, 0.6347015500068665, 0.522992730140686, 0.34768256545066833, 0.24808382987976074, -0.34229210019111633, -0.683994710445404, 0.6816923022270203, 0.023965507745742798, -0.15107572078704834, 0.06426874548196793, -1.0818201303482056, -0.1918545961380005, 0.41971516609191895, -0.02747795544564724, 0.22782117128372192, -0.08019260317087173, 0.4412943720817566, -0.03923295438289642, -0.19523154199123383, 0.3182491362094879, 0.3207971453666687, 0.5382199287414551, -0.8274329900741577, -0.5757653117179871, 0.5552611947059631, -0.885709822177887, 0.18508628010749817, -1.4936894178390503, 0.5532812476158142, 0.781093955039978, -0.23621906340122223, -0.4227537214756012, -0.1673559546470642, -0.5079210996627808, -0.2525913715362549, -0.24713745713233948, -0.3074834644794464, 0.22011595964431763, 1.0607582330703735, -0.08050484210252762, -0.24004152417182922, -0.18336068093776703, -0.3320748805999756, -0.1204097792506218, 1.2183691263198853, 0.3386078178882599, 0.29754891991615295, 0.29720816016197205, -0.19499319791793823, -0.7689701318740845, 0.8519029021263123, 0.5086884498596191, -0.567266047000885, 0.7043406367301941, -0.06931596249341965, 0.6385287046432495, 0.06443475931882858, -0.6017457842826843, 0.29478439688682556, 0.5905382037162781, 0.1993192732334137, 0.43211600184440613, -0.39316028356552124, -0.01088572759181261, -0.5701554417610168, 0.20804955065250397, -0.18341416120529175, 0.506014347076416, 0.09876809269189835, -0.5466073751449585, 0.42699795961380005, -0.6731091737747192, 4.138120651245117, 0.7753363251686096, 0.3416235148906708, -0.17660315334796906, -0.09091166406869888, 0.7775665521621704, -0.10774187743663788, -0.004026360809803009, 0.4792080223560333, -0.2636159360408783, -0.011494754813611507, -0.5124399662017822, 0.8796655535697937, 0.37951990962028503, -0.3460858166217804, 0.9626369476318359, 0.10181533545255661, 0.6393638849258423, -0.5318132042884827, -1.0209563970565796, -0.7696399092674255, 0.3844609558582306, 0.1758849322795868, -0.18271192908287048, 0.5270665884017944, 0.10330642759799957, 0.22923292219638824, -0.16112013161182404, -0.8470829725265503, -0.4541165232658386, -0.5991014838218689, -0.5668286681175232, -0.16291792690753937, 0.007989487610757351, -1.2123701572418213, 0.3507917523384094, -0.42709726095199585, -0.4787343442440033, 0.28098225593566895, 0.26157015562057495, 0.13146403431892395, -0.5211285948753357, 0.5832662582397461, -0.5657386183738708, 0.4278445839881897, 0.17752021551132202, -0.02441287785768509, 0.36465778946876526, 0.4609632194042206, -0.8698524236679077, 0.34110668301582336, -0.11927636712789536, 0.2381373941898346, -0.029850982129573822, -0.8450844883918762, -0.9579891562461853, -0.28025954961776733, 0.18426339328289032, 0.25651806592941284, 0.17585965991020203, 0.4318462312221527, -0.2319716513156891, -0.04373367503285408, 0.21571773290634155, -0.06110703945159912, 0.6131479740142822, 0.29942166805267334, -0.41947248578071594, 0.2541445791721344, -0.3057026267051697, -0.8035144209861755, -0.03284749761223793, -0.8479966521263123, 0.10918953269720078, -0.04626668244600296, 0.45087581872940063, 0.17725630104541779, 0.45800188183784485, 0.06695111095905304, 0.21058860421180725, -0.284167617559433, -0.1755525916814804, -0.05908048897981644, 0.19181354343891144, 0.06472226977348328, -0.01858736388385296, -0.38034576177597046, 0.10199107974767685, -0.6700353026390076, 0.5844593644142151, 0.37876152992248535, 1.487586498260498, 0.15558890998363495, 0.1409917026758194, -0.7195920944213867 ]
D=3: Singularities in Gravitational Scattering of Scalar Waves
Family of exact spacetimes of D=3 Einstein gravity interacting with massless scalar field is obtained by suitable dimensional reduction of a class of D=4 plane-symmetric Einstein vacua. These D=3 spacetimes describe collisions of line-fronted asymptotically null excitations and are generically singular to the future. The solution for the scalar field can be decomposed into the Fourier-Bessel modes around the background solitons. The criteria of regularity of incoming waves are found. It is shown that the appearance of the scalar curvature singularities need not stem from singularities of incoming waves. Moreover, in distinction to D=4 case, for all solutions with regular incoming waves the final singularities are inevitable.
C. Klim\v{c}\'ik and P. Koln\'ik
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211007
gr-qc/9211008
[ -0.4491887092590332, 0.04215319827198982, -0.13156957924365997, 0.15356110036373138, -0.23921118676662445, -0.11134122312068939, -0.49386459589004517, -0.18129196763038635, -0.4229882061481476, 1.9149296283721924, 0.388430118560791, -0.4925403892993927, -0.1457836627960205, -1.241133451461792, 0.17123448848724365, 0.3499940037727356, 0.1204850822687149, -0.43432435393333435, -1.1819324493408203, 0.7606119513511658, 0.0961250513792038, -0.04304800182580948, -0.6843595504760742, -0.8322897553443909, -0.1968536674976349, 1.2844891548156738, 0.6901218295097351, 0.35425689816474915, 0.8488118648529053, 0.6830055117607117, 0.46614065766334534, -0.12535706162452698, -0.49492186307907104, -0.6142671704292297, -0.14866507053375244, -0.10494963824748993, 0.5930682420730591, -0.3190617263317108, 1.147720456123352, -0.35191667079925537, 0.3816724121570587, -0.407684862613678, 0.20944015681743622, -0.483707070350647, -0.26527950167655945, 0.07731549441814423, 0.5642324090003967, 0.4777001440525055, 0.33107420802116394, -0.8149642944335938, 0.07958372682332993, 0.04896131530404091, 0.563149631023407, -0.742586612701416, -0.17493504285812378, -0.1999436914920807, 0.18352897465229034, -0.2881069481372833, -0.48959779739379883, 0.4673222005367279, 0.17567069828510284, 0.1459755152463913, 0.22921760380268097, -0.732759952545166, 0.05965472012758255, 1.3832851648330688, -0.3649999499320984, 0.8998061418533325, -0.1780378669500351, -0.6409700512886047, -0.29433488845825195, 0.14137817919254303, -0.3885193169116974, 0.6048232316970825, -0.2130921334028244, -0.2653587758541107, -0.762542724609375, -0.5658484697341919, -0.49120303988456726, -0.16344355046749115, -0.12560340762138367, 0.09847692400217056, -0.020189233124256134, 0.6995594501495361, -0.36212047934532166, 0.17739556729793549, -0.28338608145713806, -0.09657859057188034, 0.09744325280189514, 0.18263883888721466, -0.1347644031047821, 0.4682450592517853, -0.339561402797699, -0.16707897186279297, 0.6333774328231812, 0.492376446723938, -0.5631414651870728, 0.37326186895370483, -0.22528962790966034, 0.17546670138835907, -0.4338884949684143, 0.9370853304862976, -0.37063607573509216, -0.570035457611084, -0.5030005574226379, 0.5908941030502319, 0.0021621237974613905, -0.1315443068742752, -0.27861571311950684, -0.6051782369613647, 0.44111570715904236, 0.22438226640224457, 0.7107928395271301, 0.15809530019760132, -0.20003880560398102, 0.43754950165748596, -0.8266082406044006, -0.36621344089508057, -0.6825000047683716, -0.41900187730789185, -0.16920813918113708, 0.6180279850959778, 0.2760012149810791, 0.7070437669754028, -0.22351975739002228, -0.2153405249118805, 0.4093267321586609, 0.2963374853134155, -0.39293503761291504, 0.463589608669281, 0.5718159079551697, -0.3599661886692047, -0.16077160835266113, 0.5525009632110596, 0.21229010820388794, 0.3162144124507904, 0.036299705505371094, 0.38329431414604187, -0.18749311566352844, -0.6609646081924438, 0.33947882056236267, -0.637548565864563, 0.6712173819541931, 1.0375890731811523, -0.4031267464160919, 0.35430359840393066, 0.7309455871582031, 0.2371182143688202, 0.03948848322033882, -0.1674758642911911, -0.2606082260608673, -0.8698024153709412, -0.02059200033545494, 0.02853701077401638, -0.10036395490169525, 0.2750292420387268, -0.9255467653274536, -0.0597323440015316, -0.07962255924940109, -0.351899653673172, 0.7817200422286987, 0.4094849228858948, 0.5052151083946228, 0.7927945256233215, -0.5170063972473145, 0.280612051486969, -0.7959311604499817, -0.3731059730052948, 0.15189673006534576, -0.049326229840517044, -0.10182477533817291, 0.8005496859550476, 0.37029093503952026, 0.7143431305885315, 0.9694482684135437, 0.1031205952167511, 0.001256673946045339, -0.29398882389068604, -0.8534435033798218, 0.14221107959747314, 0.11502496898174286, -0.18336376547813416, 0.12132488936185837, 0.5935840010643005, -0.5542811751365662, -0.22842910885810852, 0.6446467041969299, -0.6122256517410278, 0.5032227039337158, 0.2351447492837906, -0.4385400116443634, 0.2784488797187805, -0.832278847694397, 0.9137139916419983, -0.34187039732933044, -0.3983995318412781, -1.0626338720321655, -0.9407733678817749, 0.30749818682670593, -0.5967567563056946, 0.14679715037345886, 0.37320831418037415, -0.15069863200187683, 0.5107880234718323, -0.7279947996139526, -0.9029521346092224, 0.3962845504283905, 0.38825759291648865, -0.7774850130081177, -0.4891410171985626, 0.4426998496055603, -0.2910081446170807, 0.06889771670103073, -0.3280872702598572, 0.3803931474685669, -0.06224683299660683, -0.20066168904304504, -0.10819001495838165, 0.4582473337650299, 0.03169437125325203, 0.5963240265846252, -0.3100471496582031, -0.24712584912776947, 1.5850321054458618, -0.5978363156318665, -0.15491163730621338, -0.1200818195939064, 0.776399552822113, 0.033317260444164276, 0.3156208097934723, 0.1452941745519638, -0.0433819442987442, 0.3349135220050812, 0.33484336733818054, 0.18979914486408234, -0.536424458026886, 0.6959274411201477, 1.0332098007202148, 0.05217590928077698, 0.4425162672996521, 0.1890568882226944, 0.6389123201370239, 0.0741913765668869, 0.5929887294769287, -0.5097730159759521, 0.44447705149650574, 0.10776412487030029, -0.2325049638748169, -0.6625192165374756, 0.5305153131484985, -1.0220810174942017, 0.8192808032035828, -0.33283886313438416, -0.007784668821841478, -0.7940382361412048, 0.06986360996961594, -0.26989394426345825, -0.028586575761437416, 0.2690148651599884, -0.5766196846961975, -0.6670095324516296, 0.22839677333831787, -0.6041079759597778, -1.2378557920455933, 0.28504183888435364, 0.29459086060523987, -0.8950081467628479, 0.0581490658223629, 0.6251687407493591, -0.5902374982833862, -0.9153600335121155, 0.13426059484481812, -0.3017711937427521, 0.19051963090896606, -0.06292759627103806, -0.6171597242355347, 0.21968215703964233, 0.5924277305603027, 0.4916355013847351, -0.06659649312496185, 0.010726213455200195, 0.4729349613189697, 0.04137634485960007, 0.011950815096497536, 0.04876960441470146, 0.19525949656963348, -1.1331101655960083, 0.11917809396982193, -0.9933711886405945, -0.16027255356311798, -0.3050316572189331, -0.6203573346138, -0.09138748049736023, -0.24566815793514252, 0.6450446844100952, 0.992547869682312, -0.21010982990264893, -0.15467284619808197, -0.10313855856657028, -0.9107958078384399, 0.3989599943161011, 0.012988810427486897, -0.4272002577781677, -0.5780313014984131, -0.6895754337310791, 0.6628623008728027, 0.44542360305786133, 0.13860416412353516, 0.40292027592658997, -0.3297315239906311, -0.5952802300453186, -0.2564437985420227, 0.012899702414870262, 0.43173426389694214, -0.04298504814505577, 0.8163734078407288, 0.7887244820594788, -0.04352082684636116, 0.39734524488449097, 0.09731410443782806, -0.12425122410058975, 0.0003606807440519333, 0.27801308035850525, -0.6544471979141235, 0.689319372177124, 0.43378007411956787, 0.19733883440494537, -0.14727948606014252, 0.7981978058815002, -0.8848276734352112, -0.45513716340065, -0.07662338018417358, 0.006652199197560549, 0.08601474016904831, 0.19926050305366516, 0.08074672520160675, -0.6175593137741089, -0.8564538955688477, -1.348685622215271, 0.7379769086837769, 0.5586000084877014, -0.20228295028209686, 0.5212879180908203, 0.38629284501075745, 0.5789229273796082, -0.36995428800582886, 0.7032020092010498, -0.5761594176292419, -0.36997050046920776, 0.24334716796875, -0.1781565397977829, 0.06267225742340088, 0.436228483915329, 0.24776539206504822, 0.16590657830238342, 0.046369876712560654, -0.5444003343582153, -0.7121066451072693, -0.29356634616851807, -0.12982863187789917, 0.1376773715019226, 0.49441051483154297, 0.10373083502054214, -0.5017447471618652, -0.4378284215927124, -0.24698670208454132, 0.27307674288749695, -0.01875719241797924, 0.7822445631027222, -0.43669039011001587, 0.27009278535842896, -0.030632859095931053, -0.4963332712650299, -0.11428510397672653, 0.3313741385936737, 0.1748138964176178, 0.4058113098144531, -0.14047227799892426, 0.7005860805511475, 0.07588343322277069, -0.9483722448348999, -0.4904504120349884, 0.768822193145752, 0.1825975924730301, 0.3698590099811554, -0.42726820707321167, -0.7322806715965271, 0.567974328994751, -1.020056962966919, -0.11470633000135422, -0.08823996782302856, -0.9227461218833923, 0.9211689829826355, -0.32189714908599854, -0.4699670672416687, 0.2163739651441574, -0.09857151657342911, 0.8488556146621704, -0.09103431552648544, 0.32017815113067627, 0.23609700798988342, -0.6929131746292114, 0.21558132767677307, 0.35926422476768494, -0.4066108167171478, 0.4744725525379181, -0.29472580552101135, 0.5844008326530457, 0.2465873658657074, -0.08601792901754379, 0.5096511244773865, -0.4655834138393402, -0.10334703326225281, -0.038552869111299515, 0.5812793970108032, 0.7261454463005066, 0.039923012256622314, 0.5684854388237, 0.5874050855636597, -0.18152691423892975, -0.29083332419395447, -0.012974143959581852, 0.9676603078842163, 0.6369093060493469, -0.17460255324840546, -0.5389744639396667, 0.19329316914081573, -0.6141437292098999, -0.5423650741577148, 0.47194725275039673, -0.39674878120422363, -0.8522284626960754, 0.13289077579975128, 0.3267713189125061, 0.11269546300172806, -0.11411994695663452, 0.9184040427207947, 0.34866422414779663, 0.31379619240760803, 0.2003268003463745, -0.23767873644828796, 1.0509918928146362, -0.41251105070114136, -0.24322523176670074, 0.10298163443803787, 0.18972262740135193, -0.06385771185159683, 0.681729793548584, -0.5084080100059509, -0.7974736094474792, -0.5266405940055847, -0.23996973037719727, 0.535519540309906, -0.6822354793548584, -0.28680363297462463, 0.6280960440635681, 0.2778557240962982, 0.10511934757232666, 0.5038241147994995, -0.7620534896850586, 0.012668858282268047, -0.177089661359787, -0.25427401065826416, -0.4622970223426819, -0.04401826485991478, -0.11722423136234283, -0.30622705817222595, 0.6867961287498474, 0.4942020773887634, 0.46869221329689026, 0.6808197498321533, 0.471824049949646, -0.3474104702472687, 0.04551651328802109, 0.48997947573661804, -0.460946261882782, 0.22627948224544525, 0.19799642264842987, -0.25845053791999817, -0.6428911685943604, 0.0009652639273554087, 0.6759859323501587, -0.03724602237343788, 0.26375576853752136, 0.22476232051849365, -0.42139142751693726, -0.5554128885269165, -0.4375559985637665, -0.41851288080215454, 0.6605243682861328, -0.20732708275318146, -0.04200705513358116, -0.2719053030014038, -0.4365878701210022, -0.08456283807754517, 0.10214760154485703, 0.45815539360046387, -0.20531539618968964, -0.19276462495326996, 0.7029475569725037, -0.37708085775375366, 0.3157319724559784, -0.5785752534866333, 0.5571010708808899, -0.3151026666164398, -0.6340063810348511, -0.2711881697177887, -0.858430802822113, 0.0022096065804362297, -0.348527729511261, -0.02898472547531128, 0.44836634397506714, -0.17583784461021423, -0.22959619760513306, 0.3660001754760742, 1.0943557024002075, -0.4048153758049011, -0.6322184205055237, -0.0753106027841568, 0.32349109649658203, -0.2512894570827484, -0.6165457367897034, 0.1620669662952423, 0.8442456126213074, -0.12499593943357468, 0.36306121945381165, -0.3716757595539093, -0.37737539410591125, 0.0665130466222763, -0.3559425175189972, 0.3816440999507904, -0.8687790036201477, -0.5302579998970032, -0.009389063343405724, -0.527267575263977, 0.05504561960697174, 0.3991924226284027, 0.041821420192718506, -0.5863662958145142, -0.06173563748598099, -0.2994173765182495, -0.04881485179066658, -0.1608288735151291, 0.3723360300064087, -0.29393601417541504, -0.2736726403236389, -0.6846657991409302, 1.2812504768371582, 0.08582449704408646, -0.0005230368115007877, 0.024572715163230896, -0.23801061511039734, -0.31001248955726624, 0.5567302107810974, -0.13145551085472107, 0.651933491230011, -0.805310845375061, -0.142634779214859, 0.3494758605957031, 0.31823140382766724, -0.7781530618667603, 0.24526503682136536, -0.7529350519180298, 0.3433382213115692, -0.07000070065259933, -0.024490563198924065, 0.3971872627735138, -0.3946042060852051, 0.23817166686058044, 0.15000949800014496, 0.5262334942817688, 0.9958270192146301, 0.10052739828824997, 0.12058322131633759, 0.43306925892829895, -0.01804087683558464, -0.03682807460427284, -0.6959880590438843, -0.4351579248905182, 0.34403982758522034, 0.5186583399772644, 0.0841558501124382, -0.6979289054870605, -0.9850091338157654, 0.02652476727962494, -0.6805631518363953, 0.2943098843097687, 0.23165030777454376, 0.033727604895830154, 0.7612652778625488, 0.1680566370487213, 0.0033528434578329325, -0.1679704338312149, -0.14124362170696259, 0.3726802468299866, 0.10557153820991516, -0.26252490282058716, -0.5811715126037598, -0.3290655016899109, -0.17535574734210968, -0.13147911429405212, 0.2249603569507599, 0.5218366384506226, -0.1646682173013687, 1.1676738262176514, -0.2797077000141144, -0.4911887049674988, -0.43857941031455994, -0.10672709345817566, 0.30734601616859436, -0.13428041338920593, 0.31662601232528687, -0.023498745635151863, -0.3408929109573364, 0.24460147321224213, 0.38921618461608887, -0.8802093267440796, -0.31544557213783264, 0.9016764163970947, -0.7562517523765564, -0.00010666964226402342, 0.30378541350364685, -0.3428689241409302, -0.22050043940544128, -0.15563982725143433, -1.537060022354126, -0.4412383437156677, 0.032141778618097305, -0.38293400406837463, 0.11343389004468918, -0.5211344361305237, -0.3226125240325928, 0.3802788555622101, 0.582794189453125, 0.1544359028339386, 0.6473035216331482, -0.366608202457428, -0.3913966119289398, -0.8848641514778137, -0.41294044256210327, 0.8279592394828796, 0.6359022855758667, -0.43141958117485046, -0.22189059853553772, 0.5068355798721313, -0.40978193283081055, -0.22704480588436127, 0.8223271369934082, -0.06524693965911865, 0.5677657127380371, -0.3309231400489807, 0.48749035596847534, 0.5251708626747131, 0.291250079870224, 0.38227972388267517, -0.4743793308734894, -0.6770699620246887, -0.45928144454956055, 0.2673046290874481, -0.2974817156791687, 0.0681348666548729, 0.9235388040542603, -0.2158982753753662, -0.23598191142082214, -0.6109495162963867, -0.6977152824401855, -0.12098408490419388, -0.2679603397846222, -0.5279043316841125, -0.6134712100028992, -0.2917763888835907, -0.9977086186408997, -0.5939513444900513, -0.24854910373687744, 0.4441646933555603, -0.5118234157562256, 0.603291392326355, -0.5117063522338867, 0.4484529495239258, 0.16588303446769714, 0.4590332806110382, -0.40948501229286194, -1.278314471244812, -0.8976280093193054, -0.012115062214434147, -0.4516580104827881, -0.7746157646179199, -0.403704434633255, -0.7854306101799011, 0.6334872245788574, 1.464646339416504, -0.8698365092277527, 0.8104100227355957, -0.48549050092697144, -0.8353487253189087, 0.18302905559539795, -0.25973495841026306, -0.46246078610420227, 0.5215975642204285, -0.35325631499290466, 0.6981307864189148, 0.049216948449611664, -0.06851566582918167, 0.0032722235191613436, 0.41621002554893494, -1.0834237337112427, 1.1827646493911743, 0.05431325361132622, 0.41641944646835327, 0.14444497227668762, -1.1456810235977173, 0.059172213077545166, 0.17517314851284027, -0.47870248556137085, 0.3613792061805725, -0.21194837987422943, 0.42849963903427124, -0.43689337372779846, -0.10555365681648254, 0.3479688763618469, 0.5165933966636658, -0.2526557147502899, -0.12657949328422546, -0.5835295915603638, 0.35283419489860535, 0.14119593799114227, 0.2702575623989105, 0.14447426795959473, -0.9228606224060059, 0.667193591594696, -0.061668165028095245, 0.6555495262145996, 0.20056943595409393, 0.2398226410150528, -0.08526937663555145, 0.01742161065340042, -0.03892933949828148, -0.11054754257202148, 0.5218111276626587, -0.5385408997535706, 0.6415829062461853, -0.20575492084026337, 0.1238975003361702, 0.6095756888389587, -0.79323410987854, -1.4448062181472778, 0.3239312767982483, 0.2776436507701874, -0.9086965918540955, -0.18086014688014984, 0.33684930205345154, -0.737978458404541, 0.633842945098877, -0.4379050135612488, 0.4958648383617401, -0.06622445583343506, 0.9267460703849792, 0.6379075646400452, -0.4123384356498718, -0.34920990467071533, 0.004189100582152605, -0.6175777316093445, 0.39834654331207275, -0.619133710861206, 0.6366994380950928, -0.46672409772872925, -0.7939732670783997, -0.6478229761123657, 0.22821767628192902, -0.16824555397033691, -0.27128463983535767, 0.11608681082725525, -0.271331250667572, -0.2527059018611908, 0.051368776708841324, -0.2893125116825104, -0.2151797115802765, -0.39746856689453125, 0.5957366228103638, 0.2674599289894104, 0.07632405310869217, -0.1861266791820526, -0.057455550879240036, 0.5204489231109619, 0.1303657591342926, 0.08915635943412781, 1.0305804014205933, -0.22550219297409058, 0.2672167122364044, -0.17797142267227173, 0.6622257232666016, 0.07863563299179077, 0.2620154619216919, -0.6332128643989563, 0.04318331927061081, 0.03557923436164856, -0.4561621844768524, 0.7583659291267395, 0.478134423494339, 0.39976075291633606, 0.768964946269989, -0.29454144835472107, 0.022470565512776375, 0.3646666407585144, 0.27024146914482117, 0.026497159153223038, 1.1484047174453735, -0.32521378993988037, 0.09064796566963196, -0.2927658259868622, -0.022219276055693626, 0.2195512056350708, -0.28657618165016174, -0.36157533526420593, -0.8439179062843323, 0.13134515285491943, 0.5665844678878784, -0.4934340715408325, -1.3244024515151978, -0.23066198825836182, 0.02494114637374878, 0.6801988482475281, -0.21240830421447754, -0.4508047103881836, -0.7067976593971252, 0.16886067390441895, -0.00333097530528903, -0.7561309933662415, 0.540059506893158, 0.27561816573143005, 0.282819926738739, 1.0977586507797241, 0.4856089651584625, 0.31562745571136475, 0.33614835143089294, -0.10207241028547287, -0.2391357123851776, 0.42329612374305725, -0.1763869822025299, 0.04064059257507324, 0.7682852149009705, 0.5078636407852173, 0.0996861457824707, -0.0011514273937791586, -0.2528790235519409, -0.08561040461063385, -0.6056490540504456, 0.389749139547348, 0.21962592005729675, -0.7717090845108032, -0.3702910840511322, 0.18018083274364471, 0.2622097134590149, -0.2801301181316376, 0.40394672751426697, 0.27832064032554626, -0.023388486355543137, 0.7851530313491821, 0.7160053849220276, 0.2933472990989685, 0.33082205057144165, -0.5702989101409912, -0.15469980239868164, 0.28111252188682556, 0.28670966625213623, -0.6192512512207031, 0.5873719453811646, -0.6300926804542542, 0.21222825348377228, -0.396147221326828, -0.7095507979393005, -0.4516473114490509, -0.04888305440545082, 0.7103796005249023, 1.0170950889587402, -0.41665005683898926, -0.022842109203338623, 0.8387433290481567, 0.6341074109077454, -0.026659632101655006, -0.6439124941825867, 0.23321445286273956, -0.4045976400375366, 0.47788235545158386, -0.8020118474960327, 0.3241766095161438, -0.12978428602218628, -0.35330596566200256, -0.6022850871086121, -0.2923816442489624, -0.06305424869060516, -0.809476375579834, 0.018145671114325523, -0.16659943759441376, 0.38495543599128723, 0.40711161494255066, 0.013657065108418465, -0.18863733112812042, -0.6583856344223022, -0.04717690870165825, -0.36752671003341675, 0.5173885226249695, -0.33443406224250793, -0.055063262581825256, 0.3139636814594269, -0.3788054585456848, -1.0554465055465698, 0.881351888179779, 0.4916897714138031, -0.7725679874420166, 0.5446714758872986, 0.053461648523807526, 0.05991191044449806, 0.41138920187950134, -0.010871270671486855, -0.3512992560863495, 0.12419813126325607, -0.007363080512732267, 0.6051915884017944, -0.5086717009544373, 0.17509278655052185, -0.5746932029724121, -0.8940884470939636, -0.2490706890821457, 0.027261897921562195, 0.7958377599716187, -0.12405193597078323, -0.12297874689102173, -0.9964524507522583, 4.244213581085205, 0.12232603132724762, 0.2501528859138489, -0.5607813000679016, 0.6613084673881531, 0.7208953499794006, 0.2890220284461975, -0.09964442253112793, 0.3484061062335968, -0.9882172346115112, 0.12185710668563843, -0.09256754070520401, 0.7064528465270996, 0.0171381663531065, -0.054707761853933334, 0.6964267492294312, -0.16911756992340088, -0.6784765720367432, 0.10650483518838882, -0.6577001810073853, -1.3564049005508423, -0.016864148899912834, 0.4296252429485321, 0.6995428800582886, 0.7350452542304993, 0.6422938704490662, -0.27667903900146484, -0.14102542400360107, -1.0445313453674316, -0.5197892785072327, -0.12989473342895508, -0.3779789209365845, 0.325172483921051, -0.02391056902706623, -0.8365924954414368, 0.26937952637672424, 0.3748486340045929, -0.18367916345596313, 1.2477915287017822, -0.5412096381187439, 0.22511187195777893, -1.1694681644439697, -0.044759251177310944, -0.4688253402709961, -0.004236943554133177, 1.206377387046814, 1.1411420106887817, 0.8141035437583923, 0.627646803855896, -0.5205749869346619, -0.17953993380069733, 0.008999842219054699, 0.20886828005313873, 0.5998782515525818, -0.7276308536529541, -0.4744066894054413, -0.19280366599559784, -0.5716210007667542, 0.40954357385635376, -0.1268496811389923, 1.0916987657546997, -0.12564964592456818, 0.14460128545761108, 0.37222978472709656, 0.3622084856033325, -0.07125111669301987, 0.24329201877117157, -0.17920751869678497, 0.1671326756477356, -0.26600560545921326, -0.8503722548484802, 0.058263182640075684, -0.39635518193244934, 0.13622881472110748, 0.13881295919418335, -0.21633096039295197, 0.11561089754104614, 0.22507183253765106, 0.4956449270248413, 0.3736884295940399, -0.8567266464233398, -0.040492456406354904, -0.34027037024497986, 0.3270301818847656, -0.01007060706615448, 0.3679358959197998, 0.05807832255959511, -0.5897645354270935, -0.4285971522331238, 0.46731072664260864, -0.24769265949726105, 0.5974655151367188, -0.23527352511882782, 0.8496299982070923, -0.47648411989212036 ]
Gauge Field Back-reaction on a Black Hole
The order $\hbar$ fluctuations of gauge fields in the vicinity of a blackhole can create a repulsive antigravity region extending out beyond the renormalized Schwarzschild horizon. If the strength of this repulsive force increases as higher orders in the back-reaction are included, the formation of a wormhole-like object could occur.
David Hochberg and Thomas W. Kephart
gr-qc astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211008
gr-qc/9211009
[ -0.07726318389177322, 0.22942136228084564, 0.5854249596595764, 0.48062288761138916, -0.4432854652404785, -0.1708572804927826, -0.27314308285713196, -0.4852670729160309, -1.65510094165802, 1.705511450767517, 0.5173625349998474, -0.17060725390911102, -0.03667442873120308, -0.7638213038444519, 0.2547428011894226, -0.013597910292446613, -0.06686922162771225, -0.3676704466342926, -1.5894601345062256, 0.13965368270874023, 0.08385290950536728, -0.004814823158085346, -1.2270511388778687, -0.3459477722644806, -0.2657318115234375, 0.7400571703910828, 0.4457380473613739, 0.2021404355764389, 0.9423834085464478, 0.7628039121627808, 0.0965590700507164, -0.1351906955242157, -0.46616125106811523, -1.075573205947876, 0.23654226958751678, -0.09745578467845917, 0.18958918750286102, -0.7312495708465576, 0.9376055598258972, -0.18140676617622375, 0.8765876293182373, 0.026729408651590347, 0.33558931946754456, -0.8904025554656982, -0.5707336068153381, -0.28811606764793396, -0.503817617893219, 0.024506211280822754, 0.05815558135509491, -1.2980581521987915, -0.21012994647026062, 0.08974505960941315, 0.9276308417320251, -1.0335025787353516, -0.507077157497406, -0.16134096682071686, 0.21772520244121552, 0.10704924911260605, -0.18821431696414948, 0.11705399304628372, 0.32773399353027344, 0.05801673233509064, 0.517429530620575, -0.4881487488746643, -0.017373599112033844, 1.1225316524505615, -0.2778710126876831, 0.8827189207077026, -0.06626332551240921, -0.06231357529759407, -0.08628778159618378, -0.19784873723983765, -0.7379546165466309, 0.30162736773490906, -0.5622043013572693, 0.6673230528831482, -0.4531356692314148, -0.5251979231834412, -0.9741121530532837, -0.7010820508003235, -0.31927505135536194, -0.09584765881299973, 0.14101558923721313, 0.7347519397735596, 0.051965996623039246, 0.009166217409074306, -0.3300413191318512, -0.2949751615524292, 0.11940035969018936, -0.11706700921058655, 0.016369620338082314, 0.701180100440979, -0.06267566233873367, -0.3078021705150604, 0.4545510411262512, 1.011304259300232, -0.3481108844280243, 0.25430551171302795, -0.48257213830947876, 0.4162549674510956, -0.24377524852752686, 0.677723228931427, -0.6967942714691162, 0.2999842166900635, -0.4265710115432739, 1.0591658353805542, 0.03687033802270889, -0.3623991012573242, 0.19705912470817566, -0.5960173606872559, 0.6609694361686707, 0.2416534572839737, 0.4418336749076843, 0.3004750609397888, -0.5458955764770508, 0.2636018395423889, -0.31190359592437744, -0.46697160601615906, -0.4708321988582611, -0.4748604893684387, 0.4160463511943817, 0.13501320779323578, -0.017678868025541306, 0.7775495052337646, -0.27629968523979187, -0.33980345726013184, 0.5313100218772888, 0.20547965168952942, -0.669599175453186, 0.17642579972743988, -0.05928580090403557, -0.40661901235580444, -0.28212958574295044, 0.609889566898346, 0.06831571459770203, 0.7173972725868225, -0.1343364119529724, 0.0665861964225769, -0.8911023139953613, -1.1843810081481934, 0.8517870903015137, -0.9552285671234131, 0.6494203209877014, 0.5541760325431824, -0.1335863471031189, 0.657637357711792, 0.6831344962120056, -0.19981086254119873, -0.1096498966217041, 0.08238974213600159, -0.45090779662132263, -0.4035719931125641, -0.5175451040267944, 0.11556395888328552, -0.10048989951610565, 0.3343832194805145, -1.0989235639572144, 0.3548809587955475, -0.6706559658050537, -0.05514194443821907, 0.7153797745704651, -0.352338582277298, -0.07932485640048981, 1.1244474649429321, -0.23443858325481415, -0.1477455049753189, -0.4479183256626129, -0.370620459318161, 0.3847653269767761, -0.13799582421779633, 0.2610623836517334, 0.4244532585144043, 0.26354146003723145, 0.46097612380981445, 0.8550060391426086, 0.4633699357509613, 0.08164176344871521, -0.3307267725467682, -0.5358842015266418, 0.5376175045967102, -0.5862526297569275, -0.9337539076805115, 0.501789927482605, 0.36187198758125305, -0.4711132049560547, -0.1442779153585434, 0.16636137664318085, -0.015378556214272976, 0.2560008466243744, 0.6627980470657349, -0.36430031061172485, 0.13281166553497314, -0.9009153842926025, 0.814967691898346, -0.42818108201026917, 0.04298783093690872, -1.0866594314575195, 0.04184684902429581, -0.24809347093105316, -0.40410447120666504, 0.2593986392021179, 0.4849306643009186, -0.6847865581512451, 0.7992845773696899, -1.2898808717727661, -0.09573941677808762, 1.1803144216537476, 0.2571021616458893, 0.16176177561283112, -0.37696221470832825, 0.8267536759376526, -0.11125841736793518, -0.1517331898212433, 0.013296659104526043, 0.18903200328350067, -0.038190413266420364, -0.13994796574115753, 0.5042131543159485, -0.26108449697494507, 0.1674347072839737, 0.8331252932548523, -0.35117191076278687, -0.5043004155158997, 1.1568365097045898, 0.11098934710025787, -0.24463443458080292, -0.24860383570194244, 0.8935819864273071, 0.16385433077812195, -0.17780433595180511, 0.13896919786930084, 0.08852612227201462, 0.5950157642364502, 0.12433164566755295, 0.42506611347198486, -0.45585155487060547, 0.9645851254463196, 1.4044568538665771, 0.35304754972457886, 0.10848568379878998, 0.22091807425022125, 0.026269908994436264, -0.11183390766382217, -0.04141395166516304, -0.08709339797496796, 0.5350931882858276, 0.34686344861984253, -0.21314187347888947, -0.6732877492904663, 0.8578034043312073, -1.0405066013336182, 0.5962540507316589, 0.35856470465660095, -0.38142868876457214, -1.1744402647018433, 0.2350974828004837, 0.24636785686016083, 0.23688599467277527, -0.12975820899009705, -0.18965370953083038, -0.46874821186065674, 0.7023996114730835, -0.28311535716056824, -0.178562194108963, 0.021517973393201828, 0.1652766317129135, -0.6883419156074524, -0.17599672079086304, 0.6216884255409241, -0.8105013370513916, -0.8190784454345703, -0.02696453034877777, -0.6902496814727783, 0.14208535850048065, 0.07899890094995499, -0.3989199101924896, 0.4934575855731964, -0.25492164492607117, 0.5488312840461731, -0.04430404677987099, 0.1642143279314041, 0.33623865246772766, 0.050179168581962585, 0.06419635564088821, -0.258272260427475, 0.2491288185119629, -1.3976800441741943, 0.05693816393613815, -1.1826002597808838, 0.366227924823761, -0.20241931080818176, -1.0464574098587036, 0.17171570658683777, -0.3373450040817261, 0.4232078194618225, 0.3556215763092041, -0.3179534375667572, -0.22415350377559662, -0.13826106488704681, -0.6174271106719971, 0.8025702238082886, 0.4953015446662903, -0.25629550218582153, -0.307638019323349, -0.8453379273414612, 0.6883468627929688, 0.17293888330459595, 0.3731917440891266, 0.6396341323852539, -0.020219391211867332, -0.4653856158256531, 0.25472256541252136, -0.30171817541122437, 0.560452938079834, 0.010171703062951565, 0.5543689131736755, 1.1031814813613892, -0.03469189256429672, 0.27378109097480774, -0.3798793852329254, -0.3682548701763153, -0.24369049072265625, 0.6723959445953369, -1.3081427812576294, 0.5413116812705994, 0.5338329076766968, 0.38149237632751465, -0.24147586524486542, 0.30358579754829407, -0.9549768567085266, -0.65233314037323, -0.3712008595466614, -0.39020225405693054, 0.6328050494194031, -0.19648593664169312, 0.2899189591407776, -0.4371207058429718, -0.29549795389175415, -0.5826421976089478, 0.7161867022514343, 0.6868149042129517, -0.5384275913238525, 0.7546985149383545, 0.5352922081947327, 0.26238778233528137, -0.016409792006015778, 0.40699276328086853, -0.022690340876579285, -0.9123792052268982, 0.5205745697021484, -0.16043062508106232, 0.10970693081617355, 0.6791329383850098, 0.5210729837417603, -0.19027623534202576, -0.057807065546512604, 0.06528773903846741, -0.46682319045066833, -0.828304648399353, -0.32655587792396545, 0.3217468857765198, 0.6080177426338196, 0.020122552290558815, -0.5537546277046204, -0.7211518883705139, -0.290046364068985, 0.1139567643404007, -0.20649287104606628, 0.7327916622161865, -0.23015110194683075, 0.458010196685791, 0.17411234974861145, -0.2177114337682724, -0.49592965841293335, -0.22471971809864044, 1.3220638036727905, 0.9760424494743347, 0.45361343026161194, 0.6657611131668091, -0.15494711697101593, -0.9398502111434937, -0.2350204885005951, 0.7936099767684937, 0.21164613962173462, 0.30934423208236694, 0.3170507550239563, -0.432352215051651, 0.056760452687740326, -0.4201606512069702, -0.34083640575408936, -0.05955048277974129, -0.76766437292099, 0.8399392366409302, -0.5315039157867432, -0.8194572329521179, -0.2244817018508911, 0.3406875729560852, 0.1306675523519516, 0.2357444316148758, 0.20818036794662476, -0.21173176169395447, -0.19737385213375092, 0.11389324069023132, 0.4632335305213928, -0.11746592074632645, -0.4619917571544647, -0.43013909459114075, 0.5936962366104126, -0.08907359838485718, 0.3693540692329407, 0.36595603823661804, 0.019400829449295998, 0.09980952739715576, -0.43725529313087463, 0.4555826783180237, 0.964188277721405, -0.034985728561878204, 0.3166268467903137, 0.29172685742378235, -0.7433074712753296, -0.23273007571697235, -0.13866642117500305, 0.817533016204834, 0.6220040917396545, 0.021424056962132454, -0.32624495029449463, 0.13715283572673798, -0.14791348576545715, -0.14690209925174713, 0.5944610238075256, -0.577731728553772, -0.8981528282165527, -0.050596341490745544, 0.24677690863609314, -0.19579847157001495, -0.10385574400424957, 0.7409803867340088, 0.51849365234375, 0.5243139863014221, 0.33610770106315613, -0.24741598963737488, 0.8631501793861389, -0.6526230573654175, -0.35018306970596313, -0.0016377575229853392, -0.1907096803188324, 0.1412741243839264, 0.7593541145324707, -0.13166455924510956, -0.7339611649513245, -0.1398691087961197, 0.05757937207818031, 0.5397568941116333, -0.2270272970199585, -0.9543712139129639, 0.8172014951705933, -0.3143281936645508, -0.8403376936912537, 0.15018264949321747, 0.0404624417424202, -0.2124817818403244, 0.34757116436958313, -0.0622013621032238, -0.23134483397006989, 0.15661148726940155, -0.26629528403282166, -0.5490381121635437, 0.9567583799362183, 0.40704524517059326, 0.10078315436840057, 0.9454394578933716, 0.11760857701301575, -0.17933212220668793, 0.1896267980337143, 0.6447278261184692, -0.5679750442504883, -0.1907283514738083, -0.5789380669593811, -0.5382631421089172, -0.518743634223938, 0.19648277759552002, 0.5029628872871399, -0.16439859569072723, 0.15171712636947632, 0.19091033935546875, -0.7578314542770386, -0.2353951632976532, -0.09119642525911331, -0.6737738847732544, 0.5809680819511414, -0.28192996978759766, -0.4980033338069916, -0.4074377417564392, -0.48431628942489624, 0.5505809783935547, 0.22249667346477509, 0.026295023038983345, -0.4429718554019928, 0.22512248158454895, 0.07982605695724487, -0.4129301905632019, -0.10949079692363739, -0.6309345364570618, 0.5456597208976746, -0.39864373207092285, -0.7231376767158508, -0.5280165076255798, -0.9973351955413818, -0.16597864031791687, -0.08789573609828949, -0.1995711475610733, -0.02414376102387905, -0.36047443747520447, 0.23974008858203888, 0.12560847401618958, 0.6799517869949341, 0.10939574986696243, -1.0923062562942505, -0.1768229454755783, 1.3664265871047974, 0.5022872686386108, -0.47055166959762573, 0.21026524901390076, 0.28307369351387024, -0.002767494646832347, 0.08531427383422852, -0.5506544709205627, -0.12298742681741714, 0.21509075164794922, -0.4175114929676056, 0.49340420961380005, -0.5431576371192932, -0.07714898884296417, -0.6064777374267578, -0.5645303726196289, 0.07912074029445648, 0.24370382726192474, 0.39616474509239197, -0.7971266508102417, -0.3902411460876465, -0.0974968746304512, 0.4329838454723358, 0.09430108964443207, -0.14138785004615784, -0.3482940196990967, -0.4451022148132324, -0.8406471610069275, 0.8240588903427124, -0.41741034388542175, 0.153151273727417, 0.3972112834453583, -0.2094172239303589, -0.19560673832893372, 0.9929282665252686, 0.16831959784030914, 0.6054688096046448, -0.6820027828216553, 0.06737545132637024, 0.8414878249168396, -0.027796616777777672, -0.34862014651298523, 0.06853342056274414, -1.0647002458572388, 1.3770242929458618, 0.07974464446306229, -0.34512630105018616, 0.3408769965171814, -0.38661837577819824, 0.5414729714393616, 0.0696503221988678, 0.1050996407866478, 0.8330112099647522, 0.11835148930549622, -0.18548791110515594, 0.7328771948814392, -0.24300698935985565, -0.6121394038200378, -0.6426635980606079, -1.0007261037826538, 0.2886686623096466, 0.424479603767395, -0.27851560711860657, -0.024232517927885056, -0.3958105444908142, 0.270836740732193, -1.3729110956192017, 0.27775049209594727, 0.4161475598812103, 0.5056600570678711, 0.5230139493942261, -0.3368781805038452, 0.2716626524925232, -0.4362412393093109, -0.10047023743391037, 0.02672983705997467, -0.4842653274536133, -0.13828517496585846, -0.9315703511238098, -0.8079767823219299, -0.3463519811630249, -0.5412490367889404, 0.3769433796405792, 0.7958977222442627, -0.21739313006401062, 1.2633507251739502, -0.11768532544374466, -0.5865263938903809, -0.3306889832019806, 0.726675808429718, 0.25852134823799133, 0.14789672195911407, 0.5869818329811096, -0.05655727535486221, -0.2366478145122528, -0.000030700026400154456, 0.5026980638504028, -0.9345433115959167, -0.5383110642433167, 0.6577031016349792, -0.18761974573135376, -0.1005602553486824, 0.4843665361404419, 0.02758771739900112, -0.13250292837619781, -0.46877020597457886, -0.540381133556366, -0.5443163514137268, -0.44048938155174255, -0.5636433362960815, 0.04763800650835037, 0.30952727794647217, -0.5573468804359436, 0.18293723464012146, 0.06300908327102661, 0.03352784365415573, 0.8062641024589539, -0.2920229732990265, -0.16884052753448486, -0.7233055830001831, -0.18734177947044373, 1.228257656097412, 0.08580673485994339, -0.5216148495674133, -0.1026630699634552, 0.18146468698978424, -0.5119312405586243, -0.30301016569137573, 0.5786195397377014, -0.0015062903985381126, -0.24210534989833832, -0.5204075574874878, 0.6236159801483154, 0.3773892819881439, 0.4544580578804016, 0.0937890112400055, 0.11249533295631409, -0.7846602201461792, -0.47681260108947754, 0.2816491723060608, -0.24178169667720795, 0.08851693570613861, 0.8367713689804077, 0.1552780419588089, -0.09456929564476013, -0.682905912399292, -0.5794276595115662, -0.17632563412189484, -0.4420619308948517, -0.10482103377580643, -0.9335257411003113, -0.6955736875534058, -1.0400980710983276, -0.5892404317855835, -0.07537788897752762, 0.5357422828674316, -0.5352110266685486, 0.3388577699661255, -0.25626736879348755, 0.3434149920940399, 0.28499168157577515, 0.23350787162780762, -0.07768035680055618, -0.8083967566490173, -0.4953732192516327, 0.24197952449321747, 0.08969010412693024, -0.935608983039856, -0.4733791947364807, -0.6501596570014954, 0.31919386982917786, 0.9289848804473877, -0.8383159637451172, 0.7103438377380371, -0.938197672367096, -0.6873132586479187, 0.09946542978286743, 0.23567678034305573, -0.20017194747924805, 0.7016832828521729, -0.06347164511680603, 0.5919065475463867, -0.032122962176799774, 0.07763540744781494, -0.13990959525108337, 0.319557249546051, -0.8909288644790649, 0.6986860632896423, 0.03442102298140526, 0.6827361583709717, 0.19010548293590546, -0.5937349796295166, 0.051176849752664566, 0.3282783329486847, -0.9192289710044861, 0.09975577145814896, -0.2560821771621704, 0.9519674181938171, -0.0687611773610115, -0.2705901265144348, 0.6218879222869873, -0.1653919368982315, -0.07451330125331879, -0.7820522785186768, -0.8993294835090637, -0.021400146186351776, -0.15794765949249268, 0.08657850325107574, 0.08995272219181061, -0.857944130897522, 0.4024238884449005, -0.3871065676212311, 0.9183645248413086, 0.38535454869270325, -0.31081122159957886, -0.3219258487224579, -0.07393331825733185, -0.11110028624534607, -0.044416189193725586, 0.2856718599796295, -0.5394859313964844, 1.2711153030395508, 0.5841005444526672, 0.2858228087425232, 0.19842199981212616, -0.31267133355140686, -1.2662745714187622, 0.39113909006118774, -0.046961475163698196, -0.2213306576013565, 0.3270518481731415, 0.08599156886339188, -0.562839925289154, 0.4102630019187927, -0.779000461101532, 0.6909785866737366, -0.3177501857280731, 0.6311482787132263, 0.8169563412666321, -0.010322386398911476, -0.4186843931674957, -0.06212454289197922, -0.8848675489425659, 0.03718702867627144, -0.4315073788166046, 0.4322570562362671, -0.37643203139305115, -0.7405195832252502, -0.2472154051065445, 0.4853283762931824, -0.04053642600774765, 0.04631105065345764, -0.3515920341014862, -0.3641226589679718, -0.3387371003627777, 0.07577024400234222, -0.7231369018554688, -0.10810962319374084, -0.7468401789665222, 0.3000223934650421, -0.011845005676150322, -0.12247109413146973, -0.08963063359260559, -0.1131785586476326, 0.5509843826293945, 0.2705383598804474, -0.028143329545855522, 0.6577278971672058, -0.07234352082014084, -0.675504744052887, -0.03873114660382271, 0.4663245677947998, 0.30793020129203796, 0.32638058066368103, -0.2047557532787323, 0.4706937372684479, 0.37823009490966797, -0.13665294647216797, 0.5325400233268738, -0.24122679233551025, -0.05664484202861786, 0.42772069573402405, 0.23063060641288757, -0.16922743618488312, -0.15615783631801605, 0.655797004699707, 0.035024356096982956, 0.4306615889072418, -0.25255006551742554, -0.38202381134033203, -0.07148890197277069, 0.48240017890930176, 0.07229907065629959, -0.04004165902733803, -0.10292407870292664, -0.8259308338165283, 0.07486147433519363, 0.578950822353363, -0.21035151183605194, -0.4777226746082306, -0.014934401027858257, 0.1605527698993683, 0.7578890323638916, -0.29030781984329224, 0.04440966248512268, 0.25182127952575684, 0.25678184628486633, 0.37183478474617004, -0.8692433834075928, 0.5818080306053162, 0.258696049451828, -0.019629597663879395, 0.7150314450263977, 0.9384347796440125, 1.011793851852417, 0.8295906186103821, -0.1585429459810257, -0.7261722683906555, 0.13181272149085999, 0.33385929465293884, -0.5678802728652954, 0.6993333697319031, -0.47971028089523315, -0.1370241791009903, 0.20454540848731995, -0.5082511901855469, 0.1733960509300232, -0.6938660740852356, 0.7791631817817688, 0.5190154314041138, -0.3962317109107971, 0.011602269485592842, -0.24174557626247406, 0.30479201674461365, 0.4244675636291504, 0.6963424682617188, 0.13197316229343414, 0.2779978811740875, 0.46562209725379944, 0.9408881068229675, 0.2931137979030609, 0.19345393776893616, -0.4890924096107483, -0.07284535467624664, 0.5316380262374878, 0.48066404461860657, -0.1369418203830719, 0.7129223346710205, -0.22482658922672272, 0.3975841999053955, -0.3532727062702179, -0.3101596534252167, -0.4089089035987854, -0.2179049253463745, 0.4867611527442932, 0.3184175491333008, -0.31962040066719055, -0.3802778720855713, 0.8360584378242493, 0.47416478395462036, -0.02719438262283802, -0.676723301410675, 0.15648198127746582, -0.8553133010864258, 0.2370859831571579, -0.6855788230895996, 0.4832729697227478, -0.16527287662029266, -0.17623953521251678, -0.4217591881752014, -0.4556294083595276, 0.07680265605449677, -0.3767218291759491, -0.5210750699043274, -0.21161314845085144, 0.3265819549560547, 0.2579793334007263, 0.01987583376467228, 0.2546481192111969, -0.22746671736240387, -0.6328384280204773, -0.3463785648345947, 0.37581145763397217, -0.37609976530075073, -0.3653717339038849, 0.43448877334594727, 0.06448215246200562, -0.7838704586029053, 0.3757074773311615, 0.7984604835510254, -0.42394691705703735, 0.4896591007709503, 0.14165693521499634, -0.2001013308763504, 0.2381521463394165, 0.019785907119512558, 0.39302462339401245, 0.25097018480300903, 0.6583188772201538, 0.7350585460662842, -0.5099227428436279, 0.006596543826162815, -0.6725895404815674, -0.6096840500831604, -0.29601484537124634, 0.021234752610325813, 0.9081854224205017, 0.13672935962677002, -0.07604695111513138, -1.0452163219451904, 4.1920084953308105, 0.8895227909088135, 0.6875872611999512, -0.2908852696418762, 1.027356743812561, 0.8127187490463257, 0.20973119139671326, -0.42108985781669617, 0.13113629817962646, -0.3170175850391388, 0.08943669497966766, 0.4012274146080017, 0.39139848947525024, -0.6575919985771179, 0.49055954813957214, 0.6551876068115234, -0.018574876710772514, -0.9836713671684265, 0.06943902373313904, -0.4116399586200714, -0.689822793006897, -0.21759425103664398, 0.1260887235403061, 0.37960273027420044, 0.31077975034713745, 0.7141758799552917, 0.17681185901165009, -0.7462373375892639, -0.6014195084571838, -0.8509274125099182, -0.1721494048833847, -0.8250353932380676, 0.1637212336063385, -0.09526300430297852, -0.7260010242462158, 0.38660454750061035, -0.10047613084316254, -0.60893714427948, 0.47803056240081787, -0.3974401652812958, -0.41031262278556824, -0.9672662019729614, 0.16744275391101837, -0.08708170801401138, -0.6307891607284546, 1.1330729722976685, 0.802433431148529, 0.8956678509712219, 0.6146091818809509, -0.5758945345878601, 0.22419658303260803, 0.16622598469257355, 0.012772629968822002, 0.13839773833751678, -0.8284137845039368, -0.3998021185398102, -0.022319717332720757, -0.062024787068367004, 0.7114145755767822, 0.12927144765853882, 0.43733885884284973, -0.17513272166252136, -0.05010276287794113, 0.22331386804580688, 0.44590774178504944, 0.3142811357975006, -0.008043106645345688, -0.09506011754274368, 0.34698599576950073, -0.15245257318019867, -0.8335477113723755, -0.07852600514888763, -0.1679408848285675, -0.5542886257171631, 0.05080608278512955, -0.27595245838165283, 0.33721110224723816, 0.26922717690467834, -0.05833861231803894, 0.3239572048187256, -0.8509317636489868, 0.04906948655843735, -0.07908327877521515, -0.08700110018253326, -0.25596070289611816, 0.5835291147232056, 0.2178226113319397, 0.23281249403953552, -0.5804172158241272, 0.23417463898658752, 0.041407179087400436, 1.221934199333191, -0.23693177103996277, 0.009595131501555443, -0.5438478589057922 ]
Positivity of Entropy in the Semi-Classical Theory of Black Holes and Radiation
Quantum stress-energy tensors of fields renormalized on a Schwarzschild background violate the classical energy conditions near the black hole. Nevertheless, the associated equilibrium thermodynamical entropy $\Delta S$ by which such fields augment the usual black hole entropy is found to be positive. More precisely, the derivative of $\Delta S$ with respect to radius, at fixed black hole mass, is found to vanish at the horizon for {\it all} regular renormalized stress-energy quantum tensors. For the cases of conformal scalar fields and U(1) gauge fields, the corresponding second derivative is positive, indicating that $\Delta S$ has a local minimum there. Explicit calculation shows that indeed $\Delta S$ increases monotonically for increasing radius and is positive. (The same conclusions hold for a massless spin 1/2 field, but the accuracy of the stress-energy tensor we employ has not been confirmed, in contrast to the scalar and vector cases). None of these results would hold if the back-reaction of the radiation on the spacetime geometry were ignored; consequently, one must regard $\Delta S$ as arising from both the radiation fields and their effects on the gravitational field. The back-reaction, no matter how "small",
David Hochberg, Thomas Kephart and James W. York
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211009
gr-qc/9211010
[ 0.3821285367012024, -0.3915214538574219, 0.2146913707256317, 0.45266205072402954, -0.1230558305978775, -0.17958524823188782, -0.2595422863960266, -0.6317257881164551, -1.0865588188171387, 1.3622180223464966, -0.23036547005176544, -0.023810379207134247, 0.15797768533229828, -1.0872939825057983, 0.521065354347229, 0.3226979374885559, -0.5800320506095886, -0.03419282287359238, -1.6144464015960693, 0.9803491830825806, 0.5047232508659363, 0.14778003096580505, -0.591461718082428, -0.08034615218639374, -0.2680031955242157, 0.757098913192749, 0.3877885341644287, 0.7131322622299194, 1.0084383487701416, 1.1808432340621948, 0.34254613518714905, 0.26819735765457153, -0.12168239802122116, -0.10560979694128036, -0.619810938835144, -0.21127618849277496, -0.3522816002368927, -0.3254241347312927, 0.5182506442070007, -0.5101746916770935, 0.637540340423584, -0.039244938641786575, -0.2309100329875946, -0.23933915793895721, -0.35820120573043823, 0.35557013750076294, -0.31409135460853577, 0.21015869081020355, -0.408115416765213, -1.2106690406799316, 0.3344222605228424, -0.3382091522216797, 0.5421102643013, -0.46401411294937134, -0.5918834209442139, -0.1552789956331253, -0.23389200866222382, 0.04479992017149925, -0.2854011654853821, -0.2705989181995392, 0.20835211873054504, -0.374195396900177, -0.031369153410196304, -0.8015835285186768, -0.06961728632450104, 0.12489466369152069, -0.14178599417209625, 0.8723962903022766, -0.1222689300775528, -0.6756364107131958, 0.07290317118167877, -0.2994329035282135, -0.5369557738304138, 0.3222988247871399, -0.3301050066947937, 0.5659763813018799, -0.10360927879810333, -0.49249064922332764, -0.945967972278595, -0.5794228911399841, 0.17783871293067932, -0.1607089638710022, -0.08200788497924805, 0.3227294087409973, -0.42894601821899414, -0.08924664556980133, 0.02777916006743908, -0.7399659156799316, 0.27098962664604187, 0.1813117414712906, 0.17356882989406586, 0.8665952682495117, -0.59381502866745, 0.15731960535049438, 0.963616669178009, 0.8584660887718201, 0.2352222502231598, 0.5566878914833069, -0.30619925260543823, -0.23701854050159454, 0.14086627960205078, 0.4695287048816681, -0.2606152296066284, 0.7087276577949524, -0.6725192070007324, 0.40434515476226807, -0.25993257761001587, 0.2768942415714264, -0.25110816955566406, -0.5135149955749512, 0.6055256128311157, -0.41222089529037476, 0.5329145789146423, 1.0050915479660034, 0.5087791085243225, 0.41404277086257935, -0.41132253408432007, 0.06800062209367752, -0.7860377430915833, -0.6107792854309082, -0.016427025198936462, 0.17082342505455017, 0.45207419991493225, 1.2296149730682373, -0.2994011640548706, -0.1933450996875763, 0.4389421045780182, 0.0804937481880188, -0.4728739261627197, 0.3464988172054291, 0.4155151844024658, 0.0991600900888443, 0.09383741766214371, 0.21693500876426697, -0.6585029363632202, -0.2637796998023987, -0.6286886930465698, 0.10859435051679611, -0.07273629307746887, -0.1318703442811966, 0.27597150206565857, -0.9189487099647522, 0.2168194204568863, 1.1236869096755981, 0.008287692442536354, 0.07320062071084976, 0.6958251595497131, 0.6389799118041992, 0.31787681579589844, 0.0542488768696785, -0.028082014992833138, -0.10283911973237991, -0.10684679448604584, 0.18806004524230957, -0.13629870116710663, 0.4519374966621399, -0.4075170159339905, -0.19045008718967438, -0.45607295632362366, -0.5868677496910095, 0.44108694791793823, -0.47487884759902954, -0.0033128203358501196, 0.6480754613876343, -0.5210210680961609, 0.4539371430873871, -0.46044960618019104, -0.4419324994087219, 0.7221027612686157, 0.02332422509789467, 0.05784820765256882, 0.1685493141412735, -0.11903107911348343, 1.53304922580719, 1.073440432548523, 0.10789031535387039, 0.4273870289325714, -0.31712606549263, -0.1386098563671112, 0.39738988876342773, 0.32414117455482483, -1.076051115989685, 0.6115005016326904, -0.020313477143645287, -0.46572479605674744, -0.22892539203166962, 0.19568558037281036, -0.7917132377624512, 0.8338205814361572, 0.10593351721763611, -0.30461475253105164, -0.07062424719333649, -0.1428324282169342, 0.47687840461730957, -0.8353631496429443, 0.6502791047096252, -1.7700819969177246, 0.14672228693962097, -0.6641589999198914, -0.48881152272224426, -0.02978048473596573, -0.05048063024878502, -1.432172179222107, 0.45530974864959717, -1.7571830749511719, 0.336620956659317, 0.8967244029045105, 0.2407161295413971, -0.590817391872406, -0.3499886989593506, 0.5661799907684326, -0.33672547340393066, 0.4664347767829895, -0.2792252004146576, 0.2737516164779663, 0.9283158779144287, -0.2525440752506256, 0.3577166497707367, 0.08504608273506165, 0.24991542100906372, 0.30683228373527527, -0.018298771232366562, 0.9331548810005188, 0.672171413898468, 0.21386389434337616, -0.9728342294692993, 0.07662851363420486, 0.5468122363090515, 0.6294122934341431, -0.25787314772605896, 0.05375521257519722, 0.10897307097911835, -0.12316083163022995, 0.5218369364738464, 0.3090212345123291, -0.08888941258192062, 0.938890814781189, 0.38975903391838074, 0.23339956998825073, 0.4305039644241333, -0.33269378542900085, 0.2637074291706085, 0.40434983372688293, -0.4286368191242218, -0.7410441040992737, 0.5080729126930237, 0.17952954769134521, 0.5936101078987122, -0.4980129599571228, 0.5825572609901428, -0.4495954215526581, -0.008464979939162731, -0.05026254057884216, 0.2846466302871704, -1.5508097410202026, -0.3900836706161499, 0.1716957837343216, 0.7325030565261841, -0.12860500812530518, 0.562680721282959, 0.04982858896255493, -0.49015864729881287, -0.1364007592201233, -0.6289545893669128, 0.24364981055259705, 0.7537442445755005, -0.6711989641189575, 0.2918653190135956, 0.5450248718261719, -0.4854636490345001, -1.289322018623352, 0.251534640789032, -0.5262489318847656, -0.07924668490886688, -0.8744127154350281, -0.07213690131902695, 0.7328692078590393, -0.3419305682182312, 1.0204322338104248, 0.33278030157089233, -0.4757400155067444, 0.5682172179222107, -0.5817705392837524, 0.018998637795448303, 0.43573886156082153, 0.19004227221012115, -1.2117713689804077, 0.09050574898719788, -0.8434003591537476, 0.38987573981285095, -0.3253457844257355, -0.44997870922088623, 0.8518497347831726, -0.08850287646055222, 0.19714665412902832, 0.21907521784305573, -0.7992867827415466, -0.14781512320041656, -0.6110485792160034, -0.7506344318389893, 0.332535058259964, 0.6630541086196899, -0.1419956237077713, -0.3118864595890045, -1.2800742387771606, 1.2384639978408813, -0.09793867915868759, -0.9153597354888916, 0.482421338558197, -0.21464860439300537, -0.9613664746284485, 0.9149264693260193, 0.6967193484306335, 0.27008140087127686, 0.0033306474797427654, 1.0122326612472534, 0.5052830576896667, 0.1551937460899353, -0.30072885751724243, -0.42755839228630066, -0.6194025874137878, 0.6337387561798096, 0.3192259967327118, -0.38181018829345703, 0.2316553145647049, 0.925498366355896, 0.13040532171726227, -0.42759260535240173, 0.46379655599594116, -1.2316291332244873, -0.9051411747932434, -0.19620610773563385, -0.3732890784740448, 0.5056241154670715, 0.10929632931947708, 0.3735071122646332, -0.6145532131195068, -0.05498303845524788, 0.2878362238407135, 0.1810304969549179, 0.07401980459690094, -0.037871018052101135, 0.2189573496580124, 0.032852672040462494, 0.42372238636016846, -0.542590856552124, 0.05640222132205963, -0.2580362856388092, -0.4444544315338135, 0.2883020341396332, -0.3860558271408081, 0.1847405582666397, -0.2515866458415985, 0.07251017540693283, -0.2108156383037567, 0.6422180533409119, -0.04234294965863228, -0.10851622372865677, -0.45440778136253357, -0.07933654636144638, 0.06581994891166687, 0.798879861831665, -0.05193747952580452, -0.1310340166091919, -1.1426998376846313, 0.06807579845190048, -0.18271119892597198, 0.540618360042572, 0.5018525719642639, -0.7567067742347717, 0.43502989411354065, 0.30876266956329346, -0.6551546454429626, 0.6340860724449158, -0.17390550673007965, 0.1466447114944458, 0.3309025466442108, 0.12956181168556213, 0.8168502449989319, -0.24043554067611694, -0.9319208860397339, -0.3418296277523041, 0.6611116528511047, 0.15218092501163483, 0.538557767868042, 0.1397252231836319, -0.22522780299186707, 0.14082928001880646, -0.8481402397155762, -0.3553941249847412, -0.7312273979187012, -0.6530678272247314, -0.305124968290329, -0.009023237973451614, -0.09177921712398529, 0.46683210134506226, 0.40482765436172485, 0.6118167042732239, 0.29574957489967346, 0.1302104890346527, -0.44161155819892883, 0.2958100140094757, 0.5609875321388245, 0.8700895309448242, -0.7746007442474365, 0.5795872211456299, -0.4332641661167145, -0.05894343554973602, 0.6317205429077148, -0.012159458361566067, 0.08602415770292282, -1.0236529111862183, -0.801997721195221, -0.8501651287078857, 0.37346717715263367, 0.22902002930641174, -0.3667582869529724, 0.1865922510623932, 0.28458309173583984, 0.5023587346076965, 0.1772390902042389, 0.00366260576993227, 0.6785995960235596, -0.015732107684016228, 0.5867154598236084, -0.784699559211731, 0.14264489710330963, -0.04459018260240555, -0.24410578608512878, 0.50469571352005, -0.6144040822982788, -0.700502872467041, -0.7335079312324524, -0.2873832583427429, 0.10868684947490692, 0.1600598692893982, 0.9172407388687134, 0.7084384560585022, 0.40487879514694214, -0.631585955619812, -0.28290748596191406, 1.2674857378005981, -0.7446796894073486, -0.011507311835885048, 0.028155550360679626, 0.03004901483654976, -0.1955339014530182, 0.8305308818817139, -0.13110734522342682, -0.7229306697845459, -0.3454053997993469, -0.8286292552947998, -0.12416176497936249, -0.44030705094337463, -0.7067302465438843, -0.09181611239910126, -0.20023754239082336, -0.26327839493751526, 0.9140753746032715, -0.23457182943820953, -0.2526180148124695, 0.09024025499820709, -0.10318364948034286, -0.29843029379844666, 0.04549659788608551, 0.584257185459137, 0.09222345799207687, 0.8680477142333984, 0.6886866092681885, 0.1130974069237709, 0.3804848790168762, 0.08359970152378082, -0.6850900650024414, 0.2637251913547516, 0.7335460782051086, -0.05790165439248085, -0.7572717070579529, -0.6069648861885071, 0.00487713934853673, -0.7380588054656982, -0.03324861824512482, -0.08977147191762924, -0.4355841875076294, 0.12499790638685226, 0.05307542160153389, -0.9463821649551392, -0.8191927075386047, -0.7054531574249268, -0.543682873249054, 0.17430290579795837, -0.31492680311203003, 0.19373595714569092, 0.6135798692703247, -0.4096406102180481, -0.18947769701480865, -0.8575072884559631, -0.5918951630592346, -0.002952190116047859, 0.18233397603034973, 0.8790507912635803, 0.2398836463689804, 0.6731449365615845, -0.9545814990997314, 0.7091163396835327, -0.6054304838180542, 0.1811835765838623, -0.5574149489402771, -0.2615472376346588, -0.7302612066268921, -0.28420403599739075, 0.46663549542427063, 0.12620775401592255, -0.06770157814025879, 0.28718671202659607, 0.12479119002819061, 0.29113849997520447, 0.25180718302726746, -1.2852102518081665, -0.37570899724960327, 0.07050610333681107, 0.3972811698913574, -0.18080168962478638, 0.35041123628616333, 0.6712246537208557, 0.11323870718479156, 0.2482973337173462, -0.04009898379445076, -0.4451965391635895, 0.3306747078895569, -0.6873690485954285, 1.1996748447418213, -1.03652822971344, -0.3245376646518707, 0.03841545432806015, -0.40988799929618835, 0.8090179562568665, 0.9523866772651672, -0.6043576598167419, -0.2030162662267685, -0.6725009679794312, -0.35165145993232727, 0.0021699347998946905, -0.699642539024353, 0.1917797327041626, -0.4482590854167938, -0.46310850977897644, -0.21727897226810455, 0.7664375305175781, 0.056170687079429626, 0.1519952416419983, 0.3280804753303528, 0.37078437209129333, 0.47904500365257263, 0.6941671371459961, 0.37872639298439026, -0.1724647581577301, -0.36448052525520325, -0.29891523718833923, -0.3634091317653656, 0.584418773651123, -0.11553768068552017, 0.3274519145488739, -0.6301130652427673, 1.003208041191101, -0.15394483506679535, -0.44508394598960876, -0.09321842342615128, 0.15214021503925323, 0.4289095103740692, -0.9676847457885742, -0.023467084392905235, 0.25923341512680054, -0.2949044108390808, 0.7162477374076843, 0.5644132494926453, -0.4629998207092285, -0.7787178158760071, -0.5597500801086426, -1.1392836570739746, 0.8971716165542603, -0.03219068422913551, -0.12375065684318542, -0.7340792417526245, -0.2638698220252991, -0.0005882527912035584, 0.5260554552078247, 0.4152053892612457, 0.36616015434265137, 0.12372077256441116, 0.4115631580352783, -0.09854310750961304, -0.10485684871673584, -0.3482770323753357, -0.16715475916862488, 0.19124352931976318, 0.07980643957853317, 0.25900644063949585, 0.6544286012649536, -0.08568041026592255, -0.48761722445487976, 0.18839702010154724, -0.07572665810585022, 0.011902142316102982, -0.4662523567676544, 0.6124983429908752, 0.07074076682329178, -0.383301317691803, -0.28303927183151245, -0.07189714163541794, -0.054738227277994156, 0.031889304518699646, 0.17716512084007263, 0.5715133547782898, 0.4600529670715332, 0.2790931463241577, 0.07248996198177338, -0.6736335754394531, -0.24332422018051147, 0.46393701434135437, -0.47078758478164673, -0.16669750213623047, 0.7794246673583984, 0.17416630685329437, -0.03254684805870056, -0.08590581268072128, -0.9469791054725647, -0.47921743988990784, -0.4398539066314697, -0.46818438172340393, 0.2382419854402542, 0.31645864248275757, -0.15783366560935974, 0.4107619822025299, 0.4003334641456604, 0.5798310041427612, 0.18160223960876465, 0.058830223977565765, -0.5666534900665283, -0.026545032858848572, 0.19849549233913422, 1.0644510984420776, -0.26630645990371704, -0.8003517985343933, -0.1913532018661499, 0.2454182505607605, -0.2696869671344757, -0.5303348898887634, 0.9417718648910522, -0.48373904824256897, 0.2206486016511917, 0.05813543125987053, 0.4989098310470581, -0.1611311286687851, 0.5790075063705444, -0.22438184916973114, -0.18300098180770874, -0.3802870810031891, -0.5348866581916809, -0.4991346597671509, -0.98553466796875, 0.2312401980161667, 0.7035430073738098, -0.4132876694202423, 0.3103432059288025, -0.013926146551966667, 0.1170245110988617, 0.03252943232655525, -1.1969923973083496, -0.198195219039917, -1.2364839315414429, 0.05664977803826332, -0.6493589878082275, -0.0006963050691410899, 0.22843700647354126, 0.5713024735450745, -0.5806946754455566, 0.17690229415893555, -0.6725383996963501, -0.13195258378982544, 0.19989052414894104, 0.3418182134628296, -0.6176814436912537, -0.8892669081687927, -0.23457548022270203, 0.2433832287788391, -0.11034063249826431, -0.33316171169281006, -0.5220403075218201, -0.33611559867858887, -0.08582119643688202, 0.5925455093383789, -0.023267649114131927, 0.35610511898994446, -1.0870331525802612, -0.29293304681777954, 0.28149864077568054, 0.03827252611517906, -0.4875572919845581, 0.5277589559555054, 0.3219689130783081, 0.7481076121330261, 0.6522202491760254, 0.1240106001496315, -0.061942774802446365, 0.19253012537956238, -0.7210901379585266, 0.4139960706233978, 0.05029752105474472, 0.447221964597702, -0.47365331649780273, -0.6586899757385254, -0.275433212518692, 0.15718552470207214, -0.9993299841880798, 0.33621612191200256, -0.5523912906646729, 0.31515029072761536, -1.0092849731445312, 0.500037670135498, -0.3954085111618042, 0.08098055422306061, 0.08531627058982849, 1.199465036392212, -0.5225264430046082, 0.22202464938163757, 0.04897012561559677, 0.7308945059776306, -0.5891526341438293, 0.04668854922056198, 0.7442497611045837, -0.028377441689372063, -0.06447536498308182, -0.051538195461034775, -0.48035508394241333, 0.6404600143432617, 0.13344135880470276, -0.649077832698822, 0.117698535323143, 0.06555366516113281, -0.46364355087280273, 0.6038587093353271, 0.3331196904182434, -0.4827243387699127, 0.6725540161132812, -0.8154012560844421, -1.2524183988571167, 0.7737009525299072, -0.6775968074798584, -0.15796254575252533, 0.21336090564727783, -0.29451248049736023, 0.13353697955608368, 0.21122857928276062, -0.7831159234046936, 0.10305992513895035, 0.13695846498012543, 0.6286065578460693, 0.35915079712867737, 0.22067758440971375, -0.23215484619140625, 0.25171056389808655, -0.8629188537597656, -0.27818018198013306, -0.7658841609954834, 0.5618784427642822, -0.7515577077865601, -1.0327978134155273, -0.46884435415267944, 0.3395909070968628, -0.04329565167427063, 0.01502162590622902, 0.2835193872451782, -0.43425917625427246, -0.294503390789032, 0.25852447748184204, -0.05350552499294281, -0.1543038934469223, -0.9955316185951233, -0.06657223403453827, 0.14311735332012177, -0.5931610465049744, 0.1606106460094452, 0.31390509009361267, 0.4165230393409729, 0.2515108287334442, 0.44037050008773804, 1.3588446378707886, 0.2133016139268875, -0.3790646493434906, 0.3343225121498108, 0.039628978818655014, -0.004747476894408464, 0.6090807914733887, -0.8862944841384888, 0.29204922914505005, 0.7198493480682373, 0.10038280487060547, 0.9965498447418213, 0.6367913484573364, 0.4160565137863159, 0.4753901958465576, 0.3097867965698242, 0.17437216639518738, -0.21379753947257996, 0.15239287912845612, 0.40535518527030945, 0.23409731686115265, -0.08887525647878647, -0.19826392829418182, 0.2561436891555786, 0.2977653741836548, 0.4214895963668823, -0.22365328669548035, -0.4726826250553131, -0.31165534257888794, 0.38201576471328735, 0.5187284350395203, -0.6803970336914062, -0.1980517953634262, -0.39834535121917725, 0.08813238143920898, 0.3700432777404785, 0.7098746299743652, -0.8054909706115723, 0.37812137603759766, 1.1926809549331665, 0.06604553014039993, -0.8013817667961121, 0.5561011433601379, -0.08496222645044327, 1.3994923830032349, 0.6031696796417236, -0.21245668828487396, 0.475891649723053, 0.6568603515625, 0.29927337169647217, -1.2550793886184692, -0.3410440981388092, 0.12274988740682602, -0.6277143359184265, 0.4140605032444, -0.07186395674943924, -0.08480530977249146, -0.2574337124824524, -0.434154212474823, 0.9273669123649597, -0.32738617062568665, 0.016471795737743378, -0.0780622586607933, -0.9714190363883972, -0.41942596435546875, 0.5457547307014465, -0.28868284821510315, 0.5423250794410706, 0.8004211783409119, 0.053783658891916275, 0.4194093942642212, 1.350424885749817, 0.6388660073280334, -0.4519907236099243, 0.823477029800415, 0.0993860736489296, -0.38112419843673706, 0.3275251090526581, 0.6429115533828735, -0.3501483201980591, 0.23154716193675995, -0.8352640271186829, -0.5154032111167908, 0.5716689229011536, 0.026453353464603424, -0.09058201313018799, -0.2851129174232483, -0.20792920887470245, -0.16460999846458435, -0.6777229309082031, -0.2551978826522827, 1.442777156829834, 0.5552115440368652, -0.4904773533344269, -0.8958107233047485, 0.39081135392189026, -1.0711514949798584, -0.118443563580513, -0.9849280714988708, 0.3184356987476349, 0.15105892717838287, -0.0007807133952155709, -0.21140655875205994, -0.37429726123809814, -0.36223113536834717, -0.8184213638305664, -0.13022805750370026, -0.41621673107147217, 0.19415713846683502, 0.27767136693000793, -0.07161470502614975, 0.5074295997619629, -0.186623215675354, -0.44412264227867126, 0.16141195595264435, 1.0309933423995972, -0.12602582573890686, 0.4729677140712738, 0.7525131702423096, 0.1329515278339386, -1.0526001453399658, 0.15186738967895508, 0.6421449780464172, -0.6444753408432007, 0.6906285881996155, -0.7826219201087952, 0.3218906819820404, 0.6259175539016724, -0.45529305934906006, 0.7172361016273499, -0.16256318986415863, 0.18103908002376556, 0.572506844997406, -0.04831986129283905, -0.37019944190979004, -0.2446499615907669, -0.4204894006252289, -0.7458208203315735, 0.7049590349197388, -0.2457200288772583, -0.11034327745437622, 0.7727306485176086, -0.6821929812431335, 4.058100700378418, -0.06739361584186554, 0.640648603439331, 0.4868961572647095, 0.3902471959590912, 1.29617178440094, -0.646868884563446, 0.006342291831970215, 0.3699304461479187, -1.3364030122756958, -0.5156954526901245, -0.09252931922674179, 0.29378458857536316, -0.11083929985761642, 0.2636592984199524, 0.5122812390327454, -0.2435908168554306, -0.21587428450584412, 0.03154684603214264, -0.9306399822235107, -0.5477884411811829, -0.050203487277030945, 0.659498929977417, 0.2296140193939209, 0.45642319321632385, 0.2884417176246643, -0.0890636220574379, -0.4712575674057007, -0.5073031187057495, -0.575350821018219, -0.7138552069664001, -0.8002902269363403, 0.2117524892091751, -0.7110323309898376, -0.7637863159179688, -0.16672904789447784, -0.48288455605506897, -0.4244525134563446, 0.041567832231521606, 0.6246071457862854, -0.4704868197441101, -0.38507723808288574, 0.6726842522621155, -0.6228376030921936, 0.1383749395608902, 1.2652063369750977, -0.19347624480724335, 1.0791101455688477, 0.35335204005241394, -0.8545294404029846, 0.038133930414915085, -0.35215267539024353, 0.5910250544548035, -0.5259403586387634, -0.1101045235991478, 0.3168289065361023, -0.721315860748291, -0.0551544725894928, 0.5169284343719482, -0.4355957508087158, 0.23963887989521027, -0.10993713140487671, 0.12061555683612823, -0.28187665343284607, -0.19353346526622772, 0.010970249772071838, 0.3421836495399475, 0.02074403315782547, -0.23804280161857605, -0.2827053964138031, -0.12667812407016754, -0.3568531572818756, -0.41340893507003784, 0.295188844203949, 0.27258196473121643, 0.48600172996520996, 0.680554211139679, 0.9582505226135254, 0.02839183248579502, -0.06580766290426254, -0.7474432587623596, -0.22268235683441162, -0.36494457721710205, -0.046403560787439346, 0.23828060925006866, 0.8879784345626831, -0.27216780185699463, 0.2331816703081131, 0.05005768686532974, 0.6945015788078308, 0.45550236105918884, 0.8696628212928772, 0.39866161346435547, 0.858112096786499, -0.930355429649353 ]
Gauge (In)variance, Mass and Parity in D=3 Revisited
We analyze the degree of equivalence between abelian topologically massive, gauge-invariant, vector or tensor parity doublets and their explicitly massive, non-gauge, counterparts. We establish equivalence of field equations by exploiting a generalized Stueckelberg invariance of the gauge systems. Although the respective excitation spectra and induced source-source interactions are essentially identical, there are also differences, most dramatic being those between the Einstein limits of the interactions in the tensor case: the doublets avoid the discontinuity (well-known from D=4) exhibited by Pauli-Fierz theory.
S. Deser
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211010
gr-qc/9211011
[ 0.4635629653930664, 0.058702170848846436, -0.037662867456674576, 0.32062432169914246, -0.15737959742546082, -0.16240890324115753, -0.3831714987754822, -0.41263487935066223, 0.33145058155059814, 1.6264129877090454, 1.1592342853546143, -0.5588796734809875, -0.5190154314041138, -0.8841263055801392, -0.8451380133628845, 0.6735197901725769, 0.3206796944141388, -0.35206952691078186, -1.2569512128829956, 0.4381340444087982, -0.18603989481925964, 0.14375752210617065, -0.6926271319389343, -0.6625086069107056, -0.43890607357025146, 0.7558521628379822, 0.03873318061232567, 0.3906806409358978, 0.7825865149497986, 0.7186306715011597, 0.4919387698173523, -0.318791002035141, -0.4101462960243225, -0.5801187753677368, -0.1283840835094452, -0.5012577176094055, -0.04102295637130737, -0.8550558090209961, 0.6588470935821533, -0.5074063539505005, 0.13054093718528748, 0.19823674857616425, 0.047665003687143326, -0.3938732445240021, -0.6194236874580383, -0.24563896656036377, 0.1287568360567093, 0.2836053669452667, 0.43970048427581787, -0.8956627249717712, -0.0849727913737297, -0.6667516231536865, 0.2518902122974396, -0.8185394406318665, 0.0995650514960289, -0.3710123300552368, 0.7653437256813049, 0.313909113407135, -0.8789798021316528, -0.21289443969726562, 0.05209418386220932, 0.5394707918167114, 0.03497789055109024, -0.9595727324485779, -0.7331620454788208, 1.0098118782043457, -0.2510486841201782, 0.43606874346733093, 0.4780976176261902, -0.9549137949943542, -0.6548481583595276, -0.08664871007204056, -0.01704738661646843, 0.0848909392952919, -0.5614576935768127, 0.3832321763038635, -0.2083200067281723, -0.2500231862068176, -0.30903160572052, 0.0036194389685988426, -0.30782386660575867, 0.4981480538845062, 0.10032095015048981, 0.05956932529807091, -0.04626217484474182, -0.6525911092758179, 0.48384156823158264, -0.34571120142936707, 0.702435314655304, 0.1510772407054901, -0.47271937131881714, 0.44397446513175964, -0.6630726456642151, 0.6745262145996094, 0.6498306393623352, 0.39391353726387024, -0.26933154463768005, 0.462197482585907, -0.24339427053928375, 0.011006717570126057, 0.06825564801692963, 1.0166429281234741, -0.41970914602279663, -0.11606276780366898, -0.7820894718170166, 0.4976678788661957, 0.13673314452171326, 0.030782675370573997, -0.39699724316596985, -0.8604310154914856, -0.46634140610694885, 0.236214280128479, 1.0263744592666626, 0.30582576990127563, 0.0025990381836891174, 0.6236689686775208, -0.29995492100715637, 0.28237634897232056, -0.2708972990512848, -0.5564678907394409, -0.22937968373298645, 0.42381924390792847, -0.21392826735973358, 0.32278209924697876, -0.11721882969141006, -0.12664124369621277, -0.21594981849193573, 0.23878927528858185, -0.8600327372550964, 0.42193374037742615, 0.9980486035346985, -0.6982831358909607, -0.021570894867181778, 0.5816733241081238, 0.6224933862686157, 0.5515989661216736, 0.4420791566371918, 0.40782132744789124, 0.3346380591392517, -0.6039276719093323, -0.12903104722499847, -0.31396111845970154, 0.18150021135807037, 1.4657667875289917, -0.8208434581756592, 0.1218310073018074, 0.3185853660106659, 0.06120353564620018, -0.32790595293045044, 0.22813917696475983, 0.19912491738796234, -0.2835415005683899, 0.0654609352350235, 0.7481948137283325, -0.37458696961402893, 0.15547315776348114, -0.9832103252410889, -0.3170086443424225, -0.014748970977962017, -0.7082023024559021, 0.4474892020225525, 0.18403206765651703, 0.560662567615509, 0.5274478197097778, -0.1876370757818222, 0.24872706830501556, -1.0284603834152222, -0.7141702175140381, -0.3508214056491852, 0.0809173434972763, -0.4110530912876129, 0.5246551632881165, 0.3324085474014282, 0.5368537902832031, 1.0944734811782837, 0.967755913734436, 0.13115940988063812, -0.1169796884059906, -0.8397949934005737, 0.20377416908740997, 0.10217494517564774, -0.45198747515678406, 0.3481869399547577, 0.12726156413555145, -0.5404326915740967, -0.09621242433786392, 0.19098348915576935, -0.697364330291748, 0.04408471658825874, -0.014508070424199104, -0.5217785239219666, 0.9199950098991394, -1.4139975309371948, 0.5239301323890686, -0.8584977984428406, 0.32597973942756653, -0.4544628858566284, -0.6464341878890991, 0.21955889463424683, -0.5309045910835266, 0.17601008713245392, -0.5734595060348511, -0.42065492272377014, 0.08029161393642426, -1.1295289993286133, -0.22288745641708374, 0.8780457973480225, 0.47644779086112976, -0.5518224239349365, 0.17107895016670227, 0.497109055519104, -0.3508320450782776, 0.09036325663328171, 0.5688821077346802, 0.27694809436798096, -0.054277453571558, -0.3708445131778717, 0.04527917131781578, 0.543789267539978, 0.16443860530853271, 0.040612347424030304, 0.4866752624511719, -0.462830126285553, 1.0296969413757324, -0.14696556329727173, -0.5711856484413147, -0.26376548409461975, 0.8902088403701782, -0.21600563824176788, 0.5504765510559082, 0.09915432333946228, -0.023041274398565292, 0.32849788665771484, 0.19378721714019775, 0.579770028591156, -0.5397487282752991, 0.5814195871353149, 0.8784712553024292, 0.130160391330719, -0.5829659104347229, -0.030725043267011642, 0.25882190465927124, 0.3998219966888428, -0.14779585599899292, -1.12319815158844, 0.9068828225135803, 0.5717434883117676, 0.2977837324142456, -0.3529573082923889, 0.6243152618408203, -0.9119136333465576, 1.2609039545059204, 0.6094502806663513, 0.12528683245182037, -1.263663411140442, 0.2986588478088379, -0.2602204978466034, 0.193273663520813, -0.308576375246048, -0.3810053765773773, -0.14052921533584595, 0.03949301689863205, 0.07793258130550385, -0.7954444289207458, -0.09404745697975159, -0.05726171284914017, -0.375278502702713, 0.15513232350349426, 0.9633117914199829, -0.0699201300740242, -0.7565913796424866, -0.1712648719549179, -0.0658777728676796, -0.23219718039035797, 0.18184415996074677, 0.237753763794899, 0.37059637904167175, -0.4346690773963928, 0.7173671126365662, 0.18852634727954865, -0.31802666187286377, 0.18861277401447296, -0.6688663363456726, 0.06086624041199684, -0.8188473582267761, -0.0046115778386592865, -1.1756709814071655, 0.10309161245822906, -0.749826192855835, 0.17018920183181763, 0.04471341148018837, -0.6812193989753723, 0.4829169809818268, -0.11427094042301178, -0.36559757590293884, 0.7182939648628235, -0.23981374502182007, 0.3823467493057251, 0.04023822769522667, -0.44940441846847534, 0.6349651217460632, 0.19367587566375732, -0.5717405080795288, -0.28836187720298767, -0.9393971562385559, 0.8712188005447388, -0.07735536247491837, -0.15913847088813782, 0.8764699101448059, 0.03548598289489746, -0.3627261519432068, 0.5934838652610779, 0.11869309097528458, 1.0703374147415161, -0.05121772363781929, 0.6560119986534119, 0.5884541869163513, -0.1281333565711975, 0.5314355492591858, 0.1500375121831894, -0.5868502855300903, -0.4269282817840576, 0.11350339651107788, -1.2935361862182617, 0.657427191734314, 0.7335144877433777, 0.06937961280345917, -0.6756762862205505, 0.4605100750923157, -1.1214871406555176, -0.8489423394203186, 0.0020346054807305336, 0.1480342447757721, 0.08280376344919205, -0.3092358410358429, 0.6146628856658936, -0.055911388248205185, -0.365512877702713, -0.8160970211029053, 0.3971041142940521, 0.7644174098968506, 0.24452592432498932, -0.589076817035675, 0.6046215295791626, 0.058636680245399475, -0.023376021534204483, 0.8519972562789917, 0.011724426411092281, -0.21137011051177979, 0.04946908354759216, -0.35860493779182434, 0.19850581884384155, 0.014915136620402336, 0.26081985235214233, -0.20889927446842194, -0.3806815445423126, -0.29068058729171753, -0.08105343580245972, -1.2504055500030518, -0.7372464537620544, -0.041057128459215164, 0.2702709138393402, 0.25135213136672974, -0.8952437043190002, -0.11994528770446777, -0.9726056456565857, -0.3918388783931732, 0.23083046078681946, 0.12901592254638672, -0.557274580001831, 0.16780029237270355, 0.8574792146682739, -0.725739598274231, -0.18287748098373413, -0.19091816246509552, -0.26136133074760437, 0.8729372620582581, 0.01860220544040203, 0.4298040270805359, 0.16327784955501556, -0.11300349235534668, -0.006034624297171831, 0.7613586187362671, 0.3319076895713806, 0.43584907054901123, -0.5136407017707825, 0.06574714183807373, -0.5505261421203613, -0.23443882167339325, -0.6722810864448547, -0.36013907194137573, -0.5892300605773926, 0.22360406816005707, -0.6251500844955444, 0.005303554702550173, 0.1402098536491394, 0.4833901822566986, 1.0406556129455566, -0.04617592692375183, 0.3252829313278198, 0.05755249783396721, -0.575751006603241, 0.2799622416496277, 0.34503576159477234, -0.6045688390731812, 0.5050045251846313, -0.42721858620643616, 0.40816017985343933, 0.6442629098892212, 0.09819690883159637, -0.2553309500217438, -0.22419162094593048, -0.23041513562202454, -0.0312647745013237, 0.38540756702423096, 0.10929371416568756, 0.05357220023870468, 0.5852043032646179, 0.6572888493537903, -0.4946376383304596, -0.20710080862045288, 0.10375764966011047, 0.7494027614593506, 0.3733997941017151, 0.2076798379421234, -0.7036435604095459, -0.04800121486186981, -0.7113293409347534, 0.33657681941986084, 0.1740441918373108, 0.0395941399037838, -0.5127636194229126, -0.6266458630561829, -0.33138805627822876, 0.13403160870075226, 0.38811615109443665, 0.5391983985900879, 0.5168075561523438, 0.10416417568922043, -0.51166170835495, 0.4449096918106079, 0.9812976717948914, -0.11624813824892044, -0.5362696647644043, -0.18219316005706787, 0.016140954568982124, -0.5618392825126648, 0.7735960483551025, -0.3899974822998047, -0.8159720301628113, -0.4540407061576843, -0.6317573189735413, 0.6842542886734009, 0.042674753814935684, -0.2636062800884247, 0.0005077911773696542, 0.37634605169296265, 0.13009242713451385, 0.3247480094432831, -0.7574450969696045, 0.17955736815929413, 0.23979435861110687, -0.14040766656398773, -0.7406413555145264, -0.1786198765039444, -0.013470202684402466, -0.23590247333049774, 0.39407384395599365, 0.41157710552215576, 0.3614705502986908, 0.18975788354873657, 0.3264407813549042, -0.048919957131147385, -0.04021298512816429, 0.18959249556064606, -0.28073692321777344, -0.20736064016819, 0.14844468235969543, -0.5454158186912537, -0.02901318669319153, 0.010059394873678684, 0.7931394577026367, -0.29263511300086975, -0.20606234669685364, 0.11099541932344437, -0.5981572270393372, 0.06186026334762573, -0.37410929799079895, -0.3260185122489929, 0.8985899686813354, -0.2894844114780426, -0.15576867759227753, 0.11244088411331177, -0.9113301634788513, -0.483419805765152, -0.21015441417694092, 0.12830908596515656, -0.16922079026699066, -0.6495662927627563, 0.5474753379821777, 0.20910198986530304, 0.41235432028770447, -0.6430132985115051, 0.15260042250156403, -0.3665974736213684, -0.8151043653488159, -0.8197112083435059, -0.6634935736656189, -0.50303053855896, 0.12947560846805573, 0.6962890625, 0.26085755228996277, 0.3308160603046417, 0.44964542984962463, -0.3484143018722534, 0.7063630819320679, 0.11499331891536713, -0.5132275223731995, 0.40205833315849304, 0.20060761272907257, 0.07343646883964539, -0.2831915020942688, -0.33006030321121216, 0.4941508173942566, -0.04446524381637573, 0.235098198056221, -0.47096243500709534, -0.060337286442518234, 0.6304344534873962, -1.2792145013809204, 0.0996580421924591, -0.7250470519065857, -0.26874643564224243, -0.23281992971897125, -0.2897445559501648, -0.3906341791152954, -0.3973918557167053, -0.31212982535362244, -1.0939370393753052, -0.1888020932674408, -0.5992805361747742, 0.5422264933586121, -0.11328016966581345, 0.27574506402015686, -0.7992895841598511, -0.33129188418388367, -0.33247917890548706, 1.9200619459152222, -0.6066979169845581, -0.0603017620742321, 0.5772591233253479, -0.16818664968013763, -0.08068691194057465, 0.6320985555648804, 0.11374196410179138, 0.07292216271162033, -0.47452303767204285, -0.11348651349544525, 0.33975881338119507, 0.6472662687301636, 0.21025726199150085, 0.03651013597846031, -0.295892596244812, 0.40586188435554504, 0.2658698856830597, -0.08603356778621674, 0.1268661916255951, -0.3446429967880249, 0.4167978763580322, -0.6577709913253784, 0.2170942723751068, 0.8645045161247253, 0.8523792624473572, 0.47578784823417664, -0.3524753451347351, -0.07205403596162796, -0.23687714338302612, -0.2951944172382355, -0.3568766713142395, 0.47439149022102356, 0.4276371896266937, -0.11980795860290527, -0.5277662873268127, -0.5491376519203186, -0.18899168074131012, -0.8775932788848877, -0.3741554319858551, 0.6065270900726318, 0.24267694354057312, 0.8877279162406921, -0.6493129730224609, 0.22622226178646088, -0.12155464291572571, 0.016217201948165894, -0.2078770250082016, -0.08313191682100296, -0.6381794810295105, -0.3557070195674896, 0.014267557300627232, -0.9671167731285095, -0.6996681690216064, 0.5263336300849915, 0.5374827980995178, -0.3499738574028015, 0.7812710404396057, 0.3157433271408081, -0.3410511612892151, -0.6043367385864258, 0.2461073249578476, 0.6853358149528503, -0.09470856934785843, 0.506498396396637, 0.3664364814758301, -0.31231144070625305, -0.22008347511291504, -0.30957654118537903, -0.11657614260911942, -0.20150518417358398, 1.0571690797805786, -0.854020357131958, 0.6065972447395325, 1.2325108051300049, -0.49752137064933777, -0.7697528004646301, -1.2358839511871338, -1.495200276374817, -0.07560142129659653, 0.2517413794994354, -1.0478293895721436, -0.002559238113462925, 0.008850970305502415, -0.133287712931633, 0.41217881441116333, 0.13363920152187347, 0.0179612897336483, 0.7165923118591309, -0.3808158338069916, -0.17878344655036926, -0.47459104657173157, 0.42763665318489075, 0.4811714291572571, 0.33907681703567505, -0.4378962814807892, -0.11535234749317169, -0.052460458129644394, -0.6019784808158875, -0.5907229781150818, 0.630066454410553, -0.4466760456562042, 0.008626019582152367, -0.34320443868637085, 0.19272848963737488, 0.7053073644638062, -0.014089091680943966, -0.5139327645301819, 0.24530191719532013, -0.5838513970375061, -0.3928077816963196, -0.07282306253910065, -0.0005166168557479978, -0.14375707507133484, 1.107905387878418, 0.4148866832256317, -0.3487536609172821, -0.8201504349708557, -0.0037761509884148836, 0.4544912576675415, -0.30571413040161133, -0.7275561690330505, -0.989021360874176, -0.7069029808044434, -0.5396983623504639, -0.5206857323646545, -0.4922296702861786, 0.3238711953163147, -0.3144451975822449, 0.5410429835319519, -0.18271128833293915, 0.1643649786710739, 0.04663281515240669, 1.1813468933105469, -0.6050679087638855, -0.8066796064376831, -0.6056159734725952, 0.04365942254662514, 0.2961083948612213, -1.4183279275894165, -0.40586623549461365, -0.12258990854024887, 0.1657891571521759, 1.2196834087371826, -0.6753513216972351, 0.3280992805957794, -0.3416943848133087, -0.7944764494895935, 0.37664371728897095, 0.018524380400776863, -0.14940984547138214, 1.3953362703323364, -0.16876178979873657, 1.0406899452209473, 0.560458242893219, -0.8611969351768494, -0.01261846348643303, -0.09753777831792831, -1.1072807312011719, 0.9861041307449341, 0.22663168609142303, 0.5095462799072266, 0.36794570088386536, -0.841718316078186, 0.13629038631916046, 0.2927684783935547, -0.9636734127998352, -0.08548231422901154, -0.562849223613739, 0.7150880098342896, -0.06072292476892471, 0.14198167622089386, 0.3838255703449249, 0.4426882565021515, -0.5932385325431824, -0.33441638946533203, -1.278630256652832, -0.07838758081197739, -0.26546603441238403, 0.4858882427215576, -0.31082919239997864, -0.2919086515903473, 0.25363194942474365, -0.7526759505271912, 0.5108964443206787, 0.057068392634391785, 0.17945493757724762, 0.18262341618537903, 0.14661139249801636, -0.5590726137161255, -0.15232814848423004, 0.28008905053138733, -0.31837669014930725, 0.6811416149139404, -0.026020701974630356, 0.0069447350688278675, 0.8663917779922485, 0.2021724134683609, -1.0531432628631592, 0.292198121547699, -0.18629293143749237, -0.5678592920303345, -0.2737082839012146, 0.342970073223114, 0.494655966758728, 0.370360791683197, -0.4188333749771118, -0.11704376339912415, -0.1934703141450882, 1.008413553237915, 0.5529046654701233, -0.07969747483730316, -0.5495603680610657, 0.41030409932136536, -0.7697018980979919, 0.3486766815185547, -0.2689904272556305, 0.4216240346431732, -0.6302105188369751, -0.8528881072998047, -0.30996429920196533, -0.35357001423835754, -0.2042277604341507, -0.31166884303092957, 0.6307376623153687, -0.19188570976257324, 0.11038468778133392, -0.08217962086200714, -0.17207369208335876, -0.25867152214050293, -0.5376167893409729, 0.7699280977249146, -0.011516310274600983, -0.3238261342048645, 0.537194013595581, -0.18921102583408356, 0.6119312047958374, -0.2530905306339264, 0.11562057584524155, 1.1366567611694336, 0.10103563219308853, 0.2027353048324585, -0.3527710437774658, 0.5410683751106262, 0.216677725315094, 0.4925728142261505, -0.7152823805809021, 0.09607978165149689, 0.3373872935771942, -0.11040100455284119, 1.1149877309799194, 0.08673354983329773, 0.006178990472108126, 0.7129029035568237, -0.49971380829811096, -0.48612168431282043, 0.29750216007232666, 0.05466306954622269, -0.014880891889333725, 0.1132403016090393, -0.2251063883304596, -0.2916681170463562, 0.30335158109664917, 0.6467998623847961, 0.7678263187408447, -0.11236454546451569, 0.096164271235466, -0.38646164536476135, 0.1453161984682083, 0.34246745705604553, -0.12645362317562103, -0.8375652432441711, -0.0492771714925766, -0.029540428891777992, 0.6678405404090881, 0.0578463077545166, -0.5622506141662598, 0.7996458411216736, 0.1556595116853714, 0.42864280939102173, -0.4714342951774597, 0.10390445590019226, 0.6429162621498108, 0.8053579330444336, 0.7782924771308899, 0.26391398906707764, -0.1836039423942566, 0.6587657332420349, 0.027447646483778954, -0.8837235569953918, -0.18081729114055634, 0.5065268278121948, -0.4896197021007538, -0.12126344442367554, 0.10678152740001678, -0.13712987303733826, 0.00037262134719640017, -0.291130393743515, 0.02101988159120083, -0.22868479788303375, 0.2056311070919037, -0.29318565130233765, 0.285060852766037, 0.4518029987812042, 0.6163139343261719, 0.03807680308818817, 0.5522265434265137, 0.05776103958487511, 0.5616779327392578, 0.008773848414421082, 1.064619779586792, 0.5847882628440857, 0.2615751326084137, 0.09187059104442596, -0.26942554116249084, -0.17337384819984436, 0.3473183214664459, 0.5362756848335266, -0.40751197934150696, 0.5776174664497375, -1.0551525354385376, 0.5636605620384216, -0.6188012361526489, 0.4182519316673279, -0.5053011178970337, -0.2633671462535858, 0.9087067246437073, 0.3765633702278137, -0.2281157374382019, -0.1535647064447403, 0.31880027055740356, 0.0905829519033432, -0.2731489837169647, -0.9444928169250488, 0.646691620349884, -0.4890137016773224, 0.11901972442865372, -0.37268543243408203, 0.21536904573440552, -0.49744123220443726, 0.22991301119327545, -0.5645196437835693, 0.09725990891456604, -0.5204138159751892, -0.6525791883468628, 0.14985129237174988, -0.327056348323822, 0.7180135250091553, 0.8137038946151733, -0.04163680225610733, -0.06001001223921776, -0.4767746329307556, -0.2741539776325226, -0.18421898782253265, 1.0025129318237305, 0.24849699437618256, -0.16370947659015656, 0.44184374809265137, 0.4315982758998871, -1.1556754112243652, 0.7781277298927307, 0.6313427686691284, -0.29430091381073, 1.0066133737564087, -0.669898271560669, 0.4703274965286255, -0.10142230987548828, -0.5751504898071289, -0.013807205483317375, -0.28332647681236267, 0.6921166777610779, 0.33539602160453796, -0.5315446853637695, 0.23952631652355194, -0.013780011795461178, -0.3086826801300049, -0.4203213155269623, 0.49345359206199646, 0.441171258687973, 0.06876464188098907, 0.18333643674850464, -1.1141735315322876, 4.166904926300049, 0.11391731351613998, 0.21905793249607086, 0.23608295619487762, 0.2201484590768814, 0.9724636673927307, 0.07067710161209106, -0.4075244069099426, -0.04566654562950134, 0.024760421365499496, 0.34958937764167786, 0.1598973572254181, 0.27241334319114685, 0.6985486149787903, 0.21772879362106323, 0.5402093529701233, 0.1869637370109558, -0.03975672647356987, -0.15157310664653778, -0.1159939095377922, -0.8819156289100647, 0.49154552817344666, 0.37171489000320435, -0.03878314048051834, 0.9808728694915771, 0.17892645299434662, -0.6054813861846924, -0.7788046598434448, -0.4711577296257019, -0.000495949643664062, -0.20727954804897308, -0.26906460523605347, 0.5150870084762573, -0.5987459421157837, -0.9790173768997192, 0.8402740359306335, 0.5933313965797424, -0.5716156363487244, 0.5956375598907471, -0.4168485701084137, 0.12458483874797821, -0.5497593879699707, 0.5296794176101685, -0.396296888589859, -0.0038657241966575384, 0.5946584343910217, 0.36575978994369507, 0.6241868138313293, 0.6040462851524353, -0.9454997777938843, 0.003579741809517145, 0.814490020275116, 0.2055291086435318, 0.06419797241687775, -1.041861891746521, -0.4093077778816223, -0.0809667557477951, -0.11720343679189682, -0.5010207295417786, -0.07320161908864975, 0.7691116333007812, -0.4975939691066742, 0.06550651043653488, 0.5137086510658264, -0.22681580483913422, 0.38629868626594543, -0.34729763865470886, -0.00657992297783494, -0.0003480176965240389, -0.14962172508239746, -0.9238153696060181, -0.0991634875535965, -0.8412461876869202, -0.30995622277259827, 0.35902899503707886, 0.3002566695213318, 0.12984682619571686, 0.8396710753440857, -0.10617034882307053, 0.20375582575798035, -0.40428075194358826, 0.22164800763130188, -0.44746431708335876, 0.6785564422607422, 0.07350093871355057, 0.7281385660171509, 0.14739742875099182, -0.052305735647678375, -0.9352795481681824, 0.3970046639442444, 0.21237091720104218, 0.897298276424408, -0.2655092477798462, 0.52299565076828, -0.8836909532546997 ]
Weak-Field Gravity of Circular Cosmic Strings
A weak-field solution of Einstein's equations is constructed. It is generated by a circular cosmic string externally supported against collapse. The solution exhibits a conical singularity, and the corresponding deficit angle is the same as for a straight string of the same linear energy density. This confirms the deficit-angle assumption made in the Frolov-Israel-Unruh derivation of the metric describing a string loop at a moment of time symmetry.
Shane J. Hughes, Des J. Mc Manus, and Michel A. Vandyck
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211011
gr-qc/9211012
[ 0.14775799214839935, 0.1621445119380951, 0.4975754916667938, -0.3096737563610077, -0.025551754981279373, 0.3373323082923889, -0.34034231305122375, -0.17791154980659485, -0.8112095594406128, 1.2815957069396973, 0.508671760559082, -0.40583476424217224, 0.10709966719150543, -0.6471304893493652, -0.08243504166603088, 0.2818748652935028, 0.17213335633277893, -0.6473286151885986, -1.1391836404800415, 0.5835111141204834, -0.5339376926422119, 0.559348464012146, -1.312199592590332, -0.7098878622055054, -0.05817023664712906, 0.8793147206306458, 0.5282917618751526, 0.3818358778953552, 0.930561363697052, 0.8097360134124756, 0.6500110030174255, 0.29245609045028687, -0.3865530788898468, -0.3297862410545349, -0.6198036074638367, -0.32483187317848206, 0.2399657666683197, -0.2620187997817993, 0.9708716869354248, -0.8755879402160645, 1.049422264099121, 0.04410341754555702, 0.20219676196575165, -0.2812178432941437, -0.15754906833171844, 0.371856153011322, 0.3659873604774475, 0.14441481232643127, 0.49780648946762085, -0.8366140127182007, -0.04336393252015114, -0.3178373873233795, 0.13392071425914764, -0.6543285250663757, -0.04107661545276642, 0.022898241877555847, 0.30456599593162537, -0.06767589598894119, -0.5335784554481506, 0.30231332778930664, 0.8401232361793518, 0.544921875, 0.06976542621850967, -0.5737375617027283, 0.21014969050884247, 0.9269991517066956, -0.1830676794052124, 0.35376182198524475, 0.29649120569229126, -0.5990937352180481, 0.04649823531508446, -0.5998471975326538, -0.4255456328392029, 0.06531505286693573, -0.581584095954895, 0.45133745670318604, -0.34943529963493347, -0.2029355764389038, -0.6055243015289307, -0.33422738313674927, 0.29152169823646545, 0.4839559495449066, 0.21927006542682648, 0.22241587936878204, -0.187983438372612, -0.3099021315574646, 0.1360190510749817, -0.2838214337825775, 0.3633376657962799, -0.09483098238706589, -0.19760684669017792, 0.49850037693977356, 0.20539447665214539, 0.04938704892992973, 0.7356427907943726, 0.16006729006767273, -0.7241204977035522, 0.669334352016449, -0.1324198842048645, 0.1381746083498001, -0.4182470440864563, 0.6842141151428223, 0.2708335220813751, 0.08560476452112198, -0.37897294759750366, 1.6605868339538574, -0.0835161805152893, 0.2567542493343353, -0.027773115783929825, -1.1080448627471924, 0.12774023413658142, 0.21727512776851654, 0.15497173368930817, -0.1070476695895195, 0.057152725756168365, 0.47928857803344727, -1.1325889825820923, 0.4121797978878021, -0.2711823582649231, -0.24948498606681824, -0.7984098196029663, 0.6497754454612732, 0.27464693784713745, 0.4577796757221222, -0.38914787769317627, -0.8641098737716675, -0.0395113043487072, 0.40737098455429077, -0.2864069938659668, -0.1294076144695282, 0.3324577212333679, -0.4627605676651001, -0.18042540550231934, 0.9733003377914429, 0.1638297289609909, 0.043775152415037155, 0.5357375144958496, 0.4342378079891205, 0.05746069550514221, -0.397403359413147, -0.07474291324615479, -0.3552546203136444, 0.29925042390823364, 0.9763080477714539, -0.7018912434577942, 0.4109857976436615, -0.355129212141037, -0.06399298459291458, -0.3378712832927704, -0.10966822504997253, 0.1889295130968094, -0.359943687915802, -0.31167060136795044, -0.17148010432720184, -0.16841274499893188, 0.06380373984575272, -1.231372356414795, -0.03896849602460861, -0.05085252597928047, -0.2859797775745392, 0.4382282793521881, -0.25822338461875916, 0.28993239998817444, 0.6241375207901001, -0.7528078556060791, -0.12240676581859589, -0.9482630491256714, -0.03391603007912636, 0.23821677267551422, -0.061212584376335144, 0.07244742661714554, 0.456463485956192, -0.11278171837329865, 0.8110491037368774, 0.7576444745063782, 0.5609360337257385, -0.2717704474925995, -0.5278058052062988, -0.37073376774787903, -0.04968738183379173, -0.33033812046051025, -0.6978664398193359, 0.08247097581624985, 1.0715006589889526, -1.1212290525436401, -0.26449695229530334, 0.7475248575210571, -0.06617680937051773, 0.4197826683521271, 0.09370338171720505, 0.11091149598360062, 0.3554239869117737, -1.166304588317871, 0.21336746215820312, -0.695759654045105, -0.25580185651779175, -0.8201044201850891, -0.7812649607658386, -0.14348110556602478, -0.563806414604187, 0.08776344358921051, 0.11811976879835129, -0.21811015903949738, 0.1284259557723999, -0.7962075471878052, 0.15257927775382996, 0.9045169353485107, 0.778480052947998, -0.44520482420921326, -0.35042804479599, 0.4718790352344513, -0.4055810868740082, 0.27389341592788696, -0.2686080038547516, 0.7655022144317627, 0.4235111474990845, -0.37369081377983093, 0.6222278475761414, 0.21095864474773407, -0.1408117562532425, 0.6820313930511475, 0.050644923001527786, -0.26111361384391785, 0.6678594350814819, -0.006404324900358915, 0.08951804041862488, -0.18946652114391327, 0.8840726613998413, 0.3969341516494751, 0.1051916778087616, -0.2552858591079712, 0.039543185383081436, 0.3477917015552521, 0.5669939517974854, 0.34950268268585205, -0.35015594959259033, 0.5544326305389404, 0.8395049571990967, -0.45581039786338806, 0.047263678163290024, 0.15412762761116028, 0.4749980866909027, 0.268100768327713, 0.06954575330018997, -0.42206907272338867, 0.0830555334687233, 0.1890765279531479, 0.282306432723999, -0.4250909090042114, 0.6839267015457153, -0.7480888962745667, 0.634273111820221, -0.08936820179224014, 0.4986073076725006, -1.1577720642089844, 0.20450401306152344, -0.4783378541469574, 0.5512492060661316, 0.16615808010101318, -0.5820847153663635, 0.013588584959506989, -0.04410272091627121, -0.22932857275009155, -0.6217947006225586, 0.03526217117905617, 0.20091456174850464, -0.7138438820838928, 0.2825690507888794, 0.20952922105789185, -0.08005544543266296, -0.7202204465866089, -0.37804660201072693, 0.03362024202942848, -0.16134093701839447, -0.02795330435037613, -0.32549652457237244, 0.04042016714811325, -0.383264422416687, 0.6988643407821655, -0.06076668202877045, -0.10183196514844894, 0.33168336749076843, -0.03197033330798149, 0.12469916045665741, 0.294913649559021, 0.19117465615272522, -0.8153217434883118, 0.3004833459854126, -0.7118696570396423, 0.1582460105419159, -0.2766551673412323, -0.9698198437690735, -0.3501719534397125, -0.7789846658706665, 0.7445071935653687, 0.6588229537010193, -0.18769560754299164, 0.5098387598991394, 0.31596630811691284, -0.8326271772384644, 0.18494762480258942, -0.07836093008518219, -0.3554481565952301, -0.03958548232913017, -0.6387873888015747, 0.4621348977088928, -0.4037347137928009, 0.15072807669639587, 0.2879928946495056, -0.3198035955429077, -0.4601399302482605, 0.2952284812927246, 0.3333963453769684, 0.533566415309906, 0.02994370460510254, 0.9634760022163391, 0.6799144744873047, -0.11205338686704636, 0.021990902721881866, -0.6158284544944763, 0.007771348115056753, -0.06286246329545975, 0.11673619598150253, -0.7528135776519775, 0.29665514826774597, 0.5995688438415527, 0.3713347315788269, -0.7413526177406311, 0.6282919645309448, -0.9106892347335815, -0.6505838632583618, -0.49825766682624817, -0.27315109968185425, 0.3213529884815216, -0.026295924559235573, 0.1804506778717041, -0.3833708167076111, -0.14152847230434418, -0.5648468732833862, 0.4306529760360718, 1.1131654977798462, -0.060788288712501526, -0.01271723210811615, 0.3959687352180481, 0.15211212635040283, -0.5215426683425903, 1.1312416791915894, -0.7039690613746643, -0.055642396211624146, 0.1971084028482437, -0.031189700588583946, 0.0735793188214302, 0.8103477954864502, 0.04481301084160805, 0.06096325069665909, 0.5944566130638123, -0.7969250679016113, 0.05616757646203041, -0.27897125482559204, -0.8127094507217407, 0.4380977749824524, 0.018681813031435013, 0.23226499557495117, -0.7310476899147034, -0.9887183308601379, -0.4365014135837555, 0.47590479254722595, -0.44731825590133667, 0.4480304718017578, -1.1367632150650024, -0.03712807968258858, -0.16642634570598602, -0.6244272589683533, -0.35094916820526123, 0.26290348172187805, 0.3261529207229614, 0.4784415364265442, 0.5168461203575134, 0.462307870388031, -0.5532646775245667, -0.26726165413856506, -0.25567349791526794, 0.33867478370666504, 0.34148967266082764, 0.5858854055404663, -0.3470328152179718, -0.8840983510017395, 0.0004018689796794206, -0.39927607774734497, -0.4631575644016266, -0.8426277041435242, -0.43663233518600464, 0.31810426712036133, -0.22520874440670013, -0.4037545323371887, 0.02749653160572052, 0.6161765456199646, 0.8764810562133789, -0.2425813227891922, -0.1779206246137619, -0.07271042466163635, -1.0233927965164185, 0.16499187052249908, 0.11994114518165588, 0.022472454234957695, -0.09982539713382721, -0.6536479592323303, 0.6482749581336975, 0.40457746386528015, 0.4366702139377594, 0.36911603808403015, -0.4466187357902527, -0.31015706062316895, 0.02881457284092903, 0.19755898416042328, 0.3694026470184326, -0.3113979995250702, 0.23079913854599, 0.3000083267688751, -0.381562739610672, -0.3430536687374115, 0.34825173020362854, 0.1475675106048584, 0.5287047624588013, 0.09136504679918289, -0.6986578702926636, -0.20168142020702362, -0.6562872529029846, -0.08408673107624054, 0.4819504916667938, -0.39021727442741394, -0.9977326989173889, -0.3664553165435791, 0.5251597166061401, 0.3910346031188965, 0.2028357982635498, 0.8390696048736572, -0.20188593864440918, 1.0667740106582642, 0.327913373708725, 0.338605672121048, 0.92635577917099, -0.28396376967430115, -0.5552683472633362, 0.22370417416095734, 0.7362454533576965, -0.11771061271429062, 0.9634309411048889, -0.6131458282470703, -1.4281851053237915, -0.7460427284240723, -0.1535012125968933, 0.38622552156448364, -0.08577652275562286, -0.5175349712371826, 0.46470922231674194, -0.03813542425632477, 0.11782371252775192, 0.06173749640583992, -0.2462960183620453, 0.1260468065738678, 0.3296235203742981, -0.21676583588123322, -0.6087242960929871, -0.6311990022659302, -0.047066979110240936, -0.0044048018753528595, 0.35376492142677307, 0.5090866684913635, 0.31494271755218506, 0.9197030067443848, 0.389828622341156, 0.19263271987438202, -0.08847802132368088, 0.3953670263290405, -0.34838271141052246, -0.08474007993936539, -0.3457080125808716, -0.030115457251667976, -0.4141947329044342, 0.36249399185180664, 0.0029462557286024094, -0.5598583817481995, 0.6169294118881226, 0.34296420216560364, -0.6118872165679932, -0.026122691109776497, -0.36534401774406433, -0.5887374877929688, 0.7844530940055847, -0.1224396824836731, -0.06734056025743484, 0.21387121081352234, -0.705764651298523, -0.42661044001579285, -0.1385575383901596, 0.5513069033622742, -0.9299772381782532, 0.12943853437900543, 0.37029406428337097, -0.39343613386154175, 0.9320623874664307, -0.8915435671806335, -0.08294294774532318, -0.469577819108963, -0.7731701731681824, -0.912773847579956, -0.39526301622390747, -0.32458242774009705, 0.27443283796310425, -0.2712962329387665, -0.392538845539093, 0.07496432214975357, 0.6038891077041626, 0.05973510071635246, 1.0979093313217163, -0.044826120138168335, -0.7389371991157532, -0.17683543264865875, 0.3700392544269562, 0.2644243538379669, -0.9107542037963867, -0.19131244719028473, 0.6178519129753113, -0.16092954576015472, 0.5200647711753845, -0.37449806928634644, -0.13350704312324524, -0.5112497210502625, -0.6256552934646606, 0.055998921394348145, -0.5587263107299805, -0.43782365322113037, -0.17920570075511932, -0.598091185092926, -0.4422531723976135, 0.7048870325088501, -0.14686360955238342, -0.4117245674133301, -0.32051098346710205, -0.31702888011932373, 0.4725850820541382, -0.21661950647830963, 0.43591347336769104, -0.6490297913551331, -0.3182055652141571, -0.6307758688926697, 1.1746470928192139, -0.6278833150863647, -0.07032819092273712, -0.38693854212760925, 0.15642379224300385, -0.4481150805950165, 0.9883555173873901, -0.4359477758407593, 0.15298251807689667, -0.08621988445520401, 0.2868669629096985, 0.07629328966140747, 0.06877176463603973, -0.5095394849777222, 0.33587199449539185, -0.6827805042266846, -0.1912388652563095, -0.015375652350485325, -0.1783919483423233, 0.8316300511360168, 0.013808755204081535, 0.5495076775550842, -0.235948845744133, 0.49366605281829834, 1.0861624479293823, 0.2451675683259964, 0.4868144094944, 0.12380371987819672, -0.6250777840614319, 0.21419380605220795, -0.7620238065719604, -0.5791905522346497, 0.6544367074966431, 0.4868464171886444, 0.08651363849639893, -0.4147810935974121, -0.5601140260696411, 0.1639588326215744, -0.37708574533462524, 0.1668202131986618, 0.9802876114845276, -0.4301215708255768, 0.4875950217247009, -0.4229750335216522, -0.1582372933626175, -0.3609764277935028, 0.06379777193069458, 0.808733344078064, -0.019604993984103203, -0.24098899960517883, -0.5356945991516113, -0.9298548698425293, -0.7506672739982605, -0.6030583381652832, 0.7121756076812744, 0.967758297920227, -0.3769829273223877, 0.7181939482688904, -0.40120047330856323, -0.3684238791465759, -0.40206730365753174, 0.16368268430233002, 1.2585595846176147, -0.43060004711151123, -0.036290235817432404, 0.3597865700721741, -0.430896133184433, 0.29097262024879456, -0.4707903265953064, -0.9424934387207031, -0.004790517967194319, 0.7049826979637146, -0.3293730914592743, -0.06361653655767441, 0.20406252145767212, -0.04245142266154289, -0.5964313745498657, -1.1337982416152954, -0.9992669820785522, -0.6065111756324768, 0.2620530128479004, -0.6423031687736511, 0.29693135619163513, 0.1009107381105423, -0.0035196440294384956, 0.2874357998371124, 0.5455800294876099, 0.43777722120285034, 0.2584836184978485, -0.032023537904024124, 0.13246187567710876, -0.2654571533203125, 0.06510359048843384, 1.3133684396743774, 0.19079631567001343, -0.1793583631515503, -0.5263388752937317, 0.141912579536438, -0.011189901269972324, 0.27246955037117004, 0.15023745596408844, -0.8904069662094116, 0.36579424142837524, 0.3478640615940094, 0.5354336500167847, 0.37950700521469116, 0.09762239456176758, 0.255483478307724, 0.15483063459396362, -0.5324521660804749, -0.8300009965896606, -0.34117692708969116, 0.38007867336273193, 0.09832838177680969, 0.719292402267456, -0.22347985208034515, -0.3053874671459198, -0.16454561054706573, -0.34397417306900024, -0.28471577167510986, -0.3122008442878723, -0.5641606450080872, -1.247829556465149, -0.8815065026283264, -1.1970165967941284, 0.10154127329587936, 0.5234248042106628, 0.2180044800043106, -0.7937148809432983, 0.6534621715545654, -0.6218054890632629, 0.5540485978126526, 0.006041177548468113, 0.8679668307304382, -0.3109130859375, -0.7908153533935547, -0.8917795419692993, -0.12895403802394867, -0.10249090194702148, -1.154500126838684, -0.036535847932100296, -0.6292124390602112, 0.7735135555267334, 1.2842943668365479, -1.0533336400985718, 0.4014739692211151, -0.4284863770008087, 0.0053204637952148914, 0.18076783418655396, -0.26626473665237427, -0.7987315058708191, 0.851728081703186, -0.30309486389160156, 0.21124175190925598, 0.3204286992549896, -0.16234718263149261, -0.20628038048744202, 0.0673597976565361, -0.8519918322563171, 0.8809536695480347, 0.5202254056930542, 0.7541288137435913, 0.3659157156944275, -0.7009435892105103, -0.2935827374458313, 0.19818902015686035, -1.018754243850708, 0.17183856666088104, -0.609783411026001, 0.5177035331726074, -0.15515431761741638, 0.22969835996627808, 0.26563000679016113, 0.9838080406188965, -0.14104850590229034, 0.21185263991355896, -0.4233372211456299, 0.5451542735099792, 0.36683154106140137, 0.6794325113296509, -0.08299804478883743, -0.8029042482376099, 0.470872700214386, -0.8747168183326721, 0.6136862635612488, 0.23242700099945068, -0.07367070019245148, -0.08178871870040894, -0.009159366600215435, -0.5382272005081177, -0.46754029393196106, 0.5377368927001953, -0.48788824677467346, 0.8788477778434753, -0.4202180504798889, 0.4183482825756073, 0.6919495463371277, -0.3468867838382721, -1.510274052619934, 0.13101616501808167, -0.00688167056068778, -0.9556020498275757, 0.5059491395950317, -0.013065075501799583, -0.5764480829238892, 0.06143772974610329, -0.5388525724411011, 0.1713624745607376, -0.5298460721969604, 0.9001726508140564, 1.6395213603973389, 0.5141261219978333, 0.10009436309337616, 0.06076553836464882, -0.8338184952735901, -0.10317561775445938, -1.00417959690094, -0.30187419056892395, -1.004765272140503, -0.7931270003318787, -0.07291628420352936, 0.17719237506389618, -0.1483672559261322, 0.03933818265795708, -0.382523775100708, -0.07354705780744553, -0.017277561128139496, 0.24270784854888916, -0.4994804263114929, -0.1298651248216629, 0.23064136505126953, 0.26656168699264526, 0.5308616757392883, -0.4275016188621521, 0.48176512122154236, 0.11937733739614487, 0.5682291984558105, 0.22960853576660156, -0.18568935990333557, 1.1231144666671753, -0.022369325160980225, 0.5870047807693481, 0.8267782926559448, 0.33624255657196045, 0.5018877387046814, 0.6621422171592712, -0.23367378115653992, -0.42935386300086975, 0.4883905053138733, 0.07506059855222702, 1.2325725555419922, 0.31960177421569824, 0.12205983698368073, 0.4589909017086029, 0.008607601746916771, -0.06420285999774933, 0.21612302958965302, -0.38113173842430115, 0.04445546120405197, 1.2955924272537231, -0.8592966198921204, 0.24205206334590912, -0.16170041263103485, -0.35402506589889526, -0.029135895892977715, 0.054212357848882675, 0.3388957679271698, -0.5757347345352173, -0.23821720480918884, 0.8475481271743774, -0.2151586264371872, -1.2326576709747314, -0.45186012983322144, -0.008783495984971523, 0.7370204329490662, 0.040340304374694824, -0.1990727186203003, -0.07842899858951569, 0.4353286027908325, 0.02374347671866417, -0.08106106519699097, 0.10612443089485168, -0.3352174758911133, 0.4289681613445282, 0.7995728254318237, 0.42777857184410095, 0.08600187301635742, 0.3281130790710449, 0.02640565298497677, -0.7657915353775024, 0.6299338936805725, 0.5179688334465027, -0.16961964964866638, 0.16600912809371948, 0.22809453308582306, -0.005998346954584122, 0.11494895070791245, -0.27170926332473755, -0.13959430158138275, -0.40516290068626404, 0.1827230602502823, -0.296086847782135, -0.04599646106362343, -0.16809974610805511, 0.3823699653148651, 0.20712120831012726, 0.23178869485855103, 0.419005811214447, 0.3780532479286194, 0.13887615501880646, 0.4662678837776184, 0.9748523831367493, 0.25828927755355835, 0.052463069558143616, -0.31577324867248535, -0.24345183372497559, 0.8088039755821228, 0.07338346540927887, -0.09170042723417282, 0.2912113666534424, -0.693226158618927, -0.1681847721338272, -0.29610806703567505, 0.12911291420459747, -0.5375640392303467, -0.09396369755268097, 0.36846068501472473, 0.6349337697029114, -0.25903549790382385, -0.05892542377114296, 0.6792985796928406, 0.9120450019836426, -0.47289183735847473, -0.27687573432922363, 0.9415780305862427, -0.6108287572860718, -0.06243828311562538, -0.5299729704856873, 0.5166430473327637, -0.2859313189983368, -0.1368294656276703, -0.4755040109157562, 0.08363039046525955, -0.528830885887146, -0.3785203993320465, 0.12037618458271027, 0.5002531409263611, 0.5520024299621582, 0.632182776927948, 0.05124630779027939, 0.2850745916366577, -0.5500746369361877, -0.4962405264377594, -0.18690308928489685, 0.5433629155158997, 0.15538913011550903, 0.10620170831680298, 0.3442063629627228, -0.1999877542257309, -0.5519264340400696, 0.5889806747436523, 0.40319135785102844, -0.6657142043113708, 0.6072422862052917, -0.1852443665266037, -0.31559038162231445, -0.1303718537092209, -0.2667333483695984, 0.28732532262802124, 0.37494343519210815, 0.8181756138801575, -0.07984700053930283, -0.7611703276634216, 0.07746261358261108, -0.22586792707443237, -0.3355146050453186, -0.48885682225227356, 0.10334760695695877, 0.05794047936797142, -0.5129815936088562, 0.13807882368564606, -1.137331485748291, 4.199008941650391, 0.5019435882568359, 0.47660475969314575, -0.28462478518486023, 0.890033483505249, 0.9174772500991821, 0.14713729918003082, 0.22360864281654358, 0.3487480580806732, -0.8547778129577637, 0.08086270838975906, 0.18305128812789917, 0.17788952589035034, 0.35157039761543274, 0.6438039541244507, 0.5418809056282043, -0.35357996821403503, -0.7628247141838074, 0.03942159190773964, -0.029202185571193695, -1.0799720287322998, 0.16506914794445038, 0.1529025137424469, 0.2625575661659241, 0.6572200059890747, 0.6754775047302246, 0.29827257990837097, -0.11992181092500687, -1.0125186443328857, -0.6095858216285706, -0.17294178903102875, -0.36084526777267456, 0.5616784691810608, 0.23042529821395874, -0.954194962978363, 0.3010112941265106, -0.052371036261320114, -0.2877262532711029, 0.10574599355459213, -0.3549053370952606, 0.1265878528356552, -0.5145543813705444, 0.2137787938117981, -0.15355563163757324, -0.22468172013759613, 1.4789015054702759, 1.0321974754333496, 0.5277162194252014, 0.6409636735916138, -0.7616020441055298, -0.19439567625522614, 0.4344766438007355, -0.05897090211510658, -0.5283327102661133, -0.806214451789856, -0.4231869876384735, -0.1588580459356308, -0.06528348475694656, 0.4692990481853485, -0.03437289223074913, 0.15824414789676666, -0.14657464623451233, -0.6887817978858948, -0.42666196823120117, 0.1257932186126709, 0.09949301183223724, 0.25379642844200134, 0.09557255357503891, 0.03227253258228302, -0.7118526697158813, -0.7095434665679932, 0.2416706681251526, -0.5671878457069397, -0.32025861740112305, 0.7444544434547424, 0.7185772657394409, -0.020640350878238678, 0.31920674443244934, -0.10932374000549316, 0.11210578680038452, -0.5175572633743286, -0.44570252299308777, -0.5243765711784363, 0.7926279306411743, -0.8032903075218201, 0.7073320150375366, 0.4822118580341339, -0.3437138497829437, -0.5309964418411255, 0.4217051565647125, -0.32786285877227783, 0.5083147883415222, -0.6816543340682983, 0.43909722566604614, -1.201781988143921 ]
Inflating Lorentzian Wormholes
It has been speculated that Lorentzian wormholes of the Morris- Thorne type might be allowed by the laws of physics at submicroscopic, e.g. Planck, scales and that a sufficiently advanced civilization might be able to enlarge them to classical size. The purpose of this paper is to explore the possibility that inflation might provide a natural mechanism for the enlargement of such wormholes to macroscopic size. A new classical metric is presented for a Lorentzian wormhole which is imbedded in a flat deSitter space. It is shown that the throat and proper length of the wormhole inflate. The resulting properties and stress-energy tensor associated with this metric are discussed.
Thomas A. Roman
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211012
gr-qc/9211013
[ 0.14858387410640717, 0.2680542767047882, 0.3406197428703308, -0.15211744606494904, 0.3748653531074524, -0.743804395198822, -0.4228302538394928, 0.24324478209018707, 0.0796654149889946, 1.903387427330017, 0.283721923828125, -0.09581277519464493, -0.3105620741844177, -1.278033971786499, 0.34709593653678894, 0.31050074100494385, 0.17486082017421722, -0.14845383167266846, -0.7089437246322632, 0.10377141088247299, 0.9814209938049316, 0.1509195864200592, -0.6842440962791443, -0.21417143940925598, -0.07088836282491684, 0.6099646687507629, 0.34747952222824097, 0.7365475296974182, 1.1790242195129395, 1.074020266532898, 1.061365008354187, -0.36182233691215515, -0.05902587249875069, -1.0721793174743652, -0.3320833146572113, 0.1229916512966156, 0.2060520499944687, -0.42271965742111206, 0.6755341291427612, -0.5087354779243469, 0.5735887885093689, -0.3924369812011719, 0.044798050075769424, -0.24143904447555542, -0.31450048089027405, -0.22692203521728516, -0.039680611342191696, 0.7163301110267639, -0.14306683838367462, -1.326224684715271, 0.4417174458503723, -0.17896468937397003, 0.7361811995506287, -1.2068880796432495, -0.5201925039291382, -0.4751797318458557, -0.030122919008135796, 0.33309105038642883, -0.14462190866470337, 0.0988900437951088, 0.29585981369018555, 0.024552546441555023, -0.10308659076690674, -1.1530988216400146, -0.1780504584312439, 0.548352837562561, 0.10230620205402374, 0.705906331539154, -0.02650885097682476, -0.44577649235725403, -0.5082771182060242, 0.2019006609916687, -0.2863268554210663, 0.46966472268104553, -0.5313410758972168, 0.6745553016662598, -0.6117047667503357, -0.5131238698959351, -1.3500069379806519, -0.3503955602645874, -0.8395422101020813, 0.4586189389228821, -0.3196185529232025, 0.2225090116262436, -0.033219244331121445, -0.044799044728279114, 0.17181427776813507, 0.20715688169002533, 1.0508732795715332, 0.21181051433086395, -0.4329122304916382, 0.5470750331878662, -0.13425499200820923, 0.11475899070501328, 0.8301671743392944, 0.8796862363815308, -0.0640985444188118, 0.3131546974182129, -0.2507109045982361, -0.47843724489212036, -0.48864319920539856, 0.8486344218254089, -0.45697909593582153, 0.7056933641433716, -0.5983456373214722, 1.037466287612915, -0.39526814222335815, -0.02177918143570423, -0.3267210125923157, -0.6940106749534607, 0.11712884157896042, 0.8126868605613708, 0.8078460097312927, 0.3719988763332367, 0.08295793831348419, 0.577863335609436, -0.20023983716964722, -0.01566755399107933, -0.7836253046989441, -0.39200446009635925, 0.04592307284474373, 0.3253467082977295, 0.42069414258003235, 0.7094846963882446, -0.49660754203796387, -0.3428221344947815, 0.4117458760738373, -0.020776325836777687, -0.7527745962142944, 0.9148305058479309, 0.4666406512260437, -0.4889329969882965, 0.13700436055660248, 0.23600313067436218, -0.5387676954269409, 0.5455398559570312, 0.37741291522979736, -0.08306552469730377, 0.22054971754550934, -0.6835899353027344, 0.19514107704162598, -0.6340585947036743, 0.3435617685317993, 1.3104546070098877, -0.5959352254867554, 0.938751220703125, 0.8122568130493164, 0.6174042224884033, -0.02057519368827343, 0.16436611115932465, -0.2014724761247635, -0.502490222454071, 0.009672374464571476, 0.6876494884490967, -0.41071146726608276, 0.2825671434402466, -0.5196609497070312, -0.088053859770298, -0.02921934239566326, -0.5312076807022095, 0.8812410831451416, -0.012598010711371899, 0.6744155287742615, 0.8808454871177673, -0.37128764390945435, 0.798159122467041, -0.2611197531223297, -0.8010510802268982, 0.7836387157440186, -0.16364315152168274, -0.1259678155183792, 0.029339274391531944, 0.007716755382716656, 0.7024717330932617, 0.4683930575847626, 0.39978474378585815, -0.3013433516025543, -0.03363736346364021, -0.4166657030582428, 0.5942174196243286, -0.16950589418411255, -1.0822981595993042, 0.2421102225780487, 0.659576416015625, -0.5426706671714783, -0.4410918951034546, 0.6806139349937439, -0.7837506532669067, 0.15074075758457184, -0.7113685011863708, -0.5960993766784668, 0.5581720471382141, -0.5321139693260193, -0.03199726343154907, -0.8977705836296082, -0.07446479797363281, -1.6087160110473633, -0.23513810336589813, 0.2636280357837677, -0.47176021337509155, -0.06849756836891174, 0.2478981465101242, -0.19050824642181396, 0.7662237882614136, -0.7835394740104675, -0.6991990208625793, 0.8954951763153076, 0.30241814255714417, -0.48899996280670166, -0.6523095369338989, 0.7009719610214233, -0.34384825825691223, 0.5802488923072815, -0.09878292679786682, 0.6406967639923096, -0.09072218835353851, -0.3497448265552521, 0.4359443783760071, 0.2806706726551056, -0.056907135993242264, 0.3620084524154663, 0.06679898500442505, -0.21853552758693695, 1.4205081462860107, 0.11574064195156097, 0.09582259505987167, 0.04495425894856453, 1.317378044128418, 0.21243029832839966, 0.3146738111972809, -0.5828816294670105, 0.0018113115802407265, 0.6929547786712646, 0.2919514775276184, 0.17810823023319244, 0.4417756199836731, 0.6754801273345947, 1.128504753112793, 0.018782908096909523, 0.7075767517089844, 0.10830550640821457, 0.37245357036590576, 0.5336419939994812, 0.24331800639629364, -0.3319511413574219, 0.8394101858139038, 0.5180696845054626, 0.2721518278121948, -0.20246146619319916, 0.5709410905838013, -0.5633519291877747, 0.9189869165420532, -0.44923996925354004, -0.2795085310935974, -1.0739390850067139, -0.3420998752117157, 0.008762757293879986, 0.32541924715042114, 0.054130155593156815, -0.1412518322467804, -0.9317531585693359, -0.02535807155072689, -0.020434288308024406, -0.7809404730796814, 0.09584043174982071, -0.09358330816030502, -0.5484273433685303, -0.6053716540336609, 0.9251534342765808, -0.2627067267894745, -1.3216850757598877, 0.43217629194259644, -0.8214030265808105, -0.18484380841255188, -0.20413635671138763, -0.3753994405269623, 0.0005292837740853429, -0.042811423540115356, 0.5289000272750854, -0.19727817177772522, 0.08440188318490982, 0.5656633377075195, -0.13068898022174835, 0.14586207270622253, 0.4122913181781769, 0.15577811002731323, -0.631435751914978, -0.08793607354164124, -0.9508540034294128, -0.029568331316113472, -0.13095690310001373, -0.7586654424667358, 0.4301600456237793, -0.5410387516021729, -0.21003511548042297, 0.22173212468624115, -0.14119581878185272, -0.35776597261428833, 0.033647213131189346, -0.6383753418922424, -0.2866523563861847, 0.039713628590106964, -0.8877244591712952, -0.04865172132849693, -0.15893712639808655, 0.7812213897705078, 0.5639585256576538, -0.11760127544403076, 0.46690624952316284, -0.18375658988952637, -0.0213087759912014, 0.35588306188583374, 0.6444380283355713, 0.12049952894449234, -0.27421268820762634, 0.30753976106643677, 0.9373477697372437, 0.08191131055355072, 0.08130347728729248, -0.0360591784119606, -0.2117341160774231, -0.10337555408477783, 0.2001497447490692, -0.6824355125427246, 0.6085575222969055, 0.4139285981655121, 0.16893871128559113, -0.9005768299102783, 0.5391572713851929, -0.7846978306770325, -1.154307246208191, -0.27871695160865784, -0.3694544732570648, 0.06408748030662537, 0.2357029765844345, 0.49428027868270874, -0.05054238438606262, -0.12227135896682739, -0.25133630633354187, 0.1639573872089386, 0.1482701599597931, 0.1452447921037674, 0.0017582408618181944, 0.7785462737083435, 0.5042045712471008, 0.4260571599006653, 0.33679428696632385, -0.42427757382392883, -0.2058698832988739, 0.790148913860321, -0.8114991784095764, -0.12543757259845734, 0.458307147026062, -0.2598630487918854, 0.4381699562072754, 0.268578439950943, -0.6344028115272522, -0.29491299390792847, -0.8975793123245239, -0.40129804611206055, 0.5441139936447144, 0.25584542751312256, 0.3043193221092224, -1.1319894790649414, -0.27116066217422485, 0.18478411436080933, -0.15898096561431885, 0.9847592711448669, 0.4347112476825714, -0.9709887504577637, 0.023936817422509193, 1.03757643699646, -0.10899179428815842, -0.577410101890564, -0.20490148663520813, 0.3834989368915558, 0.7464616894721985, 0.42656803131103516, 0.3210621178150177, -0.36400797963142395, -0.0231834314763546, -0.08040077984333038, 1.3500616550445557, 0.20913830399513245, 0.8711774945259094, -0.47551339864730835, -0.6175335049629211, -0.26395049691200256, -0.05016935616731644, -0.6157305836677551, -0.0076792542822659016, -1.1127917766571045, 0.4379611015319824, -0.40238919854164124, -0.34911271929740906, 0.22217343747615814, -0.28571873903274536, 0.5883083939552307, 0.8767849802970886, -0.14860807359218597, 0.03245675936341286, 0.5222760438919067, -0.19002333283424377, 0.6781272292137146, -1.2976073026657104, 0.4454447627067566, -0.13841603696346283, 1.0855252742767334, 0.364401251077652, 0.45328783988952637, 0.06420347094535828, -0.0786040872335434, -0.08700181543827057, -0.3470139503479004, 0.6521621942520142, 0.007189865689724684, -0.28708016872406006, 0.4359075725078583, 0.35817739367485046, -0.8800172209739685, -0.07357412576675415, -0.3557915985584259, 0.5994019508361816, 0.4623830318450928, 0.4687083065509796, -0.01779058389365673, 0.0761893168091774, -0.5522426962852478, 0.4055447280406952, 0.5039541721343994, -0.32116907835006714, -0.38155508041381836, -0.9156690239906311, 0.402781218290329, 0.6673484444618225, -0.3642635643482208, 0.209352508187294, 1.1984573602676392, 0.38406506180763245, -0.36603209376335144, 0.5136195421218872, 0.6062840819358826, -0.5881600975990295, -0.11884164810180664, 0.10931649059057236, -0.2522602677345276, -0.0433695986866951, 0.17302899062633514, 0.18532204627990723, -0.48892104625701904, -0.6253452301025391, -0.22943834960460663, 0.18639831244945526, -0.39529919624328613, -0.8540957570075989, 0.2598729729652405, 0.031266823410987854, 0.15580672025680542, 0.18365705013275146, -0.23483537137508392, 0.15819820761680603, 0.17793454229831696, -0.11987528949975967, 0.6787496209144592, 0.12746037542819977, 0.7204184532165527, -0.33851122856140137, 0.6766360402107239, 0.9389893412590027, -0.02221095748245716, 0.025628145784139633, 0.1617213636636734, 0.0013882871717214584, -0.15364904701709747, 0.4987878203392029, -1.0602011680603027, -0.7636918425559998, 0.11595194041728973, -0.46684762835502625, -0.3994204103946686, 0.06630031764507294, 0.563143253326416, 0.1735977828502655, -0.1224621906876564, 0.4747196137905121, -0.8792227506637573, -0.1584056168794632, -1.0432049036026, -0.8943310379981995, 0.3010881841182709, -0.00013098330236971378, -0.21901942789554596, 0.43789592385292053, -0.927824079990387, -0.08614523708820343, 0.062268733978271484, -0.5724230408668518, -0.3581717908382416, -0.026089446619153023, 0.36112141609191895, 0.10418921709060669, 0.3962622284889221, -0.7446156144142151, -0.36097925901412964, -0.6482446789741516, -0.08389776200056076, -0.14708054065704346, -0.40027105808258057, -0.2186312973499298, -0.11781881749629974, -0.0007475217571482062, -0.3366750180721283, -0.44634732604026794, 0.2428891956806183, -0.43880143761634827, -0.030560068786144257, 0.07498543709516525, -0.7304335832595825, 0.2606504559516907, 0.2575465738773346, 0.6947036981582642, -0.6960486173629761, 0.349978506565094, 0.15234893560409546, 0.795012354850769, 0.07916098833084106, 0.3506018817424774, -0.004695720970630646, 0.6633439064025879, -1.0961214303970337, 0.8165373206138611, -1.1692359447479248, -0.3706102967262268, -0.5383334755897522, -0.7034776210784912, -0.02256322279572487, -0.01561468094587326, -0.15789785981178284, -0.33717361092567444, -0.05147629603743553, -0.2668439447879791, 0.5028176307678223, -0.23434171080589294, 0.1850937455892563, -1.3958477973937988, -0.6397110223770142, -0.39499297738075256, 0.9173716306686401, -0.38417166471481323, -0.08241064101457596, 0.5778375267982483, -0.21744024753570557, -0.369302362203598, 0.18188734352588654, 0.5353606343269348, 0.35547012090682983, -0.7590309977531433, 0.29066574573516846, 0.39058420062065125, -0.1545681208372116, -0.2245722860097885, 0.3927070200443268, -0.4504455327987671, 0.5969967842102051, 0.46115434169769287, -0.610379159450531, -0.2807101011276245, -0.3467651605606079, 0.9007695913314819, -0.5816258192062378, -0.6581646203994751, 0.8875463008880615, -0.4304955303668976, 0.46193772554397583, -0.5814615488052368, -1.1028032302856445, -0.4684908092021942, -0.20172113180160522, -0.8020861744880676, 0.16163478791713715, 0.13698352873325348, 0.020245814695954323, 0.006087184883654118, -0.9409018158912659, -0.18673758208751678, -0.40746065974235535, 0.04862627759575844, 0.2731197774410248, 0.507598340511322, 0.48524969816207886, -0.3742024600505829, -0.16025741398334503, -0.6957071423530579, -0.29111284017562866, 0.17929458618164062, -0.6437530517578125, -0.147035151720047, -0.3750472366809845, -0.30298319458961487, -0.20131169259548187, -0.2669699788093567, -0.15154395997524261, 0.2358044683933258, -0.7148635983467102, 0.7793073058128357, -0.11983255296945572, 0.0030653667636215687, -0.3740009069442749, 0.26758337020874023, -0.06727077066898346, 0.16330291330814362, 0.10773920267820358, -0.162527397274971, 0.043658576905727386, -0.0561053529381752, 0.8440292477607727, -0.1619684249162674, -0.5347670316696167, 1.1741719245910645, -0.5105351805686951, 0.03498324751853943, 0.8152777552604675, -0.14373625814914703, 0.08183073997497559, -0.05961844325065613, -0.4628240168094635, -0.6219887137413025, 0.2616580128669739, -0.11270206421613693, 0.5974845886230469, -0.10150276124477386, -0.6293174624443054, 0.22088849544525146, -0.05594538897275925, 0.081827811896801, 0.6039772033691406, 0.12324397265911102, 0.09358756989240646, -0.7851994037628174, 0.46012744307518005, 1.394248604774475, 0.40884914994239807, -0.35501569509506226, -0.5208152532577515, -0.1384461224079132, -0.4158933758735657, -0.6142470240592957, 0.4169469475746155, 0.005231100134551525, 0.3271167278289795, -0.6466273069381714, 0.8438891768455505, 0.8022165298461914, -0.3151119351387024, -0.6392999887466431, -0.022339044138789177, -0.71800297498703, -0.2701434791088104, 0.04177039489150047, 0.03806488215923309, -0.08395574241876602, 0.6378706693649292, -0.18079417943954468, 0.13584156334400177, -0.1626775860786438, 0.2705422341823578, 0.1522352248430252, -0.6196949481964111, -0.29230350255966187, -0.8060274124145508, -0.8099994659423828, -1.3622664213180542, -0.3451842665672302, -0.23990735411643982, 0.4526118040084839, -0.32770827412605286, 0.3826235830783844, -0.23598670959472656, -0.21003778278827667, 0.2262304425239563, 0.39713254570961, -0.6636119484901428, -0.45940908789634705, -0.7009456753730774, 0.4909050464630127, 0.09704804420471191, -0.8041063547134399, -0.6060525178909302, -0.6093810200691223, 0.06825140863656998, 1.0078682899475098, 0.33612459897994995, 0.760292112827301, 0.1396227926015854, -0.4056536853313446, 0.07307412475347519, -0.10277974605560303, -0.6130274534225464, 0.7679423689842224, 0.07029871642589569, 0.9232721924781799, -0.022216683253645897, 0.1831313669681549, 0.12889237701892853, 0.18392722308635712, -0.5740318298339844, 0.33865419030189514, -0.10496124625205994, 0.6645739674568176, 0.3482295870780945, -0.46229562163352966, -0.20554955303668976, 0.022778870537877083, -0.6360313296318054, 0.31448835134506226, 0.1911279559135437, 0.4748114347457886, -0.25926315784454346, -0.5108660459518433, 0.3800395131111145, 0.2679708003997803, -0.001366025535389781, -0.7950736880302429, -0.8167924880981445, 0.09872480481863022, -0.3285556435585022, 0.7491213083267212, -0.05226096138358116, -0.874886691570282, 0.061342597007751465, -0.018365873023867607, 0.24974201619625092, 0.27694836258888245, 0.21465158462524414, 0.41492971777915955, 0.10965155065059662, -0.5406298041343689, -0.10943122208118439, 0.3271452784538269, -0.2773619592189789, 0.8459872603416443, 0.5025835633277893, 0.38367438316345215, 0.4039401412010193, -0.20564013719558716, -1.6728729009628296, -0.27736160159111023, -0.3968038260936737, -0.8191717863082886, 0.33517396450042725, 0.11366927623748779, -0.16660575568675995, 0.5284417271614075, -0.3055385947227478, 0.0980023592710495, 0.0788256898522377, 0.88779616355896, 0.7731963396072388, -0.587820291519165, -0.9704409837722778, -0.25654512643814087, -0.7817838788032532, 0.2053939700126648, -0.4324047267436981, 0.23415513336658478, -0.8726113438606262, -0.7312717437744141, -0.30469292402267456, 0.18996986746788025, -0.027482086792588234, -0.34565097093582153, 0.18363326787948608, 0.01095440424978733, -0.3477751910686493, -0.3618658781051636, 0.008254348300397396, -0.2361115664243698, -0.9079544544219971, 0.3134059011936188, -0.2498599737882614, 0.1264723688364029, 0.4098185896873474, -0.2818187475204468, 0.06231633946299553, 0.3697566092014313, 0.030432822182774544, 0.7538776397705078, -0.21231293678283691, -0.18394416570663452, 0.044679123908281326, 0.7676298022270203, 0.25145426392555237, 0.5649430751800537, -0.5013838410377502, -0.04473576322197914, 0.5809420943260193, 0.013925551436841488, 0.9195605516433716, 0.1104711964726448, -0.14333394169807434, 0.6478981375694275, 0.19874371588230133, 0.14329354465007782, -0.36466357111930847, 0.009362186305224895, 0.5889180302619934, 0.8891672492027283, -0.4761398136615753, -0.4976230561733246, -0.16326776146888733, 0.025437461212277412, 0.8787012696266174, -0.25741490721702576, -0.33766335248947144, -0.1790439337491989, 0.6575605869293213, 0.0606374591588974, -0.10278812050819397, -0.25859591364860535, 0.155928835272789, -0.34336933493614197, 0.22309449315071106, -0.1848118156194687, -0.28713276982307434, -0.8401210904121399, 0.4072876572608948, -0.30863985419273376, -0.36261916160583496, 0.3576105535030365, 0.13976578414440155, 0.8619286417961121, 1.1122492551803589, 0.44383949041366577, 0.5698468089103699, 0.23168490827083588, -0.07360579818487167, -1.0739785432815552, 0.12614066898822784, -0.2892731726169586, -1.0254144668579102, 0.17782750725746155, 0.510466456413269, -0.6344761252403259, -0.11259983479976654, -0.12807148694992065, 0.1945638358592987, -0.5197076797485352, 0.7993026971817017, -0.057634904980659485, -0.4250790774822235, 0.2892363965511322, 0.3481391370296478, -0.1347864866256714, 0.026312053203582764, -0.21747639775276184, 0.5062858462333679, 0.3455554246902466, 0.7588514685630798, 0.8129642009735107, 0.4557192623615265, 0.42258790135383606, -0.7027286291122437, -0.5807894468307495, 0.5057017803192139, -0.06969046592712402, -0.12354184687137604, 0.5289385318756104, -1.026276707649231, -0.29517051577568054, 0.2056490033864975, 0.45752257108688354, -0.11066708713769913, 0.31074607372283936, 0.808229923248291, 0.8661872744560242, -0.2631109356880188, -0.07811612635850906, 0.6068883538246155, 0.8759500980377197, -0.9784454703330994, -0.7507357597351074, 0.03510567918419838, -1.2515116930007935, 0.22307917475700378, -1.7222416400909424, 0.5690931081771851, 0.2985411286354065, 0.17216387391090393, -0.469973087310791, -0.01625443808734417, -0.5183493494987488, -0.913166344165802, -0.03853795677423477, -0.7301122546195984, 0.43480366468429565, 0.9218164682388306, -0.1515984982252121, -0.04609580338001251, -0.05501965060830116, -0.5084154009819031, -0.15327706933021545, 1.247757911682129, -0.26356983184814453, 0.1556386947631836, 0.2095908671617508, 0.35066282749176025, -0.609506368637085, 0.11603356897830963, 0.10348182916641235, -0.8452550172805786, 1.0147517919540405, 0.08902105689048767, -0.05543952435255051, 0.1398603767156601, -0.2964295446872711, -0.14729048311710358, -0.02721751108765602, 0.4179893732070923, 0.2706844210624695, -0.48691526055336, -0.13098005950450897, -0.7999200820922852, -0.3760046660900116, -0.7628734111785889, -0.1264890730381012, -0.20032647252082825, -0.23438529670238495, 0.711014449596405, -1.2496854066848755, 4.080358505249023, 0.6667510867118835, 0.7726374268531799, 0.2780042588710785, 0.07835184782743454, 0.9252047538757324, -0.24178379774093628, -0.011747072450816631, -0.2161501795053482, -0.6960132718086243, 0.08320808410644531, 0.34224870800971985, 1.059981346130371, -0.4922369718551636, 0.5625389814376831, 0.7516881227493286, 0.03301651030778885, -0.09994779527187347, -0.42515215277671814, -0.8038419485092163, -1.1744887828826904, 0.6566708087921143, -0.5281020998954773, 0.4858444631099701, 0.7513114809989929, 0.5157355070114136, 0.28941428661346436, -0.7601224780082703, -0.15435470640659332, -0.07003988325595856, -0.4643547236919403, -0.17178533971309662, -0.12089559435844421, -0.670466423034668, -0.5875545740127563, 0.32163184881210327, -0.1858510822057724, -0.9268618226051331, 0.7384445071220398, -0.05079188942909241, -0.04445420205593109, -0.6477577686309814, 0.24314522743225098, 0.053946059197187424, -0.26805341243743896, 1.097469687461853, 0.7382625937461853, 0.6415199637413025, 0.675597071647644, -0.39071542024612427, 0.09953498095273972, -0.12373630702495575, -0.08505914360284805, -0.6232472658157349, -0.4948374629020691, -0.5054329037666321, -0.21822908520698547, -0.13597528636455536, 0.7206268906593323, -0.44654735922813416, 0.7489269375801086, -0.12948092818260193, -0.33134526014328003, -0.29550376534461975, -0.23629873991012573, 0.7188969850540161, -0.10966429114341736, -0.11011798679828644, 0.06373385339975357, -0.06469198316335678, -0.15047679841518402, 0.13403990864753723, -0.8185666799545288, -0.050387002527713776, 0.4574466943740845, 0.32514411211013794, -0.43527060747146606, 0.7391814589500427, -0.18811044096946716, 0.702575147151947, -0.44533559679985046, 0.026268107816576958, -0.4682106077671051, 0.015050587244331837, -0.4299485981464386, 0.7697204947471619, -0.08116002380847931, -0.20950563251972198, -1.1581517457962036, 0.4906193017959595, 0.4665272533893585, 0.24113672971725464, -0.0870671197772026, -0.4648562967777252, -0.9210498929023743 ]
Gauge Formulation of the Spinning Black Hole in (2+1)-Dimensional Anti-de Sitter Space
We compute the group element of SO(2,2) associated with the spinning black hole found by Ba\~nados, Teitelboim and Zanelli in (2+1)-dimensional anti-de Sitter space-time. We show that their metric is built with SO(2,2) gauge invariant quantities and satisfies Einstein's equations with negative cosmological constant everywhere except at $r=0$. Moreover, although the metric is singular on the horizons, the group element is continuous and possesses a kink there.
Daniel Cangemi, Martin Leblanc and Robert B. Mann
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211013
gr-qc/9211014
[ 0.1309029906988144, 0.4595646262168884, -0.0333930179476738, 0.01787979155778885, -0.16428858041763306, -0.01623060368001461, 0.20896115899085999, -0.1287687122821808, 0.003001695964485407, 1.5638993978500366, -0.15060049295425415, 0.18291014432907104, 0.29523158073425293, -1.3061316013336182, 0.48427456617355347, 0.6713466644287109, -0.08849779516458511, -0.285621702671051, -1.3076112270355225, 0.6694558262825012, 0.6113740801811218, 0.06549713760614395, -1.1973038911819458, -0.6079753041267395, -0.2149575799703598, 1.0598442554473877, 0.7131612300872803, -0.21829819679260254, 0.9670494794845581, 1.0366884469985962, 0.12713362276554108, -0.09114718437194824, -0.6750585436820984, -0.5004779696464539, -0.5051485300064087, 0.2718490660190582, -0.2205606997013092, -0.18511679768562317, 0.26737451553344727, -0.7158447504043579, 0.36845070123672485, 0.07381518930196762, 0.17614932358264923, -0.6231510639190674, -0.7203006744384766, 0.18923045694828033, 0.5604488253593445, 0.2969093322753906, -0.09774625301361084, -1.2466708421707153, 0.15237361192703247, -0.19554772973060608, 0.14936748147010803, -1.2132625579833984, -0.4087378680706024, 0.0570453405380249, 0.26666054129600525, 0.23643758893013, 0.08262571692466736, 0.6078765392303467, 0.441732257604599, 0.16586199402809143, 0.29162824153900146, -0.8848466277122498, -0.3428279459476471, 0.7126994729042053, -0.06858541071414948, 0.8899639248847961, 0.0016723261214792728, 0.10743945837020874, -0.1938858926296234, 0.05334582179784775, -0.2724446654319763, 0.21149897575378418, -0.7122213840484619, 0.8444775938987732, -0.7977355718612671, -0.5405260324478149, -0.4606490731239319, -0.5326738953590393, 0.018281588330864906, 0.143476203083992, -0.23066629469394684, 0.41693225502967834, -0.40227213501930237, -0.27896231412887573, 0.31756946444511414, -0.059917252510786057, 0.7709999084472656, -0.10688629746437073, -0.20289777219295502, 0.329235315322876, -0.256088525056839, 0.1353699266910553, 0.46287667751312256, 0.5715801119804382, 0.06787125021219254, 1.2132940292358398, 0.2657402455806732, 0.03444870933890343, -0.34403571486473083, 1.497462511062622, -0.26461321115493774, 0.21872825920581818, -0.8227474093437195, 0.7840928435325623, -0.7810165882110596, -0.0006571377161890268, -0.7292467951774597, -0.4865313470363617, -0.1201690137386322, 0.5771508812904358, 0.8869712948799133, 0.2797049582004547, 0.34616222977638245, 0.22283028066158295, -0.42424196004867554, -0.25490623712539673, -0.7511661648750305, -0.5502357482910156, 0.3907329738140106, 0.3937356770038605, 0.20300690829753876, 1.092430830001831, -0.897218644618988, -0.4540126621723175, 0.22312748432159424, 0.6204598546028137, -0.6637327671051025, 0.769862711429596, 0.5473094582557678, -0.430125892162323, -0.3660106360912323, 0.09656023979187012, -0.09983615577220917, -0.2677167057991028, 0.08791066706180573, 0.011077141389250755, 0.43669450283050537, -0.30953267216682434, 0.10532650351524353, -0.2539438307285309, -0.010629963129758835, 1.3012186288833618, -0.0015145461075007915, 0.2819034159183502, -0.07023419439792633, 0.316222608089447, -0.4631998836994171, -0.19233117997646332, -0.024760937318205833, 0.2266988307237625, 0.2507977783679962, 0.5452167391777039, -0.18205183744430542, -0.17149344086647034, -0.983953058719635, 0.20209302008152008, 0.0591479167342186, -0.2717697322368622, 0.5788752436637878, -0.2362946718931198, 0.2302110493183136, 0.627469539642334, -1.1114084720611572, 0.7053396701812744, -0.43235906958580017, -0.2743157148361206, 0.06501626968383789, 0.26683178544044495, -0.4155581593513489, 0.42425867915153503, 0.07890323549509048, 0.7735505700111389, 0.9588339328765869, 0.9092540144920349, 0.2786979675292969, 0.12914998829364777, -0.285957008600235, 0.33042603731155396, -0.00968239363282919, -0.9636103510856628, 0.15275251865386963, 0.3059196472167969, -0.7787859439849854, 0.21992936730384827, 0.42715972661972046, -0.38747677206993103, 0.7126969695091248, 0.2051018923521042, -0.8104374408721924, 0.05356121435761452, -0.723457932472229, 0.7073720097541809, -1.3715215921401978, 0.43191012740135193, -0.7887466549873352, -0.3174261152744293, -0.19039155542850494, -0.24636664986610413, 0.36947619915008545, -0.03385145589709282, -0.7645882368087769, -0.25442439317703247, -1.0578588247299194, -0.10402856767177582, 0.657158613204956, 0.4480220377445221, -1.0277100801467896, -0.07489930838346481, 1.0264686346054077, -0.627882719039917, 0.29290497303009033, -0.35905787348747253, 0.6387693881988525, 0.3838421106338501, -0.9028294086456299, -0.20048275589942932, -0.3520493507385254, -0.06266533583402634, 0.7092134356498718, -0.034100279211997986, -0.30952024459838867, 0.8001235723495483, 0.1592632383108139, -0.5449923872947693, 0.7481582164764404, 1.080893635749817, -0.21579673886299133, 0.5318450331687927, 0.45600518584251404, 0.4986734390258789, 0.22470447421073914, 0.8501186370849609, 0.6916329860687256, -0.24559912085533142, 0.826108455657959, 0.874540388584137, 0.8444063663482666, 0.0878387987613678, -0.01711764559149742, 0.13006390631198883, 1.1072006225585938, -0.5476182699203491, -0.9701666235923767, 0.19079707562923431, 0.04671000316739082, 0.35284319519996643, -0.2530026435852051, 0.7655816078186035, -0.4018525183200836, 0.3737143278121948, 0.2080182135105133, -0.010328199714422226, -1.4096423387527466, -0.003921926487237215, 0.030892055481672287, 0.5178024768829346, 0.1144942045211792, -0.5256626009941101, 0.22060461342334747, 0.052664615213871, -0.27847376465797424, -0.5441399812698364, -0.7509871125221252, 0.6109790802001953, -0.8734865188598633, -0.2872501611709595, 0.9811807870864868, -0.42749154567718506, -0.9955223798751831, -0.07486139237880707, -0.28480541706085205, -0.2771431505680084, -1.0037508010864258, -0.2270124852657318, 0.4443039894104004, 0.06530174612998962, 0.5496030449867249, 0.36838898062705994, 0.15274806320667267, 0.09124451875686646, -0.05188624933362007, 0.40264591574668884, 0.270636647939682, -0.04028390347957611, -1.0502910614013672, -0.05895914137363434, -1.2432498931884766, 0.24682021141052246, -0.06430651992559433, -0.6831440329551697, 0.6149128675460815, -0.08324349671602249, -0.18751540780067444, 0.21552926301956177, -0.285207062959671, 0.46644747257232666, -0.8214325904846191, -0.7475423216819763, 0.60574871301651, 0.401454895734787, -0.29723262786865234, -0.03258872777223587, -0.6006739139556885, 1.445162057876587, 0.10664911568164825, -0.45867058634757996, 0.8203417658805847, -0.3782617449760437, -0.6146166920661926, 0.5747926235198975, 0.3049505949020386, 0.7059890031814575, -0.3141649067401886, 0.3764846920967102, 0.4523399770259857, -0.19822074472904205, -0.3448489308357239, -0.10541998594999313, -0.5209197402000427, -0.29429373145103455, 0.5868549346923828, -0.834287703037262, 0.7507980465888977, 0.2787483036518097, -0.04454241320490837, -1.0520737171173096, 0.8482176065444946, -1.303274393081665, -1.1054660081863403, -0.6843349933624268, -0.49976155161857605, -0.3464840352535248, 0.16197992861270905, 0.05879424884915352, -0.4333266019821167, -0.6455011963844299, -0.062859907746315, -0.06222768872976303, 0.3694302439689636, -0.283732146024704, 0.41216331720352173, 0.6505472660064697, 0.2549593150615692, 0.44722840189933777, 0.0882955938577652, -0.6672680974006653, 0.13214896619319916, 0.5032213926315308, -0.8913509845733643, 0.2336311936378479, 0.1497945487499237, -0.3797168433666229, 0.23126520216464996, 0.6058512926101685, -0.6944151520729065, -0.22878576815128326, -1.2042025327682495, -0.6625365614891052, 0.790017306804657, 1.36869478225708, 0.37459057569503784, -1.177995204925537, -0.46523481607437134, 0.19856680929660797, -0.20876595377922058, 0.7251433730125427, 0.630125880241394, -1.1901932954788208, 0.12055239826440811, 0.5706086754798889, -0.18732771277427673, -0.3838474154472351, 0.06072695180773735, 0.010326039046049118, 0.5557706356048584, 0.3070283532142639, 0.14089012145996094, 0.07028012722730637, -0.15875840187072754, -0.4452534317970276, 0.6968064904212952, -0.0067382934503257275, 1.0158414840698242, 0.12608473002910614, -0.36610010266304016, 0.32152819633483887, -0.6434702277183533, -0.4299057722091675, -0.510718822479248, -0.6722051501274109, 0.0357578881084919, 0.050686851143836975, -0.09533358365297318, 0.2856806516647339, -0.09276368468999863, 0.39441609382629395, 0.28189098834991455, -0.09273263067007065, 0.09786911308765411, 0.5178093314170837, 0.2842525541782379, 0.3948066532611847, -0.858461856842041, -0.03301309049129486, -0.22004066407680511, 0.321510374546051, 0.36235058307647705, 0.4579145312309265, 0.07651527225971222, -0.6809608936309814, -0.33314409852027893, -0.043512046337127686, 0.638308048248291, -0.2763839662075043, -0.05248517170548439, 0.25865936279296875, 0.28645744919776917, -0.003848134307190776, 0.2778276801109314, 0.36778539419174194, 0.9132124185562134, 0.48781058192253113, 0.5473155379295349, -0.2757102847099304, 0.14888989925384521, -0.4535539448261261, 0.0705055519938469, 0.5668659210205078, -0.6911577582359314, -1.2062832117080688, -0.4481547772884369, 0.446951687335968, 0.2597554624080658, -0.26532116532325745, 0.22180405259132385, 1.1025347709655762, 0.4408993422985077, -0.46282505989074707, 0.5259096026420593, 0.9662600159645081, -0.3389670252799988, 0.22176502645015717, -0.35824474692344666, -0.73150634765625, 0.11802177876234055, 0.7066701650619507, -0.20682846009731293, -0.6274186968803406, 0.033648908138275146, 0.11498616635799408, 0.5433990359306335, -0.4996008574962616, -0.9029980301856995, 0.2912839949131012, -0.1558064967393875, 0.1638021022081375, 0.516150951385498, -0.1999496966600418, 0.0826195776462555, 0.4681989848613739, 0.3789284825325012, 0.04141765460371971, 0.7377510666847229, 0.23340238630771637, 0.40427735447883606, 1.2342723608016968, 0.982452392578125, 0.18784348666667938, 0.2095535546541214, 0.2435554414987564, -0.14418919384479523, -0.5832597613334656, 0.5962609648704529, -0.46869224309921265, -0.6178110241889954, -0.11064661294221878, -0.12592577934265137, -0.16449594497680664, -0.2414080649614334, 0.5969594717025757, 0.09569724649190903, 0.42182013392448425, -0.06692445278167725, -0.8502134084701538, -0.34698623418807983, -1.15760338306427, -0.5064650177955627, 0.5326129198074341, -0.1795489341020584, -0.4763071537017822, 0.34507864713668823, -1.1242581605911255, -0.5051143765449524, -0.030836427584290504, -0.07467997819185257, 0.1980198174715042, -0.7422822713851929, 0.45388534665107727, 0.20015862584114075, 0.6745058298110962, -1.2123979330062866, 0.42889603972435, -0.7398586869239807, -0.05242324620485306, -0.4828338623046875, -0.605491042137146, -0.6494401097297668, -0.11859530955553055, 0.17232440412044525, 0.22255946695804596, 0.30146756768226624, 0.21739841997623444, 0.45556214451789856, 0.129459947347641, -0.26193779706954956, -1.1225637197494507, -0.39048171043395996, 0.3409949839115143, 0.32502856850624084, -0.6960740685462952, -0.27626028656959534, 0.09027769416570663, 0.6091408729553223, 0.46532580256462097, -0.10447322577238083, -0.42919662594795227, -0.10093820840120316, -1.23893141746521, 0.9909757375717163, -0.8721293210983276, -0.3219383656978607, -0.3110676407814026, -0.2984974682331085, 0.6976431608200073, 0.43516063690185547, 0.07368381321430206, -0.2538626492023468, -0.5510934591293335, -0.5317090153694153, 0.31967493891716003, -0.7286844849586487, 0.39775949716567993, -1.1042958498001099, -0.4105037748813629, -0.3846234083175659, 1.1792680025100708, -0.28574293851852417, 0.30599889159202576, -0.15494367480278015, 0.4918798804283142, -0.6213353276252747, 0.35012465715408325, 0.4115733802318573, 0.03476010635495186, -0.15445870161056519, -0.14659740030765533, -0.31562668085098267, -0.10520274192094803, -0.18915846943855286, 0.39981988072395325, -0.03930738568305969, 0.7569394707679749, -0.006726250518113375, 0.025210874155163765, 0.12666435539722443, -0.4835748076438904, 0.6413074135780334, -0.8192101120948792, -0.22156591713428497, 0.749933660030365, -0.24771644175052643, 0.26419803500175476, -0.30063295364379883, -0.8639795780181885, -0.4341963231563568, -0.5451469421386719, -0.7758718729019165, 0.7384287714958191, -0.2708823084831238, -0.25259527564048767, -0.7827655673027039, -0.5915672779083252, -0.6083170175552368, 0.011327986605465412, 0.17610208690166473, 0.5069851279258728, 0.3463210165500641, 0.5956106185913086, -0.3455493450164795, -0.18640954792499542, -0.3335324823856354, 0.32214564085006714, 0.2054690718650818, -0.4358782470226288, 0.47955024242401123, -0.25506559014320374, -0.5391964912414551, -1.1232179403305054, -0.10154423862695694, 0.08185430616140366, -0.1074967086315155, -0.1896384358406067, 0.7273767590522766, 0.10621358454227448, -0.12331793457269669, -0.5280784368515015, -0.10278304666280746, -0.03946342691779137, -0.29045569896698, 0.662308394908905, 0.9529509544372559, 0.20553135871887207, 0.07304379343986511, 0.08777769654989243, -0.8178979754447937, -0.5343561768531799, 1.0122628211975098, -0.9935469031333923, -0.12097445130348206, 0.6273074150085449, 0.01355657260864973, 0.23939034342765808, -0.9151739478111267, -1.100825548171997, -0.16764505207538605, 0.5797448754310608, -0.4128532111644745, 0.6716001629829407, 0.034628625959157944, -0.24355639517307281, 0.2970353066921234, 0.4727429151535034, -0.04233033210039139, 0.2319667637348175, 0.1743163764476776, -0.3058719336986542, -0.7293994426727295, 0.014927119947969913, 1.1513640880584717, 0.9118984937667847, -0.3641955256462097, 0.40405726432800293, 0.23430989682674408, -0.6016714572906494, -0.5419580936431885, 1.0398859977722168, -0.7235674858093262, -0.34865355491638184, -0.2396128922700882, 0.10738484561443329, 0.20549972355365753, 0.04724152013659477, -0.11590023338794708, -0.6359725594520569, -0.5786958932876587, -0.2821018695831299, -0.13931015133857727, 0.15766017138957977, 0.7473242878913879, 0.36462387442588806, 0.417511522769928, 0.45474353432655334, -0.1428760439157486, 0.6063910126686096, -0.2086920440196991, -0.7851973176002502, -0.5789998769760132, -1.3172246217727661, -0.8056607842445374, -0.5991601943969727, 0.19065961241722107, -0.4441414177417755, 0.21187040209770203, -0.16863074898719788, 0.35098522901535034, 0.17092789709568024, 0.20599782466888428, 0.006973051931709051, 0.6959137320518494, -0.8980372548103333, -0.7385944724082947, -1.0367716550827026, 0.009075346402823925, -0.01944541744887829, -0.6984319686889648, -0.04977629706263542, -0.3319595158100128, -0.22501865029335022, 0.9789738655090332, -0.04666442051529884, 0.3315105140209198, -0.835756778717041, -0.9870741367340088, 0.6541222333908081, 0.0790787860751152, -1.001423716545105, 1.0119718313217163, -0.25589901208877563, 0.7234486937522888, 0.5830343961715698, 0.1849355399608612, -0.3401274085044861, 0.216410294175148, -0.8487561941146851, 0.05385119467973709, 0.43737220764160156, 0.794833242893219, -0.15845568478107452, -1.0021347999572754, -0.1728551834821701, 0.3717520534992218, -0.9131122827529907, 0.06811883300542831, 0.16371986269950867, 0.34896576404571533, -0.9510931968688965, 0.29989534616470337, 0.04594995081424713, -0.1596285104751587, -0.1593225747346878, 0.2778361141681671, -0.7511065006256104, -0.03702807053923607, 0.2108302265405655, 0.13096395134925842, -0.49698320031166077, -0.6372560858726501, 0.3940887749195099, -0.1445874273777008, 0.23118196427822113, 0.3112172782421112, 0.0058080111630260944, 0.07688873261213303, 0.04568307846784592, -0.24280290305614471, -0.14324088394641876, 0.1972600817680359, 0.09075608849525452, 1.3120276927947998, 0.43219199776649475, 0.1853565275669098, 0.5543614625930786, -0.46352624893188477, -0.8369385600090027, -0.08283647894859314, -0.3794885575771332, -0.5076119899749756, 0.43152737617492676, -0.0029848753474652767, 0.05793558061122894, 0.1646127700805664, -0.3540413975715637, -0.15793004631996155, 0.2068563848733902, 1.1150987148284912, 0.6106424331665039, -0.8435932397842407, -0.632729172706604, -0.2734187841415405, -1.0271413326263428, 0.268236368894577, -0.36998873949050903, 0.5210288763046265, -0.8414497971534729, -1.3720728158950806, 0.034730687737464905, 0.2884185314178467, -0.2960231602191925, -0.32828396558761597, 0.5457695722579956, 0.04325578734278679, -0.9103101491928101, -0.19984732568264008, 0.12021256238222122, 0.038186609745025635, -0.9726852774620056, 0.05285148695111275, 0.38665059208869934, -0.3521377444267273, -0.07305192202329636, 0.3076851963996887, 0.2957190275192261, -0.32509756088256836, -0.055215366184711456, 0.7457855939865112, 0.1618317812681198, -0.10869450867176056, 0.19881336390972137, 0.38722294569015503, 0.4320008456707001, 0.3633691072463989, -0.6339263916015625, -0.05734815448522568, 0.7981317639350891, -0.08808129280805588, 0.8090044260025024, -0.23321978747844696, 0.11578546464443207, 0.43143707513809204, 0.17686955630779266, -0.01554696075618267, -0.019598301500082016, -0.481697678565979, 0.2535221576690674, 0.47702717781066895, 0.04119476303458214, -0.18355441093444824, -0.15091711282730103, 0.2695207893848419, 0.5064349174499512, -0.29237648844718933, -0.35586050152778625, -0.4983505308628082, 0.33806660771369934, 0.5167698860168457, -0.5135369300842285, -0.2589232325553894, 0.13381242752075195, -0.5238602161407471, 0.5031143426895142, -0.08203299343585968, -0.664095938205719, 0.47209301590919495, -0.011663022451102734, -0.32170629501342773, -0.017970798537135124, 0.5117191672325134, 0.2055066078901291, 0.8338746428489685, 0.8663819432258606, 0.14600731432437897, -0.012977011501789093, 0.4316530227661133, 0.6103776097297668, -0.6996707320213318, -0.14509069919586182, 0.05751749128103256, -0.7389837503433228, 0.14853820204734802, 0.2436138093471527, -0.34867599606513977, -0.4420270323753357, -0.2777628004550934, 0.22453463077545166, -0.1650143563747406, 0.9024983048439026, -0.2985767126083374, -0.7133451104164124, -0.3074356019496918, 0.27132317423820496, -0.28459662199020386, 0.1473606377840042, 0.3916948139667511, 0.19456204771995544, 0.19174522161483765, 1.1958256959915161, 0.9375612735748291, 0.6193161606788635, 0.2751259505748749, -0.4584163725376129, -0.3944639265537262, 0.7691662311553955, 1.0792070627212524, 0.2394983023405075, 0.15115772187709808, -0.8963091969490051, -0.15293405950069427, 0.5488194227218628, -0.008368118666112423, -0.3327593207359314, -0.21470414102077484, 0.3677947223186493, 0.3786216378211975, -0.6092641353607178, 0.08665725588798523, 0.6673455834388733, 0.39737340807914734, -0.8502277135848999, 0.0932726040482521, 0.5997370481491089, -1.1272413730621338, -0.11026990413665771, -1.5653289556503296, 0.39371195435523987, -0.2046450972557068, 0.30297884345054626, -0.2297438234090805, -0.4787673354148865, -0.21556983888149261, -0.6648769974708557, -0.18732695281505585, -0.26868557929992676, 0.27344071865081787, 1.450065016746521, -0.4163166582584381, 0.061209484934806824, 0.07486405968666077, -0.49570727348327637, -0.34997957944869995, 0.9584361910820007, 0.4558040499687195, 0.8944868445396423, 0.6719843149185181, 0.2746102809906006, -1.0982270240783691, 0.24176527559757233, 0.48238325119018555, -0.9666494727134705, 0.6911561489105225, -0.3229577839374542, 0.09333603829145432, 0.607609212398529, -0.6086055636405945, 0.24460992217063904, 0.3115256428718567, 0.423240602016449, 0.5319886207580566, 0.16100911796092987, -0.07103164494037628, -0.37323489785194397, -0.7012044787406921, -0.6010481715202332, -0.4864864945411682, 0.39460065960884094, -0.409940242767334, 0.7288554906845093, -0.7558144927024841, 4.001134395599365, 0.6558738350868225, 0.2128274142742157, -0.04196811467409134, 0.5400335788726807, 1.1259138584136963, 0.10551033914089203, 0.4547506272792816, 0.055004723370075226, -0.9663662910461426, -0.24134217202663422, 0.6604568362236023, 0.39558154344558716, -0.07686468958854675, -0.22188065946102142, 0.6850630044937134, -0.065401591360569, 0.05632788687944412, -1.0262932777404785, -0.28954389691352844, -1.114842414855957, -0.06993985176086426, -0.32858845591545105, 0.28478965163230896, 0.49618977308273315, 0.0561540387570858, -0.14170612394809723, -0.2073071151971817, -0.41966375708580017, -0.03627624362707138, -0.5384171009063721, 0.018646324053406715, -0.11667074263095856, -0.540627658367157, -0.8678852915763855, 0.13709118962287903, -0.20318447053432465, -0.45698046684265137, 0.46268048882484436, 0.21258445084095, -0.3480221629142761, -0.9387980699539185, 0.40823933482170105, -0.17968440055847168, -0.04083516076207161, 1.071966528892517, 0.4358956813812256, 0.5842419862747192, 0.6749778985977173, -0.34456104040145874, -0.2196330726146698, 0.4175160229206085, 0.4152772128582001, -0.8848137259483337, -0.6432669758796692, -0.48874396085739136, -0.36089617013931274, -0.14775198698043823, 0.42742225527763367, -0.29514235258102417, 0.5806689262390137, -0.05314590409398079, -0.22753357887268066, -0.1000131145119667, -0.1837904006242752, 0.29716959595680237, 0.7461593747138977, -0.20661981403827667, 0.07572095096111298, -0.06751473248004913, -0.5540363192558289, 0.1229248195886612, -0.43559616804122925, -0.20382283627986908, 0.4266308844089508, 0.2519342303276062, -0.080915167927742, 0.4918653666973114, -0.31885862350463867, 0.6239509582519531, -0.34089669585227966, 0.14587587118148804, -0.25721803307533264, -0.027420632541179657, 0.2668621242046356, 0.8644874095916748, -0.5307478904724121, 0.05868786200881004, -0.7804039120674133, 0.8850801587104797, 0.21462316811084747, 0.9877961874008179, -0.0388958640396595, 0.019711779430508614, -0.9017319679260254 ]
Unification of Gravity and Yang-Mills Theory in (2+1)-Dimensions
A gauge and diffeomorphism invariant theory in (2+1)-dimensions is presented in both first and second order Lagrangian form as well as in a Hamiltonian form. For gauge group $SO(1,2)$, the theory is shown to describe ordinary Einstein gravity with a cosmological constant. With gauge group $G^{tot}=SO(1,2)\otimes G^{YM}$, it is shown that the equations of motion for the $G^{YM}$ fields are the Yang-Mills equations. It is also shown that for weak $G^{YM}$ Yang-Mills fields, this theory agrees with the conventional Einstein-Yang-Mills theory to lowest order in Yang-Mills fields. Explicit static and rotation symmetric solutions to the Einstein-Maxwell theory are studied both for the conventional coupling and for this unified theory. In the electric solution to the unified theory, point charges are not allowed, the charges must have spatial extensions.
Peter Peldan
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211014
gr-qc/9211015
[ 0.027360951527953148, 0.3653804659843445, -0.07866869866847992, 0.0884961485862732, -0.11758963018655777, -0.26113951206207275, 0.3189307749271393, -0.6575480103492737, -0.6505795121192932, 1.5461703538894653, 0.20933179557323456, -0.013827265240252018, -0.2250150889158249, -0.5815527439117432, 0.1457047313451767, 0.5483079552650452, -0.05575734004378319, -0.4557713270187378, -1.284801959991455, 0.23313352465629578, -0.24418435990810394, 0.6206062436103821, -0.9857845902442932, 0.06361256539821625, -0.5829251408576965, 1.064782738685608, 0.8368616700172424, 0.07960060238838196, 0.9193826913833618, 1.256259799003601, 0.3255119025707245, 0.5059768557548523, 0.244293212890625, -0.8265814781188965, -0.5733326077461243, -0.32377469539642334, 0.257260799407959, -1.019444227218628, 0.914292573928833, -0.39000460505485535, 0.44038230180740356, 0.18569305539131165, 0.24193885922431946, -0.23853753507137299, -0.8375546336174011, -0.2789476215839386, 0.27095359563827515, -0.012844955548644066, 0.09282267093658447, -0.9185571670532227, 0.08624034374952316, -0.016215350478887558, 0.5384041666984558, -0.1878921538591385, -0.8432004451751709, -0.4100588262081146, 0.4990198612213135, 0.6609703302383423, -0.3990844488143921, 0.18884973227977753, 0.32305505871772766, -0.07627951353788376, 0.3885187804698944, -1.1524165868759155, 0.2878309190273285, 0.5952815413475037, -0.17571082711219788, -0.025355011224746704, -0.09921550005674362, -0.04721038043498993, -0.6140011548995972, -0.5551332831382751, -0.7700157165527344, 0.6428202390670776, -0.33646920323371887, 1.1900935173034668, -0.8359361886978149, -0.4370756447315216, 0.1613791286945343, -0.6826470494270325, 0.5845373272895813, 0.6388726234436035, -0.6776533722877502, 0.4941882789134979, -0.02234245464205742, 0.03890450671315193, 0.3819600045681, -0.3558221757411957, 0.5418601036071777, 0.14159779250621796, -0.26283639669418335, 0.6110666394233704, -0.1825578808784485, 0.5643787980079651, 0.9043398499488831, 0.5456136465072632, -0.4817699193954468, 1.3865305185317993, 0.028588179498910904, 0.6159711480140686, 0.2222229540348053, 0.9973515868186951, -0.4427087604999542, 0.6501281261444092, -0.37724336981773376, 0.7522150278091431, -0.1398521512746811, 0.4359234571456909, -0.29102227091789246, -0.1641232818365097, 0.5340543389320374, 0.10452624410390854, 0.8806846737861633, -0.3547804355621338, 0.3438202440738678, 0.18098926544189453, -0.23317264020442963, 0.1696387529373169, -1.0620388984680176, -0.43503037095069885, -0.051265131682157516, 0.6426337361335754, 0.27592745423316956, 0.760138213634491, -0.4292563796043396, -0.922947108745575, 0.3132001459598541, 0.19649913907051086, -0.005157129373401403, 0.4183151125907898, 0.003875833936035633, -0.30204328894615173, 0.42269226908683777, 0.8101839423179626, -0.38682517409324646, 0.08411362767219543, -0.20071262121200562, 0.197516068816185, -0.3826768398284912, -0.5276593565940857, -0.16088271141052246, -0.37202009558677673, -0.03825367987155914, 1.2054232358932495, -0.222138449549675, 0.16406510770320892, -0.0775734931230545, -0.2841099202632904, -1.1730144023895264, -0.3044576346874237, -0.08753670006990433, -0.7202082872390747, 0.14355657994747162, 0.26540684700012207, -0.40369439125061035, -0.22325561940670013, -0.4921918213367462, 0.2954578697681427, -0.26592621207237244, -0.6896233558654785, 0.4499646723270416, -0.5071665644645691, 0.29919901490211487, 1.2895573377609253, -0.5889661312103271, 0.32802918553352356, -0.30989930033683777, 0.12061359733343124, -0.30937206745147705, -0.17333129048347473, -0.011548107489943504, 0.5918135643005371, 0.17038235068321228, 0.31437185406684875, 0.824293851852417, 0.12545715272426605, -0.016619643196463585, 0.296111524105072, -0.1695503294467926, 1.1368544101715088, 0.18996231257915497, -1.023884892463684, 0.5960451364517212, 0.6281619668006897, -0.5537115931510925, -0.5031231641769409, 0.8044527769088745, -0.48537206649780273, 0.4569641053676605, -0.04176317900419235, -0.8215234279632568, 0.2330395132303238, -0.6865686178207397, 1.4376620054244995, -0.8282384872436523, 0.5825120806694031, -1.0613205432891846, 0.20089131593704224, -0.0074228085577487946, -0.21559353172779083, -0.09706428647041321, 0.12039970606565475, -0.6706728339195251, 0.35484352707862854, -0.6343028545379639, -0.10197073966264725, 0.07674212753772736, 0.2690957486629486, -0.4975568950176239, -0.037363201379776, 0.6304330229759216, -0.7055888175964355, 0.4577246308326721, 0.05714242905378342, 0.2447836995124817, -0.10697899758815765, -0.18066048622131348, 0.0559842586517334, -0.30516326427459717, 0.13552460074424744, 0.17935951054096222, 0.2251262217760086, 0.09449905157089233, 0.9042137265205383, -0.12200024724006653, -0.14727556705474854, -0.0717955008149147, 0.8271707892417908, 0.03267638012766838, 0.899731457233429, 0.45679423213005066, 0.20628204941749573, 0.5481786131858826, 1.1814253330230713, 0.8218294382095337, -0.7707847952842712, 1.077221393585205, 0.5656331777572632, -0.2201666235923767, 0.009635895490646362, 0.4038574695587158, -0.12615741789340973, 0.47481659054756165, -0.23905132710933685, -0.30040407180786133, 0.14644047617912292, 0.5787821412086487, -0.13866639137268066, -0.22629143297672272, 0.3944675326347351, -0.3889855146408081, 0.36028870940208435, 0.44209611415863037, -0.4910188913345337, -1.4594197273254395, 0.4643881022930145, -0.588487446308136, 0.3152450621128082, 0.08173389732837677, -0.21230071783065796, -0.4966236352920532, -0.09108470380306244, 0.09729181975126266, 0.036439746618270874, -0.465375155210495, -0.32666200399398804, -0.6086488366127014, -0.5288729667663574, 0.6572278141975403, -0.6122498512268066, -0.9377697706222534, -0.35069215297698975, -0.9575152397155762, 0.2733195722103119, -0.7929332852363586, -0.35495415329933167, 0.5501516461372375, -0.1081753820180893, 0.9094184637069702, 0.6385793685913086, -0.3148252069950104, -0.1705312579870224, -0.39437296986579895, 0.016728676855564117, -0.013322170823812485, 0.22750119864940643, -0.942166805267334, 0.14793555438518524, -0.545069694519043, -0.20384617149829865, -0.15310585498809814, -0.679654061794281, 0.40678274631500244, -0.01794157177209854, 0.300723671913147, 0.08295504003763199, -0.26031869649887085, -0.22516752779483795, -0.2558387815952301, -0.9027995467185974, -0.3959558606147766, 0.37972044944763184, 0.2655593454837799, 0.2556036412715912, -0.45735251903533936, 0.8824947476387024, 0.24318018555641174, -0.2895354628562927, 0.30730339884757996, -0.05482298508286476, -0.6668590903282166, -0.14798307418823242, 0.6552165746688843, 0.8811094164848328, -0.05249069258570671, 0.4878908395767212, 1.2740832567214966, -0.09396077692508698, 0.20542025566101074, -0.21338659524917603, -0.318957656621933, -0.31814906001091003, 0.5579130053520203, -0.28820115327835083, 0.7519487738609314, 0.4011540412902832, 0.26233425736427307, -1.0737680196762085, 0.5577516555786133, -0.33149975538253784, -0.8992884159088135, -0.03925754129886627, -0.5430960655212402, 0.11853580176830292, -0.4951363205909729, 0.5000425577163696, -0.2804427742958069, -0.48154130578041077, -0.14880988001823425, 0.7802757024765015, 0.4852621257305145, 0.1488332450389862, 0.4050980508327484, 0.3249885141849518, 0.36936521530151367, 0.27381929755210876, 0.8522279262542725, -0.04741121456027031, 0.1307825893163681, -0.04573839157819748, -0.4353206157684326, -0.02091788500547409, 0.056577324867248535, -0.043390676379203796, -0.4947279691696167, 0.3786487579345703, -0.32720428705215454, -0.39803749322891235, -0.9053371548652649, -0.21821774542331696, 0.24703790247440338, 0.40662240982055664, -0.1470687836408615, -1.066264033317566, -0.8017229437828064, -0.24957987666130066, 0.10616527497768402, 0.20126275718212128, 0.666447103023529, -0.5111603140830994, 0.24413758516311646, 0.6230139136314392, -0.6578148603439331, 0.12080720067024231, 0.20531384646892548, 0.3672831356525421, 0.7164525985717773, -0.27544742822647095, 0.08446328341960907, -0.3727414011955261, -0.07620910555124283, -0.09710562229156494, 0.41509371995925903, 0.11479243636131287, 0.6409550309181213, -0.2715291678905487, -0.23990555107593536, 0.07075681537389755, -0.4862430691719055, -0.15250910818576813, -0.043206918984651566, -0.931684136390686, 0.14812253415584564, -0.23146556317806244, 0.0046054646372795105, -0.1310153603553772, 0.4193851351737976, 0.8028867840766907, 0.0785617008805275, -0.002559658605605364, 0.07912667095661163, 0.4252129793167114, 0.27381759881973267, 0.7699498534202576, -0.5680855512619019, -0.17314039170742035, -0.6639995574951172, 0.7682269811630249, 0.3407703936100006, -0.3252469301223755, 0.08581661432981491, -0.6883159279823303, 0.07821531593799591, 0.04554354026913643, 0.7126908302307129, 0.39442768692970276, -0.6797680258750916, 0.5335577726364136, 0.5122982263565063, -0.07239704579114914, -0.23932217061519623, 0.4100307524204254, 0.8554958701133728, 0.2670285105705261, 0.06486037373542786, -0.7086628675460815, -0.33304905891418457, -0.802223265171051, -0.16806992888450623, 0.412154883146286, -0.5543841123580933, -0.90609210729599, -0.5619094967842102, 0.041856568306684494, 0.050600335001945496, 0.3064049184322357, 1.015845775604248, 0.7382050156593323, 0.37234818935394287, -0.38937118649482727, 0.18314538896083832, 0.7417344450950623, -0.13261687755584717, -0.20869497954845428, -0.14937670528888702, -0.13599345088005066, -0.27549681067466736, 0.5843745470046997, 0.15865851938724518, -0.6865012049674988, -0.2677226960659027, -0.31163838505744934, -0.35419419407844543, 0.16969159245491028, -0.5727015137672424, 0.1501978039741516, -0.05297940969467163, 0.22286586463451385, 0.597007155418396, -0.4871542751789093, 0.7032774090766907, -0.07072044909000397, -0.1578284204006195, -0.58705073595047, 0.375100702047348, 0.44754764437675476, 0.18843400478363037, 0.8547633290290833, 0.40760183334350586, 0.8843547701835632, 0.5284950733184814, 0.41395339369773865, -0.09000058472156525, 0.26547834277153015, 0.7916504144668579, -0.7016531229019165, -0.42436784505844116, -0.08806820958852768, -0.30814993381500244, -0.7052304744720459, -0.12008862942457199, 0.524133563041687, -0.46051254868507385, -0.46980923414230347, -0.11460325866937637, -0.8420093059539795, -0.8693379163742065, -0.059223074465990067, -0.7893380522727966, 0.5394233465194702, -0.4240040183067322, -0.3968001902103424, 0.3009446859359741, -0.036152973771095276, 0.22015415132045746, 0.19829195737838745, 0.2196466624736786, 0.2118198275566101, -0.4036073386669159, 0.47323280572891235, 0.22081264853477478, 0.9147537350654602, -0.5111353993415833, 0.1386972814798355, -0.5902829170227051, -0.23846392333507538, -1.0386663675308228, -0.47423145174980164, -0.3261543810367584, -0.29097872972488403, 0.25120726227760315, -0.20147477090358734, 0.21427381038665771, 0.584059476852417, 0.338487446308136, 0.4583521783351898, -0.11340604722499847, -0.46450480818748474, -0.025182263925671577, 0.4722514748573303, 0.7488095164299011, -0.4479762315750122, -0.3796630799770355, 0.7464821338653564, 0.10879834741353989, 0.18325315415859222, -0.529936671257019, 0.24236610531806946, 0.39068976044654846, -1.3848237991333008, 0.48992809653282166, -1.1461888551712036, -0.41762804985046387, -0.11663756519556046, -0.061000872403383255, 0.5473265647888184, 0.2434244602918625, 0.43576446175575256, -0.8565822839736938, -0.7132490277290344, -0.21221444010734558, 0.5198808312416077, -0.9235031008720398, -0.15557286143302917, -0.738178551197052, -0.25117531418800354, -0.44486695528030396, 1.3930894136428833, -0.4331800639629364, -0.033872541040182114, 0.4677497148513794, 0.34219619631767273, 0.20272494852542877, 0.615505576133728, 0.4703770577907562, 0.25122860074043274, -0.3922976851463318, -0.2771080434322357, 0.8251791596412659, -0.0807863399386406, -0.25285103917121887, -0.1888999342918396, -0.6306442022323608, 0.41519907116889954, -0.402273029088974, 0.24752546846866608, 0.33335599303245544, -0.3288203775882721, 0.6918292045593262, -0.8089625239372253, -0.3207509219646454, 0.15668441355228424, 0.3623994290828705, 0.29510048031806946, 0.036386873573064804, -0.6717187166213989, -0.44602295756340027, -0.5547198057174683, -0.8573446273803711, 0.3684137463569641, -0.2025148719549179, -0.6727972030639648, -0.9885777831077576, -0.3546024262905121, 0.028157539665699005, 0.10441868007183075, 0.3337099552154541, -0.22294257581233978, 0.8294941186904907, 0.2981546223163605, -0.23662209510803223, -0.36861303448677063, -0.7337548732757568, -0.0366431325674057, 0.18197999894618988, -0.07053511589765549, -0.5687639117240906, -0.9009871482849121, -0.19773195683956146, -0.7696740031242371, -0.4382074475288391, 0.659296989440918, 0.431659460067749, -0.21469062566757202, 0.5690465569496155, 0.15051674842834473, -0.1609731763601303, -0.41919004917144775, 0.2573469877243042, 0.13605350255966187, -0.6441562175750732, 0.836635172367096, 0.6662502884864807, -0.024209000170230865, 0.06717952340841293, 0.19019728899002075, -1.0049389600753784, -0.5701161623001099, 0.4755373001098633, -0.32278257608413696, 0.06357349455356598, 0.44837668538093567, -0.5048123598098755, -0.34596288204193115, -0.8671214580535889, -0.9914988875389099, -0.19309403002262115, 0.3949197828769684, -0.8046979308128357, 0.2788099944591522, 0.051718249917030334, 0.3000607192516327, 0.4087445139884949, 0.30736497044563293, 0.38108688592910767, 0.46740394830703735, 0.4655671715736389, 0.04470484331250191, -0.17639747262001038, 0.3841896057128906, 0.7716303467750549, 0.07251986861228943, -0.8623858690261841, 0.3299539089202881, 0.6195188760757446, -0.285616934299469, -0.46942567825317383, 1.1745309829711914, -0.47957345843315125, -0.14039133489131927, -0.02582835778594017, 0.0927855372428894, -0.40776515007019043, -0.4156457781791687, -0.44164323806762695, 0.6804574728012085, -0.7754345536231995, -0.4358614385128021, 0.34875941276550293, -0.08320382237434387, 0.44297534227371216, 0.28588706254959106, -0.3334318697452545, -0.10057831555604935, -0.2199358493089676, 0.3791379928588867, 0.09845103323459625, -0.37547510862350464, -0.7777413129806519, -1.7699012756347656, -0.7002273797988892, -0.8312870264053345, 0.5654154419898987, -0.048155125230550766, 0.8239104747772217, -0.47485288977622986, -0.12665852904319763, 0.20117232203483582, 0.11029140651226044, -0.12560538947582245, 1.1717901229858398, -0.6336769461631775, -0.823560893535614, -0.6561205983161926, 0.5358266830444336, 0.10513444989919662, -1.79521906375885, -0.28471049666404724, -0.28561151027679443, 0.25671231746673584, 0.6037269830703735, -0.836775541305542, 0.190980926156044, -0.13618291914463043, -0.330906480550766, 0.012377201579511166, -0.2964833676815033, -0.8978077173233032, 0.5501598715782166, -0.5530786514282227, 0.9007526636123657, -0.011257088743150234, 0.1801120489835739, -0.2453901320695877, 0.2541719079017639, -0.9285801649093628, 0.2592147886753082, 0.29635339975357056, 0.5739025473594666, 0.038985900580883026, -1.6483776569366455, -0.2747466266155243, 0.08308195322751999, -0.6153252124786377, -0.2053961306810379, -0.15983325242996216, 0.5581211447715759, -0.7025882005691528, 0.09564175456762314, 0.3765173554420471, 0.37056249380111694, -0.2681601047515869, 0.37077394127845764, -0.5880887508392334, -0.24692264199256897, -0.14942355453968048, 0.31345900893211365, -0.05259587988257408, -0.29800429940223694, 0.12360164523124695, -0.5153418183326721, 0.2914092242717743, -0.06492084264755249, 0.041836660355329514, 0.374610036611557, 0.2196909338235855, -0.7306257486343384, -0.2621515095233917, 0.12076669931411743, -0.18845060467720032, 1.1483066082000732, 0.19626958668231964, -0.01857026480138302, 0.19233429431915283, -0.674929141998291, -0.855165958404541, -0.17436961829662323, -0.5160117149353027, -0.41957855224609375, -0.017903495579957962, 0.03855370357632637, 0.07157115638256073, 0.6078169345855713, -0.4762938916683197, 0.19140712916851044, 0.28473424911499023, 1.3458610773086548, 0.8556265830993652, -0.3561675250530243, -0.4178531765937805, -0.04634341597557068, -0.9000188112258911, -0.7432923316955566, -0.25853046774864197, 0.4247114658355713, -0.8734724521636963, -0.608242928981781, -0.08888213336467743, -0.12542255222797394, -0.25096315145492554, -0.32070520520210266, 0.4929710626602173, -0.5856612920761108, -0.21027015149593353, -0.5024999380111694, 0.1268247812986374, -0.14213190972805023, -1.1651623249053955, 0.07617397606372833, -0.08787324279546738, -0.1532062292098999, 0.24031975865364075, -0.11021354794502258, 0.6739020347595215, 0.4324643909931183, -0.08994869887828827, 1.295637607574463, -0.2525337338447571, -0.3266865313053131, 0.5817509889602661, 0.35150498151779175, 0.12511615455150604, 0.8473016619682312, -1.2527568340301514, 0.6288534998893738, 0.6113478541374207, -0.18174241483211517, 0.6797866821289062, 0.5152503252029419, -0.02655218169093132, 0.13829129934310913, 0.5597128868103027, -0.03777163103222847, -0.2460900843143463, 0.03335198387503624, 0.34333929419517517, 0.607693076133728, -0.3268268406391144, 0.10394369810819626, 0.225833922624588, 0.7758741974830627, 0.8818528056144714, -0.05162940174341202, -0.28484705090522766, -0.520476758480072, 0.6138579249382019, 0.5479617118835449, -0.3469140827655792, -1.0038347244262695, -0.48008862137794495, 0.09710361063480377, -0.3205220699310303, 0.13919393718242645, 0.07112322747707367, 0.7296499609947205, 0.2108796387910843, 0.25096404552459717, -0.06250932812690735, 0.5577352643013, 0.44179457426071167, 0.802030622959137, 0.8605709671974182, 0.34536266326904297, 0.4505341649055481, 0.5607476234436035, -0.2953713834285736, -0.8873318433761597, -0.10478875786066055, -0.23766811192035675, -0.3631936013698578, -0.196842223405838, -0.022836023941636086, -0.19553376734256744, -0.8854995369911194, -0.2588474750518799, 0.2098838835954666, -0.22943492233753204, 0.5649077892303467, -1.0435078144073486, -0.47134560346603394, -0.6282248497009277, -0.0701659545302391, -0.44276323914527893, 0.3950226902961731, 0.8175538778305054, 0.5627617239952087, 0.33790144324302673, 1.1231087446212769, 0.3162737786769867, 0.42726361751556396, 0.6496513485908508, -0.4114571809768677, -0.05095836520195007, 0.994093656539917, 0.18247109651565552, -0.3559983968734741, 0.14835378527641296, -0.5066850781440735, -0.27440935373306274, 0.12196295708417892, 0.1264829784631729, -0.2400023341178894, 0.07221416383981705, 0.5684769153594971, 1.0293898582458496, 0.014713767915964127, 0.24392452836036682, 0.4506050944328308, 0.15883228182792664, -0.7491087913513184, -0.2305363118648529, 0.8407799601554871, -1.2081881761550903, 0.2797163724899292, -1.2941405773162842, -0.28284189105033875, 0.391175240278244, 0.08467525988817215, -0.8512683510780334, -0.11669006198644638, -0.30254489183425903, -0.27999573945999146, 0.058567292988300323, -0.45887821912765503, 0.0725107342004776, 0.6554050445556641, -0.43082278966903687, 0.06006434187293053, -0.4762662649154663, -0.8511542677879333, -0.12496675550937653, 1.371573567390442, -0.05705961585044861, 0.02136041596531868, 0.7383902072906494, 0.5153051614761353, -1.2024545669555664, 0.3272857367992401, 0.5489048361778259, -0.509302020072937, 0.1657002866268158, -0.49949273467063904, 0.29611465334892273, 0.6801026463508606, -0.8485836982727051, 0.053729280829429626, 0.4043009281158447, 0.21892720460891724, 0.5437124371528625, -0.0031018811278045177, 0.07049378752708435, -0.03190600872039795, -0.23868520557880402, -0.6197225451469421, -0.019898606464266777, 0.16572973132133484, -0.5619932413101196, 0.9388618469238281, -0.6678088307380676, 4.059474945068359, 0.8281185626983643, 0.708873987197876, 0.31752097606658936, 0.6207408905029297, 1.5478166341781616, -0.4958091080188751, 0.6388906836509705, 0.42401108145713806, -1.1736183166503906, 0.019274858757853508, 0.6729742288589478, 0.1415606290102005, -0.3507729768753052, -0.5851881504058838, 0.44699257612228394, 0.18336279690265656, 0.2073238641023636, -0.6511573791503906, -0.21068593859672546, -0.5990017652511597, 0.5334551930427551, 0.09383942931890488, -0.26430216431617737, 0.29265066981315613, 0.24598249793052673, 0.015685701742768288, -0.2601003050804138, -0.3238009512424469, -0.3271239101886749, -0.4064297378063202, -0.6898127794265747, -0.2581374943256378, -0.2482350617647171, -1.441491723060608, 0.5271507501602173, -0.6375712156295776, -1.0650110244750977, 0.29612603783607483, 0.18259786069393158, 0.09382451325654984, -0.7650637626647949, 0.07721683382987976, -0.18133150041103363, 0.5588335394859314, 0.6413107514381409, 0.22997337579727173, 0.2074834555387497, 0.5625901222229004, -0.9946293830871582, 0.16842854022979736, -0.09783638268709183, 0.6653051972389221, -1.393791913986206, -0.24259696900844574, -0.4182247221469879, -0.33844611048698425, -0.33970731496810913, 0.09372089803218842, -0.19999359548091888, 0.6413396000862122, -0.3565410077571869, -0.1282300055027008, 0.05823690444231033, 0.3211377263069153, 0.0013371986569836736, 0.8726652264595032, -0.03718115761876106, 0.06558965146541595, -0.20294450223445892, -0.848008930683136, 0.1663053333759308, -0.130201518535614, -0.23080818355083466, 0.21633708477020264, 0.15152879059314728, -0.10422040522098541, 0.2179017961025238, -0.7726047039031982, 0.772405743598938, -0.8598604202270508, 0.1939929872751236, 0.40204256772994995, 0.2637908160686493, -0.49954938888549805, 0.5242049694061279, -0.39303267002105713, 0.38467755913734436, -0.6016882658004761, 0.5456002354621887, -0.009126764722168446, 0.6426480412483215, -0.24925832450389862, 0.03652532771229744, -0.26621395349502563 ]
Discrete Symmetry, Non-Commutative Geometry and Gravity
We describe the geomety of a set of scalar fields coupled to gravity. We consider the formalism of a differential Z_2-graded algebra of $2\times 2$ matrices whose elements are differential forms on space-time. The connection and the vierbeins are extended to incorporate additional scalar and vector fields. The resulting action describes two universes coupled in a non-minimal way to a set of scalar fields. This picture is slightly different from the description of general relativity in the framework of non-commutative geomety.
N. Mohammedi
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211015
gr-qc/9211016
[ -0.05616018921136856, 0.16212838888168335, 0.31947648525238037, -0.0017418584320694208, 0.026206284761428833, -0.1374514251947403, -0.23435334861278534, -0.27091649174690247, -0.48319149017333984, 1.3342982530593872, 0.36598944664001465, -0.00809780228883028, -0.44827693700790405, -1.1807730197906494, -0.43931451439857483, 0.136655792593956, 0.40830424427986145, -0.4522872865200043, -1.4763134717941284, -0.09869205951690674, 0.03207877278327942, 0.13668881356716156, -0.8170838356018066, -0.911417543888092, 0.17925909161567688, 0.9436546564102173, 0.1271241158246994, 0.22787360846996307, 0.46448734402656555, 0.8548668622970581, 0.5910640358924866, 0.14214636385440826, 0.20325630903244019, -0.3469953238964081, -0.2304883599281311, -0.26342326402664185, -0.23122099041938782, -0.7641809582710266, 0.810520350933075, -0.13115212321281433, 1.2749446630477905, 0.011687731370329857, -0.22711509466171265, -0.24585090577602386, -0.2815108299255371, -0.278678834438324, -0.5602702498435974, 0.033585526049137115, -0.2543553411960602, -0.9347289204597473, 0.06344261765480042, -0.14180605113506317, 0.04989911988377571, -1.1168216466903687, -0.805444598197937, -0.5204963088035583, -0.09877023100852966, -0.19428576529026031, -1.134086012840271, -0.5032715797424316, 0.8078501224517822, 0.7025434374809265, 0.5061146020889282, -0.5945397019386292, -0.13293349742889404, 1.5297350883483887, -0.23933935165405273, 0.5461341142654419, -0.3495587408542633, -0.37962496280670166, -0.06223622336983681, -0.274254709482193, -0.5710488557815552, 0.28103095293045044, -0.2741376459598541, 0.5300336480140686, -0.40843668580055237, -0.6852108836174011, -0.9464110732078552, -0.7438554167747498, -0.15284158289432526, -0.09757589548826218, 0.3290727138519287, 0.8035882115364075, 0.029086733236908913, -0.5110325813293457, 0.26370981335639954, -0.2415049523115158, 0.18019044399261475, 0.6204713582992554, 0.03946106508374214, 0.6706975698471069, -0.709435224533081, 0.27442798018455505, 0.7487283945083618, 0.8420725464820862, 0.06805345416069031, -0.05480191484093666, -0.4339770972728729, -0.029860490933060646, 0.08456174284219742, 0.5177183151245117, -0.6840142607688904, 0.03852982446551323, -0.20521385967731476, 1.4095793962478638, -0.11166412383317947, 0.5095294713973999, -0.47512516379356384, -0.6287698149681091, 0.11936450749635696, 0.4303770959377289, 0.5158731341362, -0.4308687448501587, 0.005853539332747459, 0.5319987535476685, -0.376806378364563, -0.002684696577489376, -0.004697410389780998, -0.4703274965286255, -0.21516986191272736, 1.0534048080444336, 0.053775135427713394, 0.0029245715122669935, -0.19705234467983246, -0.7613657116889954, -0.03420581668615341, 0.8824979066848755, -0.3161785304546356, 0.11471683531999588, 0.2681182026863098, -0.5419005751609802, -0.28945037722587585, 0.6556419730186462, -0.004660551901906729, -0.16148622334003448, 0.7093983888626099, 0.5793421268463135, -0.2765199542045593, -0.21744970977306366, 0.15959563851356506, -0.9970546960830688, 0.17037668824195862, 1.1015878915786743, -1.4504892826080322, 0.44010233879089355, 0.43940842151641846, -0.4737120270729065, -0.40128853917121887, -0.5164138078689575, -0.2408929318189621, -0.40247195959091187, -0.10306636989116669, 0.14318953454494476, 0.3687201738357544, -0.43962904810905457, -0.7719882130622864, 0.3133903741836548, -0.0784309133887291, -0.1748722791671753, 0.4581323564052582, 0.23383475840091705, 0.2273935228586197, 1.407358169555664, -0.07577802985906601, -0.2704528868198395, -0.5566603541374207, -0.41262850165367126, 0.21805651485919952, -0.7761778235435486, -1.0229722261428833, 0.47879618406295776, 0.12085297703742981, 0.5362387299537659, 1.1139369010925293, 1.0971981287002563, -0.21781785786151886, -0.6533716917037964, -0.2312847375869751, 0.08708310127258301, 0.17977388203144073, -0.8422529697418213, 0.16677992045879364, 0.9613251090049744, -0.3387654423713684, -0.15298736095428467, 0.48205262422561646, -0.1678469181060791, 0.236508309841156, -0.03256503865122795, -0.03495926037430763, 0.11857491731643677, -0.47149747610092163, 0.574661135673523, -0.8495359420776367, -0.22400245070457458, -0.7110304236412048, -1.1974327564239502, -0.15732496976852417, -0.015726134181022644, 0.33281210064888, 0.003950146026909351, -1.0559256076812744, 0.8678921461105347, -0.5730283856391907, -0.1539888232946396, 1.1703598499298096, 0.040412407368421555, -0.4002666771411896, -0.21325650811195374, 0.4957428276538849, -0.06880684942007065, 0.23725631833076477, 0.04161896929144859, 0.2212694138288498, 0.008392774499952793, 0.06200317665934563, -0.3928781747817993, -0.19796429574489594, -0.006936228834092617, 0.7216945290565491, -0.3430129289627075, 0.04230852425098419, 1.025315523147583, -0.05077803507447243, -0.045475348830223083, 0.0950017124414444, 0.5432115793228149, 0.2551267445087433, 0.31418392062187195, -0.5832116007804871, -0.19439361989498138, 0.4876743257045746, 0.3650910258293152, 0.5830169320106506, -0.3108392655849457, 0.8975938558578491, 0.41065436601638794, 0.007001885678619146, 0.30876487493515015, 0.10646827518939972, 0.5788518190383911, 0.14038875699043274, 0.14541052281856537, -0.12938955426216125, 0.5801334381103516, -0.41471925377845764, -0.06725281476974487, -0.07786644995212555, 0.8639282584190369, -0.507208526134491, 0.2857604920864105, -0.19336704909801483, 0.647335946559906, -1.092085599899292, 0.2971571683883667, 0.0032674495596438646, 0.6767250895500183, 0.6406906247138977, -0.5371447801589966, 0.07660430669784546, 0.31086406111717224, -0.28622540831565857, -0.9112292528152466, 0.2547460198402405, 0.6945776343345642, -0.5776863098144531, -0.26994624733924866, 1.151207685470581, -0.4309961199760437, -0.9478487968444824, -0.0603761225938797, -0.35329169034957886, -0.03349529206752777, -0.26665306091308594, -0.11071658879518509, -0.3590654730796814, -0.39963629841804504, 0.19515500962734222, -0.5109361410140991, -0.04967912659049034, 0.445482462644577, -0.3845786154270172, -0.24558471143245697, 0.520878791809082, 0.3571578562259674, -0.9388453960418701, -0.5865456461906433, -0.9868927001953125, -0.7122353911399841, -0.43882396817207336, -0.8781728744506836, -0.38654571771621704, -0.4389837086200714, -0.14086195826530457, 1.2909133434295654, -0.060383569449186325, -0.15748178958892822, 0.16190509498119354, -0.43164190649986267, 0.19711582362651825, 0.3287893533706665, -0.5227845311164856, -0.14477604627609253, -0.48529234528541565, 1.1843736171722412, -0.1573336273431778, 0.004587764851748943, 0.6462024450302124, -0.46111467480659485, -0.5685340762138367, 0.25672927498817444, 0.3064110279083252, 0.10288872569799423, -0.27812257409095764, 0.3661845624446869, 0.6739233732223511, -0.397488534450531, 0.614845871925354, -0.0864243358373642, 0.0440538115799427, -0.16517461836338043, 0.49497294425964355, -0.11081022769212723, 0.09396583586931229, 1.2979332208633423, 0.15499387681484222, -0.415381520986557, 0.3386828899383545, -0.5342391729354858, -0.06940101087093353, -0.42050039768218994, -0.2803226709365845, 0.5972113013267517, 0.1637430638074875, -0.08635027706623077, -0.32535815238952637, 0.36948850750923157, -0.7086220383644104, 0.02397160418331623, -0.03883068263530731, 0.21921959519386292, 0.09407311677932739, 0.1619667112827301, 0.3768310844898224, -0.24299436807632446, 0.7486559152603149, -0.1900627613067627, -0.3877982795238495, 0.08519410341978073, -0.08026766777038574, 0.307327538728714, 0.49835067987442017, 0.5354434251785278, 0.18823447823524475, 0.0537964403629303, -0.023618359118700027, -0.08304524421691895, -0.4939386248588562, -0.06471162289381027, 0.0025047126691788435, -0.03314908593893051, -0.15603968501091003, -0.4002619981765747, -0.5781501531600952, -0.42466747760772705, 0.06891640275716782, -0.03135346993803978, 0.2373039871454239, -0.6580751538276672, -0.06254719197750092, 0.3416392505168915, -0.9412901997566223, -0.39688193798065186, 0.12899033725261688, 0.7872782349586487, 1.0367342233657837, 0.5794097185134888, 0.7613921761512756, -0.24388638138771057, -0.016356179490685463, -0.7032594680786133, 0.6633180975914001, 0.38495519757270813, 0.270654559135437, -0.3074469566345215, -0.4892023801803589, -0.2917904555797577, -0.3007998466491699, -0.6288226842880249, -0.035578325390815735, -0.7231464982032776, 0.04389241710305214, -0.8006199598312378, -0.7439408302307129, 0.44616463780403137, 0.5192455649375916, 0.31082260608673096, 0.05779063329100609, 0.35286688804626465, -0.24653640389442444, -0.5540062785148621, -0.38222816586494446, 0.20644161105155945, -0.27071499824523926, 0.7185420989990234, -0.7099988460540771, 0.6110605001449585, 0.2429642230272293, 0.3250439763069153, 0.07380375266075134, -0.0674372985959053, -0.0006947927759028971, -0.11200260370969772, -0.09479285776615143, 0.3801569938659668, 0.1857180893421173, 0.19068536162376404, 0.38833561539649963, 0.12133920192718506, -0.022870851680636406, -0.2589156925678253, 0.8241274356842041, 0.26836785674095154, -0.0041123684495687485, -0.8157414793968201, 0.6878387928009033, -0.43630677461624146, 0.3160998523235321, 0.5602401494979858, -0.35345661640167236, -0.5326195955276489, -0.5734860897064209, -0.05418933928012848, 0.34571003913879395, 0.16322383284568787, 0.9870181083679199, 0.09296170622110367, 0.3186381161212921, -0.3223631680011749, 0.07285548001527786, 0.8819335103034973, -0.019785543903708458, -0.3699052929878235, -0.19374409317970276, 0.5664611458778381, -0.3631419241428375, 0.4281374216079712, 0.28368425369262695, -0.49391457438468933, -0.10785403847694397, -0.44144904613494873, 0.5313769578933716, -0.7982965111732483, -0.5396605134010315, 0.5241850018501282, 0.16542164981365204, -0.12412361055612564, 0.6435364484786987, 0.18690712749958038, 0.15930496156215668, -0.30201107263565063, -0.32753515243530273, -0.595673680305481, -0.7444635629653931, -0.06553489714860916, 0.31597670912742615, 0.8264089822769165, 0.44382888078689575, -0.00022740446729585528, 0.18415524065494537, 0.09080187976360321, 0.40926283597946167, 0.0408594086766243, 0.09609842300415039, -0.031657665967941284, -0.03332885354757309, -0.09070751816034317, -0.4263708293437958, -0.33506590127944946, 0.43687736988067627, 0.9491361379623413, -0.2403699904680252, -0.003596734721213579, 0.16616550087928772, -0.6341398358345032, -0.05492020770907402, -0.41648662090301514, -0.7314784526824951, 1.025352120399475, -0.17095331847667694, -0.4132903814315796, 0.18587027490139008, -0.42092031240463257, 0.374225914478302, -0.8185889720916748, 0.17262214422225952, -0.1967688351869583, 0.26075899600982666, -0.23096705973148346, 0.12145990133285522, 0.1337464451789856, -0.7997931241989136, 0.180040180683136, -0.20692500472068787, -0.4404309391975403, -0.45616328716278076, -0.6246097683906555, -0.2941158413887024, -0.06817647069692612, 0.6678255200386047, 0.3199000060558319, -0.4004899859428406, 0.3637353479862213, -0.14674650132656097, 0.2718222141265869, 0.14310309290885925, -0.5745187401771545, 0.3395174741744995, 1.0530222654342651, 0.4201701283454895, -0.724335253238678, 0.34902605414390564, 0.8684716820716858, 0.06402400135993958, 0.4675734043121338, -0.2743639349937439, -0.5913527607917786, 0.34549635648727417, -1.0056432485580444, -0.03500671312212944, -0.4932200610637665, -0.44660475850105286, -0.26793670654296875, -0.4763222634792328, 0.15047217905521393, 0.12697431445121765, -0.04052755609154701, -0.17980939149856567, -0.2560141086578369, -0.31888464093208313, 0.5346735715866089, -0.5496535897254944, -0.34059035778045654, -0.8108760118484497, -0.4598563015460968, -0.47365880012512207, 1.2887605428695679, -0.6550304889678955, 0.5538678169250488, 0.16497549414634705, -0.35863420367240906, -0.19960139691829681, 0.855568528175354, 0.01739337667822838, 0.2519749701023102, -0.2919626533985138, 0.3480837643146515, 0.30124974250793457, 0.31767159700393677, -0.45617562532424927, 0.7060374021530151, -0.17585167288780212, 1.1206754446029663, -0.24586395919322968, -0.6159749627113342, -0.05632523074746132, -0.484593003988266, 0.9264132976531982, -0.18203690648078918, 0.20332904160022736, 0.9362773895263672, 0.11814579367637634, 0.3622297942638397, 0.5067479610443115, -0.5819865465164185, 0.01470392756164074, -0.6219111680984497, -0.6180374622344971, 0.5887853503227234, -0.6277057528495789, -0.4261241853237152, 0.015902752056717873, -0.5906004905700684, 0.034891240298748016, -0.5558881163597107, 0.33387458324432373, 0.21466860175132751, 0.2736472189426422, 0.4338556230068207, -0.3356822729110718, -0.1896112561225891, 0.03627213090658188, -0.023255910724401474, 0.17990493774414062, -0.4259800910949707, 0.08895067125558853, -0.31558263301849365, -0.03519277274608612, -1.3232381343841553, -0.8398038148880005, 0.3775131404399872, 0.43596208095550537, -0.862347424030304, 0.5435651540756226, 0.07326193153858185, 0.031426988542079926, -0.5834623575210571, -0.3058430850505829, 0.18784838914871216, 0.07531508058309555, 0.42922326922416687, 0.22623147070407867, 0.1931990534067154, -0.2527543604373932, 0.01987306959927082, -0.2630213499069214, -0.3438923954963684, 0.4255974292755127, -0.5862777233123779, 0.03685208782553673, 0.494373083114624, 0.10293442010879517, -0.20779629051685333, -0.12483330816030502, -1.5720338821411133, -0.8606796264648438, -0.613057553768158, -0.2750847041606903, -0.22397613525390625, -0.003136472776532173, -1.2221359014511108, 0.7637378573417664, 0.40486711263656616, 0.31289413571357727, -0.009411905892193317, -0.028520211577415466, 0.14176885783672333, -0.3956068158149719, -0.08821829408407211, 0.38129398226737976, -0.21051648259162903, 0.23342680931091309, 0.11244367063045502, -0.09943845868110657, -0.4489412307739258, -0.2879713475704193, 0.6058423519134521, -0.23491281270980835, 0.5512930750846863, -0.37154829502105713, -0.018559182062745094, 0.716051459312439, 0.41923999786376953, -0.046171966940164566, 0.16050368547439575, -1.0830280780792236, -0.5369991660118103, 0.05399903282523155, -0.3042159378528595, 0.47998279333114624, 0.2592330276966095, -0.27248743176460266, -0.15384651720523834, -0.4432649612426758, 0.2508198916912079, 0.3050086498260498, -0.05477575212717056, -0.8654814958572388, -0.3334467113018036, -0.28698310256004333, -0.6192682981491089, -0.5759707093238831, -0.20948420464992523, 0.7964085340499878, 0.09993898868560791, 0.3008520305156708, -0.03849358856678009, 0.44260844588279724, 0.2502163052558899, -0.057848889380693436, 0.007883992046117783, -0.5937545895576477, 0.028480757027864456, -0.5874267220497131, -0.23563072085380554, -1.1751750707626343, -0.159175306558609, -0.381863534450531, -0.014051933772861958, 0.7704747915267944, -0.2334907501935959, -0.17524150013923645, -0.6192011833190918, -0.36757388710975647, 0.11461497098207474, 0.4422084093093872, -0.6566210389137268, 0.6608499884605408, 0.10316308587789536, 0.8873127102851868, 0.07292068004608154, -0.4399377107620239, -0.18280670046806335, 0.019156726077198982, -1.1211891174316406, 0.810327410697937, 0.7681770920753479, 0.36126309633255005, -0.19873589277267456, -0.3094572126865387, 0.5206875801086426, 0.6468403935432434, -0.34820836782455444, 0.3243498206138611, -1.0305521488189697, 1.153459072113037, -0.2923111617565155, 0.06713536381721497, 0.363808274269104, 0.6130585670471191, -0.04046263173222542, 0.2448379099369049, -0.19955387711524963, 0.452221542596817, -0.22865962982177734, 0.41646021604537964, 0.23019953072071075, -1.1835170984268188, 0.9693824052810669, -0.6176392436027527, 0.16911546885967255, 0.40513330698013306, 0.3551517426967621, 0.04740528389811516, 0.7313805818557739, 0.025309447199106216, -0.10543505847454071, 0.19680209457874298, -0.8160011172294617, 0.307717502117157, 0.3611932098865509, 0.12895828485488892, 0.2700921297073364, -0.5851497650146484, -0.9767781496047974, 0.5874415040016174, -0.4567427933216095, -0.8051589727401733, 0.276650995016098, -0.3832261860370636, -0.32462525367736816, -0.15496474504470825, -0.4456363022327423, 0.2286618947982788, 0.0022183372639119625, 0.5257791876792908, 1.8737008571624756, 0.22116680443286896, -0.5412512421607971, 0.2990654408931732, -0.09941715002059937, 0.04913860931992531, -0.6187366247177124, 0.40019485354423523, -0.7548305988311768, -0.9675452709197998, -0.5566864609718323, 0.49204692244529724, -0.37088143825531006, 0.0429680198431015, -0.43261176347732544, -0.36617186665534973, 0.20964226126670837, 0.27379554510116577, -0.12256292253732681, -0.3546912670135498, -0.2912535071372986, 0.43190500140190125, 0.30263492465019226, -0.3220342695713043, 0.18989183008670807, -0.0334462933242321, 0.7114339470863342, -0.04235716164112091, 0.018388547003269196, 1.5392688512802124, 0.2725576162338257, 0.026460811495780945, 0.04182841256260872, 0.10073467344045639, 0.06954392790794373, 0.01783815398812294, -0.5565372705459595, -0.06024951860308647, 0.5140596628189087, 0.0802864283323288, 0.39331114292144775, 0.0012522180331870914, 0.12441277503967285, 0.6420608758926392, -0.0745038092136383, 0.2467680126428604, -0.385297030210495, 0.5113189220428467, 0.2743741571903229, 0.6987256407737732, -0.2520237863063812, -0.3541001081466675, 0.05028967931866646, 0.1799558401107788, -0.056086864322423935, 0.22468255460262299, 0.32991671562194824, -0.909778356552124, -0.2975521683692932, 0.25440889596939087, -0.4005647599697113, -0.9834413528442383, -0.3974645435810089, -0.1511986404657364, 1.0607551336288452, 0.43587207794189453, -0.03602586314082146, -0.07108738273382187, 0.04463459178805351, -0.40600430965423584, -0.5342330932617188, 0.5785060524940491, 0.33853429555892944, 0.2677227854728699, 1.2543600797653198, 0.3724800944328308, 0.0942499041557312, 0.08686237037181854, 0.2670961022377014, -0.6730681657791138, 0.02943996526300907, 0.5834212899208069, -0.4916178584098816, 0.04976315423846245, -0.4980737566947937, -0.010736603289842606, 0.2364278882741928, -0.02477341890335083, 0.44730710983276367, -1.1888803243637085, -0.0074734752997756, 0.07018028199672699, -0.24109050631523132, 0.157260000705719, 0.14365732669830322, 0.36443355679512024, 0.11358805745840073, 0.04064302518963814, 0.6269877552986145, -0.1562974452972412, 0.02511526085436344, 0.9758340716362, 0.431028813123703, 0.25751906633377075, -0.45514291524887085, -0.5529947280883789, 1.0406509637832642, 0.770410418510437, -0.7545934915542603, 0.8036589622497559, -0.42549052834510803, -0.09839115291833878, -0.31492897868156433, 0.11132029443979263, -0.33571678400039673, -0.6286272406578064, 1.1587835550308228, 0.13101038336753845, 0.3695487976074219, 0.22636893391609192, 0.49931639432907104, 0.5946547985076904, -0.5019125938415527, -0.6267316341400146, 0.4528982639312744, -0.5262547135353088, 0.45212623476982117, -0.4112439453601837, 0.477875292301178, 0.03909779340028763, -0.28081732988357544, -0.6554731130599976, -0.5211254358291626, -0.12966667115688324, -0.6762137413024902, -0.00214881612919271, -0.19155046343803406, 0.7197498679161072, 0.5873027443885803, 0.6254019737243652, -0.4393455684185028, 0.3134167492389679, -0.2869877815246582, 0.5305619239807129, 0.8041601777076721, -0.8238806128501892, -0.0628821849822998, -0.045184534043073654, -0.3404507637023926, -0.46659186482429504, 0.48189759254455566, 0.9018722772598267, -0.5440155863761902, 0.20547671616077423, -0.03603316843509674, 0.4136168956756592, 0.1303127259016037, -0.29773324728012085, 0.44933196902275085, 0.6516850590705872, 0.13243117928504944, -0.24477246403694153, -0.3880116641521454, 0.1818813681602478, -0.8957822918891907, 0.12369904667139053, -0.003077991306781769, 0.5567346215248108, 0.04898230731487274, -0.23985861241817474, 0.040891580283641815, -1.2602134943008423, 4.221869468688965, 0.6825569868087769, 0.6791216135025024, -0.5177249312400818, 0.8322290182113647, 0.9435173273086548, -0.20493395626544952, -0.9190788865089417, 0.45453256368637085, -0.2614279091358185, -0.20278656482696533, 0.11919877678155899, 0.24514630436897278, -0.29355111718177795, 0.47651925683021545, 0.9416872262954712, -0.4771548807621002, -0.2150813490152359, 0.45081108808517456, -0.5018494725227356, -0.967413604259491, -0.22875209152698517, -0.037123747169971466, 0.0510820634663105, 0.6143090128898621, 0.8996794819831848, 0.1655513048171997, -0.619462788105011, -0.3174612820148468, -0.07881975173950195, -0.19575293362140656, -0.8255495429039001, -0.025764361023902893, -0.43909817934036255, -1.9495974779129028, 0.8960030674934387, 0.10891394317150116, -0.6415393352508545, 0.46960020065307617, -0.7358775734901428, -0.04280729964375496, -1.340667724609375, 0.11635798960924149, 0.2299167364835739, -0.13522620499134064, 1.0836281776428223, 0.21978580951690674, 1.0107098817825317, 0.8820699453353882, -0.4395758807659149, 0.16764706373214722, -0.11221390962600708, 0.12284667789936066, 0.05075144022703171, -1.2558614015579224, -0.3286876976490021, -0.5837287902832031, -0.4271624982357025, 0.6884749531745911, -0.8842103481292725, 0.31653985381126404, -0.18085986375808716, -0.16393671929836273, 0.0193417239934206, 0.09204620867967606, -0.20361697673797607, 0.047288332134485245, -0.08148650079965591, 0.22357316315174103, 0.4087187945842743, -0.41430285573005676, -0.40013259649276733, -0.6529982686042786, 0.4414387047290802, 0.39777132868766785, -0.06317327916622162, 0.22322812676429749, 0.14264820516109467, -0.3903363347053528, -0.23814977705478668, 0.19784203171730042, 0.1898173838853836, -0.9192649722099304, 0.07113394141197205, -0.3888658881187439, 0.5322920680046082, -0.1260121762752533, -0.36224862933158875, -0.33951887488365173, 0.6299957036972046, 0.7202053666114807, 0.9079522490501404, 0.10547792166471481, 0.18334531784057617, -0.5584725737571716 ]
Vacuum Polarisation and the Black Hole Singularity
In order to investigate the effects of vacuum polarisation on mass inflation singularities, we study a simple toy model of a charged black hole with cross flowing radial null dust which is homogeneous in the black hole interior. In the region $r^2 \ll e^2$ we find an approximate analytic solution to the classical field equations. The renormalized stress-energy tensor is evaluated on this background and we find the vacuum polarisation backreaction corrections to the mass function $m(r)$. Asymptotic analysis of the semiclassical mass function shows that the mass inflation singularity is much stronger in the presence of vacuum polarisation than in the classical case.
W. G. Anderson, P. R. Brady, and R. Camporesi
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211016
gr-qc/9211017
[ 0.2247876077890396, 0.24292194843292236, 0.2966114580631256, -0.0443384125828743, -0.07474465668201447, 0.18048685789108276, 0.7650729417800903, -0.188015416264534, -0.6713587045669556, 1.7335059642791748, 0.6118696928024292, -0.2670131027698517, 0.1786378026008606, -0.9326902627944946, 0.19498561322689056, 0.2840632200241089, -0.5454787015914917, -0.14048323035240173, -1.399387240409851, 0.12072861939668655, 0.6603522300720215, 0.8326245546340942, -0.8783841729164124, -0.21932260692119598, -0.3815394341945648, 0.543999433517456, 1.1500545740127563, 0.39691171050071716, 1.2165119647979736, 0.9555659890174866, 0.3664124608039856, -0.057094037532806396, -0.293522447347641, -0.3980068564414978, -0.2917402386665344, 0.14193812012672424, 0.1538613885641098, -0.6334509253501892, 1.112348198890686, -0.500903844833374, 0.7472863793373108, -0.08957158774137497, 0.42657649517059326, -0.20842155814170837, -0.5841400027275085, 0.6333086490631104, 0.20635986328125, -0.3189098536968231, -0.34151750802993774, -1.248447299003601, 0.26959866285324097, -0.6154672503471375, 0.20305876433849335, -0.482265442609787, 0.09088703244924545, -0.05514362454414368, 0.345398485660553, 0.06862194091081619, -0.06049913540482521, 0.5656368732452393, -0.16589094698429108, -0.21542535722255707, 0.18742039799690247, -1.1057766675949097, 0.5998906493186951, 1.0721752643585205, -0.15198658406734467, 0.1799955666065216, 0.04594486206769943, -0.8290800452232361, -0.3058711886405945, -0.05552608147263527, -0.6087306141853333, -0.08151387423276901, -0.3395436704158783, 1.0284054279327393, -0.5281417369842529, 0.22493837773799896, -0.2136126607656479, -0.1212446317076683, 0.5386115908622742, 0.36915943026542664, -0.05765645205974579, 0.9882457256317139, -0.43673792481422424, -0.5136603116989136, 0.2090625762939453, -0.07341562956571579, 0.7719865441322327, -0.18228672444820404, -0.33678656816482544, 0.4646010994911194, -0.18087682127952576, -0.05902143195271492, 0.13559256494045258, 0.557228147983551, -0.5355079770088196, 0.6242930889129639, 0.08507151156663895, -0.3460065424442291, 0.045754462480545044, 0.9341870546340942, -0.4770197570323944, 0.2865505516529083, -1.4074434041976929, 0.98101407289505, -0.3776899576187134, 0.6063306927680969, -0.1872720718383789, -0.7905699610710144, 0.5641138553619385, 0.4593665897846222, 0.7455745339393616, 0.012926708906888962, 0.5136883854866028, 0.3791051506996155, -0.6703499555587769, 0.42505118250846863, -0.3156837522983551, -0.13772453367710114, -0.33832690119743347, 0.10403476655483246, 0.4999409019947052, 0.7445416450500488, -0.6993595361709595, -0.17278273403644562, 0.2567867934703827, 0.14834299683570862, -0.5620107650756836, 0.21615342795848846, 0.14407767355442047, -0.36689335107803345, 0.6262704730033875, 0.8247569799423218, 0.2780766189098358, 0.5327749252319336, 0.10122592002153397, 0.33873504400253296, -0.6165258288383484, -0.5631791949272156, -0.25417694449424744, 0.21768426895141602, -0.060466792434453964, 0.988523542881012, -0.6189514398574829, 0.2512184679508209, -0.12449613958597183, -0.1420544981956482, -0.9257799386978149, -0.2428320199251175, 0.1282453089952469, -0.562455952167511, 0.34073376655578613, 0.24371419847011566, -0.18420450389385223, -0.020363230258226395, -0.7124910950660706, -0.18799670040607452, -0.06818373501300812, -0.15256258845329285, -0.1483648270368576, -0.27266332507133484, 0.6513438820838928, 1.566635251045227, 0.03937053680419922, 0.7026484608650208, -0.8944005370140076, 0.014013255015015602, -0.017952119931578636, 0.41709190607070923, -0.23797185719013214, 0.4922713339328766, 0.05745609104633331, 0.9246814250946045, 1.6426002979278564, 0.8729815483093262, -0.7773222327232361, 0.0743153914809227, -0.12692011892795563, 0.5667301416397095, 0.07947271317243576, -0.9512532949447632, 0.6399758458137512, 0.09185773134231567, -1.2836729288101196, -0.26951220631599426, 0.0967431515455246, -0.6365209221839905, 0.6915197372436523, -0.22617940604686737, -1.2440483570098877, 0.5279061794281006, -0.595777153968811, 0.6459673643112183, -0.44891488552093506, 0.22971028089523315, -1.2793275117874146, 0.02831963635981083, -0.7144055366516113, -0.649490237236023, -0.29669761657714844, 0.09237182140350342, -0.4499722421169281, -0.2433924376964569, -1.0683529376983643, 0.1186891719698906, -0.06471491605043411, 0.7658417224884033, -0.714959979057312, 0.5658397078514099, 0.5595284104347229, 0.001222884515300393, -0.6670979261398315, -0.14593791961669922, 0.4403718411922455, 0.5489600300788879, 0.02877930738031864, 0.16514964401721954, -0.5411697626113892, 0.39119502902030945, 0.4796313941478729, 0.6186667084693909, 0.1707974076271057, 0.7857248783111572, 0.43980684876441956, -0.04928732290863991, 0.18455524742603302, 1.330849528312683, -0.47026726603507996, 0.6639559268951416, -0.1615040898323059, 0.015516301617026329, 0.3994842767715454, 0.3204836845397949, 1.0313504934310913, -0.4362761974334717, 1.4819515943527222, 0.9670345783233643, -0.21294958889484406, -0.00863699521869421, 1.3880943059921265, 0.35276514291763306, 0.8225135803222656, 0.0966501459479332, -0.461003839969635, 0.19450441002845764, 0.15065018832683563, 0.1153399795293808, -0.7352500557899475, 0.21596340835094452, -0.3662456274032593, 0.39176034927368164, 0.4154793620109558, -0.45126673579216003, -1.2876002788543701, 0.5578439235687256, -0.5938283801078796, 0.08440988510847092, -0.27371373772621155, -0.33097952604293823, -0.03639611601829529, -0.15268146991729736, -0.10623881220817566, -0.46083804965019226, -0.5859889388084412, 0.09700959920883179, -0.2615283131599426, 0.16831712424755096, 0.13741378486156464, -0.6110800504684448, -1.5609636306762695, -0.38368505239486694, -0.3016098737716675, -0.15752632915973663, -0.21858543157577515, -0.5669446587562561, 0.7768596410751343, -0.3103741705417633, 0.6844477653503418, 0.4457283318042755, 0.05036186799407005, 0.1408870369195938, 0.1805407553911209, 0.015380850993096828, -0.19450080394744873, 0.08363193273544312, -0.7518486380577087, 0.411792129278183, -1.3278805017471313, 0.27081072330474854, -0.29895952343940735, -0.8235357999801636, 0.6248752474784851, 0.012106098234653473, 0.5501168370246887, 0.4491232633590698, 0.10025995969772339, -0.5666406750679016, -0.49111461639404297, -0.9533917903900146, -0.19595353305339813, -0.4019790291786194, -0.05952185392379761, 0.29516106843948364, -0.5410430431365967, 1.2410646677017212, -0.2128084897994995, -0.26646214723587036, 0.4602813422679901, -0.05575462058186531, -0.4016892611980438, -0.4194520115852356, 0.336698979139328, 0.5746396780014038, -0.2823805510997772, 0.07630975544452667, 0.3556448221206665, -0.07779966294765472, 0.2653377652168274, -0.5576326251029968, 0.03635334223508835, -0.3038334846496582, 0.6919326186180115, -0.9326483011245728, 0.22036221623420715, 0.5786727666854858, -0.38258829712867737, -0.9277616143226624, 0.6072498559951782, -1.0626345872879028, -1.2316298484802246, -0.07870488613843918, -0.6341018080711365, 0.14580944180488586, -0.0004990706220269203, 0.05550980567932129, 0.21135222911834717, -0.4827742874622345, 0.29991498589515686, 0.49536800384521484, 0.45477938652038574, -0.33583876490592957, 0.18516327440738678, 0.3475905954837799, -0.10548124462366104, -0.01309997122734785, 0.5572484135627747, -0.0653456524014473, -0.05588508024811745, -0.041853275150060654, 0.01950109750032425, -0.03920440003275871, 0.27971652150154114, 0.4476560652256012, -0.10293042659759521, 0.4156894385814667, -0.5336965918540955, -0.48917219042778015, -0.6987430453300476, -0.08967593312263489, 0.5448251366615295, 0.21490606665611267, -0.09821812063455582, -0.7179374694824219, -1.1784895658493042, -0.45591306686401367, 0.11552011966705322, -0.15585540235042572, 0.2657858729362488, -0.60370934009552, 0.674924910068512, -0.3192012906074524, 0.05218816548585892, -0.2988807260990143, -0.04597191512584686, 0.1862056702375412, 0.6364846229553223, 0.3514593541622162, 0.009294013492763042, -0.5435755252838135, 0.08643722534179688, -0.07727586477994919, 0.6874927878379822, -0.5946556329727173, 0.7312259078025818, -0.011329077184200287, 0.11519379913806915, -0.3958655893802643, -0.5726285576820374, -0.4218093752861023, 0.023374095559120178, -0.5540990829467773, -0.30932652950286865, -0.5347223877906799, -0.4418148100376129, -0.19070813059806824, 0.13311752676963806, 1.2098568677902222, 0.2681916654109955, -0.13856565952301025, -0.13742318749427795, 0.29928261041641235, -0.13126786053180695, 0.37374040484428406, -0.5522254705429077, -0.14042948186397552, -0.7991995215415955, 0.3700178563594818, 0.04905955493450165, 0.01409053336828947, 0.5010260939598083, -1.4321507215499878, -0.32446902990341187, 0.0060501438565552235, 1.2933751344680786, 0.22759626805782318, -0.4173838198184967, -0.12975460290908813, 0.15400978922843933, -0.6807414889335632, -0.790320873260498, -0.054116424173116684, 0.8021359443664551, 0.4198611080646515, 0.3099443018436432, -0.34536558389663696, -0.012877614237368107, -0.6133330464363098, 0.012204046361148357, 1.1124168634414673, -0.316671758890152, -0.5032126903533936, -0.026460830122232437, 0.11779951304197311, 0.4776487648487091, 0.40199124813079834, 0.8733780980110168, 0.37895452976226807, 0.3315454423427582, -0.5427430272102356, 0.03699256107211113, 1.103710651397705, -0.6807727813720703, 0.03542513772845268, -0.3374539911746979, 0.3902861177921295, -0.30145347118377686, 1.1323883533477783, -0.0826776996254921, -0.6240496635437012, -0.7042579650878906, -0.19067725539207458, 0.5239990949630737, -0.3695133924484253, -0.5060983300209045, 0.45100393891334534, -0.3604186773300171, 0.14317332208156586, 0.7878345251083374, -0.9700620174407959, 0.5027864575386047, 0.14038777351379395, 0.5097781419754028, -0.5473900437355042, 0.29289934039115906, 0.011372466571629047, -0.5756897926330566, 0.338754802942276, 0.8503330945968628, 0.5308648347854614, 0.38441869616508484, -0.22003960609436035, 0.06004859134554863, 0.36322954297065735, 1.2801271677017212, -0.3727727234363556, -0.3654893636703491, -0.5605247616767883, -0.43681949377059937, -0.9774623513221741, -0.49303996562957764, -0.1514659821987152, -0.4317370355129242, 0.363981693983078, -0.2947206497192383, -0.5272079706192017, -1.0922722816467285, -0.2745307981967926, -0.697563648223877, 0.3927743434906006, -0.353652685880661, 0.3239392638206482, 0.060190510004758835, 0.1280667930841446, -0.6313696503639221, 0.012503083795309067, -0.17141121625900269, -0.26175084710121155, 0.02259436808526516, 0.26423826813697815, 0.04083641991019249, 0.7418054938316345, 0.002506370423361659, 0.6333956122398376, -0.7236225008964539, -0.7557471394538879, -0.43101248145103455, -0.5331763029098511, -0.45811814069747925, -0.11362465471029282, 0.8082906603813171, -0.4302820861339569, 0.6344003677368164, 0.9340943098068237, 0.3357224464416504, 0.6196605563163757, -0.1777542531490326, -1.0254502296447754, -0.3874891996383667, 0.6442724466323853, 0.0684981495141983, -0.0032405515667051077, 0.21955522894859314, 0.44645535945892334, 0.4013333022594452, 0.09409447014331818, -0.31654369831085205, -0.22561822831630707, 0.32272037863731384, -1.4890908002853394, 0.32373347878456116, -0.7053600549697876, -0.5391078591346741, -0.29951030015945435, -0.48641639947891235, -0.22710919380187988, 0.1695869117975235, -0.5092039704322815, -0.5532687306404114, 0.014244889840483665, -0.3242153823375702, 0.44550585746765137, -0.19611863791942596, -0.11494063585996628, -0.776698887348175, 0.555965006351471, -1.0476218461990356, 2.264669418334961, -0.3650338649749756, -0.1501273512840271, 0.15423156321048737, 0.40582388639450073, -0.35808050632476807, 0.3871454894542694, 0.18664608895778656, -0.41291847825050354, -0.8597767949104309, 0.2716302275657654, 0.5688640475273132, 0.07439710944890976, -0.07990803569555283, 0.3850383162498474, -0.20975588262081146, 0.6980443596839905, 0.12201424688100815, 0.6267106533050537, -0.0055138044990599155, -0.0462905652821064, 0.6956551671028137, -0.6420288681983948, -0.3103567659854889, 0.6074005365371704, -0.03863312676548958, 0.06515797227621078, -0.4911653399467468, -0.4860303997993469, -0.10461743175983429, -0.8428242802619934, -0.6187475919723511, 0.41874274611473083, -0.3338906466960907, -0.27770763635635376, -0.8681912422180176, -0.9404096007347107, 0.28401967883110046, 0.05545945465564728, 0.004189205355942249, 0.21243247389793396, 0.43791863322257996, 0.14290852844715118, -0.3458230197429657, -0.2585553228855133, 0.1889977753162384, -0.24134357273578644, 0.21724756062030792, -0.20586273074150085, -0.028552493080496788, -0.7585735321044922, -0.36975619196891785, -0.7042580246925354, -0.4928680956363678, 1.0069822072982788, 0.05115682631731033, -0.4901672303676605, 0.5405162572860718, -0.28163424134254456, -0.005447073839604855, -0.15638478100299835, 0.41776242852211, 0.6268206238746643, -0.3734232187271118, 0.36178216338157654, -0.06791932880878448, 0.4943616986274719, -0.04775632917881012, 0.2245507389307022, -0.9601022601127625, -0.2906140685081482, 0.9419951438903809, -0.7079972624778748, 0.2125883847475052, 1.3235831260681152, -0.23662212491035461, -0.3293011784553528, -0.8271272778511047, -0.5592288970947266, -0.853105902671814, 0.14461328089237213, -0.8016993999481201, 0.06800887733697891, -0.4346393346786499, -0.10513807833194733, -0.38214194774627686, 0.6114140152931213, 0.6179536581039429, 0.36774304509162903, 0.4011732339859009, -0.19140103459358215, -0.24738334119319916, 0.054847557097673416, 0.7355387806892395, 0.3291390538215637, -0.7319155931472778, -0.17655408382415771, -0.16495271027088165, -0.33478739857673645, -0.655207633972168, 0.8937039375305176, -0.7868593335151672, -0.6928116083145142, 0.36199289560317993, 0.6061439514160156, -0.19229762256145477, 0.3302222788333893, 0.06672097742557526, 0.24239282310009003, -0.5037856698036194, -0.007736189756542444, 0.19352301955223083, 0.016998710110783577, 0.28013500571250916, 0.5740958452224731, -0.3272968530654907, 0.10866933315992355, 0.13759773969650269, 0.8745267391204834, -0.030940089374780655, -0.9372268319129944, -0.8730677366256714, -1.396785855293274, -0.3217548131942749, -1.1318814754486084, -0.40293341875076294, 0.31678423285484314, 0.39224886894226074, -0.5037571787834167, 0.3463115096092224, 0.014286383986473083, -0.3266541659832001, 0.526378333568573, 1.401639699935913, 0.03349573165178299, -0.7211095094680786, -0.4939660131931305, 0.15108352899551392, 0.11676972359418869, -1.1457629203796387, -0.3024807274341583, -0.14383380115032196, -0.2479598969221115, 0.7362042665481567, -0.8700024485588074, 0.38975948095321655, -0.28801801800727844, 0.04455570876598358, 0.2750234305858612, 0.02603881247341633, -0.8662818670272827, 1.2754614353179932, -0.0995933786034584, 0.5702525973320007, 0.3218027353286743, -0.3641287088394165, 0.32528984546661377, -0.2952817380428314, -1.529686450958252, 0.9473572969436646, -0.03236766904592514, 0.6454280614852905, 0.27725058794021606, -0.9826354384422302, 0.15478520095348358, 0.24360159039497375, -0.8341124057769775, -0.44496050477027893, -0.6295924186706543, 0.6625289916992188, -1.2437188625335693, -0.21616123616695404, -0.18439941108226776, 0.18321220576763153, -0.32490238547325134, 0.09759056568145752, -1.1384433507919312, 0.24327802658081055, -0.5686307549476624, 0.4094694256782532, 0.27890366315841675, -0.5599878430366516, 0.12777087092399597, -0.5270166397094727, 0.32172006368637085, -0.2256910800933838, 0.00859588012099266, 0.41797730326652527, 0.0431603342294693, 0.21747583150863647, -0.059529293328523636, 0.7371423840522766, -0.603411078453064, 0.6121425032615662, 0.6159235239028931, 0.44506126642227173, 0.15077616274356842, -0.732496976852417, -0.9879915714263916, 0.2408420890569687, -0.5368363261222839, -0.4692087769508362, -0.2158193141222, 0.3234122395515442, -0.00700336042791605, 0.4300044775009155, -0.9924402832984924, 0.2480461448431015, 0.02759852260351181, 1.3274567127227783, 0.8540568947792053, -0.49569523334503174, 0.42903417348861694, 0.5193368792533875, -0.8786211609840393, -0.20263409614562988, -0.2018776684999466, 0.29770538210868835, -0.6190215945243835, -0.33190396428108215, 0.09838945418596268, -0.13954511284828186, -0.3709995150566101, 0.11289310455322266, 0.5001651644706726, -0.04196985065937042, 0.15779435634613037, -0.46318328380584717, 0.31359776854515076, -0.19265353679656982, -0.6541340351104736, 0.5742471218109131, -0.10685070604085922, -0.31711873412132263, -0.41187524795532227, -0.3972022235393524, 0.47271808981895447, 0.21910959482192993, 0.10038096457719803, 1.269927740097046, 0.7365251779556274, -0.6645529866218567, 0.7177106142044067, 0.21871763467788696, 0.6369014382362366, 0.9781590104103088, -0.510932445526123, 0.17566323280334473, 0.3342888057231903, 0.19674262404441833, 0.6481260657310486, 0.20902103185653687, 0.3873487114906311, 0.06215742975473404, 0.31187060475349426, -0.0022087732795625925, 0.020221304148435593, -1.023160696029663, 0.3056163191795349, 0.382409930229187, -0.37978503108024597, 0.2285543531179428, 0.23733733594417572, 0.16337177157402039, 0.29115554690361023, -0.33737215399742126, -0.6424856185913086, -0.5478518009185791, 0.19207006692886353, 0.13866578042507172, -0.597823977470398, -0.6099053025245667, -0.18573738634586334, 0.30492013692855835, 0.2946033179759979, 0.11178981512784958, -0.3490604758262634, 0.5924758911132812, 0.13942864537239075, -0.014674884267151356, -0.0990901067852974, 0.03199411928653717, 0.13591551780700684, 0.6267750859260559, 1.4371947050094604, 0.09325353056192398, 0.36541688442230225, -0.008641403168439865, -0.3311198055744171, -0.5937275886535645, 0.2471807301044464, -0.2460857629776001, -0.32512813806533813, 0.3042825162410736, 0.26512575149536133, -0.41290128231048584, -0.9000231027603149, -0.4697931408882141, -0.07428158819675446, -0.23971916735172272, 0.6334373950958252, -0.13163892924785614, 0.20513270795345306, -0.5680273771286011, 0.3472321033477783, -0.1439250260591507, 1.1543285846710205, 0.477365642786026, 0.6585296988487244, -0.3407135605812073, 0.9822677969932556, 0.9258070588111877, 0.799419105052948, 0.2949049174785614, -0.03667667508125305, -0.08635538816452026, 0.5400460362434387, -0.0756618082523346, -0.21622464060783386, 0.64240962266922, -0.530403196811676, -0.4526827335357666, -0.012497453950345516, 0.14647246897220612, -0.4450148344039917, -0.1254725307226181, 0.43065914511680603, 1.2150920629501343, -0.299839586019516, -0.1169104352593422, 1.045565128326416, -0.19303196668624878, -0.04984289035201073, -0.33134886622428894, 0.5755802392959595, -1.1843953132629395, 0.006195425987243652, -1.2701927423477173, 0.7899457216262817, 0.7925733327865601, 0.4414873719215393, -0.5569437742233276, 0.013135743327438831, -0.18475665152072906, -0.5595178008079529, -0.28197187185287476, -0.58014976978302, 0.1906677633523941, 0.24573388695716858, -0.5440149903297424, -0.09151404350996017, -0.6977018713951111, -0.6525688767433167, -0.2984926104545593, 0.8964715600013733, 0.4288948178291321, 0.10943914204835892, 1.0602095127105713, 0.13855594396591187, -1.306750774383545, 0.4258851706981659, 0.414823055267334, 0.029237501323223114, 0.6160592436790466, 0.22979949414730072, -0.24725691974163055, 0.1709386110305786, -0.3662675619125366, -0.1443028599023819, 0.2931796908378601, 0.3868507444858551, 1.2686485052108765, -0.3620857894420624, -0.0034382594749331474, 0.022005170583724976, -0.3906584680080414, -0.6629381775856018, 0.13161686062812805, 0.945992112159729, -0.7760538458824158, 0.429335355758667, -0.4553337097167969, 3.85664701461792, 0.38590705394744873, 0.6419661045074463, -0.1850576251745224, 0.7736049890518188, 1.260215401649475, 0.09548710286617279, 0.18042822182178497, 0.023503566160798073, -0.8432937860488892, 0.47039875388145447, 0.2927917242050171, -0.14680923521518707, -0.6129597425460815, 0.43146923184394836, 0.5681176781654358, 0.31890907883644104, -0.2488182783126831, -0.31535202264785767, -0.11433524638414383, -0.7418186664581299, 0.11319094896316528, 0.5545315742492676, -0.3191334903240204, 0.2834428548812866, 0.5858754515647888, -0.39482781291007996, -0.7327594757080078, -0.6400754451751709, -0.8854516744613647, -0.09454968571662903, -0.8165450692176819, 0.11889871209859848, -0.7131803631782532, -0.9265180826187134, 0.3893221616744995, -0.16625089943408966, -0.7616062164306641, -0.24625299870967865, 0.3616354167461395, -0.3343839943408966, -0.04005594551563263, 0.3985552191734314, -0.12616823613643646, 0.5830041170120239, 0.8984635472297668, 0.5728050470352173, 0.8463271260261536, 0.14059707522392273, -1.1717121601104736, -0.011655359528958797, -0.09398646652698517, 0.17890772223472595, -0.9094966650009155, -0.828621506690979, -0.704623281955719, -0.55600905418396, -0.2935110628604889, 0.4539177715778351, -0.3899069130420685, 1.0017215013504028, -0.39486250281333923, -0.1459217667579651, 0.3964621424674988, -0.2306153029203415, 0.23648931086063385, 0.18738329410552979, 0.33111992478370667, 0.35967573523521423, -0.6020281314849854, -1.3595467805862427, 0.07526068389415741, -0.1988227218389511, -0.10376186668872833, 0.07222265005111694, 0.22198276221752167, -0.13000938296318054, 0.42973268032073975, -0.1894262433052063, 1.079600214958191, -1.0627280473709106, 0.12629246711730957, 0.17969587445259094, 0.7313344478607178, 0.24867087602615356, 0.7916581630706787, -0.5697201490402222, -0.2360592633485794, -0.6267319917678833, 0.5089449286460876, -0.0019128741696476936, 0.43154361844062805, -0.4482102692127228, 0.4216371774673462, -0.5232719779014587 ]
The Relation between Physical and Gravitational Geometry
The appearance of two geometries in one and the same gravitational theory is familiar. Usually, as in the Brans-Dicke theory or in string theory, these are conformally related Riemannian geometries. Is this the most general relation between the two geometries allowed by physics ? We study this question by supposing that the physical geometry on which matter dynamics take place could be Finslerian rather than just Riemannian. An appeal to the weak equivalence principle and causality then leads us the conclusion that the Finsler geometry has to reduce to a Riemann geometry whose metric - the physical metric - is related to the gravitational metric by a generalization of the conformal transformation.
Jacob D. Bekenstein (University of California at Santa Barbara and Hebrew University of Jerusalem)
gr-qc astro-ph hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211017
gr-qc/9211018
[ 0.7184803485870361, -0.431461900472641, 0.6109603047370911, -0.053420212119817734, 0.3644305169582367, -0.7502483129501343, -0.03528345376253128, 0.2429608702659607, -1.228110432624817, 0.5974364280700684, 1.1934658288955688, -0.21445192396640778, -0.0005836286582052708, -0.45958182215690613, -0.3259148597717285, 0.4483082890510559, -0.26681792736053467, 0.02133503556251526, -0.9079990386962891, -0.018878385424613953, 0.5548064708709717, 0.08375921100378036, -1.2076354026794434, -0.5564838647842407, -0.12006425857543945, 0.12628073990345, 1.0388635396957397, 0.20679442584514618, 0.6647880673408508, 0.35052961111068726, 0.2007315456867218, -0.7336524128913879, 0.12650157511234283, -0.38803231716156006, -0.53115314245224, -0.016088474541902542, 0.1700422614812851, -0.6462305784225464, 0.8408665657043457, 0.20069709420204163, 0.3449431359767914, 0.0500490665435791, -0.42626094818115234, -0.5668423771858215, -0.9144500494003296, -0.8259623646736145, -0.5566059350967407, 0.24377892911434174, -0.005015121307224035, -1.1991214752197266, 0.20346498489379883, -0.4255625605583191, 0.5514031052589417, -0.3885345458984375, -0.32397639751434326, -0.7726041078567505, 0.7675113081932068, 0.014772670343518257, 0.015088238753378391, 0.30966249108314514, -0.042176008224487305, 0.21880511939525604, 0.3185292184352875, -1.3765180110931396, 0.3046301305294037, 0.4390384256839752, -0.6867380142211914, 0.8518310785293579, 0.5282748937606812, -0.7376219630241394, -0.0882030501961708, -0.4346509873867035, -0.5726163387298584, 0.008209354244172573, -0.47574710845947266, 0.7250581979751587, -0.21376942098140717, -0.10281047970056534, -0.7919771671295166, -0.15580402314662933, -0.2623322606086731, -0.557318389415741, -0.6642199158668518, 0.36203572154045105, -0.3895452916622162, 0.020509062334895134, -0.13161668181419373, -0.3300510346889496, 0.4620484411716461, -0.015950391069054604, -0.4228895902633667, 0.5430451035499573, 0.30696073174476624, -0.19575558602809906, 0.9562548995018005, 0.595259964466095, -0.004211096093058586, 0.44712382555007935, 0.6770795583724976, 0.006325256545096636, -0.4954831004142761, 0.8174881339073181, -0.6812017560005188, 0.8750298023223877, -0.06759612262248993, 1.060506820678711, -0.3504616916179657, 0.46956220269203186, -0.06294214725494385, -0.22260917723178864, 0.8319010734558105, -0.5674489736557007, 0.7327865958213806, 0.7116334438323975, -0.11862087994813919, 0.5171544551849365, -0.07896936684846878, 0.3054291009902954, -1.033625602722168, -0.3032873868942261, 0.3419489562511444, 0.2405707985162735, 0.9086611270904541, 0.8353721499443054, 0.20375584065914154, -0.4868147373199463, 0.4777739942073822, -0.3365429639816284, -1.3174583911895752, 0.7092564702033997, 0.43775248527526855, -0.588196873664856, -0.31670793890953064, 0.09047169238328934, -1.0599339008331299, 0.5250726342201233, -0.8842352628707886, -0.10918392986059189, -0.3285266160964966, -0.34846872091293335, 0.7408589124679565, -0.6536920666694641, 0.5043284893035889, 1.2544076442718506, 0.003287695348262787, -0.0960659310221672, 0.4253956377506256, 0.13610802590847015, -0.09558501094579697, 0.41784659028053284, 0.24857351183891296, -0.05863218754529953, -0.36763399839401245, 0.41998523473739624, 0.02057342790067196, 0.32244157791137695, -0.5169623494148254, 0.10757925361394882, -0.8232988119125366, -0.20552565157413483, 0.3349613547325134, -0.6620675921440125, 0.15747050940990448, 0.8870965242385864, 0.11826801300048828, 0.5263456702232361, -0.2946670353412628, -0.24158643186092377, -0.12083037197589874, -0.12254327535629272, 0.04521692916750908, -0.28150200843811035, 0.256759911775589, 1.0389548540115356, 0.4219634532928467, 0.3692503273487091, 0.33890774846076965, -0.38695383071899414, -0.0676322802901268, 0.5221791863441467, -0.08916233479976654, -0.6372209191322327, 0.9691388607025146, 0.31410062313079834, -0.5595001578330994, -0.560784637928009, -0.02713535539805889, -0.31498271226882935, 0.012721352279186249, 0.23653659224510193, -0.4560818672180176, 0.3198232054710388, -0.3334429860115051, 0.44196435809135437, -1.2634810209274292, 0.9168988466262817, -1.3381414413452148, 0.43924379348754883, -0.8200139999389648, -0.002451796317473054, -0.5739448070526123, 0.34017810225486755, -0.7654194235801697, -0.1832098364830017, -1.0355228185653687, 0.49352070689201355, 0.4328954219818115, 0.9769992232322693, -0.508080005645752, 0.023762958124279976, 0.234876811504364, -0.18702815473079681, 0.48828601837158203, -0.3640981912612915, 0.021388575434684753, 0.13791891932487488, -0.019906025379896164, 0.9005956053733826, 0.19608357548713684, 0.2556229531764984, 0.6344010829925537, 0.7785042524337769, 0.253940612077713, 0.8712613582611084, 0.10187654942274094, 0.1245896965265274, 0.01112230122089386, 0.945904016494751, 0.10593769699335098, 0.29181110858917236, 0.16185107827186584, -0.03908989205956459, 0.8232200145721436, 0.5443947315216064, -0.08172863721847534, 0.08680615574121475, 0.9514179229736328, 0.28451424837112427, 0.46809202432632446, 0.3030691146850586, 0.18677978217601776, -0.21422959864139557, 0.8567023277282715, 0.15177211165428162, 0.0258354339748621, -0.013152523897588253, 0.010421410202980042, 0.4103890061378479, -0.6137810945510864, 0.64239501953125, -0.013473454862833023, 0.4154614806175232, 0.0409504659473896, 0.27446049451828003, -1.4956806898117065, -0.4239632785320282, 0.42386895418167114, -0.1666247844696045, -0.16598105430603027, -0.7166024446487427, 0.19535623490810394, -0.4566100239753723, 0.029030442237854004, -0.12272216379642487, -0.3024674355983734, 0.62621009349823, 0.1451113373041153, 0.079893097281456, -0.0092192143201828, -0.6919032335281372, -1.19636869430542, -0.19282086193561554, -0.5996212363243103, 0.024470238015055656, -1.1916260719299316, -0.08558692783117294, 0.6637224555015564, -0.7478439211845398, 0.9833997488021851, 0.02295108698308468, -0.4506421983242035, -0.26448094844818115, -0.5067471861839294, 0.2754405438899994, 0.16874028742313385, -0.02510821260511875, -0.40697354078292847, 0.4364934265613556, -0.9648123383522034, 0.4547189474105835, -0.3907400965690613, -0.023622354492545128, 1.4329379796981812, -0.5532506108283997, -0.3191893994808197, -0.7323288917541504, -0.653321385383606, -0.23111166059970856, -0.6193232536315918, -0.2841501235961914, -0.03290139138698578, 1.0769989490509033, -0.12257968634366989, 0.29776033759117126, -0.9258046746253967, 0.5074723958969116, -0.02861502580344677, -0.6753304600715637, 0.31936129927635193, 0.5964138507843018, -0.42719823122024536, 1.3385250568389893, 0.07939480245113373, 0.28263938426971436, -0.10748337209224701, 0.5994024872779846, 0.30312976241111755, 0.09659384191036224, -0.020242128521203995, -0.72793048620224, -0.7899030447006226, 0.3033338189125061, -0.2369101494550705, -0.23728936910629272, -0.32996872067451477, 0.5719045400619507, -0.28659787774086, -0.6929561495780945, 0.1027241200208664, -1.2898643016815186, -0.8925169706344604, -0.374502032995224, -0.6488232612609863, 0.5122911334037781, -0.16830509901046753, -0.1586388498544693, -0.480053573846817, -0.40416836738586426, 0.639754056930542, 0.19746558368206024, 0.353210985660553, -0.5258265137672424, 0.3988604247570038, -0.1786547303199768, 0.7867770791053772, 0.3156641721725464, -0.2466789186000824, 0.30694350600242615, -0.489701509475708, 0.39664918184280396, -0.3134712874889374, 0.13363316655158997, -0.48609521985054016, 0.1265745759010315, 0.18031524121761322, 0.12186677753925323, -0.34001702070236206, -0.29714861512184143, -0.8567883372306824, -0.031231796368956566, 0.3784410357475281, 0.6780918836593628, -0.11604680120944977, -0.15681420266628265, -0.5114313364028931, 0.09993377327919006, -0.9663662910461426, 0.23704688251018524, 0.5577120184898376, -0.442436546087265, 0.5618939399719238, 0.23699745535850525, -0.16357921063899994, 0.5211458802223206, -0.36844000220298767, 0.39962688088417053, 0.6237273812294006, 0.2131083458662033, 0.6290587186813354, -0.6373190879821777, -0.22818301618099213, 0.05176549777388573, 0.16613565385341644, 0.09654019773006439, 0.9017902612686157, -0.028212225064635277, 0.3407342731952667, 0.03802987560629845, -0.5559574961662292, -0.9587544798851013, -0.4208793640136719, -0.7124561667442322, -0.3402903378009796, -0.19437924027442932, -0.4948454797267914, -0.21287867426872253, 0.3169732093811035, -0.248739555478096, 0.15943185985088348, 0.5926093459129333, 0.3055432438850403, 1.6423897743225098, 0.5794506072998047, 1.2989872694015503, -0.8212172389030457, -0.4569215476512909, -0.38718435168266296, 0.46750739216804504, 1.094761610031128, -0.47870489954948425, -0.17541106045246124, -0.4620394706726074, -0.16995970904827118, -0.2836058437824249, 0.7978389263153076, -0.006871008314192295, -1.1409993171691895, 0.9807860851287842, 0.2671836316585541, 0.22539855539798737, -0.16263741254806519, 0.38747140765190125, 0.5342691540718079, 0.008781123906373978, 0.690815806388855, -0.8542706966400146, -0.428491473197937, -1.0108251571655273, 0.5272944569587708, 0.7699334025382996, -0.7531040906906128, -1.100939154624939, -0.893204391002655, -0.7042531371116638, -0.11977799236774445, 0.22778549790382385, 0.45484524965286255, 0.9877986907958984, 0.3400759696960449, -0.6331323385238647, -0.27238595485687256, 0.4249803125858307, -0.06440576910972595, 0.06922347098588943, -0.07525025308132172, -0.08702512085437775, -0.6593404412269592, 0.6747534871101379, 0.03802585229277611, -0.7654841542243958, 0.21494533121585846, -0.4532207250595093, 0.6241306066513062, -0.16558708250522614, -0.5311887860298157, -0.7873315215110779, 0.5696329474449158, -1.0219327211380005, 0.05306393280625343, -0.1349157691001892, 0.39369645714759827, 0.0790431872010231, 0.12667278945446014, -0.12883543968200684, -0.16250813007354736, 0.6606441736221313, 0.17158977687358856, 0.8280869126319885, 0.979694128036499, 0.12527652084827423, 0.0579054169356823, 0.3334099054336548, -0.5688689947128296, -0.3574959933757782, 0.7347825765609741, -0.10684338212013245, -0.4149324595928192, -0.05000171437859535, -0.4414479434490204, -0.03543506935238838, -0.7294378876686096, -0.5515385270118713, -0.5384486317634583, -0.21117639541625977, 0.42730963230133057, -0.4670347571372986, -0.16890566051006317, -0.4062770903110504, -0.7179429531097412, -0.14475569128990173, -0.05038278177380562, -0.26956263184547424, 0.5271342992782593, -0.25482144951820374, 0.13843335211277008, 0.06301838159561157, -0.4281858503818512, 0.1177421510219574, 0.19895322620868683, 0.6470524072647095, 0.5153232216835022, 1.1627850532531738, 0.09781122952699661, 0.4003642499446869, -0.21763306856155396, 0.6499122381210327, -0.463070273399353, -0.5375627279281616, -0.7778172492980957, -0.39160099625587463, -0.3715091943740845, -0.14342883229255676, -0.34303268790245056, 0.3125782012939453, -0.0373702235519886, 0.3521491289138794, 0.11017835140228271, -0.8435375094413757, -0.24554596841335297, 1.1111571788787842, 0.27800244092941284, -0.4980422854423523, -0.04266738519072533, 0.36677443981170654, -0.1350916624069214, 0.10338998585939407, 0.27745485305786133, -0.6212720274925232, 0.48594099283218384, -0.7442120313644409, 0.7750447988510132, -1.2512717247009277, 0.032702427357435226, -0.6285527944564819, -0.9446062445640564, 0.6710033416748047, 0.6637663245201111, 0.24521537125110626, -0.4765876233577728, -0.7155071496963501, -0.44061678647994995, -0.1976616382598877, -0.517808735370636, 0.11647125333547592, -0.8574427366256714, -0.506199836730957, -0.6210795044898987, 1.047094464302063, -0.006786680314689875, -0.40495654940605164, 0.643522322177887, 0.4428532123565674, 0.2405049055814743, 0.403783917427063, 0.0098415557295084, -0.5084900259971619, -0.4553721249103546, -0.3948448896408081, 0.1859801709651947, 0.29989638924598694, -0.022679036483168602, 0.34990575909614563, -0.9616824984550476, 1.6798073053359985, 0.5664675831794739, -0.3587934970855713, 0.30490168929100037, 0.1173136830329895, 0.5862555503845215, -0.29492807388305664, -0.24575640261173248, -0.5073621869087219, 0.249327152967453, 0.5731770396232605, 0.3400324583053589, -1.012359619140625, -0.4758312702178955, -0.19510531425476074, -1.1798232793807983, 0.6088092923164368, 0.17160838842391968, 0.29444509744644165, -0.5009507536888123, -0.4925747811794281, 0.17349880933761597, 0.7329445481300354, 0.8669784069061279, 0.3174504339694977, 0.9451615810394287, 0.04329633712768555, -0.16542086005210876, -0.42694398760795593, -1.0533322095870972, -0.11182016134262085, -0.11705031991004944, -0.3973120152950287, 0.15765675902366638, 0.15964141488075256, -0.8351394534111023, -1.1115046739578247, -0.06754405051469803, 0.1620129644870758, 0.37066248059272766, -0.15222328901290894, 0.902129054069519, -0.12370135635137558, -0.28174835443496704, -0.0179726742208004, 0.026855232194066048, -0.08935607224702835, 0.32790470123291016, 0.5803642868995667, 0.24793881177902222, 0.3272305130958557, 0.46279045939445496, 0.7188438177108765, -0.7945541143417358, -0.8041298985481262, 1.0067769289016724, -0.5370479226112366, -0.01637503132224083, 0.5285885334014893, 0.09123163670301437, -0.9087489247322083, -0.3115251958370209, -0.0224335715174675, -0.2877480089664459, -0.43587759137153625, -0.14846697449684143, 0.48027291893959045, -0.05142541974782944, 0.3299500346183777, 0.3566575050354004, 0.34538379311561584, 0.13251379132270813, 0.2500508427619934, 0.28266769647598267, -0.39359262585639954, 0.008358213119208813, 0.3385550379753113, 1.5459932088851929, -0.21222102642059326, -1.5486440658569336, 0.14647337794303894, 0.41994571685791016, -0.5486459732055664, -0.2812669575214386, 0.082857146859169, 0.4682331681251526, -0.38399314880371094, 0.2513274550437927, 1.1654270887374878, 0.49288007616996765, 0.4233857989311218, -0.44315415620803833, -0.4261956214904785, -0.051265448331832886, -1.1352235078811646, -0.012218264862895012, -0.1199953705072403, 0.4491198658943176, 0.18999797105789185, -0.3974083364009857, -0.20045527815818787, 0.5684638023376465, 0.38670289516448975, 0.052118320018053055, -1.385269045829773, -0.04882565140724182, -1.0361390113830566, -0.3163531422615051, -0.9287681579589844, 0.052472688257694244, 0.5942720174789429, 0.5013408064842224, -0.7421894669532776, 0.38833725452423096, 0.29551786184310913, -0.31151846051216125, -0.012605599127709866, 0.8257561922073364, -0.4762303829193115, -0.15641570091247559, 0.13655658066272736, -0.03910426050424576, 0.6291225552558899, -0.3507104516029358, -0.528572678565979, -0.3483961820602417, -0.37038376927375793, 1.0380322933197021, 0.18836426734924316, 0.4236883819103241, -0.4067990779876709, -0.17067217826843262, 0.29969242215156555, -0.3726249933242798, -0.8822701573371887, 0.6163228750228882, -0.0789116621017456, 0.9918379187583923, 0.06162170693278313, 0.29938405752182007, -0.32146570086479187, -0.050363726913928986, -0.3509669899940491, 0.13651125133037567, -0.03970051929354668, 0.40580448508262634, 0.1890566349029541, -0.5063751339912415, 0.5128739476203918, -0.5825722217559814, -1.2277039289474487, 0.7300280928611755, 0.27454873919487, 0.6671636700630188, -0.23605450987815857, -0.05006273463368416, -0.38125136494636536, -0.26124081015586853, 0.2961675822734833, 0.365450382232666, -0.5432177186012268, -0.3282635509967804, -0.3252464532852173, 0.5059476494789124, -0.7489550113677979, 0.15381485223770142, -0.24109911918640137, -0.2011680155992508, -0.48741766810417175, 0.1822054535150528, -0.34759199619293213, -0.09883465617895126, -0.2937297224998474, -0.8154160976409912, -0.8834022283554077, -0.06278754025697708, -0.19102898240089417, 0.5066085457801819, 0.5776183009147644, -0.8749924898147583, 0.28308913111686707, -0.628264844417572, -0.9380449056625366, 0.27656692266464233, -1.097599983215332, -0.29630789160728455, 0.43651753664016724, -0.5995836853981018, 0.30945301055908203, 0.6142544150352478, -0.6131976842880249, 0.4832759201526642, 0.45952966809272766, 1.0795857906341553, 0.5155304670333862, -0.2834133207798004, -0.06970308721065521, -0.144356369972229, -1.1419073343276978, -0.5389220714569092, -0.850003719329834, -0.06204734742641449, -0.909437358379364, -1.011648178100586, -0.012553535401821136, 0.06994315981864929, 0.035448428243398666, -0.18331068754196167, 0.19408218562602997, 0.0015242890221998096, -0.14713075757026672, 0.00299286050722003, -0.3420697748661041, -0.20995990931987762, -0.8954967260360718, 0.451713502407074, -0.40213561058044434, -0.6569513082504272, 0.14574146270751953, 0.07584662735462189, -0.13119971752166748, 0.582463800907135, -0.13820567727088928, 0.9705184698104858, 0.4510064125061035, -0.5075719356536865, 0.9286410808563232, 0.36515575647354126, 0.5726396441459656, 0.4030582010746002, -0.8443043828010559, 0.7966639399528503, 1.033660650253296, 0.9762322306632996, 0.9481244683265686, 0.3281189799308777, 0.09135863929986954, -0.06928353756666183, 0.8568214178085327, 0.1615796983242035, -0.23314210772514343, 0.2901512384414673, 0.4058677852153778, 0.5629979968070984, 0.1439107358455658, -0.9205654263496399, 0.29489198327064514, 0.07719272375106812, -0.01130724512040615, -0.0547352209687233, -1.4154629707336426, -0.04706549644470215, 0.35360458493232727, 0.3570450246334076, -0.5100258588790894, -0.18736562132835388, -0.3906495273113251, 0.19751444458961487, 0.22882190346717834, 0.22230501472949982, -0.34630632400512695, -0.038890253752470016, 0.7910724878311157, -0.26114606857299805, 0.050411123782396317, 0.6808964014053345, 0.30425283312797546, 0.4427032172679901, 0.6172885298728943, 0.2656444013118744, 0.4546607732772827, 0.6651803851127625, -0.42364999651908875, -0.7982770204544067, -0.41349542140960693, -0.2436121553182602, -1.2185273170471191, -0.09196305274963379, -0.12290848791599274, -0.3019217848777771, -0.6036614179611206, -0.5697948336601257, 0.28749433159828186, -0.5455837845802307, 0.22614160180091858, 0.4507267475128174, -0.2056807428598404, -0.42488816380500793, 0.8583697080612183, 0.4203585386276245, 0.7969464659690857, 0.8441776633262634, 0.012640087865293026, 0.47452208399772644, 0.903736412525177, 1.2680820226669312, -0.3510247766971588, 0.4308956265449524, 0.33986610174179077, -0.20884035527706146, 0.5621914267539978, 0.13453403115272522, -0.7669033408164978, -0.25955796241760254, -0.46876129508018494, -0.33034101128578186, -0.2846742272377014, 0.5939663052558899, 0.17943286895751953, -0.07230181246995926, 0.44462478160858154, 0.5875627994537354, -0.8459016680717468, 0.6512165069580078, 0.7956904768943787, 0.5055369734764099, -0.28533726930618286, -0.5718182921409607, 0.18573971092700958, -1.292165994644165, -0.4517488479614258, -1.7983163595199585, 0.8001625537872314, 0.801293134689331, 0.4105302393436432, -0.24437390267848969, -0.4438548982143402, -0.40081873536109924, -0.7157458066940308, -0.140582874417305, -0.874114990234375, 0.08932164311408997, 0.09672244638204575, 0.0639684721827507, 0.4912814199924469, -0.38561227917671204, 0.0407516174018383, -0.1631157100200653, 1.0350077152252197, -0.2904830873012543, 0.552496075630188, 0.5434926748275757, 0.3094595670700073, -0.3406112790107727, -0.17344273626804352, 0.9097679257392883, -0.8874109983444214, 0.6966280341148376, -0.13267363607883453, 0.5561573505401611, -0.05684575065970421, -0.7922934889793396, -0.085364930331707, 0.10106860101222992, 0.15279144048690796, 0.17402520775794983, -0.10039645433425903, 0.5318273901939392, -0.35080668330192566, 0.026456667110323906, -1.0666885375976562, 0.14848841726779938, -0.480193555355072, 0.6222994327545166, -0.2624688148498535, -1.0507211685180664, 3.8705241680145264, 1.0473377704620361, 0.7295637130737305, 0.6057601571083069, 0.7862386107444763, 1.9279453754425049, 0.02691551484167576, 0.11853951215744019, 0.1089538037776947, -0.8959252238273621, -0.520161509513855, 0.26430949568748474, 0.3558158874511719, -0.21353383362293243, -0.19270417094230652, 0.888950765132904, -0.4760521650314331, 0.4763517379760742, -0.2783682644367218, -0.6032288670539856, -0.7607046961784363, 0.34304556250572205, 0.14402730762958527, -0.4647809565067291, 0.29562440514564514, 1.3426061868667603, 0.20980943739414215, -0.6184764504432678, -0.6035559773445129, -0.4616524279117584, -0.38619786500930786, -0.7209994792938232, 0.28595882654190063, -0.2704564332962036, -0.8481133580207825, 0.5364024043083191, -0.47361862659454346, -0.7226678729057312, 0.3202599287033081, 0.3543161451816559, 0.13885317742824554, -0.4307959973812103, 0.6398690938949585, -0.35334017872810364, -0.47604137659072876, 0.4861551821231842, -0.9544939398765564, 0.4668179154396057, 0.3969322144985199, -0.7867200970649719, 0.6092464923858643, -0.19563230872154236, 0.18682770431041718, -0.928723156452179, 0.04179508984088898, 0.19682373106479645, -0.7532194256782532, 0.5767175555229187, 0.3202729821205139, -0.24053886532783508, 0.5684889554977417, -0.18487229943275452, -0.13831676542758942, 0.11877696216106415, -0.16602155566215515, 0.24866598844528198, 0.38507306575775146, 0.010238747112452984, -0.31251904368400574, 0.4444226622581482, -0.1003146693110466, -0.8246589303016663, -0.8158594369888306, -0.03921733424067497, -0.008925576694309711, -0.08515443652868271, -0.44157513976097107, 0.5612152814865112, -0.14680001139640808, 0.2788022458553314, -0.06011638790369034, -0.4164811372756958, 0.3730262219905853, -0.45206400752067566, 0.20933175086975098, 1.132814884185791, 0.06452809274196625, 0.08971147984266281, 0.0020482626277953386, 0.4902621805667877, 0.405622661113739, 0.7503422498703003, 0.08113770931959152, 0.22843724489212036, -0.4398477077484131 ]
Generalized Fierz Identities and the Superselection Rule for Geometric Multispinors
The inverse problem, to reconstruct the general multivector wave function from the observable quadratic densities, is solved for 3D geometric algebra. It is found that operators which are applied to the right side of the wave function must be considered, and the standard Fierz identities do not necessarily hold except in restricted situations, corresponding to the spin-isospin superselection rule. The Greider idempotent and Hestenes quaterionic spinors are included as extreme cases of a single superselection parameter.
William M. Pezzaglia Jr. (Physics, Santa Clara University)
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211018
gr-qc/9211019
[ 0.43224307894706726, -0.2733507752418518, 0.008079593069851398, -0.21200977265834808, 0.10423896461725235, 0.017302365973591805, -0.27788597345352173, -0.10105925798416138, -0.5929361581802368, 0.9573268890380859, 0.5102518796920776, -0.3816995620727539, -0.21364815533161163, -1.0588555335998535, 0.47296956181526184, 0.3754958510398865, -0.4016280472278595, -0.39949217438697815, -1.5300086736679077, 0.5814023017883301, 0.7859705686569214, 0.3556753695011139, -1.148632287979126, -0.15661115944385529, -0.18763713538646698, 0.7161089777946472, 0.976639449596405, 0.05488007888197899, 1.0025140047073364, 0.5271119475364685, 0.6630474925041199, 0.26334160566329956, 0.06873774528503418, -0.560287356376648, 0.0892421305179596, 0.2544148862361908, -0.019238783046603203, -0.6357766389846802, 1.1451245546340942, -0.16225150227546692, 0.3770257532596588, 0.12411370128393173, 0.07487111538648605, -0.9132437109947205, -1.119895577430725, -0.18874676525592804, 0.23576995730400085, -0.01928263157606125, -0.11056289821863174, -1.3594701290130615, -0.17228542268276215, -0.06590094417333603, 0.5944532752037048, -1.0994523763656616, -0.21410764753818512, -0.43890759348869324, 0.022558260709047318, 0.7682489156723022, -0.5946651697158813, 0.4792513847351074, 0.3145819306373596, 0.4018992781639099, 0.320321261882782, -1.023727536201477, -0.13074302673339844, 0.8907445073127747, -0.25742602348327637, 0.5009755492210388, 0.2716088593006134, -0.35797131061553955, -0.2231607586145401, -0.7348982691764832, -0.748100221157074, -0.008394671604037285, -0.5621685981750488, 0.2899704873561859, -0.48918282985687256, -0.561933696269989, -0.8399729132652283, -0.3514634668827057, -0.16391466557979584, -0.43914133310317993, -0.3984960615634918, 0.5388739705085754, -0.41330620646476746, 0.008850929327309132, 0.1458684653043747, -0.4269145727157593, 0.5263091921806335, 0.40063101053237915, -0.6192620992660522, 0.31722763180732727, 0.0616845041513443, -0.028673190623521805, 0.5954278707504272, 0.5602914690971375, 0.08441852778196335, 0.4458038806915283, 0.011598140932619572, 0.25538170337677, -0.6597097516059875, 1.198290228843689, 0.13306762278079987, 0.3927224278450012, -0.12750722467899323, 1.0318398475646973, -0.7590005993843079, 0.18186843395233154, -0.014669044874608517, -0.3909163773059845, 0.3254244327545166, -0.20198002457618713, 0.32493939995765686, 0.2477663904428482, -0.10498872399330139, 0.7280290126800537, -0.5898342132568359, -0.19134655594825745, -0.7275633811950684, -0.0847557783126831, -0.48542746901512146, 0.4243033826351166, 0.9682214856147766, 0.8075553178787231, 0.03889823704957962, -0.3384052515029907, 0.17827624082565308, -0.32395610213279724, -0.91661137342453, -0.10425318032503128, 0.1233406737446785, -0.3999022841453552, 0.04991040378808975, -0.05551855266094208, -0.3895956873893738, 0.39689382910728455, 0.0745970830321312, -0.14250552654266357, -0.8373762369155884, -0.30307844281196594, 0.6018216609954834, -0.6891637444496155, 0.48965442180633545, 1.0366486310958862, -0.36070165038108826, 0.5971604585647583, 0.04193556681275368, -0.054657433182001114, -0.41585573554039, 0.4775908589363098, 0.1851230263710022, -0.6305616497993469, -0.05844564735889435, -0.04086614027619362, -0.06244420260190964, -0.15476058423519135, -0.949749767780304, 0.06509295105934143, -0.5020462274551392, -0.4646128714084625, 0.6437112092971802, -0.14417217671871185, 0.0125566516071558, 0.9331217408180237, -0.05964739993214607, 0.550589382648468, -0.4788995385169983, 0.3133605718612671, 0.42305320501327515, -0.03670415282249451, -0.15904617309570312, 0.12447575479745865, 0.05163976922631264, 0.4669521152973175, 1.0007755756378174, 0.641547679901123, 0.06367900222539902, -0.04810832813382149, -0.4190267026424408, 0.12279138714075089, -0.10833556950092316, -0.6021754145622253, 0.5021140575408936, 0.8568021059036255, -0.7886075377464294, -0.31036376953125, 0.3861205577850342, 0.08243080973625183, 0.3265649974346161, 0.41469812393188477, -0.952557384967804, 0.6135311126708984, -0.912522554397583, 0.8360900282859802, -0.44455844163894653, 0.583875298500061, -1.073249340057373, -0.10550104081630707, -0.009048165753483772, -0.1998305469751358, 0.0941147580742836, -0.12133168429136276, -0.7468494176864624, 0.06402403116226196, -1.112483024597168, 0.6008720397949219, 0.3057698905467987, 0.38538384437561035, -0.1308707296848297, 0.2660439610481262, 0.49248138070106506, -0.1317247748374939, 0.3018372654914856, -0.6537805795669556, 0.43871939182281494, -0.16813215613365173, -0.6023829579353333, 0.705013632774353, 0.10986174643039703, -0.21437205374240875, 0.8259963989257812, 0.5027806758880615, -0.020296836271882057, 0.9837722778320312, 0.17682287096977234, 0.021334443241357803, 0.06264945864677429, 1.0164846181869507, -0.3617572784423828, 0.5200241208076477, 0.3552524149417877, 0.12353251874446869, 0.288961261510849, 0.08931837975978851, 0.35830792784690857, -0.3927501142024994, 1.061537504196167, 0.5327355861663818, 0.8242708444595337, 0.2655653953552246, 0.48468321561813354, 0.04665890336036682, 0.6339223384857178, -0.049342937767505646, -0.5195496678352356, 0.5318419933319092, 0.4994659721851349, 0.02837076224386692, -0.4788638949394226, 0.6536789536476135, -0.9738339185714722, 0.6698392033576965, 0.40277132391929626, 0.1302698403596878, -1.2914183139801025, 0.42798227071762085, 0.053811024874448776, 0.672557532787323, 0.14360582828521729, -0.6038397550582886, 0.0713004320859909, 0.5692993998527527, 0.15744459629058838, -0.3010387718677521, -0.8236170411109924, -0.35081353783607483, -1.0648139715194702, -0.06013530120253563, 0.5459630489349365, -0.5146155953407288, -1.0746641159057617, 0.12768159806728363, -0.8181574940681458, 0.17007046937942505, -0.45331504940986633, -0.263601154088974, 0.25454363226890564, -0.2012939304113388, 0.5949360132217407, 0.21164070069789886, 0.3184731602668762, 0.12468668073415756, -0.045722465962171555, 0.053661804646253586, 0.4922868609428406, -0.07283961027860641, -0.6877384781837463, 0.418952077627182, -1.2986021041870117, -0.0877879187464714, 0.42095062136650085, -0.577578067779541, 0.17501792311668396, -0.11118943989276886, 0.49308910965919495, -0.05127369612455368, -0.2903815507888794, 0.22625881433486938, -0.40844863653182983, -0.8088931441307068, 0.10039609670639038, 0.6633479595184326, 0.22737658023834229, 0.15785059332847595, -0.8169794678688049, 0.7343746423721313, -0.08848492801189423, -0.39371493458747864, 0.35986098647117615, -0.17743758857250214, -0.4777018427848816, 0.10798953473567963, 0.152563214302063, 0.40006914734840393, -0.12826965749263763, 0.6327226161956787, 1.01316237449646, 0.05659393593668938, -0.2937212288379669, 0.16351573169231415, -0.514915943145752, 0.287732869386673, 0.5495935082435608, -0.7533653378486633, 0.3008481562137604, 0.3963107466697693, 0.4281276762485504, -0.4775908291339874, 0.28590866923332214, -1.2584559917449951, -0.9860624670982361, -0.06505586206912994, -0.5694620013237, -0.1624501794576645, -0.08053956925868988, -0.019993938505649567, -0.5033495426177979, 0.05762353166937828, 0.31146425008773804, 0.7891526222229004, 0.5530005693435669, -0.08173803985118866, 0.2802543640136719, 0.22327721118927002, 0.174931600689888, 0.283209890127182, 0.723724901676178, -0.41457217931747437, -0.07678912580013275, 0.47936779260635376, -0.08356747776269913, 0.28630343079566956, 0.050921279937028885, -0.6649079918861389, -0.12997598946094513, 0.20271168649196625, -0.553654670715332, 0.2027980238199234, -0.8846358060836792, -0.40051358938217163, 0.025420667603611946, 0.7419317960739136, 0.3932931423187256, -0.6127339005470276, -0.8032439351081848, 0.20147910714149475, -0.2033703774213791, 0.5758271217346191, 0.7218024730682373, -0.6231760382652283, 0.15036876499652863, 0.03866736963391304, -0.23878543078899384, -0.21772104501724243, -0.6534466743469238, 0.11079032719135284, 0.5904877781867981, 0.5492973327636719, 0.24479341506958008, -0.01603625901043415, -0.4463426172733307, -0.028813853859901428, 0.7260299324989319, 0.12272731214761734, 0.5486260652542114, -0.16130204498767853, -0.4599587321281433, 0.023880235850811005, -0.18496555089950562, -0.7687066197395325, -0.06320754438638687, -0.6204058527946472, -0.21722637116909027, -0.7708628177642822, -0.19064971804618835, -0.12306249886751175, 0.6180647015571594, 0.5080040097236633, 0.287384033203125, -0.2428518384695053, 0.17767223715782166, 0.09781656414270401, 0.3622707724571228, 0.44990599155426025, -0.41486504673957825, 0.05686207488179207, -0.48882338404655457, 0.6247565746307373, 0.9047542214393616, 0.1798127442598343, 0.132077157497406, -0.6008017659187317, 0.26527366042137146, -0.34184861183166504, 0.7114006876945496, 0.8402839303016663, -0.388803631067276, 0.5820357203483582, 0.1335458904504776, -0.14388951659202576, -0.008421912789344788, 0.5932708978652954, 0.6987468004226685, 0.29794418811798096, -0.3216077387332916, -0.5152384042739868, 0.11529752612113953, 0.04638402909040451, 0.04564344882965088, 0.8170943260192871, -0.18215312063694, -0.6381976008415222, -0.1447136551141739, 0.07130870968103409, 0.1591697633266449, 0.07925797253847122, 0.5467740297317505, 0.46013420820236206, 0.7287895679473877, -0.12183284014463425, -0.1472683846950531, 1.0238674879074097, -0.4469142258167267, -0.10170800238847733, -0.259766161441803, -0.11075662821531296, -0.47741299867630005, 1.0197839736938477, -0.033892709761857986, -1.0169658660888672, 0.7170572280883789, -0.11473232507705688, 0.15326325595378876, 0.1835315078496933, -0.8719103336334229, -0.12657929956912994, 0.3198244869709015, -0.358898401260376, 0.299256294965744, -0.11135225743055344, -0.0971115231513977, 0.015320940874516964, 0.26663944125175476, -0.7905009984970093, 0.3875817656517029, -0.19936256110668182, -0.2585057020187378, 0.5119531154632568, 0.18737564980983734, 0.06941638141870499, 0.5080349445343018, 0.11675091087818146, -0.306867778301239, -0.08053415268659592, 0.7521021366119385, -0.2074766904115677, -0.31782785058021545, -0.27689358592033386, -0.22207914292812347, -0.5822747945785522, -0.1345473676919937, 0.4117487370967865, -0.3148442208766937, -0.07256317138671875, 0.7038453817367554, -1.0766685009002686, -0.4397779405117035, -0.5613420009613037, -0.8672382235527039, 0.9554336071014404, -0.16243445873260498, -0.5726270079612732, -0.0649762898683548, -0.3588152825832367, -0.13648582994937897, -0.3235437273979187, -0.025515154004096985, -0.08434305340051651, 0.39258071780204773, 0.17380738258361816, -0.25164908170700073, 0.4354102313518524, -0.5457793474197388, 0.3047906458377838, -0.5498562455177307, -0.49481549859046936, -0.5165470838546753, -0.8201007843017578, -0.32082250714302063, 0.007431247737258673, 0.0926242396235466, -0.40810927748680115, 0.3736976683139801, 0.15282712876796722, 0.08585579693317413, 0.32416144013404846, -0.25118541717529297, -1.016942024230957, -0.010269282385706902, 0.5513582229614258, 0.49361249804496765, -0.2959541082382202, 0.07931645959615707, 0.7292559742927551, -0.06013587862253189, 0.520999550819397, 0.016357537358999252, -0.4169778823852539, 0.2850191593170166, -1.0694748163223267, 0.8090222477912903, -1.1846165657043457, -0.2378586083650589, -0.5575802326202393, -0.7297012209892273, 0.5459086894989014, -0.41649025678634644, 0.42179521918296814, -0.5632349848747253, -1.1412394046783447, -0.2291250079870224, -0.08115842938423157, -0.8571280241012573, 0.8262071013450623, -0.9383988380432129, -0.35627397894859314, -0.9485690593719482, 0.5933874249458313, -0.5891791582107544, 0.14558368921279907, 0.219190314412117, -0.011696016415953636, -0.36201176047325134, 0.43656158447265625, 0.3159809708595276, -0.2740718722343445, -0.7879375219345093, 0.029440999031066895, 0.507754385471344, -0.5006924271583557, -0.22271642088890076, 0.536316990852356, -0.6111313104629517, 0.8785895109176636, -0.3832564353942871, -0.24008165299892426, 0.1638868749141693, -0.20577587187290192, 0.5965704917907715, -0.521369993686676, 0.31052514910697937, 0.7355965971946716, 0.057370513677597046, -0.18408863246440887, -0.007661732379347086, -0.22788412868976593, -0.3848700523376465, -0.26117292046546936, -0.38968706130981445, 0.4151037931442261, 0.15660476684570312, 0.14462660253047943, -0.2275916039943695, 0.03099299781024456, -0.40284979343414307, -0.6407021880149841, 0.49333837628364563, 0.20091290771961212, 0.567076563835144, 0.012960102409124374, -0.8771993517875671, -0.27539777755737305, -1.0275901556015015, 0.3050077557563782, -0.014024279080331326, -0.059097032994031906, -0.39486077427864075, -0.35388389229774475, -0.4151836931705475, -0.8305411338806152, -0.21543359756469727, 0.5588082075119019, 0.2872689366340637, -0.021070005372166634, 1.2529634237289429, 0.6289196014404297, -0.12065554410219193, -0.014622164890170097, 0.029334699735045433, -0.3008677363395691, -0.18627354502677917, 0.6404378414154053, 0.3526430130004883, 0.3553306460380554, -0.3099918067455292, 0.48638004064559937, -0.2924022674560547, -0.17440277338027954, 0.8294313549995422, -1.0465281009674072, 0.1951497495174408, 0.9559323191642761, -0.017870711162686348, -0.34446683526039124, -0.5717446804046631, -0.9747229218482971, -0.5665269494056702, 0.33922380208969116, -0.512109100818634, 0.05361980199813843, -0.09302783012390137, -0.027866195887327194, -0.40386003255844116, 0.08622091263532639, 0.45629197359085083, 0.7781912684440613, -0.250826895236969, 0.06671463698148727, -0.5162654519081116, -0.1537342220544815, 1.2780760526657104, -0.11617543548345566, -0.756252110004425, 0.3151538670063019, 0.5472509264945984, -0.2708020806312561, -0.2525724768638611, 0.7150530219078064, -0.9690905809402466, 0.1767478585243225, 0.08195607364177704, 0.25778377056121826, 0.3843379616737366, 0.5033501386642456, -0.026299212127923965, -0.25728172063827515, -0.5541443228721619, -1.068949818611145, -0.1726074516773224, 0.006508890073746443, 0.2951275706291199, 0.22218479216098785, 0.02745112217962742, -0.06894771754741669, -0.3168283998966217, -0.27398961782455444, 0.12374327331781387, -1.3091970682144165, -0.17916709184646606, -1.3230087757110596, -1.0261000394821167, -0.8590657114982605, -0.16002637147903442, -0.03228563070297241, 0.8543174862861633, -0.7259260416030884, 0.666851818561554, -0.5408019423484802, 0.17516176402568817, -0.15737316012382507, 0.8679600358009338, -0.6290130019187927, -0.6995094418525696, -0.6502342820167542, 0.32849717140197754, 0.6851451992988586, -1.2252435684204102, -0.7593414187431335, -0.08830059319734573, 0.34781670570373535, 1.374739170074463, -0.6163725852966309, 0.4228161871433258, -0.3701794147491455, -1.149092674255371, 0.5755783915519714, 0.3476566672325134, -0.5249601006507874, 0.9423088431358337, -0.2886950969696045, 0.7087656259536743, 0.5271440148353577, 0.1267361044883728, -0.4313383102416992, 0.24322322010993958, -1.1243304014205933, 0.3494461476802826, 0.017723219469189644, 0.6974850296974182, 0.2725723385810852, -0.9326602220535278, 0.17189408838748932, -0.18955741822719574, -0.4573071300983429, -0.011910389177501202, 0.4433113932609558, 0.5875706076622009, -0.7151936888694763, 0.28468337655067444, -0.2449055016040802, 0.0973760336637497, 0.4380669891834259, 0.0236287172883749, -0.9305142164230347, 0.037061676383018494, -0.1395767629146576, -0.08347884565591812, 0.19227738678455353, -0.32359418272972107, 0.40465718507766724, -0.11098318547010422, 0.5490972995758057, 0.29947009682655334, -0.15920673310756683, 0.1642938256263733, -0.6144921183586121, 0.09616163372993469, -0.04823293536901474, 0.5871052742004395, -0.5997837781906128, 1.1906577348709106, 0.8331489562988281, 0.2360023856163025, 0.3907043933868408, -0.21011367440223694, -0.864439845085144, 0.37752825021743774, -0.23347610235214233, -1.20806086063385, 0.149260014295578, -0.0030493931844830513, 0.03378983587026596, 0.6671398878097534, -0.783094584941864, 0.2630402147769928, 0.49733588099479675, 1.37347412109375, 0.7384365797042847, -0.17622554302215576, -0.7782074809074402, 0.41018426418304443, -1.0800142288208008, -0.6931135058403015, -0.46377962827682495, 0.2741692364215851, -1.0162451267242432, -0.9907199144363403, -0.23328346014022827, 0.16406908631324768, -0.06807379424571991, -0.30843663215637207, 0.44327759742736816, 0.29506203532218933, -0.4151698350906372, -0.5314607620239258, -0.6452237963676453, 0.1784694492816925, -0.6826750040054321, 0.07044001668691635, 0.1814466118812561, -0.054882027208805084, -0.08785121887922287, -0.005745863541960716, 0.28341495990753174, 0.3969968855381012, 0.5418766140937805, 1.429383397102356, -0.2799531817436218, -0.3074042797088623, 0.22627851366996765, 0.2986479699611664, 0.2435683012008667, 1.1209803819656372, -0.9295331835746765, 0.3136427104473114, 0.9777805805206299, -0.12795627117156982, 1.1041353940963745, -0.0916045606136322, -0.41317152976989746, 0.2241131067276001, 0.6517277359962463, 0.0010213828645646572, -0.09400766342878342, 0.5136718153953552, 0.5512638092041016, 0.24720539152622223, -0.4839537441730499, -0.12362630665302277, -0.1300470381975174, 0.7814637422561646, 0.3951077163219452, 0.13182096183300018, -0.1633327603340149, -0.7189924120903015, 0.29949814081192017, 0.44847598671913147, 0.17315320670604706, -0.6772095561027527, -0.43461233377456665, 0.7038596272468567, 0.10266845673322678, -0.14146609604358673, -0.5146777033805847, 0.4299045205116272, -0.12031754106283188, 0.3458732068538666, -0.2674025893211365, 0.38102027773857117, 0.07941028475761414, 0.06871993839740753, 0.7977936863899231, -0.06037518009543419, 0.6017546653747559, 0.9275917410850525, -0.15088675916194916, -0.6751970648765564, 0.0792706310749054, -0.014903571456670761, -0.748329758644104, 0.2042667716741562, 0.012701609171926975, -0.6016111373901367, -0.45168009400367737, -0.6620689630508423, 0.2099730223417282, -0.5199053883552551, 0.20244371891021729, -0.3460899889469147, -0.25442448258399963, -0.5150542259216309, 0.2479349821805954, 0.1707911491394043, 0.28622955083847046, 0.5056675672531128, 0.7656569480895996, 0.15343651175498962, 0.704026460647583, 1.3103975057601929, 0.2725456953048706, 0.44269517064094543, -0.4047149121761322, 0.1877378523349762, 0.9885306358337402, 0.4269936680793762, -0.19895583391189575, 0.5569130778312683, -1.0657730102539062, 0.1508985161781311, -0.2003418505191803, -0.0613052174448967, -0.20116689801216125, -0.0027066769544035196, 0.40992361307144165, 0.41355133056640625, -0.16105784475803375, 0.023040931671857834, 0.7032995223999023, 0.3570518493652344, -0.28067561984062195, 0.2352549284696579, 0.6818780303001404, -1.3438866138458252, 0.07425942271947861, -1.7375537157058716, 0.6176838874816895, 0.3196999430656433, -0.08268074691295624, -0.3864544630050659, -0.5299898982048035, -0.31121882796287537, -0.6334843039512634, 0.009186899289488792, -0.5547546148300171, -0.30117908120155334, 1.2959448099136353, -0.5127267241477966, -0.0905628427863121, -0.6161147356033325, -0.6283833980560303, -0.5722384452819824, 0.9213771224021912, -0.09784846007823944, 0.10441713780164719, 0.5119743347167969, 0.6094292998313904, -0.8891011476516724, 0.6005088090896606, 0.9067413210868835, -0.6054959893226624, 0.5923515558242798, -0.47905001044273376, 0.26902034878730774, 0.662152886390686, 0.05016045644879341, -0.7478204965591431, 0.1836753636598587, 0.3314878046512604, 0.6785119771957397, -0.44944438338279724, 0.28979480266571045, -0.8089985847473145, -0.7380892038345337, -0.8744412064552307, 0.3668818771839142, -0.01647309400141239, -0.1699572056531906, -0.23681345582008362, -0.8623476624488831, 4.102370738983154, 0.3388725519180298, 0.5462658405303955, 0.29651328921318054, 0.9366502165794373, 1.281212568283081, -0.003002036828547716, 0.10485485941171646, 0.26219964027404785, -0.9479895830154419, -0.4715980291366577, 0.16360315680503845, -0.3745526075363159, -0.22752253711223602, -0.28909072279930115, 0.37536904215812683, -0.5666426420211792, -0.3723350763320923, -0.2168232947587967, 0.32363754510879517, -1.0387545824050903, -0.16666725277900696, 0.42059841752052307, -0.15621033310890198, 0.44414934515953064, 0.5545436143875122, -0.13503354787826538, -0.623634934425354, -0.4048611521720886, -0.049455419182777405, -0.22504371404647827, -0.5980653166770935, 0.13237282633781433, -0.16746081411838531, -1.158947229385376, 0.7823458909988403, -0.40838417410850525, -0.3230735957622528, 0.6518624424934387, -0.4977456033229828, 0.09326270967721939, -0.5042906999588013, 0.2093624621629715, -0.1742871105670929, 0.19263072311878204, 1.1779321432113647, 0.1663874387741089, 0.5603395700454712, 0.6046596169471741, -1.0758886337280273, -0.46118271350860596, 0.06893713027238846, 0.5567868947982788, -0.24938145279884338, -0.2652168273925781, -0.4435395896434784, -0.007880196906626225, -0.45070862770080566, 0.072792649269104, 0.12339020520448685, 0.35166803002357483, -0.6276018619537354, 0.1846800148487091, 0.23040136694908142, 0.3367311954498291, 0.1756615787744522, 0.5174274444580078, 0.005173083394765854, 0.13559189438819885, 0.20284175872802734, -0.7414171695709229, 0.08383439481258392, -0.7178353071212769, -0.23813053965568542, -0.0931607037782669, 0.0023911800235509872, -0.1612776666879654, 0.18589076399803162, 0.01876004971563816, 0.6796684861183167, -0.4648438096046448, -0.042145080864429474, 0.03879031911492348, 0.07513399422168732, -0.19645428657531738, 0.4950629472732544, 0.2877800464630127, 0.392098993062973, -0.3837512731552124, 0.3736458718776703, -0.37056052684783936, 0.4187728464603424, -0.4591902792453766, 0.8494558334350586, -0.5786375403404236 ]
What can we learn from the study of non-perturbative quantum general relativity?
I attempt to answer the question of the title by giving an annotated list of the major results achieved, over the last six years, in the program to construct quantum general relativity using the Ashtekar variables and the loop representation. A summary of the key open problems is also included. Also included are expositions of several new results including the construction of spatially diffeomorphism invariant observables constructed by coupling general relativity to matter fields.
Lee Smolin
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211019
gr-qc/9211020
[ -0.037633270025253296, 0.2345626801252365, 0.34542280435562134, 0.19364033639431, -0.029650047421455383, -0.3480245769023895, -0.17711937427520752, -0.24277634918689728, -0.7628872990608215, 1.9841712713241577, 0.36564022302627563, -0.5821215510368347, 0.2560591399669647, -1.058349370956421, -0.3949721157550812, 0.19915060698986053, -0.7446503043174744, -0.766007661819458, -1.5025484561920166, 0.6151662468910217, -0.13346683979034424, -0.027094854041934013, -1.1655343770980835, -0.5958386659622192, -0.4585815966129303, 0.9015993475914001, -0.023054132238030434, 0.030627766624093056, 1.0113658905029297, 0.9344673752784729, 0.5093441009521484, -0.33448681235313416, -0.2964356243610382, -0.586245596408844, -0.7010520696640015, 0.551947832107544, 0.009550423361361027, -0.25787606835365295, 0.4482300281524658, -0.8341497778892517, 0.6122060418128967, 0.08754269033670425, 0.6426089406013489, -0.3464525043964386, -0.5303778052330017, 0.13337408006191254, 0.3171146512031555, -0.34639379382133484, 0.2028140276670456, -0.8639554381370544, -0.07685144245624542, -0.010367789305746555, 0.24217447638511658, -0.6027023792266846, 0.45993202924728394, -0.3422979712486267, 0.04184828698635101, -0.07807222008705139, 0.03238146752119064, 0.1764957159757614, 0.38210955262184143, 0.8020728826522827, 0.5584549903869629, -1.2149882316589355, 0.2578442692756653, 1.0929713249206543, -0.3121565282344818, 1.0482966899871826, -0.02158213220536709, -0.5823174715042114, -0.21258433163166046, -0.2729129195213318, -0.03791911527514458, -0.0781276673078537, -0.7077009677886963, 0.5877090692520142, -0.34155046939849854, -0.2918797433376312, -0.6464474201202393, -0.34312859177589417, -0.4698570668697357, -0.13688769936561584, 0.49278733134269714, -0.02538454905152321, -0.07212414592504501, -0.8207373023033142, 0.044785480946302414, -0.6455016136169434, 0.6149460673332214, 0.26770442724227905, 0.04339294135570526, 0.21865856647491455, -0.20344386994838715, 0.19307610392570496, 0.6894470453262329, 0.5063418745994568, -0.23450620472431183, 0.06381712853908539, -0.0007206344744190574, 0.49898242950439453, -0.09880204498767853, 0.5687189698219299, 0.18711358308792114, -0.2035829871892929, -0.7407182455062866, 1.058581829071045, -0.12649862468242645, 0.5292714238166809, -0.14640729129314423, -0.929945170879364, -0.0028191765304654837, 0.4327833652496338, 0.19644398987293243, 0.7531694173812866, 0.36328354477882385, 1.098366618156433, -0.08011494576931, -0.14775072038173676, -0.7753292918205261, -0.5627080202102661, 0.23376663029193878, 0.7330939173698425, 0.29214024543762207, 0.5886560678482056, 0.018360329791903496, -0.6520381569862366, 0.36354637145996094, 0.5106567740440369, -0.7044976353645325, 0.6348353028297424, 0.3199898600578308, -0.7673130631446838, -0.1675305813550949, 0.5250450372695923, 0.4308793544769287, 0.38677918910980225, 0.33878159523010254, 0.2574865221977234, 0.09403852373361588, -0.24390821158885956, 0.20482976734638214, -0.5970494747161865, 0.11911536753177643, 0.7875169515609741, -1.0607935190200806, 0.029221711680293083, -0.2987963855266571, 0.0028540731873363256, -0.29793134331703186, 0.007238619029521942, -0.12704701721668243, 0.16829878091812134, 0.4808591604232788, 0.7175378799438477, 0.12194637954235077, 0.024456288665533066, -1.2114572525024414, 0.05824553221464157, -0.41737669706344604, -0.5300369262695312, 0.7096896767616272, 0.40510401129722595, 0.24965697526931763, 0.37621888518333435, -0.7394210696220398, 0.40782496333122253, -1.016288161277771, -1.048682451248169, 0.37857964634895325, -0.08190575242042542, -0.01651550456881523, -0.08525437116622925, 0.1392829269170761, 0.6761614084243774, 0.8623014688491821, 0.10371386259794235, 0.11656270921230316, -0.3276967406272888, 0.011436651460826397, -0.06177540868520737, 0.09104813635349274, -0.2379542887210846, 0.2707176208496094, 0.44140222668647766, -0.35764163732528687, -0.8186538219451904, 0.2558131217956543, -0.5359547138214111, 0.4932534098625183, 0.3093573749065399, 0.07124420255422592, 0.5855035185813904, -1.2986083030700684, 0.8549579977989197, -0.8764048218727112, -0.34214746952056885, -0.8691805005073547, -0.1244622990489006, 0.025445930659770966, -0.6879653930664062, -0.10619547963142395, 0.3818259835243225, -0.5712139010429382, 0.7546260952949524, -1.340401530265808, 0.05079537630081177, 0.3679857552051544, 0.6799143552780151, -0.5829695463180542, -0.0923803448677063, 0.7029793858528137, -0.7231752276420593, -0.38883325457572937, -0.057498667389154434, 0.2514931857585907, 0.31340503692626953, -0.1962747871875763, 0.8404732346534729, 0.2028115689754486, -0.4899236857891083, 0.7498598098754883, 0.12449918687343597, 0.30540403723716736, 0.32591238617897034, -0.3038760721683502, -0.46350398659706116, -0.12458547204732895, 0.5039041638374329, 0.29657238721847534, 0.36223146319389343, 0.27382349967956543, 0.16024187207221985, -0.08648676425218582, -0.001460678642615676, 0.3859357237815857, 0.019944731146097183, 0.5132800340652466, 1.07086980342865, -0.8908756971359253, -0.4047645032405853, 0.4559050500392914, 0.22532328963279724, 0.3365732431411743, 0.3708183169364929, -1.093509316444397, 0.1966073215007782, 0.27855217456817627, 0.0018752326723188162, -0.4337656497955322, 0.4398554265499115, -0.6784231066703796, 0.23392587900161743, 0.5675393342971802, 0.10147181153297424, -1.5338640213012695, 0.30331888794898987, 0.1429879367351532, 0.40561747550964355, 0.2510531544685364, -0.8563778400421143, -0.21672509610652924, 0.5367400050163269, -0.07879635691642761, -0.6106031537055969, -0.7316566109657288, 0.17555442452430725, -0.744809627532959, 0.6639166474342346, 0.88287752866745, -0.622028648853302, -0.6797453761100769, -0.16036558151245117, -0.21647481620311737, -0.13684456050395966, -0.2198011577129364, -0.3231038451194763, 0.3915937840938568, -0.765454888343811, 0.8597992658615112, 0.9121332764625549, -0.02730659209191799, -0.2345043420791626, 0.5988752841949463, 0.5855097770690918, -0.2952086627483368, -0.1523868888616562, -1.046791434288025, 0.39046233892440796, -1.044007658958435, 0.32511118054389954, -0.1278357356786728, -0.37136149406433105, -0.29344338178634644, -0.24081598222255707, 0.3258518576622009, 0.431777685880661, -0.25419750809669495, 0.4056868255138397, -0.24705912172794342, -0.6097047328948975, 1.1265052556991577, 0.4710407853126526, -0.4029691219329834, 0.3502492308616638, -1.2960536479949951, 0.6467682123184204, -0.4143880307674408, -0.2891263961791992, 0.6753556132316589, 0.08283543586730957, -0.5432920455932617, 0.506046712398529, -0.4784122407436371, 0.4494800865650177, 0.09485212713479996, 0.599588930606842, 0.5152735710144043, 0.07119441032409668, -0.04979335144162178, -0.4002571702003479, -0.3883953392505646, -0.5571513175964355, 0.4295368194580078, -0.6736770272254944, 0.4547967314720154, 0.3418186604976654, 0.949937641620636, -0.7801505923271179, 0.38628658652305603, -1.0579235553741455, -1.141472578048706, 0.45033377408981323, -0.6016943454742432, -0.12247979640960693, 0.15289975702762604, 0.27756786346435547, -0.9154953360557556, -0.423576295375824, -0.6208582520484924, 0.640762448310852, 0.4920292794704437, -0.07881612330675125, 0.44614464044570923, 0.5105082392692566, 0.2004149854183197, 0.06960869580507278, 0.8640456795692444, -0.14753200113773346, -0.07433582842350006, 0.32658761739730835, 0.043557289987802505, 0.17311236262321472, -0.20562930405139923, -0.1581520140171051, -0.196341872215271, 0.06239214166998863, -0.24665671586990356, -0.5083874464035034, -0.7986649870872498, -0.7232130169868469, 0.23229892551898956, 0.4269089698791504, 0.2173238843679428, -0.24178162217140198, -0.46825021505355835, 0.47800448536872864, 0.04505043849349022, 0.13798335194587708, 0.39035719633102417, -0.7380915880203247, 0.12820088863372803, 0.5497823357582092, -0.149830624461174, -0.37192463874816895, -0.3322185277938843, 0.5377249717712402, 0.32188576459884644, -0.005324065685272217, 0.40912148356437683, -0.35937049984931946, -0.2000943273305893, -0.5753853917121887, 0.9611976742744446, 0.07916457206010818, 0.6001155972480774, -0.4008167088031769, -0.7031568884849548, 0.23859265446662903, -0.25775012373924255, -0.698066234588623, 0.03668185696005821, -0.5099673271179199, -0.16351620852947235, -0.4316389262676239, -0.3586820065975189, 0.32809537649154663, 0.3225882351398468, 0.6694296598434448, 0.15635298192501068, 0.015796564519405365, 0.2514009475708008, -0.3590465188026428, -0.5835254788398743, 0.5721304416656494, -0.16177266836166382, -0.08539378643035889, -0.5925613045692444, 0.5398960113525391, 0.3721901774406433, 0.46789875626564026, 0.3499806821346283, -0.11954513192176819, 0.2711206376552582, -0.4433610141277313, 0.7781975269317627, -0.029404746368527412, -0.17505647242069244, 0.11079001426696777, 0.85806804895401, -0.03176020458340645, -0.443092405796051, 0.8651400804519653, 0.5638778209686279, 0.15216441452503204, -0.15041497349739075, -0.9597947001457214, 0.4163341224193573, -0.2690810263156891, 0.07758884876966476, 0.7114478349685669, -0.1811421662569046, -0.9538671970367432, -0.1675901561975479, 0.04492969065904617, 0.39111363887786865, 0.15001846849918365, 0.9452325701713562, 0.38237902522087097, 0.5206059813499451, -0.005237042438238859, 0.09311752766370773, 0.7065234184265137, -0.5840063095092773, -0.21709699928760529, 0.006697535049170256, 0.06623172760009766, -0.12629978358745575, 0.17641380429267883, -0.5822958946228027, -0.9988973736763, -0.4006984233856201, -0.38482552766799927, 0.5350003838539124, -0.42334648966789246, -0.49107682704925537, 0.2149263471364975, 0.0017662777099758387, -0.1690300554037094, 0.1308363825082779, -0.10770778357982635, -0.07310923933982849, 0.14945457875728607, 0.1253300905227661, -0.32402247190475464, -0.37002766132354736, -0.09693975746631622, -0.17894501984119415, 1.0166151523590088, 0.5192455649375916, 0.07671098411083221, 0.443242609500885, 0.42228519916534424, -0.23751889169216156, 0.012887396849691868, 0.2270684540271759, 0.12004885822534561, -0.6816136240959167, -0.05369359254837036, -0.24860939383506775, -0.4172922968864441, 0.35359299182891846, 0.32966482639312744, -0.7886658906936646, 0.4317969083786011, -0.3451021909713745, -0.7416834235191345, -0.17451438307762146, -0.20757688581943512, 0.09454312175512314, 0.6320482492446899, -0.4357020854949951, -0.21654260158538818, -0.21325643360614777, -0.34651973843574524, -0.21609489619731903, -0.2964783012866974, -0.26279520988464355, -0.6561107635498047, 0.014530890621244907, 0.07720692455768585, -0.06764224916696548, 0.28860512375831604, -0.6265801787376404, 0.684283971786499, -0.33790332078933716, -0.28436341881752014, -0.47746899724006653, -0.013919266872107983, -0.13141398131847382, -0.022200807929039, 0.4974825978279114, -0.4403933584690094, 0.27224960923194885, -0.17620375752449036, 0.6234712600708008, 0.49842512607574463, -0.46416670083999634, -0.5583692193031311, -0.09863891452550888, 0.04294397681951523, 0.6487631797790527, -0.42088583111763, -0.00005582904850598425, 0.22556304931640625, -0.7426101565361023, 0.25757765769958496, -0.5398508310317993, -0.7549365162849426, 0.4628859758377075, -0.9428563117980957, 0.3694210648536682, -0.8856672048568726, 0.030883509665727615, -0.031848661601543427, -0.10375139862298965, 0.029174860566854477, 0.600706934928894, -0.315775066614151, -1.0772044658660889, -0.04016432538628578, -0.368384450674057, 0.15578797459602356, -0.6673494577407837, 0.0064260573126375675, -0.3196655511856079, -0.09617514908313751, -0.7779664397239685, 1.3104181289672852, -0.42253807187080383, -0.14960886538028717, 0.08035273104906082, -0.0831373855471611, -0.46342507004737854, 0.32793164253234863, -0.06960982829332352, -0.00983740109950304, -0.31536224484443665, 0.5515241026878357, 0.0517311617732048, 0.3650670051574707, -0.614962637424469, 0.5103467106819153, -0.24374334514141083, 0.7946903109550476, -0.5989311933517456, -0.2812696397304535, -0.029197072610259056, 0.23961862921714783, 0.9053491353988647, -0.21901777386665344, 0.6673679947853088, 0.7970467805862427, 0.501633882522583, 0.31510376930236816, -0.13563916087150574, -0.12340201437473297, 0.24032410979270935, -1.153894066810608, -0.3231959640979767, 0.26814472675323486, 0.9203864932060242, -0.17740999162197113, -0.24573329091072083, -0.1843942254781723, -0.514572262763977, -0.13242903351783752, 0.3457920253276825, -0.014406656846404076, -0.09594673663377762, 0.1865621656179428, -0.5605565905570984, 0.3001585006713867, -0.4320100247859955, 0.0029974624048918486, 0.4660145044326782, -0.10684765875339508, -0.1562734693288803, -0.507392406463623, -0.37472015619277954, -0.891283392906189, -0.49040496349334717, 0.5520837903022766, 1.1622616052627563, -0.15055637061595917, 1.0426689386367798, -0.3184850513935089, -0.16382987797260284, -0.529556155204773, -0.08629608154296875, 0.8047912120819092, -0.18374256789684296, 0.23046697676181793, 0.4654974639415741, 0.35675543546676636, 0.1674450933933258, 0.35812219977378845, -1.0366946458816528, 0.09054400771856308, 0.8356063961982727, -0.04561426490545273, -0.49305960536003113, 0.34259435534477234, 0.24561059474945068, -0.11510694772005081, -1.112494945526123, -1.222963571548462, -0.435705304145813, 0.7081266045570374, -0.7552491426467896, -0.2612367868423462, -0.0818614512681961, -0.023164724931120872, -0.06053200364112854, 0.3302641212940216, 0.8869044780731201, 0.4010389447212219, 0.24069009721279144, -0.47618407011032104, -0.30908825993537903, -0.06669757515192032, 1.447806715965271, -0.17776723206043243, -0.8307898640632629, 0.0046930559910833836, -0.32415053248405457, -0.46740928292274475, -0.18823005259037018, 0.5531551837921143, -0.7297715544700623, 0.575124204158783, -0.24331636726856232, 0.07792044430971146, -0.05291401594877243, 0.1367817521095276, -0.08211501687765121, 0.06626179814338684, -0.7958577871322632, -0.7981120944023132, -0.31498730182647705, 0.21958798170089722, 0.35625702142715454, 0.6441991925239563, 0.027561575174331665, -0.12534530460834503, -0.4168909788131714, -0.535111665725708, -0.043667566031217575, -0.34207916259765625, -0.18466384708881378, -0.786521315574646, -0.46929532289505005, -1.2431849241256714, -0.42106878757476807, -0.04081040993332863, -0.09118533879518509, -0.4056643545627594, 0.5383505821228027, -0.05839133262634277, -0.09618697315454483, 0.2676757276058197, 0.5718269348144531, -0.25788846611976624, -0.6089493632316589, -1.0504999160766602, 0.21957308053970337, 0.16510945558547974, -0.7487891316413879, -0.3879576027393341, 0.033004846423864365, 0.009422512724995613, 0.8128748536109924, -0.38367170095443726, 1.1042673587799072, -0.2976780831813812, -0.7008990049362183, 0.13590370118618011, 0.3501422703266144, -0.9466089606285095, 1.1823198795318604, -0.4882885813713074, 0.6168379187583923, 0.49629345536231995, -0.2510921061038971, 0.0736595168709755, -0.17193159461021423, -0.9907343983650208, 0.41924571990966797, -0.12273190170526505, 0.4832810163497925, 0.6321927905082703, -0.7427248358726501, -0.07978116720914841, 0.2637980878353119, -1.051046371459961, -0.2879782021045685, -0.5775655508041382, 0.6803728342056274, -0.10583533346652985, 0.08029386401176453, 0.24137087166309357, 0.06535261869430542, -0.10501817613840103, 0.684069037437439, -0.9150542616844177, -0.17827583849430084, 0.08766071498394012, 0.467511385679245, -0.42817559838294983, -0.47694024443626404, 0.2553812861442566, -0.3343564569950104, 0.7868732213973999, -0.03186289966106415, -0.18365247547626495, 0.2530021667480469, 0.019735116511583328, -0.4336928725242615, -0.28953781723976135, -0.026697324588894844, -0.7082343101501465, 0.6035527586936951, -0.036087311804294586, 0.2964394688606262, 0.24101969599723816, -0.38056817650794983, -0.9499746561050415, 0.3560526967048645, 0.0019194220658391714, -0.4098793864250183, 0.026261502876877785, -0.1633390188217163, -0.4868622422218323, 0.023362252861261368, -0.5270781517028809, 0.02294541522860527, -0.37204569578170776, 0.5990872979164124, 0.887661874294281, 0.3629240095615387, 0.06905565410852432, 0.2942943572998047, -0.5793241858482361, -0.6348963975906372, -0.4826706349849701, -0.2206857055425644, -0.3391513526439667, -0.8483704924583435, -0.3512266278266907, 0.4763961732387543, -0.5338531732559204, -0.08875550329685211, 0.09232059866189957, -0.5669379234313965, -0.23666785657405853, 0.04445357248187065, -0.03636014461517334, -0.18450358510017395, -0.2860168516635895, 0.34016546607017517, 0.34400177001953125, -0.4996006488800049, 0.5989552736282349, -0.4969135522842407, 0.6510040760040283, -0.1352176070213318, -0.25720471143722534, 0.8665693402290344, 0.1465943455696106, -0.23430737853050232, 0.19210955500602722, 0.212980717420578, 0.38067275285720825, 0.8158425688743591, -0.2751550078392029, -0.25204339623451233, 0.3522319495677948, -0.13366444408893585, 0.6956540942192078, 0.10044986754655838, -0.01636919379234314, -0.03580327704548836, 0.23627108335494995, 0.4488365352153778, -0.48668721318244934, 0.15572787821292877, 0.004181619267910719, 0.10067497193813324, -0.4225156903266907, 0.16419565677642822, -0.44449126720428467, 0.3074586093425751, 0.4126000702381134, 0.18765826523303986, 0.0328175313770771, -0.9759499430656433, -0.351079523563385, -0.024770895019173622, -0.3108137547969818, -0.4707303047180176, -0.21422964334487915, 0.25119858980178833, 0.12592926621437073, 0.38080960512161255, -0.043347425758838654, 0.9193981289863586, 0.19397857785224915, 0.45260095596313477, -0.41899287700653076, 0.3531677722930908, 0.6413271427154541, 0.7542102932929993, 1.0637298822402954, 0.5550553202629089, 0.5364895462989807, 1.0056310892105103, -0.126453697681427, -0.367289662361145, 0.19077906012535095, 0.14241017401218414, -1.1994516849517822, -0.13081414997577667, -0.1181546151638031, 0.3529239892959595, -0.061316296458244324, -1.2204878330230713, -0.42637529969215393, -0.5365488529205322, 0.22778728604316711, 0.5216473937034607, -0.475003182888031, 0.6045452952384949, 0.361055463552475, 0.1800367832183838, 0.3343462347984314, 0.45529264211654663, -0.130611851811409, -0.4014875292778015, 0.8356589674949646, 0.8298435211181641, 0.0069327703677117825, 0.40910467505455017, -0.5078608393669128, -0.3194332420825958, 0.24508969485759735, 0.44309452176094055, -0.4421887695789337, 0.6567142009735107, 0.034392744302749634, -0.08972039818763733, -0.11792365461587906, 0.11983360350131989, -0.26668623089790344, 0.1604977548122406, 0.5035936236381531, 0.5009555220603943, -0.18599958717823029, -0.104839026927948, 0.6700090169906616, 0.9169912934303284, -0.28616756200790405, -0.5020923018455505, -0.08523735404014587, -0.5822004079818726, 0.12528204917907715, -0.9589909315109253, 0.6659225821495056, 0.0765267014503479, 0.2967076599597931, -0.5838803648948669, 0.01317544560879469, -0.8017893433570862, -0.981250524520874, -0.11264283955097198, -0.17307952046394348, 0.5665401816368103, 0.8351413607597351, 0.31202319264411926, 0.14883339405059814, -0.5135291218757629, -0.10067509114742279, 0.16038626432418823, 1.2189357280731201, -0.18855924904346466, -0.23546545207500458, 0.6150915622711182, 0.0067801708355546, -0.6295613646507263, 0.9865938425064087, 0.9121607542037964, -0.2549048066139221, 0.5657824873924255, -0.5277358293533325, 0.17081879079341888, -0.20119166374206543, -0.6070184111595154, 0.11691451072692871, 0.09947852045297623, 0.5018053650856018, 0.31759318709373474, -0.22542548179626465, 0.5223373770713806, -0.3252517879009247, -1.0159894227981567, -0.07340272516012192, 0.3460906744003296, 0.44066861271858215, -0.4161868989467621, 0.401166707277298, -0.49089348316192627, 4.264026165008545, 0.5741004347801208, 0.8950408101081848, 0.04651860147714615, 0.6820524334907532, 1.0844039916992188, -0.004318244755268097, 0.027800850570201874, 0.22934047877788544, -0.4778176248073578, -0.009386390447616577, 0.22448846697807312, 0.1786651611328125, -0.15837258100509644, -0.07732606679201126, 0.5254115462303162, 0.024987539276480675, 0.2196938842535019, -0.42397555708885193, -0.46595504879951477, -1.3035345077514648, 0.08295919001102448, -0.21362090110778809, -0.4611527919769287, 0.4741102159023285, 0.4783613383769989, 0.38721856474876404, -0.2975479066371918, -0.3985868990421295, -0.21570932865142822, -0.8647170066833496, -0.2299770712852478, -0.030984822660684586, -0.2027951180934906, -1.377896785736084, 0.5503091216087341, 0.31761541962623596, 0.14316178858280182, 0.6807775497436523, -0.4686952531337738, 0.0036922460421919823, -0.8857901692390442, 0.048055499792099, 0.21620003879070282, -0.5657370090484619, 0.61093670129776, 1.1205328702926636, 0.5129489302635193, 0.33818867802619934, -0.3064609467983246, 0.5618754625320435, 0.6190574169158936, 0.5331562757492065, 0.19380594789981842, -1.1916234493255615, -0.05402369424700737, -0.3214367628097534, -0.0019331681542098522, 0.35652175545692444, -0.05601981282234192, 0.8129268288612366, -0.1897469162940979, -0.3447123169898987, -0.07673130184412003, 0.17336614429950714, 0.2381419986486435, 0.5547419190406799, 0.6275798678398132, -0.597352921962738, -0.25637513399124146, -0.3247491121292114, 0.054108742624521255, -0.9570484757423401, -0.1998671293258667, 0.24944166839122772, 0.22004172205924988, -0.26298055052757263, 0.5840919017791748, -0.3800584077835083, 0.03887183964252472, -0.28227707743644714, -0.41061580181121826, 0.04067846015095711, 0.6731096506118774, 0.02633204683661461, 0.1265157014131546, 0.355207622051239, -0.22690525650978088, -0.06666789948940277, 0.47719281911849976, -0.05591748282313347, 0.49224257469177246, 0.2063276320695877, 0.06871218234300613, -0.2643675208091736 ]
Superluminary Universe: A Possible Solution to the Initial Value Problem in Cosmology
The spontaneous breaking of local Lorentz invariance in the early Universe, associated with a first order phase transition at a critical time $t_c$, generates a large increase in the speed of light and a superluminary communication of information occurs, allowing all regions in the Universe to be causally connected. This solves the horizon problem, leads to a mechanism of monopole suppression in cosmology and can resolve the flatness problem. After the critical time $t_c$, local Lorentz (and diffeomorphism) invariance is restored and light travels at its presently measured speed. The kinematical and dynamical aspects of the generation of quantum fluctuations in the superluminary Universe are investigated. A scale invariant prediction for the fluctuation density amplitude is obtained.
J. W. Moffat
gr-qc astro-ph hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211020
gr-qc/9211021
[ 0.2489071935415268, 0.42481786012649536, 0.36699607968330383, 0.3780766725540161, -0.28639650344848633, 0.18747712671756744, -0.6947085857391357, -0.28917092084884644, -0.8529333472251892, 1.412480354309082, -0.12257704138755798, -0.6162002682685852, -0.5696561336517334, -0.4902883470058441, 0.10863955318927765, 0.08852000534534454, -0.2672264873981476, -0.12185391783714294, -1.0256409645080566, 0.4130132496356964, -0.31429335474967957, 0.7267314195632935, -1.137898564338684, -0.8953273296356201, -0.6743210554122925, 1.1780202388763428, 0.35222771763801575, 0.21102800965309143, 0.8139269351959229, 0.6964029669761658, -0.07623855024576187, -0.03182913362979889, 0.241581991314888, -0.06369339674711227, -0.607907772064209, 0.2585882544517517, -0.1632595956325531, 0.30533263087272644, 1.073021411895752, -0.32795900106430054, 0.4281519055366516, 0.1298007220029831, 0.09310426563024521, 0.2547149658203125, -0.8150747418403625, -0.0391092374920845, -0.42169034481048584, 0.4162440001964569, 0.6225680708885193, -0.48713505268096924, 0.17806492745876312, -0.13851256668567657, 0.3547844886779785, -1.2355934381484985, 0.39212241768836975, 0.05810670182108879, 0.49881455302238464, 0.6700595021247864, -0.37056607007980347, -0.0983586236834526, 0.4100262224674225, 0.3018999993801117, 0.6590889692306519, -0.7304644584655762, 0.3637761175632477, 1.4456145763397217, 0.1173912063241005, -0.1035981997847557, -0.04670335724949837, -0.6706902384757996, 0.13355350494384766, -0.2200508862733841, -0.2641095221042633, 0.30216774344444275, -0.13197286427021027, 0.7870625257492065, -0.5261354446411133, 0.016146792098879814, -1.2555285692214966, -0.4254041016101837, 0.168477863073349, -0.105342797935009, -0.33048951625823975, 0.2774244248867035, 0.3758259415626526, -0.43207088112831116, 0.4149520695209503, -0.15620115399360657, 0.3724610507488251, 0.4425431787967682, -0.2667466402053833, 0.4973989427089691, -0.5988941192626953, 0.3488076627254486, 0.498514860868454, 0.5687129497528076, -0.4788022041320801, 0.9694526195526123, 0.07282169908285141, 0.45061245560646057, -0.2339867800474167, 0.6071213483810425, -0.12504363059997559, 0.4523906707763672, -0.7246460914611816, 0.7778286933898926, 0.3846535086631775, 0.8453165292739868, -0.4349026381969452, -0.7226699590682983, -0.041298944503068924, -0.346854031085968, 1.1512081623077393, 0.4436107277870178, 0.48963451385498047, 0.24902209639549255, -0.16100072860717773, 0.07479032129049301, -0.8920680284500122, -0.4744434356689453, 0.15178807079792023, 0.5116679668426514, 0.3112047612667084, 0.5870664715766907, -0.5871272683143616, -0.31782904267311096, -0.6301109194755554, 0.4282325506210327, -0.44856101274490356, 0.015234648250043392, -0.1412864327430725, -0.6689887642860413, -0.09438017755746841, 0.9732081890106201, -0.004813757725059986, -0.09911376982927322, 0.12286023050546646, 0.742874264717102, -0.9705973863601685, -0.9704156517982483, 0.29483291506767273, -0.6993483901023865, -0.18262995779514313, 1.1473628282546997, -1.1847567558288574, 0.009151768870651722, -0.03460041061043739, 0.5117963552474976, -0.24366946518421173, 0.14885377883911133, -0.3465328812599182, 0.08596847206354141, 0.21036726236343384, 0.38725340366363525, -0.08694478869438171, -0.12284955382347107, -1.365597128868103, 0.14916950464248657, 0.11380020529031754, -0.7978048324584961, 0.35593658685684204, -0.11502496898174286, 0.05723633989691734, 0.8071582913398743, -0.6681508421897888, 0.313425213098526, -0.7733075022697449, -0.05689661577343941, 0.3171471953392029, -0.025845587253570557, -0.40016332268714905, 0.5863843560218811, -0.25630661845207214, 0.5930360555648804, 0.46636253595352173, 0.220298171043396, 0.3848617970943451, -0.4434621334075928, -0.34155556559562683, 0.7411077618598938, 0.5997063517570496, -1.1556200981140137, 0.294646292924881, 0.7068148255348206, -0.6942654848098755, -0.1497717797756195, 0.288553386926651, -0.4472437798976898, 0.7995835542678833, -0.3543901741504669, -1.2209463119506836, 0.8663604259490967, -0.925711452960968, 0.43199074268341064, -0.9010736346244812, 0.41987359523773193, -1.020289659500122, -0.5091245174407959, -0.2914360463619232, -0.7681247591972351, 0.7021002173423767, 0.015818355605006218, -0.8985373973846436, 0.6741037964820862, -1.0228211879730225, -0.21671262383460999, 0.3983721137046814, 0.5867834687232971, -1.1619220972061157, 0.07184557616710663, 0.4580642879009247, -0.4656082093715668, 0.2737028896808624, -0.11405075341463089, 0.12663960456848145, -0.033279359340667725, -0.32636478543281555, 0.2587989866733551, 0.36140602827072144, 0.03134462237358093, 0.05434464290738106, -0.21464863419532776, 0.8685792684555054, 1.1789063215255737, 0.15781955420970917, -0.5209532976150513, 0.8372889161109924, 0.7691442370414734, -0.6305845379829407, 0.4226418733596802, -0.16688422858715057, -0.09928514808416367, 0.6089520454406738, 0.6553337574005127, 0.2093699872493744, -0.3312388062477112, 0.6681534647941589, 0.4460609555244446, -0.2967867851257324, -0.13170449435710907, -0.053034137934446335, 0.19764602184295654, 0.07860861718654633, 0.24627380073070526, -1.1185978651046753, 0.3591255843639374, 0.37781989574432373, -0.19468173384666443, 0.45830202102661133, 0.5341865420341492, -0.9742065668106079, 0.3268623948097229, 0.35898399353027344, 0.24372315406799316, -1.0785940885543823, 0.20880739390850067, 0.10082048922777176, 0.5426589846611023, 0.4492722749710083, -0.3158726990222931, -0.3829178810119629, 0.18804754316806793, -0.23624670505523682, -0.5619946718215942, 0.2299162745475769, -0.20692887902259827, -0.6122779846191406, 0.5752300024032593, 0.7831256985664368, -0.7691194415092468, -0.710447371006012, 0.36821115016937256, -0.11144819110631943, 0.18649938702583313, -0.47469303011894226, 0.3046884834766388, -0.06129658594727516, -0.4700068533420563, -0.07274559885263443, 0.21923789381980896, -0.17869094014167786, 0.14707238972187042, -0.20302923023700714, -0.12234418839216232, -0.03121206723153591, 0.05734829604625702, -0.8603022694587708, 0.14680048823356628, -1.074730634689331, 0.22158263623714447, 0.007927955128252506, -0.2396850436925888, -0.37723156809806824, -0.34338250756263733, 0.2582761347293854, 0.2748992443084717, -0.4718745946884155, 0.3560638427734375, -0.01000580657273531, -0.3850402235984802, 0.9857677817344666, 0.4531399607658386, -0.27743104100227356, 0.042116548866033554, -1.1879802942276, 0.9271889328956604, 0.1576724797487259, -0.1344154179096222, 0.6476534008979797, -0.17877574265003204, -0.7659024596214294, 0.66306072473526, 0.49225714802742004, 0.6298570036888123, -0.12374822050333023, -0.0006447157356888056, 0.40130895376205444, 0.079571932554245, -0.09055846184492111, -0.15640640258789062, -0.7143219113349915, -0.9386076927185059, 0.9210317134857178, -0.4454977512359619, 0.588043749332428, 0.5220262408256531, 0.42941203713417053, -1.068862795829773, 0.36802273988723755, -0.9964646100997925, -0.6257646679878235, -0.034234851598739624, 0.11303779482841492, 0.3448381721973419, 0.2801416516304016, 0.4106248915195465, -0.03708210587501526, -0.4252200424671173, -0.7753413319587708, 0.7947037220001221, 0.9214253425598145, -0.3204270601272583, -0.14716531336307526, 0.19085757434368134, -0.40079495310783386, 0.20729881525039673, 0.6240549087524414, 0.260431170463562, 0.33464545011520386, 0.762645423412323, 0.03260454908013344, 0.21681445837020874, -0.0208424162119627, 0.27022919058799744, 0.09280290454626083, 0.28730279207229614, 0.03948269784450531, -0.09807955473661423, -0.9788152575492859, -0.5961524844169617, 0.025274693965911865, -0.4851045608520508, 0.5250087380409241, -0.631427526473999, -0.12022007256746292, -0.019926564767956734, -0.191524475812912, 0.03156951069831848, 0.17459550499916077, -1.2369295358657837, 0.07623733580112457, 0.17827849090099335, -0.6498615741729736, -0.40390029549598694, 0.10008379817008972, 0.09686385840177536, 0.4193281829357147, -0.08405140787363052, 0.053288787603378296, -0.6024786233901978, -0.028662851080298424, -0.8091850876808167, 0.4742051064968109, 0.41883209347724915, -0.2428525984287262, 0.323062539100647, 0.06134611368179321, 0.08749620616436005, -0.4886292517185211, -0.3067249059677124, -0.4374903440475464, -0.3685278296470642, 0.22970791161060333, -0.9563890099525452, -0.7037123441696167, 0.3638800382614136, 0.3108997941017151, 0.398314893245697, 0.07045726478099823, 0.1777314990758896, -0.006667970679700375, -0.469391405582428, 0.187310129404068, 0.037245187908411026, 0.044776398688554764, 0.5651401281356812, -0.8625116944313049, 0.47070610523223877, 0.038086749613285065, 0.4058547019958496, 0.3894679844379425, -0.39206674695014954, -0.10505081713199615, -0.6096606850624084, 0.5231809616088867, 0.22618038952350616, 0.04884640872478485, 0.9454963803291321, 0.19869767129421234, 0.08781079202890396, -0.11962340027093887, 0.9430590271949768, 0.6127029061317444, 0.3790406286716461, 0.07970301806926727, -0.5804545879364014, 0.6777480840682983, -0.38676899671554565, 0.5123536586761475, 0.669614315032959, -0.49933913350105286, -1.14486825466156, -0.5782192349433899, 0.18784752488136292, 0.6771206855773926, 0.24543963372707367, 0.785189151763916, 0.22624024748802185, 0.5611492395401001, -0.33700624108314514, -0.0933775007724762, 0.7780201435089111, -0.5117268562316895, -0.45586708188056946, -0.18142105638980865, 0.25413990020751953, -0.3726470470428467, 0.5640068650245667, 0.12413664162158966, -1.208306908607483, -0.42450371384620667, -0.04281318560242653, 0.5372688174247742, -0.3690606355667114, -0.861235499382019, 0.8590493202209473, -0.04005813226103783, -0.4593876600265503, 0.2950875759124756, -0.5575677752494812, 0.10113897174596786, 0.15676522254943848, -0.17176052927970886, -0.1818356215953827, 0.37713178992271423, 0.05666257441043854, -0.049803972244262695, 0.7034640312194824, 0.32747551798820496, 0.47507423162460327, 1.0581103563308716, 0.49492359161376953, -0.09325563162565231, -0.05179306119680405, 0.4022999405860901, 0.041632942855358124, -0.4634341895580292, -0.12087100744247437, 0.26911088824272156, -0.3876917362213135, -0.12742403149604797, 0.2995365262031555, -0.5710816383361816, -0.43402576446533203, 0.029463451355695724, -0.98872971534729, -0.8980380892753601, -0.5611218214035034, -0.6404775977134705, 0.9458898901939392, 0.023256372660398483, -0.1064111664891243, 0.526093065738678, -0.4818514585494995, -0.09195378422737122, -0.46704909205436707, -0.1473526954650879, -0.018029749393463135, 0.33266809582710266, 0.7094255685806274, -0.6269544363021851, 0.2544494867324829, -0.627121090888977, 0.5782604813575745, -0.504058301448822, -0.6413970589637756, -0.8703293800354004, -0.35018765926361084, -0.3859400153160095, 0.5545733571052551, 0.11349799484014511, 0.2748354375362396, -0.25957155227661133, -0.1492682844400406, -0.022884557023644447, 0.5716550946235657, -0.2617778778076172, -1.053322672843933, 0.01038761530071497, -0.029702870175242424, 0.6086807250976562, -0.1448112279176712, -0.5418106913566589, 1.160150408744812, -0.2919248640537262, 0.6522493958473206, -0.10428239405155182, -0.5930315852165222, 0.8491520285606384, -0.8883576393127441, 0.39971262216567993, -0.487430602312088, -0.22605225443840027, 0.1113320142030716, -0.8552120923995972, 0.10359057784080505, 0.14757488667964935, 0.147097647190094, -0.6031482219696045, 0.14416947960853577, 0.04432300478219986, 1.3083209991455078, -0.4552513659000397, 0.09932093322277069, -0.23082897067070007, 0.10101761668920517, -0.24533051252365112, 0.8516132831573486, -0.1061144769191742, 0.04423407092690468, 0.06849265843629837, -0.581699788570404, -0.053133733570575714, 1.0423043966293335, 0.10686831176280975, -0.2940715551376343, -0.1099780723452568, -0.39116013050079346, 0.8462230563163757, 0.356131911277771, 0.017967017367482185, 0.19616657495498657, -0.41987156867980957, 0.7720557451248169, -0.17046722769737244, -0.33713966608047485, 0.3603387475013733, -0.0535101555287838, 0.1714888960123062, -0.658180296421051, 0.09726858139038086, 1.4378997087478638, -0.2459944784641266, 0.325292706489563, 0.5545855164527893, -0.8763726949691772, -0.0062548755668103695, -0.9272425770759583, -1.2333537340164185, 0.6472778916358948, 0.005704274866729975, -0.7704132199287415, 0.250507116317749, -0.7204279899597168, -0.15958890318870544, 0.250744491815567, 0.3394557535648346, 0.04145615175366402, 0.293704092502594, -0.08232229948043823, -0.3877556025981903, -0.2684200704097748, -0.3552227020263672, -0.21566571295261383, 0.06051415950059891, -0.023754531517624855, 0.10665420442819595, -0.4127797782421112, -0.08581260591745377, -0.4181683361530304, -0.5142336487770081, 0.3416324555873871, 0.38224467635154724, -0.14873456954956055, 1.166569471359253, -0.030671298503875732, 0.2602400481700897, -0.7183273434638977, -0.20697937905788422, 0.5827836394309998, -0.4643024504184723, 0.17532220482826233, 0.6066545844078064, 0.2696860730648041, 0.1298118233680725, 0.34849148988723755, -0.8107637763023376, -0.0675736516714096, 0.6242817044258118, -1.2450426816940308, -0.05180199071764946, 1.0377650260925293, 0.4685053527355194, -0.48965582251548767, -0.8141564726829529, -0.8347216248512268, -0.5744937658309937, 0.7527081966400146, -1.0655708312988281, 0.15146733820438385, -0.031885311007499695, -0.07075142860412598, 0.4531276822090149, 0.04288795217871666, 0.49819865822792053, 0.9633758664131165, -0.06429785490036011, 0.06457223743200302, -0.9480910301208496, 0.04690741375088692, 1.1795047521591187, 0.21406199038028717, -0.8026551604270935, 0.10431277006864548, 0.6939360499382019, -0.9287077188491821, -0.09066988527774811, 1.077624797821045, -0.7219203114509583, 0.1553480625152588, -0.021396810188889503, 0.05731857940554619, 0.345238596200943, -0.028999540954828262, -0.7087815999984741, -0.1149366945028305, -0.6468849778175354, -0.7198081016540527, 0.2721403241157532, -0.245029017329216, 0.4699659049510956, 0.21148306131362915, -0.3113570213317871, 0.36813119053840637, -0.5557256937026978, -0.16794100403785706, 0.1634664237499237, -1.1606649160385132, -0.38024383783340454, -0.9620500206947327, -0.8622507452964783, -0.7042262554168701, 0.1700654923915863, -0.19707198441028595, 0.4803803563117981, -0.5889921188354492, 0.4187268912792206, 0.05858222395181656, -0.2532312273979187, 0.37108808755874634, 0.7772483229637146, -0.5546629428863525, -0.6781222224235535, -0.689760684967041, 0.1530398428440094, -0.21949981153011322, -1.0787731409072876, -0.5019909739494324, -0.659885823726654, 0.327767014503479, 1.3405792713165283, -0.4958415925502777, 0.5789182782173157, -1.1173416376113892, -0.8177086114883423, 0.14480341970920563, -0.0586276575922966, -0.868486225605011, 1.1477892398834229, -0.2535445988178253, 0.7723792195320129, 1.0582902431488037, -0.13325831294059753, -0.06931339204311371, 0.45541560649871826, -0.6553613543510437, 0.1782054752111435, 0.15985162556171417, 0.9140205383300781, 0.6002746224403381, -0.9875701069831848, 0.39250648021698, 0.47231626510620117, -0.3204168677330017, -0.24133984744548798, -0.7166643738746643, 0.808972954750061, -0.6254035234451294, 0.9829233884811401, 0.3784548044204712, 0.3578832149505615, -0.20606820285320282, 0.847621738910675, -0.6463649272918701, 0.024408912286162376, -0.12708574533462524, 0.3837257921695709, 0.06701726466417313, -0.38912537693977356, 0.22278763353824615, -0.8385108709335327, 0.35710224509239197, -0.01780492439866066, -0.09725537151098251, 0.15793476998806, -0.04456814378499985, 0.08018533885478973, -0.023413831368088722, 0.35549816489219666, -0.22002862393856049, 0.6894552707672119, -0.0863208994269371, 0.45920759439468384, 0.05107174441218376, -0.2596946060657501, -1.0615352392196655, 0.4993602931499481, -0.02296251803636551, -0.8249178528785706, 0.28183966875076294, -0.22601082921028137, -0.18025615811347961, 0.2568665146827698, -0.21451085805892944, 0.5905711650848389, -0.10249808430671692, 0.8391653299331665, 1.1791800260543823, 0.13484029471874237, -0.27792036533355713, 0.719809353351593, -0.32177937030792236, 0.0019308192422613502, -0.5501376390457153, 0.1377241462469101, -0.9120667576789856, -0.5671136379241943, -0.4618842303752899, 0.4739105999469757, 0.44046398997306824, 0.1961050033569336, 0.15307243168354034, -0.20927970111370087, -0.07624460011720657, 0.019549861550331116, -1.256377935409546, -0.22018948197364807, -0.411235511302948, 0.43204134702682495, 0.41139936447143555, -0.29284343123435974, 0.2909688353538513, 0.1740647703409195, 0.6442650556564331, 0.4768874943256378, 0.008584592491388321, 1.314897894859314, 0.07486208528280258, -0.07580245286226273, 0.2544197738170624, 0.4875873029232025, 0.5448451042175293, 0.6617903113365173, -0.5528907179832458, 0.5804211497306824, 0.21299713850021362, 0.32999199628829956, 0.29152941703796387, 0.19816282391548157, -0.1289522498846054, 0.07495157420635223, -0.09224982559680939, 0.2717713713645935, 0.40235698223114014, -0.152109295129776, -0.10264004021883011, 0.31485962867736816, -0.48986300826072693, -0.19466914236545563, -0.403086394071579, 0.30324986577033997, 0.2196616530418396, -0.2119636833667755, -0.25567957758903503, -0.4631612002849579, -0.2867850065231323, 0.3425508737564087, -0.526455283164978, -1.0385452508926392, -0.5548887848854065, -0.01790643110871315, 0.7620912790298462, -0.36552149057388306, -0.40104150772094727, 0.7003905177116394, -0.3169989287853241, 0.1393924355506897, -0.6736142039299011, 0.5582345724105835, 0.16952872276306152, 0.9693911671638489, 0.7882727384567261, 0.5311094522476196, 0.2565435767173767, 0.47477203607559204, 0.05167490616440773, -0.822126567363739, 0.03797583281993866, 0.1615002155303955, -0.8323154449462891, -0.29864048957824707, 0.20361168682575226, 0.07901807129383087, -0.19059890508651733, -0.07340763509273529, 0.6900378465652466, -1.0527451038360596, 0.01800527796149254, -0.21175241470336914, 0.20300418138504028, 0.02055102400481701, 0.1146678626537323, 0.067878857254982, 0.5131611227989197, 0.8776882290840149, 0.7029015421867371, -0.031257521361112595, 0.7264121174812317, 0.6058992743492126, 0.4243814945220947, 0.3479394018650055, -0.29568928480148315, -0.3552057445049286, 0.5546267628669739, 0.3364393711090088, -0.4121253788471222, 0.5077683925628662, -0.9731165170669556, -0.35788220167160034, -0.4423072934150696, 0.27834591269493103, 0.19366630911827087, -0.09631148725748062, 0.2856845557689667, 0.6040870547294617, -0.3042824864387512, 0.09431520104408264, 1.2080968618392944, 0.49969878792762756, -0.8843433260917664, -0.8201212882995605, 0.2751843333244324, -0.9436527490615845, -0.30263978242874146, -1.0934531688690186, 0.8671966195106506, 0.24046769738197327, -0.18249692022800446, -0.09588645398616791, -0.7305114269256592, -0.5496718883514404, -0.2500772774219513, -0.19364501535892487, -0.062172625213861465, -0.057745520025491714, 0.5096896290779114, -0.1099599152803421, 0.22286653518676758, -0.48133736848831177, -0.6156803369522095, -0.16673259437084198, 1.048897385597229, -0.4967091977596283, 0.001199165009893477, 0.33945074677467346, 0.09943896532058716, -0.8455576300621033, 0.8085581064224243, 0.2156682312488556, -0.9848536849021912, 0.43168461322784424, -0.38553476333618164, 0.5474573969841003, 0.1020529568195343, -0.4467187523841858, 0.3285617530345917, 0.07606962323188782, 0.3334195017814636, 0.5935260653495789, -0.9419224262237549, 0.38573476672172546, -0.48225459456443787, -0.6260260343551636, -0.1709168702363968, 0.14294734597206116, -0.024594556540250778, -0.08936914801597595, 0.4762304127216339, -1.1026511192321777, 4.03785514831543, 0.4680159389972687, 0.18368501961231232, -0.0170065276324749, 0.7127214670181274, 0.8590571880340576, 0.013894455507397652, -0.11531785130500793, 0.003381210146471858, -0.7914548516273499, 0.0628623217344284, 0.5406341552734375, 0.10949117690324783, 0.20505063235759735, -0.18919992446899414, 0.23655103147029877, 0.2156776338815689, -0.3481976389884949, -0.3462108373641968, -0.6303162574768066, -0.5141868591308594, 0.4642289876937866, -0.21464291214942932, -0.601409912109375, 0.10403091460466385, 0.45878446102142334, 0.2553260028362274, -0.4380827248096466, -0.5198286771774292, -0.2981816828250885, 0.11868736892938614, -0.4426936209201813, 0.044128742069005966, -0.07039573788642883, -1.717612862586975, 0.4947100877761841, 0.12709413468837738, -0.9096021056175232, 0.5580430626869202, -0.16733412444591522, 0.12093149125576019, -0.6782402396202087, -0.37158867716789246, -0.9045958518981934, -0.39664316177368164, 0.37617117166519165, 0.7861822247505188, 0.9132450819015503, 0.6424758434295654, -0.833293616771698, -0.0943979024887085, 0.10216318815946579, 0.5575865507125854, -0.6759285926818848, -0.7286142110824585, -0.7980766296386719, -0.49314674735069275, -0.19937555491924286, 0.3722340762615204, 0.5301060080528259, 0.7334138751029968, -0.5110052824020386, -0.18966111540794373, 0.2553989589214325, 0.1186903789639473, -0.04118514433503151, 0.44408082962036133, -0.04149545729160309, -0.24615314602851868, -0.6132742762565613, -0.6631945967674255, -0.3150250017642975, -0.23540887236595154, -0.7299879193305969, 0.47512340545654297, 0.5294219851493835, 0.5617222189903259, 0.2767028212547302, -0.9918440580368042, 0.16035579144954681, -0.8790066838264465, -0.2400667518377304, -0.3667454421520233, 0.2965514063835144, -0.5431994795799255, 0.8176040649414062, 0.1307763010263443, 0.6775078773498535, -0.15326480567455292, 0.8693791031837463, -0.41131922602653503, 0.6134132146835327, -0.2189657837152481, 0.17781522870063782, -0.6677626967430115 ]
Dilaton Contributions to the Cosmic Gravitational Wave Background
We consider the cosmological amplification of a metric perturbation propagating in a higher-dimensional Brans-Dicke background, including a non trivial dilaton evolution. We discuss the properties of the spectral energy density of the produced gravitons (as well as of the associated squeezing parameter), and we show that the present observational bounds on the graviton spectrum provide significant information on the dynamical evolution of the early universe.
M.Gasperini and M.Giovannini
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211021
gr-qc/9211022
[ 0.549190878868103, -0.564085841178894, 0.378083735704422, -0.2576064169406891, 0.49490219354629517, 0.4973248541355133, -0.6153219938278198, -0.12677578628063202, -0.958929181098938, 1.0559618473052979, 0.9982118606567383, 0.11808443814516068, -0.4365236163139343, -1.1638011932373047, -0.1617850661277771, 0.14275266230106354, -0.267337828874588, -0.18603502213954926, -1.456576943397522, 0.14482548832893372, 0.8465140461921692, 0.4156258702278137, -1.3488996028900146, -0.48795443773269653, -0.6818784475326538, 0.35149839520454407, 1.173026442527771, -0.13493043184280396, 1.1517598628997803, 0.7949416637420654, 0.7827157378196716, -0.31519752740859985, 0.08367308229207993, -0.8220916390419006, -0.05296984687447548, 0.10169678181409836, -0.10600811243057251, -1.087884545326233, 1.2202765941619873, 0.08938632905483246, 0.4139443635940552, 0.1847395896911621, 0.1923188865184784, -0.8274739384651184, -0.9971815347671509, -0.39307692646980286, 0.7175440788269043, -0.1422203928232193, 0.30613794922828674, -0.9170436859130859, -0.14651958644390106, -0.5843660831451416, 1.0869215726852417, -1.0065081119537354, -0.4372488558292389, -0.20293065905570984, 0.6183741092681885, 0.25101378560066223, -0.4362581670284271, 0.02130270004272461, 0.7130489349365234, 0.3640933632850647, 0.42932745814323425, -0.945217490196228, -0.022137172520160675, 0.5632946491241455, -0.3273327052593231, 0.6234573721885681, 0.17466650903224945, -0.6320415735244751, -0.2995243966579437, -0.41907361149787903, -0.6593069434165955, 0.45150938630104065, -0.5067495107650757, 0.6199878454208374, -0.4265071153640747, -0.5211005210876465, -0.6560560464859009, -0.1339217722415924, -0.11373721063137054, -0.26489412784576416, 0.18444813787937164, 0.18781018257141113, -0.6845044493675232, 0.25599732995033264, 0.011985931545495987, -0.03866543248295784, -0.20753969252109528, -0.1183413714170456, -0.35837846994400024, 0.7639002799987793, 0.1671082228422165, -0.05301632359623909, 0.6263801455497742, 0.7711317539215088, -0.2273145169019699, 0.8510346412658691, 0.301999032497406, 0.45699232816696167, -0.4648730456829071, 1.6237906217575073, 0.002659289399161935, 0.5873754620552063, -0.3205324709415436, 0.7175577282905579, -0.31137242913246155, -0.007750846445560455, 0.028356511145830154, -0.7183400392532349, 0.3081684410572052, -0.12226628512144089, 0.3315946161746979, -0.2391848862171173, -0.4467950761318207, -0.11837715655565262, -0.5684575438499451, 0.05383656173944473, -0.2340579330921173, -0.062425702810287476, 0.32300421595573425, 0.25180456042289734, 0.5339059233665466, 0.9368423819541931, 0.003849098924547434, -0.6615652441978455, 0.07946737855672836, 0.03486701473593712, -0.9694499969482422, -0.24806196987628937, 0.563670814037323, -0.6622605919837952, 0.24764609336853027, 0.04616827145218849, -0.3205748200416565, 0.4897516667842865, -0.14543311297893524, 0.280967652797699, -0.7105954885482788, -0.640967071056366, 0.5488253831863403, -0.5313971638679504, 0.6060430407524109, 1.1861140727996826, -0.6011115312576294, 0.48663130402565, -0.5511960983276367, 0.7194172739982605, -0.3078899085521698, 0.10619610548019409, 0.17962528765201569, -0.5616604089736938, -0.14247046411037445, 0.5299786329269409, -0.3490387201309204, -0.14084801077842712, -0.5942658185958862, 0.2825336158275604, -0.39722204208374023, -0.4006596505641937, 0.45461633801460266, 0.3178739845752716, 0.3216279447078705, 1.67746102809906, -0.6280441284179688, 0.16758568584918976, -0.7671487331390381, -0.1895873099565506, -0.21775011718273163, 0.21976813673973083, -0.12525887787342072, -0.23606529831886292, -0.027696575969457626, 0.1581217348575592, 1.088775634765625, 0.5298705101013184, -0.10179075598716736, -0.18921341001987457, 0.04090419411659241, 0.4913354516029358, -0.31556636095046997, -0.9311717748641968, 1.3023091554641724, 0.8129681944847107, -0.31677958369255066, -0.6761025190353394, 0.14557534456253052, 0.2759987413883209, -0.058028578758239746, 0.5164209008216858, -0.7178183794021606, 0.5251685380935669, -0.6448854804039001, 1.2766605615615845, -0.289676308631897, 0.36922594904899597, -0.9203312993049622, 0.282341331243515, -0.46197277307510376, -0.33348017930984497, 0.08301979303359985, -0.3456321358680725, -0.7035473585128784, 0.4324319362640381, -0.8968313932418823, 0.4579918384552002, 0.2915058434009552, 0.4780886173248291, -0.3488582968711853, 0.1768808811903, 1.063503384590149, -0.1963554173707962, 0.12156907469034195, 0.09702491015195847, 0.41932716965675354, -0.4099542498588562, -0.6537849307060242, 0.02761102467775345, 0.38621068000793457, 0.4357956647872925, 1.1168527603149414, 0.8222382664680481, -0.31124985218048096, 0.7258367538452148, 0.09803346544504166, -0.40534159541130066, -0.3682418465614319, 1.6207044124603271, -0.45697084069252014, 0.5613074898719788, 0.1061822921037674, 0.11822985857725143, 0.42246630787849426, 0.5951924920082092, 0.4428248107433319, -0.2175968885421753, 1.1924508810043335, 0.606782853603363, 0.6022945642471313, 0.05632106587290764, 0.14651784300804138, 0.2717137038707733, 0.8067989349365234, -0.16712307929992676, -0.9280484914779663, 0.7941147685050964, 0.5582793354988098, 0.6720059514045715, -0.23753294348716736, 0.7663460373878479, -0.4954940676689148, 0.6288713216781616, 0.01212422177195549, 0.04526182636618614, -1.2070424556732178, 0.5916581749916077, 0.47210511565208435, 0.5766502618789673, -0.12414626777172089, -0.3691158890724182, -0.07338915020227432, -0.03691761568188667, -0.07727577537298203, 0.0022127931006252766, -0.7765216827392578, -0.09082673490047455, -0.49290165305137634, 0.07323615252971649, 0.4275418519973755, -0.2865782380104065, -0.7374138236045837, -0.4117881655693054, -0.869483470916748, -0.28100425004959106, -0.6430284380912781, -0.0016034916043281555, 0.02933664806187153, 0.05477336049079895, 1.2297825813293457, 0.20002295076847076, -0.058096110820770264, 0.3908699154853821, -0.0381179042160511, -0.006563232280313969, 0.1587560772895813, -0.014904151670634747, -0.6536082625389099, 0.10117001831531525, -1.216745138168335, 0.19580355286598206, 0.3653574287891388, -0.7788910269737244, 0.6403701305389404, -0.09139188379049301, -0.023618794977664948, -0.6295325756072998, -0.19965782761573792, -0.38195449113845825, -0.5597797632217407, -0.5541580319404602, -0.1443326622247696, 0.4840162694454193, 0.3529416024684906, 0.553851842880249, -0.17323075234889984, 0.6603475213050842, -0.2764934003353119, -0.17581620812416077, 0.4991757869720459, -0.21190281212329865, -1.0851171016693115, 0.17743641138076782, 0.2942570745944977, 0.5339083671569824, -0.26301997900009155, 0.8554056286811829, 1.1251118183135986, -0.2838937044143677, 0.425715833902359, -0.1993827223777771, -0.3370290994644165, 0.11252936720848083, 0.4943296015262604, -0.8613907694816589, -0.19027985632419586, 0.7686622142791748, 0.3368753492832184, -0.8757316470146179, 0.34194251894950867, -1.145780086517334, -0.6368270516395569, -0.6041727662086487, -0.5259700417518616, -0.3816772699356079, -0.3717288374900818, 0.40014761686325073, -0.49807146191596985, -0.23734328150749207, 0.2092859447002411, 0.4684407711029053, 0.23940107226371765, -0.0691119059920311, 0.3923814296722412, 0.4789612889289856, 0.23002372682094574, 0.27121391892433167, 0.3218176066875458, -0.7500675320625305, -0.254476398229599, 0.28871750831604004, -0.3816834092140198, 0.33667171001434326, 0.7658136487007141, -0.6919247508049011, -0.0013332144590094686, 0.13260884582996368, -0.7511364221572876, -0.34171098470687866, -1.3643916845321655, -0.3586682081222534, 0.4083334803581238, 0.5523423552513123, 0.48257938027381897, -0.8144760727882385, -0.7496134042739868, -0.18296757340431213, 0.2710726261138916, 0.28344258666038513, 1.2135549783706665, -0.5686815977096558, 0.12315840274095535, 0.29861465096473694, -0.6551148295402527, 0.06717540323734283, -0.7467015385627747, -0.3557858467102051, 0.4670908749103546, 0.5759721398353577, -0.4078996181488037, -0.5117956399917603, -0.19234931468963623, -0.5622459650039673, 0.41209548711776733, 0.056553684175014496, 0.6478067636489868, -0.35623079538345337, -0.7132437229156494, 0.0376141183078289, -0.13668011128902435, -0.5347380042076111, -0.41011297702789307, -0.7668126821517944, 0.11587461829185486, -0.4447402060031891, -0.32029592990875244, -0.48305845260620117, 0.8132445812225342, 0.6828563809394836, 0.27093565464019775, -0.18729855120182037, 0.5506023168563843, 0.8459693789482117, 0.18361549079418182, 0.2667933404445648, -0.39976879954338074, 0.6662103533744812, -0.5189038515090942, 0.7067276239395142, 0.6338790059089661, -0.06016407534480095, 0.12833534181118011, -0.32351982593536377, 0.177998349070549, 0.2329513281583786, 0.673529326915741, 0.8658754229545593, -0.8626750707626343, 0.562150776386261, 0.3798912465572357, -0.15232326090335846, -0.6199935674667358, 0.3439718186855316, 0.5930485129356384, 0.7879289388656616, 0.18843720853328705, -0.7086631655693054, -0.2639063894748688, -0.5701348781585693, 0.5314269661903381, 0.6228527426719666, -0.7738438844680786, -0.7036298513412476, -0.12497658282518387, 0.4266763925552368, 0.3220597803592682, 0.3352400064468384, 0.8675636053085327, 0.34124839305877686, 0.5702238082885742, 0.3668476939201355, -0.11361551284790039, 0.7139338850975037, -0.2952885925769806, 0.10763418674468994, 0.2967124283313751, -0.005971776787191629, -0.3980550169944763, 0.4864870607852936, -0.026539020240306854, -0.7294007539749146, 0.0026944561395794153, -0.1426047682762146, 0.03684639185667038, -0.3165143132209778, -0.28059884905815125, -0.11587376892566681, 0.3510432243347168, -0.4331737160682678, -0.259337455034256, -0.19439958035945892, -0.03048766776919365, -0.1544559746980667, 0.3814704418182373, -1.0626320838928223, 0.3145720660686493, -0.13700547814369202, -0.25801724195480347, 0.40803906321525574, 0.1418997347354889, 0.0390043668448925, 0.37641671299934387, 0.22061607241630554, 0.631561815738678, 0.07953721284866333, 0.5001412630081177, -0.8847135901451111, 0.06149420142173767, 0.01051983144134283, -0.4843743145465851, -0.7788451910018921, -0.9997392296791077, 0.6470264196395874, -0.3201133608818054, 0.3280402421951294, 0.5543537139892578, -0.667236328125, -0.7493916153907776, -0.632180392742157, -1.413623332977295, 0.2941426932811737, -0.014199984259903431, -0.29472512006759644, 0.13255828619003296, -0.049916017800569534, -0.327616423368454, -0.0772489681839943, -0.42041975259780884, -0.44458523392677307, -0.2544103264808655, -0.03590459004044533, 0.5598495006561279, 0.4071706235408783, -0.32193654775619507, 0.46537643671035767, 0.12089542299509048, -0.6305497884750366, -0.8492209315299988, -0.6018374562263489, 0.03204630687832832, 0.7170406579971313, -0.1089097410440445, -0.5616877675056458, 0.4506887197494507, 0.18323557078838348, 0.041664570569992065, 0.24407362937927246, -0.2896077334880829, -0.9682878255844116, 0.006251494865864515, 0.5722818374633789, 0.6179105043411255, -0.7988856434822083, 0.01259407214820385, 0.22787480056285858, -0.07620511949062347, 0.7264867424964905, -0.3126519024372101, -0.23116765916347504, 0.20783397555351257, -1.1887038946151733, 0.6117064952850342, -1.1246953010559082, -0.4131680130958557, -0.43479952216148376, -0.617394208908081, 0.12916715443134308, 0.13785965740680695, 0.42775747179985046, -0.7169479131698608, -0.3923704922199249, -0.26323121786117554, 0.4154265820980072, -0.9319219589233398, 0.6575889587402344, -0.9661625027656555, -0.37929031252861023, -0.752872884273529, 0.6970410346984863, -0.05649501457810402, 0.20250317454338074, 0.3757897615432739, 0.200611412525177, -0.1990245282649994, 0.29616042971611023, 0.27959197759628296, -0.09011133760213852, -0.691190242767334, 0.3785208761692047, 0.06361788511276245, 0.44390392303466797, 0.13563475012779236, 0.742611289024353, -0.49616527557373047, 0.6869620680809021, -0.18119825422763824, -0.1566205620765686, 0.25898322463035583, -0.0064339484088122845, 0.5907426476478577, -0.5332868695259094, -0.20060566067695618, 0.35623040795326233, 0.3861158490180969, 0.6760133504867554, -0.13338804244995117, -0.7201002240180969, -0.1810508817434311, -0.3489855229854584, -0.5525195598602295, -0.006696997210383415, 0.41495281457901, -0.49471020698547363, -0.4471423029899597, 0.19143684208393097, -0.565462589263916, -0.7769169807434082, 0.10328684002161026, 0.35130369663238525, 0.38150352239608765, -0.057850852608680725, -0.8840309977531433, 0.036420788615942, -0.6869043707847595, -0.05197083204984665, -0.2268858253955841, -0.26251131296157837, -0.22647060453891754, -0.20875948667526245, -0.5724586844444275, -1.0141801834106445, -0.9464696049690247, 0.5380219221115112, 0.28182947635650635, 0.18867701292037964, 0.99198317527771, 0.6632956266403198, -0.23545973002910614, -0.43532437086105347, 0.12325768917798996, -0.10413994640111923, -0.10395777970552444, 0.7880043983459473, 0.2879221737384796, 0.13123026490211487, -0.24790026247501373, 0.6715283989906311, -0.6437022686004639, -1.14424729347229, 1.0304900407791138, -0.4761260449886322, 0.15916137397289276, 0.3676539361476898, 0.2404598742723465, -0.8827251195907593, -0.809889554977417, -0.9326468110084534, -0.6241129040718079, 0.23223011195659637, -0.556530773639679, 0.6411459445953369, -0.6744101643562317, -0.15330027043819427, -0.24161380529403687, 0.18409745395183563, 0.1534637063741684, 0.5405871868133545, 0.044283702969551086, 0.3311183452606201, -0.4380192458629608, -0.16551168262958527, 1.0209050178527832, 0.42381489276885986, -0.8565909266471863, -0.26269999146461487, 0.042329732328653336, 0.23507985472679138, 0.02570786140859127, 0.9130436778068542, -0.7080559134483337, -0.3097316324710846, 0.3628372848033905, 0.587293267250061, 0.15311899781227112, 0.13619476556777954, -0.10823404043912888, -0.2374511957168579, -0.514539361000061, -1.0480512380599976, 0.012923792004585266, 0.217707559466362, 0.535908579826355, 0.5111269354820251, -0.03430711477994919, -0.16109155118465424, -0.27080783247947693, -0.059866975992918015, 0.17501680552959442, -0.6496705412864685, -0.3747105300426483, -1.5342211723327637, -1.4555180072784424, -0.8598175048828125, 0.00686348881572485, 0.019777953624725342, 0.6640014052391052, -0.7988746166229248, 0.2810872793197632, 0.0977126881480217, 0.20832671225070953, -0.22795502841472626, 1.012026071548462, -0.36711153388023376, -0.35568827390670776, -0.9580828547477722, 0.14017228782176971, 0.3115254044532776, -1.590891718864441, -0.08662226051092148, -0.23327326774597168, 0.7631455659866333, 0.9637793898582458, -0.25344958901405334, 0.17279839515686035, 0.2604644000530243, -1.0322028398513794, 0.4113026559352875, -0.22159752249717712, -0.689932644367218, 0.5520230531692505, -0.11732212454080582, 0.9041032791137695, 0.2034016251564026, 0.5654305219650269, -0.30067741870880127, -0.0012684485409408808, -0.6294257044792175, 0.3093625009059906, 0.09154172241687775, 0.45327243208885193, -0.20505042374134064, -0.8699796795845032, 0.19589099287986755, -0.2808622717857361, -0.5959961414337158, 0.05360577255487442, 0.48074468970298767, 0.4151628613471985, -0.7780651450157166, -0.2650032937526703, 0.05452607944607735, 0.2514839470386505, -0.05655210465192795, 0.39466390013694763, -0.14733771979808807, 0.11368690431118011, -0.32844969630241394, 0.11157411336898804, -0.3057451844215393, -0.10728863626718521, 0.4468792676925659, -0.2745436429977417, -0.01675735041499138, 0.04861610382795334, -0.3254820704460144, 0.1354629397392273, -0.384816437959671, -0.08500885218381882, -0.35397428274154663, 0.23810778558254242, -0.4347601532936096, 0.6632161736488342, 0.47122806310653687, -0.11365240812301636, 0.028214821591973305, -0.1994393914937973, -0.4927504360675812, 0.17361728847026825, -0.4713709354400635, -0.9947681427001953, -0.037473294883966446, -0.1834670454263687, -0.09614142775535583, 0.19927848875522614, -0.5526337027549744, 0.12470132112503052, 0.30822324752807617, 1.359948992729187, 0.6373405456542969, -0.1247127428650856, -0.1637706756591797, 0.8984600901603699, -1.1777949333190918, -0.49653559923171997, -0.8653753995895386, 0.27960819005966187, -0.9996877908706665, -0.7710617780685425, 0.06394194066524506, 0.14326347410678864, -0.1680082082748413, 0.22115129232406616, 0.5390936136245728, 0.11208423227071762, 0.3074866533279419, -0.07019177079200745, -0.5717154741287231, 0.1276261806488037, -0.5080084800720215, 0.3459920287132263, 0.1572185456752777, -0.8083059787750244, -0.2553333044052124, 0.08590570837259293, 0.5457758903503418, -0.11083244532346725, 0.22471842169761658, 0.9739585518836975, -0.22894084453582764, -0.8868300318717957, 0.13722288608551025, 0.3410959541797638, 0.4554978311061859, 0.6667616367340088, -0.3319588005542755, 0.6709182262420654, 0.7473289966583252, 0.45139768719673157, 1.320618748664856, 0.12163526564836502, -0.686512291431427, 0.41110357642173767, 0.7850038409233093, 0.1411791741847992, -0.07057348638772964, 0.277910441160202, 0.7241461277008057, 0.4723842740058899, -0.19303688406944275, 0.12018910050392151, 0.3267230987548828, 0.44044890999794006, 0.6046057343482971, -0.10002042353153229, -0.33023959398269653, -0.43086451292037964, 0.10372646898031235, 0.8351052403450012, -0.2835801839828491, -0.6363823413848877, -0.4143490195274353, 0.525337815284729, 0.008979596197605133, 0.3221524655818939, -0.13557113707065582, 0.44440001249313354, -0.062199242413043976, 0.4389793574810028, -0.07431180030107498, 0.4249849319458008, 0.5020015835762024, 0.33588549494743347, 0.68672114610672, 0.13362155854701996, 0.13433408737182617, 1.1535987854003906, -0.14003847539424896, -0.6277497410774231, 0.12350969761610031, 0.12267367541790009, -0.9303380846977234, 0.22902752459049225, -0.21937882900238037, 0.10618890076875687, -0.350908100605011, -0.2690228819847107, -0.14569036662578583, -0.40866827964782715, -0.09252472966909409, 0.09123749285936356, 0.007029023487120867, -0.3391318619251251, 0.10113783180713654, 0.1721184402704239, 0.6268771886825562, 0.4547135531902313, 0.532779335975647, -0.046957068145275116, 0.6725972890853882, 0.9298120737075806, 0.6515411734580994, -0.12376487255096436, -0.03525323420763016, 0.09841462224721909, 0.9362120628356934, 0.2821120321750641, 0.00771293556317687, 0.5069041848182678, -0.7609539031982422, -0.20184467732906342, 0.006506940815597773, 0.07207819819450378, -0.27646404504776, -0.3421827554702759, 0.8204437494277954, 0.4828832447528839, -0.4851457178592682, 0.11620698124170303, 0.6116032600402832, 0.44251635670661926, -0.6871199607849121, 0.05935608968138695, 0.8869982957839966, -0.9922196269035339, 0.22929143905639648, -1.447648048400879, 0.8459160923957825, 0.16414111852645874, 0.14154131710529327, -1.0783302783966064, -0.4254201054573059, 0.2890704572200775, -0.5840631127357483, -0.24701061844825745, -0.939863920211792, -0.2298935353755951, 1.1895493268966675, -0.16536618769168854, 0.2709914445877075, -0.6141040325164795, -0.7219732999801636, -0.774458646774292, 0.898984432220459, 0.24134424328804016, 0.08617310225963593, 0.8639454245567322, 0.4155173897743225, -1.4791362285614014, 0.42391639947891235, 0.8680186867713928, -0.7680463790893555, 0.5487468838691711, -0.5323050618171692, 0.154404878616333, 0.47836625576019287, -0.22972677648067474, 0.07147910445928574, 0.5270103216171265, 0.42069295048713684, 0.6639956831932068, -0.6187741756439209, 0.4936089813709259, -0.22801072895526886, -0.19131295382976532, -1.1283708810806274, 0.2672813832759857, 0.05163969472050667, -0.5988609790802002, -0.4226027727127075, -0.5043240189552307, 3.979095935821533, 0.6199812889099121, 0.6851246953010559, -0.3448205590248108, 1.1932990550994873, 0.6101991534233093, -0.36284905672073364, 0.21514877676963806, 0.5059325695037842, -0.4561878442764282, -0.26657193899154663, 0.2802923023700714, -0.3789225220680237, -0.17333468794822693, -0.15561580657958984, 0.2804044187068939, -0.34125417470932007, -0.13735508918762207, -0.5858278870582581, -0.36800360679626465, -1.445238709449768, 0.19957756996154785, 0.0738411471247673, -0.020728908479213715, 0.2198989987373352, 0.852350115776062, 0.16313330829143524, -0.8559839725494385, -0.4856729209423065, -0.6195374131202698, -0.15057472884655, -0.6127676367759705, 0.04412960261106491, 0.24091744422912598, -1.4632023572921753, 0.49830517172813416, -0.2773330807685852, -0.43870246410369873, 0.13226500153541565, 0.21916915476322174, 0.016650192439556122, -0.6091626286506653, 0.365867018699646, -0.13239449262619019, 0.05553510785102844, 1.214431643486023, 0.1384201943874359, 0.27983999252319336, 0.5431765913963318, -0.8067854046821594, -0.1185142919421196, 0.11337076872587204, 0.3245718777179718, -0.6762632727622986, -0.51621413230896, -0.49016115069389343, 0.13475081324577332, -0.23821428418159485, 0.70221346616745, -0.17661064863204956, 0.2711237370967865, -0.3976885676383972, 0.054895997047424316, -0.03243652358651161, 0.27655351161956787, 0.3332746624946594, 0.24229927361011505, -0.3624604642391205, 0.2951931655406952, -0.3769708573818207, -0.6407232284545898, 0.23063190281391144, -0.5197350978851318, -0.1437201350927353, 0.33643126487731934, 0.3398677110671997, -0.1673755794763565, 0.5893356800079346, -0.0493595227599144, 0.5645177960395813, -0.7671723365783691, -0.2612532675266266, 0.48675668239593506, -0.5477527379989624, 0.08370529115200043, 0.8219178318977356, -0.007945929653942585, 0.44168099761009216, -0.536342203617096, 0.629252016544342, -0.002651392947882414, 1.0012000799179077, -0.7679100632667542, -0.16980233788490295, -0.6044291257858276 ]
Quantum Gravity by the Complex Canonical Formulation
The basic features of the complex canonical formulation of general relativity and the recent developments in the quantum gravity program based on it are reviewed. The exposition is intended to be complementary to the review articles available already and some original arguments are included. In particular the conventional treatment of the Hamiltonian constraint and quantum states in the canonical approach to quantum gravity is criticized and a new formulation is proposed.
Hideo Kodama
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211022
gr-qc/9211023
[ -0.2864525616168976, 0.852413535118103, 0.1548590511083603, 0.24486224353313446, -0.11579734086990356, -0.22942166030406952, -0.06907230615615845, 0.4838893413543701, -0.2355378270149231, 1.2366786003112793, 0.38767173886299133, 0.37499552965164185, -0.2755269706249237, -1.0404722690582275, -0.5778274536132812, -0.2847610414028168, -0.09842859953641891, -0.14431698620319366, -1.0772255659103394, 0.1442209929227829, 0.6266173720359802, 0.5895634293556213, -0.8583735227584839, 0.3066020607948303, -0.5428736209869385, 0.7432399988174438, 0.6349188089370728, 0.41041672229766846, 0.8192372918128967, 0.9814674854278564, 0.22898545861244202, 0.1649172157049179, 0.09657727181911469, -0.6255289912223816, 0.7667086720466614, 0.25977909564971924, 0.5759264826774597, -0.9348317384719849, 0.8243241906166077, -0.4660145044326782, 0.07363297790288925, 0.42910537123680115, -0.0745801329612732, -0.6063669323921204, -0.6510304808616638, 0.46366623044013977, 0.37795087695121765, 0.5573301911354065, 0.8542065620422363, -0.7239377498626709, 0.3054839074611664, -0.7528933882713318, 0.6222052574157715, -0.7993419766426086, 0.2993214428424835, -0.5101853013038635, 0.30382269620895386, 0.07844860106706619, -0.19273404777050018, 0.8275011777877808, 0.25484052300453186, 0.6544755101203918, 0.2483948916196823, -1.2035008668899536, 0.5070387125015259, 0.8547801375389099, -0.09390397369861603, 0.09934224933385849, 0.15582115948200226, -0.6574008464813232, -0.002190027153119445, 0.2714870870113373, -0.29630836844444275, 0.39948350191116333, 0.03361641243100166, 0.7048603892326355, 0.29196760058403015, -0.32210588455200195, -0.44826075434684753, 0.15852662920951843, 0.3505888879299164, 0.34416523575782776, -0.3054678738117218, 1.0537986755371094, -0.6503963470458984, -0.28006884455680847, 0.43791159987449646, -0.11744575947523117, 0.26471856236457825, -0.1782888025045395, -0.11325015127658844, 0.5024042129516602, -0.5855352878570557, 0.13442213833332062, 1.063138484954834, -0.08605553209781647, 0.006679105572402477, 0.33760058879852295, 0.30415430665016174, 0.09544900059700012, 0.3201046288013458, 0.7418166995048523, -0.41258886456489563, 1.1332359313964844, -0.04498014599084854, 0.6997180581092834, 0.1254633069038391, 0.32962653040885925, -0.20682841539382935, -0.8573377132415771, -0.018327536061406136, 0.11024845391511917, 0.5483152270317078, 0.2398034930229187, 0.48775386810302734, 0.5047164559364319, -0.4819933772087097, 0.07019385695457458, -0.7117106914520264, 0.0061879837885499, 0.4130166471004486, 0.709686815738678, 0.39381203055381775, 0.9150407910346985, -0.6304066777229309, -0.34114718437194824, 0.5581108927726746, -0.20728838443756104, -0.5112385153770447, 0.06491677463054657, -0.09754330664873123, -0.5258719325065613, -0.13345356285572052, -0.2501533627510071, -0.22626172006130219, 0.24083659052848816, 0.18491828441619873, 0.2799283564090729, -0.00590512715280056, -0.7928354740142822, -0.23988166451454163, -0.33302438259124756, 0.05268210917711258, 0.8218123912811279, -0.4610881507396698, 0.37677428126335144, 0.08418679982423782, 0.2592160701751709, -0.40003669261932373, -0.13335666060447693, -0.06334848701953888, -0.3711472451686859, -0.7621648907661438, 0.9426835775375366, -0.5022521018981934, -0.7477317452430725, -1.0734065771102905, -0.7242527008056641, -0.13921701908111572, -0.02523590251803398, 0.12238000333309174, -0.3483305275440216, 0.33415159583091736, 1.4356160163879395, -0.5186796188354492, 0.8376879692077637, -0.6880909204483032, -1.0678077936172485, -0.12424571812152863, 0.7424971461296082, -0.38227957487106323, -0.04399885609745979, -0.03594350442290306, 0.4717714190483093, 1.358810544013977, 0.29113638401031494, -0.36011990904808044, -0.21704910695552826, -0.6197629570960999, 0.48150840401649475, -0.1000746414065361, -1.2003892660140991, 0.7661048173904419, 0.6359814405441284, -0.35393476486206055, 0.06538177281618118, -0.09957580268383026, -0.3542731702327728, 0.1211693286895752, -0.11803621798753738, -0.01794898509979248, 0.7480531334877014, -1.0887397527694702, 0.9460641741752625, -1.1920455694198608, -0.10041921585798264, -0.9003676772117615, -0.39568421244621277, -0.18758495151996613, -0.8778814673423767, 0.5619951486587524, 0.21294504404067993, -0.72735995054245, 0.7871586084365845, -0.7316494584083557, 0.028842126950621605, 0.9625341892242432, 0.7333168387413025, -0.38526469469070435, 0.315157026052475, 0.9047719240188599, 0.21932922303676605, -0.015480177477002144, -0.0788038820028305, 0.1783667802810669, 0.34049689769744873, -0.43239763379096985, 0.7422241568565369, -0.42453715205192566, 0.3757920265197754, 1.00045645236969, 0.3812003433704376, -0.6260676383972168, 0.8283843994140625, 0.7984782457351685, -0.13648049533367157, 0.32532086968421936, 1.1963016986846924, 0.032652825117111206, 0.5063101649284363, -0.12264653295278549, -0.09676219522953033, 0.2914772629737854, 0.02364814467728138, 0.5352418422698975, -0.047890208661556244, 0.5789995789527893, 0.43873322010040283, 0.11478890478610992, 0.043236080557107925, 0.19530025124549866, 0.3405008018016815, 1.261371374130249, -0.09126615524291992, -0.21487142145633698, 1.1043120622634888, 0.7342133522033691, 0.3953022062778473, -0.5165898203849792, 0.5119936466217041, -0.7334911823272705, 0.09671203047037125, 0.5194815397262573, -0.07421007007360458, -0.8234899044036865, 0.23975756764411926, 0.6276037096977234, 1.0810660123825073, -0.34478217363357544, -0.34953629970550537, -0.23663663864135742, -0.3062054514884949, 0.03920413926243782, 0.0354803167283535, -0.7911438345909119, -0.5666708946228027, -0.8693258762359619, -0.13576744496822357, 0.5229349732398987, -0.4608601927757263, -1.4837929010391235, 0.06363191455602646, -0.1518251597881317, -0.7858883738517761, -0.3182142972946167, -0.07961401343345642, -0.0007778314757160842, 0.2788875997066498, 1.1966993808746338, -0.2702861726284027, -0.2848070561885834, 0.020701952278614044, -0.5170639753341675, -0.05499636381864548, -0.28323638439178467, 0.2588520646095276, -0.37301039695739746, -0.22265809774398804, -1.0113670825958252, 0.8668572306632996, -0.19881309568881989, -0.8761140704154968, 0.4883680045604706, 0.1994539201259613, 0.05855564400553703, -0.16337625682353973, -0.3007429838180542, 0.5294926762580872, -0.6349759101867676, -0.24688564240932465, 1.1430164575576782, 0.5822271704673767, -0.41537904739379883, -0.27740296721458435, -0.38591626286506653, 0.9596486687660217, -0.4501436650753021, -0.5722924470901489, 0.3082427382469177, 0.07058820873498917, -0.45167049765586853, 0.07584493607282639, 0.16001257300376892, 0.09411231428384781, -0.4094431698322296, 0.4442577362060547, 0.4293611943721771, 0.07811219990253448, 0.18644048273563385, -0.19798293709754944, -0.7284932136535645, -0.7655962109565735, 0.43791884183883667, -0.9579201340675354, -0.04299990087747574, 0.6826478242874146, 0.11774805188179016, -0.8539080023765564, 0.8079931139945984, -0.5519920587539673, -0.5359846949577332, -0.025412991642951965, -0.31387460231781006, 0.1760985106229782, -0.053782545030117035, 0.14677980542182922, -0.3273978531360626, -0.14032097160816193, 0.38069483637809753, -0.07752978801727295, 0.2816459536552429, -0.7117588520050049, 0.20665693283081055, 0.011839738115668297, 0.29678139090538025, 0.008447523228824139, 0.004669979214668274, 0.21538145840168, -0.585059404373169, 0.30080750584602356, -0.40726181864738464, 0.08351265639066696, 0.4076099097728729, 0.30748212337493896, 0.17127977311611176, -0.13477309048175812, 0.41861072182655334, -0.23211653530597687, -0.929506778717041, -0.24396495521068573, -0.395407497882843, -0.1162334457039833, 1.0705064535140991, -0.9626727104187012, -0.6623609066009521, 0.05387802794575691, -0.5467840433120728, -0.16469770669937134, 0.4160727560520172, -1.084423303604126, 0.2351926863193512, 0.23192144930362701, -1.127130150794983, -0.07507366687059402, -0.6400707960128784, 0.08534170687198639, 0.35797667503356934, 0.2382628470659256, -0.32817795872688293, -0.34998270869255066, -0.48410552740097046, 0.23553185164928436, 0.29387253522872925, 0.4606654942035675, -0.010249299928545952, -0.058411553502082825, -0.06411013752222061, 0.06668715178966522, -0.09403672069311142, -0.3930168151855469, -0.10653796046972275, -1.6673486232757568, 0.352468878030777, -0.42598727345466614, -0.9685699939727783, 0.1566694676876068, 0.5435707569122314, 0.9351440668106079, -0.0936228483915329, 0.2628098130226135, -0.5643065571784973, 0.08300483226776123, -0.33134233951568604, 0.6909081935882568, -1.123766303062439, 0.009943201206624508, -0.1314418464899063, 0.6327129602432251, 0.7996765375137329, -0.3104819357395172, 0.48633140325546265, -0.4754532277584076, -0.3685012757778168, 0.05747486650943756, 1.3319191932678223, -0.2705978453159332, 0.659078061580658, 0.5436686873435974, 0.22359740734100342, -0.485734224319458, -0.3029284179210663, 0.16592420637607574, 0.28366121649742126, 0.7670994400978088, -0.0638120025396347, -0.4871676564216614, 0.015605898573994637, -0.7377586364746094, 0.3732498288154602, 0.5451793074607849, -0.16814345121383667, -1.0167927742004395, -0.0795300230383873, 0.40617185831069946, 0.12052891403436661, 0.07965292781591415, 0.6150663495063782, 0.9692835807800293, 0.3027757704257965, -0.5388197898864746, 0.6358833909034729, 1.4753729104995728, -0.6103777885437012, 0.039722930639982224, 0.3077870309352875, 0.360221266746521, 0.4117172658443451, 0.2805127203464508, 0.17974449694156647, -0.09895378351211548, 0.29174622893333435, -0.2647770941257477, 0.9470707178115845, -0.33195096254348755, -0.5284438133239746, 0.607332706451416, 0.11398062109947205, -0.6492911577224731, 0.8667040467262268, -0.23074083030223846, -0.55085688829422, -0.01103650126606226, -0.338850200176239, -0.6565164923667908, -0.3148331046104431, 0.8763701319694519, 0.08712784200906754, 0.6102426648139954, 0.38703402876853943, -0.33050426840782166, 0.13389348983764648, -0.19620467722415924, -0.9410919547080994, 0.17037004232406616, 0.5607656836509705, -0.2788216471672058, -0.41504931449890137, 0.2564094662666321, -0.4152831733226776, -0.1266147941350937, 0.025990890339016914, 0.23520876467227936, -0.23310263454914093, 0.2031257301568985, -0.33811697363853455, -0.31565967202186584, -0.7939976453781128, -0.5867922306060791, -0.9998166561126709, 0.44208359718322754, -0.3755108714103699, 0.010511164553463459, -0.6919887065887451, -0.7495304942131042, 0.4950442612171173, -0.6774196624755859, -0.13066557049751282, -0.5388947129249573, 0.011544314213097095, -0.3698490560054779, 0.08118966221809387, 0.07285439968109131, -0.7340391874313354, 0.5895197987556458, 0.05653927102684975, 0.004827786702662706, -0.364887535572052, -0.7011624574661255, -0.17429281771183014, -0.02255556918680668, 0.1299993395805359, 0.2483932375907898, -0.23777589201927185, 0.45865023136138916, 0.014194438233971596, 0.15655340254306793, -0.3582381010055542, -0.7900577783584595, 0.1373993158340454, 0.4883671998977661, 0.6484259366989136, -0.9553343057632446, -0.06378374993801117, -0.013594564981758595, 0.7082209587097168, 0.3773789703845978, -0.3784257769584656, -1.3078111410140991, 0.18656446039676666, -1.4579628705978394, 0.7399300336837769, -0.4473628103733063, -0.1454402655363083, -0.5749555826187134, -0.1777457445859909, -0.27401429414749146, 0.5534136295318604, -0.20614758133888245, -0.45866358280181885, -0.5354416966438293, -0.12867479026317596, 0.27578893303871155, -0.4044897258281708, 0.36475542187690735, -0.2067466825246811, -0.18693043291568756, -0.43846920132637024, 1.3540438413619995, -0.38642266392707825, -0.6619266867637634, 0.6193287968635559, 0.45939597487449646, -0.39373159408569336, 0.14477498829364777, 0.27877673506736755, -0.3268152177333832, -1.084365725517273, 0.489352822303772, 0.2994479537010193, 0.010465063154697418, 0.5385048389434814, 0.42012518644332886, -0.039991460740566254, 0.37711378931999207, 0.15823981165885925, 0.252828449010849, -0.6855301260948181, -0.15684965252876282, 0.6105572581291199, 0.1951497197151184, -0.178245410323143, 0.3984529674053192, -0.14122283458709717, 0.4165118634700775, 0.19325196743011475, -0.784868597984314, -1.0365791320800781, -0.17173174023628235, -1.3525891304016113, 0.0039337859489023685, 0.1790599822998047, -0.33166229724884033, -0.419518381357193, -0.20859691500663757, -0.14529949426651, -0.25045153498649597, 0.25738784670829773, 0.7407543659210205, 0.7214707136154175, 0.5144522786140442, -0.8098018765449524, 0.24974346160888672, -0.380948007106781, -0.09154365211725235, 0.35890787839889526, -0.4500654339790344, -0.09718456864356995, -0.39726522564888, -0.24272601306438446, -0.6357040405273438, -0.7337636947631836, 0.12382366508245468, 0.17964690923690796, 0.1507275253534317, 0.5485191941261292, -0.12078290432691574, -0.016650961712002754, -0.012821572832763195, 0.6584426760673523, 0.34995293617248535, -0.18554630875587463, 0.3994702398777008, 0.04005242511630058, -0.019814230501651764, -0.2123410850763321, 0.09122084081172943, -0.7940571308135986, 0.03721661865711212, 0.6716135144233704, -0.2472030371427536, -0.20895367860794067, 0.7825775146484375, -0.4141785800457001, -0.8682546615600586, -0.149419367313385, -0.6976730823516846, -0.284044474363327, 0.27817046642303467, -1.066324234008789, -0.5670844912528992, -0.15361621975898743, -0.21450206637382507, -0.2473025619983673, -0.1567535102367401, 0.7807521820068359, 0.13745754957199097, 0.33480045199394226, -0.9328619241714478, -0.8178216814994812, 0.1629478931427002, 0.8861227631568909, 0.20505234599113464, -0.5552995800971985, 0.23463578522205353, -0.1678193062543869, -0.402554452419281, -0.20001159608364105, 0.4757797122001648, -0.2936706840991974, 0.03774340823292732, -0.02239837497472763, 0.602037250995636, 0.15858246386051178, 0.506645143032074, 0.3556177020072937, 0.9683466553688049, -0.5366376638412476, -0.7659924030303955, -0.05805724114179611, -0.17578046023845673, 0.2462618052959442, 0.6830960512161255, -0.14760789275169373, 0.1064884290099144, -0.48720547556877136, -0.050694216042757034, -0.26580187678337097, -0.44390544295310974, -0.8334731459617615, -0.5143747925758362, -0.7659111022949219, -1.100284218788147, -0.42354291677474976, 0.26468437910079956, 0.36154717206954956, -0.2355819195508957, 0.5624833106994629, 0.2581789195537567, 0.34617066383361816, 0.22038453817367554, 0.955777108669281, -0.2871784269809723, -0.40810200572013855, -0.2993900775909424, -0.4997495114803314, -0.16039833426475525, -0.7164486646652222, -0.22255174815654755, -0.21682363748550415, 0.33828121423721313, 0.9817992448806763, -0.6529736518859863, 0.5151374340057373, -0.2236039936542511, -0.5867767930030823, 0.4641066789627075, -0.14283032715320587, -0.9159281849861145, 1.7029796838760376, -0.45963895320892334, 0.5780922174453735, -0.25653326511383057, -0.10457867383956909, -0.4195781350135803, -0.3716147541999817, -0.7988228797912598, 0.8592522740364075, -0.11208533495664597, 0.6795170307159424, 0.5282002687454224, -0.41063302755355835, -0.13007880747318268, 0.39814019203186035, -0.4454866647720337, -0.14429527521133423, 0.10504889488220215, 0.7972334623336792, -0.44257238507270813, -0.05210238695144653, -0.40959104895591736, -0.15884718298912048, -0.24080263078212738, -0.507635235786438, -0.17450298368930817, -0.5482993125915527, -0.4517807960510254, 0.356342613697052, -0.3444942533969879, -0.8229010105133057, 0.8479216694831848, -0.3151232898235321, 0.2358347475528717, 0.21123237907886505, 0.02256418764591217, 0.4965642988681793, -0.33979663252830505, -0.29369595646858215, 0.08695141971111298, 0.4928953945636749, -0.17032966017723083, 0.6227046251296997, 0.7529024481773376, 0.37566184997558594, 0.5873309969902039, -0.23138807713985443, -0.3752107620239258, 0.31349000334739685, -1.0807905197143555, -0.7452930212020874, 0.697117269039154, -0.37450170516967773, 0.6272915005683899, 0.415375292301178, -0.8342588543891907, -0.02014702744781971, -0.09718293696641922, 0.8587227463722229, 0.9204281568527222, -0.6468397974967957, -0.6120966672897339, 0.4214493930339813, -0.9972903728485107, -0.11572662740945816, -0.3688516914844513, 0.6887708902359009, -0.37412455677986145, -1.2663137912750244, -0.34078964591026306, 0.00622602878138423, -0.20450475811958313, -0.6402955651283264, -0.18241029977798462, -0.04228709638118744, 0.11429249495267868, -0.4905668795108795, -0.3327934145927429, -0.6091268062591553, -1.0445142984390259, -0.16258949041366577, -0.3761756122112274, -0.11676298826932907, 0.028601650148630142, 0.15174192190170288, 0.5155811309814453, 0.11778884381055832, -0.4822123348712921, 0.9968348741531372, 0.7461100816726685, -0.2019399106502533, -0.20819109678268433, 0.24628417193889618, 0.6437662839889526, 0.6105465292930603, -0.6615086197853088, 0.5310046076774597, 0.8984698057174683, 0.03127921372652054, -0.28005677461624146, -1.2838196754455566, -0.12278349697589874, 0.33525291085243225, -0.0308743417263031, -0.48341086506843567, -0.16744773089885712, -0.2821063995361328, 0.1376112550497055, 0.15402457118034363, 0.17705902457237244, -0.40343019366264343, 0.2701399624347687, -0.49856629967689514, 0.15714408457279205, -0.15469564497470856, -1.016948938369751, -0.7219695448875427, 0.10317275673151016, 0.580865740776062, -0.1094769686460495, 0.23790991306304932, -0.46663790941238403, 0.5603247284889221, -0.0029241626616567373, 0.09815847873687744, -0.9402527213096619, 0.276700496673584, 0.5694175958633423, -0.10872238129377365, -0.4774041771888733, 0.4112702012062073, 0.18145982921123505, 0.8111082911491394, 0.2178565412759781, -0.2152712047100067, 1.0559825897216797, 0.5875562429428101, -0.3102184534072876, -0.8952624797821045, -1.211998462677002, -0.6118056178092957, -0.690097987651825, -0.11129674315452576, 0.5935989022254944, -0.579042911529541, -0.2919447124004364, -0.580120325088501, -0.09666365385055542, -0.8043820261955261, 0.3120093047618866, 0.4674881398677826, -0.30919963121414185, -0.4326866567134857, 0.047577809542417526, 0.6550766229629517, 0.2578297555446625, 0.543987512588501, 0.34058547019958496, 0.34921795129776, 1.348505973815918, 0.5957251191139221, 0.5432043075561523, -0.2986305058002472, -0.781869113445282, 0.08494852483272552, 0.14137089252471924, 0.48087090253829956, 0.10326306521892548, 1.3536860942840576, -0.8615151643753052, 0.6725428700447083, -0.49729347229003906, -0.0725407674908638, 0.29496467113494873, -0.3547038435935974, 0.22957272827625275, 0.22038951516151428, -0.4526022672653198, 0.07423311471939087, 0.35169896483421326, 0.5747043490409851, 0.1321069896221161, -0.5381508469581604, 0.4506300687789917, -1.0729467868804932, 0.5228952765464783, -1.0248032808303833, 0.6070609092712402, 0.08106530457735062, 0.031842105090618134, 0.02795552648603916, -0.1042250543832779, -0.42584362626075745, -0.7385936975479126, -0.4706747531890869, -0.26177000999450684, 0.3426131308078766, 0.9147679209709167, 0.4133869409561157, 0.6172501444816589, -0.5157399773597717, -1.0005658864974976, -0.34387168288230896, 0.3964208662509918, -0.16333003342151642, 1.195101022720337, 0.5342963933944702, 0.27711039781570435, -1.3627498149871826, 0.9915267825126648, 0.7659212350845337, -0.1412087082862854, 0.27603423595428467, 0.09167585521936417, -0.08494514971971512, -0.2780931293964386, -0.7166749835014343, 0.23347525298595428, 0.5130979418754578, -0.19384299218654633, 0.7828437685966492, -0.08168398588895798, 0.0517251193523407, -0.5505861043930054, -0.6145156025886536, -0.4240180253982544, 0.32204318046569824, 0.4634366035461426, -0.6116307377815247, -0.43574151396751404, -1.102622389793396, 3.971829891204834, 0.9364431500434875, 0.05181466415524483, -0.046715572476387024, 0.8090176582336426, 1.4194039106369019, 0.4415872395038605, -0.00431218883022666, 0.20005272328853607, 0.35499870777130127, -0.07175557315349579, -0.3770272135734558, 0.39617812633514404, 0.010783212259411812, 0.5000061392784119, 0.7766029238700867, -0.0459371916949749, -0.14601747691631317, -0.2436598241329193, -0.5437299013137817, -1.3832926750183105, 0.06718596816062927, 0.27675148844718933, 0.3571326732635498, 0.30959030985832214, 0.32123106718063354, -0.3845859169960022, -0.5972357392311096, -0.5338597893714905, -0.23759788274765015, -0.3475170433521271, -0.8082172870635986, 0.5545974373817444, -0.5205117464065552, -0.14141680300235748, 0.18562310934066772, -0.7269569635391235, 0.2068764567375183, -0.11724304407835007, -0.10440476983785629, -0.4029931426048279, -0.07790204882621765, 0.5889936685562134, -0.4582378566265106, 0.1164747029542923, 1.486953616142273, 0.06830727308988571, 0.6822778582572937, 0.8080227971076965, -0.3532504141330719, 0.4890310764312744, 0.10266429930925369, 0.4127081632614136, -0.419912189245224, -0.9200676679611206, -0.32808125019073486, -0.20609062910079956, -0.3019675016403198, 0.9103165864944458, -0.024269694462418556, 0.4803487956523895, 0.8034713268280029, -0.28318947553634644, 0.46468639373779297, 0.20165769755840302, -0.17984893918037415, 0.025270577520132065, -0.19642779231071472, -0.13419964909553528, 0.1833701729774475, -0.6764810681343079, -0.1380130648612976, -0.2625575065612793, -0.912647545337677, -0.05890672281384468, 0.19947685301303864, 0.16703756153583527, 0.6182073950767517, -0.38231161236763, 0.6470990777015686, -1.119005799293518, -0.2056351602077484, 0.11160951107740402, -0.046498414129018784, 0.4810217320919037, 1.2502574920654297, 0.17918190360069275, -0.07893724739551544, -0.7108993530273438, 0.40632373094558716, 0.3097062408924103, 0.7635403275489807, -0.45441609621047974, 0.6770415306091309, -0.42704400420188904 ]
Gravitational Waves in the Nonsymmetric Gravitational Theory
We prove that the flux of gravitational radiation from an isolated source in the Nonsymmetric Gravitational Theory is identical to that found in Einstein's General Theory of Relativity.
N. J. Cornish, J. W. Moffat and D. C. Tatarski
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211023
gr-qc/9211024
[ 0.7287670373916626, 1.1852772235870361, 0.37263166904449463, -0.44623616337776184, 0.08101856708526611, 0.4546946585178375, 0.05025235190987587, 0.12723448872566223, -0.5874958634376526, 1.7496347427368164, 0.8134149312973022, 0.18604372441768646, -0.3828841745853424, -0.9908075332641602, -0.6816580891609192, 0.16483476758003235, -0.14743655920028687, 0.40734484791755676, -0.5308963656425476, 0.24124263226985931, -0.3634614646434784, 0.3671310842037201, -0.9223980903625488, -0.8165162801742554, -0.9434724450111389, 0.8126173615455627, 0.7843887209892273, -0.21225865185260773, 1.3668763637542725, 1.1275436878204346, 1.1210179328918457, 0.2408178746700287, -0.3791114091873169, -0.9714869260787964, -0.1640326976776123, -0.017267409712076187, -0.06540394574403763, -0.06440717726945877, 0.5507991313934326, -0.8641630411148071, 0.5832536220550537, 0.03960971534252167, 0.16213424503803253, -0.14594516158103943, -0.7709420323371887, -0.11541318893432617, 0.18920530378818512, -0.23467738926410675, -0.47545313835144043, -1.1310595273971558, 0.2986098825931549, 0.06265483051538467, 0.34807470440864563, -0.733095109462738, 0.06319918483495712, -0.09035459905862808, -0.15337210893630981, 0.12813742458820343, -0.1559341996908188, 0.43982091546058655, 0.9077825546264648, 1.027559757232666, 0.7134794592857361, -0.7029305696487427, 0.8319212794303894, 1.2339651584625244, -0.4059267044067383, 0.3532902002334595, 0.3492460250854492, -0.39616623520851135, -0.3269444406032562, -0.2038273960351944, -0.17073185741901398, 0.49177077412605286, -0.17110534012317657, 1.2590266466140747, -0.3534696400165558, -0.18331676721572876, -0.7091789245605469, -0.5787491798400879, 0.33429086208343506, -0.4127638339996338, 0.06012440845370293, 0.18818537890911102, -0.18776369094848633, -0.1371634155511856, -0.07933118939399719, 0.08613048493862152, 0.39153119921684265, 0.32434359192848206, 0.3922489285469055, 0.8119543194770813, 0.21880856156349182, -0.12480460852384567, 0.5871684551239014, 0.8203946352005005, 0.06800159066915512, 0.8290965557098389, 0.759621798992157, 0.40943923592567444, -0.6346872448921204, 0.9825736284255981, -0.17464478313922882, 0.2317165583372116, -0.36991944909095764, 0.5693868398666382, -0.4327402114868164, 0.6656492948532104, -0.25330719351768494, -0.6719725728034973, -0.24390168488025665, 0.09035204350948334, 0.659407913684845, 0.33717435598373413, 0.016357706859707832, 0.5855557322502136, -0.4568425416946411, -0.0005397296044975519, -0.7701610326766968, -0.940182626247406, -0.5747290849685669, 0.38801613450050354, 0.6941537857055664, 0.6336791515350342, -0.4450681507587433, -0.8564831614494324, 0.06907031685113907, 0.2881372570991516, -0.28451067209243774, -0.11622697114944458, 0.08951853215694427, 0.1640593409538269, -0.20312640070915222, 0.6534039974212646, 0.15725202858448029, 0.6136161088943481, 0.5934209227561951, 0.3904817998409271, -0.21359403431415558, -0.7549120783805847, -0.14158007502555847, 0.09682124108076096, 0.676041305065155, 1.2653005123138428, -0.7152357697486877, 0.6314859390258789, -0.19656361639499664, -0.212147057056427, -0.4796156883239746, -0.3644918203353882, -0.9324299693107605, -0.43602612614631653, 0.07529239356517792, 0.28107815980911255, 0.30753040313720703, -0.12669111788272858, -1.1679279804229736, -0.17444786429405212, -0.010145478881895542, -0.6068996787071228, 0.15157876908779144, 0.45863059163093567, 0.5961941480636597, 1.0372202396392822, -0.9123917818069458, 0.23713946342468262, -0.9532201886177063, -0.4002739191055298, -0.08002766221761703, -0.30701351165771484, 0.5967646241188049, 0.1730624884366989, -0.07246449589729309, 0.33596789836883545, 0.8960862159729004, 0.9106857180595398, 0.17304763197898865, -0.25588172674179077, -0.5019175410270691, 0.6723210215568542, -0.1163177341222763, -0.11017963290214539, 0.8323776721954346, 0.7951682209968567, -0.6999940276145935, -0.7440536022186279, -0.0777689591050148, -0.26334115862846375, 0.45174795389175415, 0.2359759360551834, -0.5630071759223938, 0.4139360189437866, -1.4764598608016968, 1.145748496055603, -1.022634744644165, -0.1652292013168335, -1.032767415046692, -0.13689421117305756, -0.08654098957777023, -0.7440491914749146, 0.1600414216518402, 0.1350763738155365, -0.6834088563919067, 1.0158671140670776, -1.2621642351150513, -0.06133340299129486, 0.11905914545059204, 0.6789500713348389, -0.29141438007354736, 0.04055703058838844, 0.2907404601573944, -0.2411545366048813, 0.2092277854681015, -0.7097827792167664, 0.7355908751487732, -0.031884532421827316, 0.012846666388213634, 0.3375982940196991, 0.5685742497444153, -0.4410002529621124, 0.7792754769325256, 0.04350654408335686, -0.05056849494576454, 0.8812665343284607, -0.005556940101087093, -0.2313130795955658, 0.5731166005134583, 0.31953588128089905, -0.24785299599170685, 0.11834662407636642, 0.3937864601612091, 0.5273783206939697, -0.009062521159648895, 0.4165841341018677, 0.2727934420108795, -0.18492445349693298, 0.04246823489665985, 0.7202448844909668, -0.24541500210762024, 0.376649409532547, 0.3644666373729706, 0.30415087938308716, 0.39741721749305725, 0.2905142307281494, -0.9732338190078735, 0.3386992812156677, -0.26377347111701965, -0.04391920194029808, -0.26820066571235657, 0.4875507056713104, -0.3409832715988159, 0.6489430665969849, -0.5116387009620667, 0.266980916261673, -1.162448525428772, -0.13289518654346466, 0.1309802234172821, 0.4499856233596802, 0.13314981758594513, -1.2552342414855957, -0.608393132686615, 0.521208643913269, -0.17978762090206146, -1.4649633169174194, -0.569080114364624, 0.9012545943260193, -0.4013526439666748, -0.0064664576202631, 0.7632081508636475, -0.19924841821193695, -1.4145649671554565, 0.016096893697977066, -0.7807921171188354, -0.15507040917873383, -0.3490084111690521, 0.04248073324561119, 0.10854083299636841, -0.0742887556552887, 0.38258540630340576, -0.08825068175792694, -0.20200276374816895, 0.2878338396549225, 0.5689528584480286, 0.2981269955635071, -0.3343789279460907, 0.19991730153560638, -0.5417431592941284, 0.06290140002965927, -1.110073208808899, 0.3168376088142395, -0.09001174569129944, -0.7611309885978699, -0.47285622358322144, -0.5465763807296753, -0.015203272923827171, 0.10224009305238724, -0.38010498881340027, 0.2797165811061859, -0.1510600447654724, -0.7650356888771057, 1.0544260740280151, 0.34540292620658875, -0.5812503695487976, 0.06180429086089134, -1.1689918041229248, 0.662331759929657, 0.11066119372844696, -0.41086891293525696, 0.979870617389679, -0.2623238265514374, -0.7961915135383606, 0.3909205198287964, 0.3443780243396759, 0.4666415750980377, -0.1499345451593399, 0.9330981373786926, 0.7084009051322937, -0.24769724905490875, 0.8074725866317749, -0.6494797468185425, -0.30308157205581665, -0.20214147865772247, 0.3942311406135559, -0.5043960809707642, 0.6849899291992188, 0.8812788128852844, 0.9067776799201965, -1.0949721336364746, 0.5088215470314026, -1.5503160953521729, -0.932744562625885, 0.11360415071249008, -0.12877170741558075, 0.14320437610149384, -0.475359708070755, -0.3338302969932556, -1.1006371974945068, -0.17423857748508453, -0.2297092229127884, 0.9102373123168945, 0.865227460861206, -0.691887378692627, 0.48967278003692627, 0.4331527650356293, 0.12559238076210022, -0.3216441869735718, 0.7831024527549744, -0.6998874545097351, -0.3856152594089508, 0.36324962973594666, -0.4599260985851288, 0.0819767415523529, -0.15126551687717438, -0.5922347903251648, -0.44412410259246826, 0.5646064281463623, -0.23119337856769562, 0.0082621481269598, -0.7587786316871643, -0.4939795732498169, 0.639481782913208, 0.2778078019618988, 0.6331056952476501, 0.00775022292509675, -0.43719449639320374, -0.16139863431453705, 0.1626535952091217, -0.0308119747787714, 0.502999484539032, -1.2162861824035645, 0.12783072888851166, -0.15436111390590668, -0.07450731098651886, -0.04986223578453064, 0.2658056318759918, 0.005792661104351282, 0.20751187205314636, 0.6622210144996643, -0.0310624111443758, -0.32067349553108215, -0.4835021197795868, -0.06406854093074799, 0.7518147826194763, 0.31870055198669434, 0.3591218888759613, 0.0045456066727638245, -0.016878845170140266, 0.2883874475955963, -0.13820040225982666, -0.7380726337432861, -0.706466555595398, -0.7783944606781006, 0.5058102011680603, -0.6821796298027039, -0.3031962513923645, 0.2942863702774048, 0.8552414774894714, 1.132703423500061, -0.3789544999599457, 0.14035692811012268, -0.09110499173402786, -0.4226266145706177, 0.45250511169433594, 1.1450871229171753, 0.3956770598888397, 0.4221418797969818, -0.6268091201782227, 0.8237280249595642, -0.3818017244338989, 0.7547743320465088, -0.026897845789790154, -0.8613912463188171, -0.027391342446208, -0.9689566493034363, 0.6061960458755493, -0.12232376635074615, -0.3588216304779053, 0.8474388718605042, 0.07709085941314697, 0.5167523622512817, -0.21824398636817932, -0.32349881529808044, 0.22589056193828583, 0.7051751613616943, -0.08897406607866287, -0.8748186826705933, -0.2132301926612854, -0.8482181429862976, 0.3912908732891083, -0.02269391342997551, -0.23328721523284912, -1.3175474405288696, -1.0214780569076538, -0.5126259326934814, -0.11602504551410675, 0.17092189192771912, 0.5820483565330505, 0.1594545990228653, 0.21400675177574158, -0.08055154979228973, -0.14693337678909302, 0.7537686824798584, -0.7416794300079346, -0.7689897418022156, 0.21943454444408417, 0.32138121128082275, -0.5626907348632812, 0.8725079894065857, -0.57984459400177, -0.8447192311286926, -0.3232073187828064, -0.20057128369808197, 0.8588865995407104, -0.13727794587612152, -0.6664929389953613, -0.06623654067516327, 0.1827654093503952, -0.16292864084243774, -0.03780636191368103, -0.44236236810684204, 0.11333082616329193, 0.2571076452732086, 0.027028148993849754, -0.9708179235458374, -0.6049771308898926, -0.24198156595230103, 0.08718037605285645, 0.43352001905441284, 0.6604901552200317, -0.016013741493225098, 0.6799498796463013, -0.29848042130470276, -0.06920254230499268, 0.1054476648569107, 1.1533061265945435, -0.3571721017360687, 0.02219318225979805, 0.41059520840644836, -0.13831426203250885, -0.4520990252494812, -0.1548824906349182, 0.313846617937088, -0.5134490132331848, 0.5293685793876648, -0.07449665665626526, -1.3652130365371704, -0.2798154950141907, -0.781370222568512, -0.40536728501319885, 0.629574179649353, -0.20714707672595978, -0.6765183806419373, -0.14120608568191528, -0.19322456419467926, 0.14808160066604614, 0.2813333570957184, -0.4168352484703064, -0.024601969867944717, 0.05404676869511604, 0.6710646748542786, -0.47814998030662537, 0.7186533212661743, -0.513485312461853, -0.13689951598644257, -0.44704699516296387, -0.427848219871521, -0.8134737610816956, -0.7042519450187683, -0.12553741037845612, 0.19859381020069122, 0.03480317443609238, -0.37100592255592346, 0.04513082280755043, -0.28235429525375366, -0.03244542330503464, 0.8560044765472412, 0.09265291690826416, -0.8561834692955017, -0.6493680477142334, 0.029143745079636574, 0.2890830636024475, -0.43434473872184753, 0.07446401566267014, 0.8955105543136597, -0.23192422091960907, 0.36560943722724915, -0.22582799196243286, -0.5772901773452759, 0.07606513798236847, -0.6203824281692505, 0.3706801235675812, -1.3626095056533813, -0.22807985544204712, 0.104009248316288, -0.6320121884346008, -0.0011520909611135721, 0.6745453476905823, -0.04188595712184906, 0.3412477970123291, -0.1640649139881134, -0.4301828145980835, 0.5819151401519775, -0.17709369957447052, 0.09591929614543915, -0.3476032614707947, -0.1346745491027832, -0.36020103096961975, 1.3622630834579468, -0.8494293093681335, -0.23745125532150269, 0.24543915688991547, 0.5239707827568054, -0.23231445252895355, 0.8875926733016968, 0.01477735210210085, -0.23991408944129944, -0.15730158984661102, 0.11495912820100784, 0.3635673224925995, -0.02215457335114479, -0.5312843918800354, -0.21470127999782562, -0.6334632635116577, 0.7003048658370972, 0.024911411106586456, 0.36759597063064575, 0.7486181855201721, 0.25626105070114136, 1.1315253973007202, -0.9531937837600708, 0.1479576677083969, 0.5551918148994446, 0.1320919692516327, 0.9478573203086853, 0.04797650873661041, -0.7737225294113159, 0.21695221960544586, -1.0034674406051636, -0.9938464164733887, 1.0637052059173584, 0.18789410591125488, -0.058834318071603775, -0.6459209322929382, -0.6213458180427551, -0.33374905586242676, -0.20599018037319183, 0.5826136469841003, 0.3024841845035553, 0.3090696930885315, 0.8611747622489929, -0.18379895389080048, 0.4198579788208008, -0.0756799504160881, -0.20250293612480164, 0.7426286339759827, -0.2468908429145813, 0.1130129024386406, -0.07619661092758179, -0.441529780626297, -0.009502097964286804, -0.4293609857559204, 0.8417333364486694, 0.7687250971794128, -0.00964371021836996, 1.098528265953064, -0.09222280234098434, -0.4861280918121338, -0.7009410262107849, -0.1653832495212555, 0.46686285734176636, 0.41620439291000366, 0.06825464963912964, 0.13034281134605408, -0.40609410405158997, 0.4580494463443756, 0.023345505818724632, -1.156238317489624, -1.196303129196167, 0.9208394289016724, -0.8080080151557922, -0.21346841752529144, 0.08890622854232788, -0.4178617000579834, -0.36004263162612915, -1.1767135858535767, -1.3644046783447266, 0.04850149527192116, 0.8743702173233032, -0.7003090977668762, 0.298588365316391, 0.18779723346233368, 0.3517734110355377, -0.07778394967317581, 0.3150118887424469, 0.5353240966796875, 0.8885887861251831, 0.23220206797122955, 0.3367628753185272, -0.21674470603466034, 0.016592659056186676, 1.2243237495422363, 0.19862157106399536, -0.5435044765472412, -0.12254203110933304, -0.20058494806289673, -0.43844476342201233, 0.16190630197525024, 0.8028160929679871, -0.3922784626483917, 0.17840658128261566, 0.08717317879199982, 0.3521040976047516, 0.19191481173038483, 0.07914161682128906, 0.13941191136837006, 0.36527761816978455, -0.8994389176368713, -0.8875792026519775, -0.26788461208343506, 0.14557096362113953, 0.1801348626613617, 0.4192640781402588, -0.03143547847867012, 0.26574766635894775, 0.05488359183073044, -0.5088801980018616, -0.09205131232738495, -0.956246018409729, 0.3920820951461792, -1.0014387369155884, -0.759138286113739, -0.6251161694526672, -0.45937687158584595, -0.12162596732378006, 0.5996738076210022, -0.9221813082695007, 0.518941342830658, 0.16631022095680237, 0.09545943886041641, 0.09321611374616623, 0.6308321952819824, -0.11867932230234146, -0.26837724447250366, -1.0483458042144775, -0.05115198716521263, -0.4275512397289276, -1.2014411687850952, -0.27185821533203125, -0.331770122051239, 0.7465975880622864, 1.1801806688308716, -0.207450732588768, 0.10655108839273453, -0.524395227432251, -0.7065234780311584, 0.2926251292228699, 0.3113088309764862, -1.1323859691619873, 0.8069968223571777, -0.7678901553153992, 0.558139443397522, 0.4901435971260071, 0.46684643626213074, -0.3407096266746521, 0.37735456228256226, -1.4782415628433228, 0.42780929803848267, 0.34126824140548706, 0.4602036476135254, 0.19145649671554565, -0.7361146807670593, 0.5957595705986023, 0.195749893784523, -0.7899167537689209, -0.7343117594718933, -0.5209689736366272, -0.7221291661262512, -0.27701619267463684, 0.35029011964797974, -0.32940223813056946, 0.7139659523963928, -0.27862030267715454, 0.3476217985153198, -0.07923419773578644, -0.01637808419764042, -0.1585894376039505, 0.40842050313949585, -0.2574886083602905, -0.33914461731910706, 0.3879840672016144, -1.0063457489013672, -0.30419906973838806, 0.6968355774879456, -0.37009793519973755, 0.6662259697914124, 0.03723057731986046, -0.70018070936203, -0.39493414759635925, 0.616246223449707, -1.331181287765503, 0.7822356820106506, 0.04180377349257469, 0.20950165390968323, 0.47701820731163025, -0.20833730697631836, -1.0541775226593018, 0.5806094408035278, 0.01362188346683979, -0.5170219540596008, 0.15103015303611755, -0.3821216821670532, -0.01591828092932701, 0.25264808535575867, -0.37754639983177185, 0.21277526021003723, 0.13686808943748474, 0.8039026856422424, 0.6373151540756226, 0.0022731705103069544, 0.07917129248380661, 0.665372371673584, -0.8407749533653259, 0.08791377395391464, -0.6175148487091064, 0.3017941117286682, -0.6243283748626709, -0.3308310806751251, 0.03711263835430145, 0.3386324942111969, -0.00028362160082906485, -0.3480577766895294, 0.03209150955080986, 0.11596909165382385, 0.3535937964916229, -0.8086212873458862, 0.7391374707221985, -0.23385058343410492, -0.1631687432527542, 0.5777308940887451, 0.34549680352211, -0.4208715260028839, 0.627232015132904, 0.37553372979164124, 0.8644435405731201, 0.23270559310913086, -0.27653267979621887, 0.7697343826293945, -0.5285027027130127, 0.6150595545768738, 1.0167443752288818, 0.4934673011302948, 1.182461142539978, 0.9282168745994568, -0.23891383409500122, 0.48075637221336365, 0.14622986316680908, 0.1918533593416214, 0.998433530330658, 0.15190330147743225, -0.028359923511743546, 0.8056857585906982, 0.03517797216773033, 0.08088500052690506, 0.9186676740646362, 0.16611169278621674, -0.21317341923713684, 0.5880842804908752, -0.416445255279541, 0.5874502062797546, 0.10807448625564575, -0.2815195918083191, -0.4706678092479706, -0.37289977073669434, 0.17125840485095978, -0.114483542740345, -0.2744579613208771, 0.7740241289138794, -0.6935039758682251, -0.24451151490211487, -1.107399821281433, 0.236005961894989, -0.25622040033340454, -0.37137746810913086, -0.4930107295513153, 0.4306303858757019, 0.8003255128860474, 0.1813374161720276, -0.8820158839225769, 0.5605976581573486, 0.13033242523670197, 0.4039047956466675, 0.5524352192878723, 0.6216251850128174, 0.33748653531074524, 0.23372651636600494, -0.05873904377222061, -0.656197726726532, 0.10557255893945694, 0.09553556144237518, -1.0000145435333252, -0.17812582850456238, 0.58330899477005, -0.4770529568195343, -0.32115811109542847, -0.27009040117263794, 0.16025717556476593, -0.6625325679779053, -0.5068405270576477, 0.4349621832370758, 0.00918006431311369, -0.27060604095458984, -0.00560704106464982, -0.4179724156856537, 0.2932131886482239, 0.6817945837974548, 1.2648862600326538, 0.1570860594511032, 0.8056977391242981, 0.8515670299530029, 0.34254077076911926, 0.04921247437596321, -0.5950257778167725, 0.03337179496884346, 0.3574688732624054, 0.3666042685508728, -0.8978284597396851, 0.24144406616687775, -0.5800395011901855, -0.4291112422943115, -0.515480101108551, -0.025588897988200188, -0.28269413113594055, -0.08305016905069351, 0.05718221142888069, 0.5288029313087463, -0.34497228264808655, 0.16563498973846436, 0.527113139629364, 0.6676978468894958, -0.464195191860199, -0.6321146488189697, 0.5865054726600647, -0.695555567741394, 0.02989286556839943, -0.8100179433822632, 0.13845747709274292, -0.31475722789764404, -0.13701002299785614, -0.2874435484409332, -0.6100609302520752, -0.5227826237678528, -0.45037609338760376, -0.1542128324508667, 0.037845056504011154, 0.6326330900192261, 0.5461083650588989, -0.08081194758415222, 0.6167553663253784, -0.29442518949508667, -0.142263725399971, 0.07279423624277115, 1.2108821868896484, -0.7515843510627747, 0.5290405750274658, 0.7201011180877686, -0.17173610627651215, -1.2965128421783447, 0.9162634611129761, 0.814990222454071, -0.5615525841712952, 0.06904809176921844, -0.48510971665382385, 0.35139787197113037, 0.24423857033252716, -0.2892128825187683, -0.04268578439950943, 0.015575913712382317, 0.4125823676586151, -1.1712454557418823, -0.38052040338516235, -0.10334411263465881, -0.545074462890625, 0.39326369762420654, -0.4807475209236145, 0.46839118003845215, 0.2641259431838989, -0.4811534583568573, 0.6284967064857483, -0.18363505601882935, 3.8075835704803467, 0.6868508458137512, 1.1139848232269287, -0.5766687393188477, 0.6478544473648071, 1.013696551322937, 0.05133868008852005, 0.061096709221601486, 0.5605432987213135, -0.5044235587120056, 0.18896484375, 0.47335636615753174, -0.2322292923927307, 0.33660924434661865, 0.4498288333415985, 0.31472688913345337, 0.32569757103919983, 0.10615668445825577, -0.19389373064041138, -0.4392046332359314, -0.9382699728012085, 0.27422499656677246, 0.2088581919670105, -0.6006221175193787, 0.7116937637329102, 0.7671587467193604, 0.49090632796287537, -0.28801432251930237, -0.43307730555534363, -0.30879825353622437, -0.19501270353794098, -0.4121743142604828, -0.4026034474372864, -0.3490683436393738, -1.1832871437072754, -0.13399840891361237, -0.13694904744625092, -0.2584134340286255, -0.12661923468112946, -0.09287534654140472, 0.4292934834957123, -0.6462451815605164, 0.05176904797554016, -0.7663621306419373, 0.03004252351820469, 0.7056514620780945, 0.5400238037109375, 0.7899882197380066, 0.32175320386886597, -0.7942672371864319, 0.003911126870661974, 0.20296329259872437, 0.7199802994728088, -0.8843033909797668, -1.0176039934158325, -1.051581859588623, -0.466324120759964, -0.5154171586036682, 0.1209777444601059, 0.26473304629325867, 0.8291281461715698, -0.532236635684967, -0.3757866322994232, -0.5937209129333496, 0.2335597574710846, -0.08672361820936203, 0.38321933150291443, -0.1426311582326889, -0.41104137897491455, 0.20254838466644287, -0.3848140239715576, -0.31207475066185, -0.7117114067077637, -0.32988816499710083, -0.07403139024972916, 0.14788436889648438, 0.6503499746322632, 0.6639470458030701, -0.797534704208374, -0.09819220006465912, -0.9123532176017761, 0.035603638738393784, 0.227767676115036, 0.3408661186695099, -0.3085813522338867, 0.8618987798690796, -0.2652829885482788, -0.5278428792953491, -0.2540394961833954, 0.4736078381538391, 0.11507195979356766, 0.8825864791870117, -0.6684251427650452, -0.002460542833432555, -1.3955317735671997 ]
Tunneling in Anisotropic Cosmological Models
Tunneling rate is investigated in homogenous and anisotropic cosmologies. The calculations is done by two methods: Euclidean and Hamiltonian approaches. It is found that the probability decreases exponentialy as anisotropy is increased.
R. Mansouri and M.Mohazzab (BROWN)
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211024
gr-qc/9211025
[ -0.1402512788772583, 0.45890867710113525, 0.16925644874572754, -0.26867613196372986, -0.07478341460227966, -0.05986480042338371, -0.5753577351570129, -0.24330267310142517, -0.30863577127456665, 0.9475754499435425, 0.24151182174682617, -0.4395254850387573, -0.7412616014480591, -1.3734409809112549, -0.06234085187315941, -0.4049837291240692, -0.006629666779190302, -0.046954769641160965, -0.9366114139556885, -0.6635586023330688, 0.8528586626052856, -0.2304173707962036, -0.9909490942955017, -0.04395245388150215, -0.3414539396762848, 0.5673640370368958, 0.5985482931137085, 0.3849260210990906, 0.9980433583259583, 1.0583909749984741, 0.1246098205447197, -0.8772544860839844, -0.4446594715118408, -0.9806011319160461, 0.059066299349069595, -0.0636376142501831, 0.03785765543580055, -0.23801325261592865, 0.8738399744033813, -0.6708097457885742, 0.42191651463508606, 0.5187920331954956, 0.28529971837997437, -0.2374233901500702, -0.5902627110481262, -0.17561869323253632, 0.07948366552591324, 0.19376341998577118, 0.19070850312709808, -0.57489413022995, 0.06384781748056412, -0.4487050771713257, 0.37818217277526855, -0.3969086706638336, -0.27364400029182434, -0.6247718334197998, 0.059437382966279984, 0.6685786247253418, -0.04487469047307968, -0.24893103539943695, 0.8006504774093628, 0.411719411611557, 0.3074636161327362, -1.2568901777267456, 0.03574680909514427, 1.3395755290985107, 0.16724392771720886, 0.23031584918498993, -0.28917765617370605, -0.8186272382736206, 0.46532386541366577, -0.2821172773838043, -0.06802806258201599, 0.5107326507568359, 0.10655885189771652, 0.5672335028648376, -0.16859577596187592, -0.05379524454474449, -1.9200674295425415, 0.08790333569049835, 0.08807556331157684, -0.0720246210694313, -0.03730326145887375, 0.3082685172557831, 0.13931873440742493, -0.5807151794433594, 0.14292581379413605, -0.5437520146369934, 0.3660433888435364, -0.24723704159259796, -0.44351646304130554, 1.2085658311843872, -0.9566534161567688, 0.03033704124391079, 0.6313638091087341, 0.1582069993019104, -0.24402189254760742, -0.7150241732597351, -0.22502776980400085, 0.4094710350036621, 0.22897839546203613, 0.9464738965034485, -0.24103215336799622, 0.507048487663269, -0.20550893247127533, 0.8114292025566101, 0.11609248071908951, 0.35268422961235046, 0.3284193277359009, -0.5441228151321411, 0.43193453550338745, 0.002858521416783333, 0.4614652395248413, 0.7293728590011597, -0.041173238307237625, 0.700735330581665, -0.3920767605304718, -0.19280794262886047, -0.0012709938455373049, 0.08309629559516907, -0.4329058527946472, 0.2686106860637665, 0.26043981313705444, 0.37698617577552795, 0.3401784598827362, -0.38067010045051575, -0.02015681378543377, -0.5376262664794922, -0.9029694199562073, -0.3182820677757263, 0.11486529558897018, -0.5213614106178284, 0.26992881298065186, -0.5418577194213867, 0.08533020317554474, 0.48286351561546326, 0.3631700277328491, 0.203979954123497, -0.4970380663871765, -0.645463228225708, 0.10696469247341156, -1.1773722171783447, 0.5557994246482849, 1.4290152788162231, -0.9610545635223389, 0.815338134765625, -0.013746454380452633, 0.006383221596479416, 0.422933965921402, -0.014090883545577526, 0.36127769947052, -0.31275758147239685, 0.06694750487804413, 0.7944445013999939, -0.1089572012424469, -0.8200883269309998, -1.1420509815216064, 0.1573309451341629, -0.44420120120048523, -0.5034576654434204, 0.05106485262513161, -0.15937195718288422, 0.7481557130813599, 0.8173139691352844, -0.13074733316898346, 0.06557692587375641, -0.2522013485431671, -0.5277923345565796, 0.11265089362859726, 0.2802858054637909, 0.020947415381669998, 0.0030382955446839333, 0.5613786578178406, 0.2605701684951782, 0.36868205666542053, 0.14230409264564514, 0.08302683383226395, -0.20480674505233765, -0.3540596663951874, 0.10459962487220764, 0.12194021791219711, -0.6463884711265564, 0.5011303424835205, 0.5815975666046143, -0.34477004408836365, 0.5211927890777588, -0.40092819929122925, 0.17683009803295135, -0.17254135012626648, 0.029834434390068054, -0.48150888085365295, 0.36152032017707825, -0.9555751085281372, 0.10228780657052994, -0.7914850115776062, -0.16493789851665497, -0.43434062600135803, 0.22404392063617706, -0.07358650863170624, -0.8551814556121826, 0.3388310968875885, -0.02907172404229641, -0.5475143790245056, 0.7862542867660522, -0.94046550989151, -0.44709867238998413, 1.0901283025741577, 0.4525746703147888, -0.7788528203964233, 0.19933271408081055, 0.696679949760437, 0.20357732474803925, -0.057019464671611786, 0.10708893090486526, 0.11472367495298386, 0.6883233189582825, -0.11336077749729156, 0.41745319962501526, 0.5194215774536133, -0.009340680204331875, 0.8014672994613647, 0.06689788401126862, 0.4829826056957245, 0.7013094425201416, 0.23242275416851044, -0.675565779209137, -0.1575552523136139, 1.0290632247924805, 0.11186999827623367, 0.7320221066474915, -0.19376212358474731, 0.3356647491455078, 0.7302807569503784, 0.05787811055779457, 0.5022546648979187, -0.20870797336101532, 0.4822394549846649, 0.20219069719314575, 0.7512415051460266, 0.17664681375026703, 0.4127735495567322, 0.2601425349712372, 0.5266665816307068, 0.5987836718559265, -0.025699608027935028, 0.29756999015808105, 0.5244998335838318, 0.8358105421066284, -0.3400796055793762, 0.8004035949707031, -0.754403293132782, 1.1389524936676025, 0.17212603986263275, 0.2939445972442627, -0.49679967761039734, 0.08313475549221039, 0.5879917144775391, 0.3594695031642914, -0.18166233599185944, -0.3811909258365631, -0.4901467561721802, 0.0011639369186013937, -0.33073195815086365, -0.4915235936641693, 0.532495379447937, 0.36588090658187866, -0.48854970932006836, -0.011799578554928303, 0.6308508515357971, -0.4060380160808563, -1.4378057718276978, 0.3310726583003998, -0.2752421796321869, -0.8815617561340332, -0.4429384469985962, -0.09176626056432724, 0.2526671886444092, -0.5856950879096985, 1.0085018873214722, -0.5817140936851501, -0.13711640238761902, 0.8825705051422119, -0.2227984070777893, 0.4489206075668335, -0.2617231011390686, 0.4647054672241211, -1.155936360359192, 0.5221035480499268, -0.3793906271457672, 0.928036630153656, 0.020392121747136116, -0.12363862991333008, 0.17512187361717224, -0.5642489790916443, 0.16273914277553558, -0.31770819425582886, -0.5819773077964783, -0.18854263424873352, 0.13916389644145966, -0.1096372902393341, 0.16429539024829865, 0.9798001050949097, -0.01745021902024746, 0.27344810962677, -0.5118159055709839, 0.5400773882865906, -0.3594038188457489, -0.5624536871910095, 0.5704898238182068, -0.3414478302001953, -0.6220917701721191, 0.23775005340576172, 0.004941344261169434, 0.3891119956970215, 0.0027084911707788706, 0.04438468813896179, 0.9528798460960388, -0.0523417666554451, 0.3549627959728241, 0.05641743540763855, -0.5699992775917053, -0.6272801160812378, 0.09614353626966476, 0.04868616536259651, -0.5148937106132507, 0.5120206475257874, 0.24366316199302673, -0.15832918882369995, 1.0815486907958984, -0.8181893229484558, -0.24116255342960358, 0.05818112939596176, 0.21351194381713867, 0.5363845825195312, -0.11422344297170639, -0.15977151691913605, -0.0880567654967308, 0.5488940477371216, 0.16268959641456604, 1.0037448406219482, 0.794791042804718, -0.3394438624382019, 0.158049538731575, 0.3502274453639984, -0.0835767388343811, -0.1277002990245819, 0.7070226669311523, 0.27642181515693665, -0.3986091613769531, 0.6579355597496033, -0.7016592025756836, -0.5262464880943298, 0.3216826319694519, 0.17400483787059784, 0.27518144249916077, 0.2231244295835495, 0.17465496063232422, 0.053400106728076935, -0.47128036618232727, 0.2007465958595276, -0.2982307970523834, 0.41068366169929504, 0.8407551646232605, -0.4539618194103241, -0.9679670333862305, 0.591282308101654, 0.020525304600596428, -0.0886632576584816, 0.3956252634525299, -0.32316768169403076, 0.18410485982894897, 0.03545365482568741, -0.692704439163208, -0.25958606600761414, -0.3079025149345398, -0.6390811800956726, 0.9690192937850952, 0.9514851570129395, 0.9642560482025146, -1.0301214456558228, -0.6084991097450256, -0.25887247920036316, 0.5695576071739197, -0.05467934161424637, 0.06232433021068573, -0.36670243740081787, 0.030066218227148056, 0.10881326347589493, -0.2266380339860916, -1.3724879026412964, -0.5121647119522095, -0.47207188606262207, -0.5655110478401184, -0.8567647337913513, -1.075448989868164, 0.09221867471933365, 0.3334008753299713, 0.25604817271232605, 0.0056631918996572495, -0.24641111493110657, -0.027442237362265587, -0.12128597497940063, 0.1726382076740265, 0.5235319137573242, -0.8823034763336182, 0.35325583815574646, -0.7074922919273376, -0.3408164978027344, 0.02438046969473362, -0.04716112092137337, 0.4382997155189514, -0.2361421436071396, -0.42912501096725464, -0.051894981414079666, 0.750033438205719, 0.15810059010982513, -0.10569270700216293, 0.681856095790863, -0.21741093695163727, 0.3094344139099121, -0.813154399394989, 0.8018046021461487, -0.16877417266368866, 0.5892809629440308, -0.24085907638072968, -0.2973974049091339, 0.6592550277709961, -0.915489912033081, 0.3642538785934448, 0.89434415102005, -1.062707781791687, -0.6668748259544373, -0.21853643655776978, 0.06506379693746567, 0.48737138509750366, 0.16425061225891113, 0.6409943103790283, 0.43816521763801575, 0.2193801999092102, 0.06238671392202377, 0.0036002458073198795, 1.0320870876312256, -0.20817913115024567, 0.20601008832454681, -0.09328003972768784, 0.28008341789245605, -0.330309122800827, -0.18209853768348694, 0.30132994055747986, -0.29329413175582886, -0.5209059715270996, -0.6160144209861755, 0.9939635396003723, -1.214370608329773, -0.7799066305160522, 0.2609402537345886, 0.5259764790534973, -0.9365803003311157, 0.18864576518535614, -0.08258514851331711, 0.2903250455856323, 0.33068299293518066, 0.11352360993623734, -0.7476009726524353, -0.7581329345703125, 0.010688850656151772, -0.3186052143573761, 0.21038398146629333, 0.4297747015953064, -0.3147190809249878, 0.4861993193626404, 0.2220568209886551, -0.6078155636787415, 0.2930964231491089, 0.7513583302497864, -0.056941207498311996, 0.13789409399032593, 0.0860225185751915, -0.14368689060211182, -1.1005275249481201, -0.03156746178865433, 0.43360698223114014, -0.2710507810115814, -0.49820151925086975, 0.022465812042355537, -0.9375396966934204, -0.7659394145011902, -0.3046025037765503, -0.8929721117019653, 0.5615288019180298, -0.42227834463119507, -0.08249148726463318, -0.3379939794540405, -0.3255886435508728, -0.2883520722389221, -0.16850440204143524, -0.28284457325935364, -0.778971791267395, 0.131198450922966, -0.2204435020685196, -0.17415978014469147, 0.4240873456001282, -0.4741097092628479, 0.3771165609359741, 0.19689419865608215, -0.366619348526001, -0.5607936978340149, -0.5525248646736145, -0.18713901937007904, 0.06079626828432083, -0.32841360569000244, 0.15702326595783234, -0.5509503483772278, 0.16850775480270386, 0.3334154784679413, 0.40839916467666626, -0.39422479271888733, -0.6262037754058838, -0.2943553626537323, -0.04340898618102074, 0.7155507206916809, -0.38675162196159363, -0.4322744309902191, 0.2737523317337036, 0.4161115884780884, 0.4601764380931854, -0.20334993302822113, -1.2815358638763428, 0.4395985007286072, -0.8594918251037598, 0.49883562326431274, -0.6976887583732605, 0.2625523805618286, -0.617409348487854, -1.1695280075073242, -0.14350171387195587, 0.011800889857113361, 0.4179271161556244, -0.2706514000892639, -0.13787908852100372, 0.38943037390708923, 0.5850798487663269, -0.42239081859588623, 0.8430867195129395, -0.9793626666069031, -0.46444961428642273, -0.8464251160621643, 1.1600193977355957, -0.053311556577682495, -0.5274423360824585, 0.4590536952018738, 0.10331769287586212, 0.2646254003047943, 0.6719722747802734, 0.19123516976833344, -0.17059430480003357, -0.6260939240455627, 0.0391879603266716, 0.3042137920856476, -0.11385398358106613, -0.10415206104516983, 0.41118454933166504, -0.18871013820171356, 0.9302043914794922, 0.054472170770168304, -0.22543303668498993, -0.29892998933792114, -0.03565016761422157, 0.2984966039657593, 0.36983272433280945, 0.05654893442988396, 0.7210164666175842, 0.39394935965538025, -0.18396274745464325, 0.35005101561546326, -0.839731752872467, -1.1248456239700317, -0.11645721644163132, -0.778727650642395, 0.00012651454017031938, 0.6394264101982117, 0.011205569840967655, -0.2570425570011139, -0.014978396706283092, -0.6311792731285095, -0.394924521446228, 0.2975158989429474, -0.08185629546642303, 0.3876464366912842, -0.21373572945594788, -0.8864583969116211, 0.052978869527578354, -0.3561945855617523, 0.25670596957206726, 0.5273717641830444, -0.2770210802555084, -0.1483609974384308, 0.33519959449768066, -0.04122699424624443, -0.9380125403404236, -0.5720317959785461, 0.5901317000389099, 0.35704609751701355, -0.4310418963432312, 0.615710437297821, 0.4182221293449402, 0.5062057971954346, 0.19456343352794647, 0.025421572849154472, 0.11450764536857605, -0.16286303102970123, 0.7552211880683899, -0.1869170069694519, 0.29966139793395996, 0.02136702463030815, 0.39820796251296997, -0.2765292227268219, 0.5875818729400635, 1.0846507549285889, -0.7225629687309265, -0.10903418809175491, 0.6400591135025024, -0.296190470457077, -1.0268456935882568, 0.1338513195514679, 0.0959649607539177, -0.8309630155563354, 0.2282368391752243, -0.29770299792289734, -0.268766850233078, 0.2866801917552948, -0.02735881507396698, 0.01679239422082901, 0.462117999792099, 0.10751659423112869, 0.12388177216053009, -0.4512632191181183, 0.14231479167938232, -0.5741220712661743, 0.10512907058000565, 1.7119861841201782, 0.5774922370910645, -0.09071624279022217, -0.15411929786205292, -0.16615276038646698, -0.7389258146286011, -0.3702065944671631, 0.9288874864578247, -0.32380005717277527, 0.46851858496665955, 0.6541509628295898, 0.7982537150382996, 0.6339390277862549, 0.10861386358737946, 0.08719741553068161, 0.5052108764648438, -0.27796635031700134, -0.7111309170722961, -0.7892593741416931, -0.7569991946220398, -0.009580987505614758, 0.45312848687171936, 0.1343715637922287, 0.24219024181365967, 0.05212411284446716, -0.10671412944793701, 0.1404721587896347, -0.25893348455429077, 0.43118956685066223, -0.845910906791687, -0.9757013916969299, -0.3528909385204315, -0.23990997672080994, 0.4574793577194214, 0.7728729248046875, -0.40584564208984375, 0.31330743432044983, 0.09693924337625504, -0.2259991317987442, 0.5431171655654907, 0.905088484287262, -0.19906578958034515, -0.6354162096977234, -0.593163788318634, 0.17286032438278198, -0.13392536342144012, -1.191650629043579, -0.6855396628379822, -0.6746662259101868, 0.5349034667015076, 1.228347897529602, -0.537690281867981, 0.6308580040931702, -0.4226911664009094, -0.2451269030570984, 0.44087275862693787, -0.4607447385787964, -0.3788089454174042, 0.9183245897293091, -0.4495040476322174, 1.6629191637039185, 0.2204684317111969, 0.07245704531669617, 0.368708074092865, 0.24796287715435028, -0.9093318581581116, 0.41564232110977173, -0.23713262379169464, 1.401244878768921, 0.3835543692111969, -0.47781243920326233, 0.20575428009033203, 0.6477993726730347, -0.7616981863975525, -0.09900104999542236, -0.2285395711660385, 0.034403055906295776, -0.10491649806499481, -0.010405153967440128, -0.4869297444820404, 0.6043780446052551, 0.8340449929237366, -0.05057298019528389, -1.1709619760513306, -0.10359765589237213, -0.6505275964736938, 0.5856369733810425, -0.13106386363506317, -0.040666110813617706, -0.12828481197357178, -0.24573364853858948, 0.13856108486652374, 0.4271652102470398, 0.012837481684982777, 0.4894544780254364, -0.5586409568786621, 0.16481950879096985, 0.4342102110385895, -0.08998827636241913, -0.6448938250541687, 0.7582653164863586, 0.5252892971038818, -0.01546428445726633, 0.33792757987976074, -0.12576930224895477, -0.8874590396881104, 0.3195653557777405, -1.1503453254699707, -0.8846179246902466, 0.6747697591781616, -0.287386953830719, 0.44071874022483826, 0.02266816608607769, -0.8757448196411133, 0.4367437958717346, 0.6185541749000549, 0.9740357995033264, 0.8221904635429382, -0.08131598681211472, -0.9304192662239075, 0.5109707117080688, -0.31876423954963684, -0.44823673367500305, -0.9253252744674683, -0.13086549937725067, -1.2923376560211182, -1.0843456983566284, -0.6981196999549866, 0.25266677141189575, -0.4015244245529175, -0.23121459782123566, 0.22798046469688416, -0.19984233379364014, 0.4525703489780426, -0.5271075963973999, -0.8524397015571594, -0.12662312388420105, -0.8766632676124573, 0.07612910121679306, -0.32858631014823914, 0.5128557682037354, 0.17131967842578888, -0.0550585575401783, 0.7478665113449097, -0.09629301726818085, -0.1668851226568222, 1.0294533967971802, 0.2559310793876648, -0.020003631711006165, 0.47373297810554504, 0.8260954022407532, 0.1695524901151657, 0.6299338936805725, -0.7693977355957031, 0.5481207370758057, 0.7338014841079712, -0.15557953715324402, 0.4821794927120209, 0.13218840956687927, -0.23180970549583435, -0.07414114475250244, 0.2623511552810669, 0.10653650760650635, -0.11972107738256454, 0.1014074981212616, 0.22574201226234436, 0.5539389252662659, 0.14445079863071442, 0.31135714054107666, 0.5781818628311157, 0.21132688224315643, 0.6170079708099365, -0.20644807815551758, -0.5031288266181946, -0.5088738203048706, -0.05427504703402519, 0.5970513224601746, -0.10857821255922318, -0.7203354835510254, -0.5115749835968018, 0.6656160950660706, 0.15807853639125824, 0.0832301527261734, -0.34389591217041016, 0.03609136492013931, 0.8621772527694702, -0.21268098056316376, 0.028606105595827103, -0.03592894971370697, 0.4044283926486969, 0.3938120901584625, 0.3415321111679077, 0.4047349989414215, -0.2126845270395279, 0.8421001434326172, -0.2083001583814621, -0.6280114650726318, 0.052913978695869446, 0.32873183488845825, -1.1754482984542847, -0.12076602131128311, -0.3503955006599426, -0.6828686594963074, -0.1471882164478302, -0.4209703505039215, 0.6170824766159058, -0.8539004921913147, -0.26722273230552673, 0.398176908493042, -0.5580755472183228, -0.0929742231965065, 0.18484337627887726, 0.21903792023658752, 0.6581006050109863, 0.19565372169017792, 0.6851120591163635, -0.4601757228374481, 0.9483975768089294, 0.749350368976593, -0.11944316327571869, -0.07370949536561966, -0.8256177306175232, -0.13985413312911987, 0.12009494751691818, -0.1361832171678543, -0.3319741189479828, 1.3934873342514038, -0.5378051996231079, -0.39881759881973267, -0.616270899772644, -0.12903587520122528, 0.08280414342880249, -0.5240663886070251, 1.1681382656097412, 0.16945189237594604, -0.5028409957885742, 0.9259272813796997, 0.36244407296180725, 0.1417020857334137, -0.044558085501194, -1.2990063428878784, 0.1360323131084442, -1.068586826324463, -0.5339407920837402, -1.1645585298538208, 0.22887128591537476, 0.32420584559440613, -0.3547395169734955, -0.8514689207077026, -0.3764727711677551, -0.4346407651901245, -0.7160575985908508, -0.5357816815376282, -0.6133794784545898, -0.10316336899995804, 0.44248855113983154, 0.14358903467655182, -0.4214121103286743, -0.40662702918052673, -0.8068835735321045, -0.2523100972175598, 1.3083446025848389, -0.22331354022026062, 0.7638741731643677, 0.04368879273533821, 0.3671054244041443, -0.7067351341247559, 0.6588948369026184, 0.5713463425636292, -0.8862215280532837, 1.1222431659698486, 0.11950543522834778, 0.3178563416004181, -0.28091898560523987, -0.7930456399917603, 0.6311625242233276, 0.7326697707176208, -0.23709188401699066, 0.723360002040863, -0.3046066164970398, 0.41532382369041443, -0.794822096824646, 0.1855980008840561, -0.28463730216026306, 0.21731844544410706, 0.5642092823982239, -0.7318016290664673, -0.12325508147478104, -1.371064305305481, 4.003535270690918, 0.5080705881118774, 0.8778747320175171, 0.20869721472263336, 0.38504740595817566, 0.7367315292358398, -0.08410238474607468, 0.15680046379566193, 0.32615718245506287, 0.11228812485933304, -0.3263300955295563, 0.07788074016571045, 0.9412301182746887, -0.2953501045703888, 0.6043407917022705, 0.6355441212654114, -0.17160871624946594, -0.4754183888435364, 0.888896107673645, -1.0100826025009155, -1.3344391584396362, 0.3774793744087219, -0.3157351315021515, -0.03495783731341362, 0.4880269169807434, 0.4752481281757355, 0.13511839509010315, -0.5990809798240662, -0.48663583397865295, 0.051736485213041306, -0.48711568117141724, -0.980739951133728, 0.386898398399353, -0.42279577255249023, -0.8915216326713562, 0.3979652523994446, -0.7561342716217041, -0.4326823651790619, 0.1006927341222763, -0.17219802737236023, -0.34277594089508057, -0.5100924372673035, -0.10731953382492065, 0.29651781916618347, -0.06458611786365509, 1.3591947555541992, 0.3520388603210449, 0.7835704684257507, 1.026357889175415, -0.5649990439414978, -0.07553787529468536, 0.008002406917512417, 0.13570892810821533, -0.2766696810722351, -0.6328427195549011, -0.12966042757034302, -0.33329713344573975, -0.5548733472824097, 0.5169572234153748, -0.2549862563610077, 0.9638857841491699, -0.056832462549209595, -1.0058515071868896, 0.29202646017074585, -0.13424257934093475, 0.03589101880788803, -0.12069141119718552, -0.08504889905452728, -0.4697781801223755, 0.039340149611234665, -0.24416068196296692, 0.19646641612052917, -0.5047541856765747, -0.6696569323539734, 0.27598682045936584, 0.16404204070568085, -0.4798851013183594, 0.08686425536870956, -0.5099102258682251, 0.004665151238441467, -0.5690808892250061, -0.10976177453994751, -0.1001194640994072, -0.5218889713287354, 0.2436840534210205, 1.2297563552856445, 0.31398874521255493, -0.28232839703559875, -0.5342010855674744, 0.5653999447822571, 0.2579973340034485, -0.09473735839128494, 0.08314990997314453, 0.28955307602882385, -0.41572386026382446 ]
Spin effects in the inspiral of coalescing compact binaries
We derive the contributions of spin-orbit and spin-spin coupling to the gravitational radiation from coalescing binary systems of spinning compact objects. We calculate spin effects in the symmetric, trace-free radiative multipoles that determine the gravitational waveform, and the rate of energy loss. Assuming a balance between energy radiated and orbital energy lost, we determine the spin effects in the evolution of the orbital frequency and orbital radius. Assuming that a laser interferometric gravitational observatory can track the gravitational-wave frequency (twice the orbital frequency) as it sweeps through its sensitive bandwidth between about 10 Hz and one kHz, we estimate the accuracy with which the spins of the component bodies can be determined from the gravitational-wave signal.
Lawrence E. Kidder and Clifford M. Will (Washington University, St. Louis) and Alan G. Wiseman (Northwestern University, E...
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211025
gr-qc/9211026
[ 0.4250013530254364, 0.08433253318071365, 0.5014232993125916, 0.24955664575099945, 0.038838036358356476, -0.36741185188293457, -0.2558293640613556, 0.32368534803390503, -0.40760478377342224, 1.119110345840454, 0.4616307020187378, 0.04159552603960037, -0.07101397216320038, -0.5319294929504395, 0.31563207507133484, 0.44665321707725525, 0.22264108061790466, -0.3331751823425293, -1.8890552520751953, 0.2544289529323578, -0.059466321021318436, -0.0026121088303625584, -0.8861401677131653, -0.6871355175971985, -0.6209520697593689, 0.30713579058647156, -0.16224847733974457, 0.5556504130363464, 0.9043799638748169, 1.2430213689804077, 1.1098161935806274, -0.3935880661010742, -0.04338238388299942, -0.8470233082771301, -0.02345327101647854, 0.043620746582746506, 0.4804241359233856, -0.9128921627998352, 0.5190296173095703, -0.2132323533296585, 0.6154803037643433, -0.4529492259025574, 0.011514037847518921, -0.4302230775356293, -0.5783258676528931, -0.18676045536994934, -0.5476657748222351, 0.8152121901512146, 0.01841895841062069, -0.757991373538971, 0.17106893658638, -0.7456041574478149, 0.006362969055771828, -1.3217767477035522, 0.14382445812225342, 0.20937815308570862, 0.31633076071739197, -0.25184938311576843, -0.6072348356246948, -0.5999860763549805, 0.03887658193707466, 0.22151541709899902, 0.8124222159385681, -0.4081708490848541, -0.009818468242883682, 1.522788166999817, -0.08088289946317673, 0.656181275844574, 0.5131126642227173, -0.1093619242310524, -0.0857631117105484, 0.4695533215999603, -0.23949407041072845, -0.040124136954545975, -0.44726476073265076, 0.25003546476364136, -0.3973366916179657, -0.5317320227622986, -0.3077465295791626, -0.7216627597808838, -0.22389726340770721, -0.16009248793125153, 0.1428917646408081, 0.3120729625225067, -0.1388307511806488, -0.2844126522541046, 0.14504610002040863, 0.13672952353954315, 0.622173011302948, 0.06774883717298508, -0.016071347519755363, 0.16537314653396606, -0.4007152318954468, -0.04240408539772034, 0.5800767540931702, 1.2400610446929932, -0.18466776609420776, 0.08183184266090393, -0.37826138734817505, 0.13957227766513824, -0.05521203577518463, 0.6845930814743042, -0.7193195819854736, 0.14128315448760986, -0.9905593991279602, 0.8163720369338989, -0.3379036784172058, 0.44203951954841614, -0.13684681057929993, -0.9518680572509766, 0.48829153180122375, 0.5227169394493103, 0.6555057168006897, 0.39504528045654297, -0.7764601111412048, 0.31962600350379944, -0.7688430547714233, -0.4246911108493805, -0.6978482604026794, -0.28389284014701843, -0.650343120098114, 0.7003908753395081, -0.0598369725048542, 0.32410502433776855, -0.40101346373558044, -0.16256245970726013, 0.126937136054039, 0.789148211479187, -0.3261270821094513, 0.6094154119491577, 0.7993059754371643, -0.915949821472168, -0.7206479907035828, 0.6761660575866699, 0.17346207797527313, 0.5195494890213013, 0.21268118917942047, -0.21135415136814117, 0.07714427262544632, -0.3759014308452606, 0.4690556228160858, -0.2855145335197449, 0.2647576332092285, 0.9711716175079346, -0.9341393709182739, 0.489535927772522, 0.1808106005191803, -0.047595735639333725, -0.7493762373924255, -0.3558862805366516, -0.08230791985988617, -0.5487810373306274, -0.1314866840839386, -0.18412832915782928, 0.17927339673042297, -0.04595662280917168, -0.41957199573516846, 0.13145770132541656, -0.020235568284988403, -0.24029497802257538, 0.8028968572616577, -0.19184568524360657, 0.23395729064941406, 1.5565292835235596, 0.19847793877124786, 0.6095682978630066, -0.39917874336242676, -0.0822863057255745, 0.2698344588279724, -0.203457310795784, -0.3995274603366852, 0.043263599276542664, 0.04088486358523369, 0.5286227464675903, 0.881641149520874, 0.6102920174598694, -0.40477773547172546, -0.6476856470108032, -0.15180115401744843, 0.16724959015846252, 0.015416011214256287, -0.5661920309066772, 0.7053544521331787, 0.9085959196090698, -0.8907095789909363, -0.24645358324050903, 0.6093525290489197, -0.012817217968404293, -0.15435919165611267, -0.19847598671913147, -0.38835474848747253, 0.25228363275527954, -0.7556376457214355, 0.3956478238105774, -0.9149417281150818, 0.1151469349861145, -0.8385311961174011, -0.686944305896759, -0.07268927246332169, 0.23886922001838684, 0.2718642055988312, 0.053173284977674484, -0.4352554380893707, 1.0080535411834717, -0.8715774416923523, -0.6559728980064392, 0.859424889087677, 0.20993158221244812, -0.3104439675807953, -0.17689871788024902, 0.45705991983413696, -0.42912665009498596, -0.3610261380672455, -0.18175968527793884, 0.2725750803947449, -0.12993763387203217, 0.04346818849444389, 0.46760091185569763, -0.25660720467567444, -0.02938365377485752, 0.8826402425765991, -0.09625862538814545, -0.8587871789932251, 1.7415851354599, 0.0662904903292656, -0.638805091381073, -0.09724432975053787, 0.6915468573570251, -0.3384995460510254, -0.3997262120246887, -0.13673007488250732, -0.13301922380924225, 0.07221745699644089, 0.6906996965408325, 0.2871784269809723, -0.32919391989707947, 1.4661508798599243, 0.829535961151123, -0.2226891964673996, -0.28020480275154114, 0.2554400563240051, 0.1919892430305481, -0.5248391628265381, 0.5736554861068726, -0.262714684009552, 1.2382171154022217, 0.16871416568756104, 0.039701834321022034, -0.20752780139446259, 0.9310482740402222, -1.0114281177520752, 0.3395537734031677, -0.10454078018665314, 0.5861953496932983, -1.4286868572235107, 0.12787142395973206, -0.29288023710250854, 0.18164470791816711, 0.23689784109592438, -0.6528439521789551, -0.9385863542556763, 0.054826315492391586, -0.12384729087352753, -0.30683454871177673, -0.10790640860795975, -0.10509707778692245, -0.3334064483642578, -0.422834575176239, 1.119470238685608, -0.78192138671875, -1.1303433179855347, 0.03002549335360527, -0.547476053237915, -0.04112694039940834, 0.5278376936912537, -0.5081857442855835, 0.000158692680997774, 0.6126760840415955, 0.3661912679672241, 0.22558894753456116, -0.1292181760072708, 0.2266317754983902, -0.07293254137039185, -0.28251737356185913, -0.14240528643131256, 0.4162110388278961, -1.0778526067733765, -0.20331180095672607, -0.9909184575080872, -0.08662262558937073, -0.21180179715156555, -1.4548895359039307, 0.1909257173538208, -0.10513540357351303, 0.18878298997879028, 0.5050346255302429, 0.09992637485265732, -0.19425491988658905, -0.08589596301317215, -0.4526970386505127, 0.26379889249801636, -0.09014309197664261, -0.6864991784095764, -0.36294084787368774, -0.09473337233066559, 0.6955633759498596, -0.13298997282981873, 0.3674927353858948, 0.6489490866661072, -0.45099493861198425, -0.7044134736061096, 0.4201755225658417, 0.1624404639005661, 0.38701215386390686, -0.5668929815292358, 0.7773920297622681, 0.3541458249092102, -0.47179460525512695, 0.7481414079666138, -0.5003829598426819, 0.13786928355693817, -0.3586537539958954, 0.2545882761478424, -0.4606349766254425, 0.6403070688247681, 1.094555139541626, 0.3476426303386688, -0.4483344554901123, 0.3134351670742035, -0.8774322867393494, -0.6992601752281189, -0.16901345551013947, -0.6058217287063599, 0.32646608352661133, 0.2172860950231552, 0.38050413131713867, -0.4035417437553406, -0.7597931027412415, -1.1877102851867676, -0.045714959502220154, 0.029173240065574646, -0.2674286365509033, -0.0369650237262249, 0.45762941241264343, 0.49925941228866577, 0.26970574259757996, 0.5009598135948181, -0.30212095379829407, -0.5305874347686768, 0.4457322955131531, -0.6880309581756592, -0.05612504854798317, 0.5542453527450562, 0.40828895568847656, 0.2721782922744751, -0.24983899295330048, -0.5923503637313843, -0.785370945930481, -0.41944581270217896, -0.9266535043716431, 0.6523492336273193, -0.22368144989013672, -0.0905088409781456, -0.24138785898685455, -0.2174822837114334, -0.02425060048699379, -0.0932307243347168, 0.04895395785570145, 0.6183631420135498, -0.5525011420249939, 0.3995155096054077, 0.7122617959976196, -0.699553370475769, -0.11806226521730423, -0.3665577173233032, 0.3729683458805084, 0.8007761836051941, 0.17787082493305206, 0.3389696776866913, 0.10147567093372345, -0.5600094795227051, -0.8161646723747253, 0.9194265007972717, 0.6288116574287415, 0.1307194083929062, -0.1630168855190277, -0.9215785264968872, -0.3874076306819916, -0.27635353803634644, -0.6508919596672058, -0.08356808125972748, -1.3251069784164429, 0.2360236793756485, -0.5982624888420105, -0.6769231557846069, -0.006400417536497116, 0.3031329810619354, 0.15616260468959808, 0.3071214556694031, -0.0038041372317820787, -0.1309136152267456, -0.36707329750061035, 0.19633439183235168, 0.3325008749961853, -0.37992775440216064, 0.20962926745414734, -0.4902905523777008, 0.4606298804283142, 0.4006190001964569, 0.3099851608276367, 0.03365758806467056, -0.06773892790079117, 0.21528218686580658, 0.2989518642425537, 0.6702086329460144, 0.4541904926300049, 0.2804357707500458, 0.14518055319786072, 0.291352778673172, -1.1156102418899536, 0.02803005836904049, -0.1413654088973999, 1.193420648574829, 0.5313853025436401, 0.17864175140857697, -0.9212548136711121, 0.00024971034144982696, -0.24931716918945312, 0.4962095022201538, 0.798262357711792, 0.01057389099150896, -0.383847177028656, -0.04102914035320282, 0.15020784735679626, 0.2540920376777649, 0.1244727149605751, 0.8970884680747986, 0.5162491202354431, 0.7949527502059937, -0.07701188325881958, -0.20708037912845612, 1.284063696861267, -0.04208780452609062, 0.03549366444349289, 0.19133327901363373, 0.6506299376487732, -0.3105849623680115, 0.25815463066101074, 0.05154649540781975, -0.8076800107955933, -0.15302500128746033, -0.47262147068977356, 0.4451150894165039, -0.05516430363059044, -0.8192899227142334, 0.5508617162704468, 0.6192728877067566, 0.026327379047870636, 0.6081032752990723, -0.2822086215019226, -0.27352356910705566, -0.10086894035339355, -0.28198951482772827, -0.82823646068573, -0.3652455806732178, 0.5488574504852295, -0.18635909259319305, 0.8317134380340576, 0.725727915763855, 0.40929004549980164, -0.04145052656531334, 0.02689862810075283, 0.21645820140838623, 0.24745193123817444, -0.06946749240159988, -1.2126275300979614, -0.2216683030128479, 0.3031822741031647, -0.6566659808158875, -0.04645375907421112, 0.05465389043092728, 0.6035159230232239, -0.2591490149497986, 0.10085966438055038, -0.3769374191761017, -0.5549317002296448, -0.05852287635207176, -0.35703927278518677, -0.6129478812217712, 0.38514792919158936, -0.1620793491601944, 0.2512098550796509, -0.04954338073730469, -0.23338767886161804, 0.045362405478954315, -0.3176349401473999, 0.3934086263179779, 0.11815900355577469, -0.37175047397613525, 0.5686069130897522, -0.0981287881731987, -0.06840749084949493, -0.6160007119178772, 0.36334025859832764, -0.2707420885562897, -1.1083054542541504, -0.7920249700546265, -0.8029986023902893, -0.19079792499542236, 0.24646644294261932, 0.5011289715766907, 0.23281525075435638, -0.12640923261642456, 0.6702395677566528, -0.7504773139953613, 0.6663196086883545, 0.10271549969911575, -0.9075722098350525, 0.9478881359100342, 1.1076983213424683, 0.4946105480194092, -1.0060137510299683, 0.21594862639904022, 0.3507087230682373, 0.25098398327827454, 0.43774956464767456, 0.16112995147705078, -0.05403202027082443, 0.5967192649841309, -0.45464909076690674, -0.24005326628684998, -0.5238698720932007, -0.6079050302505493, -0.5089078545570374, -0.5361379981040955, 0.1786295771598816, 0.08098021894693375, 0.4832000434398651, -0.0791485458612442, 0.181001216173172, -0.8347690105438232, 0.5467806458473206, -0.3310593068599701, -0.7222332954406738, 0.18568694591522217, -0.2929435968399048, -0.7266321182250977, 1.5124932527542114, -0.37154635787010193, 0.45510464906692505, 0.464360773563385, -0.35817188024520874, -0.32565540075302124, 0.3736090362071991, 0.5922651290893555, 0.1424945443868637, -0.38738811016082764, -0.028425611555576324, 0.9200388789176941, 0.5368548035621643, -0.24996913969516754, 0.519281804561615, -0.23545297980308533, 0.4621622860431671, -0.6239292025566101, 0.21824969351291656, 0.04454322159290314, -0.19738039374351501, 0.6402459144592285, 0.23728066682815552, 0.21344660222530365, 0.9517167806625366, 0.24204444885253906, 0.5665669441223145, 0.22156408429145813, -0.23976969718933105, -0.4112788140773773, -0.5728716850280762, -0.5619900226593018, 0.5005092024803162, 0.3067591190338135, -0.12999020516872406, 0.1332857459783554, -1.3238550424575806, -0.04458862543106079, -0.5845190286636353, 0.5915736556053162, 0.2078625112771988, 0.6651704907417297, 0.7226184606552124, -0.42792853713035583, 0.4513229429721832, 0.16242505609989166, -0.4399110972881317, -0.4457286298274994, -0.0552765429019928, 0.0041460637003183365, -0.3387296497821808, 0.20504654943943024, -0.5604963302612305, -0.22630338370800018, 0.23005281388759613, 0.2018958032131195, -0.12391437590122223, 0.8443702459335327, 0.48577842116355896, -0.8014002442359924, -0.6051062941551208, 0.3163657784461975, 0.2081661820411682, -0.5127953886985779, 0.26656201481819153, -0.26535528898239136, -0.07506387680768967, 0.2555929720401764, 0.18033196032047272, -0.21650896966457367, -1.0756381750106812, 1.219977617263794, -0.9913653135299683, -0.0655466616153717, 0.11152172833681107, 0.09558533132076263, 0.047691505402326584, -0.37006711959838867, -1.764920949935913, -0.7105448842048645, -0.3046237528324127, -0.8522037863731384, 0.14907562732696533, -0.36740562319755554, -0.8025609254837036, 0.37763968110084534, -0.03588772192597389, 0.26866933703422546, 0.5530810356140137, 0.3991236984729767, -0.050491079688072205, -0.776553213596344, 0.5334380269050598, 0.6950563192367554, 0.11711730062961578, -0.013941190205514431, -0.425567626953125, 0.2881675958633423, -0.35072019696235657, -0.6092976927757263, -0.057748906314373016, 0.1291816383600235, -0.07262099534273148, -0.48976239562034607, 0.7141419053077698, 0.6341260075569153, 0.5774075388908386, -0.17637935280799866, -0.22329066693782806, -0.9577072262763977, -0.24150395393371582, 0.719083309173584, 0.28977036476135254, -0.09797835350036621, 1.213918924331665, -0.772284746170044, -0.4223371148109436, -0.3304648995399475, 0.3276708424091339, 0.03663137927651405, 0.014743641018867493, -0.8556193709373474, -0.7425833940505981, -0.22806982696056366, -1.3706717491149902, -0.3520151376724243, -0.06266360729932785, 0.6909260749816895, -0.5730541944503784, 1.0237078666687012, -0.06310030072927475, 0.3640667796134949, 0.5173227787017822, 0.15913623571395874, 0.12020474672317505, -0.38612180948257446, -0.5078080296516418, 0.2069758027791977, -0.7333058714866638, -1.0042632818222046, -0.1841331273317337, 0.20859280228614807, 0.30393683910369873, 0.8642211556434631, 0.026296300813555717, -0.017237938940525055, -0.5024062991142273, -0.9443399310112, 0.32736480236053467, 0.21100254356861115, 0.3665022552013397, 0.8257085680961609, -0.5260834693908691, 0.7023783326148987, 0.11510559171438217, -0.7536909580230713, -0.41946348547935486, 0.16272404789924622, -0.8294966220855713, 1.0253020524978638, 0.26266807317733765, 0.25833338499069214, 0.5100717544555664, -0.6154905557632446, 0.22565197944641113, 0.48668530583381653, -0.7832884192466736, 0.25052186846733093, 0.27510565519332886, 0.5416381359100342, -0.6203348636627197, -0.49455201625823975, 0.8991147875785828, -0.23412565886974335, -0.37317290902137756, -0.1095697209239006, -0.3223728537559509, 0.2604295611381531, -0.5341915488243103, 0.04406282305717468, -0.5312830805778503, -1.2643390893936157, 0.3486778140068054, -0.2682834267616272, 0.9645963311195374, 0.4160938262939453, 0.41907796263694763, 0.34313657879829407, 0.7921713590621948, -0.06529555469751358, -0.6715656518936157, -0.1963229477405548, -0.6717374324798584, 0.5077989101409912, 0.204926535487175, 0.2940123975276947, 1.3968297243118286, -0.504319965839386, -1.8328919410705566, 0.10797760635614395, -0.09074540436267853, -0.36318641901016235, -0.08239324390888214, -0.05201228708028793, -0.297171950340271, 0.4502212107181549, -0.24125789105892181, 0.6086221933364868, -0.27797403931617737, 0.578721821308136, 1.0149812698364258, -0.2476784586906433, -0.24235327541828156, 0.02760244905948639, -0.4809817373752594, 0.2958320379257202, -0.1350211799144745, 0.8430715203285217, -0.20712529122829437, -0.7122440934181213, -0.5786473155021667, 0.34299471974372864, -0.33111780881881714, -0.17408712208271027, -0.6793251037597656, -0.5813910961151123, -0.2826721668243408, 0.004336509387940168, -0.46491488814353943, -0.22835226356983185, -0.33740168809890747, 0.3478381335735321, 0.14183741807937622, -0.19929993152618408, -0.0828937366604805, -0.39100947976112366, 0.13825689256191254, -0.2596869468688965, -0.1686510145664215, 0.7025266289710999, 0.17904828488826752, -0.35191062092781067, 0.10220465064048767, 0.6716789603233337, -0.47484341263771057, 0.48418301343917847, -0.24960245192050934, 0.4102361798286438, -0.039451826363801956, -0.10750117152929306, 0.6671875715255737, -0.14228323101997375, -0.040542103350162506, 0.5671852827072144, 0.06574060767889023, -0.3090619444847107, 0.3006572723388672, 0.2021968513727188, 0.2420758754014969, 0.8357642889022827, -0.4239550232887268, -0.47730347514152527, -0.546427309513092, 0.790445864200592, -0.3542313873767853, 0.08613694459199905, -0.3203791677951813, -0.6166666746139526, 0.4848214089870453, 0.9585254788398743, -0.8062950372695923, -0.8230595588684082, -0.4108549654483795, 0.621763288974762, 0.288503497838974, -0.016871154308319092, 0.07594754546880722, -0.09667856246232986, -0.024647274985909462, -0.3627270460128784, -0.3013400435447693, 0.34008845686912537, 0.7698685526847839, 0.6290124654769897, 0.6946841478347778, -0.16907060146331787, 0.6460023522377014, 0.3038659691810608, -0.5085711479187012, -0.08298137038946152, 0.1513271927833557, 0.21827852725982666, -0.36687031388282776, 0.3059543967247009, 0.31646421551704407, -0.4986944794654846, -0.061690088361501694, -0.10278809070587158, 0.05392478033900261, -0.540042519569397, 0.11448205262422562, -0.18344849348068237, -0.2323378622531891, 0.3400425910949707, 0.24281835556030273, -0.11349201202392578, 0.009958915412425995, -0.11694636940956116, 0.3421567678451538, -0.1856229305267334, 0.5120794773101807, 1.3546886444091797, 0.676483690738678, -0.3843960464000702, -0.6973744630813599, -0.7945871353149414, 0.6050914525985718, 0.4543490409851074, -0.4246254563331604, 0.35327282547950745, -0.7648775577545166, 0.22729475796222687, -0.39743199944496155, 0.14065390825271606, -0.28848955035209656, 0.47010740637779236, 0.42594391107559204, 0.5490132570266724, 0.05366692692041397, -0.22756224870681763, 0.3919508159160614, 0.7902733683586121, -0.6344718933105469, -0.8119407296180725, -0.03572096675634384, -0.5857767462730408, 0.5428282618522644, -0.3071838617324829, 0.8107628226280212, 0.2361014038324356, 0.06132559850811958, -0.7335159778594971, -0.3747726380825043, 0.1682676076889038, -0.7765629291534424, -0.07210207730531693, -0.16850924491882324, 0.4951069951057434, 0.8599880337715149, 0.055040158331394196, 0.22064301371574402, -0.176679328083992, 0.03936932235956192, -0.22591190040111542, 1.218416690826416, -0.15963508188724518, -0.3246113657951355, 0.5447427034378052, 0.3329693078994751, -0.746697187423706, 0.8882532715797424, 0.5609535574913025, -0.31341299414634705, 0.09360349923372269, 0.4435197114944458, 0.28708532452583313, 0.2567712664604187, -0.15552464127540588, -0.40528741478919983, -0.1753600537776947, 0.7193356156349182, 0.3173823058605194, -0.8901909589767456, -0.36039555072784424, -0.5607389211654663, -0.4268881678581238, -0.17474602162837982, 0.9997381567955017, 0.4301603138446808, -0.013251383788883686, -0.006155767012387514, -1.3042492866516113, 3.9996936321258545, 0.537580132484436, 0.6882275342941284, -0.8308129906654358, 0.7344269752502441, 0.7523064017295837, 0.18188415467739105, -0.5852725505828857, 0.3585747480392456, -0.6195764541625977, 0.13559211790561676, -0.3270232081413269, 0.45769935846328735, -0.2742133140563965, 0.435488760471344, 0.7754855751991272, 0.13626934587955475, 0.33797627687454224, 0.40592363476753235, -1.0458091497421265, -1.3883734941482544, -0.1024680957198143, 0.13668794929981232, 0.5101795196533203, 0.4518298804759979, 0.8184636235237122, 0.1363525092601776, -0.7941425442695618, -0.1275259554386139, -0.3804037868976593, -0.5471056699752808, -0.7586387991905212, -0.10983890295028687, 0.46818915009498596, -1.1709829568862915, 1.0657192468643188, 0.593603789806366, -0.5912172794342041, 0.3823587894439697, -0.29115036129951477, 0.35850703716278076, -1.296560287475586, 0.2697833478450775, -0.06434933841228485, 0.18995162844657898, 0.6758455634117126, 1.0634363889694214, -0.042938556522130966, 0.8814181685447693, -0.4518406391143799, 0.34320512413978577, 0.02891063503921032, 0.15335407853126526, 0.27913016080856323, -1.1241545677185059, -0.5044202208518982, -0.34339141845703125, -0.3877987861633301, 0.40180742740631104, -0.7134304046630859, 0.47808408737182617, -0.0031125391833484173, -0.2580339312553406, 0.11112097650766373, 0.02377178706228733, 0.47612014412879944, 0.3758358955383301, -0.30995553731918335, 0.12451080977916718, -0.22195027768611908, -0.5848132371902466, -0.41687244176864624, -0.8446832299232483, 0.02370659075677395, 0.13740120828151703, -0.09071630984544754, -0.10838401317596436, 0.06376907974481583, -0.3969111144542694, 0.6189448237419128, -0.4945305585861206, 0.04605520889163017, -0.6304581761360168, 0.693873405456543, -0.2571515142917633, 0.5457248091697693, -0.24303583800792694, -0.27687665820121765, -0.9182763695716858, 0.5936513543128967, 0.27443814277648926, 0.7947753667831421, -0.36623141169548035, 0.7809638977050781, -1.1854486465454102 ]
Cauchy horizon singularity without mass inflation
A perturbed Reissner-Nordstr\"om-de Sitter solution is used to emphasize the nature of the singularity along the Cauchy horizon of a charged spherically symmetric black hole. For these solutions, conditions may prevail under which the mass function is bounded and yet the curvature scalar $R_{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta} R^{\alpha\beta\gamma\delta}$ diverges.
P.R. Brady, D. Nunez and S. Sinha
gr-qc astro-ph
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211026
gr-qc/9211027
[ 0.1441442221403122, 0.42586928606033325, 0.7651375532150269, -0.11824557930231094, 0.3794989585876465, -0.1261579692363739, -0.17988380789756775, -0.2715335786342621, -0.44080162048339844, 1.7385941743850708, 0.1950550079345703, -0.2981473207473755, -0.26919353008270264, -0.681308388710022, -0.2452893853187561, 0.5969551205635071, -0.13163506984710693, -0.4051635265350342, -1.5582339763641357, 0.34581291675567627, -0.26247894763946533, -0.2780008614063263, -0.995261013507843, -0.7936543822288513, -0.07561434060335159, 0.9541545510292053, 0.3114243149757385, 0.4518434703350067, 1.2135077714920044, 1.2301214933395386, 0.7328972816467285, -0.577885627746582, -0.5263935327529907, -0.5238704681396484, -0.3951270580291748, 0.4708974361419678, 0.5769463181495667, -0.6407812237739563, 0.5615972876548767, -0.6396425366401672, 0.55577552318573, -0.4128461182117462, 0.5542182326316833, 0.13235090672969818, -0.5719122886657715, 0.44387924671173096, -0.3005600869655609, 0.036431409418582916, 0.14621978998184204, -1.312671184539795, -0.25420093536376953, -0.03900064900517464, -0.09915132820606232, -0.2129184901714325, -0.03430444747209549, 0.3805064558982849, 0.1506364345550537, 0.6301815509796143, -0.6183998584747314, 0.08099713921546936, 0.7246389389038086, 0.5602607727050781, 0.8875060081481934, -0.5369135141372681, -0.7513095736503601, 0.9943992495536804, 0.016587119549512863, 0.4955713450908661, 0.16666503250598907, -0.5671972036361694, -0.36811110377311707, -0.6218002438545227, 0.25819188356399536, 0.4336336553096771, -0.6856292486190796, 1.3322429656982422, -0.10944394767284393, -0.17027629911899567, -0.7543596625328064, -0.8600158095359802, 0.1507442593574524, 0.20026418566703796, -0.2867875397205353, 0.21956303715705872, 0.08920520544052124, -0.44158703088760376, 0.40773871541023254, -0.45857852697372437, 0.5290926098823547, 0.0587184876203537, -0.12101534754037857, 0.7315253615379333, 0.08472465723752975, 0.17017707228660583, 0.2094465047121048, 0.4349960684776306, -0.0751473531126976, 0.46017226576805115, 0.7450194358825684, 0.2828276455402374, -0.27064913511276245, 0.9618938565254211, -0.43926095962524414, 0.3509863018989563, -0.7084428668022156, 0.7952893972396851, -0.13270555436611176, 0.42889633774757385, -0.24221523106098175, -1.1147243976593018, -0.2300201654434204, -0.1617114394903183, 0.7437305450439453, 0.6868776082992554, 0.7021384835243225, 0.2535267472267151, 0.024568120017647743, 0.13963094353675842, -0.8125810623168945, -0.4174268841743469, -0.06940475851297379, 0.2784106135368347, 0.10799405723810196, 0.5602007508277893, -0.031980764120817184, -0.5032650232315063, -0.7792132496833801, 0.6202839016914368, -0.5139239430427551, 1.0045872926712036, -0.6710620522499084, -0.5983361601829529, -0.06511203199625015, 0.8045667409896851, 0.44522204995155334, 0.2398078888654709, 0.2849895656108856, 0.54667729139328, -0.2855142056941986, -0.8232645988464355, 0.6947854161262512, -0.4751681089401245, -0.4198010265827179, 0.9700693488121033, -0.8116938471794128, -0.11644387245178223, 0.3216874897480011, 0.3524470031261444, 0.04353802651166916, 0.4208277463912964, -0.952416718006134, 0.015186122618615627, 0.5397206544876099, 0.6121450662612915, -0.259548544883728, -0.2122565358877182, -0.9567768573760986, 0.2863900065422058, -0.41052544116973877, -0.6222724318504333, 0.645508348941803, 0.22080294787883759, 0.35598644614219666, 0.7401151061058044, -0.3024977445602417, 0.29381611943244934, -0.28939518332481384, -0.46590399742126465, 0.4082944691181183, -0.5661193132400513, -0.13538481295108795, 0.5961591601371765, -0.2424895018339157, 0.005270801950246096, 0.8260382413864136, 0.8757566809654236, 0.3358246982097626, -0.5566192269325256, 0.18103574216365814, 0.8130773305892944, -0.4367474615573883, -0.23184244334697723, 0.42194128036499023, 0.28366973996162415, -0.45756301283836365, -0.04177318513393402, 0.08464516699314117, 0.07025592774152756, 0.3283177614212036, 0.3474794626235962, -0.9019738435745239, 1.0041431188583374, -1.1274659633636475, 0.7679183483123779, -0.6445015072822571, 0.10710802674293518, -1.0274252891540527, -0.11503765732049942, 0.04778165742754936, -0.5162748098373413, 0.3281148374080658, -0.04373195022344589, -0.5936870574951172, 0.219554141163826, -1.5866819620132446, 0.3895633816719055, -0.04909733682870865, 0.8533130288124084, -0.2952512502670288, 0.35408392548561096, 0.5509583353996277, -0.2948962152004242, 0.12641847133636475, -0.43158867955207825, -0.2250954955816269, -0.21183694899082184, -0.2843661308288574, 0.21970191597938538, 0.6117790937423706, -0.3765668570995331, 0.4235360622406006, 0.1432877480983734, 0.381880521774292, 1.1976261138916016, -0.07607515156269073, -0.7241153717041016, 0.6686870455741882, 0.955191433429718, 0.03190743178129196, 0.2675468623638153, 0.1774596869945526, 0.6789169311523438, 0.21849548816680908, 0.2883022427558899, 0.3159952163696289, -0.614809513092041, 0.7902040481567383, 0.496995747089386, -0.4160262942314148, -0.003215589327737689, 0.11447426676750183, 0.08689837157726288, 0.3376725912094116, 0.6337421536445618, -0.8048430681228638, 0.3865203559398651, 0.2604912519454956, -0.08944272994995117, -0.4929453134536743, 0.47324734926223755, -1.1819888353347778, 0.642720639705658, -0.10170942544937134, -0.27434322237968445, -1.3252366781234741, -0.03233060985803604, -0.13992246985435486, 0.9177319407463074, -0.2689410448074341, -0.7995492815971375, -0.29837948083877563, 0.14770333468914032, -0.06315145641565323, -0.6387708783149719, -0.29687538743019104, 0.19380587339401245, -0.8457160592079163, 0.12254781275987625, 0.676027238368988, -0.27301841974258423, -0.6759096384048462, -0.13880015909671783, -0.27602216601371765, 0.018475262448191643, -0.3375425636768341, -0.1435510218143463, -0.009088284336030483, -0.5131692290306091, 0.017630282789468765, 0.5938582420349121, -0.4157349467277527, 0.4573252201080322, 0.4284551739692688, 0.1755443513393402, -0.5411083102226257, 0.03796711191534996, -1.1122252941131592, 0.21321088075637817, -1.0715696811676025, -0.0998794212937355, -0.06147424504160881, -0.7150355577468872, -0.06653692573308945, -0.1337577998638153, 0.29003748297691345, 0.48676741123199463, -0.3304147720336914, 0.3460276424884796, 0.022682737559080124, -0.5242286324501038, 0.5425758361816406, 0.5385839343070984, -0.25985807180404663, -0.16386210918426514, -1.2537446022033691, 0.915681004524231, -0.9981774091720581, -0.5276308059692383, 0.4926604628562927, -0.43776166439056396, -0.42669716477394104, -0.3059847056865692, -0.42810437083244324, 0.20965248346328735, -0.31046080589294434, 0.010195204056799412, 0.6312983632087708, -0.07174255698919296, 0.16283151507377625, -0.1300080120563507, -0.9827175736427307, -0.20816513895988464, 0.73349928855896, -0.1256122589111328, 0.4050082266330719, 0.6695888638496399, 0.7581800222396851, -0.8026372194290161, 0.3334735929965973, -0.9451916813850403, -0.8043940663337708, 0.3968559503555298, -0.2568693459033966, 0.12458176165819168, 0.06494732946157455, -0.21900060772895813, -0.8193284869194031, -0.32447049021720886, 0.07677879184484482, 0.815047562122345, 0.8129165172576904, 0.6478009819984436, 0.07965011149644852, 0.8476489782333374, -0.03597547486424446, 0.1590273082256317, 1.174215316772461, -0.2822533845901489, 0.09606454521417618, -0.03281460702419281, -0.13344401121139526, -0.3196724057197571, -0.2528493106365204, 0.35599425435066223, -0.07465629279613495, -0.07388538867235184, -0.7193857431411743, -0.13203127682209015, -0.6727216839790344, -0.5285951495170593, 0.26952266693115234, 0.24121522903442383, 0.2957583963871002, -0.2023025006055832, -0.32695382833480835, 0.26516133546829224, 0.0646820217370987, 0.154210165143013, 0.21550074219703674, -0.7068516612052917, 0.0921204537153244, 0.41901567578315735, -0.14821100234985352, -0.01879846304655075, -0.18848970532417297, 0.1540290266275406, 0.5644465088844299, -0.2596905529499054, 0.2846241891384125, -0.5763041973114014, 0.028943611308932304, -0.792016863822937, 1.2608270645141602, 1.0331822633743286, 0.22970576584339142, 0.07537667453289032, -0.022511787712574005, -0.061673372983932495, -0.38891521096229553, -0.386126309633255, -0.6732880473136902, -0.5626433491706848, 0.3313854932785034, -1.4406360387802124, -0.9284089803695679, 0.1998869925737381, 0.6337836980819702, 0.9371526837348938, -0.019639458507299423, -0.025439120829105377, 0.21366126835346222, -0.5263495445251465, -0.2720884382724762, 0.8219676613807678, 0.267803817987442, 0.2454996407032013, -0.8984796404838562, 0.6760420799255371, 0.23163634538650513, -0.020456938073039055, 0.822352945804596, -0.31396666169166565, -0.12987902760505676, -0.39820829033851624, 0.7829841375350952, 0.48155561089515686, 0.2823978364467621, 0.4182594120502472, 0.1958971470594406, -0.24662990868091583, -1.232546091079712, 0.21713419258594513, 0.49567145109176636, 0.8082290887832642, -0.198465034365654, -0.9563353657722473, 0.004849629942327738, -0.9243323802947998, 0.38891106843948364, 0.7235077619552612, 0.5534010529518127, -0.7228038311004639, -0.2231968343257904, 0.3193747103214264, -0.06174512207508087, 0.5560252666473389, 0.44506576657295227, 0.22515401244163513, 0.3482319414615631, -0.07453803718090057, -0.007732323836535215, 0.8345946669578552, -0.7020671367645264, -1.008030652999878, 0.17616532742977142, -0.23440861701965332, -0.16998901963233948, 0.7061892747879028, -0.5334038734436035, -0.6911318302154541, 0.5213233828544617, -0.4111282527446747, 0.5165591239929199, 0.3773188591003418, -0.9838199615478516, 0.21988268196582794, -0.0045824190601706505, 0.1718405932188034, 0.5132902264595032, -0.6371651887893677, -0.14910510182380676, -0.024240665137767792, 0.27135682106018066, -0.5435516834259033, -0.2538743317127228, 0.035036735236644745, 0.34971916675567627, 1.1070748567581177, 0.5805184841156006, 0.7494597434997559, 0.45024698972702026, 0.10159197449684143, 0.23264895379543304, -0.08757002651691437, 0.8712403178215027, -0.5421711206436157, -0.31439757347106934, -0.04891708865761757, -0.2698751389980316, -0.7873509526252747, 0.16930724680423737, 0.47124937176704407, -0.723190188407898, 0.7239168286323547, 0.04979178309440613, -0.605650007724762, -0.7445814609527588, -0.05924239009618759, -0.5977609753608704, 0.5166106820106506, -0.5369173884391785, -0.3930547535419464, -0.45397815108299255, -0.11742086708545685, 0.30690640211105347, -0.17813721299171448, -0.11932846158742905, -0.07464288920164108, -0.568997859954834, 0.5363816618919373, -0.4634163975715637, 0.5539154410362244, -0.7707165479660034, 0.571366012096405, -0.6339945197105408, -0.32461926341056824, -0.6807687282562256, -0.7053489685058594, -0.2557808458805084, 0.346264123916626, -0.22064228355884552, -0.6360564231872559, 0.4646316468715668, -0.002318368060514331, 0.060740649700164795, -0.10034387558698654, -0.0378420427441597, -0.44479265809059143, -0.13047046959400177, 0.09653688222169876, 0.8629180788993835, -0.7641767859458923, 0.022474927827715874, 0.6660161018371582, -0.2540995478630066, -0.02480616420507431, -0.7270702123641968, -0.2038763016462326, 0.21905075013637543, -0.9277788400650024, -0.0017853169701993465, -1.0174330472946167, 0.08999001234769821, 0.4675586521625519, -0.2961527109146118, 0.2705053985118866, -0.08949806541204453, 0.038122955709695816, -0.3092390298843384, -0.4434947371482849, -0.3131398856639862, 0.03085041604936123, -0.23603756725788116, 0.08987383544445038, -0.567236065864563, 0.028324488550424576, -0.7087863683700562, 0.852287769317627, -0.9367464184761047, -0.050644151866436005, 0.6096548438072205, 0.08137679845094681, -0.28889235854148865, 0.10029647499322891, -0.1229872927069664, -0.07531284540891647, 0.479849636554718, 0.2152511328458786, 0.8543804883956909, 0.6423198580741882, -0.2765938639640808, 0.19826793670654297, -0.7544522881507874, 0.5970960855484009, -0.20752331614494324, 0.0001170620380435139, 0.5795702338218689, -0.0806969627737999, 0.8205165863037109, -0.4236901104450226, 0.37346264719963074, 0.944435715675354, 0.19112767279148102, 0.6560440063476562, -0.30919256806373596, -0.4409531354904175, -0.14219625294208527, -0.6511358022689819, -0.8727622628211975, 0.7111415863037109, -0.36770522594451904, -0.01695903204381466, -0.23943816125392914, -0.332412987947464, -0.0985882580280304, -0.21636930108070374, -0.11951155960559845, -0.0705207958817482, 0.10619327425956726, -0.1813901960849762, -0.52342689037323, 0.5772892832756042, -0.14652332663536072, -0.27132201194763184, 0.07599741220474243, 0.07726699858903885, -0.7154774069786072, 0.18858884274959564, 0.04680094122886658, -0.7217636108398438, -0.2972639203071594, 0.46746039390563965, 0.6373902559280396, -0.2855735421180725, 0.727196455001831, -0.2899005711078644, -0.2850496768951416, -0.8683704733848572, -0.07673405855894089, 0.2710372507572174, 0.1439613550901413, 0.5317736268043518, 0.6576389670372009, -0.14970998466014862, -0.1900307536125183, 1.046068549156189, -0.5552707314491272, -1.1356624364852905, 0.8071915507316589, -0.8989720344543457, -0.12533752620220184, 0.5157633423805237, 0.04314793273806572, -0.7577663064002991, -0.9446246027946472, -1.572210431098938, 0.24684566259384155, 0.7935710549354553, -0.45714059472084045, -0.20983968675136566, -0.3439818322658539, -0.027238041162490845, 0.5549033284187317, 0.7810100317001343, 0.6981050968170166, 0.4839427173137665, 0.3517630398273468, 0.11193132400512695, -0.6345083713531494, 0.2729085385799408, 0.998279333114624, 0.692304790019989, -1.0513651371002197, 0.12334970384836197, -0.29721879959106445, -0.3222349286079407, -0.38833460211753845, 0.3961547315120697, -0.23404142260551453, 0.01920238323509693, 0.03048240952193737, -0.1986827552318573, 0.0819740891456604, 0.25594890117645264, -0.35876184701919556, 0.27672290802001953, -0.3216167688369751, -0.8365898132324219, -0.26311513781547546, -0.10510812699794769, 0.20767970383167267, 0.5915841460227966, 0.6897294521331787, 0.1420876532793045, -0.8786507248878479, -0.21208585798740387, -0.08397042751312256, -0.7642719745635986, -0.5405123829841614, -0.8120383620262146, -0.6833431720733643, -0.6602637767791748, -0.23078399896621704, -0.11838450282812119, 0.7678428292274475, 0.054036300629377365, 0.23836693167686462, -0.329752653837204, -0.2707770764827728, 0.18844151496887207, 0.7829890847206116, -0.20729777216911316, -0.8359830975532532, -1.031510591506958, 0.584165632724762, -0.24948279559612274, -1.200561761856079, -0.43140220642089844, 0.043052494525909424, 0.0021185462828725576, 0.7853153944015503, -0.47158151865005493, 1.1789519786834717, -0.3326725661754608, -0.7057757377624512, 0.18681806325912476, 0.37554609775543213, -0.5954832434654236, 1.0850340127944946, -0.6040356159210205, 0.9639605283737183, 0.6042366027832031, 0.049553245306015015, -0.2404446303844452, -0.029056433588266373, -1.0690691471099854, 0.11556718498468399, 0.1925131380558014, 0.6328463554382324, -0.09625814855098724, -1.3441569805145264, 0.42083561420440674, 0.5443031191825867, -0.7548506259918213, -0.5594642162322998, -0.3805931806564331, 1.282102108001709, -0.8258791565895081, -0.3720722496509552, 0.042103007435798645, 0.8473883867263794, -0.3009489178657532, 0.3536628782749176, -0.45020347833633423, -0.1939016431570053, 0.0019506510579958558, 0.5068956017494202, -0.06640136986970901, 0.24468544125556946, 0.509386420249939, -0.619024395942688, -0.10512285679578781, 0.11702978610992432, -0.3702811300754547, 0.26999911665916443, -0.11326092481613159, -0.4110015332698822, -0.5936961770057678, -0.08187288790941238, -0.823822021484375, 0.3778197765350342, 0.6640089750289917, 0.14591042697429657, 0.29184234142303467, -0.4158664345741272, -1.0785800218582153, 0.01001022756099701, -0.4862075448036194, -0.2517237961292267, -0.13238854706287384, -0.19732406735420227, 0.16130103170871735, 0.27975115180015564, -0.37030258774757385, -0.1206301748752594, -0.3422583341598511, 1.1149868965148926, 0.784621000289917, 0.036813829094171524, -0.4900718033313751, 0.15468387305736542, -0.9305337071418762, -0.6686099171638489, -0.5357548594474792, -0.011921077966690063, -0.6317489147186279, -0.5702875852584839, -0.48721298575401306, 0.05186603590846062, -0.20805439352989197, 0.17640237510204315, 0.5101205706596375, 0.2664516866207123, -0.28128284215927124, -0.32623252272605896, -0.5976495146751404, -0.05723714083433151, -0.07613562792539597, 0.04098380357027054, -0.2660975456237793, -0.15476401150226593, 0.1871398389339447, 0.02787591516971588, 0.3148464858531952, 0.11285147070884705, -0.2889837622642517, 0.9395054578781128, 0.05635329708456993, -0.1713085174560547, 0.9230866432189941, 0.5663907527923584, 0.6600996255874634, 0.7023317217826843, -0.31618669629096985, 0.036331906914711, -0.0808580219745636, -0.08578002452850342, 0.6334652900695801, 0.04649101570248604, -0.04508873075246811, -0.045972563326358795, 0.34272193908691406, 0.1882084757089615, -0.2760762572288513, -0.2535143792629242, -0.25145941972732544, 0.1102975606918335, -0.29870709776878357, 0.8651831746101379, -0.7285652756690979, 0.2714311480522156, 0.05582433566451073, 0.4809841513633728, 0.4070862829685211, -0.5680490732192993, -0.15562376379966736, 0.13509084284305573, -0.542028546333313, -0.9909542202949524, -0.7006195187568665, 0.51235032081604, -0.3097623884677887, 0.06320960819721222, -0.06636485457420349, 0.7516281008720398, 0.17298729717731476, 0.47681742906570435, -0.526338517665863, 0.5164487361907959, 0.6938323974609375, 0.6915113925933838, 0.8262853026390076, 0.8992497324943542, 0.3823736011981964, 0.2821885347366333, 0.3842623233795166, -0.7112683653831482, -0.42797642946243286, -0.0810452550649643, -1.0964717864990234, 0.24652817845344543, 0.196869358420372, -0.17070403695106506, 0.029762787744402885, -1.282009482383728, 0.09642529487609863, -0.3681764006614685, 0.15454043447971344, 0.17852023243904114, -0.36353474855422974, -0.04613099247217178, -0.14771270751953125, 0.05060853436589241, 0.6500048637390137, -0.07907641679048538, 0.37010297179222107, -0.1839543581008911, 1.1160188913345337, 0.8927854299545288, 0.03838752582669258, 0.09179949760437012, -0.2708823084831238, 0.1947842836380005, 0.522526204586029, 0.8823127746582031, -0.32555288076400757, 0.8452140688896179, -0.6650521755218506, 0.013317003846168518, -0.6246849894523621, -0.2374333292245865, -0.833101212978363, 0.5765995383262634, 0.1572612076997757, 0.6194155216217041, -0.14885109663009644, -0.10922852903604507, 0.163066104054451, 0.029332341626286507, -0.49329790472984314, -0.1251162439584732, 0.36260485649108887, -1.1642303466796875, -0.025831367820501328, -0.6279420852661133, 0.624308705329895, 0.17543457448482513, -0.7132411003112793, -0.23953722417354584, -0.294515997171402, -0.7632914781570435, -1.2248231172561646, -0.3785053789615631, -0.6454116702079773, 0.4813215434551239, 1.031007170677185, 0.12986119091510773, 0.4635814130306244, -0.8105849623680115, -0.38690185546875, 0.27623939514160156, 1.5274558067321777, 0.1534692496061325, -0.050263699144124985, 0.8937883973121643, 0.01279084850102663, -0.9094489812850952, 0.7986103892326355, 1.0952107906341553, -0.21458794176578522, 0.3593495488166809, -0.6434484124183655, -0.11190644651651382, -0.33372223377227783, -0.6378815770149231, 0.13388043642044067, 0.21938644349575043, 0.7147393822669983, -0.6464509963989258, -0.48491260409355164, 0.23272038996219635, -0.29666006565093994, -0.19369639456272125, -0.49282220005989075, 0.7172850966453552, -0.02340634912252426, -0.25298717617988586, -0.0170780960470438, -0.06771405041217804, 4.009372234344482, 0.6403221487998962, 0.4396347999572754, 0.23396435379981995, 0.7040219902992249, 0.6559960842132568, 0.24504375457763672, 0.2842679023742676, 0.738782525062561, -0.6727997064590454, -0.5137743353843689, 0.7999866604804993, 0.5392470955848694, 0.20913256704807281, 0.05403521656990051, 0.32863518595695496, 0.29362449049949646, 0.521393895149231, -0.3398820757865906, -0.6388399004936218, -1.0041579008102417, 0.5135723948478699, 0.23068642616271973, -0.38451582193374634, -0.20885099470615387, 0.15120422840118408, 0.6654064655303955, -0.611639142036438, -0.3572596609592438, -0.18470542132854462, -0.2603762149810791, -0.5224803686141968, 0.0709245353937149, -0.3693137466907501, -1.5141762495040894, 0.51310795545578, 0.16977910697460175, -0.022701816633343697, 0.5656836628913879, -0.3963148295879364, -0.03546907752752304, -0.07171041518449783, -0.3059070110321045, -0.3744615912437439, 0.1305556297302246, 0.8037987351417542, 0.5633864998817444, 0.878726601600647, 0.5661960244178772, -0.7464997172355652, -0.0975918397307396, 0.32522228360176086, 0.9433450698852539, -0.35190218687057495, -0.7131931781768799, -0.507084310054779, -0.10958732664585114, -0.4660351872444153, 0.020384693518280983, 0.1419343501329422, 1.0908516645431519, -0.6578027606010437, 0.15189649164676666, 0.11228842288255692, -0.050503700971603394, 0.2968043088912964, 0.6316263675689697, -0.23509085178375244, -0.4592190682888031, 0.10368440300226212, -0.8489274978637695, -0.10611890256404877, -0.8114371299743652, -0.7203381061553955, 0.3474031984806061, 0.18093155324459076, 0.06359993666410446, 0.17794129252433777, -0.48695796728134155, 0.23087210953235626, -0.4901309311389923, -0.503997266292572, 0.3513377010822296, 0.680210530757904, -0.05803223326802254, 0.5965728163719177, 0.4415544271469116, 0.4003309905529022, -0.01791532151401043, 0.6442493796348572, 0.42549049854278564, 1.3200603723526, 0.07311853021383286, -0.12660610675811768, -0.8735445141792297 ]
Chaotic Friedmann-Robertson-Walker Cosmology
We show that the dynamics of a spatially closed Friedmann - Robertson - Walker Universe conformally coupled to a real, free, massive scalar field, is chaotic, for large enough field amplitudes. We do so by proving that this system is integrable under the adiabatic approximation, but that the corresponding KAM tori break up when non adiabatic terms are considered. This finding is confirmed by numerical evaluation of the Lyapunov exponents associated with the system, among other criteria. Chaos sets strong limitations to our ability to predict the value of the field at the Big Crunch, from its given value at the Big Bang. (Figures available on request)
E. Calzetta and C. El Hasi
gr-qc
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211027
gr-qc/9211028
[ 0.4067815840244293, -0.28293082118034363, 0.40904200077056885, -0.15541161596775055, -0.0009270869195461273, -0.46486008167266846, -0.04464985057711601, 0.07177874445915222, -1.0657153129577637, 0.8576819896697998, 0.924780547618866, 0.02064388431608677, 0.06792899966239929, 0.15406282246112823, -0.12038801610469818, 0.5550308227539062, -0.7367951273918152, -0.09585907310247421, -1.638786792755127, 0.3608114421367645, 0.381039023399353, 0.18084874749183655, -1.6134049892425537, -0.34978505969047546, -0.9365817308425903, -0.030334990471601486, 0.3968242108821869, -0.1401877999305725, 0.9771620035171509, 0.8423027992248535, 0.7080716490745544, -0.46370384097099304, 0.08653507381677628, -0.3363558053970337, -0.22675776481628418, 0.26895231008529663, 0.1569676250219345, -0.2415088564157486, 0.8485049605369568, -0.5731534957885742, 0.6129634976387024, 0.3248363137245178, 0.4014040529727936, -0.0676814541220665, -1.0900157690048218, -0.4762338399887085, 0.3434046506881714, -0.3013114631175995, -0.26224905252456665, -0.8530925512313843, 0.4320325255393982, 0.12647387385368347, 0.4488511085510254, -0.5977396368980408, -0.002134260954335332, 0.050959475338459015, 0.15055106580257416, 0.786703884601593, -0.18380047380924225, 0.6403797268867493, 0.41398367285728455, -0.36630338430404663, 0.7132030129432678, -0.997563898563385, 0.08851095288991928, 0.6005284190177917, -0.5910265445709229, 0.21008460223674774, -0.341033399105072, -0.5996741652488708, -0.337123304605484, -0.5401458740234375, -0.21660307049751282, -0.39538827538490295, -0.37635162472724915, 0.7877126336097717, -0.16438516974449158, 0.08202032744884491, -0.48003172874450684, -0.24385128915309906, 0.11142255365848541, -0.629176676273346, -0.03286059945821762, 0.05557624250650406, 0.2816426157951355, -0.18495436012744904, 0.040722813457250595, -0.6007330417633057, -0.19953426718711853, -0.2347736805677414, 0.3521675765514374, 0.9167298078536987, 0.0958881750702858, 0.0526500940322876, -0.042538102716207504, 0.7103211283683777, -0.14546135067939758, 0.46094948053359985, 0.7308796644210815, 0.312677264213562, 0.023816995322704315, 1.209773302078247, 0.2986588478088379, 1.0142652988433838, -0.6452072262763977, 0.7145109176635742, -0.22599531710147858, 0.476863294839859, -0.5596799254417419, -0.6498584151268005, -0.15317250788211823, 0.08908823877573013, 0.25220543146133423, 0.7126277685165405, -0.27009451389312744, 0.4840675890445709, 0.36585214734077454, -0.23748812079429626, -0.1447255164384842, -0.3542129695415497, 0.28348901867866516, -0.06445001810789108, 0.6021258234977722, 0.4581272304058075, 0.22922661900520325, -0.06710603833198547, -0.03588680177927017, 0.11759914457798004, -0.7592856287956238, -0.6400009393692017, -0.02718142420053482, -0.2454599142074585, 0.5570031404495239, 0.374099463224411, -0.6170673966407776, 0.6867552399635315, -0.52228182554245, 0.17468199133872986, 0.04852396994829178, 0.020588060840964317, 0.7236385941505432, -0.6349306106567383, 0.5011809468269348, 0.567279040813446, -0.16627684235572815, 0.4966970384120941, -0.19534005224704742, 1.0037678480148315, -0.24029235541820526, 0.11555943638086319, -0.18401765823364258, -0.0501907616853714, -0.15495899319648743, -0.0771121233701706, 0.07365602254867554, -0.2604043483734131, -0.701262891292572, 0.2667761445045471, -1.2398186922073364, -0.38433027267456055, 0.3539910912513733, 0.01461698953062296, -0.23912997543811798, 0.3605688810348511, -0.03880173712968826, -0.048673827201128006, -0.6169719099998474, -0.35705170035362244, 0.09754621237516403, 0.08592326939105988, 0.41398367285728455, -0.3424272835254669, 0.18269556760787964, -0.040369968861341476, 0.9078415036201477, 0.5155956745147705, 0.2150999754667282, 0.3298672139644623, -0.2268824428319931, 0.11975137889385223, 0.08996731787919998, -0.3889912962913513, 1.4410847425460815, 0.3777506351470947, 0.49256569147109985, -0.7715519070625305, -0.5403081178665161, 0.5433686375617981, -0.10056453943252563, 0.2168838381767273, -0.5285906791687012, 0.17391985654830933, -0.5575607419013977, 0.7699394226074219, -0.1581994593143463, 0.3521881401538849, -0.8592624068260193, 0.45764273405075073, -0.2901601791381836, -0.10205644369125366, -0.21764753758907318, 0.7172952890396118, -1.764475703239441, 0.2538122534751892, -1.5837104320526123, 0.2941588759422302, 0.5699281096458435, 0.7246392965316772, -0.2288859337568283, 1.0676074028015137, 0.06412181258201599, -0.1445593535900116, -0.24857871234416962, -0.0676700696349144, 0.047808825969696045, -0.7036136984825134, -0.3969087600708008, 0.7143766283988953, 0.2821972668170929, 0.2969663143157959, 0.7545484900474548, 0.3001191318035126, 0.11266641318798065, 0.5018368363380432, 0.3898789584636688, -1.0395408868789673, 0.24793414771556854, 0.9711686372756958, -0.45904722809791565, 0.46215546131134033, 0.3271804451942444, 1.0933846235275269, -0.3083605468273163, 0.398885577917099, 1.1496087312698364, -0.1593916118144989, 0.40170300006866455, -0.013058432377874851, 0.7683443427085876, -0.5069859027862549, 0.3705351948738098, 0.5841487050056458, 0.5043758749961853, 0.28992071747779846, -0.4804929494857788, 0.3417099416255951, 0.2279054969549179, -0.31140968203544617, 0.11146608740091324, 0.49795639514923096, -0.6275621652603149, 0.5771126747131348, 0.4231756925582886, 0.31919968128204346, -1.1407220363616943, 0.08895452320575714, 0.5586360096931458, 0.03330422192811966, -0.36223769187927246, -0.5880531072616577, 0.021997302770614624, -0.10380460321903229, -0.2725808620452881, -0.44145500659942627, -0.06658705323934555, 0.46915051341056824, 0.06779995560646057, 0.3280683159828186, -0.016978850588202477, -0.922179102897644, -0.5788348317146301, -0.34094876050949097, -0.6945587992668152, -0.10382495820522308, -0.6020641326904297, -0.28913992643356323, 0.4912097454071045, -0.7320267558097839, 0.7867543697357178, 0.16006845235824585, -0.23132897913455963, 0.17661236226558685, 0.09160864353179932, 0.8253566026687622, -0.27244046330451965, -0.49349501729011536, -0.48616817593574524, 0.416429728269577, -0.8728376626968384, 0.2017574906349182, 1.0188632011413574, -0.7973392605781555, 0.5937187075614929, -0.38746845722198486, -0.4347350597381592, -0.265485942363739, -0.4675585925579071, -0.36929503083229065, -0.6658016443252563, -0.41837096214294434, -0.056029997766017914, 0.6216822862625122, 0.4158180058002472, 1.0597440004348755, -0.8370822072029114, 1.2583478689193726, -0.07337815314531326, -0.13917624950408936, 0.7664774060249329, 0.4198418855667114, -0.8835618495941162, 0.20059216022491455, -0.6199952363967896, 0.49689599871635437, 0.16506429016590118, 0.47070443630218506, 0.573296070098877, -0.0886707678437233, 0.1823320984840393, -0.25243061780929565, -0.5064495801925659, -0.1114150658249855, 0.14873214066028595, -1.111280918121338, -0.061357393860816956, 0.380741685628891, -0.32103151082992554, -0.4336751699447632, 0.06532817333936691, -1.275361180305481, -0.31235140562057495, -0.11566421389579773, -0.44861775636672974, 0.17452213168144226, -0.12235268205404282, -0.24867357313632965, -0.5902670621871948, -0.03143193572759628, 1.0648362636566162, 0.65304034948349, 0.7821754813194275, -0.705025851726532, 0.1700570434331894, -0.500300943851471, -0.009857337921857834, 0.4509892463684082, 0.4581972658634186, 0.09345243871212006, -0.2017664909362793, 0.15906496345996857, -0.13138851523399353, 0.21380731463432312, -0.11732140183448792, -0.215689554810524, 0.25982365012168884, 0.41857942938804626, -0.8400691747665405, -0.3379365801811218, -0.8898020386695862, -0.31316816806793213, 0.7834480404853821, 0.31281501054763794, -0.1666473001241684, -0.3875066936016083, -1.3073523044586182, -0.1962842047214508, -0.024998579174280167, -0.08459056168794632, 0.4078359305858612, -0.6182843446731567, 0.32165253162384033, -0.4638434648513794, 0.14836007356643677, 0.05860484763979912, -0.8601000905036926, 0.09763602912425995, -0.20544278621673584, 0.8063297867774963, 0.26566070318222046, -0.6820666193962097, -0.5159740447998047, 0.010417223908007145, -0.042102497071027756, 0.3524199426174164, 0.5143222212791443, -0.0030643411446362734, -0.002816608175635338, 0.011785243637859821, -0.28161290287971497, -0.6396780014038086, 0.013221579603850842, -0.3444804847240448, -0.31129634380340576, -0.5200935006141663, -0.6339725255966187, 0.1548944115638733, 0.6677485108375549, 0.039664700627326965, 0.17938518524169922, -0.1943383514881134, 0.062083203345537186, 0.8628522157669067, 0.3841423988342285, 1.0845032930374146, -0.4369928538799286, -0.06925588101148605, -0.03485424444079399, 0.8328629732131958, 0.30153340101242065, 0.3676818311214447, -0.3279874622821808, -0.5832575559616089, -0.028417004272341728, -1.0710729360580444, 0.2516123056411743, 0.5593320727348328, 0.051548827439546585, 0.3078468441963196, 0.6825703978538513, 0.1633812040090561, -0.8192071914672852, 0.49604934453964233, 0.538004457950592, 1.0258675813674927, 0.6857454776763916, -0.6771196722984314, 0.3741439878940582, -0.34923356771469116, 0.7923488020896912, 0.8996015787124634, -0.18129858374595642, -0.8058763146400452, -0.4675212502479553, 0.47972655296325684, -0.7446114420890808, 0.3545667827129364, 0.42732298374176025, -0.01051810197532177, 0.2761712670326233, -0.5342087149620056, -0.011739188805222511, 0.35805875062942505, -0.8930891752243042, -0.5178127288818359, -0.03057553432881832, 0.10975854098796844, 0.019412118941545486, 0.07904733717441559, -0.18220631778240204, 0.22719600796699524, 0.2621557116508484, -0.46390432119369507, 0.2049662172794342, -0.41301897168159485, 0.1311875581741333, 0.0789046511054039, 0.8524260520935059, -0.3699052929878235, -0.08816444873809814, 0.29693275690078735, 0.5089607238769531, -0.41982725262641907, 0.5673184990882874, -0.22320760786533356, 0.3661535978317261, 0.47161251306533813, 0.22856047749519348, 0.30630189180374146, 0.5121404528617859, 0.15936851501464844, -0.00915879849344492, -0.13088537752628326, -0.2569797933101654, -0.19757048785686493, 0.34670090675354004, -0.4847424626350403, -0.8215699791908264, 0.16357752680778503, -0.2726762890815735, 0.19445176422595978, -0.5622448921203613, -0.05382419750094414, 0.016025859862565994, 0.08557009696960449, -0.19027163088321686, -0.987642765045166, -0.9387105107307434, -0.3292849659919739, -0.7997580170631409, 0.6620502471923828, -0.5045109987258911, -0.3324061334133148, 0.08245187252759933, -0.08075891435146332, -0.789149820804596, -0.18498702347278595, -0.3413195312023163, -0.2877008616924286, 0.5217034220695496, -0.2325025349855423, 0.04054959863424301, 0.6686355471611023, -0.4843703508377075, 0.2371390163898468, -0.46302512288093567, -0.07195737957954407, -0.1124897450208664, -0.5742045640945435, 0.13458198308944702, -0.019689219072461128, -0.22380100190639496, -0.37180188298225403, 0.1805715560913086, 0.2235783040523529, 0.37269794940948486, 0.06143971532583237, -0.10440292954444885, -0.5867457985877991, 0.24989591538906097, 0.4821110665798187, 0.5546135306358337, -0.578230619430542, -0.5046588182449341, -0.033998437225818634, -1.0443005561828613, -0.10943488776683807, -0.13385924696922302, -0.8233747482299805, -0.18097306787967682, -0.4603075683116913, 0.99607253074646, -0.680905282497406, -0.12333007156848907, -1.0143145322799683, -0.6610920429229736, 0.0731302797794342, 0.3595549166202545, 0.10671016573905945, -0.31892940402030945, -0.48204952478408813, -0.3803555369377136, -0.08121462166309357, -0.2964520752429962, 0.3323323428630829, -0.38094669580459595, -0.500858724117279, -0.6249203085899353, 1.0579134225845337, -0.7845103740692139, -0.1987610012292862, 0.1749095469713211, 0.03180929273366928, 0.36270788311958313, 0.5894002318382263, 0.8890091776847839, -0.17053745687007904, -0.4230063259601593, 0.11189454793930054, 0.07649249583482742, 0.7458571195602417, 0.26863422989845276, 0.444389671087265, -0.7826666235923767, 0.9989650249481201, 0.0826800987124443, -0.7937551736831665, -0.07813156396150589, 0.20214203000068665, 1.0899121761322021, -0.8809084296226501, -0.05021475628018379, -0.17805564403533936, 0.1570514738559723, 0.31174731254577637, -0.321479856967926, -1.0247325897216797, -0.48543471097946167, -0.9429105520248413, -0.48498523235321045, 0.6547552943229675, 0.24824152886867523, -0.16003960371017456, -0.3223617672920227, -0.2139298915863037, 0.09096653014421463, -0.1882169544696808, 0.6267580389976501, 0.4381502568721771, 0.4062291383743286, -0.05568554624915123, -0.1435159146785736, 0.4433720111846924, -0.5330466032028198, 0.14637382328510284, -0.07510495185852051, 0.5491701364517212, -0.11371032893657684, -0.14978204667568207, -0.5092900991439819, -0.9738739728927612, -0.22367587685585022, 0.42087361216545105, 0.43527746200561523, -0.07318215072154999, 0.7413550615310669, 0.12751606106758118, -0.60985267162323, 0.04854680970311165, 0.09253218024969101, 0.11590918153524399, -0.08135197311639786, 0.5903949737548828, 0.051567401736974716, -0.09849874675273895, -0.6558515429496765, 1.0471140146255493, -1.0410943031311035, -0.5076947808265686, 0.90569669008255, 0.03801968693733215, -0.2671618163585663, 0.8824754357337952, 0.4101983606815338, -0.7976445555686951, -0.8914980888366699, -0.31069982051849365, -0.18158096075057983, 0.04827587679028511, -0.6159405708312988, -0.5476704835891724, -0.283220499753952, -0.3842739760875702, 0.10317325592041016, 0.4487084448337555, 0.34572866559028625, 0.19525295495986938, 0.1278044879436493, -0.1829395443201065, -0.5361126661300659, -0.0265850517898798, 1.0011066198349, 0.11819028109312057, -0.7134982347488403, -0.2177983820438385, 0.16013041138648987, 0.17704693973064423, -0.33940762281417847, 1.1074823141098022, -0.39665859937667847, 0.09273344278335571, 0.6243306398391724, -0.0059335678815841675, 0.4952425956726074, -0.06519698351621628, 0.47608599066734314, -0.01881919801235199, 0.13071651756763458, -1.6665418148040771, 0.3947642147541046, 0.4739185869693756, 0.7255613803863525, 0.10479278117418289, -0.4177241027355194, -0.1351662278175354, 0.6193267107009888, 0.6271249055862427, -0.5593675971031189, -1.0223238468170166, -0.34079480171203613, -1.4181281328201294, -0.7489515542984009, -0.7924565672874451, 0.2742718756198883, 0.07331257313489914, 0.2523174285888672, -0.48693177103996277, -0.06374292820692062, -0.727362871170044, -0.23693393170833588, -0.07307979464530945, 1.2105871438980103, -0.35126855969429016, -0.07112102210521698, -0.8102295994758606, 0.5126286149024963, -0.23200340569019318, -0.5351877808570862, -0.706639289855957, 0.05774756520986557, -0.285327285528183, 0.4726414382457733, -0.8706607222557068, 1.5403889417648315, -0.33248764276504517, -0.3807530105113983, -0.24521104991436005, 0.07319609820842743, -0.6501075625419617, 0.6664504408836365, -0.3270501494407654, 0.6160053610801697, 0.0191704910248518, 0.3608017563819885, -0.28607407212257385, 0.1371307224035263, -1.3346203565597534, 0.4509907364845276, -0.16464672982692719, 0.30264440178871155, 0.7763257026672363, -0.3576820492744446, 0.48819056153297424, 0.07942074537277222, -0.796940803527832, -0.026926247403025627, 0.7221401333808899, 0.9394239187240601, -0.22395062446594238, 0.1444655805826187, -0.6749082207679749, -0.15742410719394684, 0.21090167760849, 1.1270298957824707, -0.34016215801239014, -0.9308022260665894, -0.31032267212867737, 0.4118672311306, 0.04335514456033707, 0.1420203000307083, -0.022282009944319725, -0.08456554263830185, -0.553352952003479, 0.3435581922531128, -0.8336811661720276, 0.2693537473678589, -0.7297055125236511, -0.19047614932060242, -0.5572795271873474, 0.7274655103683472, -0.782913863658905, 0.8338296413421631, 0.6012877225875854, -0.12983906269073486, -0.033967599272727966, -0.45699721574783325, -0.5820177793502808, 0.251708984375, -1.0424631834030151, -1.0970903635025024, 0.06194242462515831, -0.2845897674560547, 0.031429223716259, 0.16103386878967285, -0.4380917549133301, -0.4441654682159424, 0.6380425095558167, 1.1155462265014648, 0.3789980411529541, -0.12213996797800064, -0.7811115384101868, 0.7731171250343323, -0.5199687480926514, -0.7951684594154358, -0.21798110008239746, -0.34479108452796936, -0.9056209921836853, -0.6416994333267212, -0.8314351439476013, 0.4034537076950073, -0.1707029789686203, -0.10845278203487396, -0.38345593214035034, -0.02851705253124237, 0.25879985094070435, 0.16307984292507172, -0.29432570934295654, 0.43604275584220886, 0.0254758782684803, 0.46000272035598755, -0.3456977307796478, -0.07952196151018143, 0.14315439760684967, -0.02412196435034275, 0.3519788086414337, 0.04059342294931412, -0.10977981239557266, 0.7366977334022522, 0.08376453071832657, -0.4230576455593109, 0.5648415088653564, 0.648884654045105, 0.4273888170719147, 0.7001518607139587, -0.4149840176105499, 0.3296237587928772, 0.5530992746353149, 0.671474039554596, 0.5661365389823914, 0.4305047392845154, 0.16066975891590118, 0.01831873506307602, 0.4504961371421814, 0.13481445610523224, 0.58380126953125, 0.3324005603790283, -0.2054452747106552, 0.22197820246219635, -0.40705376863479614, 0.17917577922344208, 0.3635399341583252, 0.3076084554195404, 0.4012233018875122, -0.38675710558891296, -0.5506685972213745, -0.41649195551872253, -0.33106350898742676, 0.7947041392326355, 0.23912011086940765, -0.5130102038383484, -0.4180833399295807, 0.6535777449607849, 0.01048676110804081, -0.025126256048679352, -0.6679606437683105, 0.6666504144668579, 0.9346300363540649, 0.7189810872077942, -0.32065221667289734, 0.40810906887054443, 0.5623486638069153, 0.7952835559844971, 0.8639500141143799, 0.19726717472076416, 0.5216331481933594, 1.0346492528915405, -0.47912800312042236, -1.0055577754974365, 0.2829859256744385, -0.11095982789993286, -1.201385736465454, 0.11775610595941544, 0.36010169982910156, -0.25028741359710693, -0.12048289179801941, -1.0183762311935425, 0.93596351146698, 0.17523358762264252, -0.11584997922182083, 0.3199455738067627, -0.698880672454834, -0.489075243473053, 0.3789909780025482, 0.494181752204895, 0.7203058004379272, 0.7899650931358337, 0.7182930111885071, 0.046961475163698196, 0.700802743434906, 0.938683032989502, 0.29415276646614075, -0.5647740960121155, -0.027534065768122673, 0.33910486102104187, -0.08211246132850647, 0.15987160801887512, -0.06159370765089989, 0.021471409127116203, -0.03804810717701912, -0.34785744547843933, -0.07980187237262726, 0.2631022334098816, -0.22187939286231995, -0.6675329804420471, 0.4703048765659332, 0.841904878616333, -0.18511763215065002, 0.2031814604997635, 0.3982381224632263, 0.06542935967445374, 0.15920467674732208, -0.2109585404396057, 0.033875543624162674, -0.898573100566864, -0.24915017187595367, -0.955127477645874, 0.936208963394165, 0.2761978805065155, -0.04904114082455635, -0.23645278811454773, -0.4167136549949646, -0.4325757622718811, -0.7571731805801392, -0.18385599553585052, -0.8196917176246643, -0.2418099343776703, 0.720592200756073, 0.2069438248872757, 0.4616466760635376, -0.4613504707813263, -0.24766498804092407, -0.5465729236602783, 1.420580267906189, -0.48535624146461487, 0.9721649885177612, 0.6544356346130371, 0.016166867688298225, -1.046844244003296, 0.15359744429588318, 0.9313084483146667, -0.8795861601829529, 0.5463824272155762, -0.4025380611419678, 0.4162145256996155, -0.35683488845825195, -0.5182695388793945, 0.028264733031392097, -0.035913530737161636, 0.04215116798877716, 0.6025527715682983, -0.6394491791725159, 0.0030342775862663984, -0.7021198868751526, -0.021796340122818947, -0.7854834198951721, 0.11071272194385529, 0.1169063150882721, -0.17456117272377014, 0.4020994305610657, -0.8359440565109253, 4.089486598968506, 0.9976506233215332, 0.3312865197658539, 0.7048766016960144, 1.0384364128112793, 1.0364991426467896, 0.3089653551578522, -0.13254164159297943, 0.07661373913288116, -0.9533489942550659, 0.1740266978740692, 0.30555593967437744, -0.6378076076507568, -0.6387770771980286, 0.4713445007801056, 0.9460057616233826, -0.20225471258163452, -0.41103240847587585, -0.30458757281303406, -1.0455745458602905, -1.0487278699874878, 0.18224979937076569, 0.06482809036970139, -0.577903151512146, -0.46886539459228516, 0.1931813806295395, 0.4789600968360901, -0.48565706610679626, -0.12532760202884674, -0.8701611757278442, -0.6358051300048828, -0.6189140677452087, -0.09494100511074066, 0.29431116580963135, -0.9280961155891418, 0.5270251035690308, 0.29769644141197205, -0.17266395688056946, 0.32130444049835205, -0.23745372891426086, -0.22955332696437836, -0.11869969964027405, 0.513592004776001, 0.05206160992383957, -0.6964035034179688, 0.6615201234817505, -0.21074527502059937, 0.6263158321380615, 0.28756555914878845, -0.9614386558532715, 0.6097249388694763, -0.22056619822978973, 0.5513138175010681, -0.3728080093860626, -0.2368927001953125, -0.26124829053878784, -0.27271056175231934, 0.17093999683856964, 0.045170146971940994, -0.2572135627269745, 0.8118290305137634, -0.19821031391620636, 0.2132289558649063, -0.13132108747959137, 0.3960488736629486, 0.2098296582698822, 0.5866603255271912, -0.15795956552028656, -0.5338144898414612, 0.24938128888607025, -0.6066710948944092, -0.8124353289604187, -0.5240011215209961, -0.15341521799564362, 0.2849198281764984, 0.26108884811401367, -1.0380735397338867, 0.4772833585739136, 0.05071038380265236, -0.2618025839328766, -0.09236510097980499, -0.43289631605148315, 0.08070849627256393, -0.7852961421012878, 0.44407716393470764, 0.8434607982635498, 0.21547454595565796, 0.5335385799407959, -0.208542138338089, 0.12667489051818848, 0.38216474652290344, 0.553494930267334, -0.39214208722114563, 0.36313021183013916, -0.2242874950170517 ]
Thawing the Frozen Formalism: The Difference Between Observables and What We Observe
In a parametrized and constrained Hamiltonian system, an observable is an operator which commutes with all (first-class) constraints, including the super-Hamiltonian. The problem of the frozen formalism is to explain how dynamics is possible when all observables are constants of the motion. An explicit model of a measurement-interaction in a parametrized Hamiltonian system is used to elucidate the relationship between three definitions of observables---as something one observes, as self-adjoint operators, and as operators which commute with all of the constraints. There is no inconsistency in the frozen formalism when the measurement process is properly understood. The projection operator description of measurement is criticized as an over-idealization which treats measurement as instantaneous and non-destructive. A more careful description of measurement necessarily involves interactions of non-vanishing duration. This is a first step towards a more even-handed treatment of space and time in quantum mechanics. (This paper was written for the festschrift of Dieter Brill.)
Arlen Anderson
gr-qc hep-th
November
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9211028
gr-qc/9212001
[ 0.14967741072177887, 0.32564210891723633, 0.15243719518184662, -0.2630411386489868, -0.10884228348731995, -0.4874166250228882, 0.19592595100402832, -0.036650240421295166, -0.7031039595603943, 1.7108724117279053, -0.07817517220973969, 0.21931086480617523, -0.3065122663974762, -0.4463701546192169, 0.11919877678155899, 0.8615750670433044, 0.14377738535404205, -0.5010733604431152, -1.5875786542892456, 0.30742067098617554, 0.3318605422973633, 0.3940401077270508, -0.9177945256233215, -0.6653819680213928, -0.0939008891582489, 0.7106016278266907, -0.2733665406703949, 0.49409088492393494, 0.846200168132782, 1.4339685440063477, 0.1730753779411316, 0.042098268866539, 0.047168001532554626, -0.5318162441253662, -0.1298234909772873, 0.03842196241021156, -0.12091632187366486, -0.833550751209259, 0.6462833881378174, -0.23807428777217865, 0.4178652763366699, 0.34280267357826233, 0.2752844989299774, -0.11867260187864304, -0.2166615128517151, 0.0786542147397995, -0.4576684236526489, 0.3898511230945587, -0.18922185897827148, -0.7700708508491516, -0.06382602453231812, -0.6973555684089661, 0.49143970012664795, -0.8984227180480957, -0.5558403730392456, -0.3458946645259857, 0.648169994354248, 0.5928765535354614, -0.8098360896110535, -0.12062342464923859, 0.3084200620651245, 0.3696831464767456, 0.1725369691848755, -1.1976470947265625, -0.0647902861237526, 1.3325334787368774, 0.03840478137135506, 0.005675243213772774, -0.11654438078403473, -0.09216761589050293, -0.5587427616119385, -0.46431902050971985, -0.16140154004096985, 0.5282847881317139, -0.3229038715362549, 0.18562465906143188, -0.6962496042251587, -0.6823661923408508, -0.4604191780090332, -0.594943642616272, -0.17063255608081818, 0.44900211691856384, -0.19477829337120056, 0.37606939673423767, -0.13678960502147675, -0.6831328868865967, -0.296902060508728, 0.36782941222190857, 0.3951173424720764, 0.429475337266922, -0.36005401611328125, 0.6380571722984314, -0.5817151069641113, 0.8897234797477722, 0.92503422498703, 1.2904536724090576, -0.06980016827583313, 0.7077531814575195, -0.18437226116657257, 0.21372252702713013, -0.2590438723564148, 1.0889387130737305, -0.6858125925064087, 0.7920953035354614, -0.6117777824401855, -0.012424040585756302, 0.22503769397735596, 0.3575085997581482, -0.2412235140800476, -0.9369932413101196, 0.38819265365600586, 0.4025731086730957, 0.30214932560920715, 0.166696235537529, 0.09521271288394928, 0.43060848116874695, -0.6797507405281067, -0.42229387164115906, -0.8352281451225281, -0.2747460901737213, 0.1463681012392044, -0.14190390706062317, 0.15034563839435577, 1.191872000694275, -0.1182687059044838, -0.6053658127784729, 0.166639044880867, 0.8900233507156372, -0.13769057393074036, -0.03956463932991028, 0.5364465117454529, -0.36438652873039246, -0.15189160406589508, 0.8634963035583496, 0.1623522788286209, -0.3051506578922272, -0.30981993675231934, 0.9419121146202087, -0.3907020390033722, -0.6360187530517578, 0.45449745655059814, -0.5220857858657837, 0.2328527271747589, 1.2957617044448853, -0.5232357382774353, 0.6499469876289368, 0.5528017282485962, 0.7105158567428589, -0.8042284250259399, 0.470983624458313, 0.04954828694462776, -0.3595491349697113, 0.5125886797904968, 0.08090834319591522, 0.2796178162097931, -0.11262387037277222, -0.5612221360206604, -0.009089556522667408, -0.10627739131450653, -0.12211768329143524, 0.6306153535842896, 0.1473836451768875, 0.2247965782880783, 1.509675145149231, 0.19956956803798676, 0.5067071318626404, -0.8866240978240967, -0.4946797490119934, 0.1559915989637375, -0.043317779898643494, -0.8573535084724426, 0.33812257647514343, -0.2590765058994293, 0.7672226428985596, 0.902880847454071, 0.31513017416000366, 0.0932604968547821, -0.1909976601600647, -0.07343117147684097, 0.8413040637969971, -0.05648198351264, -1.2334561347961426, 0.4350128471851349, 0.9692021608352661, -0.4827457368373871, -0.4576898217201233, 0.7572780847549438, -0.5712922215461731, 0.08804363757371902, -0.13742195069789886, -0.6615135073661804, 0.6860454082489014, -0.8454259037971497, 0.7223299741744995, -0.5152631998062134, 0.651783287525177, -1.2605407238006592, -0.3659137785434723, -0.4675932228565216, -0.11578163504600525, 0.3403330147266388, 0.16911634802818298, -0.9793203473091125, 0.5091673135757446, -0.7512715458869934, -0.021265927702188492, 0.3567543625831604, 0.4247606694698334, -0.2973578870296478, -0.04810623824596405, 0.2474062442779541, -0.7304819822311401, 0.2738001048564911, 0.4182274639606476, 0.35714125633239746, -0.20082218945026398, -0.8600314259529114, -0.36769625544548035, 0.5645445585250854, 0.08211188018321991, 0.9750048518180847, 0.3103179335594177, -0.5704758167266846, 1.4465452432632446, -0.08290216326713562, -0.41421443223953247, -0.19639019668102264, 0.8270150423049927, 0.09436231106519699, 0.4565504193305969, 0.1659669429063797, 0.22817489504814148, 0.5032941699028015, -0.2557264566421509, 0.8980700373649597, -0.5212835669517517, 0.9842110276222229, 1.013229250907898, 0.2534119486808777, 0.09265965223312378, -0.13213545083999634, 0.8242220282554626, 0.6530914306640625, 0.0288402009755373, -0.5895465016365051, 0.8898294568061829, 0.29622140526771545, -0.010950014926493168, -0.47897517681121826, 0.7573435306549072, -1.3970433473587036, 0.8470563888549805, -0.04631705954670906, 0.32102200388908386, -1.0521903038024902, 0.2447744458913803, -0.11103424429893494, 0.41403883695602417, 0.213138610124588, -0.29765406250953674, -0.39817696809768677, 0.3911605179309845, 0.28121471405029297, -1.16245698928833, 0.07199858874082565, 0.1086801216006279, -0.2464815080165863, -0.6865906119346619, 0.7785348296165466, -0.6958295702934265, -1.2013853788375854, -0.05549820140004158, -0.15577511489391327, -0.021418986842036247, -0.06419290602207184, -0.36104363203048706, -0.050950657576322556, -0.18255704641342163, 0.4017252027988434, -0.060505129396915436, -0.11945783346891403, 0.017230089753866196, -0.2766296863555908, -0.2840659022331238, -0.37230637669563293, 0.26786577701568604, -1.3054828643798828, -0.16149060428142548, -1.084504246711731, -0.3008360266685486, -0.588016927242279, -0.17999224364757538, 0.21986697614192963, 0.010610577650368214, 0.36358895897865295, 0.25411173701286316, -0.025159642100334167, -0.42592066526412964, -0.5235127806663513, -0.9547362923622131, 0.1046491414308548, -0.09102694690227509, -0.3735027611255646, 0.15732444822788239, -0.43764081597328186, 1.1677002906799316, 0.37566831707954407, 0.27451035380363464, 0.8096740245819092, -0.45185351371765137, 0.005165605805814266, -0.40082573890686035, 0.6215231418609619, 0.5826184749603271, -0.5549988150596619, 0.5832018256187439, 0.7828217148780823, 0.159293532371521, 0.35328593850135803, -0.29875636100769043, -0.3823367953300476, 0.03330807015299797, 0.6177493929862976, -1.2408357858657837, 0.211526557803154, 1.0288949012756348, 1.107564091682434, -0.7548776865005493, 0.6539549827575684, -0.5273025631904602, -0.4475247859954834, -0.02034544013440609, -0.3055693209171295, 0.7284258008003235, 0.2102057933807373, 0.8655912280082703, -0.5593467950820923, -0.5853527188301086, -1.1529576778411865, -0.06501802802085876, 0.6228079199790955, -0.6543087363243103, -0.3209216892719269, 0.4370404779911041, -0.180580273270607, -0.35106971859931946, 0.6604617834091187, -0.14880883693695068, -0.14125679433345795, 0.27742063999176025, -0.79635089635849, -0.24878491461277008, 1.2782262563705444, 0.012020248919725418, -0.10002928972244263, 0.0821981132030487, -0.25006383657455444, -0.11045863479375839, -1.0205600261688232, -0.5857388377189636, 0.08946996182203293, -0.0473649688065052, -0.21207989752292633, -0.5559507012367249, 0.1325686126947403, -0.6611148715019226, 0.23399974405765533, 0.23725832998752594, 0.5807549953460693, -0.8803895115852356, 0.13740897178649902, 0.9013974070549011, -0.6024826765060425, 0.21188795566558838, -0.08072858303785324, -0.01684989593923092, 0.667597770690918, -0.28311610221862793, 0.08864318579435349, -0.3951669931411743, 0.37640076875686646, -0.9758363962173462, 0.8277149796485901, 0.2402632087469101, 0.2563004493713379, 0.7377240061759949, -0.4316774606704712, -0.1461617350578308, -0.06394357234239578, -0.3237714171409607, -0.8441791534423828, -0.9671311378479004, -0.45884373784065247, -0.31084421277046204, -0.06060659885406494, 0.11973170191049576, 0.2806367576122284, 0.6283793449401855, 0.19224868714809418, -0.18982695043087006, 0.17025244235992432, 0.27991220355033875, -0.3465084731578827, 0.2652927041053772, -0.6794437170028687, 0.432070791721344, -0.684237539768219, 0.11727648973464966, 0.2773556411266327, -0.0999714657664299, 0.29915520548820496, -0.20022903382778168, 0.32800233364105225, -0.5724806189537048, 0.8769607543945312, 0.46115508675575256, -0.2613140046596527, 0.3611401915550232, 0.18721996247768402, -0.333356112241745, -0.32055458426475525, 0.17511121928691864, 0.7948846817016602, 1.1533514261245728, -0.18220357596874237, -0.6417933702468872, -0.31111010909080505, -0.4578765332698822, 0.5834326148033142, -0.013851853087544441, -0.5100316405296326, -0.5407623052597046, -0.20251941680908203, 0.19858181476593018, -0.014060876332223415, 0.696496844291687, 0.5748713612556458, 0.29272451996803284, 0.9100919365882874, 0.04413270205259323, 0.1665326952934265, 0.36852213740348816, 0.2424987554550171, -0.40466272830963135, 0.24289123713970184, -0.041641902178525925, 0.0385773591697216, 0.5961654186248779, -0.06437084823846817, -0.7215098142623901, -0.49070820212364197, -0.25049182772636414, -0.05216206610202789, -0.10640455782413483, -0.49758821725845337, 0.22407788038253784, 0.14339827001094818, -0.5616393685340881, 0.6288278102874756, -0.33951109647750854, 0.08179003745317459, 0.48148542642593384, -0.25586700439453125, -0.7258606553077698, -0.1340027004480362, 0.12084707617759705, -0.09748844057321548, 0.3964449167251587, 0.874933123588562, 0.3534280061721802, 0.2493913620710373, 0.29408928751945496, 0.012354821898043156, 0.10757887363433838, 0.5499649047851562, -1.0585113763809204, -0.2143176794052124, 0.3609364628791809, -0.6132871508598328, -0.7999924421310425, 0.05652505159378052, 0.8552067279815674, -0.3486435115337372, -0.24800360202789307, -0.214148610830307, -0.6091209650039673, -0.6240230798721313, -0.7000632882118225, -0.9491994976997375, 0.6596902012825012, -0.5450871586799622, -0.11539185047149658, 0.48046448826789856, -0.49647030234336853, -0.06400465965270996, 0.23471739888191223, 0.3228026330471039, -0.03622023016214371, -0.3298902213573456, 0.34882208704948425, 0.41226160526275635, 0.36162588000297546, -0.9386174082756042, 0.19715017080307007, -0.2870497703552246, -0.9370571970939636, -0.8641354441642761, -0.6061317324638367, 0.1252954602241516, 0.3341376781463623, -0.14305749535560608, -0.21237890422344208, -0.0011710181133821607, -0.2959320545196533, 0.02072787657380104, 0.43094581365585327, 0.3520558774471283, -0.6116384267807007, 0.08643107116222382, 0.8761544227600098, 0.38855382800102234, -0.7720365524291992, 0.0296698659658432, 0.5327518582344055, 0.07391117513179779, 0.42481809854507446, -0.41833174228668213, 0.11129365861415863, 0.7871066927909851, -1.5062661170959473, 0.17011983692646027, -0.7929329872131348, -0.1405383050441742, -0.4250936210155487, -0.5673660039901733, 0.548896074295044, 0.498605340719223, 0.18395963311195374, -0.6151936650276184, -0.3344402313232422, -0.27756398916244507, 0.749334454536438, -0.49004605412483215, -0.3195731043815613, -0.9227693676948547, -0.5740851163864136, -0.14284870028495789, 1.2122780084609985, -0.2709091007709503, 0.33084040880203247, 0.4094051420688629, -0.5477855801582336, -0.5754688382148743, 0.44909414649009705, -0.0735471174120903, -0.03631057217717171, -0.6319053173065186, 0.3785374164581299, 0.6805362105369568, 0.6227671504020691, -0.4162015914916992, -0.024513190612196922, -0.29074838757514954, 0.5256877541542053, -0.09450247138738632, -0.11524640023708344, 0.38102617859840393, -0.4767463505268097, 0.6506388187408447, -0.6564028263092041, -0.38851872086524963, 0.6334689259529114, -0.097249336540699, 0.6223573684692383, -0.1174626275897026, 0.005868669133633375, -0.06507410854101181, -0.6095794439315796, -0.7716821432113647, 0.9048225283622742, -0.025664489716291428, -0.4149690568447113, -0.7692772746086121, -0.3192335069179535, 0.21915248036384583, -0.24414223432540894, 0.43762218952178955, 0.3542450964450836, 0.6362059116363525, 0.6907219290733337, -0.13424386084079742, -0.40308907628059387, -0.14275388419628143, -0.052685871720314026, -0.3444790542125702, -0.17756287753582, -1.0501363277435303, -0.6794763207435608, 0.07673049718141556, -0.7453725934028625, -0.9084020853042603, 0.44595274329185486, 0.9536862969398499, -0.30902305245399475, 0.444706529378891, -0.27363115549087524, -0.15137805044651031, -0.4466742277145386, 0.04346093162894249, 0.22852657735347748, 0.048982683569192886, 1.2086069583892822, 0.5437567234039307, -0.4911227226257324, 0.8656709790229797, 0.8178876638412476, -0.8304396271705627, -0.5323110818862915, 0.6197993755340576, -0.4464472830295563, 0.020705685019493103, 0.2047421634197235, -0.5617973208427429, -0.1804661601781845, -1.1043086051940918, -1.2199980020523071, -0.5225049257278442, 0.7436919212341309, -0.4402030110359192, 0.2948518693447113, -0.44788065552711487, -0.4100761413574219, 0.7283729314804077, -0.14744235575199127, 0.4764713943004608, 0.21404018998146057, 0.20270097255706787, 0.023815790191292763, -0.27451086044311523, 0.08948143571615219, 0.9386672973632812, 0.1346699446439743, -0.6658675074577332, -0.17457696795463562, -0.2684907615184784, -0.01808474399149418, -0.5717600584030151, 0.619900107383728, -0.1369081288576126, 0.03972192481160164, -0.3418685793876648, 0.5561994910240173, 0.1908811330795288, -0.2469928115606308, -0.39005017280578613, 0.10041241347789764, -1.2827941179275513, -0.5528352856636047, 0.6586889624595642, 0.37259241938591003, 0.3853057324886322, 0.7823073863983154, -0.5422525405883789, 0.15276333689689636, -0.25520816445350647, -0.06956922262907028, -0.1049906387925148, -0.6837420463562012, -0.19342514872550964, -1.1012073755264282, -0.880618691444397, -1.2871214151382446, -0.4144207537174225, -0.1584208607673645, -0.40599173307418823, -0.7492449879646301, 0.6655438542366028, -0.3925614655017853, -0.32293689250946045, 0.5191576480865479, 0.8159220814704895, -0.03738563135266304, -0.5631186962127686, -0.8980505466461182, 0.33519428968429565, 0.01680750399827957, -1.2720469236373901, 0.04427626356482506, -0.673800528049469, 0.0026738112792372704, 1.0175410509109497, -0.32767432928085327, 0.7726885080337524, -0.08768629282712936, -0.8295513391494751, 0.6073777675628662, -0.2926933765411377, -0.6021670699119568, 0.5103501677513123, -0.14554640650749207, 0.7783547043800354, 0.5127492547035217, -0.33355513215065, 0.0918441116809845, 0.29067468643188477, -0.8816373944282532, 0.6281560659408569, 0.018308047205209732, -0.022453470155596733, -0.1684538871049881, -1.3716132640838623, 0.3288235366344452, 0.5772953033447266, -0.7634605169296265, -0.15776512026786804, -0.787824273109436, 0.661898136138916, -0.3165084719657898, -0.017348678782582283, -0.133894145488739, 0.5498631596565247, -0.5815781354904175, -0.19298754632472992, -0.39978328347206116, 0.2841290533542633, -0.44915035367012024, 0.3356415033340454, 0.06589358299970627, -0.3466128408908844, 0.1864715963602066, 0.22076289355754852, 0.5707879066467285, -0.2584038972854614, -0.28240203857421875, 0.2750110328197479, 0.3623044490814209, -0.6240440011024475, -0.10149215161800385, 0.234098881483078, -0.5933656692504883, 0.728182315826416, -0.10528887063264847, 0.2149478793144226, 0.41217559576034546, -0.5027825236320496, -1.7877328395843506, -0.08909610658884048, -0.09368840605020523, -0.29342445731163025, -0.1724998950958252, -0.4023796021938324, 0.3320996165275574, 0.6092012524604797, -0.8042911887168884, 0.21534568071365356, -0.3421865403652191, 1.345263957977295, 0.5367197394371033, -0.41552966833114624, -0.26950234174728394, 0.2566116750240326, -0.6294195652008057, -0.19112403690814972, -0.5025700926780701, 0.43248432874679565, -0.32829156517982483, -0.584915816783905, -0.5284165740013123, 0.24405375123023987, -0.251099169254303, 0.07419759780168533, 0.4138050973415375, -0.9202134013175964, -0.24636349081993103, -0.09866752475500107, -0.9172285795211792, -0.23587453365325928, -1.0494040250778198, 0.15250544250011444, 0.6473973393440247, -0.40555310249328613, 0.20400817692279816, 0.4077260494232178, 0.711808979511261, 0.2831997275352478, -0.1906900703907013, 0.8072015643119812, -0.19709433615207672, -0.31131166219711304, 0.01750512793660164, 0.5515083074569702, 0.46518877148628235, 0.13369768857955933, -0.405884712934494, 0.27965497970581055, 0.5275231003761292, 0.1843317449092865, 0.557977020740509, 0.06918623298406601, -0.046594154089689255, 0.44091343879699707, 0.3728742003440857, 0.07729700207710266, 0.10353440046310425, -0.011676738038659096, 0.1843222677707672, 0.40024352073669434, -0.14002388715744019, -0.6003700494766235, -0.14782355725765228, 0.5822884440422058, 0.4604250192642212, -0.017542950809001923, -0.058393411338329315, -0.3520664572715759, 0.30309823155403137, 0.650253176689148, -0.7765779495239258, -0.6718853712081909, -0.44764444231987, 0.3203619718551636, 0.6615872979164124, 0.26640939712524414, -0.29517826437950134, 0.36561402678489685, 0.08353050798177719, -0.034572020173072815, -1.0844000577926636, 0.4166656732559204, 0.36121129989624023, 0.6561707854270935, 0.7484045028686523, 0.6378877758979797, 0.24543875455856323, 0.5089709758758545, -0.030917637050151825, -1.402808666229248, -0.03252280130982399, 0.6401848196983337, -0.7052572965621948, 0.15598370134830475, -0.12022023648023605, -0.6228217482566833, 0.05233624204993248, -0.37871840596199036, -0.14206527173519135, -0.001807876513339579, 0.41917213797569275, 0.09635978937149048, -0.41379305720329285, 0.28856512904167175, 0.38186609745025635, 0.1631893366575241, 0.42647573351860046, 0.5706581473350525, 0.4244779944419861, 0.4434209167957306, 0.22161099314689636, 0.6443144083023071, 0.47414717078208923, 0.28325486183166504, -0.6783646941184998, -0.10508343577384949, 0.5767902731895447, 0.06597398221492767, 0.04752287641167641, 0.0881265178322792, -0.5589104890823364, 0.3814282715320587, -0.21707555651664734, 0.013946828432381153, 0.13683322072029114, 0.03652198612689972, 0.8614116907119751, 0.52351975440979, -0.27284833788871765, 0.1835930049419403, 0.46166783571243286, -0.01243059802800417, -0.5762938857078552, -0.2516404092311859, 0.3553682565689087, -0.7629472017288208, 0.5420480370521545, -1.3192795515060425, 0.35711780190467834, 0.8517416715621948, -0.611640989780426, -0.3938538730144501, -0.6841674447059631, -0.059818148612976074, -0.764873743057251, -0.45229536294937134, -0.11256252229213715, 0.46158742904663086, 1.2135372161865234, 0.01980987936258316, 0.45510315895080566, -0.3913537859916687, -0.46645277738571167, -0.31352686882019043, 0.8107002973556519, -0.2781532406806946, 0.11981604993343353, 0.542434573173523, 0.07725510001182556, -0.5770057439804077, 0.2646248936653137, 0.6767457127571106, -0.31796127557754517, 0.6199905872344971, 0.08234471827745438, 0.39356786012649536, 0.3953361213207245, -0.25735586881637573, 0.5640292167663574, 0.3325745165348053, 0.5990503430366516, 0.3544992208480835, -0.21095703542232513, -0.11064781248569489, -0.865403950214386, 0.04703780636191368, -0.8125750422477722, 0.43566152453422546, 0.23160743713378906, -0.4062940180301666, 0.2729695439338684, -0.627002477645874, 4.027046203613281, 0.8407482504844666, 0.772318422794342, 0.33543387055397034, 0.532551646232605, 0.6245114207267761, -0.25060516595840454, -0.31629592180252075, 0.4360429048538208, -0.508828341960907, 0.6393164992332458, 0.18692250549793243, 0.5352008938789368, 0.19107170403003693, -0.01149600651115179, 0.21176742017269135, -0.14931796491146088, 0.4221245348453522, -0.1967124044895172, -0.43747907876968384, -0.8550922870635986, 0.20726431906223297, 0.14327986538410187, -0.5722169280052185, 0.37147679924964905, -0.10770118236541748, -0.0894530713558197, -0.967915415763855, -0.4150370657444, -0.2638969421386719, -0.5885866284370422, -0.5217732787132263, -0.05344294384121895, -0.2955249845981598, -1.129302740097046, 0.8046826720237732, 0.13380901515483856, -0.7651732563972473, 0.21512331068515778, 0.02276940457522869, -0.5519425868988037, -0.07518412917852402, 0.7558119297027588, -0.8150709271430969, 0.04609766975045204, 0.7361304759979248, 0.717422604560852, 0.07183703035116196, 0.6864708065986633, -0.3555196225643158, 0.06470508873462677, 0.17863678932189941, 0.01877979002892971, -0.1917850375175476, -0.9429479837417603, -0.4304317831993103, -0.5254207253456116, -0.27979832887649536, 0.21209371089935303, -0.0015439107082784176, 0.5338734984397888, -0.04363526403903961, -0.33927759528160095, -0.14696428179740906, 0.2761787474155426, 0.7353284358978271, 0.39876556396484375, -0.0310676209628582, 0.3894743025302887, -0.4295238256454468, -0.3923830986022949, 0.1707204133272171, -0.3630501627922058, -0.2863066792488098, 0.059409867972135544, 0.7702111005783081, 0.11466570943593979, 0.5516573190689087, -0.569577693939209, 0.8214266300201416, -0.3972931206226349, -0.07449040561914444, -0.9379842877388, 0.35098496079444885, 0.01204630546271801, 0.38854271173477173, 0.1923130750656128, 0.21132837235927582, -0.5243299603462219, 0.4206787347793579, -0.033740438520908356, 0.910687267780304, -0.3565436601638794, -0.21186797320842743, -0.2742651700973511 ]
Cosmic Censorship in 2-Dimensional Dilaton Gravity
The global structure of 2-dimensional dilaton gravity is studied, attending in particular to black holes and singularities. A gravitational energy is defined and shown to be positive at spatial singularities and negative at temporal singularities. Trapped points are defined, and it is shown that spatial singularities are trapped and temporal singularities are not. Thus a local form of cosmic censorship holds for positive energy. In an analogue of gravitational collapse to a black hole, matter falling into an initially flat space creates a spatial curvature singularity which is cloaked in a spatial or null apparent horizon with non-decreasing energy and area.
Sean A. Hayward
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212001
gr-qc/9212002
[ 0.4527622163295746, 0.5689374804496765, 0.5245089530944824, -0.009593217633664608, 0.001042693853378296, 0.6276453733444214, 0.28170478343963623, -0.2169683277606964, 0.36134955286979675, 1.0292010307312012, 0.26886114478111267, -0.33320581912994385, 0.1778964102268219, -0.9099377393722534, 0.36757874488830566, 0.7259179353713989, 0.045666150748729706, -0.785740077495575, -0.7856975793838501, 0.4794926047325134, 0.8609169721603394, 0.2998976707458496, -0.7799043655395508, -0.7145338654518127, -0.6252726912498474, 0.28964439034461975, 1.3476581573486328, 0.2816236615180969, 1.3037679195404053, 1.2287192344665527, 0.4044587016105652, 0.010213210247457027, -0.1845090389251709, -0.5169671773910522, -0.3510681688785553, 0.20944376289844513, -0.10353264212608337, -0.9785568118095398, 1.315437912940979, -0.9096413850784302, 0.8327074646949768, 0.3338111340999603, -0.46506088972091675, -0.5405874848365784, -0.6475324034690857, 0.38636115193367004, 0.807951033115387, 0.06304106116294861, -0.00804630946367979, -0.9154775738716125, -0.018297849223017693, -0.6231873035430908, 0.15556815266609192, -0.9712220430374146, 0.3055605888366699, -0.21906529366970062, 0.14244027435779572, -0.013092510402202606, -0.42743629217147827, 0.7118237614631653, 0.2194884717464447, 0.227382630109787, 0.183384969830513, -1.062496304512024, -0.009512941353023052, 1.0368465185165405, -0.08690541237592697, 0.7442046403884888, -0.3183979392051697, -0.4036664664745331, 0.02179289609193802, 0.14618122577667236, -0.6651584506034851, 0.6352016925811768, -0.5190357565879822, 0.8101744651794434, -0.43578118085861206, -0.41932907700538635, -0.25211024284362793, -0.551332414150238, -0.09917576611042023, 0.08477894961833954, 0.04215744510293007, 0.6348563432693481, -0.48583704233169556, 0.0625992938876152, 0.38316306471824646, -0.10321290791034698, 0.2938680052757263, -0.04136085510253906, -0.45312556624412537, 0.29741665720939636, -0.49731191992759705, 0.36597171425819397, 0.26225435733795166, 0.6313093304634094, -0.33458980917930603, 0.7815118432044983, 0.2050807923078537, 0.24470657110214233, -0.45248040556907654, 1.4155871868133545, -1.006938099861145, -0.16236191987991333, -1.0935138463974, 1.3295155763626099, -0.5531584620475769, 0.15036293864250183, 0.056223541498184204, -0.8976910710334778, 0.08016559481620789, 0.3607684373855591, 0.5879495143890381, -0.2558189034461975, -0.0008112272480502725, 0.11135149002075195, -0.4967460334300995, -0.054209645837545395, -0.5211263298988342, -0.8372073769569397, 0.32310566306114197, 1.018600583076477, 0.4278228282928467, 1.1528862714767456, -0.5008742809295654, 0.18516720831394196, 0.4848175048828125, -0.1866375207901001, -0.8266084790229797, 0.1992179900407791, 0.2376742660999298, -0.7012938261032104, 0.08892134577035904, 0.27983006834983826, -0.20520848035812378, -0.13889531791210175, 0.3768194615840912, -0.1024080440402031, 0.5649151802062988, -0.33920818567276, -0.19476883113384247, 0.19017234444618225, -0.004802813287824392, 1.122704029083252, -0.5141373872756958, 0.3023786246776581, -0.3787843585014343, -0.004646493587642908, -0.9851265549659729, 0.06752239912748337, 0.0999026820063591, 0.39720213413238525, -0.15192672610282898, 0.3003024160861969, -0.336226224899292, -0.29430198669433594, -0.8000223636627197, 0.023554028943181038, 0.3728893995285034, -0.34221863746643066, -0.2600998878479004, -0.15707841515541077, 0.668489396572113, 1.3907806873321533, -0.3132127821445465, 0.3485703468322754, -0.8263399600982666, -0.3666003346443176, 0.0033306675031781197, 0.8366881012916565, -0.9118347764015198, 0.5841280817985535, 0.1349927932024002, 0.9178235530853271, 1.2018247842788696, 0.8217368125915527, -0.15966425836086273, -0.39896494150161743, -0.79958176612854, 0.5923730731010437, -0.20654065907001495, -0.49753138422966003, 0.4342670142650604, 0.6336782574653625, -0.44679534435272217, 0.02910776250064373, 0.3198724091053009, -0.2172611802816391, 0.2628018260002136, -0.20922894775867462, -0.9578371047973633, 0.21243715286254883, -1.3246077299118042, 1.3887745141983032, -0.5286865830421448, 0.2986660301685333, -0.8147969841957092, -0.6164026856422424, -0.30858510732650757, -0.14521120488643646, -0.192374125123024, 0.26966503262519836, -0.8612508773803711, 0.18067283928394318, -1.159557580947876, 0.1452457457780838, 0.1177559569478035, 0.6210695505142212, -0.8877593278884888, 0.2550557255744934, 0.8970361351966858, -0.5084581971168518, 0.057628288865089417, -0.2217717170715332, -0.04341152310371399, 0.7391200661659241, -0.12360956519842148, 0.2484467625617981, -0.007222098298370838, 0.5172739624977112, 0.5017971396446228, 0.3801409602165222, -0.16730336844921112, 0.8056950569152832, 0.5845487117767334, -0.35072433948516846, 0.15627706050872803, 1.3298500776290894, -0.4912162125110626, 0.0322001688182354, 0.36904066801071167, -0.1463671326637268, 0.8045766949653625, 0.5818819403648376, 0.40829890966415405, 0.14892232418060303, 0.9884063601493835, 0.3362012803554535, 0.4213380217552185, 0.4754159152507782, 0.34287214279174805, 0.1190045177936554, 0.9985560178756714, -0.34945836663246155, -0.41975992918014526, 1.3080443143844604, 0.7554651498794556, 0.10022983700037003, -0.2555355131626129, 0.5085585713386536, -0.5799432992935181, 0.4289804995059967, 0.44488322734832764, 0.3566191494464874, -1.2887957096099854, 0.40628939867019653, 0.39452624320983887, 0.42887502908706665, -0.07434126734733582, -0.5237026810646057, -0.44663265347480774, 0.006090473849326372, -0.7514477372169495, -0.5166264176368713, -0.32953718304634094, 0.3460544943809509, -0.5931728482246399, -0.21965506672859192, 0.9576415419578552, -0.4018871784210205, -1.0010608434677124, -0.37930718064308167, -0.04856191202998161, -0.3882635533809662, -0.44437843561172485, -0.05721810832619667, 0.35220620036125183, -0.10641883313655853, 1.0237207412719727, 0.4593563377857208, -0.6119431257247925, 0.3593120574951172, -0.24355201423168182, 0.3538834750652313, -0.045382265001535416, 0.6994853615760803, -1.0070842504501343, 0.33306071162223816, -1.290244460105896, 0.07199215888977051, 0.5683310031890869, -0.5035117864608765, 0.779551088809967, -0.14986594021320343, 1.020482063293457, 0.3588308095932007, -0.8056689500808716, -0.6056460738182068, -0.6639161109924316, -1.4183787107467651, 0.7375766038894653, 0.2596065104007721, -0.1624026894569397, 0.17100004851818085, -0.17746375501155853, 0.4735158383846283, -0.07197517901659012, -0.7094005942344666, 0.501975417137146, -0.16814948618412018, -0.38298165798187256, 0.7135957479476929, 0.5035282969474792, 1.0227359533309937, -0.42245185375213623, -0.11944980919361115, 0.4596389830112457, 0.03374219313263893, 0.057014092803001404, -0.11894148588180542, -0.5881767868995667, -0.05864505469799042, 0.48756951093673706, -0.41094401478767395, 0.15794795751571655, 0.8115069270133972, 0.3896321654319763, -0.6462463140487671, 0.4875285029411316, -0.9645115733146667, -0.8256238698959351, -0.7555987238883972, -0.2709714472293854, -0.4533880949020386, -0.5928559899330139, 0.26162996888160706, -0.9585719704627991, 0.058217719197273254, -0.10880031436681747, 0.11414274573326111, 0.5352222323417664, -0.35642009973526, 0.11610119789838791, 0.4200754463672638, -0.32257533073425293, -0.03452107682824135, 0.49130555987358093, -1.2709795236587524, 0.10533478111028671, 0.7857693433761597, -0.5112940073013306, 0.08169644325971603, 0.2475155144929886, 0.07823533564805984, 0.052708256989717484, 0.39547523856163025, -0.003981015644967556, -0.1373680830001831, -0.672056257724762, -0.427704781293869, 0.4151529371738434, 1.0360393524169922, 0.6994036436080933, -1.0555775165557861, -0.3726564645767212, -0.20400165021419525, -0.29875248670578003, -0.023989444598555565, 0.7917500138282776, -0.8809382915496826, 0.3632252514362335, 0.2093091458082199, -0.7953577637672424, -0.18800382316112518, -0.4140986204147339, -0.15347787737846375, 0.588355302810669, 0.5274699926376343, 0.7947031259536743, 0.06005200743675232, -0.18404455482959747, -0.32966160774230957, -0.19244065880775452, -0.2880462110042572, 0.5177217125892639, 0.04727731645107269, -0.3660435676574707, 0.09124623984098434, -0.8577170372009277, -0.8955138325691223, -0.32965120673179626, -0.8507078289985657, 0.1634635180234909, -0.10021166503429413, -0.14037275314331055, 0.11403664201498032, 0.43775004148483276, 0.5444478392601013, 0.4032934606075287, -0.11814124137163162, -0.17519916594028473, 0.12954559922218323, -0.28277266025543213, -0.2325945496559143, -1.0682015419006348, 0.34182921051979065, -0.1406872421503067, 0.5111212730407715, 0.8813045620918274, -0.5765003561973572, 0.2587028443813324, -0.5451508164405823, -0.3185044527053833, 0.3149690330028534, 0.5076454281806946, -0.578309953212738, -0.3162645697593689, 0.1769758015871048, -0.06365553289651871, -0.02271978370845318, -0.38299107551574707, 0.12758032977581024, 0.7040089964866638, 0.2891525328159332, 1.0425305366516113, -0.06398624926805496, 0.12521393597126007, -0.9405365586280823, -0.005452377256006002, 0.7195557355880737, 0.27336955070495605, -0.8834602236747742, -0.3731447458267212, -0.1903597116470337, 0.1154298335313797, 0.5572847723960876, 1.4105489253997803, 0.28014999628067017, 0.5843377709388733, -0.7639263272285461, 0.17640823125839233, 1.2906497716903687, -0.004352187737822533, 0.7106682658195496, 0.3188335597515106, -0.23807814717292786, -0.15736322104930878, 0.4416883587837219, 0.09644243121147156, -0.8742825984954834, -0.39139875769615173, -0.1559315174818039, 0.7354070544242859, -1.025395154953003, -0.6396162509918213, 0.06256270408630371, -0.28998297452926636, -0.49461060762405396, 1.0033351182937622, -0.7292949557304382, 0.4459298849105835, 0.4100288450717926, 0.359009712934494, -0.45363470911979675, 0.7518256902694702, 0.39950183033943176, -0.45088955760002136, 0.33642569184303284, 0.764484703540802, 0.13706408441066742, 0.17422544956207275, -0.29647618532180786, -0.24673761427402496, -0.35748204588890076, 1.2292602062225342, -0.4903615117073059, -0.2801923453807831, 0.35614049434661865, -0.8840230703353882, -0.30618032813072205, -0.31644773483276367, 0.2260345220565796, -0.28066349029541016, -0.22353586554527283, 0.3243063688278198, -0.9396424889564514, -1.4558595418930054, -1.0636427402496338, -0.9786432385444641, 0.5435250997543335, 0.04715293273329735, 0.2444227933883667, -0.4818412959575653, -0.22905708849430084, -0.33803221583366394, 0.3157053589820862, -0.26841601729393005, -0.2962689995765686, 0.10692216455936432, 0.5521404147148132, 0.28325143456459045, 0.2645534873008728, -1.0308837890625, 0.6047171354293823, -0.5471572279930115, -0.07775451242923737, -0.5462071895599365, -1.1683515310287476, -0.3203575313091278, -0.1380539983510971, -0.5360555648803711, 0.016970913857221603, 0.6907685399055481, 0.45558029413223267, 0.2825530171394348, -0.35207611322402954, 0.18324397504329681, -0.7416278123855591, -0.7170423865318298, 0.9004030227661133, 0.5668402910232544, -0.340220183134079, -0.5405053496360779, 0.6719720959663391, 0.5800319910049438, -0.31928253173828125, 0.15529130399227142, -0.1928849071264267, 0.026850219815969467, -1.6354202032089233, 0.4438835680484772, -1.082878828048706, -0.18698987364768982, -0.42870086431503296, -0.8807322382926941, -0.05436559394001961, 0.12658624351024628, 0.3096357583999634, -0.5145602226257324, -0.17478205263614655, -0.39092913269996643, 0.36248788237571716, -0.31503114104270935, 0.42515629529953003, -1.0833691358566284, 0.11989910900592804, -1.0651674270629883, 1.3934205770492554, -0.25557881593704224, -0.1101648211479187, 0.7691224813461304, 0.5239078998565674, 0.4852461516857147, 0.026551319286227226, 0.045067910104990005, -0.2379249930381775, -0.5331243276596069, -0.48176005482673645, 0.3835437595844269, 0.6349133253097534, 0.5674859285354614, 0.5187387466430664, -0.4005812406539917, 0.3834567368030548, -0.03552548214793205, 0.30536288022994995, -0.4152488112449646, -0.8122888803482056, 0.394832581281662, -0.607654869556427, -0.056285493075847626, 0.9558170437812805, -0.011338893324136734, 0.737892746925354, 0.035756222903728485, -0.7837819457054138, 0.17055130004882812, 0.09273620694875717, -0.42893609404563904, 0.4237513840198517, -0.017617223784327507, -0.44147664308547974, -0.5675650238990784, -0.301881343126297, -0.3391996920108795, 0.09299232810735703, -0.2972579598426819, 0.7768027186393738, 0.20921458303928375, 0.44774073362350464, 0.051394667476415634, 0.16267988085746765, -0.1507510393857956, 0.16358502209186554, 0.16138790547847748, -0.08665969222784042, 0.4650631844997406, -0.5277273058891296, -0.16693979501724243, -1.3371089696884155, -0.3049338459968567, 0.5903631448745728, 0.43855416774749756, -0.1219748705625534, 1.0239934921264648, -0.015604292973876, -0.23425546288490295, -0.4476463794708252, 0.4298046827316284, -0.11678149551153183, 0.02264641970396042, 0.6801198720932007, 0.503585696220398, 0.19980740547180176, -0.3050825893878937, -0.022526193410158157, -0.8679274320602417, -0.10406120866537094, 0.9679849147796631, -0.5385794043540955, -0.24869994819164276, 0.7484945058822632, 0.5595306754112244, -0.6011233925819397, -0.04131372645497322, -0.42179498076438904, 0.1917436122894287, -0.27050143480300903, -0.5719269514083862, 0.04666503891348839, -0.28216132521629333, -0.1165573000907898, -0.025768913328647614, 0.30770426988601685, -0.625639021396637, 0.16905026137828827, 0.037704963237047195, 0.14834004640579224, -0.36870574951171875, -0.4236101508140564, 1.0708471536636353, 0.5816372632980347, -0.0015482977032661438, 0.2152164876461029, -0.07941121608018875, 0.22929567098617554, -0.5099664330482483, 0.8337622880935669, -0.9436787962913513, -0.1971169263124466, 0.29274478554725647, 0.2231835126876831, -0.057396288961172104, -0.22574277222156525, 0.27712282538414, 0.16299599409103394, -0.5818843841552734, -0.16786962747573853, -0.019048217684030533, 0.10815761238336563, 0.663747251033783, 0.5194732546806335, -0.13156184554100037, -0.014308333396911621, -0.12354343384504318, 0.4948415756225586, 0.16090232133865356, -0.2632924020290375, -0.3990277647972107, -0.9380883574485779, -0.7578200101852417, -0.9319760203361511, -0.17268133163452148, -0.008192077279090881, 0.7518057227134705, -0.0442376546561718, 0.2536056339740753, 0.3297675549983978, 0.2193269580602646, 0.16977015137672424, 0.9280141592025757, -0.49144622683525085, -0.880644679069519, -0.42835789918899536, -0.4677503705024719, -0.5465276837348938, -0.6419717073440552, -0.058524370193481445, -0.12023656815290451, 0.3061458468437195, 1.5846779346466064, -0.24058973789215088, 0.5606178045272827, -0.5751143097877502, -0.7641868591308594, 1.1003215312957764, -0.42622995376586914, -0.4534524083137512, 0.8065664768218994, -0.030804816633462906, 1.4235373735427856, 0.4058806896209717, -0.09032975137233734, -0.006277046166360378, -0.3608781099319458, -1.5444042682647705, 0.503329873085022, -0.019106954336166382, 0.8542112708091736, -0.6171481013298035, -0.9032298922538757, -0.23627154529094696, 0.6878983974456787, -0.843998908996582, 0.3537065386772156, 0.4576752185821533, 0.6938790678977966, -0.9896113276481628, 0.632669985294342, -0.052482958883047104, -0.0879531055688858, 0.011381386779248714, 0.3340003490447998, -0.8219527006149292, 0.25910666584968567, 0.3458523452281952, 0.12237366288900375, -0.2588924467563629, -0.7666578888893127, 0.06826500594615936, -0.6082226634025574, -0.04878862947225571, 0.1443602442741394, 0.15599606931209564, 0.20780611038208008, -0.24848656356334686, 0.08871684968471527, -0.46296748518943787, 0.20860852301120758, -0.4531606435775757, 0.7014123797416687, 0.13580407202243805, 0.6259028315544128, 0.45301520824432373, -0.11991068720817566, -0.3934800326824188, -0.28692030906677246, -0.7440170049667358, -0.5661192536354065, -0.030545657500624657, 0.6059114933013916, 0.09859350323677063, 0.6877934336662292, -0.5874398946762085, 0.3635307252407074, 0.44515809416770935, 0.8777139782905579, 0.12592150270938873, -0.016595222055912018, -0.7035377621650696, 0.4738694727420807, -1.0038714408874512, -0.8505134582519531, -0.5021832585334778, 0.28648558259010315, -1.4227828979492188, -1.1814038753509521, 0.08047255128622055, 0.05968226119875908, -0.0935656949877739, -0.023696713149547577, 0.9048704504966736, 0.3355453610420227, -0.23372171819210052, -0.4128689765930176, -0.5167983770370483, -0.3249991536140442, -0.9878964424133301, 0.5536819100379944, 0.1526113897562027, -0.23421265184879303, -0.4218696653842926, 0.6791713833808899, 0.6703365445137024, 0.2605247497558594, -0.10804252326488495, 0.8766417503356934, 0.3039131760597229, -0.4824592173099518, 0.11586901545524597, 0.6958835124969482, 0.22030997276306152, 0.7730310559272766, -0.46354594826698303, 0.37129420042037964, 0.6782767176628113, -0.6419952511787415, 0.05879836529493332, -0.2744581699371338, -0.37561357021331787, 0.27794450521469116, -0.4480694532394409, -0.2900010943412781, 0.08941725641489029, -0.739477813243866, 0.7077805995941162, 0.3589625358581543, 0.21173904836177826, -0.9074387550354004, -0.20201988518238068, -0.1060287281870842, 0.5347736477851868, -0.7396537065505981, -0.42781227827072144, -0.6039160490036011, 0.3584180176258087, 0.31587108969688416, -0.6764870882034302, -0.2888506054878235, -0.11188791692256927, -0.01305672712624073, 0.22365714609622955, -0.3460904061794281, -0.6318590641021729, 0.3808366656303406, 0.5959071516990662, 0.19569015502929688, 0.11952529847621918, 0.24313926696777344, -0.05651019141077995, 0.8552267551422119, 0.6176155805587769, -0.25774499773979187, -0.17210641503334045, 0.38682425022125244, 0.06572024524211884, -0.8255789875984192, -0.29043787717819214, -0.7289958596229553, -0.8958444595336914, -0.2529653012752533, 0.6344975829124451, 0.03196108341217041, -0.386480450630188, -0.16426050662994385, 0.2162380814552307, 0.039058685302734375, 0.8471174240112305, -0.08291702717542648, -0.49267035722732544, -0.4428943991661072, 0.40839043259620667, -0.41091153025627136, 0.6242960095405579, -0.08536148071289062, 0.0180752482265234, 1.002713918685913, 0.8187422156333923, 0.7984808683395386, 0.47951245307922363, -0.1158405989408493, -0.12418472021818161, -0.4792293608188629, 0.5010650753974915, 0.4539527893066406, -0.07921824604272842, 1.0245966911315918, -0.5427747368812561, -0.02738037519156933, 0.3538941442966461, -0.09977982193231583, 0.24764077365398407, -0.4911007583141327, 0.4678477644920349, 1.039884090423584, -0.4723988175392151, 0.3606092631816864, 0.5963056683540344, 0.4145958125591278, 0.35737815499305725, -0.26162025332450867, 0.3345435559749603, -1.0031508207321167, 0.6055670976638794, -1.9601786136627197, 0.5158256888389587, -0.08758021146059036, 0.08778547495603561, -0.9380313158035278, -0.37361955642700195, 0.01999608799815178, -0.905884861946106, -0.0013733482919633389, -0.470744252204895, 0.024279022589325905, 0.9251675605773926, -0.47336697578430176, 0.7985771298408508, -0.3345036506652832, -0.7322380542755127, -0.16052624583244324, 1.0139697790145874, 0.19529470801353455, 0.47485750913619995, 0.6444315314292908, 0.6836022734642029, -1.3840889930725098, 0.2901080846786499, 0.5663846135139465, -0.5170227289199829, 0.8445740938186646, 0.05748530104756355, 0.2233286201953888, 0.26712146401405334, -0.6766368746757507, -0.3258745074272156, 0.6815348863601685, -0.2769272029399872, 0.746090829372406, 0.3653687536716461, 0.015361091122031212, -0.7634694576263428, -0.8783265948295593, -0.8970837593078613, 0.059100549668073654, 0.5166111588478088, -0.44119909405708313, -0.10305014997720718, -0.6648305654525757, 3.7366302013397217, 0.20684148371219635, 0.5241368412971497, -0.4579387903213501, 0.6005840301513672, 0.7199065089225769, -0.3116261065006256, 0.40017038583755493, 0.2800882160663605, -1.1883571147918701, 0.48356661200523376, 0.2138267457485199, 0.660024881362915, -0.19013527035713196, 0.771977424621582, 0.7646724581718445, -0.73246830701828, 0.24619044363498688, -0.2229590117931366, -0.5276353359222412, -1.5026758909225464, -0.42308178544044495, 0.3362589180469513, 0.45291709899902344, 0.0028948632534593344, 0.7055515646934509, -0.3123358190059662, -0.2969282567501068, -0.9702416062355042, -0.5953320264816284, -0.21453537046909332, -0.8265633583068848, 0.10903262346982956, -0.19981373846530914, -0.9598701596260071, -0.2806457579135895, -0.3849104046821594, -0.3542248606681824, 0.5450365543365479, 0.3738005459308624, -0.6342824101448059, -0.47794702649116516, 0.6031255722045898, -0.46567147970199585, 0.5163078904151917, 1.3963792324066162, 0.3837989568710327, 0.770881712436676, 0.2835136651992798, -0.6331388354301453, 0.2549421787261963, 0.14805454015731812, 0.8823730945587158, -0.48675376176834106, -1.22081458568573, -0.3282835781574249, -0.7002539038658142, -0.5957450866699219, 0.8638001680374146, -0.7014248371124268, 0.8382328748703003, -0.36469709873199463, -0.37397992610931396, 0.07494170218706131, -0.06156589463353157, 0.5854495763778687, 0.6480770707130432, -0.17970271408557892, -0.48952314257621765, -0.2620895802974701, -0.8311180472373962, 0.05245806649327278, -0.773489773273468, 0.024584684520959854, 0.21693311631679535, -0.038084615021944046, -0.23233643174171448, 0.4577217102050781, -0.18212105333805084, 0.6426827311515808, -0.9096181392669678, -0.34086161851882935, -0.10519415140151978, -0.16032005846500397, 0.23678787052631378, 1.2021191120147705, -0.6861087679862976, 0.1399943083524704, -0.7876519560813904, 0.5951990485191345, -0.36571070551872253, 0.3790780007839203, -0.44940510392189026, 0.3391391336917877, -0.7729526162147522 ]
Galilean Theories of Gravitation
A generalization of Newtonian gravitation theory is obtained by a suitable limiting procedure from the ADM action of general relativity coupled to a mass-point. Three particular theories are discussed and it is found that two of them are invariant under an extended Galilei gauge group.
R. De Pietri, L. Lusanna, M. Pauri
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212002
gr-qc/9212003
[ -0.34430834650993347, 0.16341182589530945, -0.16144528985023499, -0.02243228256702423, 0.486994206905365, 0.3904713988304138, -0.06539377570152283, -0.21368654072284698, -0.4274703562259674, 1.582739233970642, 0.43143990635871887, -0.023349612951278687, 0.11422567069530487, -0.6379448175430298, -0.031267277896404266, 0.8782805800437927, -0.28640997409820557, -0.4777887761592865, -1.178138017654419, -0.11421405524015427, 0.46527132391929626, 0.21006077527999878, -0.6980764269828796, -0.7937533259391785, -0.4251146912574768, 0.21626482903957367, 0.5934532284736633, -0.19569352269172668, 0.8894198536872864, 1.360980749130249, 0.7838033437728882, -0.117918960750103, -0.30108633637428284, -0.7718260884284973, -0.4999941289424896, -0.3061756193637848, -0.4139679968357086, -0.44663310050964355, 0.6009691953659058, -0.7576857805252075, 0.8095149993896484, -0.47659987211227417, -0.1203838437795639, -0.23899661004543304, -0.4352843463420868, 0.023979512974619865, 0.22968296706676483, -0.09741546958684921, -0.27659153938293457, -1.5048023462295532, -0.23045380413532257, 0.024861710146069527, 0.5631512403488159, -0.42847707867622375, -0.6665475368499756, -0.009185269474983215, 0.45334938168525696, 0.026080498471856117, 0.104433573782444, -0.17467345297336578, 0.314777672290802, 0.20542879402637482, -0.40455958247184753, -0.857427716255188, -0.23844262957572937, 0.6682361960411072, -0.2809359133243561, 0.4085308909416199, -0.3977055549621582, -0.7852591872215271, -0.8679092526435852, -0.5025705099105835, -0.5926223993301392, -0.11307121068239212, -1.2111653089523315, 0.6859139800071716, -0.5482085943222046, 0.26629024744033813, -0.315059095621109, -0.5296209454536438, 0.7324784398078918, 0.4082117974758148, -0.5174768567085266, 0.5438963174819946, -0.462555468082428, 0.28041067719459534, 1.0311553478240967, 0.09102950990200043, 0.3149096965789795, 0.3695411682128906, 0.19431230425834656, 0.7480674982070923, 0.11285819858312607, -0.5475049018859863, 0.6206467151641846, 0.8530183434486389, -0.4275820851325989, 1.1117136478424072, -0.11239925026893616, 0.03854188695549965, -0.21922309696674347, 1.0772439241409302, 0.2834470570087433, 0.5138920545578003, -0.5583494901657104, 1.0751794576644897, -0.47036129236221313, 0.0018895508255809546, -0.21412676572799683, -1.1064789295196533, 0.7912347316741943, 0.045068610459566116, 0.29038283228874207, 0.7443805932998657, 0.38113850355148315, 0.09239928424358368, -0.3102455735206604, -0.30534470081329346, -1.0483760833740234, -0.23008239269256592, -0.03703061863780022, 0.38734227418899536, 0.4011423885822296, 0.19188335537910461, -0.5406852960586548, -0.7839694023132324, 0.11595745384693146, 0.565591037273407, -0.40387335419654846, 0.4402461051940918, 0.21863669157028198, 0.3871519863605499, -0.13128872215747833, 0.46716850996017456, 0.43349480628967285, -0.07849937677383423, -0.03168096765875816, 0.7136576771736145, 0.33436477184295654, -0.488908588886261, 0.6324895620346069, -0.16650846600532532, 0.4745468199253082, 0.95374596118927, -0.5797125101089478, 0.8496807217597961, -0.10487877577543259, -0.04545900970697403, -0.4257093667984009, -0.14038215577602386, 0.5454516410827637, 0.06457673758268356, 0.2309081256389618, 0.45022299885749817, -0.24176734685897827, 0.3740025460720062, -0.9388734698295593, 0.40460681915283203, -0.40006256103515625, -0.18563559651374817, -0.077678382396698, -0.14215029776096344, 0.7419126629829407, 0.866698682308197, -0.1516273021697998, 0.1143350601196289, -0.8454475402832031, -0.6995108127593994, 0.2989864647388458, -0.4703710973262787, -0.7259878516197205, 0.20715391635894775, -0.1466900110244751, 0.5062965750694275, 1.1823965311050415, 0.9179970622062683, 0.12087470293045044, -0.09045636653900146, -0.22253289818763733, 0.38873744010925293, -0.48243558406829834, -1.0830167531967163, 1.277942419052124, 0.8179530501365662, -0.5640168786048889, -0.23142081499099731, 0.36926937103271484, 0.048052094876766205, 0.7879530191421509, -0.05408963933587074, -0.9334872364997864, 0.6734842658042908, 0.0036367038264870644, -0.043975990265607834, -0.9078241586685181, 0.22600668668746948, -1.0719958543777466, 0.9807774424552917, -0.23313839733600616, 0.09543779492378235, 0.16028422117233276, 0.030791986733675003, -1.0800601243972778, 0.04432687163352966, -0.9067460298538208, 0.1253715455532074, 0.8337293863296509, 0.6224733591079712, -0.3512902557849884, 0.25285014510154724, 0.774405837059021, 0.18213385343551636, -0.06153978034853935, -0.675601601600647, 0.6388368010520935, 0.46707260608673096, 0.27576878666877747, 0.21532303094863892, -0.24477195739746094, -0.14300374686717987, 0.6802880764007568, 0.414465069770813, -0.02848525159060955, 0.5084457397460938, 0.2022809088230133, 0.27322936058044434, 0.026913076639175415, 0.49743980169296265, -0.024022813886404037, 0.8708693981170654, 0.03977188095450401, 0.9192970395088196, -0.34785789251327515, -0.030154267325997353, 1.355556607246399, -0.18264734745025635, 0.7908413410186768, 0.6462368965148926, 0.41936373710632324, 0.16661596298217773, 0.6296714544296265, 0.6657957434654236, 0.5168237686157227, 0.0874045267701149, -0.583768904209137, 0.36397871375083923, 0.08021121472120285, 0.7703131437301636, -0.5286266803741455, 0.6974030137062073, -0.8487454652786255, 0.2054939866065979, -0.02063736692070961, 0.36351659893989563, -1.290768027305603, 0.9052861332893372, -0.42527738213539124, 0.34011879563331604, -0.07302454859018326, 0.11012142151594162, 0.3395218551158905, 0.24087578058242798, 0.17580457031726837, -0.8551406860351562, -0.45599302649497986, 0.568912148475647, -0.6482691764831543, 0.1892562359571457, 0.16274647414684296, -0.8571156859397888, -1.428826928138733, -0.472179114818573, -0.6044548153877258, 0.16209088265895844, -0.3194615840911865, -0.29419445991516113, 0.3765665590763092, -0.21676219999790192, 0.684954047203064, -0.22047457098960876, -0.20547834038734436, -0.11608850210905075, -0.11099980771541595, -0.07080934196710587, 0.28185465931892395, -0.18700462579727173, -1.2089242935180664, 0.12464935332536697, -0.7574414610862732, 0.06199957802891731, -0.6478338241577148, -0.59657883644104, -0.008022001013159752, 0.15445300936698914, 0.3542352616786957, 0.3219779431819916, 0.45655712485313416, -0.10977204889059067, -0.3967273235321045, -0.7106955647468567, -0.6907773017883301, -0.34554970264434814, -0.07672453671693802, -0.27472883462905884, -0.7738770246505737, 0.9576560258865356, -0.33299094438552856, -0.21739600598812103, 0.5360018610954285, 0.07953549921512604, -0.6228112578392029, -0.14435304701328278, 0.4491923749446869, 0.07148768752813339, -0.301993191242218, 0.873469352722168, 0.8672565221786499, 0.17069481313228607, 0.06540089845657349, -0.4295935332775116, -0.47537198662757874, -0.35535550117492676, 0.4868543744087219, -0.8824779391288757, 0.5631039142608643, 1.0755054950714111, 0.4562392830848694, -0.7944594025611877, 0.7049922347068787, -0.3577398955821991, -0.6032821536064148, -0.10744495689868927, -0.3321584463119507, 0.15795862674713135, 0.3259056508541107, 0.07084003835916519, -0.13384787738323212, -0.670470118522644, 0.5104968547821045, 0.4352463185787201, 0.20429833233356476, -0.36952242255210876, 0.2009602040052414, 0.10487043857574463, -0.02066223695874214, 0.1932348608970642, 0.04633419215679169, -0.5029369592666626, -0.3783208429813385, 0.024479040876030922, -0.4302923083305359, 0.2819003164768219, 0.02947113662958145, -0.014455802738666534, -0.2782844305038452, 0.07803384214639664, -0.8725942373275757, -0.14581088721752167, -0.3439308702945709, 0.20266759395599365, -0.47778838872909546, 0.5377093553543091, -0.4095231294631958, -1.1258965730667114, -1.086920142173767, -0.2502395510673523, -0.5296617150306702, 0.0993301123380661, 0.8547102808952332, -0.8936710357666016, 0.9198141098022461, -0.23475365340709686, -0.1522904336452484, -0.1215520054101944, -0.5382975935935974, -0.11132802814245224, -0.10931022465229034, 0.3495614528656006, 0.46073463559150696, -0.5183699727058411, -0.6086517572402954, -0.8034622669219971, 0.6663119196891785, -0.1913982331752777, 0.39572376012802124, -0.10065608471632004, -0.02871888130903244, -1.1422566175460815, 0.0715174525976181, -0.3071553111076355, 0.02642243355512619, -0.09189734607934952, -0.42369377613067627, -0.1250617504119873, -0.247843936085701, 0.05139164999127388, 0.3227235972881317, 0.8157898187637329, 0.37833210825920105, -0.1566142588853836, 0.0681350976228714, 0.7922307848930359, -0.4202080965042114, 0.4222259223461151, -0.7192891240119934, 0.2153223603963852, -0.48797401785850525, 0.07646579295396805, 0.3808361887931824, 0.31816595792770386, -0.11269649118185043, -0.3296554982662201, 0.24110780656337738, 0.03484781086444855, 0.3283742666244507, 0.39330247044563293, -0.9043719172477722, 0.11166904866695404, 0.23559331893920898, -0.1008685976266861, -0.5133233666419983, -0.3597632050514221, 0.3509153723716736, 0.9172942042350769, 0.35439637303352356, -0.603118896484375, -0.1892247349023819, -0.10994420945644379, 0.1881042718887329, 0.4161165654659271, -0.44886162877082825, -0.7306048274040222, -0.32891467213630676, -0.22699113190174103, -0.3453989326953888, 0.787825345993042, 1.1329984664916992, -0.11254231631755829, 0.6072691082954407, -0.6686766743659973, -0.2256704717874527, 1.2081146240234375, -0.31609266996383667, -0.17001798748970032, 0.02510000765323639, 0.5916147828102112, -0.05639214441180229, 0.9166848063468933, -0.5107260346412659, -0.6752187609672546, -0.6808438301086426, -0.03239486739039421, -0.11023593693971634, -0.3174848258495331, -0.6405338644981384, 0.0683201402425766, 0.16259250044822693, -0.6761430501937866, 0.6615380644798279, -0.04482147470116615, 0.5793235898017883, 0.19726291298866272, 0.21218818426132202, -0.08662381023168564, -0.35592150688171387, 0.24617959558963776, -0.08926442265510559, 0.8757176399230957, 0.6883732080459595, 0.4136140048503876, 0.5444983839988708, -0.5990073084831238, 0.10357367992401123, -0.3364328444004059, 0.08245771378278732, -0.6899519562721252, -0.12370477616786957, -0.6585388779640198, -0.2567698359489441, -0.09709646552801132, -0.16818276047706604, 1.012549877166748, 0.07449403405189514, 0.09034907817840576, 0.13552579283714294, -0.5142930746078491, -1.200063943862915, -0.32454296946525574, -0.8027787804603577, 0.3096056878566742, -1.0930311679840088, -0.1736624538898468, 0.2516253590583801, -0.38732871413230896, 0.08395261317491531, -0.20024940371513367, -0.18146802484989166, 0.3069404661655426, 0.06323987990617752, 0.7484889030456543, 0.41288989782333374, 0.7320857644081116, -0.5890054106712341, 0.11272118985652924, -0.22931672632694244, -0.3348641097545624, -0.7258208990097046, 0.28488782048225403, -0.6074192523956299, 0.4738353490829468, -0.2356826215982437, -0.27924877405166626, 0.4659869074821472, 0.25820818543434143, 0.3442877233028412, 0.48410138487815857, 0.19082769751548767, -0.054468125104904175, 0.14503249526023865, 0.20637623965740204, 0.5174229741096497, -1.0806267261505127, -0.1748305857181549, 0.9705842733383179, -0.0793202668428421, 0.17653116583824158, -0.30610421299934387, -0.12389905750751495, 0.7065807580947876, -1.425394892692566, 1.2919977903366089, -1.0959110260009766, -0.6048139333724976, -0.7409713268280029, 0.35416239500045776, 0.3451915681362152, 0.37108853459358215, -0.08210381120443344, -0.6370165944099426, -0.46573886275291443, -0.43885040283203125, 0.3144252896308899, -0.7463995218276978, 0.22188782691955566, -0.7164101004600525, -0.7729649543762207, -1.0603200197219849, 0.8627544045448303, -0.6704719662666321, -0.29517340660095215, 0.10110216587781906, 0.5479151606559753, -0.2617010772228241, 0.30601635575294495, 0.1856529414653778, 0.10985292494297028, -0.612002968788147, -0.2091464102268219, 0.3167155086994171, 0.36463403701782227, -0.20246896147727966, 0.13427744805812836, -0.2747420072555542, 0.3200264573097229, 0.11944007873535156, 0.4075309932231903, 0.7440258264541626, -0.42644229531288147, 0.31758424639701843, -0.8384314179420471, -0.11808285862207413, 0.22838462889194489, -0.1626492291688919, -0.501193642616272, -0.635560929775238, -0.5468354821205139, -0.9660053253173828, -0.6388311386108398, -0.9536091685295105, 0.5622031092643738, 0.07843239605426788, -0.5380337238311768, -0.12137971073389053, -0.6526761054992676, -0.0033433374483138323, -0.45086437463760376, 0.20278385281562805, 0.36586320400238037, 0.5917884111404419, 0.13439032435417175, -0.44048693776130676, 0.2067059427499771, -0.3361656069755554, 0.25594285130500793, 0.2739768624305725, -0.09507481753826141, -0.35123491287231445, 0.009457072243094444, 0.22189319133758545, -1.0318506956100464, -0.16231192648410797, 0.3218829929828644, 0.045182373374700546, -0.047274328768253326, 0.9022224545478821, 0.9186885952949524, -0.7542876601219177, -0.14797604084014893, 0.29199865460395813, -0.2703685760498047, -0.05044563487172127, 0.6426961421966553, 0.2338467389345169, 0.32590827345848083, 0.06547356396913528, 0.2878921627998352, -0.8263372778892517, 0.4854011535644531, 0.8113255500793457, -0.6702910661697388, -0.5133671760559082, 0.07369904220104218, 0.05429625138640404, -0.4699859321117401, -0.398163378238678, -0.8211490511894226, -0.448140412569046, 0.6995140910148621, -0.10026875883340836, 0.012942914851009846, -0.13075369596481323, -0.5528346300125122, 0.18642541766166687, 0.896251380443573, 0.08720210194587708, -0.06846863776445389, 0.7822028398513794, -0.24324387311935425, -0.29803305864334106, 0.21188965439796448, 1.2447692155838013, -0.2669900953769684, -0.9363593459129333, 0.1895385980606079, 0.008281242102384567, 0.29570329189300537, -0.726884663105011, 0.5525246262550354, -0.8121534585952759, 0.264319509267807, 0.23473621904850006, 0.13825872540473938, -0.471693754196167, 0.18445640802383423, -0.05315609648823738, 0.08922174572944641, -0.33653825521469116, -0.2683578431606293, 0.15456341207027435, 0.38953113555908203, 0.11007657647132874, 0.5179738402366638, 0.1589990258216858, -0.1957085132598877, 0.2648913562297821, 0.5027685165405273, -0.7763903737068176, -0.7075347900390625, -0.744886577129364, -1.4119205474853516, -0.6801705360412598, -1.053916573524475, -0.07053183019161224, 0.02206660993397236, 0.1823849081993103, -0.3700358271598816, 0.14144349098205566, 0.1372591257095337, 0.604405403137207, -0.09070459753274918, 1.7471051216125488, -0.7854664921760559, -0.6078053712844849, -0.7228309512138367, 0.14362262189388275, -0.44787994027137756, -0.92863929271698, -0.26377445459365845, -0.45779716968536377, -0.14180482923984528, 0.7145593166351318, 0.3223125636577606, 0.4582200050354004, -0.4490148723125458, -0.2143852710723877, -0.13273438811302185, -0.45456117391586304, -0.9585843682289124, 0.5562184453010559, 0.34804531931877136, 0.8651650547981262, 0.07906244695186615, 0.43990713357925415, 0.5022005438804626, 0.05618758499622345, -1.1412020921707153, 0.7235203385353088, 0.0625356063246727, 0.8361641764640808, 0.3241613507270813, -0.8489459753036499, 0.08216016739606857, 0.3758174777030945, -1.2100234031677246, 0.1612154245376587, -0.1887185424566269, 0.5580033659934998, -0.453870952129364, -0.38938525319099426, -0.042155925184488297, 0.8414028882980347, -0.4203943610191345, -0.13247379660606384, -0.7401244044303894, 0.13113661110401154, 0.19991515576839447, 0.5400060415267944, 0.06066422536969185, -0.16089420020580292, 0.23156072199344635, -0.5574786067008972, 0.5623598098754883, -0.14324255287647247, -0.39291858673095703, -0.20858997106552124, 0.484142541885376, 0.16226236522197723, -0.4280383288860321, -0.14009004831314087, -0.8698703050613403, 0.8207620978355408, 0.21779383718967438, 0.2298852652311325, 0.3688845634460449, -0.2568250894546509, -0.7373545169830322, -0.037980422377586365, -0.3644176721572876, -0.6560999751091003, 0.3690347373485565, 0.03234625607728958, -0.460800439119339, 0.15854452550411224, -0.48750025033950806, 0.03494500741362572, 0.41742587089538574, 1.45365309715271, 0.7142444849014282, -0.435768187046051, -0.3767774999141693, 0.135041743516922, -0.7894344329833984, -0.06383583694696426, -0.4054141342639923, 0.47802498936653137, -0.2779427468776703, -0.8837069869041443, 0.6595927476882935, 0.28375640511512756, -0.515339732170105, -0.2541638910770416, 0.10921511799097061, 0.5282420516014099, -0.4113861322402954, -0.3033754527568817, -0.12216302007436752, -0.3536825478076935, -1.1504161357879639, 0.09660698473453522, 0.3536175489425659, 0.4160134196281433, -0.10701628774404526, 0.5536314845085144, 0.2760901153087616, -0.23853348195552826, -0.02673136256635189, 1.1829607486724854, -0.5750552415847778, -0.5755141377449036, 0.6019874811172485, 0.3579493463039398, 0.26937392354011536, 0.21552053093910217, -0.31613463163375854, 0.28993773460388184, 0.08316371589899063, 0.19495296478271484, 0.5471709370613098, 0.45134302973747253, 0.20783431828022003, 0.402759850025177, 0.21085311472415924, -0.1961509883403778, -0.015698524191975594, -0.12398272007703781, -0.17264606058597565, 0.2571016252040863, -0.5404306054115295, 0.04439650848507881, 0.10062864422798157, 0.9963771104812622, 0.7477753162384033, 0.1916070431470871, -0.18897119164466858, 0.07212469726800919, 0.22138871252536774, 0.2471398413181305, -0.5801411867141724, -0.358685702085495, -0.41495218873023987, 0.2740362584590912, 0.18627525866031647, -0.2595539093017578, 0.1485079526901245, -0.07056884467601776, 0.41264277696609497, 0.14392055571079254, -0.25525587797164917, 0.9198921322822571, 0.3014916181564331, 0.3939710855484009, 0.5964422225952148, 0.26490166783332825, 0.5004717111587524, 0.4914487898349762, 0.10487549006938934, -0.8784859776496887, -0.13988293707370758, 0.6531438827514648, -0.8053978681564331, 0.4618719816207886, 0.05336714908480644, -0.3834988474845886, -0.5060931444168091, -0.8806911706924438, 0.943758487701416, 0.36350613832473755, 0.26578399538993835, -0.03697197139263153, -0.06390176713466644, -0.45755675435066223, 0.28514665365219116, -0.12502744793891907, 0.7123568654060364, 0.4002734422683716, 0.5660777688026428, 0.06673314422369003, 0.8001617789268494, 1.3522727489471436, 0.4368005692958832, 0.4005824029445648, -0.6520797610282898, -0.11906302720308304, 0.5604340434074402, -0.12179990112781525, -0.13040843605995178, 0.5344948172569275, -0.600332498550415, -0.14960893988609314, 0.43717217445373535, 0.11151468753814697, -0.1731058657169342, 0.7708001732826233, 0.4723731279373169, 0.6144754886627197, -0.31939077377319336, 0.00904366746544838, 0.7843242287635803, -0.05609804764389992, -0.014437979087233543, 0.24717706441879272, 0.7343790531158447, -0.9211662411689758, 0.07670842111110687, -1.8531147241592407, 0.04376855120062828, 0.11853178590536118, -0.4662678837776184, -0.6389029622077942, -0.3649635910987854, 0.3217949867248535, -0.20478250086307526, 0.025182880461215973, -1.1401399374008179, 0.4816036522388458, 0.9090404510498047, -0.046406522393226624, 0.45089906454086304, -0.30567657947540283, -0.8427212834358215, -0.31667834520339966, 1.0209187269210815, 0.7043398022651672, 0.3783529996871948, 0.599335789680481, -0.13720791041851044, -0.7007428407669067, 0.2628837525844574, 0.07341105490922928, -0.624410092830658, 0.7026553750038147, -0.5314405560493469, 0.09217219799757004, 0.0776614397764206, -0.8837316632270813, -0.46836861968040466, 0.24627548456192017, 0.8037601709365845, -0.22641286253929138, -0.29718002676963806, 0.3141797184944153, -0.4345141053199768, 0.11570257693529129, -0.7110794186592102, -0.15725216269493103, -0.00837593711912632, -0.8565911054611206, 0.17230990529060364, -0.5814729928970337, 4.077529430389404, 0.54489666223526, 0.8988884687423706, 0.5726184844970703, 0.8568485379219055, 0.9830593466758728, -0.37668102979660034, 1.1705551147460938, 0.42814409732818604, -0.5695047378540039, -0.3359808027744293, 0.4930536150932312, 0.3045978248119354, 0.08259209990501404, 0.507926881313324, 0.18403145670890808, -0.3346981108188629, -0.3160493075847626, 0.07892744243144989, -0.4482343792915344, -0.8100725412368774, -0.02402692660689354, -0.05196144059300423, 0.035310979932546616, 0.18215355277061462, 0.3167397379875183, 0.266946017742157, -0.686492919921875, -1.1408021450042725, -0.19763103127479553, -0.7379038333892822, -0.45052099227905273, 0.04776692017912865, 0.05511318892240524, -1.052933931350708, 0.030101817101240158, -0.42714154720306396, -0.30643436312675476, 0.06577028334140778, 0.03510488197207451, 0.47078171372413635, -0.24019329249858856, 0.3320726752281189, -0.42165276408195496, 0.3032001554965973, 0.616557240486145, 0.18608412146568298, 0.712662398815155, 0.7789758443832397, -0.8121795654296875, -0.1064753457903862, -0.357485294342041, 0.4370972812175751, -0.9209789633750916, -0.4746403992176056, -0.18314766883850098, -0.23637643456459045, -0.5070088505744934, 0.12394537776708603, -0.2725825011730194, 0.39963749051094055, -0.12201318144798279, -0.5001949667930603, -0.39184582233428955, 0.055828168988227844, -0.49643561244010925, 0.417908251285553, -0.5184210538864136, 0.3328957259654999, -0.11910249292850494, -0.35506123304367065, -0.15674293041229248, -0.3712509870529175, -0.09183190762996674, 0.2532048225402832, 0.10991328954696655, -0.46053919196128845, 1.0697680711746216, -0.3308548927307129, -0.05284048616886139, -0.5005025267601013, 0.3298998773097992, -0.053346991539001465, 0.08556444197893143, 0.7415048480033875, 0.5910490155220032, -0.02009071223437786, 0.058155469596385956, -0.6032395362854004, 0.4848056733608246, 0.06006646901369095, 0.5114790797233582, -0.3553992509841919, 0.03172522410750389, -0.7400592565536499 ]
Exotic Differentiable Structures and General Relativity
We review recent developments in differential topology with special concern for their possible significance to physical theories, especially general relativity. In particular we are concerned here with the discovery of the existence of non-standard (``fake'' or ``exotic'') differentiable structures on topologically simple manifolds such as $S^7$, \R and $S^3\times {\bf R^1}.$ Because of the technical difficulties involved in the smooth case, we begin with an easily understood toy example looking at the role which the choice of complex structures plays in the formulation of two-dimensional vacuum electrostatics. We then briefly review the mathematical formalisms involved with differentiable structures on topological manifolds, diffeomorphisms and their significance for physics. We summarize the important work of Milnor, Freedman, Donaldson, and others in developing exotic differentiable structures on well known topological manifolds. Finally, we discuss some of the geometric implications of these results and propose some conjectures on possible physical implications of these new manifolds which have never before been considered as physical models.
Carl H. Brans and Duane Randall
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212003
gr-qc/9212004
[ -0.05388614535331726, -0.3286365270614624, 0.45086172223091125, -0.04967502877116203, -0.44928407669067383, -0.8339736461639404, -0.8803298473358154, -0.19348390400409698, -1.012341856956482, 1.608812689781189, 0.20492634177207947, -0.014557991176843643, -0.33325669169425964, -0.7998911738395691, 0.24341905117034912, -0.1914369910955429, 0.05640559643507004, -0.5303895473480225, -1.1914197206497192, -0.29639914631843567, 0.4489041864871979, -0.12293644994497299, -1.2590422630310059, -0.6360892057418823, -0.8880571722984314, 1.0378409624099731, 0.1561574786901474, 0.6580008268356323, 0.8664772510528564, 0.9217591881752014, 0.5221198797225952, -0.7985629439353943, -0.05784225836396217, -0.6549444198608398, 0.5115042924880981, -0.41758596897125244, -0.003287501400336623, -0.3987060487270355, 0.37079551815986633, -0.11226392537355423, 0.5335063338279724, -0.3706851899623871, 0.6474643349647522, -0.262725293636322, -1.0355030298233032, 0.08149609714746475, -0.21181657910346985, 0.44276943802833557, 0.18307115137577057, -1.378024935722351, -0.39281705021858215, -0.31534162163734436, 0.30091536045074463, -0.6413790583610535, -0.359885036945343, 0.06127410754561424, 0.09883225709199905, 0.39361268281936646, -0.05604907125234604, 0.35928285121917725, 0.930544912815094, 0.2477036863565445, 0.5508255958557129, -1.1228103637695312, -0.05172412842512131, 1.5023906230926514, -0.3145727217197418, 0.3687496781349182, 0.05967520549893379, -1.1488035917282104, 0.5227685570716858, -0.7589765787124634, -0.23078025877475739, 0.17728814482688904, -0.2444837987422943, 0.8305296301841736, -0.2460411638021469, -0.06981100887060165, -0.6473454833030701, 0.3392427861690521, 0.4672650396823883, -0.4442615211009979, -0.17065834999084473, 0.24692334234714508, 0.06752748042345047, -0.6109800934791565, 0.12243587523698807, -0.5422889590263367, 0.3951214551925659, -0.17694774270057678, 0.1991807222366333, 0.791614830493927, -0.5757473707199097, -0.05274354666471481, 0.3028923273086548, 0.5623685717582703, -0.6519227027893066, -0.2028515338897705, -0.24979422986507416, 1.0615819692611694, -0.2177276760339737, 0.36343052983283997, -0.14368464052677155, 0.1934519112110138, -0.30664175748825073, 0.6454929709434509, 0.1272086799144745, 0.24026155471801758, -0.3199131488800049, -0.7125961184501648, -0.21950745582580566, 0.24422116577625275, 0.36230576038360596, 0.5496655106544495, 0.2227790206670761, -0.010732267051935196, -0.2145335078239441, -0.21170315146446228, -0.8072014451026917, 0.0894889160990715, 0.2830871045589447, 0.8597941994667053, 0.5377882719039917, 0.6665347814559937, 0.22775210440158844, -0.11414410173892975, -0.21854166686534882, 0.1152881383895874, -0.2525362968444824, 0.23632188141345978, 0.7397525906562805, -0.20998677611351013, 0.1861700862646103, -0.2843722701072693, 0.2874221205711365, 0.962401807308197, 0.20650921761989594, 0.1426675021648407, -0.28158053755760193, -0.6742306351661682, 0.2990930378437042, -0.8279883861541748, 0.4664604961872101, 0.8357419967651367, -0.41539984941482544, 0.5582171082496643, 0.6545059084892273, -0.1201976016163826, 0.44113782048225403, 0.20840194821357727, -0.2988077402114868, -0.36484166979789734, 0.019310608506202698, -0.19622023403644562, -0.5003402233123779, 0.14393767714500427, -0.6259917616844177, 0.6001659035682678, -0.6782494187355042, -0.20160703361034393, 0.045713577419519424, 0.06390564888715744, 0.8521215319633484, 1.3767986297607422, -0.027003809809684753, 0.16825541853904724, -0.311145156621933, -1.0329762697219849, -0.08332792669534683, -0.15844695270061493, -0.7335171699523926, -0.29192203283309937, 0.3613675534725189, 0.6867836117744446, 0.8390108942985535, 0.3583400249481201, 0.33710071444511414, -0.12689590454101562, -0.4299396872520447, -0.20022667944431305, -0.029542183503508568, -0.18953761458396912, 0.3579215705394745, 0.6618033051490784, -0.2607853412628174, -0.20368574559688568, -0.11258568614721298, -0.35481008887290955, 0.27708202600479126, 0.48308706283569336, 0.08690977096557617, 0.15662549436092377, -0.8557931780815125, 0.6657739281654358, -0.646536648273468, 0.5305028557777405, -0.6913296580314636, -0.4638284742832184, -0.0045860097743570805, -0.20612342655658722, 0.22984889149665833, 0.06725071370601654, -0.5807240009307861, 0.8260456919670105, -0.8472640514373779, -0.5036694407463074, 0.8874170184135437, 0.03770648315548897, -0.5532788634300232, 0.0449969619512558, 0.2494927942752838, 0.10368269681930542, 0.12959881126880646, -0.6477455496788025, 0.40268805623054504, -0.10010339319705963, -0.4375956952571869, 0.2452293336391449, 0.10021238029003143, -0.10409089177846909, 0.947068452835083, 0.4023461639881134, 0.6845042109489441, 0.8959494829177856, 0.006696035154163837, -0.47881314158439636, 0.06422720104455948, 0.7730658054351807, 0.4432727098464966, 0.4725697338581085, -0.10564437508583069, 0.24760977923870087, 0.19529137015342712, 0.1364370435476303, 0.5786055326461792, 0.02886451780796051, 0.42668306827545166, 0.5108444094657898, 0.15878678858280182, -0.3185732960700989, 0.053959522396326065, -0.2764212191104889, 0.7184195518493652, 0.324629545211792, 0.049760978668928146, 0.32952240109443665, 0.34852156043052673, -0.041822176426649094, -0.18812334537506104, 0.8550316095352173, -0.44404706358909607, 0.9562581777572632, 0.10660124570131302, 0.5201365947723389, -0.7623884677886963, -0.010532929562032223, 0.3856673538684845, 0.5538538098335266, 0.08038630336523056, -0.6909998655319214, -0.7230891585350037, 0.36898475885391235, -0.18993331491947174, -0.7699193954467773, 0.46095365285873413, -0.20171195268630981, -0.28198516368865967, 0.10488060861825943, 0.3864702582359314, -0.6411905288696289, -1.158888339996338, 0.4135650396347046, -0.42826926708221436, -0.2087991088628769, -0.18051280081272125, -0.4767052233219147, 0.21945630013942719, -0.2744148075580597, 0.9420645833015442, -0.3368538022041321, -0.193873792886734, 0.35500553250312805, -0.015008373185992241, 0.5072446465492249, -0.4019675850868225, 0.06659085303544998, -0.7013219594955444, 0.14201664924621582, -1.1625354290008545, -0.02824294939637184, 0.28389623761177063, -0.23230163753032684, -0.2242249697446823, -0.4538140296936035, -0.1689639389514923, 0.518054723739624, -0.6992867588996887, 0.2782437205314636, -0.38615351915359497, -0.5737909078598022, 0.16619710624217987, 0.7074020504951477, 0.15673604607582092, -0.12813392281532288, -0.8052972555160522, 0.9403426051139832, 0.07656324654817581, -0.3287993371486664, 0.8833439946174622, -0.11732609570026398, -0.9199035167694092, 0.22639508545398712, -0.5085945725440979, 0.5216258764266968, 0.01835116744041443, 0.23813845217227936, 0.8965820074081421, 0.3079424202442169, 0.5526221394538879, -0.5619083642959595, -0.4764365255832672, -0.31550517678260803, 0.8342902660369873, -0.6405837535858154, 0.3493323028087616, 0.5767037868499756, 0.4239000380039215, -0.0958104282617569, 0.8111147284507751, -0.9815503358840942, -0.7073517441749573, -0.055825818330049515, -0.44774025678634644, 0.3151422441005707, 0.9163796305656433, -0.19910171627998352, 0.2780643701553345, 0.02559281513094902, -0.05312466621398926, 1.1771472692489624, 0.4099980294704437, -0.40926221013069153, 0.19041979312896729, 0.6243821978569031, 0.3822720944881439, 0.14804990589618683, 1.0031311511993408, 0.26420024037361145, -0.198026642203331, 0.4294671416282654, -0.2546411454677582, -0.01825292408466339, 0.4904123842716217, 0.27395501732826233, -0.2745899260044098, -0.43663284182548523, -0.8757990002632141, 0.17395196855068207, -0.3438265919685364, -0.024190912023186684, 0.48984846472740173, 0.2775190770626068, 0.1414135992527008, -0.2984493672847748, -0.799462080001831, 0.26240086555480957, 0.28916406631469727, 0.5441368818283081, 0.5691444277763367, -0.24799351394176483, 0.5860868096351624, -0.4176792502403259, -0.7980265021324158, -0.7024181485176086, -0.13404986262321472, 0.21995016932487488, 0.4249687194824219, 0.46026551723480225, 0.5619428157806396, -0.767581582069397, -0.7044677734375, -0.8578386902809143, 1.0075901746749878, 0.1060049757361412, 0.235600546002388, -0.30298635363578796, -0.4205564260482788, 0.13336585462093353, -0.5294654965400696, -0.18227557837963104, -0.22894251346588135, -1.0035775899887085, 0.24658843874931335, -0.914174497127533, -0.4107872545719147, -0.011030921712517738, 0.31748008728027344, 0.448956698179245, 0.22316983342170715, 0.15069212019443512, 0.20869219303131104, -0.2894414961338043, -0.33756324648857117, 0.7367632985115051, -0.5806065201759338, -0.0606076642870903, -0.6630340218544006, 0.49423232674598694, 0.2696167528629303, 0.2459746152162552, 0.28848010301589966, -0.4641607701778412, 0.5009348392486572, -0.07417716085910797, -0.19939829409122467, 0.7813954949378967, 0.15369655191898346, 0.8637779355049133, 0.7388809323310852, -0.4430977702140808, -0.5966254472732544, 0.2640160322189331, 0.7692934274673462, 0.6172058582305908, -0.05616263300180435, -0.16756980121135712, -0.10576494038105011, -0.028283443301916122, 0.35849133133888245, 0.6156479120254517, -0.54273521900177, -0.5345245599746704, -0.3732023239135742, 0.28101325035095215, 0.33316320180892944, 0.17158223688602448, 1.1727540493011475, 0.08232829719781876, 0.47090408205986023, 0.09702719748020172, -0.03491337224841118, 1.1453627347946167, -0.8287021517753601, 0.7359520792961121, -0.16879895329475403, 0.5340330600738525, -0.3625137209892273, 0.45832517743110657, -0.11333929747343063, -0.8209443688392639, -0.18565961718559265, -0.7361896634101868, 1.0217349529266357, -0.5623999834060669, -0.1254332810640335, 0.33972710371017456, 0.4186132848262787, -0.34250956773757935, 0.22410857677459717, 0.3278473913669586, -0.3348842263221741, 0.018581097945570946, 0.455949604511261, -0.15618564188480377, -0.8421400189399719, -0.45852503180503845, -0.2337808907032013, 0.6182261109352112, 0.4621904492378235, 0.20693516731262207, 0.49196064472198486, 0.6325627565383911, -0.417818546295166, -0.02450917847454548, 0.2955038547515869, -0.38618984818458557, -0.14000144600868225, 0.10688035935163498, -0.030173810198903084, -0.5391601324081421, -0.018974199891090393, 0.776041567325592, 0.2583768665790558, -0.11579578369855881, 0.29633089900016785, -1.397910714149475, -0.5000224709510803, -0.19765566289424896, -0.1559431105852127, 0.6375587582588196, -0.5373682975769043, -0.6009032130241394, -0.15224887430667877, -0.6442477107048035, -0.012055031955242157, -0.3947484493255615, -0.5919312238693237, -0.3458566665649414, -0.12497911602258682, 0.3872951865196228, 0.13617171347141266, 0.24818430840969086, -0.21476896107196808, -0.3937586545944214, -0.20027674734592438, -0.18840348720550537, -0.1767844557762146, -0.8366804122924805, -0.3139438033103943, 0.3077377378940582, 0.35176214575767517, 0.20257233083248138, -0.4589235186576843, -0.12019095569849014, -0.029499780386686325, -0.30303147435188293, -0.5834683775901794, -0.8656059503555298, 0.21370245516300201, 0.4915751516819, 0.04955914616584778, -0.4888553321361542, -0.21093519032001495, 0.39989739656448364, -0.29076284170150757, 0.37792617082595825, -0.6464563608169556, -0.9647955298423767, 0.35821327567100525, -1.0066289901733398, 0.5547212362289429, -0.9904277920722961, -0.3602457344532013, -0.42608779668807983, -0.6905930638313293, -0.5425718426704407, 0.012260155752301216, 0.15109314024448395, -1.0697790384292603, 0.1356319934129715, -0.05042243003845215, -0.12076689302921295, -0.7437198758125305, 0.060780320316553116, 0.4461553990840912, -0.5955773591995239, -0.2024269849061966, 0.8216739296913147, -0.2791588008403778, -0.06731846183538437, -0.23969517648220062, -0.40295299887657166, -0.23593400418758392, 0.24169795215129852, 0.09795797616243362, 0.20505383610725403, -0.4895996153354645, -0.3671327233314514, 0.5885860919952393, 0.24553410708904266, -0.6130849719047546, 0.6522203683853149, -0.13595201075077057, 0.777812659740448, -0.42372334003448486, -0.6534682512283325, 0.09471731632947922, 0.030542992055416107, 0.4670797884464264, 0.16281549632549286, 0.4030385911464691, 0.5588843822479248, 0.315860390663147, 0.34729093313217163, 0.30800795555114746, -0.4602685570716858, -0.2908679246902466, -0.39372518658638, -0.7342053055763245, 0.462994247674942, 0.7018691897392273, 0.43536320328712463, -0.2739724814891815, -0.3929307162761688, -0.085307277739048, -0.931700587272644, 0.5069809556007385, -0.12942789494991302, 0.43919435143470764, 0.3302735388278961, -0.6224669814109802, 0.2450319230556488, 0.18697868287563324, -0.33964821696281433, 0.0916822999715805, -0.01591315120458603, 0.11834906041622162, -0.3678603172302246, -0.2885093092918396, -0.4193400740623474, -0.37504249811172485, 0.13322234153747559, 0.6722487807273865, -0.11505090445280075, 0.9232902526855469, 0.07820559293031693, -0.15812256932258606, -0.05375833064317703, 0.5497076511383057, 0.4887743592262268, -0.3485444486141205, 0.8576808571815491, -0.4052133560180664, 0.3180476427078247, -0.16027477383613586, 0.33703404664993286, -0.8472240567207336, -0.2120579034090042, 0.990290105342865, -0.8043349385261536, 0.004348900634795427, 0.7992381453514099, -0.11577873677015305, -0.47207701206207275, 0.14225776493549347, -1.2319821119308472, -0.4371287226676941, -0.27439767122268677, -0.5940057039260864, -0.1623353511095047, 0.14583086967468262, -0.9215987324714661, 0.40737196803092957, 0.6317306160926819, -0.00954817607998848, 0.6016207933425903, -0.578273594379425, -0.24720577895641327, -0.9321203231811523, 0.5192186832427979, 0.8242222666740417, 0.36703255772590637, -0.6185620427131653, -0.04889117181301117, 0.07797656953334808, -0.5209412574768066, -0.5416799187660217, 0.5479232668876648, -0.12663517892360687, 0.26695117354393005, -0.13175970315933228, 0.6512100100517273, 0.9452611207962036, 0.2637350559234619, -0.5214059352874756, -0.39264753460884094, -0.8567569255828857, -0.37231817841529846, 0.0011608540080487728, -0.3279118239879608, 0.06204300373792648, 0.5117014050483704, -0.45108363032341003, -0.31990286707878113, -0.3394427001476288, -0.24966353178024292, -0.20428480207920074, -0.9908748865127563, -0.07460927963256836, -0.7667953372001648, -0.8037509322166443, -1.2861069440841675, -0.023801732808351517, -0.09542980790138245, 0.8347148299217224, -0.4669019877910614, 0.9862496852874756, -0.3579094111919403, -0.2613086998462677, 1.0212397575378418, 0.7183884978294373, -0.1621292233467102, -0.1909412443637848, -0.9165186882019043, -0.0334644615650177, -0.39305412769317627, -0.8436517715454102, -0.8453220129013062, -0.533812940120697, -0.17184334993362427, 1.1198879480361938, -0.7329452037811279, 0.3055954873561859, -0.13843117654323578, -0.9624595642089844, 0.32636722922325134, -0.0649418905377388, -0.8497034311294556, 1.0208745002746582, 0.1410074084997177, 1.1635712385177612, -0.02118895761668682, -0.2378479540348053, 0.1099596694111824, -0.22728638350963593, -0.9877692461013794, 0.765354335308075, -0.811201810836792, 0.7117525339126587, 0.563830554485321, -0.410656601190567, 0.1505717635154724, 0.019025186076760292, -0.8219598531723022, 0.0681297779083252, 0.13648706674575806, 0.2995671331882477, -0.27287188172340393, 0.017591139301657677, 0.15043696761131287, 0.2322348952293396, -0.2172056883573532, 0.2852729856967926, -0.6320233941078186, -0.9263468980789185, -0.2879430651664734, 0.23344434797763824, 0.1953364908695221, -0.5813273191452026, -0.4134017825126648, -0.49987947940826416, 0.3274478614330292, 0.6106082797050476, 0.16792841255664825, -0.21168942749500275, -0.057690009474754333, -0.4530949592590332, -0.3794027864933014, 0.19176030158996582, -0.8113054633140564, 0.856554388999939, 1.1056028604507446, -0.07085546106100082, 0.5291712880134583, -0.3428575396537781, -1.0428175926208496, 0.6013340950012207, -0.04929441213607788, -0.8214163780212402, 0.9652081727981567, -0.28003913164138794, -0.09963657706975937, -0.12129629403352737, -0.7187594771385193, 0.2375761866569519, 0.08771712332963943, 1.0235644578933716, 0.6820750832557678, -0.16462956368923187, -0.38234269618988037, 0.5885470509529114, -0.5953751802444458, -0.02676059864461422, -1.115417718887329, 0.6086487174034119, -0.15063521265983582, -0.520817756652832, -0.7105605602264404, 0.18074440956115723, -0.05583219975233078, -0.08360420167446136, -0.2431860864162445, -0.08330574631690979, -0.19188377261161804, -0.18801584839820862, -0.6536445021629333, -0.34747353196144104, -0.27429527044296265, 0.49059590697288513, -0.374234676361084, -0.29401886463165283, -0.16082167625427246, -0.048919983208179474, 0.6914016604423523, -0.013193121179938316, -0.6531985402107239, 1.1459691524505615, 0.028827868402004242, -0.8862284421920776, 0.18385182321071625, 0.7171798348426819, 0.055916428565979004, 0.49183911085128784, -0.23770610988140106, 0.3061283230781555, 0.3067795932292938, 0.0036554012913256884, 0.39234718680381775, 0.3356378674507141, 0.027410784736275673, 0.2451554387807846, 0.4117355942726135, 0.1724090576171875, 0.12087336927652359, 0.45035478472709656, -0.2111666202545166, 0.5570956468582153, -0.3110308349132538, 0.04889931529760361, 0.05450662225484848, 0.2672620415687561, 0.1905650794506073, 0.47774413228034973, 0.06060861423611641, -0.2518579661846161, -0.6329153180122375, 0.5414468050003052, -0.4678298234939575, -0.8165016770362854, -0.8123944401741028, 0.40890955924987793, -0.21287964284420013, -0.05731440708041191, -0.18276500701904297, -0.25510045886039734, 0.37932243943214417, 0.15916553139686584, -0.4308988153934479, 0.6580913066864014, 0.7679252624511719, 0.242390975356102, 0.8494377732276917, 0.3532204329967499, 0.22531242668628693, 0.7316884398460388, 0.012711148709058762, -0.33095183968544006, -0.09982924908399582, 0.11604713648557663, -0.9335798621177673, -0.10293643921613693, 0.13914325833320618, -0.11541759967803955, -0.18924927711486816, -0.6412007808685303, 0.7741919159889221, -0.6888048052787781, -0.18447691202163696, 0.3761870861053467, -0.690983235836029, -0.09559803456068039, 0.1652245670557022, 0.16733309626579285, -0.0804036408662796, 0.019039219245314598, 0.5843706130981445, -0.3590988218784332, 0.9733597636222839, 1.508139967918396, -0.06856618076562881, 0.2194231003522873, -0.6108927130699158, 0.5417560338973999, 0.13459570705890656, 0.05211670324206352, -0.3289976119995117, 0.8976420164108276, -0.14602549374103546, 0.22287434339523315, -0.7276016473770142, -0.0501134879887104, -0.5667852759361267, -0.2107452154159546, 0.3577725887298584, 0.32857123017311096, -0.3812622129917145, 0.2752087712287903, 0.612159788608551, 0.029357075691223145, -0.3354555368423462, -1.029266119003296, 0.26105642318725586, -1.3188228607177734, 0.014394929632544518, -1.1570367813110352, 0.4409472942352295, 0.12970636785030365, -0.27713826298713684, -0.6175090074539185, -0.33827006816864014, 0.2276131808757782, -0.49153122305870056, -0.2997245192527771, -0.0015804311260581017, 0.5491041541099548, 1.1801835298538208, 0.37258434295654297, 0.11791824549436569, -0.6134119033813477, -0.33937692642211914, -0.04941648989915848, 1.2058336734771729, 0.3020970821380615, 0.03437376767396927, 0.38791948556900024, -0.08160897344350815, -1.0037181377410889, 0.8233153820037842, 0.7882142066955566, -0.8432040214538574, 0.9155893921852112, -0.0684351846575737, 0.7831175923347473, 0.4156016707420349, -1.0884077548980713, -0.3893181085586548, -0.31885841488838196, 0.2544539272785187, 0.1712985336780548, -1.2848706245422363, 0.148138165473938, -0.4400978684425354, -0.24488164484500885, -0.007514622528105974, 0.4812648296356201, 0.03824217990040779, 0.24416182935237885, -0.22104227542877197, -1.6284161806106567, 4.10314416885376, 0.8583952784538269, 0.12194982916116714, 0.00941021740436554, 1.15486741065979, 0.9881260991096497, 0.05946807190775871, 0.34369367361068726, 0.40565451979637146, -0.08772590011358261, -0.5395908355712891, -0.24388770759105682, 0.3966129720211029, -0.2689022123813629, 0.15928031504154205, 0.800299346446991, -0.2678760886192322, -0.1303892284631729, 0.11757251620292664, -0.6516696810722351, -1.0160672664642334, -0.004683102015405893, -0.2561386823654175, 0.1610572338104248, 0.22871436178684235, 0.3176604211330414, -0.11898364871740341, -0.5100488662719727, -0.3911152482032776, -0.2924897074699402, -0.3013436794281006, -0.6916241645812988, 0.430932879447937, -0.6361707448959351, -0.9024187326431274, -0.18162067234516144, 0.004418464843183756, 0.8453094363212585, 0.9375004768371582, -0.47145920991897583, 0.23022595047950745, -1.311253547668457, 0.5993603467941284, -0.6353669166564941, -0.03216594085097313, 1.247607946395874, 0.5737932324409485, 1.1606792211532593, 1.0223536491394043, -0.7171511054039001, 0.7409034967422485, 0.23084336519241333, 0.31639376282691956, -0.12804697453975677, -0.6433024406433105, -0.10195887833833694, 0.015492493286728859, -0.20955917239189148, -0.07318766415119171, -0.3428138196468353, 1.4184801578521729, -0.1505507379770279, 0.4404028058052063, -0.265020489692688, 0.11896204948425293, -0.2768581807613373, -0.6816748380661011, -0.2545902132987976, -0.5612152218818665, 0.3324929177761078, -0.5045034885406494, -0.17550548911094666, -0.6172603368759155, -0.6709820628166199, 0.34749293327331543, 0.28997859358787537, 0.29480648040771484, 0.4826420545578003, 0.027935544028878212, -0.28076303005218506, -0.6944775581359863, -0.10848530381917953, 0.23787721991539001, -0.009845771826803684, 0.06018322706222534, 0.7718216180801392, 0.4561936855316162, 0.2512935698032379, -0.33999499678611755, -0.08130599558353424, 0.21696193516254425, 0.5662754774093628, 0.3358895778656006, 0.6252086758613586, -0.6453647613525391 ]
Quantum Vacuum Instability Near Rotating Stars
We discuss the Starobinskii-Unruh process for the Kerr black hole. We show how this effect is related to the theory of squeezed states. We then consider a simple model for a highly relativistic rotating star and show that the Starobinskii-Unruh effect is absent.
A L Matacz, A C Ottewill and P C W Davies
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212004
gr-qc/9212005
[ 0.4146609604358673, 0.6500288248062134, 0.6124081015586853, 0.3937489688396454, 0.05512823164463043, 0.4249759912490845, -0.36523744463920593, -0.3490600287914276, -0.30601176619529724, 1.5520833730697632, 0.41444578766822815, -0.4496856927871704, -0.07281026244163513, -1.4465097188949585, -0.16136601567268372, 0.7559823393821716, 0.37068113684654236, -0.09600013494491577, -0.5137994289398193, 0.3449574112892151, -0.3692878782749176, -0.23840443789958954, -0.7597597241401672, -0.5444176197052002, -0.49959462881088257, 0.6681939959526062, 0.28292688727378845, 0.26984086632728577, 0.8569048047065735, 0.818601131439209, 0.13141605257987976, -0.3239741623401642, -0.054494213312864304, -0.5680739879608154, -0.3783765137195587, -0.02180575206875801, 0.5385788679122925, -1.0563913583755493, 0.6581552624702454, -0.7040796875953674, 0.9671179056167603, 0.24929334223270416, 0.2428278774023056, -0.1557646542787552, -0.2606254518032074, 0.33279597759246826, 0.5994079113006592, 0.1520676463842392, 0.48314395546913147, -0.9402591586112976, -0.0798623263835907, -0.5229238271713257, 0.19355575740337372, -0.6541649699211121, 0.3862345516681671, -0.3063579797744751, 0.15250959992408752, -0.09138426929712296, -0.07733745872974396, 0.32944002747535706, 0.8031302690505981, 0.13842368125915527, 0.4356268346309662, -0.6814409494400024, -0.6578800678253174, 0.7802731394767761, -0.025053314864635468, 0.24930311739444733, 0.3649474084377289, -0.15431618690490723, -0.19673913717269897, 0.09229472279548645, -0.436395525932312, 0.44491273164749146, -0.11553727835416794, 0.45126768946647644, -0.09550023823976517, -0.39886474609375, -0.38615450263023376, 0.39026394486427307, 0.3951147496700287, -0.08886834233999252, 0.5190839767456055, 0.8190504312515259, 0.11030806601047516, -0.19670675694942474, 0.32529011368751526, 0.24244895577430725, 0.4776049554347992, -0.37977978587150574, -0.4241725504398346, 0.33213216066360474, -0.6981988549232483, 0.013358332216739655, 0.24724799394607544, 0.6210294961929321, -0.5087162852287292, 0.32884955406188965, 0.05689699947834015, 0.27330318093299866, 0.02922959253191948, 1.2525633573532104, -0.5113874077796936, 0.13408610224723816, -0.6091020703315735, 1.0040302276611328, 0.02234645001590252, 0.5922863483428955, 0.000631659000646323, -0.8092079162597656, -0.2340587079524994, -0.16842058300971985, 0.3368235230445862, 0.25167316198349, 0.008894423954188824, -0.13069312274456024, -0.1546207070350647, 0.23595929145812988, -0.948738157749176, -0.6021355390548706, 0.18052349984645844, 0.6404876112937927, -0.09810811281204224, 0.46049195528030396, -0.1378031224012375, -0.22075678408145905, -0.32439547777175903, 0.3743012845516205, -0.21058909595012665, -0.09527036547660828, 0.7576626539230347, -0.8230225443840027, -0.1902758777141571, 0.18120203912258148, 0.5175149440765381, 0.14195388555526733, 0.8128142952919006, -0.005004442762583494, 0.2974936068058014, -0.48793575167655945, 0.1070910394191742, -0.4689316749572754, -0.006315227597951889, 0.9641760587692261, -0.5775916576385498, 0.18957749009132385, -0.47239819169044495, 0.2330397516489029, -0.479729562997818, 0.2179999202489853, -0.28481265902519226, -0.14635662734508514, -0.23213385045528412, 0.5112349987030029, -0.36183804273605347, 0.09898606687784195, -0.6844594478607178, 0.04872522130608559, -0.17547571659088135, -0.15741002559661865, 0.2501415014266968, -0.46098917722702026, 0.38540032505989075, 0.8096880912780762, -0.2784724533557892, 0.4147537052631378, -0.8549004197120667, -0.82705157995224, -0.491554856300354, -0.22978897392749786, -0.1563262641429901, 0.42241141200065613, 0.1701045036315918, 0.4628477394580841, 1.0999183654785156, 0.2980000674724579, 0.0856485515832901, -0.047343846410512924, -1.103513479232788, -0.22610929608345032, -0.08028078079223633, -0.5396096110343933, 0.3199472427368164, 0.07411319017410278, -0.4068678617477417, 0.0801931843161583, -0.36634811758995056, 0.05178601294755936, 0.29233798384666443, 0.041891247034072876, -0.4304659366607666, 0.06397687643766403, -1.1561700105667114, 0.5288397669792175, -1.0801726579666138, 0.17326472699642181, -0.9130407571792603, -0.1755952090024948, -0.35156404972076416, -0.34686747193336487, 0.4772089421749115, -0.27122175693511963, -0.6163278818130493, 0.033659908920526505, -1.0400946140289307, 0.037675853818655014, 0.6285510659217834, 0.3334398567676544, -0.5471898317337036, -0.37369099259376526, 0.9645859003067017, 0.0022921639028936625, 0.20128586888313293, 0.20851649343967438, -0.10380745679140091, 0.33005765080451965, -0.634671688079834, -0.38599687814712524, -0.16367754340171814, 0.09450729936361313, 0.6963632702827454, -0.00884194951504469, -0.25837650895118713, 1.0814119577407837, 0.5129703283309937, -0.7615790367126465, 0.1615944653749466, 0.7291924953460693, 0.056318894028663635, -0.02295650728046894, -0.06353385746479034, 0.01908978261053562, -0.1992316097021103, 0.060177505016326904, -0.31290802359580994, -0.3023340106010437, 1.0671995878219604, 0.9091507196426392, 0.11409015208482742, -0.004182709846645594, 0.11950759589672089, 0.05789600685238838, 0.545734167098999, 0.1727675497531891, -0.6213567852973938, 1.2011507749557495, 0.46878132224082947, -0.07726562023162842, -0.5666372179985046, 0.4201394021511078, -0.25939565896987915, 0.29101842641830444, -0.013485733419656754, -0.005234131123870611, -1.3777981996536255, 0.559086799621582, 0.28916090726852417, 0.24648548662662506, -0.2842421233654022, -0.41530993580818176, -0.12343176454305649, 0.23049478232860565, 0.26892444491386414, -0.38325896859169006, -0.22077986598014832, 0.17582283914089203, -1.080014705657959, 0.5048725605010986, 0.4963100254535675, -0.0878462865948677, -0.5586657524108887, -0.13888563215732574, -0.30990415811538696, 0.06287632882595062, -0.1508583128452301, -0.640813946723938, 0.06655049324035645, -0.012186525389552116, 0.924623966217041, 0.11455971002578735, -0.07821430265903473, 0.5238794088363647, -0.09073150157928467, 0.5227136015892029, -0.8738203048706055, 0.39076927304267883, -0.9026033282279968, 0.3577122986316681, -1.504333734512329, 0.15905232727527618, -0.32101505994796753, -0.5673942565917969, -0.49468788504600525, -0.16676479578018188, -0.17168478667736053, 0.768657386302948, -0.21165134012699127, 0.8070667386054993, -0.16881635785102844, -0.4697554409503937, 1.1583218574523926, 0.054030388593673706, -0.15894688665866852, -0.6555692553520203, -0.805812656879425, 0.5901777148246765, -0.4566810429096222, -0.3077695369720459, 0.4637490212917328, -0.30716371536254883, -0.4973580837249756, 0.5978788137435913, 0.09867073595523834, 1.0039260387420654, -0.1910562962293625, 0.6345765590667725, 0.7631635665893555, -0.0751723200082779, 0.5618236064910889, -0.9574002623558044, -0.8970533013343811, -0.514900267124176, -0.08648093044757843, -0.6797396540641785, 0.45561689138412476, 0.6459847092628479, 0.17743079364299774, -0.6658300757408142, 0.5660257935523987, -0.6011879444122314, -0.6048011779785156, -0.29091477394104004, 0.11520837992429733, 0.14116963744163513, -0.725508451461792, 0.035025231540203094, 0.14312192797660828, -0.01611320860683918, -0.31061235070228577, -0.02948012948036194, 0.426187664270401, 0.1998269110918045, -0.2766817808151245, 1.0730777978897095, -0.09683308750391006, 0.2075977623462677, 0.4652557671070099, 0.09014112502336502, -0.01423899456858635, 0.03910873457789421, -0.5261222124099731, -0.2228633463382721, 0.0811610221862793, 0.4876965880393982, -0.28756168484687805, -0.20222066342830658, 0.021986670792102814, -0.08307565003633499, -0.7155027985572815, -0.3358520269393921, -0.026928722858428955, 0.5615321397781372, 0.38352155685424805, -0.6966061592102051, -0.326560378074646, 0.42252272367477417, -0.15134283900260925, -0.21725648641586304, 0.18369203805923462, -1.1124769449234009, 0.060899846255779266, 0.3203994035720825, -0.891009509563446, -0.4384477436542511, -0.11654063314199448, 0.17461887001991272, 0.7032687664031982, 0.3296337425708771, 0.5800244808197021, -0.1736830174922943, -0.4376770257949829, -0.19923906028270721, 0.19719387590885162, 0.13053567707538605, 0.31466883420944214, -0.0892268568277359, 0.1266796886920929, 0.2667712867259979, -0.12457378208637238, -0.4758712351322174, -0.3037961423397064, -0.9907072186470032, 0.2752455174922943, -0.17885421216487885, -0.3953477144241333, 0.09319815784692764, 0.698373556137085, 0.7852151393890381, 0.31440892815589905, 0.31910327076911926, 0.34147343039512634, -0.884925901889801, 0.05205236375331879, 0.4062957167625427, 0.19319601356983185, -0.07734009623527527, -0.49510806798934937, 0.4518067240715027, 0.329789400100708, 0.03280370682477951, 0.20071664452552795, -0.2285127341747284, 0.056823987513780594, 0.31801772117614746, 1.073516845703125, 0.08521641790866852, 0.19054919481277466, 0.17495037615299225, 0.017840968444943428, 0.02796974405646324, -0.41340959072113037, 0.2518034279346466, 0.30012181401252747, 0.606805682182312, 0.5498548746109009, -0.4703670144081116, -0.25053057074546814, -0.7520320415496826, 0.6813281178474426, 0.08966187387704849, -0.4915255904197693, -0.6920315623283386, 0.2327754646539688, 0.08763120323419571, 0.018002761527895927, 0.5370756983757019, 0.48370441794395447, 0.6383262276649475, 0.680128812789917, 0.037367239594459534, -0.2586584985256195, 1.0031685829162598, -0.37994250655174255, 0.1821574717760086, 0.13987137377262115, 0.06752274930477142, -0.19892087578773499, 0.708034098148346, -0.18091407418251038, -0.9007876515388489, -0.099039725959301, -0.1984686255455017, 1.4317024946212769, 0.29326391220092773, -0.6942806839942932, 0.5853074193000793, 0.32508164644241333, 0.2358378767967224, 0.5226530432701111, -0.49165797233581543, 0.004764627665281296, 0.4978477358818054, -0.45551562309265137, -1.187644362449646, -0.11425791680812836, 0.30976179242134094, -0.1681598275899887, 0.4965077042579651, 0.5227115154266357, -0.054819826036691666, 0.7838562726974487, -0.1031799167394638, 0.22492432594299316, -0.12759581208229065, 0.4496171772480011, 0.08630947768688202, 0.08982552587985992, 0.061728812754154205, -0.22684016823768616, -0.1928229033946991, 0.19642119109630585, 0.4430992603302002, -0.05836695060133934, 0.2779649794101715, 0.5711666941642761, -0.5642566680908203, -0.32537615299224854, 0.011285253800451756, -0.437841534614563, 0.6097229719161987, -0.4465042054653168, -0.019845588132739067, -0.9337484240531921, -0.18396198749542236, -0.645228385925293, 0.02277386747300625, 0.07175588607788086, 0.1478472352027893, -0.03975073993206024, -0.11880117654800415, 0.05623858422040939, -0.08326108008623123, -0.6691022515296936, 1.1313631534576416, -0.42820119857788086, -0.8267151713371277, -0.30445441603660583, -0.13012151420116425, 0.185140922665596, 0.24707743525505066, 0.16393157839775085, 0.32476767897605896, 0.2480376958847046, 0.5399413704872131, -0.5072503685951233, 0.7915670871734619, -0.16164493560791016, -0.8925495147705078, 0.17053546011447906, 0.4036143720149994, 0.14999620616436005, -0.3695182204246521, -0.12641969323158264, 0.5220622420310974, 0.2572072148323059, 0.0968218594789505, -0.4543305039405823, 0.04300275817513466, 0.29304710030555725, -0.876810610294342, 0.17669644951820374, -0.5528532266616821, -0.8432490825653076, 0.04437020421028137, -0.8253857493400574, -0.0704546645283699, 0.37335386872291565, -0.0358792208135128, -0.7456560730934143, -0.3844861090183258, -0.644287645816803, -0.2097819298505783, -0.4369969069957733, -0.20074453949928284, -0.433683842420578, 0.2513121962547302, -0.8966120481491089, 1.5515782833099365, -0.838549017906189, -0.2457205057144165, 0.38435718417167664, 0.1656046360731125, 0.22391314804553986, 0.4774550497531891, -0.17472916841506958, 0.03855874761939049, -0.42473459243774414, 0.30120450258255005, 0.20110905170440674, 0.8337891697883606, 0.032656777650117874, -0.030529169365763664, -0.18308378756046295, 0.6881961822509766, -0.16094905138015747, -0.4491036832332611, -0.14987263083457947, -0.5051501989364624, 0.8705647587776184, -0.33174899220466614, 0.268331378698349, 0.621342122554779, 0.19305476546287537, 0.22533860802650452, 0.10832454264163971, -0.2520895004272461, 0.08112698793411255, -0.3569508194923401, -0.7727534174919128, 0.44678017497062683, 0.16941015422344208, -0.0714915320277214, -0.35270872712135315, -0.4064579904079437, -0.3339502811431885, -0.7727798223495483, -0.2284335047006607, 0.588573694229126, 0.06000798940658569, 0.5015305876731873, -0.5006574392318726, 0.24280773103237152, 0.18835531175136566, 0.0015614068834111094, 0.11467470973730087, -0.09176544845104218, -0.1424749344587326, -0.38371026515960693, -0.15080691874027252, -0.5934678912162781, -0.577475368976593, 0.6418741345405579, 0.3981780409812927, -0.12332973629236221, 1.1753357648849487, 0.04382292181253433, 0.11832256615161896, -0.14319095015525818, 0.2984985411167145, 0.2259303629398346, -0.303512305021286, 0.37169602513313293, 0.26709872484207153, 0.07526645809412003, 0.44094839692115784, -0.2498907893896103, -0.6814879775047302, -0.5827070474624634, 0.9521512389183044, -0.5447214841842651, 0.11565586179494858, 0.6180030703544617, 0.10354074090719223, -0.344917356967926, -0.4612009823322296, -1.0687206983566284, 0.2298734188079834, 0.2822159230709076, -0.7252273559570312, -0.16730451583862305, -0.07365851104259491, -1.0651535987854004, 0.22384963929653168, 0.26041823625564575, -0.09328841418027878, 0.34928202629089355, -0.023407841101288795, 0.33229634165763855, -0.5853809714317322, -0.5313906073570251, 0.8780825734138489, 0.6933231949806213, -0.536989688873291, 0.14837266504764557, -0.09684266895055771, -0.22398366034030914, -0.3034389317035675, 1.0953397750854492, -0.5715412497520447, -0.08293550461530685, -0.021991189569234848, 0.21987417340278625, -0.47375595569610596, 0.189130038022995, -0.11066588014364243, 0.07185668498277664, -0.4643661081790924, -0.31574547290802, 0.00147963163908571, -0.05641321465373039, 0.3772692382335663, 0.5860653519630432, 0.18142934143543243, 0.06906402856111526, -0.1001032143831253, -0.6056357026100159, 0.306596577167511, -0.19328752160072327, -0.3538355231285095, -0.6165676116943359, -0.9961829781532288, -0.7111844420433044, -0.15457451343536377, -0.02759876847267151, 1.1292716264724731, 0.08174117654561996, 0.4144860804080963, -0.07316477596759796, 0.7606993317604065, -0.12620709836483002, 0.3030052185058594, 0.12393896281719208, -0.5134921073913574, -0.26017147302627563, 0.14902882277965546, -0.13339029252529144, -0.8197491765022278, 0.2788463532924652, -0.09484707564115524, -0.10377206653356552, 1.1690267324447632, 0.20725876092910767, 0.2981346547603607, -0.2918298840522766, -0.7792086601257324, 0.5857604742050171, -0.1419636756181717, -1.021019697189331, 0.7091577053070068, -0.5758189558982849, 1.3127362728118896, 0.5600600242614746, -1.204808235168457, -0.4187420904636383, 0.025678439065814018, -1.3688621520996094, 0.8403489589691162, 0.14704596996307373, 0.9321655631065369, -0.39875057339668274, -0.5194726586341858, -0.0487016960978508, 0.5980571508407593, -1.2282005548477173, -0.3089286684989929, 0.18747352063655853, 0.7847649455070496, -0.5630545616149902, 0.15289483964443207, -0.18445146083831787, 0.14305752515792847, -0.34384074807167053, -0.3374648988246918, -0.8134281635284424, 0.19765496253967285, -0.19169895350933075, 0.05042629316449165, -0.526924729347229, -0.4597250819206238, 0.18948087096214294, -0.8769627809524536, 0.1647336184978485, 0.38106852769851685, -0.07903999835252762, -0.2473381757736206, -0.3267533481121063, -0.2753645181655884, -0.06964141875505447, 0.16271214187145233, -0.5896627902984619, 1.170456051826477, -0.019880017265677452, 0.05702126398682594, 0.23761700093746185, -0.11838270723819733, -1.285366415977478, 0.5144420862197876, -0.18931891024112701, -0.43366801738739014, 0.24576790630817413, 0.1353527456521988, -0.14165906608104706, 0.09320022910833359, 0.0007645805599167943, 0.05629555508494377, 0.4160131514072418, 0.17447584867477417, 0.5929749608039856, 0.06740526109933853, -0.5708338022232056, 0.20920680463314056, -1.013137936592102, -0.45026934146881104, -0.6071988940238953, 0.12774111330509186, -0.6717107892036438, -0.6172780990600586, -0.030514653772115707, -0.007238414138555527, 0.1686745136976242, -0.03464159741997719, 0.31444695591926575, -0.08598046749830246, -0.2348545342683792, -0.16580377519130707, -0.909993588924408, -0.20143811404705048, -0.33262506127357483, 0.6286956071853638, -0.43261173367500305, -0.06438956409692764, 0.24566367268562317, -0.36349475383758545, 0.6954939961433411, 0.08628959953784943, -0.3495737910270691, 0.7302037477493286, 0.1616770476102829, -0.31054285168647766, 0.07047472894191742, 0.7170701622962952, 0.3774541914463043, 0.43413710594177246, -0.4018811285495758, 0.2523078918457031, 0.559968113899231, -0.20472481846809387, 0.34959790110588074, -0.38483551144599915, -0.20862187445163727, 0.2919454574584961, -0.1129811555147171, -0.12764695286750793, 0.06707307696342468, -0.14498552680015564, 0.11275531351566315, 0.13512249290943146, -0.4107881188392639, -0.29503098130226135, -0.17608481645584106, 0.3416629731655121, 0.14269667863845825, 0.16056136786937714, -0.09162624180316925, -0.789615273475647, -0.11899445205926895, 0.717674732208252, -0.4654577970504761, -1.1244328022003174, -0.18594999611377716, 0.35918736457824707, 0.330270916223526, -0.27534934878349304, 0.07662282139062881, 0.6736153960227966, 0.15840750932693481, 0.3159758448600769, 0.2521771788597107, 0.39618274569511414, 0.13692882657051086, 0.7032161355018616, 0.33522212505340576, 0.12008502334356308, -0.026319991797208786, 0.5139890909194946, 0.03862321749329567, -0.8810344934463501, 0.011575938202440739, -0.0648336261510849, -0.23379351198673248, -0.04663222283124924, 0.46156492829322815, -0.35839512944221497, -0.27062320709228516, -0.6436526775360107, 0.4243479371070862, -0.8105623126029968, -0.00007776485290378332, 0.40267568826675415, -0.8689644932746887, 0.22902455925941467, 0.6611359119415283, 0.19496160745620728, 0.054688118398189545, 0.33080339431762695, 0.07249794155359268, 0.5942012667655945, 1.346032738685608, 0.91009521484375, 0.2599042057991028, 0.08574461191892624, -0.2135343998670578, -0.6497295498847961, 0.0464911125600338, 0.6250630021095276, -0.7194536924362183, 0.45180603861808777, -0.8249090909957886, 0.70456862449646, -0.029352359473705292, 0.08999072015285492, -0.4741450548171997, -0.3967116177082062, 0.7170966863632202, 0.34916481375694275, -0.41563767194747925, 0.09886917471885681, 0.3641205132007599, 0.27218225598335266, 0.7551929354667664, -0.6289123892784119, 0.5995315909385681, -0.9127421975135803, 0.1595863550901413, -0.4039469361305237, 0.0982474833726883, -0.525780439376831, -0.08894277364015579, -0.8191238045692444, -0.344512403011322, -0.3537915050983429, -0.5600413084030151, -0.17402219772338867, -0.27877354621887207, 0.16924667358398438, 0.7662574052810669, 0.19309154152870178, 0.033784449100494385, -0.2588517963886261, -0.7817229628562927, 0.018043965101242065, 0.6687485575675964, -0.2070821076631546, 0.2647877335548401, 0.6681687831878662, 0.41951504349708557, -1.1963460445404053, 0.7358487844467163, 0.6161534190177917, -0.46877360343933105, 0.6360182762145996, -0.17549672722816467, 0.43351414799690247, 0.013157854788005352, -0.6507524847984314, 0.5544365048408508, 0.2754945755004883, 0.38388314843177795, 0.4702875316143036, -0.7394220232963562, 0.06844639033079147, 0.043997857719659805, -0.7029235363006592, -0.1877451390028, 0.5784698128700256, 0.4910396635532379, -0.2657075524330139, -0.11269944906234741, -0.7819840908050537, 4.405937671661377, 0.21706949174404144, 0.2679440379142761, -0.36115390062332153, 0.5444312691688538, 0.35080456733703613, 0.5622883439064026, -0.31770896911621094, 0.13185928761959076, -0.7473479509353638, 0.05597708001732826, 0.02408301644027233, 0.3588191270828247, -0.019219083711504936, 0.6898260712623596, 0.34852713346481323, -0.040019478648900986, -0.2459631711244583, 0.07846818119287491, -0.30188071727752686, -0.7779678702354431, -0.15046437084674835, -0.2060910314321518, -0.23694296181201935, 0.9243305921554565, 0.4797244966030121, 0.32985571026802063, -0.3620023727416992, -0.5207734107971191, -0.39442694187164307, -0.3987827003002167, -0.20440347492694855, -0.14508016407489777, -0.7853671312332153, -0.5649480819702148, -0.012440971098840237, -0.48292967677116394, -0.015015237964689732, 0.5300396680831909, -0.2258162647485733, -0.19981013238430023, -0.9737403392791748, 0.456754595041275, -0.38366618752479553, 0.0008949396433308721, 0.9650139212608337, 0.42829740047454834, 0.5268675088882446, 0.4463534653186798, -0.6041033864021301, 0.006081175059080124, 0.2802540957927704, 0.08989603817462921, 0.13091562688350677, -0.8758053183555603, 0.13828398287296295, 0.013568178750574589, -0.48061424493789673, -0.2649518847465515, -0.36673349142074585, 0.9081746339797974, -0.03479882702231407, -0.30975693464279175, 0.5396765470504761, 0.02888726070523262, 0.3797414004802704, -0.31473085284233093, 0.029210280627012253, -0.5614709258079529, 0.25151705741882324, -1.064537763595581, -0.058389656245708466, -0.6549050807952881, -0.5321680307388306, 0.6773803234100342, -0.22521375119686127, -0.032353490591049194, -0.17550094425678253, -0.1889668107032776, 0.4356100559234619, -0.5087576508522034, 0.16120727360248566, -0.5527775287628174, 0.1774977594614029, -0.03929334878921509, 0.7907398343086243, -0.5812104940414429, -0.00027511827647686005, -0.1438453644514084, 0.17124471068382263, -0.05520050227642059, 0.6000375151634216, -0.4788896441459656, -0.20114468038082123, -0.49523651599884033 ]
Dark Matter and Non-Newtonian Gravity From General Relativity on a Stringy Background
An exact solution of Einstein's field equations for a static spherically symmetric medium with a radially boost invariant energy-momentum tensor is presented. In the limit of an equation of state corresponding to a distribution of radially directed strings there is a $1/r$ correction to Newton's force law. At large distances and small accelerations this law coincides with the phenomenological force law invented by Milgrom in order to explain the flat rotation curves of galaxies without introducing dark matter. The present model explaines why the critical acceleration of Milgrom is of the same order of magnitude as the Hubble parameter.
Harald H. Soleng
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212005
gr-qc/9212006
[ 0.35219278931617737, 0.4220193922519684, 0.645540714263916, -0.5457991361618042, -0.055372923612594604, 0.060721199959516525, -0.1576441079378128, -0.08469090610742569, -1.130644679069519, 1.9584009647369385, 1.3572736978530884, -0.3729102313518524, -0.0712776780128479, -0.7089975476264954, -0.13843044638633728, 0.42347291111946106, 0.04035227745771408, -0.0681995302438736, -1.2379258871078491, 0.3692009747028351, -0.5248358845710754, 0.15179596841335297, -0.8230760097503662, -0.6577966213226318, -0.8799194693565369, 1.1610305309295654, 0.18684569001197815, 0.23973578214645386, 1.086087942123413, 0.7413503527641296, 0.6339782476425171, 0.2050289511680603, -0.23328101634979248, -0.550560712814331, -0.20440827310085297, -0.5959246754646301, 0.07767769694328308, -0.5214329361915588, 0.7029678225517273, -0.48498693108558655, 0.4051832854747772, -0.442337304353714, 0.15676429867744446, 0.11916559934616089, -0.7028998732566833, -0.019435932859778404, -0.39037302136421204, -0.432952344417572, -0.590385377407074, -1.156654715538025, 0.16765005886554718, -0.2533637285232544, 0.5188672542572021, -1.0498648881912231, 0.23364920914173126, -0.5987475514411926, -0.4575212299823761, 0.2817259430885315, -0.3735333979129791, -0.1869068592786789, 0.4401804208755493, 0.7436410784721375, 1.3290643692016602, -0.39941316843032837, 0.18916575610637665, 1.4685765504837036, 0.2527182400226593, 0.23916500806808472, 0.362052857875824, -0.35604429244995117, -0.5856757164001465, -0.3581755757331848, -0.5353764295578003, -0.18220223486423492, -0.5662880539894104, 0.487990140914917, 0.0743882805109024, -0.30957868695259094, -0.9545189738273621, -0.8532971739768982, 0.6171505451202393, -0.12641960382461548, -0.3165888488292694, 0.05214506387710571, 0.4066110849380493, -0.08894701302051544, 0.2624962031841278, -0.3160405158996582, 0.26763930916786194, 0.4444293975830078, 0.3768375813961029, 0.6872247457504272, -0.299506813287735, 0.048486560583114624, 0.6037176251411438, 0.858270525932312, -0.2612813711166382, 0.5626204013824463, 0.6544933915138245, 0.6758432984352112, -0.17329134047031403, 0.9433321356773376, -0.09906259179115295, 0.2587619721889496, -0.5599775910377502, 0.9432165622711182, -0.7117679119110107, 0.42019328474998474, -0.407939076423645, -0.9249828457832336, -0.08408518880605698, 0.227630615234375, 0.7817283272743225, 0.135830819606781, -0.14913073182106018, 0.8669447302818298, -0.3874565660953522, 0.2489541620016098, -0.959459662437439, -0.9697949886322021, -0.3386032283306122, 0.7392086386680603, 0.13889022171497345, 0.42442786693573, -0.3521387577056885, -0.9727106690406799, -0.2279490977525711, 0.10037966817617416, -0.6036584377288818, 0.45711278915405273, -0.013794613070786, -0.6893205046653748, -0.5396784543991089, 0.2498922199010849, -0.05644926428794861, 0.6104611158370972, 0.4019584357738495, 0.20600180327892303, -0.6014333367347717, -0.7920599579811096, 0.18476834893226624, -0.09179683029651642, -0.05254063382744789, 1.1344627141952515, -0.6252796053886414, 0.5523176193237305, -0.22160592675209045, 0.22334451973438263, -0.6331912279129028, -0.3550306558609009, -0.09008600562810898, -0.1694362312555313, 0.402197927236557, 0.26156187057495117, -0.31676608324050903, -0.03359736129641533, -1.3779855966567993, 0.2666459381580353, -0.6262261271476746, -0.6610048413276672, -0.13988298177719116, 0.389921635389328, 0.4824956953525543, 1.0207308530807495, -0.8735912442207336, 0.5769655704498291, -0.6986050605773926, -0.29339084029197693, -0.030514324083924294, -0.18155059218406677, -0.18091508746147156, 0.07130777835845947, -0.3972056210041046, 0.21651691198349, 0.37945556640625, 0.7806138396263123, 0.6113027334213257, 0.40051624178886414, -0.1135282963514328, 0.18070782721042633, -0.434758722782135, -0.2302878201007843, 0.7140349745750427, 0.49972328543663025, -1.0723377466201782, -0.3354146480560303, -0.3737490475177765, -0.41512444615364075, 0.5103469491004944, 0.519741415977478, -0.8209121227264404, 0.4986467659473419, -1.4511067867279053, 0.25904208421707153, -0.9015362858772278, 0.3825075030326843, -1.4531378746032715, 0.060189954936504364, 0.7256181836128235, -0.8554895520210266, 0.13622619211673737, 0.45343419909477234, -0.8831512331962585, 0.3008253872394562, -1.101224422454834, 0.34786131978034973, 0.11761056631803513, 0.7650418281555176, 0.0692492350935936, -0.1231100782752037, -0.005035371985286474, 0.03560473769903183, 0.14807477593421936, -0.2363940179347992, 0.3553045988082886, -0.4414275586605072, 0.32224196195602417, 0.4881502389907837, 0.20633810758590698, -0.3911648392677307, 0.4486962556838989, 0.1313360184431076, 0.1592406928539276, 1.1573541164398193, -0.1014154925942421, -0.09930209070444107, 0.48756521940231323, 0.5864972472190857, -0.27911141514778137, 0.35232895612716675, 0.023614833131432533, 0.10789895057678223, 0.25019019842147827, 0.5106534361839294, 0.29563966393470764, -0.2368943989276886, 1.079424500465393, 1.2802660465240479, -0.8256638646125793, -0.00016397731087636203, 0.3904300034046173, -0.07907712459564209, 0.688575804233551, -0.08496889472007751, -0.9224510192871094, 0.2077595442533493, -0.23113244771957397, 0.2525068521499634, 0.153135284781456, 0.8216423392295837, -0.7656129002571106, 0.7618567943572998, -0.18632729351520538, 0.34263092279434204, -0.9962352514266968, 0.5392031669616699, -0.2806622087955475, 0.6308370232582092, -0.20807407796382904, -0.6631894707679749, -0.8353930711746216, 0.2519226670265198, -0.03899543732404709, -0.783252477645874, -0.2896888554096222, 0.5838706493377686, -0.7374964952468872, 0.2707802951335907, 0.48254770040512085, -0.10231326520442963, -0.9695999026298523, -0.16749195754528046, -0.34135425090789795, 0.2862360179424286, -0.352538526058197, 0.25126349925994873, -0.17908449470996857, -0.41581669449806213, 0.5568416714668274, 0.23170217871665955, 0.18652942776679993, 0.5768589377403259, 0.49370887875556946, 0.16637614369392395, -0.2549313008785248, 0.15334680676460266, -1.3635597229003906, 0.012221609242260456, -1.2252485752105713, 0.4361855983734131, -0.2963375747203827, -0.8318082690238953, -0.38116949796676636, -0.5888533592224121, 0.2279161512851715, 0.5761092305183411, -0.42558032274246216, -0.14063121378421783, -0.10751386731863022, -0.22657452523708344, 0.786516547203064, 0.5357573628425598, 0.03223264217376709, -0.40631428360939026, -0.5226253271102905, 0.8667762875556946, -0.4421605169773102, 0.15042351186275482, 1.1816312074661255, -0.3647197186946869, -0.31399136781692505, 0.8620191812515259, -0.0036000744439661503, 0.6234128475189209, -0.24729536473751068, 0.424129843711853, 0.6588663458824158, -0.06775905191898346, 0.47448980808258057, -0.4810246527194977, -0.33319786190986633, -0.09383783489465714, 0.9129790663719177, -0.5883124470710754, 0.6845696568489075, 0.7248249650001526, 0.5099372267723083, -1.2582509517669678, 0.07093317806720734, -1.1502163410186768, -0.8486528396606445, -0.2535889148712158, -0.4121692478656769, 0.017631160095334053, -0.05641606077551842, 0.06394445151090622, -0.3906187117099762, -0.37483304738998413, -0.3621115982532501, 0.8508771061897278, 0.6976943016052246, -0.365911066532135, 0.31077566742897034, 0.5786139369010925, 0.14645931124687195, 0.38107091188430786, 1.0183905363082886, -0.2348165661096573, -0.8384217619895935, 0.593880832195282, 0.1683199256658554, 0.6136227250099182, 0.233476459980011, -0.02266533114016056, -0.2503598928451538, 0.20993950963020325, -0.34023240208625793, -0.38099756836891174, -0.4627608060836792, -1.0406898260116577, -0.15952038764953613, 0.042496953159570694, -0.08094000071287155, -0.012054365128278732, -0.5274040102958679, -0.27392590045928955, -0.5128482580184937, -0.055616602301597595, 0.47403332591056824, -1.45491623878479, 0.19619636237621307, 0.7421877980232239, -0.8188473582267761, -0.20102019608020782, -0.01075498852878809, 0.396774023771286, 0.41676634550094604, 0.4606439471244812, -0.20408523082733154, -0.8413006067276001, -0.4549405872821808, -0.48075395822525024, 0.6943722367286682, 0.5740579962730408, 0.3610556125640869, -0.3165471851825714, -0.9000614285469055, 0.053077343851327896, -0.010647227987647057, -0.6355976462364197, -0.014233581721782684, -0.7931476831436157, 0.1009768471121788, -0.8799207210540771, -0.7261269092559814, 0.10266328603029251, 0.46512821316719055, 0.6410462260246277, 0.2406035214662552, -0.009476647712290287, 0.21956181526184082, 0.13133461773395538, -0.23367832601070404, 0.537166178226471, -0.13088253140449524, 0.13947772979736328, -0.8875700235366821, 0.8974016308784485, -0.22537079453468323, 0.6923193335533142, 0.36452123522758484, -0.41013193130493164, 0.21457864344120026, -0.30702343583106995, 0.5474481582641602, 0.20227187871932983, -0.231521874666214, 0.7419520616531372, 0.2995378375053406, -0.07640700787305832, -0.8152620792388916, 0.1226709708571434, -0.027201641350984573, 0.5082536935806274, -0.33314213156700134, -1.229284644126892, 0.44615253806114197, -0.36172863841056824, 0.10589417070150375, 0.28492867946624756, -0.21530002355575562, -1.2714638710021973, -0.6125254034996033, 0.14988063275814056, 0.26062214374542236, 0.35753244161605835, 0.46653416752815247, -0.3647070527076721, 0.2247656285762787, -0.3774314522743225, 0.2786523401737213, 0.7216954827308655, -0.5926680564880371, -0.630826473236084, -0.7228102684020996, 0.438528835773468, -0.6268168687820435, 0.7729566693305969, -0.3586660921573639, -1.5309916734695435, -0.0593092255294323, -0.5176092386245728, 0.7644275426864624, -0.47609639167785645, -0.1646263599395752, 0.18735158443450928, 0.33140257000923157, 0.00882557313889265, 0.14781399071216583, -0.27534353733062744, 0.47449228167533875, 0.40451163053512573, -0.01885358616709709, -1.0285675525665283, -0.07155419886112213, -0.12471292167901993, -0.09143596887588501, 0.9827042818069458, 0.49202269315719604, 0.30333247780799866, 1.1766828298568726, 0.3991820514202118, -0.4418564438819885, -0.2649415135383606, 0.7975242733955383, -0.03722938522696495, -0.022179529070854187, 0.4779461622238159, -0.15791533887386322, -0.7510942816734314, -0.06520498543977737, 0.4274224042892456, -0.6637630462646484, 0.5351430773735046, -0.26134952902793884, -1.1982988119125366, -0.41062048077583313, -0.2861139476299286, -0.502001166343689, 0.32048559188842773, -0.10289161652326584, -0.6086869835853577, -0.0857354924082756, 0.2046239823102951, 0.059118323028087616, 0.2500249147415161, -0.6656594276428223, -0.9409918189048767, -0.5714244842529297, 0.43783625960350037, -0.24722011387348175, 0.702968418598175, -0.6918438673019409, 0.1721174269914627, -0.4093915522098541, -0.4754384458065033, -1.102787733078003, -0.2541312575340271, -0.19348005950450897, 0.700965166091919, -0.23237299919128418, -0.5595362186431885, 0.3464773893356323, -0.15352557599544525, -0.3837829828262329, 0.39684468507766724, -0.27584490180015564, -0.7850324511528015, -0.17062024772167206, 0.8434957265853882, 0.46287843585014343, -0.5533970594406128, 0.2496906965970993, 0.7782695293426514, -0.4336416721343994, 0.5946570038795471, 0.20024310052394867, -0.29457947611808777, 0.37345996499061584, -1.0052496194839478, 0.5616046786308289, -0.7585029602050781, 0.15941500663757324, -0.138504296541214, -0.3306032717227936, 0.1648804396390915, 0.24751776456832886, -0.21517637372016907, -0.10115856677293777, -0.12276270985603333, -0.49287495017051697, 0.41230008006095886, -0.10576518625020981, -0.1881159096956253, -0.19149528443813324, 0.1731879562139511, -0.04451358690857887, 1.1633737087249756, -1.029569387435913, -0.16682957112789154, 0.10914810001850128, -0.06112050637602806, -0.8530862927436829, 1.1159915924072266, -0.296781450510025, -0.2155706137418747, -0.3549449145793915, 0.15854929387569427, 0.7370790839195251, -0.14386531710624695, -0.4367656707763672, 0.4985409080982208, -0.6196399331092834, 0.8302538990974426, -0.21419034898281097, 0.394490122795105, 0.6845546960830688, 0.40142688155174255, 0.9153769612312317, -0.924332320690155, 0.2849683165550232, 0.5859614610671997, 0.6377136707305908, 0.39254385232925415, 0.02258840762078762, -0.451724648475647, -0.07097233831882477, -1.3170262575149536, -1.163228988647461, 0.9490711688995361, 0.34624454379081726, -0.2322119027376175, -0.2373826801776886, -0.6818288564682007, 0.13044817745685577, -0.5624150633811951, 0.051491327583789825, 0.09411964565515518, 0.15785115957260132, 0.24559617042541504, -0.3077479600906372, 0.10169339179992676, 0.016041798517107964, -0.08546102046966553, 0.019705114886164665, 0.147878035902977, 0.511240541934967, -0.7444220781326294, -0.10685139894485474, -0.8613544702529907, -0.3468106985092163, 0.4979366064071655, 0.9791877269744873, 0.052554093301296234, 0.6668588519096375, -0.04212250933051109, -0.624297022819519, -0.6425575613975525, -0.1507549285888672, 0.3915465474128723, -0.2581022083759308, 0.28885453939437866, 0.19010035693645477, 0.23828165233135223, 0.21421973407268524, 0.2298567146062851, -1.0875521898269653, -0.6049326658248901, 0.9255785942077637, -0.3233388066291809, -0.14324185252189636, 0.6936168074607849, 0.43790966272354126, -0.4123120903968811, -1.0997859239578247, -1.789087176322937, -0.3967745006084442, 0.6767765283584595, -0.7246568202972412, 0.15416023135185242, 0.28322723507881165, -0.15854650735855103, 0.278105229139328, 0.3061037063598633, 1.0448753833770752, 0.35981592535972595, 0.4845130741596222, 0.09296874701976776, 0.03388546034693718, 0.23017239570617676, 0.924383282661438, 0.1987939029932022, -0.8714101314544678, -0.4306364357471466, -0.23219852149486542, -0.7546008825302124, -0.02225063182413578, 0.837407112121582, -0.3029564321041107, 0.1866176277399063, 0.04256562516093254, 0.25076913833618164, 0.688853919506073, -0.12909021973609924, -0.1632804274559021, -0.4089048206806183, -0.6621130108833313, -0.6748493909835815, -0.018779944628477097, 0.37160077691078186, 0.13984811305999756, 0.5731000304222107, -0.29960405826568604, -0.354816734790802, -0.2935161888599396, -0.10438856482505798, -0.03302842751145363, -0.9210046529769897, -0.40357205271720886, -1.5056612491607666, -0.40154075622558594, -0.9975796937942505, -0.05640406534075737, -0.24523651599884033, 0.2905086874961853, -0.48288679122924805, 1.256274700164795, 0.12202553451061249, 0.14788614213466644, -0.5681078433990479, 0.7893641591072083, -0.11041063815355301, 0.07142574340105057, -0.4658472239971161, 0.2695508599281311, 0.10696430504322052, -1.0735055208206177, -0.4495774507522583, -0.22150735557079315, 0.02878858894109726, 1.2715975046157837, -0.6929815411567688, 0.2227696180343628, -0.7532591819763184, -0.3757283091545105, 0.22969618439674377, 0.010222511366009712, -0.7245978116989136, 0.7275388240814209, -0.9188888072967529, 0.4508904814720154, 0.04310955852270126, 0.7262661457061768, -0.027002526447176933, -0.022701332345604897, -1.4213738441467285, 0.11507143825292587, 0.32088151574134827, 0.27811935544013977, 0.1704198271036148, -0.5258143544197083, 0.6883045434951782, 0.05225236713886261, -1.0812029838562012, 0.16168349981307983, -0.4297170042991638, 0.454541951417923, 0.30258986353874207, 0.3924688994884491, -0.04982484504580498, 0.5295928716659546, -0.11706137657165527, 0.20759792625904083, -0.33887410163879395, 0.05059637874364853, 0.19575370848178864, 0.3355581760406494, -0.18284572660923004, -0.5796942710876465, -0.05060996487736702, -0.6241083145141602, 0.07186181098222733, 0.8527787923812866, 0.027532227337360382, 0.3562847375869751, -0.6556063890457153, -0.13104239106178284, -0.4305424690246582, 0.13653524219989777, -0.987401008605957, 1.1671347618103027, -0.03328811749815941, 0.21665534377098083, 0.592982292175293, -0.1383523941040039, -0.9115078449249268, 0.4031922519207001, -0.3170187175273895, -0.3512592613697052, 0.054393086582422256, 0.4480806291103363, -0.3425927460193634, -0.017800290137529373, -0.5208449959754944, 0.1364910900592804, 0.39052265882492065, 0.8215749859809875, 1.0195454359054565, 0.26064810156822205, -0.06933912634849548, 0.4789138734340668, -0.5846357345581055, -0.28914257884025574, -0.004219312220811844, 0.5701451897621155, -0.35623541474342346, -0.28522399067878723, 0.08999073505401611, 0.45497462153434753, -0.4239300489425659, -0.07309817522764206, 0.387838751077652, 0.44288137555122375, 0.34174972772598267, -0.39869803190231323, 0.17434963583946228, 0.26373034715652466, -0.35449960827827454, 0.7730035185813904, 0.50423663854599, -0.5564855933189392, 0.5973870158195496, 0.3098013401031494, 0.30618393421173096, 0.04115082696080208, 0.07748223096132278, 1.2365336418151855, -0.16315723955631256, 0.07356392592191696, 0.5874680876731873, 0.0689430758357048, 0.7055054306983948, 0.3181757926940918, 0.2624296545982361, 0.12161847949028015, 0.671859860420227, 0.4822659492492676, 0.6977024078369141, 0.09767887741327286, 0.05525849759578705, 0.7311879396438599, 0.36673328280448914, 0.3627508580684662, 0.2466335892677307, -0.05502725765109062, -0.23981483280658722, 0.3535849452018738, -0.3969414234161377, 0.2244783490896225, -0.2772233188152313, 0.04324924573302269, 0.0641210526227951, 0.4136750400066376, 0.05286521837115288, -0.22485914826393127, -0.18754474818706512, 0.40011849999427795, -0.1732877790927887, -0.7344105243682861, -1.1355743408203125, 0.24503450095653534, 0.11466867476701736, -0.03658365458250046, -0.03198542073369026, 0.6465178728103638, 0.4900490343570709, -0.07451864331960678, -0.2557908296585083, 0.11811193078756332, 0.5130892395973206, -0.08872389048337936, 0.6864064931869507, 0.5935705900192261, 0.689428985118866, 0.30991125106811523, 0.7309395670890808, -0.8728045225143433, 0.30948951840400696, 0.1484043300151825, -1.0426265001296997, -0.1267896294593811, -0.02563367784023285, -0.35153019428253174, -0.14881901443004608, -0.768689751625061, 0.27246832847595215, -0.5048465728759766, 0.08620965480804443, 0.023358382284641266, -0.30084899067878723, -0.19453401863574982, 0.3017702102661133, -0.536113440990448, 0.2000630497932434, 0.4857981204986572, 0.4180862605571747, -0.25271373987197876, -0.11962128430604935, 0.9034934043884277, -0.13590054214000702, 0.42833632230758667, -0.33605697751045227, 0.348558247089386, 0.9963152408599854, 0.33561208844184875, -0.8123500943183899, 0.5373125672340393, -0.14696066081523895, -0.21434351801872253, 0.10177237540483475, 0.08989601582288742, -0.3878316879272461, 0.09714341163635254, -0.10098370164632797, 0.3822803795337677, 0.18108020722866058, -0.010907550342381, 0.17050166428089142, 1.1223664283752441, -0.6117269992828369, -0.2791890501976013, 0.13310381770133972, -0.9852136969566345, 0.11600107699632645, -0.7399956583976746, 0.41819703578948975, 0.08845005184412003, 0.08942096680402756, -0.4246019124984741, -0.16460998356342316, -0.5414832830429077, -0.43401259183883667, -0.20943205058574677, -0.5216192603111267, 0.3307320773601532, 0.7394037842750549, -0.054278355091810226, 0.49023908376693726, -0.2323722094297409, -0.1958771049976349, -0.29114383459091187, 1.1523603200912476, -0.09795717895030975, 0.025800315663218498, 0.4731016457080841, 0.009316305629909039, -0.9352086186408997, 0.9207738637924194, 0.7819477915763855, -0.244782492518425, 0.6156812310218811, -0.533907413482666, 0.29248911142349243, 0.6360228657722473, 0.09616739302873611, 0.31020423769950867, 0.26410651206970215, 0.8844074010848999, -0.3637133836746216, -0.505525529384613, 0.2968023717403412, -0.5450045466423035, -0.23213376104831696, -0.7495090365409851, 0.7750831842422485, -0.21661941707134247, -0.050651781260967255, 0.9987717270851135, -1.1110347509384155, 3.908210515975952, 0.7635515332221985, 0.8847931027412415, -0.07168973237276077, 1.1033319234848022, 1.0060176849365234, -0.3171047866344452, -0.20969073474407196, 0.4445473253726959, -0.5580453872680664, -0.12178342789411545, 0.7773032188415527, -0.32252898812294006, 0.11783395707607269, -0.0011548881884664297, 0.6994885802268982, 0.4353976547718048, -0.46331465244293213, -0.9923685789108276, -0.14604607224464417, -0.9594170451164246, 0.7248165607452393, -0.08585850149393082, -0.47611674666404724, 0.15208560228347778, 0.7955048680305481, 0.497717946767807, -0.6829204559326172, -0.3591156303882599, -0.5011615753173828, -0.23687636852264404, -0.15083283185958862, -0.470927894115448, -0.6045677065849304, -1.5789381265640259, 0.3438641428947449, -0.5283691883087158, -0.24326501786708832, 0.4037315845489502, 0.031134217977523804, 0.6766587495803833, -0.46139225363731384, 0.18606463074684143, -0.5709317326545715, 0.06978432834148407, 0.4472488760948181, 0.40327349305152893, 0.44564947485923767, 0.5410433411598206, -0.7658503651618958, 0.027821313589811325, 0.20509138703346252, 0.6036064624786377, -1.3570265769958496, -0.6813671588897705, -0.5637428760528564, 0.03736765682697296, -0.5346401929855347, 0.08292051404714584, -0.026688361540436745, 0.562464714050293, -0.4982369542121887, 0.20660436153411865, -0.4510270953178406, 0.8012955188751221, 0.3406713604927063, 0.4860982298851013, 0.21205686032772064, -0.24089787900447845, -0.3126811981201172, -0.28831884264945984, 0.05285826325416565, -0.688630223274231, -0.6611414551734924, -0.10054060816764832, -0.25484931468963623, 0.5213475227355957, 0.5447061061859131, -0.37698623538017273, 0.43312153220176697, -0.8245821595191956, 0.16817504167556763, -0.5565842986106873, 0.8501774668693542, 0.06350355595350266, 0.28399360179901123, 0.5469610095024109, -0.6380680799484253, -0.7129946351051331, 0.4940289258956909, 0.10777408629655838, 0.9050124883651733, -0.6575751304626465, 0.2570827901363373, -0.43467652797698975 ]
On Cosmological Isotropy, Quantum Cosmology and the Weyl Curvature Hypothesis
The increasing entropy, large-scale isotropy and approximate flatness of the universe are considered in the context of signature change, which is a classical model of quantum tunnelling in quantum cosmology. The signature change hypothesis implies an initial inflationary epoch, the magnetic half of the Weyl curvature hypothesis, and a close analogue of the conformal singularity hypothesis. Adding the electric half of the Weyl curvature hypothesis yields, for a perfect fluid, only homogeneous and isotropic cosmologies. In the cosmological-constant case, the unique solution is the Vilenkin tunnelling solution, which gives a de Sitter cosmology.
Sean A. Hayward
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212006
gr-qc/9212007
[ 0.29656049609184265, 0.05463554710149765, 0.2611553370952606, 0.09821498394012451, -0.13068193197250366, -0.25119444727897644, -0.4015836715698242, -0.18817727267742157, 0.20012781023979187, 1.5247737169265747, 1.1071144342422485, -0.34288638830184937, -0.41715818643569946, -0.8041934370994568, -0.8803554773330688, 0.5262018442153931, 0.10301709920167923, -0.5498250722885132, -1.201920747756958, 0.3478674590587616, -0.20517019927501678, -0.04136570543050766, -0.7538283467292786, -0.7546253800392151, -0.32767871022224426, 0.9381565451622009, -0.20277467370033264, 0.3232978582382202, 0.7918190360069275, 0.9177255630493164, 0.34732717275619507, -0.32010209560394287, -0.10460282862186432, -0.7455887794494629, -0.1783614456653595, -0.6418989300727844, 0.06765968352556229, -0.8733015060424805, 0.6118344664573669, -0.7245588302612305, 0.04010775685310364, 0.027293981984257698, 0.1735413670539856, -0.4439685642719269, -0.343826562166214, -0.19698978960514069, 0.12248577922582626, 0.3087998926639557, 0.18864059448242188, -0.6798487305641174, -0.008704796433448792, -0.6038228869438171, 0.20662683248519897, -0.8015279769897461, -0.18183356523513794, -0.32851627469062805, 0.7215377688407898, 0.22029562294483185, -0.8628365993499756, -0.022291578352451324, -0.02078111097216606, 0.6509166359901428, -0.05245474725961685, -0.6521949768066406, -0.6778299808502197, 0.7518179416656494, -0.1934385448694229, 0.4454460144042969, 0.20436786115169525, -0.7968851327896118, -0.6773731708526611, -0.2062085121870041, 0.364298015832901, 0.043224237859249115, -0.4973759651184082, 0.5321244597434998, -0.32746422290802, -0.4803512990474701, -0.3841065466403961, 0.048690665513277054, -0.10710591077804565, 0.4024285674095154, 0.20419521629810333, 0.2700989544391632, -0.06958979368209839, -0.3570881187915802, 0.6125541925430298, -0.03803956136107445, 0.6293208599090576, -0.014568976126611233, -0.29223915934562683, 0.47403714060783386, -0.704963743686676, 0.6615307331085205, 0.7392109036445618, 0.30465593934059143, -0.28697970509529114, 0.47688964009284973, -0.007397334091365337, 0.20147256553173065, 0.038660138845443726, 1.2385165691375732, -0.43289414048194885, 0.06265377253293991, -0.639868974685669, 0.5157023072242737, -0.05791812762618065, 0.2591306269168854, -0.18675920367240906, -0.9464560151100159, -0.39914464950561523, 0.1993204802274704, 0.9799880981445312, 0.2363862842321396, 0.23362243175506592, 0.4694634974002838, -0.21257171034812927, 0.3843159079551697, -0.43475258350372314, -0.4790765643119812, -0.43574726581573486, 0.42677250504493713, -0.2864348292350769, 0.184248685836792, -0.13347476720809937, 0.040156275033950806, -0.3590868413448334, 0.4628360867500305, -0.877505362033844, 0.7458107471466064, 1.0264133214950562, -0.6739747524261475, -0.1907399743795395, 0.6057068109512329, 0.5313500761985779, 0.5827302932739258, 0.6044726967811584, 0.38865116238594055, 0.420728862285614, -0.5550203323364258, -0.07543068379163742, -0.356552392244339, 0.369701623916626, 1.4328187704086304, -0.7516270279884338, 0.2176358848810196, 0.12608127295970917, 0.06329703330993652, -0.41639113426208496, 0.28673139214515686, 0.07452051341533661, -0.35517531633377075, 0.12117041647434235, 1.053045630455017, -0.3992418646812439, -0.05239260941743851, -0.8885631561279297, -0.05483553558588028, 0.006605933886021376, -0.4391036331653595, 0.47090983390808105, 0.19573195278644562, 0.7217361330986023, 0.6214739084243774, 0.03395981714129448, 0.2598738670349121, -0.8541547656059265, -1.0012333393096924, -0.6786702871322632, 0.036001428961753845, -0.5088521838188171, 0.5047033429145813, 0.24320738017559052, 0.3619108200073242, 1.0077929496765137, 0.9572412371635437, 0.25114133954048157, -0.15764473378658295, -0.8840315341949463, 0.12348241358995438, 0.03884585201740265, -0.4578254818916321, 0.6199916005134583, 0.47021400928497314, -0.432431697845459, -0.23145797848701477, 0.16528362035751343, -0.4018726944923401, -0.23112618923187256, -0.09407321363687515, -0.43281668424606323, 0.8411444425582886, -1.3818594217300415, 0.6041778922080994, -0.7315258383750916, 0.23191232979297638, -0.37832576036453247, -0.7222009301185608, 0.3614490330219269, -0.5735118389129639, 0.2381550371646881, -0.41217660903930664, -0.4069598317146301, 0.044735487550497055, -0.9003857374191284, -0.5048711895942688, 0.6716346740722656, 0.5604278445243835, -0.4374282658100128, 0.19751060009002686, 0.21690607070922852, -0.2641395032405853, 0.18438172340393066, 0.5081591010093689, 0.2581230700016022, 0.106236033141613, -0.44966498017311096, -0.006043304223567247, 0.48573654890060425, 0.2572754919528961, 0.27825304865837097, 0.6473590135574341, -0.3932047188282013, 1.2105463743209839, -0.29853555560112, -0.27993130683898926, -0.2989705204963684, 0.9598177075386047, 0.26729822158813477, 0.7317114472389221, 0.016457535326480865, 0.21585188806056976, 0.1188730001449585, 0.23322957754135132, 0.4176204204559326, -0.4625362157821655, 0.300432413816452, 0.7953819036483765, 0.13487862050533295, -0.6195976138114929, -0.14966201782226562, 0.3104429543018341, 0.4559541940689087, 0.06523656100034714, -1.1430164575576782, 1.2706997394561768, 0.5282406806945801, 0.3315353989601135, -0.21212369203567505, 0.5704011917114258, -0.7607321739196777, 0.9791600704193115, 0.4442260265350342, -0.11956319212913513, -1.246716022491455, 0.4960693418979645, -0.03972917050123215, 0.18042871356010437, -0.10239940136671066, -0.7200315594673157, -0.20153942704200745, 0.03754812479019165, 0.16257302463054657, -0.823584258556366, -0.05105321481823921, -0.18137462437152863, -0.2213190495967865, -0.10786670446395874, 0.8432246446609497, -0.01890438422560692, -0.7841318249702454, -0.2989916503429413, -0.2941523492336273, -0.28740957379341125, 0.08439604192972183, 0.28580912947654724, 0.2684660255908966, -0.3558841943740845, 0.9013583660125732, 0.2193755805492401, -0.3012956976890564, 0.10602628439664841, -0.7949478030204773, 0.33350810408592224, -0.6792427897453308, 0.18067674338817596, -0.9324125051498413, -0.036835912615060806, -0.8183624148368835, 0.1845405101776123, -0.23928366601467133, -0.4704512655735016, 0.5851101875305176, -0.3425215482711792, -0.42352020740509033, 0.50846928358078, 0.03648719564080238, 0.3544153869152069, -0.0005505738081410527, -0.6218690872192383, 0.5685930252075195, 0.06830470263957977, -0.6329658031463623, 0.011056248098611832, -0.6682324409484863, 0.6867849230766296, -0.2097146064043045, -0.20695404708385468, 0.7074657678604126, -0.11645077913999557, -0.3803013265132904, 0.5712587833404541, 0.11528068035840988, 1.030434012413025, -0.32334622740745544, 0.6885246634483337, 0.4261114299297333, 0.0008960463455878198, 0.46755918860435486, -0.004321222193539143, -0.5168548822402954, -0.13386867940425873, 0.17534317076206207, -1.2280032634735107, 0.42368414998054504, 0.867107093334198, 0.21487927436828613, -0.7174805402755737, 0.5540689826011658, -0.8123359680175781, -1.1269947290420532, 0.16226428747177124, 0.3673238456249237, 0.17147807776927948, -0.4304104447364807, 0.253022164106369, 0.060341302305459976, -0.3412785530090332, -0.7019088864326477, 0.21701981127262115, 0.684240460395813, 0.24688556790351868, -0.5679306387901306, 0.4679114818572998, -0.200198695063591, 0.1950020045042038, 0.6182447075843811, -0.16371728479862213, -0.04042688384652138, 0.0746319442987442, -0.2878097593784332, -0.0669545829296112, -0.0569315031170845, 0.1677328497171402, -0.028577769175171852, -0.30203986167907715, -0.35398995876312256, -0.2075188159942627, -1.1424407958984375, -0.6759846806526184, -0.06196397915482521, 0.4043859839439392, 0.5087987184524536, -0.9329602718353271, -0.040661707520484924, -0.9317148327827454, -0.34194982051849365, 0.17522941529750824, 0.16805532574653625, -0.4958347678184509, 0.07114797085523605, 0.9329736232757568, -0.8288922905921936, -0.25048452615737915, -0.21554026007652283, -0.11030197143554688, 1.0112124681472778, 0.11044195294380188, 0.3159090280532837, 0.024209680035710335, 0.1256575584411621, -0.32847848534584045, 0.5729605555534363, 0.19065703451633453, 0.21735960245132446, -0.2586207687854767, 0.08128088712692261, -0.42179563641548157, -0.2708740830421448, -0.6683082580566406, -0.3846898674964905, -0.7643537521362305, 0.1896521896123886, -0.5764120221138, -0.05147363245487213, -0.040811602026224136, 0.44868209958076477, 0.8511766791343689, 0.20504510402679443, 0.1966446042060852, 0.3009711802005768, -0.5519552230834961, 0.15082764625549316, 0.31104975938796997, -0.8262931108474731, 0.46773862838745117, -0.3836454153060913, 0.27834460139274597, 0.9063603281974792, -0.06547436118125916, -0.1806587129831314, 0.028434745967388153, -0.05074222385883331, 0.08840416371822357, 0.50318443775177, -0.3287833034992218, -0.04006282612681389, 0.726714551448822, 0.6623055338859558, -0.47405704855918884, -0.3100004196166992, 0.34020912647247314, 0.5381188988685608, 0.7026128172874451, 0.3388402760028839, -0.7929925322532654, -0.13333074748516083, -1.0767760276794434, 0.5264409184455872, 0.1329757124185562, 0.06323718279600143, -0.2763926088809967, -0.5795716643333435, -0.15512225031852722, 0.1250840574502945, 0.17786149680614471, 0.5627050995826721, 0.8216672539710999, 0.20897358655929565, -0.6779377460479736, 0.3519754409790039, 0.8998904824256897, -0.11183932423591614, -0.37568700313568115, -0.14073310792446136, -0.018688147887587547, -0.3632911741733551, 0.6985085606575012, -0.44832515716552734, -0.7736619710922241, -0.460771381855011, -0.2891860604286194, 0.8069945573806763, 0.047899261116981506, -0.1257166713476181, 0.2382320910692215, 0.28626397252082825, 0.19260042905807495, 0.4673588275909424, -0.6303415298461914, -0.03210541605949402, -0.022457702085375786, -0.25503402948379517, -0.8784566521644592, -0.44607865810394287, 0.07748137414455414, -0.37581300735473633, 0.6046305894851685, 0.6380768418312073, 0.15997852385044098, 0.3474656343460083, 0.20430801808834076, 0.023237939924001694, -0.08804339915513992, 0.23996570706367493, -0.37605544924736023, -0.07935801148414612, 0.3365459740161896, -0.8371721506118774, 0.08598260581493378, 0.22463485598564148, 0.7867974638938904, -0.30470454692840576, -0.24704265594482422, 0.09517616778612137, -0.44359585642814636, 0.34254470467567444, -0.16716918349266052, -0.3476630449295044, 0.6965889930725098, -0.49456703662872314, -0.16495223343372345, -0.0774058997631073, -0.8092357516288757, -0.4400075376033783, -0.17736731469631195, 0.014595002867281437, -0.23609060049057007, -0.6637763977050781, 0.4503496587276459, 0.20601853728294373, 0.4246710240840912, -0.5715430378913879, 0.08632663637399673, -0.28168585896492004, -0.42855972051620483, -0.6786777377128601, -0.4034784436225891, -0.3534219264984131, 0.4190081059932709, 0.5794293284416199, 0.1646060049533844, 0.387938916683197, 0.29550641775131226, -0.2075742781162262, 0.8111248016357422, 0.08272352814674377, -0.3339838981628418, 0.1616523265838623, 0.21840710937976837, 0.29910627007484436, -0.35907086730003357, -0.21988078951835632, 0.535822331905365, 0.004126377869397402, 0.3196223974227905, -0.49242106080055237, -0.34832262992858887, 0.5559236407279968, -1.2756505012512207, -0.00082145951455459, -0.8443728089332581, -0.42370104789733887, -0.3797674775123596, -0.2937757968902588, -0.3803083300590515, -0.37261632084846497, -0.18478229641914368, -1.1888290643692017, -0.2451643943786621, -0.7938624024391174, 0.12127748131752014, -0.05276613309979439, -0.11645619571208954, -0.830900251865387, -0.40462836623191833, -0.7609728574752808, 1.8947887420654297, -0.7141570448875427, -0.12565168738365173, 0.32613101601600647, -0.1736287623643875, 0.21195034682750702, 0.6545053124427795, 0.16550830006599426, -0.06764083355665207, -0.5105199217796326, -0.03608031943440437, 0.4502584636211395, 0.8612346053123474, 0.047747474163770676, 0.07446014136075974, -0.28265249729156494, 0.4436246454715729, 0.48299387097358704, -0.028427807614207268, 0.018775861710309982, -0.43107911944389343, 0.3849519193172455, -0.7118808031082153, 0.384111613035202, 0.8691631555557251, 0.8021584749221802, 0.7678328156471252, -0.4607000946998596, -0.1757131665945053, -0.13918651640415192, -0.3687209486961365, -0.42353665828704834, 0.2554594874382019, 0.39301633834838867, -0.18150191009044647, -0.6147497892379761, -0.5159193873405457, -0.2204882949590683, -0.9893091320991516, -0.4177514910697937, 0.5182502269744873, 0.3904487192630768, 0.9130085706710815, -0.8617886304855347, 0.4240286350250244, 0.14752110838890076, 0.12062656134366989, -0.27620580792427063, -0.18362145125865936, -0.6548344492912292, -0.19212394952774048, 0.040784575045108795, -1.0404103994369507, -0.8296947479248047, 0.483697772026062, 0.6601276993751526, -0.24822969734668732, 0.534904956817627, 0.25569459795951843, -0.0454990491271019, -0.6556388735771179, 0.5072311162948608, 0.4884380102157593, -0.06132640689611435, 0.5177850127220154, 0.3223898112773895, -0.31896886229515076, -0.0537002868950367, -0.16521887481212616, -0.18897199630737305, -0.1750609129667282, 1.0354931354522705, -0.8562543392181396, 0.43171364068984985, 0.997345507144928, -0.30241528153419495, -0.9342142343521118, -1.1964231729507446, -1.4394969940185547, -0.12886396050453186, 0.36518436670303345, -1.0555611848831177, 0.05658455193042755, -0.2278648018836975, -0.33681800961494446, 0.608395516872406, 0.05531255900859833, -0.3918672204017639, 0.8848864436149597, -0.36534589529037476, -0.12012750655412674, -0.6428142786026001, 0.21641826629638672, 0.5928269624710083, 0.3441554307937622, -0.49041905999183655, -0.21208104491233826, -0.32584911584854126, -0.6588564515113831, -0.5837801098823547, 0.5358378887176514, -0.2411731332540512, 0.01884414441883564, -0.24162255227565765, 0.2563612163066864, 0.5786048769950867, 0.07282549142837524, -0.4424969553947449, 0.3571285307407379, -0.6456257700920105, -0.30930447578430176, -0.09717413038015366, 0.3192117214202881, -0.1834200769662857, 0.9882033467292786, 0.3996947705745697, -0.430587500333786, -0.805181086063385, 0.15566635131835938, 0.1563611775636673, -0.05696688964962959, -0.9146206378936768, -0.9366006851196289, -0.8866022825241089, -0.5894282460212708, -0.4186442196369171, -0.4909794330596924, 0.17974010109901428, -0.1567210555076599, 0.5256102681159973, 0.1137426421046257, 0.19392390549182892, 0.0018144097412005067, 1.0574673414230347, -0.2506426274776459, -0.6084572672843933, -0.6291199922561646, -0.15210753679275513, 0.15722385048866272, -1.3789371252059937, -0.2733282148838043, -0.01679564267396927, 0.0799902006983757, 1.0504270792007446, -0.6358939409255981, 0.2991718649864197, -0.5177928805351257, -0.7189486026763916, 0.5247078537940979, -0.1470339596271515, -0.25555849075317383, 1.3615223169326782, -0.2500816583633423, 1.2185842990875244, 0.45470520853996277, -0.9156941771507263, -0.22905424237251282, -0.07095910608768463, -0.9798325896263123, 0.8186019062995911, 0.38404580950737, 0.4379473924636841, -0.028149770572781563, -0.7884410619735718, 0.15669776499271393, 0.40467143058776855, -0.9747791290283203, -0.09671054035425186, -0.5623767971992493, 0.8448342084884644, -0.009738756343722343, 0.05953693762421608, 0.11218205094337463, 0.29711249470710754, -0.6348046660423279, -0.3158243000507355, -1.1314626932144165, -0.17525696754455566, -0.21175123751163483, 0.29680055379867554, -0.4074678421020508, -0.044630926102399826, 0.31051215529441833, -0.7505050301551819, 0.12177689373493195, 0.15703457593917847, 0.240007683634758, 0.14910852909088135, 0.29806628823280334, -0.5773712396621704, -0.45128941535949707, 0.34981769323349, -0.39538732171058655, 0.7630131840705872, 0.07831862568855286, -0.13346518576145172, 0.8489376306533813, 0.21541155874729156, -1.044106364250183, 0.4265352785587311, -0.33398231863975525, -0.5667577385902405, -0.4606870114803314, 0.3115891218185425, 0.8209893703460693, 0.38203954696655273, -0.5874413847923279, 0.0608418807387352, -0.21262280642986298, 0.9311407208442688, 0.41119322180747986, -0.172594353556633, -0.70606529712677, 0.37980470061302185, -0.8352072834968567, 0.38620296120643616, -0.18136544525623322, 0.5082494616508484, -0.3255229890346527, -0.96824049949646, -0.3190233111381531, -0.41573572158813477, -0.13533379137516022, -0.2549796998500824, 0.6955440044403076, -0.33489856123924255, -0.030015088617801666, -0.1542874127626419, -0.12435247004032135, -0.37014254927635193, -0.6057940125465393, 0.7055752873420715, -0.1747487187385559, -0.20072218775749207, 0.2947676181793213, 0.06703490763902664, 0.6016387343406677, -0.07248503714799881, -0.16217856109142303, 0.856262743473053, 0.3664802610874176, 0.18033990263938904, -0.40002018213272095, 0.5478893518447876, 0.15576405823230743, 0.38878390192985535, -0.8507013320922852, -0.017181970179080963, 0.2574501931667328, -0.2084333747625351, 0.8832566142082214, 0.20173706114292145, -0.13643525540828705, 0.8259957432746887, -0.5533333420753479, -0.4711982011795044, 0.25188082456588745, -0.033478058874607086, -0.15418122708797455, 0.3014441728591919, -0.1211087629199028, -0.22522549331188202, 0.2983412742614746, 0.6200013160705566, 0.7446468472480774, -0.21745958924293518, 0.09464874863624573, -0.18098069727420807, -0.032795682549476624, 0.49896183609962463, -0.0890209972858429, -0.5619097948074341, 0.006890986580401659, -0.1409798264503479, 0.7042797207832336, -0.08742459118366241, -0.3455439805984497, 0.9249322414398193, 0.27803507447242737, 0.4082437753677368, -0.5360925793647766, -0.005335862748324871, 0.7448582649230957, 0.5994011759757996, 0.5418007373809814, 0.6027195453643799, -0.08757347613573074, 0.47027090191841125, -0.10089240968227386, -0.9507004022598267, -0.36237668991088867, 0.47437426447868347, -0.6004844307899475, -0.2494717836380005, 0.12343268096446991, -0.12105251103639603, 0.33616217970848083, -0.49129119515419006, 0.039174195379018784, -0.2069682627916336, 0.04433514177799225, -0.3723984658718109, 0.23904556035995483, 0.2549779713153839, 0.755336344242096, 0.10411377251148224, 0.430804580450058, 0.00999714620411396, 0.6156094670295715, -0.07258249074220657, 1.118572473526001, 0.5660046339035034, 0.46531251072883606, -0.022973958402872086, -0.20410804450511932, -0.17964927852153778, 0.11240825802087784, 0.7708251476287842, -0.555560290813446, 0.656160831451416, -1.0318001508712769, 0.46044519543647766, -0.6627147793769836, 0.30335870385169983, -0.508276641368866, -0.3915594220161438, 0.9226519465446472, 0.5723391175270081, -0.14551854133605957, 0.05593717470765114, 0.19857047498226166, 0.1601134091615677, -0.13570521771907806, -0.8482645153999329, 0.32473140954971313, -0.5239824652671814, 0.09033461660146713, -0.49564793705940247, 0.2786302864551544, -0.6585482954978943, 0.24465250968933105, -0.5685368776321411, 0.17972739040851593, -0.37886282801628113, -0.5109615325927734, -0.18808500468730927, -0.40701737999916077, 0.9282460808753967, 1.026755928993225, 0.1595897376537323, 0.07601485401391983, -0.20228825509548187, 0.017809893935918808, -0.18522672355175018, 0.9771973490715027, 0.24374090135097504, 0.06546801328659058, 0.4550427794456482, 0.26697811484336853, -0.9882006645202637, 0.558402419090271, 0.7231555581092834, -0.37408727407455444, 0.9353481531143188, -0.7604165077209473, 0.3048331141471863, -0.10730737447738647, -0.6081390380859375, 0.07585885375738144, -0.07218796014785767, 0.5952420234680176, 0.43811142444610596, -0.5939804315567017, 0.4790448844432831, -0.17082269489765167, -0.1605435013771057, -0.23095019161701202, 0.4754340946674347, 0.38279691338539124, -0.14506275951862335, 0.10803841799497604, -0.8096209168434143, 4.240662574768066, 0.17609667778015137, 0.14936897158622742, 0.3198874890804291, 0.13611310720443726, 0.6822461485862732, 0.12351219356060028, -0.434311181306839, 0.06642540544271469, 0.18748342990875244, 0.26826050877571106, 0.2002999186515808, 0.444082647562027, 0.6601563096046448, 0.24795491993427277, 0.4877905547618866, -0.023887570947408676, 0.3545319437980652, -0.02742137387394905, -0.2629965543746948, -0.9780229330062866, 0.31029558181762695, 0.04328468069434166, -0.10594785958528519, 0.6140442490577698, -0.014788253232836723, -0.27893784642219543, -0.9466240406036377, -0.7201821804046631, 0.0950002521276474, -0.43596401810646057, -0.3009432554244995, 0.41718989610671997, -0.5506719350814819, -0.9281052350997925, 0.6635155081748962, 0.6414404511451721, -0.4648406207561493, 0.6082906126976013, -0.3831929862499237, 0.20114333927631378, -0.7782164812088013, 0.593510091304779, -0.3737332820892334, -0.055710580199956894, 0.5560247302055359, 0.14261901378631592, 0.6563500165939331, 0.6380954384803772, -0.7064305543899536, 0.024800561368465424, 0.5182273387908936, 0.14988593757152557, 0.3496950566768646, -0.9210037589073181, -0.36284637451171875, 0.029859818518161774, 0.021558456122875214, -0.38627317547798157, 0.04167119413614273, 0.7385811805725098, -0.5944749116897583, 0.06375545263290405, 0.5841929316520691, -0.20190688967704773, 0.3464769721031189, -0.06527650356292725, -0.037964146584272385, 0.016673030331730843, -0.11083849519491196, -0.7046715021133423, -0.4029735028743744, -0.7428803443908691, -0.20659354329109192, 0.31761837005615234, 0.19753538072109222, -0.023825665935873985, 0.8327124118804932, -0.34058547019958496, -0.04311292991042137, -0.21653328835964203, 0.4606574475765228, -0.2856161296367645, 0.46817585825920105, 0.059609606862068176, 0.5490341186523438, -0.007716470398008823, 0.05683346465229988, -0.9062677621841431, 0.3767358064651489, 0.4355068504810333, 0.8926514983177185, -0.045828208327293396, 0.27352502942085266, -0.7825698852539062 ]
Weak-Field Gravity of Revolving Circular Cosmic Strings
A weak-field solution of Einstein's equations is constructed. It is generated by a circular cosmic string revolving in its plane about the centre of the circle. (The revolution is introduced to prevent the string from collapsing.) This solution exhibits a conical singularity, and the corresponding deficit angle is the same as for a straight string of the same linear energy density, irrespective of the angular velocity of the string.
Des J. Mc Manus and Michel A. Vandyck
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212007
gr-qc/9212008
[ 0.020151089876890182, -0.20805588364601135, 0.7807682752609253, -0.23969167470932007, 0.20335711538791656, -0.2901354432106018, -0.4447200298309326, -0.7931085228919983, -1.0868169069290161, 1.3209184408187866, 0.9735413193702698, -0.6601954698562622, -0.39628249406814575, -0.90198814868927, 0.09670951217412949, 0.3082084357738495, -0.2300039529800415, -0.4648365378379822, -1.965248465538025, 0.18791921436786652, -0.21569886803627014, 0.23487026989459991, -1.5207427740097046, -0.8893268704414368, -0.6589478254318237, 0.9746811389923096, 0.6174755692481995, 0.5412268042564392, 1.3032639026641846, 0.445716917514801, 0.6456590294837952, -0.44202500581741333, 0.04238211363554001, -0.7910418510437012, 0.02769535221159458, 0.207223042845726, 0.4343664050102234, -0.1411658078432083, -0.017367009073495865, -0.4477187693119049, 0.35977524518966675, 0.27925044298171997, 0.8073940873146057, -0.3127058446407318, -0.7520191073417664, -0.05696520954370499, -0.5044656991958618, -0.22207972407341003, -0.02136518433690071, -1.024423599243164, -0.5294994711875916, -0.06124372407793999, 0.6804232001304626, -1.175192952156067, 0.02716437354683876, -0.30094584822654724, -0.06889982521533966, 0.679828941822052, -0.22766022384166718, 0.247527614235878, 1.0923224687576294, 0.9489337801933289, 0.6035588383674622, -0.7808560729026794, -0.36075422167778015, 1.1521369218826294, -0.5472878813743591, 0.34260326623916626, 0.3156557083129883, -0.44206130504608154, 0.01983712799847126, -0.5475966930389404, -0.8212310075759888, 0.20282620191574097, -0.37519723176956177, 0.6967478394508362, -0.231512188911438, 0.0672302320599556, -0.6665364503860474, -1.0352857112884521, 0.5940501689910889, -0.4190519154071808, 0.027623172849416733, -0.12698352336883545, 0.5595381855964661, -0.8479511141777039, 0.2938728928565979, -0.5391388535499573, 0.1437196582555771, 0.49229931831359863, 0.10233394056558609, 0.9535416960716248, -0.03675580769777298, 0.08961604535579681, 0.5789182186126709, 0.9726759791374207, -0.0809212476015091, 0.4590843915939331, 0.32378536462783813, 0.9614236950874329, 0.06498923152685165, 0.26878786087036133, -0.24100206792354584, 0.518012285232544, -0.17475663125514984, 0.2667149603366852, 0.23747970163822174, 0.656126856803894, -0.6482526659965515, -1.089200496673584, -0.0755198672413826, -0.4554741382598877, 0.47355231642723083, 0.5172368288040161, 0.32797056436538696, 0.5103142857551575, -0.07298721373081207, 0.051942821592092514, -0.4088856875896454, -0.8188263773918152, -0.07534687221050262, 0.2854848802089691, 0.25387847423553467, 0.8643083572387695, 0.1336793303489685, -0.6878734827041626, 0.20165950059890747, 0.17041070759296417, -0.5583714246749878, 0.3812796473503113, 0.21334689855575562, -0.7288824915885925, -0.45802009105682373, -0.00934759434312582, -0.0343022346496582, 0.6426718235015869, -0.003539383178576827, -0.11200369894504547, -0.8945372104644775, -0.40667152404785156, 0.9462249875068665, -0.9532871246337891, 0.2720327377319336, 0.8312135338783264, -0.475241094827652, 0.08109265565872192, 0.05308958515524864, 0.4650780260562897, -0.024574361741542816, 0.33166563510894775, -0.6892207860946655, 0.3619065284729004, 0.24004213511943817, 0.3978593051433563, -0.7514016032218933, -0.30677351355552673, -0.983851969242096, 0.6587939858436584, -0.7980893850326538, -0.7373776435852051, 0.07194574177265167, 0.23945645987987518, 0.21718358993530273, 0.6296083331108093, -0.5461412072181702, 0.003850142238661647, -0.44125595688819885, -0.35861656069755554, 0.14672818779945374, 0.14843377470970154, -0.11397122591733932, 0.3640577793121338, -0.2667539119720459, 0.3388007581233978, 0.6426588296890259, 0.28711920976638794, 0.3100314140319824, 0.04077684134244919, 0.03207061067223549, 0.5871042013168335, 0.08117631822824478, -0.5741543769836426, 0.6633102893829346, 0.752588152885437, -0.8608629703521729, -0.8289346098899841, -0.49166908860206604, -0.37059032917022705, 0.33986133337020874, 0.3706618547439575, -0.054132211953401566, 0.7498528957366943, -1.0753529071807861, 0.6657681465148926, -0.4700782001018524, 0.23369035124778748, -0.8904979825019836, 0.08620789647102356, -0.14974330365657806, -0.7012224793434143, -0.05838643014431, -0.4603572189807892, -0.8633666038513184, 0.3267741799354553, -0.9785891175270081, 0.37057650089263916, 0.5620173811912537, 0.7552652359008789, -0.6526205539703369, -0.18835100531578064, 0.07753429561853409, -0.27285218238830566, 0.15249204635620117, -0.32202669978141785, 0.39230433106422424, -0.8491780757904053, -0.08206932246685028, 0.3194039762020111, 0.8753026127815247, -0.5605555772781372, 0.6915570497512817, 0.40288493037223816, 0.36396482586860657, 0.7002209424972534, -0.27825963497161865, -0.2552299201488495, 0.311209112405777, 0.8742775321006775, -0.05583325773477554, 0.16585294902324677, 0.1934744417667389, 0.7968919277191162, 0.44536343216896057, 0.12248964607715607, 0.1165735125541687, 0.06776440888643265, 0.8527851104736328, 0.6376698613166809, -0.20844899117946625, -0.27173513174057007, -0.23622877895832062, 0.23327144980430603, 0.6266300678253174, 0.32917776703834534, -0.6576560735702515, -0.15311047434806824, -0.020187530666589737, 0.24876922369003296, -0.20437274873256683, 0.8985119462013245, -1.1388357877731323, 0.650603711605072, -0.014320879243314266, 0.5692539811134338, -1.1589016914367676, -0.14347751438617706, 0.2007867842912674, 0.7963706851005554, -0.08711542189121246, -0.6549076437950134, -0.39395758509635925, 0.21855174005031586, 0.24731087684631348, -0.6761220693588257, -0.5218982100486755, 0.04057461768388748, -0.3587796688079834, 0.3384494483470917, 0.3580580949783325, -0.2082558572292328, -0.2812016010284424, 0.022741658613085747, -0.556637704372406, 0.46620938181877136, -0.1861310452222824, -0.2129366397857666, -0.0961097776889801, -0.6170231103897095, 0.9159770607948303, 0.47334355115890503, 0.28533437848091125, 0.3659348487854004, 0.47130998969078064, 0.4461195468902588, 0.02136053517460823, -0.3090730309486389, -1.0270543098449707, 0.30052459239959717, -0.4526304006576538, 0.05634923279285431, -0.30830031633377075, -0.2687372863292694, -0.09430801123380661, -0.39815014600753784, 0.0389438159763813, -0.16524526476860046, -0.5632695555686951, 0.1537107676267624, 0.02775038778781891, -0.32349690794944763, 0.015084479935467243, 0.6789198517799377, -0.5636633038520813, -0.09396808594465256, -1.2691371440887451, 1.3065769672393799, -0.1285719871520996, -0.22264966368675232, 0.6361615657806396, -0.5387156009674072, -0.583311915397644, 0.8727346658706665, -0.3070065677165985, 0.19489696621894836, 0.20389187335968018, 0.5406537652015686, 0.7159443497657776, -0.3759967088699341, -0.2468450665473938, -0.04059230908751488, -1.0291155576705933, -0.32376617193222046, 0.6699719429016113, -0.5796103477478027, 0.2568298578262329, 0.831946849822998, 0.772138237953186, -0.5678324103355408, 0.293218195438385, -1.5059008598327637, -0.21743574738502502, -0.06735602021217346, -0.829810380935669, 0.057638198137283325, -0.15441572666168213, 0.06125275790691376, -0.6215748190879822, -0.25551730394363403, -0.34702274203300476, 1.0052008628845215, 0.4694369435310364, -0.5539272427558899, 0.7443135380744934, 0.23920834064483643, 0.4570324122905731, 0.21737046539783478, 0.8774662017822266, -0.14054006338119507, -0.08102630078792572, 0.007619031704962254, -0.41372695565223694, -0.10382448136806488, 0.6318906545639038, -0.08620387315750122, 0.15749657154083252, -0.10194132477045059, -0.761081874370575, 0.008256739005446434, -1.137285828590393, -0.45423394441604614, 0.12048131227493286, 0.6945986747741699, 0.3366162180900574, 0.12412237375974655, -0.8447467088699341, 0.289114773273468, 0.09432881325483322, 0.30350154638290405, 0.7011532187461853, -1.2702701091766357, -0.18333472311496735, -0.25917211174964905, -0.6790772676467896, -0.09681914746761322, -0.0669461265206337, 0.8014202117919922, 0.4989652633666992, -0.010929562151432037, 0.2864067554473877, -0.6382730603218079, -0.43995240330696106, -0.9368662238121033, 1.0144649744033813, 0.34162071347236633, 0.4293265640735626, -0.24880924820899963, -0.6300495266914368, 0.42637112736701965, -0.6314643621444702, -0.32360443472862244, -0.3030300438404083, -0.8769838213920593, -0.2638666331768036, -1.1226633787155151, -0.24989920854568481, 0.17020657658576965, 0.7746217250823975, 0.28505176305770874, -0.17771600186824799, -0.270007848739624, 0.2934046983718872, 0.04200032725930214, 0.09956857562065125, 0.8714199066162109, 0.3234115242958069, 0.2547459006309509, -0.7375699281692505, 0.31535428762435913, 0.650760293006897, 0.644602358341217, 0.15916243195533752, -0.6304866075515747, 0.021947020664811134, -0.1385066658258438, 1.0111351013183594, 0.5486403107643127, 0.01655518263578415, 0.802740752696991, 0.783001720905304, 0.15479233860969543, -0.24865607917308807, 0.884522020816803, 0.16399726271629333, 0.5554233193397522, -0.2897210419178009, -1.0538886785507202, 0.05633267015218735, -0.3711850643157959, 0.28207075595855713, 0.7314416170120239, -0.21149106323719025, -1.184427261352539, -0.354055792093277, 0.7324746251106262, -0.2943883240222931, 0.6598710417747498, 0.5702323913574219, -0.34955745935440063, 0.9189674258232117, 0.05808255821466446, 0.18679217994213104, 0.057386692613363266, -0.6328204274177551, -0.5626239776611328, 0.06229706481099129, -0.07732032239437103, -0.5165153741836548, 0.4228416383266449, -0.4707479476928711, -0.9686294794082642, 0.08191794157028198, -0.44654273986816406, 0.33282196521759033, -0.3149515986442566, -0.45674294233322144, 0.08520291745662689, 0.07824552804231644, -0.2662951350212097, -0.2517422139644623, -0.20654608309268951, 0.5611642599105835, 0.15726694464683533, 0.15144799649715424, -0.6872416138648987, -0.15188221633434296, 0.4423801600933075, 0.36862635612487793, 0.7450469732284546, 0.7079038619995117, 0.16888219118118286, 0.6968722343444824, 0.5047559142112732, -0.5209077596664429, -0.17558005452156067, 0.15860362350940704, -0.5408813953399658, -0.08197098225355148, -0.23513363301753998, -0.10711611807346344, -0.6331778168678284, 0.14285209774971008, 0.18017971515655518, -0.33786246180534363, 0.1502804160118103, 0.2609269320964813, -1.3777340650558472, -0.4967038929462433, -0.24417972564697266, -0.7225883603096008, 0.5908509492874146, -0.303864449262619, -0.8353835940361023, -0.013528171926736832, -0.11479181051254272, 0.34319281578063965, -0.34821727871894836, -0.543119490146637, -0.8412452936172485, -0.16288691759109497, 0.43543362617492676, -0.03254203870892525, 1.1786315441131592, -0.24797101318836212, 0.2933066487312317, -0.47993171215057373, -0.3707588315010071, -0.8318262100219727, -0.44946610927581787, -0.09067083150148392, 0.26702722907066345, 0.09981119632720947, -0.08613260090351105, -0.30281591415405273, -0.5457048416137695, 0.15300841629505157, -0.1950090527534485, -0.4782625734806061, -0.806627094745636, 0.09074222296476364, 0.21240267157554626, 0.660004734992981, -0.6026491522789001, 0.07012087106704712, 0.4894697070121765, -0.25070083141326904, 0.25502076745033264, -0.4693185091018677, -0.6377164125442505, 0.9170929789543152, -1.1386195421218872, 0.8034374117851257, -1.366452693939209, 0.03210662677884102, 0.24085286259651184, -0.07472284883260727, -0.05912221968173981, 0.0978325605392456, 0.12115025520324707, -0.5049033761024475, -0.23214185237884521, 0.16191495954990387, 0.05178959667682648, -0.5623854994773865, 0.0855579599738121, -0.11977501958608627, -0.055745624005794525, -0.3087954819202423, 0.7693596482276917, -0.35352399945259094, 0.4003331959247589, 0.7071425914764404, 0.27693068981170654, -0.19324368238449097, 0.47772958874702454, -0.2144838273525238, -0.19176961481571198, -0.2349388152360916, -0.046555209904909134, 0.9771398305892944, 0.24337658286094666, -0.4319074749946594, 0.7431212067604065, -0.7715455889701843, 0.5509251952171326, -0.21394814550876617, -0.15383997559547424, 0.3528410792350769, 0.46331101655960083, 0.7937868237495422, -0.6951500773429871, 0.012761983089148998, 0.28313693404197693, 0.7448630332946777, 0.4666108191013336, -0.24635232985019684, 0.21593394875526428, -0.19685865938663483, -1.130623459815979, -0.8030589818954468, 0.41438236832618713, 0.38431888818740845, 0.014803161844611168, -0.0259452685713768, -0.09004279971122742, -0.5893785953521729, -0.5073835849761963, 0.3594297468662262, -0.19481314718723297, 0.5077863335609436, -0.22428978979587555, -0.16465389728546143, -0.14310425519943237, -0.5339139699935913, -0.535682201385498, 0.03872907534241676, 0.7462651133537292, -0.23874294757843018, -0.16447168588638306, -0.9323555827140808, -0.7072768807411194, -0.9227868318557739, 0.1668083518743515, 0.8257231712341309, 0.22229142487049103, 1.1740946769714355, 0.23285938799381256, -0.3143056631088257, -0.04639768600463867, -0.4379023611545563, 0.45563605427742004, -0.07428357005119324, 0.6525170207023621, 0.44442370533943176, 0.6938062906265259, -0.4256863594055176, 0.47559258341789246, -0.7335273623466492, -0.2317143827676773, 1.1747081279754639, -0.4706120193004608, -0.19247981905937195, 0.5307068824768066, 0.20689736306667328, -0.6329253911972046, -0.7695938944816589, -1.3172494173049927, -0.3311110734939575, 0.3398782014846802, -0.9617229700088501, 0.277934193611145, -0.5082082748413086, -0.38826650381088257, 0.730456531047821, 0.49683868885040283, 0.6381598711013794, 0.5006200671195984, 0.05797071009874344, -0.11485932022333145, 0.1403840184211731, 0.12419624626636505, 1.2743874788284302, 0.28041762113571167, -0.5857691168785095, -0.2794301509857178, 0.26810428500175476, -0.10878177732229233, 0.7650776505470276, 0.6911529302597046, -0.14170615375041962, -0.17487183213233948, -0.21905365586280823, 0.27066484093666077, 0.09113410115242004, 0.3602398931980133, -0.39866575598716736, -0.3725641667842865, -0.20216724276542664, -1.1043062210083008, 0.08083292841911316, -0.004316677805036306, 0.4065248966217041, 0.32711464166641235, -0.48772895336151123, -0.14784285426139832, -0.6642823815345764, -0.5702999830245972, -0.289468377828598, -0.9568931460380554, 0.014778034761548042, -1.5537033081054688, -0.43441009521484375, -0.8805325031280518, -0.07717692852020264, 0.20474621653556824, 0.40593987703323364, -0.8001591563224792, 0.8455047607421875, -0.627713143825531, 0.3373997211456299, 0.1844058334827423, 0.8038853406906128, -0.7234905362129211, -0.5958061814308167, -1.3996012210845947, 0.17528492212295532, -0.23906110227108002, -1.0911470651626587, -0.1492370069026947, -0.1879202425479889, 0.41966816782951355, 0.7310584783554077, -1.1575504541397095, 0.4019522964954376, -0.22732895612716675, -0.4137031137943268, 0.5112541913986206, 0.1235847920179367, -1.3174779415130615, 0.780086874961853, -0.6865271329879761, 0.8155604600906372, 0.273629754781723, 0.5257286429405212, -0.8355972170829773, -0.24029286205768585, -1.4270652532577515, 0.5070202946662903, 0.012268065474927425, 0.1881980150938034, 0.5651400089263916, -0.48224687576293945, 0.2878594696521759, -0.30099621415138245, -1.2198352813720703, -0.2305171638727188, -0.424111932516098, 0.6537200212478638, 0.008982676081359386, 0.4641040563583374, 0.20621997117996216, 0.4438931941986084, -0.2210717499256134, 0.6120473742485046, -0.4018019437789917, -0.5514288544654846, 0.3286746144294739, 0.4746760427951813, 0.1526104211807251, -0.4218234717845917, 0.10727967321872711, -0.36154812574386597, 0.14911241829395294, 0.3408750593662262, -0.46381333470344543, 0.402155339717865, -0.34251707792282104, -0.3951358199119568, -0.5906823873519897, -0.05199773982167244, -0.5481380820274353, 1.2459810972213745, 0.02983975037932396, 0.0584086999297142, 0.2615976333618164, -0.6082270741462708, -0.6117953658103943, 0.8948253393173218, -0.10061661899089813, -0.5377890467643738, 0.19566196203231812, -0.2279144823551178, -0.5656338334083557, 0.13846400380134583, -0.6880015134811401, 0.18413880467414856, 0.1949433833360672, 0.7286257147789001, 0.7027611136436462, 0.3316572606563568, -0.8359055519104004, 0.6602301001548767, -0.4417218565940857, -0.9690383672714233, -0.7384524941444397, 0.5523232221603394, -0.7281115055084229, -0.5234870314598083, -0.2158258855342865, 0.5683557391166687, 0.0002274633152410388, -0.18212737143039703, 0.308974027633667, 0.0761369839310646, 0.18487350642681122, 0.06697167456150055, -0.28086212277412415, 0.10738035291433334, -0.033550020307302475, 0.23397554457187653, -0.10922759771347046, -0.44033902883529663, 0.1972290277481079, 0.3107287585735321, 0.8106496334075928, 0.43786418437957764, -0.6019976735115051, 1.084228515625, 0.2577874958515167, 0.13865655660629272, 0.4070427715778351, 0.09557998180389404, 0.7089951038360596, 0.41500356793403625, -0.5359087586402893, -0.2202901840209961, 0.31622251868247986, 0.5837648510932922, 0.3853493332862854, 0.11585993319749832, 0.18122345209121704, 0.49502721428871155, 0.7551645636558533, 0.21413272619247437, 0.04031573235988617, 0.2617892324924469, 0.25689882040023804, 0.005775111727416515, 0.11155718564987183, 0.2200881689786911, -0.3670775592327118, 0.44230857491493225, -0.008749709464609623, 0.4515727460384369, -0.170901820063591, -0.4603849947452545, -0.11626927554607391, 0.24992747604846954, 0.12947286665439606, -1.4525794982910156, -0.7966617941856384, 0.4685314893722534, -0.15950044989585876, 0.019981632009148598, 0.16365022957324982, 1.038404941558838, 0.46375197172164917, 0.42884188890457153, -0.3049623370170593, 0.48665785789489746, 0.6360718607902527, 0.5060834884643555, 0.4780033230781555, 0.82087641954422, 0.2193843424320221, 1.070933222770691, 0.2485274374485016, -0.6560938954353333, 0.0665665864944458, 0.43340468406677246, -1.0072662830352783, -0.2692415118217468, -0.13239388167858124, -0.38867178559303284, -0.22580675780773163, -1.0958666801452637, 0.09100595116615295, -0.44597211480140686, -0.25285604596138, 0.7187849283218384, -0.22184647619724274, -0.12933430075645447, 0.40130966901779175, -0.08361292630434036, 0.20782247185707092, 0.6043016910552979, 0.32021963596343994, -0.3366648554801941, 0.833320677280426, 0.8659886717796326, -0.04969995468854904, 0.4163721799850464, 0.19467005133628845, 0.4929904043674469, 0.5062374472618103, 0.4131244122982025, -0.41784560680389404, 0.9308283925056458, -0.08622399717569351, 0.079380102455616, -0.2051396667957306, 0.20728448033332825, -0.41834405064582825, -0.1492769569158554, 0.49669313430786133, 0.18130022287368774, -0.370380699634552, 0.20002742111682892, 0.5425013899803162, 0.2626235783100128, -0.5955732464790344, -0.6277474164962769, 0.1628299355506897, -1.3783165216445923, -0.284121572971344, -0.6183220744132996, 0.4429806172847748, 0.39637601375579834, -0.04217333346605301, -0.43678826093673706, -0.3109039068222046, -0.6550379395484924, -0.8165373206138611, -0.06035109981894493, -0.14158953726291656, 0.2636702060699463, 0.9067292809486389, 0.3275279402732849, -0.06720580160617828, -1.291555404663086, -0.23491576313972473, -0.07089051604270935, 1.5212416648864746, 0.07360392808914185, -0.13472925126552582, 0.8384233117103577, -0.1750791370868683, -0.7025182247161865, 0.5460900664329529, 1.11857008934021, -0.3036622107028961, 0.6471256017684937, -0.5329535603523254, 0.3533489406108856, 0.22952917218208313, -0.2318805605173111, 0.13614392280578613, -0.021067742258310318, 0.12349756807088852, -0.0831790342926979, -0.3508528769016266, 0.2529528737068176, -0.049259621649980545, 0.001530566718429327, -0.3196813762187958, 0.5864155292510986, 0.14906269311904907, -0.5940545797348022, -0.08260553330183029, -0.3672468364238739, 3.9696261882781982, 0.804210364818573, 0.987566351890564, -0.1272372603416443, 1.0718817710876465, 0.8627070188522339, -0.06973050534725189, -0.23953431844711304, 0.6772507429122925, -0.6910433769226074, -0.5030686259269714, 0.6862549185752869, 0.3315994143486023, -0.17705705761909485, 0.1288849413394928, 0.5769773125648499, -0.17721650004386902, -0.1894148886203766, -0.5838932394981384, -0.12589699029922485, -0.8931539058685303, 0.35434576869010925, -0.08506937325000763, -0.9045339226722717, 0.02712167613208294, 0.287324458360672, 0.6297101378440857, -0.07616137713193893, -0.5040631294250488, 0.09680382162332535, -0.24211286008358002, -0.6140031814575195, -0.3431607484817505, -0.33364397287368774, -1.4630333185195923, 0.15933857858181, -0.06148369237780571, -0.069900743663311, 0.21222266554832458, -0.1387338489294052, 0.48937660455703735, -0.3599272668361664, 0.32217180728912354, -0.3095414638519287, 0.04771792143583298, 0.9321427941322327, -0.11041063070297241, 0.7856280207633972, 0.32634270191192627, -0.7560654878616333, 0.6669380068778992, 0.12130188941955566, 0.7551626563072205, -0.7798317670822144, -0.978244423866272, -0.3406931757926941, -0.045588843524456024, -0.036239977926015854, 0.32147541642189026, 0.019316425547003746, 1.1412245035171509, -0.08417659997940063, 0.09913913905620575, -0.31309986114501953, -0.08602354675531387, 0.14902378618717194, 0.7583014369010925, 0.2901928722858429, -0.10241777449846268, -0.34319326281547546, -0.7328158617019653, -0.07931067049503326, -0.9610128998756409, -0.3902023136615753, 0.37055984139442444, 0.3060867488384247, -0.3593862056732178, 0.346291720867157, 0.10998328030109406, -0.22162212431430817, -0.27691778540611267, -0.3720262348651886, 0.015557858161628246, 0.2907911539077759, -0.36497750878334045, 0.5239534974098206, 0.25445446372032166, -0.1913326233625412, 0.47917670011520386, 0.5793084502220154, 0.22588598728179932, 0.9652103781700134, -0.052851371467113495, 0.09897942841053009, -0.5848574042320251 ]
The Coherent State Representation of Quantum Fluctuations in the Early Universe
Using the squeezed state formalism the coherent state representation of quantum fluctuations in an expanding universe is derived. It is shown that this provides a useful alternative to the Wigner function as a phase space representation of quantum fluctuations. The quantum to classical transition of fluctuations is naturally implemented by decohering the density matrix in this representation. The entropy of the decohered vacua is derived. It is shown that the decoherence process breaks the physical equivalence between vacua that differ by a coordinate dependent phase generated by a surface term in the Lagrangian. In particular, scale invariant power spectra are only obtained for a special choice of surface term.
A.L. Matacz
gr-qc astro-ph
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212008
gr-qc/9212009
[ 0.22166165709495544, 0.3272321820259094, 0.19600404798984528, 0.13591225445270538, -0.11367611587047577, -0.13281065225601196, 0.46902742981910706, -0.3324979543685913, -0.17130957543849945, 0.7860989570617676, 0.5384873747825623, 0.6080237030982971, 0.32732638716697693, -1.2291839122772217, 0.172372967004776, 0.3878372609615326, -0.06421513110399246, -0.5482797026634216, -1.5261536836624146, 0.7214088439941406, 0.20272842049598694, -0.6748487949371338, -0.8635327816009521, -0.44876742362976074, -0.314584881067276, 0.7870479226112366, -0.04718830808997154, 0.25123897194862366, 0.6735758781433105, 1.4345729351043701, 0.3540588617324829, -0.5468498468399048, 0.06103720888495445, -0.7002525329589844, -0.6189628839492798, -0.23276717960834503, -0.1077999696135521, -0.604755163192749, 0.6967058181762695, -0.2933397591114044, 0.406863808631897, -0.3724273145198822, 0.04020499810576439, -0.6784310340881348, -0.9052152633666992, 0.1557052731513977, 0.5761083960533142, 0.8542399406433105, 0.09972696751356125, -0.980515718460083, -0.1379690170288086, -0.26248282194137573, 0.4181711673736572, -0.2709576487541199, -0.26668649911880493, 0.3276536464691162, 0.21043772995471954, -0.0657930076122284, -1.1136373281478882, -0.28198862075805664, -0.19645468890666962, 0.40787583589553833, 0.5616942644119263, -0.6352601647377014, 0.048079054802656174, 1.1539064645767212, -0.5151499509811401, 0.9099858999252319, 0.08118049055337906, -0.32756638526916504, -0.35572493076324463, 0.23392878472805023, -0.21070891618728638, 0.3682589828968048, -0.6671927571296692, 0.10349058359861374, -0.6331115961074829, -0.42251265048980713, 0.015020102262496948, -0.018688181415200233, -0.18812775611877441, 0.1858743578195572, -0.15157842636108398, 0.25298625230789185, -0.0012873419327661395, -0.20365600287914276, -0.12045373022556305, -0.9680742025375366, 0.6053593754768372, 0.2883639931678772, 0.296639621257782, 0.2774197459220886, -0.682153046131134, 0.31899216771125793, 0.7229514122009277, 0.924391508102417, -0.5925071239471436, 0.39315369725227356, -0.06246842443943024, 0.3148878812789917, -0.7287564873695374, 1.1011110544204712, -0.5259336829185486, -0.03082370012998581, -0.6088783740997314, 0.2504063546657562, -0.6285946369171143, 0.7084687352180481, -0.08687736093997955, -0.8449808955192566, 0.40686002373695374, 0.4490851163864136, 0.7046660780906677, 0.006595334503799677, -0.096002496778965, 0.26812446117401123, -1.0059051513671875, 0.25441762804985046, -0.4971822202205658, -0.4659839868545532, 0.10273683071136475, 0.5908789038658142, -0.03409142792224884, 0.4110219478607178, -0.6750849485397339, -0.11223995685577393, -0.02148738130927086, 0.41699862480163574, -0.5097828507423401, 0.5585821270942688, 0.16887277364730835, -0.49617528915405273, -0.1156853437423706, 0.3079841434955597, -0.4803902208805084, 0.04754527285695076, 0.4726635813713074, 0.3025994896888733, 0.36230841279029846, -0.316576212644577, 0.29826197028160095, -0.7198237180709839, -0.04179009795188904, 0.9081435799598694, -0.18653656542301178, 0.33704712986946106, 0.8642148971557617, -0.27895766496658325, -0.2387622594833374, -0.021133026108145714, 0.14384786784648895, -0.7323417663574219, -0.2487514168024063, 0.2212902009487152, -0.0385117381811142, -0.199165940284729, -0.3942626714706421, 0.6687074303627014, 0.282784104347229, -0.1577795445919037, 0.06295499205589294, -0.21998843550682068, 0.37570706009864807, 1.003372311592102, -0.23362308740615845, 0.10553917288780212, -0.6764281988143921, 0.020759355276823044, 0.37828388810157776, -0.7255429029464722, -0.35268735885620117, 0.46446382999420166, 0.3561243712902069, 0.6957234144210815, 0.9728988409042358, 0.3434954583644867, -0.2400282323360443, -0.09212784469127655, -0.0546320304274559, -0.30757102370262146, 0.3864421844482422, -0.36718422174453735, 0.4638913869857788, 0.5727035999298096, -0.1196230873465538, 0.0856747180223465, 0.10572832822799683, -0.47689732909202576, 0.6892765164375305, 0.41654539108276367, -0.2520947754383087, 0.24009540677070618, -0.6131424307823181, -0.06257185339927673, -1.2687695026397705, -0.32427358627319336, -1.6009618043899536, -0.2403670847415924, 0.02201869525015354, -0.28477486968040466, 0.6909632086753845, 0.9486939907073975, -0.48213061690330505, 0.5149287581443787, -1.0153192281723022, -0.2875441908836365, 0.7635897994041443, -0.24105237424373627, -0.5734517574310303, -0.3313370645046234, 0.6171199083328247, -0.30938735604286194, 0.4075114130973816, -0.3126578629016876, 0.32840612530708313, 0.4408928155899048, -0.5110079646110535, -0.18679895997047424, -0.3283897936344147, 0.47837722301483154, 0.8138152360916138, -0.1809537261724472, -0.4750441014766693, 1.4595963954925537, -0.1140405535697937, -0.699505627155304, 0.4558367431163788, 0.25727739930152893, 0.15310533344745636, -0.09158904105424881, 0.21292191743850708, 0.0352446623146534, -0.26318129897117615, 0.3015907406806946, 0.1467091143131256, -0.04621776193380356, 0.6089189052581787, 0.6101804375648499, 0.4935799837112427, -0.15447339415550232, -0.07249271124601364, -0.3792063593864441, 0.1751566380262375, 0.4128457009792328, -0.5404689311981201, 0.5104596614837646, -0.34650132060050964, 0.25097912549972534, -0.8557755351066589, 0.8816731572151184, -0.9118723273277283, 0.5698414444923401, -0.11641494929790497, 0.5567119121551514, -0.7599825263023376, 0.6664215326309204, -0.11715594679117203, 0.4423586130142212, 0.4284106492996216, -0.680797815322876, -0.4064813554286957, 0.11213117837905884, -0.5866524577140808, -0.20904958248138428, -0.0726904571056366, 0.8235767483711243, -0.11659056693315506, -0.5221923589706421, 0.6516778469085693, -0.5617125034332275, -1.5742663145065308, -0.0070742396637797356, -0.48505374789237976, 0.20495402812957764, -0.7481082081794739, -0.16384544968605042, 0.5300261378288269, -0.2541969418525696, 0.2912707030773163, 0.4068269431591034, -0.37689363956451416, 0.5573641061782837, -0.03615473955869675, -0.18065300583839417, 0.42860591411590576, 0.7201838493347168, -1.7005573511123657, -0.03245529159903526, -1.0891375541687012, 0.22973784804344177, -0.4415834844112396, -0.9879136085510254, 0.28261882066726685, -0.043604668229818344, 0.5209946632385254, 0.6478668451309204, -0.22910311818122864, 0.21375513076782227, -0.24641110002994537, -0.7591937184333801, 1.0003248453140259, 0.6786279678344727, 0.08260877430438995, 0.006461115088313818, -0.26396846771240234, 0.9454540610313416, 0.43695858120918274, -0.04157794266939163, 1.1763650178909302, -0.06302595883607864, -0.6449266076087952, 0.15856803953647614, 0.06961912661790848, 0.5227687954902649, -0.2885785698890686, 0.2524068057537079, 1.1609067916870117, 0.33336272835731506, -0.022947268560528755, -0.4363667070865631, -0.5302317142486572, -0.09211348742246628, 0.21097223460674286, -0.6891531944274902, 0.6805862188339233, 1.1580594778060913, -0.02663954347372055, -0.2985314428806305, 0.5743446350097656, -1.2800588607788086, -0.9839880466461182, -0.5382351875305176, -0.03892884403467178, -0.016352441161870956, 0.42857855558395386, 0.3755774199962616, -0.29204466938972473, -0.29628801345825195, -0.15683546662330627, 0.45180097222328186, 0.34501418471336365, -0.17157800495624542, 0.44459864497184753, 0.5769306421279907, 0.7125684022903442, -0.2793538272380829, 0.10592694580554962, -0.8669530153274536, -0.5632484555244446, 0.44795501232147217, -0.6671294569969177, -0.3058781325817108, 0.17659330368041992, 0.18991883099079132, 0.19208453595638275, -0.013001954182982445, -0.6255810260772705, -0.48856547474861145, -0.5978890657424927, -0.6042664647102356, 0.6151911020278931, 0.4379469156265259, -0.10095986723899841, -0.4445158541202545, -0.5246186852455139, -0.30798131227493286, 0.02103409543633461, 0.23744067549705505, 0.3958832621574402, -0.7785830497741699, 0.3551889955997467, 0.14773601293563843, -0.7174587249755859, 0.3002399802207947, -0.3699246644973755, 0.44064098596572876, 0.576468825340271, 0.333501935005188, 0.7901771068572998, 0.1925935000181198, -0.12776978313922882, -0.3005739450454712, 1.1533288955688477, 0.107416532933712, 0.3561500012874603, -0.33018654584884644, 0.019819773733615875, -0.15487132966518402, -0.5283845067024231, -0.6219600439071655, -0.5964999198913574, -0.45721670985221863, 0.6617050170898438, -0.3762250244617462, -0.6848461627960205, -0.19641463458538055, -0.18281525373458862, 0.4018037021160126, 0.7183430194854736, -0.44655051827430725, 0.26576507091522217, -0.6144281029701233, 0.147736594080925, 0.49728304147720337, -0.08459296822547913, 0.4403303861618042, -0.27342668175697327, -0.11585048586130142, 0.6824951171875, -0.20057056844234467, -0.21474236249923706, -0.3559011220932007, -0.3622176945209503, 0.14600101113319397, -0.20341241359710693, 0.5044957995414734, 0.0061125243082642555, 0.002191447652876377, 0.7180164456367493, 0.4021760821342468, -0.5258439779281616, 0.25218483805656433, 1.2954530715942383, 0.470182329416275, 0.18834608793258667, -0.04680595546960831, -0.201324462890625, 0.3432832360267639, 0.0526910200715065, 0.49542203545570374, -0.4126678705215454, -0.7269536852836609, -0.4591606557369232, 0.5126957893371582, -0.08961502462625504, -0.7797571420669556, 0.9983072280883789, 0.1913597732782364, 0.20271655917167664, -0.361767053604126, 0.13667984306812286, 1.8024933338165283, -0.4010595977306366, -0.07648655027151108, 0.13340584933757782, 0.24879348278045654, -0.20498064160346985, 0.6520158052444458, -0.463531494140625, -0.19771002233028412, -0.3707335293292999, -0.7902281284332275, 0.6605645418167114, -0.12566983699798584, -1.0505223274230957, 0.8546823263168335, 0.3384670317173004, -0.1716788113117218, 0.4205203950405121, -0.26365727186203003, -0.4108697772026062, 0.06138179078698158, -0.1472093164920807, -0.28382784128189087, -0.043562982231378555, -0.009628727100789547, -0.6096620559692383, 0.8282468318939209, 0.21022862195968628, 0.3336937427520752, -0.08485540747642517, 0.31333181262016296, -0.339316725730896, 0.16804909706115723, 0.10104933381080627, -0.18436844646930695, -0.38757991790771484, 0.032358165830373764, -0.5469595193862915, 0.2076704055070877, -0.11596742272377014, 0.6679681539535522, -0.06881783157587051, 0.5517107844352722, 0.15228326618671417, -0.8062666654586792, -0.5663246512413025, -0.8748003840446472, -0.7036490440368652, 0.333143413066864, -0.4473182260990143, -0.29434770345687866, -0.45182061195373535, 0.4797123372554779, -0.032506901770830154, 0.16061602532863617, 0.9001778960227966, -0.30509987473487854, -0.32248619198799133, 0.29614728689193726, 0.4793543219566345, -0.09717363119125366, -0.6492509245872498, 0.5601996779441833, -0.8325293064117432, -0.1673099398612976, -0.4705764353275299, -0.8633583784103394, -0.44387736916542053, 0.04093886539340019, 0.09809818863868713, 0.11562871187925339, -0.35246220231056213, 0.254067987203598, -0.05573366582393646, 0.3192118704319, -0.2484833151102066, -0.7439678907394409, 0.18948759138584137, 0.9217845797538757, 0.5441974997520447, -0.34950417280197144, -0.5699566602706909, 0.4334876835346222, 0.28334107995033264, 0.3749687671661377, -0.08934561163187027, -0.6829061508178711, -0.03513757139444351, -0.5901247262954712, 0.7297667264938354, -0.757472038269043, -0.8579899668693542, -0.3113633692264557, -0.03528884798288345, -0.10695238411426544, 0.7716430425643921, -0.1648608148097992, -0.6351740956306458, -0.3308846354484558, -0.5280963182449341, -0.10652469098567963, -0.7874734401702881, 0.1612175852060318, -0.35551923513412476, -0.41613736748695374, -0.1348247528076172, 1.5450621843338013, -0.6106018424034119, 0.3914150297641754, 0.29621151089668274, 0.11699603497982025, -0.08448559045791626, 0.4176039397716522, 0.26129162311553955, 0.34344273805618286, -0.47850745916366577, -0.2778915762901306, 0.15907980501651764, 0.6796440482139587, -0.3167349696159363, -0.19606046378612518, -0.5621994137763977, 0.4954923987388611, -0.2659745216369629, -0.18836776912212372, 0.01412443071603775, 0.19511984288692474, 0.6231158375740051, -0.12178359180688858, 0.569144070148468, 0.587151825428009, -0.38500529527664185, 0.7048999667167664, 0.09766677767038345, -0.3408735990524292, -0.6794783473014832, -0.47737088799476624, -0.6152478456497192, 0.7297160029411316, 0.11448780447244644, 0.40789318084716797, -0.40427181124687195, -1.026607871055603, 0.25642308592796326, -0.16263942420482635, 0.46676114201545715, 0.6353973746299744, -0.5252352356910706, 1.0039515495300293, 0.04594484344124794, 0.1444839984178543, -0.0071216668002307415, -0.28982657194137573, 0.21141842007637024, -0.46851998567581177, 0.4341384470462799, -0.18663950264453888, 0.31844744086265564, -0.7843886017799377, 0.46821948885917664, 0.21897631883621216, 0.10605394840240479, -0.9557424187660217, 1.022207498550415, 0.17662879824638367, -0.9432438015937805, -0.6951023936271667, 0.3936253786087036, 0.1062493771314621, -0.530282735824585, 0.7254387140274048, -0.013139977119863033, -0.10313233733177185, -0.14035199582576752, -0.17026913166046143, -0.8585907220840454, -0.5585559606552124, 0.8553301095962524, -0.9485875964164734, 0.010692654177546501, 0.03617335110902786, -0.12538950145244598, 0.09713832288980484, -0.4980408251285553, -0.9852999448776245, 0.4556616544723511, -0.9150539636611938, -0.3897716701030731, 0.2372041493654251, -0.44862988591194153, -0.6636963486671448, 0.2548598051071167, 0.13270160555839539, -0.14799277484416962, 0.08558230102062225, 0.49398401379585266, 0.49713587760925293, -0.6393845677375793, 0.15989252924919128, 0.9079799056053162, 0.2850746512413025, -0.16893132030963898, -0.13847510516643524, 0.46408116817474365, -0.5901539921760559, -0.7651647925376892, 1.0340501070022583, -0.012375841848552227, 0.22129252552986145, -0.3420053720474243, 0.013152306899428368, 0.136427640914917, 0.14583350718021393, 0.03971247747540474, -0.31109198927879333, -0.810944676399231, -0.0584331676363945, 0.29711291193962097, -0.21427609026432037, 0.019512096419930458, 0.6869733929634094, -0.3974970877170563, -0.09260836243629456, -0.035293061286211014, -0.20944948494434357, -0.36903420090675354, -0.24628134071826935, -0.5938703417778015, -0.9914345145225525, -0.711793839931488, -0.6997531652450562, 0.10716774314641953, -0.2958448529243469, 0.7836955785751343, -0.2563014328479767, 0.31499049067497253, -0.271042138338089, 0.4815666675567627, 0.295054167509079, 0.7480660676956177, 0.042585987597703934, -1.459006428718567, -0.27672407031059265, -0.31569334864616394, -0.5566920638084412, -0.9109032154083252, -0.36994966864585876, -0.43982571363449097, 0.02925284393131733, 0.5974144339561462, -0.33580291271209717, 0.46731963753700256, -1.166347861289978, -0.6046218276023865, 0.22145265340805054, 0.07105060666799545, -0.12094121426343918, 0.19792184233665466, 0.12600485980510712, 0.8354593515396118, 0.30059391260147095, 0.027975760400295258, 0.2109949141740799, 0.43834057450294495, -0.5334025025367737, 1.1094460487365723, 0.005432696547359228, 0.14725878834724426, -0.497674822807312, -0.6785548329353333, -0.023266980424523354, 0.8319671154022217, -0.8364507555961609, 0.1869508922100067, -0.10430444031953812, 0.4196724593639374, -0.8505862951278687, -0.03394985944032669, 0.5335928797721863, 0.2704736292362213, -0.6016449928283691, 0.39107638597488403, -0.41922518610954285, -0.1563080996274948, 0.3786255717277527, -0.14931751787662506, -0.3429090082645416, -0.7303402423858643, 0.22304463386535645, 0.22807374596595764, 0.29537278413772583, 0.23969027400016785, 0.19783134758472443, -0.2543814778327942, 0.3402915596961975, 0.14001062512397766, -0.08055759966373444, -0.419609934091568, -0.3852598965167999, 0.8016646504402161, 0.6200246214866638, -0.14636683464050293, 0.587679386138916, -0.36923494935035706, -1.3870060443878174, 0.06511015444993973, -0.3077584505081177, -0.14654041826725006, 0.43641480803489685, -0.19412867724895477, -0.5935807228088379, -0.0025954353623092175, -0.3768483102321625, 0.47920098900794983, -0.029433362185955048, 1.1485365629196167, 0.43330690264701843, -0.43365129828453064, -0.370344877243042, -0.0951082855463028, -0.9888520240783691, 0.2475762516260147, -0.7732059359550476, 0.9502806067466736, -0.3391106128692627, -1.0262190103530884, -0.35916462540626526, 0.35232245922088623, -0.07256767898797989, -0.2567686140537262, 0.4049735367298126, -0.26642340421676636, -0.28874319791793823, 0.23900896310806274, -0.16110439598560333, -0.7425357103347778, -0.0045340717770159245, 0.1166888102889061, 0.1042131558060646, 0.39940887689590454, -0.10947570204734802, -0.7143734693527222, 0.3852381706237793, -0.6574969291687012, -0.3471671938896179, 0.8702685832977295, 0.3428053855895996, -0.07039281725883484, -0.2000328153371811, 0.600014865398407, 0.2575676441192627, 0.5921233296394348, -0.8617610931396484, 0.17141535878181458, 0.3159242868423462, 0.27941015362739563, 0.47836828231811523, -0.14223593473434448, -0.0027291285805404186, 0.7858601808547974, 0.24518762528896332, -0.2757363021373749, 0.40456488728523254, 0.07621848583221436, -0.15670864284038544, 0.07976720482110977, 0.002770721446722746, 0.06733711063861847, -0.15856750309467316, 0.5817185044288635, 0.7764527201652527, -0.36165550351142883, -0.2180207520723343, -0.57664555311203, 0.47100281715393066, 0.5222621560096741, -1.1855493783950806, -0.6950443983078003, -0.32008445262908936, -0.4465087652206421, 0.028988691046833992, 0.13149574398994446, -0.3201908469200134, -0.9293186664581299, 0.578303873538971, 0.2264721542596817, -0.05488032475113869, 0.6481542587280273, 0.6664264798164368, 0.6230161190032959, 0.6902760863304138, -0.011754818260669708, 0.27138930559158325, 0.47058069705963135, -0.12507279217243195, -0.8720044493675232, 0.10123253613710403, 0.044570524245500565, -0.4945288896560669, -0.1745775043964386, 0.25062453746795654, 0.12180157750844955, -0.34175142645835876, -0.17358724772930145, 0.5813584327697754, -0.14778557419776917, 0.7038790583610535, 0.028803464025259018, -0.47832924127578735, -0.43149280548095703, 0.7302500605583191, -0.40137460827827454, 0.3832053542137146, -0.18600274622440338, -0.22371914982795715, 0.5631505250930786, 0.9403606653213501, 0.9467576146125793, -0.3592401444911957, 0.43531137704849243, -0.15279386937618256, -0.46084633469581604, 0.45979973673820496, 0.8489277958869934, -0.4219166934490204, -0.09451286494731903, -0.7945985198020935, -0.1810278296470642, -0.218195840716362, -0.21841175854206085, -0.4474731385707855, -0.16976216435432434, 0.5747864246368408, 0.2517560124397278, -0.25644391775131226, -0.13481742143630981, 0.7921799421310425, 0.1622014194726944, -0.47451409697532654, -0.597693145275116, -0.1198670044541359, -0.21084719896316528, 0.14111824333667755, -0.7368473410606384, 0.3023950159549713, -0.4964989721775055, -0.026616202667355537, -0.6821777820587158, -0.28175532817840576, 0.040822677314281464, -0.8969928026199341, -0.5669662356376648, -0.12114045023918152, 0.2734666168689728, 0.8753752112388611, 0.08992850035429001, 0.22577598690986633, -0.15813055634498596, -0.3415352702140808, -0.5889937281608582, 0.7701500654220581, 0.09386111795902252, 0.3114233613014221, 0.5161408185958862, 0.32517603039741516, -0.9314345121383667, 0.7506148219108582, 0.6356058120727539, -0.5583141446113586, 0.7320784330368042, 0.16399294137954712, 0.03720026835799217, 0.30157631635665894, -0.4934607446193695, -0.17190727591514587, 0.32541266083717346, 0.43648967146873474, 0.40134933590888977, -0.29237133264541626, -0.0803462341427803, -0.7022786736488342, -0.6985806226730347, -0.42795825004577637, 0.35535910725593567, 1.1806056499481201, -0.45640113949775696, 0.05309361591935158, -0.9878970980644226, 4.147948265075684, 0.34784698486328125, 0.7116346955299377, -0.10742126405239105, 0.6680194139480591, 0.9318588376045227, 0.31025418639183044, 0.42858943343162537, 0.39302000403404236, -0.5583381652832031, -0.28275826573371887, 0.11900018900632858, 1.2538676261901855, 0.145497128367424, -0.09873649477958679, 1.151885986328125, -0.03295198827981949, -0.0603802427649498, 0.19990582764148712, -1.2748291492462158, -1.0828191041946411, 0.01350338477641344, 0.4927513003349304, 1.0997897386550903, 0.6597768664360046, 0.4158575236797333, -0.014789912849664688, -0.8727805018424988, -0.4712563753128052, -0.2421857714653015, -0.5542656183242798, -0.5895116329193115, 0.05411295220255852, 0.3132825195789337, -0.8713282942771912, 0.22050410509109497, 0.6319191455841064, -0.05453799292445183, 0.2673954665660858, 0.1315714567899704, -0.05431332811713219, -1.4415510892868042, 0.4751017093658447, -0.3978205919265747, -0.007648929487913847, 0.8192094564437866, 0.6410834789276123, 0.5074821710586548, 0.6279550790786743, 0.49204233288764954, -0.023351537063717842, 0.12257959693670273, -0.3556937873363495, 0.27942952513694763, -0.7415246963500977, -0.46033722162246704, -0.8765217065811157, -0.482494980096817, 0.05681941658258438, -0.801381528377533, 0.8871040344238281, -0.06410281360149384, -0.6397109031677246, 0.13876159489154816, -0.26340070366859436, 0.4560396671295166, 0.47142404317855835, 0.0720885843038559, -0.10978925228118896, 0.08588813245296478, -0.9796743392944336, 0.22650420665740967, 0.09508882462978363, 0.39132753014564514, 0.13471372425556183, 0.22751936316490173, -0.11216840147972107, 0.17357048392295837, 0.15800680220127106, 0.39412108063697815, -0.2150634378194809, 0.5215368866920471, -0.32695263624191284, 0.2686179280281067, -0.4042826294898987, 0.5674418807029724, -0.3029146194458008, -0.29785874485969543, -0.7464727163314819, 0.8156681060791016, 0.3935151696205139, 0.7263943552970886, -0.26876431703567505, 0.9059378504753113, -0.7737028002738953 ]
Magnetically Charged Black Holes and their Stability
We study magnetically charged black holes in the Einstein-Yang-Mills-Higgs theory in the limit of infinitely strong coupling of the Higgs field. Using mixed analytical and numerical methods we give a complete description of static spherically symmetric black hole solutions, both abelian and nonabelian. In particular, we find a new class of extremal nonabelian solutions. We show that all nonabelian solutions are stable against linear radial perturbations. The implications of our results for the semiclassical evolution of magnetically charged black holes are discussed.
Peter C. Aichelburg and Piotr Bizon
gr-qc hep-th
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212009
gr-qc/9212010
[ -0.01674354076385498, 0.2789967656135559, 0.009688024409115314, 0.07901977002620697, 0.14394140243530273, -0.16422484815120697, -0.2360275685787201, 0.20106157660484314, -1.2426201105117798, 1.4544481039047241, 0.9267190098762512, 0.2821935713291168, -0.11882577836513519, -0.9163558483123779, 0.22972625494003296, 0.22279556095600128, -0.013671171851456165, -0.2210659235715866, -0.9213213324546814, 0.1602519154548645, 0.14194107055664062, -0.028980253264307976, -0.7544560432434082, -0.3326457738876343, -0.2867998480796814, 0.6814279556274414, 1.0026347637176514, 0.5998516082763672, 1.280913233757019, 1.3029742240905762, 0.923985481262207, 0.0605049692094326, -0.4146397113800049, -0.6765136122703552, 0.4961380064487457, -0.1401325911283493, 0.201795294880867, -0.8155678510665894, 1.100929617881775, 0.4260098934173584, 0.5816672444343567, 0.2920193076133728, 0.2908056676387787, -0.6699144244194031, -0.8969772458076477, -0.13363699615001678, -0.11439944803714752, 0.15066999197006226, -0.3477441072463989, -0.9882902503013611, -0.6206241846084595, -0.21152269840240479, 0.600567638874054, -0.7651745676994324, -0.02514042519032955, -0.8066921234130859, -0.17221520841121674, 0.1776537448167801, -0.8792553544044495, 0.2182697057723999, 0.8562115430831909, 0.8704220652580261, 0.9209674596786499, -0.94236820936203, 0.46906206011772156, 1.5161888599395752, -0.534306526184082, 0.40654996037483215, -0.43308404088020325, -0.45269596576690674, -0.1394355744123459, -0.7439529895782471, -0.5900548100471497, 0.015079711563885212, -0.46298325061798096, 0.4828154146671295, -0.3834163248538971, -0.2720560133457184, -1.1392713785171509, 0.009247737005352974, 0.19095221161842346, -0.3204616606235504, -0.6585482954978943, 0.6899133920669556, -0.06488105654716492, 0.25640398263931274, 0.15159650146961212, -0.5144068598747253, -0.2136780321598053, -0.26729053258895874, -0.019402923062443733, 0.4747847616672516, 0.07924991846084595, -0.1549685001373291, 0.6262025833129883, 0.9364897012710571, -0.718545138835907, 0.6429271101951599, 0.23919083178043365, 0.5606624484062195, -0.3112854063510895, 0.8966493010520935, -0.2733069360256195, 0.3389854431152344, 0.1698063611984253, 0.042545679956674576, -0.289274662733078, 0.07905300706624985, -0.4021000862121582, -0.8276455402374268, 0.15644343197345734, 0.15752717852592468, 0.0640752837061882, -0.24249349534511566, -0.19776034355163574, 0.4246275722980499, -0.8654311895370483, -0.6472198963165283, -0.9591206908226013, -0.5449668765068054, 0.044278647750616074, 0.27289098501205444, 0.8103120923042297, 0.8172731399536133, -0.43760842084884644, -0.8537757992744446, 0.3695530593395233, 0.2306361049413681, -0.9472454786300659, 0.3808481693267822, 0.1351599395275116, -0.5433222055435181, -0.3900609016418457, 0.21226616203784943, 0.05719197168946266, 0.5879527926445007, -0.327007919549942, 0.17524735629558563, -0.7304619550704956, -0.981417179107666, 0.7106550931930542, -0.22394698858261108, 0.6382785439491272, 1.0251234769821167, 0.1275501847267151, 0.6018108129501343, 0.5184385776519775, 0.3185693323612213, 0.0454808808863163, 0.533942461013794, -0.07704738527536392, -0.6569406986236572, -0.1420486867427826, -0.23882202804088593, -0.5224664807319641, -0.045050811022520065, -1.0764375925064087, 0.4198247492313385, -0.24263031780719757, -0.01731906458735466, 0.3022857904434204, 0.6127122640609741, 0.10608714818954468, 0.9915607571601868, -0.5240845084190369, -0.13382278382778168, -0.18852491676807404, -0.00443896371871233, 0.21221335232257843, 0.25351038575172424, -0.23727768659591675, 0.09837745130062103, -0.32945212721824646, 0.5337620377540588, 1.200419545173645, 0.28862646222114563, 0.112174853682518, 0.06437131017446518, -0.04170260950922966, 0.3418111205101013, -0.39026588201522827, -0.3659698963165283, 0.7905080914497375, 1.080663800239563, -0.4776962399482727, -0.589996337890625, -0.047500304877758026, -0.0690089613199234, -0.28349968791007996, 0.41481536626815796, -0.07743487507104874, 0.6367246508598328, -1.755043387413025, 0.42923685908317566, -0.6717075109481812, 0.419903039932251, -1.0828624963760376, -0.05688000097870827, 0.48265358805656433, -0.9736893773078918, 0.11562753468751907, 0.22517958283424377, -0.7232075929641724, 0.3968158960342407, -0.5744749307632446, 0.35573992133140564, 0.6656880974769592, 0.40662240982055664, -0.13317100703716278, -0.6109070181846619, 0.4574781656265259, -0.12225894629955292, 0.3924660384654999, -0.27839395403862, 0.3399706780910492, -0.5369957089424133, -0.03232401981949806, 0.44129452109336853, 0.49857574701309204, -0.23419047892093658, 0.5311108231544495, 0.08593109250068665, -0.3405661880970001, 1.2048370838165283, 0.28393319249153137, -0.2256680428981781, -0.34243345260620117, 0.7581572532653809, -0.24243246018886566, 0.11524864286184311, 0.4892749786376953, 0.7681003212928772, 0.5578240752220154, 0.24866677820682526, 0.1983812302350998, -0.7557802200317383, 0.7006394267082214, 0.8885552287101746, 0.5388407707214355, 0.16703753173351288, -0.01189515646547079, 0.3856530785560608, 0.14979857206344604, -0.8343614339828491, 0.04191625863313675, 0.9916536211967468, -0.4746919274330139, -0.09049668163061142, -0.7801505923271179, 0.9850746393203735, -0.5052922964096069, 0.7153041362762451, -0.08150821924209595, -0.020713936537504196, -1.1234498023986816, 0.2963356673717499, 0.10638973861932755, 0.35166382789611816, 0.07714388519525528, -0.6304001808166504, -0.16552239656448364, 0.2057604342699051, -0.20327235758304596, -0.980899453163147, -0.40446358919143677, -0.022954199463129044, -0.874947190284729, -0.025797873735427856, 0.10072872787714005, 0.16060665249824524, -1.009183645248413, 0.41181275248527527, -0.5956210494041443, -0.1077047735452652, -0.4489995539188385, -0.27965787053108215, 0.7165207862854004, 0.43010273575782776, 0.33639153838157654, 0.16129924356937408, 0.5596583485603333, 0.35155490040779114, 0.2672126889228821, -0.08684004843235016, -0.24726276099681854, 0.2439119666814804, -0.9469532370567322, -0.11746275424957275, -0.6590383052825928, 0.32581472396850586, -0.12388435751199722, -0.46152910590171814, 0.2070748507976532, -0.49661847949028015, 0.8030557036399841, 0.39182090759277344, -0.5243963599205017, -0.6988970637321472, -0.30569514632225037, -0.5754023790359497, 0.7744410634040833, 0.1384856402873993, 0.21040546894073486, 0.11516942083835602, -0.4694574773311615, 0.5838292241096497, 0.6590083837509155, 0.2579743266105652, 0.9582091569900513, -0.4973852038383484, -0.26081645488739014, -0.15920859575271606, 0.28947800397872925, 0.712033748626709, -0.15853670239448547, 1.2036494016647339, 0.9899770021438599, -0.22800657153129578, 0.5568862557411194, 0.04451826214790344, -0.2872525155544281, -0.21347582340240479, 0.4500981271266937, -1.515601634979248, 0.8491654396057129, 0.5536507368087769, 0.6386302709579468, -0.6621202230453491, 0.29223451018333435, -0.9955018758773804, -0.040976494550704956, -0.1440703123807907, -0.6042953729629517, 0.13738299906253815, 0.06799371540546417, -0.10178903490304947, -0.3685271441936493, -0.34308773279190063, -0.08208741992712021, 0.6793195605278015, 0.5304874777793884, -0.7875277400016785, -0.25021228194236755, 0.1285949945449829, 0.4132183790206909, -0.33514508605003357, -0.04460793361067772, -0.5095531940460205, -0.2525619566440582, 0.4189428985118866, -0.13515718281269073, 0.30348262190818787, 0.3285769820213318, 0.00863732025027275, 0.05461987480521202, -0.21588844060897827, -0.3051890730857849, -0.18503674864768982, -0.9474217295646667, -0.9638850688934326, 0.19472205638885498, 0.1400446891784668, 0.2567007839679718, -0.40502408146858215, -0.9222341775894165, -0.6140521168708801, 0.4031108021736145, 0.22972740232944489, 0.7055221199989319, -1.0523688793182373, 0.2461334764957428, 0.08113420754671097, -0.44538700580596924, 0.27097615599632263, -0.20407141745090485, 0.6956697702407837, 0.3913368284702301, 0.1383361965417862, -0.2239113599061966, -0.3413088321685791, -0.7072270512580872, 0.042933396995067596, 0.6260627508163452, 0.5599696636199951, 0.6075707077980042, 0.07962062954902649, -0.8615449666976929, 0.2877894937992096, -0.34241199493408203, -0.27587175369262695, -0.23130059242248535, -1.221703290939331, 0.47519195079803467, -0.30148032307624817, -0.1785552203655243, -0.02719436213374138, 0.15192358195781708, 0.585412859916687, 0.3795388340950012, -0.1449451595544815, -0.4107939898967743, 0.11265822499990463, -0.06707309931516647, 0.6950469017028809, -0.4339645206928253, -0.32035452127456665, -0.34777477383613586, 1.003668189048767, 0.14978773891925812, 0.45708853006362915, 0.5861768126487732, -0.3835294544696808, 0.2389371544122696, -0.7324857711791992, 0.5878536105155945, 0.4839220941066742, -0.19261051714420319, 0.4816138446331024, 0.372031033039093, -0.5917938947677612, -0.1477244794368744, 0.09405355155467987, 0.709166944026947, 0.45560067892074585, -0.6137746572494507, -0.44393160939216614, 0.19754193723201752, 0.09027218818664551, 0.36658456921577454, 0.344582200050354, -0.3155107796192169, -0.9035632610321045, -0.6762714982032776, 0.3906276226043701, 0.15012024343013763, 0.08833986520767212, 0.7122608423233032, -0.4538702368736267, 0.3185916543006897, -0.24217750132083893, -0.5718107223510742, 0.37999749183654785, -0.48933228850364685, -0.7173535823822021, 0.0695965588092804, 0.15083152055740356, -0.13106459379196167, 1.047183871269226, -0.370784193277359, -1.0838156938552856, -0.23502382636070251, -0.08047616481781006, 0.5485785007476807, -0.00776111613959074, -1.0490456819534302, 0.1567075401544571, 0.03417418152093887, -0.780622124671936, 0.3910587728023529, -0.047200240194797516, 0.29710274934768677, 0.20260381698608398, -0.12244658172130585, -0.4024612009525299, 0.3096736669540405, -0.16253019869327545, -0.4040907919406891, 0.3417501747608185, 0.13507047295570374, 0.6683154106140137, 0.5818827748298645, 0.3729782998561859, -0.2887858748435974, 0.09902393817901611, 0.8239351511001587, -0.613321840763092, -0.15449059009552002, -0.199468195438385, -0.4114774763584137, -0.4602571129798889, -0.4149129092693329, 0.5950069427490234, 0.07276597619056702, 0.5623578429222107, 0.061755530536174774, -0.7967380285263062, -0.11111945658922195, -0.5317808389663696, -0.9734632968902588, -0.13160346448421478, 0.16146263480186462, -0.6546866297721863, 0.28939756751060486, 0.04765480011701584, 0.3972029387950897, 0.26961180567741394, -0.22315526008605957, -0.7665189504623413, -0.01778440922498703, -0.17613786458969116, 0.05009545385837555, 0.14418722689151764, -0.5270569920539856, 0.28805482387542725, -0.8521499633789062, 0.07526689022779465, -0.8213911652565002, -0.6717059016227722, 0.0812767818570137, 0.044949840754270554, -0.3596443831920624, -0.45026475191116333, 0.1555924117565155, -0.11643903702497482, -0.03860187530517578, 0.33338072896003723, -0.6474445462226868, -0.5165787935256958, -0.26540812849998474, 1.1370066404342651, -0.0514756515622139, -0.6723597049713135, -0.2590011656284332, 0.8596897721290588, -0.07133303582668304, 0.3549322187900543, 0.24824950098991394, -0.6812758445739746, 0.530488133430481, -0.7610086798667908, 1.0172348022460938, -0.8837620615959167, 0.23379740118980408, -0.6168950200080872, -0.2981839179992676, -0.22606410086154938, 0.11528030037879944, -0.14376331865787506, -0.0780242308974266, 0.0764513686299324, 0.21665532886981964, -0.0072803255170583725, 0.022407619282603264, 0.23649978637695312, -0.3237561583518982, 0.009415880776941776, -0.2086406797170639, 1.1382216215133667, -0.6895985007286072, 0.07408478111028671, 0.6149210929870605, -0.3112218677997589, -0.40050387382507324, 0.5486906170845032, -0.13300484418869019, 0.43428823351860046, -0.671090304851532, 0.3855915367603302, 1.068006157875061, 0.26324188709259033, -0.02411249466240406, 0.19090962409973145, -0.6137486696243286, 0.6705522537231445, -0.01945284754037857, 0.2404337376356125, 0.2816683351993561, 0.12395093590021133, 0.6322725415229797, -0.5232465267181396, 0.23201744258403778, 0.5103000998497009, -0.09850850701332092, 0.3665400445461273, -0.15239110589027405, -0.8712621927261353, 0.3507414758205414, -0.5544794201850891, -0.8715323805809021, 1.1285679340362549, 0.1217707097530365, -0.1838027387857437, -0.5048458576202393, -0.15277686715126038, 0.13062189519405365, -0.9743250012397766, 0.09882904589176178, 0.41362595558166504, 0.3343558609485626, 0.38188767433166504, -0.1924741417169571, -0.1120339184999466, -1.0031700134277344, -0.11868223547935486, -0.139799565076828, 0.08457078039646149, 0.10181806236505508, -0.9711686372756958, -1.2006666660308838, -0.6463693976402283, -0.4628531336784363, 0.16924643516540527, 0.7086706161499023, 0.037453435361385345, 0.6260582804679871, 0.0013836229918524623, -0.4881569445133209, -0.7737379670143127, -0.130885511636734, 0.5992162823677063, -0.0022250486072152853, 0.5448840260505676, 0.2130512148141861, -0.6276015043258667, -0.05901295691728592, -0.1375134289264679, -0.965840756893158, -0.6350992918014526, 0.39782029390335083, -0.45564213395118713, 0.1910773366689682, 0.5004464983940125, -0.13848473131656647, -0.77623051404953, -0.6704301238059998, -0.6787236332893372, -0.28456246852874756, 0.23528696596622467, -0.6058546304702759, 0.11564952880144119, -0.3175300359725952, 0.07270762324333191, 0.10744436085224152, 0.42940753698349, 0.3662348687648773, 0.1404685378074646, 0.23056556284427643, -0.028386345133185387, -0.37793663144111633, 0.09135019779205322, 1.3978489637374878, -0.2956881523132324, -0.890754222869873, -0.6519248485565186, 0.09463097900152206, 0.06786929816007614, -0.0497441329061985, 0.6949998140335083, -0.331214040517807, -0.19493438303470612, -0.18927791714668274, 0.8827869296073914, 0.5182873010635376, 0.4600585699081421, -0.3154655396938324, 0.24497917294502258, -0.686769962310791, -0.41173675656318665, 0.3537372946739197, -0.09296315908432007, -0.2145342230796814, 0.824665367603302, -0.35466960072517395, -0.14109650254249573, -0.20318295061588287, -0.28155094385147095, -0.5482574701309204, -1.1034398078918457, -0.004933708813041449, -1.5295721292495728, -0.48882776498794556, -1.8531486988067627, -0.5220807194709778, -0.030271321535110474, 0.6148968935012817, -0.5991430878639221, 0.7263635993003845, -0.26898011565208435, -0.1722376048564911, -0.20137690007686615, 0.7336208820343018, -0.6420947909355164, -0.4908519685268402, -0.4925004839897156, 0.4505364000797272, 0.5486770868301392, -1.0622352361679077, -0.3701367974281311, -0.5174241662025452, 0.3144333064556122, 1.325533151626587, -0.9672631621360779, 0.5221843719482422, -0.3355335295200348, -0.7092818021774292, 0.6968234777450562, -0.11020630598068237, -0.6365242004394531, 0.6668962836265564, 0.08115211874246597, 0.574844479560852, -0.101717010140419, 0.7260006666183472, 0.05394161865115166, -0.4199602007865906, -0.8545947074890137, 0.18874995410442352, -0.38086700439453125, -0.3797818124294281, 0.07674241065979004, -0.5827547311782837, 0.8274749517440796, -0.042055483907461166, -0.7434583902359009, 0.3989771902561188, -0.8182113766670227, 0.011284027248620987, -0.4935900866985321, 0.16468952596187592, 0.2158479392528534, 0.24277368187904358, -0.4777677655220032, -0.14121878147125244, -0.2779349684715271, 0.10023326426744461, 0.5928082466125488, 0.017639178782701492, 0.07771527022123337, -0.40081706643104553, -0.37726905941963196, -0.39569321274757385, 0.15474937856197357, 0.07900158315896988, 0.16026948392391205, 0.12181394547224045, -0.46669864654541016, -0.19465836882591248, -0.18447346985340118, 0.4630924463272095, -0.5346759557723999, 0.7400913834571838, 0.4318588674068451, 0.050801921635866165, 0.33522912859916687, -0.6608603596687317, -0.7515904307365417, 0.5717347860336304, -0.039694998413324356, -0.3438788056373596, -0.12204992026090622, 0.1984943151473999, -0.13398943841457367, 0.5829870104789734, -0.46000176668167114, 0.15440022945404053, 0.057919275015592575, 1.2283928394317627, 0.7384159564971924, -0.29401928186416626, -0.269959032535553, 0.088641457259655, -0.7322730422019958, -0.10047067701816559, -0.9629736542701721, 0.7081913352012634, -0.40152084827423096, -0.7425448894500732, -0.1029575914144516, 0.47400882840156555, -0.11734359711408615, -0.23009590804576874, 0.5486088991165161, -0.3503256142139435, 0.3067198097705841, 0.3448292911052704, -0.1973801851272583, -0.35233092308044434, -0.31355610489845276, 0.5097678303718567, 0.6221318244934082, -0.23109759390354156, 0.5022822022438049, -0.11534189432859421, 0.7937653064727783, 0.5577009320259094, 0.27471137046813965, 1.278525471687317, -0.29842737317085266, 0.025632256641983986, 0.3084225356578827, 0.017380334436893463, 0.7979592084884644, 0.836216151714325, -0.23775523900985718, 0.33755287528038025, 0.610116183757782, -0.0932975709438324, 0.8645167350769043, -0.45293641090393066, -0.022349553182721138, 0.5896372199058533, 0.10111383348703384, 0.12176790088415146, -0.20232881605625153, 0.5711979269981384, 0.025384631007909775, 0.5172339677810669, -0.3471076488494873, -0.27719932794570923, -0.3234612047672272, 0.3397151827812195, 0.2762323319911957, -0.17206412553787231, -0.27561822533607483, -0.13219718635082245, 0.359470009803772, 0.6455055475234985, -0.09673342853784561, -0.72186678647995, -0.5587339997291565, -0.14436842501163483, 0.485175758600235, -0.5903980731964111, -0.772817850112915, 0.6491063833236694, 0.40597429871559143, 0.1123901829123497, -0.5877488851547241, 0.6215700507164001, 0.18415480852127075, -0.11479749530553818, 0.8821340799331665, 0.6512817144393921, 0.6812440156936646, 0.6305399537086487, -0.20780803263187408, -0.9950252175331116, 0.033431459218263626, 0.36869674921035767, -0.9457367658615112, -0.02422742359340191, -0.22364723682403564, -0.010051405057311058, 0.03699886053800583, -0.5838867425918579, -0.02494135871529579, -0.615412175655365, 0.3314332962036133, 0.0721830278635025, -0.126541867852211, -0.10175760835409164, -0.01960384100675583, -0.3466757833957672, 0.732861340045929, 0.3475005328655243, -0.0058828191831707954, -0.31222572922706604, 0.46465665102005005, 1.3791048526763916, -0.0186791829764843, 0.40829038619995117, -0.27419641613960266, 0.1068403571844101, 0.7784136533737183, -0.17335247993469238, -0.3159235417842865, 0.5932084918022156, -0.09129710495471954, 0.22576136887073517, -0.29853254556655884, -0.19601453840732574, -0.5460426807403564, 0.01664530672132969, 0.22682541608810425, 0.29859548807144165, -0.15275408327579498, 0.07355382293462753, 0.4322986900806427, 0.5790082216262817, -0.41501960158348083, -0.6660685539245605, 0.2054034173488617, -0.8708047270774841, 0.02593967877328396, -0.7670718431472778, 1.168601632118225, -0.661815881729126, -0.17504678666591644, -0.3831753134727478, -0.38721153140068054, -0.13990679383277893, -0.688647449016571, -0.32104572653770447, -0.21401308476924896, 0.39419642090797424, 0.7092235684394836, -0.22035737335681915, 0.8597977161407471, -0.5440660119056702, -0.5326846837997437, -0.013966917991638184, 0.9030735492706299, 0.1195802167057991, 0.17457561194896698, 0.6556106805801392, 0.20752693712711334, -1.0532861948013306, 0.42276081442832947, 1.0946240425109863, -0.6329387426376343, 0.3580743968486786, -0.6392053961753845, -0.34280142188072205, -0.0798133984208107, 0.6560105085372925, 0.4438089430332184, 0.14105920493602753, 0.6852628588676453, -0.042796969413757324, -0.6284926533699036, 0.24940399825572968, -0.5924986600875854, -0.11704886704683304, -0.8962954878807068, 0.4406455159187317, 0.39065977931022644, -0.10549579560756683, 0.010493703186511993, -1.0338786840438843, 4.076398849487305, 0.6058471202850342, 0.6538302302360535, 0.24842335283756256, 1.0480538606643677, 1.1518267393112183, 0.17785310745239258, -0.37136387825012207, 0.3208128809928894, -0.4962965250015259, 0.1286952644586563, 0.2642834484577179, -0.011132904328405857, -0.05926860496401787, 0.2202034741640091, 0.819246768951416, 0.09576726704835892, -0.4717220664024353, -0.3562973737716675, -0.11971632391214371, -0.6134941577911377, 0.3073267936706543, 0.2436625212430954, 0.03048032708466053, 0.34031692147254944, 0.6643902063369751, 0.6224889159202576, -0.8161185383796692, -0.4442831873893738, -0.5506348013877869, -0.24987801909446716, -0.8063372373580933, -0.07898955047130585, -0.2872553765773773, -1.0337567329406738, 0.26963070034980774, -0.25856366753578186, 0.04066503047943115, 0.8333595991134644, 0.019328752532601357, 0.03635868430137634, -0.402028352022171, 0.542763888835907, -0.4581976532936096, 0.021494071930646896, 0.7509515285491943, 0.6370482444763184, 0.382917195558548, 0.6713688969612122, -0.5824618935585022, 0.187707781791687, 0.18415941298007965, 0.1653144657611847, -0.5077612996101379, -0.6144651174545288, -0.49960145354270935, 0.0014936156803742051, -0.3290601968765259, 0.4572528898715973, 0.1436060070991516, 0.36238518357276917, -0.4518337547779083, 0.02531825751066208, 0.31114399433135986, 0.6182174682617188, 0.42767947912216187, 0.02735654078423977, 0.15025000274181366, 0.5118830800056458, -0.5368510484695435, -0.6788694262504578, 0.08207529038190842, -0.6061208248138428, -1.1525089740753174, -0.4974279999732971, 0.5385299921035767, 0.5665091872215271, 0.7509542107582092, -0.22546438872814178, 0.3928459584712982, -0.5406999588012695, -0.6414660811424255, -0.21139267086982727, 0.2500617206096649, -0.019567547366023064, 0.12552694976329803, 0.169161856174469, -0.21891477704048157, -0.5948075652122498, 0.2041022926568985, 0.08412329107522964, 0.9961904883384705, -0.5069242119789124, 0.22694826126098633, -0.7068583965301514 ]
Black Hole Tunneling Entropy and the Spectrum of Gravity
The tunneling approach for entropy generation in quantum gravity is applied to black holes. The area entropy is recovered and shown to count only a tiny fraction of the black hole degeneracy. The latter stems from the extension of the wave function outside the barrier. In fact the semi-classical analysis leads to infinite degeneracy. Evaporating black holes leave then infinitely degenerate "planckons" remnants which can neither decay into, nor be formed from, ordinary matter in a finite time. Quantum gravity opens up at the Planck scale into an infinite Hilbert space which is expected to provide the ultraviolet cutoff required to render the theory finite in the sector of large scale physics.
A. Casher and F. Englert
gr-qc hep-th
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212010
gr-qc/9212011
[ 0.3663635551929474, -0.013141237199306488, 0.21554702520370483, 0.5847167372703552, 0.17232662439346313, -0.009704256430268288, -0.6426331400871277, 0.19001181423664093, -0.6913053393363953, 1.1056729555130005, 1.1879329681396484, 0.19448022544384003, -0.7600330114364624, -0.3128833770751953, -0.28232064843177795, 0.33721983432769775, 0.07661213725805283, -0.27101045846939087, -1.7277753353118896, -0.01961291767656803, 0.01989605464041233, 0.5612057447433472, -1.1920729875564575, -0.3343038260936737, -0.1542970836162567, 0.6121041178703308, 0.5825817584991455, 0.5072872638702393, 1.1568299531936646, 0.4998258054256439, 0.9278354644775391, -0.3120109438896179, -0.27596908807754517, -0.7423332333564758, -0.5095798373222351, -0.033737823367118835, -0.12401483952999115, -0.17368656396865845, 1.0090653896331787, -0.2542992830276489, 0.05224433168768883, 0.4256283938884735, 0.1158679872751236, -0.2270089089870453, -0.7186631560325623, -0.037233274430036545, 0.11325546354055405, 0.28244462609291077, 0.2645041346549988, -0.5344946384429932, -0.35826951265335083, -0.007889003492891788, 0.18893274664878845, -0.9524104595184326, -0.07690728455781937, -0.5495993494987488, 0.6674803495407104, 0.2099405825138092, -0.3039642572402954, 0.2425476312637329, 0.30178362131118774, 0.44895505905151367, 0.5836236476898193, -0.8901740312576294, 0.28346842527389526, 1.0530821084976196, -0.03955581411719322, 0.13931502401828766, 0.08479301631450653, -0.9491987228393555, 0.22193686664104462, -0.2776772975921631, -0.20544125139713287, 0.2529580593109131, -0.6232911944389343, 0.04883571341633797, 0.018316494300961494, -0.09910518676042557, -0.660843551158905, 0.1826639622449875, 0.47003185749053955, -0.22136938571929932, -0.38685286045074463, -0.23688772320747375, -0.5256267786026001, -0.48120152950286865, 0.17482545971870422, -0.3244636654853821, 0.11794940382242203, 0.056260980665683746, 0.0864255502820015, 0.6039299964904785, -0.08110271394252777, -0.34041157364845276, 0.7971559166908264, 0.7450013160705566, 0.0678543969988823, 0.3358006179332733, 0.3658992350101471, 0.09931343793869019, -0.06697621196508408, 0.7218407392501831, -0.07600931823253632, 0.44748491048812866, -0.6104108691215515, 0.7119562029838562, -0.08932067453861237, 0.2862713634967804, -0.38441038131713867, -0.8271608948707581, 0.29831844568252563, 0.1665613353252411, 0.32539913058280945, 0.2902613878250122, 0.01975928619503975, 0.5939497947692871, -0.19079707562923431, -0.1326690912246704, -0.8687714338302612, -0.5300156474113464, -0.12684795260429382, 0.5303177237510681, 0.5151157975196838, 0.97747403383255, 0.3156633675098419, -1.0147733688354492, -0.10443641245365143, -0.1259898692369461, -0.6431413292884827, 0.2173646092414856, -0.22539512813091278, -0.7117152810096741, 0.03976381570100784, 0.1666758507490158, -0.21892049908638, 0.33734631538391113, 0.17754481732845306, -0.38308510184288025, -0.26788967847824097, -0.5141744613647461, 0.3668416142463684, -0.8654674887657166, 0.2776658833026886, 0.6833967566490173, -0.47349169850349426, 0.06892012804746628, -0.2359492927789688, -0.23522397875785828, -0.0811217725276947, -0.23849470913410187, 0.04383325204253197, -0.2825600206851959, -0.3237600028514862, 0.45991355180740356, -0.15934792160987854, -0.017249563708901405, -1.4375512599945068, 0.18259704113006592, -0.23987312614917755, 0.06298433989286423, 0.45716992020606995, -0.07701180875301361, 0.07171580195426941, 0.8118377327919006, -0.3702321946620941, -0.07337487488985062, -0.5240577459335327, -0.2698923349380493, 0.35803359746932983, 0.10320862382650375, -0.5031974911689758, 0.01728597842156887, -0.19441817700862885, 0.8393092155456543, 0.9211441874504089, 0.7183243632316589, 0.2396741360425949, -0.0563797764480114, -0.5791488885879517, 0.2298983633518219, 0.006902712397277355, -0.8144203424453735, 0.9155727028846741, 0.6053441166877747, -0.9232375621795654, -0.6156061887741089, 0.18200521171092987, -0.29538753628730774, 0.3802279531955719, -0.19080157577991486, -0.8112974762916565, 0.9566734433174133, -1.2868753671646118, 0.3278715908527374, -0.6362183690071106, 0.2835046052932739, -1.2111314535140991, -0.07445844262838364, -0.023299768567085266, -0.3560497462749481, -0.12631569802761078, 0.1351374238729477, -0.7619139552116394, 0.25233909487724304, -0.9709871411323547, 0.31216415762901306, 0.06716407835483551, 0.8036621809005737, -0.3972707688808441, 0.2297997921705246, 0.4983779788017273, -0.4525319039821625, 0.031119033694267273, -0.20394209027290344, 0.2785987854003906, -0.4255460798740387, 0.02796137146651745, 0.38210803270339966, 0.16503818333148956, 0.2994115948677063, 0.8416754007339478, 0.2137700468301773, -0.13307476043701172, 0.49604612588882446, 0.13749893009662628, -0.23779858648777008, 0.446682870388031, 1.017898678779602, -0.25443071126937866, 0.5378460884094238, 0.023511985316872597, 0.2970646917819977, 0.030501438304781914, 0.3636237382888794, 0.3350602090358734, 0.2627975046634674, 0.7744100689888, 0.9422796368598938, -0.27395743131637573, -0.06875365972518921, 0.4462090730667114, 0.08577308803796768, -0.06018531695008278, -0.15834058821201324, -0.17372485995292664, 0.21170099079608917, 0.47949498891830444, 0.6088139414787292, -0.5317084193229675, 0.6710516810417175, -0.8366745710372925, 0.5653511881828308, 0.1907014101743698, -0.048239219933748245, -0.5876767039299011, 0.42329058051109314, 0.16758421063423157, 0.3537735641002655, -0.48092368245124817, -0.5085179209709167, -0.2580794095993042, 0.0701369196176529, 0.02085823006927967, -1.0155328512191772, -0.15810036659240723, 0.07480724155902863, -0.5122153162956238, 0.31874626874923706, 0.16766023635864258, -0.031684983521699905, -0.9066149592399597, 0.445872038602829, -0.3706905245780945, -0.07695800811052322, -0.45842862129211426, 0.10827544331550598, 0.13306614756584167, -0.653071939945221, 1.0327624082565308, -0.16366180777549744, 0.1173010841012001, 0.3699811100959778, -0.10076700150966644, -0.07818293571472168, -0.404754102230072, 0.008456314913928509, -0.4585331082344055, -0.15865986049175262, -1.1403303146362305, 0.7860294580459595, -0.4097593128681183, 0.024796761572360992, 0.17615625262260437, -0.20462779700756073, 0.31816139817237854, -0.219309464097023, -0.45414218306541443, 0.026857588440179825, -0.3654264509677887, -0.3054634928703308, 0.5454546213150024, 0.6153347492218018, 0.4175412952899933, 0.12058079242706299, -0.8282758593559265, 0.8785573840141296, -0.043335720896720886, -0.4592486023902893, 0.7626013159751892, -0.16207444667816162, -0.7806017994880676, 0.558121383190155, -0.39644894003868103, 0.339493066072464, -0.133035346865654, 0.9716119766235352, 0.8641929030418396, 0.03936741501092911, 0.191945880651474, -0.2873975336551666, -0.6819819211959839, -0.27572527527809143, 0.5274834036827087, -0.8593252301216125, 0.18887895345687866, 0.8353851437568665, 0.1508580446243286, -0.8982207775115967, 0.2630404233932495, -0.9814751744270325, -0.524578332901001, 0.04404648765921593, -0.22544260323047638, 0.24776221811771393, -0.3933003842830658, 0.4411488473415375, -0.3728674352169037, -0.1970054656267166, -0.7277122139930725, 1.2009509801864624, 0.22900649905204773, 0.05903416872024536, 0.3020269572734833, 0.13755735754966736, 0.4501916468143463, 0.10433351993560791, 0.5254915356636047, 0.052434682846069336, -0.15036259591579437, 0.5281484127044678, -0.2520788311958313, 0.3570888936519623, 0.12572047114372253, -0.7063458561897278, 0.20048746466636658, 0.13425137102603912, -0.016237353906035423, -0.6067631840705872, -1.1083011627197266, -0.4857005774974823, -0.40695732831954956, 0.7187309861183167, 0.2558716833591461, -0.44235342741012573, -0.6316062808036804, -0.20117801427841187, -0.5798737406730652, 0.18721000850200653, 0.2661963999271393, -1.0841453075408936, 0.1190449669957161, -0.19380134344100952, -0.5382503271102905, -0.09121019393205643, -0.17317071557044983, 0.2435409277677536, 0.5486029982566833, 0.6880856156349182, -0.17905092239379883, -0.08794189244508743, -0.7949007749557495, -0.33229127526283264, 0.5775175094604492, 0.08948470652103424, 0.8448172211647034, 0.14181315898895264, 0.2606092691421509, -0.08432479202747345, -0.13081054389476776, -0.6007320880889893, -0.12280996143817902, -0.9114213585853577, 0.4300120174884796, -0.726995050907135, 0.24624134600162506, -0.12144119292497635, 0.6555112600326538, 0.7770166397094727, 0.35898569226264954, -0.27177494764328003, 0.5585556030273438, 0.2548183500766754, 0.5170949697494507, 0.37140583992004395, -0.5331013202667236, 0.47568127512931824, -0.5590342283248901, 0.9391246438026428, 0.48577311635017395, 1.0697847604751587, 0.028264259919524193, -0.352464884519577, -0.10726551711559296, -0.3994655907154083, 0.7228874564170837, 0.024846937507390976, -0.5347288846969604, 0.14468863606452942, 0.43623268604278564, -0.06410108506679535, -0.8554978370666504, 0.4931390881538391, 0.5203248858451843, -0.142960324883461, 0.02623712085187435, -0.43810614943504333, 0.2619760036468506, -0.36803165078163147, 0.2264833301305771, 0.7420917749404907, -0.551567554473877, -0.7909744381904602, -0.27747759222984314, 0.4237009882926941, 0.07617919892072678, 0.5426633954048157, 0.8985061645507812, 0.7261638045310974, 0.23344989120960236, 0.05508194863796234, 0.1691884547472, 0.7843205332756042, -0.6077213883399963, -0.4950510263442993, 0.19855618476867676, 0.12324706465005875, 0.031262289732694626, 0.3623228967189789, -0.16661900281906128, -1.1017544269561768, 0.3039378821849823, -0.10677153617143631, 0.4711463451385498, -0.4686310589313507, -0.3763132393360138, -0.35488396883010864, 0.30854442715644836, -0.7814444899559021, 0.7997748255729675, 0.5986276268959045, 0.34155014157295227, 0.04996243864297867, -0.1981547474861145, -0.14311347901821136, 0.08631934225559235, 0.15840168297290802, -0.43027815222740173, 0.7016405463218689, 0.03922619670629501, 0.03137458488345146, 0.22700536251068115, 0.6505277752876282, -0.47032418847084045, 0.03843967616558075, 0.2906045615673065, -0.40016090869903564, -0.055294468998909, -0.010130546987056732, 0.1807122677564621, -0.6619735956192017, -0.21695466339588165, 0.2541455328464508, -0.35436856746673584, 0.6089908480644226, 0.1252942979335785, -0.6477311253547668, -1.0290498733520508, -0.7314669489860535, -0.7184789776802063, 0.39118069410324097, -0.45208218693733215, 0.08042427152395248, 0.5226145386695862, -0.6864556074142456, -0.22408047318458557, -0.25385618209838867, -0.04004872590303421, -0.3583833873271942, -0.20757970213890076, 0.7557766437530518, -0.5552501678466797, 0.7033965587615967, -0.5461073517799377, 0.5404731631278992, -0.05961373448371887, -0.4469611346721649, -0.6902332305908203, -1.1348923444747925, -0.053589656949043274, 0.2786578834056854, 0.5338582396507263, 0.06062836945056915, 0.2281380295753479, -0.31903043389320374, 0.2614171504974365, -0.2635078728199005, -0.12706494331359863, -0.5052928924560547, -0.4165102243423462, 0.3944421708583832, -0.08151650428771973, -0.4113583564758301, 0.0929541066288948, 0.5330703258514404, 0.2857314646244049, 0.5751336216926575, -0.3064176142215729, -0.9083892107009888, 0.6104068756103516, -1.3096554279327393, 0.710723876953125, -0.9345822930335999, 0.08722971379756927, -0.5851719379425049, -0.6168175935745239, 0.0976102352142334, 0.19111613929271698, 0.21716880798339844, -0.6405842900276184, -0.3940584063529968, -0.014428961090743542, 0.11609183251857758, -0.32999926805496216, 0.3100017309188843, -0.34476327896118164, -0.010835179127752781, -0.4837769865989685, 1.0354037284851074, -0.6019518375396729, 0.19325144588947296, 0.4497596025466919, 0.06989093869924545, -0.7302022576332092, 0.6451327204704285, 0.19093938171863556, -0.6643533110618591, -0.6869322061538696, 0.47594591975212097, 0.23944620788097382, -0.18678230047225952, 0.09590113908052444, 0.5184891819953918, -0.6723015308380127, 0.606971025466919, -0.4880122244358063, -0.27474164962768555, 0.3556273281574249, -0.1823553889989853, 0.35235926508903503, -0.13203740119934082, -0.29781079292297363, 0.7635423541069031, 0.48331552743911743, 0.2969318926334381, 0.1784086525440216, -0.6527699828147888, -0.10969385504722595, -0.20215854048728943, -0.6345677375793457, 0.572799563407898, 0.5241377353668213, -0.3783484697341919, -0.07553613930940628, -1.0415178537368774, -0.06659244000911713, -0.46093669533729553, 0.5614428520202637, 0.27998414635658264, 0.0672171339392662, -0.24781534075737, -0.17862418293952942, -0.44831687211990356, -0.8893871307373047, 0.5103833675384521, 0.23392412066459656, 0.12070374935865402, 0.35412588715553284, -0.553520143032074, -0.6300851106643677, -0.7390708327293396, -0.3969006836414337, 0.360198438167572, 0.8475496768951416, -0.1289607584476471, 0.7918388247489929, 0.2415875345468521, -0.3380559980869293, -0.24236100912094116, -0.004661493469029665, 0.31576231122016907, 0.15587280690670013, 0.3291774392127991, 0.38832563161849976, 0.19872869551181793, -0.8326423764228821, 0.27244266867637634, -1.0718421936035156, 0.2391515076160431, 1.2448484897613525, -1.08879554271698, -0.2160263955593109, 0.8483688831329346, 0.5527015328407288, -0.7860339283943176, -0.8013666868209839, -1.097830057144165, -0.4789719879627228, 0.18556874990463257, -0.13715395331382751, -0.09804342687129974, -0.22808486223220825, -0.0761004388332367, 0.3376222252845764, -0.03267744556069374, 0.4919480085372925, 0.3150883913040161, 0.3963083028793335, -0.36450591683387756, -0.5449119806289673, 0.3124932646751404, 1.6045721769332886, 0.012586751952767372, -0.9848574995994568, 0.31070587038993835, 0.06212373077869415, -0.05822497978806496, 0.11120076477527618, 0.5666724443435669, -0.7013254761695862, 0.021706243976950645, 0.08877560496330261, 0.18876416981220245, 0.5136522054672241, -0.008133778348565102, 0.3290146291255951, 0.17466041445732117, -0.3040440082550049, -0.7209914326667786, 0.37158074975013733, -0.2713187038898468, 0.06722169369459152, 0.4559858739376068, 0.09940273314714432, 0.18766416609287262, -0.45487236976623535, -0.2015531212091446, 0.02084234543144703, -1.0508686304092407, -0.4467214345932007, -1.1593748331069946, -0.8856850266456604, -0.9540428519248962, -0.03409399092197418, 0.7609907984733582, 0.2912118136882782, -0.30211639404296875, 0.21990449726581573, 0.24005107581615448, 0.0927223265171051, 0.19031484425067902, 0.9168210625648499, -0.4229724109172821, -0.32187914848327637, -1.047005534172058, 0.13850484788417816, 0.33791816234588623, -1.4716345071792603, -0.47174298763275146, -0.540020763874054, -0.3228999972343445, 1.2496271133422852, -0.4790298342704773, 0.8956694006919861, -0.5646037459373474, -0.4895818829536438, 0.16456864774227142, -0.2627533972263336, -0.8313720226287842, 0.8662864565849304, -0.5373961925506592, 0.6938034892082214, 0.09721090644598007, 0.9972205758094788, -0.19815772771835327, -0.36195293068885803, -1.012424111366272, 0.3319876194000244, -0.03842582926154137, 0.2594335973262787, 0.48828718066215515, -0.8159306049346924, 0.7351555824279785, 0.09028267115354538, -0.702246904373169, -0.24803100526332855, -0.3717704117298126, 0.3653484880924225, -0.27602675557136536, 0.1529923975467682, -0.31135934591293335, 0.6979227066040039, -0.09327292442321777, 0.40714606642723083, -0.3247302174568176, -0.20069800317287445, 0.16800200939178467, 0.3202924132347107, 0.36466464400291443, -0.09773091226816177, -0.48949792981147766, -0.14925222098827362, 0.3107169568538666, 0.7120305299758911, -0.15135963261127472, -0.08458942919969559, -0.41949209570884705, 0.09077006578445435, -0.31578943133354187, 0.7381445169448853, -0.5250638723373413, 0.6362764239311218, 0.2969430088996887, 0.014681834727525711, 0.0364401713013649, -0.694308876991272, -0.31558746099472046, -0.04939529299736023, -0.557108998298645, -0.629803478717804, 0.18443180620670319, -0.07534997910261154, -0.28064805269241333, 0.49209898710250854, -0.25953367352485657, 0.5156724452972412, -0.053765568882226944, 1.2176198959350586, 0.9205202460289001, -0.14471572637557983, -0.8556368947029114, 0.39858880639076233, -0.33065834641456604, -0.5137113928794861, -0.8819333910942078, 0.41862621903419495, -1.0379055738449097, -0.8054202795028687, -0.36222562193870544, 0.5805114507675171, -0.5922505855560303, -0.048806313425302505, -0.24688613414764404, -0.0043479641899466515, 0.41007351875305176, -0.3086284101009369, -0.8547255992889404, 0.049478691071271896, -0.624272882938385, 0.44745802879333496, 0.4732072651386261, -0.623939037322998, 0.3966573476791382, -0.16063249111175537, 0.5580602884292603, 0.45456022024154663, 0.2641659080982208, 1.0193581581115723, 0.3242012560367584, -0.1550164371728897, 0.1860475242137909, 0.4422730803489685, 0.5239092707633972, 0.7931376099586487, -0.515393853187561, 0.5580001473426819, 0.7055671811103821, 0.13182906806468964, 0.646075963973999, 0.20863880217075348, 0.47233742475509644, -0.04031038284301758, -0.21911656856536865, -0.13658028841018677, -0.06629779189825058, 0.004094874951988459, 0.37790438532829285, -0.3095298111438751, -0.11871965229511261, -0.21848250925540924, -0.24402302503585815, 0.40479135513305664, 0.0768570750951767, 0.019982248544692993, -0.5454276204109192, -0.5340253710746765, 0.22122667729854584, 0.5745941400527954, -0.4474857449531555, -0.8457834720611572, -0.7551162838935852, 0.1578403115272522, 0.22118690609931946, -0.1987045258283615, -0.5171332955360413, 0.48785173892974854, 0.3968912363052368, -0.1966208815574646, -0.2300562858581543, 0.37981775403022766, 0.623720109462738, 0.5795809030532837, 0.419464111328125, 0.4781872034072876, 0.3552357256412506, 0.7496277093887329, -0.7495676279067993, -0.8040335774421692, 0.49978774785995483, 0.23071321845054626, -0.8341990113258362, -0.1950540989637375, -0.6651325821876526, 0.12978312373161316, -0.20250234007835388, -0.9901916980743408, -0.23117727041244507, -0.18955133855342865, -0.2051956057548523, 0.395233154296875, -0.48290184140205383, -0.4195927083492279, -0.013904535211622715, 0.3164217174053192, 0.18651707470417023, 0.7979699969291687, 0.3842996060848236, -0.17731626331806183, 0.1665523648262024, 1.2382097244262695, 0.2923153340816498, 0.5260916948318481, -0.2860254645347595, 0.039978232234716415, 0.5557316541671753, 0.6278601288795471, -0.27953752875328064, 1.0197051763534546, -0.2258247584104538, 0.05898014456033707, -0.1685955971479416, 0.06374002248048782, -0.27427494525909424, 0.08277534693479538, 0.6332963109016418, 0.409871369600296, -0.34107300639152527, 0.4912535548210144, 1.2671332359313965, 0.7938710451126099, -0.017192121595144272, -0.4719565808773041, 0.5758102536201477, -0.7421273589134216, -0.05100273713469505, -1.0580698251724243, 0.5523389577865601, -0.0863727554678917, 0.1969432234764099, -0.5474610328674316, -0.8569261431694031, -0.36080202460289, -1.002559781074524, 0.38552048802375793, -0.9587899446487427, 0.23265525698661804, 0.6916479468345642, 0.12792669236660004, 0.34965330362319946, -0.8545882701873779, -0.44858089089393616, -0.45725587010383606, 1.298095703125, 0.3856787085533142, -0.2601603865623474, 1.1246936321258545, 0.19467990100383759, -0.8847579956054688, 0.5017900466918945, 0.6002440452575684, -1.41777765750885, 0.6845453977584839, -0.13484765589237213, 0.7255682945251465, -0.031516183167696, -0.3334804177284241, 0.343494713306427, -0.11635012924671173, 0.7478058338165283, 0.3356887996196747, -0.373226523399353, 0.09924336522817612, -0.45590919256210327, -0.5185261964797974, -0.6140537261962891, 0.3242773413658142, 0.21423222124576569, -0.4965643286705017, 0.0567987859249115, -1.3926187753677368, 4.198882102966309, 0.9876793026924133, 0.4290091097354889, 0.3225390911102295, 0.694429337978363, 0.7109605073928833, -0.10159993916749954, -0.0155265424400568, 0.41814830899238586, -0.6961584091186523, -0.045864287763834, -0.20112162828445435, 0.056748755276203156, -0.006835682317614555, 0.09686923772096634, 0.49606433510780334, -0.03628327324986458, -0.21104665100574493, -0.5229257345199585, -0.39924824237823486, -0.9315912127494812, 0.05721031501889229, 0.21532252430915833, -0.24812892079353333, 0.4838687777519226, 0.5797693133354187, -0.004598117433488369, -0.525248646736145, -0.4964637756347656, -0.4621697962284088, -0.19782212376594543, -0.5827345848083496, 0.2753237187862396, -0.19737949967384338, -1.3930625915527344, 0.3912605047225952, -0.32529446482658386, -0.5536674857139587, 0.27338528633117676, -0.22943803668022156, 0.3251114785671234, -0.37219518423080444, 0.22230060398578644, -0.7167348861694336, -0.45124608278274536, 1.122373104095459, 0.34157633781433105, 0.448137104511261, 0.6771842241287231, -0.9469195008277893, -0.15752539038658142, 0.19564425945281982, 0.4357994794845581, -0.6694352626800537, -1.024745225906372, -0.3499663174152374, 0.1501251608133316, -0.20005379617214203, 0.5519405007362366, 0.3073979318141937, 0.6962118148803711, 0.0877898633480072, -0.3021817207336426, 0.2557271718978882, -0.01610463298857212, 0.18284781277179718, 0.29473960399627686, 0.10496136546134949, -0.07673320919275284, 0.2758372724056244, -0.8672507405281067, -0.4231663644313812, -0.3502858877182007, -0.28953152894973755, 0.13773615658283234, 0.10234348475933075, -0.12490846961736679, 0.3601457476615906, -0.1578287035226822, 0.2824859917163849, -0.2747195065021515, -0.14664794504642487, -0.12419432401657104, 0.05379892885684967, 0.13092032074928284, 0.8052034378051758, 0.32415759563446045, 0.32369765639305115, -0.26489102840423584, 0.2873309254646301, 0.03392213582992554, 1.0163228511810303, -0.18166884779930115, 0.38590291142463684, -0.7285093069076538 ]
A Nonlinear Model of a Quantum Minisuperspace System with Back Reaction
We consider the quantum evolution of the space-independent mode of a $\lambda {\phi}^4$ theory as a minisuperspace in the space of all $\phi$. The motion of the wave packet in the minisuperspace is then compared to the motion of a wave packet in a larger minisuperspace consisting of the original minisuperspace plus one space-dependent mode. By comparing the motion of the two packets we develop criteria that tell us when the quantum evolution in the space-independent minisuperspace gives us useful information about the true evolution in the larger minisuperspace. These criteria serve as a toy model for similar(but much more complex) criteria that will tell us whether or when quantized gravitational minisuperspaces can possibly give any useful information about quantum gravity.
Marcos Rosenbaum, Michael P. Ryan and Sukanya Sinha
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212011
gr-qc/9212012
[ 0.37406083941459656, 0.3879059851169586, 0.4637100398540497, 0.3705653250217438, 0.3825942575931549, -0.28896793723106384, -0.17383846640586853, 0.2783181965351105, -0.3143898546695709, 1.1175098419189453, 0.4135008156299591, 0.21162308752536774, -0.024946600198745728, -0.7199405431747437, 0.016229545697569847, 0.34347623586654663, -0.05220077559351921, -1.151431918144226, -1.5143977403640747, 0.07238435000181198, -0.5074184536933899, -0.1503598839044571, -0.536516010761261, -0.47534382343292236, -0.060982417315244675, 0.6039021015167236, 0.17197537422180176, 0.008025513961911201, 1.0266231298446655, 0.590507447719574, 0.020899631083011627, -0.006322004366666079, -0.22556143999099731, -0.6225591897964478, -0.15173828601837158, -0.26565760374069214, 0.4013819396495819, -0.6096319556236267, 0.6080003380775452, -0.22239266335964203, 0.6097633242607117, -0.17145483195781708, 0.456962525844574, -0.4906211793422699, -0.7989328503608704, 0.7017523646354675, -0.14397697150707245, 0.5956644415855408, -0.5388811826705933, -0.6350942850112915, -0.4278753995895386, -0.1677204817533493, -0.24893252551555634, -0.9626267552375793, -0.11534179002046585, 0.03557949885725975, 0.07840438932180405, 0.0068686483427882195, -0.7240204215049744, -0.6943756341934204, 0.2573094964027405, 0.8330951929092407, 0.2389393001794815, -0.31976255774497986, -0.3501009941101074, 0.8613592982292175, 0.10299555957317352, 0.3263321816921234, 0.3998890519142151, -0.049023181200027466, -0.728412926197052, -0.47244688868522644, 0.1978827714920044, 0.472309947013855, -0.18105991184711456, 0.42561808228492737, 0.08086340874433517, -0.7441510558128357, -0.21065399050712585, -0.34575244784355164, 0.1873260885477066, 0.5557844042778015, 0.14476145803928375, 0.22561274468898773, -0.40820515155792236, -0.6488631963729858, 0.4370171129703522, -0.1655891090631485, 0.9911476373672485, 0.08515195548534393, -0.6235178112983704, 0.6835612058639526, -0.16816306114196777, 0.3993658721446991, 1.0248448848724365, 0.5684909820556641, -0.1406690627336502, 0.624998152256012, 0.2683054208755493, 0.5431631803512573, -0.49742043018341064, 1.5668150186538696, -0.8247342705726624, 0.05068518966436386, -0.6628109216690063, 0.8049662709236145, -0.23791342973709106, 0.545055627822876, -0.18651728332042694, -0.5650253891944885, 0.40757429599761963, -0.11539417505264282, 0.8038396835327148, 0.5432729125022888, 0.4135613441467285, 0.7151196002960205, -1.1881649494171143, 0.0963156595826149, -1.3009730577468872, -0.32684066891670227, -0.8710100650787354, 0.8660071492195129, -0.21763679385185242, 0.4887910485267639, -0.24074742197990417, -0.722763180732727, -0.5387895703315735, 0.5650419592857361, -0.8664705753326416, 0.8123570084571838, 0.47685563564300537, -0.8652786612510681, -0.009096809662878513, 0.7587760090827942, 0.12764129042625427, 0.2820585370063782, 0.34005168080329895, 0.11468812078237534, -0.2585810124874115, -0.6785998344421387, -0.01439596712589264, -0.44222643971443176, 0.42545291781425476, 1.222951054573059, -0.7083644270896912, 0.5730606913566589, 0.31138867139816284, -0.5575673580169678, -0.8912238478660583, 0.29617881774902344, -0.5617137551307678, -0.13560622930526733, 0.1753610074520111, 0.40884578227996826, 0.46270596981048584, -0.5550826787948608, -0.9292799234390259, -0.6210950613021851, 0.059423819184303284, -0.3083140254020691, 0.9157110452651978, -0.41122227907180786, 0.6129645109176636, 1.2898305654525757, 0.4357878565788269, 0.6423560976982117, -0.5199828743934631, 0.13078269362449646, 0.16756442189216614, 0.11068527400493622, -0.3877914249897003, 0.488861620426178, 0.6149523258209229, 0.2348524034023285, 0.8854236006736755, 0.3029375970363617, 0.2652568519115448, 0.049514155834913254, -0.7731467485427856, 0.9969197511672974, 0.39206019043922424, -0.03321055695414543, 0.37289875745773315, 0.21488595008850098, -0.5446211099624634, -0.2637762725353241, 0.3145863711833954, -0.37214675545692444, 0.009452537633478642, 0.08597423136234283, -0.6060654520988464, 0.863511860370636, -1.4769833087921143, 0.3665131628513336, -0.8181731700897217, 0.12343765050172806, -0.27294236421585083, -0.04143259674310684, -0.16640302538871765, 0.21800565719604492, 0.2725321650505066, -0.11370660364627838, -0.8606231808662415, 0.24976126849651337, -1.1223289966583252, -0.11195267736911774, 0.6433943510055542, 0.23874565958976746, -0.24531716108322144, -0.3189243972301483, 0.752930223941803, -0.2571676969528198, -0.08760057389736176, -0.2911781668663025, 0.7122666239738464, 0.39478549361228943, -0.4288119375705719, 0.13608524203300476, 0.2600816786289215, 0.21796956658363342, 0.5433505177497864, -0.030476372689008713, -0.48435333371162415, 1.3877054452896118, 0.49443233013153076, -0.8049172163009644, -0.507213830947876, 0.6965067386627197, -0.11537779122591019, 0.22311744093894958, -0.08075771480798721, -0.21816755831241608, 0.049664147198200226, 0.06449442356824875, 0.43248456716537476, -0.6246082186698914, 0.7415077686309814, 1.0707833766937256, -0.1962919980287552, 0.04207766428589821, 0.4331803619861603, -0.0782933309674263, 0.40167656540870667, 0.7154561877250671, -0.6039400696754456, 0.5581075549125671, 0.41970330476760864, -0.40374013781547546, -0.7995033264160156, 0.7869495749473572, -0.7777476906776428, 1.0018489360809326, 0.08913112431764603, -0.16192153096199036, -1.747633695602417, 0.016112977638840675, -0.30949532985687256, 0.7670976519584656, 0.33147189021110535, -0.5959388017654419, -0.24599725008010864, -0.2507966160774231, -0.12345552444458008, -0.37216711044311523, -0.35564085841178894, 0.001970555167645216, -0.680484414100647, 0.014692030847072601, 1.240166425704956, -0.501140296459198, -0.9924359321594238, -0.277559369802475, -0.30494317412376404, -0.21629011631011963, -0.14020389318466187, 0.3516831696033478, -0.13620202243328094, 0.026687458157539368, 0.3396984040737152, 0.6221683621406555, 0.04840843752026558, -0.05902088060975075, -0.5192452669143677, 0.1523885279893875, -0.2188740074634552, 0.3234268128871918, -1.2669525146484375, -0.4068310260772705, -0.8839649558067322, 0.6755450367927551, -0.2799031138420105, -1.0418705940246582, 0.5038720369338989, -0.4036279320716858, 0.2801583409309387, 0.5396047830581665, -0.01185389794409275, 0.2974950075149536, -0.20963694155216217, -0.25393933057785034, 0.6111204028129578, 0.17832845449447632, 0.26216623187065125, -0.3950956165790558, -0.3761228919029236, 0.6941357254981995, -0.15440113842487335, -0.5550007224082947, 0.4627002775669098, -0.09870439767837524, -0.4181585907936096, 0.0567190945148468, 0.07932917028665543, 0.9611302614212036, -0.3275690972805023, 0.4795537292957306, 0.5184668302536011, -0.11053064465522766, 0.40853437781333923, -0.7966728210449219, -0.5614023804664612, -0.4099764823913574, 0.48487114906311035, -0.8390039801597595, 0.25965896248817444, 1.1804404258728027, 0.36507534980773926, -0.6531240940093994, 0.485426127910614, -0.9493195414543152, -0.7954845428466797, -0.019310779869556427, -0.3270290195941925, 0.23451991379261017, 0.5544305443763733, 0.1729990690946579, -0.7792915105819702, -0.17350517213344574, -0.2968113124370575, 0.3394533097743988, 0.2995690107345581, -0.5000436902046204, -0.4265797436237335, 0.578195333480835, 0.13137635588645935, 0.32776620984077454, 1.027244210243225, -0.7590861916542053, 0.31665492057800293, -0.15649305284023285, -0.12550364434719086, -0.5419564247131348, 0.16376373171806335, 0.0395941436290741, -0.0431705042719841, 0.13499797880649567, -0.09571816772222519, -0.05647890269756317, -0.7622702717781067, -0.5515992641448975, 0.415365070104599, 0.12294642627239227, 0.15207821130752563, -0.5203804969787598, -0.3653530478477478, 0.18789558112621307, -0.22611278295516968, 0.26036667823791504, 0.32465946674346924, -0.7237620949745178, -0.002377077704295516, 1.00442636013031, -0.27307796478271484, -0.13143539428710938, -0.580352783203125, 0.11616924405097961, 0.8341848850250244, 0.10734361410140991, 0.3773791193962097, 0.4109130799770355, 0.03597177565097809, -0.48909568786621094, 0.4073789715766907, 0.29061248898506165, 0.4000968635082245, 0.16276432573795319, -0.32274022698402405, 0.24651113152503967, 0.10773307830095291, -0.32757067680358887, -0.6483860015869141, -1.1655993461608887, 0.1385418176651001, -0.9212585091590881, -0.635589599609375, 0.06596405804157257, -0.021198859438300133, 0.8641122579574585, -0.556458592414856, 0.0683804526925087, -0.17540253698825836, -0.28331172466278076, 0.023273548111319542, 0.28376004099845886, -0.4736887812614441, 0.02012716419994831, -0.8806854486465454, 0.05930740758776665, 0.29213747382164, 0.19900228083133698, 0.5743635892868042, -0.894256591796875, 0.09595741331577301, 0.16609501838684082, 1.5382392406463623, 0.060033105313777924, -0.6865421533584595, 0.8767128586769104, 0.40560656785964966, -0.30247074365615845, -0.8599615693092346, 0.340909481048584, 0.8265480995178223, 0.5707614421844482, -0.5318788290023804, -0.6513089537620544, 0.09365996718406677, -0.7074307799339294, 0.1495547741651535, 0.5730522274971008, -0.04301191493868828, -0.13386929035186768, -0.07980336248874664, 0.25592172145843506, 0.5393937230110168, 0.46797433495521545, 0.49588295817375183, 0.6129440069198608, 0.3144717514514923, -0.15461701154708862, -0.32036465406417847, 1.1874645948410034, 0.06067649647593498, -0.2416735291481018, 0.11419831961393356, 0.2136864960193634, -0.5467603802680969, 0.5687528252601624, -0.08666542917490005, -1.2471249103546143, -0.33605825901031494, -0.3387913703918457, 0.5233335494995117, -0.09075094759464264, -0.9651864767074585, 0.4317135214805603, -0.3494660556316376, 0.1477959156036377, 0.7551100850105286, -0.3731098771095276, -0.4302103817462921, -0.06608861684799194, -0.7165083885192871, -0.757499635219574, -0.7393929958343506, 0.1015629768371582, -0.2979603111743927, 0.5979322195053101, 0.6140503883361816, 0.10731436312198639, 0.406282901763916, -0.02004295028746128, -0.026433300226926804, 0.07277823239564896, 0.5508127212524414, -0.46543270349502563, -0.12655876576900482, 0.3659767508506775, -0.5935467481613159, -0.6162149310112, -0.4566541016101837, 0.4634094536304474, 0.011058609932661057, -0.1872709095478058, -0.5146970152854919, -0.23591075837612152, -0.5016840696334839, -0.42433252930641174, -0.8838343620300293, 0.39633071422576904, -0.4967957139015198, -0.08326844871044159, -0.1463676393032074, -0.14828521013259888, 0.16945238411426544, -0.11743678897619247, 0.017199398949742317, -0.12532323598861694, -0.4119328260421753, 0.4486840069293976, -0.3694993257522583, 0.08789654076099396, -0.6203638911247253, 0.5985057353973389, -0.26097193360328674, -0.4350469410419464, -0.8108344674110413, -0.5231890082359314, -0.25375857949256897, 0.2676950693130493, -0.11945861577987671, 0.13708238303661346, -0.13297559320926666, 0.25758376717567444, -0.009908318519592285, 0.7035298347473145, -0.2855055034160614, -0.5730860233306885, 0.4138846695423126, 0.5575349926948547, 0.000807779491879046, -0.7936958074569702, -0.17008985579013824, 0.5616757273674011, 0.027888746932148933, 0.5200223922729492, 0.2588726878166199, -0.1807769238948822, 0.3614172041416168, -1.401495099067688, 0.09083250164985657, -0.8879058361053467, 0.0179219339042902, -0.14347167313098907, -0.3661545515060425, 0.41064152121543884, 0.1601993590593338, 0.3377761244773865, -0.7752559185028076, -0.2795764207839966, -0.6831430792808533, 0.7164010405540466, -0.4367460310459137, -0.47781240940093994, -0.7683622241020203, -0.11948448419570923, -0.6975997090339661, 1.0747073888778687, -0.25275397300720215, 0.08259765803813934, 0.5402848124504089, 0.1471661925315857, -0.2504917085170746, 0.5245525240898132, 0.08861372619867325, 0.08516010642051697, -0.49398523569107056, 0.10406523942947388, 0.447421133518219, 0.648695707321167, -0.6157562732696533, 0.382475882768631, -0.6822560429573059, 0.789387047290802, -0.3243149518966675, 0.16266050934791565, 0.008123233914375305, -0.18951617181301117, -0.06688430160284042, -0.5463073253631592, 0.015188775956630707, 1.2696610689163208, 0.4202384650707245, 0.3562004864215851, -0.22463665902614594, -0.22171199321746826, -0.19221645593643188, -0.2885257303714752, -0.21697141230106354, 0.7615105509757996, 0.04845636710524559, -0.12925897538661957, -0.7495918869972229, -0.05674760043621063, 0.2783290147781372, -0.600919246673584, 0.7609961628913879, 0.3092304766178131, 0.12353591620922089, 0.36280709505081177, -0.5691116452217102, -0.07230472564697266, -0.011948330327868462, 0.35714614391326904, 0.24636584520339966, 0.3562674820423126, -0.038174062967300415, -0.022945381700992584, -0.24739086627960205, -0.5370436906814575, -0.34520792961120605, 0.39292171597480774, 0.28104349970817566, -0.8044910430908203, 0.327615350484848, -0.16449201107025146, -0.08603151142597198, -0.6338583827018738, -0.028999801725149155, 0.16241702437400818, -0.22621354460716248, 0.19341854751110077, 0.20476673543453217, 0.4907142221927643, 0.8558282256126404, -0.1627587080001831, -0.46270492672920227, -0.6200470328330994, 0.8997365236282349, -1.0525814294815063, 0.18546278774738312, 0.15503181517124176, -0.07050228118896484, -0.38409122824668884, -1.095287799835205, -0.838029146194458, -0.08399368822574615, 0.38597333431243896, -0.5511746406555176, 0.03814959153532982, -0.05094430223107338, -0.21224237978458405, 0.5106881856918335, 0.05759669840335846, 0.5796024799346924, 0.1448369324207306, 0.17638222873210907, 0.3645508289337158, -0.5333541035652161, 0.45899274945259094, 1.006781816482544, 0.42187395691871643, -0.365550696849823, 0.15061704814434052, -0.4563012719154358, -0.6555827856063843, -0.36686399579048157, 0.29299625754356384, -0.22928735613822937, 0.24648955464363098, 0.031517043709754944, -0.1593829095363617, 0.23168422281742096, 0.17031671106815338, -0.28272077441215515, 0.33993110060691833, -0.7958945035934448, -0.3269590139389038, -0.14431552588939667, -0.17685307562351227, 0.39167320728302, 0.8832130432128906, 0.37654417753219604, -0.10228151082992554, -0.5043640732765198, 0.2178134322166443, 0.5491223335266113, -0.8905152082443237, -0.6583274006843567, -1.0761098861694336, -0.9246479868888855, -1.2217612266540527, -0.3286242187023163, -0.024628285318613052, 0.8896878957748413, -0.1655515730381012, 0.42816758155822754, 0.2843710780143738, 0.0005641219904646277, 0.6096130013465881, 0.5908255577087402, -0.13478997349739075, -1.0496834516525269, -0.4377572536468506, -0.0333990715444088, 0.17695125937461853, -1.3924980163574219, -0.3608914017677307, -0.10631714761257172, 0.3350217640399933, 1.2018672227859497, -0.23100736737251282, -0.06591226905584335, -0.8779535293579102, -0.8962161540985107, 0.7960094213485718, 0.3289269208908081, -0.1934165507555008, 1.0236120223999023, -0.6145567297935486, 0.9501228332519531, 0.2310500591993332, -0.498487263917923, -0.018114570528268814, 0.6472089886665344, -0.5182293057441711, 0.9533976316452026, 0.3975934684276581, 1.2324410676956177, 0.3630274534225464, -1.3135602474212646, 0.09755943715572357, 0.785548210144043, -0.6196883916854858, 0.08045615255832672, -0.4286103844642639, 0.6637653708457947, -0.9272100329399109, 0.45496249198913574, 0.31524381041526794, 0.24029843509197235, -0.13731637597084045, 0.23098458349704742, -1.0809155702590942, -0.13131271302700043, -0.03479761257767677, 0.22265207767486572, -0.16342899203300476, -0.557513952255249, 0.6615667343139648, -0.6333250999450684, 0.523820161819458, 0.28488603234291077, 0.2615734040737152, 0.28681227564811707, 0.3373294770717621, -0.14458565413951874, -0.6106374859809875, -0.13608835637569427, -0.00908825546503067, 0.8533605337142944, 0.014798479154706001, 0.3178800642490387, 0.7534059882164001, 0.10052043944597244, -1.4368946552276611, 0.07833878695964813, 0.01986326463520527, -0.3637021481990814, 0.27133771777153015, -0.448340505361557, 0.34041333198547363, 0.8054121732711792, -0.6831738948822021, 0.3962445855140686, -0.13978420197963715, 1.1720271110534668, 0.7167555093765259, 0.23575946688652039, 0.28159210085868835, 0.5103124380111694, -0.644142210483551, -0.09712592512369156, -0.20185957849025726, 0.37350574135780334, -1.0233079195022583, -0.4077566862106323, -0.48318809270858765, 0.07393282651901245, -0.261905699968338, -0.5057706832885742, 0.37467512488365173, -0.3383597433567047, -0.5289852619171143, -0.07015342265367508, -0.6198738813400269, -0.5461075305938721, -0.661450982093811, 0.10999218374490738, -0.13555605709552765, -0.34380918741226196, -0.1658007949590683, -0.28959453105926514, 0.5611624121665955, 0.371527761220932, 0.29475727677345276, 0.9395192265510559, 0.31185153126716614, -0.018280882388353348, -0.09051783382892609, 0.6177476644515991, 0.2157512754201889, 0.5985026955604553, -0.39570727944374084, 0.013393065892159939, 0.39785099029541016, 0.020594924688339233, 1.0421479940414429, 0.0852203369140625, -0.44652795791625977, 0.5712228417396545, 0.24909155070781708, 0.5040797591209412, 0.025961454957723618, 0.06361295282840729, -0.3683653175830841, 0.13933557271957397, -0.3140036165714264, -0.17544889450073242, -0.2601732015609741, 0.21713171899318695, 0.02129983901977539, -0.04682081937789917, 0.09036076068878174, -0.6781636476516724, 0.013534290716052055, -0.14731308817863464, -0.8177688717842102, -1.3003158569335938, -0.8991744518280029, -0.02777518704533577, -0.0905449241399765, 0.12708988785743713, 0.057731710374355316, 0.6186739802360535, 0.5710045099258423, -0.25157198309898376, -0.7805310487747192, 0.22585618495941162, 0.0008585220202803612, 0.7066829204559326, 0.8138956427574158, 0.5881227254867554, 0.10405997931957245, 0.2499428391456604, -0.061053626239299774, -0.34908527135849, -0.19132444262504578, 0.13163195550441742, -1.3884271383285522, 0.26523861289024353, -0.08428671211004257, -0.3928053081035614, -0.8467889428138733, -0.7952315211296082, -0.08944538980722427, -0.7875143885612488, 0.4863426089286804, -0.38166970014572144, -0.6086767315864563, -0.10570969432592392, 0.35367104411125183, 0.2528080940246582, 0.24690774083137512, 0.7096437215805054, 0.38552454113960266, -0.5640224814414978, 0.6776617169380188, 0.40779924392700195, -0.008367808535695076, 0.24421243369579315, -0.18273131549358368, -0.6660285592079163, 0.46734586358070374, 0.12903237342834473, -0.5797491669654846, 0.4424906373023987, -1.1264317035675049, -0.4285523593425751, -0.061125293374061584, 0.13058678805828094, 0.188720241189003, -0.06493566930294037, 0.44764867424964905, 0.2306700199842453, -0.45691487193107605, -0.14070773124694824, 0.30754953622817993, 0.5404362082481384, -0.38367852568626404, -0.6242996454238892, 0.5421342253684998, -1.0100873708724976, -0.042046964168548584, -0.9871025681495667, 0.3732146918773651, 0.6858581900596619, -0.08589466661214828, -0.28625476360321045, -0.28049153089523315, -0.3136254549026489, -0.6609137654304504, -0.3616996109485626, -0.09586326777935028, 0.18872234225273132, 1.0935122966766357, 0.07607929408550262, -0.2574642300605774, -0.21241053938865662, -0.13477648794651031, 0.0007730509387329221, 1.2797353267669678, 0.3138720393180847, -0.25532305240631104, 0.9239964485168457, 0.19262269139289856, -1.2516098022460938, 0.9123162031173706, 1.0517734289169312, 0.31494656205177307, 0.4708627760410309, -0.08600933849811554, 0.5055208802223206, 0.1895516961812973, -0.5452050566673279, 0.10390859097242355, 0.603981614112854, 0.6399964690208435, 0.312226265668869, -0.3012731969356537, 0.19210903346538544, -0.6962290406227112, -0.0691424235701561, -0.38222119212150574, 0.6681232452392578, 0.4701502323150635, -0.6136252880096436, 0.3458224833011627, -0.7439318895339966, 4.052931785583496, 0.7004476189613342, 0.4072948098182678, -0.06898616999387741, 0.5448424220085144, 0.6142218708992004, -0.08017085492610931, -0.1000492125749588, 0.27026984095573425, -0.38819706439971924, 0.2268318384885788, -0.45606109499931335, 0.5813081860542297, 0.5385586619377136, -0.29156187176704407, 0.8777368664741516, 0.07689616829156876, 0.26908567547798157, -0.41418391466140747, -0.9120107293128967, -0.9709784984588623, 0.6341875791549683, 0.1877942681312561, -0.022717991843819618, 0.663910448551178, 0.24199579656124115, 0.49694719910621643, -1.0106744766235352, -0.34889310598373413, -0.5009174346923828, -0.7850952744483948, -0.6948185563087463, -0.1929866373538971, -0.23292143642902374, -1.1191753149032593, 0.6413804888725281, -0.3223443925380707, -0.2595612406730652, 0.18566779792308807, 0.149030402302742, 0.2860472798347473, -0.5636976361274719, 0.15554918348789215, -0.5071858763694763, 0.9040895104408264, 0.5310545563697815, 0.7514263391494751, 0.6271339058876038, 0.5502316951751709, -0.7998360991477966, 0.20504459738731384, 0.29605481028556824, 0.5195993185043335, -0.17201973497867584, -0.6956177949905396, -1.090236783027649, -0.5290224552154541, -0.13857413828372955, 0.4055263102054596, 0.15798434615135193, 0.9273143410682678, 0.07106000185012817, -0.09689661115407944, 0.5276703834533691, -0.04764027148485184, 0.33743032813072205, 0.4590930640697479, -0.08644135296344757, -0.10973682999610901, -0.4207074046134949, -1.105409026145935, -0.33196860551834106, -0.6309508085250854, -0.5348133444786072, -0.36591705679893494, 0.513420820236206, 0.5240835547447205, 0.09526123106479645, -0.22066128253936768, 0.4393033981323242, -0.44296836853027344, 0.15193384885787964, -0.02253810688853264, 0.38296037912368774, 0.07724902778863907, 0.19597569108009338, -0.3394125699996948, 0.07533229142427444, -0.6722981333732605, 0.7748779058456421, 0.398225873708725, 0.7740057110786438, 0.0898103341460228, 0.7029821872711182, -0.6585677266120911 ]
Collisions of Einstein-Conformal Scalar Waves
A large class of solutions of the Einstein-conformal scalar equations in D=2+1 and D=3+1 is identified. They describe the collisions of asymptotic conformal scalar waves and are generated from Einstein-minimally coupled scalar spacetimes via a (generalized) Bekenstein transformation. Particular emphasis is given to the study of the global properties and the singularity structure of the obtained solutions. It is shown, that in the case of the absence of pure gravitational radiation in the initial data, the formation of the final singularity is not only generic, but is even inevitable.
C. Klim\v{c}\'ik and P. Koln\'ik
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212012
gr-qc/9212013
[ 0.8322931528091431, 0.5606070160865784, 0.624055027961731, -0.9203245043754578, -0.30108535289764404, 0.5117612481117249, -0.45579764246940613, -0.07668241113424301, -0.22339563071727753, 1.1953221559524536, 0.6440128684043884, -0.18583372235298157, -0.029341373592615128, -0.840459406375885, -0.2413588911294937, 0.7204983234405518, -0.29388514161109924, -0.4674638509750366, -1.4923127889633179, -0.5914835929870605, -0.19343705475330353, 0.3499547839164734, -0.973865270614624, -1.1171658039093018, -0.5274212956428528, 0.3598053753376007, 0.6945706009864807, -0.11684762686491013, 1.213216781616211, 0.835342288017273, 0.48786526918411255, -0.4444619119167328, 0.4323740005493164, -0.9616455435752869, -1.0656229257583618, -0.24918489158153534, 0.10802852362394333, -0.6083776354789734, 0.4878610670566559, -0.5475242137908936, 1.008945345878601, -0.2154659628868103, 0.05895291268825531, -0.4215123951435089, -0.6741475462913513, -0.12951549887657166, 0.1076108068227768, -0.08135060966014862, 0.12085448205471039, -0.4886235296726227, 0.3602900505065918, 0.08999694138765335, 0.5036212801933289, -1.2056255340576172, 0.16364040970802307, -0.11191699653863907, -0.25944647192955017, 0.02462751977145672, -0.4331536889076233, -0.04759721830487251, 0.9780042767524719, 0.9433459043502808, 0.5380876064300537, -0.5449553728103638, -0.08487612009048462, 0.792695939540863, -0.43119245767593384, 0.4300590455532074, 0.07990604639053345, 0.11266911774873734, -0.6068925857543945, -0.8343288898468018, -0.40282678604125977, 0.17668181657791138, -0.4132686257362366, 0.40769311785697937, 0.2178998589515686, -0.3542387783527374, -0.32668057084083557, -0.6578083038330078, 0.2908635139465332, 0.4512547552585602, 0.13454870879650116, 0.5523145198822021, -0.09397204220294952, -0.9509871006011963, 0.7179624438285828, 0.22177660465240479, -0.010091302916407585, 0.5979442596435547, -0.1371999979019165, 0.5053657293319702, -0.1923144906759262, 0.3608124852180481, 1.0120540857315063, -0.19717083871364594, -0.15656541287899017, 0.8279294967651367, 0.3322286605834961, 0.15803776681423187, 0.10102685540914536, 0.7724352478981018, -0.8325350880622864, -0.12733879685401917, -0.6698920726776123, 0.699566125869751, -0.7193426489830017, 0.5252172350883484, -0.40359488129615784, -1.1390550136566162, -0.04901311546564102, 0.4451684057712555, 0.2839209735393524, 0.2901758551597595, 0.11349882930517197, 0.2728995382785797, -0.09433682262897491, 0.3829079866409302, -0.17509259283542633, -0.4021699130535126, -0.536109447479248, 1.2433627843856812, -0.2663840353488922, -0.022519662976264954, 0.3487093150615692, -0.5531753301620483, -0.3656617999076843, 0.6015681028366089, -0.760767936706543, 0.43809637427330017, 0.24451930820941925, -1.020202398300171, -0.19872859120368958, 1.5114991664886475, 0.17928446829319, 0.0316903218626976, 0.43773388862609863, 0.8497721552848816, -0.30612751841545105, -0.4481910169124603, -0.07832688093185425, 0.42343270778656006, -0.22169716656208038, 1.519552230834961, -1.272818922996521, 0.2244064062833786, -0.2771337032318115, -0.6320467591285706, -0.8241997957229614, 0.33332863450050354, -0.17220430076122284, -0.09516195207834244, 0.22221316397190094, 0.9737575054168701, -0.3158913552761078, -0.32679975032806396, -0.5289990305900574, -0.026675740256905556, 0.14905370771884918, -1.0660772323608398, -0.07145007699728012, -0.39099839329719543, 0.14169859886169434, 0.6789841651916504, -1.306085228919983, 0.14639070630073547, -0.7559921145439148, -0.14839054644107819, -0.108239084482193, -0.5646350979804993, -0.4812368154525757, 0.4359254539012909, 0.15739557147026062, 0.06749268621206284, 0.3748265206813812, 0.834763765335083, 0.1542941778898239, -0.03285568580031395, -0.1157231330871582, 0.5483395457267761, -0.2614125907421112, -0.20534418523311615, 0.6610100269317627, 0.6389973163604736, -0.018900861963629723, -0.6014796495437622, -0.7844304442405701, -0.0031995298340916634, 0.7215607166290283, -0.016925731673836708, -0.6674434542655945, 1.146423578262329, -0.8920442461967468, 0.817522406578064, -0.9763783812522888, 0.3491690158843994, -0.8061109185218811, 0.381313294172287, -0.08924619108438492, -0.3131091594696045, 0.2804747521877289, 0.3215945065021515, -0.4759029448032379, 0.6333357095718384, -0.3243049085140228, 0.12395171821117401, 0.15726763010025024, 0.2885328233242035, -0.9402238130569458, 0.5967159271240234, 0.7446022629737854, -0.28143179416656494, 0.3555881381034851, -0.3488467037677765, 0.3286891281604767, -0.06474097073078156, -0.4742690920829773, 0.20237712562084198, -0.3153707981109619, -0.3204815089702606, 0.9412173628807068, 0.12557004392147064, 0.221654012799263, 0.7738034725189209, -0.24462300539016724, -0.5222340822219849, -0.014150903560221195, 0.9886656403541565, -0.3424013555049896, 0.7613478899002075, -0.04779019579291344, 0.13371969759464264, -0.03920716419816017, 0.5684213638305664, 0.7229837775230408, -0.6204158663749695, 1.1300925016403198, 0.9593732357025146, -0.7385859489440918, 0.1727897673845291, -0.12812180817127228, 0.21597978472709656, 0.16034230589866638, 0.19408594071865082, -1.1472910642623901, 0.531666100025177, -0.14399278163909912, -0.31720268726348877, -0.07902397960424423, 0.7284221053123474, -0.46044835448265076, 0.6106315851211548, -0.353363960981369, -0.00035252151428721845, -1.4326213598251343, -0.0319601371884346, 0.08142653107643127, 0.4249853491783142, -0.4158387780189514, -0.7011528015136719, -0.055552609264850616, 0.06264980137348175, -0.03605164960026741, -0.6578273177146912, -0.1730329692363739, 0.803278386592865, -0.24567967653274536, 0.45361050963401794, 0.4585234522819519, -1.0487415790557861, -0.7587093710899353, -0.1903395801782608, -0.7189831137657166, 0.13672028481960297, 0.07611294835805893, 0.33462777733802795, -0.41811999678611755, -0.21053457260131836, 0.7757064700126648, 0.0036175958812236786, -0.35371679067611694, 0.5708215236663818, -0.6522069573402405, -0.14085182547569275, 0.023340022191405296, -0.00628687022253871, -1.2497057914733887, 0.3685031235218048, -0.7067701816558838, 0.24979402124881744, -0.25915318727493286, -0.26053041219711304, -0.4342601001262665, -0.41608425974845886, 0.6815319061279297, 0.3776719570159912, -0.44054409861564636, 0.5935360193252563, 0.489705353975296, -0.8793148994445801, 0.032862674444913864, 0.21944433450698853, -0.5398951768875122, -0.10051573812961578, -1.1193345785140991, 0.9119207859039307, -0.4747549593448639, -0.46586599946022034, 0.22387312352657318, 0.2789958417415619, -0.394475519657135, 0.37171366810798645, 0.23231594264507294, 0.8260728716850281, -0.26252642273902893, 0.6114086508750916, 0.7700242400169373, -0.10566062480211258, 0.7566370368003845, -0.3496273159980774, -0.8832587599754333, -0.3476116359233856, 0.07268108427524567, -0.09138186275959015, 0.12198970466852188, 1.6800150871276855, 0.34940505027770996, -1.4173882007598877, -0.17020513117313385, -0.5542489290237427, -1.0624772310256958, -0.20613475143909454, -0.0008082419517450035, -0.1698574721813202, -0.30244180560112, 0.17105408012866974, -0.6191210150718689, -0.8074354529380798, -0.5031386613845825, 0.7582563161849976, 0.679066002368927, 0.34473559260368347, 0.6150174140930176, 0.9246941208839417, -0.373014360666275, -0.38590139150619507, 0.5303261280059814, -1.1107755899429321, 0.021475661545991898, 0.013970177620649338, -0.06927259266376495, 0.6873453259468079, -0.2672702372074127, -0.0014805400278419256, -0.38373664021492004, 0.8469131588935852, -0.26965248584747314, 0.019499482586979866, -0.7550592422485352, -0.7293418049812317, -0.07005016505718231, 0.3832325339317322, 0.06187431514263153, -0.32741355895996094, -0.29269158840179443, 0.2865939438343048, -0.5211979746818542, 0.19579242169857025, 0.27873510122299194, -2.0428192615509033, 0.2883754372596741, -0.014943400397896767, -0.5697301626205444, -0.39237311482429504, -0.1305103302001953, -0.5256951451301575, 0.2210197001695633, 0.859984278678894, 0.4517158567905426, -0.05897798761725426, 0.026462456211447716, -0.4980092942714691, 0.39704257249832153, 0.08061239123344421, 0.08897426724433899, 0.2086752951145172, 0.07937752455472946, 0.1541288048028946, -0.16079938411712646, -0.3564774990081787, -0.4273439347743988, -0.7852071523666382, 0.37058332562446594, -0.5203108787536621, -0.9539041519165039, -0.42038941383361816, 1.0133394002914429, 1.348522663116455, -0.12390224635601044, -0.3394378423690796, 0.049232348799705505, 0.19342942535877228, -0.20846472680568695, 0.6002494692802429, -0.020250098779797554, 1.1781829595565796, -1.1620184183120728, 0.7338764071464539, 0.2629307508468628, -0.22817860543727875, -0.08411335200071335, -0.5991994142532349, -0.00036659411853179336, 0.31848469376564026, 0.23542824387550354, -0.07158078253269196, -0.4437479078769684, 0.8614915609359741, -0.6040810346603394, 0.0031059118919074535, -0.4841257929801941, -0.21182192862033844, 0.22507260739803314, 0.7644521594047546, 0.24180862307548523, -0.6507914662361145, -0.3114356994628906, -1.2994450330734253, 0.3469598591327667, 0.7370426058769226, -0.24196642637252808, -0.9657819867134094, -0.747866690158844, 0.01618311181664467, 0.27725422382354736, 0.5094647407531738, 0.7519820332527161, 0.20203246176242828, 0.7642014026641846, -1.0026830434799194, 0.11260482668876648, 0.5786874890327454, -0.2936042547225952, -0.13882508873939514, 0.4696841239929199, 0.22378778457641602, -0.5248755216598511, 0.7031514644622803, 0.01683802716434002, -1.0504648685455322, -0.22596250474452972, -0.2001582235097885, 0.25786080956459045, -0.15189501643180847, -0.6388839483261108, 0.4740293025970459, -0.2162608653306961, -0.1378648728132248, -0.09604186564683914, -0.14492914080619812, 0.14986419677734375, -0.20793583989143372, 0.42075130343437195, -0.6336432099342346, -0.12011176347732544, 0.512999951839447, -0.15654365718364716, 0.7988868951797485, 0.7781654596328735, 0.34521082043647766, 0.41788047552108765, 0.11393733322620392, 0.3464996814727783, 0.007625112775713205, 0.4526057839393616, -0.5963677763938904, -0.18209081888198853, 0.22728268802165985, -0.08172567188739777, 0.08714999258518219, -0.28965479135513306, 0.5474626421928406, -0.5896715521812439, 0.2773987054824829, -0.3193049728870392, -0.6875032186508179, -0.6733074188232422, -0.294114887714386, -0.5728050470352173, 0.3263545632362366, 0.008244476281106472, -0.35491907596588135, 0.12514202296733856, -0.3362639546394348, 0.4716944396495819, -0.04609738662838936, -0.3770100176334381, 0.20595239102840424, 0.013218981213867664, 0.33179929852485657, 0.3251064121723175, 0.8123352527618408, -1.096786618232727, -0.1925382912158966, -0.1817454695701599, -0.5706220865249634, -0.5926738381385803, 0.13809767365455627, -0.7068624496459961, 0.4419780671596527, 0.05199620872735977, -0.91949862241745, 0.35296961665153503, -0.11211997270584106, -0.2186780571937561, -0.19817332923412323, 0.46149230003356934, -0.739553689956665, -0.052026133984327316, 0.19367866218090057, 0.5860546827316284, -0.5340985655784607, -0.06809074431657791, 0.48250216245651245, -0.13120515644550323, 0.7675847411155701, -0.28495022654533386, -0.27426204085350037, 0.4415304958820343, -1.5034213066101074, -0.0880884900689125, -1.0683352947235107, 0.013599107041954994, 0.0008427214343100786, -0.8046274781227112, 0.5062068700790405, -0.5508633852005005, 0.47739115357398987, -0.3657388687133789, -0.28007254004478455, -0.8445320725440979, 0.9810072183609009, -0.5679275393486023, -0.13009315729141235, -0.23993434011936188, 0.11510542035102844, -0.924287736415863, 1.4162968397140503, -1.028015375137329, -0.46326935291290283, -0.10198314487934113, 0.49991822242736816, -0.1397571712732315, 0.39384177327156067, -0.20478802919387817, 0.19446106255054474, -0.14276938140392303, -0.008749697357416153, 0.733956515789032, 0.569534957408905, -0.47431591153144836, 0.3745579123497009, -0.16458898782730103, -0.464835524559021, 0.18088728189468384, -0.3308408558368683, 0.5925489664077759, -0.09829925745725632, 1.0225751399993896, -0.6627006530761719, 0.19943732023239136, 0.8552500605583191, 0.359068363904953, 0.9177060723304749, -0.13590729236602783, -0.7769724130630493, -0.2681408226490021, -0.690855860710144, -0.8116136789321899, 0.5212832689285278, 0.19421198964118958, -0.4986517131328583, -0.7538158893585205, -0.16506879031658173, -0.34986644983291626, -0.14015626907348633, 0.9476799368858337, 0.08050630241632462, 0.15055009722709656, 0.04107758775353432, -0.036475177854299545, 0.4227522313594818, -0.25672173500061035, 0.44095128774642944, 0.1968291848897934, 0.5714166164398193, -0.42262330651283264, 0.3451977074146271, -0.4074985980987549, -0.379087895154953, -0.5618501901626587, 0.8197963833808899, 0.8547466993331909, 0.16130363941192627, 0.5454015731811523, -0.10693185031414032, -0.35443931818008423, -0.03717835992574692, 0.2839100658893585, 0.6624259352684021, -0.12492769956588745, 0.2651783227920532, 0.619072437286377, -0.5274775624275208, 0.584282636642456, 0.05960756167769432, -0.7117357850074768, 0.10220645368099213, 0.893144428730011, -0.22949692606925964, -0.2160542756319046, -0.237454354763031, 0.8654652833938599, -0.35198187828063965, -0.48321712017059326, -1.1485533714294434, 0.17362642288208008, 0.1932765543460846, -0.20078694820404053, -0.010371193289756775, -0.09339632838964462, -0.0027358978986740112, 0.5987530946731567, 0.16527216136455536, 0.6443802714347839, 0.32740479707717896, 0.7415546178817749, 0.01908961683511734, -1.0025238990783691, 0.13782072067260742, 1.151322603225708, 0.10451950132846832, -0.42445632815361023, 0.26364967226982117, -0.7124711871147156, -0.7505368590354919, -0.5672734379768372, 0.7982544898986816, -0.5063869953155518, 0.09997405111789703, 0.34148886799812317, -0.06025749817490578, 0.7915003299713135, -0.3652854859828949, -0.23462627828121185, 0.7445506453514099, -1.2037750482559204, -1.0022932291030884, -0.34392249584198, 0.1418369859457016, 0.2976605296134949, 0.23193955421447754, 0.23902952671051025, -0.18931879103183746, 0.1766916811466217, 0.3351922929286957, -0.0037710689939558506, -0.43432489037513733, -0.8131269216537476, -1.1174027919769287, -0.8257306814193726, -0.12734493613243103, -0.116909921169281, 0.14947102963924408, 0.09844879060983658, -0.5990272164344788, 0.26417550444602966, 0.34295007586479187, 0.0535651259124279, -0.6064146161079407, 1.3311773538589478, -0.3117586374282837, -0.18544451892375946, -0.9533368349075317, -0.13466468453407288, -0.53277587890625, -0.7408809661865234, -0.6196770071983337, 0.13269896805286407, 0.19574013352394104, 1.0162811279296875, -0.2978009879589081, 0.2585417628288269, -0.17588593065738678, -0.173617422580719, 0.0865686908364296, -0.133060023188591, -1.2695776224136353, 0.5504177808761597, -0.646484911441803, 0.8318319916725159, 0.2782551646232605, -0.19936420023441315, -0.11203828454017639, 0.38940221071243286, -0.8354370594024658, 0.26462724804878235, 0.3296400010585785, 1.6335406303405762, 0.09844622015953064, -0.3212659955024719, -0.3081112504005432, 0.4640648663043976, -0.9352254271507263, 0.19198131561279297, -0.484497606754303, 0.04893539845943451, -0.2145678848028183, 0.09304157644510269, 0.018202055245637894, 0.9421634078025818, 0.30053460597991943, 0.632715106010437, -0.10034649074077606, 0.10360044986009598, -0.17330284416675568, 0.2605045437812805, -0.14951270818710327, -0.3411328196525574, 0.14496177434921265, -1.3740355968475342, 0.7413347363471985, 0.12982921302318573, -0.32000410556793213, 0.1258144974708557, -0.15213005244731903, 0.3155229985713959, -0.32595837116241455, 0.4484213590621948, -0.07671434432268143, 0.5616767406463623, -0.051747553050518036, -0.02062014490365982, 0.03346287086606026, -0.3025180697441101, -1.26261568069458, 0.0886889323592186, -0.5890939831733704, -0.5014512538909912, 0.1656678467988968, -0.2998443841934204, 0.4637008607387543, 0.00289224018342793, -0.7877077460289001, -0.5406160950660706, -0.06792855262756348, 0.5392037630081177, 0.9583616852760315, -0.3542967438697815, -0.8138673901557922, 0.41011494398117065, -0.8856592774391174, -0.9923173189163208, -0.027970334514975548, 0.4456905126571655, -0.3736724853515625, -0.7918872833251953, 0.4465307593345642, 0.3258812129497528, -0.2522207200527191, -0.6936257481575012, -0.053731877356767654, -0.303714394569397, -0.26229342818260193, -0.10581935197114944, -0.2969878017902374, -0.3789779841899872, 0.07729683071374893, 0.06004595384001732, 0.12886787950992584, -0.24332447350025177, -0.05177778750658035, 0.3941558301448822, 0.9588892459869385, -0.21305356919765472, -0.29510578513145447, 0.8056247234344482, -0.07011209428310394, 0.17022065818309784, 0.6376480460166931, 0.26575395464897156, 0.5044934153556824, 0.07648734003305435, -0.42886805534362793, -0.2756819725036621, 0.6965513229370117, -0.036698322743177414, 0.28922921419143677, 0.498646080493927, 0.019291933625936508, 0.6607860922813416, -0.08468712121248245, -0.35020098090171814, 0.5300738215446472, 0.133412167429924, 0.40901312232017517, -0.26342153549194336, -0.47886189818382263, 0.151516392827034, 0.3862093985080719, -0.04423601180315018, 0.0794769823551178, -0.37907466292381287, -0.13069573044776917, -0.6037430763244629, -0.670230507850647, -0.10159243643283844, -0.35699987411499023, -0.7907229661941528, -0.8204893469810486, 0.9534767270088196, 0.18551580607891083, -0.0763721689581871, 0.25888803601264954, 0.9747161865234375, 0.5224600434303284, 0.3490835428237915, -0.14089685678482056, 0.21627314388751984, 0.6792904734611511, 1.1750966310501099, 0.6704250574111938, 0.3808120787143707, -0.07304907590150833, 0.2719748318195343, -0.06492128223180771, -1.2159225940704346, 0.41964414715766907, 0.5928452610969543, -0.835822582244873, -0.27992790937423706, 0.3456243574619293, -0.44906821846961975, -0.373273104429245, -0.529166579246521, 0.1410338580608368, -0.48197922110557556, 0.5048664212226868, 0.24150243401527405, 0.0945604220032692, 0.09122631698846817, 0.6663232445716858, 0.2720756530761719, 0.1288619488477707, 0.966699481010437, 0.7499163150787354, -0.26799389719963074, 0.6243157386779785, 0.7256973385810852, 0.3220803439617157, 0.3155757188796997, -0.13434521853923798, 0.2908394932746887, 0.1028202623128891, 0.3440251052379608, -0.5024808645248413, 0.6593770384788513, -0.32852673530578613, -0.4304419159889221, -0.27884235978126526, 0.186809241771698, -0.6501024961471558, 0.7529717683792114, 0.6406951546669006, 0.02254219725728035, -0.3104550838470459, -0.10775621235370636, 0.32547444105148315, 0.463948130607605, -0.00006661385850748047, 0.02934025228023529, 0.37858086824417114, -1.0281851291656494, -0.11882530152797699, -0.6440326571464539, 0.26522549986839294, 0.512679934501648, -0.06605099886655807, -0.02075841650366783, -0.08701888471841812, -0.5424079298973083, -0.5577630996704102, 0.06411352008581161, -0.28937000036239624, 0.30909955501556396, 1.545227289199829, 0.37780359387397766, 0.3869576156139374, -0.6778398752212524, -0.5708689093589783, 0.47005701065063477, 1.3421344757080078, 0.40002191066741943, 0.2837170660495758, 1.1344690322875977, 0.0682530626654625, -0.6910012364387512, 0.5286628007888794, 0.1942053884267807, -0.49346789717674255, 0.095456562936306, -0.3391450047492981, 0.2967732846736908, 0.37890782952308655, -0.7894318103790283, 0.20361800491809845, 0.5503098368644714, 0.06371526420116425, -0.2948138415813446, 0.36711230874061584, 0.31919464468955994, -0.7438218593597412, 0.05216916278004646, -0.8280152678489685, 0.637296199798584, 0.3365594744682312, -0.7607806324958801, 0.3168734312057495, -0.8833210468292236, 3.938530206680298, 0.712166965007782, 0.6993533372879028, 0.34696054458618164, 0.690828800201416, 0.8986164331436157, 0.48140600323677063, 0.5503979325294495, 0.4377739131450653, -1.027580976486206, 0.06282694637775421, -0.037512101233005524, -0.022027941420674324, 0.2602682113647461, 0.28491830825805664, 0.7655132412910461, -0.009597310796380043, 0.0867389366030693, -0.2488614022731781, 0.508801281452179, -1.0657323598861694, 0.008478904142975807, 0.09717061370611191, 0.1913306564092636, 0.527769923210144, 0.28507521748542786, 0.41601091623306274, -0.7879545092582703, -0.04495413973927498, -0.32460513710975647, -0.27401602268218994, -0.24462823569774628, -0.17603768408298492, 0.0069399927742779255, -1.5159631967544556, 0.33619049191474915, 0.20013616979122162, -0.626341700553894, -0.1964564323425293, 0.5094000101089478, 0.08153493702411652, -0.5606908202171326, 0.9525254964828491, -0.6635257005691528, 0.18309538066387177, 0.5844168663024902, 0.40539389848709106, 0.07140317559242249, 0.30901357531547546, -0.33541396260261536, 0.10077597945928574, -0.33678850531578064, 0.2826637327671051, -1.215077519416809, -1.0283817052841187, -0.606246292591095, 0.5081127882003784, -0.8376811742782593, -0.5353647470474243, 0.049752458930015564, 0.6663148403167725, -0.9244016408920288, -0.5265350937843323, 0.202919602394104, 0.2717714011669159, -0.4946499466896057, 1.0906659364700317, 0.2414788454771042, -0.34353211522102356, -0.07622974365949631, 0.03289688751101494, 0.23011571168899536, -0.49223482608795166, -0.17051449418067932, 0.17977134883403778, 0.05771896615624428, -0.0649423748254776, 0.35200852155685425, -0.3824186623096466, -0.5078954100608826, -0.2261650115251541, 0.38573944568634033, -0.36275163292884827, 0.4881264865398407, 0.00991097092628479, 0.4642575681209564, -0.08927534520626068, -0.22539687156677246, 0.3951064944267273, 0.6839209794998169, 0.27396830916404724, 0.8897289037704468, -0.1637602150440216, 0.0989064946770668, -0.3913739323616028 ]
Inhomogeneous and anisotropic cosmologies
This is a review of cosmological models prepared for the Pont d'Oye workshop on the origin of structure in the universe. The classes of models are discussed in turn, and then some of their uses are considered.
M.A.H. MacCallum
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212013
gr-qc/9212014
[ 0.6531171202659607, 0.37715116143226624, 0.8121434450149536, -0.4760722219944, -0.22331219911575317, 0.21649400889873505, -0.0309225395321846, -0.17693421244621277, -0.5805607438087463, 1.1360719203948975, -0.10581617057323456, 0.051811039447784424, -0.3141903579235077, -0.49523404240608215, 0.1419794261455536, -0.05429966002702713, -0.09189508110284805, -0.47797486186027527, -0.921684980392456, 0.7909038066864014, 0.4331636428833008, 0.5104191899299622, -1.0863769054412842, -0.5443745255470276, -0.3084591329097748, 0.7230281829833984, 1.1206308603286743, 0.6683067083358765, 1.130499005317688, 0.8917255997657776, 0.9270380139350891, 0.08752376586198807, 0.26978951692581177, -1.0955908298492432, -0.4116906523704529, 0.5633485317230225, 0.04458571970462799, -0.48154011368751526, 1.2034176588058472, -0.5805715322494507, 0.30210626125335693, -0.34275078773498535, 0.5036565065383911, 0.21672993898391724, -0.6607571840286255, 0.07953764498233795, -0.08500178158283234, -0.2728343605995178, 0.10186146199703217, -0.9152077436447144, 0.1313696801662445, 0.006507472135126591, 0.5904280543327332, -0.7201400399208069, -0.31073620915412903, -0.1590789407491684, -0.013632472604513168, 0.050551798194646835, -0.43954309821128845, -0.3477238714694977, 0.36311429738998413, 0.3344762623310089, 0.2918727993965149, -0.5686650276184082, 0.08859463036060333, 0.8156812191009521, -0.3148003816604614, -0.21569465100765228, 0.7134562134742737, -0.05080612003803253, -0.05921715870499611, -0.5559626221656799, -0.3214646279811859, 0.4455171525478363, -0.6885543465614319, 0.39849478006362915, -0.3329513967037201, -0.04111611098051071, -0.06606848537921906, -0.2880772650241852, 0.6367979645729065, -0.12712693214416504, -0.087522953748703, 0.9391742944717407, -0.7341170907020569, -0.4086444675922394, 0.5630956292152405, 0.006564376410096884, 0.2222648710012436, 0.14707735180854797, 0.4710821509361267, 0.502070963382721, -0.25753194093704224, -0.2757570743560791, 0.483371764421463, 0.5590904951095581, -0.16223809123039246, 0.699182391166687, 0.5923932194709778, 0.6198093891143799, -0.20537783205509186, 0.7288578152656555, -0.3948683440685272, 0.4041942358016968, -0.8859298825263977, 1.2221722602844238, -0.4455513656139374, -0.08548718690872192, -0.13002578914165497, -1.024753212928772, 0.08713975548744202, 0.21737231314182281, 0.1945517659187317, 0.049179527908563614, 0.42852920293807983, 0.34544870257377625, -0.5746846795082092, 0.10563667118549347, -0.2984772324562073, 0.04572995379567146, -0.7118287086486816, 0.632439911365509, -0.3233667016029358, 0.4486865997314453, -0.1730671226978302, -0.5044682025909424, -0.4231898784637451, 0.30925923585891724, -0.40950703620910645, 0.22822760045528412, -0.2973998188972473, -0.3640865981578827, 0.06742750853300095, 0.9960251450538635, -0.04790414497256279, -0.11737366020679474, 0.3148695230484009, 0.5654361844062805, -0.6735773086547852, -0.4401373565196991, 0.05813467130064964, -0.30892181396484375, -0.5821076035499573, 1.250964879989624, -1.0214087963104248, 0.08194257318973541, -0.4676688611507416, -0.30977797508239746, -0.55637526512146, -0.38899338245391846, -0.0387696698307991, -0.401777446269989, 0.48388737440109253, 0.7705609798431396, -0.3916223347187042, -0.1204749047756195, -0.8609762787818909, 0.1512669324874878, -0.41603028774261475, -0.5727693438529968, -0.13091371953487396, -0.39851221442222595, 0.08575665205717087, 0.995762288570404, -0.6713608503341675, 0.8278286457061768, -0.8057293891906738, -0.37251442670822144, 0.1380796879529953, -0.2548563480377197, -0.895846962928772, 0.41318997740745544, -0.790037989616394, 0.1905113160610199, 0.639409065246582, 1.0479599237442017, 0.22737300395965576, -0.2920219898223877, -0.7693637609481812, 0.866053581237793, -0.4042714238166809, -0.31539440155029297, 0.6343351602554321, 0.2517149746417999, -0.13467077910900116, -0.3817903995513916, -0.07182173430919647, -0.3518873155117035, 0.6131341457366943, -0.28790897130966187, -0.7896853089332581, 0.9724843502044678, -1.157007098197937, 0.9408267736434937, -0.8120149970054626, 0.4841937720775604, -0.8257187008857727, -0.012194623239338398, 0.4566154479980469, -0.32743215560913086, -0.16716966032981873, 0.01533112209290266, -0.6311988830566406, 0.6494837999343872, -0.8747605681419373, 0.12116691470146179, 0.47164034843444824, 0.8033299446105957, -0.5964993238449097, 0.11475859582424164, 0.1679026484489441, -0.4142485558986664, 0.38905465602874756, -0.2794548273086548, 0.2657468616962433, -0.19347041845321655, -0.053044095635414124, 0.8247246742248535, -0.5289478302001953, -0.1550981104373932, 0.6408039331436157, 0.4784165322780609, -0.03642132505774498, 0.5560101866722107, 0.25177568197250366, 0.07191678136587143, -0.08419238030910492, 0.6598277688026428, -0.6929146647453308, 0.12730935215950012, -0.40052345395088196, -0.12185601145029068, -0.06143645942211151, 0.33257415890693665, 0.6143639087677002, 0.1673196405172348, 1.0262455940246582, 0.7637985348701477, -0.1614135056734085, 0.043254099786281586, 0.21279160678386688, -0.16648589074611664, 0.6325663328170776, 0.6131072044372559, -0.928457498550415, 0.6568302512168884, 0.1679183393716812, -0.3152052164077759, 0.19317784905433655, 0.9324697256088257, -0.7503660321235657, 0.553799569606781, 0.5238142013549805, -0.14253288507461548, -1.4000250101089478, 0.3074966371059418, -0.29112568497657776, 0.7200613021850586, -0.15905329585075378, -0.7524815201759338, -0.42895427346229553, 0.2190546691417694, -0.459228515625, -0.39300233125686646, -0.9130918979644775, 0.30554619431495667, -0.786115288734436, -0.041769105941057205, 0.4476911127567291, -0.35786718130111694, -1.2283300161361694, -0.49667075276374817, -0.4523063600063324, 0.3315953016281128, -0.16289101541042328, 0.17196981608867645, 0.33248552680015564, -0.44819536805152893, 0.6484723091125488, 0.5460643172264099, -0.2738524377346039, 0.3554631173610687, 0.23060208559036255, -0.04628210887312889, -0.22242406010627747, 0.7962799072265625, -0.8497750163078308, 0.26940813660621643, -0.8817915320396423, 0.745019257068634, 0.010145287960767746, -0.4448453187942505, -0.403674840927124, -0.2500694990158081, 0.5190866589546204, 0.2880147695541382, 0.04197242483496666, 0.14735592901706696, 0.11746625602245331, -1.0936652421951294, 0.40115663409233093, -0.05956556275486946, -0.9188714623451233, -0.26600831747055054, -0.4114171266555786, 0.587517499923706, -0.7695123553276062, -0.07070651650428772, 0.5128200650215149, -0.4605973958969116, -0.7179707884788513, 0.22250497341156006, 0.0683690533041954, 0.26649534702301025, 0.02638266794383526, 0.030550912022590637, 0.7667080760002136, -0.17230626940727234, 0.15890398621559143, -0.8239333629608154, -0.5417912602424622, -0.12001729756593704, 0.9664719104766846, -0.20755431056022644, -0.07732045650482178, 0.7111858129501343, 0.054935555905103683, -0.6510741114616394, 0.08132418990135193, -0.6385269165039062, -0.8775184154510498, -0.3653850555419922, -0.23858392238616943, 0.09561628103256226, -0.023146118968725204, -0.3675556480884552, -0.4734156131744385, -0.0721515342593193, -0.3528375029563904, 0.02035083808004856, 0.6289443969726562, -0.07955754548311234, -0.00100128841586411, 0.7488827705383301, 0.0218052938580513, -0.6453527808189392, 0.5762787461280823, -0.4120022654533386, -0.11208511888980865, 0.3192373216152191, -0.6085168719291687, 0.31704437732696533, -0.13068625330924988, 0.24085184931755066, 0.20520976185798645, 0.5844321250915527, -0.010882807895541191, -0.04602685198187828, -0.8816055059432983, -0.4333094358444214, 0.3149825930595398, 0.33007171750068665, 0.451274573802948, -0.7530160546302795, -0.6479182839393616, 0.8029250502586365, -0.24779826402664185, 0.13805389404296875, 0.5172134041786194, -0.8877692818641663, 0.6757681369781494, 0.35206905007362366, -0.8123902678489685, -0.1388987898826599, -0.4217860698699951, 0.18774452805519104, 0.6861578822135925, 0.0075648874044418335, 0.2829306721687317, -0.5912346243858337, -0.03418318182229996, -0.6246688961982727, 0.9494097828865051, 0.2359897494316101, -0.2451055645942688, -0.07984663546085358, 0.17186035215854645, 0.08325321972370148, -0.19224129617214203, -0.7819787859916687, -0.571286678314209, -0.46562471985816956, 0.16301821172237396, -0.31069788336753845, -0.6913238763809204, 0.6225747466087341, 1.0980068445205688, 1.0711193084716797, -0.20200452208518982, -0.13484971225261688, 0.5504794716835022, 0.2561669647693634, 0.29030725359916687, 0.5339519381523132, 0.016590196639299393, 0.5840819478034973, -0.4166443347930908, 0.5639480352401733, 0.50496506690979, 0.38231360912323, 0.08132833987474442, -0.35995838046073914, -0.03411056473851204, -0.0412549264729023, 0.726763129234314, 0.0858166515827179, 0.05401921644806862, 0.09264540672302246, -0.18206094205379486, 0.18620920181274414, -0.6670546531677246, 0.6273117661476135, 0.6799476146697998, 0.15547649562358856, 0.02315342426300049, -0.6478139162063599, -0.006100548896938562, -0.7033997178077698, 0.33347728848457336, 0.19858697056770325, 0.09508445113897324, -0.894428551197052, -0.5460997223854065, -0.24935142695903778, 0.001766081666573882, 0.3095588982105255, 0.45684710144996643, 0.6887405514717102, 0.5004501342773438, -0.3784244656562805, 0.41636958718299866, 1.3586151599884033, -0.11575596034526825, 0.0009462909656576812, 0.18117780983448029, 0.3460957109928131, -0.14979137480258942, 0.6220064163208008, -0.4311394989490509, -1.1744755506515503, 0.14787426590919495, -0.2695949077606201, 0.7961345314979553, -0.19481544196605682, -1.024462342262268, 0.35828718543052673, 0.11047697812318802, -0.026379413902759552, 0.12104853987693787, 0.056166451424360275, 0.06677019596099854, -0.40825119614601135, 0.4089864492416382, -0.7061481475830078, 0.30121323466300964, 0.2980085015296936, 0.22323349118232727, 0.6041370034217834, 0.6748592853546143, 0.30026859045028687, 0.5934215188026428, 0.6078987121582031, -0.5199381113052368, 0.15182963013648987, 0.3407062590122223, -0.5840132236480713, -0.35461828112602234, 0.19099721312522888, -0.032249320298433304, -0.899781346321106, 0.28449374437332153, 0.6347619295120239, -0.2567448019981384, 0.265204519033432, -0.0023457054048776627, -0.7021380066871643, -0.9147595763206482, -0.307496577501297, -0.8295831680297852, 0.587911069393158, -0.27155017852783203, -0.448158860206604, 0.0685311108827591, -0.21572628617286682, 0.20933885872364044, 0.061070170253515244, 0.05478426441550255, -0.4835587739944458, -0.39902180433273315, -0.05416298285126686, 0.2541077136993408, 0.564714789390564, -0.47821688652038574, 0.2076411247253418, -0.33855515718460083, -0.6732089519500732, -0.9633680582046509, -0.1362718641757965, -0.8222922086715698, 0.11147461086511612, 0.06784667074680328, -0.42127683758735657, 0.6946281790733337, -0.06983230262994766, 0.4251266121864319, 0.3530289828777313, 0.46892568469047546, -0.32886025309562683, -0.29135623574256897, 0.23244710266590118, 0.5666651129722595, -0.5124951004981995, -0.47467315196990967, 0.815159022808075, -0.2522362172603607, 0.22423452138900757, -0.7033884525299072, -0.4620552957057953, 1.0557187795639038, -1.6921501159667969, 0.10726776719093323, -1.0796306133270264, -0.1310262382030487, -0.41168099641799927, -0.263590544462204, 0.34067487716674805, -0.28010109066963196, 0.29396119713783264, -0.6024407148361206, -0.40352579951286316, -0.6673287153244019, 0.3103892207145691, -0.6988193988800049, 0.10638915747404099, -0.6456730961799622, 0.27718687057495117, -0.10221904516220093, 1.6528725624084473, -0.5810349583625793, -0.1991628259420395, 0.3761947751045227, 0.26820850372314453, -0.7375970482826233, 0.03325430676341057, -0.09719721972942352, -0.41115638613700867, -0.23205110430717468, 0.1620362251996994, 0.8763192296028137, 0.662289559841156, -0.12266811728477478, 0.09823822975158691, -0.2728709280490875, 0.05482868477702141, 0.03670341521501541, -0.03787451982498169, 0.005991079844534397, -0.03033175878226757, 0.8974319696426392, -1.0341466665267944, 0.38612857460975647, 0.9331797957420349, 0.28751039505004883, 1.0007696151733398, 0.31762728095054626, -0.7873250246047974, -0.08680444210767746, -0.5222526788711548, -0.348074734210968, 0.3808825612068176, 0.11102576553821564, -0.296610563993454, -0.12391876429319382, -0.8991646766662598, -0.34140193462371826, -0.5180580615997314, 0.5011992454528809, 0.013349625281989574, 0.3761637806892395, 0.02136101946234703, -0.2029675543308258, 0.317215234041214, -0.1838957965373993, 0.031707827001810074, -0.16613559424877167, 0.16423222422599792, -0.7610942125320435, -0.21815025806427002, 0.11745987087488174, -0.8792508244514465, -0.6906096935272217, 0.5262445211410522, 0.5877262949943542, -0.017281709238886833, 0.723097026348114, 0.5702724456787109, -0.30576831102371216, -0.5614473223686218, 0.015708131715655327, 0.44819530844688416, -0.45790085196495056, 0.6345117688179016, -0.11541590094566345, 0.1040320098400116, 0.04170319437980652, 0.3470495939254761, -0.9521737098693848, 0.3269179165363312, 0.8855487704277039, -0.5782818794250488, -0.1373724639415741, 0.3117876648902893, 0.19571322202682495, -0.35071253776550293, -1.0239739418029785, -1.1732434034347534, 0.07391331344842911, 0.3163248300552368, -0.09031926840543747, -0.08010859787464142, -0.272681325674057, -0.2614695429801941, -0.05112968757748604, 0.36480942368507385, 0.56573086977005, 0.06680896878242493, 0.37689828872680664, 0.15559479594230652, -0.6137449741363525, 0.4585767686367035, 0.6268627047538757, 0.27154111862182617, -0.19653655588626862, -0.36387553811073303, -0.49446022510528564, -0.3994719684123993, -0.27551499009132385, 0.9449679851531982, -1.2936991453170776, 0.20571981370449066, 0.2500421702861786, 0.4844958186149597, -0.007968218997120857, 0.0700027346611023, -0.3843901455402374, -0.059632863849401474, -0.7442119121551514, -0.6580968499183655, -0.2769513428211212, 0.029443250969052315, 0.4108695089817047, 0.32502132654190063, 0.16359327733516693, -0.26596978306770325, -0.023595811799168587, 0.3548470437526703, -0.11715952306985855, -0.7062156200408936, -1.0434952974319458, -0.9205559492111206, -0.8766397833824158, -1.0941308736801147, 0.2666908800601959, 0.30385759472846985, 0.52180016040802, -0.8063322305679321, -0.11886075139045715, -0.1873372346162796, 0.5022205710411072, -0.10600745677947998, 1.4723937511444092, 0.02767266519367695, -0.4712487459182739, -0.5804387331008911, -0.12823794782161713, -0.5541872382164001, -1.330820918083191, -0.3527008891105652, 0.08405991643667221, 0.4252154529094696, 0.8073684573173523, -0.09810741990804672, 0.7110109329223633, -0.40715160965919495, -0.020084884017705917, 0.38030505180358887, -0.03997437655925751, -1.362981915473938, 0.7600014805793762, -0.3605164587497711, 0.806121289730072, 0.1380617767572403, 0.49969345331192017, 0.2468198835849762, -0.052642934024333954, -0.9819812178611755, 0.34165769815444946, 0.12273667752742767, 0.8583593964576721, -0.4013279676437378, -0.7683968544006348, -0.2051897644996643, 0.3378748297691345, -0.7935472130775452, 0.25815045833587646, 0.19238047301769257, 0.06627117097377777, -0.5570077896118164, 0.11063558608293533, 0.12412279844284058, 0.37751367688179016, -0.07983054965734482, 0.486758828163147, -0.5340707898139954, 0.3778142035007477, -0.0676410049200058, 0.4300647974014282, -0.21742823719978333, -0.13698667287826538, 0.17567208409309387, -0.9475375413894653, 0.36975932121276855, 0.43354105949401855, 0.1600639671087265, -0.12048739194869995, -0.18654100596904755, 0.047379810363054276, -0.1956535279750824, 0.8106505274772644, -0.3643620014190674, 0.718539834022522, 0.034205883741378784, -0.028731049969792366, 0.017973557114601135, -0.49048110842704773, -0.6073437929153442, -0.1830901950597763, -0.6038053631782532, -0.7719769477844238, 0.5578353404998779, -0.18855537474155426, 0.07830868661403656, -0.09588790684938431, -0.3468858301639557, 0.274339884519577, 0.2742150127887726, 1.0957889556884766, 0.8830380439758301, -0.008222305215895176, -0.4710911512374878, 0.7338730096817017, -1.3627890348434448, -0.46469593048095703, -0.17897123098373413, 0.42041638493537903, -0.7152553796768188, -0.7253543734550476, 0.06399039924144745, 0.0941765308380127, -0.16045093536376953, -0.26044124364852905, 0.1313869208097458, 0.16730087995529175, -0.20251579582691193, -0.0453871451318264, -0.21831242740154266, -0.20047219097614288, 0.047562241554260254, 0.6300462484359741, 0.7152224183082581, -0.41241899132728577, 0.14836709201335907, 0.28687310218811035, 1.356400728225708, -0.24032405018806458, -0.5723356008529663, 1.157216191291809, 0.16889558732509613, -0.21758021414279938, 0.6747362017631531, -0.07403677701950073, 0.5406351685523987, 0.945248007774353, -0.665755033493042, 0.16149449348449707, 0.7096471190452576, 0.3155791461467743, 0.3180178701877594, -0.043623920530080795, -0.0344952791929245, 0.5888592004776001, 0.38932567834854126, 0.31326329708099365, -0.28253036737442017, -0.2485066056251526, -0.1466006636619568, 0.057813599705696106, -0.34161534905433655, 0.5182994604110718, 0.181028813123703, 0.10455330461263657, 0.15310736000537872, -0.3511309027671814, -0.08723418414592743, -0.5922431945800781, -0.02947525680065155, 0.7342361807823181, -0.580997109413147, -0.7164932489395142, -0.5668883919715881, 0.8162403702735901, -0.09634403884410858, -0.05300073325634003, -0.46166643500328064, 0.5933114886283875, 0.29430490732192993, 0.41013121604919434, -0.2258671224117279, 0.07333279401063919, 0.39885950088500977, 0.04841454699635506, 0.928946852684021, 0.1491393744945526, 0.8551366925239563, 0.4448806345462799, 0.3002420663833618, -0.5955389738082886, 0.40664565563201904, 0.05044068396091461, -0.8091566562652588, -0.5155066251754761, 0.3551538586616516, -0.14457818865776062, -0.027802372351288795, -0.19432233273983002, -0.3189437687397003, -0.4277622699737549, -0.11318565160036087, 0.027802105993032455, -0.11429008841514587, -0.11043823510408401, 0.254180908203125, -0.0989966094493866, 0.2943578064441681, 0.46904638409614563, 0.6261762380599976, -0.6710821986198425, 0.40110743045806885, 0.6709805727005005, -0.05714568495750427, -0.4048939049243927, -0.49533748626708984, 0.27103033661842346, 0.45237481594085693, 0.5213175415992737, -0.26774898171424866, 0.4199441075325012, -0.560627818107605, 0.40662381052970886, 0.2277289181947708, 0.20942774415016174, -0.12462202459573746, 0.6106072664260864, 0.16449740529060364, 0.5541070103645325, -0.017827695235610008, -0.3192463219165802, 0.2838681638240814, 0.5717708468437195, -0.18377181887626648, 0.056904152035713196, 0.4761555790901184, -0.8508220911026001, -0.11310210078954697, -0.7886870503425598, 0.28840208053588867, -0.02850961685180664, -0.32423529028892517, -0.5890147686004639, -0.4165607988834381, -0.15990050137043, -1.0513389110565186, -0.07345844060182571, -0.9750468134880066, 0.2953675389289856, 0.9855996966362, -0.23628759384155273, 0.2506505250930786, -0.4550338685512543, -1.1286673545837402, 0.28164517879486084, 1.0150020122528076, 0.16243882477283478, 0.20922952890396118, 0.7912160754203796, 0.28524476289749146, -0.6997515559196472, 0.5624464154243469, 0.14537520706653595, -0.044067103415727615, -0.2748751938343048, -0.2459418773651123, 0.2649786174297333, 0.05976588651537895, -0.2521623969078064, -0.16354641318321228, 0.7848355174064636, 0.5134207606315613, 0.04325029253959656, -0.27002501487731934, 0.17499017715454102, -0.06512662023305893, -0.20470911264419556, -0.7412445545196533, 0.7471188306808472, -0.03354005143046379, -0.6430761814117432, -0.08188528567552567, -0.49186477065086365, 4.190903186798096, 0.8087778687477112, 0.7666782140731812, -0.46290600299835205, 0.8028537034988403, 1.1442204713821411, 0.2691689729690552, 0.10122063755989075, 0.24704097211360931, -0.8216677308082581, 0.060748714953660965, 0.17413295805454254, 0.36221975088119507, 0.38578876852989197, -0.3584807217121124, 0.19451183080673218, -0.13763463497161865, -0.30774548649787903, -0.16803625226020813, 0.2753770053386688, -1.1940115690231323, 0.11157763004302979, -0.12757766246795654, -0.731221616268158, 0.20213516056537628, 0.6393800377845764, 0.40779420733451843, -0.18911392986774445, -0.5906273722648621, -0.34640341997146606, -0.4517483413219452, -0.44877710938453674, -0.07204782962799072, -0.03185206279158592, -1.502074956893921, 0.7753832936286926, -0.14081361889839172, -1.1324435472488403, 0.671196460723877, 0.11136386543512344, 0.3740352392196655, -0.34522518515586853, 0.23548831045627594, -0.36668872833251953, 0.45063668489456177, 0.8950542211532593, 0.4444735646247864, -0.3249974846839905, 0.6745237112045288, -0.8965522050857544, -0.1351851522922516, -0.07900218665599823, -0.07351095974445343, -0.8073174953460693, -0.4536702334880829, -0.6936912536621094, 0.2838861346244812, -0.3214122951030731, 0.07756225019693375, -0.4380297064781189, 0.5750806331634521, -0.3810124397277832, -0.43460336327552795, 0.1375129520893097, 0.3789379894733429, 0.1927577704191208, 0.6714363098144531, 0.009079528041183949, -0.529398500919342, -0.16414785385131836, -0.7681724429130554, 0.14184345304965973, -0.21579428017139435, 0.2594224214553833, 0.3504306375980377, 0.20623360574245453, 0.24590592086315155, -0.2180097997188568, -0.8972857594490051, 0.40201714634895325, -0.6829442977905273, 0.5099143981933594, -0.030193837359547615, 0.4559013843536377, 0.009723791852593422, 0.264510840177536, 0.05937185510993004, -0.10817475616931915, -0.8010181188583374, 0.5877806544303894, 0.20791059732437134, 0.2637920081615448, -0.48081547021865845, -0.020428301766514778, -0.3873353898525238 ]
Anisotropic and inhomogeneous cosmologies
This review was given at the 65th birthday meeting of D.W. Sciama, The Renaissance of General Relativity and Cosmology, to be published by Cambridge University Press. It presents progress in the understanding of non-standard relativistic cosmologies during Sciama's career, organized by the areas of application rather than the mathematical types of the models.
M.A.H. MacCallum
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212014
gr-qc/9212015
[ 0.6445344686508179, 0.050978340208530426, 0.4306078553199768, -0.08423420786857605, 0.24510104954242706, -0.00037474249256774783, 0.46812400221824646, -0.6731173396110535, -0.6791520714759827, 1.0101895332336426, 0.2703956365585327, 0.10485530644655228, 0.1943405121564865, -0.7839177846908569, 0.20209141075611115, 0.5092771649360657, 0.06796453893184662, -0.8548704385757446, -1.2438101768493652, 0.6546427011489868, 0.3287865221500397, 0.47696301341056824, -1.3611348867416382, -0.5736891031265259, -0.2542702257633209, 0.7799074053764343, 0.6412823796272278, 0.38072407245635986, 0.8287027478218079, 0.8887762427330017, 0.43604862689971924, -0.12955796718597412, -0.14632387459278107, -0.48520833253860474, -0.8157166242599487, 0.05062873661518097, 0.008753054775297642, -0.2766237258911133, 0.8425481915473938, -0.5323463082313538, 0.6741044521331787, -0.23043139278888702, 0.1831958293914795, -0.17927971482276917, -0.29209262132644653, 0.37258559465408325, 0.33694586157798767, 0.3133500814437866, -0.24941898882389069, -0.9711278676986694, 0.009243174456059933, -0.25716346502304077, 0.4377007484436035, -0.7208629250526428, -0.6364254355430603, -0.2597488462924957, 0.47234639525413513, 0.37350544333457947, -0.20602326095104218, -0.2917044460773468, 0.48777055740356445, -0.158787339925766, 0.09485382586717606, -0.877906322479248, 0.012185282073915005, 0.661116898059845, 0.06764596700668335, 0.2630804777145386, 0.2876669466495514, -0.4354091286659241, -0.6149652600288391, -0.5735035538673401, -0.3453887403011322, 0.6913660168647766, -0.7267290949821472, 0.9310405850410461, -0.5835768580436707, -0.21099990606307983, -0.31968414783477783, -0.2336694449186325, 0.184464231133461, 0.018738197162747383, -0.5079771280288696, 0.39424756169319153, -0.479902058839798, -0.4484748840332031, -0.1558198183774948, 0.204432874917984, 0.8278809189796448, 0.2137991040945053, -0.11011992394924164, 0.3792541027069092, -0.23206938803195953, -0.38128072023391724, 0.30174821615219116, 0.4992186427116394, -0.25642675161361694, 1.0339796543121338, -0.000961250567343086, -0.1039242073893547, -0.5850020051002502, 1.2443608045578003, -0.29294875264167786, 0.09791570901870728, -0.6888773441314697, 0.9802266955375671, -0.48094412684440613, 0.23352113366127014, -0.27363258600234985, -0.25793078541755676, 0.07643450796604156, 0.436178594827652, 0.7934141755104065, 0.04650365188717842, 0.398334264755249, 0.30948954820632935, -0.40250954031944275, -0.2537463903427124, -0.8364235758781433, -0.31657353043556213, 0.3917646110057831, 0.39167168736457825, 0.2864099442958832, 0.4663071930408478, -0.8603829145431519, -0.7277746200561523, -0.01248735561966896, 0.8633221387863159, -0.6867924332618713, 0.33112725615501404, 0.5613816976547241, -0.06100764498114586, -0.36148977279663086, 0.2288820594549179, 0.10272496938705444, -0.34459421038627625, -0.3269939422607422, 0.10748030990362167, 0.14836260676383972, -0.27650171518325806, 0.30008235573768616, -0.7691720724105835, -0.06641573458909988, 1.2912639379501343, -0.3244417607784271, 0.030801793560385704, 0.44299790263175964, -0.38469362258911133, -0.7942428588867188, 0.0754297748208046, -0.17882317304611206, -0.00521041639149189, 0.09434542804956436, 0.26200130581855774, 0.017050201073288918, -0.039396021515131, -0.8758248090744019, 0.03664005547761917, -0.3558448553085327, -0.40982240438461304, 0.8450849056243896, -0.6055893898010254, -0.0746881365776062, 1.1241294145584106, -0.46494272351264954, 0.6394544243812561, -0.7728277444839478, 0.4984579086303711, 0.3418191373348236, -0.16714154183864594, -0.12689322233200073, 0.171042338013649, -0.1667969524860382, 0.6464282870292664, 0.46387338638305664, 0.5187931656837463, 0.02640354260802269, -0.302080899477005, -0.14482228457927704, 0.48269492387771606, -0.16761909425258636, -0.7941614985466003, 0.5789265036582947, 0.3529268503189087, -1.1095095872879028, -0.15484261512756348, 0.44619840383529663, -0.567620575428009, 0.8777229189872742, -0.032406244426965714, -0.7138245105743408, 0.41347622871398926, -0.4869801104068756, 0.5828847885131836, -0.8583071827888489, 0.21196679770946503, -1.461456060409546, 0.3147611618041992, -0.4228473901748657, -0.09048581123352051, 0.06741319596767426, -0.07784678041934967, -0.9772547483444214, -0.11648209393024445, -1.0901001691818237, -0.04609221592545509, -0.08085989207029343, 0.5110756754875183, -0.433262437582016, -0.5633928775787354, 0.6680560111999512, -0.3775394558906555, 0.2555036246776581, -0.4927649199962616, 0.4509076774120331, -0.20215348899364471, -0.6638981103897095, 0.19642046093940735, -0.4124889373779297, 0.04694078490138054, 0.7195755243301392, 0.5453291535377502, 0.06581725180149078, 0.8927546143531799, 0.05886142700910568, -0.1889403909444809, 0.3961591124534607, 0.3129502534866333, 0.13154664635658264, 1.0158190727233887, 0.40056127309799194, 0.48095032572746277, 0.293393075466156, 0.17292307317256927, 0.520867645740509, 0.23450568318367004, 0.4314116835594177, 0.6464728116989136, 0.410253643989563, 0.47826993465423584, 0.3444994390010834, 0.21364538371562958, 0.5443106889724731, -0.03928840532898903, -0.9599668979644775, 0.20065733790397644, 0.011598529294133186, 0.4339584708213806, -0.23339708149433136, 0.9882028102874756, -0.6612082719802856, 0.22821849584579468, 0.31272009015083313, -0.3290994465351105, -0.98199862241745, 0.22339209914207458, -0.23245488107204437, 0.219610795378685, 0.26365867257118225, -0.2847190201282501, -0.038219161331653595, 0.34483394026756287, 0.3223360776901245, -0.2325589507818222, -0.4615749418735504, 0.1510293036699295, -0.3144361078739166, -0.11101650446653366, 0.8957847356796265, -0.7631350755691528, -1.3311729431152344, -0.2766447067260742, -0.5378140807151794, 0.1189940795302391, -0.802366316318512, -0.54939866065979, 0.7579949498176575, -0.3636832535266876, 0.5807533264160156, 0.4773370623588562, -0.03458152338862419, 0.3469681739807129, -0.5345572233200073, 0.08389681577682495, 0.30535826086997986, -0.015940425917506218, -0.9387420415878296, -0.06942419707775116, -1.190322756767273, 0.14040057361125946, -0.45182767510414124, -0.18874533474445343, 0.7304349541664124, -0.015432751737535, 0.47413280606269836, 0.1920473277568817, -0.5247582197189331, 0.1979333460330963, -0.2659945487976074, -1.3016771078109741, 0.050883278250694275, 0.4286210238933563, -0.03971420228481293, 0.07875281572341919, -0.394685834646225, 0.9787546396255493, -0.11298485845327377, -0.5642051100730896, 0.20405443012714386, -0.42354974150657654, -0.5772972106933594, 0.04770217463374138, 0.3981497585773468, 0.7619444131851196, 0.07346688210964203, 0.38901287317276, 0.47630107402801514, 0.14040201902389526, -0.37875550985336304, -0.5852373838424683, 0.1755000799894333, -0.5918605923652649, 0.9165435433387756, -0.7481658458709717, 0.7982795834541321, 0.5772496461868286, 0.08536645025014877, -0.8356474041938782, 0.8040762543678284, -1.0176371335983276, -1.075707197189331, -0.6068601608276367, -0.4654600918292999, 0.3390708565711975, 0.5083920359611511, 0.23243452608585358, 0.038640499114990234, -0.5980021953582764, -0.38380885124206543, 0.35993191599845886, 0.27600476145744324, 0.07933275401592255, 0.08649975061416626, 0.48957470059394836, 0.23743918538093567, -0.12756289541721344, 0.7295721769332886, -0.5411570072174072, 0.33722519874572754, 0.5190343856811523, -0.3765482008457184, -0.21523688733577728, 0.4717991054058075, -0.5745231509208679, -0.24437899887561798, 0.1099463701248169, -0.4138558804988861, 0.08107376843690872, -1.2678310871124268, -0.47840747237205505, 0.3639106750488281, 0.5581315159797668, -0.028884142637252808, -1.0895023345947266, -0.4678250849246979, -0.32341471314430237, -0.29133811593055725, 0.5355191230773926, 0.5725656747817993, -0.6639549732208252, 0.14310964941978455, 0.46164757013320923, -0.010869590565562248, -0.40255263447761536, -0.24369478225708008, 0.3708290159702301, 0.6091263294219971, -0.008343120105564594, 0.37017562985420227, -0.20776104927062988, -0.1326863318681717, -0.8469582796096802, 1.0427498817443848, -0.21065546572208405, 0.7086637616157532, 0.3163816034793854, 0.006041236221790314, -0.19816264510154724, -0.25107550621032715, -0.2554362416267395, -0.2634667456150055, -0.9168676733970642, -0.08892730623483658, -0.23504823446273804, 0.0486501082777977, -0.24246247112751007, 0.26920610666275024, 0.6020302176475525, -0.030183255672454834, 0.14968101680278778, 0.18533527851104736, 0.547757625579834, 0.6205664873123169, 0.5831370949745178, -0.5871869921684265, -0.12243834137916565, -0.7404385209083557, 0.4696243107318878, 0.6389424800872803, 0.21101714670658112, 0.20855779945850372, -0.6905567049980164, -0.07843247801065445, -0.15421530604362488, 0.8456302285194397, 0.08388692885637283, -0.20611391961574554, 0.32202017307281494, 0.013630185276269913, -0.44297027587890625, -0.07142115384340286, 0.24774330854415894, 1.065354824066162, 0.5406126379966736, 0.14126582443714142, -0.5221694707870483, 0.033491671085357666, -0.6422300338745117, 0.22464872896671295, 0.4176238477230072, -0.9439473152160645, -1.0351340770721436, -0.08652065694332123, 0.0034931739792227745, 0.38440144062042236, -0.11984632164239883, 0.7321200966835022, 1.0106805562973022, 0.6752181649208069, -0.415515273809433, 0.1755077838897705, 0.8679240942001343, -0.7881633043289185, -0.25126615166664124, -0.25248071551322937, -0.06366071850061417, -0.2915046811103821, 0.7514258027076721, -0.331753671169281, -0.9475915431976318, -0.4720045030117035, -0.2955571413040161, -0.029903942719101906, -0.3793944716453552, -0.6413492560386658, 0.5847194194793701, -0.18921884894371033, 0.1882658749818802, 0.7315566539764404, 0.07849523425102234, -0.10202784836292267, 0.3749510943889618, -0.12384764850139618, 0.09291399270296097, 0.7973785996437073, 0.12245675921440125, 0.5191125273704529, 0.08912207186222076, 1.2272521257400513, 0.42437493801116943, 0.26041117310523987, 0.19294030964374542, -0.0639028549194336, -0.12210240960121155, 0.43449196219444275, -0.5472699999809265, -0.5416772365570068, -0.07385601848363876, -0.22195570170879364, -0.5262649655342102, -0.4224911630153656, 0.39458808302879333, -0.07541698217391968, 0.3060207962989807, 0.0859675481915474, -0.7092142701148987, -0.3760468065738678, -1.0725011825561523, -0.8922467231750488, 0.5842142105102539, -0.39077258110046387, -0.08350422978401184, 0.1809755265712738, -0.8554782271385193, -0.36471232771873474, 0.017137713730335236, -0.1418222337961197, 0.20446820557117462, -0.25381365418434143, 0.4239208698272705, -0.13008052110671997, 0.5258705615997314, -0.7929493188858032, 0.3049915134906769, -0.7141382098197937, -0.03723903000354767, -0.4303678274154663, -0.2015286237001419, 0.004119467921555042, 0.08672962337732315, 0.2730252146720886, -0.164799302816391, 0.1142713651061058, 0.3647359311580658, 0.21415039896965027, 0.15363189578056335, -0.6711506247520447, -0.8912325501441956, 0.22020767629146576, -0.018045470118522644, 0.34385237097740173, -1.023415446281433, -0.31063899397850037, 0.8518732786178589, 0.3649429678916931, 0.10784900188446045, -0.4229383170604706, -0.27001067996025085, 0.11539965867996216, -1.3502155542373657, -0.2602894902229309, -1.1164699792861938, -0.5068413615226746, -0.48627370595932007, -0.36261579394340515, 0.5645814538002014, 0.3210567831993103, -0.22210635244846344, -0.3826279938220978, -0.5371108055114746, -0.3936437666416168, 0.14405949413776398, -1.1243131160736084, 0.10653652250766754, -0.8939570188522339, -0.616389274597168, -0.45979487895965576, 0.8695957660675049, -0.19131405651569366, 0.17001278698444366, 0.43387889862060547, 0.14087413251399994, 0.2982955574989319, 0.5156667828559875, 0.20895002782344818, 0.1466219276189804, -0.5279687643051147, 0.06591469049453735, 0.20581212639808655, -0.40968430042266846, -0.3662105202674866, 0.46038395166397095, -0.4520517885684967, 0.6921167969703674, -0.40234750509262085, -0.6287664771080017, 0.42132920026779175, 0.17260843515396118, 0.7066056132316589, -0.881027340888977, -0.2359468936920166, 0.5780182480812073, -0.06068751588463783, -0.12009969353675842, -0.08714025467634201, -0.8332605361938477, -0.19291704893112183, -0.5046758651733398, -0.35376209020614624, 0.7369567155838013, -0.06871841847896576, -0.46525371074676514, -0.7482929825782776, -0.6201083660125732, 0.5815955996513367, 0.39964351058006287, 0.9013655185699463, 0.2014855146408081, 0.27639347314834595, 0.2929331362247467, 0.3057417571544647, -0.2947525084018707, -0.7580958604812622, 0.16475722193717957, 0.38248685002326965, 0.006193861365318298, -0.11848100274801254, -0.003890502266585827, -0.5452622175216675, -0.7339460849761963, -0.13428431749343872, -0.21346616744995117, 0.3665662109851837, -0.5831001400947571, 0.5444798469543457, -0.07515420764684677, -0.44241705536842346, -0.16119073331356049, -0.06290514022111893, -0.01592393033206463, -0.32467928528785706, 0.39910978078842163, 0.5211597084999084, 0.45716214179992676, 0.27079880237579346, 0.34130600094795227, -0.2694090008735657, -0.28790974617004395, 0.5576174259185791, -0.581229031085968, -0.02170887589454651, 0.43689462542533875, -0.04292483627796173, 0.211501345038414, -1.175491213798523, -0.7623274326324463, -0.41791823506355286, 0.45780041813850403, -0.21667157113552094, 0.7836591601371765, 0.020015301182866096, 0.09909270703792572, 0.5554665327072144, 0.5784138441085815, 0.28371602296829224, 0.25405916571617126, 0.06776890903711319, 0.3073243796825409, -0.2931807041168213, 0.25712087750434875, 1.0883339643478394, 0.26689890027046204, -0.6022984385490417, 0.22691768407821655, 0.4652901291847229, -0.21376310288906097, -0.6696256995201111, 0.5347287654876709, -0.8905046582221985, -0.05894185230135918, 0.11538498103618622, -0.14579574763774872, -0.019632568582892418, -0.348502516746521, -0.19305172562599182, -0.6622697114944458, -0.4485667943954468, 0.0013632012996822596, 0.12305472791194916, -0.09450534731149673, 0.5031989216804504, 0.5487110018730164, -0.35238149762153625, -0.15598410367965698, -0.22569601237773895, 0.6478556990623474, 0.02340579777956009, -0.9994403719902039, -0.6590794324874878, -1.102781057357788, -0.36347416043281555, -0.700635552406311, 0.21959683299064636, 0.08516412228345871, -0.1127958595752716, -0.18900704383850098, 0.27283212542533875, -0.16702774167060852, -0.09775039553642273, 0.161227285861969, 1.2542612552642822, -0.7135819792747498, -0.19610239565372467, -0.4737796485424042, 0.3240785300731659, 0.022431258112192154, -1.1160050630569458, -0.6767839193344116, -0.44321826100349426, 0.11056170612573624, 0.7125390768051147, -0.43646442890167236, 0.3448507785797119, -0.6738724708557129, -0.6745507717132568, 0.13651326298713684, 0.29592132568359375, -1.292043924331665, 1.0052144527435303, -0.30627432465553284, 0.8067290186882019, 0.44439926743507385, 0.30570828914642334, 0.019802505150437355, 0.3183150887489319, -0.5228484869003296, 0.33284926414489746, 0.3512961268424988, 0.9204817414283752, -0.009166248142719269, -1.0063555240631104, -0.3083926737308502, 0.34225791692733765, -0.8126415014266968, 0.5444198846817017, -0.1468488574028015, 0.3887844681739807, -1.0145151615142822, 0.45629987120628357, 0.21002431213855743, -0.15056928992271423, -0.5112226009368896, 0.4862290918827057, -1.006579041481018, -0.0827149748802185, -0.07658082991838455, 0.03184640780091286, -0.4097149074077606, -0.22666782140731812, 0.7280856966972351, 0.2521267235279083, 0.3996237516403198, 0.1885240077972412, -0.26364991068840027, -0.08106554299592972, 0.18048204481601715, -0.09540365636348724, -0.03911442309617996, 0.2529727816581726, 0.28643232583999634, 1.2791129350662231, 0.33224934339523315, -0.12597067654132843, 0.25478890538215637, -0.7378246784210205, -1.3807878494262695, -0.21345701813697815, -0.16065554320812225, -0.5045470595359802, 0.8654735088348389, -0.16497573256492615, 0.08405163884162903, 0.2587682604789734, -0.8321884870529175, -0.07165578007698059, 0.7583433985710144, 1.336747169494629, 0.8471300005912781, -0.014125971123576164, -0.43409258127212524, -0.31977248191833496, -0.9518545866012573, -0.43638256192207336, 0.17943400144577026, 0.05331367626786232, -0.6309095025062561, -0.8684402108192444, 0.05361373722553253, -0.012385512702167034, -0.2837078869342804, -0.40786001086235046, 0.2701740860939026, -0.40935802459716797, -0.5472686886787415, -0.599044144153595, 0.29946228861808777, 0.16860324144363403, -0.7771554589271545, 0.3866977095603943, 0.361022025346756, -0.6608858108520508, 0.1866212636232376, 0.10342523455619812, 0.17551706731319427, 0.3891710638999939, -0.018217721953988075, 0.5946947932243347, 0.0033147891517728567, 0.10406932234764099, 0.6991152167320251, 0.5836519002914429, 0.2866637110710144, 0.4028077721595764, -0.6722735166549683, 0.10056061297655106, 0.7920674085617065, 0.11347953230142593, 0.5211144089698792, 0.4034546911716461, -0.1398725062608719, 0.5359628796577454, 0.30491793155670166, -0.031543318182229996, -0.2116633802652359, 0.1433355212211609, 0.17295192182064056, 0.6166691184043884, -0.2225176841020584, -0.7340071201324463, 0.10357838124036789, 0.21692629158496857, 0.6175314784049988, -0.09787897765636444, -0.4062649607658386, -0.5884318351745605, 0.7772430777549744, 0.5153191089630127, -0.32608935236930847, -0.600002110004425, -0.1850588023662567, 0.2380490005016327, 0.1573893129825592, 0.12983350455760956, -0.027350226417183876, 0.08248791098594666, 0.11814159154891968, -0.28798767924308777, 0.04245156794786453, 0.8414199948310852, 0.22548647224903107, 0.7895952463150024, 0.699377715587616, 0.3382156789302826, 0.4454014301300049, 0.6771131157875061, 0.055199142545461655, -0.23603393137454987, -0.09923090040683746, 0.1932774931192398, -0.6006130576133728, 0.04012259468436241, 0.26694393157958984, -0.3434731066226959, -0.6303967237472534, -0.3573804795742035, 0.045208510011434555, 0.17656417191028595, 0.34514763951301575, -0.2031821608543396, -0.6619435548782349, -0.04363296180963516, 0.5637878775596619, 0.12686114013195038, 0.17633283138275146, 0.6714019775390625, 0.613230288028717, 0.4647355377674103, 1.1952918767929077, 1.1526020765304565, 0.27548277378082275, 0.26473110914230347, -0.27431896328926086, -0.22609156370162964, 0.6979181170463562, 0.45190200209617615, -0.11758801341056824, -0.14817747473716736, -1.2383906841278076, -0.10369977355003357, 0.12837547063827515, 0.2624569833278656, -0.09270919114351273, -0.0043633561581373215, 0.4022500514984131, 0.40371429920196533, -0.21882185339927673, -0.5920465588569641, 0.6857956051826477, 0.3180267810821533, -0.574039101600647, 0.2985382378101349, 0.8440616130828857, -1.027969479560852, -0.07040988653898239, -1.3296539783477783, 0.40077918767929077, 0.4915027618408203, 0.09924591332674026, -0.5030545592308044, -0.7358424663543701, -0.4790937006473541, -0.4289637804031372, -0.0842660665512085, -0.3466666340827942, -0.06827837973833084, 0.6337331533432007, -0.7722350358963013, 0.2103450745344162, -0.32688987255096436, -1.0358827114105225, -0.16915102303028107, 0.7900228500366211, 0.30067896842956543, 0.20153486728668213, 0.5344816446304321, 0.42468971014022827, -0.8267967104911804, 0.5994279384613037, 0.554446280002594, -1.170123815536499, 0.6542500257492065, -0.458413302898407, 0.23614639043807983, 0.89058917760849, -0.8395344018936157, 0.17244412004947662, 0.1640188843011856, 0.3331679701805115, 0.5302945971488953, -0.19425706565380096, 0.05347738415002823, -0.49865615367889404, 0.018325626850128174, -0.40839898586273193, 0.056219279766082764, 0.3633100092411041, -0.2806796729564667, 0.28464558720588684, -1.030847430229187, 4.219829559326172, 1.241647481918335, 0.18006333708763123, -0.4005609154701233, 0.6858329772949219, 1.3246610164642334, -0.13252969086170197, 0.5204161405563354, -0.012210661545395851, -0.952588677406311, -0.3788697421550751, 0.46691271662712097, 0.2895040512084961, -0.0369042344391346, -0.03812871873378754, 0.6366729736328125, -0.07179096341133118, 0.12450107932090759, -0.5137803554534912, 0.011251118965446949, -0.673239529132843, 0.48733025789260864, -0.015881458297371864, -0.04504548758268356, 0.44804948568344116, 0.32810845971107483, 0.03749391436576843, -0.2735629379749298, -0.6428959965705872, -0.2771574854850769, -0.4570953845977783, -0.47790926694869995, -0.3027440309524536, -0.4821459949016571, -1.0495930910110474, 0.04986308515071869, -0.16216622292995453, -0.8124955892562866, 0.31004542112350464, 0.36195382475852966, 0.011203553527593613, -0.5598815679550171, 0.674479603767395, -0.4137754738330841, 0.21219205856323242, 0.6365532875061035, 0.3307872414588928, 1.0605018138885498, 0.4651277959346771, -0.4681210517883301, 0.16584232449531555, 0.027592597529292107, 0.3089127838611603, -0.7425804734230042, -0.6487166285514832, -0.8900888562202454, -0.3846501111984253, 0.1023087203502655, 0.1475619375705719, 0.0475861094892025, 0.19812266528606415, -0.46120724081993103, -0.30809175968170166, 0.07429757714271545, -0.214213028550148, 0.3853534162044525, 0.5527158975601196, -0.040678005665540695, 0.3192066550254822, -0.7134124040603638, -0.4056631624698639, -0.06575895100831985, -0.4185369610786438, -0.0011443133698776364, 0.35446420311927795, 0.7444887757301331, -0.1686374694108963, 0.6367035508155823, -0.3383123576641083, 0.5998629927635193, -0.25072765350341797, 0.1857827752828598, 0.15051424503326416, 0.09408517926931381, -0.40089911222457886, 0.7836262583732605, -0.2977170944213867, 0.3468802571296692, -0.48970040678977966, 0.4830203354358673, 0.23634760081768036, 0.6843875050544739, 0.14705096185207367, 0.1523483544588089, -0.6432414650917053 ]
(1+1)-Dimensional Methods for General Relativity
This is an article contributed to the Brill Festschrift, in honor of the 60th birthday of Prof. D.R. Brill, which will appear in the Vol.2 of the Proceedings of the International Symposia on Directions in General Relativity. In this article we present the (1+1)-dimensional method for studying general relativity of 4-dimensions. We first discuss the general formalism, and subsequently draw attention to the algebraically special class of space-times, following the Petrov classification. It is shown that this class of space-times can be described by the (1+1)-dimensional Yang-Mills action interacting with matter fields, with the spacial diffeomorphisms of the 2-surface as the gauge symmetry. The constraint appears polynomial in part, whereas the non-polynomial part is a non-linear sigma model type in (1+1)-dimensions. It is also shown that the representations of $w_{\infty}$-gravity appear naturally as special cases of this description, and we discuss briefly the $w_{\infty}$-geometry in term of the fibre bundle.
J.H. Yoon
gr-qc
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212015
gr-qc/9212016
[ -0.1881265640258789, 0.28374430537223816, 0.950548529624939, 0.46497243642807007, 0.005643006414175034, -0.47878095507621765, -0.49426794052124023, -0.16398249566555023, -0.2697129547595978, 1.660760760307312, 0.7203903794288635, 0.020450463518500328, -0.274299293756485, -1.126914143562317, -0.3677363097667694, 0.21613408625125885, -0.25657525658607483, -0.7148126363754272, -1.4991002082824707, 0.1951509714126587, 0.10921522229909897, -0.49352437257766724, -1.1005606651306152, -0.7201889753341675, -0.4342558979988098, 1.2454909086227417, 0.029351331293582916, 0.6285415887832642, 0.8118704557418823, 0.9373995661735535, 1.116011381149292, -0.34975937008857727, 0.034153662621974945, -0.45902636647224426, -0.5264336466789246, 0.05731120705604553, 0.37290096282958984, -0.14779025316238403, 0.6042168140411377, 0.00395702151581645, 0.4743933081626892, -0.5804398655891418, 0.5574359893798828, -0.609641432762146, -0.49582141637802124, -0.46769124269485474, 0.2594485580921173, 0.8261181116104126, -0.01810884289443493, -1.2252063751220703, 0.22345827519893646, -0.26728498935699463, 0.4890563488006592, -0.6898307800292969, -0.6697746515274048, 0.2618807852268219, 0.3548905551433563, -0.32320016622543335, -0.31270501017570496, -0.4869900941848755, -0.26840850710868835, 0.29510897397994995, 0.19838084280490875, -0.5837428569793701, -0.7061760425567627, 1.236435890197754, -0.1571609526872635, 0.7719903588294983, -0.051888272166252136, -0.7985532879829407, -0.4051862359046936, 0.26257824897766113, -0.08009232580661774, 0.13805796205997467, -0.5287924408912659, 0.39950716495513916, -0.6137768030166626, -0.5678137540817261, -0.8724080920219421, 0.010528733022511005, -0.4514067769050598, 0.39254650473594666, 0.13001057505607605, 0.23091784119606018, -0.2400505244731903, -0.5258165597915649, 0.01738317683339119, -0.23177482187747955, 0.6181924343109131, -0.06191519647836685, -0.48410195112228394, 0.4024702310562134, -0.7817651033401489, -0.10730301588773727, 0.8305568099021912, 0.9045475721359253, -0.5591778755187988, 0.2660534679889679, -0.21800272166728973, 0.24640944600105286, -0.26941022276878357, 1.0138111114501953, -1.1955010890960693, 0.3954276442527771, -0.7873691320419312, 0.6577070951461792, 0.31228527426719666, 0.5558226108551025, -0.31964969635009766, -1.0660343170166016, 0.07272927463054657, 0.9546096920967102, 0.5562581419944763, 0.7655189037322998, -0.21157243847846985, 0.8210753798484802, -0.5821044445037842, -0.05152400955557823, -0.324099600315094, -0.28291943669319153, 0.16621947288513184, 0.17203311622142792, 0.501587986946106, 0.3138217329978943, -0.5677323341369629, 0.09790904819965363, -0.033165790140628815, 0.8190047740936279, -0.29496607184410095, 1.0878264904022217, 0.6105676293373108, -0.09620919078588486, -0.050457678735256195, 0.5192099809646606, 0.44319722056388855, 0.6980436444282532, 0.21736197173595428, 0.3650647699832916, -0.23212343454360962, -0.5755960941314697, 0.34190911054611206, -0.5995496511459351, 0.18776173889636993, 1.0085139274597168, -0.6745096445083618, -0.19166667759418488, 0.9994392991065979, -0.20670349895954132, -0.14829933643341064, -0.07424233108758926, -0.37317681312561035, -0.09327048808336258, -0.06779246032238007, 0.6310332417488098, -0.1770903468132019, -0.3485453426837921, -0.45430880784988403, 0.4074348211288452, -0.396096408367157, -0.15680831670761108, 0.7731413245201111, 0.37520402669906616, 0.24656419456005096, 0.7478525042533875, -0.32382550835609436, 0.07152427732944489, -0.3679686188697815, -0.5334978699684143, 0.6245770454406738, 0.12600673735141754, -0.2912227511405945, 0.214817076921463, 0.29515719413757324, 0.749195396900177, 0.8048537969589233, 0.7036274075508118, 0.006359616760164499, -0.07424921542406082, -0.23434969782829285, -0.018039144575595856, -0.45180341601371765, -0.13056951761245728, 0.44554731249809265, 0.10011659562587738, -0.5421535968780518, -0.12916746735572815, 0.3833960294723511, -0.3742353618144989, 0.03315163403749466, 0.46256622672080994, -0.2517251670360565, 0.057275496423244476, -1.0609222650527954, 0.3920770287513733, -0.5581302642822266, -0.2416526973247528, -0.7215644717216492, -0.3287663757801056, -0.6657049059867859, -0.3021339178085327, 0.3304900825023651, -0.556479275226593, -0.3014093339443207, 0.6352730989456177, -1.068907380104065, -0.6323521733283997, 0.7154582142829895, 0.6375971436500549, -0.3230561316013336, -0.21738505363464355, -0.02585633471608162, -0.3847808539867401, -0.4009440839290619, 0.7077756524085999, 0.06256779283285141, -0.20245398581027985, -0.4043388366699219, 0.4170266389846802, 0.5327966213226318, 0.26316922903060913, 0.5415353178977966, -0.10524556785821915, 0.03994901478290558, 1.1468437910079956, -0.532723605632782, -0.04918833076953888, 0.33265745639801025, 0.270503431558609, 0.7050222754478455, 0.5544042587280273, 0.4602847099304199, 0.5256226658821106, 0.14680363237857819, 0.5959007740020752, 0.707176923751831, 0.20758838951587677, 0.6890195608139038, 1.010711908340454, 0.2514607310295105, -0.08881140500307083, 0.24213160574436188, 0.02018841542303562, -0.6218071579933167, 0.9351999759674072, -0.38988009095191956, 0.7407201528549194, 0.01159562449902296, -0.3485082983970642, -0.154414564371109, 0.6149963140487671, -1.2424826622009277, 0.7077851295471191, 0.007813021540641785, -0.7049534916877747, -1.1050260066986084, 0.04714001715183258, -0.18934446573257446, 0.26852548122406006, -0.11243784427642822, -0.2719419598579407, -0.22239233553409576, 0.2797623872756958, -0.2265348732471466, -0.5299496650695801, 0.36227965354919434, -0.15566661953926086, -0.11936212331056595, -0.3047754168510437, 0.7304825782775879, -0.219553604722023, -1.5676013231277466, -0.14870592951774597, -0.2959516644477844, -0.171373650431633, 0.12082641571760178, 0.2605282664299011, 0.4239603877067566, -0.2074284702539444, 0.7037631273269653, -0.2762959897518158, 0.47346773743629456, 0.18940822780132294, -0.2941513657569885, -0.25193846225738525, -0.14290964603424072, 0.07109302282333374, -0.3639463186264038, -0.07527948915958405, -0.4080158472061157, 0.34744173288345337, -0.8144481182098389, -0.32467857003211975, 0.20501559972763062, 0.20519687235355377, 0.24864093959331512, 0.617502748966217, 0.10753188282251358, -0.31652453541755676, 0.46300867199897766, -0.6611192226409912, 0.30180805921554565, -0.12485846877098083, -0.5073171257972717, -1.11967933177948, -0.9683102965354919, 0.8809004426002502, 0.23679648339748383, -0.2833629846572876, 0.597988486289978, -0.2548847496509552, -0.9582151174545288, 0.058398663997650146, 0.11969243735074997, 0.14498864114284515, -0.10647809505462646, 0.9209273457527161, 0.7978007197380066, -0.19425632059574127, 0.3213178515434265, -0.514833927154541, -0.019366780295968056, -0.31651464104652405, 0.6436108350753784, -0.7247385382652283, 0.1721240133047104, 1.2738122940063477, 0.040583766996860504, -0.45108649134635925, 0.6119573712348938, -0.8109686374664307, -0.5808042287826538, 0.21299584209918976, 0.26088789105415344, 0.23096376657485962, 0.37029358744621277, 0.4647585153579712, -0.28675544261932373, -1.0164963006973267, -1.2324129343032837, 0.4824962913990021, 0.2957945764064789, -0.41525378823280334, -0.44333702325820923, 0.7918658256530762, 0.11824081093072891, -0.38312506675720215, 0.5672351717948914, -0.3688216805458069, -0.3174450695514679, 0.21916383504867554, -0.5601868629455566, -0.15085060894489288, 0.35601162910461426, 0.1924818903207779, 0.4299432039260864, -0.041439928114414215, -0.8392779231071472, -0.5339757800102234, -0.5816555619239807, -0.45849573612213135, -0.0658627450466156, 0.6083397269248962, 0.19958510994911194, -0.38709577918052673, 0.06032136455178261, -0.5346282720565796, 0.13769443333148956, 0.5859801769256592, 0.3514060974121094, -0.4931194484233856, 0.21073663234710693, 0.3066808879375458, -0.007624189835041761, -0.5147416591644287, -0.21493251621723175, 0.39190953969955444, 1.0565768480300903, -0.6045137643814087, 0.4437779188156128, 0.17784972488880157, -0.33207249641418457, -0.4158255159854889, 0.49527353048324585, 0.5256942510604858, 0.16943134367465973, 0.19263410568237305, -0.43621566891670227, -0.350903183221817, -0.2964896261692047, -0.34609919786453247, -0.6136943101882935, -1.1029508113861084, 0.2769180238246918, -0.37377920746803284, -0.0978260189294815, 0.051495928317308426, 0.3468365967273712, 0.6752464175224304, -0.12938255071640015, 0.16471458971500397, 0.0900854766368866, -0.10049477219581604, 0.2192438542842865, -0.15331941843032837, -0.3937811553478241, 0.11230966448783875, -0.18435005843639374, 0.24899205565452576, 0.25188466906547546, 0.3353657126426697, 0.4714537560939789, -0.36860522627830505, -0.36104458570480347, -0.3388770818710327, 0.49314889311790466, 0.21756279468536377, -0.2648635506629944, 0.5586280226707458, 0.27720972895622253, -0.5109186172485352, -0.37334638833999634, 0.8702733516693115, 0.7005531787872314, 0.15421313047409058, 0.15529990196228027, -0.7805362939834595, 0.2933841645717621, -0.20415610074996948, 0.5671541690826416, 0.6968761682510376, -0.6926352977752686, -0.2602517008781433, -0.22705677151679993, 0.003532886039465666, 0.6069912910461426, -0.21977190673351288, 0.8745074272155762, 0.027034694328904152, 0.21292835474014282, 0.045518502593040466, 0.021607425063848495, 0.9048066735267639, -0.1898016631603241, 0.2095494419336319, 0.37579846382141113, 0.016781825572252274, -0.4324563443660736, 0.491231769323349, -0.10510539263486862, -0.5639411211013794, -0.42262986302375793, -0.7367218136787415, 0.19023938477039337, -0.5850682258605957, -0.42396166920661926, 0.6173080205917358, 0.25078892707824707, 0.013364897109568119, 0.4966658651828766, -0.010939869098365307, 0.14189080893993378, -0.18976621329784393, 0.020414013415575027, -0.2679370045661926, -0.40665727853775024, 0.10402081161737442, -0.41718363761901855, 0.053207170218229294, 1.016816258430481, 0.2562832534313202, 0.20795604586601257, -0.06477722525596619, 0.04530709236860275, 0.2105410099029541, -0.4902576804161072, -0.907202959060669, -0.2816920876502991, -0.10673031210899353, -0.6635538339614868, -0.5397080779075623, -0.5333340764045715, 1.0552959442138672, -0.39910534024238586, -0.3549720048904419, 0.04895945265889168, -0.2948475778102875, -0.19754137098789215, -0.7272053360939026, -0.4623570144176483, 0.501383364200592, -0.2224612683057785, -0.09069153666496277, 0.12557268142700195, -0.5194569230079651, -0.4231143295764923, -0.08787787705659866, -0.19584180414676666, -0.40652018785476685, 0.01802889071404934, 0.3681463897228241, 0.27329885959625244, 0.023582855239510536, -0.7642408013343811, 0.6765817999839783, 0.0802944228053093, -0.5013442039489746, -0.6076580882072449, -0.5312095284461975, -0.2714996635913849, -0.014574981294572353, 0.6138556599617004, -0.14320680499076843, -0.025450918823480606, 0.2524130642414093, -0.14307911694049835, 0.625113844871521, -0.0710178092122078, -0.6815844774246216, 0.23567095398902893, 0.40863150358200073, 0.5423649549484253, -0.9196053147315979, -0.15102308988571167, 0.7982680797576904, 0.2013912796974182, 0.7183153033256531, 0.04724900424480438, -0.1252405047416687, 0.28271234035491943, -0.7584102153778076, 0.22717635333538055, -0.6294676065444946, -0.05339960753917694, -0.9735678434371948, 0.14172716438770294, -0.03899184614419937, -0.10723696649074554, -0.23311367630958557, -0.8303487300872803, 0.06449071317911148, -0.4150879383087158, 0.8091294765472412, -0.4087490737438202, -0.14595100283622742, -0.13841573894023895, -0.17135347425937653, -0.769239604473114, 0.9735913276672363, -0.18631969392299652, 0.4528142511844635, 0.4870566129684448, -0.6546894311904907, 0.19094257056713104, 0.5175879001617432, 0.01799064502120018, 0.33828598260879517, -0.31369608640670776, 0.6008576154708862, 0.589201807975769, 0.09860983490943909, -0.5367401242256165, 0.29359522461891174, -0.6197971105575562, 0.48362722992897034, 0.3718455135822296, -0.11823225766420364, 0.10047867149114609, 0.20357361435890198, 0.49373841285705566, -0.5391292572021484, 0.07679229974746704, 1.3656526803970337, 0.09317221492528915, 0.2025129199028015, 0.40424299240112305, 0.0001018371112877503, -0.16961833834648132, -0.2777717709541321, -0.5407838225364685, -0.4320509135723114, -0.07176419347524643, -0.03358948603272438, -0.37405189871788025, -0.4015800952911377, -0.060523901134729385, -0.8489997386932373, 0.35425299406051636, 0.4373273253440857, 0.3093755543231964, 0.9368318319320679, 0.15726913511753082, 0.13760291039943695, -0.6329091787338257, -0.3610449433326721, 0.31722989678382874, 0.23956069350242615, -0.18976783752441406, -0.05742974206805229, 0.034474145621061325, -0.6210132837295532, -0.4109979569911957, 0.28368398547172546, 1.1385583877563477, -0.2922219932079315, 0.6353572010993958, 0.5628769397735596, -0.6639830470085144, -0.7348212003707886, -0.15852388739585876, -0.23305679857730865, -0.5142876505851746, 0.2658841907978058, -0.21147029101848602, -0.09605639427900314, -0.29631495475769043, -0.16706685721874237, -0.5378443598747253, -0.16318777203559875, 0.8499290943145752, -0.8202384114265442, 0.047762393951416016, 0.03545967862010002, -0.48102787137031555, -0.009325427934527397, -1.1962698698043823, -1.6072921752929688, -0.4216751158237457, -0.12284933775663376, -0.772791862487793, -0.26650381088256836, -0.3493974208831787, -0.633653461933136, -0.09478120505809784, -0.10016410052776337, 0.1622646301984787, 0.6704308390617371, 0.05957524850964546, -0.17124828696250916, -0.5595219731330872, 0.5335292816162109, 0.7601015567779541, 0.719917893409729, -0.027868952602148056, -0.11295842379331589, 0.49448710680007935, -0.3379170298576355, -0.4962683916091919, 0.6026830673217773, -0.2795056700706482, 0.5083832740783691, -0.6337816119194031, 0.2745171785354614, 0.2730371057987213, 0.5348787307739258, -0.21524186432361603, 0.38112881779670715, -0.2903524935245514, -0.2912432849407196, 0.7166322469711304, -0.26398763060569763, 0.2443806678056717, 1.4068005084991455, -0.2923871576786041, -0.047685734927654266, -1.0277155637741089, 0.20305585861206055, -0.04111796244978905, -0.3696887195110321, -0.5528972148895264, -1.0865639448165894, -0.3490281403064728, -0.5133829116821289, -0.6559175252914429, -0.03194037079811096, 0.3860885500907898, -0.4582193195819855, 0.11257271468639374, -0.6608642339706421, 0.3015888035297394, 0.2815138101577759, 1.057182788848877, -0.20761099457740784, -0.49422794580459595, -0.7639656066894531, 0.6908692717552185, -0.4773033857345581, -0.9447129964828491, -1.2440807819366455, -0.8030490875244141, 0.6038796901702881, 0.8553186655044556, -0.5172712206840515, 0.7308080792427063, -0.4472607970237732, -0.5944096446037292, 0.41231831908226013, 0.46874457597732544, -0.42361122369766235, 0.6005290746688843, -0.17084220051765442, 0.918237030506134, 0.565535306930542, -0.630340576171875, -0.11446969956159592, -0.3268475830554962, -0.7272688746452332, 0.6315146088600159, 0.0015173852443695068, 0.5677822232246399, 0.28909534215927124, -0.8531787991523743, 0.2198624163866043, 0.7080344557762146, -1.1457855701446533, 0.3711361885070801, -0.7285537123680115, 0.6800490021705627, -0.5790010690689087, -0.34125158190727234, 0.6328663229942322, 0.3995363116264343, -0.47665470838546753, 0.4411320090293884, -0.7965801358222961, -0.450365275144577, -0.25507333874702454, 0.46240317821502686, -0.2238980382680893, -0.8297666311264038, 0.22865983843803406, -0.13613229990005493, 1.104007363319397, -0.06344649195671082, -0.043791819363832474, 0.4153939187526703, 0.20540498197078705, -0.30911269783973694, -0.1925170123577118, -0.09252399206161499, -0.2512642741203308, 0.48740994930267334, 0.0037490238901227713, 0.0018475338583812118, 0.6170859336853027, -0.5912986993789673, -0.9228186011314392, 0.291416734457016, -0.19188331067562103, -0.5332720279693604, -0.3999258875846863, -0.03095059283077717, -0.305549293756485, 0.31613972783088684, -0.38556426763534546, 0.10084638744592667, -0.7125117778778076, 1.1689658164978027, 0.5177030563354492, 0.219076007604599, -0.4269072115421295, 0.25168606638908386, -0.2979634702205658, 0.3159281313419342, -0.31456658244132996, 0.010973961092531681, -1.058759093284607, -0.5816795825958252, -0.6029170155525208, 0.6865526437759399, -0.4961584210395813, -0.14317955076694489, -0.010197248309850693, -0.18807721138000488, -0.624026358127594, 0.0545247383415699, -0.6578214168548584, -0.13626940548419952, -0.4138276278972626, 0.3170168101787567, -0.15592312812805176, -0.21646252274513245, 0.0841788575053215, 0.14782366156578064, 0.3351989686489105, -0.11756948381662369, -0.5800918936729431, 0.6128368973731995, -0.09594855457544327, -0.08581613749265671, -0.12565968930721283, 0.3355105519294739, -0.29860109090805054, 0.4412112534046173, -0.4639708697795868, 0.3622288107872009, -0.17076455056667328, -0.03734641149640083, 0.6344888806343079, -0.4526163339614868, 0.6188568472862244, 0.5374652147293091, -0.3405393064022064, 0.007089871913194656, 0.34246042370796204, 0.45038938522338867, 0.12519791722297668, 0.36528125405311584, -0.2984153628349304, -0.14219136536121368, -0.15849511325359344, -0.019777506589889526, 0.15672960877418518, 0.0075570279732346535, 0.026530474424362183, -0.2957618832588196, 0.05652716010808945, 0.47534632682800293, -0.1382184773683548, -1.1206450462341309, 0.3022555112838745, 0.14387500286102295, 0.3423554599285126, 0.16690872609615326, -0.3695871829986572, -0.10199008882045746, 0.3599684536457062, 0.0020945556461811066, -0.16054277122020721, 0.13354507088661194, 0.754606306552887, 0.6015950441360474, 0.41997963190078735, 0.6129356622695923, 0.41860726475715637, 0.8144295811653137, -0.2283957451581955, -0.4499899744987488, -0.2240140736103058, 0.6207084655761719, -0.6203277707099915, 0.862248957157135, 0.1042776107788086, -0.36713555455207825, 0.20048001408576965, -0.6548547744750977, -0.1726723313331604, -0.20442993938922882, 0.04843667894601822, 0.14945772290229797, -0.6213706135749817, -0.31364578008651733, 0.47586265206336975, 0.015888893976807594, 0.00849264394491911, 0.15701280534267426, 0.5030112266540527, -0.3524208962917328, 1.0377401113510132, 0.9340611100196838, 0.6204575300216675, -0.005501931998878717, -0.0581054724752903, -0.04029626026749611, 0.1146973967552185, 0.029494192451238632, -0.11060433834791183, 0.37899404764175415, -0.5461832880973816, 0.14398114383220673, 0.10302597284317017, 0.172635018825531, -0.3128144443035126, -0.06740815192461014, 0.3200089633464813, 0.4113454520702362, -0.91245037317276, 0.14014025032520294, 0.11465000361204147, 0.7447813749313354, -0.8804488182067871, -0.7744615077972412, 0.10418340563774109, -0.5375770330429077, 0.7188145518302917, -0.812419593334198, 0.3354437053203583, -0.30651789903640747, -0.3709377646446228, -0.38496556878089905, -0.4585666358470917, -0.5236559510231018, -1.5071065425872803, -0.08448342978954315, -0.30023014545440674, 0.78510582447052, 0.45319804549217224, 0.4813069999217987, -0.18029604852199554, -0.7029854655265808, -0.0176679827272892, -0.483535498380661, 1.4014191627502441, 0.06304087489843369, 0.039119232445955276, 0.1404852420091629, -0.05456232652068138, -0.6135996580123901, 0.6640297770500183, 0.662513792514801, -0.7487220764160156, 0.7859704494476318, -0.0008265249198302627, 0.22911269962787628, 0.05667521432042122, -0.4640830457210541, -0.14044588804244995, 0.2738162577152252, 0.42024487257003784, 0.7067574858665466, -0.42181313037872314, 0.04048682004213333, -0.728377103805542, 0.1733039915561676, -0.34263280034065247, 0.1909835934638977, 0.4148005247116089, -0.34380412101745605, 0.3909037411212921, -0.7915977239608765, 4.214941024780273, 0.6016512513160706, 0.6691381335258484, -0.4159921109676361, 0.0396341010928154, 0.7611225247383118, 0.6217969059944153, -0.3848208785057068, 0.1313641220331192, -0.3057281970977783, 0.4567243456840515, 0.31562143564224243, 0.4886084496974945, 0.3846065402030945, 0.3593442440032959, 0.8731616139411926, 0.26674267649650574, 0.34429293870925903, -0.19883595407009125, -0.8849964141845703, -0.7738826870918274, -0.020237978547811508, 0.2930085361003876, 0.015903476625680923, 0.47102728486061096, 0.480392187833786, 0.1562892645597458, -0.5100453495979309, -0.5660614371299744, -0.6268722414970398, -0.32403087615966797, -0.6627203822135925, -0.14750047028064728, 0.4742896556854248, -0.6633041501045227, 0.8961161375045776, 0.12526214122772217, -0.278999000787735, 0.3807331919670105, 0.055698227137327194, 0.30629608035087585, -1.5256437063217163, 0.23480229079723358, -0.1549772173166275, -0.5931869149208069, 0.37279120087623596, 1.266454815864563, 0.570867121219635, 1.0206619501113892, -0.36908647418022156, 0.03754892572760582, 0.19407318532466888, -0.3947165310382843, 0.10705509781837463, -1.1322375535964966, -0.17427055537700653, -0.32627689838409424, -0.22675666213035583, 0.13319003582000732, -0.1488267481327057, 0.76654052734375, -0.46720147132873535, -0.13623131811618805, 0.4214671850204468, 0.2745973467826843, 0.2114986777305603, 0.10373274236917496, -0.0332418791949749, -0.1995539516210556, -0.7916353344917297, -0.6230168342590332, -0.23353807628154755, -0.9234429001808167, -0.046429768204689026, 0.30068439245224, 0.6136759519577026, 0.09849393367767334, 0.45170700550079346, 0.08116589486598969, 0.2906588613986969, -0.024997897446155548, 0.19918030500411987, 0.004171865526586771, 0.598383903503418, -0.08236251771450043, 0.7150686979293823, 0.07919179648160934, 0.18140019476413727, -0.286587119102478, 0.45592644810676575, 0.07724491506814957, 1.155434012413025, -0.338466078042984, -0.012629375793039799, -0.8507081866264343 ]
String Instabilities in Black Hole Spacetimes
We study the emergence of string instabilities in $D$ - dimensional black hole spacetimes (Schwarzschild and Reissner - Nordstr\o m), and De Sitter space (in static coordinates to allow a better comparison with the black hole case). We solve the first order string fluctuations around the center of mass motion at spatial infinity, near the horizon and at the spacetime singularity. We find that the time components are always well behaved in the three regions and in the three backgrounds. The radial components are {\it unstable}: imaginary frequencies develop in the oscillatory modes near the horizon, and the evolution is like $(\tau-\tau_0)^{-P}$, $(P>0)$, near the spacetime singularity, $r\to0$, where the world - sheet time $(\tau-\tau_0)\to0$, and the proper string length grows infinitely. In the Schwarzschild black hole, the angular components are always well - behaved, while in the Reissner - Nordstr\o m case they develop instabilities inside the horizon, near $r\to0$ where the repulsive effects of the charge dominate over those of the mass. In general, whenever large enough repulsive effects in the gravitational background are present, string instabilities develop. In De Sitter space, all the spatial components exhibit instability. The infalling of the string to the black hole singularity is like the motion of a particle in a potential $\gamma(\tau-\tau_0)^{-2}$ where $\gamma$ depends on the $D$ spacetime dimensions and string angular momentum, with $\gamma>0$ for Schwarzschild and $\gamma<0$ for Reissner - Nordstr\o m black holes. For $(\tau-\tau_0)\to0$ the string ends trapped by the black hole singularity.
C.O.Lousto and N. S\'anchez
gr-qc hep-th
December
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/9212016
hep-lat/9201001
[ 0.31886330246925354, -0.043789010494947433, -0.1449539065361023, -0.07185064256191254, -0.3135254681110382, -0.28324246406555176, 0.2092563807964325, -0.527248203754425, -0.5132177472114563, 1.0470315217971802, 0.7038025259971619, -0.36141401529312134, 0.31550106406211853, -0.5229791402816772, -0.6104547381401062, 0.5313176512718201, 0.2793720066547394, -0.7679358720779419, -0.9903380870819092, 0.2836691737174988, 0.30841267108917236, -0.09767422080039978, -1.0445356369018555, 0.039300356060266495, -0.6362093687057495, 0.8950508236885071, 0.3260577917098999, 0.062470268458127975, 0.6615243554115295, 0.28260669112205505, -0.050369322299957275, -0.3820844888687134, -0.20884226262569427, -0.362451434135437, -0.25937992334365845, -0.30606287717819214, -0.4356338679790497, 0.03716203197836876, 1.168233871459961, -0.42533063888549805, 1.1521846055984497, -0.1246325895190239, 0.26413169503211975, -0.18264007568359375, -0.7054945826530457, -0.10116158425807953, -0.2475852221250534, -0.11248362064361572, -0.10721556097269058, -1.0747238397598267, 0.32159969210624695, 0.5364151000976562, -0.24593453109264374, -0.8410966992378235, 0.0712946429848671, -0.3971562385559082, 0.16916626691818237, 0.18010501563549042, -0.6055377721786499, -0.36041259765625, 0.7415902614593506, 0.07278314232826233, 0.7330465316772461, -0.7009813785552979, 0.030170200392603874, 1.0563263893127441, -0.047723181545734406, 0.6458736062049866, -0.11391713470220566, -0.02471069060266018, -0.40996646881103516, -0.1938493251800537, -0.5720322728157043, 0.034068528562784195, -0.9783414006233215, 0.20903930068016052, 0.4077053964138031, -0.15521672368049622, -0.40978527069091797, -0.10083125531673431, -0.22197186946868896, 0.024822061881422997, -0.7544130682945251, 0.025536783039569855, -0.24315592646598816, -0.33968690037727356, 0.25939974188804626, -0.40075981616973877, 0.18824292719364166, 0.4615189731121063, -0.29337015748023987, 0.6593980193138123, -0.60416579246521, 0.4916609227657318, 0.3938370645046234, 0.5886638760566711, -0.207064688205719, 0.3052668273448944, -0.017207372933626175, 0.18439064919948578, 0.036363955587148666, 0.5212341547012329, -0.6924153566360474, 0.2874273359775543, -1.0320570468902588, 0.5777830481529236, 0.11423693597316742, 0.22888822853565216, 0.037918444722890854, -0.8950909972190857, 0.6448311805725098, -0.08603981137275696, 0.1467074602842331, 0.5297797918319702, 0.38662952184677124, 0.8198795318603516, -0.3313985764980316, 0.36439037322998047, -0.625205934047699, -0.5753973722457886, 0.12305625528097153, 0.28714367747306824, 0.3115418255329132, 0.4764670431613922, -0.09459821879863739, -0.0026484474074095488, 0.5332971215248108, 0.31254932284355164, -0.7124132513999939, 0.49392008781433105, -0.08071137219667435, -0.0462937131524086, -0.45768973231315613, 0.7655159831047058, -0.8500851988792419, 0.08913666009902954, -0.0769510567188263, 0.7695021033287048, 0.23425760865211487, -0.19575507938861847, 0.6428464651107788, -0.6552359461784363, 0.0504172258079052, 0.8071833848953247, -0.5739868879318237, -0.34556472301483154, -0.20796962082386017, -0.0731649249792099, 0.14635342359542847, 0.20034094154834747, -0.17400705814361572, -0.33321458101272583, -0.2156258076429367, 0.5315167307853699, -0.29582473635673523, 0.2329028993844986, -0.6650190353393555, 0.04877670854330063, -0.22347155213356018, -0.6129299998283386, 0.3874458372592926, 0.17211483418941498, -0.43549004197120667, 0.5619054436683655, -0.5908626317977905, 0.16283085942268372, -0.15050022304058075, 0.08611204475164413, 0.13973097503185272, -0.78033047914505, 0.11873672157526016, 0.47796303033828735, -0.1225590780377388, 0.6641029715538025, 0.2399892657995224, 0.3593985140323639, 0.7189344167709351, -0.9093371629714966, -0.4592481553554535, -0.019697776064276695, -0.38219937682151794, -0.05182059481739998, 0.22891153395175934, 0.1958620250225067, -0.6163585186004639, -0.298103004693985, -0.21911540627479553, -0.11605265736579895, 0.2702123820781708, 0.06306222826242447, -0.5047367215156555, 0.2635943293571472, -0.834496021270752, 0.7832047939300537, -0.836871325969696, -0.23167189955711365, -0.9933573007583618, 0.23552300035953522, -0.435852587223053, -0.6776090264320374, -0.415963739156723, 0.4880899488925934, -0.3784605860710144, 0.7020402550697327, -0.9586818218231201, -0.1827220469713211, 0.2871014475822449, 0.14951081573963165, -0.6257705092430115, 0.1282682865858078, 0.47022873163223267, -0.3994763195514679, 0.46460816264152527, -0.3375622630119324, -0.050005801022052765, 0.406585693359375, 0.39291912317276, 0.07258663326501846, 0.26351138949394226, 0.7124356627464294, 0.5915577411651611, -0.06950926035642624, 0.20567895472049713, 0.7755709886550903, -0.42131832242012024, -0.20802024006843567, 0.3975524604320526, 0.2998616099357605, 0.13905417919158936, -0.6636394262313843, -0.0824008658528328, 0.6695806384086609, 0.20452749729156494, 0.482694536447525, 0.5876408219337463, -0.022174188867211342, 0.08425316214561462, 0.07461370527744293, -0.1879199892282486, 0.3143640458583832, 0.1475178599357605, -0.45138439536094666, -0.0020130020566284657, -0.13665781915187836, -0.2556699514389038, 0.2742328345775604, -0.2917017638683319, 0.4770386219024658, -0.1979418694972992, 0.7409794330596924, 0.3049393892288208, 0.39716291427612305, -0.2273591011762619, 0.552225649356842, -1.3924579620361328, -0.20445998013019562, -0.44285470247268677, 0.0995590016245842, -0.32096534967422485, -0.5243467092514038, -0.31514275074005127, 0.247474804520607, -0.19007228314876556, -0.6813874244689941, -0.25145795941352844, 1.0017603635787964, -0.20811159908771515, 0.45707929134368896, 0.8573655486106873, -0.16294941306114197, -0.6364222168922424, 0.29724881052970886, -0.9440330862998962, -0.17131590843200684, -0.3365708589553833, 0.6350204944610596, 0.3769707977771759, -0.8278369903564453, 0.20306351780891418, -0.15675537288188934, -0.24662719666957855, 0.4909689426422119, 0.12946167588233948, 0.26337185502052307, 0.5393151044845581, 0.39009520411491394, -0.6088584065437317, 0.2730933725833893, -0.5938733220100403, -0.11336475610733032, -0.09082457423210144, 0.09010986238718033, 0.4768800437450409, -0.22253651916980743, 0.2990466356277466, 0.3104383647441864, -0.8947649002075195, 0.22512081265449524, 0.666208028793335, -0.471503883600235, 0.24350106716156006, 0.08027627319097519, 0.07579410076141357, 0.22162246704101562, -1.0260438919067383, 0.4860770106315613, 0.16696888208389282, -0.48078739643096924, 0.4376298487186432, 0.4140423536300659, -0.4328506886959076, 0.4882318079471588, -0.5520946979522705, -0.09124097228050232, -0.1495112031698227, 0.9655818343162537, 0.26407480239868164, 0.1515372395515442, -0.04337793588638306, -0.11475592851638794, -0.2939911484718323, -0.43750062584877014, -0.30766069889068604, 0.07631562650203705, -0.1855248212814331, 0.6529706120491028, -0.09480910003185272, -0.5117896199226379, 0.17212702333927155, -0.5635460019111633, -0.9844299554824829, 0.46019843220710754, -0.8184806704521179, 0.6117958426475525, -0.30670300126075745, 0.3922019898891449, -0.5323466658592224, 0.2885954678058624, -0.27347859740257263, 0.0467788428068161, 0.4948272705078125, -0.3875843584537506, 0.5404943823814392, 0.5393633842468262, 0.4126075804233551, -0.20810385048389435, 0.42721256613731384, -0.1888551414012909, -0.9307425022125244, 0.239496111869812, -0.43732142448425293, 0.32559555768966675, -0.1981057971715927, 0.19265396893024445, -0.0012485808692872524, 0.25291916728019714, -0.3169117867946625, -0.2628211975097656, -0.6835308074951172, -0.7091518640518188, 0.19590464234352112, 0.8379538059234619, 0.06309764832258224, -0.07196200639009476, -0.4280078113079071, 0.005339063238352537, 0.36603015661239624, -0.31551098823547363, 0.07108098268508911, -0.40633830428123474, 0.07918071746826172, -0.4394494295120239, -0.25906240940093994, 0.22035260498523712, 0.13286875188350677, 0.31245991587638855, 0.7909577488899231, 0.670509397983551, 0.8176953196525574, -0.019597312435507774, -0.36525285243988037, 0.30732765793800354, 0.738434910774231, 0.6043038964271545, 0.5743260383605957, 0.1560399979352951, 0.41093680262565613, 0.22906415164470673, -0.8367294073104858, -0.352795273065567, -0.27158889174461365, -0.3812553584575653, 0.5573861598968506, -0.37846723198890686, -0.386627197265625, -0.25879421830177307, 0.047067221254110336, 0.3289468586444855, 0.1588340401649475, -0.16560408473014832, 0.5757550001144409, 0.04440821707248688, 0.0961584821343422, 0.6857032179832458, 0.17567229270935059, 0.24206236004829407, -0.5859174728393555, -0.04157618433237076, -0.06177618354558945, -0.21189165115356445, -0.4313823878765106, -0.5855704545974731, -0.24031773209571838, -0.8711370825767517, 0.5138919353485107, 0.17401936650276184, -0.4641040563583374, 0.08991829305887222, 0.0876443162560463, 0.6204169988632202, -0.27278634905815125, 0.39869996905326843, 0.2583868205547333, -0.09870507568120956, 0.5206945538520813, -0.8308641314506531, 0.07488454878330231, -0.7300118803977966, 0.17481465637683868, 0.8756633996963501, -0.35033121705055237, -1.019403100013733, -0.6972309947013855, -0.3624524474143982, -0.25008711218833923, 0.032045233994722366, 0.7567357420921326, 0.6283665895462036, -0.481509268283844, -0.8183594942092896, -0.3403475880622864, 1.1409531831741333, -0.40059128403663635, -0.35085198283195496, 0.7006461024284363, 0.04908616095781326, 0.2748081088066101, 0.17373088002204895, -0.14455869793891907, -0.6170358657836914, 0.19171054661273956, -0.9740645885467529, 0.06600280851125717, -0.56697678565979, -0.6168896555900574, -0.266619473695755, -0.27072474360466003, -0.41482892632484436, 0.7157202959060669, 0.4773249328136444, -0.16178545355796814, -0.4749355614185333, 0.09270338714122772, -0.38257575035095215, -0.13138170540332794, 0.19559046626091003, 0.44678330421447754, 1.2066022157669067, 1.2039421796798706, 0.3823849856853485, 0.22717183828353882, 0.5735406279563904, 0.03624388948082924, -0.0937986895442009, 0.24769684672355652, 0.03937263786792755, -0.10477976500988007, -0.35639438033103943, -0.09497734904289246, -0.8757160305976868, -0.5330700874328613, -0.3343943655490875, -0.12602832913398743, 0.5552999973297119, -0.1649521440267563, -0.7606517672538757, -0.6448219418525696, 0.05434461683034897, -0.633595883846283, 1.0602357387542725, -0.13813258707523346, -0.018333248794078827, 0.18075300753116608, 0.12919016182422638, 0.09197772294282913, -0.33303168416023254, -0.562913179397583, -0.34228238463401794, 0.9749286770820618, 0.4765832722187042, 0.8824776411056519, 0.7768299579620361, -0.5694964528083801, 0.9016773104667664, -0.2162066251039505, -0.040780313313007355, -0.044653233140707016, -0.12186777591705322, -0.2521061599254608, -0.28547433018684387, 0.44933244585990906, 0.10488372296094894, 0.07014378905296326, -0.2658008635044098, -0.7721307277679443, -0.28955215215682983, 0.2652589976787567, -0.2719268202781677, 0.14228063821792603, 0.3786275386810303, 0.4757145345211029, -0.3562239408493042, -0.09265727549791336, 0.18547676503658295, 0.2839573919773102, 0.10551348328590393, 0.035323601216077805, -0.7434248328208923, 0.3560698330402374, -0.5762805938720703, 0.18814876675605774, -0.556515097618103, -0.2016100287437439, 0.02158655971288681, -0.8596343398094177, -0.0586300753057003, 0.6984561681747437, 0.2969604432582855, 0.44121381640434265, -0.25879552960395813, -0.1632925122976303, 0.3094649016857147, -0.5662353038787842, -0.5420572757720947, -0.1257198452949524, -0.14252646267414093, -0.3201729953289032, 0.45472434163093567, -0.7634055018424988, 0.4482085108757019, -0.02839980646967888, -0.14103348553180695, -0.14008596539497375, 0.6309754252433777, 0.6296898126602173, 0.26629865169525146, 0.5226374268531799, 0.3964117467403412, 0.0261037927120924, 0.3206046521663666, -0.6064484119415283, 0.45864418148994446, -0.6749332547187805, 1.0806505680084229, -0.5668327808380127, -0.4013676941394806, -0.016191042959690094, 0.34106364846229553, 0.7046234607696533, -0.341529905796051, 0.5880750417709351, 1.0157475471496582, -0.7155172824859619, 0.3547917306423187, 0.6502653956413269, -0.6569616198539734, -0.07142247259616852, -0.19562789797782898, -0.5296459794044495, 0.6675742268562317, -0.11522875726222992, -0.2421770542860031, -0.47375115752220154, -0.5028344392776489, -0.42177411913871765, 0.0375237800180912, 0.1947755217552185, 0.1716424971818924, 0.06272664666175842, 0.0050556776113808155, 0.32358914613723755, 0.47694092988967896, -0.6609551310539246, 0.426212340593338, -0.12810827791690826, 0.028299646452069283, -0.12120625376701355, 0.048567913472652435, -0.3397093117237091, -1.0226892232894897, 0.1318310797214508, 0.1209474727511406, 0.11202181875705719, -0.03997108340263367, 0.5032162666320801, -0.8875391483306885, -0.5657860040664673, 0.314501017332077, -0.03915047645568848, 0.23053120076656342, 0.012506338767707348, 0.4691329896450043, 0.36000892519950867, -0.08483389019966125, 0.19703908264636993, -0.07320943474769592, -0.08490744233131409, -0.09769698232412338, 0.5200872421264648, -0.45391595363616943, -0.2009313702583313, 0.49009793996810913, 0.11192168295383453, -0.6304929256439209, -0.28545916080474854, -1.4453963041305542, -0.26279038190841675, -0.24048154056072235, 0.10691816359758377, -0.5640165209770203, -0.22171026468276978, -0.27699682116508484, 0.19230756163597107, 0.8453159928321838, -0.026832159608602524, -0.16189469397068024, 0.3681526184082031, -0.2421416938304901, -0.8015779256820679, -0.1812567263841629, 1.387426495552063, 0.02652355283498764, -1.1979984045028687, 0.4070315659046173, 0.4492475688457489, -0.8520953059196472, -0.3371015191078186, 0.7018132209777832, -1.2191307544708252, 0.3220888674259186, 0.25347989797592163, -0.006214064080268145, 0.18152108788490295, 0.2317735254764557, 0.4508377015590668, 0.5660998225212097, -0.21689394116401672, -0.5929322242736816, -0.5474045276641846, -0.3202137053012848, 0.36471202969551086, 0.43317657709121704, 0.452972948551178, 0.18026217818260193, -0.010102068074047565, -0.26466330885887146, -0.12278963625431061, -0.4153820276260376, 0.21913239359855652, -0.8079649806022644, -0.19844554364681244, -0.31254035234451294, -0.02658039890229702, 0.36831486225128174, 0.7469452023506165, -0.25357481837272644, -0.06305750459432602, -0.06837398558855057, 0.05032752454280853, 0.11671961843967438, 0.009377657435834408, -0.23949991166591644, -1.0175672769546509, -0.11938443779945374, -0.5398359298706055, -0.10536452382802963, -1.0018408298492432, -0.042144615203142166, 0.2939419150352478, -0.27747976779937744, 0.6139155626296997, -0.5141721367835999, 0.8029780983924866, -1.0344430208206177, -0.5956801772117615, -0.17461779713630676, 0.20925301313400269, -0.5844040513038635, 0.31969156861305237, -0.02550683356821537, 0.8243575096130371, 0.22244137525558472, -0.013001872226595879, -0.11985892057418823, 0.007259498815983534, -0.5503392815589905, -0.18077675998210907, 0.19069689512252808, 0.8042733669281006, -0.09114177525043488, -0.8353772163391113, 0.12571346759796143, 0.41926807165145874, -0.9809754490852356, -0.3739206790924072, -0.4901667535305023, 0.07064235210418701, -0.435756117105484, 0.5179212689399719, -0.2268892079591751, 0.41397422552108765, 0.5494036674499512, 1.322843074798584, -0.31899648904800415, 0.5098937749862671, -0.05435391888022423, 0.4953530728816986, -0.33204182982444763, 0.5010660886764526, 0.49118566513061523, -0.6281887888908386, 0.20896342396736145, 0.8365644812583923, -0.41767266392707825, -0.3266093134880066, -0.07471060752868652, -0.1154269427061081, 0.020089181140065193, -0.13371901214122772, -0.4025987386703491, 0.41753238439559937, 0.4166947901248932, -0.6242867112159729, -0.7185429334640503, -0.3752337098121643, -0.7007205486297607, 0.7752469182014465, -0.7762634754180908, -0.31048357486724854, -0.3147996664047241, -0.5163604021072388, 0.18685731291770935, 0.5151758193969727, 0.1245437040925026, 0.33645305037498474, 0.058922089636325836, -0.6609988212585449, 0.5410494804382324, -0.31632453203201294, -0.39101794362068176, -0.020273946225643158, -0.8502048850059509, -0.7647697329521179, -0.8096674680709839, 0.7067891359329224, -0.9547462463378906, -1.025813341140747, -0.49459129571914673, 0.6445779204368591, -0.18726831674575806, -0.07418480515480042, -0.44753697514533997, -0.40067362785339355, 0.15309403836727142, -0.21071548759937286, -1.0420480966567993, -0.4187089502811432, -0.7154147624969482, 0.527866780757904, -0.5579302310943604, -0.7425585985183716, 0.35286960005760193, -0.3000935912132263, 0.4172181785106659, -0.23026548326015472, 0.002293903613463044, 1.0500357151031494, 0.48714014887809753, -0.20892775058746338, 0.797921895980835, -0.0006301937974058092, 0.3601516783237457, 0.25061681866645813, -0.40842705965042114, 0.18920807540416718, 0.8154722452163696, -0.1157250925898552, 0.49517449736595154, 0.6431065797805786, 0.3610212802886963, -0.06862425804138184, -0.3714650571346283, 0.28066205978393555, 0.23779018223285675, 0.33489087224006653, 0.033954378217458725, 0.4234057366847992, -0.36431369185447693, 0.07654190808534622, 0.08360861986875534, 0.14874427020549774, 0.5113983750343323, -0.35516971349716187, -0.03779616579413414, 0.3164495825767517, 0.022327778860926628, 0.11915234476327896, -0.8106492757797241, -0.36874905228614807, -0.29416730999946594, 0.15483546257019043, 0.4129903316497803, 0.20021645724773407, 0.0033373136539012194, 0.6478729844093323, 0.4392207860946655, -0.0784728080034256, 0.15349823236465454, 0.4790387749671936, 0.09142555296421051, 0.8329559564590454, 0.595445990562439, 0.1983100026845932, 0.511464536190033, -0.16876117885112762, 0.23517662286758423, -0.7218326926231384, 0.4279818534851074, 0.4015078842639923, -1.179846167564392, 0.45066362619400024, -0.4317929148674011, -0.1447967141866684, -0.7953932285308838, -0.4735006093978882, -0.029306354001164436, -0.8970009088516235, 0.08453003317117691, 0.7867422699928284, -0.2611130475997925, 0.5266942977905273, 0.31726160645484924, 0.16898831725120544, 0.13611742854118347, 0.5283264517784119, 0.09723636507987976, -0.058639805763959885, 0.9185554385185242, 0.8634926080703735, 0.4838109314441681, 0.13973617553710938, 0.17841872572898865, -0.6902787685394287, 0.7407688498497009, 0.7105597853660583, -0.1116684079170227, 0.7622749209403992, -0.02633356675505638, -0.8717031478881836, 0.15633252263069153, -0.20464320480823517, -0.428890198469162, -0.4482690393924713, 0.10981258004903793, 0.0007882621721364558, -0.2012706845998764, -0.5091146230697632, 1.2886422872543335, 0.004955205135047436, -0.4065694212913513, -0.4835365414619446, 0.15709024667739868, -0.1021970883011818, -0.7624346017837524, -0.846282958984375, 0.16156426072120667, 0.01946408674120903, -0.13616719841957092, -0.10003197193145752, -0.37954914569854736, -0.8370246887207031, -0.4455660581588745, 0.7669853568077087, -0.3772646188735962, 0.33904996514320374, -0.01803658902645111, -0.11193209141492844, 0.3098051846027374, -0.5333799123764038, 0.3347746729850769, 0.511378288269043, 0.9511443376541138, -0.10007985681295395, -0.29802456498146057, 0.21600885689258575, 0.6176924705505371, -0.5552548766136169, 0.6764410734176636, 0.6188371181488037, -0.6494752764701843, 0.5328770279884338, -0.33791807293891907, 0.5946012735366821, 0.7230755090713501, 0.08383943140506744, 0.17031008005142212, 0.34348034858703613, -0.4157772362232208, -0.5290964841842651, -0.32803913950920105, 0.09211470186710358, -0.8518282175064087, 0.278452068567276, -0.5187345743179321, -0.013495337218046188, -0.1564583033323288, 0.10270806401968002, 0.48848599195480347, -0.9078545570373535, 4.470637321472168, 0.5889626741409302, 0.28144973516464233, 0.2860027253627777, 0.6061100959777832, 1.0065512657165527, -0.4340185225009918, -0.17442156374454498, 0.40211132168769836, -0.4818430542945862, -0.45459309220314026, -0.4520060420036316, -0.04725421220064163, -0.2978324890136719, -0.1817055493593216, 0.8502951264381409, -0.37214866280555725, 0.17838099598884583, 0.6130997538566589, -0.5770491361618042, -0.4672776162624359, 0.19804581999778748, 0.21218237280845642, -0.04503205418586731, 0.4131569564342499, 0.45420050621032715, 0.34339582920074463, -0.2894786596298218, -0.033497199416160583, -0.34010499715805054, -0.5902631878852844, -0.8782710433006287, 0.08166492730379105, 0.012712374329566956, -0.8404878377914429, 0.8307158350944519, -0.4927781820297241, -0.3069203197956085, -0.02512478455901146, -0.03593576326966286, -0.24135839939117432, -0.3783169090747833, 0.12929069995880127, -0.04967956990003586, -0.4048987627029419, 0.5591646432876587, -0.27628880739212036, 0.6112213134765625, 0.5564704537391663, -0.7016161680221558, 1.0016027688980103, 0.3086356818675995, 0.5305625796318054, -0.579063355922699, -0.7695209980010986, 0.005823489744216204, -0.421093612909317, -0.04740006849169731, 0.0249159075319767, -0.45077967643737793, 0.42217251658439636, -0.6218751668930054, -0.5899666547775269, 0.4596836268901825, -0.3287621736526489, 0.46499666571617126, -0.2664783000946045, 0.6475591063499451, -0.7037560343742371, -0.2430780827999115, -0.12638701498508453, -0.002308549592271447, -0.1580747365951538, 0.36617735028266907, 0.30403652787208557, 0.0065822722390294075, -0.2972355782985687, 0.07549146562814713, -0.4082258641719818, 0.24083110690116882, 0.38130566477775574, 0.1434096395969391, -0.025738665834069252, 0.1371098756790161, 0.7118484973907471, 0.7436309456825256, -0.34849807620048523, 0.2556643486022949, 0.14093711972236633, 0.5750725269317627, 0.05637965351343155, 0.8702059388160706, -0.0005889164167456329, 0.43976306915283203, -0.6273807883262634 ]
Monte Carlo Simulations of Higgs-Fermion Systems
To gain understanding of the Higgs-fermion sector of the standard model, we study the one-component $Z_2$ symmetric and the four-component O(4) symmetric scalar models coupled to staggered fermions using the hybrid Monte Carlo algorithm. We map out the phase diagrams, and show that the $Z_2$ model has a tree level perturbative behaviour at all points in the broken phase. The O(4) model on the other hand is shown to have two characteristically different behaviours; one for large Yukawa couplings where the fermions get infinitely heavy and decouple in the continuum limit, and one for small Yukawa couplings where the fermions remain light. For very small Yukawa couplings the fermions show the expected tree level perturbative behaviour and for larger values the influence of the fermions becomes substantial. After estimating the finite size effects at small Yukawa couplings we make relatively accurate measurements of the scalar mass and wave function renormalization constants at the point $\kappa=0.0$ and $y=0.85-0.95$. Even though this is not the largest value possible for the Yukawa coupling we are able to show that the bound of the Higgs mass will move up significantly, from around $600 GeV$ to around $900 GeV$, by including fermions in the model. Likewise we show that a bound can be put on the fermion mass, around $200 GeV$. The largest value of the bare Yukawa coupling is obtained at rather large negative $\kappa$. Due to bad convergence rates in the inversion of the fermion matrix, which is needed in the updating procedure, this region has not been possible to investigate.
Jonas Berlin
hep-lat
January
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9201001
hep-lat/9201002
[ 0.5013226270675659, 0.24410033226013184, -0.2134629637002945, 0.4311090111732483, -0.178379088640213, 0.03081977367401123, -0.09114280343055725, -0.3834648132324219, -0.4510481655597687, 1.4303556680679321, 1.1699347496032715, -0.30042776465415955, 0.2535596191883087, -1.0695048570632935, -0.41593748331069946, 0.2675035297870636, -0.46937593817710876, -0.354095995426178, -1.2698655128479004, 0.14616619050502777, 0.16778092086315155, -0.33119139075279236, -1.08282470703125, -0.9219340085983276, -0.785379946231842, 0.5394407510757446, 0.42002198100090027, 0.27721333503723145, 1.0252256393432617, 0.7114250063896179, 0.5911886096000671, -0.7529875636100769, -0.40873920917510986, -0.5402252078056335, -0.4849839508533478, -0.07160983234643936, -0.5004836320877075, 0.2447613924741745, 0.6755577921867371, -0.5379893779754639, 0.9770284295082092, -0.05729706957936287, 0.3461366295814514, 0.04160873219370842, -0.8274407386779785, 0.10937020927667618, -0.14011068642139435, 0.312216579914093, -0.043403565883636475, -1.2335456609725952, 0.3962791860103607, 0.5711168050765991, 0.4274049997329712, -1.0126515626907349, -0.048683833330869675, -0.3972987234592438, -0.3872607350349426, 0.253991961479187, -0.4928101599216461, -0.23412923514842987, 0.719527542591095, 0.12684915959835052, 0.613236665725708, -0.5468265414237976, 0.4641779959201813, 1.0007712841033936, -0.5257253050804138, 1.089306354522705, -0.15633702278137207, -0.16526129841804504, -0.20817597210407257, -0.618369996547699, -0.7823753356933594, -0.19728168845176697, -0.5465269684791565, 0.3484567701816559, 0.27835318446159363, -0.46678268909454346, -1.0901429653167725, -0.27198389172554016, -0.1443621814250946, -0.25572478771209717, -0.0822310522198677, 0.6157846450805664, 0.052420955151319504, -0.729874849319458, 0.01278498861938715, 0.017803704366087914, 0.24419791996479034, 0.1286775767803192, -0.43408703804016113, 0.7377386689186096, -0.041226375848054886, 0.1113509088754654, 0.4415477514266968, 0.38515278697013855, 0.46913838386535645, 0.48400819301605225, 0.34649744629859924, -0.3908948600292206, -0.47395625710487366, 0.5145965218544006, -0.5959855318069458, 0.20880714058876038, -0.24414044618606567, 0.17593444883823395, -0.16727928817272186, 0.36893290281295776, 0.1377173811197281, -0.39844807982444763, 0.3438701033592224, 0.2448854297399521, 0.11561540514230728, 0.722611129283905, 0.21962764859199524, 0.7386814951896667, -0.06183132156729698, -0.06165724992752075, -0.5561065077781677, 0.08654171973466873, -0.11031515151262283, 0.21713761985301971, 0.09276014566421509, 0.6719945669174194, -0.006678350735455751, -0.17285610735416412, 0.8761179447174072, 0.28067585825920105, -0.47847360372543335, -0.2925091087818146, -0.038457922637462616, -0.29416623711586, -0.378541499376297, 0.6870434880256653, -0.3104745149612427, 0.09888245910406113, -0.12001807242631912, 0.39622336626052856, 0.16292965412139893, -0.028318116441369057, 0.805705189704895, -0.7577405571937561, 0.3292241394519806, 0.9338342547416687, -0.4179575443267822, 0.19516518712043762, 0.3482287526130676, -0.20928338170051575, -0.06901784241199493, 0.36584407091140747, -0.45621761679649353, -0.4578917920589447, -0.2204778492450714, 0.651451051235199, 0.2410937249660492, 0.33077237010002136, -0.8686645030975342, 0.03354816883802414, -0.8634556531906128, -0.45375025272369385, 0.23791000247001648, -0.3474130630493164, -0.24542473256587982, 0.19005809724330902, -0.40205350518226624, 0.0662827417254448, -0.14280463755130768, -0.0740819051861763, 0.27632206678390503, -0.40596070885658264, 0.726827085018158, -0.0020807036198675632, -0.12268020957708359, 0.8756974935531616, 0.20777533948421478, 0.45869022607803345, 0.4372645318508148, -0.5544620752334595, -0.23312515020370483, 0.7286855578422546, -0.02898784540593624, -0.10758129507303238, 0.792807936668396, 0.07151874154806137, -0.33674803376197815, -0.059834811836481094, -0.4181460738182068, -0.7434386610984802, 0.05126034468412399, 0.11726005375385284, -0.17579883337020874, 0.29529452323913574, -0.8235923051834106, 0.6284475922584534, -0.4178782105445862, -0.5753687024116516, -0.8495122790336609, 0.3596755862236023, -0.6894099712371826, -0.6538112759590149, -0.07750225812196732, 0.5433700680732727, -0.605699360370636, 0.50719153881073, -1.0311481952667236, 0.0914083793759346, 0.424297958612442, 0.039412349462509155, -0.3113076388835907, 0.06919083744287491, 0.2466072291135788, -0.3661191761493683, 0.329610675573349, -0.06177243962883949, 0.09725705534219742, 0.7622320652008057, -0.3255043029785156, -0.06577470153570175, 0.10995437204837799, 0.06849559396505356, 0.5804526805877686, 0.14019811153411865, 0.10148990899324417, 0.7694366574287415, 0.06752895563840866, 0.11316251009702682, 0.5540275573730469, 0.30985453724861145, 0.37995827198028564, 0.0126364566385746, -0.4707626700401306, 0.45791077613830566, 0.01940501481294632, 0.05115440487861633, 0.717954695224762, 0.3138068914413452, 0.26011696457862854, 0.8286759257316589, 0.03889144957065582, 0.5635456442832947, -0.0602773018181324, -0.3631369471549988, 0.22514869272708893, -0.3409115970134735, -0.5781238675117493, 0.21955935657024384, -0.3064745366573334, 0.1984562873840332, -0.7517799139022827, 0.7326177954673767, 0.11999858170747757, 0.24018782377243042, 0.20846213400363922, 0.49997657537460327, -0.8991138935089111, -0.1684766560792923, 0.10370717942714691, 0.12779216468334198, -0.17130887508392334, -0.13720516860485077, 0.01239989697933197, -0.238325834274292, -0.06423810124397278, -0.6225020885467529, -0.5216940641403198, 1.1404249668121338, -0.22616712749004364, -0.05573646351695061, 0.5647052526473999, -0.29378384351730347, -0.9210594892501831, 0.10309644788503647, -0.9610440731048584, 0.07510479539632797, -0.5982378721237183, 0.4821387827396393, 0.6644494533538818, -0.7987107634544373, 0.5825386643409729, -0.022402368485927582, -0.32917678356170654, 0.43368417024612427, -0.011038452386856079, 0.5341582298278809, 0.7809228301048279, 0.2791283130645752, -0.6974954009056091, 0.13220395147800446, -0.6964962482452393, -0.27711349725723267, 0.2530704438686371, 0.04808101803064346, 0.492854505777359, -0.3921228349208832, 0.0165276899933815, 0.06972575187683105, -1.3424922227859497, -0.250253289937973, 0.45120733976364136, -0.6872572898864746, 0.28844913840293884, 0.6896306276321411, -0.25972163677215576, 0.04311707243323326, -0.7807137966156006, 0.7780659794807434, -0.25893765687942505, -0.20833301544189453, 0.620267927646637, 0.3147745430469513, -0.1694372147321701, 0.715261697769165, -0.2087477296590805, 0.2141333967447281, 0.14513027667999268, 0.7955372929573059, 0.6090821623802185, 0.44849103689193726, -0.20270785689353943, -0.041699428111314774, 0.12289828062057495, -0.007582628633826971, -0.22252437472343445, -0.6859683990478516, 0.004426141269505024, 0.3402285873889923, -0.21929362416267395, -0.6982407569885254, 0.324735552072525, -1.0662668943405151, -0.8357320427894592, 0.03791014105081558, -1.2285752296447754, 0.7833587527275085, -0.5134324431419373, 0.335875928401947, -0.6070005297660828, 0.4590994417667389, -0.027815788984298706, 0.31583577394485474, 0.5342406630516052, -0.1543087661266327, 1.0379939079284668, 0.4221522808074951, 0.22651806473731995, -0.3369384706020355, 0.6728736162185669, -0.018887922167778015, -0.8545880913734436, 0.46308180689811707, -0.7124969363212585, 0.4167638421058655, 0.020376168191432953, -0.0038483068346977234, 0.03148525208234787, 0.7158640027046204, 0.011046824045479298, -0.11469611525535583, -1.0747530460357666, -0.1121860146522522, 0.5055219531059265, 0.5248355865478516, 0.10954390466213226, 0.09861964732408524, -0.6926206946372986, 0.059164851903915405, 0.5534753799438477, 0.1672377586364746, 0.2031233012676239, -0.8488896489143372, 0.09676643460988998, -0.12418794631958008, -0.16864356398582458, -0.1661214381456375, -0.09610365331172943, 0.22904153168201447, 0.4058721959590912, 0.74512779712677, 0.9300591349601746, -0.16048744320869446, -0.32943016290664673, 0.46169719099998474, 0.8212393522262573, 0.3760472238063812, 0.3705289959907532, 0.10710828006267548, -0.21937258541584015, 0.24251537024974823, -0.936672568321228, -0.7742627263069153, -0.3217787444591522, -0.20348873734474182, 0.047980766743421555, -0.9461089968681335, -0.12825986742973328, -0.2854175865650177, 0.2400582879781723, 0.533821165561676, 0.2332158237695694, 0.3094535171985626, 0.09376683831214905, 0.0038220281712710857, 0.47287705540657043, 0.8653067350387573, -0.01975960284471512, -0.3273850381374359, -0.8799421787261963, 0.216169536113739, 0.3129991292953491, 0.5593198537826538, -0.19024153053760529, -0.7735804915428162, -0.21857771277427673, -0.740656316280365, 0.2558960020542145, 0.20319700241088867, -0.6462434530258179, 0.5149049162864685, -0.09582807123661041, 0.2498270720243454, -0.1700483113527298, -0.22145402431488037, 0.16507013142108917, 0.034922413527965546, 0.14231304824352264, -0.9952550530433655, 0.09202022105455399, -0.3639037609100342, 0.7226400971412659, 0.990004301071167, -0.7446471452713013, -0.7604763507843018, -0.6649091839790344, 0.0710039958357811, -0.28742435574531555, -0.4629978835582733, 0.498160183429718, 0.1579018235206604, -0.20164810121059418, -0.9031793475151062, -0.2871982455253601, 0.46064186096191406, -0.8968715071678162, -0.5140700936317444, 0.1644228994846344, -0.16288509964942932, 0.46936753392219543, 0.7431604862213135, 0.11499440670013428, -0.3363610804080963, 0.2044503539800644, -0.3107578456401825, 0.9092182517051697, -0.5650859475135803, -0.7430799603462219, -0.25251445174217224, 0.03339221328496933, -0.5056275725364685, 0.37370315194129944, -0.1416209191083908, -0.17503352463245392, -0.4092116355895996, -0.11712245643138885, -0.24693740904331207, -0.23319432139396667, 0.2674315273761749, 0.09204696118831635, 1.188686490058899, 0.6288424730300903, 0.5388216972351074, 0.15690737962722778, 0.5496882796287537, 0.36919012665748596, -0.04423537105321884, 0.4187355041503906, 0.11626029014587402, -0.07969392836093903, -0.7441416382789612, -0.27125319838523865, -0.6705780029296875, -0.8341336250305176, 0.48389023542404175, -0.2380000799894333, 0.5518428683280945, 0.4301559329032898, -1.0603512525558472, -0.1418425738811493, -0.13042904436588287, -0.6237236261367798, 0.43159982562065125, -0.28354373574256897, -0.2806931734085083, 0.24483683705329895, -0.1616765260696411, -0.08695632219314575, 0.022712796926498413, -0.5586135983467102, -0.3576977849006653, 0.7730809450149536, 0.6171557307243347, -0.05323908105492592, 0.763047993183136, -1.1017078161239624, 0.8189460635185242, -0.38370126485824585, 0.019510475918650627, 0.0059701683931052685, -0.7857784032821655, -0.5588864088058472, -0.202095627784729, 0.1352514773607254, -0.6062409281730652, -0.5645068287849426, 0.25578901171684265, 0.32433587312698364, -0.3649217188358307, 0.10539387911558151, -0.26369813084602356, -0.7080442309379578, 0.5019049644470215, 0.2143028825521469, -0.49012327194213867, 0.41999951004981995, 0.25752875208854675, 0.44164255261421204, 0.23747456073760986, 0.015985464677214622, -0.5756375193595886, 0.0846862867474556, -0.6293136477470398, 0.16915662586688995, -1.0028715133666992, -0.5710485577583313, -0.03154551982879639, -0.6978504061698914, 0.21925349533557892, 0.6345056295394897, 0.1845770627260208, 0.2586110234260559, -0.3840828537940979, -0.5929930806159973, -0.13206882774829865, -0.7613769173622131, -0.05945438891649246, -0.9922874569892883, -0.5444572567939758, -0.7701227068901062, 0.8881688714027405, -0.6334600448608398, 0.058580927550792694, -0.01454246137291193, -0.2779488265514374, -0.14820034801959991, 0.7263715863227844, 0.6449793577194214, 0.10772451013326645, 0.08515513688325882, 0.761555552482605, -0.095455601811409, -0.22789958119392395, -0.7229195237159729, 0.8581576347351074, -0.5316691994667053, 1.2317748069763184, -0.5339555740356445, -0.2251499593257904, 0.09602725505828857, -0.07224686443805695, 0.561939001083374, -0.3837480843067169, 0.1955927312374115, 0.11443199217319489, -0.3591751158237457, 0.6839668154716492, 0.3518490195274353, -0.49993863701820374, -0.6088476181030273, -0.1058797761797905, -0.5478370189666748, 0.5536715388298035, -0.029288265854120255, 0.05760191008448601, -0.6568359136581421, -0.8705822825431824, -0.3833763897418976, -0.37150007486343384, -0.0392763614654541, 0.37530848383903503, 0.3363291025161743, 0.14589816331863403, -0.21961086988449097, 0.6464055776596069, -0.7043982148170471, 0.17460106313228607, -0.13404543697834015, -0.5676687955856323, -0.3896598517894745, 0.23836535215377808, -0.299946129322052, -1.0055263042449951, -0.23609723150730133, 0.2903297245502472, 0.4567243158817291, -0.40441447496414185, 0.9306910634040833, -0.5432016849517822, -0.34758442640304565, -0.20626947283744812, 0.0014564084121957421, 0.23896388709545135, 0.3207346796989441, -0.08049862086772919, 0.03453220799565315, -0.2651016414165497, -0.1655457466840744, 0.550653874874115, -0.10190550237894058, -0.08202457427978516, 0.629051685333252, -0.5835432410240173, -0.2599080801010132, 0.18728961050510406, -0.02403571829199791, -0.7574643492698669, -0.427836149930954, -1.048296570777893, -0.809475302696228, -0.15249593555927277, 0.20485174655914307, -0.24022530019283295, 0.24558690190315247, -0.016170132905244827, 0.44112682342529297, 0.9552628993988037, 0.3374457061290741, -0.04117947816848755, -0.44817185401916504, 0.14351555705070496, -0.9506577253341675, 0.05204586684703827, 1.4072656631469727, -0.001000812859274447, -0.8424981832504272, -0.23812246322631836, -0.18819013237953186, -0.17801633477210999, 0.05661129578948021, 0.2610739469528198, -0.9205381274223328, 0.5502336025238037, 0.5251748561859131, 0.23127295076847076, 0.5843652486801147, 0.11633557826280594, 0.2892700135707855, -0.17573589086532593, -0.1158800721168518, -0.8089909553527832, -0.9130111932754517, -0.6353651285171509, -0.09651931375265121, 0.29599255323410034, 0.19829538464546204, 0.33693981170654297, 0.4920932352542877, -0.25732359290122986, 0.07296306639909744, -0.6147122383117676, 0.36345815658569336, -1.1472359895706177, -0.4736955463886261, -0.4280514717102051, -0.1735335886478424, 0.22549207508563995, 0.11468475311994553, -0.038219522684812546, -0.33946090936660767, -0.10610532760620117, -0.5080810785293579, 0.6352577209472656, -0.09375400841236115, 0.16440962255001068, -0.6386675834655762, -0.339508056640625, -0.22537299990653992, 0.16993899643421173, -0.6831815242767334, -0.08182202279567719, 0.45410871505737305, -0.16016431152820587, 0.4080955386161804, -0.1825389564037323, 0.8331385850906372, -0.13614998757839203, -0.19484922289848328, -0.04585927724838257, 0.06762559711933136, -0.7469710111618042, 0.5412887930870056, -0.5029690265655518, 0.7667614817619324, 0.11167509108781815, 0.14683589339256287, -0.39941948652267456, -0.024218542501330376, -0.7472644448280334, -0.4530071020126343, -0.2082032412290573, 0.7464554309844971, 0.22213523089885712, -0.9953376650810242, 0.2108796089887619, 0.20292852818965912, -0.8320490717887878, 0.3869248032569885, -0.35976967215538025, -0.30495908856391907, 0.2400035709142685, 0.26668235659599304, -0.30989697575569153, 0.3398548364639282, -0.17893315851688385, 0.5871632695198059, -0.29517436027526855, -0.03489148989319801, -0.20704953372478485, 0.26244309544563293, -0.07644351571798325, 0.29735440015792847, -0.0699465274810791, -0.3748912513256073, -0.0035604711156338453, 1.276108741760254, -0.34433096647262573, -0.17806169390678406, -0.015817994251847267, -0.19017904996871948, -0.12848268449306488, 0.18187367916107178, -0.7888127565383911, 0.3736567497253418, 0.6278852224349976, -0.5123417973518372, -0.49605506658554077, -0.5792635083198547, -0.37467160820961, 0.46825680136680603, -0.6390841603279114, -0.4257426857948303, -0.1704389899969101, -0.25428226590156555, 0.06302527338266373, -0.026512959972023964, -0.31987059116363525, 0.20758600533008575, -0.14647233486175537, 0.15435931086540222, 0.2846984267234802, -0.2940557599067688, -0.363215833902359, 0.4798243045806885, -1.3024369478225708, -0.5510580539703369, -0.27546441555023193, 0.5481493473052979, -0.4219758212566376, -0.7645834684371948, 0.022168993949890137, 0.6111996173858643, -0.2661176323890686, -0.13395270705223083, -0.0658288449048996, 0.037016648799180984, 0.29309213161468506, -0.02798357605934143, -0.28381678462028503, -0.00978159625083208, -0.05052337795495987, 0.7376546859741211, -0.3678878843784332, -0.9132134318351746, 0.25158119201660156, -0.37747061252593994, 0.0885595977306366, -0.1529742330312729, 0.003960494417697191, 0.7197778224945068, -0.020627932623028755, -0.513313889503479, 1.5202001333236694, 0.10477945953607559, 0.5136544108390808, 0.6580365300178528, -0.4431341588497162, 0.3690645098686218, 0.638704240322113, 0.1522682160139084, 0.45829275250434875, 0.4082435667514801, -0.31312069296836853, -0.4356348216533661, 0.011684826575219631, 0.5134299397468567, 0.171930193901062, 0.6058105230331421, 0.14132419228553772, 0.3013171851634979, -0.0686488226056099, 0.22398419678211212, 0.3315759003162384, 0.41155970096588135, 0.3412353992462158, 0.027681628242135048, -0.35610759258270264, -0.22353896498680115, -0.1658838540315628, 0.2719479501247406, -0.435556560754776, -0.13529309630393982, -0.2618333399295807, 0.31540626287460327, 0.12657201290130615, -0.12233925610780716, -0.20106171071529388, 0.8897470235824585, 0.5708845853805542, -0.2446180135011673, -0.01138292159885168, 0.5106911659240723, 0.029678814113140106, 0.9955015182495117, 0.1797509789466858, 0.5461493730545044, 0.6965711116790771, 0.23946446180343628, 0.04856930673122406, -1.017194390296936, 0.6757789254188538, 0.7418931722640991, -1.4334807395935059, -0.02127886563539505, -0.2540551722049713, -0.5231184959411621, -0.267966628074646, -0.4195746183395386, -0.057450491935014725, -0.7755777835845947, 0.33525988459587097, 0.7398800849914551, -0.32167676091194153, 0.5087381601333618, 0.7915282845497131, -0.10937566310167313, 0.7286704182624817, 0.5774545073509216, 0.37175676226615906, 0.23324193060398102, 0.8951428532600403, 1.0347926616668701, -0.23927560448646545, 0.09405960887670517, -0.5020954608917236, -1.1964123249053955, 0.4233956038951874, 0.7059957981109619, -0.06954245269298553, 0.4884558320045471, -0.13751763105392456, -0.7340633869171143, 0.35777196288108826, -0.20642171800136566, -0.6068843007087708, -0.2637525200843811, 0.3356021046638489, 0.22641180455684662, -0.16874517500400543, -0.3819844126701355, 1.2706568241119385, 0.4522518813610077, -0.4751022160053253, -0.40679964423179626, 0.11034192144870758, -0.5153054594993591, -0.3383566439151764, -0.871563196182251, 0.6641466021537781, 0.1704034060239792, 0.07324495911598206, 0.13946659862995148, -0.7162765264511108, -0.8259449601173401, -0.8371720314025879, 0.32786935567855835, -0.3388217091560364, 0.4864312708377838, 0.38488495349884033, 0.07386383414268494, 0.5176901817321777, -0.44482141733169556, 0.18179842829704285, 0.14373748004436493, 0.8816378116607666, -0.15415970981121063, 0.37964504957199097, 0.08511468768119812, 0.2963371276855469, -0.6112297773361206, 0.2042331099510193, 0.48274940252304077, -0.9471787214279175, 0.41828158497810364, -0.37164226174354553, 0.21050265431404114, 0.10581211745738983, 0.16235223412513733, 0.7041449546813965, 0.4629751145839691, 0.39634448289871216, -0.6692322492599487, -0.2545735836029053, -0.3141040802001953, -1.3706992864608765, 0.4053230285644531, -0.6595545411109924, -0.13086946308612823, -0.028913589194417, 0.5255032777786255, 0.3260347843170166, -0.28664886951446533, 4.349759578704834, 0.9540778994560242, 0.8971272706985474, 0.0909019336104393, 0.3623794913291931, 0.9564019441604614, -0.4129495322704315, -0.04492947459220886, 0.029526766389608383, -0.7064415216445923, 0.04841195046901703, 0.33412498235702515, 0.19100522994995117, -0.39913082122802734, -0.24605724215507507, 0.5653822422027588, -0.07961070537567139, 0.19439256191253662, 0.5090265274047852, -0.6227664947509766, -0.45826902985572815, 0.04543343931436539, 0.147310271859169, 0.06354985386133194, 0.9534489512443542, 0.5497187376022339, -0.0838656947016716, -0.31981298327445984, 0.15892381966114044, -0.2638448178768158, -0.6081849336624146, -1.036801815032959, -0.1508844792842865, -0.270029217004776, -0.6092386841773987, 0.7719465494155884, -0.08368819952011108, -0.7489596009254456, 0.566838264465332, -0.17455829679965973, -0.45290422439575195, -0.5362438559532166, 0.29036352038383484, 0.15901362895965576, -0.7851728796958923, 0.879880964756012, 0.2145722508430481, 1.0302734375, 0.8276413083076477, -0.39452704787254333, 0.6224234700202942, -0.3346687853336334, 0.5233139991760254, -0.031054437160491943, -0.9683901071548462, 0.07933859527111053, -0.6075479984283447, -0.23296502232551575, 0.5123845338821411, -0.21694208681583405, 0.6190638542175293, -0.23888933658599854, -0.7783356308937073, 0.37508469820022583, 0.05695512890815735, 0.10094021260738373, -0.24252411723136902, 0.5751401782035828, -0.29565438628196716, -0.1901274174451828, 0.14297425746917725, 0.08287181705236435, -0.1387258619070053, 0.5456224679946899, 0.370084673166275, 0.24990379810333252, -0.3108639121055603, 0.3109162747859955, -0.5679967403411865, -0.12140639126300812, 0.07292792946100235, -0.38232114911079407, -0.0650940015912056, 0.2219175100326538, 0.31048446893692017, 0.9011895060539246, -0.2859017550945282, -0.15428784489631653, 0.0592113621532917, 0.8579761385917664, 0.13206616044044495, 1.0753527879714966, -0.1582687497138977, 0.36609700322151184, -0.7273480892181396 ]
A Study of Symmetry Restoration at Finite Temperature in the O(4) Model Using Anisotropic Lattices
Results of investigations of the O(4) spin model at finite temperature using anisotropic lattices are presented. In both the large $N$ approximation and the numerical simulations using the Wolff cluster algorithm we find that the ratio of the symmetry restoration temperature $T_{\rm SR}$ to the Higgs mass $m_{\rm H}$ is independent of the anisotropy. We obtain a lower bound of $0.59 \pm 0.04$ for the ratio, $T_{\rm SR}/m_{\rm H}$, at $m_{\rm H}a \simeq 0.5$, which is lowered further by about 10% at $m_{\rm H}a \simeq 1.$
R.V. Gavai, U.M. Heller, F. Karsch, B. Plache, and T. Neuhaus
hep-lat
January
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9201002
hep-lat/9201003
[ 0.29073411226272583, 0.5589821934700012, 0.06916935741901398, 0.010209936648607254, 0.7150557637214661, -0.4848942458629608, 0.1177125945687294, -0.3146820664405823, -0.8625182509422302, 1.2352145910263062, 1.535643219947815, 0.09956903755664825, 0.3481420874595642, -0.8057212829589844, 0.2326997071504593, 0.04425949603319168, -0.5069470405578613, -0.4510403275489807, -0.7143596410751343, -0.3258933126926422, 0.08365381509065628, 0.14707843959331512, -1.2632390260696411, -0.36663100123405457, -0.45998603105545044, 0.7106579542160034, 0.5563645362854004, 0.24239276349544525, 1.1986291408538818, 0.33158957958221436, 0.5307351350784302, -0.45477625727653503, 0.06053226813673973, -0.47708436846733093, -0.15770664811134338, -0.19513118267059326, -0.3426293134689331, 0.2343260496854782, 0.43076834082603455, -0.381830632686615, 0.675733745098114, -0.20219644904136658, 0.436026006937027, -0.35482117533683777, -0.7307371497154236, -0.3839203417301178, 0.47229647636413574, 0.4834413230419159, 0.05698743462562561, -1.2011516094207764, 0.009138963185250759, 0.15906009078025818, 0.09766560792922974, -0.7172377109527588, 0.24861900508403778, -0.07128926366567612, 0.13365530967712402, -0.1011994406580925, -0.8000732660293579, -0.42647549510002136, 0.9841618537902832, -0.4277534484863281, 1.0715546607971191, -0.8900920152664185, 0.5994574427604675, 0.09890551120042801, -0.991353452205658, 0.49312159419059753, -0.08160939812660217, -0.37771591544151306, -0.8912474513053894, -0.8437964916229248, -0.35029515624046326, -0.047037430107593536, -0.5707913637161255, 0.35181549191474915, -0.11973164975643158, 0.18582119047641754, -1.447218894958496, -0.3377486765384674, -0.07963620126247406, -0.4356854557991028, -0.650083065032959, 0.647632360458374, 0.014082458801567554, -0.7907052636146545, 0.3955170512199402, 0.07886315137147903, -0.11229222267866135, 0.04719408601522446, -0.11451151221990585, 0.8041214942932129, 0.22954802215099335, 0.2183222472667694, 0.20764510333538055, 0.6793627738952637, 0.10335542261600494, 0.393939733505249, 0.5620665550231934, 0.40387359261512756, 0.009087211452424526, 0.9005042910575867, -0.30139967799186707, 1.0356645584106445, -0.9805186986923218, 0.3512551188468933, 0.3987381160259247, 0.3795885741710663, -0.6381245851516724, -0.4446691572666168, -0.02877509780228138, 0.1475669890642166, 0.03493770956993103, 1.1254361867904663, -0.08114753663539886, 0.0026835051830857992, 0.041630398482084274, 0.3428114652633667, -0.5908470749855042, -0.0788857713341713, -0.21874432265758514, 0.13179977238178253, 0.05673743411898613, 0.2593967616558075, -0.06323392689228058, -0.3787246346473694, 0.2472076565027237, 1.074942946434021, -0.7382647395133972, 0.33558785915374756, -0.10667283087968826, 0.06757185608148575, 0.22738033533096313, 0.36021098494529724, -1.0731617212295532, 0.3527546226978302, -1.0347844362258911, 0.02028290554881096, 0.4305713474750519, 0.26574549078941345, 0.7819722294807434, -0.7057498097419739, 0.2739199995994568, 0.8937186598777771, -0.1628255844116211, 0.4386090636253357, 0.9346274733543396, -1.4059337377548218, -0.18601568043231964, 0.6693267822265625, -0.5408757328987122, 0.12701621651649475, 0.005165030248463154, 0.12006756663322449, -0.5009127855300903, 0.39568808674812317, -0.655364990234375, 0.3153567612171173, -0.2935321033000946, -0.19120945036411285, 0.6723611354827881, -0.07665156573057175, -0.534075140953064, 0.684747576713562, -0.28053975105285645, 0.5908079147338867, -0.24499069154262543, -0.2141394317150116, -0.1365402638912201, -1.0696558952331543, -0.07975369691848755, 0.1711948812007904, -0.33911433815956116, 0.5801153182983398, 0.06735344231128693, 0.6991891860961914, 0.3835563063621521, -0.013688426464796066, 1.34944748878479, 0.07841816544532776, 0.08735650777816772, -0.1956295371055603, 1.0378649234771729, -0.42772358655929565, -0.27709048986434937, 0.46976354718208313, -0.261263906955719, 0.0686371922492981, -0.19437575340270996, 0.5071049928665161, -0.05500161275267601, 0.28627291321754456, -0.2961086630821228, 0.4978046715259552, -0.7293623089790344, -0.2685849070549011, -1.025281548500061, 0.12107525765895844, -0.6974629759788513, -0.3343241512775421, -0.5099184513092041, 0.722428560256958, -0.9013329744338989, 0.5878329277038574, -1.5385984182357788, 0.350858598947525, -0.21197807788848877, 0.4048128128051758, -0.424628883600235, -0.1747778207063675, 0.28387102484703064, -0.11191454529762268, 0.33491480350494385, -0.7549405097961426, 0.3056722581386566, 0.23900079727172852, -0.6232956051826477, 0.29637834429740906, 0.5583634376525879, -0.6427555680274963, 1.0250723361968994, 0.4914168119430542, -0.5572400093078613, 0.5814000964164734, 0.07691045850515366, -0.40339288115501404, 0.6140499711036682, 0.5275474786758423, 0.23941844701766968, 0.24780918657779694, 0.04470958560705185, 0.6236732006072998, 0.3255576491355896, 0.35803890228271484, 0.8158026337623596, 0.5847165584564209, 0.3772408366203308, 0.5710468888282776, 0.7415602207183838, 0.4115006923675537, 0.25032538175582886, -0.2870293855667114, 0.7145085334777832, 0.45853862166404724, 0.001807946478947997, -0.22222426533699036, -0.3634043037891388, 0.4417191445827484, -0.6587669849395752, 0.3265160620212555, -0.43997660279273987, 0.633547842502594, 0.22973771393299103, 0.6678634881973267, -0.3969286382198334, 0.4823228120803833, 0.20014554262161255, 0.04148004576563835, -0.6891597509384155, 0.03603962063789368, -0.3602451980113983, 0.07275967299938202, -0.1680782437324524, -0.44817793369293213, -0.17782028019428253, 0.8933882117271423, 0.4485219419002533, -0.10564715415239334, -0.28604641556739807, -0.20459045469760895, -1.0447843074798584, -0.4669773280620575, -0.6770125031471252, -0.10961071401834488, -0.5459578037261963, -0.4075563848018646, 0.7683827877044678, -0.7620297074317932, 0.31028228998184204, -0.12649092078208923, -0.18206726014614105, 0.6271204352378845, -0.3066352903842926, 0.3243214190006256, 0.5904769897460938, 0.30637019872665405, -1.339698314666748, 0.4223121404647827, -0.4169193208217621, 0.3242036700248718, 0.020367546007037163, 0.06726695597171783, 1.0262444019317627, -0.5376101732254028, 0.17190611362457275, -1.0452386140823364, -0.28358152508735657, -0.44890135526657104, 0.19910138845443726, -0.5527693033218384, 0.07446998357772827, 0.22999811172485352, -0.3130568563938141, -0.05806407332420349, -0.7380176782608032, 0.9843966364860535, 0.12737171351909637, -0.05861778184771538, 0.7897465825080872, 0.741261899471283, -0.6500738263130188, 0.7502917051315308, -0.4556311368942261, -0.2287174016237259, -0.005243020597845316, 1.0126374959945679, 0.9491685032844543, 0.4074874818325043, -0.206849604845047, -0.8402706384658813, -0.3806719183921814, 0.2138945460319519, 0.19242091476917267, -0.7620971202850342, -0.4161628782749176, 0.768049418926239, 0.14676155149936676, -0.6017303466796875, 0.2982608675956726, -1.0536434650421143, -1.058161735534668, 0.00266873836517334, -0.6159395575523376, 0.9570896029472351, 0.28557491302490234, 0.19001604616641998, -0.612750768661499, 0.2943951189517975, 0.1256222128868103, 0.8973231315612793, 0.21948763728141785, -0.6003282070159912, 0.6884514689445496, 0.07173614203929901, 0.09897034615278244, -0.18636243045330048, 0.6929844617843628, -0.29726114869117737, -0.0004881611675955355, 0.7450562119483948, -0.36931112408638, -0.020572271198034286, 0.5212751626968384, 0.04843577742576599, -0.3171998858451843, 0.4651576578617096, -0.3703727424144745, -0.62960284948349, -0.37944260239601135, -0.19313320517539978, 0.8130353093147278, 0.4691871106624603, 0.2000861018896103, 0.23578540980815887, -0.8341169953346252, -0.44131842255592346, 0.030287880450487137, 0.22202470898628235, 0.8023900389671326, -0.7422093749046326, 0.5754936337471008, 0.03330550342798233, -0.33517736196517944, 0.3183760643005371, -0.2384706288576126, -0.0690820962190628, 0.15811443328857422, 0.9417954683303833, 0.56456059217453, -0.7736859321594238, -0.8239734768867493, 0.33064544200897217, 1.0555635690689087, 0.7903099656105042, 1.2757160663604736, 0.34658920764923096, -0.518913984298706, -0.5384661555290222, -0.41708847880363464, -0.18688218295574188, 0.05267999693751335, 0.23077957332134247, -1.1461117267608643, -0.44657066464424133, -0.42731431126594543, -0.5003558993339539, 0.455562949180603, 0.41595956683158875, 0.07354001700878143, -0.12506596744060516, 0.8802841305732727, 0.4273568391799927, 0.5215384364128113, 0.5580611228942871, 0.25528839230537415, -0.5067124962806702, -1.0582503080368042, 0.390620619058609, 0.5066468715667725, -0.06938900053501129, 0.27825507521629333, -0.41519874334335327, -0.28249725699424744, -0.4994213581085205, 0.354753702878952, 0.48488789796829224, -0.3913498818874359, -0.08678305149078369, -0.5245091915130615, 0.3650965988636017, -0.596953809261322, 0.015468635596334934, -0.21691173315048218, 0.7295172214508057, 0.30597957968711853, -1.2993810176849365, 0.3843238055706024, -0.3990537226200104, 0.36342504620552063, 0.4776487648487091, 0.015830839052796364, -0.9637300372123718, -0.23571328818798065, 0.0693739578127861, -0.6560578346252441, 0.30831873416900635, 0.5405489802360535, 0.3181658089160919, -0.2532353103160858, -1.0010581016540527, -0.2230023741722107, 0.6906338930130005, -0.32000499963760376, -0.00284905219450593, 0.3346298038959503, 0.04571814090013504, -0.445318341255188, 0.7132936716079712, 0.2127619981765747, -1.0234055519104004, -0.2751760184764862, -0.06113047152757645, -0.1039309874176979, -0.09445459395647049, -0.7707072496414185, -0.14460036158561707, 0.054658081382513046, -0.538067102432251, 0.3428228199481964, -0.03099690191447735, 0.5484188795089722, 0.04441982880234718, 0.3305267095565796, -0.12115244567394257, -0.6211799383163452, 0.1514343023300171, 0.7010520100593567, 0.3701314628124237, 0.4508737325668335, 0.374223530292511, 0.1927950233221054, 0.321354478597641, 0.5781878232955933, -0.10856977105140686, 0.5801742672920227, -0.1089712381362915, -0.08167973160743713, -0.39438074827194214, -0.0721978098154068, -0.5004329681396484, -1.0923349857330322, 0.23884986340999603, -0.4637477397918701, 0.6525758504867554, 0.33722570538520813, -0.43431612849235535, -0.7065184116363525, -0.9789877533912659, -1.0017808675765991, 0.42085927724838257, 0.24193927645683289, -0.2163805514574051, 0.37681150436401367, -0.7025920152664185, 0.4021349847316742, 0.366835355758667, -0.21972650289535522, 0.012262010015547276, 0.9600924253463745, 0.7375867962837219, 0.2636054754257202, 0.6319302916526794, -0.3366568982601166, 0.07531682401895523, -0.3329605758190155, 0.544909656047821, -0.28915420174598694, -0.7804512977600098, -0.18087710440158844, -0.356979638338089, 0.1252097636461258, -0.7180776000022888, 0.21196453273296356, 0.1579180359840393, 0.45283207297325134, -0.07132476568222046, -0.3214912712574005, -0.47467657923698425, -0.9754700064659119, 1.0983660221099854, -0.030646931380033493, -1.429113507270813, -0.2814476191997528, 0.11810386925935745, -0.12955980002880096, 0.239893838763237, 0.39453333616256714, -0.6972091794013977, -0.18874499201774597, -0.3519012928009033, 0.25663405656814575, -0.9213137030601501, -0.12776415050029755, -0.489723265171051, -1.0015186071395874, 0.3813319206237793, 0.7011459469795227, 0.7844871282577515, -0.2982899248600006, -0.22181817889213562, -0.8926149010658264, -0.23657158017158508, -0.3726206123828888, -0.2707110345363617, -0.49930238723754883, 0.16670840978622437, -0.019741222262382507, 0.6347373723983765, -0.2889373302459717, -0.7433604598045349, 0.5220821499824524, -0.10564550757408142, 0.07533633708953857, 1.133794903755188, 0.2289121001958847, -0.43516671657562256, 0.3095703721046448, 0.10049775242805481, 0.4072262942790985, -0.20270614326000214, -0.9967827796936035, 0.7368517518043518, -1.4397510290145874, 0.9200571179389954, -0.3937339186668396, 0.25971493124961853, -0.19607879221439362, 0.10377401113510132, 0.9489535093307495, -1.0306336879730225, 0.32138949632644653, -0.49159300327301025, -0.24177326261997223, 0.6270278096199036, 0.25615498423576355, -0.9074740409851074, 0.0332142598927021, -0.785671591758728, -1.4823272228240967, 0.9808657765388489, -0.2151581346988678, -0.14049217104911804, -0.8805294632911682, -0.4165365993976593, 0.12344836443662643, 0.17268839478492737, 0.869136393070221, 0.6166189908981323, 0.38803428411483765, -0.050163641571998596, 0.385195791721344, -0.592425525188446, -0.3843710422515869, -0.23201154172420502, -0.1889646202325821, -0.41071173548698425, -0.17119109630584717, 0.0013063225196674466, -0.414882630109787, -0.9919552206993103, 0.026137342676520348, 0.19816358387470245, 0.5529167652130127, -0.5307161808013916, 0.7340511679649353, -0.5515560507774353, -0.3899509608745575, -0.45079466700553894, -0.27128148078918457, 0.2632265090942383, 0.4096968472003937, 0.23784729838371277, -0.02737283706665039, 0.11719351261854172, -0.022867299616336823, 0.8473411798477173, -1.0164488554000854, -0.2928851246833801, 0.4421486556529999, -1.2181075811386108, -0.6371005177497864, 0.26789340376853943, 0.627576470375061, -0.7105127573013306, -0.742347240447998, -0.35721638798713684, -0.2721269726753235, -0.2504730224609375, -0.3524545729160309, 0.4468367099761963, -0.4732586145401001, -0.45278021693229675, 0.34435492753982544, 0.6552658081054688, 0.19899629056453705, -0.230552539229393, 0.46158045530319214, -0.15847057104110718, -0.3811647891998291, 0.7463381886482239, 1.2191917896270752, 0.028162088245153427, -0.039951495826244354, -0.4432462155818939, 0.07875220477581024, -0.22673474252223969, -0.09250931441783905, 0.24590200185775757, 0.041820820420980453, 0.1433214247226715, 0.6234046816825867, 0.2580086588859558, 0.6169069409370422, -0.2784980237483978, 0.47065386176109314, -0.528338611125946, 0.14942878484725952, -1.1811039447784424, -0.4045563042163849, 0.23328876495361328, 0.17696735262870789, 1.1589090824127197, -0.012760927900671959, 0.37446749210357666, 0.3577157258987427, -0.21341077983379364, -0.4624495506286621, -1.3272119760513306, 0.3738037049770355, -1.7384182214736938, -0.3087693154811859, -0.7622127532958984, -0.1512441784143448, -0.2856701910495758, 0.07286858558654785, 0.3094257116317749, -0.1340639591217041, -0.5084161758422852, 0.027617530897259712, -0.32919809222221375, 0.10207555443048477, -0.009941915050148964, -0.6807406544685364, -0.6438949108123779, 0.10241033881902695, -0.40539827942848206, -0.5188287496566772, -0.018128443509340286, 0.011562616564333439, 0.20887024700641632, 0.688376247882843, -0.819945216178894, 0.46703001856803894, -0.5581672787666321, -0.8471226692199707, -0.10485944151878357, 0.24726861715316772, -0.9991021752357483, 0.17976514995098114, -0.7253015637397766, 0.26760435104370117, -0.1643056720495224, 0.1734427809715271, -0.15394622087478638, 0.3870023190975189, -0.88826984167099, -0.8227425813674927, -0.1731596738100052, 0.06648322194814682, 0.31596457958221436, -0.2536454200744629, 0.22458180785179138, -0.2022823840379715, -0.9425995349884033, 0.2343454360961914, -0.38109341263771057, 0.16768001019954681, -0.7208614349365234, 0.04636021703481674, 0.09830191731452942, 0.43877291679382324, -0.19097626209259033, 0.254574716091156, -0.12038551270961761, -0.2685791850090027, -0.5673093199729919, -0.2037978321313858, -0.4427017569541931, 0.5494022369384766, 0.28222352266311646, -0.7276225686073303, -0.6007197499275208, 0.6699697375297546, -0.49179697036743164, 0.0433528870344162, -0.22779172658920288, -0.261247843503952, -0.11239472031593323, 0.09748455882072449, -0.2265813797712326, 1.033134937286377, -0.01241863239556551, -1.4967858791351318, -0.5780664682388306, -0.4638734459877014, -0.7008744478225708, -0.3063177764415741, -1.2344523668289185, -0.064270980656147, 0.002829254139214754, -0.029239222407341003, -0.003583058249205351, 0.4045918881893158, -0.2126157134771347, 1.1326779127120972, 0.6089147925376892, 0.38388592004776, -0.004710737615823746, 0.02140704356133938, -0.28884685039520264, 0.25180211663246155, -1.083794116973877, -0.07517470419406891, -0.18874287605285645, 0.17693951725959778, -0.7813699245452881, -1.1010167598724365, 0.3241255581378937, 0.4621345102787018, -0.1669512242078781, 0.5721838474273682, -0.40175700187683105, 0.20574119687080383, 0.37122899293899536, -0.055988479405641556, 0.01260498259216547, 0.6904119253158569, -0.3379463851451874, 0.8042204976081848, -0.18434706330299377, -0.9200429916381836, 0.02538282796740532, 1.0609099864959717, 0.13314339518547058, 0.17359012365341187, -0.08133688569068909, 0.2580603361129761, 0.10444382578134537, -0.7033052444458008, 1.13359797000885, 0.2542354464530945, 0.9787073731422424, 0.21691973507404327, 0.39106154441833496, 0.1641560196876526, 0.4473610520362854, 0.4223743677139282, 0.3787901997566223, 0.6771860122680664, 0.7421880960464478, 0.371508926153183, -0.21206159889698029, 0.3714005947113037, 0.36260682344436646, -0.07275167852640152, 0.5828498005867004, 0.4222259819507599, -0.5905114412307739, 0.3182063102722168, 0.12731754779815674, -0.034897688776254654, -0.04211535304784775, 0.4277682900428772, -0.37430933117866516, -0.046268947422504425, -0.2513071894645691, 0.20484699308872223, -0.23843005299568176, -0.6795186400413513, -0.10420811176300049, 0.24688495695590973, 0.20091558992862701, 0.1663157045841217, -0.10417283326387405, 0.5790068507194519, 0.668025016784668, 0.05600247159600258, 0.3533918857574463, 0.3753868341445923, 0.41061830520629883, 0.3240508735179901, 0.7403843998908997, 0.45714071393013, 0.7901490330696106, 0.38345402479171753, 0.2110457867383957, -0.8806383609771729, 0.20158135890960693, 0.3895832598209381, -1.2227126359939575, -0.41068458557128906, -0.5053440928459167, 0.18076758086681366, -0.5914093255996704, -0.956078827381134, 0.7473768591880798, -0.4458840489387512, 0.49647948145866394, 1.0325217247009277, -0.44249725341796875, 0.31349799036979675, 0.7304331660270691, -0.07805250585079193, 0.4188593626022339, 0.80865877866745, 0.2527790665626526, -0.026509825140237808, 1.2145706415176392, 1.6622564792633057, -0.14705434441566467, 0.40235772728919983, -0.19267773628234863, -0.04677644744515419, 0.45613592863082886, 0.35565078258514404, -0.23845919966697693, 0.5998332500457764, -1.3716129064559937, -0.6613391041755676, 0.0818052589893341, -0.07985331118106842, -0.3840799927711487, -0.42496562004089355, 0.40187036991119385, 0.2855895161628723, -0.5073200464248657, -0.4492737948894501, 1.6786900758743286, 0.5416039824485779, -0.18379884958267212, -0.23612742125988007, 0.2918360233306885, -0.5644447803497314, -0.1674652099609375, -1.4639919996261597, 1.1734862327575684, 0.7565946578979492, -0.21679815649986267, -0.42951396107673645, -0.7301861047744751, -0.48604896664619446, -0.7305505871772766, -0.24378414452075958, -0.8797081708908081, 0.22939477860927582, 0.25387662649154663, 0.2900593876838684, 0.4058610200881958, -0.38262996077537537, 0.4604298770427704, 0.508398175239563, 0.51133131980896, -0.2298058718442917, 0.7460219860076904, 1.0723568201065063, 0.37291985750198364, -0.5592204928398132, 0.4212712347507477, 1.0618668794631958, -0.5359344482421875, 0.6285092234611511, 0.0702410340309143, 0.21501420438289642, -0.5607650876045227, -0.628414511680603, 0.6632238030433655, -0.09372209012508392, 0.4656127393245697, -0.995050311088562, -0.41884517669677734, -0.4631199538707733, -1.051669716835022, 0.04522845521569252, -0.9192572832107544, 0.25634440779685974, -0.35634297132492065, 0.3637372851371765, -0.6926624178886414, -0.3788934350013733, 3.93156099319458, 1.373850703239441, 1.2361561059951782, 0.15864980220794678, 1.382997989654541, 0.2876143157482147, 0.13519831001758575, 0.1829683929681778, 0.3283306658267975, -0.6737791895866394, 0.08776743710041046, 0.5412622690200806, 0.48710396885871887, -0.5047975182533264, 0.3104899525642395, 0.3603493869304657, 0.13643604516983032, 0.31774523854255676, 0.09811097383499146, -1.227272868156433, -0.47232112288475037, -0.07011688500642776, 0.26800164580345154, -0.08140415698289871, 0.3852875232696533, -0.17841078341007233, -0.04029829800128937, -0.8164770603179932, -0.31521010398864746, -0.2593807578086853, -0.24531902372837067, -0.5764313340187073, 0.20333914458751678, -0.21022513508796692, -0.4183697998523712, 0.1395878791809082, -0.4119429588317871, -0.40284615755081177, -0.07049312442541122, -0.17602942883968353, -0.37657466530799866, -0.3233654499053955, 0.15439437329769135, 0.0674385279417038, -0.576425313949585, 0.7540772557258606, 0.03246285393834114, 0.7227097153663635, 0.451048880815506, -0.6065273284912109, 0.06536846607923508, -0.7672396898269653, 0.458914190530777, -0.36949044466018677, -0.8072614073753357, -0.33588698506355286, -1.0797373056411743, -0.6164560317993164, 0.6796116828918457, 0.8331508040428162, 0.30820250511169434, 0.08268754929304123, -0.4057256281375885, -0.23303578794002533, 0.1320292055606842, 0.10135398060083389, 0.43080657720565796, -0.1618274599313736, -0.14413036406040192, 0.4591003358364105, -0.037631187587976456, -0.09273961931467056, 0.01031582336872816, 0.7938274145126343, 0.17332488298416138, -0.24868781864643097, -0.702751874923706, 0.41939979791641235, 0.19081458449363708, 0.09681717306375504, -0.5531908273696899, -0.6134705543518066, -0.3541673719882965, -0.24128887057304382, 0.029353804886341095, 0.6430271863937378, -0.2718675434589386, 0.2777111828327179, -0.4684862792491913, 0.7431356310844421, 0.4766659438610077, 0.7382946610450745, 0.20811708271503448, -0.06322687119245529, -0.8666250109672546 ]
Dynamic Critical Behaviour of Wolff's Algorithm for $RP^N$ $\sigma$-Models
We study the performance of a Wolff-type embedding algorithm for $RP^N$ $\sigma$-models. We find that the algorithm in which we update the embedded Ising model \`a la Swendsen-Wang has critical slowing-down as $z_\chi \approx 1$. If instead we update the Ising spins with a perfect algorithm which at every iteration produces a new independent configuration, we obtain $z_\chi \approx 0$. This shows that the Ising embedding encodes well the collective modes of the system, and that the behaviour of the first algorithm is connected to the poor performance of the Swendsen-Wang algorithm in dealing with a frustrated Ising model.
S. Caracciolo, R.G. Edwards, A. Pelissetto, and A.D. Sokal
hep-lat
January
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9201003
hep-lat/9201004
[ 0.41783320903778076, -0.09106489270925522, -0.39112889766693115, 0.6367262005805969, -0.15683041512966156, 0.1442650556564331, 0.2720094323158264, -0.4310982823371887, -0.7307789325714111, 0.8918697834014893, 0.6994553804397583, -0.7156110405921936, -0.0917973592877388, -0.549574613571167, -0.07194316387176514, 0.3741253912448883, 0.07068727165460587, -0.5533952713012695, -1.1433014869689941, 0.5158971548080444, 0.22206059098243713, -0.46111077070236206, -1.1351642608642578, 0.17345352470874786, -0.9243024587631226, 0.5773279070854187, 0.11230292916297913, -0.0818370133638382, 0.7015449404716492, 0.39588114619255066, 0.440779447555542, -0.42143183946609497, -0.17610697448253632, -0.011968672275543213, 0.0518052913248539, -0.5800773501396179, -0.644077718257904, -0.044686540961265564, 0.7115135788917542, -0.3049646317958832, 0.7340782284736633, -0.41903889179229736, 0.5368890166282654, -0.4011930823326111, -0.7848144173622131, -0.06672324240207672, -0.28844690322875977, -0.029835540801286697, 0.32088199257850647, -0.8433414697647095, -0.2603406012058258, 0.5828157663345337, -0.11123359948396683, -0.808128297328949, 0.05335145443677902, 0.33020859956741333, 0.033360544592142105, -0.3197906017303467, -1.447892665863037, -0.42223283648490906, 0.9845273494720459, 0.2282351553440094, 0.5280713438987732, -0.8245847821235657, 0.04860701784491539, 1.3709763288497925, 0.10624779015779495, 0.3497503399848938, 0.4173710346221924, -0.16659961640834808, -0.02425253763794899, -0.3377724587917328, -0.61116623878479, 0.07188891619443893, -1.009734869003296, 0.502436101436615, 0.2449234277009964, -0.20780551433563232, -0.41692182421684265, -0.018131166696548462, 0.032173968851566315, 0.24927948415279388, -1.060384750366211, 0.296965092420578, -0.6271476745605469, -0.2601792812347412, 0.08020101487636566, -0.6246379017829895, -0.5763509273529053, 0.3956587612628937, -0.8952515125274658, 0.9179490208625793, -0.5178435444831848, 1.0333468914031982, 0.39824947714805603, 0.5189263820648193, -0.4715038537979126, 0.24032510817050934, 0.2877887189388275, 0.24788393080234528, -0.643844723701477, 0.4656132161617279, -0.9639845490455627, 0.16532352566719055, -0.5168909430503845, 0.7491014003753662, -0.4028557538986206, 0.4150950610637665, -0.1253742128610611, -1.0321574211120605, 1.2112492322921753, -0.11470907926559448, 0.206608846783638, 0.38142773509025574, 0.26050204038619995, 0.5128975510597229, -0.5632081627845764, 0.44610899686813354, -0.5586209297180176, -0.17357560992240906, -0.24946370720863342, 0.30004554986953735, 0.15424731373786926, 0.42329931259155273, -0.1787146031856537, -0.12987813353538513, 0.2837624251842499, 0.38032224774360657, -1.0299842357635498, -0.16868525743484497, -0.33304262161254883, -0.43288466334342957, -0.38277557492256165, 0.9745444059371948, 0.19099169969558716, 0.3067285716533661, -0.2417406439781189, 0.6223345398902893, 0.341557115316391, -0.3048892319202423, 0.723674476146698, -0.5413154363632202, -0.09693539142608643, 1.2739874124526978, -0.5767319202423096, 0.06468728184700012, 0.026394560933113098, 0.31038594245910645, -0.04973962530493736, 0.3477860391139984, -0.3472253084182739, 0.03581724315881729, -0.20636042952537537, 0.35741496086120605, -0.00022840510064270347, 0.1291961818933487, -1.124316930770874, -0.5280876159667969, -0.1673973649740219, -0.5704752206802368, 0.3619142770767212, 0.8030442595481873, -0.44415193796157837, 0.5370302796363831, -0.4470449686050415, 0.29840123653411865, -0.4517352879047394, 0.15355712175369263, 0.38856321573257446, -0.445046603679657, -0.28956103324890137, 0.49800002574920654, -0.17102853953838348, 0.3163447380065918, 0.3137279748916626, 0.016653524711728096, 1.076024055480957, -1.2913010120391846, 0.028750907629728317, 0.11698992550373077, -0.13840234279632568, 0.24056603014469147, 0.5620311498641968, -0.18142253160476685, -0.3787806034088135, -0.3503851890563965, 0.3671919107437134, -0.08974062651395798, 0.21792981028556824, -0.12142454832792282, -0.4570046663284302, 0.22825594246387482, -0.43213483691215515, 0.2617061734199524, -0.6077709197998047, -0.23112881183624268, -1.1794570684432983, -0.14380131661891937, -0.4222467839717865, -0.565951943397522, 0.34364429116249084, 0.5401349067687988, -0.30080631375312805, 1.2236483097076416, -1.0635701417922974, -0.11281408369541168, 1.0948110818862915, -0.05338966101408005, -0.6032471060752869, -0.10044188797473907, 0.655610978603363, -0.2906113862991333, 0.2984774112701416, -0.44626474380493164, -0.11380711197853088, 0.1408413201570511, -0.12511169910430908, 0.23982790112495422, 0.11407920718193054, 0.6607092618942261, 0.11331785470247269, -0.14985895156860352, 0.0015883235028013587, 0.9108850955963135, 0.5146660804748535, -0.06432335078716278, 0.2934321463108063, 0.20675776898860931, -0.23907501995563507, -0.21099475026130676, -0.41096270084381104, -0.05314658209681511, 0.1762637197971344, -0.2550674080848694, 0.1118611991405487, -0.1246466189622879, 0.45723864436149597, 0.6431041359901428, -0.22261367738246918, 0.6173134446144104, 0.16714902222156525, -0.2793325185775757, -0.23197275400161743, -0.5158655047416687, -0.9955042004585266, -0.2081100195646286, 0.325727254152298, -0.007330457679927349, -0.5572788715362549, 1.0085688829421997, 0.25159120559692383, -0.007597960531711578, 0.10874764621257782, 1.1906174421310425, -1.3304029703140259, -0.13610388338565826, -0.41958561539649963, -0.031225550919771194, -0.22518330812454224, -0.0689663365483284, 0.33609893918037415, 0.1758839339017868, -0.09682033210992813, -0.5973680019378662, -0.22794455289840698, 0.9729559421539307, -0.6891762614250183, 0.2710975408554077, 1.3307721614837646, -0.09718623757362366, -0.6166371703147888, 0.06779198348522186, -0.6372215747833252, 0.2042061984539032, -0.6882566809654236, 0.01282556913793087, -0.21355493366718292, -0.7187719345092773, 0.2659943997859955, 0.12509047985076904, -0.3918156325817108, 0.3181148171424866, 0.1118977889418602, -0.0858311802148819, 0.24264293909072876, 0.6746907830238342, -0.6916059255599976, 0.5659980773925781, -0.44491609930992126, 0.4054171144962311, 0.18071292340755463, -0.2966609597206116, 0.5576996207237244, -0.0053975265473127365, 0.33430829644203186, 0.7829699516296387, -0.8394606113433838, -0.0008737784228287637, 0.24904373288154602, -0.6470246315002441, 0.2336243987083435, -0.24809415638446808, 0.5968829393386841, 0.3851860761642456, -1.0204375982284546, 0.02145451307296753, 0.2680460214614868, -0.058825962245464325, 0.25635209679603577, 0.5357962250709534, -0.5685574412345886, 0.13048067688941956, -0.25659748911857605, 0.22086907923221588, -0.2107393443584442, 0.6369081139564514, 0.24527525901794434, -0.09916675090789795, -0.024704812094569206, -0.38916370272636414, 0.02544455975294113, 0.2201652079820633, -0.561389148235321, -0.3551653325557709, 0.07719330489635468, 0.9239383935928345, 0.24388502538204193, -0.2921196222305298, 0.56891268491745, -0.9224140644073486, -0.8350776433944702, 0.1321195363998413, -0.7940065860748291, 0.03118530660867691, -0.0941242128610611, 0.3660341501235962, -0.36186277866363525, 0.13213616609573364, -0.8238171935081482, -0.10985643416643143, 0.6385713219642639, -0.4557000398635864, 0.36849892139434814, 0.9523965716362, 0.20444217324256897, 0.015065362676978111, 0.5510097146034241, -0.111440509557724, -0.9199751019477844, 0.45124906301498413, 0.2362784743309021, 0.7716219425201416, 0.31904327869415283, 0.6760183572769165, -0.16905754804611206, -0.09996592998504639, 0.1978517770767212, -0.34829777479171753, -0.3819673955440521, -0.32447195053100586, 0.23728448152542114, 0.14500972628593445, -0.12244999408721924, -0.09421682357788086, -0.40290310978889465, 0.3235243558883667, 0.28254878520965576, -0.06773471087217331, 0.33353981375694275, -0.5224253535270691, -0.039597202092409134, 0.17237435281276703, -0.6862644553184509, 0.7139666080474854, 0.5348789691925049, 0.4462965428829193, 0.9243229627609253, 0.5554125905036926, 0.3601895868778229, -0.4914400279521942, 0.3204737603664398, 0.0017672748072072864, 0.3332539498806, 0.16143256425857544, 0.8105675578117371, 0.3834131360054016, -0.1918841153383255, 0.015368572436273098, -0.7403256893157959, -0.09742891043424606, -0.38423165678977966, -0.9825177192687988, 0.7028857469558716, -0.053600698709487915, 0.076598159968853, -0.38539862632751465, -0.09421389549970627, 0.7653176188468933, 0.25233253836631775, -0.12036095559597015, 0.46047309041023254, -0.3480485677719116, 0.09639286994934082, 0.2919726073741913, 0.5944185853004456, 0.6490110754966736, -0.9203670620918274, 0.6737667918205261, -0.1296081691980362, 0.3844653367996216, 0.046379268169403076, -0.5354540348052979, -0.029149550944566727, -0.9604007005691528, 0.6751759052276611, 0.11841610819101334, -0.0980057492852211, 0.10313227027654648, 0.12011057138442993, 0.5096406936645508, 0.056091152131557465, 0.787399172782898, -0.1776956170797348, 0.20556806027889252, 0.26129475235939026, -1.2504756450653076, 0.32769864797592163, -1.0081778764724731, 0.1710861474275589, 0.7979698777198792, -0.0217643640935421, -0.6700575351715088, -0.8821494579315186, 0.3222227394580841, 0.0034829042851924896, 0.36922192573547363, 1.1160540580749512, 0.28232717514038086, -0.14423194527626038, -1.2295629978179932, -0.019272122532129288, 0.7651414275169373, -0.02800116501748562, -0.9335711002349854, 0.8778120279312134, 0.13843730092048645, 0.147750124335289, 0.596804678440094, -0.31221216917037964, -0.6236873865127563, 0.06654700636863708, -0.9954339265823364, 0.9461554288864136, -0.6266746520996094, -0.5771926641464233, -0.23795540630817413, -0.06428063660860062, -0.502324640750885, 0.6047195196151733, -0.07661648094654083, -0.6579160690307617, -0.38542795181274414, 0.10038726776838303, -0.6424092650413513, -0.7025325894355774, 0.4041237235069275, -0.19900770485401154, 0.9399762749671936, 0.9921731352806091, 0.4028033912181854, 0.17862725257873535, 0.4061342179775238, 0.13253198564052582, -0.23915652930736542, 0.3093509376049042, -0.08936168253421783, -0.2838490903377533, -0.5900155305862427, -0.20045822858810425, -0.8406493663787842, -0.2019742727279663, -0.13270892202854156, 0.6024417877197266, 0.5282663702964783, 0.27137991786003113, -0.6622060537338257, -0.6993394494056702, 0.07214882224798203, -0.5179153084754944, 0.8278165459632874, 0.4216342568397522, 0.04704661667346954, 0.7077963352203369, -0.1968294084072113, 0.5645353198051453, -0.5088809728622437, -0.4189789295196533, -0.15998239815235138, 0.6660570502281189, 1.0183478593826294, 0.930266797542572, -0.3592086434364319, -0.8378512859344482, 0.7150905728340149, -0.18184912204742432, -0.6536406874656677, -0.4610757529735565, -0.7220069766044617, 0.07404342293739319, 0.23074424266815186, 0.5329622626304626, 0.012109554372727871, -0.23665891587734222, -0.01876712590456009, -0.5425412058830261, -0.2909165322780609, 0.3634798228740692, -0.4697778820991516, 0.3902157247066498, 0.3500291109085083, 0.7357776761054993, -0.7895159721374512, 0.25950777530670166, -0.024434033781290054, 0.253301203250885, 0.009578080847859383, -0.05599450320005417, -0.3604933023452759, 0.26415058970451355, -0.7433234453201294, -0.07059477269649506, -0.2544001042842865, -0.4579508900642395, -0.2311103194952011, -0.6329834461212158, -0.04016890004277229, 0.5032436847686768, 0.8068928718566895, 0.4967358410358429, -0.3122803270816803, -0.18900856375694275, 0.7620970606803894, -0.609813928604126, -0.5098335146903992, -0.4887155294418335, -0.37821123003959656, 0.18025188148021698, 0.9869072437286377, -0.48624199628829956, -0.21476434171199799, -0.530717670917511, -0.29119712114334106, -0.19053855538368225, 0.5275708436965942, 0.5467644333839417, -0.08078796416521072, 0.1903698444366455, -0.029750695452094078, 0.2246396541595459, 0.5130887627601624, -0.60544753074646, 0.8894335031509399, -0.2505479156970978, 0.4790821075439453, -0.7814180254936218, -0.2646542489528656, 0.07975362241268158, -0.3313634693622589, 0.5516175627708435, 0.2062588930130005, 0.7233614921569824, 1.3760672807693481, -0.212772399187088, 0.28350263833999634, 0.018794551491737366, -0.6293379664421082, 0.2886797785758972, -0.5964358448982239, -0.469031423330307, 0.9763175845146179, -0.08599875122308731, -0.162587508559227, -0.22083158791065216, -1.2106544971466064, -0.16416744887828827, 0.34843480587005615, 0.1885705590248108, 0.653880774974823, 0.27046436071395874, -0.01891198754310608, 0.2804105877876282, 0.17230689525604248, -0.792353093624115, 0.0002732526045292616, -0.15613697469234467, -0.23533788323402405, 0.3094783127307892, -0.04142517223954201, -0.7511657476425171, -0.8482215404510498, -0.25310686230659485, 0.40876147150993347, 0.3597671091556549, 0.012591336853802204, 0.9957581162452698, -0.8581445813179016, -0.6020147800445557, -0.41360193490982056, 0.7059565186500549, 0.17256224155426025, 0.377566933631897, 0.642005205154419, 0.34343379735946655, -0.08053389936685562, 0.13097171485424042, -0.12718626856803894, -0.4064846336841583, -0.9480084180831909, 0.6563484072685242, -0.8050053119659424, -0.07744204252958298, 0.6857278943061829, 0.8072148561477661, -0.5467137694358826, 0.25016850233078003, -1.1228796243667603, -0.4544338583946228, -0.34201478958129883, 0.15050281584262848, -0.6499412655830383, -0.35908859968185425, 0.011807895265519619, 0.28051891922950745, 0.34497734904289246, 0.6134917140007019, 0.13772368431091309, -0.345663458108902, 0.5191353559494019, -0.33834749460220337, 0.31201067566871643, 1.0121954679489136, -0.3263425827026367, -1.068115234375, 0.25743091106414795, 0.4984859526157379, -0.21416425704956055, -0.6235942840576172, 0.5945625901222229, -0.7111881971359253, 0.17123174667358398, 0.230966717004776, 0.09533802419900894, 0.00441057700663805, 0.26486513018608093, 0.14385730028152466, 1.1400059461593628, -0.6876845359802246, -0.3135724365711212, 0.055824439972639084, 0.4821595847606659, 0.008607177995145321, 0.31044748425483704, 0.2805917263031006, 0.2705765962600708, 0.28173866868019104, -0.2981553077697754, 0.27972865104675293, -0.1848982572555542, 0.4065828323364258, -0.5260629057884216, 0.150965616106987, -1.052120327949524, -0.09802455455064774, 0.33446383476257324, 0.8510411977767944, -0.3851086497306824, -0.24365843832492828, 0.22625991702079773, 0.6691683530807495, -0.31432947516441345, -0.1644829660654068, 0.34959983825683594, -0.9723775386810303, 0.3613012135028839, -0.5343126654624939, -0.5754261016845703, -1.3084830045700073, -0.14083077013492584, 0.07849537581205368, -0.38621586561203003, 1.0921846628189087, -0.07592341303825378, 0.2937392592430115, -0.8071452379226685, -0.19728706777095795, -0.22150687873363495, -0.2565014362335205, -0.261931836605072, 0.9926455020904541, -0.45031875371932983, 0.9483595490455627, 0.2995884418487549, -0.02897363342344761, -0.3999660015106201, 0.17757627367973328, -0.46424201130867004, 0.2766711413860321, -0.14146211743354797, 0.2815251052379608, -0.049231238663196564, -0.8270511031150818, -0.08880988508462906, 0.021969832479953766, -0.5240726470947266, 0.013114097528159618, -0.9714087247848511, 0.3800755441188812, -0.33936062455177307, -0.11016977578401566, 0.4895859360694885, 0.16858726739883423, 0.3063959777355194, 0.7002264261245728, -0.12028469890356064, 0.25093966722488403, 0.2641904056072235, 0.33064863085746765, -0.13488560914993286, -0.04507576301693916, 0.16974078118801117, -0.8199893236160278, 0.034437403082847595, 0.8517494797706604, 0.07626635581254959, -0.6131764650344849, 0.0025974903255701065, 0.06813088804483414, 0.6286048889160156, 0.05510779470205307, -0.23920655250549316, 0.4722024202346802, 0.4350617527961731, -0.08731606602668762, -0.588081955909729, -1.0552911758422852, -1.2783910036087036, 0.7449548840522766, -0.4958701729774475, -0.8261805772781372, -0.12936361134052277, 0.10028177499771118, 0.3493565320968628, 1.1314234733581543, -0.3293522298336029, 0.2521028220653534, 0.137344092130661, -0.3736366331577301, 1.2088168859481812, 0.3046247363090515, -0.3197084069252014, 0.4800402522087097, -0.6991114020347595, -0.37691202759742737, -0.851157546043396, 1.023873209953308, -1.016085147857666, -1.0946141481399536, -0.793792188167572, 0.8907369375228882, 0.02845810167491436, 0.2054378092288971, -0.30451998114585876, -0.6670241951942444, -0.11948712170124054, -0.37566429376602173, -1.0057183504104614, -0.5176360607147217, -0.33532652258872986, 0.48413461446762085, -0.19748026132583618, -0.5039423108100891, 0.605369508266449, -0.3832225203514099, 0.3381778299808502, -0.11163116246461868, 0.29345062375068665, 0.8622452020645142, 0.6690182089805603, 0.05495236814022064, 0.2120644450187683, 0.33349910378456116, 0.4575488865375519, 0.38583052158355713, -0.37952253222465515, 0.41135627031326294, 0.7115893959999084, -0.40096208453178406, 0.4392648935317993, 0.316032737493515, -0.2308875322341919, 0.6471773982048035, -0.2101517915725708, -0.23656490445137024, -0.211217999458313, 0.05491184443235397, -0.3427322804927826, 0.11483640968799591, -0.4552757143974304, -0.27856993675231934, -0.8189767003059387, -0.040923092514276505, 0.9791638255119324, -0.21059639751911163, -0.22208404541015625, -0.32187408208847046, 0.003252849681302905, 0.032166995108127594, -1.3748441934585571, -0.49100491404533386, -0.31683653593063354, 0.33492323756217957, 0.880790650844574, 0.10466257482767105, -0.1749362051486969, 0.7925370931625366, 0.6756471991539001, -0.27113038301467896, -0.3178264796733856, 0.6341925859451294, 0.1809418946504593, 1.32601797580719, 0.9218278527259827, 0.41687947511672974, 0.23696736991405487, 0.1446218639612198, -0.19956454634666443, -0.9561351537704468, 0.43017759919166565, 0.23046515882015228, -0.4244380593299866, 0.4012976288795471, -0.2740057408809662, -0.5047288537025452, -1.0098623037338257, -0.6202688217163086, 0.047243405133485794, -1.1286131143569946, -0.1486901193857193, 0.5291226506233215, -0.5583957433700562, 0.6267083287239075, 0.6214614510536194, 0.6582534909248352, 0.6735562682151794, 0.5154712796211243, 0.0023699947632849216, -0.06363439559936523, 0.913727343082428, 0.962668240070343, 0.4039328098297119, -0.3105808198451996, -0.08080583810806274, -1.030065894126892, 0.5712877511978149, 0.48978081345558167, -0.3695802688598633, 0.3633406460285187, 0.3681415319442749, -0.9313058853149414, 0.07029889523983002, -0.4516851603984833, -0.2930395305156708, -0.7597317695617676, 0.688085675239563, 0.051561761647462845, -0.03632744029164314, -0.9431407451629639, 1.3685710430145264, 0.3083858788013458, -0.6029150485992432, -0.4707943797111511, 0.547541618347168, -0.17474862933158875, -0.7634502649307251, -1.1030536890029907, 0.04332149773836136, 0.06503105908632278, 0.13260053098201752, 0.01692362315952778, -0.5272912979125977, -0.6804643273353577, -0.4341948330402374, 0.25606298446655273, -0.5914287567138672, 0.3369729518890381, -0.06935489922761917, 0.0018966271309182048, 0.33060985803604126, -0.3736560046672821, 0.5429699420928955, 0.40536266565322876, 0.6753591895103455, -0.6220424175262451, -0.1778818666934967, 0.060768742114305496, 0.36635541915893555, -0.8033636212348938, 0.4069743752479553, 0.7227094173431396, -0.8859124183654785, -0.04610724747180939, -0.6229459643363953, 0.7007297873497009, 0.04142690449953079, 0.11668235063552856, 0.3256228566169739, 0.3411724269390106, 0.09638705104589462, -0.594262957572937, -0.676464319229126, -0.6821429133415222, -1.0830527544021606, -0.48019057512283325, -0.18258710205554962, 0.35851210355758667, -0.2970167398452759, 0.43835321068763733, 0.06618191301822662, -1.2641772031784058, 4.079382419586182, 0.3422026038169861, 0.47591185569763184, 0.18119186162948608, 0.8776595592498779, 0.9498503804206848, -0.6589158773422241, -0.4380047023296356, 0.39406076073646545, 0.00150450156070292, -0.4546473026275635, 0.051898498088121414, 0.08048632740974426, 0.0881163626909256, 0.08975216001272202, 0.5864819288253784, -0.44377368688583374, -0.6972559690475464, 0.42195555567741394, -1.6133278608322144, -0.6745835542678833, -0.17994266748428345, 0.35482874512672424, 0.035531070083379745, 0.4539179503917694, 0.1661006063222885, 0.241591215133667, -0.29076138138771057, -0.051710400730371475, -0.9267898797988892, 0.13743902742862701, -1.0020805597305298, 0.29723861813545227, 0.25064176321029663, -1.2827339172363281, 0.7034626603126526, 0.02865365520119667, 0.41299968957901, 0.2836166024208069, -0.6410956382751465, -0.019287724047899246, -0.6302343606948853, 0.15673565864562988, 0.09047413617372513, 0.13107813894748688, 0.6175287365913391, -0.04250028729438782, 0.553418755531311, -0.11989684402942657, -1.0183261632919312, 0.8079426884651184, 0.21459321677684784, 0.7798788547515869, -0.09348800033330917, -1.2652498483657837, -0.2597568929195404, -0.8476265668869019, 0.0874519944190979, 0.3136134743690491, -0.18244826793670654, 0.253742516040802, -0.4472222626209259, -0.1917804777622223, 0.26410380005836487, -0.1942806839942932, -0.0009506127680651844, -0.09132950007915497, 0.5883336663246155, -0.16555096209049225, -0.07098868489265442, -0.250279039144516, 0.39074844121932983, -0.24587993323802948, 0.09666450321674347, -0.2831668257713318, 0.041701290756464005, -0.6093277931213379, 0.4042400121688843, -0.468685507774353, 0.5824168920516968, 0.1452246606349945, 0.014951652847230434, -0.07499458640813828, 0.564561128616333, 0.03440913185477257, 0.90461266040802, -0.5274431705474854, 0.4388394355773926, -0.30664584040641785, 0.3560448884963989, -0.1072976291179657, 0.7978532910346985, -0.09179962426424026, 0.6723847389221191, -0.33949965238571167 ]
How to Put a Heavier Higgs on the Lattice
The cutoff dependence of the Scalar Sector of the Minimal Standard Model can result in an increase of the existing triviality bound estimates of the Higgs mass. We present a large $N$ calculation and some preliminary N=4 results that suggest that the increase can be as large as 30%, resulting to a bound of about 850 G eV.
U.M. Heller, M. Klomfass, H. Neuberger, and P. Vranas
hep-lat
January
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9201004
hep-lat/9201005
[ 0.020151400938630104, -0.34155845642089844, 0.2245214432477951, 0.12386614829301834, -0.7450282573699951, -0.0964142307639122, -0.1859254240989685, -0.6049887537956238, -0.26185721158981323, 0.9006120562553406, 0.11634760349988937, -0.1933135837316513, 0.17649906873703003, -0.5073451399803162, 0.017818743363022804, 0.19074510037899017, -0.11022282391786575, -0.8233358263969421, -1.6536734104156494, 0.5678370594978333, 0.389658659696579, -0.17444433271884918, -1.3272819519042969, -0.19697357714176178, -0.21783098578453064, 0.6301916837692261, 0.32529884576797485, 0.17158399522304535, 0.8675872087478638, 0.28024187684059143, 0.5849321484565735, -0.41848689317703247, 0.2817446291446686, -0.8150196075439453, -0.26052823662757874, 0.015988871455192566, 0.18658441305160522, -0.014081551693379879, 0.8877931237220764, -0.26042911410331726, 0.6958786845207214, -0.5822514891624451, -0.37273305654525757, -0.32648465037345886, 0.0013427541125565767, -0.8513135313987732, -0.3823687434196472, -0.838875949382782, 0.27689918875694275, -0.8473367094993591, 0.42445066571235657, 0.008268633857369423, 0.7400720119476318, -0.7116904854774475, -0.6559535264968872, -0.1953079253435135, -0.009508686140179634, -0.10551896691322327, -0.40351104736328125, -0.10241411626338959, 0.5338684320449829, -0.21609431505203247, 0.4780181348323822, -0.8619018793106079, -0.23073548078536987, 0.674197793006897, -0.6105608344078064, 0.40000200271606445, -0.3056826889514923, -0.3237904906272888, 0.12554997205734253, -0.17355656623840332, -0.9394077062606812, -0.17043159902095795, -1.1761702299118042, 0.13827690482139587, 0.5301845669746399, -0.4367874264717102, -1.0264191627502441, -0.3459939658641815, -0.41729679703712463, -0.019307924434542656, -0.11220478266477585, 0.07390821725130081, -0.4731416404247284, -0.37428054213523865, -0.029261445626616478, -0.10306768864393234, 0.261824369430542, 0.3603684902191162, 0.5321350693702698, 1.0184239149093628, -0.6062811017036438, -0.36710324883461, 0.08525089174509048, 0.40937989950180054, 0.11754141002893448, 0.3169596791267395, -0.07504428178071976, 0.23423989117145538, -0.42212948203086853, 0.09723073244094849, -1.1674251556396484, 0.7289390563964844, -0.579086422920227, 0.741249680519104, -0.030204225331544876, -0.3853958547115326, 0.20175914466381073, -0.7545734643936157, 0.47649744153022766, -0.4799449145793915, 0.02053038962185383, 0.5982200503349304, 0.2318800687789917, 0.36237820982933044, -0.46177420020103455, 0.5981879234313965, -0.17409557104110718, -0.2047559767961502, 0.6000229120254517, 0.055955756455659866, 0.6948400735855103, 0.11844188719987869, -0.08429974317550659, 0.07878603041172028, 0.04097301885485649, 0.16362442076206207, -0.811154305934906, 0.25279828906059265, 0.012274173088371754, -0.39516517519950867, -0.5487077236175537, 0.7366011142730713, -0.7353852987289429, 0.1349930614233017, -0.20636554062366486, 0.7891306281089783, -0.04750601202249527, -0.675286054611206, 0.5614559650421143, -0.27041101455688477, -0.04413287341594696, 1.0709788799285889, 0.06198586896061897, 0.5083716511726379, 0.021132782101631165, 0.4367944896221161, -0.28753218054771423, 0.4691522717475891, -0.7024878859519958, -0.3996630311012268, -0.4442523419857025, 0.44082552194595337, -0.4451673924922943, 0.5521885752677917, 0.1440729945898056, 0.33274000883102417, -0.5621510148048401, -0.22766222059726715, -0.17827068269252777, -0.5016915202140808, -0.016903692856431007, -0.18562984466552734, -0.8850352168083191, -0.2555146813392639, -0.23669368028640747, -0.2751850187778473, 0.1437484174966812, -0.5716030597686768, 0.05449104309082031, 0.025098875164985657, -0.34670600295066833, 0.7929564118385315, 0.04862910509109497, 0.441589891910553, 0.2704452574253082, -0.14067381620407104, 0.22808101773262024, 0.33190006017684937, -0.4428249001502991, -0.009677828289568424, 0.31666311621665955, -0.20396487414836884, 0.37564748525619507, -0.1970023661851883, -0.12673959136009216, -0.36696451902389526, 0.03948647528886795, 0.36227333545684814, -0.4279463589191437, 0.32628071308135986, -0.2917659878730774, 0.5390681624412537, -0.1827998161315918, -0.23928168416023254, -0.773553192615509, -0.18414948880672455, -0.5239595770835876, -0.5003836750984192, -0.25978943705558777, -0.22336792945861816, -0.31670382618904114, -0.08700232952833176, -0.9968705773353577, 0.17887955904006958, 0.8861548900604248, 0.30200403928756714, -0.7803087830543518, -0.1795983910560608, -0.042259007692337036, -0.10300863534212112, 0.012328418903052807, -0.2945323586463928, 0.5172025561332703, 0.2815506160259247, 0.116504967212677, 0.6793267130851746, 0.4364815652370453, 0.7367691993713379, 0.35897770524024963, 0.3772624433040619, 0.35463961958885193, 0.9613856673240662, -0.9150310754776001, -0.17488642036914825, 0.09949005395174026, 0.44872552156448364, 0.5415209531784058, -0.46703022718429565, -0.06212625652551651, 0.3384552299976349, -0.31254664063453674, 0.7387909293174744, 0.28230804204940796, -0.07839278131723404, 0.458789587020874, 0.30114084482192993, 0.27669838070869446, 0.3769039213657379, -0.30591151118278503, -0.7957344651222229, -0.012940311804413795, -0.09363558888435364, 0.1351383477449417, 0.5245838761329651, -0.3981667160987854, -0.3747267723083496, -0.03869601711630821, 0.11365557461977005, -0.18577590584754944, 0.6136235594749451, 0.5588223934173584, 0.060448355972766876, -0.6486015319824219, -0.24834172427654266, 0.2151518017053604, 0.3173297643661499, -0.34132352471351624, -0.17840559780597687, 0.39133697748184204, 0.15439186990261078, -0.29068809747695923, -0.19226635992527008, 0.21412904560565948, 1.4283586740493774, 0.0043504685163497925, 0.38629278540611267, 0.6095906496047974, 0.06821131706237793, -0.696223795413971, -0.26701533794403076, -0.8073194622993469, 0.04987131059169769, -0.3709045946598053, 0.4287914037704468, 0.8009265065193176, -0.7127535343170166, 0.3794538974761963, -0.1091514527797699, -0.11243358999490738, 0.2885150909423828, -0.3129878044128418, 0.23622281849384308, 0.005832793191075325, 0.026214923709630966, -0.08438315987586975, 0.8997170329093933, -0.6462099552154541, -0.2301274538040161, -0.29435595870018005, 0.48122140765190125, 0.7049972414970398, -0.5329646468162537, 0.6309784054756165, -0.7683352828025818, -0.5396818518638611, -0.11966283619403839, 0.6176089644432068, -0.3831522464752197, 0.07226983457803726, 0.5419654250144958, -0.1098468154668808, -0.5539461970329285, -1.0591849088668823, 0.5837360620498657, 0.4232039153575897, -0.49182605743408203, -0.05884021520614624, 0.1264050006866455, -0.24533364176750183, 0.3718293309211731, 0.3607182204723358, -0.19726809859275818, -0.06642759591341019, 0.908632218837738, 0.5495930910110474, 0.17400963604450226, -0.2503528594970703, -0.45030340552330017, -0.3757531940937042, -0.08237922936677933, 0.06385213881731033, -0.07969807833433151, -0.7317482233047485, 0.5212197303771973, 0.0593816377222538, -0.6417992115020752, 0.04289896413683891, -0.5167592763900757, -0.8848446011543274, 0.46476003527641296, -0.31932303309440613, 0.8821045756340027, -0.5554126501083374, 0.03727102652192116, -0.8397830724716187, 0.02196817472577095, 1.0179917812347412, 0.30167874693870544, 0.3095961809158325, -0.14317212998867035, 0.35929757356643677, 0.3793865740299225, -0.00008603148307884112, -0.1416458636522293, -0.27433574199676514, -0.425855427980423, -1.3313292264938354, 0.2100602686405182, -0.8332189321517944, 0.48172706365585327, 0.1069425567984581, 0.4677679240703583, 0.5680619478225708, 0.9124491810798645, -0.6118874549865723, -0.7130324840545654, -0.3701983094215393, -0.25416994094848633, 0.6507483124732971, 0.5913709998130798, -0.1580505669116974, 0.059858981519937515, -0.2448531687259674, -0.3347035050392151, 0.4604215621948242, -0.4964703917503357, 0.016568537801504135, -0.40639397501945496, 0.5026682615280151, -0.517265260219574, -0.13772284984588623, 0.1255704015493393, 0.03865993767976761, 0.4498582184314728, 0.4448535144329071, 0.3392725884914398, 1.0276989936828613, -0.1427583247423172, -0.10799990594387054, 0.0017449529841542244, 0.4996308982372284, 0.37171733379364014, 0.38656529784202576, 0.4983358681201935, 0.16259554028511047, -0.024004902690649033, -0.1500719040632248, -0.6859047412872314, -0.5802121758460999, 0.3538980782032013, 0.4548097252845764, -0.0882449746131897, -0.19052502512931824, -0.2716560959815979, 0.8330977559089661, -0.15268217027187347, 0.697201132774353, 0.3302825093269348, 0.3841651976108551, 0.3569101095199585, 0.5843831896781921, 0.03214322030544281, 0.08067062497138977, 0.28183630108833313, -1.0137455463409424, -0.045676883310079575, 0.07511801272630692, 0.23310986161231995, -0.8847380876541138, -0.13038267195224762, -0.5155174136161804, -0.3862215280532837, 0.14740610122680664, 0.15118759870529175, -0.7486661672592163, 0.2894672751426697, -0.10448446124792099, 0.6846810579299927, -0.02142665907740593, 0.2462606132030487, 0.7126140594482422, 0.1336166262626648, 0.29537805914878845, -0.66706383228302, 0.49724358320236206, -0.6678001284599304, 0.3208986222743988, 0.8588212728500366, -0.9160017967224121, -0.42923468351364136, -0.9449260234832764, -0.285801500082016, -0.5349774360656738, -0.05675987899303436, 0.6755673885345459, 0.251655250787735, 0.3674044609069824, -0.42440488934516907, 0.06739602982997894, -0.15012842416763306, -0.12172237038612366, -0.4382812976837158, 0.6509451270103455, -0.032276809215545654, -0.16256433725357056, 0.5850512981414795, 0.46815240383148193, -0.8177509903907776, 0.5602075457572937, -0.8933076858520508, 0.19829265773296356, -0.6298338770866394, -0.6952161192893982, 0.20293360948562622, -0.5812273621559143, -0.6044977903366089, 0.3297690749168396, 0.3595890998840332, -0.03461051359772682, -0.5792531371116638, 0.17590318620204926, -0.07522337138652802, 0.4651661217212677, 0.5156040787696838, -0.6693825721740723, 0.9407131671905518, 0.7855033278465271, 0.5158738493919373, 0.3310740888118744, 0.46830829977989197, 0.10873687267303467, -0.15778608620166779, 0.14232778549194336, 0.08418802917003632, -0.2238328903913498, -0.666326105594635, -0.36207956075668335, -0.7353479266166687, -0.6247106194496155, 0.18475760519504547, -0.6093026399612427, 0.5768091082572937, -0.08455166220664978, -0.7312710285186768, -0.5841420888900757, -0.06912031769752502, -0.9039316773414612, 0.7437194585800171, 0.24859680235385895, -0.41463884711265564, 0.7399839758872986, 0.09046284854412079, -0.05479767546057701, -0.13756625354290009, -0.7172213792800903, -0.40638267993927, 0.8009765148162842, 0.41675424575805664, 0.16661882400512695, 0.06156081706285477, -0.6375532150268555, 0.5189945101737976, -0.34514084458351135, -0.16597969830036163, -0.5835704207420349, -0.27724823355674744, -0.5100715756416321, -0.41785773634910583, 0.5112107396125793, -0.06984316557645798, 0.043355852365493774, 0.3942660987377167, -0.7149533033370972, -0.17846520245075226, 0.4727660119533539, -0.38549453020095825, -0.24708224833011627, 1.11350417137146, 0.5431098937988281, -0.021141789853572845, -0.06443429738283157, 0.5087620615959167, 0.10320896655321121, 0.6879863739013672, 0.10976678878068924, -0.7783359885215759, 0.6470493674278259, -0.03435011953115463, 0.48258838057518005, -0.44590988755226135, -0.2608051002025604, -0.0063704573549330235, -1.0984357595443726, -0.04455983266234398, 0.28375086188316345, 0.5981829166412354, -0.5377846956253052, -0.9006403088569641, 0.05534101277589798, 0.38226473331451416, 0.4334993064403534, -0.30226796865463257, -0.9461590647697449, 0.09402118623256683, -0.3321354389190674, 0.49040040373802185, -0.6869028210639954, 0.43212708830833435, -0.0536007396876812, -0.2522840201854706, -0.01863350160419941, 0.7147268652915955, 0.33438920974731445, -0.18080389499664307, 0.3865066170692444, 0.7113745212554932, -0.19778266549110413, 0.24712160229682922, -0.6020844578742981, 0.21243375539779663, -1.02460515499115, 0.30137941241264343, -0.03289392963051796, -0.5135529041290283, 0.3701215088367462, 0.06480806320905685, 0.7012466788291931, -0.9333370923995972, 0.5256008505821228, 0.7749118804931641, -0.08049573004245758, 0.561770498752594, 0.8848682641983032, -0.177492156624794, -0.3639114499092102, -0.6441370844841003, -0.5146567821502686, -0.008621434681117535, 0.10426215082406998, 0.15634824335575104, -0.0667266771197319, -0.4497379660606384, -0.00451630400493741, -0.1315104365348816, 0.6376638412475586, 0.6474191546440125, -0.3114958703517914, 0.31404972076416016, -0.37264201045036316, -0.17310480773448944, -0.3353402614593506, 0.2434009313583374, -0.07085377722978592, -0.05470684543251991, 0.17119100689888, 0.3065255582332611, -0.663750410079956, -0.5588783025741577, 0.08813177794218063, 0.2698122560977936, 0.16879981756210327, 0.019529785960912704, 0.6944488883018494, -0.024447493255138397, -0.389559268951416, -0.21926745772361755, 0.09967614710330963, -0.06457284837961197, 0.2534632980823517, -0.05227702111005783, 0.30315709114074707, 0.0053640990518033504, 0.042177844792604446, 0.6407062411308289, -0.13968698680400848, -0.11304375529289246, 0.35204601287841797, -0.6639729738235474, -0.2345585823059082, 0.36069193482398987, -0.028830796480178833, -0.8050666451454163, -0.2698555588722229, -0.7564433217048645, 0.11946508288383484, -0.7338799238204956, -0.29211047291755676, -0.45656609535217285, -0.41525813937187195, -0.4755755066871643, -0.07599093019962311, 0.8762680888175964, -0.14014177024364471, -0.26234734058380127, -0.3809966742992401, -0.5437927842140198, -0.37213024497032166, -0.5954373478889465, 1.5284903049468994, 0.18575726449489594, -0.48355937004089355, -0.17727723717689514, 0.1902707815170288, -0.7624101638793945, -0.03866592049598694, 0.20086625218391418, -0.8294002413749695, 0.44435784220695496, 0.19622403383255005, 0.3272210657596588, 0.20187896490097046, 1.1166859865188599, 0.1209842786192894, 0.1400008648633957, 0.22970303893089294, -1.492248296737671, -0.22321845591068268, -0.29941120743751526, 0.172618567943573, 0.9339775443077087, 0.3402635455131531, 0.3492431938648224, 0.3556927442550659, -0.6339450478553772, -0.059870071709156036, -0.9080897569656372, -0.4295276403427124, -0.8326426148414612, -0.7273366451263428, -0.28910085558891296, -0.22909262776374817, 0.2287488430738449, 0.9955843687057495, -0.22548235952854156, -0.10465962439775467, -1.0128594636917114, 0.456453412771225, -0.39305830001831055, 0.281332790851593, -0.1880931258201599, -0.6523080468177795, -0.11523739993572235, -0.3456331789493561, -0.26272815465927124, -0.14590825140476227, 0.09595142304897308, -0.19081322848796844, 0.13579557836055756, 0.04643237963318825, -0.38788366317749023, 0.8389472365379333, -0.6603863835334778, -0.4677443504333496, -0.10347803682088852, 0.02454289235174656, -0.6914972066879272, 0.25344881415367126, 0.44266656041145325, 0.39740243554115295, 0.4074169993400574, -0.012688331305980682, -0.023524096235632896, 0.46101054549217224, -0.3921091854572296, -0.1407691240310669, 0.31530067324638367, 0.8440328240394592, -0.09083037078380585, -1.2600586414337158, -0.2899095118045807, 0.8385694026947021, -1.5036520957946777, 0.7400256395339966, -0.30052363872528076, 0.7728146910667419, 0.03352690488100052, 0.055415909737348557, -0.08960342407226562, 0.4958125352859497, 0.7662800550460815, 1.0323811769485474, 0.07653578370809555, -0.01614305004477501, -0.03886408358812332, 0.35996729135513306, -0.31383055448532104, 0.4355834126472473, -0.13387531042099, -0.5096311569213867, 0.21633082628250122, 0.44472432136535645, -0.15113797783851624, 0.22302189469337463, -0.5299778580665588, 0.01047410350292921, 0.011306325905025005, -0.6793590188026428, -1.0195525884628296, 0.38773632049560547, 0.7334260940551758, -0.6832762956619263, -0.46991774439811707, -0.14017938077449799, -0.6414504647254944, 0.5969488024711609, -0.5768017768859863, -0.35155120491981506, -0.11990802735090256, -0.5556586980819702, 0.06519116461277008, -0.036142315715551376, -0.4114142060279846, -0.08113952726125717, -0.16113603115081787, 0.10538121312856674, -0.3369119465351105, 0.173972487449646, -0.0739457756280899, 0.19819192588329315, -0.8559775948524475, 0.4970456659793854, -0.8124380707740784, 0.19238722324371338, -1.1895081996917725, -0.8915974497795105, 0.03866296261548996, 1.0910614728927612, 0.20385099947452545, 0.013554670847952366, -0.6645169258117676, -0.15689457952976227, -0.538719654083252, -0.25406503677368164, -0.9915844798088074, -0.6106298565864563, -0.31536564230918884, -0.14003074169158936, -0.08753560483455658, -0.37854304909706116, 0.2173410952091217, -0.01836160011589527, 0.05032726004719734, 0.12705150246620178, -0.15601104497909546, 0.9793146848678589, 0.44479718804359436, -0.9181246161460876, 1.095645785331726, 0.21488595008850098, 0.1218579113483429, 0.6594181060791016, -0.6522781252861023, 0.12592118978500366, 0.7721359729766846, 0.5662227869033813, 0.8597366213798523, 0.39048972725868225, 0.6389610767364502, -0.03848527744412422, 0.6131741404533386, 0.5803970098495483, 0.006157446186989546, 0.5765474438667297, 0.20760054886341095, 0.5022097229957581, -0.4691210389137268, -0.14167773723602295, -0.005340162198990583, 0.059061311185359955, -0.2151162028312683, 0.1265822947025299, -0.4934982657432556, 0.0036536850966513157, -0.4115491509437561, 0.09416939318180084, -0.5031791925430298, 0.0012494483962655067, -0.02948424592614174, -0.07980145514011383, 0.5514923334121704, 0.056876905262470245, -0.0926227793097496, 0.2676319181919098, 0.5507032871246338, 0.15017341077327728, -0.04170404374599457, 0.3720308542251587, -0.4144833981990814, 0.9051263332366943, 0.2587951719760895, 0.8763117790222168, 0.6199166178703308, 0.4364365041255951, -0.5097867250442505, -0.21260888874530792, 0.2431967705488205, 0.5725823044776917, -0.8835042715072632, -0.17157495021820068, -0.6143128871917725, -0.03720008581876755, -0.022460751235485077, -0.22658146917819977, 0.32976141571998596, -0.726952314376831, 0.152632474899292, 0.6592386960983276, -0.20438769459724426, 0.018277710303664207, 0.7539311647415161, 0.15199321508407593, 0.1327129304409027, 0.7045835852622986, 0.08489958941936493, -0.1366838961839676, 1.5331711769104004, 1.3846220970153809, 0.25586163997650146, 0.4158923625946045, 0.1547674834728241, -0.280971497297287, 0.3698088228702545, 0.30745866894721985, -0.092723548412323, 0.49615052342414856, -0.3716872036457062, -0.1094563752412796, 0.4580398201942444, 0.35093945264816284, -0.29788243770599365, -0.1397043913602829, 0.30542561411857605, -0.40643683075904846, -0.28718042373657227, -0.3846394717693329, 1.3397588729858398, 0.8675552606582642, -0.3217381536960602, -0.3056506812572479, -0.11810106039047241, 0.0003590689448174089, -0.44600072503089905, -0.05191517621278763, 0.7497965693473816, -0.18448196351528168, -0.5775578022003174, -0.04950116574764252, -0.5835686922073364, -0.7504380941390991, -0.6572394967079163, 0.29650062322616577, -0.2235989272594452, -0.08203820884227753, 0.31176382303237915, 0.428144633769989, 0.050098828971385956, -0.6290045976638794, -0.049575746059417725, 0.2921106815338135, 0.8395209312438965, -0.19887007772922516, -0.2074546068906784, 0.2904801368713379, 0.3289059102535248, -0.1703162044286728, 0.39263325929641724, 0.43174347281455994, -1.1542342901229858, 0.6239094138145447, 0.06446265429258347, 0.46278849244117737, 0.6426028609275818, 0.0695318952202797, 0.0571446493268013, 0.7567958235740662, 0.0655258521437645, 0.4126802086830139, -0.5736335515975952, -0.5375991463661194, -0.7056789398193359, 0.32458075881004333, -0.5041853189468384, 0.5322331190109253, -0.15141747891902924, 0.2173403948545456, 0.1856960952281952, -0.8757056593894958, 4.372104644775391, 0.36661022901535034, 0.9199846386909485, 0.28401413559913635, 0.328457772731781, 0.6787698268890381, 0.23145268857479095, -0.7801275253295898, 0.11161255091428757, -0.7899576425552368, -0.4602041244506836, -0.4518495202064514, 0.11434910446405411, -0.5601502060890198, -0.14531321823596954, 1.4951589107513428, -0.4243137836456299, -0.3655646741390228, 0.4051564037799835, -0.7755746841430664, -0.39182689785957336, -0.19015762209892273, -0.03923580422997475, 0.6553326845169067, 0.3361507058143616, 0.5200051665306091, 0.42513808608055115, -0.6444888114929199, -0.2885836362838745, -0.20029354095458984, -0.5424317121505737, -0.6283183693885803, 0.42973989248275757, -0.2457190752029419, -0.46647945046424866, 0.47266387939453125, -0.031083812937140465, -0.4677477777004242, -0.35260114073753357, 0.21788911521434784, -0.24368104338645935, -0.06494592875242233, 0.4156254529953003, -0.11836247146129608, -1.0030821561813354, 1.1795133352279663, -0.8891763091087341, 0.7945355772972107, 0.5978116393089294, -0.9151804447174072, 0.5608680844306946, 0.07907918840646744, 0.49431997537612915, -0.2440566122531891, -0.6826550364494324, 0.3152620792388916, -0.15558256208896637, 0.04637967422604561, 0.10335686057806015, 0.09149084240198135, 0.26709118485450745, -0.7640016674995422, -0.21544554829597473, 0.2311442643404007, -0.09497913718223572, 0.4327840805053711, 0.415986567735672, 0.16544470191001892, -0.5330695509910583, -0.7144941091537476, 0.3355558216571808, -0.3010503947734833, -0.5865557193756104, 0.6919991374015808, 0.7509352564811707, 0.05691663175821304, -0.2622675597667694, -0.06546160578727722, 0.29772818088531494, 0.3274790346622467, 0.46718618273735046, -0.49093976616859436, -0.6495223045349121, 0.11142431199550629, 0.2745165228843689, 0.43164774775505066, -0.689683198928833, -0.042444195598363876, -0.0337725467979908, 0.6969608068466187, 0.1683080643415451, 1.031667709350586, 0.033142704516649246, 0.12327395379543304, -0.7557545900344849 ]
QCD Hadron Spectroscopy with Staggered Dynamical Quarks at $\beta = 5.6$
We present preliminary results from the 1991 HEMCGC simulations with staggered dynamical fermions on a $16^3 \times 32$ lattice at $\beta = 5.6$ with sea quark masses $am_q = 0.025$ and 0.01. The spectroscopy was done both for staggered valence quarks with mass equal to the sea quark masses and for Wilson valence quarks at six different values for $\kappa$, 0.1320, 0.1410, 0.1525, 0.1565, 0.1585, and 0.1600. In addition to the measurements performed in our earlier work, we also measured the $\Delta$ and other `extended' hadrons for staggered valence quarks and pseudo-scalar decay constants and vector meson matrix elements, the wave function at the origin, for Wilson valence quarks.
K.M. Bitar, R. Edwards, T.A. DeGrand, Steven Gottlieb, U.M. Heller, A.D. Kennedy, J.B. Kogut, A. Krasnitz, W. Liu, M.C. Og...
hep-lat
January
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9201005
hep-lat/9201006
[ 0.13720323145389557, -0.31523391604423523, 0.0171427633613348, 0.009686978533864021, -0.17412008345127106, -0.8364273905754089, -0.796128511428833, -0.24157866835594177, -0.7012284398078918, 1.3865858316421509, 1.2834246158599854, 0.4519308805465698, 0.0557219460606575, -0.5546563863754272, 0.004481067880988121, 0.6396235823631287, -0.19620168209075928, -0.6154537200927734, -1.1589024066925049, 0.6478390693664551, 0.15845784544944763, 0.16073395311832428, -1.5585994720458984, -0.24295839667320251, -0.47666433453559875, 0.19645456969738007, 0.8364995718002319, 0.16222615540027618, 1.1430875062942505, 0.7241060733795166, 1.1283552646636963, 0.06119105964899063, -0.33576512336730957, -0.4643796980381012, 0.001307586207985878, -0.5255253911018372, 0.06610340625047684, -0.3137175738811493, 0.37137049436569214, -0.43524712324142456, 0.27997103333473206, 0.282840758562088, 0.7259612679481506, -0.4212072193622589, -0.8937423825263977, -0.22132934629917145, 0.02744341641664505, -0.2179090827703476, 0.14959949254989624, -0.9984244108200073, -0.7225505113601685, -0.00027268388657830656, 0.6341944932937622, -0.6151085495948792, -0.0931745320558548, -0.035312727093696594, 0.4446620047092438, 0.7259824872016907, -0.055007170885801315, 0.33158835768699646, 0.8727056980133057, 0.3122016191482544, 0.36849647760391235, -0.9185439944267273, 0.1339825838804245, 0.9888694882392883, -0.5684624910354614, 0.42760345339775085, -0.030212992802262306, -0.7137892246246338, -0.5233227014541626, -0.7018722891807556, -0.945214033126831, 0.16671428084373474, -0.394868403673172, 0.6171756982803345, -0.11248113960027695, -0.17631107568740845, -0.5974158644676208, 0.10084018856287003, 0.36062583327293396, -0.43752366304397583, -0.9669661521911621, 0.138505220413208, -0.4439223110675812, -0.13569901883602142, -0.05847562849521637, -0.29378026723861694, -0.3428650498390198, 0.5922539234161377, 0.39496493339538574, 0.8146340250968933, 0.6681393980979919, -0.8525161147117615, 0.21271759271621704, 1.0266433954238892, 0.1552618145942688, 0.6410951018333435, -0.5782119631767273, 0.5095453262329102, -0.7083488702774048, 0.10221833735704422, -0.1479899138212204, 0.6703287363052368, -0.32083365321159363, 0.8127891421318054, -0.38081005215644836, -0.0038510579615831375, -0.6748549342155457, -1.1026304960250854, 0.4660979211330414, -0.3980076014995575, 0.2640094757080078, 0.3933570683002472, -0.11226562410593033, 0.5730968117713928, 0.07290292531251907, -0.48081937432289124, -0.7117014527320862, -0.00007439807814080268, 0.251438170671463, 0.4090336561203003, 1.1743501424789429, 0.7098281383514404, 0.4174783229827881, -0.6792301535606384, -0.15646877884864807, -0.038896344602108, -0.5002167820930481, 0.2829247713088989, 0.4872090220451355, -0.07080080360174179, -0.26336461305618286, 0.21092233061790466, -0.016832413151860237, 0.8018025159835815, -0.7862340211868286, -0.08540184795856476, -0.31343522667884827, 0.15879134833812714, 0.1994619369506836, -0.4608587920665741, 0.7090355157852173, 0.9411630630493164, 0.3278965353965759, 0.849338948726654, -0.1979968100786209, 0.6526572704315186, -0.14480839669704437, 0.3629302382469177, 0.10336194187402725, -0.2274385243654251, -0.5121400952339172, -0.12808522582054138, -0.06491518020629883, 0.39527660608291626, -0.7367664575576782, 0.3399627208709717, -0.1694815456867218, -0.008439406752586365, 0.3024987280368805, -0.1669411063194275, -0.26411768794059753, 1.0220030546188354, 0.02329389750957489, 0.340908944606781, -0.857792854309082, -0.6329278349876404, 0.5584888458251953, -0.19774450361728668, 0.27462515234947205, -0.14112167060375214, -0.23448972404003143, 0.31991156935691833, 0.4216609597206116, 1.0628851652145386, 0.257271409034729, -0.4898742735385895, 0.4271778166294098, 0.019239116460084915, -0.6026871800422668, -0.4019220471382141, 0.9985153675079346, 0.3950236737728119, -0.5106610655784607, -0.8158325552940369, -0.393117219209671, 0.42637449502944946, -0.47319966554641724, -0.08471506088972092, -0.5210214257240295, 0.3542316257953644, -1.3239489793777466, 0.6662361025810242, -0.646865963935852, 0.4014124274253845, -0.27649712562561035, -0.06033068150281906, -0.8146219849586487, -0.7968065142631531, -0.10608852654695511, -0.06944479793310165, -0.6178994178771973, 0.17458561062812805, -1.6995007991790771, 0.6342147588729858, 0.6704678535461426, 0.8149647116661072, -0.4259355962276459, -0.1929658204317093, -0.01272647362202406, -0.026722442358732224, 0.1476171314716339, -0.5902541875839233, 0.24837052822113037, -0.34591126441955566, 0.41628509759902954, 0.32294154167175293, 0.09857314079999924, 0.358434796333313, 0.37425848841667175, 0.8190737962722778, 0.2190762609243393, 0.23015092313289642, 0.220509871840477, -0.46626195311546326, -0.09657227247953415, 0.8958273530006409, -0.04157343879342079, -0.23453053832054138, -0.5281984210014343, 0.5135467052459717, 0.07685984671115875, 0.07103287428617477, 0.4737381339073181, 0.45115190744400024, 0.2786438465118408, 0.4239223897457123, 0.1920001208782196, 0.08925831317901611, 0.6216579675674438, 0.17317011952400208, 0.5524606108665466, -0.33094891905784607, -0.0800117552280426, 1.0144652128219604, -0.02200094237923622, 0.18489816784858704, -0.5917184352874756, 0.6489899158477783, -0.3292435109615326, 0.668870747089386, 0.19816307723522186, 0.554508626461029, -0.7228191494941711, 0.24869397282600403, 0.5734542608261108, -0.12580189108848572, -0.1959255188703537, -0.7628095149993896, -0.15688782930374146, 0.8473397493362427, -0.34161949157714844, -0.2714763283729553, -0.6071450114250183, 0.7950599193572998, -0.15226060152053833, -0.12746386229991913, 0.4357961118221283, 0.060367535799741745, -0.6422178745269775, -0.44571661949157715, -1.0561771392822266, 0.06855129450559616, -0.9711830019950867, -0.5370902419090271, 0.5664351582527161, -0.7682146430015564, 0.6185607314109802, -0.016275400295853615, 0.09028571099042892, 0.12849031388759613, 0.015500366687774658, 0.8222702145576477, 0.43604224920272827, -0.38215455412864685, -0.07946710288524628, 0.6111589074134827, -0.5384413599967957, -0.24571824073791504, -0.012062307447195053, -0.4955909252166748, 0.5914008021354675, -0.40959060192108154, 0.25793012976646423, -0.18483951687812805, -0.662176251411438, -0.14778512716293335, -0.8347129225730896, -0.6990717053413391, 0.5800893902778625, 0.5974180698394775, 0.30138397216796875, 0.35375866293907166, -0.6173117756843567, 0.9514268040657043, 0.5421725511550903, -0.7674340009689331, 0.7942902445793152, 0.11769585311412811, -0.6958497762680054, 1.0198408365249634, 0.04531586542725563, 0.663011908531189, -0.000030386756407096982, 1.432733416557312, 0.5294778347015381, -0.35598787665367126, -0.15113583207130432, -0.5878453254699707, -0.7373061180114746, 0.20975257456302643, 0.39757075905799866, -0.7062857151031494, 0.5986976027488708, 0.629194438457489, 0.5988321304321289, -0.720909833908081, 0.31526604294776917, -0.5385450720787048, -0.11249083280563354, -0.41797444224357605, -0.5611066818237305, 0.13643234968185425, 0.1651914268732071, -0.4859999418258667, -0.4027535021305084, -0.10545525699853897, 0.5751532912254333, 0.8134661316871643, 0.5106990933418274, -0.7131029963493347, 0.3023757338523865, 0.5076181888580322, 1.2027677297592163, 0.10324499011039734, 0.0066657825373113155, -0.678176999092102, -0.44458329677581787, 0.3287193179130554, -0.22893349826335907, 0.7073008418083191, -0.060759272426366806, 0.6265270113945007, -0.12349917739629745, -0.2914637327194214, -0.7439650893211365, -0.8576332330703735, -0.7288287281990051, -0.6756877899169922, 0.1474609076976776, 0.706056535243988, 0.3628126382827759, -0.3428482413291931, -0.9113362431526184, -0.1651105433702469, -0.44229748845100403, -0.013207238167524338, 0.9312079548835754, -1.661679744720459, 0.3229604661464691, 0.09036126732826233, -0.6960787177085876, 0.38625484704971313, -0.7233029007911682, 0.45960190892219543, 0.5076681971549988, 0.8574358224868774, -0.24464470148086548, -0.8077513575553894, -0.7642626166343689, -0.38098564743995667, 0.8786433339118958, 0.7214459180831909, 0.17973026633262634, -0.23723486065864563, -0.5825894474983215, -0.1124497801065445, 0.2924572825431824, -0.08749084919691086, -0.4893704950809479, -0.568507969379425, 0.43248769640922546, -0.5045759677886963, -0.16782385110855103, 0.2875903844833374, 1.0032494068145752, -0.12102381885051727, 0.1922665238380432, -0.045079685747623444, 0.7538967132568359, 0.9239169955253601, 0.664743959903717, 0.9404719471931458, -0.2273455411195755, 0.0049255830235779285, -0.4740072190761566, 0.5848410129547119, 0.4285689890384674, 0.6514314413070679, -0.28449687361717224, -0.42643725872039795, 0.26797279715538025, -0.2378106266260147, 0.4080718457698822, 0.41948437690734863, -0.539855420589447, 0.45884937047958374, 0.9245606064796448, 0.028456535190343857, -0.02887166477739811, 0.07002697139978409, 0.32636308670043945, 0.02331162802875042, 0.758825957775116, -1.3476814031600952, 0.164245143532753, -0.3485722243785858, 1.0023586750030518, -0.023693209514021873, 0.1908499300479889, -0.950767457485199, -0.9630536437034607, -0.05095510557293892, -0.47065770626068115, 0.5060673356056213, 0.8138566017150879, 0.19702854752540588, 0.10653010755777359, -0.5514836311340332, -0.4740264415740967, 0.46680599451065063, -0.8415989279747009, -0.29020100831985474, -0.5956847667694092, 0.46891337633132935, -0.2605346143245697, 0.40008553862571716, -0.7979449033737183, -0.5898081064224243, 0.7466888427734375, -0.30563926696777344, 0.5532769560813904, -0.24032673239707947, -0.16228976845741272, -0.9858903288841248, -0.37495359778404236, -0.3835643529891968, 0.4228332042694092, 0.06338484585285187, 0.005666820798069239, -0.2355877161026001, 0.6329734325408936, -0.8995257616043091, 0.9992637038230896, -0.008828412741422653, 0.4109767973423004, 0.4135110378265381, 0.6058181524276733, 0.3941099941730499, 0.14877942204475403, 0.06009448319673538, -0.3137698173522949, 0.019989343360066414, 0.44138628244400024, -0.4920278787612915, -0.6821224689483643, 0.4634697139263153, -0.026613162830471992, -0.0695950910449028, -0.9975124001502991, -0.12293080240488052, -0.6738528609275818, 0.776817798614502, -0.2620014548301697, -1.0205087661743164, -0.4780348837375641, -0.4861341714859009, -0.35955795645713806, -0.005129495169967413, 0.14779430627822876, -0.3529895544052124, 0.5814860463142395, -0.4651091694831848, 0.13751433789730072, 0.4247142970561981, -0.7368456125259399, -0.8736609816551208, 0.12684383988380432, 0.8333317637443542, 0.19517838954925537, 0.8633496165275574, -0.3779359757900238, 0.13734295964241028, -0.4586428105831146, -0.28535813093185425, -0.7785000801086426, -0.5906107425689697, 0.4356619715690613, -0.3508738577365875, 0.38034194707870483, -0.21269984543323517, 0.6677809357643127, 0.09472142904996872, 0.010952894575893879, 0.2572921812534332, -0.5088750720024109, -0.5481780767440796, -0.519736647605896, 0.7547774314880371, 0.23586703836917877, -1.2756799459457397, -0.23587748408317566, 0.22854310274124146, -0.9882771372795105, 0.19658322632312775, 0.3908372223377228, -1.1849685907363892, 0.11196886748075485, -0.8174296617507935, 0.8280014991760254, -0.6051696538925171, -0.27746859192848206, -0.619878888130188, -0.751120924949646, 0.49045857787132263, 0.20805786550045013, 0.7949361801147461, -0.7465537190437317, -0.8483633399009705, -0.37923991680145264, 0.2947450280189514, -0.01075064018368721, 0.014309367164969444, -0.1701672226190567, -0.5394538044929504, 0.2568570673465729, 1.3161234855651855, -0.3295382559299469, -0.014731141738593578, 0.1255079209804535, -0.18271318078041077, 0.20444726943969727, 0.15858881175518036, 0.3752875328063965, -0.6591617465019226, -0.304523766040802, -0.1581965833902359, 0.44676923751831055, 0.415770947933197, -0.43011102080345154, 0.2116507887840271, -1.166365385055542, 1.0865287780761719, -0.44341006875038147, -0.5820583701133728, 0.05505681037902832, 0.32545235753059387, 0.4109230935573578, -1.0267939567565918, -0.3867912292480469, -0.22181203961372375, 0.05706710368394852, 0.9121466875076294, -0.2923067808151245, -0.38690799474716187, -0.29489052295684814, -0.668856143951416, -0.841254711151123, 1.0048457384109497, 0.16397246718406677, 0.06464450806379318, -0.6541911959648132, -0.40308836102485657, -0.26947060227394104, -0.5427431464195251, 0.21789494156837463, 0.7250556945800781, 0.6322467923164368, -0.4678668677806854, -0.48527002334594727, 0.0657234936952591, -0.8273118138313293, -0.2598970830440521, -0.1834953874349594, 0.3925168216228485, 0.11598347872495651, -0.4382830560207367, -1.149954915046692, -0.24619895219802856, -0.2110329568386078, 0.2618427872657776, 0.45255035161972046, -0.5901271104812622, 0.6548104882240295, 0.3370194733142853, -0.28905460238456726, 0.002837696112692356, 0.08118502050638199, 0.6947702765464783, 0.26500803232192993, 0.5057466626167297, 0.4500785768032074, 0.4641083776950836, -0.31268131732940674, -0.2581064999103546, -0.8488932847976685, 0.18426725268363953, 0.7172693610191345, -0.343782901763916, -0.06362522393465042, 1.1324572563171387, 0.37178102135658264, -0.3564840853214264, -0.3943706154823303, -1.0326164960861206, -0.1279647797346115, -0.1505243331193924, 0.06676089018583298, 0.5285219550132751, -0.40169352293014526, 0.478603720664978, 0.2165144681930542, 0.7008134722709656, 0.009878714568912983, 0.7322871088981628, 0.5937144756317139, 0.006418009288609028, -0.04646670073270798, -0.1271338313817978, 1.0650759935379028, -0.5874673128128052, -0.540920078754425, -0.28232187032699585, 0.194133460521698, -0.4221397340297699, 0.08634558320045471, 0.3178339898586273, -0.49800461530685425, -0.25479283928871155, -0.2403353601694107, 0.6253670454025269, 0.14662131667137146, 0.9587112069129944, -0.1765609234571457, -0.053443655371665955, -0.49793940782546997, -0.6339627504348755, -0.2572799324989319, 0.49223387241363525, -0.02364599145948887, 1.0366610288619995, -0.09548704326152802, -0.03563213348388672, 0.1404625028371811, -0.3235718011856079, -0.1906816065311432, -1.0251203775405884, -0.408206582069397, -1.1851879358291626, -0.8373699188232422, -1.392604112625122, -0.28845009207725525, 0.6739288568496704, 0.7931073904037476, -0.3504243493080139, 0.7191659212112427, -0.3806488513946533, -0.21825765073299408, -0.598349928855896, 0.49491652846336365, -0.72702956199646, -0.022558748722076416, -0.715398371219635, -0.44478437304496765, -0.06851526349782944, -0.36958545446395874, -0.6240958571434021, 0.1835535615682602, 0.08353680372238159, 0.7386343479156494, -0.5938178300857544, 0.642355740070343, -0.5514060258865356, -0.6310950517654419, 0.18851131200790405, 0.06024574860930443, -0.8685788512229919, 0.8872646689414978, 0.3260301351547241, 0.2705225646495819, 0.2929924726486206, 0.40064963698387146, -0.28668341040611267, -0.144801527261734, -1.0097362995147705, 0.14167606830596924, -0.20052284002304077, -0.5577762126922607, 0.14840354025363922, -0.21853207051753998, 0.46019306778907776, -0.9143018126487732, -0.02897929958999157, -0.035731375217437744, 0.12886297702789307, 0.2288396656513214, -0.3774702548980713, 0.38083162903785706, -0.13641521334648132, -0.3629833459854126, -0.06795183569192886, 0.7363128066062927, 0.0912870466709137, -0.2408643215894699, 0.1592250019311905, -0.0006996382726356387, 0.2521570920944214, 0.6540076732635498, 0.02350737154483795, -0.15231691300868988, -0.2124374806880951, 0.5066338181495667, -0.11377888917922974, 0.15647117793560028, -0.5177804827690125, -0.31002381443977356, -0.8587258458137512, 0.48691627383232117, -0.8470030426979065, 0.010905146598815918, 0.08329464495182037, -0.34930047392845154, 0.21909813582897186, -0.019799184054136276, -0.19277790188789368, 0.19309626519680023, -0.6394656896591187, -0.42453688383102417, -0.3916885256767273, 0.06772545725107193, 0.28742265701293945, 0.30754974484443665, -0.583336591720581, -0.2858891785144806, 0.10655436664819717, 0.536940336227417, 0.02950168587267399, -0.5057011246681213, -0.1926080882549286, 0.2210073173046112, -1.1847501993179321, -0.11498874425888062, -0.8978576064109802, 0.8646305203437805, -0.9762980341911316, -0.7956495881080627, -0.37633928656578064, 0.7471928596496582, -0.0732390359044075, 0.0032096796203404665, -0.1080402359366417, -0.000349163863575086, 0.30175140500068665, 0.15956875681877136, -0.05417777597904205, -0.16242572665214539, 0.019686663523316383, 0.44616231322288513, 0.0932554379105568, -0.6771588325500488, 0.10197456181049347, 0.7504291534423828, 0.03744083270430565, 0.2675507962703705, 0.09903746843338013, 1.2465678453445435, -0.22536861896514893, -0.5937274694442749, 0.5151702165603638, 0.40445685386657715, 0.3446348309516907, 0.9430350661277771, -0.2862520217895508, 0.13936294615268707, 0.34574979543685913, 0.6387125253677368, 0.8024939298629761, -0.42983803153038025, -0.29720401763916016, 1.115955114364624, 0.5221341252326965, -0.06267272680997849, 0.1920255571603775, 0.8404890894889832, 0.37160447239875793, 0.3972865641117096, -0.48228833079338074, -0.16577684879302979, -0.18211327493190765, 0.31691044569015503, 0.0973854586482048, -0.2900640070438385, 0.21821993589401245, -0.172670379281044, 0.854840099811554, 0.6336674690246582, -0.7289668321609497, -0.2612188756465912, -0.42620012164115906, 0.20119459927082062, 0.2858818769454956, 0.387766569852829, -0.24899965524673462, 1.3224968910217285, 1.5525293350219727, 0.2786455750465393, -0.3472369909286499, 0.5635240077972412, 0.3029860258102417, 0.40937718749046326, 0.5540744662284851, 0.03961620852351189, 0.6476722359657288, 1.1727877855300903, -0.17322349548339844, -0.21960145235061646, -0.3355843126773834, -0.1709461361169815, -1.4343020915985107, -0.19420784711837769, -0.37837013602256775, -0.24919506907463074, -0.44360634684562683, -0.8684239983558655, 0.3831184506416321, -0.304325670003891, -0.6490391492843628, 0.472022145986557, -0.18803155422210693, -0.2723606526851654, 0.4446178078651428, 0.4001246988773346, 0.06046359986066818, 0.6144632697105408, -0.14294473826885223, 0.0037886062636971474, 0.6353803873062134, 1.426972508430481, 0.12118896096944809, -0.19694872200489044, -0.14794155955314636, 0.0936012789607048, 0.8046316504478455, 0.6479103565216064, -0.5730432271957397, 0.33109939098358154, 0.24467109143733978, -0.09949363023042679, -0.06669338047504425, 0.37295570969581604, -0.6996408700942993, 0.16884568333625793, 0.008064772002398968, 1.2810509204864502, 0.15623697638511658, 0.03008299507200718, 1.015960693359375, 0.07421520352363586, -0.1751570999622345, -0.5511578917503357, 0.16767454147338867, -0.836597740650177, -0.41668254137039185, -1.2628449201583862, 0.5350458025932312, -0.11213639378547668, -0.18212008476257324, -0.594411313533783, -0.19129598140716553, -0.3246770203113556, -0.6405063271522522, 0.11027459800243378, -0.23615598678588867, 0.2971883714199066, 0.5518255233764648, -0.15405000746250153, 0.4356807768344879, -0.5262824296951294, -0.2546878159046173, -0.4243447482585907, 0.9109538793563843, -0.16976799070835114, 0.16706600785255432, 0.3966711461544037, 0.18317726254463196, -0.6853432655334473, 1.1731770038604736, 0.8040689826011658, -0.6882429122924805, 0.2127506136894226, -1.0418707132339478, 0.5922514796257019, 0.015634063631296158, 0.20400477945804596, 0.33734384179115295, -0.24494506418704987, 0.7508604526519775, -0.06791536509990692, -1.0245132446289062, -0.2737762928009033, -0.5809192657470703, -0.3323923349380493, -0.871516764163971, 0.46430426836013794, -0.6465177536010742, 0.03464563563466072, -0.0372723788022995, -0.1828164905309677, 3.9113242626190186, 0.5352874398231506, 1.1116547584533691, 0.19306810200214386, 1.0075701475143433, 1.0790258646011353, -0.8173348903656006, -0.2824825048446655, 0.060066793113946915, -1.6426348686218262, -0.05968451127409935, 0.43073800206184387, -0.24985869228839874, 0.006095140241086483, -0.25377407670021057, 0.8005760312080383, -0.007420435547828674, 0.046232420951128006, -0.464242547750473, -0.6096521615982056, -0.6850177049636841, 0.1518203169107437, 0.26481837034225464, -0.4521356225013733, -0.24360808730125427, 0.9465408325195312, -0.01510092243552208, 0.00598451541736722, -0.48782581090927124, -0.30597442388534546, -0.2515481412410736, -0.7050836086273193, 0.27455541491508484, -0.2198515385389328, -1.445930004119873, 0.36894407868385315, -0.23872441053390503, -0.09435964375734329, 0.4195312261581421, 0.04332118481397629, 0.07852629572153091, -0.3091265857219696, 0.2921770215034485, -0.3180818259716034, -0.8458115458488464, 1.163993000984192, -0.25686508417129517, 0.7236154675483704, 0.19443045556545258, -1.3400808572769165, 0.8411169648170471, -0.21224156022071838, 0.6331068873405457, -0.780085563659668, -0.9390740990638733, -0.12203782051801682, 0.17597106099128723, 0.0108110923320055, 0.1586693823337555, -0.23741401731967926, 0.33450812101364136, -0.3812864124774933, 0.5501653552055359, -0.1517234593629837, 0.11894279718399048, 0.9414517879486084, 1.068296194076538, -0.15079723298549652, -0.2156994342803955, 0.27951857447624207, -0.7837551832199097, -0.6706469655036926, -0.5182163119316101, -0.05817868188023567, 0.36649423837661743, -0.35786134004592896, 0.18925075232982635, 0.7154890894889832, -0.19108028709888458, 0.1468883454799652, 0.14346341788768768, -0.8107578754425049, -0.13337433338165283, 0.0426250621676445, -0.4762149751186371, 0.8815299868583679, 0.6155305504798889, 0.15934856235980988, -0.39814576506614685, 0.11191705614328384, 0.27741432189941406, 1.07974374294281, -0.005234182812273502, -0.18855807185173035, -0.6961367726325989 ]
Path Integrals and Voronin's Theorem on the Universality of the Riemann Zeta Function
We explore a new approach to the path integral for a latticized quantum theory. This talk is based on work with N. Khuri and H. Ren.
Khalil M. Bitar
hep-lat
January
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9201006
hep-lat/9201007
[ 0.3207356929779053, -0.6421325206756592, 0.030280277132987976, 0.11976292729377747, -0.28741899132728577, -0.1415022909641266, -0.13480700552463531, -0.32206061482429504, 0.2718481719493866, 1.0077600479125977, 0.5805395841598511, 0.3986017405986786, 0.15832912921905518, -0.49832141399383545, 0.10467194765806198, 0.6835095882415771, 0.013358736410737038, -0.8594412803649902, -0.9557831287384033, 0.28397223353385925, 0.38544678688049316, -0.320150762796402, -1.4760712385177612, -0.8481433987617493, 0.19170953333377838, 0.7098513841629028, 0.4409165680408478, -0.3915323317050934, 1.3854683637619019, 0.3389495015144348, 0.012100259773433208, -0.34117838740348816, 0.1168442815542221, -0.3609640300273895, -0.6552692651748657, -0.3559660315513611, 0.3305899202823639, 0.6376976370811462, 0.567417562007904, -0.19615088403224945, 0.6617119312286377, -0.854856014251709, -0.4803381562232971, -0.4048823416233063, -0.26617881655693054, -0.5429332256317139, -0.052793826907873154, -0.3522787094116211, 0.5869489312171936, -0.8463138937950134, 0.4614453911781311, 0.2624827027320862, 0.2595166265964508, -0.7691758871078491, -0.7829821705818176, 0.28712499141693115, 0.4938777685165405, -0.27121198177337646, -0.8061081171035767, 0.011117435060441494, 0.9373483061790466, 0.36823397874832153, 0.4523366391658783, -0.9964969158172607, 0.314130038022995, 0.3949420154094696, -0.8603456020355225, 0.22567419707775116, 0.11640159785747528, -0.6527413725852966, -0.27944645285606384, -0.12320461124181747, -0.834598183631897, 0.0967058390378952, -0.9107510447502136, 0.1542186290025711, 0.3771139085292816, -0.7047712206840515, -1.0231975317001343, 0.0004836063599213958, -0.7772694826126099, -0.08108437806367874, -0.04312404245138168, 0.16880463063716888, -0.6451908349990845, -0.1312757432460785, -0.013699457980692387, -0.1714290827512741, -0.12757214903831482, 0.38087087869644165, 0.4985244870185852, 0.9525184631347656, -0.3075643479824066, -0.3675394356250763, 0.09012274444103241, 0.3906845450401306, -0.2750418782234192, 0.38144275546073914, 0.23011380434036255, 0.33394137024879456, -0.05999739095568657, 0.35938677191734314, -1.2096309661865234, 0.4185656011104584, -0.6037886738777161, -0.11718343198299408, -0.42770808935165405, -0.6280807852745056, 0.16610665619373322, -0.31125614047050476, 0.8091574311256409, -0.5622291564941406, -0.4713194668292999, 0.5746122002601624, 0.40855836868286133, 0.5801082849502563, 0.21169520914554596, 0.6248338222503662, 0.07489500194787979, -0.6141963005065918, 0.4739631414413452, 0.13897518813610077, 0.301117867231369, 0.11205708235502243, 0.27797409892082214, 0.14202456176280975, -0.1226905956864357, 0.27165794372558594, -1.337289810180664, 0.05296379700303078, 0.08348435908555984, -0.3635897934436798, -0.47549811005592346, 0.7120882272720337, -0.42057737708091736, -0.12167876958847046, 0.1362152397632599, 0.8910623788833618, -0.07925831526517868, -0.014269191771745682, 0.37449589371681213, -0.6091198921203613, 0.310048371553421, 1.0394084453582764, -0.3325614631175995, 0.651444137096405, -0.410148561000824, -0.1105748787522316, -0.365265429019928, 0.15117765963077545, -0.6818310618400574, -0.6866654753684998, -0.5723037123680115, 0.8060824275016785, -0.017872050404548645, 0.19866207242012024, -0.6171337366104126, 0.33339062333106995, -0.46511200070381165, 0.03387289121747017, -0.35698744654655457, 0.08755199611186981, -0.42617639899253845, -0.023792406544089317, -0.5768834352493286, -0.4079208970069885, -0.531853973865509, -0.36814993619918823, 0.05583283305168152, -0.7398627996444702, -0.28593769669532776, 0.08993405848741531, 0.10242747515439987, 0.6938859224319458, 0.49743470549583435, 0.6160587072372437, 0.34771302342414856, -0.6521717309951782, 0.2998334765434265, 0.5113301873207092, -0.3158789575099945, -0.15526866912841797, -0.03351235017180443, 0.19926752150058746, 0.13115589320659637, -0.4722520709037781, -0.03696266561746597, 0.2011067420244217, 0.5692508816719055, 0.08125021308660507, -0.15251144766807556, 0.39594852924346924, -0.42359837889671326, 0.8508449792861938, -0.009921524673700333, -0.16135723888874054, -0.640654444694519, -0.37554749846458435, -0.9173269867897034, -0.35383379459381104, 0.19221389293670654, -0.15857233107089996, -0.45664024353027344, 0.035766515880823135, -1.3695149421691895, 0.09125743061304092, 0.6003308892250061, 0.06485520303249359, -0.44564288854599, -0.24694477021694183, -0.12008202075958252, 0.08836693316698074, 0.36678510904312134, -0.11554302275180817, 0.5431249737739563, 0.21247261762619019, 0.45286327600479126, 0.0021408989559859037, 0.6903772950172424, -0.08972792327404022, 0.6334964036941528, 0.4187717139720917, 0.2506968379020691, 0.5553935170173645, -0.3542146384716034, 0.15970396995544434, -0.3795854151248932, 0.1844681352376938, 0.2714807689189911, 0.021345501765608788, 0.15929925441741943, 0.4381370544433594, -0.81975919008255, 0.413880854845047, -0.11977045238018036, 0.3095400035381317, 0.014035065658390522, -0.03121822327375412, 0.4695500433444977, 0.28393757343292236, 0.1310279220342636, -0.13439956307411194, 0.3066089451313019, 0.2582269608974457, -0.08129748702049255, 0.4241940677165985, -0.699285626411438, 0.1497454047203064, -0.28352612257003784, 0.22593799233436584, -0.6212288737297058, 0.2605965733528137, -0.11988731473684311, 0.18213865160942078, -0.4770796597003937, 0.15269866585731506, 0.25138819217681885, 0.20027543604373932, -0.012761727906763554, -0.34097224473953247, 0.15356804430484772, 0.22264111042022705, -0.3463869094848633, -0.9468481540679932, 0.12001402676105499, 1.6304800510406494, -0.21146439015865326, 0.5656161308288574, 0.8528640866279602, -0.35453715920448303, -0.6028792262077332, -0.07796163856983185, -1.078913688659668, 0.11542963236570358, -0.627079427242279, -0.23611243069171906, 1.012050986289978, -0.3668816089630127, 0.3509567677974701, -0.055588431656360626, 0.2229388952255249, 0.4260517954826355, -0.23577000200748444, 0.11574216932058334, -0.04140925034880638, 0.15296833217144012, -0.35072943568229675, 0.4514293372631073, -0.8777341246604919, -0.4363211989402771, -0.1966019570827484, 0.5654922723770142, 0.43210744857788086, -0.7042689323425293, 0.12565569579601288, -0.4572705030441284, -0.06971589475870132, -0.03909718617796898, 0.1458980292081833, -0.33576473593711853, 0.3503020405769348, 0.45650559663772583, 0.4834881126880646, -0.8308216333389282, -0.847964346408844, -0.016208840534090996, 0.09650177508592606, -0.5296197533607483, 0.04939788952469826, -0.19377638399600983, -0.1254306435585022, 0.28679755330085754, 0.30902814865112305, 0.16511628031730652, 0.028542445972561836, 0.6963313817977905, 0.5270251035690308, -0.114734947681427, -0.25481653213500977, -0.3143541216850281, -0.12172240018844604, 0.26291897892951965, 0.10724550485610962, -0.2421177625656128, -0.46535223722457886, 0.48950088024139404, 0.4624740481376648, -0.666184663772583, 0.5332533121109009, -0.3780413866043091, -0.6660977005958557, 0.46201780438423157, -0.13727104663848877, 0.5168429017066956, -0.08920515328645706, -0.08611548691987991, -0.624872088432312, 0.09659676253795624, 0.624100923538208, -0.15268875658512115, 0.15553998947143555, -0.17248573899269104, 0.48922425508499146, 0.07524079829454422, 0.26348066329956055, 0.09415776282548904, 0.16950073838233948, -0.7161263227462769, -0.48049673438072205, 0.07346681505441666, -0.7045575380325317, -0.25158774852752686, -0.005032395478338003, 0.38744333386421204, 0.7961622476577759, 0.25956788659095764, -0.6707717180252075, -0.6775895953178406, -0.8193596601486206, -0.3074403405189514, 0.9169003367424011, 0.6253165602684021, -0.08245621621608734, -0.3380501866340637, 0.09963607043027878, -0.4008256793022156, 0.747036874294281, -0.1300627887248993, 0.4377373456954956, -0.4340957701206207, 0.5390610694885254, -0.45662832260131836, -0.3444885015487671, 0.08203727751970291, -0.5163050293922424, 0.08675101399421692, 0.07606881856918335, 0.34136006236076355, 0.9342930912971497, 0.06021064892411232, -0.49737387895584106, -0.009973535314202309, 0.586387574672699, 0.26617223024368286, 0.3007899224758148, -0.0238503385335207, -0.21389904618263245, 0.032458651810884476, -0.027485141530632973, -0.41641709208488464, -0.22709326446056366, -0.3919776380062103, 0.20016714930534363, -0.0870627835392952, 0.4876418113708496, -0.43706798553466797, 0.6567023992538452, 0.17514905333518982, 0.3258115351200104, -0.12108830362558365, 0.9591839909553528, -0.1673569232225418, 0.43081778287887573, 0.16839750111103058, 0.7094600200653076, 0.3656526803970337, -0.7250341773033142, 0.02529960870742798, 0.28786343336105347, 0.08953072130680084, -0.8209037780761719, -0.11381664872169495, -0.08547241985797882, -0.3692997694015503, 0.47420987486839294, 0.1846877783536911, -0.6298360228538513, 0.12635944783687592, -0.20146766304969788, 0.8968592286109924, -0.1417163610458374, 0.19448892772197723, 0.517108142375946, 0.3937467634677887, 0.4781970679759979, -0.9856570363044739, 0.5335178375244141, -0.6734473705291748, 0.08077339828014374, 0.3081003725528717, -0.8331677317619324, -0.20993618667125702, -0.8901244401931763, -0.6929982900619507, -0.6372023224830627, 0.23940594494342804, 0.9938918352127075, -0.4844546914100647, 0.4432823956012726, -0.19610770046710968, -0.5441174507141113, 0.08698274940252304, -0.24653083086013794, -0.27599626779556274, 0.787818968296051, 0.03892634063959122, -0.13909855484962463, 0.6550553441047668, 0.038328737020492554, -0.1183185949921608, 0.2648407220840454, -0.6877131462097168, 0.7011555433273315, -0.35607749223709106, -0.44358959794044495, 0.12536601722240448, -0.7792258262634277, -0.4377829134464264, 0.47061723470687866, 0.005105969961732626, 0.10174472630023956, -0.26928651332855225, 0.4784255921840668, -0.08477795869112015, 0.43120965361595154, 0.29902610182762146, -0.2004404217004776, 0.8396019339561462, 0.811527669429779, 0.29969432950019836, 0.5909640192985535, 0.5011274218559265, 0.5895973443984985, -0.19004680216312408, 0.3677852749824524, 0.45499613881111145, 0.17327915132045746, -0.7437520623207092, -0.35557714104652405, -0.7739348411560059, -0.9186012148857117, 0.2589382827281952, -0.2665250599384308, 0.9087451696395874, -0.29111433029174805, -0.69562828540802, -0.3253350555896759, 0.43349146842956543, -0.43740418553352356, 0.43350517749786377, 0.31406933069229126, -0.1988580971956253, 0.5585348010063171, -0.19754081964492798, -0.2658761739730835, -0.4148365557193756, 0.0789201557636261, -0.1448822021484375, 0.5562452673912048, 0.5083872675895691, -0.28611811995506287, -0.04192912206053734, -1.2904951572418213, 0.7478187680244446, -0.6507300138473511, -0.24268090724945068, -0.26160866022109985, -0.3275926411151886, -0.08521635830402374, 0.057839151471853256, -0.09658020734786987, -0.22076410055160522, 0.1359049528837204, 0.23235459625720978, -0.5754202604293823, -0.08016319572925568, 0.4594346284866333, 0.08141288161277771, 0.00036260008346289396, 0.9840704202651978, -0.028036098927259445, -0.6570793390274048, -0.23077306151390076, 0.4248812198638916, -0.09158166497945786, 0.3420516550540924, -0.21501319110393524, -0.8237628936767578, 0.2679286301136017, 0.09360912442207336, 0.1974855363368988, -0.4596474766731262, -0.6271268725395203, -0.17504923045635223, -0.885217010974884, 0.28037217259407043, -0.17163987457752228, 0.39427050948143005, -0.37002429366111755, -0.4063076078891754, 0.2195451259613037, 0.38735443353652954, -0.17879633605480194, -0.08736979961395264, -0.8662048578262329, 0.11874359101057053, -0.3228779435157776, 0.36423638463020325, -0.3755081295967102, 0.31264957785606384, 0.2541798949241638, -0.203896626830101, 0.2838923931121826, 0.9109178781509399, 0.08367697149515152, -0.07654789835214615, 0.21931815147399902, 0.326087087392807, -0.5223622918128967, 0.6853392124176025, -0.2520815134048462, 0.32270997762680054, -0.3944992423057556, 0.5199914574623108, -0.8134586215019226, -0.37886592745780945, -0.06282887607812881, -0.4577014148235321, 0.9405070543289185, -0.5711876153945923, 0.585774838924408, 0.741773784160614, -0.1048588827252388, 0.5793121457099915, 0.17095401883125305, -0.7825708985328674, 0.24125102162361145, -0.335795134305954, -0.2503669857978821, 0.38548314571380615, -0.047368403524160385, -0.16330449283123016, -0.5478382706642151, -0.7222946286201477, 0.037814415991306305, -0.33918073773384094, 0.481996089220047, 0.6877034902572632, -0.8035147190093994, 0.4300779402256012, -0.27886366844177246, -0.38337600231170654, -0.15935517847537994, 0.5666787028312683, 0.22021670639514923, 0.3886078894138336, 0.39496394991874695, 0.12560270726680756, -0.834689736366272, -0.342428594827652, -0.29462501406669617, 0.20020204782485962, -0.22089512646198273, -0.07913394272327423, 0.8509259819984436, -0.03154033049941063, -0.6411099433898926, -0.47801652550697327, 0.2657920718193054, -0.22348855435848236, 0.2893924117088318, 0.13771523535251617, 0.23777349293231964, 0.36758026480674744, -0.16633976995944977, 0.1041913703083992, -0.4092935621738434, -0.19360628724098206, 0.7201833128929138, -0.7483875155448914, -0.22347043454647064, -0.07699669897556305, 0.27797266840934753, -0.2820526361465454, -0.6700060963630676, -0.4805125892162323, 0.42622363567352295, -0.4687703549861908, -0.0391494482755661, -0.5813863277435303, -0.5753474831581116, -0.24785038828849792, 0.482336163520813, 0.7246303558349609, -0.4019626975059509, -0.2612045109272003, -0.13057029247283936, 0.03275001794099808, -0.9422599673271179, -0.46129435300827026, 1.1002800464630127, 0.5495748519897461, -0.38443222641944885, -0.03804899752140045, -0.5080381631851196, 0.0574287511408329, -0.13624098896980286, 0.20236751437187195, -0.6909635066986084, -0.3283059895038605, 0.4744538366794586, 0.045318614691495895, 0.3017825186252594, 0.9605633020401001, 0.3433770537376404, -0.06552667915821075, -0.2992749512195587, -0.43820321559906006, -0.3795539438724518, 0.24525122344493866, 0.3113095164299011, 0.8493973612785339, 0.41304895281791687, 0.12564265727996826, 0.23142129182815552, -0.5935873985290527, -0.1364721655845642, -0.5926991105079651, -0.2789381742477417, -0.4925132691860199, -0.6060309410095215, -0.24563324451446533, -0.3248898983001709, 0.06398364901542664, 0.5032849907875061, 0.15199370682239532, -0.05105791985988617, -0.5840980410575867, 0.5536103248596191, -0.1192113384604454, -0.29001811146736145, -0.19382815062999725, -0.499016672372818, -0.7122889757156372, -0.4253227412700653, -0.3868841528892517, -0.21397727727890015, -0.029909556731581688, 0.20887532830238342, 0.09775061905384064, -0.4036693871021271, -0.35019898414611816, 0.7461072206497192, -1.0939743518829346, -0.8275909423828125, -0.2102503478527069, -0.42566898465156555, -0.5659274458885193, 0.3690243065357208, 0.334799587726593, 0.43573492765426636, 0.5311962366104126, 0.15202616155147552, -0.05002465471625328, 0.5771028995513916, -0.6292908787727356, -0.3035753667354584, 0.26905152201652527, 0.37854304909706116, -0.38330942392349243, -1.1171084642410278, -0.07552478462457657, 0.4413265883922577, -1.3139855861663818, 0.3512284755706787, -0.10042987018823624, 0.4892466366291046, -0.06398478895425797, 0.8351519107818604, 0.1921946108341217, 0.7608826160430908, 0.17356613278388977, 1.2590643167495728, 0.12823177874088287, 0.08536184579133987, 0.378823846578598, -0.09309553354978561, -0.0317949503660202, 0.2931024432182312, -0.2314228117465973, -0.4661467969417572, -0.20888949930667877, 0.5180925130844116, 0.3577096164226532, 0.1203540489077568, -0.16835913062095642, 0.5235979557037354, 0.3359992802143097, -1.2615104913711548, -0.6475076675415039, 0.2780909836292267, 0.38045525550842285, -0.8205837607383728, -0.07841599732637405, -0.07314901798963547, -0.44598689675331116, 0.31827646493911743, -0.8741891384124756, -0.6874493360519409, 0.2349984496831894, -0.6661392450332642, 0.394286572933197, 0.33948662877082825, -0.24784693121910095, -0.366340696811676, -0.2586304843425751, -0.0005539159174077213, -0.6118059158325195, 0.6560713052749634, -0.3262549042701721, -0.005369991529732943, -0.6579598188400269, 0.18593496084213257, -0.1427137404680252, 0.47284838557243347, -0.9069938063621521, -1.112752079963684, 0.10302905738353729, 0.9487781524658203, -0.1439141035079956, -0.10540423542261124, -0.6743091344833374, 0.21855512261390686, -0.15995876491069794, 0.25184231996536255, -1.2360000610351562, -0.39615580439567566, -0.32260212302207947, 0.43849727511405945, 0.2473733276128769, -0.39743518829345703, 0.006938534788787365, 0.6610532999038696, 0.49500927329063416, -0.027138112112879753, -0.01785484328866005, 0.6069878339767456, 0.6543083786964417, -0.5064593553543091, 0.5054980516433716, 0.13266976177692413, 0.4973987936973572, -0.2858271300792694, -0.1396002471446991, 0.10762231051921844, 0.18380415439605713, 0.09753335267305374, 0.5524097084999084, 0.31237077713012695, -0.035985007882118225, 0.18484526872634888, 0.35037654638290405, 0.39612191915512085, 0.20200516283512115, 0.5169663429260254, -0.11634339392185211, 0.09575964510440826, -0.042544979602098465, -0.1950332224369049, -0.2068454921245575, -0.00937294214963913, -0.16873016953468323, -0.330610990524292, -0.25614842772483826, -0.084526926279068, -0.2045971304178238, 0.09544824063777924, -0.5954465270042419, 0.06116557866334915, 0.19135648012161255, 0.12734758853912354, 0.7542211413383484, -0.018407747149467468, -0.2995869815349579, 0.35752394795417786, 0.6063405871391296, 0.05545840039849281, 0.12021567672491074, 0.7497441172599792, 0.11461222171783447, 0.5976468920707703, 0.5696085691452026, 0.8742217421531677, 0.5665153861045837, 0.7581126689910889, -0.21764326095581055, -0.4229123592376709, -0.21031975746154785, 0.8404026031494141, -0.7650004625320435, -0.22556014358997345, -0.8958743214607239, 0.5071974992752075, -0.24405618011951447, -0.4251590967178345, -0.05580452084541321, -0.8545243144035339, 0.12238436192274094, 1.0533509254455566, 0.1094975620508194, 0.03470742329955101, 0.4001952111721039, 0.20113956928253174, -0.03959790989756584, 0.7097851037979126, -0.2989239990711212, 0.10902395844459534, 1.370802402496338, 1.4274349212646484, -0.525920033454895, 0.12321566790342331, 0.03772265836596489, -0.6701531410217285, 0.47256240248680115, 0.20132547616958618, -0.40323328971862793, 0.5126650929450989, -0.2458036243915558, -0.262277215719223, 0.3327236473560333, 0.09743257611989975, -0.42333629727363586, -0.4267008900642395, 0.34907978773117065, 0.30898934602737427, -0.3023533821105957, -0.789994478225708, 1.4910156726837158, 0.8690494894981384, 0.23030905425548553, 0.0003887979837600142, 0.2866603434085846, -0.3211248815059662, -0.21410270035266876, -0.22329692542552948, 0.2495422512292862, -0.6882572174072266, -0.42200198769569397, -0.2708684206008911, -0.36567991971969604, -0.7359374761581421, -0.8833632469177246, 0.018122782930731773, -0.12353172898292542, 0.5176978707313538, 0.44625324010849, 0.31657886505126953, -0.007983580231666565, -0.2731247544288635, 0.23785363137722015, 0.3368240296840668, 0.6253151893615723, 0.07060503214597702, -0.16512207686901093, 1.0140478610992432, 0.8356938362121582, -0.44911444187164307, -0.1953393667936325, 0.8872879147529602, -0.7263509035110474, 0.28726691007614136, -0.17343485355377197, 0.6106055378913879, 0.17406222224235535, 0.026269152760505676, 0.23281574249267578, 0.8394120931625366, -0.1453225016593933, -0.35471323132514954, -0.5857509970664978, 0.274558961391449, -0.6895192861557007, 0.4622825086116791, -0.34337764978408813, 0.46092697978019714, 0.08788516372442245, 0.08054962754249573, 0.07867984473705292, -0.4102470576763153, 4.478339195251465, 0.4701211154460907, 0.3793124854564667, 0.08390588313341141, 0.8312399387359619, 0.2079927623271942, 0.049872588366270065, -0.9176845550537109, 0.2920248210430145, -0.528812825679779, -0.143804132938385, 0.11040210723876953, 0.4769628047943115, -0.11632081121206284, -0.35947713255882263, 0.8222197890281677, -0.7821725606918335, -0.1890242099761963, 0.2278108298778534, -1.0640151500701904, -0.20586083829402924, 0.055661655962467194, 0.3078170716762543, 0.21415916085243225, 0.3118627369403839, 0.06816058605909348, 0.1744362860918045, -0.5598447918891907, -0.27327266335487366, -0.3413965106010437, -0.5016619563102722, -0.6122053861618042, 0.16147984564304352, -0.08721046894788742, -0.8110145926475525, 0.2726532816886902, 0.8461902737617493, -0.420995831489563, -0.3318796157836914, 0.3189193308353424, -0.15496839582920074, -0.09841722249984741, 0.005101867951452732, -0.4550827145576477, -0.6700714826583862, 0.9212847948074341, -0.3104446828365326, 0.9098901152610779, 0.3632068634033203, -0.6747680306434631, 0.548454225063324, -0.03053313121199608, 0.6537306904792786, -0.1557481735944748, -1.035689115524292, 0.010832101106643677, -0.702027440071106, -0.13214923441410065, -0.0075217545963823795, 0.310275673866272, 0.4940051734447479, -0.7429420948028564, -0.2685120105743408, 0.25708410143852234, -0.6310865879058838, 0.6774060726165771, 0.16157960891723633, 0.20932643115520477, -0.8503503203392029, -0.05904627963900566, -0.18490342795848846, -0.28724274039268494, 0.06711819022893906, 0.47696468234062195, 0.388262003660202, 0.5480201244354248, -0.604737401008606, 0.21149861812591553, 0.44413885474205017, 0.05086226388812065, 0.5479519963264465, -0.8015929460525513, -0.4030923545360565, -0.21463176608085632, -0.01975897327065468, 0.4935778081417084, -0.6914229989051819, 0.01671004109084606, -0.06276431679725647, 0.7685981392860413, 0.02137015201151371, 0.6816214323043823, -0.09022247046232224, 0.30569297075271606, -0.6181566119194031 ]
On the Dynamics of Light Wilson Quarks
We describe recent results obtained as part of the High Energy Monte Carlo Grand Challenge (HEMCGC) project concerning the behaviour of lattice QCD with light dynamical Wilson quarks. We show that it is possible to reach regions of parameter space with light pions $m_\pi\ll0.2/a$, but that the equilibration time for such a system is at least of the order of 1,000 unit-length Hybrid Monte Carlo (HMC) trajectories (about a Gigaflop/sec-year). If the Hybrid Molecular Dynamics (HMD) algorithm is used with the same parameters it gives incorrect results.
A.D. Kennedy and R.G. Edwards
hep-lat
January
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9201007
hep-lat/9202001
[ 0.09647484123706818, -0.48840826749801636, 0.8583388924598694, 0.2633267939090729, 0.020153768360614777, -0.5643839240074158, 0.2504556179046631, -0.5653408169746399, -0.4079885482788086, 1.3125998973846436, 1.059250831604004, -0.7777954339981079, 0.6584792137145996, -0.6288068294525146, -0.19700011610984802, 0.43079572916030884, -0.00855482928454876, -0.6548694372177124, -0.6925752758979797, -0.3152860403060913, 0.3653647005558014, -0.2131146788597107, -1.4309720993041992, -0.9140204191207886, -0.5291805267333984, 1.0336906909942627, 0.41009700298309326, 0.6192095875740051, 1.4294530153274536, 0.42299896478652954, 0.2289346605539322, -0.24247479438781738, 0.15836068987846375, -0.500341534614563, -0.33059048652648926, -0.1756240576505661, 0.28912967443466187, 0.21574659645557404, 0.1871739774942398, -0.418214350938797, 1.6129430532455444, -0.239312544465065, 0.3167790174484253, 0.026266664266586304, -0.11301276087760925, 0.32182857394218445, -0.4384525716304779, 0.3812107741832733, 0.008703176863491535, -1.0184123516082764, 0.0950096845626831, 0.20382893085479736, 0.5754115581512451, -0.358097642660141, -0.19840897619724274, -0.08931883424520493, -0.28954017162323, -0.00861737783998251, -0.8288728594779968, -0.31207847595214844, 0.47565361857414246, 0.13657772541046143, 0.327559232711792, -0.8803172707557678, 0.3258902132511139, 1.0946745872497559, -0.28869372606277466, 0.2153320461511612, 0.03904690966010094, 0.17135882377624512, -0.6095860004425049, 0.09278532862663269, -0.9102318286895752, -0.16860395669937134, -0.8248429894447327, -0.025216715410351753, -0.45030245184898376, -0.4956668019294739, -0.5824509859085083, -0.4518510103225708, -0.11723391711711884, -0.0785735473036766, -0.6999848484992981, 0.7937938570976257, -0.11388178169727325, -0.7323212027549744, 0.06754352152347565, 0.10603546351194382, 0.11461730301380157, 0.534593939781189, 0.19810639321804047, 0.7763713598251343, -0.32898008823394775, -0.5928278565406799, 0.20603297650814056, 0.8433387875556946, 0.10890887677669525, 0.6697421669960022, 0.09388729929924011, 0.26111364364624023, 0.9046409130096436, 1.2040774822235107, -1.1275663375854492, 0.28459617495536804, -0.19428710639476776, 0.15232129395008087, -0.3929855227470398, -0.3309479057788849, -0.04872673377394676, -0.44939985871315, -0.03527824953198433, 0.19679972529411316, 0.6777471303939819, 0.17628051340579987, -0.5104543566703796, 0.616071343421936, 0.27759891748428345, -0.10880105197429657, -0.8323958516120911, -0.0612218864262104, 0.23062102496623993, 0.4248597025871277, 0.4913707971572876, -0.04648076370358467, -0.3454042673110962, -0.5086747407913208, 0.1499696671962738, 0.4270230531692505, -0.23550662398338318, 0.5591913461685181, 0.1414017528295517, -0.24167673289775848, -0.8129585981369019, 0.7935250401496887, -0.5118075609207153, 0.47128787636756897, 0.17512205243110657, 0.37082773447036743, 0.906920313835144, -0.47114089131355286, 0.7018349766731262, -0.39716899394989014, -0.37493476271629333, 1.1386865377426147, 0.7839475274085999, 0.4792492389678955, 0.13968156278133392, -0.4827083349227905, -0.20247454941272736, 0.22358979284763336, -1.208024024963379, 0.4332326352596283, 0.008296131156384945, 0.307017982006073, -0.187437504529953, 1.0430653095245361, -0.7661483287811279, 0.9677778482437134, -0.732684850692749, -0.7568198442459106, 0.022356592118740082, -0.48646029829978943, -0.7359917163848877, 0.48667797446250916, -0.4503861963748932, 0.15118610858917236, -0.41128408908843994, 0.24433618783950806, -0.1626081019639969, -0.49044984579086304, 0.2769324779510498, 0.13823582231998444, -0.22226521372795105, 1.052117943763733, 0.4905659258365631, 0.8475779891014099, 0.21419696509838104, -0.5421007871627808, -0.27672556042671204, 0.758040189743042, -0.04030666872859001, -0.6961013078689575, 0.06975249946117401, 0.7720409631729126, -0.4438466429710388, 0.03687424212694168, -0.5140715837478638, 0.09430449455976486, -0.0016158808721229434, 0.21298913657665253, -0.27732646465301514, 0.33182233572006226, -0.3969894349575043, 0.4140063226222992, -0.5463902354240417, -0.16504907608032227, -0.541976273059845, 0.9611246585845947, -1.0212681293487549, -0.3958326578140259, 0.12327985465526581, 0.31529662013053894, -0.8768200874328613, -0.15610116720199585, -1.1794681549072266, 0.10482682287693024, 0.5669673085212708, -0.25081637501716614, -0.7785049080848694, -0.7503127455711365, 0.7000172734260559, 0.21884018182754517, 0.6714054942131042, -1.095175862312317, 0.28037527203559875, 0.011803872883319855, 0.0021942986641079187, -0.21038763225078583, 0.2459796965122223, -0.5132089257240295, 0.7689577341079712, 0.6459716558456421, -0.7891867756843567, 0.7280116081237793, -0.5782657861709595, -0.22978781163692474, -0.15722571313381195, 0.5205808877944946, -0.061528295278549194, -0.07158225029706955, 0.29459652304649353, 0.7763702869415283, 0.23048077523708344, 0.5685542821884155, 0.7619738578796387, 0.38068872690200806, 0.8019253611564636, 0.46160221099853516, 0.023300478234887123, -0.2579823136329651, -0.24145513772964478, 0.2353593409061432, 0.297902911901474, 0.03779520466923714, 0.47079238295555115, 0.06036738306283951, -1.0200222730636597, 0.3392358720302582, -0.3762008547782898, 0.7633722424507141, -0.635456919670105, 1.100146770477295, 0.07863979786634445, 0.6842250823974609, -0.8680607676506042, 0.14182379841804504, 0.2953338921070099, 0.5961179137229919, -0.43896323442459106, -0.3902241587638855, -0.3428584635257721, 0.5882053971290588, -0.09722255170345306, -0.33106815814971924, -0.4729105830192566, 1.4079952239990234, -0.11982850730419159, 0.1661970168352127, 0.4321900010108948, -0.26076003909111023, -1.4745302200317383, -0.34471794962882996, -1.182390570640564, -0.02041638270020485, -0.17525869607925415, 0.11000079661607742, 0.7429569959640503, -0.6630449295043945, 0.8642280101776123, 0.24131958186626434, -0.37613531947135925, 0.36560022830963135, -0.30477556586265564, 0.4342367649078369, 0.7572417259216309, -0.5062007904052734, -0.9904002547264099, 0.33241432905197144, -0.5695223212242126, -0.08678378164768219, -0.5945708751678467, 0.11997617036104202, 0.5366913676261902, -0.5884962677955627, -0.24850700795650482, -0.3400578796863556, -0.37986454367637634, -0.2179545760154724, 0.3309492766857147, -0.3649936616420746, 0.3105410039424896, 0.671094536781311, 0.39217904210090637, -0.14575722813606262, -0.2679912745952606, 0.8986659646034241, 0.48037925362586975, 0.09327308088541031, 0.545022189617157, -0.2209564745426178, -0.42360368371009827, 0.49839746952056885, 0.23598717153072357, 0.18428285419940948, 0.15931755304336548, 0.5893489122390747, 0.5961005687713623, 0.27965593338012695, 0.12455786764621735, -0.5410383343696594, -0.7018615007400513, 0.057448554784059525, 0.008148502558469772, -0.8203180432319641, -0.5122667551040649, 0.4928407669067383, -0.11978621780872345, -1.1208171844482422, 0.14173518121242523, -0.5556836128234863, -0.2577402591705322, 0.24646803736686707, -1.0278983116149902, -0.10276056081056595, -0.36355236172676086, -0.22452907264232635, -0.6904891729354858, -0.05330812558531761, 0.10426484793424606, 0.19738902151584625, 0.06483330577611923, -0.37372732162475586, 0.8039303421974182, 0.3358127176761627, 0.7046127915382385, -0.46584564447402954, 0.39805367588996887, -0.3519222140312195, -0.2243644893169403, -0.0708220973610878, -0.6721718311309814, -0.270675927400589, 0.2412688285112381, 0.8363757729530334, -0.24586397409439087, 0.8627805113792419, -0.4968523681163788, -0.5846796631813049, -0.6436700820922852, -0.2298208773136139, -0.4087798297405243, 1.174974799156189, -0.5050899982452393, 0.29149866104125977, -0.6150071024894714, -0.4657267928123474, 0.48938530683517456, -0.6185308694839478, 1.2636693716049194, -1.400370717048645, 0.2692379951477051, 0.25903579592704773, -0.34605297446250916, 0.23597022891044617, 0.18840573728084564, 0.36673662066459656, 0.40333759784698486, 0.2839341163635254, 0.655879557132721, -0.13731104135513306, -0.6738391518592834, -0.16763955354690552, 1.2699345350265503, 1.2602136135101318, 1.178275465965271, 0.4803003668785095, -0.16237491369247437, -0.3046016991138458, -0.32804232835769653, -0.4979531764984131, -0.11518999189138412, -0.6820510625839233, -0.40077897906303406, 0.0950048416852951, -0.1729413866996765, 0.3457825481891632, 0.20263715088367462, 0.08498044312000275, 0.5634723901748657, 0.5395532846450806, 1.0486087799072266, -0.26329803466796875, 0.2894035577774048, 0.8561474084854126, -0.47575628757476807, -0.4522283971309662, -1.1910579204559326, 0.5853826999664307, -0.1456434577703476, -0.14204275608062744, -0.3104472756385803, -0.6114678978919983, -0.10197504609823227, 0.02186664752662182, 0.5763363242149353, 0.2305615395307541, -0.5255680680274963, 0.829589307308197, -0.5222495198249817, 0.23407447338104248, 0.02307603880763054, -0.5843819379806519, 1.0399349927902222, 0.8293514847755432, -0.2910194993019104, -0.920440137386322, 0.003647824050858617, -0.22798974812030792, 0.4555794298648834, -0.10229028016328812, -0.6198667883872986, -0.9363647103309631, -0.701017439365387, -0.13180966675281525, -1.3315716981887817, 0.13235749304294586, 1.0837708711624146, -0.5962154865264893, -0.1379784643650055, -0.48396217823028564, -0.1578153818845749, 0.20385974645614624, -0.10911834239959717, -0.17577658593654633, 0.2827965319156647, -0.14709711074829102, -0.04085935279726982, 0.5579119324684143, -0.036274753510951996, 0.03326895833015442, -0.27764949202537537, 0.287306547164917, 0.0627065896987915, -0.02654307521879673, -0.4847353994846344, 0.09329716116189957, -0.7356178760528564, -0.4098784327507019, 0.7774338722229004, 0.08108164370059967, 0.2577497959136963, 0.603364109992981, 0.418582558631897, -0.24803297221660614, -0.16458216309547424, -0.08375042676925659, 0.13744762539863586, 0.8967064023017883, 0.7427346110343933, 0.17108334600925446, 0.18621757626533508, 0.3386571705341339, 0.33330947160720825, -0.3949376344680786, 0.1519957333803177, 0.8820706605911255, 0.3591310679912567, -0.5485836863517761, 0.10787941515445709, -0.6673066020011902, -0.5856426954269409, 0.9920870661735535, -0.741896390914917, 0.5966606736183167, 0.10180304199457169, -0.19774915277957916, -0.21385310590267181, 0.0034573052544146776, -0.8211328387260437, 0.2727654278278351, -0.02006913721561432, -0.7663688659667969, 0.3956955373287201, -1.3963271379470825, 0.13986854255199432, 0.06981243193149567, 0.3460158407688141, -0.41917988657951355, 0.058535341173410416, 0.7437348365783691, 0.026254160329699516, 0.9521810412406921, -0.7495424151420593, 0.482446551322937, -0.7485142946243286, 0.19520139694213867, -0.5149493217468262, 0.006569487974047661, -0.23380792140960693, -0.5034050345420837, -0.12373744696378708, -0.1634393036365509, -0.16547495126724243, -0.1357959359884262, 0.26715928316116333, 0.024164779111742973, -0.04402953013777733, 0.5590842962265015, -0.847540557384491, 0.6134596467018127, -0.17974695563316345, -0.1549340933561325, -0.09332837164402008, 1.5201376676559448, 0.40514427423477173, 0.4979489743709564, -0.34827640652656555, -0.9705860614776611, 0.49278756976127625, -0.821991503238678, 0.40102437138557434, -0.9651727676391602, -0.6122327446937561, -0.17989417910575867, -1.0011982917785645, 0.33215734362602234, 0.541923999786377, -0.15472155809402466, -0.0019561464432626963, -0.020741144195199013, -0.42332911491394043, 0.5518606901168823, -0.06794439256191254, -0.2081095576286316, -0.7343123555183411, -0.5684732794761658, -0.9202748537063599, 0.7594662308692932, 0.0036280073691159487, 0.167594313621521, 0.016353052109479904, -0.05114045366644859, -0.046842191368341446, 0.6906513571739197, 0.30053389072418213, 0.13663558661937714, -0.03533108904957771, 0.1648816615343094, 0.028266655281186104, 0.8965786695480347, -0.3598785996437073, 0.5628917217254639, -0.9801912903785706, 0.21222545206546783, -0.6079052686691284, -0.40090665221214294, 0.30255401134490967, 0.042403075844049454, 1.1446387767791748, -0.7396846413612366, 0.7519338726997375, 0.19502709805965424, 0.23654711246490479, 0.5571805238723755, 0.10098395496606827, -0.7540464997291565, -0.886160135269165, -0.5586642622947693, -0.5426262617111206, 0.7693345546722412, -0.1267707347869873, -0.27646541595458984, -0.7377427220344543, -0.8333433270454407, -0.04396158084273338, -0.10960612446069717, 0.9625999927520752, 0.582706868648529, -0.34743183851242065, 0.042925309389829636, 0.543056845664978, -0.3367477357387543, -0.7627416849136353, -0.19090430438518524, 0.015764471143484116, 0.19524118304252625, -0.09911085665225983, -0.2953473627567291, -1.161157250404358, -0.7541584968566895, -0.5589215755462646, 0.25292643904685974, 0.01488441601395607, -0.046129073947668076, 0.8096832036972046, -0.09545399248600006, -0.2993067502975464, -0.7463365793228149, 0.02938942238688469, 0.10072598606348038, 0.5052813291549683, 0.7056803107261658, 0.2123057246208191, -0.20122617483139038, -0.11229123920202255, 0.9047632217407227, -0.38935479521751404, -0.5544739961624146, 0.8640344142913818, -0.4543241858482361, -0.6666648983955383, 0.18070784211158752, -0.056887321174144745, -0.6737931966781616, -0.3989209234714508, -0.5891206860542297, -0.4400656521320343, -0.5401654839515686, -0.4507196545600891, -0.2972739040851593, -0.06710367649793625, -0.703048586845398, 0.6718053817749023, 0.7050352692604065, -0.44481489062309265, -0.2583380937576294, -0.23958179354667664, -0.35018390417099, 0.021153248846530914, 0.1276904046535492, 0.9017099738121033, -0.34385791420936584, -0.5522751808166504, -0.21828442811965942, -0.47260549664497375, -0.18413539230823517, 0.13692481815814972, 0.11503545939922333, -0.44048938155174255, 0.1027478575706482, 0.21553391218185425, 0.3230253756046295, 0.10879416018724442, 0.7057670950889587, 0.26130831241607666, -0.3227007985115051, -0.011006788350641727, -0.5560276508331299, -0.47428998351097107, -0.2727188467979431, 0.4873160123825073, 0.7664347290992737, -0.2967878580093384, 0.2836820185184479, -0.39392396807670593, -0.32101231813430786, -0.35148105025291443, -1.389059066772461, 0.07631231844425201, -1.1204721927642822, -0.0420285128057003, -0.7653142213821411, -0.5135868787765503, 0.19982556998729706, 0.39636871218681335, 0.1610974669456482, 0.3581039607524872, -0.7455655932426453, 0.2701769769191742, 0.4481446444988251, 0.51484614610672, -0.3443385362625122, -0.4416636824607849, -0.7812912464141846, -0.3933289051055908, -0.7429416179656982, -0.10125735402107239, 0.4283595085144043, 0.11284810304641724, -0.5643384456634521, 0.3811430037021637, -0.010943550616502762, 0.8415604829788208, -0.9865998029708862, -0.49658772349357605, 0.05279083922505379, -0.5747561454772949, -0.7943678498268127, 0.10365132987499237, -0.5300483107566833, 0.5526840090751648, -0.04778536781668663, -0.07399814575910568, -0.7904788255691528, 0.25204965472221375, -0.8535013794898987, -0.4174667298793793, 0.5488300323486328, 0.4159151315689087, -0.5729162693023682, -0.19603651762008667, 0.5514411330223083, -0.1262168288230896, -1.0546599626541138, 0.6620527505874634, -0.4147343337535858, -0.18444201350212097, -0.08023443073034286, 0.4369617700576782, 0.4718873202800751, 0.6991544961929321, -0.19110706448554993, 0.18652848899364471, -0.37917178869247437, -0.12775926291942596, 0.31211793422698975, 0.1479039490222931, -0.5208196640014648, -0.45909664034843445, 0.6506572961807251, -1.0900044441223145, 0.6177856922149658, 0.784292995929718, -0.45707467198371887, 0.17826038599014282, -0.35026904940605164, -0.2532944977283478, -0.3134715259075165, -0.28648942708969116, -0.6752604246139526, 0.5945614576339722, -0.09111498296260834, -0.43856242299079895, -0.35754695534706116, -0.6656995415687561, -0.2634594142436981, 0.331045538187027, -1.118896722793579, -0.28905704617500305, -0.06088312715291977, -0.04914364963769913, -0.3208619952201843, -0.06776565313339233, -0.2668682932853699, 0.045901648700237274, 0.20449198782444, -0.10494356602430344, 0.30015841126441956, 0.059918567538261414, -0.26788607239723206, 0.20361724495887756, -0.5587217211723328, -0.5050649046897888, -0.28281471133232117, 0.7828035354614258, -0.6911863684654236, -0.5561306476593018, 0.2554716169834137, 0.19308137893676758, 0.5657166242599487, 0.4067458212375641, -0.4359620213508606, 0.20749463140964508, 0.3804781138896942, -0.10875172913074493, 0.018597237765789032, -0.08358971774578094, -0.9564641118049622, 0.49124473333358765, 0.1355481892824173, -0.4504312574863434, 0.826927125453949, -0.011209676042199135, 0.4461419880390167, -0.16997037827968597, -0.4415871500968933, 0.6477378606796265, 0.29046735167503357, -0.9736369848251343, 0.8740163445472717, -0.24161334335803986, 0.23347455263137817, -0.08270154148340225, -0.134982168674469, 0.19324685633182526, 0.42542219161987305, 0.36120420694351196, 0.750348687171936, 0.6539682149887085, -0.0062115928158164024, 0.7588480710983276, 0.26698312163352966, -0.02583889663219452, 0.12820535898208618, 0.23497305810451508, 0.37764832377433777, 0.7616509795188904, 0.07287421077489853, 0.1474536806344986, -0.19499945640563965, -0.07912134379148483, -0.08913806080818176, -0.1829579472541809, -0.5752377510070801, -0.07177641242742538, 0.30487823486328125, 0.12485376745462418, -0.5365353226661682, -0.3889227509498596, -0.11933162808418274, 0.2971310019493103, 0.09899281710386276, -0.18334834277629852, 0.02152436226606369, -0.05757023021578789, 0.445827841758728, 0.27451881766319275, 0.46952566504478455, 1.0253777503967285, 0.04927389323711395, 0.36587586998939514, 0.13384029269218445, 0.5689911246299744, 0.8837437033653259, 0.04486361891031265, 0.7674600481987, -0.8674947023391724, -0.5123608112335205, 0.896308183670044, -0.8415870070457458, 0.09142912924289703, -0.7549276947975159, -0.5079239010810852, -0.5887097716331482, -0.6276360750198364, -0.19034241139888763, -0.41827645897865295, 0.6706293821334839, 0.8429312705993652, -0.1488686352968216, 0.35456883907318115, 0.5946297645568848, -0.5138862133026123, 0.8732890486717224, 0.7269382476806641, -0.3422621786594391, 0.1303173452615738, 0.9894759654998779, 1.5302082300186157, 0.2666739821434021, 0.5893142223358154, 0.3687903881072998, -0.5744697451591492, 0.586906909942627, 0.18695764243602753, -0.24148935079574585, 0.9152883291244507, -0.685314953327179, -0.44823384284973145, 0.3810097277164459, 0.21053968369960785, -0.3771120011806488, -0.38809797167778015, -0.1014283150434494, -0.15506745874881744, -0.480959415435791, -0.5759330987930298, 1.4115478992462158, 0.6295338273048401, -0.06306327134370804, -0.11843697726726532, 0.11579427868127823, -0.7956969141960144, -0.6806579828262329, -0.4363149404525757, 0.043209005147218704, 0.10482744127511978, 0.09839028865098953, -0.5270224809646606, -0.5684376955032349, -0.08253518491983414, -0.8532924056053162, 0.4811076819896698, -0.8243945837020874, 0.7597722411155701, 0.28218233585357666, 0.6865401268005371, -0.24796517193317413, -0.6583729386329651, -0.47292113304138184, 0.13657627999782562, 0.959939181804657, 0.4366409182548523, -0.12229646742343903, 0.8432863354682922, 0.49404680728912354, -0.37020862102508545, -0.260635644197464, 0.971479594707489, -0.590379536151886, 1.247478723526001, -0.2554372549057007, 0.374729186296463, -0.06637822836637497, -0.3222544491291046, 0.9121543169021606, 0.07428597658872604, 0.4904945492744446, -0.5130999684333801, -0.03997279703617096, 0.24295909702777863, -0.9215545058250427, 0.6467675566673279, -0.988409161567688, 0.052826277911663055, 0.09265199303627014, 0.5583488345146179, -0.2487308531999588, -0.6277742385864258, 3.978231430053711, 1.0190972089767456, 0.6168163418769836, -0.5049983263015747, 0.597625195980072, 0.21142329275608063, 0.18494102358818054, -0.5417162775993347, 0.6025285720825195, -0.15779229998588562, -0.254033625125885, 0.7579672336578369, 0.652120053768158, 0.0511765331029892, 0.027166035026311874, 0.8061355352401733, -1.019860029220581, 0.2345951348543167, 0.45034492015838623, -0.7192274332046509, -0.5330930352210999, 0.16450874507427216, 0.2507496774196625, 0.5927566289901733, 0.2663135230541229, -0.014109824784100056, 0.4304150938987732, -0.8149550557136536, -0.7217172980308533, -0.23545090854167938, -0.2382293939590454, -1.1558005809783936, -0.18942978978157043, -0.768181324005127, -0.6036806702613831, 0.26233983039855957, 0.6377860307693481, -0.7681758999824524, 0.276992529630661, 0.5789141654968262, -0.3470451533794403, 0.2920388877391815, 0.3332340121269226, 0.28447481989860535, -0.7553427815437317, 0.7756422162055969, -0.5515159368515015, 0.6985141634941101, 0.14207734167575836, -0.8663679361343384, 0.27739250659942627, -0.5981258153915405, 1.5843744277954102, -1.060136079788208, -1.1093618869781494, -0.3358272612094879, -0.5568492412567139, -0.5673632025718689, 0.1804487258195877, -0.03726935386657715, 0.859348714351654, 0.03363010287284851, 0.20029541850090027, 0.40782028436660767, -0.5774469375610352, 0.48906266689300537, 0.32857945561408997, 0.012345412746071815, 0.4197041392326355, 0.08002535253763199, -0.2639063596725464, -0.27616405487060547, -0.23838819563388824, 0.006991394329816103, 0.4953083097934723, -0.17833323776721954, -0.11851708590984344, 0.852540135383606, 0.3426903188228607, 0.49741801619529724, -0.32763269543647766, 0.05631224811077118, 0.09042419493198395, 0.1346103847026825, -0.15012270212173462, 0.5319329500198364, -0.7063783407211304, -0.5053657293319702, 0.11259462684392929, 0.489290326833725, 0.16740064322948456, 1.402471899986267, 0.21158455312252045, -0.7778280973434448, -0.48417824506759644 ]
Monte Carlo Calculation of the Surface Free Energy for the 2d 7-state Potts Model, and an Estimate for 4d SU(3) Gauge Theory
Using the recently proposed multicanonical ensemble, we perform Monte Carlo simulation for the 2d 7-state Potts model and calculate its surface free energy density (surface tension) to be $2 f^s = 0.0241 \pm 0.0010$. This is an order of magnitude smaller than other estimates in the recent literature. Relying on existing Monte Carlo data, we also give a preliminary estimate for the surface tension of 4d SU(3) lattice gauge theory with $L_t=2$.
Wolfhard Janke, Bernd A. Berg, and Mohammad Katoot
hep-lat
February
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9202001
hep-lat/9202002
[ 0.17069821059703827, 0.11759260296821594, 0.32227689027786255, 0.3680783808231354, 0.2350635975599289, 0.06494229286909103, -0.3785223066806793, -0.16353486478328705, -0.7598810195922852, 1.8088749647140503, 0.6197832822799683, 0.27480342984199524, 0.1622948795557022, -0.5071678161621094, 0.058850642293691635, 0.5699999332427979, -0.23609353601932526, -0.9772878289222717, -1.0858503580093384, 0.6332507729530334, 0.39620518684387207, 0.016214750707149506, -1.0216490030288696, -0.30808767676353455, 0.35232216119766235, 0.7312124371528625, -0.09011930972337723, 0.5409904718399048, 1.05254328250885, 0.9369081258773804, 1.2432831525802612, -0.38380175828933716, -0.36148801445961, -0.6946209669113159, -0.2570195198059082, -0.1055702492594719, 0.39183321595191956, -0.42027583718299866, 0.659329354763031, -0.035586632788181305, 0.7123477458953857, -0.09301389753818512, 0.39216452836990356, 0.02210293337702751, -0.8138672113418579, 0.0317244678735733, -0.42232605814933777, -0.4211764633655548, -0.6380749940872192, -1.48344087600708, 0.033655934035778046, 0.18610407412052155, 0.3420643210411072, -0.783943772315979, -0.3234124779701233, -0.3998769223690033, 0.27295324206352234, 0.47425615787506104, -0.09805148839950562, 0.15959976613521576, 0.7184467315673828, 0.1566360741853714, 0.5716812610626221, -1.2032808065414429, 0.25504305958747864, 0.735363781452179, -0.18351560831069946, 0.23489691317081451, 0.22766856849193573, -0.42955282330513, -0.31647101044654846, -0.3750303089618683, -0.5422071814537048, 0.4117012321949005, -0.3825089633464813, 0.7994473576545715, 0.4497199058532715, -0.7202088236808777, -0.9544622898101807, -0.09368641674518585, 0.7514462471008301, -0.1682513803243637, -0.7122356295585632, 0.4664493799209595, -0.4249514937400818, -0.6332615613937378, 0.050592049956321716, -0.2626197636127472, 0.395395964384079, 0.26785674691200256, 0.26617634296417236, 0.5504499077796936, 0.40899693965911865, -0.280583918094635, 0.8400093913078308, 0.8764892816543579, 0.11805944889783859, 0.4538608193397522, 0.4499496519565582, 0.575596809387207, 0.21655669808387756, 0.7056151628494263, -0.4948345422744751, 0.589839518070221, -0.3959130048751831, 1.092779278755188, 0.2843760550022125, -0.3489771783351898, -0.6066017150878906, -1.3262556791305542, 0.35164928436279297, -0.4428255259990692, 0.8603118658065796, 0.6181143522262573, 0.6532205939292908, 0.46655160188674927, 0.14199623465538025, -0.06476433575153351, -0.614764928817749, -0.48288729786872864, 0.8522632718086243, 0.29193517565727234, 0.8829886317253113, 0.7986178398132324, 0.19286754727363586, -0.36423173546791077, 0.13155198097229004, 0.6673452258110046, -0.39828455448150635, 0.5172226428985596, -0.014427371323108673, -0.06913556903600693, -0.6442525386810303, 0.2745048701763153, 0.20155563950538635, -0.008715867064893246, -0.5855346322059631, -0.31657102704048157, -0.17122556269168854, -0.7267615795135498, 0.861747682094574, -0.37445738911628723, -0.575639545917511, 0.9154203534126282, 0.2385789453983307, 0.06172069534659386, 0.30621781945228577, 0.18825873732566833, -0.33126401901245117, 0.30325013399124146, -0.9765756726264954, 0.5020521879196167, -0.38218802213668823, -0.7898818850517273, 0.09647701680660248, 0.5071701407432556, -0.4021080434322357, 0.3430822491645813, -0.36971914768218994, -0.5615884065628052, 0.6240211725234985, -0.16866032779216766, -0.7855368852615356, 0.4527457654476166, -0.5658556222915649, 0.3970869183540344, -0.8667970299720764, 0.07634804397821426, 0.06749050319194794, -0.49965381622314453, -0.06777791678905487, 0.3923009932041168, -0.41364049911499023, 0.41429463028907776, 0.45910194516181946, 0.647720992565155, 0.42719680070877075, -0.012818461284041405, 0.22086457908153534, 0.35809385776519775, -0.6321160197257996, -0.5185209512710571, 0.10416220128536224, 0.31341567635536194, -0.9558507204055786, -0.5094982385635376, -0.2328748255968094, -0.14571447670459747, -0.2223963886499405, -0.15477095544338226, -0.6259182095527649, 0.41866761445999146, -0.5682705640792847, 0.7788636088371277, -0.2963777482509613, -0.26358380913734436, -1.0456428527832031, -0.21388579905033112, -0.6780890226364136, -1.0027003288269043, -0.5164095759391785, -0.12097059190273285, -0.18610234558582306, 0.5574644207954407, -1.429060697555542, 0.7912782430648804, 0.806368887424469, 0.4469062089920044, -0.4902615547180176, 0.1736321747303009, 0.21384407579898834, -0.200117826461792, 0.735600471496582, -0.6795480251312256, 0.20296832919120789, -0.2721395194530487, 0.0759940892457962, 0.2650476396083832, 0.7611299753189087, 0.22169572114944458, 0.5011030435562134, -0.14943240582942963, -0.13124783337116241, 1.0866261720657349, 0.4511525630950928, -0.7232056856155396, 0.15673254430294037, 0.5533398389816284, 0.2774810492992401, 0.39570045471191406, -0.3241618871688843, 0.9035918712615967, -0.12939995527267456, -0.2896328568458557, 0.24854598939418793, 0.5309643149375916, 0.6782442927360535, 0.7730472087860107, 0.09860404580831528, 0.659769594669342, -0.13148482143878937, 0.08282295614480972, 0.46649885177612305, 0.04692075401544571, 0.03169703483581543, 0.6746129393577576, -0.12255008518695831, -0.4315433204174042, -0.39741748571395874, 1.0853044986724854, -0.07291343063116074, 0.7684738636016846, -0.026129746809601784, 0.11125203222036362, -1.1884907484054565, -0.008138523437082767, -0.5560108423233032, 0.7217361330986023, -0.21834276616573334, -0.23570381104946136, -0.21619783341884613, -0.05453683063387871, 0.19724033772945404, -0.3769075274467468, -0.6110782623291016, 0.456733763217926, -0.32299041748046875, 0.4473300576210022, 0.5969043374061584, 0.03487982600927353, -0.9969894289970398, 0.07238192111253738, -1.020534873008728, -0.593559205532074, -0.5502345561981201, -0.2918439507484436, 0.964879035949707, -0.2951500415802002, 0.5869331955909729, 0.35516947507858276, -0.591560959815979, 0.3401356041431427, 0.05825137719511986, 0.8609411120414734, 0.2007083296775818, 0.44082000851631165, -0.8845470547676086, 0.2710844874382019, -0.6781712770462036, -0.2296893149614334, 0.23954765498638153, -0.22861208021640778, 0.66898512840271, -0.5018441677093506, 0.10271689295768738, -0.07215423882007599, -0.41300666332244873, 0.4822181165218353, -0.5085902214050293, -0.7640981078147888, 0.25058797001838684, 0.5313852429389954, -0.6202646493911743, -0.4563762843608856, -1.3885775804519653, 0.9759657979011536, 0.41535866260528564, -1.087838053703308, 0.7486960291862488, 0.47876009345054626, -0.47741180658340454, 0.16049496829509735, -0.27557477355003357, 0.3365642726421356, -0.4499943256378174, 1.6861399412155151, 1.044174313545227, -0.24843008816242218, 0.038323115557432175, -0.6628954410552979, -0.17473652958869934, 0.3347042500972748, 0.184942364692688, -0.487758606672287, -0.051822230219841, 0.8408998250961304, 0.5477291941642761, -0.6164807677268982, 0.18964523077011108, -0.7133076190948486, -0.8225292563438416, 0.06561307609081268, -0.33043092489242554, -0.04157952219247818, -0.18005280196666718, -0.013938444666564465, -0.8244136571884155, -0.1472184658050537, -0.08292970061302185, 0.6992833614349365, 0.4350557327270508, -0.3104465901851654, -0.11059984564781189, 0.5779057145118713, 0.627976655960083, 0.23445555567741394, 0.11366720497608185, -0.33847472071647644, -0.33735933899879456, 0.7841050624847412, -0.7368488311767578, 0.21025435626506805, 0.4323303997516632, 0.46098312735557556, -0.4450385570526123, -0.1075441911816597, -0.5029120445251465, -0.24971620738506317, -0.7037280201911926, -0.5909873247146606, 0.0634402260184288, 0.4823225736618042, -0.2384209930896759, -0.1722944974899292, -0.39273765683174133, -0.2958609461784363, 0.45948272943496704, -0.2519759237766266, 0.7676995992660522, -1.2234196662902832, 0.13678425550460815, -0.016616299748420715, -0.4618937075138092, -0.010369961149990559, -0.35255831480026245, 0.13983364403247833, 0.36821889877319336, -0.2856605648994446, 0.6184506416320801, -0.8116850256919861, -0.840621829032898, -0.13423237204551697, 1.1325682401657104, 0.9596275091171265, 1.1960419416427612, -0.011717463843524456, -0.8621664047241211, 0.28274744749069214, -0.6843163371086121, 0.016031814739108086, -0.2669526934623718, -0.36008042097091675, -0.070847287774086, -0.009558373130857944, 0.1523817628622055, 0.36887800693511963, 0.4595440924167633, 0.6633602976799011, 0.28607431054115295, 0.11292136460542679, 0.07754529267549515, 0.6381130814552307, 0.31399959325790405, 0.8769076466560364, -0.3030620813369751, 0.38875213265419006, -1.1750710010528564, 0.5093199014663696, 0.40211883187294006, 0.3014896512031555, -0.22268928587436676, -0.6912261247634888, 0.07037921249866486, -0.7458596229553223, 0.9231315851211548, 0.21490056812763214, -0.46982917189598083, 0.060927864164114, 0.195296972990036, -0.4691688120365143, 0.4927024245262146, 0.06422161310911179, 0.6006197333335876, -0.11375372111797333, 0.5437812805175781, -0.6666901111602783, -0.2467602789402008, -0.2723405957221985, 0.20313005149364471, 0.11825275421142578, -0.6305698752403259, -0.33919695019721985, -0.9227648973464966, 0.41765087842941284, -0.4056136906147003, 0.4849003851413727, 0.579627513885498, 0.2996530532836914, -0.1953863650560379, -0.5267263054847717, -0.39432650804519653, 0.5347539186477661, -0.4581320285797119, -0.6029583215713501, 0.18184712529182434, 0.29871857166290283, -0.30251285433769226, 0.7897025942802429, -0.3243875801563263, -0.661891758441925, 0.08926081657409668, -0.2499823123216629, 0.16881224513053894, 0.09344091266393661, -0.813892662525177, -0.30404040217399597, -0.2731824815273285, -0.30969300866127014, 0.5558410882949829, 0.03873156011104584, 0.703328013420105, -0.10317125916481018, 0.3006899952888489, -0.3919372260570526, -0.0014064189745113254, 0.5318242311477661, 0.07709929347038269, 0.8436025381088257, 0.9974439740180969, 0.4249979853630066, 0.33452337980270386, 0.4305959939956665, -0.13223914802074432, 0.015637686476111412, 0.6445001363754272, -0.38459640741348267, -0.5180409550666809, -0.42173296213150024, -0.1944057047367096, -0.8995435833930969, -0.6352182626724243, -0.15049543976783752, -0.2468961626291275, 0.958707869052887, -0.32420843839645386, -0.6293111443519592, -0.5723382830619812, -0.41615065932273865, -0.3637049198150635, 0.39360371232032776, 0.05659189447760582, -0.48717138171195984, 0.5094268321990967, -0.3335340917110443, 0.09936181455850601, 0.08576741069555283, -0.5355446934700012, -0.4183776080608368, 0.2433149814605713, 0.23197504878044128, -0.08355166018009186, -0.17049524188041687, -1.0453276634216309, 0.6226198673248291, -0.503808319568634, -0.26227062940597534, -0.13836222887039185, -0.30882444977760315, -0.04647156596183777, -0.46915698051452637, 0.496823787689209, -0.5786518454551697, 0.013745466247200966, -0.21944643557071686, -0.057857923209667206, 0.08350428193807602, -0.11434512585401535, -0.07502462714910507, 0.19281695783138275, 0.4709705412387848, 0.5805331468582153, -1.1669068336486816, 0.24123425781726837, 0.3102026879787445, -0.351357102394104, 0.15013214945793152, -0.12984329462051392, -0.23890481889247894, 0.17604483664035797, -0.6011091470718384, 0.008374842815101147, -0.5290275812149048, -0.0913054421544075, -0.6159744262695312, -0.3352968096733093, 0.23050615191459656, 0.24060097336769104, 0.37886232137680054, -0.09601035714149475, -0.5465922355651855, -0.60232013463974, 0.38200244307518005, 0.09450969845056534, -0.7492457032203674, -0.2746148109436035, 0.05676015838980675, -0.1365867704153061, 1.036698341369629, -0.7073001265525818, 0.0208585187792778, 0.41105228662490845, 0.3917558789253235, 0.019296826794743538, 0.5832500457763672, -0.1832266002893448, -0.34642162919044495, -0.033561259508132935, 0.38447442650794983, 0.5995566844940186, 0.5275551080703735, -0.5504796504974365, 0.6187185645103455, -1.1744450330734253, 0.9819512367248535, -0.6147783994674683, -0.4746154546737671, -0.0721854493021965, 0.23202937841415405, 0.6491754055023193, -0.5855544209480286, 0.4205780625343323, 0.8280199766159058, 0.08175995200872421, 0.3057488799095154, 0.022195642814040184, -0.18808777630329132, -0.5492113828659058, -0.7597618699073792, -0.9363345503807068, 0.6601438522338867, 0.14875544607639313, -0.01579454354941845, -0.8270307779312134, -0.695038378238678, 0.3116461932659149, -0.052645646035671234, 0.5720869302749634, 0.4515801668167114, 0.6839820146560669, 0.3201686441898346, 0.47463423013687134, -0.08274894207715988, -0.6915338635444641, -0.16208742558956146, 0.3319035470485687, -0.13033419847488403, 0.05026806518435478, -0.4610154926776886, -0.6716594696044922, -0.88608717918396, -0.2388148456811905, -0.079371377825737, -0.007797421887516975, 0.01473739743232727, 0.5362110137939453, -0.485086590051651, -0.4822857677936554, -0.21016408503055573, 0.23595885932445526, -0.0061168549582362175, -0.23642674088478088, 0.36703044176101685, -0.35620754957199097, 0.2879147231578827, -0.1901542842388153, 0.30048269033432007, -0.8922787308692932, -0.5451886653900146, 0.6476501226425171, -0.5756235122680664, -0.4902702271938324, 0.27866920828819275, 0.3853515088558197, -0.346828818321228, -0.46129730343818665, -1.0751837491989136, -0.019330410286784172, 0.3045492470264435, -0.7113065719604492, 0.31535372138023376, 0.320233553647995, -0.46155643463134766, 0.8856452107429504, 0.5209333896636963, -0.4138045907020569, 0.20611417293548584, 0.18488377332687378, -0.7663009762763977, -0.750578761100769, -0.1102311760187149, 1.0496958494186401, -0.3547535240650177, -0.8144017457962036, -0.21515004336833954, 0.6344548463821411, -0.49967172741889954, 0.03297401964664459, 0.26154839992523193, -0.1882845163345337, -0.04567931964993477, 0.4541563093662262, 0.32737892866134644, -0.4971192479133606, 0.590890109539032, 0.14938050508499146, 0.5623013973236084, -0.17350482940673828, -0.4843347668647766, -0.0012480831937864423, 0.5993981957435608, 0.13907350599765778, 1.1040042638778687, 0.009944900870323181, -0.3312397301197052, -0.10535641014575958, -0.28590157628059387, -0.3705008327960968, -1.4197561740875244, -0.33904993534088135, -1.058925747871399, -0.39095643162727356, -0.5552929043769836, -0.6117732524871826, 0.30717405676841736, 0.45424404740333557, -0.16622382402420044, 0.23382294178009033, -0.6780791282653809, 0.035116590559482574, 0.077241912484169, 0.14537447690963745, -0.08334299176931381, -0.6316266059875488, -0.3284136652946472, -0.2718992233276367, -0.4509199559688568, -0.7374555468559265, 0.06206562742590904, 0.11334570497274399, -0.3689633309841156, 0.3481768071651459, -0.5181629061698914, -0.007082983385771513, -0.6131579875946045, -0.713287889957428, 0.12316158413887024, -0.25143855810165405, -1.0797746181488037, 1.024134874343872, -0.17031729221343994, 0.15836699306964874, 0.3306916654109955, -0.15051309764385223, -0.3981640636920929, 0.2690240442752838, -0.746039628982544, -0.15876922011375427, 0.08317974209785461, -0.31422489881515503, -0.08165442198514938, -1.1465303897857666, -0.2747289836406708, 0.010811331681907177, -0.7997094988822937, -0.025446049869060516, -0.4108712673187256, 0.5089463591575623, -0.5132736563682556, 0.06191640719771385, 0.47566500306129456, -0.011854528449475765, 0.2919297516345978, 0.7434453964233398, -0.7257750034332275, -0.11029095947742462, -0.09555493295192719, 0.19478921592235565, 0.12426329404115677, 0.0846249908208847, 0.03416914865374565, -0.7637258768081665, 0.7202540040016174, -0.15731173753738403, 0.10609853267669678, -0.09811871498823166, -0.17445717751979828, -0.40325096249580383, -0.3319461941719055, -0.3701004981994629, -0.6781976819038391, 0.6220300793647766, -0.19583816826343536, -0.10026417672634125, -0.05692436173558235, -0.7855219841003418, -0.4793037474155426, 0.5932607650756836, -0.7765610814094543, -0.2323305904865265, 0.16287195682525635, -0.12547212839126587, 0.15394900739192963, 0.7006446123123169, -0.14177726209163666, 0.39882567524909973, 0.21890318393707275, 0.220058873295784, 0.21156850457191467, -0.3259436786174774, -0.4951447546482086, 0.2169468104839325, -0.8754472136497498, -0.3879985213279724, -0.5431255102157593, 0.7102984189987183, -0.8501222133636475, -0.6644707322120667, -0.47468701004981995, 0.8745250105857849, 0.40067073702812195, -0.2768770754337311, -0.24774757027626038, -0.5075271725654602, 0.38297271728515625, -0.9567701816558838, -0.17091651260852814, -0.08610837161540985, -0.5330177545547485, 0.4547249674797058, 0.07642403990030289, -1.264070749282837, 0.1417849361896515, 0.4409860074520111, 0.24093887209892273, 0.5593236684799194, -0.18194228410720825, 0.7742224931716919, 0.0663539245724678, -0.22164572775363922, 0.5450939536094666, -0.17966929078102112, 0.10693813115358353, 0.3076976239681244, -0.2832831144332886, -0.08087338507175446, 0.5218791365623474, 0.3246830999851227, 0.4530578553676605, 0.27140602469444275, 0.25802749395370483, 0.5733395218849182, 0.5012792944908142, -0.040692657232284546, 0.2465205192565918, 0.44624489545822144, 0.03616464138031006, 0.44476863741874695, -0.27373889088630676, -0.47940942645072937, 0.07311157137155533, 0.2382718324661255, -0.08760123699903488, 0.3360099196434021, -0.16460472345352173, -0.26827821135520935, 0.5448411703109741, 0.24860796332359314, -0.4974902272224426, -0.5703967809677124, -0.09427676349878311, 0.07042302191257477, -0.09369402378797531, 0.2963709235191345, 0.19319859147071838, 0.8142004013061523, 0.6007869839668274, -0.30002644658088684, -0.20127736032009125, 0.5243027210235596, -0.11569012701511383, 0.8762293457984924, 0.5339454412460327, 0.4941891133785248, 0.1386169195175171, 0.35599249601364136, 0.27143269777297974, -1.1026824712753296, -0.11913605779409409, 0.3419399559497833, -1.126355528831482, 0.18322518467903137, 0.08148366212844849, -0.1550632119178772, -0.36604994535446167, -0.5186628103256226, 0.7506415247917175, -0.6584248542785645, 0.18018263578414917, 0.4609735906124115, -0.6995839476585388, 0.036980289965867996, 0.6369951367378235, -0.17288529872894287, 0.15722718834877014, 0.6245201230049133, 0.6303843259811401, -0.3673129677772522, 1.193000078201294, 0.894986093044281, 0.5201774835586548, 0.12252843379974365, 0.09698467701673508, -0.2934046685695648, 0.23794938623905182, 0.5523008108139038, -0.4438106119632721, 1.0577226877212524, -1.1083945035934448, -0.01402796059846878, 0.04694949835538864, 0.2654016315937042, -0.6509889364242554, -0.32441702485084534, 0.43019238114356995, 0.5248422622680664, -0.23360545933246613, -0.4484805166721344, 1.0897679328918457, 0.6225460767745972, -0.19742386043071747, -0.19563795626163483, 0.13366791605949402, -0.5170438289642334, -0.13770930469036102, -0.45596635341644287, 0.6434068083763123, 0.26102781295776367, 0.24502652883529663, 0.03486208990216255, -0.5078524351119995, -0.4074152410030365, -0.8821708559989929, 0.19367057085037231, -0.6447782516479492, 0.4498584270477295, 0.3150833547115326, 0.5021785497665405, 0.3525998592376709, -0.6316232085227966, 0.07308304309844971, 0.002463430166244507, 0.8614278435707092, 0.029508421197533607, -0.31795069575309753, 0.729209303855896, 0.18741542100906372, -1.304526448249817, 0.47601887583732605, 0.7464686632156372, -0.49459582567214966, 0.7312690019607544, -0.5009452104568481, -0.0024473844096064568, 0.6582494378089905, -0.09523199498653412, 0.18102388083934784, -0.07422249019145966, 0.6251556873321533, 0.11828713864088058, -0.7301594614982605, -0.4550290107727051, -0.7303606867790222, -0.3009827136993408, -0.27893757820129395, 0.3489678204059601, -0.09852384030818939, 0.023718083277344704, 0.5275359153747559, -0.2835655212402344, 4.188990592956543, 1.0120649337768555, 0.5196343660354614, 0.3835681974887848, 0.8217459917068481, 1.1519746780395508, -0.5386083126068115, -0.7766655087471008, -0.07931314408779144, -0.36473768949508667, -0.585896909236908, 0.6753350496292114, 0.03459610044956207, -0.3896074891090393, 0.40788570046424866, 0.44414693117141724, -0.2376905232667923, -0.5805201530456543, -0.14309003949165344, -0.9924415349960327, -0.4440991282463074, 0.39722922444343567, 0.20437262952327728, -0.48203223943710327, 0.29393839836120605, 0.23229259252548218, 0.24938474595546722, -0.39933428168296814, -0.5164783000946045, -0.09121043235063553, -0.7138983607292175, -0.8749879002571106, -0.07595529407262802, -0.2039315551519394, -1.006192922592163, 0.5722556710243225, 0.5200712084770203, -0.19613376259803772, 0.24622856080532074, -0.25011634826660156, 0.11787130683660507, 0.11524493247270584, -0.22394029796123505, -0.5518967509269714, -0.5887970924377441, 1.322940468788147, 0.2072007954120636, 0.29128497838974, 0.1817617267370224, -0.9424811601638794, 0.7834261655807495, 0.30615147948265076, 0.8458154797554016, -0.07580453157424927, -1.5778998136520386, 0.19376064836978912, -0.05256480723619461, -0.02883654646575451, 0.2571457028388977, 0.6648874878883362, 0.560534656047821, -0.03297099471092224, 0.3236595094203949, 0.30498838424682617, -0.28116005659103394, 0.8647162318229675, 0.5969221591949463, -0.05391143262386322, -0.21713900566101074, 0.0811564177274704, -0.5426704287528992, -0.20450547337532043, -0.5922690629959106, 0.1624014973640442, 0.3038938045501709, 0.22250548005104065, 0.23991890251636505, 0.562175452709198, 0.16267649829387665, 0.29996976256370544, -0.06481286138296127, -0.7757051587104797, -0.45842066407203674, 0.30802151560783386, -0.11945488303899765, 0.5366160869598389, -0.26128828525543213, 0.17909878492355347, -0.45115670561790466, 0.35171154141426086, 0.27143532037734985, 1.1483691930770874, 0.13144448399543762, -0.07940509915351868, -0.46473050117492676 ]
Random Walks and the Correlation Length Critical Exponent in Scalar Quantum Field Theory
The distance scale for a quantum field theory is the correlation length $\xi$, which diverges with exponent $\nu$ as the bare mass approaches a critical value. If $t=m^{2}-m_{c}^{2}$, then $\xi=m_{P}^{-1} \sim t^{-\nu}$ as $t \to 0$. The two-point function of a scalar field has a random walk representation. The walk takes place in a background of fluctuations (closed walks) of the field itself. We describe the connection between properties of the walk and of the two-point function. Using the known behavior of the two point function, we deduce that the dimension of the walk is $d_{w}=\phi / \nu$ and that there is a singular relation between $t$ and the energy per unit length of the walk $\theta \sim t^{\phi}$ that is due to the singular behavior of the background at $t=0$. ($\phi$ is a computable crossover exponent.)
Joe Kiskis, Rajamani Narayanan and Pavlos Vranas
hep-lat
February
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9202002
hep-lat/9202003
[ 0.0065727075561881065, -0.6709032654762268, -0.21022415161132812, 0.20946699380874634, -0.9130064249038696, -0.3290048837661743, -0.3289540410041809, -0.29225409030914307, -0.09500779211521149, 1.8248391151428223, 0.0673050656914711, -0.024026500061154366, 0.43553584814071655, -0.5609184503555298, -0.03253352269530296, 0.8669808506965637, -0.6782258152961731, -0.8383176326751709, -1.403232455253601, 0.3230161964893341, 0.23885180056095123, -0.4836317002773285, -1.6018764972686768, -0.9704801440238953, -0.1520601063966751, 1.1919763088226318, 0.03256583586335182, 0.0481749065220356, 0.75873202085495, 0.3189433515071869, 0.35673069953918457, -0.4031473696231842, -0.29277241230010986, -0.45957404375076294, -0.5120210647583008, -0.12217316776514053, 0.3271630108356476, -0.049902383238077164, 0.6030558943748474, -0.08213135600090027, 1.0084658861160278, -0.6859242916107178, -0.15468093752861023, -0.4871765077114105, -0.1257389783859253, -0.04249575361609459, -0.44555678963661194, -0.2802644371986389, 0.6161010265350342, -1.3948032855987549, 0.2643427848815918, 0.625591516494751, 0.5829727053642273, -0.8558018207550049, -0.799960196018219, 0.0241045281291008, -0.34208962321281433, 0.2365630567073822, -0.5566338896751404, 0.2791207730770111, 1.0892828702926636, -0.016282135620713234, 0.5604918003082275, -0.681244432926178, -0.13404351472854614, 1.0695265531539917, -0.4300520122051239, 0.7471410036087036, -0.5268761515617371, -0.3631041347980499, -0.24606649577617645, 0.06643439829349518, -0.8435287475585938, 0.016460632905364037, -1.0441296100616455, -0.01669267751276493, -0.008098139427602291, -1.0519437789916992, -0.9058542251586914, -0.23364730179309845, 0.08701127767562866, 0.16653305292129517, -0.19844013452529907, 0.3771067261695862, -0.20808012783527374, -0.13011778891086578, -0.18307915329933167, 0.22510983049869537, 0.14173126220703125, 0.30299094319343567, 0.7382891178131104, 0.9141460061073303, -0.27470213174819946, -0.7533479332923889, -0.20229993760585785, 0.10670934617519379, 0.1783158928155899, 0.5625106692314148, 0.025845542550086975, 0.27342599630355835, 0.25611749291419983, 0.29451999068260193, -1.2825772762298584, 0.11876325309276581, -0.09939838945865631, 0.13807664811611176, -0.29671359062194824, -0.19332563877105713, -0.40726882219314575, -0.4288957118988037, 0.4943646788597107, -0.19161681830883026, 0.195297971367836, 0.271955668926239, 0.22345924377441406, 1.0608206987380981, 0.09185056388378143, 0.17711985111236572, -0.41278278827667236, -0.3159477710723877, 0.7402380704879761, 0.1098046749830246, -0.18813158571720123, 0.20898710191249847, 0.07742076367139816, -0.3015928864479065, 0.5985852479934692, 0.33417728543281555, -0.2906428575515747, 0.2246912568807602, -0.216868057847023, 0.01488399226218462, -0.643631637096405, 0.859463632106781, -0.32499951124191284, -0.3012068271636963, -0.3205376863479614, 0.8892229199409485, -0.23356541991233826, -0.08265319466590881, 0.391932874917984, -0.46615585684776306, -0.11512701213359833, 1.2601630687713623, 0.5177012085914612, 0.3012523353099823, 0.3753126263618469, 0.08557967096567154, -0.36856481432914734, 0.40945398807525635, -1.043786883354187, -0.31973811984062195, -0.04610111191868782, 0.35401594638824463, -0.31019118428230286, 0.5243426561355591, -0.07466979324817657, 0.2545723021030426, -0.8296308517456055, -0.35397160053253174, -0.0712764710187912, -0.04420675337314606, -0.44539642333984375, 0.3662525415420532, -0.4166427552700043, 0.09575489908456802, -0.3683948516845703, -0.40957218408584595, 0.15098829567432404, -0.5428194999694824, -0.33877429366111755, 0.29968127608299255, -0.041011616587638855, 0.6223748922348022, 0.0042878505773842335, 0.6854522824287415, 0.3800318241119385, -0.6156481504440308, 0.28016114234924316, 0.6526762843132019, -0.329703688621521, -0.2273625135421753, -0.008033948950469494, 0.15047259628772736, 0.9515929222106934, 0.3754245340824127, -0.11456089466810226, -0.4719776213169098, 0.39199358224868774, 0.23206810653209686, -0.3703542649745941, 0.2506968080997467, -0.3478934168815613, 0.9687422513961792, -0.12073840945959091, -0.6038879752159119, -0.5978531837463379, -0.12775754928588867, -0.5458208918571472, -0.4364728331565857, 0.33592933416366577, 0.2729247808456421, -0.5446199774742126, -0.06354620307683945, -0.6167232394218445, 0.2527681589126587, 0.8329864144325256, -0.10786548256874084, -0.5664050579071045, -0.4014608860015869, -0.2765714228153229, 0.05932176858186722, 0.2675979435443878, -0.3258749544620514, 0.361256867647171, 0.45031240582466125, -0.17393119633197784, -0.17583312094211578, 0.5107654333114624, 0.2835499048233032, 0.2149513065814972, 0.49412277340888977, 0.2377239316701889, 0.8685986995697021, -1.0492193698883057, -0.25962334871292114, -0.24806348979473114, 0.5595569610595703, 0.4578874111175537, -0.178629532456398, -0.04150554910302162, 0.7434251308441162, -0.4128667414188385, 0.797548770904541, 0.48893922567367554, 0.22117777168750763, 0.5119585990905762, 0.5627396702766418, 0.01851062849164009, 0.17536917328834534, 0.018024954944849014, -0.3700724244117737, 0.6091974377632141, -0.1507953405380249, 0.2731435298919678, 0.07267534732818604, -0.8896304965019226, -0.15580669045448303, -0.40933957695961, 0.08449739217758179, -0.06511291116476059, 0.34156593680381775, 0.30491209030151367, -0.43744954466819763, -0.4696434438228607, -0.3798457384109497, 0.004183873999863863, 0.7843872904777527, 0.009080489166080952, -0.2953181862831116, 0.9105775356292725, 0.31109926104545593, -0.47438979148864746, -0.8148461580276489, 0.04581822082400322, 1.211539387702942, -0.43602454662323, 0.07682298868894577, 0.8914093971252441, -0.2090129554271698, -1.0083112716674805, -0.13720455765724182, -0.9628275632858276, 0.3176329731941223, -0.45969632267951965, 0.18016771972179413, 0.6380311846733093, -0.7512396574020386, 0.3902093172073364, 0.33055901527404785, -0.0968048945069313, 0.15125808119773865, -0.7727135419845581, 0.46324580907821655, 0.23003852367401123, -0.14893950521945953, -0.15195569396018982, 0.49229294061660767, -0.7873029112815857, -0.24194055795669556, -0.4738216996192932, 0.45257773995399475, 0.8747518658638, -0.8144540786743164, 0.3051949441432953, -0.42154940962791443, -0.6200054883956909, 0.13309216499328613, -0.08886417001485825, -0.4019469916820526, 0.18611539900302887, 0.9299038052558899, 0.11924076080322266, -1.0962281227111816, -1.1412127017974854, -0.13956186175346375, 0.34937772154808044, -0.445962518453598, 0.3451540470123291, 0.07755928486585617, 0.13085295259952545, 0.03524782136082649, -0.1667034775018692, -0.020952757447957993, -0.021841146051883698, 1.1541448831558228, 0.6872408986091614, 0.47166845202445984, -0.13191351294517517, -0.5273942947387695, -0.08819528669118881, 0.3752465844154358, 0.13372085988521576, -0.3462791442871094, -0.0097573297098279, 0.18898281455039978, 0.041737135499715805, -0.35629236698150635, 0.5913105010986328, -0.2195982187986374, -0.2862301170825958, 0.21301819384098053, -0.5528764724731445, 0.5512863397598267, 0.1781633347272873, -0.13767138123512268, -0.7160651683807373, -0.08952485769987106, 0.6565534472465515, 0.22901807725429535, -0.10245271772146225, -0.22251969575881958, 0.29956966638565063, 0.31175360083580017, 0.4124525189399719, -0.21820306777954102, 0.27573835849761963, -0.6406335830688477, -0.18850450217723846, 0.2374817579984665, -0.7439557909965515, 0.046462282538414, 0.2423209697008133, 0.9470576643943787, 0.17556889355182648, 0.6017497181892395, -0.6565033197402954, -0.3101292550563812, -0.1593099981546402, -0.7729360461235046, 0.24029658734798431, 0.4754565358161926, -0.013933055102825165, -0.2505533695220947, -0.56653892993927, -0.2408864051103592, 0.23910227417945862, -0.21051043272018433, 0.358847051858902, -0.3262554407119751, 0.3886445462703705, -0.691434919834137, -0.022234700620174408, -0.02798755280673504, 0.3532586991786957, 0.5119982957839966, 0.41232961416244507, 0.00690056337043643, 0.9594959616661072, -0.2562001049518585, -0.418057918548584, 0.07117655128240585, 0.23682786524295807, 0.4870651066303253, 0.18899540603160858, 0.5245627760887146, -0.3027346432209015, 0.8835950493812561, -0.166167750954628, -0.9573109149932861, -0.18964189291000366, -0.13658346235752106, 0.023352541029453278, -0.17625343799591064, 0.7533226013183594, 0.18754270672798157, 0.46108144521713257, 0.0809742733836174, 0.14291666448116302, 0.6067637205123901, 0.7351147532463074, 0.1737460196018219, 0.3050704300403595, -0.03967819735407829, -0.0486825592815876, 0.25930511951446533, -1.0114810466766357, -0.09044786542654037, -0.10530894994735718, 0.4715821146965027, -0.5307211875915527, -0.6296446919441223, -0.22533045709133148, -0.5454037189483643, 0.8185543417930603, 0.3174155652523041, -0.7912388443946838, 0.5938674211502075, 0.16396453976631165, 0.6284472346305847, -0.23130811750888824, -0.1808317005634308, 1.1763427257537842, 0.7995290160179138, -0.13587725162506104, -0.527479887008667, 0.42772558331489563, -0.12761135399341583, 0.1700652688741684, 0.43922027945518494, -1.5024622678756714, -0.5184227228164673, -1.0084322690963745, -0.0027539851143956184, -0.5386170744895935, 0.21493007242679596, 1.2877588272094727, -0.6353490352630615, 0.5841979384422302, -0.28734493255615234, -0.6742309927940369, 0.14707615971565247, -0.20886698365211487, -0.49814459681510925, 0.5326635837554932, -0.19115716218948364, -0.18328312039375305, 0.7296389937400818, 0.08114120364189148, -0.21728752553462982, 0.379140704870224, -0.7456045746803284, 1.0717300176620483, -0.8044780492782593, -0.30579355359077454, -0.17056353390216827, -1.207273006439209, -0.09807202219963074, 0.7256396412849426, 0.04743436723947525, -0.3285175561904907, -0.20558783411979675, 0.0043268958106637, -0.6151034832000732, 0.2317708283662796, 0.06437898427248001, -0.3454743027687073, 0.9839168787002563, 0.5004889369010925, 0.45215240120887756, 0.6155921816825867, 0.9686781167984009, 0.561296820640564, -0.09633582085371017, 0.02399715781211853, 0.16429473459720612, 0.18001089990139008, -0.5242245197296143, -0.005298570729792118, -1.1493480205535889, -0.6367443203926086, 0.29642152786254883, -0.4296830892562866, 0.9578070044517517, -0.07760635018348694, -0.6731162667274475, -0.1381978839635849, 0.16186492145061493, -0.34834766387939453, 0.5711840391159058, 0.042696330696344376, -0.29257094860076904, 0.515384316444397, -0.29825666546821594, 0.1720542162656784, -0.5028849244117737, -0.06162320449948311, -0.5708458423614502, 0.2680797874927521, 0.5727236866950989, -0.5486738681793213, 0.025921599939465523, -1.3738822937011719, 0.5896045565605164, -0.6491169333457947, 0.04489646479487419, -0.7583052515983582, -0.10837372392416, 0.1247926875948906, -0.3375096619129181, 0.266547292470932, 0.06128161400556564, -0.3185093104839325, -0.23671650886535645, -0.22723275423049927, -0.13824360072612762, 0.23631669580936432, 0.34706518054008484, -0.1830732673406601, 1.006071925163269, -0.19011545181274414, -0.4590515196323395, 0.4314867854118347, 0.5150880813598633, -0.06689683347940445, 0.39878329634666443, 0.45672741532325745, -0.9087515473365784, 0.4441845715045929, -0.3047982454299927, 0.6170548796653748, -0.2221211940050125, -0.10351447761058807, -0.06694918125867844, -0.5076961517333984, 0.5052250027656555, 0.034533869475126266, 0.06661447882652283, -0.5134044885635376, -0.8218968510627747, -0.309869647026062, 0.8841882348060608, -0.2533753216266632, -0.28994643688201904, -0.8162403106689453, 0.3323787450790405, -0.3842533230781555, 0.2038360834121704, -0.32149553298950195, 0.6690429449081421, 0.024241121485829353, -0.13566890358924866, 0.2466602921485901, 0.7479801177978516, 0.04497483745217323, -0.4589596092700958, 0.7316175103187561, 0.9455415606498718, -0.3524792492389679, 0.7150649428367615, -0.6100477576255798, 0.09812866896390915, -0.6895822286605835, 0.5190907716751099, -1.1712979078292847, -0.6536071300506592, -0.08790679275989532, -0.5240773558616638, 0.9040985107421875, -0.8841362595558167, 0.9497097134590149, 0.5693397521972656, -0.6645393967628479, 0.7641388177871704, 0.6128044128417969, -0.7561914324760437, 0.3719228506088257, -0.7121784090995789, -0.4151056110858917, 0.5971407890319824, -0.21153216063976288, -0.14489899575710297, -0.7210751175880432, -0.6475440263748169, 0.3369269371032715, 0.08252043277025223, 0.05815666541457176, 0.7614113092422485, -0.35214149951934814, 0.35033926367759705, -0.6886802315711975, -0.1490870863199234, -0.43831154704093933, 0.3161720335483551, -0.04764382168650627, -0.32539162039756775, -0.010312352329492569, -0.16123796999454498, -0.5218605995178223, -0.4107472896575928, -0.19254423677921295, 0.5652545094490051, 0.06969020515680313, -0.03039901703596115, 0.9394209384918213, -0.3309047520160675, -0.5933547616004944, -0.4135844111442566, 0.2722698152065277, 0.39462247490882874, 0.3861873149871826, 0.2591431736946106, 0.358210951089859, 0.018533335998654366, 0.22938770055770874, 0.4101974070072174, -0.1348596215248108, -0.3984929025173187, 0.19534273445606232, -0.6952259540557861, -0.3395066559314728, 0.3460967242717743, -0.07290917634963989, -0.9115700721740723, -0.7587810158729553, -1.405804991722107, 0.05947713181376457, -0.3451801538467407, 0.07964032888412476, -0.31563103199005127, -0.19048817455768585, -0.3562421202659607, 0.39757052063941956, 0.9616888761520386, 0.08114743232727051, -0.2836296260356903, -0.2499631643295288, -0.6920831799507141, -0.5463125705718994, -0.4758572280406952, 1.388479471206665, -0.5416064858436584, -0.44366586208343506, -0.3243490755558014, -0.20351633429527283, 0.08538580685853958, -0.07517221570014954, 0.542487382888794, -0.6257166266441345, 0.6803950071334839, 0.17477163672447205, -0.07933475822210312, 0.22738869488239288, 1.3121486902236938, 0.1867632269859314, 0.002350016962736845, -0.21898777782917023, -0.6720644235610962, -0.45855018496513367, -0.7154363393783569, 0.12560346722602844, 0.5814250111579895, 0.2604665160179138, 0.35538870096206665, -0.17418603599071503, -0.39801648259162903, -0.3792034685611725, -0.8974827527999878, -0.1185300424695015, -0.8347813487052917, -0.2730369567871094, -0.36935752630233765, -0.3216419219970703, 0.15131600201129913, 0.6620870232582092, 0.06695804744958878, -0.004640626255422831, -0.6336796283721924, 0.08095614612102509, 0.31837794184684753, 0.5376769304275513, -0.2286672741174698, -0.65296471118927, -0.038129355758428574, -0.5162599086761475, -0.32786786556243896, -0.16772177815437317, 0.016262387856841087, 0.4317285120487213, -0.737731397151947, -0.1279411017894745, -0.3198449909687042, 1.1084301471710205, -1.024977207183838, -0.9853748679161072, 0.19525833427906036, -0.43469634652137756, -0.7902449369430542, 0.3902614414691925, 0.013179265893995762, 0.6818085312843323, 0.10689173638820648, -0.08783286809921265, -0.15910214185714722, 0.16091124713420868, -0.8239194750785828, 0.05217756703495979, 0.28686392307281494, 0.6817641854286194, -0.01241033710539341, -1.1016812324523926, -0.6420295834541321, 0.68166583776474, -0.7363287210464478, 0.7297008633613586, -0.7565971612930298, 0.5854801535606384, -0.13166482746601105, 0.7893835306167603, -0.19560405611991882, 0.5160154700279236, 0.3922136127948761, 1.3745145797729492, 0.3398017883300781, -0.1325131356716156, 0.5322867631912231, -0.2164289504289627, 0.20161636173725128, 0.3655022978782654, -0.34949085116386414, 0.01863854005932808, 0.15071579813957214, 0.7069737911224365, 0.12878604233264923, -0.20975929498672485, -0.16953516006469727, -0.09187691658735275, 0.08889386802911758, -0.6115871071815491, -0.7241907715797424, 0.15630944073200226, 0.5449272990226746, -0.7958261966705322, -0.016419542953372, -0.6329416632652283, -0.2708522379398346, 0.28400325775146484, -0.5634475350379944, -0.40783828496932983, -0.13892723619937897, -0.015410471707582474, 0.04616152122616768, 0.04839431494474411, -0.31010645627975464, -0.0019532167352735996, 0.09564567357301712, 0.18491624295711517, -0.7292637228965759, -0.12395678460597992, -0.27547305822372437, 0.026287158951163292, -0.8917258977890015, 0.1400638222694397, -0.5206387042999268, 0.6652267575263977, -0.5431556105613708, -0.7373291850090027, 0.34940916299819946, -0.10459037870168686, 0.34283220767974854, -0.09311343729496002, -0.6450556516647339, -0.029525069519877434, -0.6611036658287048, -0.06586938351392746, -0.39173272252082825, -0.9291359782218933, -0.5700836777687073, 0.3135075569152832, -0.22178547084331512, -0.2938504219055176, -0.03763631731271744, 0.005981286987662315, 0.28936782479286194, -0.0907072126865387, -0.37466365098953247, 1.1660288572311401, 0.4070241153240204, -0.8956173062324524, 0.505064845085144, -0.3099389970302582, 0.2287614643573761, 0.07723373174667358, -0.6377233266830444, 0.05190544202923775, 0.3014507591724396, 0.024779515340924263, 0.5115524530410767, 0.05480460822582245, -0.10608691722154617, -0.27028656005859375, 0.10326644778251648, 0.9253966808319092, -0.492463618516922, 0.3219802975654602, 0.4135560989379883, 0.3323500454425812, 0.16261649131774902, -0.24969390034675598, -0.21817375719547272, 0.06406059861183167, -0.2877448499202728, 0.12514521181583405, -0.5272695422172546, -0.21827547252178192, -0.36500418186187744, 0.10687943547964096, -0.662153959274292, 0.0485067218542099, 0.05006798729300499, -0.01893044263124466, 0.7301494479179382, 0.36074817180633545, 0.1930939257144928, 0.9475643038749695, 0.17254240810871124, -0.05553194135427475, 0.2753852903842926, 0.7213388085365295, -0.5442496538162231, 0.7512481212615967, 0.1799037754535675, 0.9916494488716125, 0.5828946232795715, 0.07320422679185867, -0.30099689960479736, -0.6510974168777466, 0.09643731266260147, 0.5097024440765381, -1.2687602043151855, 0.05798158049583435, -0.5136903524398804, 0.08744372427463531, 0.025717630982398987, -0.30168208479881287, 0.547451376914978, -0.6738563776016235, 0.44421640038490295, 0.6068987250328064, -0.23852978646755219, -0.1990848183631897, 0.5905337929725647, 0.16327162086963654, 0.024021875113248825, 0.49449852108955383, -0.04979638382792473, 0.0013364407932385802, 1.3838520050048828, 1.2954260110855103, -0.10282651335000992, 0.7913624048233032, 0.1904059797525406, -0.8479154109954834, 0.29023057222366333, 0.6078532338142395, -0.6403042078018188, 0.3799840211868286, -0.22180302441120148, -0.2874983549118042, 0.2757236957550049, 0.06857538223266602, -0.09449629485607147, -0.32649800181388855, 0.30931389331817627, 0.06328139454126358, -0.301418662071228, -0.639863908290863, 1.201029658317566, 1.249385118484497, -0.6215416789054871, -0.1691291183233261, 0.24933981895446777, 0.07503010332584381, -0.27253398299217224, 0.09003360569477081, 0.48969700932502747, -0.5130274891853333, -0.704145073890686, -0.09500404447317123, -0.6729657649993896, -0.4810560643672943, -0.8174642324447632, 0.2812016010284424, -0.4471379816532135, 0.22203974425792694, 0.3897276818752289, 0.7911680340766907, 0.011940387077629566, -0.5914023518562317, -0.08084265142679214, -0.040849342942237854, 0.5312064290046692, -0.39925867319107056, -0.03600180149078369, 0.7288076877593994, 0.5104171633720398, 0.03843861073255539, -0.20228050649166107, 0.7094408273696899, -0.8060367703437805, 0.5144784450531006, -0.0039254408329725266, 0.14806658029556274, 0.7633471488952637, 0.6016057729721069, 0.18434475362300873, 1.0204654932022095, 0.09581054747104645, 0.2618770897388458, -0.4017062187194824, -0.19157005846500397, -1.3204139471054077, 0.4101679027080536, -0.11622756719589233, 0.7312055230140686, -0.13194449245929718, 0.6490095853805542, 0.5782309770584106, -0.49530521035194397, 4.2152485847473145, 0.5914552807807922, 0.590821385383606, -0.1264648586511612, -0.1251271665096283, 0.5315160155296326, -0.16916847229003906, -1.1501678228378296, 0.6152812242507935, -0.7253658175468445, -0.1943696141242981, 0.19935855269432068, 0.2634561061859131, -0.17160983383655548, -0.6404687166213989, 0.8973398804664612, -0.8294090628623962, -0.41444605588912964, 0.4706270694732666, -0.7015073299407959, -0.35117802023887634, 0.27487713098526, -0.21167194843292236, 0.43116116523742676, 0.2607354521751404, 0.01335143018513918, 0.44646552205085754, -0.35325518250465393, -0.022411946207284927, -0.22170162200927734, -0.7323314547538757, -0.7576033473014832, -0.19748716056346893, -0.07910887151956558, -0.223824143409729, 0.3899152874946594, 0.4794278144836426, -0.2336323857307434, 0.30048102140426636, 0.22053493559360504, 0.17377573251724243, -0.3016497790813446, 0.08745862543582916, -0.24586312472820282, -0.6313154697418213, 0.7231684923171997, -0.08060598373413086, 0.9389410018920898, 0.5074461102485657, -0.6759670972824097, 0.411288857460022, 0.07139908522367477, 1.16011643409729, -0.49560829997062683, -0.7610001564025879, 0.1291988641023636, -0.36157381534576416, -0.4252522587776184, -0.032942116260528564, 0.06044647842645645, 0.3321116864681244, -0.6830138564109802, 0.23210389912128448, -0.18263795971870422, -0.2489100992679596, 0.9032877087593079, 0.41463130712509155, 0.21244943141937256, -0.0498451367020607, -0.25163283944129944, 0.06168472766876221, -0.7524864077568054, -0.09502673149108887, 0.3473180830478668, 0.5638902187347412, 0.15765129029750824, -0.22556397318840027, -0.13798384368419647, 0.8526291251182556, -0.15062561631202698, 0.15075086057186127, -0.8066349625587463, -0.3563586175441742, 0.061011239886283875, 0.6575937867164612, 0.38836193084716797, -0.5318227410316467, -0.3447710871696472, 0.36794453859329224, 0.5940344929695129, 0.11321543157100677, 0.9123232364654541, 0.2478749006986618, 0.44121915102005005, -0.7703030109405518 ]
Thermodynamics of Lattice QCD with 2 Light Dynamical (Staggered) Quark Flavours on a $16^3\times 8$ Lattice
Lattice QCD with 2 light staggered quark flavours is being simulated on a $16^3\times8$ lattice to study the transition from hadronic matter to a quark gluon plasma. We have completed runs at $m_q=0.0125$ and are extending this to $m_q=0.00625$. We also examine the addition of a non-dynamical "strange" quark. Thermodynamic order parameters are being measured across the transition and further into the plasma phase, as are various screening lengths. No evidence for a first order transition is seen, and we estimate the transition temperature to be $TY_c=143(7) MeV$.
S. Gottlieb, U.M. Heller, A.D. Kennedy, J.B. Kogut, A. Krasnitz, W. Liu, R.L. Renken, D.K. Sinclair, R.L. Sugar, D. Toussa...
hep-lat
February
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9202003
hep-lat/9202004
[ -0.05449742078781128, -0.010012333281338215, 0.4176602363586426, 0.13035142421722412, 0.3074681758880615, -0.14332014322280884, 0.06783407181501389, -0.42446017265319824, -0.41608336567878723, 1.487520694732666, 1.206911325454712, -0.8076556324958801, 0.4304525852203369, -1.1435478925704956, -0.5444654822349548, 0.2062332183122635, -0.4142448902130127, -0.5455833077430725, -0.4576145112514496, -0.17156489193439484, 0.2472100704908371, -0.5662760734558105, -1.3332844972610474, -0.6888992190361023, -0.449266642332077, 0.941780686378479, 0.577795147895813, 0.14562256634235382, 1.3496876955032349, 0.4950491189956665, 0.46073004603385925, -0.7046472430229187, 0.3397398591041565, -0.5437466502189636, -0.471708208322525, -0.40842920541763306, 0.3453162610530853, -0.07171007990837097, 0.20902816951274872, -0.2430339753627777, 1.5412079095840454, -0.5298457145690918, 0.28961631655693054, -0.2363615334033966, 0.1471593976020813, 0.1337427943944931, -0.2220412790775299, 0.4444654583930969, -0.12448611110448837, -1.0726745128631592, -0.022984905168414116, 0.21235601603984833, 0.35240304470062256, 0.04563337564468384, -0.11989793926477432, 0.1260768473148346, -0.053055524826049805, -0.27246183156967163, -0.39475077390670776, -0.15253044664859772, 0.6053770780563354, 0.0803249403834343, 0.45438772439956665, -0.5751766562461853, 0.5757609605789185, 0.6179106831550598, -0.28721439838409424, 0.2011980414390564, 0.23327761888504028, -0.18179388344287872, -0.8993034362792969, -0.34241196513175964, 0.24197857081890106, -0.4959389865398407, -0.5439265966415405, 0.2670738697052002, 0.14911559224128723, -0.4993400573730469, -0.8729076981544495, -0.3636022210121155, -0.2944449782371521, -0.0570717379450798, -0.7935069799423218, 0.6516551375389099, 0.09972146898508072, -0.7144857048988342, -0.07229208201169968, -0.1056157723069191, -0.18559704720973969, 0.32375961542129517, 0.43973633646965027, 0.6879699230194092, 0.4928601384162903, -0.5375309586524963, 0.4742108881473541, 0.7273445129394531, -0.20720116794109344, 0.9554778933525085, 0.4077257215976715, 0.3778776526451111, 0.038290198892354965, 1.1711103916168213, -0.3908059000968933, 0.5511370897293091, -0.6634507179260254, 0.28596237301826477, -0.14045929908752441, -0.30258193612098694, -0.1260642409324646, -0.7297704815864563, -0.3802472651004791, 0.5173274278640747, -0.22748221457004547, -0.16407160460948944, -0.5070840716362, 0.9417579174041748, 0.020269619300961494, -0.29952338337898254, -0.9799849390983582, 0.047821927815675735, 0.15316753089427948, 0.21726356446743011, 0.49568191170692444, 0.2879861295223236, 0.023459335789084435, -0.7705825567245483, 0.16820622980594635, 0.7184246778488159, -0.38456037640571594, 0.024922281503677368, -0.15724387764930725, 0.06679660081863403, -0.44945991039276123, 0.8938355445861816, -0.3009190857410431, 0.774430513381958, 0.44530758261680603, 0.04865621030330658, 0.7569582462310791, -0.33325445652008057, 0.847966194152832, -0.14992082118988037, 0.21206513047218323, 1.3645472526550293, 0.25356775522232056, 0.3295145034790039, 0.5076218843460083, -0.4273911714553833, -0.2819983959197998, 0.5275702476501465, -1.283333659172058, 0.2364339530467987, -0.057233862578868866, 0.11330865323543549, 0.21115288138389587, 0.6579324007034302, -0.7148170471191406, 0.7990773916244507, -0.7294425964355469, -0.36513420939445496, 0.1403256356716156, 0.13457098603248596, -0.4243204891681671, 0.4489276111125946, -0.47042447328567505, -0.07853695750236511, -0.6002525687217712, 0.009569394402205944, -0.196104496717453, -0.5421170592308044, 0.04891505464911461, -0.15568166971206665, -0.045112527906894684, 0.6048654317855835, 0.4045409858226776, 1.1060067415237427, 0.6751993298530579, -0.40362200140953064, 0.28333696722984314, 0.38172245025634766, -0.027909837663173676, -0.5642843246459961, 0.45311471819877625, 0.7559707760810852, 0.12207525223493576, 0.06684578955173492, -0.4889920949935913, 0.016132038086652756, -0.06481143832206726, 0.8271834850311279, 0.10157664865255356, 0.3497779369354248, -0.49346256256103516, 0.2480897456407547, -0.11770564317703247, -0.26178017258644104, -0.4355223774909973, 0.9194104075431824, -1.0640051364898682, -0.38100096583366394, -0.2864382565021515, 0.8994976878166199, -0.7564541697502136, 0.1407797634601593, -1.6137419939041138, -0.034257661551237106, -0.2047399878501892, 0.048586394637823105, -0.5314059257507324, -0.5002182126045227, 0.6730401515960693, 0.06242266669869423, 0.34596556425094604, 0.06233392283320427, -0.2554844319820404, 0.49983617663383484, -0.3798638582229614, 0.041588641703128815, 0.7473956346511841, -0.5321903824806213, 0.8205059766769409, -0.08912213891744614, -0.8139544725418091, 0.43061110377311707, -0.5467596650123596, 0.0023214176762849092, 0.17758578062057495, 0.602325975894928, 0.22862045466899872, 0.01931123621761799, -0.18442261219024658, 0.9913153648376465, -0.26617419719696045, 0.624633252620697, 0.9887077212333679, 0.5491774082183838, 0.4316062033176422, 0.6733916401863098, -0.11187244951725006, -0.17607323825359344, 0.08925498276948929, 0.571000337600708, 0.3805282413959503, 0.24100269377231598, 0.7383630871772766, 0.016398197039961815, -0.8445305228233337, 0.6677188873291016, -0.46185940504074097, 0.7594594359397888, -0.8016588687896729, 1.4443341493606567, 0.12713541090488434, 0.033551424741744995, -0.31491854786872864, 0.6435286402702332, 0.34992891550064087, 0.5250626802444458, -0.5652459263801575, -0.2862708270549774, 0.04109947010874748, 0.2024255394935608, -0.1875772476196289, -0.4005330801010132, -0.27098843455314636, 1.5671968460083008, -0.06596682965755463, 0.263455867767334, 0.07126191258430481, -0.5070220828056335, -1.3118135929107666, -0.5099086761474609, -0.84759122133255, -0.20002473890781403, -0.049145881086587906, 0.37520989775657654, 0.8865328431129456, -0.4279123842716217, 0.8172516822814941, -0.37491321563720703, 0.1500980257987976, 0.3441433012485504, 0.14274168014526367, 0.7727628350257874, 0.9315854907035828, -0.13265155255794525, -0.7637353539466858, 0.3069209158420563, -0.3400826156139374, 0.23317597806453705, -0.45717450976371765, -0.2701375484466553, 0.6062967777252197, -0.6688817739486694, 0.11502863466739655, -0.22509685158729553, -0.07495491206645966, -0.3703165650367737, 0.08745867013931274, -0.0967317596077919, 0.13312339782714844, 0.3249954581260681, -0.008721591904759407, -0.12084655463695526, -0.07293282449245453, 0.9995371103286743, 0.44193336367607117, -0.3598937392234802, 0.9732596278190613, 0.319227010011673, -0.1180747002363205, 0.06738120317459106, -0.28119343519210815, 0.1365518867969513, 0.11420121043920517, 1.0609592199325562, 0.6893462538719177, 0.11866966634988785, -0.27454492449760437, -0.8609483242034912, -0.15824544429779053, 0.18487586081027985, 0.14870785176753998, -0.717070996761322, -0.4672856032848358, 0.6108645796775818, 0.2123868316411972, -0.6825412511825562, 0.3836072087287903, -0.8333123922348022, -0.28659096360206604, 0.2953163683414459, -0.5525683760643005, 0.13685254752635956, -0.3643021583557129, -0.18593010306358337, -0.63587486743927, 0.5572248101234436, 0.14028500020503998, 0.06713597476482391, -0.08274753391742706, -0.6982435584068298, 0.44686469435691833, 0.26009926199913025, 0.35964733362197876, -0.47290536761283875, 0.3283858895301819, -0.4284404218196869, -0.27464258670806885, -0.0460539273917675, -0.9651426076889038, -0.014423412270843983, 0.7309327125549316, 0.7007593512535095, -0.20217151939868927, 0.6203510165214539, -0.9454746842384338, -0.6067612767219543, -0.44714176654815674, 0.07202471047639847, 0.22717919945716858, 0.4056178331375122, -0.7783944010734558, 0.42932215332984924, -0.5962550044059753, -0.3297763764858246, 0.7273334860801697, 0.018678346648812294, 1.2597384452819824, -0.5792252421379089, 0.4765680432319641, 0.3049771189689636, -0.3841050863265991, 0.05891920253634453, 0.3422631621360779, 0.09882386028766632, -0.13161759078502655, 0.3644009530544281, 0.957152247428894, -0.34154510498046875, -0.551807165145874, -0.4998033344745636, 0.891211986541748, 1.1395444869995117, 1.448052167892456, 0.5879305601119995, -0.6195151805877686, -0.2538573741912842, -0.3512435853481293, -0.7474810481071472, 0.021074647083878517, -0.2186795473098755, -0.1335180401802063, -0.5175894498825073, 0.07882873713970184, -0.0791962668299675, 0.7000848650932312, 0.18399272859096527, 0.0290204007178545, 0.39712026715278625, 0.6869794726371765, -0.14073756337165833, 0.1444605439901352, 0.6811753511428833, -0.2520555555820465, -0.15919514000415802, -0.9925978779792786, 0.5660637021064758, -0.2342609316110611, 0.10918585956096649, 0.10668859630823135, -0.7938645482063293, -0.33495426177978516, -0.2150881439447403, 0.6978183388710022, -0.10252879559993744, -0.44687575101852417, 0.5771428942680359, -0.3223392367362976, 0.48546406626701355, -0.4829654395580292, -0.3800034821033478, 0.70505291223526, 1.00439453125, -0.8177073001861572, -1.2871135473251343, -0.037281397730112076, -0.3729180693626404, 0.6731517314910889, 0.0173664428293705, -0.38178014755249023, -1.1303791999816895, -0.020188434049487114, -0.062096599489450455, -1.2819660902023315, -0.06099924072623253, 1.0700366497039795, -0.8348134756088257, -0.044050414115190506, -0.4421684443950653, -0.48354023694992065, 0.4389529824256897, -0.3841698467731476, -0.7140588164329529, 0.5597171187400818, -0.01921217143535614, -0.24591588973999023, 0.1472892016172409, -0.011977208778262138, -0.04218224063515663, -0.3839629888534546, -0.08440452069044113, 0.09173836559057236, -0.3602987825870514, -0.2695961594581604, -0.2748957872390747, -0.7280060648918152, -0.3388178050518036, 0.5484067797660828, -0.02690347284078598, 0.6454333066940308, 0.337236613035202, 0.20012930035591125, -0.801596999168396, -0.5044927000999451, 0.30950701236724854, 0.10700573772192001, 0.37070485949516296, 0.6541248559951782, 0.022324413061141968, -0.2291116714477539, 0.502605676651001, 0.5006698966026306, 0.16939392685890198, 0.41281357407569885, 0.3312883973121643, 0.4098300635814667, -0.1369379311800003, 0.23370547592639923, -0.7785335779190063, -0.46548011898994446, 0.3985365629196167, -0.8371801972389221, 0.4672425091266632, 0.5698472261428833, -0.39766958355903625, 0.36309361457824707, -0.28720641136169434, -0.6402365565299988, -0.03306370601058006, -0.23158183693885803, -0.6180406212806702, 0.40316498279571533, -0.5824434161186218, 0.06101373955607414, 0.2984675467014313, 0.028092101216316223, -0.5543131828308105, 0.05496903881430626, 0.8625032901763916, -0.4049709737300873, 0.9588875770568848, -0.686614453792572, 0.3761221468448639, -0.6169849038124084, 0.5655366778373718, -0.5915480852127075, 0.1472267210483551, -0.35388121008872986, -0.10430120676755905, -0.34423503279685974, -0.6518332362174988, 0.43386775255203247, -0.23832371830940247, 0.1656026393175125, 0.31343314051628113, 0.12345991283655167, 0.8235143423080444, -0.9938860535621643, 0.7774360775947571, -0.5008088946342468, -0.83767169713974, 0.017520127817988396, 1.3281742334365845, -0.09293635934591293, 0.8172594308853149, -0.10202658921480179, -0.43916308879852295, 0.06853396445512772, -0.19530744850635529, 0.6065529584884644, -0.8575087785720825, -0.6201547384262085, -0.008650214411318302, -1.2451391220092773, 0.17367985844612122, 0.7228127717971802, 0.034494832158088684, 0.3005496561527252, -0.10175561904907227, -0.8518046140670776, 0.008669600822031498, -0.20270292460918427, -0.22054344415664673, -0.5949627757072449, -0.6159940958023071, -1.1277035474777222, 0.6121422052383423, -0.32378512620925903, -0.1582028716802597, 0.14980725944042206, 0.12909303605556488, -0.28955888748168945, 0.5679795742034912, -0.17540009319782257, -0.005796455312520266, 0.0007084259996190667, 0.8332527279853821, 0.06127022206783295, 0.7758793234825134, -0.40933316946029663, 0.43092772364616394, -1.0710163116455078, 0.6632662415504456, -0.42229944467544556, 0.1300160437822342, 0.2723373770713806, 0.015321078710258007, 0.9645174741744995, -0.36974793672561646, 0.43074533343315125, -0.19151416420936584, -0.21311575174331665, 1.1019474267959595, 0.3693874776363373, -0.7870184183120728, -0.29986533522605896, -0.7185484766960144, -1.3154135942459106, 0.804057776927948, 0.1380605250597, -0.3213810324668884, -0.8185770511627197, -0.16344603896141052, 0.09036088734865189, -0.055222321301698685, 0.02580355852842331, 0.5123277306556702, 0.04532656818628311, 0.6076857447624207, 0.07544297724962234, -0.1143508329987526, -0.23402097821235657, -0.07608665525913239, 0.0883791521191597, -0.2960304915904999, -0.31243643164634705, -0.24751362204551697, -0.7181719541549683, -0.9229219555854797, -0.6064126491546631, 0.5346370935440063, -0.00994814932346344, 0.3671038746833801, 0.6551134586334229, -0.3652578592300415, -0.5911159515380859, -0.28244972229003906, -0.5201102495193481, 0.11221810430288315, 0.41016727685928345, 0.7034457921981812, -0.43923884630203247, -0.12177085876464844, -0.3407130539417267, 0.8058738708496094, -0.6110290884971619, -0.5564447641372681, 0.48170390725135803, 0.006359297316521406, -0.7476509809494019, -0.1730254739522934, -0.3658941984176636, -0.7602437734603882, -0.678222119808197, -0.5052405595779419, -0.0978449136018753, -0.011479980312287807, -0.5345144271850586, 0.344838947057724, 0.011494409292936325, -0.32487425208091736, 0.4518226981163025, 0.8562150001525879, -0.5412134528160095, -0.1701395958662033, 0.03827045485377312, -0.2587893605232239, -0.26703110337257385, 0.1304047554731369, 0.7584850788116455, -0.586713433265686, -0.5636797547340393, -0.7287151217460632, -1.0666611194610596, 0.39093881845474243, -0.10021945089101791, -0.04268132895231247, 0.10893896222114563, 0.8210383057594299, 0.21629910171031952, 0.7933470606803894, 0.006227143574506044, 0.0832003504037857, 0.6706873178482056, 0.0798678994178772, 0.3122939467430115, -0.8252013325691223, -1.0216244459152222, -0.367360919713974, 0.14873139560222626, 0.7947405576705933, -0.1659548133611679, 0.7188291549682617, -0.12400168925523758, -0.4858085513114929, -0.7836204767227173, -1.0709096193313599, 0.41487354040145874, -1.7630776166915894, -0.6599400639533997, -0.8389812111854553, -0.38461560010910034, -0.06465427577495575, 0.011064691469073296, 0.06822069734334946, 0.3808964192867279, -0.6002832651138306, -0.20398834347724915, 0.12235474586486816, 0.13013727962970734, -0.46004819869995117, -0.266139954328537, -0.8739269375801086, -0.607477605342865, -0.6932163238525391, -0.08462952822446823, 0.2564273476600647, 0.2859362065792084, -0.3875134587287903, 0.2124934047460556, -0.40964633226394653, 0.2563295364379883, -1.0834044218063354, -0.685733437538147, -0.1428796350955963, -0.2697105407714844, -0.6399797797203064, -0.14586515724658966, -0.3255656063556671, 0.13996799290180206, 0.1542377918958664, 0.02423013001680374, -0.052376776933670044, -0.01018266286700964, -0.7936092615127563, -0.3183756470680237, 0.4585062265396118, 0.3187648355960846, -0.3498493731021881, -0.5822141766548157, 0.8158514499664307, 0.21673446893692017, -1.284569501876831, 0.8030694723129272, -0.3612658679485321, -0.08086192607879639, -0.27018028497695923, 0.043755002319812775, 0.13305404782295227, 1.126117467880249, -0.13237382471561432, 0.3700343072414398, 0.11644638329744339, 0.229647696018219, -0.15464448928833008, 0.0030055546667426825, -0.49680399894714355, 0.5077614784240723, 0.23366491496562958, -0.8820030093193054, 0.2304159253835678, 0.3436919152736664, -0.5529114603996277, 0.2219655066728592, -0.10448602586984634, -0.5491445064544678, -0.43013691902160645, -0.02093580923974514, -0.5885130763053894, 0.5169645547866821, -0.11119412630796432, -0.633840799331665, -0.24884456396102905, -0.3443371057510376, -0.6154312491416931, -0.16108983755111694, -1.1585313081741333, -0.48805245757102966, -0.7694416642189026, 0.03158223256468773, -0.4006914794445038, 0.09971931576728821, -0.2184196412563324, 0.01782245747745037, 0.09777922928333282, 0.26311302185058594, -0.21089757978916168, -0.09078627079725266, 0.07844892889261246, 0.20013166964054108, -0.9814525246620178, -0.43996062874794006, -0.15170659124851227, 0.44966843724250793, -0.15689623355865479, -0.12177258729934692, 0.13480070233345032, 0.10334449261426926, 0.3347342014312744, 0.5437179803848267, -0.5728204846382141, 0.1772969365119934, 0.8355756998062134, 0.03853091597557068, 0.22827266156673431, 0.24615414440631866, -0.7063587307929993, 0.5404702425003052, -0.1476346254348755, -0.5556380748748779, 0.5500204563140869, 0.4234085977077484, 0.36491990089416504, 0.5519446730613708, -0.4674510657787323, 1.0906918048858643, -0.12769798934459686, -1.0292783975601196, 1.6364957094192505, -0.3937629759311676, 0.8803415894508362, 0.2417072206735611, 0.03918255493044853, 0.25372132658958435, 0.2261151224374771, 0.15612909197807312, 1.0410220623016357, 0.6817721724510193, 0.29283517599105835, 0.8838288187980652, -0.010331712663173676, 0.1341615915298462, 0.0836021676659584, 0.6006090641021729, 0.5121856331825256, 0.35632601380348206, -0.10026541352272034, 0.12700337171554565, -0.32862943410873413, 0.1311839371919632, -0.16730156540870667, -0.13059498369693756, -0.19108174741268158, 0.2229994833469391, -0.14123958349227905, 0.5720150470733643, -0.4807365834712982, -0.09586341679096222, -0.013718202710151672, -0.21752256155014038, 0.08737117797136307, -0.32338911294937134, -0.014069926925003529, 0.37958645820617676, 0.5509119033813477, 0.5912692546844482, 0.5043252110481262, 1.0043646097183228, -0.006444863043725491, -0.14709989726543427, 0.09021393954753876, 0.8514267802238464, 0.4874834418296814, 0.33737024664878845, 0.21357671916484833, -1.1303797960281372, -0.135696679353714, 1.2370460033416748, -1.233583688735962, -0.17261207103729248, -0.7218907475471497, -0.043088823556900024, -0.1819482445716858, -0.7149019837379456, 0.35055673122406006, -0.2480897605419159, 0.5173680186271667, 0.7664887309074402, 0.0402165949344635, -0.2190743237733841, 0.473327100276947, -0.49013739824295044, 0.4587153494358063, 0.7372614741325378, -0.046992234885692596, -0.19947941601276398, 0.7817636728286743, 1.138657808303833, 0.02864466980099678, 0.6383779644966125, 0.2370981127023697, -0.9033980965614319, 0.19741860032081604, 0.02538570761680603, -0.29163050651550293, 0.7159463763237, -0.8340536952018738, -0.919131875038147, -0.026453256607055664, -0.029853416606783867, -0.5847744345664978, -0.021325424313545227, -0.41724032163619995, 0.33487188816070557, -0.4995448589324951, -0.40095460414886475, 1.0732855796813965, 0.5862505435943604, -0.12570272386074066, -0.6885596513748169, -0.05200434848666191, -0.36134105920791626, 0.1420905888080597, -0.3694874048233032, -0.07838744670152664, 0.1183578222990036, 0.44711217284202576, -0.20340614020824432, -1.2883423566818237, -0.059156354516744614, -1.083888292312622, -0.050396937876939774, -0.22028939425945282, 0.7166551351547241, 0.00933112669736147, 0.3622039556503296, -0.19372119009494781, -0.5218671560287476, 0.11136551946401596, 0.21642763912677765, 1.1825836896896362, 0.2592475712299347, 0.24824124574661255, 0.7289541363716125, 0.4814487099647522, -0.7549992203712463, 0.18063192069530487, 0.9687557816505432, -0.3570098578929901, 0.6931544542312622, -0.257049024105072, 0.13566510379314423, -0.13460125029087067, -0.17916370928287506, 0.9636866450309753, 0.06258047372102737, 0.4932408928871155, -1.086281657218933, -0.13267990946769714, 0.023804502561688423, -1.058686375617981, 0.1472497135400772, -0.9740638136863708, -0.19632332026958466, 0.13027295470237732, 0.41271376609802246, -0.19700168073177338, 0.2695091962814331, 4.013566017150879, 1.4332469701766968, 0.6703382730484009, -0.2800915241241455, 0.6638960838317871, 0.1926926225423813, 0.23140594363212585, -0.7192654609680176, 0.4276655912399292, -0.35330313444137573, -0.1731080710887909, 0.616378128528595, 0.44610291719436646, -0.23471865057945251, -0.3384811282157898, 0.6719675064086914, -0.3286588788032532, 0.5860956311225891, 0.6729100942611694, -0.6488632559776306, -0.9782935380935669, 0.2590023875236511, -0.22809535264968872, 0.274222195148468, -0.049279630184173584, 0.059605155140161514, 0.28548648953437805, -0.9378337860107422, -0.8099071383476257, -0.4996362030506134, -0.5349730849266052, -0.7315969467163086, -0.02987467311322689, -0.5248950123786926, -0.5698340535163879, 0.498203307390213, 0.5581217408180237, 0.013889193534851074, 0.008895347826182842, 0.7722825407981873, 0.005852724425494671, 0.4377831220626831, -0.08293650299310684, 0.24498741328716278, -0.7054349184036255, 0.42145970463752747, -0.6013831496238708, 0.6316666603088379, 0.22299879789352417, -0.4312017261981964, 0.25961288809776306, -0.7695757746696472, 0.9657395482063293, -0.6196638941764832, -1.035544753074646, -0.46378687024116516, -0.770696222782135, -1.1417348384857178, 0.012756587006151676, 0.09293059259653091, 0.7881169319152832, 0.08818750828504562, 0.182635098695755, 0.16959230601787567, -0.6393610835075378, 0.8131625652313232, 0.3405974507331848, 0.098991259932518, -0.054085444658994675, 0.0836702436208725, 0.013188253156840801, -0.6257341504096985, -0.4712594747543335, -0.03231895714998245, 0.5569131374359131, -0.18078550696372986, -0.3699899911880493, 0.8154604434967041, 0.37743446230888367, 0.2126929759979248, -0.38454264402389526, -0.18792107701301575, 0.11058524250984192, 0.3729144036769867, 0.03218356892466545, 0.4575197994709015, -0.5943321585655212, -0.46652522683143616, 0.14006339013576508, 0.19876813888549805, 0.41420304775238037, 1.3442291021347046, -0.196415513753891, -0.09567323327064514, -0.6955011487007141 ]
Multicanonical Ensemble: A New Approach to Simulate First-order Phase Transitions
Relying on the recently proposed multicanonical algorithm, we present a numerical simulation of the first order phase transition in the 2d 10-state Potts model on lattices up to sizes $100\times100$. It is demonstrated that the new algorithm $lacks$ an exponentially fast increase of the tunneling time between metastable states as a function of the linear size $L$ of the system. Instead, the tunneling time diverges approximately proportional to $L^{2.65}$. Thus the computational effort as counted per degree of freedom for generating an independent configuration in the unstable region of the model rises proportional to $V^{2.3}$, where $V$ is the volume of the system. On our largest lattice we gain more than two orders of magnitude as compared to a standard heat bath algorithm. As a first physical application we report a high precision computation of the interfacial tension.
B.A. Berg and T. Neuhaus
hep-lat
February
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9202004
hep-lat/9203001
[ 0.10228478908538818, -0.10770054906606674, -0.14894135296344757, 0.805418848991394, -0.12476634234189987, -0.4262694716453552, -0.31187015771865845, -0.4422503113746643, -0.3567318916320801, 1.5433998107910156, 0.9119845032691956, -0.2212941199541092, -0.03125295042991638, -0.6761164665222168, -0.8052518963813782, 0.44018033146858215, -0.014290143735706806, -0.45653191208839417, -1.3627055883407593, 0.8209776878356934, 0.11981742084026337, -0.6043545603752136, -1.230487585067749, -0.2726175785064697, -0.6609578728675842, 0.7851235866546631, 0.021711457520723343, 0.3285214602947235, 0.9207441806793213, 0.4679332375526428, 0.4318462014198303, -1.008785367012024, 0.3345358371734619, -0.47647416591644287, -0.5518369078636169, -0.4200093150138855, 0.3208693861961365, -0.15220089256763458, 0.6996374726295471, -0.6673742532730103, 0.8016759753227234, -0.24802309274673462, -0.233426034450531, -0.06594447791576385, -0.6052349805831909, 0.2439294010400772, -0.5912926197052002, -0.31209129095077515, 0.08382446318864822, -1.1621356010437012, -0.14506195485591888, 0.13208787143230438, 0.42857852578163147, -0.14216971397399902, -0.30526620149612427, -0.5946635603904724, 0.057880107313394547, 0.45054247975349426, -0.3969542980194092, -0.4425469934940338, 0.5827571749687195, -0.1997583508491516, 0.1156063824892044, -0.5043278336524963, 0.14301833510398865, 1.3152821063995361, 0.13298103213310242, 0.9075328707695007, -0.018852362409234047, -0.2374807745218277, -0.3162550628185272, -0.006890398450195789, -0.8279468417167664, 0.03196868300437927, -0.8499665856361389, 0.06689618527889252, -0.05348275601863861, -0.6481177806854248, -1.4630870819091797, 0.3293744921684265, -0.02369237132370472, -0.10221893340349197, -0.4679414629936218, 0.34684938192367554, -0.1835208386182785, -0.15465188026428223, -0.07492318004369736, 0.1979030966758728, -0.035693924874067307, 0.7614119648933411, 0.5279406905174255, 0.7960881590843201, 0.16265742480754852, 0.09153463691473007, 0.2325144112110138, 0.12370157241821289, 0.6427027583122253, 0.22711610794067383, 0.5730201601982117, 0.07739827036857605, -0.604164183139801, 0.5654130578041077, -0.7064226865768433, -0.22734445333480835, -0.5636207461357117, 0.12987010180950165, -0.4451802670955658, 0.18111497163772583, 0.27038779854774475, -0.4728321433067322, 0.22567075490951538, -0.3965957760810852, 0.05515188351273537, 0.7452555894851685, -0.14257259666919708, 0.8878253698348999, -0.5715429782867432, 0.14366209506988525, -0.6540870070457458, -0.23017914593219757, 0.34488263726234436, 0.33517521619796753, 0.07502001523971558, 0.5549741983413696, 0.4241151213645935, -0.034684423357248306, 0.17156782746315002, 0.5964525938034058, -0.6713196635246277, 0.15068282186985016, -0.21747027337551117, -0.07036329060792923, -0.3681992292404175, 0.7929751873016357, -0.697838544845581, -0.032714713364839554, 0.2659686803817749, 0.44489938020706177, 0.250670462846756, -0.33002111315727234, 0.8357928991317749, -0.5263249278068542, -0.262716144323349, 0.9758070707321167, -0.8678476214408875, 0.5099627375602722, 0.14550913870334625, 0.45259255170822144, -0.39680320024490356, 0.5702191591262817, -0.6620240211486816, -0.4712400436401367, -0.2516782283782959, 1.0497065782546997, -0.1934112310409546, 0.6501805782318115, -0.6078534722328186, 0.1786494255065918, -0.8763422966003418, -0.585342288017273, 0.39090925455093384, 0.22918899357318878, -0.3642164170742035, 0.6215962767601013, -0.4160453677177429, 0.16227048635482788, -0.9740685820579529, -0.3794681131839752, 0.25912579894065857, -0.5431991815567017, 0.28320494294166565, 0.4401037395000458, -0.6482167840003967, 1.3310426473617554, -0.05855780839920044, 0.2875078320503235, 0.4260120391845703, -0.6255359649658203, -0.22077195346355438, 0.4404572546482086, -0.4471502900123596, -0.3239514231681824, 0.6056772470474243, -0.1283566653728485, 0.04303601384162903, -0.07716736197471619, -0.9134256839752197, -0.1963290572166443, -0.5284826159477234, 0.5346941947937012, -0.6628003120422363, 0.6509177088737488, -0.7184805274009705, 0.5112112760543823, -0.1399422585964203, -0.195290669798851, -0.5948326587677002, 0.2177552878856659, -0.31343865394592285, -0.47208744287490845, 0.22827021777629852, 0.4969552457332611, -1.0156939029693604, 0.4059331715106964, -1.2269213199615479, -0.1633485108613968, 0.3573122024536133, 0.06074674427509308, -0.9999210834503174, -0.2104181945323944, 0.2441609501838684, 0.2071983367204666, 0.3479369282722473, -0.23915161192417145, -0.2819279134273529, 0.2713370621204376, 0.04873448982834816, 0.194747194647789, 0.37161728739738464, 0.663711428642273, 0.3975635766983032, 0.49573588371276855, -0.18032659590244293, 0.8961455225944519, -0.3550838232040405, -0.7493300437927246, 0.09394828230142593, 0.8509089350700378, 0.40289565920829773, 0.042418237775564194, -0.3242000639438629, 0.2978985905647278, -0.055526651442050934, 0.49824079871177673, 0.30217018723487854, 0.18575002253055573, 0.8288107514381409, 0.8663167953491211, 0.5632965564727783, 0.08969786763191223, -0.12443273514509201, 0.19074061512947083, 0.3362383246421814, -0.1318589746952057, -0.43304187059402466, 0.3028269410133362, -0.21140362322330475, 0.5322709679603577, -0.6738608479499817, 0.7274382710456848, 0.14467522501945496, 0.6528818011283875, 0.44217222929000854, 0.6772208213806152, -0.8842131495475769, 0.19452811777591705, 0.055630266666412354, 0.1759890764951706, -0.13020464777946472, -0.25839975476264954, -0.22449922561645508, 0.22145485877990723, -0.0651044026017189, -0.6304299235343933, 0.14249946177005768, 0.8568990230560303, 0.17021772265434265, 0.27206650376319885, 0.9964026808738708, -0.41246604919433594, -1.1090210676193237, -0.06300079822540283, -0.6122452616691589, -0.06652377545833588, -0.0005046891747042537, 0.04134621471166611, 0.7168286442756653, -0.882545530796051, 0.37771210074424744, 0.1243315041065216, -0.7560541033744812, 0.8620361089706421, -0.4362090229988098, 0.537274956703186, 0.2260437309741974, -0.03319374471902847, -0.31695181131362915, 0.13021692633628845, -0.8905013203620911, 0.028886528685688972, -0.13771246373653412, 0.0766894742846489, 0.722786009311676, -0.45023947954177856, 0.3115396201610565, 0.02394348941743374, -0.4978732466697693, 0.3805372416973114, 0.28785231709480286, -0.39841747283935547, 0.34408316016197205, 0.9658384323120117, 0.3693491220474243, -0.3282853364944458, -1.186748743057251, 0.5748670697212219, 0.18813325464725494, 0.08969583362340927, 0.4267122149467468, 0.3182660639286041, -0.5580807328224182, 0.4513023793697357, -0.18260183930397034, 0.25134041905403137, 0.09722844511270523, 0.7090404629707336, 0.46539437770843506, 0.22991356253623962, 0.29575881361961365, -0.6057211756706238, -0.15830785036087036, 0.285088449716568, 0.4227603077888489, -0.23722630739212036, -0.1440524011850357, 0.8032597899436951, -0.21572285890579224, -1.0090335607528687, 0.6614763140678406, -1.0544742345809937, -0.604507565498352, 0.4281786382198334, -0.5304474234580994, 0.6049048900604248, 0.03585011884570122, 0.44464483857154846, -0.8730617761611938, -0.2930428683757782, -0.4672614336013794, 0.7327423691749573, 0.7193581461906433, -0.11967131495475769, 0.291378915309906, 0.4721369445323944, 0.09167405962944031, -0.25352534651756287, 0.12074324488639832, 0.30461135506629944, -0.6129714846611023, 0.7303138375282288, -0.7727793455123901, 0.43794915080070496, -0.11715112626552582, 0.11584097146987915, 0.3448084592819214, 0.3565431833267212, -0.25861671566963196, -0.5220829844474792, -0.6647417545318604, -0.5189028978347778, 0.14364571869373322, 0.6021237969398499, -0.03371381014585495, 0.14032618701457977, -0.44197264313697815, -0.2790089249610901, -0.06865415722131729, 0.16093485057353973, 0.15163679420948029, -0.7116017937660217, 0.12844334542751312, -0.19614540040493011, -0.4772956073284149, -0.0515420064330101, -0.009139936417341232, -0.13043850660324097, 0.26426899433135986, 0.2587042450904846, 0.7062342762947083, -0.1304788887500763, -0.19650007784366608, 0.11332490295171738, 1.0682522058486938, 0.6184507012367249, 0.32274651527404785, 0.45678386092185974, 0.33574163913726807, -0.19632379710674286, -0.43652790784835815, -0.7035953998565674, -0.49586722254753113, -0.41671788692474365, 0.3770901560783386, -0.3334600031375885, 0.11967327445745468, -0.004284502472728491, 0.5636366009712219, 0.34294894337654114, 0.6615433692932129, 0.18089337646961212, 0.316975474357605, 0.37963616847991943, 0.9370103478431702, 0.3678275942802429, -0.18840539455413818, 1.039673089981079, -0.9388481974601746, 0.46663516759872437, -0.12360463291406631, 0.5413052439689636, -0.3869653642177582, -0.3077170252799988, -0.21368832886219025, -0.9905658960342407, 0.5385869145393372, -0.19114020466804504, -0.41590267419815063, 0.7843203544616699, 0.10662276297807693, 0.280637264251709, -0.669159471988678, -0.16761521995067596, 0.8873643279075623, 0.4307889938354492, 0.2203187495470047, -0.6017107963562012, 0.614970862865448, -0.6948815584182739, 0.22018222510814667, 0.559908390045166, -0.9017174243927002, -1.3997315168380737, -0.8244303464889526, -0.5304548740386963, -0.7059733867645264, 0.10410261899232864, 0.8730314373970032, 0.14121416211128235, 0.16695119440555573, -0.4458385705947876, -0.2880687713623047, 0.660947322845459, -0.6492685079574585, -0.7516805529594421, 0.6998224258422852, -0.07589243352413177, 0.13985271751880646, 0.524345874786377, -0.5369055271148682, -0.3532075583934784, -0.11026079952716827, -0.8293083310127258, 0.045578476041555405, -0.4044152498245239, -0.35464707016944885, -0.6111524701118469, -0.4271155595779419, -0.49859920144081116, 0.8056599497795105, 0.09328906238079071, -0.059688128530979156, -0.243101567029953, -0.187923401594162, -0.3733411431312561, -0.024214979261159897, 0.38704437017440796, -0.20823238790035248, 0.7483134269714355, 0.5902701020240784, 0.29843416810035706, 0.0811089426279068, 0.436628520488739, 0.1645624190568924, 0.3142453134059906, 0.3201218247413635, 0.17951667308807373, -0.00706907082349062, -0.41909852623939514, -0.1148017942905426, -0.46290624141693115, -1.0427732467651367, -0.07331084460020065, -0.3973937928676605, 0.30477389693260193, 0.1668398082256317, -0.020439328625798225, -0.08039754629135132, -0.3245090842247009, -0.9205480217933655, 0.22106783092021942, -0.14948762953281403, -0.29524579644203186, 0.5698683261871338, -0.45891880989074707, -0.4341178834438324, -0.13719551265239716, -0.3910481929779053, 0.20393222570419312, 0.5947182178497314, 0.8709859251976013, 0.014109067618846893, 0.9733879566192627, -1.5037921667099, 0.6850056052207947, -0.5452929735183716, -0.2322913259267807, -0.8319295644760132, -0.3896627724170685, -0.5955325365066528, -0.161076620221138, 0.03906198963522911, 0.3052782416343689, -0.035503089427948, 0.22662031650543213, 0.10590514540672302, -0.41213130950927734, 0.4658999443054199, -0.5808409452438354, 0.0795087143778801, 0.6499892473220825, 0.19096779823303223, -0.2837252914905548, 0.144090473651886, 0.6470614075660706, -0.28419026732444763, 0.43565455079078674, -0.03594677895307541, -0.729796290397644, 0.4644737243652344, -0.6986818909645081, 0.4392426311969757, -0.998173177242279, -0.35478320717811584, -0.09780198335647583, -0.5674051642417908, 0.06844091415405273, 1.0251959562301636, 0.025608517229557037, -0.314353346824646, -0.28253987431526184, -0.5526815056800842, 0.16827279329299927, -0.12678290903568268, -0.052766889333724976, -0.6712290048599243, 0.11409136652946472, -0.6578341722488403, 0.3177143335342407, -0.08860848844051361, 0.15642017126083374, 0.15515172481536865, 0.04203347861766815, 0.3445434272289276, -0.02326376363635063, 0.3264089822769165, -0.20144295692443848, 0.004105902276933193, 0.5083109736442566, -0.055065739899873734, 0.5173553228378296, -0.7522067427635193, -0.04578186199069023, -0.4339674115180969, 1.576972484588623, -0.9329570531845093, -0.6028741598129272, 0.2827974855899811, 0.45625993609428406, 0.502055287361145, -0.5189809203147888, -0.10191720724105835, 0.24180273711681366, 0.1845264434814453, 0.7779379487037659, 0.4576309025287628, -0.631938099861145, -0.5152915120124817, -0.24715273082256317, -0.5927680134773254, 0.4006146490573883, -0.10833421349525452, -0.3777256906032562, -0.8959062695503235, -0.742190420627594, 0.12776178121566772, 0.1641935557126999, -0.3011348843574524, 0.35039815306663513, -0.15211598575115204, -0.05649054795503616, 0.10318976640701294, 0.12448672950267792, -0.4785849153995514, 0.6327953338623047, 0.26347616314888, 0.17623767256736755, 0.15559473633766174, -0.07417253404855728, -0.6978018283843994, -0.5362614393234253, -0.27615633606910706, 0.16520653665065765, -0.06138841062784195, -0.27576228976249695, 0.7194715142250061, -0.3310192823410034, 0.08417890965938568, -0.2646627724170685, -0.28866809606552124, 0.29030171036720276, 0.5989921689033508, 0.3302772045135498, 0.5918074250221252, -0.07023930549621582, -0.2754957377910614, 0.5153100490570068, 0.08254482597112656, 0.11969667673110962, 0.9392318725585938, -0.4998492896556854, -0.11823800951242447, 0.2971460521221161, -0.06489050388336182, -0.8541197180747986, 0.16193675994873047, -1.0670195817947388, 0.39867499470710754, -0.2856636345386505, -0.428455650806427, -0.4857041537761688, 0.05217434838414192, -0.2422313094139099, 0.9528490900993347, 0.6005032062530518, -0.2591401934623718, 0.08608274161815643, -0.45161738991737366, -0.2515813112258911, -1.111375093460083, 0.04615836217999458, 1.2092331647872925, 0.030972741544246674, -1.2880871295928955, -0.03429577127099037, 0.016859451308846474, -0.09281744062900543, -0.19105178117752075, 0.7253963351249695, -0.5821382999420166, 0.15665671229362488, 0.7118768692016602, -0.0013299145502969623, 0.33792150020599365, 0.32912129163742065, 0.30967977643013, 0.18928302824497223, -0.19309580326080322, -0.7234982252120972, -0.302574098110199, -0.3211464285850525, 0.09920717030763626, 1.2431130409240723, 0.2640936076641083, 0.27541622519493103, -0.07114633172750473, -0.3732689917087555, -0.004648921545594931, -0.3728225529193878, -0.10474834591150284, -0.6658212542533875, -0.6486331224441528, -0.29030463099479675, 0.02017088793218136, 0.38030827045440674, 0.42622432112693787, -0.13797326385974884, 0.20358721911907196, -0.01613243855535984, -0.47509869933128357, 0.007604188285768032, 0.2717391848564148, 0.1559438705444336, -0.8662176728248596, -0.4217832088470459, 0.16552968323230743, -0.050440575927495956, -0.5315907001495361, -0.14342913031578064, 0.20131561160087585, -0.12064167112112045, 0.5433807969093323, -0.2714954614639282, 1.4573886394500732, -1.127693772315979, -0.5575268268585205, 0.29583215713500977, -0.32762303948402405, -0.9790669679641724, 0.4060094654560089, -0.21598193049430847, 0.7189052104949951, 0.4972526729106903, 0.0432455949485302, 0.19751033186912537, -0.23748092353343964, -0.6546273231506348, -0.20614491403102875, -0.47598204016685486, 0.3643181025981903, -0.1818784922361374, -1.3091742992401123, -0.19366240501403809, 0.4169277250766754, -1.076238989830017, 0.5865737795829773, -0.19749699532985687, 0.14844517409801483, -0.1137048676609993, 0.011461786925792694, 0.005225074011832476, 0.3094460666179657, -0.6329048275947571, 1.1001968383789062, -0.3355724811553955, 0.007027169689536095, -0.16848701238632202, 0.36453160643577576, 0.048277635127305984, 0.4261760115623474, 0.14110378921031952, -0.15558888018131256, -0.3650820553302765, 0.5108514428138733, -0.010577505454421043, -0.5235901474952698, -0.1533202975988388, -0.14139381051063538, -0.22475986182689667, -0.42330804467201233, -0.8663821220397949, 0.4377051889896393, 0.20380829274654388, -0.7352278232574463, -0.3116527199745178, -0.48503389954566956, -0.6754979491233826, 0.32340922951698303, -1.0925003290176392, -0.7794689536094666, -0.21322816610336304, -0.49630042910575867, 0.14213290810585022, 0.3614646792411804, -0.2737268805503845, -0.46689411997795105, -0.0995202586054802, 0.24084268510341644, -0.03576081991195679, 0.036856845021247864, -0.5803546905517578, 0.4418303668498993, -0.7523312568664551, -0.2977120280265808, -0.4059617519378662, 0.7082213163375854, -0.9709383845329285, -0.8003401160240173, -0.42499417066574097, 0.5512858033180237, 0.42904627323150635, -0.18285603821277618, -0.19052481651306152, 0.023019036278128624, -0.08877094835042953, -0.24780209362506866, -0.7265133261680603, -0.4007527232170105, -0.10169318318367004, 0.34548792243003845, 0.0178995318710804, -0.06987670063972473, 0.5524492859840393, -0.023656081408262253, 0.06547384709119797, 0.31198105216026306, 0.03849329054355621, 0.5551196932792664, -0.0694756805896759, -0.6488784551620483, 1.3277502059936523, 0.004774687811732292, 0.5080221891403198, 0.484020859003067, -0.6731857061386108, 0.39607036113739014, 0.3377912938594818, 0.15389961004257202, 0.9358631372451782, 0.0559769831597805, 0.029109036549925804, 0.3566034734249115, 0.027418380603194237, -0.15570224821567535, 0.0769377052783966, 0.5294786691665649, 0.49767088890075684, -0.11486851423978806, 0.18640777468681335, -0.03806248679757118, 0.286173552274704, 0.1218053326010704, 0.049226995557546616, -0.08428379148244858, -0.15813428163528442, -0.03277206793427467, -0.06436584889888763, 0.31197476387023926, -0.6726703643798828, -0.1862628310918808, -0.5883073806762695, 0.05820903554558754, 0.5741211175918579, 0.22447820007801056, -0.29843729734420776, 0.6013921499252319, 0.7458516955375671, 0.06880787014961243, -0.014103868044912815, 0.6196058392524719, 0.5809280872344971, 1.07362961769104, 0.005231259856373072, 0.8909307718276978, 0.7535777688026428, 0.3991508483886719, 0.281770795583725, -0.8159536123275757, 0.4925811290740967, 0.30007320642471313, -1.4028130769729614, -0.12574774026870728, -0.4351959228515625, -0.38892772793769836, -0.5702216029167175, -0.40458714962005615, 0.7938033938407898, -0.5832647085189819, 0.1555945724248886, 0.46261870861053467, 0.07315922528505325, 0.03929812088608742, 0.4436883330345154, -0.09627184271812439, 0.5007572770118713, 0.9256071448326111, 0.23994660377502441, 0.0072797005996108055, 0.6633995175361633, 1.1112560033798218, 0.0996425673365593, -0.32655856013298035, 0.18978466093540192, -0.7571462988853455, 0.0416388139128685, 0.3227115273475647, -0.4353017508983612, 0.47768059372901917, -0.5494629740715027, -0.3513619303703308, 0.15405653417110443, -0.021783802658319473, -0.5041877031326294, -0.34411898255348206, 0.020220430567860603, 0.1403692364692688, -0.5956070423126221, -0.2864789664745331, 1.4343185424804688, 0.6363813877105713, -0.1499800980091095, -0.597176194190979, -0.08784759789705276, 0.04149892181158066, -0.4538087546825409, -0.7117541432380676, 0.06521109491586685, -0.28271225094795227, -0.09227532148361206, 0.15459856390953064, -0.5411205887794495, -0.24504858255386353, -0.866195797920227, 0.3051285445690155, -0.8354437947273254, 0.14771853387355804, 0.3689597249031067, -0.08061078935861588, 0.30938634276390076, -0.5626060366630554, 0.2730233073234558, -0.1119702011346817, 1.1757786273956299, 0.10521894693374634, 0.3695409595966339, 0.4362783133983612, 0.5358192920684814, -0.6902458071708679, 0.5121694803237915, 0.9366030693054199, -1.1173983812332153, 0.7199110984802246, -0.1782914251089096, 0.6132056713104248, -0.10920670628547668, 0.33295682072639465, 0.6906225085258484, -0.052764274179935455, 0.2046080231666565, -0.466624915599823, -0.8279350996017456, -0.4493027627468109, -0.9781119227409363, 0.1774999350309372, -0.48176106810569763, 0.6327885389328003, 0.31406736373901367, 0.42227110266685486, -0.13265468180179596, -0.7160670757293701, 4.282962799072266, 0.4484451413154602, 0.38675278425216675, 0.4258190989494324, 0.4441658854484558, 0.6425990462303162, -0.3598654270172119, -0.44844186305999756, 0.2110855132341385, -0.9304996132850647, 0.19760608673095703, -0.05509147793054581, 0.0545380525290966, 0.04338309168815613, -0.07354246824979782, 0.5841132998466492, -0.659888744354248, 0.033125124871730804, 0.12263629585504532, -1.1344215869903564, -0.6268402338027954, 0.4684517979621887, 0.5492064356803894, -0.35874423384666443, 0.34216904640197754, 0.26900047063827515, 0.10869718343019485, -0.5187821984291077, -0.3895094394683838, -0.11692226678133011, -0.983004629611969, -0.7339638471603394, -0.31287845969200134, -0.4438490569591522, -0.7621464133262634, 0.41917940974235535, 0.23023730516433716, -0.40129566192626953, 0.150567889213562, 0.06956768035888672, 0.045349083840847015, -0.4913846552371979, 0.23835979402065277, -0.05212540552020073, -1.0853290557861328, 1.0513055324554443, -0.18783439695835114, 0.8897272944450378, 0.5411356091499329, -0.5222446918487549, 0.5654994249343872, -0.0720735564827919, 1.0380759239196777, -0.190060093998909, -0.8584783673286438, -0.3376934230327606, -0.5866044759750366, -0.22442971169948578, 0.1282678097486496, 0.24352644383907318, 0.6390324234962463, -0.3444906175136566, -0.33389812707901, 0.38969388604164124, 0.02083520218729973, 0.570166826248169, 0.1743725687265396, -0.21303845942020416, -0.4842914342880249, 0.19354811310768127, -0.15255457162857056, -0.33756741881370544, -0.45463672280311584, 0.27506235241889954, -0.1456136554479599, 0.37758150696754456, -0.3070004880428314, 0.5452412962913513, -0.15668874979019165, 0.282626211643219, 0.10880347341299057, -0.05637029930949211, -0.5211625099182129, 0.13995376229286194, 0.017996102571487427, 0.526073694229126, -0.14137358963489532, 0.2994222640991211, 0.2808417081832886, 0.5699731707572937, 0.3944675624370575, 0.9041873216629028, 0.25555938482284546, 0.14654786884784698, -0.8193760514259338 ]
Is there a $\rho$ in the O(4) $\lambda \phi^4_4$ theory?
A Monte Carlo simulation of the O(4) $\lambda \phi^4$ theory in the broken phase is performed on a hypercubic lattice in search of an I=1, J=1 resonance. The region of the cutoff theory where the interaction is strong is investigated since it is there that a resonance would be expected to have a better chance to form. In that region the presence of an I=1, J=1 resonance with mass below the cutoff is excluded.
Khalil M. Bitar and Pavlos M. Vranas
hep-lat hep-ph
March
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9203001
hep-lat/9203002
[ -0.0018741082167252898, 0.12452211230993271, 0.1657872349023819, -0.15868519246578217, 0.5201983451843262, -0.06094597280025482, 0.04420577734708786, -0.1756974458694458, -0.6207988262176514, 1.525877833366394, 0.9293990135192871, -0.2412843555212021, 0.5805777907371521, -1.1987231969833374, -0.4659905433654785, 0.20990411937236786, -0.6895475387573242, -0.9826085567474365, -0.42011329531669617, -0.18564334511756897, 0.5287550091743469, -0.5204210877418518, -2.0220980644226074, -0.8214516043663025, -0.6851794123649597, 0.6227174997329712, 0.5409393310546875, -0.11911816149950027, 1.4858670234680176, 0.6370816230773926, 0.1979174166917801, -0.8233895301818848, 0.40085557103157043, -0.7132271528244019, -0.2857770621776581, -0.5085726976394653, 0.20122361183166504, -0.1943652480840683, 0.5939133167266846, -0.6001622676849365, 1.2443172931671143, -0.5652392506599426, 0.772749125957489, -0.31135767698287964, -0.8550952672958374, -0.22547750174999237, -0.11055551469326019, 0.020816277712583542, 0.21962521970272064, -1.0790060758590698, 0.19185014069080353, 0.10494498163461685, 0.18162186443805695, -0.13498876988887787, -0.163690984249115, 0.04432781785726547, 0.05977502092719078, 0.17471852898597717, -0.5910252332687378, -0.5795757174491882, 0.9583005905151367, 0.11370702087879181, 0.9350163340568542, -0.8084310293197632, 0.7897632718086243, 0.7236555218696594, -0.6056774854660034, 0.030425772070884705, -0.29773369431495667, -0.18324725329875946, -0.709865927696228, -0.7968106269836426, 0.14344723522663116, -0.1740892231464386, -0.604773998260498, 0.3231121003627777, -0.5808684229850769, -1.060394287109375, -1.543603777885437, -0.4927363991737366, -0.1469489336013794, -0.38294848799705505, -0.5747057199478149, 1.013610601425171, 0.45077988505363464, -0.007969623431563377, 0.5050699710845947, -0.2283346951007843, -0.08727581799030304, 0.25739094614982605, 0.06673427671194077, 0.9570942521095276, 0.19485364854335785, -0.20118801295757294, 0.5247382521629333, 0.613377034664154, 0.03732762485742569, 1.2630406618118286, 0.5255977511405945, 0.7195087671279907, 0.018541017547249794, 1.4195061922073364, -0.8354511857032776, 0.3335016667842865, -0.6015844345092773, -0.09766320139169693, -0.2743278741836548, -0.3046362102031708, -0.33233746886253357, -0.6573035717010498, 0.16252154111862183, 0.2867090404033661, 0.4638296663761139, 0.43263792991638184, -0.23230838775634766, 1.130336880683899, 0.07523631304502487, 0.6645015478134155, -0.993473470211029, -0.024134891107678413, 0.2953526973724365, 0.4508318305015564, -0.34023532271385193, -0.005500264931470156, 0.355869859457016, -0.36839672923088074, 0.48634758591651917, 1.1335856914520264, -1.2381621599197388, 0.2934010922908783, -0.5486099720001221, -0.11896061897277832, -0.3447481095790863, 1.1177154779434204, -0.3910888433456421, 0.06806948781013489, -0.11753964424133301, 0.8779857158660889, 0.45822155475616455, -0.24131643772125244, 0.6787485480308533, -0.09588971734046936, -0.05103548988699913, 1.1500006914138794, 0.06027120351791382, 0.17120704054832458, 0.7382729053497314, -0.5577566623687744, 0.1817500740289688, 0.30062490701675415, -0.8849924206733704, 0.015682362020015717, 0.11757092922925949, 0.5168681740760803, 0.021624023094773293, 0.4427134692668915, -0.7663804292678833, 1.197269082069397, -0.9988880753517151, -0.6526959538459778, 0.28979161381721497, 0.1339835226535797, -0.3733570873737335, 0.03374074399471283, -0.3703444302082062, 0.08275408297777176, -0.45271560549736023, -0.45732438564300537, -0.07046280056238174, -0.730936586856842, -0.3693868815898895, 0.07255369424819946, 0.30171632766723633, 0.1901797503232956, 0.15169644355773926, 0.5315696001052856, 0.11234069615602493, -0.5357683897018433, 0.26558494567871094, -0.11330434679985046, -0.29720619320869446, -0.19573035836219788, 0.9303367137908936, -0.0789882093667984, 0.020382432267069817, 0.2588537931442261, -0.5747343301773071, -0.6605207920074463, -0.27063512802124023, 1.0140682458877563, 0.045229505747556686, 0.851407527923584, 0.09445706754922867, 0.5329676270484924, -0.08591669797897339, -0.3957214951515198, 0.061246998608112335, 0.48476505279541016, -0.6322000622749329, -0.32708656787872314, -0.41418424248695374, 1.1279938220977783, -0.6023117899894714, -0.08449782431125641, -1.905383586883545, 0.14945915341377258, 0.1877322793006897, -0.5019838213920593, -1.3713115453720093, -0.3527531623840332, 0.48699072003364563, -0.050108905881643295, 0.17024806141853333, -0.4340176582336426, 0.3101731836795807, 0.7007454633712769, -0.5858628153800964, -0.49981963634490967, 0.891295313835144, -0.4455130100250244, 0.9205950498580933, 0.018394988030195236, -0.5963077545166016, 0.49444109201431274, -0.5611538290977478, -0.6279298663139343, 0.12465932220220566, 0.9302491545677185, 0.07251046597957611, 0.1682448834180832, -0.10852430015802383, 0.37115591764450073, 0.04793418198823929, 0.2813255488872528, 0.8091214299201965, 0.8259338736534119, 0.7621487379074097, 1.0216888189315796, 0.3123358488082886, -0.11343621462583542, 0.16150499880313873, 0.6522525548934937, 0.9984979033470154, 0.5731903314590454, 0.458443820476532, 0.38446682691574097, -0.7335771322250366, 0.2258928120136261, -0.1622902750968933, 0.06097516044974327, -0.3085430860519409, 1.0716243982315063, 0.16779139637947083, 0.18872369825839996, -0.49028539657592773, -0.02846967801451683, 0.1430211216211319, 0.44162118434906006, 0.14033208787441254, -0.41716745495796204, -0.02872587740421295, 0.18621322512626648, 0.003288478357717395, 0.010334542021155357, -0.6698141694068909, 1.5894479751586914, 0.5825713872909546, -0.17293840646743774, 0.5268174409866333, -0.6514902710914612, -1.103425145149231, -0.41070759296417236, -0.7525108456611633, -0.027919219806790352, -0.13605451583862305, 0.1826591193675995, 1.0545506477355957, -0.5144281983375549, 0.21985340118408203, -0.00046281961840577424, -0.08985749632120132, 0.6427966356277466, -0.0416836217045784, 0.5174400806427002, 0.74933260679245, -0.23763421177864075, -0.9784694910049438, 0.12412963807582855, -0.5809993147850037, 0.17596744000911713, -0.5154847502708435, 0.0039575663395226, 0.8316326141357422, -0.534112274646759, 0.33626922965049744, -0.4272581934928894, -0.5017386078834534, -0.8091993927955627, -0.1987643539905548, -0.23057018220424652, 0.1602206975221634, 0.6815951466560364, -0.15312525629997253, -0.2434414178133011, -0.22152508795261383, 0.7472206950187683, 0.4141688644886017, -0.6932785511016846, 1.0983184576034546, 0.8646348118782043, -0.4346257150173187, -0.05692081153392792, -0.3349314033985138, -0.28555774688720703, 0.012992787174880505, 0.7778118848800659, 0.8583085536956787, 0.26795920729637146, 0.06151246652007103, -0.6900835633277893, -0.464572012424469, 0.14196708798408508, 0.19042904675006866, -0.5479867458343506, -0.09292002022266388, 0.6689639687538147, 0.3496237099170685, -1.0070313215255737, 0.642551839351654, -0.7863684296607971, -0.6455613970756531, 0.26157253980636597, -0.2682543992996216, 0.4452997148036957, 0.20454587042331696, 0.061029739677906036, -0.6722069382667542, 0.4397737979888916, 0.3493300676345825, 0.5244274735450745, -0.018632225692272186, -0.4860938787460327, 0.8914847373962402, -0.05348839610815048, 0.680316686630249, -0.599377453327179, 0.704017162322998, -0.3375360667705536, -0.23281382024288177, 0.29182127118110657, -0.8282594084739685, 0.28398412466049194, 0.838239312171936, 0.8729766011238098, -0.2630874216556549, 0.4244682490825653, -0.43332821130752563, -0.6957583427429199, -0.4255494773387909, -0.3401055634021759, 1.0229707956314087, 0.5342147350311279, -0.9365266561508179, 0.6541567444801331, -0.2320535033941269, -0.19800543785095215, 0.3909969627857208, -0.3553689122200012, 0.871870219707489, -0.49130192399024963, 0.6259120106697083, 0.6552372574806213, -0.7066298723220825, 0.13578227162361145, -0.02153051644563675, -0.005797223653644323, -0.04818904399871826, 0.4900107979774475, 1.3597885370254517, -0.7095028758049011, -0.5847698450088501, -0.28778353333473206, 1.4009895324707031, 0.8441296815872192, 1.1938955783843994, 0.23044580221176147, -0.3068930506706238, 0.24858048558235168, -0.4589386284351349, -0.6711097955703735, -0.2591157555580139, -0.22774194180965424, -0.7046974897384644, -0.43932896852493286, 0.10875310003757477, -0.10058083385229111, 0.43841832876205444, 0.5653327703475952, 0.2998764216899872, 0.09375707805156708, 0.8371297717094421, 0.0654100850224495, 0.6022101044654846, 0.6664648652076721, -0.12804684042930603, 0.2792671322822571, -0.6691032648086548, 0.38949641585350037, 0.08535008877515793, 0.1530551314353943, -0.2156447470188141, -0.316382497549057, -0.09566612541675568, -0.025758149102330208, 0.5673143863677979, 0.17118677496910095, -0.5278443098068237, 0.7338895797729492, -0.3916644752025604, 0.5818571448326111, -0.15347862243652344, 0.1694040149450302, 0.9591357111930847, 1.0890145301818848, -0.17925415933132172, -1.3620895147323608, -0.1093103215098381, -0.441645085811615, 0.4580589234828949, 0.3073303699493408, -0.2410353124141693, -0.9556899666786194, -0.7826752066612244, -0.2261062115430832, -1.313269853591919, -0.10591790825128555, 1.0304062366485596, -0.49058690667152405, -0.05281210318207741, -0.33057618141174316, -0.5748376250267029, 0.35121455788612366, -0.294190913438797, -0.2316267490386963, 0.7697563767433167, -0.42146292328834534, -0.5332387685775757, 0.2688847482204437, -0.18445445597171783, 0.003707986092194915, 0.1735730618238449, -0.2244783490896225, -0.08106938749551773, -0.44422298669815063, -0.5446891188621521, -0.34529241919517517, -0.5778017044067383, -0.8482574224472046, 0.2879008650779724, -0.9398689866065979, 0.4091799557209015, -0.002888273447751999, 0.2853855490684509, -0.7259200215339661, -0.7063912749290466, 0.5045921206474304, 0.12328702211380005, 0.21588273346424103, 0.8729437589645386, 0.17618677020072937, 0.30603915452957153, 0.4800722002983093, -0.024501940235495567, 0.4495750963687897, 0.09916774928569794, 0.44260281324386597, 0.5141016244888306, -0.2612609565258026, 0.1055276021361351, -0.6990637183189392, -0.9826639294624329, 0.15482614934444427, -0.9237272143363953, 1.0776201486587524, 0.05625998228788376, -0.47859853506088257, -0.052038710564374924, -0.20952214300632477, -0.6141679883003235, 0.018965434283018112, -0.23157861828804016, -0.36695799231529236, 0.4180546700954437, -0.6501069068908691, -0.13379403948783875, -0.11493328958749771, 0.16305260360240936, -0.4313029646873474, 0.640294075012207, 0.9395586848258972, -0.4048371911048889, 0.4846845269203186, -0.09989047795534134, 0.8571053147315979, -0.49316585063934326, 0.05673889443278313, -0.07261007279157639, -0.6599761247634888, -0.4638425409793854, -0.1757131814956665, -0.4338977336883545, -0.8853294849395752, 0.454138845205307, 0.020396968349814415, 0.48049598932266235, -0.03137541189789772, -0.6019352674484253, 0.22293394804000854, -0.9079312682151794, 0.769115686416626, -0.5259201526641846, -1.298148274421692, 0.008164952509105206, 1.1887147426605225, 0.34625232219696045, 0.3379897177219391, 0.15802350640296936, -0.5574591159820557, 0.04733435809612274, -0.1542610377073288, 0.12964391708374023, -0.5498083829879761, -0.046670906245708466, -0.37409546971321106, -0.9479684829711914, 0.2576988637447357, 1.005208969116211, 0.11011826992034912, -0.5025801062583923, -0.0977226123213768, -0.5869777798652649, 0.4657050669193268, -0.6159778237342834, -0.3184906840324402, -0.6682483553886414, -0.49936243891716003, -0.6267805099487305, 0.5753315687179565, 0.2780967056751251, -0.15352824330329895, 0.2607012093067169, 0.25793716311454773, -0.1839849054813385, 0.39487412571907043, -0.0644824281334877, 0.02948005683720112, 0.3111657202243805, 0.3777632415294647, -0.40677252411842346, 0.9939740300178528, -0.3994433879852295, 0.5077301263809204, -1.0422043800354004, 0.5790809988975525, -0.8474113345146179, 0.2839624583721161, -0.3359913229942322, -0.22241678833961487, 0.7265620231628418, -0.841115415096283, 0.8373872637748718, 0.20982901751995087, -0.051311470568180084, 1.3053406476974487, 0.6988290548324585, -0.5704033970832825, -0.5268040299415588, -1.0702283382415771, -1.0165952444076538, 1.1693897247314453, -0.17319513857364655, -0.22667698562145233, -1.2075437307357788, -0.6177595257759094, 0.8232989311218262, 0.23898829519748688, 0.3326156735420227, 0.45306599140167236, -0.1893383413553238, 0.2951929569244385, -0.42321377992630005, -0.20873691141605377, -0.3191874623298645, 0.0318165086209774, 0.3093758225440979, -0.4112529456615448, -0.44219696521759033, -0.11169777065515518, -0.22745336592197418, -1.4643975496292114, -0.059647563844919205, 0.6434677839279175, -0.028429875150322914, -0.1410701721906662, 0.43350714445114136, -1.029522180557251, -0.6779458522796631, -0.2750491499900818, -0.3754379153251648, -0.32075005769729614, 0.34878039360046387, 1.1829018592834473, -0.18063010275363922, 0.34499210119247437, -0.4722745716571808, 0.5108293294906616, -0.9030064344406128, -0.3544613718986511, 0.3498799800872803, -0.09640995413064957, -0.588463544845581, -0.25733837485313416, 0.00014758015458937734, -0.8897492289543152, -0.7543368935585022, -0.4958266615867615, 0.4742042124271393, -0.4997577667236328, -0.5377534627914429, 0.5466482043266296, 0.09108205139636993, 0.04079175740480423, 0.5462472438812256, 0.43437325954437256, -0.7190203070640564, -0.4154660999774933, 0.09862379729747772, -0.6935915350914001, -0.7256243824958801, -0.3739655613899231, 0.9502089619636536, -0.45497992634773254, -0.3123782277107239, -0.4421384036540985, -0.6705367565155029, -0.2004716843366623, 0.02834714576601982, -0.3194761872291565, -0.1718994826078415, 0.7905283570289612, 0.669161856174469, 0.8529213666915894, 0.48029476404190063, 0.146061971783638, 0.7846086621284485, -0.24372714757919312, 0.007044599857181311, -0.847270131111145, -1.0273754596710205, -0.1399608701467514, 0.5715733766555786, 0.8111299276351929, 0.09921278804540634, 0.5802584886550903, 0.203939750790596, -0.5054836273193359, -0.5533542633056641, -0.5377755165100098, 0.5068711638450623, -1.166298508644104, -0.5504399538040161, -0.08509930968284607, -0.2642473578453064, -0.2469933182001114, 0.2736224830150604, 0.12946708500385284, -0.1867648810148239, -0.6530327796936035, 0.08884205669164658, 0.14988699555397034, -0.10973033308982849, 0.009060644544661045, -0.7310680747032166, -1.207129716873169, -0.01768886111676693, -0.5093638896942139, -0.4290294945240021, 0.29562389850616455, 0.19140321016311646, -0.5887427926063538, 0.17640367150306702, -0.464322566986084, 0.2872006297111511, -1.0010383129119873, -0.6994476914405823, -0.20618723332881927, -0.4389374256134033, 0.08757583796977997, -0.04585482180118561, -0.6080610752105713, 0.4108826816082001, 0.4276618957519531, 0.09609631448984146, 0.38867616653442383, 0.4617968201637268, -0.49343225359916687, -0.14278462529182434, 0.024468474090099335, 0.6237668991088867, -0.5107377767562866, -1.3485316038131714, 0.4788583517074585, -0.08120512962341309, -1.13367760181427, 0.5733652114868164, -0.17113704979419708, 0.29934048652648926, -0.13992872834205627, -0.03310122340917587, 0.031613294035196304, 1.3923476934432983, -0.41954049468040466, 0.5994410514831543, -0.24381938576698303, 0.1665460765361786, -0.011223898269236088, -0.3666774034500122, -0.9682581424713135, 0.4652879238128662, 0.32377392053604126, -1.259990930557251, -0.08125688880681992, 0.7713087201118469, -0.0953691378235817, -0.06136750057339668, -0.12795941531658173, 0.02729909121990204, -0.4760461151599884, -0.6030476689338684, -0.12713336944580078, 0.4119393527507782, 0.4992413818836212, -0.6936631798744202, -0.2789456248283386, -0.630281925201416, -0.22876200079917908, 0.0896325558423996, -1.0441163778305054, -0.13075989484786987, -0.23590917885303497, -0.47331470251083374, 0.15939217805862427, -0.2675965130329132, 0.21573269367218018, 0.5205310583114624, -0.2890775799751282, 0.3211442530155182, -0.06364158540964127, 0.5220608711242676, -0.09370598942041397, 0.3040211796760559, -1.2486847639083862, -0.42715299129486084, -0.19025155901908875, 0.4308929145336151, -0.49702513217926025, -0.7847480773925781, -0.4759560525417328, 0.1135360449552536, 0.2652079164981842, 0.3014950156211853, -0.7023449540138245, 0.5836071372032166, 0.3096559941768646, -0.002053872449323535, -0.0012606459204107523, 0.3346883952617645, -0.16817881166934967, 0.7392927408218384, 0.16177281737327576, -0.8793611526489258, 0.482693076133728, 0.04901307076215744, 0.2933484613895416, -0.07179044932126999, -0.7538837790489197, 0.5263698101043701, 0.08299238234758377, -1.0100452899932861, 1.8923605680465698, 0.5610235929489136, 0.9379334449768066, -0.14439140260219574, 0.4929678738117218, 0.4549621641635895, -0.15565238893032074, -0.01910294219851494, 0.5109400153160095, 0.5058041214942932, 0.26471567153930664, 0.4784652888774872, 0.2565174102783203, 0.44512030482292175, 0.15482614934444427, 0.535774290561676, 0.09982958436012268, 0.14833231270313263, -0.37396615743637085, 0.6114948987960815, -0.04813925921916962, 0.20458725094795227, 0.10029706358909607, -0.22002892196178436, -0.0507952980697155, 0.09954442083835602, 0.04634684696793556, 0.46249887347221375, -0.8143680691719055, -0.4356086850166321, -0.5103288292884827, 0.45875635743141174, -0.31010767817497253, 0.1411726176738739, -0.00741284154355526, 0.33717256784439087, 0.519176185131073, 0.8136917948722839, 0.21307069063186646, 0.9517000317573547, 0.765083372592926, -0.05824042484164238, 0.43710288405418396, 1.0049724578857422, 0.7252069711685181, 0.1571425199508667, 0.27220165729522705, -1.4615440368652344, -0.1431194245815277, 0.44874441623687744, -1.478070616722107, -0.5350645184516907, -0.4816246032714844, 0.3631545901298523, 0.06528417021036148, -0.7169963121414185, 0.8008618950843811, -0.8597352504730225, 0.5551202297210693, 1.0012128353118896, 0.4250832498073578, -0.1632855087518692, 0.6255900263786316, -0.2683672308921814, 0.5597608685493469, 1.015793800354004, -0.3878604471683502, -0.25484657287597656, 1.0316118001937866, 0.9937940239906311, -0.21881964802742004, 0.6156613826751709, 0.32038626074790955, -0.8211579918861389, 0.27168914675712585, 0.34873199462890625, -0.12394507229328156, 0.6124552488327026, -0.7093417644500732, -0.35542789101600647, 0.23135285079479218, -0.3714545965194702, -0.7032181024551392, 0.025069724768400192, -0.11832672357559204, 0.7852245569229126, -0.5625712275505066, -0.6537290215492249, 1.1780352592468262, 0.060583725571632385, -0.02070843055844307, -0.08798134326934814, 0.04315129667520523, -0.1351788192987442, 0.174207866191864, -0.9158889651298523, 0.30672183632850647, 0.03635072708129883, 0.8141641020774841, -0.5521911382675171, -1.1383877992630005, 0.21189169585704803, -0.9243502020835876, -0.43942269682884216, -0.5548982620239258, 0.8569396138191223, 0.07932975143194199, 0.3695751130580902, -0.3537560701370239, -0.4522617757320404, 0.4993014931678772, 0.299907386302948, 0.7563038468360901, -0.15295177698135376, 0.2396828532218933, 0.9582025408744812, 0.9966902732849121, -1.0552408695220947, 0.4338167905807495, 0.8057736158370972, -0.5054816007614136, 0.6705955862998962, 0.06401278078556061, 0.11368516087532043, -0.3416854441165924, -0.3126530051231384, 0.6986407041549683, 0.11270006746053696, 0.7772972583770752, -1.288353443145752, -0.9757994413375854, -0.1714550405740738, -0.8828634023666382, -0.22953025996685028, -1.0789387226104736, 0.003970524296164513, 0.4766407012939453, 0.6275402307510376, -0.4889167547225952, 0.3298870325088501, 3.6503164768218994, 0.6444560289382935, 0.8551504015922546, -0.22047331929206848, 0.8752029538154602, 0.530750036239624, 0.13825064897537231, -0.8252259492874146, 0.686286985874176, -0.03625539690256119, -0.027566714212298393, 0.5776857137680054, 0.41499805450439453, 0.06971199065446854, -0.5716328620910645, 0.16732491552829742, -0.5147100687026978, 0.20242007076740265, 0.21248631179332733, -1.1167737245559692, -0.755702555179596, 0.6974326968193054, -0.0470096580684185, -0.015108832158148289, -0.04046538099646568, 0.05878855660557747, 0.4304235875606537, -0.9233130216598511, -0.7231756448745728, -0.5730581879615784, -0.7723044157028198, -0.8509901762008667, -0.09331256151199341, 0.2884603440761566, -0.2890108525753021, 0.7819497585296631, 0.5070992708206177, -0.3114255666732788, 0.04234274476766586, 0.3564193844795227, 0.06506302952766418, -0.0003563029458746314, -0.3167092204093933, 0.3981122672557831, -0.9980083107948303, 0.6580280065536499, -0.6978190541267395, 0.7548767924308777, -0.020613010972738266, -0.5187232494354248, 0.46099764108657837, -0.30985674262046814, 1.1539641618728638, 0.034905269742012024, -1.4121185541152954, -0.13204872608184814, -0.8259384632110596, -1.2991037368774414, -0.2706281840801239, -0.16714751720428467, 1.0282269716262817, 0.17963740229606628, -0.1263851374387741, 0.3819175958633423, -0.8996343016624451, 0.6045628786087036, 0.7398307919502258, -0.42732709646224976, -0.03933826461434364, 0.3817906975746155, -0.27058616280555725, 0.0592489056289196, -0.42280182242393494, 0.6926185488700867, -0.07684341073036194, -0.10981869697570801, -0.19116100668907166, 0.6159095168113708, 0.24706201255321503, 0.07391135394573212, -0.2400926649570465, -0.45061397552490234, -0.23912978172302246, 0.17600791156291962, 0.004469980485737324, 0.6208509206771851, -0.4796719253063202, 0.04477277770638466, -0.1791277527809143, 0.5174477696418762, 0.359413743019104, 0.8948513865470886, 0.00794113427400589, -0.36538976430892944, -0.6242128014564514 ]
Multimagnetical Simulations
We modified the recently proposed multicanonical MC algorithm for the case of a magnetic field driven order--order phase transition. We test this {\it multimagnetic} Monte Carlo algorithm for the D=2 Ising model at $\beta=0.5$ and simulate square lattices up to size $100 \times 100$. On these lattices with periodic boundary conditions it is possible to enhance the appearance of order-order interfaces during the simulation by many orders of magnitude as compared to the standard Monte Carlo simulation.
U. Hansmann, B.A. Berg and T. Neuhaus
hep-lat
March
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9203002
hep-lat/9204001
[ 0.07979043573141098, 0.21103569865226746, 0.5952603220939636, 0.4868391454219818, 0.15991230309009552, -0.09603503346443176, -0.10342548042535782, -0.08929288387298584, -0.8112004399299622, 1.7461142539978027, 1.1704182624816895, -0.3471674621105194, 0.3623705208301544, -1.049070119857788, -0.5702549815177917, -0.053211577236652374, -0.5701508522033691, -0.5542663335800171, -0.753652036190033, -0.4658607244491577, 0.42889395356178284, -0.07759609073400497, -1.493455410003662, -1.0425758361816406, -1.0183367729187012, 0.7063970565795898, 0.6752092838287354, 0.25176170468330383, 1.8017650842666626, 0.3498341739177704, 0.44011515378952026, -0.8496719598770142, 0.05384288355708122, -1.0907869338989258, -0.2571125328540802, 0.00939656887203455, 0.4092426896095276, 0.6408594846725464, 0.2661898732185364, -0.9003655910491943, 1.6499865055084229, -0.2543674111366272, 0.825892984867096, 0.6811424493789673, -0.4872037172317505, -0.5216308236122131, -0.024244539439678192, 0.06662792712450027, 0.22458872199058533, -0.7914716601371765, 0.5241015553474426, 0.2185811847448349, 0.4150135815143585, -0.6036142110824585, 0.27587807178497314, 0.310343474149704, 0.27037325501441956, 1.0168174505233765, -0.3377950191497803, -0.32851552963256836, 1.0109587907791138, 0.06029132008552551, 0.5031867623329163, -1.031685471534729, 0.611720860004425, 0.7724384069442749, -0.4629277288913727, 0.2891148328781128, -0.06608256697654724, -0.5970224738121033, -0.3941330313682556, -0.43253272771835327, -0.20183303952217102, -0.4509911835193634, -0.7165389060974121, 1.0617951154708862, -0.5097106099128723, -0.0316956490278244, -1.4714339971542358, -0.7479533553123474, -0.10079599171876907, -0.1989203244447708, -0.4093792736530304, 0.9105157852172852, 0.3225083649158478, -0.05611152946949005, 0.17038212716579437, -0.09114975482225418, -0.4594656825065613, -0.2975844442844391, 0.1803470253944397, 0.5878147482872009, -0.022962434217333794, -0.2330540418624878, -0.04038456827402115, 0.7005151510238647, -0.18039743602275848, 0.9339617490768433, 0.5353582501411438, 0.5033280253410339, -0.40727269649505615, 0.6237973570823669, -0.4603656530380249, 0.9608787894248962, -0.02403668314218521, 0.23317527770996094, -0.030802473425865173, 0.09122638404369354, -0.5155502557754517, -0.5622806549072266, -0.11001940071582794, 0.3125726580619812, 0.5114342570304871, 0.8827795386314392, 0.1203756034374237, 0.6753166317939758, 0.12888966500759125, 0.0493285171687603, -1.0489490032196045, -0.024156806990504265, 0.3353498876094818, 0.24340389668941498, 0.023606620728969574, 0.01749276928603649, 0.05797554925084114, -0.7939938306808472, 0.26691457629203796, 0.41555359959602356, -0.3423871099948883, 0.18439100682735443, -0.2509176731109619, -0.46530741453170776, -0.06458551436662674, 0.7723001837730408, -0.13959434628486633, 0.6374061703681946, -0.2504768967628479, 1.1141877174377441, 0.20766228437423706, -1.22195565700531, 0.43406546115875244, -0.5427090525627136, 0.24937309324741364, 0.9975247383117676, 0.03110348992049694, 0.20787450671195984, 0.46859976649284363, -0.3394147455692291, -0.13840709626674652, 0.8125678896903992, -0.41479700803756714, 0.08198278397321701, -0.028966205194592476, 0.11252490431070328, -0.4024735391139984, -0.16321565210819244, -1.3634620904922485, 1.031395435333252, -0.4309650659561157, -0.18724055588245392, -0.37987878918647766, -0.491375207901001, -0.3059689700603485, 0.18443036079406738, -0.23648463189601898, 0.08832350373268127, -0.5352981686592102, -0.6348744630813599, -0.44650962948799133, -0.3620052933692932, 0.022758470848202705, -0.4611891210079193, 0.0022517391480505466, 0.4163639545440674, 0.1082378476858139, 0.3193637728691101, 0.44247376918792725, -0.38787713646888733, 0.36893200874328613, 0.6857118606567383, -0.6778284311294556, -0.023311054334044456, 1.079227089881897, 0.12017601728439331, -0.4329582154750824, -0.30374300479888916, -0.947992205619812, 0.0034945583902299404, -0.057075321674346924, 0.2351740002632141, -0.7040139436721802, 0.5426884889602661, -0.47339922189712524, 0.452309787273407, -0.5299063324928284, -0.6148305535316467, -0.9834846258163452, 0.5086870789527893, -0.8440210223197937, -0.39234891533851624, -0.41594645380973816, 0.2032887488603592, -0.4469691812992096, -0.3524124026298523, -1.1364408731460571, 0.117163747549057, 0.12312936782836914, -0.28462767601013184, -0.8037034869194031, 0.17679420113563538, 0.3644063174724579, 0.4093446433544159, 0.15396471321582794, -0.15813322365283966, -0.08417632430791855, -0.10096157342195511, -0.5031179189682007, -0.2539841830730438, 0.8648102283477783, -0.6737034320831299, 1.0018293857574463, 0.18774518370628357, 0.26337897777557373, 0.20489993691444397, -0.2071782499551773, 0.19297271966934204, 0.44069162011146545, 0.9760375618934631, 0.071377232670784, 0.29054176807403564, 0.22090868651866913, 0.6467827558517456, 0.33162230253219604, 0.5014793872833252, 1.2126579284667969, 0.37214958667755127, 0.6334573030471802, 0.4126049280166626, 0.5152799487113953, -0.25704798102378845, 0.14775389432907104, 0.1880486011505127, 0.7605774998664856, -0.071045882999897, 0.6145238876342773, 0.26236608624458313, -0.6528879404067993, 0.289119690656662, -0.35080862045288086, 1.0908021926879883, -0.3326771855354309, 1.225920557975769, 0.25022831559181213, 0.010189230553805828, -0.2841324210166931, -0.05715922638773918, -0.0946689173579216, 0.40971729159355164, -0.06588029116392136, 0.3581679165363312, 0.034432828426361084, 0.06245676428079605, -0.458477646112442, -0.2928237318992615, -0.737774670124054, 1.2192286252975464, -0.0931101143360138, 0.08415161818265915, -0.05351903662085533, -0.21247753500938416, -0.6834132075309753, -0.6494277715682983, -0.6935299634933472, 0.035095904022455215, -0.09222763776779175, 0.054220687597990036, 1.0981550216674805, -0.7134267091751099, 0.5035762786865234, -0.19445329904556274, -0.09024515002965927, 0.5541384220123291, 0.2893248200416565, 0.5067788362503052, 0.6978439688682556, -0.3072619140148163, -1.291901707649231, -0.04415528476238251, -0.7644625306129456, -0.3063567280769348, 0.07737459242343903, 0.44027066230773926, 0.6421405673027039, -0.6043348908424377, 0.26593559980392456, -0.5415220856666565, -0.48202601075172424, -0.45424604415893555, -0.11155132204294205, -0.19488921761512756, 0.16816532611846924, 0.78663170337677, -0.290683388710022, 0.28292956948280334, -0.963988721370697, 1.2336469888687134, 0.13332761824131012, -0.27323612570762634, 0.7489462494850159, 0.5440145134925842, -0.2882775664329529, 0.18655851483345032, -0.08688648045063019, 0.18051458895206451, -0.2727022171020508, 0.5310267210006714, 0.4143633544445038, 0.6378981471061707, -0.4167316257953644, -0.45674777030944824, -0.32697606086730957, -0.28138336539268494, 0.2989254891872406, -0.6199054718017578, -0.24280965328216553, 0.12331873923540115, 0.14681078493595123, -0.8467667698860168, 0.6034967303276062, -0.5205339193344116, -0.830818235874176, 0.39980804920196533, -0.9038394689559937, -0.16219130158424377, -0.2620522379875183, 0.41360682249069214, -0.6232556104660034, 0.32939985394477844, 0.45684242248535156, 0.7523563504219055, 0.645042896270752, -0.5572494268417358, 1.098496913909912, -0.0004943054518662393, 0.0020328015089035034, -0.4443349242210388, 0.7730184197425842, 0.2142173796892166, -0.41310495138168335, 0.4819214344024658, -0.8219529390335083, -0.1999317854642868, 0.7053821086883545, 0.7522218823432922, 0.5380268692970276, 0.49201154708862305, -0.7530533075332642, -0.0469670370221138, -0.7210863828659058, 0.07370107620954514, 0.7856278419494629, 0.40403982996940613, -0.7940371036529541, 0.6238993406295776, -0.7371491193771362, -0.41073939204216003, 0.5338793992996216, -0.005528271663933992, 0.8997132778167725, -0.926531195640564, 0.7719329595565796, -0.28238165378570557, -0.07729075103998184, 0.32715797424316406, -0.15631870925426483, 0.18092170357704163, -0.41199055314064026, 0.10288529098033905, 1.315248727798462, -0.705614447593689, -0.7873756885528564, 0.15687404572963715, 0.9796475768089294, 0.5953621864318848, 0.8663568496704102, 0.4449908435344696, -0.104820117354393, 0.21257217228412628, -0.7636619210243225, -0.9207872748374939, -0.022579580545425415, -0.023423591628670692, -0.5244240164756775, -0.4475473165512085, -0.09234199672937393, -0.8041716814041138, 0.7217952609062195, 0.6161679625511169, -0.1633811891078949, -0.2905556559562683, 0.787121593952179, 0.13607683777809143, 0.11514680087566376, 0.6415586471557617, 0.21298880875110626, -0.027194347232580185, -0.8794856667518616, 0.535498857498169, 0.18463176488876343, 0.009510778822004795, -0.2352445125579834, -0.4970862567424774, -0.6294311881065369, -0.47838065028190613, 0.5742054581642151, 0.4710681736469269, -0.20683030784130096, 0.9814454913139343, -0.13985712826251984, 0.16249096393585205, -0.34183812141418457, 0.21955528855323792, 0.4386931359767914, 0.8052608370780945, 0.42603543400764465, -1.112375259399414, -0.5698618292808533, -0.6167081594467163, 0.6093364357948303, 0.9129229187965393, -0.08395865559577942, -1.0556124448776245, -0.7487735152244568, 0.07346121966838837, -0.8131162524223328, -0.26601845026016235, 0.918572723865509, -0.5924970507621765, 0.04319579154253006, -0.3272005021572113, -0.14685839414596558, -0.05117158219218254, -0.7756184339523315, -0.49654620885849, 0.8234815001487732, 0.07907316833734512, -0.5873419642448425, 0.3566433787345886, 0.44469398260116577, 0.021372241899371147, -0.1585751175880432, -0.13320410251617432, 0.03679626062512398, -0.22169119119644165, -0.4114972949028015, 0.22221355140209198, -0.17422334849834442, -0.6555983424186707, 0.22068510949611664, -0.8322902917861938, 0.3270711600780487, -0.2712421715259552, 0.7778650522232056, -0.5719847679138184, -0.20941223204135895, -0.010299247689545155, 0.06151615455746651, 0.6984758973121643, 0.7470512390136719, 0.5023991465568542, 0.3890346586704254, 0.14569178223609924, 0.0537770576775074, 0.1777660995721817, 0.3115379810333252, -0.015270681120455265, 0.46347951889038086, -0.6776706576347351, 0.04566211253404617, -0.6109651923179626, -1.228760004043579, 0.8371540904045105, -0.42168763279914856, 0.4207908809185028, 0.3909301161766052, -0.9909490942955017, 0.0763009712100029, -0.023806368932127953, -0.5411484837532043, 0.14062100648880005, -0.770010232925415, -0.17741838097572327, 0.2431294322013855, -0.2022077888250351, -0.6942015290260315, 0.2118588089942932, 0.43739578127861023, -0.6957762241363525, 0.13176964223384857, 0.37893131375312805, -0.428642213344574, 0.7249919176101685, -0.8157698512077332, 0.33236077427864075, -0.29155561327934265, 0.32519516348838806, -0.2528587281703949, -1.1319690942764282, -0.5984818339347839, 0.04329513758420944, -0.8385493755340576, -0.46514689922332764, -0.09165818989276886, 0.3832700550556183, 0.43245363235473633, 0.18331804871559143, -0.3093452453613281, -0.34617507457733154, -0.9050807952880859, 0.5375857353210449, -0.26067033410072327, -1.1313291788101196, -0.4845891296863556, 1.567081332206726, -0.1467636078596115, 0.13840822875499725, -0.12345549464225769, -0.3842437267303467, -0.039264846593141556, -0.21349284052848816, -0.06112605333328247, -0.5250021815299988, -0.18897852301597595, -0.18519112467765808, -0.23796959221363068, 0.0016249418258666992, 0.32963114976882935, 0.5843711495399475, -0.10437583923339844, -0.19476482272148132, -0.3840239942073822, 0.30240797996520996, -0.6717296242713928, -0.17077770829200745, -0.3792070746421814, -0.4244675636291504, -0.4609606862068176, 0.4816344976425171, 0.1626552790403366, -0.32960838079452515, 0.4415842294692993, -0.0643724873661995, -0.2218998223543167, 0.8368657231330872, 0.08897270262241364, 0.0041529047302901745, -0.0013813305413350463, 0.32114970684051514, -0.15508638322353363, 0.3867681324481964, -0.3249427378177643, 0.1662500500679016, -1.171998143196106, 0.21980375051498413, -0.22866114974021912, 0.2917758822441101, -0.2693876326084137, 0.006933355238288641, 0.879194974899292, -0.5987984538078308, 0.17358888685703278, -0.13007716834545135, 0.31910935044288635, 1.238383412361145, 0.09985338151454926, -0.6314182877540588, -0.6526299715042114, -0.6296964883804321, -1.772730827331543, 0.8231877684593201, -0.10387364774942398, 0.2068680077791214, -0.3349665403366089, -0.1606048345565796, 0.6792911887168884, -0.10039827972650528, 0.13208317756652832, 0.22943516075611115, -0.34466129541397095, 0.09400010854005814, 0.2565164268016815, 0.1385974884033203, -0.3231590986251831, -1.0731935501098633, 0.1662643551826477, -0.0191494170576334, -0.663002073764801, -0.46318763494491577, -0.5320322513580322, -1.0898078680038452, -0.527461588382721, 0.9566068053245544, 0.7700058817863464, -0.13669085502624512, 0.8285659551620483, -0.2883850634098053, -0.22007127106189728, -1.012444257736206, -0.4730050563812256, 0.21414066851139069, 0.511367678642273, 1.300066590309143, -0.06972192227840424, -0.2595420777797699, -0.7009969353675842, 0.6415045857429504, -0.39422115683555603, -0.47668325901031494, 0.7860443592071533, -0.35846954584121704, -0.4627237319946289, -0.21159420907497406, -0.04949384555220604, -1.2790340185165405, -0.43959367275238037, -0.12051644176244736, 0.5150761604309082, 0.40843549370765686, -0.848613440990448, -0.09214484691619873, -0.29099175333976746, -0.10188255459070206, -0.11824949085712433, 0.4049699008464813, -0.6310690641403198, 0.6589890718460083, 0.16898086667060852, 0.17438462376594543, -1.1699618101119995, -0.13510552048683167, 0.8059201240539551, -0.5439057946205139, -0.11625738441944122, -0.6459243297576904, -0.014712212607264519, -0.21007616817951202, -0.08431148529052734, 0.10294472426176071, -0.484179824590683, 0.5587911605834961, 0.21063587069511414, 0.6445545554161072, 0.13827376067638397, -0.08075588941574097, 0.2817176580429077, -0.33677196502685547, 0.1574435532093048, -0.9192570447921753, -0.8468206524848938, -0.3890443742275238, 0.32741647958755493, 0.3609313368797302, -0.29008913040161133, 0.42730140686035156, 0.04431364685297012, -0.5358092188835144, -0.6256008744239807, -1.4613405466079712, 0.3749607503414154, -1.253127932548523, -0.8370673060417175, -0.3888055086135864, -0.11391487717628479, -0.7645941376686096, 0.34224429726600647, 0.14368660748004913, -0.1983826756477356, -0.8304140567779541, -0.3889775276184082, 0.2636350989341736, 0.42564094066619873, -0.2899409830570221, -0.5766627788543701, -1.250207781791687, 0.2899668216705322, -0.3571052849292755, -0.36897048354148865, 0.2052113264799118, 0.41284602880477905, -0.7526344656944275, 0.1907910257577896, -0.07371681928634644, 0.6750476360321045, -1.129154920578003, -0.5524250864982605, -0.04067722707986832, -0.5575164556503296, -0.05049154534935951, 0.29473140835762024, -0.14130799472332, 0.38212907314300537, 0.4637170135974884, 0.21567019820213318, -0.22738021612167358, 0.07027518004179001, -0.6438943147659302, -0.3489353358745575, -0.09354836493730545, 0.31305772066116333, 0.0704474151134491, -1.0355961322784424, 0.2866469919681549, -0.07536379247903824, -1.2022035121917725, 0.31088051199913025, -0.3251989185810089, -0.06247835233807564, -0.18979217112064362, -0.3774021565914154, 0.538061261177063, 0.5089336633682251, -0.23522800207138062, 0.5100239515304565, -0.4992230534553528, -0.29170751571655273, -0.4093514382839203, 0.0827641412615776, -0.3904400169849396, 0.5742387175559998, -0.23729121685028076, -0.9416007995605469, 0.058715976774692535, 0.5541349053382874, 0.03839215263724327, -0.043758243322372437, -0.4253683388233185, -0.430404931306839, -0.4071650505065918, -0.41384637355804443, -0.6257389783859253, 0.887250542640686, 0.3159593641757965, -0.006229871418327093, -0.8102721571922302, -0.6182073950767517, -0.6274416446685791, -0.4274795651435852, -0.9739193320274353, -0.2128964513540268, -0.1800999939441681, -0.35155999660491943, -0.007327977567911148, 0.06641717255115509, -0.44180652499198914, 0.22037068009376526, 0.2862567603588104, 0.4850265383720398, -0.009997360408306122, 0.39153772592544556, -0.2779967784881592, 0.5538802742958069, -1.020538568496704, -0.5641905069351196, -0.24402251839637756, 0.15153542160987854, -0.4693049192428589, 0.19866760075092316, 0.32382234930992126, 0.6478064656257629, -0.1898157298564911, 0.6852060556411743, -0.7724097371101379, 0.31449058651924133, 0.7149102687835693, 0.044347651302814484, -0.5546780824661255, 0.4537489712238312, 0.007168200798332691, 0.6642501354217529, 0.10921961069107056, -0.5428189039230347, 0.6959354281425476, -0.1518995314836502, 0.2809465527534485, 0.23453955352306366, -0.4715174734592438, 1.0290350914001465, -0.20516656339168549, -0.9969830513000488, 1.8403757810592651, 0.12523120641708374, 0.6188063621520996, -0.0939832329750061, 0.4783003330230713, 0.6584768891334534, 0.35555407404899597, -0.00130581040866673, 0.31531262397766113, 0.7340565323829651, 0.18321487307548523, 0.008709017187356949, 0.4121391773223877, 0.5328114032745361, 0.7987167239189148, 0.7523565888404846, 0.6040281653404236, 0.5772601962089539, -0.2136932611465454, 0.1961214542388916, 0.05564798042178154, -0.062059689313173294, 0.31298893690109253, -0.047133706510066986, -0.2699081301689148, -0.2489342838525772, 0.17907242476940155, 0.5736088752746582, -0.7459002733230591, -0.6112534403800964, 0.22683613002300262, 0.6414758563041687, -0.3911266326904297, -0.3937901556491852, 0.0867457315325737, 0.1094612181186676, 0.5092414021492004, 0.7789771556854248, 0.6147115230560303, 1.1180901527404785, 0.8155410289764404, 0.29367783665657043, 0.20547816157341003, 0.25559064745903015, 0.7162892818450928, 0.05278772488236427, 0.2296856790781021, -1.139613151550293, -0.22791068255901337, 0.5094855427742004, -1.005645513534546, -0.32264643907546997, -0.5872209072113037, -0.6448854207992554, 0.6757673621177673, -0.8734608888626099, 0.27497661113739014, -0.6244900226593018, 0.4546178877353668, 0.7767881155014038, 0.2128123939037323, 0.49640271067619324, 0.6827265024185181, 0.022504890337586403, 0.9209356904029846, 0.7403724193572998, -0.0158157367259264, 0.01507036853581667, 1.015626072883606, 1.2422287464141846, 0.30079442262649536, 0.25626492500305176, 0.5648028254508972, -0.6668084859848022, 0.10921128839254379, -0.34340164065361023, -0.08638136833906174, 1.0927207469940186, -0.4129180908203125, -0.5353217124938965, 0.0229496993124485, 0.1126616895198822, -0.8841618895530701, -0.36444830894470215, 0.23609744012355804, 0.5870187282562256, -0.48756882548332214, 0.1125723198056221, 0.8164231777191162, -0.21789178252220154, 0.015219874680042267, 0.024943886324763298, 0.3304227292537689, -0.6624252200126648, -0.11737271398305893, -0.5072797536849976, 0.37235063314437866, -0.038696397095918655, 0.4964529573917389, 0.0004032445722259581, -1.1992968320846558, -0.16604360938072205, -0.7053675055503845, -0.487253874540329, -0.7045418620109558, 0.9154225587844849, -0.1372387707233429, 0.5527403950691223, 0.10664486140012741, -0.8755689859390259, 0.20479564368724823, 0.4073489308357239, 0.5455268025398254, -0.0813695415854454, 0.5340014696121216, 0.8285565376281738, 0.8883538842201233, -0.7593531608581543, 0.03632825240492821, 1.1078273057937622, 0.04644760489463806, 1.0150395631790161, 0.16096188127994537, -0.13121570646762848, -0.3520655333995819, -0.6439130306243896, 0.7554358839988708, 0.3061281740665436, 0.28766679763793945, -0.6319443583488464, -0.4724561870098114, 0.24367287755012512, -0.8977489471435547, 0.36020511388778687, -1.4204914569854736, 0.061623021960258484, -0.04126182198524475, 0.3860035836696625, -0.49294525384902954, -0.3794543445110321, 3.828458786010742, 0.6298014521598816, 1.0545908212661743, 0.17694078385829926, 0.3391514718532562, 1.220861792564392, 0.13298629224300385, -0.09539523720741272, 0.011337070725858212, -0.1674928218126297, -0.0981522798538208, 1.0603139400482178, 0.5586228966712952, 0.2087385505437851, -0.3678392171859741, 0.7892763018608093, -0.6415038108825684, 0.5621553063392639, 0.16147585213184357, -1.3014380931854248, -0.8051182627677917, 0.6333661675453186, -0.2559191584587097, 0.10813691467046738, 0.08060384541749954, -0.12667299807071686, 0.35298314690589905, -0.4204561710357666, -0.49600541591644287, -0.18666303157806396, -0.12270079553127289, -0.9662652611732483, 0.005454660393297672, 0.36117875576019287, -0.40925127267837524, 0.1269983947277069, 0.34036216139793396, -0.6858736872673035, 0.34817683696746826, 0.687730073928833, 0.11930479854345322, 0.141534686088562, -0.3035525679588318, -0.006435288581997156, -0.7966420650482178, 0.17593039572238922, -0.3812388777732849, 0.5251690745353699, 0.1511935144662857, -0.45845702290534973, 0.25080984830856323, -0.3813123404979706, 1.3103121519088745, -0.371399462223053, -1.286192774772644, 0.061970632523298264, -1.213235855102539, -0.9389501810073853, -0.10881001502275467, 0.14121727645397186, 1.243318796157837, -0.2601155638694763, 0.36095672845840454, 0.46243786811828613, -0.47576457262039185, 0.8541838526725769, 0.38767191767692566, -0.37943795323371887, -0.15311750769615173, 0.47728490829467773, -0.557659387588501, -0.015602655708789825, -0.488396555185318, -0.5601608753204346, 0.5685440897941589, 0.043718066066503525, -0.6942379474639893, 0.7793103456497192, 0.08620386570692062, -0.1957317441701889, -0.17648927867412567, -0.6919431686401367, 0.4903934895992279, -0.2606267035007477, -0.30209776759147644, 0.9960286021232605, -0.5339676737785339, 0.7337508201599121, 0.41915732622146606, 0.20492033660411835, 0.42793744802474976, 0.6644194722175598, 0.20266912877559662, -0.11655354499816895, -0.1011291891336441 ]
A New Approach to Spin Glass Simulations
We present a recursive procedure to calculate the parameters of the recently introduced multicanonical ensemble and explore the approach for spin glasses. Temperature dependence of the energy, the entropy and other physical quantities are easily calculable and we report results for the zero temperature limit. Our data provide evidence that the large $L$ increase of the ergodicity time is greatly improved. The multicanonical ensemble seems to open new horizons for simulations of spin glasses and other systems which have to cope with conflicting constraints.
Bernd A. Berg and Tarik Celik
hep-lat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9204001
hep-lat/9204002
[ 0.2433522790670395, 0.19533823430538177, 0.21653558313846588, 0.28238213062286377, 0.44685837626457214, -0.5278053283691406, -0.03076758235692978, -0.42072954773902893, -0.3006822168827057, 0.9548227787017822, 0.862929105758667, -0.2599949240684509, 0.8099361062049866, -1.045088768005371, -0.32227906584739685, 0.7049440741539001, -0.18593139946460724, -0.7281978726387024, -0.5304868817329407, -0.3451036810874939, 0.16525211930274963, -0.04221327602863312, -1.5202610492706299, -0.9761573672294617, -0.5301617980003357, 0.9293596148490906, -0.08681781589984894, 0.2648688852787018, 1.2984133958816528, 0.4074610769748688, 0.5339027643203735, -0.7455370426177979, 0.36372318863868713, -0.5349527597427368, -0.8018919825553894, -0.42451003193855286, 0.2307647317647934, 0.031113699078559875, 0.22090774774551392, -0.7559340596199036, 1.1895304918289185, -0.6494740843772888, 0.47309425473213196, 0.1645246148109436, -0.2853524684906006, 0.055383361876010895, -0.2032109797000885, 0.07405143231153488, 0.26529350876808167, -1.142444372177124, -0.08911914378404617, -0.12325040996074677, 0.5298439860343933, 0.03188421204686165, -0.41980719566345215, -0.19747723639011383, 0.07214318215847015, -0.37047451734542847, -0.7279168367385864, -0.09774971008300781, 0.6012017726898193, -0.043829746544361115, 0.9827083945274353, -0.7189337611198425, 0.28424808382987976, 0.13006232678890228, 0.02721983566880226, 0.39988410472869873, 0.29945826530456543, -0.7652067542076111, -1.2015739679336548, -0.5187674164772034, -0.6150978803634644, 0.12648674845695496, -0.6491141319274902, 0.42319774627685547, 0.0068626124411821365, -0.4718495011329651, -1.3072655200958252, -0.7371314167976379, -0.6328877806663513, -0.4980870485305786, -0.7026607394218445, 0.11342914402484894, -0.45356443524360657, -0.5299582481384277, 0.28954195976257324, 0.12227556854486465, 0.12214978784322739, 0.4101145565509796, 0.8519191741943359, 0.430113822221756, 0.8846375942230225, -0.5585699677467346, 0.5748088955879211, 1.0612010955810547, 0.048830416053533554, 0.47334998846054077, 0.1608259528875351, 0.20871727168560028, -0.13357490301132202, 0.8325687050819397, -0.4279930293560028, 0.6658526062965393, -0.6109257340431213, 0.11343342065811157, 0.2282862365245819, -0.08997480571269989, -0.4531500041484833, -0.6472584009170532, -0.3703058063983917, 0.25123947858810425, -0.11515460908412933, 0.32600998878479004, -0.13954059779644012, 0.2745038866996765, 0.030858317390084267, -0.6470397710800171, -0.6901081800460815, 0.2506410479545593, -0.007188183255493641, 0.06816078722476959, 0.2934669554233551, 0.38128453493118286, -0.12051624059677124, -0.4083222448825836, 0.16444316506385803, 0.6845283508300781, -0.4764178991317749, -0.10732818394899368, 0.20706112682819366, -0.03044942580163479, -0.3211691677570343, 1.0377941131591797, -0.507850706577301, 0.24700358510017395, 0.33914947509765625, 0.14924873411655426, 0.5548692345619202, -0.23511865735054016, 0.819821298122406, -0.6720147728919983, -0.08298833668231964, 1.3995354175567627, 0.2669411301612854, 0.5418233871459961, 0.3215106427669525, -0.7770749926567078, -0.21061022579669952, 0.528035044670105, -0.7896985411643982, 0.2580808997154236, -0.32216954231262207, 0.5429690480232239, -0.1882135421037674, 0.594598114490509, -0.6469573378562927, 1.0837574005126953, -0.9776302576065063, -0.6096751689910889, 0.6806825399398804, 0.007146706338971853, -0.42925554513931274, 0.6881706714630127, -0.7322639226913452, 0.37281882762908936, -0.5674352049827576, 0.24431321024894714, -0.24034278094768524, -0.7853701710700989, 0.18945705890655518, 0.49645766615867615, -0.4220183193683624, 0.9357448816299438, 0.18827702105045319, 0.7340855002403259, 0.4921056628227234, -0.2708737850189209, 0.04789962247014046, 0.17497234046459198, -0.09843277186155319, -0.46658551692962646, 0.7719947099685669, 0.33283737301826477, -0.07328948378562927, 0.44721609354019165, -0.27578261494636536, -0.4096878170967102, 0.025531504303216934, 0.5906336903572083, 0.11370089650154114, 0.4889453053474426, -0.406376451253891, 0.29234716296195984, -0.34542331099510193, -0.425813764333725, -0.9186146855354309, 0.5174645781517029, -0.4787951409816742, -0.6371191740036011, -0.14038118720054626, 0.38697534799575806, -0.5997945666313171, 0.26229339838027954, -1.5355387926101685, 0.6870792508125305, -0.3740050494670868, 0.3008970022201538, -0.38732776045799255, -0.5666590929031372, 0.7158685326576233, -0.27817535400390625, 0.8737336993217468, -0.12232986837625504, -0.08754982054233551, 0.4008370339870453, -0.43911951780319214, 0.34412842988967896, 0.549452006816864, -0.8885493874549866, 0.7920932173728943, 0.15298216044902802, -0.5208293795585632, 1.0381178855895996, -0.2731269896030426, -0.32369470596313477, 0.37326452136039734, 0.021803922951221466, 0.3340301513671875, 0.3202625513076782, -0.11839200556278229, 1.0798835754394531, 0.07537971436977386, 0.5440989136695862, 0.6696509718894958, 0.6481620669364929, 0.7784602046012878, 0.7511873841285706, 0.3293662965297699, 0.07181096076965332, 0.10084303468465805, -0.20097161829471588, 0.24101991951465607, 0.3544127643108368, 0.31075942516326904, 0.3034669756889343, -0.6392129063606262, 0.8494597673416138, -0.5327927470207214, 0.7159848809242249, -1.252432942390442, 1.0245453119277954, 0.38307756185531616, 0.35185888409614563, -0.8137999773025513, 0.4552428126335144, 0.26396942138671875, 0.4698493182659149, -0.4766307771205902, -0.3099290132522583, -0.46868616342544556, 0.14854881167411804, 0.4719022810459137, -0.14112994074821472, -0.14660510420799255, 1.5915076732635498, 0.11367674916982651, 0.43944162130355835, -0.10113683342933655, -0.28011152148246765, -1.5354384183883667, -0.7213379144668579, -0.2969377040863037, -0.3597177267074585, -0.5133911371231079, 0.34063777327537537, 0.9347424507141113, -0.7323923707008362, 0.7044059038162231, -0.3255983889102936, -0.48687461018562317, 0.7228931188583374, 0.2330220341682434, 0.9298774003982544, 0.7277498245239258, -0.47937914729118347, -0.9287827610969543, 0.32404500246047974, -0.7580730319023132, 0.33879175782203674, -0.4540414810180664, 0.4142765402793884, 0.5971558690071106, -0.19917187094688416, 0.2613757848739624, -0.35690829157829285, -0.491497278213501, -0.11661666631698608, 0.4225980341434479, -0.5245521068572998, 0.2078927904367447, 0.8663256764411926, 0.11765122413635254, -0.2614671587944031, -0.5475268959999084, 1.0077288150787354, 0.5210303664207458, -0.29046204686164856, 0.788734495639801, 0.4668343961238861, 0.18006601929664612, 0.27629077434539795, -0.378194659948349, -0.3092917799949646, -0.03203291445970535, 1.0210258960723877, 0.9571382403373718, 0.24553419649600983, 0.053219061344861984, -0.4924566149711609, -0.26343363523483276, -0.04715900123119354, -0.2839738726615906, -0.7417058348655701, 0.022558648139238358, 1.3011250495910645, 0.23470549285411835, -0.8855999112129211, 0.07350868731737137, -0.6166945099830627, -0.5039611458778381, 0.5173789858818054, -0.5179346799850464, 0.6459833383560181, -0.38965627551078796, -0.09708577394485474, -0.717470109462738, 0.10476908832788467, 0.21075280010700226, 0.197381392121315, -0.01727214828133583, -0.40027251839637756, 0.3541206121444702, 0.3447153866291046, 0.22213293612003326, 0.1756543666124344, 0.6783455610275269, 0.07758738100528717, -0.3143715262413025, 0.1813124716281891, -1.148383378982544, -0.04991595074534416, 0.16161827743053436, 0.1824915111064911, -0.26886871457099915, 0.3644022047519684, -0.6244317889213562, -0.6004189848899841, -0.32028234004974365, -0.29252922534942627, -0.36312374472618103, 0.27437084913253784, -0.3929482102394104, 0.5456757545471191, -0.44063279032707214, -0.34325653314590454, 0.7166241407394409, -0.14703677594661713, 0.916702151298523, -0.7489290237426758, 0.995544970035553, 0.29187461733818054, 0.22432884573936462, 0.05560144782066345, 0.009434844367206097, 0.048248421400785446, -0.08019880950450897, -0.1234278529882431, 0.6966869831085205, -0.18018195033073425, -0.9493632316589355, 0.12085916101932526, 0.7726134061813354, 0.9808405637741089, 1.1276071071624756, 0.6900349259376526, -0.04798818379640579, -0.3608834445476532, -0.5592623353004456, -0.22682833671569824, -0.0028981221839785576, -0.25505203008651733, -0.19004671275615692, -0.472591757774353, -0.6010456681251526, -0.053509265184402466, 0.2235366851091385, 0.4318866431713104, 0.5028730034828186, -0.16840201616287231, 0.5640855431556702, 0.44765669107437134, 0.1301039755344391, 0.7448789477348328, 0.09714453667402267, 0.043225377798080444, -1.300726056098938, 0.25092726945877075, 0.3980158269405365, 0.23206721246242523, -0.2336970567703247, -0.5641331076622009, -0.13503092527389526, -0.629965603351593, 0.8014952540397644, -0.035693343728780746, -0.37451326847076416, 0.2751240134239197, -0.5735312700271606, 0.42030826210975647, -0.26969626545906067, -0.48972374200820923, 0.5197893381118774, 0.6963045001029968, -0.469180703163147, -0.9219529628753662, -0.42140495777130127, -0.46547067165374756, 0.4581645429134369, 0.33056899905204773, -0.68072110414505, -1.2412108182907104, -0.19019049406051636, -0.1588384062051773, -1.296077847480774, -0.44134488701820374, 0.7062410116195679, -0.3578508496284485, -0.45263436436653137, -0.7958371043205261, -0.5172112584114075, 0.4445113241672516, 0.1422826200723648, -0.6484736800193787, 0.42388683557510376, -0.007764728739857674, -0.054899878799915314, 0.5839386582374573, -0.333096444606781, -0.17376568913459778, -0.552240788936615, -0.36869198083877563, -0.11516202986240387, 0.01131123024970293, -0.28551894426345825, -0.47083166241645813, -0.773549497127533, -0.7128573656082153, 0.17920756340026855, -0.1154789850115776, 0.6952050924301147, 0.39073917269706726, 0.26800984144210815, -0.239956796169281, -0.37318646907806396, 0.5261495113372803, 0.22929111123085022, 0.696993350982666, 0.8499395251274109, -0.007145094219595194, -0.16503781080245972, 0.39362892508506775, -0.05550039932131767, 0.19690866768360138, 0.6049397587776184, 0.5818490386009216, 0.2827244699001312, -0.3404254615306854, 0.6359347701072693, -0.7094100117683411, -0.44136056303977966, 0.4292123019695282, -0.820668637752533, 0.9787124991416931, 0.23619061708450317, -0.23301681876182556, -0.4155547022819519, -0.2730132043361664, -0.819766640663147, 0.08763687312602997, -0.27425000071525574, -0.6535887718200684, 0.5078269243240356, -0.6082646250724792, -0.21581384539604187, 0.4055350422859192, 0.021579891443252563, 0.011684473603963852, -0.08773434907197952, 1.1873677968978882, 0.006623926106840372, 0.7972302436828613, -1.3634940385818481, 0.0012855451786890626, -0.6734045147895813, 0.5699647665023804, -0.2638072967529297, -0.0607307143509388, -0.2684495747089386, -0.08725501596927643, -0.21386224031448364, -0.7786915898323059, 0.3614456057548523, -0.1395161747932434, 0.4745727777481079, 0.456922709941864, 0.07514204829931259, 0.37360697984695435, -0.8806967735290527, 0.9111279845237732, -0.02371741272509098, -0.644236147403717, 0.20923377573490143, 0.8798748850822449, -0.118848517537117, 0.804670512676239, -0.24022777378559113, -0.4863976538181305, 0.2643153667449951, -0.2747666537761688, 0.18590842187404633, -1.306931972503662, -0.022289229556918144, 0.003972151782363653, -0.9674481749534607, -0.21429561078548431, 0.416829377412796, 0.29620787501335144, -0.12729759514331818, 0.10029136389493942, -0.8769437670707703, -0.19147169589996338, -0.03336724266409874, -0.2200504094362259, -0.42247942090034485, -0.3845301866531372, -0.8697156310081482, 0.7129061818122864, 0.11799223721027374, -0.03847503289580345, 0.10785891115665436, -0.00709890341386199, -0.06774850189685822, 0.46868741512298584, -0.3567993640899658, 0.30565205216407776, -0.11586379259824753, 0.8295316696166992, -0.23255468904972076, 0.27591565251350403, -0.9875741004943848, 0.2916068136692047, -1.0338925123214722, 0.7569347023963928, -0.423041433095932, 0.00278661516495049, 0.06810946762561798, -0.12506192922592163, 1.1272315979003906, -0.5668090581893921, 0.3696015179157257, -0.16119372844696045, -0.2675175070762634, 0.6208096742630005, 0.09027422219514847, -0.6746388673782349, -0.8763748407363892, -0.5672460198402405, -1.1064186096191406, 0.6007395386695862, 0.00904959999024868, -0.4595208466053009, -0.9023779630661011, -0.6019464731216431, 0.3652001619338989, 0.04919910430908203, 0.703382670879364, 0.2580004036426544, -0.05380141735076904, 0.126031294465065, 0.30648523569107056, -0.050172701478004456, -0.6017275452613831, -0.16249613463878632, 0.23173339664936066, -0.25162091851234436, -0.7309868931770325, -0.04046335816383362, -0.3384469747543335, -0.8960514664649963, 0.28539779782295227, 0.013057154603302479, 0.19164027273654938, -0.29211705923080444, 0.6582543849945068, -0.33352574706077576, -0.2707962989807129, -0.5131718516349792, -0.0802282989025116, -0.4069315791130066, 0.09074993431568146, 0.47761011123657227, -0.27075716853141785, 0.2793270945549011, 0.18240493535995483, 0.8637769222259521, -0.9456874132156372, -0.27145102620124817, 0.34340739250183105, -0.28522732853889465, -0.47205623984336853, 0.2012401521205902, -0.010103265754878521, -0.4211108684539795, -0.39934036135673523, -0.5453789830207825, -0.38766515254974365, -0.21924662590026855, -0.7097670435905457, 0.3127674460411072, 0.05695391818881035, -0.556048572063446, 0.6949616074562073, 0.5669968128204346, -0.5808063745498657, -0.005737935658544302, 0.08132646232843399, -0.07031438499689102, -0.3476538062095642, 0.21048840880393982, 1.1767112016677856, -0.1972639113664627, -0.42057573795318604, -0.392998069524765, -0.396436482667923, 0.350813090801239, -0.1303739696741104, -0.19256451725959778, -0.3291982114315033, 0.3356700539588928, 0.40182992815971375, 0.8801866769790649, -0.1692645400762558, 0.4716876745223999, 0.4949319064617157, -0.025577252730727196, 0.2549728453159332, -0.7402966022491455, -0.9509279727935791, -0.6754382848739624, 0.10691720992326736, 1.5026257038116455, -0.49231210350990295, 0.1304699331521988, 0.08269747346639633, -0.6287079453468323, -0.6189936399459839, -0.822013258934021, 0.48155757784843445, -1.8401603698730469, -0.30057817697525024, -0.6662428975105286, -0.7973887920379639, 0.12830185890197754, 0.45900970697402954, 0.20110252499580383, -0.41902923583984375, -0.6478463411331177, 0.2831485867500305, 0.03309004381299019, 0.2685374617576599, -0.7710301280021667, -0.9077466726303101, -0.7450492978096008, 0.21732114255428314, -0.9955138564109802, 0.16612686216831207, 0.10757019370794296, 0.2015271782875061, -0.40578770637512207, 0.25674182176589966, -0.06876367330551147, 0.7403815984725952, -0.7849083542823792, -0.5150935053825378, -0.30618011951446533, -0.48283493518829346, -0.8036425709724426, -0.3054353892803192, -0.5831420421600342, 0.03318341076374054, -0.2713790833950043, -0.06724049896001816, -0.026996197178959846, 0.37462565302848816, -0.9100250005722046, -0.48034003376960754, -0.27524691820144653, 0.6392064094543457, -0.5026108622550964, -0.26835471391677856, 0.5138766765594482, 0.4346431493759155, -1.3344717025756836, 0.6305493116378784, -0.7179706692695618, 0.03555376082658768, -0.5069255828857422, 0.3335180878639221, -0.32729893922805786, 0.744178831577301, -0.37019041180610657, 0.9470850825309753, -0.5807384848594666, 0.11583458632230759, -0.5087279081344604, 0.23554439842700958, -0.28106507658958435, 0.81179279088974, 0.06107001379132271, -0.651178777217865, -0.015762757509946823, 0.16993877291679382, -0.5532442927360535, -0.036007385700941086, -0.34547311067581177, 0.09356720000505447, -0.2691798210144043, -0.04992416128516197, -0.6527655720710754, 0.6778631806373596, -0.20676255226135254, -0.5889096856117249, -0.06507806479930878, -0.5667435526847839, -0.2714175581932068, 0.1602516919374466, -1.3754619359970093, -0.22974377870559692, -0.21766488254070282, 0.016838988289237022, 0.1663689911365509, 0.24206314980983734, -0.21175485849380493, -0.07586493343114853, 0.053842756897211075, 0.12637875974178314, -0.156241774559021, 0.1322820633649826, -0.227900892496109, 0.20547857880592346, -0.45341283082962036, -0.7666230797767639, -0.13818134367465973, 1.030845284461975, -0.19114555418491364, -0.4328283369541168, -0.07112535834312439, 0.31213414669036865, 0.28095829486846924, 0.2288370132446289, -0.28066375851631165, -0.29398396611213684, 0.5968083739280701, -0.18661019206047058, 0.08447091281414032, -0.007605168968439102, -0.36158427596092224, 0.25902795791625977, -0.21294745802879333, -0.7204747200012207, 0.1767716258764267, 0.6290847659111023, 0.5457693338394165, 0.4224388897418976, -0.31914016604423523, 0.598061203956604, 0.3509312570095062, -1.049023151397705, 0.9062654376029968, -0.34726905822753906, 0.6104636192321777, 0.47547221183776855, -0.21112795174121857, 0.2539561688899994, 0.29585525393486023, 0.5585837960243225, 0.6586214900016785, 1.3238722085952759, 0.3392564356327057, 0.5108670592308044, -0.09089097380638123, -0.3108026087284088, -0.006504854653030634, 0.4176456034183502, 0.32715222239494324, 0.6185721158981323, -0.2655813992023468, 0.5340480804443359, -0.2645573616027832, 0.24062910676002502, -0.03956775739789009, 0.17874374985694885, -0.35670024156570435, -0.11188356578350067, 0.48283037543296814, 0.5745728015899658, -0.39411497116088867, -0.5047398209571838, -0.5865688920021057, 0.0010992462048307061, -0.07014667242765427, 0.03979878127574921, -0.21645952761173248, 0.13903096318244934, 0.4137471914291382, 0.6293288469314575, 0.3469334840774536, 0.9741593599319458, 0.09848043322563171, 0.33023738861083984, -0.11811621487140656, 0.5725796818733215, 0.4965132772922516, 0.32183411717414856, 0.5517349243164062, -1.0671192407608032, -0.25290241837501526, 1.072137475013733, -1.1373952627182007, 0.16153018176555634, -0.2639138400554657, 0.2231011539697647, -0.40409916639328003, -1.0134788751602173, 0.3290974497795105, -0.10841857641935349, 0.9704639911651611, 0.7343230843544006, 0.14157812297344208, -0.071089006960392, 0.4398047626018524, -0.3427445888519287, 0.7746068239212036, 0.8616960644721985, -0.14472417533397675, 0.11915110051631927, 0.7072328925132751, 1.6416305303573608, -0.16424240171909332, 0.9411525130271912, -0.02799372188746929, -0.7177957892417908, 0.5925586223602295, 0.24331995844841003, -0.14086538553237915, 0.747501790523529, -1.0522403717041016, -0.850713312625885, 0.07022705674171448, 0.12105480581521988, -0.3484770357608795, 0.2258952111005783, -0.6722790598869324, 0.39336222410202026, -0.030395561829209328, -0.5489088296890259, 1.2733023166656494, 0.6077483892440796, -0.16730445623397827, -0.4256434440612793, 0.028347158804535866, -0.02356312796473503, 0.044028349220752716, -0.2678848206996918, 0.36474478244781494, 0.5418825149536133, 0.3487113416194916, -0.2989422678947449, -0.9992208480834961, -0.28948280215263367, -0.9436073899269104, 0.1372360736131668, -0.4976414442062378, 0.6708804368972778, 0.45550668239593506, 0.7759791612625122, -0.008736317045986652, -0.5899150371551514, -0.009398405440151691, -0.15358947217464447, 1.1342943906784058, -0.07210017740726471, -0.017343634739518166, 0.7021098732948303, 0.8462817668914795, -0.6201046705245972, 0.3502156734466553, 0.6460223197937012, -0.510799765586853, 0.7776088118553162, -0.2680012583732605, -0.10255037248134613, 0.1475217193365097, -0.7736022472381592, 0.6130980849266052, -0.10324978083372116, 0.7452388405799866, -0.5923802256584167, -0.09659731388092041, -0.562000572681427, -0.8687090277671814, 0.27450186014175415, -0.8180193305015564, 0.44149482250213623, -0.2712650001049042, 0.35012027621269226, 0.16615794599056244, 0.08258429914712906, 3.9433672428131104, 1.5504440069198608, 1.1636998653411865, -0.01892133057117462, 0.28750401735305786, 0.2521091401576996, 0.3523772954940796, -0.5365243554115295, 0.6916098594665527, -0.9101418852806091, -0.0690520852804184, 0.6679245829582214, 0.46767711639404297, -0.22500628232955933, -0.32576242089271545, 0.7193874716758728, -0.38081032037734985, 0.4112755358219147, 0.4749681353569031, -1.1116142272949219, -0.6300708055496216, 0.12831756472587585, 0.26002371311187744, 0.5156245231628418, 0.266605406999588, -0.1469610035419464, 0.23954744637012482, -1.2856107950210571, -0.45348769426345825, 0.3230934739112854, -0.3077547252178192, -0.8864321708679199, 0.23841425776481628, -0.561556339263916, -0.5742006301879883, 0.5387265086174011, 0.11352993547916412, -0.32467910647392273, -0.15364593267440796, 0.49310898780822754, 0.08335676789283752, 0.4172154664993286, 0.09910538792610168, -0.2135801911354065, -1.5631093978881836, 0.9858655333518982, -0.13668526709079742, 0.7064437866210938, 0.44933515787124634, -0.3075660169124603, 0.19430308043956757, -0.5962498784065247, 0.7496755719184875, -0.3698614835739136, -1.13010835647583, -0.309516578912735, -0.3579998314380646, -0.9554539918899536, -0.2129848748445511, 0.2541366219520569, 0.6266881227493286, 0.17774024605751038, -0.21540968120098114, 0.2314467430114746, -0.5699460506439209, 0.5631883144378662, 0.10834016650915146, -0.12876294553279877, -0.2041272073984146, 0.1913231462240219, 0.07519976049661636, -0.6890012621879578, -0.588821530342102, 0.24054832756519318, 0.10408121347427368, -0.40221428871154785, -0.10492865741252899, 0.6292960047721863, 0.6552500128746033, 0.25148606300354004, -0.441650390625, 0.00815508235245943, -0.1405513882637024, 0.7380701303482056, 0.5193660259246826, 0.7683399319648743, -0.129983589053154, -0.8197183609008789, 0.1594344675540924, 0.5060389041900635, 0.5231868624687195, 1.2959344387054443, -0.024461574852466583, -0.22649253904819489, -0.6359598636627197 ]
A Numerical Test of KPZ Scaling: Potts Models Coupled to Two-Dimensional Quantum Gravity
We perform Monte Carlo simulations using the Wolff cluster algorithm of the q=2 (Ising), 3, 4 and q=10 Potts models on dynamical phi-cubed graphs of spherical topology with up to 5000 nodes. We find that the measured critical exponents are in reasonable agreement with those from the exact solution of the Ising model and with those calculated from KPZ scaling for q=3,4 where no exact solution is available. Using Binder's cumulant we find that the q=10 Potts model displays a first order phase transition on a dynamical graph, as it does on a fixed lattice. We also examine the internal geometry of the graphs generated in the simulation, finding a linear relationship between ring length probabilities and the central charge of the Potts model
C.F. Baillie (Colorado) and D. A. Johnston (Heriot Watt)
hep-lat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9204002
hep-lat/9204003
[ 0.04919346049427986, 0.20035965740680695, 0.4573753774166107, 0.5077042579650879, 0.3358614444732666, -0.4687005281448364, -0.1603987067937851, 0.2856530547142029, -0.5991605520248413, 1.255548119544983, 0.610221266746521, 0.1294136345386505, 0.146656796336174, -0.7334916591644287, -0.5226829648017883, 0.3115100860595703, -0.24304470419883728, -0.2573736608028412, -0.655398964881897, -0.15665827691555023, 0.5521641373634338, -0.16566164791584015, -1.422051191329956, -0.5533686876296997, -0.2480476200580597, 0.7960941791534424, 0.5186910629272461, 0.026034008711576462, 1.2137184143066406, 0.5447295904159546, 0.8333571553230286, -0.12452588975429535, 0.3355386257171631, -0.2968873679637909, -0.46107715368270874, -0.24993348121643066, 0.412874698638916, 0.2389492690563202, 0.5878154039382935, -0.38182419538497925, 0.8375200629234314, -0.28259795904159546, 0.00493426900357008, -0.23513996601104736, 0.007631069049239159, -0.1941809058189392, -0.3520888388156891, 0.26177912950515747, -0.11220777779817581, -1.1987993717193604, -0.41277703642845154, -0.29014095664024353, 0.5273965001106262, -1.1121617555618286, -1.1065014600753784, -0.2710126042366028, 0.11073646694421768, -0.24563656747341156, -0.40262070298194885, -0.1619327813386917, 0.24853383004665375, 0.045414768159389496, 0.20686781406402588, -0.9453291893005371, 0.5006713271141052, 0.3135131299495697, -0.03204449638724327, 0.17808471620082855, 0.2580159902572632, -0.42878952622413635, -0.5812956094741821, -0.3621804118156433, -0.8176748752593994, 0.25598183274269104, -0.3761588931083679, 0.42258501052856445, -0.5359513759613037, -0.47894981503486633, -1.0220237970352173, -0.30056115984916687, -0.16781850159168243, -0.2512072026729584, -0.5998823046684265, 0.23985466361045837, -0.3386598825454712, -0.20068377256393433, 0.4444539248943329, 0.4806782305240631, 0.25412166118621826, 0.19673633575439453, 0.0890503004193306, 0.3080727159976959, 0.5223668217658997, -0.41629230976104736, 0.782599687576294, 0.9056475758552551, 0.1690014749765396, 0.7402897477149963, 0.2336810976266861, 0.32795998454093933, -0.158365398645401, 1.1245163679122925, -0.3531440198421478, 0.5918859839439392, -0.28471097350120544, 0.12905386090278625, 0.031036758795380592, 0.06029506027698517, -0.418978750705719, -0.5965025424957275, -0.0709863007068634, 0.18962448835372925, 0.15539579093456268, 0.36278992891311646, -0.15726134181022644, 0.3385757803916931, -0.034165896475315094, -0.6135045886039734, -1.1118910312652588, -0.15325967967510223, 0.25175049901008606, 0.2583979070186615, 0.9258406162261963, 0.5022264719009399, 0.23436535894870758, -0.43208473920822144, 0.05057506263256073, 0.5705409646034241, -0.7299476861953735, -0.08486117422580719, 0.19387078285217285, 0.11999301612377167, -0.5018718242645264, 0.5095672011375427, -0.5774514079093933, -0.16932260990142822, 0.05556706339120865, 0.05601220950484276, 0.009925700724124908, -0.48422694206237793, 1.0234791040420532, -0.7644012570381165, 0.0832819938659668, 1.136336088180542, -0.06061149388551712, 0.48746258020401, 0.10192109644412994, -0.1959797888994217, -0.24997322261333466, 0.285739004611969, -0.31788262724876404, -0.34896349906921387, -0.31891778111457825, 0.7221462726593018, -0.06985139101743698, 0.2996428906917572, -0.6995239853858948, 0.9991512298583984, -0.7139059901237488, -0.4064119756221771, 0.6718220710754395, -0.08914342522621155, -0.34232670068740845, 1.2773329019546509, -0.7767525911331177, 0.3798728883266449, -0.45004332065582275, 0.124661386013031, -0.12374978512525558, -0.3817860186100006, -0.21599072217941284, 0.4160095155239105, -0.3978748917579651, 1.1080090999603271, 0.382402628660202, 0.7792891263961792, 0.3614877164363861, -0.08410777896642685, 0.15364804863929749, 0.61488276720047, -0.13293060660362244, -0.6169180870056152, 0.9554123282432556, 0.5303815603256226, -0.7826553583145142, 0.09877565503120422, 0.20634455978870392, -0.2571202218532562, 0.23373045027256012, 0.5687195062637329, -0.36572834849357605, 0.41912662982940674, -0.6719268560409546, 0.6486754417419434, -0.7129108905792236, 0.06582611054182053, -1.1356585025787354, 0.4043525457382202, -0.3100374639034271, -0.4915723502635956, 0.1825752556324005, 0.2479023039340973, -0.7900180816650391, 0.5393771529197693, -1.1918485164642334, 0.38655588030815125, -0.4145614206790924, 0.5220643281936646, -0.265753835439682, -0.717218816280365, 0.43620601296424866, -0.29753121733665466, 0.9245445728302002, -0.5503891110420227, 0.38653236627578735, -0.07415086776018143, -0.07365651428699493, 0.3315938413143158, 0.27598950266838074, -0.22436200082302094, 0.7911763787269592, 0.6593695878982544, -0.47932326793670654, 1.5049214363098145, -0.11644161492586136, -0.05493755266070366, 0.10137038677930832, 0.6519613862037659, 0.276388555765152, 0.6407983303070068, 0.04581723362207413, 0.7621146440505981, 0.10388308018445969, 0.38321420550346375, 0.49440959095954895, 0.04362864792346954, 0.1951524168252945, 0.7667290568351746, 0.1466168612241745, 0.03675125539302826, 0.18542440235614777, 0.16442237794399261, 0.1263589709997177, 0.013690455816686153, -0.14286799728870392, 0.49602028727531433, -0.14921577274799347, 0.7347630858421326, -0.7366442680358887, 1.1730421781539917, -0.9979569315910339, 0.8420547842979431, 0.12600092589855194, 0.13435553014278412, -1.0054584741592407, 0.4121251106262207, 0.0018193324794992805, 0.06384723633527756, -0.266089528799057, -0.5254493355751038, -0.3608545958995819, 0.2838127613067627, 0.3138636648654938, -0.7145292162895203, -0.2370762974023819, 0.856372594833374, -0.10894806683063507, 0.19210125505924225, 0.6002032160758972, -0.4803091585636139, -1.3940068483352661, -0.1365903615951538, -0.5970712304115295, -0.3216281533241272, -0.35149911046028137, 0.12977167963981628, 0.8293645977973938, -0.4322575330734253, 0.3574102222919464, -0.2633557915687561, -0.021548902615904808, 0.893734872341156, 0.1598505824804306, 0.3219647705554962, 0.4320054352283478, -0.3352419137954712, -0.6503610610961914, 0.1540507972240448, -1.04308021068573, 0.1056704893708229, -0.7348763346672058, 0.1745278388261795, 0.2994763255119324, -0.06874937564134598, 0.11450110375881195, -0.3335569202899933, -0.4111018776893616, -0.19649454951286316, 0.21366409957408905, -0.6102246642112732, 0.12137985974550247, 0.8062521815299988, 0.6792280077934265, -0.24988724291324615, -0.3105098009109497, 0.8523435592651367, 0.4545874297618866, -0.2839903235435486, 0.3732300102710724, 0.1283717006444931, -0.34610921144485474, -0.10490511357784271, 0.11553767323493958, 0.07771056145429611, -0.11319897323846817, 1.1258903741836548, 1.04482901096344, -0.019572999328374863, -0.05174221843481064, -0.3497008681297302, -0.5519036054611206, -0.010157098062336445, 0.30588486790657043, -0.6444277167320251, 0.3661080002784729, 1.3352175951004028, 0.2945823073387146, -0.8617684841156006, 0.10194448381662369, -0.8042423725128174, -0.6287225484848022, -0.18296225368976593, -0.8045455813407898, 0.3916271924972534, -0.04492727667093277, 0.2607376277446747, -0.6198681592941284, -0.44803082942962646, -0.18574610352516174, 0.5391769409179688, 0.15309873223304749, -0.5085933208465576, 0.20435868203639984, 0.3725237250328064, 0.3305913805961609, 0.11639279127120972, 0.5293641090393066, -0.266620397567749, -0.13056689500808716, 0.162945955991745, -0.5321471095085144, -0.10060728341341019, 0.3684275150299072, -0.09986437857151031, -0.05010773614048958, 0.48777952790260315, -0.43489015102386475, -0.7128839492797852, -0.6117701530456543, -0.22378970682621002, -0.31848272681236267, 0.3300504982471466, 0.014329361729323864, -0.0385320782661438, -0.45960137248039246, -0.31855469942092896, 0.19092537462711334, 0.14848145842552185, 0.9484775066375732, -0.4497434198856354, 0.5829108953475952, 0.04327067732810974, 0.01959840953350067, 0.044649887830019, -0.036770258098840714, 0.09281337261199951, -0.030379483476281166, 0.07369081676006317, -0.012451201677322388, 0.07015708088874817, -0.6176209449768066, -0.23093760013580322, 0.7166219353675842, 0.8019022345542908, 0.9753060936927795, 0.5229806900024414, -0.1351257860660553, -0.3328964412212372, -0.0724417120218277, 0.05477854982018471, -0.278045117855072, -0.5024267435073853, 0.28625109791755676, -0.4130154550075531, -0.3575005829334259, -0.029944254085421562, 0.33174997568130493, 0.41815608739852905, 0.6259059906005859, 0.035530298948287964, 0.3554861843585968, 0.24283896386623383, 0.30412766337394714, 0.48300978541374207, -0.21713124215602875, -0.010390005074441433, -0.8542816042900085, 0.40183645486831665, 0.24938347935676575, 0.044576603919267654, -0.09384787827730179, -0.26081791520118713, 0.1846577227115631, -0.5127825140953064, 0.7133693695068359, -0.015615993179380894, -0.510242223739624, 0.4225434958934784, -0.14819420874118805, 0.3962467610836029, -0.3007453382015228, 0.11517594754695892, 0.7190346121788025, 0.5531299710273743, -0.17595048248767853, -0.9106037020683289, -0.1072416678071022, -0.07561679184436798, 0.6650948524475098, 0.017262596637010574, -0.8049627542495728, -1.0969009399414062, -0.20449067652225494, -0.0713859349489212, -0.4894859194755554, -0.19069786369800568, 0.7203007936477661, 0.10505711287260056, -0.13829396665096283, -0.40170934796333313, -0.27527448534965515, 0.5486100912094116, 0.13045373558998108, -0.7354066371917725, 0.328551709651947, 0.18157659471035004, -0.23858964443206787, 0.4799703061580658, -0.2844831347465515, -0.7157464027404785, -0.07402914762496948, -0.11840172111988068, -0.2043542116880417, -0.1799902319908142, -0.6364077925682068, -0.1376134306192398, -0.0940476655960083, -0.09707949310541153, 0.28871405124664307, -0.13032716512680054, 0.7017269730567932, 0.2650867700576782, -0.05661201849579811, 0.20760248601436615, 0.26980629563331604, 0.09110942482948303, 0.20114760100841522, 0.5687316060066223, 0.5247129201889038, -0.1114785298705101, 0.255051851272583, 0.3973458707332611, 0.14975568652153015, 0.13740651309490204, 0.5281850099563599, -0.059808529913425446, 0.2004753202199936, -0.2604430615901947, 0.43440794944763184, -0.7309339046478271, -0.7164499163627625, 0.6680013537406921, -0.5759680867195129, 0.7599812746047974, 0.2636444568634033, -0.4078434407711029, -0.6157249212265015, -0.5440481901168823, -1.0495866537094116, 0.34233930706977844, -0.19402526319026947, -0.5199609398841858, 0.48247116804122925, -0.8736744523048401, -0.25519418716430664, 0.27873286604881287, -0.2492426484823227, 0.32886016368865967, -0.015020380727946758, 0.9286384582519531, -0.07586480677127838, 0.7428442239761353, -0.9152756929397583, -0.18947599828243256, -0.5650409460067749, 0.042801935225725174, -0.649723470211029, -0.520199716091156, -0.12060697376728058, 0.1497497409582138, -0.37149420380592346, -0.5848582983016968, 0.3132975697517395, -0.21455702185630798, -0.29774579405784607, 0.15200668573379517, -0.14740271866321564, -0.40930435061454773, -0.3713328540325165, 0.9116031527519226, -0.08095812797546387, -0.9920430779457092, 0.24383221566677094, 0.7543432712554932, 0.3259183168411255, 0.7896572351455688, -0.22190022468566895, -0.4092545807361603, 0.6716626882553101, -0.6364172697067261, 0.1475299447774887, -1.5925294160842896, -0.5034615993499756, -0.2458304464817047, -1.1412886381149292, 0.0759560614824295, -0.02693796716630459, -0.08598870038986206, -0.2356429249048233, -0.20229557156562805, -0.36395061016082764, 0.015473742038011551, -0.32297375798225403, -0.07206633687019348, -0.8562813401222229, -0.16889482736587524, -0.5881555676460266, 0.5730871558189392, 0.14799878001213074, 0.7035024762153625, 0.1625150740146637, 0.030958516523241997, -0.2855023741722107, 0.46906131505966187, 0.34410151839256287, 0.13305753469467163, -0.13601553440093994, 1.0160483121871948, -0.18874439597129822, 0.007742190733551979, -0.9597263932228088, 0.5410928130149841, -0.5927138924598694, 0.5560291409492493, -0.3649847209453583, -0.4084610939025879, 0.5140931010246277, 0.22914759814739227, 0.7342025637626648, -0.8766274452209473, 0.06661729514598846, 0.3648586869239807, -0.4249947667121887, 0.4031400680541992, -0.04547024890780449, -0.8269816637039185, -0.8088290095329285, -0.5498001575469971, -0.962752640247345, 0.9565999507904053, 0.16929085552692413, -0.07702318578958511, -0.5316411852836609, -0.23326221108436584, 0.3521266579627991, 0.0941196084022522, 0.5247945189476013, 0.05233753100037575, 0.3610403835773468, 0.3948870599269867, 0.10424016416072845, -0.1231469139456749, -0.640972912311554, 0.07884003221988678, -0.09846958518028259, -0.12955598533153534, -0.3082652688026428, 0.2566392719745636, -0.6063397526741028, -0.7607967257499695, -0.29340994358062744, 0.012043703347444534, -0.0868891030550003, 0.1081659272313118, 0.38746175169944763, 0.09225066006183624, -0.13712337613105774, -0.4180789291858673, -0.2193421572446823, -0.31719455122947693, 0.22974254190921783, 0.2870013415813446, 0.10072492063045502, 0.026493996381759644, 0.019054464995861053, 0.745773196220398, -0.6352663040161133, -0.6249706745147705, 0.1559416502714157, -0.5985091328620911, -0.2941027283668518, 0.24038611352443695, -0.10407774895429611, -0.485931932926178, -0.6865803599357605, -0.8585012555122375, -0.6127649545669556, 0.27470165491104126, -0.3759717047214508, 0.10854163020849228, 0.16092535853385925, -0.6565568447113037, 0.710698664188385, 0.24565672874450684, -0.28022468090057373, 0.09841585159301758, -0.017461972311139107, -0.1021043211221695, -0.8047827482223511, 0.36501893401145935, 0.9176799058914185, -0.16082021594047546, -0.7888777852058411, -0.25732702016830444, 0.07019037008285522, 0.26586562395095825, 0.03624848648905754, 0.17528243362903595, -0.5310460925102234, 0.04722190648317337, 0.7010858058929443, 0.2805659770965576, -0.11426680535078049, 0.5606073141098022, 0.2549746334552765, 0.12712623178958893, -0.5873051285743713, -0.341786652803421, -0.1089843362569809, -0.7392048835754395, 0.493511438369751, 1.4352339506149292, -0.30504217743873596, 0.2531376779079437, -0.12782534956932068, -0.1895856261253357, -0.6779001355171204, -0.9965776205062866, 0.18712693452835083, -1.507510781288147, -0.982864260673523, -0.9953877925872803, -0.4195678234100342, 0.3460758626461029, 0.18125276267528534, -0.19233106076717377, -0.24961963295936584, -0.3524765372276306, 0.34495800733566284, 0.12455935031175613, 0.002286704024299979, -0.538771390914917, -0.42936789989471436, -0.7972939610481262, 0.3033435046672821, -0.3627980947494507, -0.7146027088165283, -0.31487610936164856, -0.38808098435401917, 0.11682101339101791, 0.22758974134922028, -0.0665772557258606, 0.44430315494537354, -0.6281517148017883, -1.0002834796905518, 0.3111967444419861, -0.5476834774017334, -0.9570481181144714, 0.39221036434173584, -0.3365512192249298, 0.5053274035453796, -0.11628080904483795, 0.6380836963653564, 0.08014871925115585, -0.18872152268886566, -0.5235585570335388, -0.18012243509292603, 0.07610850781202316, 0.2952561676502228, -0.32802659273147583, -0.50822913646698, 0.42030027508735657, 0.023908045142889023, -0.8747323155403137, 0.5018343329429626, -0.36334264278411865, 0.36283427476882935, -0.5076369643211365, 0.587391197681427, 0.26418331265449524, 0.39765664935112, -0.27333712577819824, 0.5676690340042114, -0.18949739634990692, -0.006593773607164621, -0.4613629877567291, 0.42312127351760864, -0.059027038514614105, 0.5250389575958252, 0.12061737477779388, -0.12515674531459808, -0.07795663923025131, 0.3811742067337036, -0.2960602343082428, 0.04761292040348053, -0.2829347848892212, 0.030195821076631546, -0.15500354766845703, 0.1871400773525238, -0.6355083584785461, 0.9318190813064575, 0.2588348388671875, -0.5284000635147095, -0.24532446265220642, -0.44400376081466675, -0.42284685373306274, 0.15814749896526337, -1.0927518606185913, -0.6165755391120911, -0.1146681010723114, -0.14919181168079376, 0.16579750180244446, 0.26919496059417725, -0.39724865555763245, -0.14596253633499146, -0.13912077248096466, 0.745625376701355, 0.47617414593696594, 0.04062679037451744, -0.5612428784370422, 0.23868511617183685, -0.43691784143447876, -0.2061406821012497, -0.45200470089912415, 0.48751914501190186, -0.7848689556121826, -0.683488130569458, -0.21089574694633484, 0.43877705931663513, 0.22220706939697266, 0.046783484518527985, -0.2190760374069214, -0.23133519291877747, 0.17545057833194733, -0.7047978639602661, -0.28851956129074097, -0.03323180601000786, -0.5943341851234436, 0.3839130401611328, -0.3474624752998352, -0.9298946857452393, 0.07962578535079956, 0.5271864533424377, 0.7722715139389038, 0.2753414809703827, -0.037011291831731796, 0.5636720061302185, -0.35528916120529175, -0.8887549638748169, 0.7760784029960632, 0.1225135400891304, 0.5559589862823486, 0.2832653820514679, -0.18734784424304962, 0.4838413596153259, 0.5036264061927795, 0.2224438190460205, 0.7030609250068665, 0.828852653503418, -0.024870887398719788, -0.04028313234448433, 0.25856244564056396, -0.3217428922653198, 0.0824296623468399, 0.5273919701576233, 0.5914399027824402, 0.611528754234314, -0.40053293108940125, 0.08134853094816208, 0.15099526941776276, 0.8613430857658386, 0.20743390917778015, 0.11352722346782684, -0.0017192248487845063, -0.218933567404747, 0.3551552891731262, 0.648316502571106, -0.6396167278289795, -0.37498384714126587, -0.4714474081993103, 0.500192403793335, -0.2520904839038849, -0.19290687143802643, -0.4134308397769928, 0.30832624435424805, 0.5994552969932556, 0.13907423615455627, 0.03048999235033989, 1.140592336654663, -0.013010838069021702, 0.5173441767692566, 0.3507828414440155, 0.5904762744903564, 0.677113950252533, 0.5985811352729797, 0.13641691207885742, -1.2404155731201172, -0.1172708198428154, 0.8922408819198608, -1.1582107543945312, 0.08680646866559982, -0.0246940478682518, -0.05343525856733322, -0.5593385100364685, -0.9208032488822937, -0.2139105647802353, -0.4413623809814453, 0.9042553305625916, 0.4415312707424164, -0.04294077679514885, -0.5101123452186584, 0.4089232087135315, -0.3724803328514099, 0.35172131657600403, 1.2116118669509888, 0.043765272945165634, 0.45710617303848267, 0.5622106790542603, 0.9294915795326233, 0.633272647857666, 0.9617536067962646, -0.3895755708217621, -0.8248617053031921, 0.8859158754348755, 0.5977624654769897, 0.07939574122428894, 0.4471968114376068, -1.1424239873886108, -0.22869600355625153, -0.1184295043349266, 0.15993790328502655, 0.012107660993933678, -0.10653814673423767, -0.10520943999290466, 0.3572397828102112, -0.29219287633895874, -0.03588925674557686, 0.8160796165466309, 0.5133411288261414, -0.3618154525756836, -0.41675156354904175, 0.48258092999458313, -0.8659733533859253, 0.3278755247592926, -0.838123619556427, 0.13250990211963654, 0.2648049592971802, -0.1546536684036255, -0.39264053106307983, -0.9145970940589905, 0.10103322565555573, -0.6237162947654724, -0.19550460577011108, -0.8872597217559814, 0.38319453597068787, 0.7297760248184204, 0.5468840599060059, 0.150043323636055, -0.5588313341140747, -0.36048468947410583, -0.8109506964683533, 1.0677486658096313, -0.4477628469467163, -0.14356575906276703, 0.8552877902984619, 0.8781076073646545, -0.6955817937850952, 0.24690039455890656, 0.31307274103164673, -0.8777853846549988, 1.0458904504776, -0.04716634750366211, 0.11014620959758759, 0.6149352788925171, -0.19907672703266144, 0.6623174548149109, -0.037821315228939056, 0.8125431537628174, -0.08008547127246857, -0.1741282194852829, 0.03985733166337013, -0.6078289747238159, 0.1692369133234024, -0.7216718792915344, 0.23896296322345734, -0.008355686441063881, 0.1468483805656433, -0.36870861053466797, -0.30666911602020264, 4.278702259063721, 1.109737515449524, 0.7288925647735596, 0.15578196942806244, 0.6858090162277222, 0.5219448804855347, 0.14863087236881256, -0.6182449460029602, 0.27412593364715576, -0.8640175461769104, -0.3667881190776825, 0.5248929858207703, 0.07017864286899567, -0.11421217024326324, -0.42460858821868896, 0.37888696789741516, -0.38304951786994934, 0.1947522610425949, 0.30914366245269775, -0.7602354288101196, -0.5896608829498291, 0.18292203545570374, 0.39408576488494873, 0.3077665865421295, 0.352769136428833, 0.25857532024383545, 0.46431469917297363, -1.1469025611877441, -0.6824308633804321, -0.3538898527622223, -0.26552748680114746, -1.1653380393981934, -0.32937151193618774, -0.27403661608695984, -1.0479847192764282, 0.3209400773048401, -0.22348712384700775, -0.5878121852874756, 0.21071913838386536, -0.12077152729034424, 0.3325517773628235, 0.36109670996665955, 0.30998894572257996, -0.5461323261260986, -0.8128275275230408, 1.0289404392242432, 0.16869451105594635, 0.8277968764305115, 0.7097586393356323, -0.4619135558605194, 0.07130695879459381, -0.3836783766746521, 0.7862609028816223, -0.2917286455631256, -0.9802052974700928, -0.9743869304656982, -0.049848105758428574, -0.5499235987663269, 0.005617865361273289, 0.17440636456012726, 0.2618328332901001, 0.38491517305374146, -0.4341380298137665, 0.22987444698810577, -0.17961867153644562, 0.1005801260471344, 0.29097381234169006, -0.21626444160938263, -0.09782178699970245, -0.04054003208875656, -0.3763216733932495, -0.40913471579551697, -0.746470034122467, 0.3774130046367645, -0.034108966588974, 0.1316034346818924, 0.3649255931377411, 0.7413495182991028, 0.0008948000613600016, 0.6521276235580444, -0.4707324802875519, 0.1806967556476593, 0.3792787790298462, 0.013898041099309921, -0.15693624317646027, 0.9753690361976624, 0.07975350320339203, -0.24766671657562256, -0.5933319926261902, 0.7467872500419617, 0.4162336587905884, 1.1646268367767334, -0.15219658613204956, -0.27255913615226746, -1.037582278251648 ]
Multiple Potts Models Coupled to Two-Dimensional Quantum Gravity
We perform Monte Carlo simulations using the Wolff cluster algorithm of {\it multiple} $q=2,3,4$ state Potts models on dynamical phi-cubed graphs of spherical topology in order to investigate the $c>1$ region of two-dimensional quantum gravity. Contrary to naive expectation we find no obvious signs of pathological behaviour for $c>1$. We discuss the results in the light of suggestions that have been made for a modified DDK ansatz for $c>1$.
C.F. Baillie (Colorado) and D. A. Johnston (Heriot Watt)
hep-lat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9204003
hep-lat/9204004
[ 0.11385650932788849, -0.07517555356025696, 0.16758586466312408, 0.7083408832550049, 0.5611573457717896, 0.15452513098716736, -0.2591005563735962, 0.09961580485105515, -0.9108220338821411, 1.5039904117584229, 0.7793266773223877, -0.27521267533302307, 0.01315961591899395, -0.9184726476669312, -0.008761457167565823, 0.6503743529319763, -0.3429044485092163, -0.617411732673645, -1.3266533613204956, 0.4313167929649353, 0.15646801888942719, 0.2068360149860382, -1.25838303565979, -0.6744752526283264, -0.5505192279815674, 1.365334153175354, 0.2540990710258484, 0.2902451455593109, 1.343449354171753, 0.9922534823417664, 0.5697922706604004, -0.3375822603702545, -0.16905204951763153, -0.5699445009231567, -0.61179119348526, -0.13057024776935577, 0.4411071836948395, -0.519344687461853, 1.1859090328216553, -0.32479870319366455, 0.7664270997047424, -0.3265553116798401, 0.2626470625400543, -0.5175381898880005, -0.5532873868942261, -0.17332062125205994, 0.40620675683021545, -0.3120339810848236, 0.185439795255661, -0.8932989239692688, 0.05697556585073471, 0.3315849006175995, 0.47460708022117615, -1.144857406616211, -0.37626826763153076, -0.4376938045024872, 0.7956781983375549, 0.13123995065689087, -0.37011483311653137, -0.1360376477241516, 0.8052339553833008, 0.5060115456581116, 0.41812819242477417, -1.1104353666305542, 0.3482363224029541, 1.2454261779785156, -0.29043665528297424, 0.12333876639604568, -0.19316653907299042, -1.1880097389221191, -0.8380829095840454, -0.5284226536750793, -0.1653689295053482, 0.1503383070230484, -0.08652106672525406, 0.22215108573436737, -0.38110437989234924, -0.6675234436988831, -0.7836250066757202, -0.14432619512081146, -0.11745397746562958, 0.332958459854126, -0.4596139192581177, 0.25704848766326904, 0.0029905573464930058, 0.3309750556945801, -0.10141048580408096, 0.781452476978302, 0.7346569299697876, 0.21179884672164917, -0.000710270251147449, 0.5761263370513916, 0.13304513692855835, -0.338538259267807, 0.21929305791854858, 1.0235295295715332, -0.20576082170009613, 0.7339497804641724, 0.3570994734764099, 0.1325160264968872, -0.10596205294132233, 1.6255388259887695, -0.049869440495967865, 0.9651802182197571, -0.7053154110908508, 0.7920512557029724, 0.28453201055526733, 0.31365442276000977, 0.05624569579958916, -0.5828392505645752, 0.2807760238647461, 0.07124591618776321, 0.6373502016067505, 0.34978097677230835, 0.29550138115882874, 0.46784597635269165, -0.26083970069885254, -0.6690990924835205, -0.9763955473899841, -0.21240179240703583, -0.05877867713570595, 0.23330634832382202, 1.0462453365325928, 0.7530028820037842, 0.25083962082862854, -1.0369510650634766, 0.5372055172920227, 0.6435353755950928, -0.5509994029998779, -0.11544805765151978, 0.4413819909095764, -0.1362754851579666, -0.25049009919166565, -0.13185033202171326, -0.38267064094543457, -0.25542140007019043, -0.22843123972415924, -0.03309478610754013, -0.6812766194343567, -0.5909610390663147, 0.41558340191841125, -0.6783251166343689, 0.0299893319606781, 0.9237532615661621, -0.36981627345085144, 0.5669263005256653, -0.3006663918495178, 0.3851346969604492, 0.04871014133095741, -0.3824494779109955, -0.6738278269767761, -0.1721469759941101, -0.37348082661628723, 0.15592074394226074, 0.08720344305038452, 0.40267878770828247, -1.3877034187316895, 0.8570377826690674, -0.8494163155555725, -0.7698436975479126, 0.6468181014060974, 0.14648115634918213, 0.017125388607382774, 0.9500863552093506, -0.4141799807548523, 0.08734069019556046, -0.8055439591407776, -0.12683312594890594, 0.27830877900123596, -0.08079306781291962, 0.22913362085819244, -0.0725187286734581, -0.2364107370376587, 0.3871570825576782, 0.7510718107223511, 0.14697103202342987, 0.6777349710464478, -0.6735451221466064, 0.525756299495697, 0.5209497213363647, 0.005455149803310633, -1.3082550764083862, 1.2518576383590698, 0.977588951587677, -0.6355456113815308, -0.2599625289440155, -0.19209320843219757, -0.4201516807079315, 0.4541299343109131, -0.32224708795547485, -0.7870277762413025, 0.7874923348426819, -1.1529390811920166, 0.4692877233028412, -0.5328356623649597, 0.1253446489572525, -1.095613718032837, 0.34277263283729553, -0.4779699742794037, -0.5383132696151733, -0.004551752004772425, 0.1524256467819214, -0.353093683719635, 0.22184251248836517, -1.1127986907958984, 0.21123772859573364, 0.26716887950897217, 0.2730773389339447, -0.273744136095047, -0.255018949508667, 0.4328191876411438, -0.4425905644893646, 0.41262221336364746, -0.08023631572723389, -0.1896444857120514, 0.16564932465553284, -0.5409051775932312, 0.5549429059028625, 0.6931038498878479, 0.5612912774085999, 1.0126081705093384, 0.4021032452583313, -0.362117737531662, 0.9409640431404114, -0.03457212448120117, 0.3605547249317169, 0.1611815094947815, 0.7374518513679504, 0.2276517003774643, 0.559107780456543, 0.3082354664802551, 0.5331536531448364, 0.16661548614501953, 0.15051281452178955, 1.1081753969192505, 0.5303840041160583, 0.5030220150947571, 1.2276568412780762, 0.09163234382867813, 0.21336771547794342, 0.06561268866062164, 0.38111141324043274, 0.7908073663711548, -0.4364372193813324, -0.2787112295627594, 0.622018039226532, 0.23862791061401367, 0.746487021446228, -1.2640703916549683, 0.6236101388931274, -0.4451306164264679, 0.47752895951271057, 0.04750847443938255, -0.2633187174797058, -1.0836396217346191, 0.19988000392913818, -0.4293997287750244, 0.4405408799648285, 0.015285837464034557, -0.3170258104801178, 0.15048588812351227, 0.22426778078079224, 0.24121731519699097, -0.508870005607605, -0.7673025727272034, 0.5115963816642761, -0.4799398183822632, 0.2080342173576355, 0.15394409000873566, -0.10180813074111938, -1.307739496231079, 0.22728301584720612, -0.6127086281776428, 0.10468938946723938, -0.015249005518853664, -0.03222961723804474, 0.5808006525039673, -0.19303643703460693, 0.8394271731376648, 0.5989207625389099, 0.34665414690971375, -0.20728102326393127, -0.034510184079408646, 0.07931055873632431, 0.09168527275323868, 0.08589032292366028, -0.930087149143219, 0.027722053229808807, -0.9003078937530518, 0.1030854880809784, -0.5179204344749451, -0.4292035400867462, 0.672712504863739, -0.15951403975486755, 0.7694394588470459, 0.02529003843665123, -0.580179750919342, -0.4679466187953949, -0.24412693083286285, -0.34578585624694824, 0.29502949118614197, 0.05639174208045006, 0.2971442639827728, 0.17404279112815857, -0.42440807819366455, 1.055566430091858, 0.341580867767334, 0.14050935208797455, 1.0284315347671509, -0.09153590351343155, -0.21164926886558533, -0.32183513045310974, 0.381915420293808, 0.20063616335391998, -0.19819292426109314, 0.9994101524353027, 0.9024474620819092, -0.4288637936115265, 0.42625150084495544, -0.17077681422233582, -0.0992782860994339, -0.05979729816317558, 0.6826589703559875, -0.8915463089942932, 0.5513559579849243, 0.8710763454437256, 0.4359259605407715, -0.7323745489120483, 1.0013911724090576, -0.9042609930038452, -0.8739139437675476, -0.04192059114575386, -0.8976199626922607, 0.10340757668018341, -0.10360906273126602, -0.04645605385303497, -0.7589197754859924, -0.7205365300178528, -0.40160319209098816, 0.7321733832359314, 0.31629252433776855, 0.06659205257892609, -0.10099562257528305, 0.4279157519340515, 0.10558237880468369, 0.33142128586769104, -0.03864004462957382, 0.13491013646125793, -0.03819705545902252, 0.461869478225708, -0.4991764426231384, 0.26511839032173157, 0.6242396831512451, -0.2733047306537628, 0.39069634675979614, -0.10816073417663574, 0.2479737102985382, -0.8423194885253906, -0.9430325031280518, -0.007974919863045216, -0.1216970831155777, 0.060129910707473755, -0.2677628695964813, -0.28601953387260437, -0.7500956654548645, -0.6495663523674011, 0.2198684960603714, 0.42248594760894775, 0.7612733840942383, -0.5182355046272278, -0.10661531239748001, 0.1697843074798584, 0.20961542427539825, -0.41536378860473633, -0.36479485034942627, 0.30201998353004456, 0.12088797986507416, 0.05940942093729973, -0.10420817136764526, -0.3162919580936432, -0.9480094909667969, -0.444601446390152, 0.5755631923675537, 0.6503913402557373, 0.8539233207702637, 0.053087249398231506, -0.26593732833862305, 0.4503449499607086, 0.18276093900203705, -0.49205532670021057, -0.23676635324954987, -0.4931194484233856, -0.3527032732963562, -0.8688299655914307, -0.013409014791250229, 0.1961926817893982, 0.4107392132282257, 0.8066920638084412, 0.5115031003952026, 0.0902862474322319, 0.0961492657661438, 0.58633953332901, 0.19763995707035065, 0.6378732323646545, -0.360841304063797, -0.0230685044080019, -1.1039453744888306, 0.8126769661903381, 0.16929833590984344, 0.20848430693149567, 0.436696857213974, -0.8294938802719116, 0.21722367405891418, -0.6208948493003845, 1.0076496601104736, 0.2481672465801239, -0.737694263458252, 0.044367145746946335, -0.27535730600357056, 0.09355483204126358, -0.26112237572669983, -0.5717147588729858, 0.5833699107170105, 0.42521584033966064, 0.07920602709054947, -0.5766198635101318, -0.152055025100708, -0.36555057764053345, 0.2697793245315552, 0.7674688696861267, -1.1555739641189575, -1.2184919118881226, -0.07099723070859909, -0.3275558650493622, 0.17593373358249664, 0.17904488742351532, 1.1055216789245605, -0.10242683440446854, 0.5689979791641235, 0.1269005984067917, -0.4331169128417969, 0.4700355529785156, -0.23866824805736542, -1.0037870407104492, 0.38365867733955383, 0.030721457675099373, 0.18189939856529236, 0.2672235071659088, -0.30630239844322205, -0.8477956056594849, -0.30663231015205383, -0.30875155329704285, 0.4828373193740845, -0.22236458957195282, -0.46872982382774353, -0.44221314787864685, -0.19991005957126617, -0.3612249493598938, 0.9729096293449402, -0.10143796354532242, -0.19850990176200867, 0.14612823724746704, -0.23946291208267212, -0.2891189754009247, 0.3911460340023041, 0.08357293158769608, 0.1988939642906189, 0.7944899201393127, 0.5105747580528259, 0.34463125467300415, 0.4691006541252136, 0.38639387488365173, -0.10924778133630753, 0.32546767592430115, 0.10931675136089325, -0.8153932690620422, 0.1917230635881424, -0.4896518588066101, -0.16635970771312714, -0.5299810171127319, -0.41401833295822144, 0.6377254128456116, -0.4462887942790985, 0.49435970187187195, -0.0709770917892456, -0.3997434973716736, -0.3492043912410736, -0.5513195991516113, -0.5420253276824951, 0.39693310856819153, -0.30954164266586304, 0.4208560585975647, 0.4101448357105255, -0.28117847442626953, -0.1798146814107895, 0.17078138887882233, -0.3509339392185211, 0.048316799104213715, -0.37491586804389954, 0.6206867098808289, -0.5005888938903809, 0.7095032334327698, -1.048769235610962, 0.45106664299964905, -0.1419752836227417, -0.5583745241165161, -0.5260893106460571, -0.5748652815818787, -0.06641893088817596, 0.639419674873352, 0.14526981115341187, -0.4806015193462372, 0.016319800168275833, -0.010936588980257511, 0.22408880293369293, 0.2717970609664917, -0.06926340609788895, -0.18786568939685822, -0.10792457312345505, 0.7652959823608398, -0.06604986637830734, -0.6395642757415771, 0.4884566366672516, 1.0637708902359009, 0.6149026155471802, 0.4095636010169983, -0.27505674958229065, -0.011505884118378162, 0.338166743516922, -0.8228935599327087, 0.5363254547119141, -1.1390376091003418, -1.0629068613052368, 0.23260338604450226, -0.1214037612080574, 0.009910095483064651, 0.3355702757835388, 0.24059557914733887, -0.3260357677936554, 0.26859211921691895, -0.24480430781841278, -0.058211468160152435, -0.3458855152130127, 0.09555257111787796, -0.7219513058662415, -0.08528701215982437, -1.0907868146896362, 0.6757916808128357, -0.10815685987472534, 0.5598586797714233, 0.608718991279602, -0.04055056348443031, -0.4585963785648346, 0.8676403760910034, 0.30671656131744385, -0.4047534167766571, -0.15250304341316223, 0.4433899521827698, 0.13669754564762115, -0.3175385296344757, -0.5159594416618347, 0.3952036499977112, -0.6736477017402649, 0.5318244099617004, -0.4009701609611511, -0.06517738103866577, 0.1431679129600525, -0.5218904614448547, 0.920028805732727, -0.460884690284729, 0.2741169035434723, 1.0443902015686035, -0.45165255665779114, 0.3577243983745575, 0.2080514132976532, -0.8837884664535522, -0.4146328568458557, -0.15573398768901825, -1.1451306343078613, 0.28444260358810425, 0.283502995967865, -0.5981577634811401, -0.6326863169670105, -0.9646487832069397, 0.22278562188148499, -0.4443730115890503, 0.20844949781894684, 0.25118955969810486, 0.24019169807434082, 0.2916516959667206, -0.43582409620285034, -0.26408401131629944, -0.93153977394104, -0.042808279395103455, 0.03192926198244095, -0.8218410015106201, -0.2693344056606293, -0.403879851102829, -0.6175153255462646, -0.8505468964576721, -0.506668746471405, 0.5740815997123718, 0.18988151848316193, 0.21358487010002136, 0.7322062253952026, -0.0950699970126152, -0.5019248127937317, -0.46187934279441833, -0.09179989993572235, -0.3439936339855194, -0.08179287612438202, 0.08406409621238708, 0.1253366768360138, -0.12133345007896423, -0.18603554368019104, 0.08814983069896698, -0.6887360215187073, -0.6030248999595642, 0.5983245968818665, -0.6253291964530945, -0.3625553548336029, 0.1940792053937912, -0.20506227016448975, -0.9492927193641663, -0.6016042828559875, -1.0353236198425293, -0.9019054174423218, 0.7924317717552185, -0.48262447118759155, 0.441238671541214, -0.4715198576450348, 0.1498144567012787, 0.09149457514286041, 0.6039257049560547, 0.2610640823841095, -0.1977430135011673, 0.23562555015087128, -0.41626617312431335, -0.37429311871528625, 0.04684554785490036, 1.4422551393508911, -0.1074080616235733, -1.3037524223327637, -0.03857489675283432, -0.4114726781845093, -0.14157836139202118, 0.32045993208885193, 0.4302386939525604, -0.9764976501464844, 0.3327743113040924, 0.2230585515499115, 0.5331340432167053, -0.20487923920154572, 0.4954076409339905, 0.28904974460601807, 0.14118918776512146, -0.5660064220428467, -0.5945970416069031, 0.043774623423814774, 0.33471864461898804, 0.08366601914167404, 0.8591914772987366, -0.3405603766441345, 0.08132787048816681, -0.3266223073005676, -0.6219632625579834, -0.573034942150116, -0.908636212348938, -0.2323969453573227, -1.3591513633728027, -0.6157334446907043, -1.0257773399353027, -0.9025795459747314, -0.09552065283060074, 0.13225728273391724, -0.270792692899704, 0.35735058784484863, 0.13918472826480865, -0.1006634533405304, 0.41139695048332214, 1.3609848022460938, -0.5977110266685486, -0.6321255564689636, -1.0408828258514404, 0.08529800921678543, -0.03845882788300514, -1.2818700075149536, 0.11747551709413528, 0.17686186730861664, -0.0899476483464241, 0.2930867075920105, 0.3802058696746826, 0.8203985095024109, -0.6568107008934021, -0.7941654324531555, 0.24779804050922394, -0.06979472935199738, -0.24652042984962463, 0.32557713985443115, -0.12641531229019165, 0.5191272497177124, -0.11773565411567688, 0.2656465172767639, -0.39667972922325134, -0.09072849899530411, -1.2195110321044922, -0.24583148956298828, -0.11490403115749359, 0.028033480048179626, 0.02666168473660946, -1.292229413986206, 0.792034924030304, 0.03575748950242996, -0.7580326795578003, 0.42784106731414795, -0.5389204621315002, 0.40973421931266785, -0.6879987716674805, -0.009067730978131294, 0.16904917359352112, 0.5818527340888977, -0.6564006805419922, 0.8327708840370178, -0.46431103348731995, -0.1433958262205124, -0.13213743269443512, 0.29129403829574585, 0.039331238716840744, 0.5063488483428955, 0.3308631181716919, -0.07687805593013763, 0.5468006730079651, 0.0901084840297699, -0.0736459344625473, -0.34170690178871155, -0.42424121499061584, -0.15452350676059723, 0.01791306398808956, 0.26974040269851685, 0.0054921116679906845, 1.05242919921875, 0.0493808388710022, -0.32028496265411377, 0.007450366858392954, -0.7994312644004822, -0.9693859219551086, 0.23646003007888794, -0.14750008285045624, -0.7460225224494934, -0.11642536520957947, 0.3433040976524353, -0.3063676655292511, 0.6126323342323303, -0.3314734995365143, 0.2753654718399048, -0.09429418295621872, 0.5964120626449585, 0.48094508051872253, 0.028666287660598755, 0.061952169984579086, 0.0342719741165638, -0.36835023760795593, -0.3333189785480499, 0.13592775166034698, 0.7690109014511108, -0.45073115825653076, -0.19222375750541687, -0.21146200597286224, 0.43911904096603394, -0.4258972406387329, -0.32352960109710693, 0.16669905185699463, -0.5146260857582092, 0.13572165369987488, -0.5070570111274719, -0.5397440791130066, 0.04583820700645447, -1.1602933406829834, 0.48750436305999756, -0.09601515531539917, -0.5452093482017517, 0.23380082845687866, -0.6178144216537476, 0.06345715373754501, 0.2702125906944275, -0.11303054541349411, 0.646477997303009, -0.06542365252971649, -0.5594584345817566, 0.5904765725135803, 0.475149929523468, 0.32365843653678894, 0.3526833951473236, -0.6707773804664612, 0.6769028902053833, 0.7556251287460327, 0.2758396565914154, 0.8443707823753357, 0.3388242721557617, -0.14168038964271545, -0.06326504051685333, 0.4349728524684906, 0.5013449788093567, -0.0050979130901396275, 0.287460058927536, 0.7669958472251892, 0.8053311705589294, 0.28553158044815063, -0.1220601499080658, -0.21544930338859558, 0.9079279899597168, 0.23362912237644196, -0.07568482309579849, -0.39175862073898315, 0.17649047076702118, 0.3396871089935303, 0.8011084794998169, -0.7583906054496765, -0.26186618208885193, -0.12485325336456299, 0.3025777041912079, 0.6130379438400269, -0.15493141114711761, -0.37207791209220886, 0.20834015309810638, 0.19703276455402374, -0.16285701096057892, -0.1752261370420456, 0.9414449334144592, 0.42217832803726196, 0.421867311000824, 0.12475702166557312, 0.6241384744644165, 0.2712109684944153, 0.6378596425056458, -0.38973361253738403, -0.6534784436225891, -0.04286611080169678, 0.689439594745636, -1.459242820739746, 0.6041156053543091, -0.0000017802231013774872, 0.17331930994987488, -0.3354537785053253, -0.8900978565216064, -0.13053888082504272, -0.17372509837150574, 0.2141290307044983, 0.31188005208969116, -0.1471429467201233, -0.08430179953575134, 0.3169158697128296, 0.262892484664917, 0.48619604110717773, 0.9971970915794373, -0.15209849178791046, -0.17263926565647125, 0.9493083953857422, 1.1844079494476318, 0.47974520921707153, 0.7459632754325867, -0.8282190561294556, -1.0469151735305786, 0.965079665184021, -0.16749240458011627, 0.3901686370372772, 0.9543358087539673, -0.6150303483009338, -0.1398712396621704, 0.002192747313529253, 0.22134768962860107, -0.1309286653995514, -0.5940859317779541, -0.2905717194080353, 0.6698233485221863, -0.13369090855121613, 0.22010231018066406, 1.1729350090026855, 0.5228669047355652, -0.6735882759094238, -0.6100913286209106, 0.44555938243865967, -0.7136071920394897, 0.251516729593277, -0.778979480266571, 0.40890058875083923, 0.051022376865148544, -0.17974397540092468, -0.6950738430023193, -0.6428471803665161, -0.6011099219322205, -0.8778702616691589, 0.09675625711679459, -0.5389969944953918, 0.3513895571231842, -0.08693480491638184, -0.013378319330513477, 0.834545910358429, -0.8801808953285217, -0.11941107362508774, -0.3384888470172882, 0.8827212452888489, -0.10186394304037094, -0.15896116197109222, 0.7718978524208069, 0.4402020275592804, -1.2664953470230103, 0.7149315476417542, 0.6694950461387634, -0.5248507857322693, 0.7568354606628418, -0.36787569522857666, -0.01349680870771408, 0.4548804461956024, 0.1268937885761261, 0.6761008501052856, -0.27149853110313416, 0.2465285062789917, 0.15097670257091522, -0.2612632215023041, -0.36369043588638306, -0.9539150595664978, 0.16848215460777283, -0.6228244304656982, 0.060977935791015625, 0.23000259697437286, 0.49063587188720703, 0.3295600414276123, -0.4575478434562683, 3.9758918285369873, 1.3853116035461426, 0.059985458850860596, 0.054892733693122864, 0.563478946685791, 0.7467923164367676, 0.18903565406799316, -0.5670374631881714, 0.3337119221687317, -0.7358657121658325, -0.3291581869125366, 0.34575316309928894, -0.07696358114480972, -0.2947283983230591, -0.220289409160614, 0.2274404615163803, -0.21552367508411407, -0.3480953872203827, -0.44388842582702637, -0.9072849750518799, -0.5139610171318054, 0.38356897234916687, 0.4986867904663086, 0.020178601145744324, 0.4939422309398651, 0.2541443109512329, 0.2811989188194275, -0.5709787607192993, -1.0972707271575928, -0.3837805986404419, -0.7890209555625916, -0.8494906425476074, -0.5355156660079956, 0.2783142030239105, -0.9567070007324219, 0.3310612142086029, -0.01732630655169487, -0.8137291669845581, 0.39115071296691895, 0.2702796757221222, 0.343110591173172, 0.11763028800487518, 0.23229527473449707, -0.27901747822761536, -0.2944967448711395, 0.6660483479499817, 0.391928493976593, 0.5159326791763306, 0.662456750869751, -0.6124140024185181, 0.41870230436325073, -0.08982960879802704, 0.1842271387577057, -0.5117394924163818, -1.3338446617126465, -0.6299768686294556, -0.3452741205692291, -0.16668087244033813, 0.5782383680343628, 0.20485518872737885, 0.2914453446865082, 0.03160788118839264, -0.3600635528564453, 0.1349906623363495, 0.1844107210636139, 0.9496527910232544, 0.12813004851341248, -0.25956064462661743, -0.09035452455282211, -0.42772069573402405, -0.47728443145751953, -0.18923060595989227, -0.9047576189041138, 0.12325400859117508, -0.22334624826908112, 0.1913061887025833, 0.1674165427684784, 1.0938053131103516, -0.21646849811077118, 0.6071876883506775, -0.07419911026954651, 0.01116788201034069, 0.1568041741847992, 0.19507037103176117, 0.24249804019927979, 0.9903550744056702, -0.028181569650769234, -0.16573049128055573, -0.34029659628868103, 0.35586848855018616, -0.36635977029800415, 0.9529452323913574, -0.10865418612957001, -0.22891971468925476, -1.1151092052459717 ]
Critical Behavior of Dynamically Triangulated Quantum Gravity in Four Dimensions
We performed detailed study of the phase transition region in Four Dimensional Simplicial Quantum Gravity, using the dynamical triangulation approach. The phase transition between the Gravity and Antigravity phases turned out to be asymmetrical, so that we observed the scaling laws only when the Newton constant approached the critical value from perturbative side. The curvature susceptibility diverges with the scaling index $-.6$. The physical (i.e. measured with heavy particle propagation) Hausdorff dimension of the manifolds, which is 2.3 in the Gravity phase and 4.6 in the Antigravity phase, turned out to be 4 at the critical point, within the measurement accuracy. These facts indicate the existence of the continuum limit in Four Dimensional Euclidean Quantum Gravity.
M.E. Agishtein, A.A. Migdal
hep-lat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9204004
hep-lat/9204005
[ 0.08205079287290573, 0.4869040250778198, 0.5030422806739807, 0.2583857774734497, 0.3645515739917755, -0.2811652421951294, -0.03488088771700859, -0.46403077244758606, -0.994951069355011, 1.608933925628662, 0.988774299621582, -0.33092817664146423, 0.44416579604148865, -1.0515648126602173, -0.24322918057441711, -0.2424401044845581, -0.13069461286067963, -0.8979082703590393, -0.8041860461235046, -0.5131840109825134, 0.47976619005203247, -0.8965885639190674, -1.5379363298416138, -0.6081553101539612, -0.42056846618652344, 0.25471362471580505, 0.4363088309764862, 0.27889856696128845, 1.4322481155395508, 0.4960229992866516, -0.034263454377651215, -0.9651221632957458, 0.17022892832756042, -1.3054008483886719, -0.31789645552635193, -0.292407363653183, 0.6893172860145569, -0.29328039288520813, -0.32113537192344666, -0.7296246886253357, 1.0960254669189453, -0.141805961728096, 1.279609203338623, 0.10667302459478378, -0.6890711784362793, -0.07253087311983109, -0.07278835028409958, -0.23264804482460022, 0.26640745997428894, -1.0479680299758911, 0.3831638991832733, -0.1774197369813919, 0.47831109166145325, -0.4020063877105713, 0.1081618145108223, 0.2339446097612381, 0.3783952593803406, 0.777594804763794, 0.13192491233348846, 0.10009846091270447, 0.29018446803092957, 0.3152371048927307, 1.011001706123352, -1.1824135780334473, 0.49364280700683594, 1.0004481077194214, -0.8564296364784241, 0.4287720024585724, 0.237954780459404, -0.7981997728347778, -0.5686960816383362, -1.0657105445861816, -0.03393514081835747, -0.029590850695967674, -0.49024105072021484, 0.5799935460090637, 0.3733336329460144, -0.13997021317481995, -1.7127954959869385, -0.6005138158798218, -0.28511714935302734, -0.6504389643669128, -0.3136754333972931, 0.8552713394165039, -0.304559588432312, -0.06296379119157791, 0.4901803731918335, -0.24977535009384155, 0.10474130511283875, 0.15331518650054932, 0.17463810741901398, 0.8299019932746887, 0.4849846065044403, -0.29893097281455994, 0.03194766864180565, 0.4076920449733734, -0.029808655381202698, 0.4595319628715515, 0.020580658689141273, 0.6099863052368164, -0.3206990957260132, 0.970294177532196, -0.21849915385246277, 0.632969856262207, -0.4125502407550812, 0.6320587396621704, 0.7294084429740906, -0.12130571901798248, -0.1792164444923401, -0.41811898350715637, -0.5204067230224609, 0.0330563560128212, -0.21105438470840454, 0.47077563405036926, 0.11747874319553375, 0.8136876225471497, 0.2711165249347687, 0.3310488760471344, -0.6037276983261108, 0.5086691379547119, 0.2907380163669586, 0.0573270209133625, 0.20189017057418823, 0.36728647351264954, 0.09104713052511215, -0.4232006371021271, 0.1409214287996292, 0.42696383595466614, -0.8863680958747864, -0.038357675075531006, -0.43369078636169434, -0.35904598236083984, -0.5388694405555725, 0.5818384885787964, 0.05436233431100845, 0.6080509424209595, 0.4708373248577118, 0.7998977899551392, 0.17699645459651947, -0.8236882090568542, 0.5549272298812866, -0.49155667424201965, 0.16228832304477692, 1.2459285259246826, -0.06823087483644485, 0.6186829209327698, 0.04929469898343086, -0.5548859238624573, -0.025311006233096123, 0.6026195883750916, -0.8905209898948669, -0.24148307740688324, -0.012929258868098259, 0.562877357006073, -0.23962652683258057, -0.024773303419351578, -1.228499174118042, 1.0012294054031372, -0.8588712811470032, -0.5743839144706726, 0.015194485895335674, -0.07870540767908096, -0.08108903467655182, 0.3277435004711151, 0.04463310167193413, -0.13728521764278412, -0.3274220824241638, -0.18662956357002258, -0.7679674029350281, -0.40534114837646484, 0.17943447828292847, -0.37111422419548035, -0.00017857285274658352, 0.27500230073928833, 0.0012759839883074164, 0.38869887590408325, 0.6021702289581299, -0.43378064036369324, -0.007275973912328482, 0.19387061893939972, -0.536652147769928, -0.16301700472831726, 0.620733916759491, 0.3964814245700836, 0.22148405015468597, 0.2215709239244461, -0.6496414542198181, -0.046145956963300705, -0.5295536518096924, 0.9694346785545349, -0.08385280519723892, 1.0504361391067505, -0.6098291277885437, 0.38025152683258057, -0.5043606162071228, -0.6464526653289795, 0.08044351637363434, -0.13790476322174072, -0.5377861857414246, -0.5064986944198608, 0.04914461076259613, 0.17674453556537628, -0.714234471321106, -0.062488164752721786, -1.745863914489746, 0.25134119391441345, 0.08973197638988495, 0.33566129207611084, -0.27084633708000183, -0.07779703289270401, 0.06670613586902618, 0.15221987664699554, -0.26261475682258606, -0.049573492258787155, -0.00802595354616642, 0.06514912098646164, -0.8823673129081726, 0.2693740129470825, 1.0544025897979736, -0.9501028060913086, 0.6120113134384155, -0.2746281623840332, -0.039719607681035995, 0.14987069368362427, 0.0589282251894474, -0.15432721376419067, 0.29543811082839966, 0.7160401344299316, 0.5488600134849548, 0.4013412296772003, -0.08528484404087067, 0.7854117155075073, -0.08277354389429092, 0.21448677778244019, 0.5818681120872498, 0.6017718315124512, 0.7640945315361023, 0.5198473930358887, -0.03661264106631279, -0.18789276480674744, 0.2638578414916992, 0.4076918363571167, 0.7917144298553467, 0.6209380626678467, -0.006640537641942501, 0.6218281984329224, -0.6731110215187073, 0.12207154929637909, -0.7068604230880737, -0.08573337644338608, -0.43498891592025757, 1.2659962177276611, -0.023921268060803413, 0.061150696128606796, -0.6253541111946106, -0.0023937090300023556, 0.32194602489471436, 0.4697083532810211, -0.13173241913318634, -0.46636682748794556, -0.4456236958503723, 0.31490403413772583, -0.41253137588500977, -0.1466982066631317, -0.06876499205827713, 1.1721625328063965, -0.08420077711343765, 0.22581155598163605, -0.1380741149187088, -0.830541729927063, -0.8819769620895386, -0.5322416424751282, -0.5016109943389893, -0.6137118339538574, -0.6061027646064758, -0.5568320155143738, 1.2179869413375854, -0.9487316012382507, 0.8199065923690796, -0.24148039519786835, -0.5660649538040161, 0.5813632011413574, 0.4283382296562195, 0.7654812335968018, 0.5401217937469482, -0.18223454058170319, -0.6935246586799622, 0.3380337655544281, -1.0231164693832397, 0.3216148316860199, -0.02051691524684429, 0.3144485354423523, -0.0073406631126999855, -0.5101800560951233, 0.2930615544319153, -0.22787459194660187, -0.2980962097644806, -0.8452652096748352, -0.2655812203884125, -0.46942147612571716, 0.15645286440849304, 0.4180459976196289, -0.3038102984428406, 0.013484787195920944, -0.8935689926147461, 0.8074944019317627, 0.0016386257484555244, -0.9291112422943115, 0.9124624133110046, 0.5897099375724792, -0.500921905040741, 0.4117566645145416, -0.8979473114013672, -0.3001239597797394, 0.022801289334893227, 1.2633084058761597, 0.7063068151473999, 0.5806978940963745, -0.00951410736888647, -0.4682859778404236, -0.4239523410797119, 0.04263603687286377, 0.07094808667898178, -0.6163596510887146, -0.06874974817037582, 1.0410884618759155, 0.3874230980873108, -0.9464767575263977, 0.7995773553848267, -0.5767892003059387, -0.8171976208686829, 0.23917648196220398, -0.11206480115652084, 0.2712497115135193, -0.010477418079972267, 0.4283919334411621, -0.748132050037384, 0.5716612339019775, 0.3303425908088684, 1.1482611894607544, 0.4333086311817169, -0.508801281452179, 0.5475743412971497, 0.6373110413551331, 0.2045651376247406, -0.4692338705062866, 0.9354184865951538, -0.0038358448073267937, -0.4649786353111267, 0.41265830397605896, -0.8324487805366516, -0.0698070377111435, 0.7205371260643005, 0.47270336747169495, 0.21404190361499786, 0.25852447748184204, -0.7450087070465088, 0.005073297768831253, -0.5288520455360413, 0.050617337226867676, 0.7792970538139343, 0.3664630651473999, -0.4991858899593353, 0.5442397594451904, -0.558995246887207, 0.20679430663585663, 0.9576506018638611, -0.1873224377632141, 0.8959922194480896, -0.563103199005127, 0.8710060715675354, -0.008121447637677193, -0.4164572060108185, 0.1884048730134964, -0.031268537044525146, -0.08643243461847305, 0.13477416336536407, 0.684868335723877, 1.6795809268951416, -0.7421309351921082, -0.9929642081260681, -0.339524507522583, 0.887593686580658, 0.5342507362365723, 0.560605525970459, 0.7280837893486023, -0.7744230628013611, 0.3981250524520874, -0.7131097316741943, -0.918896496295929, -0.31395265460014343, -0.6511625051498413, -0.9089024662971497, -0.19055764377117157, -0.2633093595504761, -0.5358652472496033, 0.6917822957038879, 0.3369132876396179, 0.3768482506275177, 0.2984521985054016, 0.6209430694580078, -0.1873219758272171, 0.3085918426513672, 0.645073413848877, 0.2916477918624878, 0.16082002222537994, -0.8774442672729492, 0.16927456855773926, 0.567362368106842, 0.04298410564661026, -0.07704795897006989, -0.09849794209003448, -0.1539374589920044, 0.023276446387171745, 0.8230130076408386, -0.028505239635705948, -0.31356900930404663, 0.5397971868515015, -0.4210054576396942, 0.17565301060676575, -0.6155253052711487, 0.14009079337120056, 0.12790875136852264, 0.7021769881248474, 0.1582018882036209, -1.0186372995376587, 0.08027925342321396, -0.7349873781204224, 1.0687758922576904, 0.6727683544158936, -0.5090351104736328, -1.0144422054290771, -0.336161732673645, 0.4729457497596741, -0.9107666015625, 0.04562633857131004, 0.9255592823028564, -0.10806197673082352, 0.2269454151391983, -0.2859133183956146, -0.6160698533058167, 0.1790628582239151, -0.6176079511642456, -0.3404081463813782, 0.5043489933013916, 0.16058138012886047, -0.5525152683258057, 0.0316767543554306, -0.4498445987701416, -0.3321352005004883, 0.304855614900589, -0.30424395203590393, 0.374210000038147, -0.6039591431617737, -0.30507931113243103, 0.06720894575119019, -0.31350377202033997, -0.34723085165023804, 0.5601221919059753, -0.34686627984046936, -0.15224944055080414, -0.24985525012016296, 0.6327829360961914, -1.1471261978149414, -0.8700595498085022, 0.489950031042099, -0.025298791006207466, 0.033400051295757294, 0.6888461709022522, 0.7930076718330383, 0.03747251629829407, 0.20020505785942078, -0.2703847289085388, 0.4167892634868622, 1.0193848609924316, -0.3649509847164154, 0.20932094752788544, -0.3675539195537567, 0.24103932082653046, -0.8525359034538269, -0.8327740430831909, 0.3524652123451233, -0.8576780557632446, 0.4415748119354248, 0.35975053906440735, -0.5773013830184937, -0.15995736420154572, 0.3367484211921692, -0.719912588596344, -0.24189335107803345, -0.11414362490177155, -0.5663410425186157, 0.2660404443740845, -0.0342995747923851, 0.17995068430900574, 0.5472579598426819, 0.3135426640510559, -0.029099103063344955, 0.08818939328193665, 0.7956913709640503, -0.6126000285148621, 0.24060650169849396, -0.6524174213409424, 0.18688274919986725, -0.3806283175945282, -0.09829938411712646, -0.2700366973876953, -1.102498173713684, -0.18623411655426025, 0.039865024387836456, -0.8657274842262268, -0.6948975324630737, -0.04628126323223114, 0.16231925785541534, 0.7296613454818726, 0.24071089923381805, -0.5779100060462952, -0.3449942469596863, -0.9921955466270447, 0.5213451385498047, -0.4156576991081238, -1.0604863166809082, -0.13017243146896362, 1.0299490690231323, -0.4257606565952301, -0.13368605077266693, 0.20361317694187164, -1.2114897966384888, 0.1305033564567566, 0.14594684541225433, 0.4735952913761139, -0.4543188512325287, 0.14730717241764069, -0.4004563093185425, -0.8851948380470276, -0.7147278785705566, 0.6540131568908691, 0.5367482304573059, -0.4828093349933624, -0.3389716148376465, -0.3745903968811035, -0.16380463540554047, -0.2697788178920746, -0.03197166696190834, -0.5164474844932556, -0.006056082434952259, -0.5655933022499084, 0.4682055115699768, -0.12744735181331635, -0.5497468113899231, 0.41766971349716187, 0.7621139287948608, 0.19145624339580536, 0.6442245841026306, -0.04193335026502609, 0.25053152441978455, 0.028044939041137695, 0.5043448209762573, 0.08439206331968307, 0.2622562050819397, -0.46009817719459534, 0.29211562871932983, -1.0076572895050049, 0.7056630849838257, -0.4941038489341736, -0.05487588047981262, 0.5243974328041077, 0.3803969621658325, 0.8839735388755798, -0.3907924294471741, 0.39571070671081543, -0.1384153813123703, 0.5286784172058105, 0.6763069033622742, 0.11025497317314148, -0.3304608166217804, -0.5532907247543335, -0.935041069984436, -1.568974494934082, 1.195831060409546, 0.228789821267128, -0.63458251953125, -0.2891249358654022, 0.13610559701919556, 0.6101064085960388, -0.8968904614448547, 0.19526000320911407, 0.1950460970401764, -0.05058909207582474, -0.21731027960777283, 0.18814516067504883, 0.11701075732707977, -0.5157695412635803, -0.2842892110347748, 0.5956560373306274, -0.22338564693927765, -0.9454103112220764, -0.6755430102348328, -0.690933346748352, -1.4582223892211914, -0.6730169057846069, 0.650820255279541, 0.8766918778419495, -0.03475605696439743, 0.9524127244949341, -0.10469506680965424, -0.04877909645438194, 0.034412406384944916, -0.33139005303382874, -0.08894240111112595, 0.026385875418782234, 0.8064367771148682, -0.23861145973205566, 0.5699830651283264, -0.5741549730300903, 0.6602630615234375, -1.1395915746688843, -0.14625130593776703, 1.0584346055984497, 0.07454514503479004, 0.014035106636583805, 0.24575649201869965, 0.15661799907684326, -1.4571752548217773, -0.37051907181739807, -0.08680197596549988, 0.17463596165180206, -0.1945275366306305, -0.705963134765625, -0.21484686434268951, -0.06627049297094345, -0.3205719590187073, 0.2403411567211151, 0.3599657118320465, -0.6934211254119873, 0.3777945935726166, 0.17841558158397675, -0.07263019680976868, -1.1182066202163696, 0.2208521068096161, 1.2347235679626465, -0.28942418098449707, -0.23718084394931793, -0.5795305371284485, -0.2758339047431946, -0.041574254631996155, 0.26954132318496704, 0.07576624304056168, 0.05327558517456055, -0.139263316988945, 0.2236613780260086, 0.7914308309555054, 0.18318763375282288, 0.1513797491788864, 0.9480379819869995, -0.04395822435617447, 0.09920671582221985, -0.6247985363006592, -0.8579863905906677, 0.1321975141763687, -0.05717170983552933, 0.7677546143531799, -0.49273592233657837, 0.24825705587863922, 0.09102092683315277, -0.9803685545921326, -0.021746953949332237, -1.0833557844161987, 0.4987938404083252, -1.2717405557632446, -0.6567652821540833, -1.056711196899414, -0.7239718437194824, -0.05544470250606537, 0.5175715684890747, 0.2789939045906067, -0.1245914176106453, -0.7624085545539856, 0.07891282439231873, 0.49368107318878174, 0.2708456814289093, -0.16336241364479065, -0.2462879717350006, -1.143315315246582, -0.041681669652462006, -0.5093013048171997, -0.17247040569782257, -0.8009804487228394, 0.8242169618606567, 0.18516437709331512, 0.6590728163719177, -0.891863226890564, 0.5285884141921997, -0.22325444221496582, -0.3510068953037262, -0.11784724146127701, -0.2971556782722473, -0.3210543394088745, 0.040550220757722855, -0.3877924978733063, 0.8054270148277283, 0.17559529840946198, -0.2568267583847046, -0.31390365958213806, -0.10797802358865738, -0.9532148241996765, -0.14516249299049377, -0.3325960636138916, 0.6255538463592529, -0.32814449071884155, -0.8956711888313293, 0.43978434801101685, 0.11904685199260712, -1.3674614429473877, 0.059147369116544724, 0.2757360339164734, -0.012709368020296097, -0.1202496886253357, -0.4381692707538605, 0.4654441475868225, 0.6212578415870667, -0.33732327818870544, 0.5325783491134644, -0.6063677668571472, 0.13318756222724915, -0.40351343154907227, 0.33332085609436035, -0.21140995621681213, 0.2926279306411743, 0.3628331422805786, -1.447882056236267, -0.16968458890914917, 0.32206061482429504, -0.35885798931121826, 0.11411705613136292, -0.5073825120925903, -0.19925524294376373, -0.3614777624607086, -0.017729174345731735, -0.6573271155357361, 0.8900401592254639, 0.46346980333328247, -0.5955344438552856, -0.5514560341835022, -0.9184548258781433, -0.4095979332923889, -0.03810584545135498, -1.1242040395736694, -0.10165664553642273, -0.560569703578949, -0.4693430960178375, -0.22269360721111298, -0.36568671464920044, -0.17880336940288544, 0.19032150506973267, 0.3882334530353546, 0.6147118806838989, -0.22463221848011017, 0.30277779698371887, -0.13463391363620758, 0.7089385986328125, -0.7302777767181396, -0.3215073347091675, -0.690035879611969, -0.052111878991127014, -0.2453034222126007, -0.10273516923189163, -0.16542457044124603, 0.6593509316444397, -0.3988243043422699, -0.558062732219696, -0.4386362135410309, 0.6863422393798828, 0.4454308748245239, 0.158589169383049, -0.6407975554466248, 0.39386826753616333, 0.16440357267856598, 0.34243980050086975, 0.15174952149391174, -0.3181898593902588, 0.2066507488489151, 0.3452814817428589, 0.331413209438324, -0.037648070603609085, -0.4946099817752838, 0.977249801158905, -0.016413846984505653, -0.8323432207107544, 1.1332058906555176, 0.07243125885725021, 1.0491838455200195, -0.1905962973833084, 0.287035197019577, 0.15462471544742584, 0.1038571149110794, 0.5205497741699219, 0.6227865815162659, 0.6375877261161804, 0.22291016578674316, 0.3041607439517975, 0.42368632555007935, 0.002539495239034295, 0.1822991669178009, 0.742260754108429, 0.04353497922420502, 0.27375954389572144, 0.06865229457616806, 0.28763604164123535, -0.24477025866508484, 0.31158384680747986, 0.18760539591312408, -0.09500031918287277, -0.44314366579055786, -0.43441805243492126, -0.12249325960874557, 0.4292454719543457, -0.07640387117862701, -0.5976184010505676, -0.08256646245718002, 0.9492580890655518, -0.19544778764247894, 0.20581035315990448, -0.1280757635831833, 0.4196946620941162, 0.5006628632545471, 0.5237066149711609, 0.24771437048912048, 0.599145233631134, 0.4219326674938202, -0.0486636757850647, 0.057863056659698486, 1.0329468250274658, 0.707282304763794, 0.5527657866477966, 0.14679639041423798, -1.0848033428192139, -0.48284104466438293, 0.6792134046554565, -1.6008583307266235, -0.2927180826663971, -0.577908456325531, -0.15908052027225494, 0.3021976351737976, -0.9865503311157227, 0.10762077569961548, -0.7356829047203064, 0.4635794162750244, 1.1335238218307495, 0.25325092673301697, -0.04308813437819481, 0.6021219491958618, -0.3307897448539734, 0.970673143863678, 0.4403921961784363, 0.0884900614619255, -0.40204325318336487, 1.24956214427948, 1.821808934211731, -0.15579482913017273, 0.5000193119049072, 0.09481610357761383, -0.21899642050266266, -0.0763300284743309, -0.05152839422225952, -0.25459787249565125, 1.474663496017456, -0.5337668657302856, -0.37464848160743713, -0.04247438535094261, 0.3432745039463043, -0.7933868765830994, -0.14629177749156952, 0.568953812122345, 0.5913323760032654, -0.36780211329460144, -0.053329795598983765, 1.2393349409103394, 0.19614562392234802, 0.053526654839515686, 0.0005187122151255608, -0.11531195789575577, -0.07279598712921143, 0.30737748742103577, -0.5813348293304443, 0.11628753691911697, 0.05974322184920311, 0.4515320360660553, -0.26451045274734497, -1.1521906852722168, -0.38775521516799927, -1.541327953338623, -0.4553874731063843, -0.5066087245941162, 0.795071005821228, 0.3883688151836395, 0.8735818862915039, 0.15772855281829834, -1.0624257326126099, -0.23102138936519623, 0.34165146946907043, 0.9017629623413086, 0.11857729405164719, 0.33791542053222656, 0.8526238799095154, 0.7735936641693115, -1.0146443843841553, 0.6206014752388, 0.634259819984436, -0.344723105430603, 0.5619056820869446, -0.2961784303188324, 0.2795744240283966, -0.500560462474823, -0.5485154986381531, 0.05387122184038162, 0.4325896203517914, 0.5329314470291138, -0.9353379607200623, -0.26375117897987366, 0.2895830571651459, -0.8313460946083069, -0.16862674057483673, -0.9730592370033264, 0.5314565896987915, 0.40891462564468384, 0.052329786121845245, -0.4718995988368988, 0.3803442120552063, 3.716780185699463, 0.726822555065155, 1.3598389625549316, -0.5948629975318909, 1.271280288696289, 1.2350789308547974, 0.171397402882576, -0.8028556704521179, 0.4189120829105377, 0.02632521465420723, 0.2324964702129364, 0.6006270051002502, 0.9595930576324463, -0.021838584914803505, -0.1449074000120163, 0.17884762585163116, -0.9056112170219421, 0.356533944606781, 0.6970268487930298, -1.0337083339691162, -0.7850140333175659, 0.6450777649879456, -0.49813124537467957, -0.061403244733810425, 0.11937513202428818, -0.0734480768442154, 0.4582868218421936, -1.1530308723449707, -0.3729958236217499, -0.0743849128484726, -0.5955337285995483, -0.8614355325698853, 0.5176631212234497, -0.11947803944349289, -0.6580635905265808, 0.48327872157096863, 0.3633720874786377, -0.06499999016523361, 0.5840873718261719, 0.03168642893433571, -0.007696004118770361, 0.12070433050394058, -0.42366287112236023, -0.08042935281991959, -0.9023080468177795, 0.9819189310073853, 0.031429290771484375, 0.9785454869270325, 0.7265384793281555, -0.37487292289733887, 0.6044850945472717, -0.3901160657405853, 0.6563705205917358, 0.21917463839054108, -1.1797438859939575, -0.465555340051651, -0.5542545318603516, -0.8567377924919128, 0.047049134969711304, -0.05468453839421272, 1.6287044286727905, -0.08890516310930252, -0.22256305813789368, 0.2729039788246155, -0.3641468286514282, 0.600865364074707, 0.43265363574028015, -0.10115648061037064, -0.5072104930877686, 0.37982866168022156, -0.6296408176422119, -0.211457297205925, -0.5506390929222107, -0.3148714601993561, -0.007188398391008377, -0.43930715322494507, -0.5791161060333252, 0.605577290058136, 0.01174372248351574, -0.08352197706699371, -0.3988918960094452, -0.6150375604629517, 0.2678976058959961, -0.37119820713996887, 0.4131433665752411, 1.3770625591278076, -0.15404511988162994, 0.06551435589790344, 0.06972859799861908, 0.22255319356918335, 0.6868940591812134, 0.9514188170433044, 0.11388546973466873, 0.25953206419944763, -0.3864908516407013 ]
Microcanonical cluster algorithms
I propose a numerical simulation algorithm for statistical systems which combines a microcanonical transfer of energy with global changes in clusters of spins. The advantages of the cluster approach near a critical point augment the speed increases associated with multi-spin coding in the microcanonical approach. The method also provides a limited ability to tune the average cluster size.
Michael Creutz
hep-lat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9204005
hep-lat/9204006
[ 0.8020820021629333, -0.5142383575439453, -0.6412311792373657, -0.3919984698295593, -0.03046230971813202, -0.24081671237945557, -0.43028101325035095, -0.915277898311615, -0.5830485224723816, 1.1330993175506592, 0.2475583851337433, 0.06357663124799728, -0.017728107050061226, -0.9043418765068054, -0.35998621582984924, 0.4568358063697815, -0.5761726498603821, -0.5804481506347656, -1.5825661420822144, 0.6985160112380981, 0.3458701968193054, -0.10771987587213516, -1.4819865226745605, 0.002527037402614951, -0.005575533956289291, 1.0838217735290527, -0.11081498861312866, 0.5631328821182251, 1.0421602725982666, 0.7579512596130371, 0.3766709268093109, -0.3063070774078369, -0.11300869286060333, -1.0314372777938843, 0.11654530465602875, -0.31059396266937256, -0.3050418794155121, -0.5290957093238831, 1.0016961097717285, -0.2904813289642334, 0.35632622241973877, -0.01588297076523304, -0.30346304178237915, -0.4464951753616333, -0.49639227986335754, -0.3343125283718109, -0.4595603942871094, -0.4948174059391022, 0.073651522397995, -0.9242712259292603, -0.22162848711013794, 0.563125491142273, 0.5822632312774658, -0.29523083567619324, -0.6042990684509277, -0.12017881870269775, 0.16225387156009674, -0.33900249004364014, -0.6938017010688782, -0.40265968441963196, 0.7785545587539673, -0.5198174715042114, -0.05766909942030907, -0.6215328574180603, 0.19968870282173157, 0.4521116614341736, -0.285268098115921, 0.5965699553489685, 0.2670130431652069, -0.7512832880020142, 0.2049514651298523, -0.9462583661079407, -0.7639519572257996, -0.23417146503925323, -0.6240970492362976, 0.21116191148757935, 0.3627054691314697, -0.39697131514549255, -1.1442559957504272, -0.16384786367416382, -0.5689058303833008, -0.273139625787735, -0.16737568378448486, -0.2652130722999573, -0.5988380312919617, -0.5438593029975891, 0.06808124482631683, -0.2450854629278183, -0.02387823350727558, 0.3858623802661896, 0.03307770565152168, 0.8425624966621399, 0.08096592128276825, 0.15058250725269318, 0.20419412851333618, 0.45848825573921204, -0.24622799456119537, 0.45597347617149353, -0.24152912199497223, -0.12177174538373947, -0.41683608293533325, 0.8484131097793579, -1.072204351425171, 0.5198808312416077, -0.4603768587112427, 0.2332853525876999, 0.27960115671157837, -0.019986458122730255, -0.08342189341783524, -0.3209283947944641, 0.7645295858383179, -0.1957123875617981, -0.10943488776683807, 1.0494120121002197, 0.23087507486343384, 0.6694375276565552, 0.07075688242912292, 0.23818926513195038, -0.28294435143470764, -0.6330174207687378, 0.5182517766952515, 0.2375444620847702, 0.3600085973739624, 0.24306640028953552, 0.5490284562110901, -0.21192386746406555, -0.2328723967075348, 0.5710631608963013, -1.073525309562683, -0.3861934244632721, 0.047766778618097305, -0.34636643528938293, -0.2809414863586426, 0.7239972949028015, -0.5616233348846436, -0.041800204664468765, -0.18647469580173492, -0.13149389624595642, 0.06409873068332672, -0.1406206488609314, 1.0123140811920166, -0.6401641368865967, 0.001279619988054037, 1.2858127355575562, 0.031811945140361786, -0.012434595264494419, 0.311014860868454, 0.38625749945640564, 0.14208479225635529, 0.628455400466919, -0.5279848575592041, -0.5383017063140869, -0.588089108467102, 0.15894362330436707, 0.09819776564836502, 0.5861186981201172, -0.3060109615325928, -0.3760935664176941, -0.7761443257331848, -0.695097029209137, -0.024824565276503563, -0.32685476541519165, -0.10309138149023056, 0.4991491138935089, -0.47675472497940063, 0.3190743029117584, -0.6768929958343506, -0.5914351940155029, 0.20222802460193634, -0.5001525282859802, 0.285308301448822, -0.004034972749650478, 0.2655864357948303, 0.5686495900154114, 0.5169163942337036, 0.729297935962677, 0.46886271238327026, -0.4685419499874115, 0.3353935778141022, 0.31247246265411377, -0.45883387327194214, -0.3470733165740967, 0.3774084448814392, -0.0754881426692009, -0.3201780319213867, -0.48267680406570435, -0.09387839585542679, -0.3941793143749237, -0.05546111986041069, 0.4809685945510864, 0.25877800583839417, -0.10234615206718445, 0.26102912425994873, 0.9081199169158936, -0.323649525642395, 0.17826615273952484, -0.6624110341072083, 0.20217275619506836, -0.6201901435852051, -0.47638025879859924, -0.07431470602750778, -0.3170493543148041, -0.3260556161403656, 0.6072391271591187, -1.5477879047393799, 0.04076177626848221, 1.1790739297866821, 0.1660337746143341, -0.5637563467025757, -0.06155586987733841, 0.49781277775764465, -0.2911173105239868, 0.3688306510448456, -0.36595869064331055, -0.030966775491833687, 0.25203657150268555, 0.3706694543361664, 0.5661511421203613, 0.7633286714553833, 0.942266583442688, 0.28804901242256165, 0.2841074466705322, 0.21486081182956696, 0.13282321393489838, 0.11072326451539993, -0.40722545981407166, -0.2617090940475464, 0.8535428047180176, 0.8807523846626282, -0.3817746043205261, -0.10895273089408875, -0.09017603099346161, -0.11605574935674667, 0.6828579306602478, 0.09422815591096878, -0.2725816071033478, 0.5722239017486572, 0.14987026154994965, 0.3440823256969452, 0.6234596967697144, -0.022546060383319855, -0.5070986151695251, 0.4802999198436737, -0.05640758201479912, 0.14720596373081207, 0.19145184755325317, -0.41699743270874023, 0.38632404804229736, -0.7231110334396362, 0.45782992243766785, 0.02456299401819706, 0.8162353038787842, 0.3137882351875305, 0.666858971118927, -0.9572057723999023, -0.26962074637413025, -0.27899423241615295, 0.47846317291259766, -0.0766957476735115, 0.4558960199356079, 0.7556374669075012, 0.2504907250404358, -0.57499760389328, -0.6061861515045166, 0.3297468423843384, 0.9066466093063354, 0.10968687385320663, 0.19753903150558472, 0.7855551242828369, -0.870776355266571, -0.8796282410621643, -0.0739348903298378, -1.292077660560608, -0.3195105493068695, -0.02521180361509323, -0.3933311104774475, 0.6304439902305603, -0.6584321856498718, 0.46787628531455994, -0.47999587655067444, -0.21309107542037964, 0.43208691477775574, -0.4729313850402832, 0.8630762100219727, 0.10327120125293732, 0.1814141571521759, -0.3897314667701721, 0.46665000915527344, -0.09439374506473541, -0.58854740858078, 0.0689438059926033, 0.14407144486904144, 0.7244271039962769, -0.7611113786697388, 0.3320617973804474, -0.6542110443115234, -0.21531058847904205, 0.17167353630065918, 0.155111163854599, -0.7346139550209045, 0.05017734691500664, 0.5515643954277039, -0.35461702942848206, -0.009809835813939571, -1.4262075424194336, 0.4470190405845642, -0.025117842480540276, -0.16808196902275085, -0.05427294597029686, 0.32251450419425964, -0.6275944113731384, 0.6391635537147522, 0.05014927685260773, -0.10822733491659164, -0.07947979122400284, 1.1133536100387573, 0.7009769678115845, -0.22817353904247284, -0.15517820417881012, -0.6445503830909729, -0.17166569828987122, 0.41768455505371094, -0.1753218173980713, -0.08421898633241653, -0.4937140941619873, 0.8481797575950623, 0.426155149936676, -0.18974784016609192, 0.5960260629653931, -0.40177416801452637, -0.7343143820762634, 0.008431240916252136, -0.26839447021484375, 0.5550132989883423, -0.4706166088581085, 0.3660571873188019, -0.497391939163208, 0.8045670390129089, 0.5204638242721558, 0.5684565901756287, 0.4701869785785675, 0.009545914828777313, 0.3180776834487915, 0.8436356782913208, 0.5470308065414429, -0.1937902718782425, -0.36851683259010315, 0.09044425189495087, -0.7814105153083801, 0.7474490404129028, -0.438754677772522, 0.2910322844982147, -0.373272180557251, 0.689241886138916, -0.2630404829978943, 0.49001455307006836, -0.13029929995536804, -0.19263523817062378, -0.36284148693084717, -0.15319564938545227, 0.21049360930919647, 0.7099213004112244, -0.1785093992948532, -0.2515013515949249, -0.6045979261398315, -0.6884183287620544, -0.07615190744400024, 0.22925686836242676, 0.2398247867822647, -0.29272884130477905, 0.018992003053426743, -0.24811111390590668, -0.6795204877853394, 0.13833172619342804, -0.014424323104321957, 0.721195638179779, 0.5234812498092651, 0.4388764500617981, 1.1779422760009766, -0.4357471466064453, -0.7510515451431274, 0.5491157174110413, 0.7530646324157715, 0.59736168384552, 0.7334024310112, -0.054518215358257294, 0.09734445065259933, -0.01342697348445654, -0.41594088077545166, -0.803756833076477, -0.6001718640327454, 0.15595653653144836, -0.027117086574435234, -0.23964066803455353, 0.6266200542449951, -0.4098365008831024, 0.6032646298408508, 0.5260244011878967, 0.18215183913707733, 0.043267738074064255, 0.5701301097869873, 0.046496715396642685, 0.5355719923973083, 1.0600807666778564, 0.6119493246078491, 0.3228084146976471, -0.9373786449432373, 0.20834197103977203, -0.01664314977824688, 0.7524037957191467, -0.7381680011749268, 0.11445828527212143, -0.22105321288108826, -0.7537097334861755, -0.2897476255893707, 0.1287468671798706, -0.9843717813491821, -0.003902779659256339, -0.06254680454730988, 0.9031591415405273, -0.16529276967048645, -0.07557231932878494, 0.5767582654953003, -0.006136359181255102, 0.28370293974876404, -1.0496180057525635, 0.5293522477149963, -0.2890355885028839, 0.45543184876441956, 0.679228663444519, -0.7362021207809448, -0.5595526099205017, -1.5180559158325195, -0.30794471502304077, -0.169992595911026, 0.17539426684379578, 0.903587818145752, 0.28736016154289246, 0.39806556701660156, -0.13775624334812164, -0.17603105306625366, 0.44621196389198303, 0.028521645814180374, -0.9083178043365479, 0.5999511480331421, -0.19725444912910461, -0.0710178017616272, 0.4097600281238556, 0.6520971655845642, -0.435432106256485, 0.14858417212963104, -0.84443598985672, 0.0805906429886818, -0.4756050109863281, -0.7215644121170044, 0.008896407671272755, -0.2282658964395523, 0.04276302084326744, 0.00348627264611423, 0.7994731068611145, -0.2433173805475235, 0.0022441879846155643, -0.330338716506958, -0.7283509969711304, -0.37099599838256836, 0.36000964045524597, 0.347722589969635, 0.9315919280052185, 0.4453718066215515, 0.15323065221309662, 0.030193155631422997, 0.5677919387817383, 0.049397293478250504, 0.26911380887031555, 0.32511037588119507, -0.4222649931907654, -0.3968314230442047, -0.3538471460342407, -0.2439996749162674, -0.30076056718826294, -0.07242043316364288, -0.1023324504494667, -0.2464059442281723, 0.7037768363952637, 0.10967651754617691, -0.6625537872314453, 0.12469621002674103, -0.32985517382621765, -1.0744739770889282, 0.40408986806869507, 0.293610155582428, 0.23534108698368073, 0.530631959438324, -0.2650960683822632, 0.13326752185821533, -0.2813447415828705, -1.019853949546814, -0.8394328951835632, 0.7289310693740845, 0.22191151976585388, 0.8444638252258301, -0.19868965446949005, -0.6900995969772339, 0.2737939953804016, -0.6203293800354004, 0.08651741594076157, -0.6428894400596619, -0.32460883259773254, -0.5344120860099792, 0.022191224619746208, -0.15260036289691925, 0.18115437030792236, -0.03927333652973175, 0.08630406111478806, 0.17527860403060913, -0.8415403962135315, 0.5041577816009521, -0.6155914664268494, -0.08314020186662674, 0.40661874413490295, 0.8206862807273865, -0.5557348132133484, -0.3546815514564514, 0.02104531228542328, -0.21011555194854736, 0.6765317916870117, -0.09181059151887894, -0.07562939077615738, 0.24518181383609772, -0.08488140255212784, 0.5207666158676147, -0.7584995627403259, -0.8274015784263611, -0.6989873051643372, -1.0767042636871338, -0.04041372612118721, 0.12251273542642593, 0.3107231557369232, -0.23862215876579285, -1.2977256774902344, -0.3668740689754486, 0.1911756694316864, 0.41422995924949646, 0.08245149999856949, -0.4624451696872711, -0.6307244300842285, -0.10427440702915192, 0.4471494257450104, -0.4486810266971588, -0.1426619440317154, 0.3493853509426117, -0.33263739943504333, 0.6580823063850403, 1.0254641771316528, 0.4863225817680359, -0.2155107706785202, 0.25929707288742065, 0.009234139695763588, -0.4532853960990906, 0.3325996696949005, -0.5862336754798889, 0.5172288417816162, -1.0613919496536255, 1.6258106231689453, -0.3160878121852875, -0.2827962636947632, -0.33381229639053345, -0.039380818605422974, 0.24586541950702667, -0.7993191480636597, 0.21640902757644653, 0.05373312532901764, -0.034641534090042114, -0.07670718431472778, 0.43721655011177063, -0.04593365639448166, 0.05553196370601654, -0.5185269713401794, -0.7648530006408691, 0.2773277163505554, -0.1393706053495407, 0.3678077459335327, -0.3259997069835663, -0.543581485748291, 0.04873719811439514, 0.055723316967487335, 0.19140475988388062, 0.4205515384674072, 0.23669496178627014, 0.3854813277721405, -0.23126785457134247, 0.00020280369790270925, -0.6618978977203369, 0.1397234946489334, 0.06493154168128967, -0.2741377353668213, -0.053317610174417496, 0.17569905519485474, -0.21367992460727692, -1.1164143085479736, -0.24445195496082306, 0.47655051946640015, 0.3503267168998718, -0.6605419516563416, 0.4472826421260834, -0.281859815120697, -0.9902248382568359, -0.30315446853637695, 0.3683995008468628, -0.05279313027858734, 0.5694951415061951, -0.17424458265304565, -0.4754345715045929, 0.6226069331169128, -0.23014454543590546, 0.4592198431491852, 0.09993211179971695, -0.2599935233592987, 0.11958033591508865, -0.0928150862455368, -0.12705786526203156, 0.41314995288848877, 0.10039258003234863, -0.8063299059867859, -0.0738375186920166, -0.10471127927303314, 0.2658415734767914, -0.6602883338928223, -0.4479941725730896, -0.23588642477989197, -0.13849230110645294, -0.20424310863018036, 0.1821436733007431, 0.5070181488990784, -0.05565788224339485, -0.609295129776001, -0.06440678238868713, -0.2977830171585083, -0.3248887062072754, -0.2427896112203598, 1.2403050661087036, -0.21181707084178925, -0.631285548210144, 0.053943682461977005, 0.10391932725906372, -0.5749382972717285, -0.4112560749053955, 0.8159343600273132, -0.11833149194717407, 0.4760071635246277, 0.6592200994491577, 0.09296199679374695, 0.8758577704429626, 0.6398865580558777, 0.18981890380382538, 0.2889561951160431, -0.3335009813308716, -1.0356849431991577, -0.6747491955757141, -0.5692583918571472, -0.08497831225395203, 0.630937397480011, -0.009979408234357834, 0.13980981707572937, 0.09136539697647095, -0.026388736441731453, -0.4461316168308258, -0.5970969796180725, -0.46881383657455444, -0.8838059306144714, -0.5340387225151062, -0.08624043315649033, -0.6227115392684937, 0.4158064126968384, 1.0443174839019775, -0.19140483438968658, -0.4462050199508667, -0.48076653480529785, -0.2625906467437744, 0.06734105199575424, 0.5298815369606018, -0.09503523260354996, -1.1240359544754028, -0.02586282044649124, -0.9762102365493774, -0.13311724364757538, 0.032315727323293686, -0.34789517521858215, 0.24569685757160187, 0.29741448163986206, 0.3143434226512909, -0.14125916361808777, 0.8738678693771362, -0.6111398339271545, -0.7411593794822693, 0.07950910180807114, -0.23760919272899628, -0.08479936420917511, 0.6004273891448975, 0.5792677402496338, 1.47895085811615, 0.3293887674808502, 0.11757747828960419, -0.10427634418010712, -0.8301552534103394, -0.759122371673584, 0.5211105346679688, 0.09536907076835632, 0.16886329650878906, -0.46828413009643555, -1.058587670326233, -0.11855808645486832, 0.36524102091789246, -1.2218937873840332, 0.2708756625652313, -0.1338854283094406, 0.4089426100254059, -0.4334123432636261, 0.8212457895278931, 0.610939621925354, 0.7165833115577698, 0.13417279720306396, 0.7561947703361511, 0.15631328523159027, -0.10291456431150436, 0.3365245461463928, 0.12734709680080414, 0.3841385245323181, 0.27442941069602966, -0.7611664533615112, -0.5025554299354553, -0.36725670099258423, 0.22220435738563538, -0.24509836733341217, 0.6276692152023315, -0.6024110913276672, -0.44727078080177307, -0.17758183181285858, -0.7395833730697632, -0.7263901233673096, 0.7746070027351379, 0.7847840189933777, -0.7793298959732056, -0.2876718044281006, -0.29890069365501404, -0.643881618976593, 0.033450622111558914, -1.0293339490890503, -0.6004459261894226, 0.39749690890312195, -0.4884946644306183, 0.24052943289279938, -0.3120783865451813, -0.3142869770526886, 0.08642195910215378, 0.4557352364063263, 0.7032079696655273, -0.1866164207458496, 0.1677236109972, -0.6965131163597107, 0.04982181638479233, -0.8690203428268433, -0.25514495372772217, -0.5623408555984497, 0.5786696672439575, -1.4743975400924683, -0.4571753442287445, -0.602160632610321, 0.7976909279823303, 0.4600817859172821, -0.4470638334751129, -0.12637022137641907, -0.15522906184196472, 0.3231024444103241, 0.053955912590026855, -0.41558539867401123, -0.43717098236083984, -0.541003406047821, 0.7343105673789978, -0.5308566689491272, -0.2929908335208893, -0.3152003884315491, 0.08634708821773529, -0.22034510970115662, 0.5800403952598572, -0.07176196575164795, 0.7829635739326477, 0.37026622891426086, -0.6546837091445923, 1.1526798009872437, 0.08107142895460129, 0.18050874769687653, 0.5786283612251282, -0.30077219009399414, 0.1562732309103012, 1.0948868989944458, 0.052601445466279984, 0.617121696472168, 0.07767654955387115, 0.1885053962469101, 0.20880074799060822, 0.5571617484092712, -0.09809175878763199, -0.01551275234669447, 0.7833927869796753, 0.5592355132102966, 0.3497733771800995, 0.07760874927043915, -0.054249830543994904, 0.4086885154247284, 0.6051920652389526, 0.5177394151687622, -0.20090001821517944, 0.24059076607227325, -0.0600893534719944, -0.24368447065353394, 0.1269516795873642, -0.0734255388379097, -0.3532453775405884, 0.2902854084968567, -0.29055315256118774, 1.0042734146118164, 0.20578648149967194, 0.16714555025100708, -0.11216762661933899, 0.6468166708946228, -0.0070045324973762035, -0.31233087182044983, 0.5851540565490723, -0.24401146173477173, 0.9225960969924927, 1.0648813247680664, 0.919593870639801, 0.3961907625198364, 0.3476606607437134, -0.2533605396747589, -1.0406622886657715, 0.05535808205604553, 0.7088147401809692, -0.8078017234802246, -0.11461535096168518, -0.22423948347568512, -0.1639929711818695, -0.14437605440616608, -0.5774924159049988, 0.7335384488105774, -0.6904869675636292, -0.5812183022499084, 0.8328664898872375, -0.47895967960357666, -0.18638810515403748, 0.6446919441223145, 0.6227952837944031, 0.33557218313217163, 0.44709697365760803, 0.8996447920799255, 0.09405145794153214, 1.0799129009246826, 0.41716939210891724, 0.14537173509597778, -0.3796713650226593, -0.007601599674671888, -0.4590539038181305, -0.20775948464870453, -0.17095567286014557, -0.13475018739700317, 0.5279969573020935, -0.6290613412857056, -0.593061089515686, 0.46136781573295593, 0.0004556480562314391, -0.048662155866622925, -0.02492021955549717, 0.8278304934501648, -0.20343779027462006, -0.2547711431980133, -0.3379105031490326, 1.1811329126358032, 0.2701259255409241, -0.4269227385520935, -0.6693599820137024, 0.2787363827228546, -0.248749241232872, -0.32050666213035583, -0.6711025834083557, 0.5807929635047913, -0.6312876343727112, -0.43799957633018494, -0.43263426423072815, -0.4127221405506134, -0.5546936988830566, -0.00978068821132183, -0.4683029055595398, -0.16148041188716888, 0.16497473418712616, 0.6922380328178406, 0.15934479236602783, 0.3297434151172638, -0.16521647572517395, 0.018323630094528198, -0.24216699600219727, 0.31361132860183716, 0.05301177129149437, 0.3456662893295288, 0.025379445403814316, 0.7720087170600891, -0.38299044966697693, 0.27619364857673645, 1.073101282119751, -0.6404088735580444, 0.526000440120697, -0.4221057593822479, 0.10924624651670456, 0.761070728302002, 0.07847876846790314, -0.1651850789785385, 0.37363553047180176, 0.04023358225822449, 0.015434595756232738, -0.40917718410491943, -0.13571880757808685, -0.1122804582118988, 0.34450244903564453, -0.4986637234687805, 0.7046830058097839, -0.202766552567482, 0.24038520455360413, 0.16712458431720734, -1.0173557996749878, 4.230340480804443, 0.6844883561134338, 0.4601699113845825, 0.31270915269851685, 0.3906596004962921, 0.6770273447036743, -0.5670215487480164, -0.28459402918815613, 0.16656064987182617, -0.39540255069732666, -0.6566423773765564, 0.22070913016796112, -0.23136794567108154, 0.0801493376493454, -0.1392388790845871, 1.3218053579330444, 0.017142003402113914, -0.4666542112827301, 0.3535388708114624, -0.6510487794876099, -0.47370657324790955, 0.07751680165529251, 0.09681891649961472, -0.39725828170776367, 0.5225715637207031, -0.27396857738494873, -0.03855353221297264, -0.3252689242362976, 0.16261298954486847, -0.15910205245018005, -0.4647621810436249, -0.6233422756195068, 0.48394736647605896, 0.024601634591817856, -0.8912310004234314, 0.922507643699646, -0.21415801346302032, -0.262942910194397, -0.2934918701648712, -0.2645491063594818, -0.14424236118793488, -0.8602806329727173, -0.11888758093118668, -0.06680852174758911, -0.03905445709824562, 1.2092691659927368, -0.8843470811843872, 0.40700793266296387, 0.6161612272262573, -1.1381701231002808, 0.9439427256584167, -0.10091474652290344, 0.20147810876369476, -0.06714700162410736, -0.5177479386329651, 0.6779987215995789, -0.2913646697998047, -0.1759273111820221, 0.04574461653828621, 0.8557730317115784, -0.19028478860855103, -0.01830688863992691, -0.26052170991897583, 0.1736096441745758, 0.09672863036394119, 0.45159098505973816, -0.0973631888628006, 0.4410390257835388, -0.5927802324295044, -0.04825908690690994, 0.4141102433204651, -0.07943069934844971, -0.5828964114189148, 0.5333301424980164, 0.6463282704353333, -0.051867254078388214, -0.44724881649017334, 0.6441407203674316, -0.7341562509536743, -0.33322060108184814, 0.3285852074623108, -0.6332730054855347, -0.009952059015631676, 0.039142630994319916, 0.07202702760696411, 0.8222172260284424, 0.023806588724255562, 0.1596982479095459, 0.08118213713169098, 0.3471985459327698, 0.4970487952232361, 0.5503683090209961, 0.19789335131645203, -0.3274611830711365, -0.4145609438419342 ]
Point-Split Lattice Operators for B Decays
The matrix element which determines the B meson decay constant can be measured on the lattice using an effective field theory for heavy quarks. Various discretizations of the heavy-light bilinears which appear in this and other B decay matrix elements are possible. The heavy-light bilinear currently used for the determination of the B meson decay constant on the lattice suffers a substantial one-loop renormalization. In this paper, we compute the one-loop renormalizations of the discretizations in which the heavy and light fields in the bilinear are separated by one lattice spacing, and discuss their application. Readers of this paper may also be interested in our paper on the application of Symanzik's improvement program to heavy-light currents (paper number 9203221 on hep-ph).
Oscar F. Hernandez and Brian R. Hill
hep-lat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9204006
hep-lat/9204007
[ 0.44683921337127686, -0.2176189422607422, -0.36375513672828674, 0.15140563249588013, -0.17014336585998535, -0.6469631195068359, -0.3313652575016022, -0.2973085045814514, -0.7939397692680359, 1.3937897682189941, 0.1970459669828415, -0.02632153406739235, 0.2921202778816223, -0.6431781053543091, 0.3582100570201874, 0.6497164368629456, 0.12310554832220078, -0.4630073606967926, -1.4126861095428467, 0.756336510181427, 0.56429523229599, -0.1436319202184677, -1.4312223196029663, -0.3564826250076294, -0.09301791340112686, 0.6722663640975952, 0.9202319979667664, -0.2771914601325989, 1.4436894655227661, 0.45664718747138977, 0.01467210054397583, -0.39179322123527527, -0.505016028881073, -0.5584139227867126, -0.510311484336853, -0.8090100884437561, -0.5763187408447266, -0.04417255520820618, 0.46764808893203735, 0.4297764301300049, 0.6560832262039185, 0.2261558324098587, -0.6597031354904175, -0.6159593462944031, -0.5974761843681335, 0.25370824337005615, -0.6680139899253845, -0.3704815208911896, 0.518990159034729, -1.3609766960144043, 0.031023891642689705, 0.3889775574207306, 0.15001113712787628, -0.7816214561462402, -0.30020490288734436, -0.2187560796737671, 0.23249241709709167, 0.0983218401670456, -0.8938004374504089, -0.025415681302547455, 0.9434080123901367, 0.12959489226341248, 0.2662791609764099, -0.4979875981807709, 0.18581539392471313, 0.10360740125179291, -0.22584876418113708, 0.8226884603500366, -0.2737399637699127, -0.4492330849170685, -0.5426720380783081, -0.4332692325115204, -1.6099153757095337, 0.5007463693618774, -1.2419111728668213, -0.1967179924249649, -0.04694226384162903, -0.42036202549934387, -1.0727450847625732, -0.006717346142977476, 0.20659346878528595, -0.391681045293808, -0.39363300800323486, 0.6613338589668274, -0.4439747631549835, -0.26927855610847473, -0.2437896877527237, -0.4935755133628845, -0.385931134223938, 0.8441417813301086, 0.16636431217193604, 0.7708702683448792, 0.12154366075992584, -0.11369315534830093, 0.6397906541824341, 0.10781773179769516, 0.20074491202831268, 0.3036143183708191, -0.30937832593917847, -0.2876121699810028, 0.08039692044258118, 0.22609461843967438, -0.647315263748169, -0.017625337466597557, -0.7605379819869995, -0.1329990029335022, -0.5864891409873962, -0.3593498468399048, -0.186665877699852, -0.6034919023513794, 0.0690302774310112, -0.538680911064148, 0.473613440990448, 0.41561824083328247, 0.019323984161019325, 0.1984720081090927, -0.3348066210746765, 0.32446789741516113, -0.37301144003868103, -0.7063661217689514, 0.3827182352542877, -0.10993306338787079, 0.050076935440301895, 0.4561225175857544, -0.030971042811870575, -0.04145919904112816, 0.3755464553833008, 0.3476109206676483, -0.9700249433517456, 0.6656336784362793, 0.16854241490364075, 0.08908221125602722, -0.5212568044662476, 0.3288361430168152, -0.17663949728012085, -0.01643381454050541, -0.4756360352039337, 0.4786914885044098, 0.2655179798603058, -0.1579255759716034, 0.9401815533638, -0.560488760471344, 0.4650748670101166, 1.3171899318695068, 0.7427476048469543, -0.08277872204780579, 0.3317018747329712, 0.22672979533672333, -0.3982081413269043, 0.3416208326816559, -0.23868989944458008, -0.3052464425563812, -0.2171250730752945, 0.10424648225307465, 0.10573609173297882, 0.5454186797142029, -0.8314935564994812, 0.2458725869655609, -0.13341227173805237, -0.4740629494190216, 0.7056369781494141, -0.14322763681411743, -0.9502263069152832, 0.17008496820926666, -0.4969862401485443, 0.26271018385887146, -0.6399353742599487, -0.368894100189209, 0.16596105694770813, -0.9987771511077881, -0.2465115487575531, 0.3072304427623749, -0.31262242794036865, 0.45553725957870483, 0.6211220026016235, 0.5028588771820068, 0.9811407327651978, -0.693945050239563, -0.41614827513694763, 0.26076582074165344, -0.20324452221393585, -0.3087572455406189, 0.1392441987991333, -0.040031254291534424, -0.0325477197766304, -0.35300594568252563, -0.0632239431142807, -0.1885044425725937, 0.10316672921180725, 0.2924628257751465, -0.17163723707199097, 0.33874037861824036, -0.5462351441383362, 0.9247788190841675, -0.47982749342918396, -0.1975180059671402, -0.9971829056739807, 0.0793333575129509, -0.9529042840003967, -0.20942123234272003, 0.07550447434186935, -0.03949953615665436, -0.9362595677375793, 0.1133107990026474, -1.4244568347930908, 0.3914293050765991, 0.8287585377693176, 0.11514675617218018, -0.7431735992431641, 0.09458683431148529, -0.11624720692634583, -0.3111129701137543, -0.17064905166625977, -0.6344591379165649, 0.3145028054714203, 0.1978927105665207, 0.5181407928466797, 0.24383004009723663, 0.6910454034805298, 0.29123520851135254, 0.2517941892147064, 0.28055205941200256, 0.2685334384441376, 0.47609981894493103, -0.03722492605447769, -0.49603787064552307, -0.13700951635837555, 0.7169390320777893, 0.14348633587360382, -0.5760529637336731, -0.26625460386276245, 0.7991489768028259, 0.39172157645225525, 0.5130043625831604, -0.04592760279774666, 0.2271302044391632, 0.5993380546569824, -0.008581623435020447, 0.6755596399307251, 0.6478267312049866, 0.0555584691464901, -0.2432493418455124, 0.24748563766479492, -0.4335998594760895, -0.28793421387672424, 0.25759434700012207, -0.6888312697410583, 0.5561872124671936, -0.402827650308609, 0.3725936710834503, 0.36482149362564087, 0.5922070741653442, -0.0420263297855854, 0.03665751591324806, -1.041778326034546, 0.08448796719312668, 0.18094512820243835, 0.34759342670440674, -0.2229311615228653, 0.25763481855392456, 0.5264095664024353, 0.3149867057800293, -0.18437886238098145, -0.5269765853881836, -0.7694271802902222, 1.0878229141235352, -0.1032591462135315, 0.24785424768924713, 0.7426478862762451, -0.39363616704940796, -1.0393508672714233, -0.4325545132160187, -1.2312016487121582, 0.054423846304416656, -0.6470528244972229, 0.1274167001247406, 0.9711734652519226, -1.005184531211853, 0.13779161870479584, 0.21955545246601105, 0.2099190652370453, 0.5828243494033813, -0.8011649250984192, 0.1796441376209259, 0.7882190346717834, 0.26711392402648926, -0.0020817953627556562, 0.4899856448173523, -0.24126097559928894, -0.5656576752662659, -0.2656548023223877, 0.2519994378089905, 0.4213753044605255, -0.5561919212341309, 0.6813791990280151, -0.5514684915542603, -0.5452016592025757, -0.4934866726398468, 0.12027183175086975, -0.5869331359863281, -0.08511372655630112, 0.504796028137207, -0.23145422339439392, -0.7327629327774048, -0.9092471599578857, 0.2536461055278778, 0.2627888321876526, -0.37922203540802, -0.2356838583946228, 0.00685874791815877, -0.35702425241470337, 0.5514618158340454, 0.08766958862543106, -0.4169637858867645, -0.2579335868358612, 0.9088404178619385, 0.3953537940979004, -0.01723460480570793, -0.4957015812397003, -0.3209143579006195, -0.12451857328414917, 0.26694169640541077, 0.1300102323293686, -0.6809782385826111, 0.05276160687208176, 0.37163281440734863, 0.14148323237895966, -0.4516179859638214, 0.37246108055114746, -1.080803632736206, -1.098779320716858, 0.006262711714953184, -0.19791443645954132, -0.10690679401159286, 0.08897463232278824, -0.01403026096522808, -1.0434303283691406, 0.37564346194267273, 0.6044828295707703, 0.3443264961242676, 0.5925989747047424, -0.40678924322128296, 0.3638249337673187, -0.014043630100786686, 0.7469308376312256, -0.12738804519176483, -0.14995357394218445, -0.7029075622558594, -0.7232148051261902, 0.2381308376789093, -0.5584010481834412, 0.05399725213646889, -0.21069282293319702, 0.4810362458229065, 0.09750671684741974, 0.7043064832687378, -0.47863471508026123, -0.38064390420913696, -0.2777622640132904, -0.8689420223236084, 0.26298385858535767, 0.7738931179046631, 0.014116300269961357, -0.4028421640396118, -0.1813478320837021, -0.11831653863191605, 0.08266444504261017, 0.14378541707992554, 0.7441509366035461, -0.5293242335319519, 0.24582530558109283, 0.41762542724609375, -0.45993074774742126, 0.21644902229309082, -0.1692558377981186, 0.10995463281869888, 0.8509128093719482, 0.19471967220306396, 0.6385324597358704, 0.002420310629531741, -0.6016673445701599, -0.057479433715343475, 0.6860595345497131, 0.3598468601703644, 0.4521268606185913, -0.16497011482715607, -0.29817742109298706, -0.2708088755607605, -0.17441818118095398, -0.27312034368515015, -0.6205594539642334, 0.1158669963479042, 0.27821633219718933, 0.050669461488723755, 0.23386621475219727, -0.05331069231033325, 0.5812612175941467, 0.15887919068336487, -0.3282383978366852, 0.12207850068807602, 0.19979305565357208, -0.16220836341381073, 0.8076402544975281, 0.21626146137714386, -0.04838835075497627, 0.26830971240997314, -0.6769201159477234, -0.04252707585692406, 0.37552207708358765, 0.7997230291366577, 0.01755550131201744, -0.13728336989879608, -0.2677437961101532, -0.6716188788414001, 0.348863422870636, 0.3091701567173004, -1.2227954864501953, 0.6794676780700684, 0.14343996345996857, 0.36800408363342285, 0.12012270092964172, 0.047932159155607224, 0.7715973854064941, 0.00556917255744338, 0.7095156311988831, -1.3094570636749268, 0.8212903738021851, -0.1987302303314209, 0.1910337656736374, 0.553153932094574, -0.7955865263938904, -0.6949818134307861, -0.9933505654335022, 0.025716062635183334, -0.2579912543296814, 0.14451348781585693, 0.8465698957443237, -0.007440624292939901, -0.2607163190841675, -0.9360736608505249, -0.179035484790802, 0.9005727767944336, -0.3105122148990631, -0.4042203426361084, 0.907182514667511, -0.07934817671775818, -0.3474558889865875, 1.0004969835281372, 0.17584073543548584, -0.553662896156311, 0.48063012957572937, -0.9545129537582397, 0.5164859890937805, -0.4641340374946594, -1.0801985263824463, -0.7263767123222351, -0.28399014472961426, -0.5871896743774414, -0.04478427767753601, -0.12682680785655975, -0.3187212347984314, -0.18525561690330505, -0.15079784393310547, -0.5167747139930725, 0.16042198240756989, -0.10303028672933578, 0.44301411509513855, 0.5559083223342896, 0.5191546082496643, 0.4982093870639801, 0.31953978538513184, 0.31205910444259644, -0.23424947261810303, -0.05781165510416031, 0.12469621747732162, 0.12020832300186157, -0.06796608120203018, -0.2335876226425171, -0.1792370229959488, -0.540490448474884, -0.6203739643096924, 0.03697723522782326, 0.24981482326984406, 0.35228490829467773, 0.4800533652305603, -1.0373376607894897, -0.3717361092567444, -0.47623345255851746, -1.2770920991897583, 0.276464581489563, 0.9835570454597473, -0.4468817114830017, 0.6967702507972717, -0.9739164113998413, 0.13660135865211487, -0.2771330177783966, -0.22708773612976074, -0.30653896927833557, 0.16935385763645172, 1.0402677059173584, 0.7149844169616699, -0.07226285338401794, -0.6984144449234009, 0.5092428922653198, -0.5744072794914246, 0.264094740152359, -0.5760968327522278, -0.47551247477531433, -0.4834975600242615, -0.28838619589805603, 0.3845592439174652, 0.12589938938617706, 0.39783525466918945, -0.2803911864757538, -0.26728639006614685, -0.716101348400116, -0.10609541088342667, -0.3198549747467041, 0.018494369462132454, 0.801781177520752, 0.16925139725208282, -0.6491333246231079, -0.5271073579788208, 0.08031801134347916, -0.4024231433868408, 0.1837475448846817, 0.14127668738365173, -0.9033463597297668, 0.2737922668457031, -0.13933736085891724, 0.3815741539001465, -0.5690352916717529, -0.3957810699939728, 0.14397840201854706, -0.5133920311927795, 0.6792706847190857, 0.2797529399394989, 0.5457391738891602, -0.0072433375753462315, -1.0041462182998657, 0.11119882017374039, 0.40698152780532837, -0.2924640476703644, -0.38871505856513977, -0.5833109021186829, -0.11848002672195435, -0.05323082208633423, 0.8817495107650757, 0.41359660029411316, 0.3562305271625519, -0.4324814975261688, -0.30367326736450195, 0.1865517646074295, 0.5820928812026978, -0.15800735354423523, 0.05388934910297394, -0.0051869479939341545, 0.05369376763701439, 0.0401008315384388, 0.6853477954864502, -0.4656587541103363, 0.13419955968856812, -0.366543173789978, 1.3137428760528564, -0.5338677167892456, 0.30495646595954895, -0.504339873790741, 0.3255063593387604, 0.4215138554573059, -0.509345531463623, -0.09362345188856125, 0.3372340500354767, -0.128072589635849, 0.15846379101276398, 0.037987373769283295, -0.5215840339660645, 0.30851930379867554, -0.48115578293800354, -0.7706312537193298, 0.5764962434768677, 0.14966259896755219, 0.6396347880363464, -0.5195102691650391, -0.36903467774391174, 0.18160350620746613, 0.42163798213005066, -0.05303480476140976, 0.603406548500061, 0.35832029581069946, 0.28886693716049194, -0.11966923624277115, -0.7316197156906128, -0.3649956285953522, 0.474644273519516, -0.10638979822397232, 0.2249603569507599, 0.30601075291633606, 0.37497037649154663, -0.28238412737846375, -0.30635011196136475, 0.17111413180828094, 0.43732839822769165, -0.0759432464838028, -0.04768894240260124, 0.6557063460350037, -0.03642426058650017, -0.6400710940361023, -0.025946086272597313, -0.15716290473937988, 0.6634596586227417, 0.5883574485778809, 0.41256263852119446, 0.371841698884964, 0.34980660676956177, 0.7424152493476868, 0.282969206571579, 0.11675163358449936, -0.47687917947769165, 0.5785208940505981, -0.2470555156469345, -0.011765004135668278, 0.6346118450164795, 0.02408970147371292, -0.3809570372104645, -0.2163645625114441, -0.006724225822836161, 0.12682022154331207, -0.9137691855430603, -0.15375036001205444, -0.011051304638385773, -0.0785270407795906, 0.12632007896900177, 0.4254944920539856, 0.5169135928153992, -0.21994826197624207, 0.187469020485878, -0.21044962108135223, -0.26313522458076477, -0.6662682294845581, -0.30930396914482117, 1.436999797821045, -0.15031000971794128, -0.5385255217552185, 0.27825066447257996, 0.24132093787193298, -0.04028898850083351, -0.5376003384590149, 0.567868709564209, -0.5156328678131104, 0.33651405572891235, -0.10702218115329742, 0.08849672228097916, 0.46246206760406494, 1.079567551612854, 0.2199099063873291, -0.4171644151210785, -0.1327267736196518, -0.6724257469177246, 0.06722528487443924, -0.4308429956436157, 0.32846933603286743, 0.45337289571762085, 0.13444042205810547, 0.582813024520874, 0.194279745221138, -0.21962298452854156, -0.09359399229288101, -1.1974551677703857, 0.21726129949092865, -1.1676714420318604, -0.5012062191963196, -0.22508610785007477, -0.16269245743751526, 0.13837118446826935, 0.8279422521591187, -0.10542643070220947, -0.010661890730261803, -0.5075400471687317, 0.18013626337051392, -0.2018129825592041, 0.027605406939983368, -0.15603503584861755, -0.8228263854980469, 0.3999360203742981, -0.03836333006620407, -0.4664894938468933, -0.21052244305610657, 0.10821075737476349, 0.46033158898353577, 0.055959686636924744, 0.46703919768333435, 0.20033064484596252, 0.4808206558227539, -1.040779709815979, -1.2613497972488403, 0.04293546453118324, -0.6568449139595032, -0.47919711470603943, 0.9530518054962158, 0.18351304531097412, 0.8476760983467102, 0.06802766770124435, -0.03424669802188873, -0.3302512764930725, 0.018463188782334328, -0.3056006133556366, 0.31936442852020264, 0.4351658821105957, 0.08025652915239334, -0.08443520963191986, -0.338501513004303, -0.5952844619750977, -0.07632359862327576, -1.0404739379882812, 0.5609534382820129, -0.655754804611206, 0.14357218146324158, -0.5635845065116882, 0.3065662682056427, 0.41728535294532776, 0.2039230912923813, 0.4780527651309967, 0.8674027323722839, 0.21928642690181732, 0.2786690592765808, 0.535419225692749, 0.4386789798736572, 0.004640721250325441, -0.16912947595119476, -0.021283267065882683, -0.08275623619556427, -0.15265333652496338, 0.8454342484474182, 0.23635633289813995, 0.4860798418521881, -0.04290979355573654, -0.5718375444412231, -0.2596801221370697, -0.43933865427970886, -0.5235584378242493, 0.4433387517929077, 0.686651885509491, -1.0041518211364746, -0.3485371470451355, -0.7636677622795105, -0.8433263301849365, 0.1406915932893753, -0.37963345646858215, 0.30124470591545105, -0.030351445078849792, -0.5480048060417175, 0.33704522252082825, 0.5106493830680847, 0.18812380731105804, -0.4401279389858246, 0.45104965567588806, 0.8766244649887085, -0.3478905260562897, -0.19578149914741516, -0.12946414947509766, -0.10345736891031265, -0.8930371403694153, -0.34569770097732544, -0.4970170259475708, 0.6872224807739258, -1.2421249151229858, -0.7274029850959778, 0.02901523932814598, 0.8991628885269165, 0.34922000765800476, -0.5106422305107117, -0.12252826243638992, 0.0033957092091441154, -0.4659061133861542, -0.01942809857428074, -0.6550490260124207, -0.6181002259254456, 0.21289922297000885, 0.6888484954833984, 0.04082173854112625, 0.030999453738331795, 0.009044167585670948, -0.10542097687721252, -0.16079260408878326, 0.05142083019018173, -0.003764551831409335, 0.95878005027771, 0.5243310332298279, -0.8019703030586243, 0.4373573362827301, 0.31689414381980896, 0.02182021178305149, 0.46816107630729675, -0.8579014539718628, 0.20512250065803528, 0.45572778582572937, 0.5205900073051453, 0.46515363454818726, 0.05280875787138939, 0.14445261657238007, 0.35726314783096313, 0.2692704498767853, 0.7201016545295715, -0.31188151240348816, 0.1053861454129219, 0.7912023067474365, 0.09012983739376068, -0.24275419116020203, 0.25091856718063354, -0.20696642994880676, -0.23481087386608124, 0.324032723903656, -0.3290382921695709, -0.5598793625831604, -0.26480039954185486, 0.5913999080657959, -0.2473677098751068, -0.7408326864242554, -0.4654519557952881, -0.07157783955335617, -0.21893875300884247, 1.4079535007476807, 0.20921501517295837, -0.09393321722745895, 0.9041020274162292, 0.4829566776752472, -0.017301099374890327, -0.09410178661346436, 0.44767534732818604, -0.14143945276737213, 0.46669459342956543, 0.9075413346290588, 0.011941242963075638, 0.1615029275417328, 0.6884114742279053, 0.1683908998966217, -1.0464911460876465, 0.014134379103779793, 0.5393155813217163, -0.7508686780929565, 0.12229643762111664, -0.6734244227409363, -0.09751075506210327, -0.28312209248542786, -0.41717278957366943, 0.2609657347202301, -0.3060165047645569, 0.3996381163597107, 0.3773953318595886, -0.3084942102432251, -0.0815921276807785, 0.5029170513153076, 0.07862591743469238, 0.28179559111595154, 0.23874440789222717, -0.07650209218263626, -0.39512568712234497, 0.689400315284729, 1.6259878873825073, 0.08092128485441208, 0.2661355435848236, 0.5770889520645142, -0.2966831922531128, 0.08785492926836014, 0.15964509546756744, 0.16260170936584473, 0.5496798753738403, -0.5204992294311523, -0.6997142434120178, 0.3080335557460785, -0.11652099341154099, 0.06003189459443092, -0.15729466080665588, 0.49804621934890747, -0.4064542353153229, -0.38969987630844116, -0.3187536895275116, 1.664457082748413, 0.5379456877708435, -0.7614130973815918, -0.01807306706905365, 1.005784273147583, -0.8334707617759705, -0.42045363783836365, -0.45885947346687317, 0.5373175740242004, -0.2802351713180542, -0.41087567806243896, 0.007837413810193539, -0.5606008768081665, -0.4356048107147217, -0.7131533026695251, -0.15812362730503082, -0.3631018102169037, 0.731823742389679, 0.7013620734214783, -0.18375203013420105, 0.43660789728164673, -0.18088357150554657, -0.045280370861291885, 0.4569786489009857, 0.32009637355804443, -0.04467986896634102, -0.18897747993469238, 0.9155296087265015, 0.6067686080932617, -0.4762391149997711, 0.5183554291725159, 1.0215052366256714, -0.3536999523639679, 0.3707857131958008, -0.5096320509910583, 0.5353103876113892, 0.37230217456817627, -0.046045932918787, -0.07022618502378464, 0.29381686449050903, -0.10091052949428558, 0.6651177406311035, -0.3293500542640686, 0.2761801481246948, -0.6887871623039246, 0.17735172808170319, -0.7341676950454712, 0.4185861349105835, 0.010742447338998318, 0.04108056053519249, 0.43016695976257324, -0.7107847332954407, 4.30527925491333, 0.5656448006629944, 0.6601992845535278, 0.7147008180618286, 0.445657342672348, 0.8780000805854797, -0.41034623980522156, -0.49211442470550537, 0.330518901348114, -0.5188558101654053, -0.7413821816444397, 0.22600401937961578, 0.04537753015756607, -0.24910740554332733, 0.023470133543014526, 0.7986359596252441, -0.5219829082489014, -0.7692245841026306, 0.11067714542150497, -0.3509001135826111, -0.5497804284095764, 0.11693151295185089, 0.2642478346824646, 0.133080393075943, 0.43754738569259644, 0.10253868252038956, 0.26430654525756836, -0.4345434308052063, -0.4655708074569702, -0.3554411828517914, -0.7364760041236877, -0.7563847899436951, 0.631791889667511, -0.5692352056503296, -0.10554500669240952, 0.6998291015625, 0.3231326639652252, -0.317716509103775, -0.17390701174736023, 0.21669599413871765, 0.21706685423851013, -0.5488951206207275, 0.19742581248283386, -0.5724629163742065, -0.2606077194213867, 1.4693821668624878, -0.49526146054267883, 0.644993007183075, 0.35536736249923706, -0.6952943801879883, 0.29854387044906616, -0.09613315016031265, 0.1457863301038742, -0.8298425078392029, -0.7360644340515137, 0.7390896081924438, -0.3025883138179779, 0.04135940968990326, 0.1215912252664566, -0.0237563606351614, 0.05434771999716759, -0.4822104871273041, -0.16649596393108368, 0.4159873425960541, -0.11974292993545532, 0.4196734130382538, 0.19851401448249817, 0.2504049837589264, -0.5738810896873474, 0.2362806797027588, -0.24713705480098724, -0.7753640413284302, -0.009262134321033955, 0.05696774646639824, 0.6767550706863403, 0.21495454013347626, -0.18698011338710785, 0.38206177949905396, 0.27469196915626526, -0.3876956105232239, 0.6416023969650269, -0.4393206834793091, -0.34597811102867126, -0.4595630168914795, 0.022618182003498077, 0.10560561716556549, -0.13169452548027039, 0.3493870794773102, -0.2578577995300293, 0.5264056324958801, 0.5335740447044373, 0.7224341034889221, 0.3392280638217926, 0.0845123827457428, -0.4811166226863861 ]
Chiral Perturbation Theory for the Quenched Approximation of QCD
[This version is a minor revision of a previously submitted preprint. Only references have been changed.] We describe a technique for constructing the effective chiral theory for quenched QCD. The effective theory which results is a lagrangian one, with a graded symmetry group which mixes Goldstone bosons and fermions, and with a definite (though slightly peculiar) set of Feynman rules. The straightforward application of these rules gives automatic cancellation of diagrams which would arise from virtual quark loops. The techniques are used to calculate chiral logarithms in $f_K/f_\pi$, $m_\pi$, $m_K$, and the ratio of $\langle{\bar s}s\rangle$ to $\langle{\bar u}u\rangle$. The leading finite-volume corrections to these quantities are also computed. Problems for future study are described.
Claude Bernard and Maarten Golterman
hep-lat
April
1,992
https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-lat/9204007